The URL can be used to link to this page

Salem Probate and Family Court Renovation - July 24, 2012dcam & aotcSALEM PROBATE & FAMILY COURT RENOVATIONperry dean rogers | partners architectsjuly 24, 2012trc1209 st1 july 24, 2012TODAY’S AGENDA1. introductions Team Experience Experience with Relevant Historic Projects2. project overview Framing the Issue: Goals and Approach Program Development 3. historic considerations Character-deﬁ ning features4. sustainable design5. questions Mechanical Engineer (M/P/FP)BVH Integrated ServicesGeorge Iskra, P.E., PresidentThomas Iskra, P.E., Proj ManagerLandscape ArchitectCarol R. Johnson AssociatesJohn Amodeo, ASLA, LEED APJohnathan Law, AssociateElectrical EngineerBVH Integrated ServicesMichael Pang, P.E.Speciﬁ cations ConsultantKalin AssociatesMark Kalin FAIA FCSI LEED, PresidentHistoric Preservation SpecialistBuilding Conservation Associates, Inc.Andrea M. Gilmore, DirectorCory Trembath, Sr ConservatorStructural EngineerLim Consultants, Inc. Susan Burkhardt, P.E., PrincipalCost EstimatorFaithful+GouldPaul Male, Senior Vice PresidentCivil EngineerNitsch EngineeringAnthony Donato, P.E., CFM, LEED APTim McGivern. P.E.MA Building Code ConsultantRolf Jensen & AssociatesCarl Nelson, P.E.OUR TEAMperry dean rogers | partners architectsMartha Pilgreen Principal-in-ChargeTom McCartySenior Project ManagerAnne BrockelmanProject ManagerRyan SenkierProject ArchitectSalem Probate & Family CourtDCAMShirin Karanﬁ loglu, Director of ProgrammingElayne Campos, Deputy DirectorBob Barry, Deputy Director, ConstructionAnn Schiro, Project ManagerPaul Ford, Project Manager, ConstructionJeff Novak, Project EngineerAOTCRichard L’Heureux, Project Manager Kim Wright, Court Administrator Pamela O’Brien, Register of Probatejuly 24, 2012 HISTORIC AGENCIES SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION GUIDELINES NOTEBOOK MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSIONWilliam Francis GalvinSecretary of the Commonwealthjuly 24, 2012 OVERVIEW OF RELEVANT HISTORIC PROJECTSPERRY DEAN ROGERS | PARTNERS ARCHITECTSBUILDING CONSERVATION ASSOCIATESBVH INTEGRATED SERVICESjuly 24, 2012 PART OF PERRY DEAN’S LEGACY AfterBeforecolonial williamsburg:over 85 buildings restoredrelevant historic projectsjuly 24, 2012 99 RENOVATION/RESTORATION PROJECTS1990199220021926-19522002199819921985198719861998perry dean’s relevant experience25 projects on the national register of historic places1985200419982009july 24, 2012 relevant historic projects•Buildingtechnologyfirm,foundedin1985•Specializeintherestoration,preservation,andconservationofhistoricbuildingsandworksofart•Detailedknowledgeofandextensiveexperienceinbuildingmaterials•ViewbuildingpreservationasakeycomponentofsustainableandenergyͲefficientdesign•Extensiveexperiencewithlocal,state,andfederalhistoriccommissionsandregulationsBuildingConservationAssociates,Inc.•ConditionsAssessment•ResearchandDocumentation•StrategicPlanning•RestorationDesign•MaterialsConsultation•ConstructionAdministration•InspectionServicesjuly 24, 2012 SelectedRelevantProjectsMassachusettsStateHouse,Boston,MA•Comprehensiveinteriorsurvey•HistoricValueRankingsof2007MasterPlan•FinishesstudiesinSenateReadingRoomandHouseofRepresentativesSuite•PlasterconservationsurveysinSenateReadingRoomandHouseChamberjuly 24, 2012 SelectedRelevantProjectsStarrͲAxinn Center,MiddleburyCollege,Middlebury,VT•Restorationof1927and1957Buildingsaspartofadaptivereuseproject•Existingconditionssurvey•Constructiondocuments•Projectmonitoring•RecipientofBostonSocietyofArchitects2009SustainableDesignAwardjuly 24, 2012 SelectedRelevantProjectsNewHavenSuperiorCourthouse,NewHaven,CT•HistoricalRestorationStudy•Archivalresearch•Finishesanalysis•Documentationanddevelopmentofcomprehensivedatabaseofallinteriorandexteriorbuildingmaterials•PreparationofNationalRegisternominationjuly 24, 2012 SPECIFIC RELEVANT EXPERIENCE PERRY DEAN ROGERS | PARTNERS ARCHITECTSjuly 24, 2012 relevant project experienceDCAM Award for Design Excellence 2008PLYMOUTH TRIAL COURTrelevant experiencejuly 24, 2012 LAWRENCE SUPERIOR COURTHOUSErelevant experiencejuly 24, 2012 BAKER HOUSE, MITAFTERBEFORErelevant experiencejuly 24, 2012 BAKER HOUSE, MITAFTERBEFORErelevant experiencejuly 24, 2012 YALE - BRANFORD AND SAYBROOK COLLEGEScomparable projectPerry Dean • BVH • BCARelevance to Salem Probate & Family Court Project:• Restoration; Working within historical context• Multiple constituencies• Multi-disciplinary consultant group • Formulation of goals and workplan preparation• Existing conditions assessment• Comprehensive building systems analysis & upgrade• Universal Design• Energy savings analysis / Sustainable design• Comprehensive Feasibility StudySALEM PFCjuly 24, 2012 comparable projectYALE SALEM PFCjuly 24, 2012 comparable projectSALEM PFC YALEjuly 24, 2012 comparable projectYALE - BRANFORD AND SAYBROOK COLLEGESjuly 24, 2012 YALE - BRANFORD AND SAYBROOK COLLEGEScomparable projectBeforeBeforeBRANFORD DINING HALL• Disassembling the panelsjuly 24, 2012 YALE - BRANFORD AND SAYBROOK COLLEGEScomparable projectAfterMid-Point• Reassembling the roomjuly 24, 2012 TODAY’S AGENDA1. introductions Team Experience Experience with Relevant Historic Projects2. project overview Framing the Issue: Goals and Approach Program Development 3. historic considerations Character-deﬁ ning features4. sustainable design5. questions july 24, 2012 • Support the mission, organization and operations of the User Agency.• Design buildings that respect and reﬂ ect local urban design considerations.• Ensure that the Commonwealth’s buildings balance short- and long-term beneﬁ ts and costs to ensure long-term useful life and capacity for future changes in operation and use.• Employ Universal Design principles.• Achieve a degree of sustainability that minimizes negative environmental impact and maximizes features that conserve natural resources.• Make public buildings that convey a public spirit, civic-mindedness, innovation, accessibility and social permanence.DCAM GOALS FOR COURTHOUSE DESIGNjuly 24, 2012 AOTC GOALS FOR COURTHOUSE DESIGN• Provide efﬁ cient and cost-effective judicial services to the public.• Design a facility that supports the courts functions efﬁ ciently. • Reinforce the importance of the court in society as a place where citizens participate in the justice system.• Ensure the safety and security of all court staff and users.• Enhance the delivery of justice by using technology to provide court users with an array of options to assist in court-related business and practices efﬁ cient collection, analysis and communication of information.• To provide the best work environment for the health and well-being of the court staff as well as the public.july 24, 2012 e,PROJECT LOCATIONjuly 24, 2012salem probate & family court36 Federal StreetSalem, MA1912 pfc1979 additionjuly 24, 2012 UNDERSTANDING THE VISIONTo build upon the existing body of work and achieve consensus through an understanding of the PFC’s needs with multiple strategies and to provide a sensitive rehabilitation of historical components.july 24, 2012 july 24, 2012july 24, 2012 july 24, 2012july 24, 2012 FRAMING THE ISSUE july 24, 2012goals • Understand current programmatic and functional needs of the Trial Court, and Probate & Family Court Department in Essex County, Salem.• A certiﬁ ed study and conceptual design for the renovation of the existing PFC building• Review and provide economical solution for Temporary Space for PFC operations during the renovation• Analyze and recommend a separate Heating Plant for adjacent Superior Court and County Commissioner’s Buildingschallenges• To accommodate the needs of a contemporary courthouse within an existing building while retaining its historic character and distinctiveness• To carefully evaluate program needs for the PFC in the context of Essex County, while also considering the adjacent Ruane Judicial Center as an asset to be leveraged PROGRAMMING ISSUES:• Right-sizing; afﬁ rming the PFC’s needs in the context of Essex County and the Ruane Judicial Center• Accommodating large, contemporary courtrooms in existing historic envelope• Secure circulation: maintaining separation of public, staff & detainees - New stair locationsjuly 24, 2012CHALLENGES / CONSTRAINTS THE PROBATE & FAMILY COURT PROGRAMUSER POPULATION:• General Public Jurors Litigants, Pro Se Litigants Detainees Researchers Victims; Witnesses Advocates Press / Media Clinicians; Social Services Families - All age groups• Courts Personnel & Staff Judges Clerk Magistrate Probation Ofﬁ cers Register of Probate Court Ofﬁ cers Building Management Court Interpreters Court Reporters IT & other support• Professionals Defense Attorneys Prosecutors Mental health workers Advocates Mediators• District Attorneys & ADA’s• Public Safety Ofﬁ cers• Service Providers Couriers Maintenance & Concession Vendors Translators Child care providersPROGRAMS SUPPORTED BY THE PFC:• Department of Revenue (DOR)• Family Law / Pro Se Center• Alternative Dispute Resolutionjuly 24, 2012 MEETING THE PROGRAM july 24, 2012• Alternative Dispute Resolution• Un-represented Litigants (Pro Se)• Information Technology• Social Servicessalem pfc issues:• Department of Revenue - “DOR Day” - Must accommodate large surge of patrons every other week: shared, dual-use spaces - Use Hearing Room, Pre-Trial Conference Rooms, Waiting Areas• Family Law / Pro Se Center - Reliance on Registry of Probate staff to oversee Public Research Area; share conference rooms - Share/combine Public Waiting/Transaction areas with Probate• Detainees - Low anticipated detainee use; - Share secure circulation (corridor & elevator) with judges & staffkey issues in contemporary courthouses • Diverse user groups• Separate zones of circulation• Multiple entry points• Security DEPARTMENT DEPARTMENT GROSS SQ FTCourt sets (4 Courtrooms) 11,875 Court Support & Holding 696 (includes Court Ofﬁ cers; Detainee Holding)Judicial Ofﬁ ces & Support 3,931Register of Probate 11,544 (includes approx 4,000s sf high-density Records Storage)Probate Probation 7,618Entry / Lobby Area 1,279 Supplemental Operations 1,635 (includes Pro Se/Family Law Center, DOR)Secure Waiting 455 Building Support 6,003 TOTAL 45,036 Dept GSF 1912 Probate & Family Court: 50,000 GSF1979 Addition 27,000 GSF = 77,000 GSF TOTAL EXISTING = 58% Target Efﬁ ciencyPROGRAM DEVELOPMENTjuly 24, 2012(2 large courtrooms @ 2,000 sf seating 50-60 spectators 2 small courtrooms @ 1,400 sf seating 25-30 spectators) PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT | Depts by Size (GSF)45,036 Total Dept GSFjuly 24, 201211,875Court Sets6963,93111,544Reg of Probate7,618Probation1,2791,635455 6,003Court sets (4)Court Support & Holding Judicial Ofﬁ ces & SupportRegister of Probate Probate Probation Entry / Lobby Area Supplemental Operations Secure Waiting Building Supportjuly 24, 2012 TODAY’S AGENDA1. introductions Team Experience Experience with Relevant Historic Projects2. project overview Framing the Issue: Goals and Approach Program Development 3. historic considerations Character-deﬁ ning features4. sustainable design5. questions july 24, 2012 BUILDING EXTERIOR | Historic Elementsjuly 24, 2012 Exterior•Partofcomplexofcourts•Strongsymmetry•Durablematerials:•Standingseamcopper•Granite•Brickjuly 24, 2012CHARACTER-DEFINING FEATURES Exterior•Consistentwindowbayrhythm•Crispdetailing,narrowmortarjointsjuly 24, 2012 South Elevation•NonͲtraditionalcolumncapitals•8/8DoubleͲhungwoodwindows•Spare,articulatedpanelsbetweenfloorsjuly 24, 2012 North Elevation –East and West wings•Transitionofmaterialsanddetailing:stonetobrick•NonͲtraditionalcolumncapitals•8/8DoubleͲhungwoodwindows•Spare,articulatedpanelsbetweenfloorsjuly 24, 2012 North Wing•Continuationofwindowbayrhythm•Tallerwindows•Mottledtextureonbricksjuly 24, 2012 Windows•Typicallyoperable8/8wooddoubleͲhung•Pairsofoperable1/1wooddoubleͲhungwithdecorativetransomsatnorthwing•Stileextensionsattopsashes•Brickflatarchesorstonelintels•Stonesillsjuly 24, 2012 Entry Portico•6Ioniccolumns•Tall,ornamentaldoorwaywithinscribedplaque•Decorative, operablecasementwindows•Paneledwoodceiling•Pairofdecorativecastmetallightstandardsjuly 24, 2012 BUILDING INTERIOR | Historic ZonesZONE 1 Areas of high architectural or historic signiﬁ cance: RESTOREZONE 2 Areas with fewer signiﬁ cant featuresZONE 3 Areas with minimally-signiﬁ cant architectural or historic featuresjuly 24, 2012july 24, 2012 Entry Vestibule•Wooddoorwayforrevolvingdoors(nowpairofhingeddoors)•Woodtransomandtrim(exteriortransomnonͲoriginal)•Plaque•Decorativeplastercornice•Marblefloortilesandbaseboardjuly 24, 2012 Main Lobby•Elevatorwithdecorativemetalworkexterior•Monumentalstairwithmarblestepsandwainscot•Decorativemetalcornicesandstairbalustradesjuly 24, 2012 Main Lobby•Plasterceilingsanddeepcornices•Decorativemillworkwithtransomwindows•Marblepilastersandfloortiles•Large,ceilingͲmountedlightfixturejuly 24, 2012 2ndFloor Lobby•Monumentalpublicspace•ContinuationofMainLobbyfeatures•Marble“balustrade”guardrailsjuly 24, 2012 2ndFloor Lobby•Decorative,operablewoodcasementwindows•Strongsymmetry•Durablematerialsjuly 24, 2012 Register of Probate•Tallceilings•Plasterpilastersanddeepcornicesatbeams•Tallwindowswithtransoms•Decorativemillworkpanelsandtransomsjuly 24, 2012 Register of Probate•Large,unifiedvolumesofspace•Woodlaylight atsecondfloor(missingskylightabove)july 24, 2012 Session 1 Courtroom•Large,shallowsaucerdomecoffer•Tall,woodpaneledwainscot•Decorativewoodentrywaywithdoubledoors•Deepcornicesandbeams•PilastersandfreeͲstandingcolumns•Judge’sbenchjuly 24, 2012 Corridors•Tall,sparespaces•Bookmatched marblewainscot•Marblefloortiles•Woodmillworkatcentralbaysjuly 24, 2012 Other Featuresjuly 24, 2012 Air conditioningSupplementary powerOriginal PowerTel-Data TechnologyHeating & assoc. pipingSubsequent dedicated powerFinding a Balanced SolutionEXISTING CONDITIONSjuly 24, 2012 ENVELOPE ADDITIONNO ENVELOPE CHANGEDEMO 1979 WINGPFC - CONCEPTS EXPLORED1648 SFActiveRecords Sto.64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical943 SFActiveRecords Sto.215 SFWeatherVestibule142 SFSecurityScreening /Queuing163 SFConf Rm169 SFFile Rm /ImpoundedRecords122 SFToilet122 SFToilet188 SFRegister ofProbate117 SFAsst. Register118 SFOfficeManager141 SFEquipment /Supply Rm610 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette72 SFMail Area72 SFTrash /Recycling1409 SFRoom450 SFDORTransactionWaiting201 SFDORTransactionCounter81 SFDOR Clerical81 SFDOR Clerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical4' - 6"4' - 6"4' - 6"180 SFPublic Conf.Rm142 SFPublic Conf.Rm80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical5' - 0"5' - 0"5' - 0"311 SFFamily LawCtr Waiting260 SFToilet240 SFToilet199 SFFamily LawCtrConference107 SFFamily LawCtr Office100 SFFamily LawCtr PublicCounter226 SFMain EntrySecurityOffice246 SFPublicResearchArea99 SFFamily LawCtr PublicComputer99 SFFamily LawCtr PublicComputer2462 SFLobby80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical972 SFActiveRecords Sto.72 SFClerical72 SFClerical156 SFSecurityScreening /Queuing156 SFConf Rm91 SFFile Rm /ImpoundedRecords247 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette465 SFDORTransactionWaiting85 SFDOR Clerical85 SFDOR Clerical150 SFDORTransaction356 SFPublic Conf.Rm325 SFFamily LawCtr Waiting316 SFFamily LawCtrConference336 SFPublic Conf.Rm129 SFFamily LawCtr Office100 SFFamily LawCtr PublicCounter78 SFFamily LawCtr PublicComputer77 SFFamily LawCtr PublicComputer374 SFPublicResearchArea486 SFMain EntrySecurityOffice791 SFActive RecordSto.80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical972 SFActiveRecords Sto.2989 SFLobby72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical626 SFActiveRecords Sto.479 SFActiveRecords Sto.136 SFToilet72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical72 SFClerical75 SFClerical75 SFClerical75 SFClerical75 SFClerical118 SFToilet202 SFEquipment /Supply Rm93 SFMail Area91 SFTrash /Recycling131 SFAsst. Register115 SFOfficeManager195 SFRegister ofProbate1395 SFProbationTransactionWaiting118 SFDisputeIntervention704 SFActive RecordSto.111 SFSupervisoryClerical110 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFDisputeIntervention122 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer191 SFEquipment /Supply Rm120 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer215 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette120 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer180 SFChiefProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer80 SFDrug TestingToilet68 SFTrash /Recycling52 SFProbationTransactionCounter64 SFClerical63 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFAssoc. Prob.Officer218 SFLobby233 SFToilet224 SFEquipment /Supply Rm130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer130 SFProbationOfficer120 SFDisputeIntervention119 SFDisputeIntervention8' - 0"6' - 0"6' - 0"5' - 0"2600 SFFacilities243 SFExist ElecRoom366 SFSecureCirculation233 SFToilet120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer124 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer117 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer712 SFActive RecordSto.80 SFSupervisoryClerical120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer64 SFAssoc. Prob.Officer120 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFDisputeIntervention106 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFDisputeIntervention8' - 0"8' - 0"120 SFDisputeIntervention106 SFDisputeIntervention233 SFToilet224 SFEquipment /Supply Rm80 SFDrug TestingToilet64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical4' - 6"4' - 6"4' - 0"243 SFExist ElecRoom3' - 0"218 SFLobby174 SFChiefProbationOfficer122 SFDisputeIntervention145 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette120 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer138 SFConf Rm366 SFSecureCirculation3396 SFFacilities1035 SFProbationTransactionWaiting120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer180 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer117 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer126 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer80 SFSupervisoryClerical120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer120 SFProbationOfficer64 SFAssoc. Prob.Officer120 SFDisputeIntervention141 SFDisputeIntervention107 SFDisputeIntervention107 SFDisputeIntervention152 SFDisputeIntervention233 SFToilet224 SFEquipment /Supply Rm81 SFDrug TestingToilet64 SFClerical64 SFClerical243 SFExist ElecRoom218 SFLobby101 SFDisputeIntervention126 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer321 SFSecureCirculation3328 SFFacilities1037 SFProbationTransactionWaiting64 SFClerical62 SFClerical710 SFActive RecordSto.6' - 3 1/2"8' - 0"5' - 0"186 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette186 SFConf Rm100 SFDisputeIntervention120 SFProbationOfficer233 SFToilet79 SFDisputeIntervention86 SFDisputeIntervention1492 SFCourtroom1803 SFCourtroom110 SFConf Rm110 SFConf Rm1628 SFCourtroom1666 SFCourtroom134 SFConf Rm138 SFConf Rm103 SFConf Rm103 SFConf Rm262 SFCourtrm Vest104 SFConf Rm5048 SFLobby191 SFConf Rm258 SFToilet133 SFDetaineeHolding133 SFDetaineeHolding51 SFAV Storage815 SFSecureCirculation1186 SFHearingRoom166 SFCourtrm Vest52 SFAV Storage52 SFAV Storage104 SFConf Rm258 SFCourtOfficers'Break Rm238 SFToilet55 SFToilet282 SFSecureWaiting845 SFSecureCirculation105 SFAV Storage16' - 4 1/2"37' - 10"6' - 0"39' - 5"5' - 0"33' - 4"57' - 3 1/2"7' - 0"43' - 4"34' - 10"48' - 0 1/2"24' - 8 1/2"48' - 0 1/2"UP48' - 0 1/2"48' - 0 1/2"1782 SFCourtroom1793 SFCourtroom2084 SFCourtroom122 SFConf Rm67 SFCourtrm Vest67 SFCourtrm Vest129 SFConf Rm358 SFToilet2095 SFCourtroom177 SFToilet121 SFToilet359 SFToilet61 SFDetaineeHolding61 SFDetaineeHolding109 SFConf Rm149 SFConf Rm153 SFCourtrm Vest144 SFCourtrm Vest106 SFConf Rm78 SFSecureCirculation106 SFConf Rm285 SFHearingRoom226 SFConf Rm536 SFSecureCirculation494 SFSecureCirculation372 SFSecureCirculation164 SFSecureCirculation122 SFConf Rm122 SFConf Rm129 SFConf Rm39' - 0"10' - 1 1/2"8' - 6"5' - 0"5' - 0"44' - 6"43' - 8 1/2"43' - 7 1/2"43' - 7 1/2"3625 SFLobbyUP1717 SFCourtroom1381 SFCourtroom1427 SFCourtroom2084 SFCourtroom124 SFConf Rm164 SFConf Rm148 SFConf Rm142 SFConf Rm142 SFConf Rm142 SFConf Rm142 SFConf Rm162 SFConf Rm740 SFSecureCirculation234 SFToilet1105 SFHearingRoom286 SFConf Rm235 SFToilet177 SFToilet265 SFJudge265 SFJudge265 SFJudge265 SFJudge284 SFEntry &Waiting233 SFConf Rm611 SFJud.Secretary136 SFEquipmentRm118 SFSupply Rm25 SFAV Storage25 SFAV Storage25 SFAV Storage25 SFAV Storage25 SFAV Storage25 SFAV Storage50 SFDetaineeHolding50 SFDetaineeHolding3791 SFLobby166 SFAV Storage117 SFCourtrm Vest45 SFCourtrm Vest45 SFCourtrm Vest45 SFCourtrm Vest240 SFCourtOfficers'Break Rm257 SFConf Rm189 SFChief CourtOfficer5' - 1 1/2"38' - 11"8' - 2"12' - 8 1/2"40' - 0"43' - 7 1/2"48' - 0 1/2"33' - 8 1/2"33' - 8 1/2"485 SFSessionsClerk123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager120 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager119 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManagerUP1602 SFCourtroom1611 SFCourtroom1798 SFCourtroom104 SFConf Rm104 SFConf Rm104 SFConf Rm104 SFConf Rm760 SFSecureCirculation325 SFToilet1807 SFCourtroom177 SFToilet253 SFJudge251 SFJudge251 SFJudge251 SFJudge325 SFToilet85 SFDetaineeHolding85 SFDetaineeHolding196 SFCourtrm Vest145 SFConf Rm362 SFSecureCirculation106 SFSecureCirculation145 SFConf Rm234 SFConf Rm491 SFSecureCirculation63 SFAV Stor36' - 0"8' - 0"4' - 6"8' - 5 1/2"48' - 0 1/2"37' - 7 1/2"48' - 0 1/2"37' - 7 1/2"387 SFHearingRoom139 SFConf Rm139 SFConf Rm214 SFCourtrm Vest3323 SFLobby44' - 6"43' - 8 1/2"523 SFLobby445 SFJud.Secretary440 SFSessionsClerk261 SFEquipment &Supply Rm118 SFAsst. ChiefCourt Officer221 SFCourtOfficers'Break Rm117 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager110 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager156 SFKitchenette342 SFConf Rm &Libraryjuly 24, 2012LEVEL 0LEVEL 1LEVEL 1MLEVEL 2LEVEL 2M18,240 SF ADDITION10,620 SF ADDITIONRENOVATION ONLYCONF. RM. ADDITIONSECURE CIRCULATION ADDITIONjuly 24, 2012NO LONGER UNDER CONSIDERATION.NOT ADVANTAGEOUS PROGRAMMATICALLY SCHEME A:NO ENVELOPE CHANGE -RENOVATION ONLYSCHEME B:DEMO 1979 WING -NEW ADDITION @ NORTHEVALUATION OF 1979 ADDITIONjuly 24, 2012july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION OPEN - PARKING/ MECH011M22MCOURTROOMSREGISTRY OF PROBATEPROBATIONPUBLICJUDICIALFACILITIES / BLDG. SVCS.NORTH WING: 1979 EXISTINGORDEMO & BUILDNEW ADDITION1912 ORIGINAL BUILDINGFEDERAL STREETSECTION | Proposed Program Distributionjuly 24, 2012july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION 703 SFActive RecordSto.109 SFDisputeIntervention109 SFDisputeIntervention104 SFDisputeIntervention233 SFToilet224 SFEquipment /Supply Rm83 SFDrug TestingToilet243 SFExist ElecRoom218 SFLobby107 SFDisputeIntervention543 SFSecureCirculation2736 SFFacilities191 SFProbationTransactionCounter122 SFDisputeIntervention138 SFDisputeIntervention122 SFDisputeIntervention122 SFDisputeIntervention0 SFnitorialupply107 SFDisputeIntervention145 SFDisputeIntervention233 SFToilet116 SFProbationOfficer106 SFProbationOfficer169 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer122 SFAsst. ChiefProb. Officer192 SFChiefProbationOfficer112 SFProbationOfficer112 SFProbationOfficer112 SFProbationOfficer106 SFProbationOfficer112 SFProbationOfficer116 SFProbationOfficer106 SFProbationOfficer106 SFProbationOfficer10' - 3"115 SFProbationOfficer115 SFProbationOfficer115 SFProbationOfficer225 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette80 SFSupervisoryClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFAssoc. Prob.Officer190 SFToilet190 SFToilet7' - 6"5' - 0"2187 SFProbationTransactionWaiting4' - 9"4' - 9"6' - 0"10' - 11 1/2"700 SFMechanical 1" = 20'-0"1LEVEL-00 NEC 0Bjuly 24, 2012SCHEME A | No Envelope ChangeLEVEL 0july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION SCHEME A | No Envelope Change113 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical1488 SFActiveRecords Sto.64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical932 SFActiveRecords Sto.215 SFWeatherVestibule142 SFSecurityScreening /Queuing64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical230 SFConf Rm340 SFFile Rm /ImpoundedRecords122 SFToilet122 SFToilet120 SFAsst. Register120 SFOfficeManager141 SFEquipment /Supply Rm610 SFStaff BreakRm w/Kitchenette72 SFMail Area72 SFTrash /Recycling1556 SFActive RecordSto.686 SFDOR Clerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical247 SFFamily LawCtrConference253 SFPublic Conf.Rm80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical80 SFSupervisoryClerical151 SFToilet211 SFToilet226 SFMain EntrySecurityOffice246 SFPublicResearchArea3333 SFLobby142 SFPublic Conf.RmDOR TransactionCounterDOR Transaction &Family Law WaitingFamily Law CenterPublic Computers64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical186 SFRegister ofProbate64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical64 SFClerical78 SFSupervisoryClerical 1" = 20'-0"1LEVEL-01 NEC 1Cjuly 24, 2012LEVEL 1july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION SCHEME A | No Envelope Change177 SFToiletNot EnclosedJudge251 SFJudge251 SFJudge251 SFJudge445 SFJud.Secretary440 SFSessionsClerk261 SFEquipment &Supply Rm118 SFAsst. ChiefCourt Officer221 SFCourtOfficers'Break Rm117 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager110 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager123 SFAsst. JudicialCaseManager156 SFKitchenette342 SFConf Rm &Library 1" = 20'-0"1LEVEL-02 MEZZ NEC 2Ajuly 24, 2012LEVEL 1Mjuly 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION SCHEME A | No Envelope Change48' - 0 1/2"1861 SFCourtroom4371 SFLobby1688 SFCourtroom1621 SFCourtroom125 SFConf Rm307 SFToilet281 SFCourtrm Vest112 SFConf Rm112 SFConf Rm2084 SFCourtroom58 SFAV Storage168 SFConf Rm118 SFConf Rm70 SFDetaineeHolding96 SFDetaineeHolding768 SFSecureCirculation673 SFHearingRoom53 SFAV Storage53 SFAV Storage125 SFConf Rm350 SFToilet300 SFSecureWaiting1129 SFSecureCirculation137 SFConf Rm160 SFConf Rm445 SFHearingRoom171 SFCourtrm Vest258 SFCourtOfficers'Break Rm238 SFAsst. ChiefCourt Officer199 SFCourtrm Vest43' - 7 1/2"83 SFToilet122 SFJan. 1" = 20'-0"1LEVEL-02 NEC 2Bjuly 24, 2012LEVEL 2july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION SCHEME B | North AdditionUP2215 SFCourtroom173 SFConf Rm475 SFHearingRoom10' - 10"40' - 0"55' - 8"174 SFConf Rm76 SFCourtrm Vest605 SFLobby19' - 0"25' - 0"111 SFSecureCirculation182 SFToilet183 SFToilet1688 SFCourtroom1621 SFCourtroom2084 SFCourtroom118 SFConf Rm168 SFConf Rm112 SFConf Rm112 SFConf Rm281 SFCourtrm Vest125 SFConf Rm4492 SFLobby191 SFConf Rm258 SFToilet96 SFDetaineeHolding70 SFDetaineeHolding58 SFAV Storage768 SFSecureCirculation1186 SFHearingRoom53 SFAV Storage53 SFAV Storage125 SFConf Rm238 SFToilet55 SFToilet300 SFSecureWaiting199 SFCourtrm Vest 1" = 20'-0"1LEVEL-02 ED 2Ajuly 24, 2012LEVEL 2july 24, 2012CURRENTLY UNDER INVESTIGATION july 24, 2012TODAY’S AGENDA1. introductions Team Experience Experience with Relevant Historic Projects2. project overview Framing the Issue: Goals and Approach Program Development 3. historic considerations Character-deﬁ ning features4. sustainable design5. questions SUSTAINABLE DESIGN PRIORITIES • Envelope Improvements• Optimizing Energy Performance - Mechanical system - Electrical: Lighting • Energy modeling to test and ﬁ ne-tune strategies• Consideration of impact on historic building• Health and well-being of occupants and the publicEO484; Mass LEED Plus; LEED Silver min.july 24, 2012 HISTORIC BUILDINGS | Improving Energy Efﬁ ciencyjuly 24, 2012MINIMAL ALTERATION• Reduce air leakage• Install storm windows*• Add Attic insulation*• Seal & insulate ducts & pipes• Weather strip doors / add storm doors• Add shading devices (interior*/exterior)MORE ALTERATION• Add/Reconﬁ gure interior vestibules• Replace windows*• Add insulation to exterior walls*• Install cool roofs and green roofs• Replace doors**presently pursuingUPGRADING BUILDING COMPONENTS:• Balance goals of energy efﬁ ciency & potential energy savings with protection of historic property’s materials & features• Understand and leverage the existing building’s inherent energy-efﬁ cient features• Prioritize energy upgrades for improvements that provide the most payback and least compromise to historic character QUESTIONSjuly 24, 2012