14-16 BROWN STREET - BUILDING JACKET l�^loo bF&VAJ 5T
OPendatior
OEM&
74520 400/oP4
a
CITY OF SALEM
PUBLIC PROPERTY
DEPARTMENT
rIM6I'.ItL1i.Y DIUSCOLf,
MAYOR
120 WASHINGTON STRGFT * SAL19M,MASSACH USF:1'15 01970
Ti,L:978-745-9595 ♦ FAX:978-740-9846
October 21, 2009
Mr. David Sherf Esq. �d0a7
By email to:
dctvid.sherf@sherflaw.com
RE: Zoning Opinion for property 14-16 Brown Street, Salem
Dear Mr. Sherf,
According to our records, the property at 14-16 Brown Street is a pre-existing non-
conforming commercial building that contains 6 units of commercial space in athe R-3
zone.
Use of all units as commercial space may continue without violation of the Zoning
Ordinance.
This letter, however, should by no means be interpreted that this building is entirely in
compliance with Building, Health or Fire Prevention regulations.
Sincerely,
Tho as St. ierre
Buil i Cptiegioppap �if'c r
cc: file,
14- 16 BROWN STREET
k
1
aCITY OF SALEM
PUBLIC PROPERTY
DEPARTMENT
KIMUFRI,}Y DRISCOLL
MAYOR
120 Wl15FIINGTON$'rREE'1'+ SALEhI,D'IASSACI-WSE'1"1'S 01970
TFL:978-745-9595 ♦ FAX:978-740-9846
October 21, 2009
Mr. David Sherf Esq.
By email to:
david.sherf@sherflaw.com
RE: Zoning Opinion for property 14-16 Brown Street, Salem
Dear Mr. Sherf,
According to our records, the property at 14-16 Brown Street is a pre-existing non-
conforming commercial building that contains 6 units of commercial space in athe R-3
zone.
Use of all units as commercial space may continue without violation of the Zoning
Ordinance.
This letter, however, should by no means be interpreted that this building is entirely in
compliance with Building, Health or Fire Prevention regulations.
SinCre,
y
Tho t . "�'p e_14�
Building Commissioner and Zoning Officer
cc: file,
' f LItU IIs �aaLM, � .' U55=411UHe
DECISION ON PETITION OF GEORGE ROBERT MAGUIRE CON'CERNING PROPERTY LOCATED AT
IL4,16-BR04VN;STREET, SALE11 MHT II 57 AN '7R
FILA is
This is a direct appeal by the Petitioners, George Magu�Nac-iand, Robert Maguire,
through their .attorney, George P. Vallis, One.Church Street, SSalem; :F 6WthP"S plicable
terms of the City of Salem Zoning Ordinance to allow them to construct a building to
contain .4 .professional officesand a dwelling unit on parcel of land located on- a R-3
District. .
Hearing was held on this appeal on March 28, 1978, pursuant to notices mailed post
paid to the Petitioners,. Board Members, Abutters, Abutters to Abutters, and others and
a notice was duly published in the Salem Evening News advising of this public hearing.
Chairman, James H. Boulger, Jr. opened the meeting with Board Members, Donald
Eames, Douglas Hopper and Arthur Labrecque being present. The application was submitted
to obtain a variance from the applicable terms of the Zoning Ordinance with respect to
use, lot area, rear and side yard Isetback and frontage requirements. The Petitioners,
through their attorney, submitted the following evidence:
Property is owned by the Beverly Savings Bank having acquired the property on May
19, 1977, through foreclosure proceedings. The property contains approximately 9,964
sq. ft. of land according to the plan submitted with the petition. Prior to 1975 there
stood on the property 2 buildings containing 24 dwelling units which buildings were
subsequently demolished. It. was pointed out that the property contained 38 feet of
frontage and at its widest point on the Northerly bound was 58 feet. It would:, therefore,
be impossible to erect an economically feasible building without the necessity of a
variance from the density regulations as to the size and shape of the property. It was
- also pointed out that most of the buildings in the immediate area are of a multi-family
variety and that they are non-conforming in that they fail to meet the density requirements
of -the 'present Zoning Ordinance. Mrs. Lucille Nadeau, owner of property at 10 Brown St. ,
abutting Petitioners' parcel, voiced her opposition.
The Board took the matter under advisement until its regularly scheduled hearing
on.April 25, 1978, at which time it unanimously voted to grant the variance as requested
by the Petitioners subject to the following conditions:
1. That She air conditioning unit on the roof face northwest over the parking area;
2. That the Petitioners install curbing at the entrance of the parking area;
3. That the Petitioners replace the sidewalk in the front of the building with bricks
4. That the Petitioners restore the fence located at the easterly boundary.
n.
.Decision on property located at 14-16 Brown St. Page 2
The Board reviewed all the evidence presented and considered carefully the
plans heretofore mentioned. The Board found that a variance could be granted without
substantial detriment to the public good or substantial de���a t n #rgT R�,qa" tent of
the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance, and that literal enfo'rceme It t14e.�rovisions
of the Zoning By-laws would cause substantial hardship to t=om Fetitioners and that
. special conditions with respect to lot size and placement of the buildings thereon
exist not generally affecting other lots and structures. in Cth�CdsstriKtEH.NAss.
Variance voted unanimously subject to conditions outlined above.
APPEAL FROM THIS DECISION, IIF ANY, SHALL BE MADE PURSUANT TO SECTION 17 OF. THE MASS.
GEN. LA}9S, CHAPTER 808, AND SHALL BE FILED WITHIN 20 DAYS AFTER TETE DATE OF FILING OF
THIS DECISION IN TI-M OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK.
PURSUANT TO MASS. GEN. LAWS, CHAPTER 808, SECTION 11, THE VARIANCE OR SPECIAL PERMIT
GRANTED HEREIN, SHALL NOT TAKE EFFECT UNTIL A COPY OF THE DECISION, BEARING THE
CERTIFICATIaN OF THE CITY CLERK THAT 20 DAYS HAVE ELAPSED AND NO APPEAL HAS BEEN FILED,
" OR THAT, IF SUCH AN APPEAL HAS BEEN FILED THAT IT HAS BEEN DISMISSED OR DENIED IS
RECORDED IN THE SOUTH ESSEX REGISTRY OF DEEDS AND INDEXED UNDER THE NAME OF THE OWNER
OF RECORD OR IS RECORDED AND NOTED ON THE WINER'S CERTIFICATE OF TITLE.
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK.
BOARD OF APPEALS
BY
ane T. Lun vegan, 'SevEtary
i
i r '
P
l
C
08/61/9 1a20zaunuo0 - AITaag jaazaS umozg qj-3 j panssT fziusdriOa0 30 aoT_;z1.za
1
(DUI PTV I,7ZX„Z1 u21S p000-i goazg 991# 61/T1;S
(8L/81/8 aznnanz:4saadnS)
•susTd aad Be SuzpjTng a0T330 us IDaza oy (jzno0 �S urozg 9-*7) 60C# 8Z
�
� .� (2UTTTa.tp u/s TTomaQ
-4 y /yp "t-}'
�DuI' •00 Buz}Toasts aun3da1�
i aaauna €
Z �Z 185X15L poom LTszTomaC
° 1SOG I OBVM S311MV330.ONI SMO1S d0'ON SN0ISN3WIU IY1731VW 38n.Gnsis _
i
3S UmOaU 9T-tiTmaTsS JO 4TO 902:# I +7L/6T/L
N011VD01 I 313NM0 ON 11W.3d I 11Wi 3d iO 31V7 ;
�T J
of '^t`CLemlt`Telwf seftz - NO..........44.-80......... .. ..
l = OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS 6/19/80
DATE........................
....,...
0
' Certificate of Approval for Building Occupancy
tO�MIM p0�
THIS SHALL CERTIFY THAT ................... 14 16 BROWN STREET RALTY
F ......................................................
14-16 BROWN STREET
haspermission to occupy premises at........................................ .............................................,........,..,
commercial in accordance with the City of Salem
for .............................................................................. purposes,
Zoning Ordinance and Building Code, providing that this use shall conform to the terms of the application on
file in this office, and to the provisions of the Statutes, and to the City Zoning Ordinance and City Building Code. n
Any violation of any of the terms above noted is an immediate revocation of this certificate.
CITY ENGINEER WIRING INSPECTOR PLUMBING INSPECTOR GAS_INSPECTOR I FIRE DEPT, INSPc'CT Ot
Rough In trio Rough Insp ion Ro ' h Inspection Rough Insp9tion FloInspec"of
Flna nspection Final Inspection Final Inspa:.tion Final Inspecti
o
n Fi ai InsptztN d n
_ INSPECTOR OF BUILDINGS
SALEM POLICE DEPARTMENT
OFFICER'S REPORT
CASE OF 41917 DATE `J -;Z 3 . l
ADDRESS 3 f A/c,c-,:/-r O ST_ SIy.1 e
NATURE OF CASE
TIME
REPORTED BY S,; r-r f
ADDRESS S.4 rH P
OFFICER }C (A� - Ca l/a /%w,v _ •�
DETAILS OF CASE
'THP
/
S/ sac:
/ AleC'SIFl
/9 l7Pf.'i-/i' �IP J�A I,% 4P YL /G /L0 ,Pfr/ �•.N / /-/C�l�%/7 ,
:
�1 5n i.g 7-P J"J .<, � r %/-�,g l •%f-�P %9 .sem��/� P s
S� ( Tg e 1.3 o p , c_ 1c ��l �A--f2
G(i/1-7// �e i'>!rct ;.� s
v ,
%3 Pi nr S C �-�PG ✓=;f7 r, i t) TF. r/1-,Pf. cs Pte/
As3nU P A S t? 3 =i= n i i a3, J= N s
leiS1o2CA
NO OFFICER iS 9-3 OAIVl71-1.7