Loading...
MEETING PACKET AUGUST 2014 -r i i r e a CITY OF SALEM., MASSA.CHUSETT'S . . . [r- BOARD OF.HEALTH PablicHealth 120 W.,1SIIINGI'ON S`III ET,, ' Z1.,00R Prevent.Promote.rtolcon. TEL. (978)741-1800 FAX'(978)745=0343 'KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL ltamdin@salem.coni L,U2121'11AMI)IN,RS/Mi-ITS,UlO,(T-Fs { MAYOR HE,ki u AGENT i NOTICE OF MEETING You are hereby notified that the Salem Board of Health.will hold its regularly scheduled meeting Thursday August 7, 2014 at 7.00 PM rd City Hall Annex 120 Washington St 3 Floor Room 313 i MEETING AGENDA 1. Call to order , 2. Continuation of Public comment on the Board of Health Amendments to Regulation 24: Restricting the sale and use of Tobacco Products and Nicotine Delivery Products Amendments 3. Vote on Amendments to Regulation 24 a 4. Adjournment Larry Ramdin Health Agent cc: Mayor Kimberley Driscoll, Board of Health, City Councilors Next regularly scheduled meeting is September 9, 2014 at 7pm at City Hall Annex, 120 Washington Street Room 312. Know your rights under the open meeting law MGL chapter 30A ss. 18-25 and City Ordinance section 2-2028 through 2-2033 • • r .. CITY OF SALEM BOARD OF HEALTH MEETING MINUTES August 7, 2014 MEMBERS PRESENT: Dr. Barbara Poremba, Chair, Dr. Shama Alam &Dr. Danielle Ledoux, Gayle Sullivan & Paul Kirby OTHERS PRESENT: David Greenbaum, Sr. Sanitarian&Council Liaison Beth Gerard EXCUSED: Larry Ramdin Health Agent TOPIC DISCUSSION/ACTION 1. Call to Order 7:00pm Chairperson, Dr. Poremba, advises audience of the rules for the public comment section on the meeting. 2. Tobacco Regulation public Chair opens public comment at approximately 7:05pm. comment continuation Comments were received from: Sheldon Stone-Vapor Outlet Mike Allen-Red Lion Smoke Shop Marie Sweetlane - 40R Highland Ave Derek Arnold &PC -Witch Dr. • Rinus Oosthoek-Ex Director Salem Chamber Commerce Mike Lash -anti-establishment Nicole Snow Dawson- 190 Bridge Street Councilor at Large Tom Furey Brad Morin—Tedeschi Food Store Esteban Pinelou—My Convenience Grocery Councilor at Large William Legault Matt Reynolds - Lexington High School student All comments are on record at the Salem Board of Health Office The following letters were read into the record: *NECSA *Councilor Josh Turiel *Henry K Philofsky Columbia University *Testimony Ex. Dr. Steve Ryan NECSA *Petition for action against tobacco 21 Total signatures 558. Of that 119 are Salem residence *Nicole Snow Dawson Patient Advocate with MA patient's advocacy alliance All letters are available at the Salem Board of Health office Chair closed the public comment at approximately 8:55pm The Board discussed the comments and consulted with the following technical • advisors: Dr. Jonathan Winickoff, Pediatrician Joyce Redford, Director of the North Shore Tobacco and Alcohol Policy Program Cheryl Sabata- Sr. Staff Atty. -provides legal information to Boards of Health Chair Barbara Poremba read into record a prepared statement to the Board about the mission of this Board and how important it is to make decision that protect the public whether it's the popular vote or not. • Gayle Sullivan motioned that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24 section C Definition replace current definition of Minor as follows: Minor:Any individual who is under the age of twenty one (21). Also that we amend Section 2 (C)as follows: a.The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell nicotine delivery products at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The sale of nicotine delivery products to minors under 21 years of age is prohibited."The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell e-cigarettes at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The use of e-cigarettes at indoor establishments may be prohibited by local law."The notices shall be no smaller than 8.5" by 11" and shall be posted conspicuously in the retail establishment or other place in such a manner so that they may be readily seen by a person standing at or approaching the cash register.These notices shall directly face the purchaser and shall not be obstructed from view or placed at a height of less than four(4)feet or greater than nine(9)feet from the floor. 3. Identification: Each person selling or distributing tobacco or nicotine delivery products shall verify the age of the purchaser by means of valid government-issued photographic identification containing the bearer's date of birth that the purchaser is 21 years old or older.Verification is required for any person under the age of 27. Dr.Shama Alam 2nd • Board had an "in depth" discussion on motion for approximately 1 hour. Before vote was brought forward by the Chair, Dr. Ledoux asked if she had to vote. Gayle Sullivan replied that she thinks you have to vote when there is a motion. Chair called for a vote on the Motion Gayle Sullivan& Dr. Barbara Poremba voted in favor of motion Paul Kirby and Dr.Shama Alam voted against the motion Gayle Sullivan asked if Danielle was abstaining from the vote. Dr. Danielle Ledoux asked if she could. No one answered her question. Dr. Ledoux voted in favor of the motion Chair asked for the members to show their vote again for the record. Motion passed 3-2 Paul Kirby motioned that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24,Section F as follows; F. Cigar Sales Regulated: 1. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed a single cigar 2. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed any original package of two or more cigars, unless such package is priced for retail sale at$5.00 or more. 3.This Section shall not apply to: • a.The sale or distribution of any single cigar having a retail price of two dollars and fifty cents ($2.50)or more. b.A person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes to another person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes with the intent to sell or distribute outside the boundaries of Salem. 4.The Salem Board of Health may adjust from time to time the amounts specified in this Section to reflect changes in the applicable Consumer Price Index by amendment of this regulation. 2nd Gayle Sullivan—No discussion, motion passed unanimously Dr.Shama Alam motioned that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24, Section P as follows P.Violations: 1. It shall be the responsibility of the establishment, permit holder and/or his or her • business agent to ensure compliance with all sections of this regulation pertaining to his or her distribution of tobacco and/or nicotine delivery products.The violator shall receive: a. In the case of initial violations observed at an inspection within a 36 month period, a fine of one hundred dollars ($100.00) per violation. b. In the case of violations observed at the second inspection within 36 months of the date of a current violation,a fine of two hundred dollars ($200.00) per violation and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for seven(7) consecutive business days. c. In the case of violations observed at the three or more inspections within a 36 months of a current violation, a fine of three hundred dollars($300.00) and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for thirty(30) consecutive business days or the City of Salem Board of Health may revoke the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit. 2nd by Dr. Danielle Ledoux,no discussion,motion passed unanimously Dr.Shama Alam motioned that Amendments will be in effects on January 12015. Paul Kirby 2"d,all in favor, motion passed unanimously • 3. MEETING ADJOURNED: 10:10pm Respectfully submitted, Heather Lyons-Paul Clerk of the Board Next regularly scheduled meeting is September 9 2014 at 7pm At City Hall Annex, 120 Washington Street, 3'd floor Conference Room, Salem. • Salem Board of Health Regulation 24Amendment C Definition Existing: Minor:Any individual who is under the age of eighteen (18). Proposed: Minor:Any individual who is under the age of twenty one(21). Existing:Section 2(C) a. The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell nicotine delivery products at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The sale of nicotine delivery products to minors under 18 years of age is prohibited."The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell e-cigarettes at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The use of e-cigarettes at indoor establishments may be prohibited by local law."The notices shall be no smaller than 8.5"by 11"and shall be posted conspicuously in the retail establishment or other place in such a manner so that they may be readily seen by a person standing at or approaching the cash register.These notices shall directly face the purchaser and shall not be obstructed from view or placed at a height of less than four(4)feet or greater than nine(9)feet from the floor. 3. Identification: Each person selling or distributing tobacco or nicotine delivery products shall verify the age of the purchaser by means of valid government-issued photographic identification containing the bearer's date of birth that the purchaser is 18 years old or older.Verification is required for any person under the age of 27. Proposed : a. The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell nicotine delivery products at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The sale of nicotine delivery products to minors under 21 years of age is prohibited."The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell e-cigarettes at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The use of e-cigarettes at indoor establishments may be prohibited by local law."The notices shall be no smaller than 8.5"by 11"and shall be posted conspicuously in the retail establishment or other place in such a manner so that they may be readily seen by a person standing at or approaching the cash register.These notices shall directly face the purchaser and shall not be obstructed from view or placed at a height of less than four(4)feet or greater than nine(9)feet from the floor. 3. Identification: Each person selling or distributing tobacco or nicotine delivery products shall verify the age of the purchaser by means of valid government-issued photographic identification containing the bearer's date of birth that the purchaser is 21 years old or older.Verification is required for any person under the age of 27. Existing F.Cigar Sales Regulated: 1. No retailer, retail establishment,or other individual or entity shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed a cigar unless the cigar is contained in an original package of at least four(4)cigars. 2.This Section shall not apply to: a. The sale or distribution of any cigar having a retail price of more than two dollars and fifty cents b. A person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes to another person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes with the intent to sell or distribute outside the boundaries of City of Salem. 3.The Board of Health may adjust from time to time the amounts specified in this Section to reflect changes in the applicable Consumer Price Index by amendment of this regulation. Proposed F. Cigar Sales Regulated: 1. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed a single cigar. 2. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed any original package of two or more cigars,unless such package is priced for retail sale at$5.00 or more. A 3.This Section shall not apply to: a. The sale or distribution of any single cigar having a retail price of two dollars and fifty cents($2.50) or more. b. A person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes to another person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes with the intent to sell or distribute outside the boundaries of Salem. 4.The Salem Board of Health may adjust from time to time the amounts specified in this Section to reflect changes in the applicable Consumer Price Index by amendment of this regulation. Existing P(1) P.Violations: • 1. It shall be the responsibility of the establishment,permit holder and/or his or her business agent to ensure compliance with all sections of this regulation pertaining to his or her distribution of tobacco and/or nicotine delivery products.The violator shall receive: a. In the case of a first violation,a fine of one hundred dollars($100.00). b. in the case of a second violation within 36 months of the date of the current violation,a fine of two hundred dollars($200.00)and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for seven (7)consecutive business days. c. In the case of three or more violations within a 36 month period,a fine of three hundred dollars($300.00)and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for thirty(30)consecutive business days or the City of Salem Board of Health may revoke the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit. Proposed k P.Violations: 1. It shall be the responsibility of the establishment, permit holder and/or his or her business agent to ensure compliance with all sections of this regulation pertaining to his or her distribution of tobacco and/or nicotine delivery products.The violator shall receive: d. In the case of initial violations observed at an inspection within a 36 month period,a fine of one hundred dollars($100.00)per violation. n e. In the case of violations observed at the second inspe ction within 36 months of the date of the current violation,a fine of two hundred dollars($200.00)per violation and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for seven (7) consecutive business days. f. In the case of violations observed at the three or more inspections within a 36 months of a current violation,a fine of three hundred dollars($300.00)and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for thirty(30)consecutive business days or the City of Salem Board of Health may revoke the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit. • Salem Board of Health Regulation 24 Amendment • I move that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24 section C Definition replace current definition of Minor as follows Minor:Any individual who is under the age of twenty one (21). Also that we amend Section 2(C)as follows : a. The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell nicotine delivery products at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The sale of nicotine delivery products to minors under 21 years of age is prohibited."The owner or other person in charge of a shop or other place used to sell e-cigarettes at retail shall conspicuously post a sign stating that"The use of e-cigarettes at indoor establishments may be prohibited by local law."The notices shall be no smaller than 8.5" by 11"and shall be posted conspicuously in the retail establishment or other place in such a manner so that they may be readily seen by a person standing at or approaching the cash register.These notices shall directly face the purchaser and shall not be obstructed from view or placed at a height of less than four (4)feet or greater than nine (9)feet from the floor. 3. Identification: Each person selling or distributing tobacco or nicotine deliver products shall verify the • p g g delivery Y age of the purchaser by means of valid government-issued photographic identification containing the bearer's date of birth that the purchaser is 21 years old or older.Verification is required for any person under the age of 27. Motion Made by: Seconded: Vote: I move that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24,Section F as follows F.Cigar Sales Regulated: F. Cigar Sales Regulated: 1. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed a single cigar 2. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed any original package of two or more cigars, unless such package is priced for retail sale at$5.00 or more. 3.This Section shall not apply to: a. The sale or distribution of any single cigar having a retail price of two dollars and fifty cents ($2.50) or more. b. A person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes to another person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes with the intent to sell or distribute outside the boundaries of Salem. 4.The Salem Board of Health may adjust from time to time the amounts specified in this Section to reflect changes in the applicable Consumer Price Index by amendment of this regulation. Motion Made by: Seconded: Vote: Motion: I move that we ament Salem Board of Health Regulation 24,Section P as follows P.Violations: 1. It shall be the responsibility of the establishment, permit holder and/or his or her business agent to ensure compliance with all sections of this regulation pertaining to his or her distribution of tobacco and/or nicotine delivery products.The violator shall receive: a. In the case of initial violations observed at an inspection within a 36 month period,a fine of one hundred dollars($100.00)per violation. • b. In the case of violations observed at the second inspection within 36 months of the date of a current violation,a fine of two hundred dollars ($200.00) per violation and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for seven (7) consecutive business days. c. In the case of violations observed at the three or more inspections within a 36 months of a current violation, a fine of three hundred dollars ($300.00) and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for thirty(30)consecutive business days or the City of Salem Board of Health may revoke the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit. Motion Made by: Seconded: Vote: Alternative to amendment to Section P( better as an explanation of the amendment) In cases where multiple violations at the same time occur,any additional monetary fines to be assessed shall be the same amount as the initial violation amount, but only the initial violation will be used to calculate permit suspensions. • i I move that we amend Salem Board of Health Regulation 24,Section F as follows F.Cigar Sales Regulated: F. Cigar Sales Regulated: 1. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed a single cigar 2. No person shall sell or distribute or cause to be sold or distributed any original package of two or more cigars, unless such package is priced for retail sale at$5.00 or more. 3.This Section shall not apply to: a. The sale or distribution of any single cigar having a retail price of two dollars and fifty cents($2.50) or more. b. A person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial purposes to another person or entity engaged in the business of selling or distributing cigars for commercial • purposes with the intent to sell or distribute outside the boundaries of Salem. 4.The Salem Board of Health may adjust from time to time the amounts specified in this Section to reflect changes in the applicable Consumer Price Index by amendment of this regulation. Motion Made by: Seconded: Vote: Motion: I move that we ament Salem Board of Health Regulation 24,Section P as follows P.Violations: 1. It shall be the responsibility of the establishment, permit holder and/or his or her business agent to ensure compliance with all sections of this regulation pertaining to his or her distribution of tobacco and/or nicotine delivery products.The violator shall receive: a. In the case of initial violations observed at an inspection within a 36 month period,a fine of one hundred dollars($100.00)per violation. b. In the case of violations observed at the second inspection within 36 months of the date of a current violation,a fine of two hundred dollars($200.00) per violation and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for seven (7) consecutive business days. c. In the case of violations observed at the three or more inspections within a 36 months of a current violation,a fine of three hundred dollars ($300.00)and the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit shall be suspended for thirty(30)consecutive business days or the City of Salem Board of Health may revoke the Tobacco and Nicotine Delivery Product Sales Permit. Motion Made by: Seconded: Vote: Public Comments from BOH meeting 8/7/14 Sheldon Stone co-owner of The Vapor Outlet I opened store 3 months ago. Had he know this was going to arrive; I definitely wouldn't have come to Salem. In talking to several people, and that's why we don't have many attending, is because after getting your notice they felt that you've already made your determination of what you are going to do. And I think we can stand here all day and give you different reasons and it wouldn't change your feelings. However, I want to ask you two questions. By raising the age from 18 to 21 preventing those smokers from purchasing tobacco in Salem to you honestly believe they won't go a mile or two to Lynn or Peabody or some other town to obtain cigarettes.. You must know that is precisely what they will do. My second question is; have you done any research on how many smoking have been successful in getting off tobacco to using electronic cigarettes. I'll bet you haven't. But I can tell you that the short time we have been in business we've had customers do so. By banning electronic cigarettes you will not only fail in reducing nicotine consumption among that group between ages 18 to 21 but you will succeed in preventing electronic cigarettes from helping them to get free of tobacco and destructive nicotine. Before you ration and act the amendment, rather than a few people in the Health Department making this decision and by your admission there are only five that are involved, you ought to put this before the people of Salem in a referendum in order to have a full and open debate on this important question. I can tell you from my own experience that we have a lot of females coming in, 30%to 40%of our business. And they come in, they don't want to smoke cigarettes anymore but they do want to vapor. And by vaporing you have a degree of nicotine that goes from 24 to 0%. 1 vapor myself at 0% and the women do the same thing because they don't want to start up smoking cigarettes. And your notifications were very explicit on mentioning vapor cigarettes. Now if you wanted something very constructive and the state would mandate this then I'd say that would be fine. Mike Allen owner of Red Lion Smoke Shop We allow people to vote and defend but they cannot chose to make a decision on tobacco is unreasonable. Although that is true for alcohol it is done universally so no community is at a disadvantage. How we rent a hotel room is done by a private company not be regulation or laws. I believe the proposed regulation does not have its intended outcome. Is only going to stop using tobacco because they are inconvenienced by having to go to a neighboring community. The proposed regulation will not affect the SSU nontobacco use policy, it will not affect senior housing, it will not affect places where people can and cannot smoke, and it will not affect people who hate tobacco. These people are not stake holders for this proposed regulation. The parole that was made between this smoking regulation and smoking ban years ago regarding restaurants in Salem is also not valid since restaurants do not sell tobacco. We bill Salem as a tourist destination. We will now be telling tourists those who can purchase tobacco legally elsewhere are now being sent out of Salem to shop. I have been in the business for over 40 years, almost 34 in Salem. My belief is that the only result of this proposed regulation will be to drive business away from Salem businesses to neighboring communities and would be considerably more than just tobacco sales. The economy is not so great to even have to give up a small part of our revenue that it will be more than a loss in tobacco sales. The unintended consequence is a loss in sales of magazines batteries candy gasoline and other merchandise. Shoppers will rather • shop in one location than go to many to purchase all that they need. Please don't make us an island. Let Salem businesses have a level playing field Marie Sweetlane 40r Highland Ave I feel that at 18 you can fight a war•, you have to register to vote so why not sell cigarettes to these people. You're not making the right decision. You are a tourist destination. I am not American born. Europeans think you're stupid. I don't want me taxes to go up anymore. Please do not do this. I beg you. Derek Arnold Witch Dr. My attorney advised me not to speak. I just want to let you know I have a bellybutton. PC Nicaloci Witch Dr. I also have an elbow. My words have no meaning in these meetings. I've seen it time and time again so I have nothing else to say. Rinus Executive Director of the Salem Chamber of Commerce I do represent businesses in Salem that sell tobacco, clothing, food,toys and a host of many other products that are legal in the United States. What is happening tonight is that the Salem Board of Health is contributing in making Salem an island. This will essentially make Salem a lesser city to do business in. And as a speaker said before we have new business and business that have been here a long time that will be hurt by this decision. People will go outside the city to buy According to the surgeon general 9 out of 10 have started before 18. The goal is to not have them start before then by informing them of the dangers and your efforts should be focused on that point of view. If I am correct you are still legal to smoke them at 18; then I don't understand why you are trying to make it illegal to purchase We want Salem to be a far place to do business. Mike Lash- anti-establishment As I think Beth Gerard might have in her posession candy cigarettes that were outlawed nine years ago. You can pass them around if anyone wants to look at the candy cigarettes. But feel free to continue your toothless attact on tobacco. You don;t have the man power you dont have the reasonablity to enorce these laws but you do have the odacity to put these laws on the books and further continue the problems of tobacco use. Once agian your giving the forbidden fruit up there were those beautiful 18 yr olds to try to get. It doesn't work. the War on drupgs doesn't work. Tobacco is a drug. Why are we wasting tie trying to stop it. You wont. It going to cont and your going to be selfdefeting in the closing or inticing of this forbidden object. nicole snow dawson 190 bridge street I'm a patient advocate with a Massachusetts again NECYS and I'm also a patient. I read the ordinancne and some of the langauge might have unintended consequences. These picutures are to help guide me through my discussion here. Chadmore is ninetewen years old and he lives in CO.He uses a vap pen or an e-cigeratee to inhalemedical canibus. The 2nd page is of Charolette Fay she's 5 yrs old. the Fay family are medical canibus representative. They had to move to CO to get the prescription their daughter needs. She has a sezure disorder that would give her up to 100 a day. And she does not have them anymore because of cannibas. and on the last page in a kidney patient who's using a vapor to help with the nausea that comes with the treatment of cancer. Cancer is a very heard illness and canibus has been one way to combat the side effects of kemo therapy. Nausea I know is vert debilitating because I am a patient myself suffering from multiple car accidents, neck injuries. I have muscle spasms in my neck nausea. These pieces of equipment that they using are vaporization products. And other language you have here in this amendment, 21 and under will not be able to purchase vaporization devises at as medical dispensary or store. Please I am asking the department to look further into this and see if there will be any unintended consequences for patients. The dispensaries haven't opend yet. At 17 you will be able to purchase these with a parent but at 18 you will not. Thank you Tom Furey Councilor at Large Congratulate your stance on this issue restaurants are now flourishing an island - we need to send a message the board has a voice tobacco is a gate way drug to other illegal drugs Brad Morin no comment Esteban No Comment Councilor Leagult Applaud you all for your due diligence Vet 30 years in cousin that's going into soon- has every right to defend his country and come back with physical damage. this legislation is not terrible it's just backwards. Matt Renalds 17 years old Lexington High involve in movement to raise 21 ramped in high school how is this legal to smoke at 14 just a restriction to buy them 8%of senior class is 19 - tobacco industries is brilliant strength of our noises mouth or stronger than our minds it would cut of supply to high school students Dear Members of the Board, I understand and empathize with the desire to reduce smoking-both of adults and of underage smokers. I think reducing smoking rates is laudable. I don't think, however,that raising the age for tobacco purchases to 21 is ultimately an effective way of doing that. Given that the legal age for the possession and use of tobacco remains 18, I believe all we are doing is applying an additional burden to Salem businesses that sell tobacco and tobacco products.Were there a state-wide initiative to make the age for tobacco use higher, I'd likely be more supportive towards this measure before you. I think there are better ways to reduce tobacco use and presence in the city that the Board would be better-served in considering. Requiring the use of cigarette disposal poles and making sure that their use is enforced (most businesses already do have them) at bars. Banning tobacco use in some or all of our city parks.These would have more value in my eyes than a measure that simply makes a minor change at best to buying habits. Salem was a public health leader when we banned tobacco use in restaurants and bars.That was a wonderful accomplishment that improved the city for virtually all and set a path that most communities now follow. I believe this measure before you, however,does not have a comparable impact since it does not really affect the smokers themselves - it simply makes it more difficult for the businesses that legally sell tobacco to remain good citizens. Thank you for your consideration. Josh Turiel, Councillor Ward 5 City of Salem Sian in Sheet for Tobacco Sales Regulation "Please print information" 8/7/2014 Name (print) Street Address Establishment C%6 el F r, V c o Al crN 04.- Sign in Sheet for Tobacco Sales Regulation "Please print information'" 8/7/2014 NAME (PRINT) STREET ADDRESS ESTABLISHMENT a r•v 72 S"00 4 Sign in Sheet for Tobacco Sales Regulation "Please print information" 8/7/2014 Name (print) Street Address Establishment w e- /21 4 S-� L- Atrg Alt 4'1­4 c A Ir,o �� e of c- V l caw�d �b � Name Establishment Contact Info LAJLTZH ZJ Fy- S,Fqe6DOL) a0pt v APO 19 121 XdA6411 'T 7 '5 0-7 SAS Name Establishment Contact Info C1124 4rL v f aw CCU C PETITION FOR ACTION SALEM, MA Petition summary I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matter. I can sit on a jury. I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and actions. The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board-of Health has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City of Salem not to follow the Board of Health's recommendations. Action petitioned We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting our right for to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME ZIP code Comment VA V-0 600 C ep!�`'•1 � e"a,C e -�Or �u(I$ SFOu, Wars-IU0\d.1c n/H 7a Tke S}fvg yl e 1S mac{I cl -70 VA Zls� p \ � \J C[C,, z (� a o f 7 G 4 NA AlZ [rfc�o 0 p 'C D1 q�I Ici PalliLk dadvoln� V I 1- a0��� 2 c) io nc�e �,Q / b,r�h getz neon � �MD� \01b I a e a�� 1$ WQ S � ouldn '-� need l d l 3 �0 wa14 (Aril 10oi 2� c��. Q �� 1 1—� ckolc- . PETITION FOR ACTION SALEM, MA Petition summary I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matter. I can sit on a jury. ,, I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and actions. The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board of Health,has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City of Salem not to follow the Board of Health's recommendations. Action petitioned We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting our right for to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME ZIP code Comment A Y fJJL p-(,hti a��0 • 1 Q14bo r. PETITION FOR ACTION SALEM, MA Petition summary I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matters. I can sit on a jury. I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and r actions The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board of Health has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City of Salem not to follow the Board of health's recommendations. Action petitioned,' We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting my right to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME ZIP cone Comment r � �,�� o3oxj w A2Fy0J TLI�ti 124 ate- nM drk APT-) kP 0) gALLJL,,,k �-,Xt V C ' Q OVY- p O/ C , �a I-v) 4 ,I�o 1(6h e r PQCp� �w— X11(4n �lVpla-I-IV.,ljDle�o qr4i 01qqG De4wl:A _C \� 0� PETITION FOR ACTION SALEM, MA Petition summary= I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matters. I can sit on a jury. I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and y' actions The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board of Health has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City-of Salem not to follow the Board of health's recommendations. Action petitioned ' We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting my right tot", to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME :ZIP code Comments ,, .. . en C) s ova M OL l� �l 170 Fo'��SSr�n 4S 5�'►�ok� as t�e�l tp,/- 0 � 1 q 71 3q Q9 Cori Cri,2 o a(-"Go� ♦ S PETITION FOR ACTION SALEM, MA Petition-summary * I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background ' I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matters. I can sit on a jury. I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and actions The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board of Health has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City of Salem not to follow the Board of health's recommendations. Action petitioned We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting my right for: to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME C Z1P codle ;: omment T .. I )ia,v, r-V— e-Ac 10, a­7 v hl f q yoct )0/ 0-A qq Jon Ai_ ,( vw d L4 S go S� V�/VIP PETITION FOR ACTION • SALEM, MA Petition summary I'M 18 YEARS OLD OR OLDER AND I VOTE. and background I can die for my country. I am deemed as an adult in all legal matter. I can sit on a jury. I can marry whomever I choose. I am responsible for my own debts and actions. The Salem Board of Health is introducing a City proposal limiting my freedom of choice. The Salem Board of Health has a proposal that will limit my health care choices. I am very disappointed in the decisions of Salem's Board of Health. I ask the City of Salem not to follow the Board of Health's recommendations. Action petitioned We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to stop limiting our right for to freedoms of choice as an adult. NAME ZIP code Comment JC L \J t0 L rcl,,A l Q,,)►/enc.— o l 9 Za Z)i cTAT e-: rn I iPe. �41 , Oil � � �Sccen 0 06 ) rch�el �Zk ��2 NO -1--: ujo L,)d had-e Aaxon �Jm-e_� -7 Gk°`,`, Z 4 L la,0 ` add 3 yea rS • NAME ZIP code Comment di�Neen6 M\ ko,,a I Cf. C- J k Maws 0/ 96 4- �V) R0-2 Ap �(0 Mot no S e vt S'e-. • Ceh �-o wof .� os 4 je cot- 1 1 a �l9 83 OL-b5 �>q � X av vS�cN V?U. Dl� 3U 062-4 - I omm NAME ZIPcode` Cent G� k� (AA A-- C 5k,14- � S Z0 1 � Z b s L it ©/W fl, l?e p1 C pI q I.S- del I vu OA/V� 40", vl �2 d 0 7- C.'O'h 9to fd wa( bot Alulo 1 �v► H , NAME ZIPcode Comment - `� ,�� ON 4o l o 1 >�- �19 (0 c)4z--- <2,,� fq 60 . tqo7 61 R�6 • i NAME ZIP code Comment Dt-fem it SN.hj-loioc,h © 1 WOLLO ! cm Qalyk- a ct Q n w A-R mio Ca o° 0 ( 5 LA 70L TJ � o ( t4vc�rn2�,— 6 �� � � - c rc, z l 7 �a/*� Awla 3 C) 01930 J+s O-S ; h i 0(2 CO JO�n Acr--esLd 19 (v firc P.��f ^,vs4 s4op c(;cAO-41 his w� YO J CL- VQo V, A, 7 AN Q F /ba V 0 I S r� v e Po l NAME ZIP code Comment � ��wh 1�ti4���d�c�s� ti►�n ►►� t�r�,,�>c 01590 Vance U-brei\- 0\q"to � encu (I '�9 6 m�&Vw O l i COA %tZAQ90S o t(�o DOK)T6HAA) 6C- I CA90� C;o Sc w I \14 I ake -n S W Se O( q3C) 0► q0( I on I A) Clcl 0 . se- j -e uel o lye< � filn(l ii Z" v 0f 5 �.. NAME ZIP code Comment '(2e OS�Pa^ c) COO�7 01e( 62 11� alq � � occ ' u` jsso Q \Q\ S 0 L� 1Ac q N � (�Q -F Corco* Gl 4�1 tiD o1q�0 Ia-7o (Cl VD S T� � N c k�Xx Oc, q � Iq a3 NAME ZIP code Comment a �4SOlqSlb14- i-,scuremo �&) k, acW T41 Aa, �ourkoutis ()VA'Ole- fj 6193 (S2 Lucas Lnf7AL O/S3 �e 7��eol , d o-M l cA-ssl(,e D 19 9z rAAA D I gr�, a, I)";n o a s +00 he �) �'i ►� e, u) vV-e Olm OA eve 1, MIS a� I'(-v �O US 0) NAME ZIP code Comment jq A.4�w • c ,f I dv4l Y,414 G /J\,/ 01q -5 • 01930 O1gl s JDO 5 UC.r cs 01 W 11"4t • NAME ZIP code Comment D (NCO C) \C'Mili/ 1 i am CAS ALx ft�js <4b 7 � f o q 02 o� o UgOD" 0 Vq 70 A HA, A 16 kn C�(Nw euc Is C.,` Q � cJN _ NAME ZIP code Comment g&a a IDom,'61C n rivet+ 0l 2 3 C'e mi (]� 6 1 [p ynJ c 6, Ot6 e.lioulV� (v tow r s�c of o,�r I v� ffic c( 2 5 P� 1�v1 e Mo )F *4kp )V" cL, C1,11 Dark w Q ('R 2q apV\jk%s OJ 9 70 l;hf�S Co �4ro \Q.�7w\ C� qo�- NAME ZIP code Comment �N,�u3y)i-6L L n I Q(Ob KlAQe* Poe 01�66 A 56f\ ip• T Bend , Sell 0 I KQ RAN13 �JCIV441 f ICAA G�one 0lGj~jO 3e&se 0 R3 C) • 4"r OICI 3O q+c Q 01070 V/,/P PCCr'av 0107 NAME ZIP code Comment • 0 r"13o c>l s 4m (,v , O 1 01 Y 5 CA ( 1101 MIL I 01115 C6v►s�� U�ohyl t, 7-o q3 v • G� �(Qs lea 1 9 NS I C'av� ot,c e �,� y�,�• . U� s,er 0 1 9 70 C 0 0(17D • O�q NAME ZIP code Comment �� ► 7l zQi/b 1�7ree40 w, G�. Vra Cote bl b4 %famoll- 0) o Yll ,c e C IIC�C , D"IJ � V1�ii��f1 � �{tiuer' �lR,�un � ju.eZ-c w'tiA ��SuQQtr }�►.Swcc hL 5 �I'�I:c�l' S��cS an UUM Gl COL nCCA CI��; NAME ZIP code Comment 01 jw &tl 0 i 0 FO (�--�,je (A , A- Ol q 70 3t)(161TY0, a0 o l a- Cb l 6 t s af) OAv1 V 6eokr\ CM G 1 4-�e f hh < < Cad 4—rA fk Ok I/90A DG�D� VU& YO t(xk(d N 1U,P-k 61 Q ,A , oa GC �,��� 019gr `YOe- U Q lq 70 ( q-16 �a Fes ©1 cl O Ci lq76 of C�01�p t A O(An,J Fv-v-ra4- D l l ( � a C', e�/IO Kill W wn/ `� aas i 9 o 2 NAME ZIP code Comment nC �ekgNCO;S ����� a� f o ff do ��l �►s��,►a�✓,' q I 5 0� b 1 �Ss lly oxncr-e- IF ffil �J 0 I �3 �rea K�anCl n - Y 144el VjI� 6( 9r� Iive fvee � T) rC--- bn\��\n N'� (o\qn0 ee lass-o •{�2n tNI�H o1y 1S' 0/ /.sue c 197041(Od 90 Ol I 1-� Mejjndwlclrroo,lA— Olq 5 A/tj WO 6� • JC�SiCa PrapafK of q O 6 NAME ZIP code Comment E, c9 l M A r K \Ao\wlftlt4� 0 70 CdoAi r,c i- tok,.t +o ge Jrw�� 4 a5 C) / q S Ifile- a 1 9 5-3 Sables Puy) Ojq 7 () _ \j Or\-\� q\ vJ'� 0 16 b SU Cc�t�� QUA �S © 1 a G® S PI vsZ!ee p AL rev C� �o C� jq 6 l� �6.f ✓ GASqly OT v,e G ki-Aer\ o i ci (S TAak , �17IC� /a" a 01770 R,d C" I(S LA -FOAK �D—ao j wiT 1�0t' k I C4 0 S US 0) q70 D v v-L, 13 OOOA�i PG ORG NAME ZIP code Comment n Gh�ss� 0 i�t23 O'All s C) 4a-v►� 6e.v \ \ o OOr)Or—l\ 019 00 Lk OlBf\jq � vv, '&astikw d i 4 0 F�IeAVYN of ciao,« . �,Nn(PV lcdhaw 01 �a1 P4kL hal"1&5 del l4va.ScQ f q S owe a flee 6hd C-6IID v 21 is is e-e rf-cci a �G.vl Z d Sal a W-1-CA &td &)Se n 7ZL 0 lct 15 kcsoovc�,--s • v RA V. -Q.-1 c. NAME ZIP code Comment OM LA O«30 0/S 7d MR ofbS f G kOC4? as 0 (q v NAME ZIP code Comment Tiwr 0 iq-2 C919 70 10 , �t f�r/f-�G����Sn�✓ a«�f 0 1 /M/l&V'v jof-p-AlID PAO Oust 0 a NAME ZIP code: Comment, 91 ✓t K v9pt l ® Acc ojgS -7 DI�D OALk W-7 'AA9 (c, i os vi Gclo no rn ONO e e/-k 4 is AM, Museop � " O)q6,o y NAME ZIP;code; Comment oL7 Z6 r--".Ihdo Ellis q0 1 Ica 0I a 73renjct7 '13t,� en o 1 y 7 0 ,D- 0 . l Cal (o0 l az 01�6 o1 qdz o Wo NAME- Z1P-,cage Comrrient - � ►a �. ofIq 0 �AQ,r; i O Acbericx. 01107 a/ g/ o V`IC cx L LoCV-Cl\r j .q NAME ZIPcode. = Comment_ �1�II�Grn � �e olglo 01 g7c7 AmanC(OL (CA 0!9 0-7 C. cam' O c o 1 • I,i.Z a\) n k°Il col c e olc�co At-lul �� olq6o NAME; ZIP>codeR: Comment .t.: 1M QW o 19oa -m loc�c/ 50 ,A— 01170 ti o I cl -4a( I br- `-+C-1 Cc�n �►1� fl � JV- U t .7 es Q o 6.c• fWW4V 6025 2 �Ntw ►l . L'U'd s tit h .1 ¢, 10 b �- f- r,%,C e T O 7C) k,%.A `l J J 4 NAME code °;Comment �: � C) z 2A�7 1 � Yoc) 4a C) 1 S q