Loading...
16 Kosciuszko Street - C of A application - exterior renovation Date Stamp vT � a'; x its; 4 AN 2 2 2'j r3 Salem Historical Commission UsE^ CC ForOtf c i7s '®niy �68= =Ax -8 bL-- ,; APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance, application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness for: ❑ New Construction ❑ Moving V Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Sign ❑ Other District: Derby Street ❑Lafayette Street ❑McIntire ❑Washington Square Address of Property: t (P k4O 7 C I il 5 Z o S'r 0;-r Name of Record Owner(s): 3 At I? G '4p 1?g14 Owner Mailing Address: 2-� W A-5 H►W 4 Mel, `?q f ar-!5©z—_ 5,&LSM4 , MA, D 11q-10 Description of Work ProlRosed Please type or print clearly.Attach additional sheets, as necessary. ST,Lur rvVR%,o L 0jj u oho4 tt�4wrr ;- F*or- Prvt+. %PI 04/TiD-m lu r� 'P�-A��j 004W l• • �� . (.w k A O— - 7Danlavis Name of Applicant: � Q 10 i►% ❑Owner❑Contractor❑TenantEROther: oU A-APf Signature: I Date: 7:Ya4A . a it> / g Tel. #: E-mail Address:_q 2 m Q j1 r s,ber/l,r 1,"j,", Certificate will be mailed to the owner unless odWrwise indicated her Certificate should be mailed to: Name e� Mailing address: iJ/IG' City: LL( MAP 35 LOT 408 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA "® MARITIME PARK DRILL IRON HOLE ROD SET SET N 07'15'30" W 1.00' 40.00' I MAP 35 LOT 402 AREA = 1830 f S.F. M MAP 35 LOT 401 MAP 35 LOT 403 TUCKER WHARF MICHAEL MARTIN CONDOMINIUM 14 KOSCIUSKO \, , . ,. ,\ • ,\ i.s 18 KOSCIUSKO ST. IRON ROD DRILL SET HOLE SET L., N 1. 13.2' \ •. . \. Z DWELLING #16 40.00' o'7 S 10*00'44" E DISK 0.2�— J o.3' DRILL HOLE FOUND SET IN SIDEWALK KOSCIUSKO STREET PLAN OF LAND 16 KOSCIUSKO STREET GA L \, SALEM SMITH 1 N Inx � 1 PROPERTY OF JAY C. CHAPIN L LAND�v SCALE 1" = 20' JANUARY 16, 2018 NORTH SHORE SURVEY CORPORATION 14 BROWN STREET — SALEM, MA 978-744-4800 #4558 I ME mm ME- ^: .......... ........... --- �s - 3 Eli P.PPp . -S. - ' ` ............ r r - -- ��.�.M A HE mm 0. 01/2212018 13ERNERARCHITECTS Scale: 1/4' 1'-0" Chapin-Forget Residence 5 Whittier Road 16 Koscluszko Street Marblehead, MA 01945 Salem,MA 01970 ew metal chimney ne x 5 tg new aspalt shingles 40year remove existing slate roofing 6"half round gutter W/3'rou T_ Kill -- new w_J­nJo_wr,to match frame 2'-9"x 4'-7 new 1 x&T&G flush boards existingsizes 1TDH 3456 new 1 xG wood shutters FIT remove existing orwaf I &stairway from�! ewLa k Mnew water table r: newstucclWA 01122/2018 X\�61 13ERNER ARCHITECTS Scale: 1/4"= 1 11-01F Chapin-Forget Residence 5 Whittier Road 16 Koscluszko Street X Marl7lehead, MA 01945 Salem,MA 01970 i - f i i i i i tul i. f 3;1 01/22/201& BERNER ARCHITECTS Scale: 1/4"= T-O" Chapin-Forget Residence 5 Whittier Road 16 Kvsciuszko Street Marblehead, MA 01945 Salem, MA 01970 R r r w - rc �� R�lWWiii • __ ru■■-_err�a --_ __— [■■■piol�i iY ■![■!■rnelQ® • ■EE zzz i! ■ ■s�laa�' ----- Gliiii�5���• r■ ��I�I� 1�1� �!![1� am■f� irs�!!Gui�i®m�� i iiili v ii ■!�m!o I • w . ■�A!lilimsMI �EN � � i OVA 01/22/2018 x 5ERNER ARCHITECTS Scale: 114!'= 1'-0" Chapin-Forget Residence 5 Whittier Road 16 Koscluszko Street Marblehead, MA01945 Salem, MA 01970 1 � r � ��� _ l _ — � it r■ ■ i i I t - � a - � ! ■ININiI�■irs ■utNENENUINraiNn■ia ■ iNtN1NlNi 0 IN1NIN718 iNl ■ ■INlNININININININII■I!I ■iN1NINkNiNININlNIIrINI i ■ININININININININII■r■I ININlNHIN lNlNlNllf I W. lilt kwl7ililaEilNiiiEif;l ININlNINlNINfNIN!!■Ilrl INININENlNINiN1NFNINII ININlN11!lENININiNlalDO rril::l�'�I�f�IN�f�' ININI�11 iWlNlir�lli}NrNINININII EENiNINl�IfrNI�INiN NEININININlNININlNINH IkNiNININININUENINrI I I I I I 4 I —� I j I T_ `y 11 L I i 01/22/2018 BERNER ARCHITECTS Scale: 1/4"= T-O" Chapin-Forget Rest ence x�m5 Whittier Road 16 Kosciuszko Street Marblehead, MA 01945 Salem, MA 01970 6f E Y " 01 I I i s II I n I II LI L I I I = N I p,LV I I I I C'j 3 3'-0" - III II I I I I I I I I � j I I I j � �� I � 01/22/201& I L \M/�j BERNER ARCHITECTS Scale: 1/4"= T-0" Chapin-Forget Residence ��77 5 Whittier Road 16 Kosciuszko Street z Marblehead, MA 01945 Salem, MA 01970 16 Kosciusk-o Street, House land This house -....,as built for J y es Curran, "llanborer, it so etime betv;een 6 _'ar -1861 (when t'_e lot .-has sold to �ur_�an) and 1067 CT.-.,hen wirst _--setivas hi-1 for )ro-oerty, vizt et " 2 -acI.er is .Lar a ,souse .orth •. GO c� its 15�G ' so lot :sort^ %- 00;;' , Usually :ter-person b'a?s anur b�.n 1OL ::its the i-itantion of bui l din` on it, c:% so _ tend O th]7i1c that, Jos e C r ,u. ra_. u bilt house r—L-ht a;-ay, ill„ ' -^e (notorloasl;y erroneous ) uaiem prorerty- a liAsOu j..� V._lv assess'_' en;= records indicate a 6-,year. ;gait before building. The house probably was not built b--.ore 1 861 , des_oite its older anoearance : the absence Of _lrep l a ces-of an- trace of f ir2cla ces--tends to confirm an 1 86Gs bulldin,`-' da.te, it. is� oossible t--at this eras an o?der I!Ouse t -at was :-loved to this site in 1 0361 . Doubtlessly, its anac_r•onistic "t_Lro ;bac -" a nearance can be &ttributed to the fact that J.�; es Curran, an Iris- i_--_ig-rant iacorer, had no need for ( and probably could not afford) a ::_odish Victorian. residence, & was eui to content to build a sir_rle, solid, old-fashi oned :louse. J--mes Curran first an )ears in SalenA records .ith the Directory of 1855, when :e find = living in a rouse at "Tucker ' s ':"hart" (no nu_sber s-,ecified) , :sere he is also listed in 1857 1859. 'phis s i tuatlon leads ._e to ::under if he might h=ve 'aou ° �t tie House in 855 Jec.se B E.duards, the' House-carpenter I.iho, on 13 Dec 18541 , boa-ht the lot tr_at was sold to Curran in 1661 . It could be that Edwards built the house soon of ter buying the land, sold the 'rouse alone to Curran in 1855, later sold the land on laic ra the house stood. Jut this is sheer s�eculatlon. A.t any rate, the 1861 Direc ,ory lists James Curran as living in a '_?ouse at ;`6 Tuc'_•�erto .iharf. Possibl7 the -ore�ent .ouse -T-ias t.-_en T6; but one cannot be sure, since, as :;cir_t;yre 's 16351 nap of �3 leh shows, a. _,neat deal of the present even-nunbe_ed side of the street was then salt -rater, 3, ti_ere is a 23-year gap bet ;een the ma-os of 1851 w 187i_, Z ;ahicn period no record has been left regarding the filling-in & develo-o_.ent of Tucker' s inarf. throughout the 18603 Janes Curran is listed only as living in a house on 2uc .er' s .:harf;' in 1 367 & 1869,* he is called J mies Cullen (sic) , the nar.:e undo ,'-.hicn the ei;,,y assesses -izm from 1867-70I By 1872, his souse on 'tucker' s .d arf is numbered 8, c it is not until it1 71 that finally beco^Ies 16 -kckerts ;r:-1 ari which is the number it bears into the %Cth century. J=Ies Curran, Salew laborer, died 2 Oct 1681 , leaving a house land at 16 -•ucker' s ;r_�arf :-forth . !�80, and 2 children: Lizzie (Curran) E:ife of JO-un =latson; 3: Joan Curran, r?ho in 1882 sold his father 's ecuate to T o-Has _:agony. t � - ( y his At ��le ti__e of His death b-= own, hand) , ;sir. Carr^n -..,as 58 years old. (For further reference, see the back page of the Salei.i 3vaning ews for 3 Oct 1881 - ) All things considered, I submit 1861 as the year in which this house was built. Robert Booth 14 --jaY 1976 Massachusetts Cultural Resource Information System Scanned Record Cover Page Inventory No: SAL.2638 Historic Name: Curran,James House Common Name: Address: 16 Kosciusko St f; y. -ti City/Town: Salem Village/Neighborhood.- Derby Street Local No: 35-402 Year Constructed: r 1870 Architect(s): Architectural Style(s): No style Use(s): Single Family Dwelling House Significance: Architecture Area(s): SAL.HN:Derby Waterfront Historic District SAL.HO:Derby Street Local Historic District Designation(s): Local Historic District(12/17/1974);Nat'l Register District (05/17/1976) Roof:Asphalt Shingle Building Materials(s): Wall:Wood;Wood Clapboard Foundation:Brick The Massachusetts Historical Commission(MHC) has converted this paper record to digital format as part of ongoing projects to scan records of the Inventory of Historic Assets of the Commonwealth and National Register of Historic Places nominations for Massachusetts. Efforts are ongoing and not all inventory or National Register records related to this resource may be available in digital format at this time. The MACRIS database and scanned files are highly dynamic; new information is added daily and both database records and related scanned files may be updated as new information is incorporated into MHC files. Users should note that there may be a considerable lag time between the receipt of new or updated records by MHC and the appearance of related information in MACRIS. Users should also note that not all source materials for the MACRIS database are made available as scanned images. Users may consult the records,files and maps available in MHC's public research area at its offices at the State Archives Building,220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston,open M-F, 9-5. Users of this digital material acknowledge that they have read and understood the MACRIS Information and Disclaimer (hftp://mhc-macris.net/macrisdisclaimer.htm) Data available via the MACRIS web interface,and associated scanned files are for information purposes only.THE ACT OF CHECKING THIS DATABASE AND ASSOCIATED SCANNED FILES DOES NOT SUBSTITUTE FOR COMPLIANCE WITH APPLICABLE LOCAL,STATE OR FEDERAL LAWS AND REGULATIONS.IF YOU ARE REPRESENTING A DEVELOPER AND/OR A PROPOSED PROJECT THAT WILL REQUIRE A PERMIT,LICENSE OR FUNDING FROM ANY STATE OR FEDERAL AGENCY YOU MUST SUBMIT A PROJECT NOTIFICATION FORM TO MHC FOR MHC'S REVIEW AND COMMENT.You can obtain a copy of a PNF through the MHC web site Iwww.sec.state.ma.us/mhc) under the subject heading"MHC Forms" Commonwealth of Massachusetts Massachusetts Historical Commission 220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125 www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc This file was accessed on: Monday, December 4,2017 at 12:09 PM NRHD 5/17/1976; LHD, 12/17/1974 -•ii� :` FORM B - BUILDING Assessor's USGS Quad Area(s) Form Number Number 35-402 Salem HO 2638 Massachusetts Historical Commission Massachusetts Archives Building 220 Morrissey Boulevard Boston, Massachusetts 02125 Town Salem Place (neighborhood or village) Derby Street s 16 Kosciusko Street is Name James Curran House Present Residential riginal f Construction 1861-1874 u. see Bibliography* Form Astylistic e act/Builder or Material: tion Brick Wall/Trim/ Clapboard/Wood oc ram, < r y �4e VI: 6— inn'�'I It, •' Roof e$l9 5 m y M •�1 .('11: my y r� 1 ,. Asphalt Shingles °~ outbuildings/Secondary Structures Ilk ' N jai o� m ,'� •�� 8. iqo o t`o j�ie'1 Major Alterations (with dates) .bL 1,j s 59 Condition Good 2638 Moved X no yes Date Art Acreage 1,680 SF :., i. Setting Set directly on sidewalk in a Recorded by: Susan Ceccacci and densely-settled neighborhood of 19th and Dianne L. Siergiej 20th-century residences. Organization: Commonweal Collaborative Date: July 1995 i 2 `i F. _ i 7 u BUILDING FORM 16 Kosciusko Street ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION See continuation sheet. Describe architectural features. Evaluate the characteristics of this building in terms of other buildings within the community. This 2-story, 3-bay, center-entry, gable-roofed house is 1 bay deep and has a 2-story rear ell. Eaves project slightly and are entirely plain. Window frames are molded and window sash are 2/2. The entrance is recessed. The simplicity of the shape and trim of the house fails to suggest a particular style or period. The only important decorative feature is a cornice overdoor on small, scroll brackets with pendants that likely dates from the late nineteenth century. The door itself is possibly a recent addition, yet it is in the late nineteenth century spirit and adds an important decorative touch to this otherwise unadorned house. With horizontal panels at the bottom, it has a glazed top trimmed with colored, leaded, milk glass forming a floral motif and the number '11611. HISTORICAL NARRATIVE See continuation sheet. Discuss the history of the building. Explain its associations with local (or state history. Include uses of the building and the role(s) the owners/occupants played within the community. Property along what is now Kosciusko Street was Hawkes' Wharf before it began was subdivided for house lots during the early 1850's by its owner, Jonathan Tucker of Salem. In 1851, Tucker seems to have bought most of the former wharf from George Wheatland of Salem. In 1854, Tucker sold a parcel, including the lot on which this house stands, for $500 to Jesse B. Edwards, housewright. In turn, Edwards sold a 40' x 42' lot, apparently smaller than the original lot, for $150 to James Curran, a Salem laborer. Between 1861 and 1874, the existing house had been built for Curran, possibly by Edwards. James Curran was married and had two children. Curran died by his own hand at age 58 in 1881. In that year, the house and land were valued at $480. In 1882, the property was sold for $600 to Thomas Murphy. Houses along this street were occupied largely by residents of Irish descent during the mid and late nineteenth century. Before the turn of the century, the street down Tucker's Wharf became known as Grant Street. When the house again changed hands in 1907, it passed to Wactaw [sic. ] (alias William) Kohn of Salem, who was apparently of Polish origin. Successive owners were also Polish, as the neighborhood became heavily populated by Poles during the early twentieth century. Around the turn of the century, Eastern European immigrants, especially Poles, seeking empkuymeiTL were attracted by the expanding industrial base of Salem. Many settled in the Derby Street area which remained one of the most densely-populated parts of the city. By 1911, Grant Street had been renamed Kosciusko Street, reflecting the changing ethnic character of the area. BIBLIOGRAPHY and/or REFERENCES X See continuation sheet. Recommended for listing in the National Register of Historic Places; If checked, see attached National Register criteria statement form. INVENTORY FORM CONTINUATION SHEET Salem 16 Kosciusko Street Area HO Form No. 2638 BIBLIOGRAPHY and/or REFERENCES (continued) *Booth, Robert, Research Report: 16 Kosciusko Street, May 14, 1976, Historic Salem Inc., Salem, Massachusetts. 1872. Beers, D. G. & Company, Atlas of Essex Count_ Massachusetts, Hopkins, G. M. & Co., Atlas of Salem Massachusetts, 1874. McIntyre, Henry C. E., Map of the Citv of Salem Mass, 1851. 1897. Richards, L. J., Atlas of the Cit7 of Salem Massachusetts. . .., - Walker Lithograph and Publishing Company, Atlas of the Cit of Salem, Massachusetts, 1911. ' e f 2 . �,` ��. 2. Town Street address—_ Name Use: original & present Present owner ",,7 ' &--�Av V ! I L'It- Open to public Date Style �c.� Source of date c� Cc Architect Architectural reason for inven drying: .. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ OR part of Area # 3, CONDITION Excellent Good Fair Deteriorated Moved Altered-Added - - - - - - --- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 4. DESCRIPTION FOUNDATION/BASEMENT: High ED Low Material WALL COVER: W� Brick Stone Other - ROOF: Ridge Gambrel Flat Hip Mansard o er Cupola Dormer windows Balustrade Grillwork _ CHIMNEYS:02 3 4 Center End Interior Irregular Cluster Elaborate STORIES: 103 4 ATTACHMENTS: Wings Ell Shed — PORCHES: 1 2 3 4 PORTICO Ralrnn r FACADE: Gable end: Front side Ornament Entrance Side Front Center/Side Details: Windows: Spacing: Regular. Irregular Identical/Varied Corners: Plain Pilasters Quoins Q E- 5. Indicate location of building in relation to 6. Footage of structure from street U nearest cross reets and other iSdings Property has �(Q feet frontage on street a Recorder _ - For a qj Photo # r1 Date S �3 �,. 2 } `- SEE REVERSE SIDil. -�' ' r ■ RELATION OF SURROUNDING _.,, STRUCTURE 1. Outbuildings 2. Landscape Features: Agriculture Open Wooded Garde Formal/Informal Predominant features Landscape architect 3. Neighborin Structures - Style: Ionia a era reek Revival Gothic Revival Italian Villa Lombard Rom. Vene an c Mansard Richardsonian Modern Use; sidenti Commercial Religious Conditions: Excellent Goo Fair Deteriorated - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - GIVE A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF HISTORIC IMPORTANCE OF SITE (Refer and elaborate on theme circled on front of form) BIBLIOGRAPHY AND/OR REFERENCE RESTRICTIONS OriginalOwner: - - Dead Information: Book Number_ Page —Registry of Deeds Form B. 1OM-6-71-049688 ip 17 Owl •� ....... . 44 i rL i F .t. xis A r _- Zle 4 i I I KY 4 f 7 _ �AI+- I r r t ir * z ip 14 i ,tI z f _ F - .. -- _ _ .. �'' •L � - � mow,- . � F 1 .� :� r► � i:;d= a•si �;;�� : dry t. ,� _ .rrw • R AAr - ,.,is.=- �� � rya' � .-•�.._. Classic Copper & Slate 59 Pond Street Lynn, MA 01904-2622 E-Mail: classiccopperandslate@gmail.com Phone: 781-581-7880 Website: www.classiccopperandslate.com David Berner Berner Architects drberner@mac.com Re: 16 Kosciuzko Street Salem, MA David, To remove existing skylight and slate back: $850.00 To cut roof and install two new skylights: $850.00 each $1,700.00 This price does not include the skylights or the flashing kits. To install 50 feet of copper ridge-cap @ $20.00 per foot: $1,000.00 To step-flash and re-slate new chimney: $600.00 To slate area once existing chimney is removed: $600.00 Slate repair: To replace thirty slate+/-@$50.00 per: $1,500.00 Total estimate: $6,250.00 Any wood repair required will be brought to your attention and may result in an additional charge Terms 50/50 Thank you for considering our company Terry Johnson and Debby Hesson From: Terry and Debby classiccopperandslate@gmail.com Subject: Re:16 Kosciusko St.Salem Date: December 27,2017 at 8:59 PM To: David Berner drbernerC�mac.com Hi David, You are asking me what type of nails are holding the slate on the roof now. There is no way to tell if all the nails on the slate roof are the same without removing each slate. When was roof was installed? When were repairs and changes were made the roof? Who did the slate work? All questions to which I do not have answers. What I can tell you is we only use ring- shank copper nails. Thanks Debby On Wed, Dec 27, 2017 at 4:43 PM, David Berner <drberner!pmac.com> wrote: My big question is existing fasteners are what type and what condition. Manny shingles of unknown life expectancy Tell what u think Thanks David. iPhone 781-460-8090 On Dec 27, 2017, at 10:13 AM, Terry and Debby <classiccopperandslateQgmaii.com> wrote: Hi David, I have attached the estimate. Please contact me with any questions. I can recommend a mason. Thanks Debby On Mon, Dec 18, 2017 at 6:59 PM, Terry and Debby <classiccopperandslate gmail.com> wrote: David, We will visit the site later this week and send you an estimate. Thank you M-kk- f . -•-•---.-..ate-^'�M+v.�-�w:—kr. _—w.� �. rtir��. ae�rti-:.--��T�.�Yrr�.�..R`�rwww�r•� •�� z�, '1 .�—'��� •...ry�y.!Trfw'-rr.��.���-.+.�v�;�ry�^TM+��_ter" '.X,� •1��•�'�+'I� _ -• - -�..�...-�,�-.ter_,�-.-,T,,,,. °sue-..�..• _-----�---- I —_�