16 CHANDLER ROAD - BERUBE, ALFRED & JEANINE - ZBA 16 Chandler Road R-2
Alfred & Jeanine Berube
Co.
Titv of
Pourb of �kpprzl
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF JOHN DOUROUDIS FOR A VARIANCE AT
20 CIRCLE HILL ROAD (R-1)
A hearing on this petition was held on June 29, 1988 with the following
Board Members, James M. Fleming, Chairman7 Messrs. Richard Bencal, John
Nutting, Edward Luzinski, and Associate Member Arthur LaBracque. Notice
of the hearing was sent to abutters and others, and notices of the hearing
were properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance with the
provisions of Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A.
The petitioner, the owner of the property is seeking a Variance from rear
setback to allow for the construction of a one (1) story addition at the
locus. The property is located- in an R-1 zone.
The Variance which has been requested my be granted upon a finding of
the Board that:
a. special conditions and circumstances exist which especially affect
the land, building or structure involved and which do not generally
affect other lands, buildings and structures in the same district;
b. a literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would
in volve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise to the
petitioner; and
c. desirable relief my be granted without substantial detriment to
the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating
from the intent of the district or the purpose of the Ordinance.
The Board of Appeal, after hearing the evidence presented at the hearing,
makes the following finding of fact:
1. No opposition to the petition was presented at the hearing.
2. Ward Four Councillor Leonard O'Leary sent a letter in support of
the plan.
3. The proposed addition is in harmony with the existing neighborhood.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented
at the hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows:
1. Special conditions exist which affect the premesis which do not
generally affect the district.
2. Literal enforcement of the Zoning Ordinance would involve a
substantial hardship upon the petitioner.
3. The variances requested can be granted without substantial detriment
to the public good and without substantially derogating from the
intent of the district or the purpose of the Ordinance.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF JOHN DOUROUDIS FOR A VARLb11JCE AT
20 CIRCLE HILL ROAD (R-1 ) SALEM
Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted unanimously, 5-0, to grant the
relief requested subject to the following conditions:
1. That the exterior finishes of the addition be in harmony wi the
exterior finishes of the existing building.
2. That all construction conform to the requirements of the
Massachusetts Building Code, and that the petitioner obtain the
necessary building permit.
3. That all construction be done as per the plans suhmitted to the
Board of Appeals.
4. That a Certificate of Occupancy be obtained prior to Occupancy
of the addition.
VARIATCE GRA=
,Jaff�es M. Flerfting, Esq.�/
Chairman, Board of Appeal
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN' FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
'P�!-' T
tyl
re
of A IS
FRUI#
varb of 4pral Wffl)M' K.SALEM.AAS.S.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF ALFRED & JEANNINE BERUBE FOR A
SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 16 CHANDLER ROAD (R-1 )
A hearing on this petition was held March 30, 1988 with the following Board
Members present: James Hacker, Chairman; Messrs. , Bencal, Fleming, Luzinski and
Strout. Notice of the hearing was sent to abutters and others and notices of the
hearing were properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance with
Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A.
Petitioners, owners of the property, are requesting a special permit to extend
nonconforming side setbacks to allow construction of a second floor addition in
this R-1 district.
The provision of the Salem Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request
for a Special Permit is Section V B 10, which provides as follows:
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary appearing in this Ordinance, the Board
of Appeal may, in accordance with the procedure and conditoins set forth in
Section VIII F and IX D, grant Special Permits for alterations and reconstruction
of nonconforming structures and for changes, enlargement, extension or expansion of
nonconforming lots, land, structures, and uses, provided however, that such change,
extension, enlargement or expansion shall not be substantially more detrimental
than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood.
In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests,
guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding
by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health,
safety convenience and welfare of the city's inhabitants.
The Board of Appeal, after careful consideration of the evidence presented at the
hearing, and after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact:
1 . There was no opposition;
2. Proposed extension would be in keeping with the neighborhood.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at the
hearing, concludes as follows:
1 . The proposed second floor addition will be in harmony
with the neighborhood;
2. The Special Permit requested can be granted without
substantial detriment to the public good and without
nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent
of the district or the purpose of the Ordinance.
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF ALFRED & JEANNINE BERUBE FOR A
SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 16 CHANDLER ROAD, SALEM
page two
Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted unanimously, 5-0 to grant the
Special Permit requested, subject to the following conditions:
1 . A building permit be obtained;
2. All requirements of the Salem Fire Dept. be adhered to;
3. Construction be done as per plans submitted;
4. A certificate of occupancy b obtained
GRANTED
Peter Stroult, Member, Board of Appeal
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
APPEAL I R,):�A -, "j%
1� N, 1. - SHALL U PURSUANT TO SLCTION 17 TH-
LE;4FRAL LAVS, 8S�' A:4D S,9,,,LL E,, -
Li fi::S nEOr:' 20 DA(S A,—IER THE E
. -1 !', THE OFF;L� OF THE MY CLER"'. Or
F 11:S,'%T T"C L,' S C HA-T,Q 11. THF
HEREii�.
-IFItcl L)WIL A CLPY
1. "N 'T IHEE CLER .
CR THAT. IF S: AP,-- L H
"';' APFEAL
RECC2C; FIL-, A! 11
-D IN THE ��-,7H ESSEX qE_IST I �EIN MS j:11D FTi
OF RECORD OR IS Rz��RDED AND N07E Pf OF DEEC� ANO %�E:ED II.;-,LP -,!. %'..'
D ON THE OViNERS C.RrIFJCA-li OF TITLE.
BOARD OF �PFEAL
vz� a
1A\LL AWP 40;J*TlZV4110a *HAL-l�
'THE HA,,0;6AeHVjrv�TT* WTAore VVIL,71061 "PP.
t:
fatj�jreo pf2lpF- To WIT-H T14� Wo�-K , t�,
-�+E OPTgAeT01t V��ZI5( A4-� V1 �-lE-WfSll'9W*
IW THt: HEX rlzlolz 'ro rPOC*L-17IW& Nlrl� TH � WOIZ14,
TH� 6OWTlZ,&eTOR
TH� Afz(,HlTe4 O�
P-P Y P*�7 6OWVITl4'W* THAT \IAlzy �RP�-1 THOO�
'ir,%HoWW l �J THL-
-e76CV;zE OrH& AgeHjrg��'T'ej LOT A�-Etk ��774
/Ar�fO 12 0\/P4. 00 AwY HATefz1*1� SVP�49T] rVTIOW':� alz
�K- -
IP TH� wor
'TlO9,: r;
AL�L 6aL09 47�L�4, v 'TO PE �-lA Er 117Y ArzCHIrP/,T
IW4TA��AT1094F WITH TH$ At7ppoplAT�-
�TlWry �OW4�jlgk-ev, F-ET W11%�L --
aLL. or�-rz#-*L.C- \Nl4vpw,* Ise Paoolz4 6H#,�L r�X145TIOC, PE2�,14 ir c
�Av i rr�-c, wl r-LA-L- ��F*Kvo
L7009 VWIT* - 4H.A�L R7�- A'FrROVE0
�2y OWWEPFZI 114)
j�,Po RM OLA=IWO 71fpee�p VVITH THS O\NIJ �f-,
L:.-r--LZ-MIX ii7,
_RN,
�J�W e:VT5VeTVVz�
X�
C f-WV PLO 9
77--
.7
ti
%
�,OAP.
t+
O
&W r ��
O
v � s
V�s A--
_ 1
i
s
o� V v �
h',,f' IM I'IFt GOLVMI.1 !�Xie,T'G) EL ESL rAuK
VW ft&t_' �iOV� ( rAIh7 'b� LCLA(�b!-I
Ar-
s �
j
s
S �
N
l�
vv �
rti
�s �
i
i O
i
Ar-
tL
4 fl
--t-
ATTII'�L
- T - v
V% A- .-
I
O
o
1/A°I s �;
- - fz4af C7verhal'VJ IIrHI'�'
-
-- — ---C• �9
S
' o
� NEARER tii� � �
14 114 E Fi61.D �S
°TEvia
�` p.Eavg2'p
PULL OTQ-
t2AIL WALL I --
1oP of WALL AT L "�
!if' AoovE Tf A V
NotiluG-�EE �u �
wr7. w v L. N -
r}zEAnJ4,
t3jWU c Loy�Tti-' � —
�O p$MPI{J i I � � _ }2s�eGJ+s door opcnin'- �
µcw; door +rim - -4
aO FI RM Ex i�.T'c, v co
! L - TH��
_d _r A— C�
Floor I 4� 1 0
- - - - --
1 /Aq �0 , cq
� S
GL i ApJAG(oW T rO
� . '•c.° p�kQulR&bY 1pnEep S -IN
12 P EG�4- - ALL IZA�..�I LI C>
to P PRE�iv -7 z P
-. Mr-LA';H 0 AT 12POW aX - -�,. # NTT WHITE, Vt&-K 1'ic4"
WkLL 14 l�Wj I P ki ( TY ) - EIZT. G ILI-I. FIR 4v4, k:vcpe
Rl
- - -- - , -
wIuPow 42:.&T wiuvow 4,01 LIMIT OP Exit'(, — V
-- __
_ J ,�_ C-•,�TER� PiG� Of ^� i S� O
J 11 T , ,, ,,� wALL ft"aW sL
GOuF
C.or _ , 6' I Wv 0 L�#
Ir
I-- - - - "���i'•o" 131F'LG caTHEnRW.� GcIL•IIJIe I j
pco� 11 ) RI bur s.P>ovG p
�— -- — --OI IQ
F L o
A6 E�I�'G
-1z N WEW GhIGK ar - �M.L v0w�l N " I I = fl �-
EXINf 6 Plop- 6GGk41(l /pro SIC -- Y
FLP�,N aGi RER'D h I To LTMtz 1G
NSW GHIMuL^f ! I�Eptzoorl �__ x I p way-Ire v t�-
FxtEur7lo�l K
f, Mot-TAF- To HINT6
Ex14'(IIJ6, GEILIWG FA{J(0. IG. �' O Q
�OWA1�► 1 L.o.. ,�
00
ra
do
-
t 2 0"" b' dJ - i< I N I u
- !La"K
- - pi11$0I-D DK d` W L I o `+c
10,
v
T
o F-11 T aI Gl"�Jrl wvZZI-
Vs
� econcl 00r
to 1 -
Rapm nIsn Sc4I uIG - - V1n,�o\\,/ Sc ule
doom gam& floor \Vail I 6o111nj yc ✓�
h'IaatePi� roerfti _ G2rrGI � th I � Z.rruG c� Tye �V��
+�•�hi� + } I J S Fzarnar �s
icy roam Gzrpr.+ I b/oda tom,. qcrzc("•G"
5300 All ?'erm h Game a S eld sn-
Gl dtiet i GarP�' - �eo� Gorfirr?1 hhGlv�ag
role, IOGjdrle,
IG' 'O h 4kt° A10I =rma shicic} Galserren f
G I dart 4 I G1rps+ I Wood w/P owr�r G G 2�w ✓. 1' Y " ' I r.
A10 �et IdGlci G�StrT1Cn�' O M
0 At 4 7 \�1
�l0 GS5 15 G 1 5 1 Al I 0 A10 Lemen� �` 'may
�Oraq� Garre,+ 'i,G.�V•g -GGJ1r IinG� IJ,LG. t1 , � G, �i 2 4 g
u II 1 I �• 510E I5 • � �' L' AtolNo �10 {��rrna shrlc�• patio �,.r dJ
dill \�dI01 S'�1,\V,P7, h�'A I �\�OO�t S
p I I e z II I at" 5' .0v Sh ks is G,Arwc merit
Grisi r \ViW 'i'v, I;. pr A I i w"A I I v v
- 4A.f r'1• I�•G,w•h Confirm tilt I&$ 4 h4l �u �{ •O/a 2 D ?�erma•Shitic{ Alvn;nq Q
atl+ Ti lc +;I& w9irriGd3+ WoeIF I w/ owner
rlex��r:mc I�' 04' site )AI A10 �Srm*'e-hCLO #O'c,,,;-FrewrW oust A+W
Li ncn woo ''✓2G.W.P , rrF� � �Vi o� � Gdnf irm hHeINAno
v.v/ownGP * I-dGATL7W AI.Jt2 PE9GFI.(T or ULTw,&\A I.ET LIbII 12ErJV6TItfa GLQZI W&
ro P�Cr q thl Gua?I'� PAY O\Np F-R
• h�T1ou :/,�'1
- v -a-
Gftll"iUEY Ex1ElJoi►OV� /� -� —Ah�I-tPL( �iHIuGLE*-� '(o S
To � '•O" o•P�oVE rJ W � V
RIDvE MDGioti►R'r (�IPTGH �XIGiT'G•
MORTAR TO MATGwt'1NL"' � —
Ex1�T'G• �r+lMu✓:� FxtE!u IoL I —
FP�GIA } ��u{�Fo�IA CPI•nb� v� _ �11
Raor- --- ---- - 10 W/ PFLIY EDGE FLo�vHIWO
U
L-+clHtt'G e;WF-1WtY pLP.oA4'G
L1Nr-lwPtiL �uT � C-G1 'I.li
xt
lTrrlaa�
4iHIwC/4. i TRIM TO �-
I < rI�TGH bxl-0161 erwp)
- - - 2IJD rLDo� S'
- - - _ - - f- Ix � T1aI O •
0VbKH-4,w To HATCH Lxl�irb
LS
_ V
- I yT FLOOR
00
— — _ --- - -- � P76r-1EuT v v
ca
iron
f+ -
_0 \
n -
� o
� s �
10
lz
4' r `--' PA�i� lip G,u PjpOr�ilA (PIJtd� N
d \\_. /W/ 171ZIP E17G& I�I.ACiN ub c4
'41 TOP O- PLPT� �s S
RAptEi2ei , A-7HEttFl1'i ID�R IJ GPhEMeWT olo° —
, ' hHINf Eti AI�pKIo{JL �/ \� �_ P70A e�w Wlwf2ow volt
17
- h167GH EX I�i t I Ills / \ 2 u I7 PL
m 41
� orloc
v �
V
a
-Ji
ewT
rn �
- � 1 G{ h '� v,� 1 A � � , Z v � '�" � O it tia � l� , i�4"= I '• p �
O
v � R
�EGTIoN 1/ ,a,y
I
o� S
V
,P,TTIG FAP- GONYIizh'C p�
W/OW LoG,aTIDµ�
NE
S o � —
t � S }
Q 1 � Faux � Giv�PAxIA ( puTv) � Ol
�10 P10 Li1h'I, w/ URI EDGE FL.�iH'!� S� xu
_ - - — Tor OP PLAT& v z
,� , _� �NIuGI.L-�i To MATH Eriltif'!1 (I'l.ltb� 4) �U �
AI
IL
a � � � I I�oF iNTErzS�tlolJ
TfLIM TO MATC41 l:XlGlf'G
FI�iG III F�- �v 7
ti \P
Ar-
_-
i yT F�oo►� m C(�
-t- v
� � L
tiEG'(10 N 1 /p.�l
dear 18 y On
87. 0 � 4
� o
vs -
o�
TILE FIVE -i4Pz
GEI1CiJT WAy s
'GHIM{Jh' L�TL'IJGil01J T� � � _�
ATl IG FAF+ - Go,�= a-1 �s1'•0" I �ovE W EW ILI DGE • i V + �-
w/ Om42 T(PE .o'f --- MA�ioNRY MoKtltz To = j TA
-- P� FOLpXI�I A
(�b - FLN
P'
xll
� �� cI+IMN�Y W'a�'nI�IP! Ea E�(.ayN N��•) � V� �
S
-E--
-- - �clyf 'G Fl,at,H 'riI�i('G L v v C-V-
To REMp.Ik �� GHIr11JC�
N � V
TRIM To Hgt,+l
P w VI 1ZFr b j I.AIJH i IJ b AT EptT WA4.L/
L Nt7 t%LooR- \_ _p0o� INTEasEaG'i IOIJ <tYPIGAI.I
`✓ i '� _ �LOG� _ _ _ _
ri
�o �