20 BUENA VISTA AVENUE - BUILDING JACKET �o �� �� �
� -
. ,
} cif of Arm, Aasszr4us4k
Psarb of (A"Pzl CITY CLERK.S",LEK MASS.
5��1y14t��
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF ARTHUR & ELISSA SIMARD FOR
A VARIANCE ATS 20 BUENA IST AVENUb
A hearing on this petition was held July 15, 1987 with the following Board .
Members present: James Fleming, Vice Chairman; Messrs. , Luzinski, Strout and
Associate Member LaBrecque. Notice of the hearing was sent to abutters and others
and notices of the hearing were properly published in the Salem Evening News in
accordance with Massachusetts General Laws Chanter 40A.
.The petitioners, representing themselves, seek a Variance from rear and side
yard setbacks to allow for the continued use of an existing deck. The locus
of the property is in an R-1 district.
The Variance which has been requested may be granted upon a finding of the
Board that:
a. special conditions and circumstances exist which especially affect
the land, building or structure involved and which are not generally
affecting other lands, buildings and structures in the same district;
b. literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would invol
substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the petitioner;
c. desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the
public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the
intent of the district of the purpose of the Ordinance.
The Board of Appeal, after careful consideration of the evidence presented and
after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact:
1 . No opposition to the petition was presented at the hearing;
2. The deck has existed for a considerable length of time;
3. The petitioners cannot sell, or otherwise encumber the
property without the requested relief.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at the
hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows:
1 . The relief requested may be granted without substantial
detriment to the public good;
2. Hardship, in the form of the ledge on the property and the easement
on the property, makes placement of the addition in any other spot
on the property impossible;
3. Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involve
substantial hardship to the petitioner.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF ARTHUR & ELISSA SIMARD FOR A
VARIANCE AT 20 BUENA VISTA AVE. , SALEM
page two
Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted unanimously, 5-0, to grant the
Variance requested, subject to the following conditions:
1 . The deck is to remain as it currently exists;
2. The petitioners must comply with all the requirements of the
Salem Fire Department, relative to fire safety.
VARIANCE GRANTED
/James M. Fleming, Esq.
Vice Chairman, Board of Appeal
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
APPEAL SlIkLL BE "ADE PO,acUA`JT TO SECT:GiJ 17 DF THE %MMS.
G .,..-_ ti'�_ i'J Di./S ,F7 -HE DATE OF FILING
,'c DE," TOE F'ri C.E THE CLEi2 K. -
Cr 7F.i.. . . '
PJ45f Yi 0 7 ,OS UEi '.i IN t?,S:A..,CE E'AL ER"IT
Ci.;I EED h-T Sk A.L , T ',E _ J^T, `' Cr _. - C . ..i Tat �ERT-
FiCATIOfl F 'I- . ,.h; ..,: .� D,*..-S 1 SED -. EAL u.,.
OR TH.-,T. F ^i' PaE S _I c .E, T IT hAS 1-`2D ? ;.E.^ IS
REO^ cEC j'4 .,.;U H Ef_ c. D fJ c U.-i,_- - ,. . .E CF TRE 0`:1"ER
OF RECORD OR IS RECORDED AND i OIEO ON THE OWNER'S CERTIFICATE OF TITLE.
BOARD OF APPEAL
l
5
I
1
I
�` �P�i � �-o � _. .�...
, �hc Cummunwc•rlth ol'Massachusetts
��� � DoarJ of Building Rrgulaliuns nnJ StanJarcls C'ITY
�y j Massachusrus Sta�e BuilJing Cwle, 780 CMR, 7'"eJition ��F SALFM
/ I� �� Rr��irrdJwroun•
V IIuilJing Pertnil Applicatiun To Cunstruct, Rrpair, Rrnuvate Or Drmolish a /. :INAY
� Une-or T�vu-Fumilv Dwrffing
i�� Thia Section For O.Rcid Use Onl
I BuilJing Permil Number: D e Applied:
ISigwWre� 1� � �D
Nuildiny Cummivi d Iropec�a uf ildin�{f f}rle �
SECTION 1: SITE tNFORMATION
I.1 Pro ertr Ad,drear. , 1.2 Afaeaon Ma d� Parcd Numben
B�j�11C»fKn�iS-f/i- !�-✓P P
1.1 a Is Ihis an acce ted streel?yes no Map Number Paecel NumEer
I.J Zonlo�loformatbo: I.J Propertr Dlmeoilom: �
Yuning Disvict PropoxJ Ux Ld Area(sq Il) Fron�age(It)
I.S Bulldln`Setbacks�0)
From Vord SiJe Yards Rear Yerd
Rrquircd ProviJed Requircd Provided Requiied Provided
f�t �" 3 r � .,F
1.6 W�ter Sypply:(M.G.L c.�o,§54) 1.7 Flood Zoee tnformatloo: t.8 Sew�Qe DVpoaal Sy�tem:
2une: Ouuide Flood ZoneT
Public m Private O Check if e�0 Municipd O On ei�e disposel ryslem ❑
SECTION2: PROPERTYOWNERSHIP�
2.1 Owner�of Rceord: �
O l'r �l L�GI L� _ u/:S 'h4- 9�-1/-�
Nume(Print) A rcu fw Service: -
�
Signmure Telephoro
SEGTION�: DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED WORK�(c6cek all tAat�pply)
New Construction O Eaiating Building❑ Owner-Occupied O Repairs(s) ❑ Alteration(s) ❑ Addilion
Demolition O Accessory Bldg.O Numberof Unib Other O Specify: �
Brief Descrip�ion of Proposed Work': —� ' Al2��1 � C f.�;1-f
�c-��JrzmS a e�`t'hec.('�t�C -.i f�?�(� S a.�,Q CcA 5ar�.awr .iSnCtL.
SECTIOIV 4: ESTIMATED CORSTRUCT(ON COSTS
Item Estimated Costr. 011lcl�l Use Only
Labor and Materials �
I. DuilJing 5 �, � 1. Ouilding Pertnit Fee:S Indica�e how fee i�determined:
�. Elec�rical S����� ���y � O Slandard Citylf'own Applica�ion Fee
❑Total Projat Cosl (Item 6)c mulliplia x
3. Plumbing 5 VU. W 2. O�her Fees: S
�. Mechanical �HVAC) S List:
S. Mechanical �Firc S
Su ms�ion Tutal All Fees:f
Check No. Check Amount: Cuh Amount:
6. Tofal ProJect Ca�t: S
3 ��W ❑Paid in Full O OutsianJing Balance Due:
ti/
uN�
5
� .,. _..
1ECTIOIV 3: CONSTRUCTIOIV JERVICES
i,1 Llcea�ed Con�trucUon Supervbo�ICSL) � v?� 7/?J
&��` { � I.icense Number Ii%pll'JUu�I I)0lC
N�une ul'CSI •I IolJer � � I.iv C'5L�I'ype I+K bslnw�
T A��vS S `1�S'�i�l<L t�M
e � �x�cri ion
:� `� . /� �7� U Unmtric�eJ u w 75.000 Cu.Fi.
�� R Resiricud IR2 Famil lhvellin
tii _ynawrc M M lhd
�2L�5'-Yy�� RC RaiJemial Roulin Coverin
I'.IepMme WS RaiJemial WinJowanJSidin
tiF RaiJenlial Solid Fuel Bumin A liame In�tallaiiun
D RefiJrntial Demolition
�3.2 lat Ho Im rovementCootnctor(HIC) �yg� 2
� �M �1�" Regisumion Number
I IIC Company Name w f IIC Re ielr�m N:une �
U
AJ
� , E. irr�' n Dale
tiiyn:uurc Tciephune �
SECTIOIV 6: WORKERS'COMPENSATION INSURAIVCE AFFIDAVIT(M.C.I_a �57.f 23C(6))
Worken Compmsetion Insurance afTidsvi�musl be compleled and submitted wilh this app�ication. Failure to provide
thia affid�vit will rcsult in the denial of the Issuance of the building permil.
Signed Affidavit AttachedT Ya .......... No...........O
SECTIOIV�a:OWNER AUTHORIZATION TO BE COMPLETED WHEN
OWNER'3 AGENT OR CONTRACTOR APPLIES FOR BUILDINC P6RMIT
� , as Owner of the aubject property hercby
authorize to act on my behalf,in all matters
relative to work nuthorizcd by thia building permit applicalion. �
Si urcofOwner Dute
SECTIOIY 7b:OWNER�OR AUTHORIZED AGENT DECLARATiON
� �� � ��j 4 ,as Owner or Authorized Agent hereby declare
that lhe statements and infortnation on the forcgoing application urc We and accurate,to Ihe best of my knowledge and
behalf.� ��y I�
c,._
Prim Nam� k /!� /�
-�-¢-.�
Si�{nalure of�(hv or�uiKorittd Agent Date
Si unJer�he airo and nal�in of 'u
NOTES:
I. An Ow�er who ubtains a building permit to do his/her own work,or an owner who him an unrcgistered cantroctor
(nol rcgistercd in the Home Improvement ConUoctor(HIC)Program),will�}Q(have accas lo the orbitration
progr�m or guardnry fund under M.G.L.c. IJ2A.O�her importan� infortnation on�he HIC Proyram and
Construc�ion Supervisor Licensing(CSL)can be found in 780 CMR Regulations 1 IO.R6 and 1 IO.RS, rc�pectively.
�. When subs�an�ial work is planncJ,provide�he informalion below:
To�al floors area(Sq.Ft.) (including garage, finished basemenVatlia,decka or porch)
Grost living uea(Sq. FI.) Flabi�able room counl
Number of fircplacer Number of bedrooms
Number of bathrooms Number of half%batha
Type uf heating system Number of decks/purches
Ty�pe of couling system Encloxd ()pen
). "Total Project 5yuarc Foo�age"may be substimtnd for"Tulal Projrct Cos�"
m.__.��_�,- ._
' I
� ;
, ,
-- - s
i ,
i
i j�
� � ��k + '
� ' _� �
���� � j �
�=� _,_,\ � �__._ �
cq W ,- - --- ! ^ �
">' � ' Vj
�= � �
� -- � �
� <� � ,
� �1 _ _�1� .
-� �
;�- ,� � �
��. � � , .
.� ��-=! �a� _I� �
� _ ,�,� ,;, �
i i I ��
� , I �_ �.x�� � �
� �: ,� .� _ __ , �
.;
; ; � ::.
� E __� �
; __:__.
, ,:
, _ ,. .
__�� ;
� �
� _��
;
�
r
;
' i � � ..z.
j �� � ��L
� .�. � a
� � x--
� � �
� ���� � �
C �
i n��
ii ----- -- _ , -.,:e
._W _ � _
,
' �� . _�.. ._� i � , .. -- - �1
� i�� _ - - _. _ __ _� .�--- �
�
I r� - - - � E - - _-_ � � �
_+ � �
; � �
� �
I ;� .�-_ � ;� -- -- --- ---- �� �, �
� ,� �.. � _ . _ _ __ . -,
,
i __. _a_ ____ _ _._�, ` '�"
' � � I. ', �
ii�, ._.,._.. t � _ _ `�, ` , A.
f
__ � �t.: - _�_ . ..,___ s._ _.�
, � � - -�-� - � � -.. --- `�s'
, ,
,�
; �r -
�, i
r -.- _
t --..__ _ _ _ � ,
. -- -
� ,_ _
� _ _.- .- -
; <, i � _
� `� � � - -- �
�
� � i , ; ; f -- __ _ _ _� _ ._. ,.
, ` :
i (; __ - ! ' E - -- --- �
,. �_ _..__-- _ _.._. --- ------_—
� i I�____ --� ; ' - �
: N , . : — -_ __ _ ___ _
. � . , � � —
? ` 3 , s �
i . � � !{- ..--. __-: 1 � .-.'.- -.-. _._. _" .._ .._'_ - �
� ' ,
, LL _
! ' ! i I �'�' �
.� G G , ' '_ .'__ _.... . .-___- . . . ... ."_ _
r - ' ----- � --��------ -- � - - - -_._. - �- . — .
-� --� i - ---- ' --- - --� -'-- -- ' �
�. � ; ; t -- � 5J
: ` , ,
� t --�� �
; > � _ _ : _ _ . .- --- — — --- r.
. i", fl, ( —'_— _._— _____... ._-_. . .
- , .__' _ '_ . —__ �
� � -�
' I - -� ( L. . ._._.. � . __ ' .' . ._" _ �
7 I ' � . —__—` �. .� " ' � ._—
1
� j i -_ r
; � r � -- ,I =�
4
: : . _._. __._. .. . _. .__. . ... ____
___ _____ _ i
. . . ....._._ . . . :
' f. i . ._. .. . _._._ __ __. . � .
I � 1 3
� � • � , . _. �.. .. � J��� �
. ._. ... . .. _._ _ ___
I � s � ���
�. ! " . . ..__. _ ^
� { ` - �'� � ��
, i 1� _, � _ _- ---- ---- -- � �
S ' .___.-..::_.___.._. . ._ _ _ . _. . _ ___ r r
' ! ! { ' " � P'�
� t ___ � ' __ ___ '_ —
` _. _- ' __ — -.
? __._ __ _ ._ �
_ - �--� _ -_ ----� �
_ _ � � �`
_ ___ _
�� � . N x �' . . . . n � ��6Gt � .
� a- - - ` 3 " �s
� � �i �- �� a �._ 4 y c�_ �� �
� .� �F '. �� �T i x! Sn ''��
.G �j�'� � ' h 6 ti: '�\'�` �(' ¢ �"'��� '�'
� •4,� .., R.� � `"-.-" p ,-- '� �Y: f s;,.-�.`� 4L�,;; �r �.L '
f a + n c � � ' ' • u � �
'',��, �e; i-: 1 4�'. `� iy�'T-? `r ,� `G, ���, c�a Lh i�
1/�a ��- � � � ` s� � rF ,C �r�.y � �y/ �
� �,(' 4-a X,,�'"�'„�, C ,_ Viy `Cy ' �' � 5„f f �q �
t ".� G �� C.., t �� t!"4r '"' �J '1'�iA _..+
f ^�' � • '-"" 8Y1 �'+
i J . / �. '- d•'
/
i �' �" , ��"<_ _ v �:.
4 � � - ^ y
� � .�,c� �� �`v
�r �
i �
�
C�OSET CLOSET
-_ - _ � - ____-_
�
I %
, .,
�; - i i ,- -
�II I ; i i �'{
� ; i ,, ;
�.
a;:
f ; , �;
� � :; ; I;�
' �
i ; " � �;,;
�i E ji � i��
�;i �.
� ; � , -,
�� - �-- � ' '
_ , ;
� ;
�
�
�,;�.,
% � ��
;'� J;>
�,
� -�;� ; � �
;
- ---- - -- ;.-„
,� �
,�
LfVING AREA , .
636 sq ft
�
�
�
� z � �
4 �� to �
T � �
�' @ s �
� �
�' ` � -�� ��
� � � �
:fi�� � � � I� �
� ,
� � e� �� . I � � �.�� �
. r
�,�- ��°s � � � , ; j -
� � gs. � I � � �;
� � � ��� � � � ��}
.�i �1 ��- � i�-' . ° 1'
� � � '� i �
5� "h1 ' _--_ �� � '_ � .
O fi " ` �S? '�'�l )
. �� z �' �-` � .
C' ws ! I �
` � � I
� � i �� �
, �� i �� � �
. � � � �
r ��
� ,
f ; ,
; I � !
� f
ji
I I �
! ___ -- � �
� a
� �/oTE.s' ••
, �
\=� /. - T�l,CS �,c..4�t/ �y,4,.s �,PE�.4.PE0 U�t/oE.P �.�0-
�� CEOv.PlJL �4�Q/O TEC/-�N/CAG ,S'T.4it/p�J.PGc'S'Fo.e
�
. �� � tifO.PrG.4GE G o.4�t/ /.V.S�E�'Tio�c%3' ..4.t/O GCSE
FO.P .4�t/Y OT.�.�E.P �t�.eG�?�'E /.S �.Eb�'//B/7,�0•
. 2. �•eOPE.�lY Gi�vE.S' Gr/E.PE id/oT E.S�B.C✓.3'.4�E0
� BY /Y��l�i�/.4it/'/C.4L �,e0�2.�',E�1y.,SY/.P!/.Ey.�1No .�/O
GU,4,e�4tir.E'E�' .4.PE'�1.4OJE.��' To T/r.�E o.e
�l/�'�/� �//✓�Ti9 �yE�i�/E � Ol�t/�t/E.eS.�.�/P L/i(/E.�'. �.vo qF'�'S.E,TS,S'f,i0l/LO il/OT
, BE �'S'EO � G�TE.P.�/.t/E i�o�E.PTY�G/N,ES.
_ ; �29 i¢ � - T/T.G.E .PE.F� E,���-� �EG�CST.QY oF OEEQ9,
4 � ' ' _ ` - OEEO � Boo.G�' �.�dloB : �i9G� ioo
�'>a ac. � � �\ . . . . , ..
uto ,e�uo � � I ° - � - �
� � � i o 3 �.T'� � f�Y..4�c/ : ,o�..B�.� /iq � ���9� BB
�� � a � �� �p � B.4.SE0 Oit/ �1�1,Y .E�NOK/G60�E BEL/EF ,.4it/O
� -- i ^�Q"' /.t/FY>.P�.4T/�N, I ,4�E.PEBY CE.PT/Fy T,4/.4T
� - ' ' .�a��� e.Y y,e�r "5,`�' � T.�/E PE.PiY�.4.t/Eil/T�'T.P!/G'7Y/.P
�'�' .4.PE
- � ' GOClTEO �4.5'�Y-,�Ol�t/i(./,�/E.PEON.�1it/O T.�/.4T
�s` _ E.�/ � M � .4CCO.P01i1/G 727 Tf�E F. E. iYI.4. iLl.4�F0.2
'�, "`K N . � o ��9��� � CO.vf.1�lUifr'/TY /B%. Zaoio2-mo,�� 0,4TE0 �-.s=�.s'
h , � ��� � � T.�/E s�.ec'EG F,4G.G��j' i,�/ ,4.v'.4,P��4 CL.4s.Si�iEo
� /2°O,�/��� i .Qs' t?�.t/E G �.vvi �.� .��000�
\ s / / IT /.S iYIY ?,eOFE.5.3/Oit/..�4L ��/N/O.C/ T.'�.4T T.siE
a � �.��.�,���,T sT.���T�.��-� ���,�-o.�.�Eo
� � �or �o�
l ,���� /O¢OO s�� Tt� T.�lE GiJi' � Gl� ��9GE.r' 20rt//�t/G
, > O/.fAE.t/.Sict�/y.C. .2.EQU/.eE.NE.ti`T.5 �Yi/.E�c./Co.V.Sl.et/CT.EO.
B'�` Ti+'.(9' CE�F'/G477o�/�5' �JL� �,4�/O ti�1iTE0
_ Tt� T,UE �,Pl'i�' G/,S'TEO BE.Col.�/.
- 7'3•.3� ' " °�,.,��i.r.e.*���u.��
.?-��'/r9 �
��O.PTGA�.'E' L0.4it/ �s!/.S.�ECT/�iV �L.4�t/
:
' ` 20 .6'v��i� l�i.�r�9 �9y�'�v�
' .T�9G Ei!! � /�iJ�9�✓� -
G'E�T/F/EO TO.'
✓°ua�°
��,Zf10F -�%LE.vJ F/v� .t'0,�7�AG� CO��O.e�i97/O.v�
�`� /T� ..SUGGGsS.So. .P.�4 A,u-O/oiPi �9_�f��G..uj Aw�.d
_ ,. �� THEODOFiE y -�/A-20.r1 .sfi/.FG<E�Pi C9SEJ-� E9<PUi-Bt
. . c4i pWyEp , � . v�'C.4GE.• / =='90 ' �. ... � �i91' /3� �999 .. . ..
ra.3o�ae oTrE E�' o`riy�-,�, iit/c. .�'l/.ei�EY�,2.5
No>E �.v�,eoy�/�E-tir o< sy�o � /9G CEivT��4G sT,eEE7" .�'AU�US� i1�1�4.
i.��o �.e9i�c�6 E Ey�E�f�ti7 ���'� ' /0 O• BOX 9B Z
�>B/J P33 -d/SS O/90�
a -�d � 90
� � � �
dvB .vo. 79�oa