319 Essex Street - C of NA application - confirmation for 3tab shingles Patricia Kelleher
From: Morris Schopf <schopf@verizon.net>
Sent: Monday,August 19, 2019 12:56 PM
To: Patricia Kelleher
Cc: Myra Ameigh; Marijke Ameigh; Sarah Cahill
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Attachments: Existing Roof 319 Essex Street Certainteed XT-25 traditional shingle proposed
replacement 8-19-19 jpg
OK. Certainteed XT-25 traditional shingle.
Color: Gray Frost
Match image attached.
All information from the original application is the same. Proposed material has changed
to fully matching color and style.
M
On Monday, August 19, 2019, 11:11:33 AM EDT, Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher@Salem.com>wrote:
I apologize for the confusion. The shingles currently on the building appear to be 3-tab shingles. Therefore, if the owners
wish to replace with a 3-tab shingles such as the Certainteed XT-25 traditional shingle, then a Certificate of Non-
Applicability can be issued.
htt s://www.certainteed.com/resources/TraditionalShin lesBrochSoutheast. df
Patti
i
From: Morris Schopf<schopf@verizon.net>
Sent: Monday, August 19, 2019 10:59 AM
To: Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher@Salem.com>
Cc: Myra Ameigh <mameigh14@gmail.com>; Marijke Ameigh <ameighmarijke@gmail.com>; Sarah Cahill
<scahill@Salem.com>
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Attached is a photograph of the existing roof at 319.
It was our intention to replace the roof with a previously approved product. I was merely responding to your induction that
"The Commission has approved GAF Slateline and Certainteed Hatteras architectural shingles, which have a flat
appearance and a straighter edge."
1
Please review the attached photograph of the existing condition and indicate what product lines have
been previously approved which are suitable for replacing the attached roof.
Thanks
Morris
On Monday, August 19, 2019, 10:45:37 AM EDT, Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher(o7Salem.com>wrote:
Hi Morris,
I apologize for not responding sooner to your email. Please complete the attached application for a Certificate of Non-
Applicability. For the application, please include a current photo of the building and its roof. If the roof is currently a 3-tab
shingle, then a 3-tab shingle would need to be used to qualify for an in-kind replacement. If you are proposing to change
from a 3-tab to an architectural shingle, which is the classification for the GAF Slateline Hatteras shingle you are
proposing, then a public hearing would need to be scheduled at the Commission's September 4th meeting.
Thank you,
Patti
From: Morris Schopf<schopf(a verizon.net>
Sent: Tuesday, August 13, 2019 10:18 AM
To: Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher r@Salem.com>
Cc: Myra Ameigh <mameigh14ftgmail.com>; Marijke Ameigh <ameighmariike(a).gmail.com>
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Attached is request for approval of replacement in kind with material previously approved by the
commission.
2
M
On Tuesday, August 6, 2019, 11:39:59 AM EDT, Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher(a)Salem.com>wrote:
Hi Morris,
I just want to confirm that you will be submitting a new application for a Certificate of Non-Applicability to install Stab
shingles at 319 Essex Street. Therefore, I will withdraw the Certificate of Appropriateness application for architectural roof
shingles at the property
Thank you,
Patti
-----------------------------
Patti Kelleher
Preservation Planner, City of Salem
i
Department of Planning& Community Development
98 Washington Street, 2nd Floor
Salem, MA 01970
Phone: 978-619-5685
pkelleher(o7salem.com
www.salem.com
www.preservinigsalem.com
3
From: Morris Schopf<schoof(a)verizon.net>
Sent: Monday, August 5, 2019 9:44 AM
To: Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher@Salem.com>
Cc: Myra Ameigh <mameighl4(o)gmail.com>
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Will do. Thanks.
M
On Monday, August 5, 2019, 09:38:29 AM EDT, Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher(a]Salem.com>wrote:
Hi Morris,
Yes, if the owner agrees to install 3-tab shingles, the Commission can review under a request for a Certificate of Non-
Applicability without a public hearing. Please include the name of the shingle manufacturer, the model name and the
color to be used.
Thank you,
Patti
From: Morris Schopf<schopf(ab_verizon.net>
Sent: Friday, August 2, 2019 9:32 AM
To: Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher(a.Salem.com>
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Can I just re-apply with an approved roofing material?
M
4
On Thursday, August 1, 2019, 01:37:18 PM EDT, Patricia Kelleher<pkelleher Salem.com>wrote:
Hi Morris,
The Commission reviewed the application for 319 Essex Street and determined that the request for a new roof constitutes
a change as the applicant is proposing to replace a 3tab asphalt shingle with an architectural shingle. Please have the
property owner complete the attached application and return it as soon as possible. If the application is submitted by 8/5,
it can be scheduled for the Commission's August 21st public hearing. Please note that in previous applications in the
McIntire District, the Commission has not approved Timberline High Definition architectural roof shingles due to their
pronounced angled cut and 3-dimensional appearance. The Commission has approved GAF Slateline and Certainteed
Hatteras architectural shingles, which have a flat appearance and a straighter edge.
Best,
Patti
From: Morris Schopf<schopf c(77,.verizon.net>
Sent: Tuesday, July 30, 2019 8:49 AM
To: Sarah Cahill <scahill@Salem.com>
Cc: Patricia Kelleher< kelleher Salem.com>
Subject: Re: 319 Essex Street
Could you email ilne a copy of the letter. I would like to apply for the building permit on Monday week.
M
On Friday, July 26, 2019, 10:13:26 AM EDT, Sarah Cahill <scahill Salem.com>wrote:
Good day Morris,
5
I am responding to your query on behalf of Patti as she is out of the office until Wednesday. I am currently filling out a
Cert of Non-applicability application to send to the Board. Can you provide the homeowners name/s and if 319 Essex is
there current mailing address?
All the best,
Sarah O'Halloran Cahill
City of Salem Planning Assistant
Department of Planning & Community Development
98 Washington St., 2nd Floor
Salem, MA 01970
9 78-619-5685
scahill. salem.com
6