7 LORING HILLS AVENUE - ZBA 7 Loring Hills Avenue R-3
Map 21 Lot 96
Vinnin Association Rlty Tr.
: A
yA THEEALEY W66 VpNINO NEW6"TIIC6PAY 6EMEYEER]:IBBI 9, '•Lf
L'
SALEMLZ ,
b
La. rfi-'ixd' cdo. Zu-.rNuuta 3Bxb.naMcA aks wnurYsin� h3somSIan -
LNwet.rtepUnt 5Bat and Rachel S
olt who eededinth Hwill �t R d Chair@ineinmime"y
hM8nt onebuiIt einmore of M1Th arrs,
ebn2SAEMfFThb n Mle5tl Co. �4
8t h' bbel°e teabet eenthe'
8
"o'
rd of'APGe 1 aN I e elr dy Ftulnetl'B¢ttU rbR eln Fied 1 1 Jurtue CaueF t ndnminl a el Pruence
4 8. .<Pttiel P t II cut f sea!°r Ips ho M1I h d':'•In tp P t cure; 6 d 't ° W I FeFlnd en
e Ile
naFNN f t2lhea vwa<t ferrea from Set Has that VIVN p M1 wn the MN 1 t 8 h°ppi 8 ull
rtler =6 Is9 Ptl -f emWtll 1 8h e I ind tai G h° dti'
N IgFF naf two
dl Iron Z 1 8 E eN CF'm Ri h SN mendF R t sly dem ,Jh Ip[ IR t tly ttF area es
cannurd In^ h VII d A E I dIt % t atei tF tM 8 a t Ud.th t da
ue I V o d L tl e.1, hom eaedlntF' tY M Id:be I M1 Y tF tM1 h la ha 811 t
d Pneeded4F¢Z 820 ca• I k t 800a a I P e d 1[ t f th n d $I'P':
P t 4ullf ry
1@ b tFe M p utLL, 'I 11 d N tN b°ecd d mH F
the'=N tl etl'lentl rt n' LvulnB thecelenRw I Thenonl�M1 wJl Feetwa. -
theaC°°tA: Y. ^"pmetlt t heuWl Ihn�th th itynfthelnard M6 brick building 4
Land CCU"J E R p V S 1 liepl,l aflidal tl d e<ro dl g1Y this matter 1 Htinee and Salter thought Ne"
n a tl�smleUtl ma enu aiE Rene experts had argued n.missed ;£ I.na Rom-Summa n wR The.k ..
Petl tl Y.'" at P k°a Publlc,Feuing 1 t `i`Ne16hbi amca thfl mNng home ""man" were Y
N ne_home o ers ft¢FeM
Munch
that e nunby M the nursing F Ia nere - P ted by Amm Y J F R
/,µf 5¢ pn1�E<.Th pp 1 by the
e18hb° Wee RI a by t nrys
S IE W an. talup
(91tu of �ttlem, ��ZI85tIL�1uSPttS
Boarb of rAu}teul SPR
�Nn 1V' V
FILE;:'-:
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF VINNIN ASSOCIATES REALTY TRUST ::IT( r:
FOR A SPECIAL PERMIT AT 7 LORING HILLS AVENUE (MAP 21 , PARCEL 96)
R-3 Zone
A hearing on this petition was held March 28, 1990 with the following Board
Members present: James M. Fleming, Chairman; Richard A. Bencal , Vice Chairman;
Edward Luzinski , Richard Febonio and Associate Member Peter Dore. Notice of
the hearing was sent to abutters and others and notices of the hearing were
properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance with Massachusetts
General Laws Chapter 40A.
Petitioner, owner of the property, is requesting a Special Permit in order to
allow construction of a 123 bed nursing home in this R-3 zone.
The provision of the Salem Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request
for a Special Permit is Section IX D, which provides as follows:
"In hearing and deciding applications for Special
Permits, the Board of Appeal shall decide such
questions as are involved in determining whether
such Special Permit should be granted, and shall
grant Special Permits with such conditions and
safeguards as are appropriate under this Ordinance
or shall deny Special Permits when not in harmony
with the purpose and intent of this Ordinance.
The Board of Appeals shall not have the power to
grant any Special Permit where use of land or structure
is specifically excluded from the district. "
In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests,
guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding
by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health,
safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants.
The Board of Appeal , after careful consideration of the evidence presented at the
public hearing, and after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact:
1 . The proposed use is in harmony with the intent specified in the City of
Salem Zoning Ordinance as it pertains to the R-3 zone with the grant of a
Special Permit.
2. Various letters of support for the project were read, as well as actual
testimony being voiced by health care professionals and others.
3. Opposition,in the form of letters, was read and actual testimony was
also voiced by abutters and others.
4. The ownership and operation of the proposed nursing home would be by
persons with long experience in this industry. They have owned and
operated such facilites in the area.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF VINNIN ASSOCIATES REALTY TRUST FOR
A SPECIAL PERMIT AT 7 LORING HILLS AVENUE (MAP 21 , PARCEL 96) , SALEM
page two
5. The need for nursing home bed space , as stated by petitioner and others,
is very acute.
6. Petitioner presented an actual recent traffic count study for visitors,
employees and delivery vehicles at similar facilities.
7. The 2 acre lot of the proposed nursing home is in close proximatey to an
area of mixed uses, such as commercial and residential .
8. The proposed use of a nursing home would be less of a traffic burden
than residential . The area is served by major roadways.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented, the
Board of Appeal concludes as follows :
1 . The proposed use will promote the public good by meeting the need for
nursing homes.
2. The proposed nursing home is in harmony with the intent of the Zoning
Ordinance.
3. The proposed nursing home will promote the public health, safety convenience
and welfare of the City's inhabitants.
Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted unanimously, 5-0, to grant the
Special Permit requested, subject to the following conditions:
1 . Petitioner meet all requirements of the Salem Fire Department.
2. Property Street numbering be obtained the the City of Salem Assessors Office.
3. All construction be done as per existing City and State building Code and
as per plans and dimensions submitted.
4. Proper shrubbery shall be placed, and maintained in perpetuity, along lot
lines and throughout the property with the approval of the Salem Planning
Department.
5. Any and all dumsters shall be placed away from the present adjacent
condominiums site line and these dumpsters shall also be properly screened.
6. Property approvals, if required, be obtained from any and all other
applicable City and State Boards or Commissions, such as, but not limited to,
the Planning Board, Conservation Commission or Board of Health.
7. A Certificate of Occupancy be obtained.
8. Petitioner explore, and make good faith effort to secure traffic lights
for interseciton of Carol Way and Loring Avenue.
9. Petitioner shall abide by all decisions of the Salem Planning Board
relative to traffic flow for this and adjacent projects.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF VINNIN ASSOCIATES REALTY TRUST FOR
A SPECIAL PERMIT AT 7 LORING HILLS AVENUE (MAP 21 , PARCEL 96) , SALEM
page three
10. Petitioner shall obtain rights, if required, to use Loring Hills Avenue.
If,and when, such permission is obtained, petitioner shall be responsible
for all maintenance, repair, snow plowing and the like for Loring Hills
Avenue.
11 . Petitioner shall , in conjunction with adjacent condominium associations,
work out a proportionate payment for shared common areas and facilities.
12. Developer shall cooperate with building a guardhouse or other safety
facility for the condominium association on Carol Way or Loring Hills Ave.
SPECIAL PERMIT GRANTED 44 d ��)
c ar A. Be al , Vice Chairman'—
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to section 17 of
the Mess. General Lacs, Chapter 808, and shall be filed within 20 days
after the date of filing of this decision in the office of the city clerk.
Pursuant to Mass. (,,emara) Laws, chooter 808, Section 11, the variance
or •_peeial Permit p,rowe- he:em shall not take effect until a copy of the
decision, bearing, the certd`.cation of the City clerk that 20 days have
elapsed and no appeal has been til^tl, or that, it such appeal has been
filed, that it has been dism155e4 or denied is recorded In the South Essex
Registry of Deeds and indexed under the name or the owner of record or
is recorded and noted r,i the owner's certificate of Title.
BOARD OF APPEAL!
3y,
BOARD OF APPEALS '
PAP ZI 8 Zia AM "J9
RECEIVED
CITY OF SALEM,MASS,
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
y present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives; staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
RIWI
-a-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
rF _/ _ .
�!.
0
OF APPEALS
L , ce V
20
C. � cirr uF sE :°'Ass. F�►�9�l6
sk. t p�
c��vr \0 A .
I1 n I i 1 @J?L
1 � E c CCS, Q,wl
kj
Xla CO 2- U 1-�E-
X vCn0
H. HENRY. STARK
William Luster
City Planner
One Salem Greene
Salem, MA 01970
March 10, 1990
RE: Proposed 123 bed Nursing Home
At the Village At Vinnin Square
Dear Sir:
I am a resident, owner and registered voter of 19 Valiant Way
at the Village At Vinnin Square. I have reviewed the concept
and particulars of the above proposed facility. I am versed
on the proposed facilities operational and functional
particulars. I am very much in favor of this anticipated
building. Iurge you, your department and the respective city
departments to summarily approve this project.
There is a proven need for this facility for which I trust
your actions will satisfy.
Thank you for the opportunity to express my opinion.
Respectfully,
Margaret E.S�rk
.n a'
w a o 1990
oUj
MpR 1 4
U v�
o
g
m
HOME CARE GROUP
. of t he Nor t h S h o r e
Visiting Nurse Association of Greater Salem, Inc.
Community Home Care, Ltd.
27 Congress Street, P.O. Box 4566 -
Salem, MA 01970
(508)745-9050 -
n
March 19, 1990 - ' ' UD
0
Salem Zoning Board of Appeals
One Salem Green
Salem, MA 01970
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing on behalf of the Home Care Group of the North Shore to
request your support for the 123 bed nursing home proposed for Loring
Hills Ave.
The Home Care Group of the North Shore is the parent company of the Visiting
Nurse Association of Greater Salem and Community Home Care, Ltd. Our organiz-
ation has been providing home health services in the Salem community since
1897. We provide nursing care, rehabilitation services, social services,
support services, home health aide services, private duty services, and hospice
services to individuals in their homes. It is often through the provision of
home care services that we see people being able to remain in their home
despite acute or chronic illnesses. We also see many people who have reached
the point where they are no longer able to remain in their home and patients
and families must seek out nursing home arrangements.
The Home Care Group also provides discharge planning through a contractual
relationship with Salem Hospital . The great numbers of people in the Salem
area awaiting nursing home placement in both the hospital and the community
is something we deal with on a daily basis, and our staff is critically aware
of the impact this nursing home shortage has upon patients and their families.
It is because of our involvement both in providing home care services and
discharge planning that we come in contact on a daily basis with anywhere from
20-40 people awaiting nursing home placement at any point in time. We urge
your support for additional nursing home beds on Loring Hills Avenue.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
. aew
• Linda A. Billows,
President
LAB/clb
cc: Richard Bane
Mr. William Luster, City Planner BOA Ur�F ii Rey
City of Salem, Planning Department
One Salem Green N? Z$ 2 02 pW °90 �, E
Salem, MA 01970 1
RECEIVEDMAR 2 6 1990
RE: Proposed Nursing Care Facility SALEM,MASS.
AwfM PtANiIING flfPT.
Loring Hills Avenue ..
Dear Mr. Luster:
i am writing this letter, as a resident of 53 Valiant Way, an abutter
to the proposed nursing care facility, and as an abutter in favor of the
proposed facility as initially presented. By way of background, I have
twelve years experience in the real estate industry, presently the
principal of Marigot Associates, Inc., an appraisal and consulting business
serving local lenders and private clients.
i speak in favor of the proposed nursing home, after conversations
with the developer, proposed operators, and after scrutiny of plans and
renderings made available to residents of the Village at Vinnin Square and
the Loring Hills Avenue Condominium, and after several meetings one of
which you attended. My support is generated from several distinct areas,
specif Ica)ly:
1. Need for services - the acute need locally and statewide for
nursing care is well documented.
2. Land Use - within the context of Residential I I I zoning specific
to the site In question, the proposed use does not appear in
conflict with surrounding land use (commercial and
residential), and appears to have less of an impact with regard
to traffic volume and overall density than twenty-five
residential units allowed by right on this two acre site.
3. Development Team History - the developer, Vinnin Associates,
has a local history In the immediate neighborhood of
sensitivity in site planning and quality of construction
evidenced by the highest sales values of any project in Salem.
The operators, the Bain and Salter families, are widely
recognized for the quality of the care facilities they currently
operate, most of which are local and in residential
neighborhoods.
r
4. Tax Revenues - the increase in revenue to the City of Salem is a
benefit that in these times of fiscal constraint, should not be
ignored.
As a result, I hope that both your department and the Board of Appeals
will look favorably upon the proposed care facility, and continue to seek
input from immediate abutters regarding legitimate concerns centered
around the routing of traffic, parking, and landscape/site treatments
harmonious with the existing environment.
Thank you in advance for your consideration.
Re,pectful fitted,
j
ciC
(:ark E. George
53 Valiant Way
Salem, MA 01970
f
HOME CARE GROUP
o f t h e N o r t h S h o r e
Visiting Nurse Association of Greater Salem, Inc.
Community Home Care, Ltd.
27 Congress Street,P.O. Box 4566
Salem, MA 01970
(508)745-9050
.e
March 19, 1990 n.a
CW -�
r. T'
-' '� -n
Salem Zoning Board of Appeals R
One Salem Green
Salem, MA 01970
To Whom It May Concern:
I am writing on behalf of the Home Care Group of the North Shore to
request your support for .the 123 bed nursing home proposed for Loring
Hills Ave.
The Home Care Group of the North Shore is the parent company of the Visiting
Nurse Association of Greater Salem and Community Home Care, Ltd. Our organiz-
ation has been providing home health services in the Salem community since
1897. We provide nursing care, rehabilitation services, social services,
support services, home health aide services, private duty services, and hospice
services to individuals in their homes. It is often through the provision of
home care services that we see people being able to remain in their home
despite acute or chronic illnesses. We also see many people who have reached
the point where they are no longer able to remain in their home and patients
and families must seek out nursing home arrangements.
The Home Care Group also provides discharge planning through a contractual
relationship with Salem Hospital . The great numbers of people in the Salem
area awaiting nursing home placement in both the hospital and the community
is something we deal with on a daily basis, and our staff is critically aware
of the impact this nursing home shortage has upon patients and their families.
It is because of our involvement both in providing home care services and
discharge planning that we come in contact on a daily basis with anywhere from
20-40 people awaiting nursing home placement at any point in time. We urge
your support for additional nursing home beds on Loring Hills Avenue.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
" amu
amu\jQ
Linda A. Billows
President
LAB/clb
cc: Richard Bane
BOARD aFWCALs 01
GEORGE A. AUBERTIN
17 Saltonstall Parkway HAfl 2S 37 �`� 190
Salem, MA 01970
RUEIVED
March 22, 1990 CITY OF 54LEI4,HAS$,
Salem Zoning Board of Appeals
One Salem Green
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Ladies and Gentlemen:
I am writing to lend my full support to the application by
Vinnin Realty Associates Trust for a Special Permit to allow
construction of a 123 bed nursing home at 7 Loring Hills
Avenue. This petition is scheduled to be heard at your
meeting March 28 , 1990.
Having been involved in elder affairs in the City of Salem
for the last eight years, during which time I was President
of the Salem Chapter of the AARP, I must emphasize to you
how urgently this city is in need of a nursing home. The
senior citizens of Salem who do need long term care have no
alternative but to leave the city at a time in their lives
when being close to their home and family is precisely what
they need the most.
I have met with the proposed operators of the nursing home,
and am impressed with their plans, their philosophy and
their track record. They are local people, all living in
Swampscott and Marblehead, and they will be a very welcome
addition to our fine city.
I urge you str6ngly to grant the special permit for this
facility as expeditiously as possible. The need in this city
for nursing home beds increases each day and the longer that
we delay the process, the worse our problem will be.
I thank you for your consideration.
Very Truly Yours,
Q
George A. Aubertin
Editor, Salem AARP Newsletter
BOARD OF APPEALS
KENNETH DEMB
36 CEDAR STREET MARBLEHEAD MAS�.,01945
fiAR 18 F2
EEUI IVFD
CITY OF SXLEp1,P1A55,
Mr . William Luster
City Planner--City of Salem
1 Salem Green
Salem, Mass. 01970
Dear Sir :
I am writing to you in support of the concept of a life-care facil-.
ity such as is being planned for thei "Village at Vinnin Square" , and
as described in their brochure as a retirement community . As I
understand the proposed development , it will consist of a number of
residential units associated with a nursing facility which will be
reserved for the residents as needed by them.
I have visited such communities in Eastern Massachusetts and in
Florida, and in each case I can state that the development was a
credit to the area in which it operates. As you must know, the
elderly segment of the population is growing rapidly and its needs
must be met in a systematic manner . Planning for a life-care
facility should therefore be a first priority .
The people in these residences are active and independent , and it is
a source of comfort to know that in the event that one of tnem. must
be given special medical attention , the nursing facility is there
for them. This type of installation fulfills a need for the elder .
population that cannot be served in any other way , and it would be a
credit to the City of Salem to have such a modern approach to the
elderly of the' city and the surrounding communities.
The builders and operators of this community are well known in the
area as responsible people, and their existing installations should
be a clue as to the quality of buildings and plant they expect to
operate. I would urge you to react favorably to their proposal .
Very sincerely yours,
KENNETH DEMB
March 26, 1990
f
Robert V. AMC BOARD OF APPEALS REAL ESTATE
40 GLENDALE AVE., PEABODY, MA 01960 (508) 530.1436 APPRAISER
Fc t0 , AS90
CITY Of �R6
William Luster
City Planner
City of Salem
Salem, Massachusetts 01970
Dear Mr. Luster:
Just recently the undersigned had occasion to make an appraisal of
the twenty-nine plus acre parcel of land owned by the Vinnin Associates
Realty Trust located on and to the rear of Loring Avenue, Loring Hills
Avenue and Weatherly Drive, Salem, Massachusetts.
The appraisal was made for bank mortgage purposes and included many
of the residential condominium units located within Phases I, II and III
of the Village at Vinnin Square Condominium Complex. The formal written
appraisal report also included a two acre parcel of land fronting on
Loring Hills Avenue that is proposed for.use as a site for the construct-
ion of a nursing home.
In the appraisal process, the appraiser gives substantial consideration
to locational features and neighborhood influences. In the subject case, I
made a full investigation of the neighboring land uses and assessed what
effect, if any, the same would have on the value of the property being appr-
aised as well as on the neighborhood of which the appraised property is a
part.
With reference to the proposed nursing home, I examined the plans of
the proposed building as well as the site and topographical plans that are
in attendance to the building. My review of these plans suggested clearly
to me that the design of the building, its architectural style and its set-
ting on the two acre parcel would be very compatible with existing building
of its locus and as such, I concluded that the construction of such a fac-
ility and its presence in the 'locus would have no adverse effect on the value
of neighboring properties or the overall utility of the ways and streets of
the locus.
Ver truly ours,
Robert V. Noone
RVN/ea
6OARD OF APPE"S
52 ��
REcriv�t�
CITY OF SALEJ4JIA5S;
Mr. and Mrs. Emmanuel Gerontis
31 Weatherly Drive
Salem, MA 01970
March 17, 1990
Mr. William Luster
City Planner
City of Salem
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Grosvenor House Nursing Home
Dear Sir:
We are owners, occupants and taxpayers of 31 Weatherly Drive,
at the third phase of The Village at Vinnin Square. We've had a
chance to review the particulars and operative aspects of the
proposed 123 bed nursing home on a Form A lot at "The Village".
We approve of this proposed program. We encourage you and the City
to approve this proposal in summary fashion. We trust you will act
positively for the petitioner.
Res ctful ,
Emmanuel and Valerie Gerontis
BOARD OF APPEALS
52
R`Wyreo
A
George and Marina K�44SRiSsLEF"'SS.
29 Weatherly Drive
Salem, MA 01970
March 17, 1990
Mr. William Luster
City Planner
City of Salem
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Grosvenor House Nursing Home
Dear Mr. Luster: ,
We are residents of The Village at Vinnin Square at 29
Weatherly Drive. Our family has a long history of personal and
professional involvement in the City of Salem.
We have reviewed the proposed Grosvenor House Nursing Home.
There is a tremendous need for this proposal in Salem. We are very
much in favor of this anticipated building. We endorse this and
encourage you to approve Vinnin Associates proposal.
Thank you for the opportunity to express our opinion.
R pectrM;�
,
10/--
and Kargakis
"fez
2�7) 1 .
\. al.\>. ._��
f. .,�4. ,� ti,
44;4 r .. � _ n.\,. y",.
V.' t � .. �,tai+ m'.�hY.v+. �
i;
i
< ,
��
�� '� � �\
/, � ;
g
r
r I r y • �, r �I'
J % r
I ;
t
774�;�
Ab
ate- �- L -�- -
.tiN-2--
w � ,
JOSEPH ERLICH ®9E.40 S ti.tea
10812 LAKE PALM LANE
BOYNTON BEACH, FL 33437 QP p M _
v� 22 MAR
a� tea,.•••
_ j rosemrte
�� e ca u t, 0/990
�.. -
y--
aa`-
7.
✓� v C��+ .nip-ecae�al� ,C�-.v�. orL ara ,Ir�c�urL�
���h2�-���?�� �r'u' c�ix�a�o�ow✓ C�n�a , I
v
i
r
�-
n�rn La "3
tTi
to o f/N
Titg of 'Sttlem, pnesuchusetts 13
3 Uoffire of tl v @litg Tounrif
'8t keTa Titg �Hull
WARD COUNCILLORS
MARK E. BLAIR - 1990
COUNCILLORS-AT-LARGE PRESIDENT
GEORGE A.NOWAK
1990
JOSEPHINE R. FUSCO KEVIN R.HARVEY
DONALD T.BATES CITY CLERK VINCENT J.FURFARO
GEORGE P.McCABE
LEONARD F.O'LEARY
JOHN R.NUTTING
DAVID B.GAUDREAULT
RICHARD E.SWINIUCH
SARAH M.HAYES
MARK E.BLAIR
March 26, 1990
Mr. James M. Fleming, Chairman
Board of Appeal
City of Salem
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Chairman Fleming:
Enclosed is a letter from Norma Teague, 6 Loring Hills Avenue,
U-A2 , concerning the proposed nursing home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue.
She has many concerns about the impact this proposed project wi$1
have. Ms . Teague ' s concerns are shared by many residents in the
area who will be attending the March 28th Board of Appeals meeting.
I would appreciate the enclosed letter being entered into
the record of March 28th, and that all members of the Board receive
a copy. Many residents will be attending this meeting and I am
sure, as always , the Board of Appeals will address their concerns .
Sincerely,
MARK E. BLAIR
COUNCILLOR WARD SEVEN
MEB/deb
A
COPY: Norma Teague
r*a p
vr:a
n> b�
Qn ,.�.
Re: Proposed Nursing Home at 7 Loring Hills Ave, Parcel 96 Mar 22, 1990
Comments of close abutter, Norma Teague, 6 Loring Hills Ave. , Unit A-2
Drainage - a few years back this parcel was swamp-land, sometimes turning into
a po nd where ducks would congregate. The Loring Hills Condos were constructed
on the same type of wetlands. As a result, we have a very high water table.
Basements in Al and A2 flooded seriously until the Trustees installed a heavy-
duty sump pump. At times this pump operates 24 hours a day. It is my most far-
reaching impact concern that the use of this land, covered by such a large build-
ing, will compound the current drainage and flooding.
Access to Loring Hills Avenue from Loring Avenue - The Village Shopping Plaza
and the Professional Building use this entrance exit for their customers and
personnel. At times, when the Stanestsky Fun eral Home has a large funeral
cortege, I use the Village Condo's road in order to get out. This will also be
the entrance and egress for the nursing home's ambulances, hearses, deliveries
and personnel. Because of the many businesses at this juncture, cars are parked
on both sides of Loring Avenue.
Impact on my immediate neighborhood - I don't want to see and hear ambulances
and hearses. I don't want to hear the cars of employees as three shifts break-i
each day - especially at 11 pm and 7 am. The employee and delivery entrance is;
directly opposite my bedroom. I don't want to look at a long, unbroken stretch'
of a brick building from my windows and patio. I don't want the quiet of this
little neighborhood to change by the inappropriate use of that land for a
nursing home. Surely our day-to-day lives and the investment in our property
should be seriously considered.
IF the nursing home proposal is inevitable, I respectfully request these
stipulations:
Absolutely NO EXHAUST SYSTEMS should be vented in our direction or to the rear
of the Shopping Plaza. All systems should face the wooded area on the other
side of the building. The kitchen fumes and odors, the steam from the laundry
room, the air-conditioning units should not be seen or heard by us. I am keenly
aware of the noise from exhaust systems because of the experience we had with
the compressors (four large units) on the roof of the Village Plaza. The Salem
Health Department had the owners install bafflers (?), and we now have about
50/ less noise. For close to three seasons we kept our windows and doors closed
in order to keep from going bonkers.
SIDEWALKS should be installed on Loring Hills Avenue in line with those of the
Plaza. Between the sidewalk and building, real trees (such as fast-growing
maples) should be planted, They should not skimp on the spacing of these trees;
we will need them to camouflage the monotomy of the huge brick wall the building
will create.
DUMPSTERS?- We now have four close-by - two at Richdales/Lena's and two at Papa
Gino's. We also have flocks of sea-gulls as a result of the garbage; they roost
on our roodh and mess up the patios and walks. Dumpsters at the new site will
also be used for food disposal. Again, these should face the wooded area; we
should not see them. Sincerely,
Norma Teague
BOARD OF APPEALS
q4P 26 16 APS `99
RECEIVED
CITY Or SALEM,MASS.
1
N BORD OF APPEALS l
RECEIYED
CITY OF SALEH,MASS.
March 22, 1990
Mr. William Luster RECEIVED ,
City Planner
One Salem Green MAR 23 1990
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Mr. Luster,
SALEM PLANNING DEPT.
I really appreciate your being at the meeting last
night re the proposed nursing home which will be
directly across the street from my condo unit (A$).
This morning I put my thoughts in writing and came
up with the attached comments. I'd like to request
that you go over it first and then deliver it by
hand to Mr. James M. Fleming, Chairman of the Board
of Appeal. Perhaps you could discuss it with him,
and tell him about the reaction you may have had
at last night 's meeting.
Sincerely,
Norma Teague U
A2 Loring Hills Av/01970
i
i
Re: Proposed Nursing Home at 7 Loring Hills Ave, Parcel 96 Mar 22, 1990
Comments of close abutter, Norma Teague, 6 Loring Hills Ave. , Unit A-2
Drainage - a few years back this parcel was swamp-land, sometimes turning into
a po nd where ducks would congregate. The Loring Hills Condos were constructed
on the same type of wetlands. As a result, we have a very high water table.
Basements in Al and A2 flooded seriously until the Trustees installed a heavy-
duty sump pump. At times this pump operates 24 hours a day. It is my most far-
reaching impact concern that the use of this land, covered by such a large build-
ing, will compound the current ,drainage and flooding.
Access to Loring Hills Avenue from Lorin Avenue - The Village Shopping Plaza
and the Professional Building use this entrance exit for their customers and
personnel. At times, when the Stanestsky Fun eral Home has a large funeral
cortege, I use the Village Condo's road in order to get out. This will also be
the entrance and egress for the nursing home's ambulances, hearses, deliveries
and personnel. Because of the many businesses at this juncture, cars=are parked
on both sides of Loring Avenue.
Impact on my immediate neighborhood - I don't want to see and hear ambulances
and hearses. I don't want to hear the cars of employees as three shifts break
each day - especially at 11 pm and 7 am. The employee and delivery entrance is
directly opposite my bedroom. I don't want to look at a long, unbroken stretch
of a brick building from my windows and patio. I don't want the quiet of this
little neighborhood to change by the inappropriate use of that land for a
nursing home. Surely our day-to-day lives and the investment in our property
should be. seriously considered.
IF the nursing home proposal is inevitable, I respectfully request these
stipulations:
Absolutely NO EXHAUST SYSTEMS should be vented in our direction or to the rear
of the Shopping Plaza. All systems should face the wooded area on the other
side of the building. The kitchen fumes and odors, the steam from the laundry
room, the air-conditioning units should not be seen or heard by us. I am keenly
aware of the noise from exhaust systems because of the experience we had with
the compressors (four large units) on the roof of the Village Plaza. The Salem
Health Department had the owners install bafflers(?), and we now have about
50J less noise. For close to three seasons we kept our windows and doors closed
in order to keep from going bonkers.
SIDEWALKS should be installed on Loring Hills Avenue in line with those of the
Plaza. Between the sidewalk and building, real trees (such as fast-growing
maples) should be planted. They should not skimp on the spacing of these trees;
we will need them to camouflage the monotomy of the huge brick wall the building
will create.
DUMPSTERS - We now have four close-by - two at Richdales/Lena's and two at Papa
Gino's. We also have flocks of sea-gulls as a result of the garbage; they roost
on our root and mess up the patios and walks. Dumpsters at the new site will
also be used for food disposal. Again, these should face the wooded area; we
should not see them.
� Sincerely,
� � W
Norma TeagueT m
(nn czo
nTn
r:ZM.
" -u rn
to cr+ Cn
Ab
23 VALIANT WAY
SALEM, MA 01970
March 23, 1990
Mr. James M. Fleming, Chairman
City of Salem Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Mr. Fleming:
I am writing re the public hearing for "all persons interested in the petition
submitted by Vinnin Associates Realty Trust for a special permit to allow
construction of a 123 bed nursing hone at 7 Loring Hills Avenue Assessors Map 21 ,
Parcel 96 (R-3)".
In view of the fact that there has been little publicity about this proposal, some
of us have been unable to attend the Wednesday night meetings, and many resident
owners have not returned from wintering in the south, I think the timing of these
hearings has precluded many from voicing an opinion. I request that until everyone
affected is properly provided with details of physical design, results of traffic
and environmental impact studies, apprised of resultant possible advantages/
disadvantages and given ample time to comment, granting of this easement will either
be delayed or denied. I commend Mr. Zieff for his desire to build a nursing home,
as I'm sure there is a definite need .for such a facility. However, I and many t
others here at the Village question the highly visable, choice location he would
like to use in this endeavor and would welcome his selection of a more suitable
location. I also think it appropriate to point out that; had his nursing home
been the first priority of his development of the Village rather than his last,
his degree of success in marketing and selling his Phases 1 , 2 and 3 could have
been greatly diminished. I have no doubt that his design will be pleasing, but
an additional 123 bed nursing home at that location can't help,, `� change the nature
of the pond area which now provides a most attractive entrance,,would also provide
an ideal environ for patients to stroll and be strolled in during all but the winter
months.
Thank you for considering the dilemma of the home owners at The Village of Vinnin
Square and for your help in postponing this decision until we have more time to
assess the pros and cons.
Sincerely, // o
Carolyn T. Peirce
'SSV!�!'!•;3+ ;i d0 Alli
03A!3a13a
06, WV 50
Sl73ddv 0 Omo
eo�,no .OWLS-231
�PPo
1'lA� 26 8 37 Q 9�
o <,4r� RECEIVED
OF p
/� CITY OF SALEII,HASS
o/p 7p
y `s
�rTrNT/o�v .
�y ri�T>' "/ ms`s r f-cGa���/NG �o�v STo�cr-/o✓
p,vr�/s f 1}7-
T�.��/
o � T OF
vlTi� Tr /T� w evev �S
Ale fC.5/9 eo-T ,.y7- �a T vPe4 �y
you
Is
s
lg!!:�oIAI � el� Ja ,vS
CVkk cA✓T
.51Y r • pyo
f� ® Y
�wo raL �GkS u' � �H� c' / �C �0 /o "iI "G
sTi�T/or✓ d rood �STol�e �v�✓�.✓ aOAltl7
se i4c
�•�o�,s �ov/.vim i
� �' • �°�'�o 'S ��.�s�'s :z' -,� o`er �''��s
�N� � erg ddFF/c
S<o T
ul lr
�o w
/ �o.v G /�' !�G .l�/f1A� 6ekOco'.S
G
�j / y G✓/�c,✓ e/✓%e�/,vim /�"N � /
Com1 71
.
/ /� ,,,vas �;�� �� •��
/7 w 1,7 /
�pcTe� ��H �c` es vl�/ Tom ��l� lcl�S �y1
1,e Al !(OG �GG /S
ole �/ s l�p�.�r/ r /� T�J ��i��
T 1v��� /ji�Tp��ST
/! wm��� GG�.�T� � •v /���I/T/ o.v�t� �'�zlt�4°�S
�'N 4
oNd/ T/o
ppA�p OF
1.9
RrS��vh4,pAA5S•
CITY OF
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, . pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also,
2-Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours, A
/ /
r
B[?ARO OF 0PEALS
1819 R 90
RECD. VED
CITY OF SALEM,MASS-
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
S� 2L�C L- e- 69 Ce)
USE THE INTERNATIONAL
AIR AYBILLPMEMSWITHIN TO PUERTO RICO A NSA.,NON U AND LHAWAIIOCATIONS
A�RBG�� .40 4 9 2 0�9 61
USE THE AL AIR1800LL385355 SHIPMENTS TOLL
ORICO AND ALL NONNSlOGTIONS TRACKING NUMBER
QUESTIONS?CALL 80G 238-5355 TULL FREE.
60452DE
f
Dale RECIPIENT'S COPY `
MOSCOW=I
) "
From(Your Name),Please Print ;Your Phone Number(Very Important) To(flecipient's Name)Please Print jgetipenls Plpne rvumcerlverylmponaml
t s
Company '1 DepadmeM/ForloNo Company Department/floor No.
BVeel Atldress Exact Street Atltlress(Wefxrat DtliuxroP.G.BaaaPO Zm®CPdsJ
x t
City— -' _ Slate Z/PRequiretl Ciy $late ZIP Requiretl
YOUR INTERNAL BILLING REFERENCE INFORMATION(First 24 characters VON 4WON invoice.) IF OLD FDR PICK-UP,Pont FEDEX AdSas Hee r
j 5 eel f
1
A dress
YMFNT I❑BIII Senber 2❑Bill R cigenl's F ItlEx AM.No. 3❑Bill aid Perry FeJEx Acct.No. A❑ ill Gedil Card City $WIe ZIP Required
SO Gash // 1 '
SERVICES 1 OELIVERYAND SPECIAL HANDLING ncxPaasl roua oauaeP own Emp. a: 1 Date Federal Express Use+'
(Check Dory one box) my Base C arges'
(eony,ob V (Re(ivery VINOr j r tu[ SVF �CasM1 Recevea µ�-'x]�-�-.
v i
PnaS OrenpBh( ' STerrderd WarrrlBNf • } s ❑Retu SM1 pm
Eernm Semcro „ 1.❑ NGLO FBRWCN UP ox eo.nr
(i��(� ❑rn'ra Pony �,pcM19Jrppel. p,cn�.To polo Declatl Iue Charge'
buvresmwn tl bdd..d mwnt) 2 DEIIV WEH;DAY SIT 1 drd5$
11 ❑YOURRIDING�51 ❑ 3 DRIVErPar mreUuaiDAY,Ln' awl ❑ _�t y Other 1
_._
LHA
� DANGEAD�G lamawrye) `
I6❑FEDIXLETTER•58 Q'FTDIX LETTER• ,❑Trowe.aeeieboamnowcmos s.mnxl � 'ty U �51 e{. Zip
__
12❑MUNK 52❑,FEIDIX RPK` • 5❑IWwMSi S El 1 ena �I TMaI Total jTolal___. . 1f} ' n Olher2
13 FEDIXBDN 53 FEDIXBDX 6 DRY ICE,.,.,....�.......� m.. " 1 p Total err as
14❑FEDIX Ti 54❑FEDIXCASE 'r-0 {❑ OTHER SPECIAL SERVICE...,..®,._„_ DIMSHIPMENT(HesyeegMSdxTxe0W) X `'.
( Dale/Time Received FedEx Employee Number REN191Ory DATE tl M
Economy SWi NMvyweight$BmCe/ B❑ ❑ lbs. PART#1 195W SRCEF II/89
(Iwmery Slargard Arv) (Iw Ema La and or any ❑ SAFURDAYARIK-UP gexiveE pl
FORMAT p01a
(OeLveryty V) mU .'Orr L.Ads.) 9 la+ —ipel 10 R'olarsWd 30 om Bm 01"1441
11
buvrress ceYt1 JI l
70❑NFAVYWEIGHT^ 10❑ .1,. 40BSC. Release e19M FE C.
f
ECONOMY So❑REFERRED 11 ❑ t y,<<oT t !/ ( ' On- IRop 503ratim SynaWre-,,,,__. .r,„„_,v,,.�.,_�.._......_..-.,b.,_..... PRIMED IN.
SERVICE HFAVWL.hlli" d'v^^”^^"-^� FedF�r• �/ , � Da1641im®�� / f}� USA.
jDewerY roaretei may `DecWred Valve Lime SI00. t2 HOLIRAYDELIVERYr onv�el Em o S /
OR WWI ns meereas. "Ga�lwda'ivary schebu nugm
zfU
MULTIPLE PACKAGE SERVICE TERMS AND CONDITIONS
DEFINITIONS •negpfiabreinstruments.anaother'Ielns listedo f5mcrimenlService Guitle.
On this Airbill,we,our and us refer to Federal Express Corporation,its I If yoµsend more than onepackagetinthis Airbill,you mayfill in the inner
If - off employees and agents You and your refer to the sender,its employees declared value for aU packagits,not to exceed the$100,$500 a$.MiODO
+and agents. percentage limit adsorbed eboke(Examplgq^packageacan have Winter'
AGREEMENT TO TERMS declared value of up to f1126JW0) ->
By giving us your package to deliver,you agree to all the terms on this If more than one package reshipped on this av ill;Ourliablily for toss oi-
Alrbill and in our current Service Guide,which is available on request.II damage will be limited to the actual value Of the packages)lost or
there is a conflict between the content Service Guide and this Alrbill,the damaged(not to exceed the lesser of the total declared value or the per
Service Guide will control No one is authorized to alter or modify the terms package limits described above)You have the responsibility of provingthe
of our Agreement actual loss or damage.
RESPONSIBILITY FOR PACKAGING AND COMPLETING AIRBILL FILING A CLAIM
You are responsible for adequately packaging your goods and for ALL CLAIMS MUST BE MADE BY YOU IN WRITING'.Youmust notify
property filling out this Alrbill Omission of the number Of packages and us of your claim within strict time limits.See current Service Guitle,
waght per packageflbm this Airbilfwill result in a billing based On our best Well consider your cem filed if you call and notify our Customer
estimate of the rrumber Of packages received from you and an estimated Service Department at 800-238-5355 and notify us in writing as soon as
�•,� ,,,,, "default"weight per package,as determined and canonically adjusted by possible.
us. Within 90 days after you notify us of your claim,you must send us all
IF YOU AREAIR TRANSPORTATION TAX INCLUDED relevant informationabout it We are not obligated toad on any claim until
Our basic rale includesafeaeraltax required by Internal Revenue Code you have paid all transportation charges,and you may not deduct the
MAKING AN MPSSantini on the air transportation podion onhissemce. - � amount of your claim from those charges. _
.. If the recipient accepts your package'with,innoting ahy damage on to
LIMITATIONS ON OUR LIABILITY delivery record,we will assume that the package was delivered in grainSHIPMENT, APPLY
"ANO LIABILITIES NOT ASSUMED condition.In order for us to process your claim,you must,to the extent
Our liability for loss or damage to your package is limited to your actual possible,make the original shipping cartons and packing available for
THE SELF ADHESIVE damages or$100,whichever is less.unless you pay for and declare a inspection
higher authorized value.We do nolprovidecargo liability insurance.but T .RIGHT TO INSPFC,T4
you may pay an adoiitional.charge for each ad0llional$100 of declared Mmay,mourgpUen,open and Inspect year packages public orafter
MPS COPY HERE
value:If you declare a higher vabe and'pay the additional charge,our —you give them to us to deliver:
liability will be thelesser of your declared value or the actual value of your N08O.D.SERVICES
package - 4/
^+ In any evenll we will not be liable for any damages,Whether direct, We dont provide CO.O services.
Incidental,special or consequential in excess of the declared value of a RESPONSIBILITY FOR PAYMENT
shipment,whether or not Federal Express had knowledge that such Even if you give us dif erent payment instructions,you will always be
arl
aages lnlght be Incurred including,but not limited to,loss of income primarily responsible for all delivery costs,as well as any costs we may
Crumble. Incur in either returning your package to you or warehousing it pending
We wun1 Its liable for your acts or omissions.including but not limited to dispgsiligrf
improper or insufficient packing.securing,marking or addressing,or for "QUALIFIEDACCEPTANCE r}
theactsorqqm,issims,of the recipient or anyone else wilhan interest in thebacks We reserve the tight t0 reject a shipment al any time,when such
terms f ofir tenemewonnt lie war t be[tablehe for los violates or dam of the shipment would be likely to cause damage or delay to other'shipments,
terms of Don.agreement cy won't pr liable for loss of or damage to equipment or pelsonnel,or if the transportation of which is prohibited by
^
shipments won
, cash,le for to or other prohibited items. law or is in violation of any rules contained in this Airbill or our Service
;iargotWe won'(,oe liable for loss,damage a delay caused by events we Guide.
c _ weather
control.dit Including but not limited to acts t God perils i the air, MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE
P-�� a. rn - writes nslco Ions,mechanical delays, acts of public enemies,war,
strike&civil andquonsgfaots ads)wisionsof ual Or apparent authority.
aIn nd
someevent of untimely delivery,Federal Exprestransportatioll n
charge,our esta
rote customs and quarantine off icials)with actualaapparent authority and withervice Guid for further oformatiall Vanspodation charges.See
current Service Guide for lather in(drma4pn.
r r I I Int DECLARED VALUE LIMITS
., . The highest declared value hi allow fore high Letter and FedEx Pak '
shipments is.000.les Other shipments,the highest declared value we
- allowrs which Case
settee high package contains itemsof'extraordinary500,Itmof 't
value;'inwhichcas:tmClue arpest declaredvalue weallowis$500,Ilmedi r Pert 11113500 SRCEF
_., "exHaadharyvalue;'inclrxleartwoM,jewelry,furs,money precious metals, Rev.11/89
79
32 � ' �
i?cGF1vL'�
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
6
as
J
na 1v
YA
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
S
AX4 � ��.
Barbara M. Toby
3810 Rowena Circle
West Palm Beach, FL 33417
BOA2� OF ��PEp4S
$ 32
��AR 28�tC?,.d0
March 20, •1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
BOARD OF APPEALS
32 °90
RECEIVED
CITY OF SALEP%11,MASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
L
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
G /
_9
AR,/711
J
- _
c � �
a
gf�AS �F ?PEALS
VAR 32 P `95
RF.CEY4E
C11Y
OF SAtcM,SQA$$.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after MaySri when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this ' special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
1
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
IAI�
BOARD OF APPEALS 8i3t!i D 0iF �:�'FE�iL�
MAR S 28 A41 �9a FAR 20 8 37 01 T
RE(,EiVED REC'EWE'D
CITY OF SAt.EH,MASS, CITY OF SALEM,MASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01D70
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-a-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
BOARD OF PPPEALS
BAR 2G B 37 V X99
RECEIVED
CITY DF stki.EM,MASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
C GAY Q�.�Q
zo
It
i
00 PPP�ALS
RECEIVED
CITY 6F S�EFP4,h1A55.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours, / e
�f -7v�fq�iAYli1
�I�AFxD OF ppPEALS
i�pR C6 37 Al'1 °90
(te%I=lyf-,C
CITY OF HASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
BOAftp Or" k:FPEALS
FiAR 2� 5 37 V 'M
RECE11JED
CITY OF SALE14,HASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc, will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home' in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours, /
f�
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
VICTOR W E27th A COHEN
1380 N.W. 27th AVENGE
F DELRAY BEACH, FL 33445
$OAFiD DF APPEALS
jig 37
RECEIVED
CITY OF SALtFa�14ASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-a-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
5�
r7a
k
4ft
10
v, c .
.= r
HARD Gr APPEALS
MAP N 8 37 AM '90
REUMD
CITY OF SAEE�1,)41ASS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,,
!r� D/,�QU�I�
�L
X70
f�
f
l
BOARD OF : " �11LS
MAR U qu
RECI
CITY OF St.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
r
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
��-�-
��,.,�
h
- n kR
IRR 26 8 3 ,
RECEIVEC
CITY OF SALEIM,
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly
yours,
J
r
i
' iO F 1PPE:A L
®� ?ra All a fi ll+1 2S t'J t i
RECEWcO
CITY OF SALEM,
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
y -2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
J�1 klLA�cQ�� t4
�t
BOARD OF APPE41-S
«Aft ZG 8 ?6 AM `90
RECEIVED
CITY OF SALEM,f0L;1,3.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 03.970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very
�truly yours,
L4V
qI r `' W
�°- -l � - -
la�
- , . �
BOARD OF APPEALS
FgR 26 $ 16
RECEIVED
CITY OF SALEM,WS.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
LUBOVSKY
60 FREEDOM 1 OUM
APT.218
SALEM,MA 01670
6.0ARD 0€ API' :i:LS
MAR Z6 0 36 ` °q(1
RECEIVE1
CITY OF SALEM. >„
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Saler.!, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
r -z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly �yours,
le
477 u�
AeIL / ,, D i 970
Gr
BAAR;D .DF APPEALS
ase, 2'6 36 Gi� '90
�,Ecwweo
�9TY o SALM HAS S.
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28 , 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
t
_ -- 1
�J��3MAR 4c
IRWIN SHAPIRO
11094 APPLEGATE LANE
BOYNTON BEACH, FLORIDA 33437
r �\
JEW
,
.:ASS.
C1SY OF SH,....
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: . Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
S Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
{ 1
,Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
. 4
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
0
t
f
YC-0/
March 28, 1990
Board of Appeals
City of So em
City Hall
93 Washington Street
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Board Members :
P.A. R. Properties is the managing agent for Summit Estates Condominiums ,
261 units, located at 1000 Paradise Road in Swampscott, The Glen
Condominiums, 60 units, located at One Loring Avenue, in Swampscott and
Loring Hills Condominiums, 38 units located at 6 Loring Hills Avenue,
in Salem. All properties are in the proximity of the Vinnin Square
area .
Numerous unit owners and residents have contacted me regarding the
proposed 123 bed nursing home to be constructed on the parcel of land
located at 7 Loring Hills Avenue per the Assessors Mop 21 , Parcel 96 .
The purpose of this letter is to express deep concern on this subject
to the Planning Board/Board of Appeals .
During the past three years there has been much- development in--this
area. The construction of the Village At Vinnin Square will add
approximately 350 new homes . In addition, a new office building was
built at 530 Loring Avenue, along with the Village Shops . Residents
of the condominium communities, office personnel of The Contemporary
Building and customers/staff of the Village Shops use Loring Hills
Avenue as a means of entrance and exit . Residents in this area do
not feel Loring Hills Avenue can handle additional traffic .
The construction of the nursing home will generate vehicles due to
staffing, visitors, vendors, ambulances, etc . Many residents are
concerned with inadequate parking facilities and the flow of traffic
from Loring Hills Avenue and Carol Way on to Loring Avenue. These
are extremely dangerous intersections . An accident recently occurred
in this area which resulted in a fatality . Due to the many businesses
located at the junction of Loring Hills Avenue and Loring Avenue,
vehicles are currently parking on both sides of said roadways .
The nursing home will basically be in the back yard of residents at
Loring Hills Condominiums and many residents of The Village at Vinnin
Spare . Residents are concerned with the noise of ambulances , sight
of hearses , odors from cooking, trash removal , dumpster care and
noise generated from the HVAC equipment .
1000 .Vavadise Road, Swampscott, Mfg 01907, (617) 599-1000
Board of Appeals
City of Salem
March 28, 1990
Page Two.
At this time, numerous owners of Summit Estates, Loring Hills
Condominiums, The Glen and Village at Vinnin Square feel strongly
that the City of Salem should view 7 Loring Hills Avenue as an
unacceptable location for the construction of a nursing home .
Thank you for your consideration .
Very truly yours ,
P A<R . PR(�P�ERTI S, INC.
r'+Pap/icia R. n
1
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
I1 n
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990 .
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-2-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
March 20, 1990
City of Salem
Board of Appeal
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass 01970
ATTN: JAMES M. FLEMING, Chairman
RE: Application for special permit to Construct a 123 Bed Nursing
Home at 7 Loring Hills Avenue
Gentlemen:
The undersigned own and maintain our home in the abutting area
known as "the Village at Vinnin Square. "
Those of us who own and reside in this area have great
interest in this matter since we are directly affected.
The undersigned, together with a great many of our neighbors
are presently vacationing in Florida and, therefore, unable to be
present at the hearing on March 28, 1990.
Since we feel we should have the right to be heard, we request
that the hearing date be postponed or the hearing be continued
until after May 15th when most of us will return.
Because we believe that granting this special permit is not
in the public interest, we request that you record that we oppose
the granting of the permit.
We call your attention to the problems in the location for a
nursing home. The access road is Essex Street which is heavily
travelled and feeds into Vinnin Square with three shopping malls.
The immediate vicinity has a cemetery, a funeral parlor, a fast
food establishment, another shopping area containing a bank, pizza
parlors, other stores, two convenience stores, gas stations, etc.
The addition of a nursing home, which will add ambulances,
delivery vehicles, visiting friends and relatives, staff personnel,
etc. will add to traffic problems, hazards to safety, and will
change the character of the neighborhood.
-z-
Also, the petitioner is involved in the continuing development
of the "Village at Vinnin Square" with additional traffic.
We believe that the allowance of a nursing home in this area
would be contra-indicated and completely against the public
interest.
Very truly yours,
4/
March 22 , 1(;90
To: Mr. James Fleming , Chaixman 0IV(3� N A
Board of Appeal
City of Salem
Salem, Ma
Sir:' We the undersigned are strongly opposed to the issuance of a
special permit to Vinnin Associates Realty Trust Parcel B:, The Village
at Vinnin Square. We request, since we are all abutters that their
permit be denied.
Our reasons will be expre�+ +ho Appeal mee frig. // /�/S
(-als'
Signed: C,041,c /y�� *
-
-- . .. .._... ..._..._.- - -... .
,
• � � i lI U
c
f Ir
v
�
L1
i
I
March 22 , 1c,90
To: Mr. James Fleming, Chairman 6W(6/ AIA-
Board of Appeal
City of Salem
Salem; Ma
Sir:: We the undersigned are strongly opposed to the issuance of a
special permit to Vinnin Associates Realty Trust Parcel B, The Village
at Vinnin Scuare. We request, since we are all abutters that their
permit be denied. j
Our reasons will be expressed at the Appeal meeting. {
Signed:
------------
"G01
LC
n �
(
march 22 , 1(90
To: Mr. James Fleming, Chairman
Board of Appeal A
City of Salem
Salem, Ma
Sir:, We the undersigned are strongly opposed to the issuance of a
special permit to Vinnin Associates Realty Trust Parcel R, The Village
at Vinnin Square. We request, since we are all abutters that their
permit be denied.
Our reasons will be expressed at the Appeal meeting.
Signed:
-----------------
Ala
et el
Z4
...........
----------
.............
March 22 , 1c;90
To: Mr. �'Jame.s FleminE; Chairman
'Board- of Appeal
City of Salem `. --- ----- - - --- -- I
Salem; Ma ;ss
Sir:• Wethe undersigned are strongly opposed to the issuance of a !
special permit to Virnin Associates Realty Trust Parcel B:, The Village
at Vinnin Scuare. We request., since we are all abutters that their
permit be denied.
Our reasons will be expressed at the Appeal meeting.
Signed:
5a #3oq
f2EFd1n #Am w41.
Sic rrr 3
.i
44,
March 22 , 1(90
To: Mr. James Fleming, Chairman
Board of Appeal
City of Salem
Salem, Ma
j
Siry We the undersigned are strongly opposed to the issuance of a
special permit to Vinrin Associates Realty Trust Parcel B, The Village
at Vinnin Square. We request, since we " are all abutters that their
permit be denied.
,_Our reasons will be expressed at the Appeal meeting.
Signed:
/ -
fee�1�.Y Zlmw
A SQL
--------
os
,r
�7
� ��1�{.c.e�eGP • 1�'� oL� I
� a__ ,
� , n � <
.�
1 �
t
M1
1 ! .
. . :a _ .a
��
5
� � �
�♦
-
! i \n A
����+ \[ �
�� � x
T � _
_ �i �
' � � - 1 ♦ �' e 1 �
I
' , .may � 1ea } � �-' � s
� _ > >
1
t �
1 . ,.+� i 1. ��
— . -. !
�� S t A
_ � .. r � ` s
1
( ^ � r
_� `� ',. f
� ��
� ,
_ '• r �
�� � I
�:
T-
I
� � ..
. . , � ,t� r
_ . . :�_
� ,r
�.' � �. I
s�
i
� 1 I
r
t � �. �_ .� , �. _ ._. _ v
t � +/
i .�
' �' .
,If
I
i
I�
i
i
li .
I
if
N/F
V"A6[ AT VINN44 SQUARE H LORING CONDOMINIUM TRUST, w '\
2
� - _ 57I�42 ooc
73.76 ce❑ �/ /
NSF \ \/
,/q� V ILLA4E AT
) VINNIN SQV42E O
/ / / �\ S coNDOMINIOMT'QV
9900- 16.765 37 W ..S.o4%6'/
L �. -
y1 w / 55� 59.20 /5.00
901 w
R'73UCIDoo
h /V / 1S9 YI
/ � l �yy 4r /- ' Ct I
PROPOSED y�•yu \ AatdA
E ref
PROPERD;
TY L N / .>' NVAtAONAr /b
001.
0 ��tur�F� � / � ' �- -bp` _- _- - % ( `\ - / •�� \
�Ra �N3'se3seM � 'UPy9��
74Z4>o0 \ \ \ Oe`� N/F
\ 1 / \1 X6.,1`�'�. I \ \ \\ �\ \ ° 6� I \ \�,
�� I \ 1500 / ,f` 6`--"%`\ \ \ \ 68 \
/ IV 4
5
LOT D-2
/ o so\`\ \\ AREA=- 2.9"A►CRES
(t
om 6? \
ZL
7/0/9./
LA
v V// s>. 121c 64 \ \ \D
ED
Clq
O O/ ,P<o \ \\ y / N/C
-I VE O co/Y/3/NEo /NVEbrDr¢S
rausr zg227 I- 3�oc' \ \ \ / / If4t.7Y T�ueT
56 0
Ln64.33 P--/
NIP: .169.9 C'2500 /
NNIN A550CATE5
'�.LT/TRUST ¢:13.0'
_ / uID
u/F
� // /47. 75 W CONDOMINIUM T¢UST. ¢ In
2
73.76 13
56-"1 2'ZS.00
- 54 It_ I �I /.. / _/_`= /9' VILLAGE AT \ i
` 1
5 _ 1 .> VINNINS6VA2E
O
_50 —
(11'd5'37'W
16.76
59.2015.00 /
j '
p �`� Sol f / / 1 L-,SO73.00
o /
\ D• / Y// t7L / P �tl /�
/v / 9\ N /
l0
50 .
ROPO . ID, /
/ PROP
_A8 /
Dor
036 _- ��
_SG(P4co
Mr
5--
'68 \
61
+y
- _62—
\\ 43 ...
��, p yo
e � � LOT D-2 �`> -= � o•
5 a
/1,0 /� 5.0\`6 \ \AREA= 2.gACRES \ ` c
a ,W �0/4.% L=60.0., O/./ '�aV"\ 6 \\\�
,0 463 w/�� 1 q o8g., o
/ s b �Z)C.g bq \ \ \,.\\ \ \\ \ \\ \\(A ,.
pyo
O
z 99 N/F QIVA
/vSATHEPV_ DIVE a
/ 11� CONDOMINIUM TRUST P=3
t"e "--g2.27 �/ _ c'O�' \ \ \ / / A,<_Ac.TY" T/1 u.�T
R=55.00 "s
LP 6 w' N
L=64.33 P-
9 ,so `7 `>i9•, 5 \ \ Ip Q -
�N89os'o7" VINNIN A550CINTES L__ 00 z,/3 \ \ !40
7 222.23 REALT, TRU5T
Z45.ZO ��o \ /10� /
s /
LP LD
/
'�If 1J�:10li .ee.
r i
477
�•s "r i, k
d .(
Tel
Ic
04
e
J
F
Y `RT
x
a
x
a
w e,
k +
+ Y
' 7
yg�
i
a '
m
y�
r '
,
,... ,,, � °• y := tr"� 'r .''`.d``..t� '�..,. r,.,"-�-� _ s, ,,�: �,.; W. 19�y ;r,v �.r �. .v.. �r�'
Jr
IF Y' :',y,' i > vf s
t Jr �
-a ,. � P •'- :.. r r + i,• .. ._ ..... _ e..' ., '-,... ----"' > d __..
� e �4sfi �.. :, � � ,: 0. I !�, .. .� v ... .y..... - ..
SL ..
0
_I a
Ap
,
1
•-yam � ��} _,,, � r
ar .,_"' ...... _.. , '. . . 'ZM1e, ..x.:. i -,.. � .:L :. . r. ,f :. yw ,_.i! •'i' _ f , .. b "^ :4.. s f [.
'..� # -,..� .. �.. .. •:'Irv; _._: �.. ...,,Tel` �x��' �. ,..�E � t. :. : .r S ' i ...:x 3' ,
• ,n: .. • r>. „. � �. :. -.. � ) .... s „ �.. ? t{._.. '{j\ rte-- .:_' ... ,.
,y ,' i �1 1. .•.fi 1 , '. � .:_ I -Af � : 1 .iF �: . �f 1 � T I. I : . .r. . _, � f
.� � Lw r f i � i Ir f"v ,- :. i u: l � . 5:.. r � d d '.. .. - •.._. 0 �• ,�
+ .✓ Syw' , ry.. i , ,L + L-. r a :I. : c. { ._- .'r .. { r. y e ,t : 4
ly,
, � , .. ,. ♦ r,.- .o . .. v fl „JC/. .. , .. '..: f '.. .. .meq(`/ r ..- .:;.. .,'r � ^, R F b
.., v ._.. a .[. .N a . ..: ':. • r$" _
i a
+ ��y' ♦: :, r.,.. .f. ..wire.:. r. .r. .e.. :.
.^... ! .a ... ... { +.. �µ i .( : :i e..^.. ,• y 1 ... _.. Y}u/... "AM'<M:; ..,.. .• �t'�'yg ,' . . n :,i. x... Y -.1�
., w.`.-. �. s »w. - a t,. f , ✓ rxx M"...w e. _r r ..:"'Y!4,- .ei� s.. .., _ A
4
) =.aEa,.$YFz..mn^.tiw.^ri .....-, .. .. . .., «"•. .. ..'_":Ss�+y.:.. . - -- ..._ +*-wd.3_....•.w � �c:, ."S1 - . . n03. �'cwuy,.:. )f
w
J3�
kr
Y
e
' P W
v .
m
s
d`
^Arc'
b
w .
Y S
h
e'
. w ,�.._.. .... ,« _. .n «:�.. .♦ P k. 'C., w-.. 4.uS".._. < :,.- _.,rv,:_.'i. .. +1 c.-s:
_ .. .n.yt. M1 C ...'_.. -
�yu
ro.
AW-1 r' .iax�..., ,. -
-
._. .x.-•fid`,-x� .