14 LEMON STREET - SKOMURSKI, JOSEPH - ZBA 14 Lemon R-2
Joseph Skomurski
� - J
z�
Qlitg of Wpm, Aussar4usetts
Paurb of �ppzal
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF JOSEPH SKOMURSKI FOR A -
SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 14 LEMON ST. , SALEM (R-2) R ,'
A hearing on this petition was held January 16, 1985 with the following Board
Members present: Edward Luzinski, Vice Chairman; Messrs. ,Gauthier, Strout,
Associate Member and ActingSecretary Bencal. Notice of the hearing was sent to
abutters and others and notices of the hearing were properly published in the
Salem Evening News in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A.
The petitioners, owner of the premises, request a Special Permit to extend and
alter a pre-existing nonconforming use by replacing a second floor window with
a door leading to stairs and a deck in the R-2 district.
The provision of the Salem .Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request
for a Special Permit is Sectio V B 10, which provides as follows:
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary appearing
in this Ordinance, the Board of Appeal may; in
accordance with the procedure and conditions set
forth in Section VIII F and IX D, grant Special Permits
for alterations and reconstruction of nonconforming
structures, and for changes, enlargement, extension or
expansion of nonconforming lots, land, structures,
and uses, provided, however, that such change, extension,
enlargement or expansion shall not be substantially more
detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the
neighborhood.
In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests
guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding
by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health,
safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants.
The Board of Appeal, after hearing the evidence presented at the hearing and
after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact:
1 . No opposition was presented to the plan;
2. The structure has been used as a two family dwelling for
several years;
3. The alteration will add a second egress to the second floor to
bring it in compliance with present regulations.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at
the hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows:
1 . The relief requested does not create a substantial detriment
to the public good, nor does it substantially derogate from or
nullify the intent or purpose of the Ordinance.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF JOSEPH SKOMURSKI FOR A
SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 14 LEMON ST. , SALEM
page two
Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted 4 - 0 to grant the relief requested
provided that:
1 . The deck must be 16 feet long and 6 feet wide;
2. Other alterations must be per the plans submitted.
SPECIAL PERMIT GRANTED
2
chard A. B ca , Acting ecretary
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
4
PU-
Ln
b .0
4
1� J
uwil To
APEEi.L FRO;,t THIS DcL IF A!:Y. SHALL BE FEL,DVFITHIC!20 DAYS AETER,THE DATE
SIOt:,
RCE, AFD. SHALL BE FI
CENEP4L LEIS. GH�Pi E'.. VARiAT;CE OR S'. ?� C= ,_!•.
SECTI^iJ Il. THEc c BE4i;l::G Til' " 'r
;'r ThIS LcC aU Iti THE G`'IGE OF THE GiTY GLER I -
c i L . C4APTER E'S,
.
p hcnt . SHALL T'� TW1 EFFECT Oi. L'A C^PY OF O h PEiL,PC _
S HA'r ELAPSED
HAS EEE DS- .: TFc t v GF
Cr TLE CITY CLEFY 1HAT 20 DAY AND Itl-"EXED 'b,-.""
LF. Td AT. IF Si:LH F.a F�PF:F.S H:S BEET. FILE THAI IT
OF RN'-L) OR IS RETARDED AtTD tiOTED ON THE
OYIi1ER'S CERTIFICATE OF TITLE.
RECJF.AEp tit THL' SOOTH ESSEX 2Ei-iSTRY OF DEEDS
BOARD OF APPEAL
_ 4 K
aY7V
v 11 .F
-
iz,
N
a S ;
ry,
21
3
jA
F 4 x1 }
-
�
LY
ANY
jil
x
N 4 y4� Y _?a i¢^ Y .�ZQIC �1 GW ( Z'J•• Jam.` iK -..-nyS v1L Y t _ t € .,a
reig
' �"4�.a'3 , i, ..:��' x�, -... •.' `c t.' i v �:. ' -, � z s_`-.-"r ! sf+.*.^ � e4�`i `^ sH ,�sS.",w _vr )1 z � �...� ° m 4r t f e �
- _ tc. S.. ' �+ -� �*`^,-."F�a-E� ""�`"� 'a�-- E �! �"�"t "-` 3,-#" � ,x �F75E :✓„ , �yi�"45. � ' ,� s` $. . s,.; r +�. c"' - _:...
+� 4F's �:• ..f "h n f- � :- � .X p. S .�f^ -.:..a' Hn.Y � "7 hg:i � P i..
-c'. F s:• d ., y � �._ ': "`si L'ah T.a Ni R.� f`} ": q ''. w{x y
�� � �a�7t
l,S
q p i
3 % C:: -
,k : .-...�iF
• , - s. _
r
_4 - - - -_ -
_ ,.- - --- - - - -
Y .
_1. _ t `. _ I
._..
y .. _w is - -
-.ii
.. y - _ - N -
.: _ :.
.
i-
_ + _ _
Ln.
_. j
,
_. ,.., - , ._ r. .. - _ -
1. _ r T"s - _ . --... -� - - - _ _ e _ _ -
�Y
�' .. .. - Y'4 'r
- x ,. n' 1 _ r yds _ a'-. ,
�L r
s _
s - - _ �i 4 l_ .t a�� FAArr%iR) a -
. _
-
�. a _ _ _ j ;
:.3.... - - rte.. r _ }. _
._m a.' � _
-t',. 1 aT X_,
l
4
Z
i
"''
_ _ -ti -F- �..
:
._ S ..r-.:.- .. a_.. + -
:,• ".
524—.k Jcs? .5,, 3%8- r
- _
' . -
4 _ T
k :.. ! r4
I 1.
V
_ c x k` .�`� t t' _
4 - _� ,_ ht 9 'e .� L P
y F'� i j t R' �-P 1 {b
_ b R �. 1 1�X 1 •e
m, r a ,[ f k - �; a t
a, I _ v _ Ola► S t, S 1 I K`t "_ r -� f h F m
x. .�a t.1� r 1 t '
I
_ t/ ..e _ t. ,4 s y e�' r t i� Fx -t a -F' '�
5.,, 1,_y < G - `x FI - t - "'i'� ice'p j T� 5 t �+ _t s Y
;<e. A $ s t y i < r :� 3 T t a z Y - - i 2 +. .,g
-vS-+,��': a.c 2` .y � e.}�' 3 `.v Y' `F �.. vW,tr.y�1 y µ ram y :'3"", 4 5:. b-. , 3 e 4•yll� ?` c •I - �' v.---1 S;- .e3
,.r, ;x.- ;f i, ,:Via.. , a , - -,-t i •�,. pt`Y_,'.y,'�-§'r*� sa 'c w.. -s--,., 3 � t*.i_ >_ a. _+ :e, '�"FL
,.-.tel v1 8'x -Pry s z r t n - ° '..*," a� ;,i .' s- ,,.-.1a' .,..r -e-a s v.. ,.`s e . i r-T +,a' 1' a - r n
.a 9 :. > T w ,.-.. .�::, ��'_'..- v?zew,. r T r e x txrK- ,w':x 4 x� 7:a s ^- 4 ' _9 z '' „sa `;: "`°r.- _:fi,,,�"
- t t *-I k :� r"��aAG i':`::'. "'R"�" '�3 ��.. &t �" -x.;::o`e`-''`sR m..-`% "�^w_ s r-..""� nR^"'Y s ;S � _a- .c+. _ -. ,v: x ;� ,
vX•. -� °- y :;p ...-". ��{(�' _ _'F > :+d'lv ..,F -.�. .R v}e.. •r',: < '•`.y x s •w�':., � - �'`-'L". 3.c'�` : '�.-
i, tf ,r ::.'- �,r cam', "pr a t� ,',d :..P , { x x. `�'z ` t"c' sz^ - ^s...4a A „ '.:-'. ::a Y h 1._.. a y r a-- r, kr..r ^y 3 ff , r,t ;w,i.
-• : Y-..-.-. TF:- -.. '+ tv s� .� ti+,z -{ ".,,r - y .F H - x. T + K Y-
$s`.4 �,: '{m � }�:" _o- ri , � X v R - _t � <;d`3 ,e '? ..ey .. ,Y'.. x t`.-t ,arca" f .a. � .t'k- -
e� -)'.. .p,. `1 t ^t�_s< - ^c-'4.z F '. ' iw& r ',F. ,,,3,iiYx" moi. r Zr- r "aY- .z :r.�'v
s ,,.� .k,. l w °n:"h .w. ^L•'x° - ay, r; 3, a� k: w'. .5 .,sa"r,, tP..;h r #..`f '': .¢,.- x - 4 i'' :r $..8 +:r � 1^
.:_' "sa ' L '.Y n 3 , r re>:� '_ :P � .. �s � .aa--'F —G ..*' u,T- `�x �. ¢ �. #
y.3 � t`r�'L"t '^r. n-e,t". 2 ,r;...; ,_.i ..._� 'L a. s a -'i'2' C- ':.a .... - "t,- --1 yI ,^, �c g '`Y" .; a _ v ^s ""---- 'at �� �4"S'i � ,w. om
Wa Y:. Y ;¢. t •,X""e�. _,a '- 2k e,4' ,, . ."c -Vie`._:s'- ' .�' F't '4 s:�: t`^ ,,:. ,- , -- u... ',. R, ,r�.� . ^- '^a„ +P a t Y y Wx
J°. ... ?s:_ z i� : ,.r-." 4 }� ?�..» -...' �tY � _:.a.' a z '-� ." s'. �C � .s.` s 3 � -r �,vP -.fix �§'F•y ..%ta
__
.._x,. ', zh �, t... „" -.�- '?r.',< �.:'" 4 .;. c via.,:' 3,..k '..7,;:_ .G '„ yty' .-r'i:
,mt ..:." ,�, .s ,.-.a.:--.: x -,- u 3..wn. _, ,..:�.,. E. _..�__: .�- Px. ...a••, ff e�.. :-" F t.wq m .. G,- .'..4 y. 3 "G r :t 'Fr s s # >*
S,.'t .s .t..,. V 4 4aiT: ✓ z::x ti 'v.».s #.§.,n °' s,�, �.,, `d+'=t < 5 <.
i..-i -'<^ t, Fi:.;t x n ` <t i S f—. d t i, a� '- P F '.+,sr E 1 yr S,"j. F q �S �K .?-ir-4 =,.^ t}, '�:-, 'a
' - r f'� e_ s.. 9 "KL t-.a- 'f vf. +a ...- f 5` ,+> ._ s a . Y -t-,' 3'.i _
.c t, i Tvf'",-,'% T �::.. rr1 'Y y. ,ra�t"''F :- '. a s:. .•a: sr x t- -t +'Au. .-7 i iF {`� t.A�:^v .f S
r h t - P `4 �+•.., -R�aa.".> PY is .rA' 3„ x :i }'c Y 7 . - 1. 3fi :`'< -c ." ,� .a t :, F #p - Y_
- r , e¢ p -rn _ a ^`.+,. _,��`Y -' x k i 9r 5. s r £•s. -.a X1.1 xe az, a-1., 4 t. _
11
- "t r _ i i x T 1=x a x �t + ''..e f, * » �- Y'"3 retY$� 'kt y ',r, y ^,a,^s' S r _ a k "_ re ✓,. s. -
�r b "` - ✓.., r a.' "`k`�' .7"4 ,R> .:i..r sq a'4: u + ..�.. '" } 1. . ^. .f4 a -z.,, e a"i+ ue d+� .Y 'x _
vxi*-c, ". '.`.C,, ,:a.... _'-...*4. ;k. :.,., a =.� E-. '`�.t�e: +,:.,..ye 'R::.. d'p.�js,ki,'�. +�!3f }�.. _;t,. a s✓*fr5.-4. Ami S,i!'t:', 4 2` '[�,1 .5. ,F,;3 tn,,.y i" ,T„.. -
x- I- '' 11
'
a.
,
" Y ._ §a .-='� �, s t,i ... ..- �A �.--,.. :.;.',.6y _ :_.:�'`��-`....,zi:.£�'e:: 'x-,. ' :.....v ',3 :-v .,. ..,dsw. ..d.";�•`s �:3' �. _ ... ».aafr.,.,,ti: �x a