The URL can be used to link to this page

55 WARREN STREET - DISTRICT FILES �; A\ :nrrn �ir�ri Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)619.5685 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ✓ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition ✓ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act(M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire District Address of Property: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: Richard Jones and Naomi Cottrell Description of Work Proposed: Approval based on drawings prepared by Jones Architecture dated May 12,2017. Work includes: • Removal of rear mudroom,basement bulkhead and back stair; • Installation of one Marvin Ultimate all wood true-divided 6/1 window in location of removed rear vestibule • Removal of single window on east elevation • Construction of 10'-6"x 12'-8"single-story addition on east elevation.Windows to be Marvin Ultimate wood true-divided windows in size and mullion pattern to match existing windows on house. New door and granite stair to be added to rear of addition. Door to be wood full-light Marvin Contemporary Door. • Installation of new Bilco steel bulkhead at rear of house. • Installation of new wood capped flatboard cedar fencing at rear property line and across driveway. Fence at driveway to be T tall with gate and painted or stained to match color of house trim. Fence at rear property line to include gate with a height range of approximately 4'tall to T tall. This fence to remain unpainted. NOTE: The height of the fence may require a zoning variance. Upon completion of work,please notify Historical Commission staff for final review and sign-off of Certificate. Dated: June 22, 2017 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION The homeowner has the option not to commence the work(unless t relates to resolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals)prior to commencing work. r h ��C011®IT,I��i "v 't ' CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS o DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND 9a�y, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL MAYOR 120 WASHINGTON STREET ♦ SALEM,MASSACHUSETTs 01970 TELE:978-619-5685 4 FAX:978-740-0404 TOM DANIEL,AICP DIRECTOR STAFF MEMORANDUM TO: Salem Historical Commission From: Patti Kelleher Date: June 15,2017 RE: 55 Warren Street-Request for Certificate of Appropriateness Property Address: 55 Warren Street Historic Name: Patrick Mullin House Dates Constructed: 1925 Architectural Styles: Dutch Colonial Built in 1925 after the Great Salem Fire of 1914,this house is a well-preserved example of the Dutch Colonial style. Distinctive features of the house include a gambrel roof(typical of the Dutch Colonial style),a columned entrance porch,tripartite windows on each side of the entrance,a side sunporch and Mile clapboard siding. This property is one of several properties on Warren Street that extend from Warren Street through to Dalton Parkway. 11 411 16 q 9 U6 4,J ^ J IC 23R 418 — '46 44 4]0 1< ]9 43d $ �I 45 BPt tD Y1Pl 63 ♦�YY 56 H.tS 4Il 5 5/ 9 55 i ll 8 IS t] 66 61 "10 T' 01 i H 3 6H m 6] Id i 11 70 13 1] e 9 31 NtR[uR[ 33 5: _� SUM SiN le 36 lg x m ] s 5 6 Proposal: • Construct new side addition Install two new fences 1 Staff Memo to Historical Commission—June 15,2017 55 Warren Street Page 2 Staff Comments: The owners of this property have undertaken a series of restoration projects over the past few years. In 2013,the owners removed aluminum siding to restore the building's original wide wood clapboard siding. In 2015,they removed a glass entry vestibule(not original)and restored the building's entrance and stairs. The owners are now seeking to remove a rear(south) mudroom(not original)and construct a new one-story addition on the east side of the house. This addition would be approximately half the size of the existing sunroom on the building's west side. Specific details of this work include: ■ Removal of rear mudroom,basement bulkhead and back stair; ■ Installation of one Marvin Ultimate all wood true-divided 6/1 window in location of removed rear vestibule(visible from Dalton Parkway) • Removal of single window on west elevation • Construction of 10'-6"x 12'-B"single-story addition(According to owner,the addition complies with zoning setbacks). Windows on addition will match size and mullion pattern of existing windows on house. New door and granite stair to be added to rear of addition(visible from Dalton Parkway). Door to be all wood full-light Marvin Contemporary Door. Comment: I asked the owner,who is the project architect,if it was possible to move the two windows on the front of the addition closer together so that they would read as a paired window,which is a typical design element of the Colonial Revival style and isfound elsewhere on this house. He responded that the interior layout of the addition restricts the location of the windows. Location of new addition Owners are also proposing to install two new fences: ■ 5'tall Flat board capped fence between the addition and side property line to hide trash and recycling cans. Fence will run parallel to Warren Street and will be painted to match existing trim color of house(existing chain link fence on side property boundaries will remain) • Flat board capped fence with 4'wide gate at rear(south)property line. Fence to follow grade of property,ranging from 4'to 7'tall. The existing chain link fence will be removed. Comments:The requestfor a 7'heightat the tallest edge of the fence is higher than most fences approved by the Commission. Also,it is unclear how the board fence will connect with the existing sideyard chain link fence which is approximately 4'high. Staff r to Historical Commission / 55 Warren Page Mi 171 1 View of existing rear fence from IR r- s . _ v♦•R Dalton - � 1 Corner of existing chain link fences. New rear solid board fence would join existing . yard fence - Patricia Kelleher From: Richard Jones <rick@jonesarch.com> Sent: Friday, June 16, 2017 9:08 AM To: Patricia Kelleher Cc: Naomi Cottrell Subject: Re: application for Historical Commission Patti. The front fence will be 5'-0". The intent is to screen garbage, recycling, and firewood storage, and provide some privacy. The metal fence at the back property line will be removed. We will retain the metal fence along the side property lines. Although I agree that bringing the two windows together on either side of a 6" post similar to the ganged together windows in the sunroom may look more consistent, it does not work with the interior configuration of rooms. It is more important to us to center the window at the interior hall and bathroom. To create the exterior expression of the windows ganged together, they would have to be pushed into the comer and not have any interior trim. Also, this is blot a second sunroom or main living space like the other ganged window conditions. It is a secondary element. Much like many of the precedent images that we submitted, these generally look more utilitarian. We prefer the windows as drawn for these reasons. Thanks for your comments and questions. Feel free to call me to discuss further. Rick On Jun 16, 2017 8:50 AM, "Patricia Kelleher" <pkclleher(a4salem.com> wrote: Hi Rick, I have a couple of questions about your application for a new addition and fences at 55 Warren Street: Can you please let me know the height of the front painted fence. The plans state that the back fence will range from 4' to 7' in height but does not specify the height of the front fence. Also, I believe there is an existing chain link fence along the property's boundaries. Will this be retained? For the design of the new addition,would it be possible to bring the two windows on the north elevation closer together so that they read as paired windows similar to the paired windows on the north elevation of the sunroom and on the east elevation? I realize that the interior configuration of the addition may make this problematic,but if the windows were closer together the exterior would read more typical of the Colonial Revival style. i Thank you and look forward to meeting you at the Commission meeting next Wednesday. Patti ---------------------------- Patti Kelleher Community Development Planner, City of Salem Department of Planning & Community Development 120 Washington Street, 3`a Floor Salem, MA 01970 Phone: 978-619-5685/ Fax: 978-740-0404 pkelleher(a,salem.com www.salem.com 2 Date Stamp D Salem Historical Commission I C� ,,��ul�l y4,vbLiJFiv1ENT; 120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 For Office Use Only (978)6195685 FAX(978)740-0404 APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance, application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness for: ❑ New Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑✓ Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Sign ❑ Other District: ❑Derby Street ❑Lafayette Street ❑✓ McIntire ❑Washington Square Address of Property: 55 Warren Street,Salem,MA 01970 Name of Record Owner(s): Richard Jones and Naomi Cottrell Owner Mailing Address: (same) Description of Work Proposed Please l}/ie or I)nl clearh. Allach additional sheets, as necessv7: The proposed work includes a one-story addition on the east side of the existing house. Consistent with dutch colonial gambrel houses of this period,the opposite (west) side of the existing house has a one-story sunroom ringed with windows. As is typical of this typology,we are proposing a small addition on the driveway side of the house that will serve as entry/mudroom/powder room. The proposed addition is approximately half the size of this existing sunroom, projecting 10'-6" from the east side of the house, and running 12'-8" alongside the house; it is within the zoning setback. Windows matching the size and mullion pattern of the existing windows in the house are used on the front(facing Warren St) and east side(facing neighboring property). A door and new granite stair faces the backyard (looking toward Dalton Pkwy). A new painted wood fence adjacent to the addition screens the back yard from Warren Street. A new unpainted wood fence is to be built along rear property line(facing Dalton Pkwy). Additionally,an existing vinyl clad mudroom/vestibule, and basement bulkhead/headhouse are to be demolished. These are not original to the existing house, as evidenced by the face that the wide clapboard exterior cladding of the 1924 house extends through these additions. The mudroom/vestibule will be replaced by a window into the kitchen, again matching the existing size and mullion pattern of existing windows in the house. The existing Trex stair to the back door is eliminated. The basement bulkhead/headhouse will be replaced with a low, Bilco ptd steel bulkhead that is much less visually obtrusive than the existing headhouse. 0 Name of App ' Richard o s and Naomi Cornell E]Owner❑Contractor❑Tenant❑Other: Signature: Date: 05.26.17 Tel. 4: 617.834. 652 (cell)/978.5 4.520 ho E-mail Address: rick@jonesarch.com Certificate will be made ner unless otherwise indicated here: Certificate should be mailed to: Name Richard Jones Mailing address:55 Warren Street City:Salem State:MAZip: 01970 ATTACHED DOCUMENTATION An application will not be considered complete unless all work items are thoroughly described and the application includes all information needed_for the Commission to make a determination. Failure to submit a complete application may result in a continuation to a future meeting Recommended information includes: Photos of existing conditions,taken from all public ways Site plan showing location of improvements Elevation drawings of the existing conditions and proposed improvements Drawings of details and other special conditions, including profiles Description, photographs, and/or catalog cuts of proposed materials (please bring to the meeting product samples, if appropriate) Dimensions (i.e. height of fence, size of pickets and posts, etc.) Paint color samples, if applicable (no less than 2"x2") Location and size of all mechanical equipment, such as transformers, HVAC equipment, electrical service and meters, and proposed screening SYMBOL LIST ABBREVIATION LIST ROON NAA@ ACT ACOUSTICAL CEILING TILE GA OUNCE OT QUARRY' TILE ® SEEM NAME AND NUMBER ADD ADDITIONAL GALV GALVANIZED OTY QUANTITY C 4DJ ADJACENT Sc GENERAL CONTRACTOR AFF ABOVE FINISH FLUOR GL GLASS R RISER AZ AIR HANDLING UNIT OLA: GLAZING RA RETURN AIR DOOR NUMBER ALUM ALUMINUM CASH GYPSUM WALL BOARD RAD RADIUS �'• AREA APPROXIMATELY CYP GYPSUM RD ROOF DRAIN s„ RIMER ACOUSTIC WOOD PANEL REG REGISTER Cottrell/dINIBB RBSIdBOCB AWP ACOUSTIC WALL PANEL Ho HOSE BIBB RED REQUIREMENT 1 HC HANDICAP/HANDICAP ACCESSIBLE REDD REQUIRED ~j 55 Warren Street 4_Y WINDOW ivFE BD BOARD HDW HARDWARE REV RENSON/REVERSE - -- _ Salem.MA BIT BITUMINOUS HM HOLLOW METAL RM ROOM - HOGG BUILDING NOR HORIZONTAL RD ROUGH OPENING BLK BLOCK HP HIGH POINT RSL RESILIENT FLOURING _ BLKC BLOCKING MT HEIGHT RUB RUBBER /0 DM BEAM HTR HEATING, VENTLAFON & AIR CGJD. Sm. RAIN WATER LEADER ACLU AmOUNI n D 4 { •' -- -- l I DOT BOTTOM HVAC SFE T/MU f f SUP BUILT-UP RODENG NW HARDWARE CAN SOUND ATTENUATION BOARD EIEv TMr _ _ COLUMN TAG AND LINE SC SOLID CORE C COURSE (BACK) ID INSIDE SM CO CORNER ARD INS INSULATION INCANDESCENT NCANDESCEN110N SOPH $11:1RAR OPPOSITE HAND 1 _ CB CATCH BASIN RI INCHES SECT SECTION SECTION CEM CEMENT INCL INCLUDE/INCLUDING/INCLUDED SIR SIMILAR T ROOM ELEVATION SYMBOL CI CAST IRON INT INTERIOR SPEC SPECIFICATION/SPEC6ICA PONS CIP CAST IN PLAN[ SO SQUARE CJ CONTROL JOINT J JOINT(MASONRY) 55 STAINLESS STEEL Cl CENTER UNE JAN JANITOR SSII STAINLESS STEEL _ CLO CEILING JUNCTION BOX STA STATION A - CLO CLOSET J1 JOINT STD STANDARD - (^�W-7 CUP CLEAR/CLEARANCE STI STEEL -- `�� Ex1ER10P ELEVATION CMU CONCRETE MASONRY UNIT LCC LEAD COATED COPPER STUB STORAGE COL COLUMN LP LOW PpEI susp SUSPENDED COMP COMPRESSIBLE/COMPRESSION LAM LAMINATED S1RUCi STRUCTURE/STRUCTURAL { CONIC CONCRETE LAV LAVATORY Nm CONST CONSTRUCTION LINO LINOLEUM T TREAD ---•4. CONT CONTINUOUS LTG LIGHTING TBD FRENCH DR _ I •I DETAIL BUBBLE CP CENTER POINT TO TRENCH DRAIN _1 / CPT CARPET MAT MATERIAL THK THIGH/THICKNESS Ci CERAMIC TILE MA% MAXIMUM tEL TELEPHONE -----' DUH CABINET UNIT HEATER MB MARKER BOARD TO TOP OF _ MECH MECHANICAL TOC TOP OF CONCRETE --- —' DET DETAIL MEMO MEMBRANE TOF TOP OF FOOTING _ OF DRINKING FOUNTAIN MFR MANUFACTURER TOR TOP OF RAIL C. SECTIOSTEN DETAIL DIA DIAMETER MIN MINIMUM TOB TOP OF STEEL DN DOWN MISC MISCELLANEOUS TOW TOP OF WALL OR DOOR MO MASONRY OPENING TRi TREAT/TREATED ws PKDDI 5 A WE HI DWG DRAWING MTI METAL RT TOILET STORY nO'HI Ox T. EAST SDE Cf ME E SIM TW LYRICAL 1 5 rv0i mAAD THE A. {�F1' SPOT ELEVATION EA EACH NIC NOT IN CONTRACT PD sERAIX. EL OT 4P EJ EXPANSION JOINT NO NUMBER UNIT UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE. F M ELEVATION SITE NOT TO SCALE CA PTD SC FENCE ASH h MIITERIAI LATE TD scRELN 1CUH. PCP MATERIAL/ELEVATION F1EC ELECTRIC/ELECTRICAL NUM NUMBER AM VINri COMPOSITION TILE A.PECYCLIFL I�t _. S g p-p ENC ENCLOSURE ELEVATOR VEP VERTICAL CWTo-mEFS ENC ENCLOSURE OC ON CENTER NF VRIFYONEE IN FIELD PLASTER ENG ENGINEER OF OUTSIDE FURNISH VP VENEER PLLSTER '-- "• �T EPDX EPDXY/EPDXY PAINT OFCI OWNER FURNISH CONTRACTOR INSTALL VWC NNri WALL COVERING --_. u WALLT'PE EO/EOU EQUAL CHD OWNER FURNISH OWNER INSTALL EQUIP EQUIPMENT ONG OVERHEAD DOOR W/ WITH _ END EMERGENCY ROOF GRAIN OFA OVERHEAD WILL WC WAIEP CLOSET c. _I TEXT ETR EXISTING tU REMAIN OPH OPPOSITE HAND WD WOOD DETAIL NOTE EWC ELECTRIC WATER COOLER OPP OPPOSITE WF WIDE FLANGE L _ EXIST EXISTING DENG WENINO WH WALL HYDRANT EXP EXPANSION ORD OVERFLOW EDGE DRAIN WIN WINDOW ' EXT EXTERIOR W/o WITHOUT - .. 1 -�-. � �--�— .• PAV PAVER WP WORN POINT MATERIAL BREAK LINE FACE HIRE ANNUNCIATOR PANEL_ PC PRECAST WPP WATER PROOFING r ED FLOOR DRAIN PGL PLATE GLASS NUB WALL UTILITY BOX FON FOUNDATION PH PARTIAL HEIGHT WWF WELDED NEE FABRIC p ERVC FIRE DEPARTMENT VALVE CABINET PL PLUMPLATE ` SEC FlRE Ex TINGUISHER CABINET PLAM PLASTIC LAMINATE SYMBOLS USED AS ABBREVIATIONS WA P F.I-I T L L EFT 'RE MOORSEC TRANSITION PLUM PLUMBING I AND FIN 'RE HOSE CABINET POR PORCELAIN < ANGLE t REVISION OUBOLE FIN FINISH PM PRESSED METAL O AT 1 Alamio�n l FLA MOOR PTD PAINTCL/C L CENTERLINE PLR FLOOR PT PAINT/PRESSURE TREATED [ CHANNEL JONES, FLUOR FLUORESCENT PTC PARTITION DEGREE I FOC FACE OF CONCRETE PVL POL'MNYL CHLORIDE N NUMBER FOR FACE OF HHRH 2 PERCENT FOR FACE OF WALL 0 ROUND (DIAMETER) I 10 De by Sq.Sure,INC CENTER LINE FRE FACE T WALL d 70 Derby Sq.Suite 3N FBPC FIRE/FEET IPE CABINET Salem,MA 01970 FT MOT/FEET GLADNr, SYMBOL FTG FOOTING NB FLOW UTILITY BOX 978.746.5200 NR NRNINfli WVIWjMB98rCb.CORI ® HA14DICAP PARKING/SEATING q[ i!u.!umf•nI uwu u,u.uuvv v+,ry :S WPRf!fl. InLll DRAWING LIST "` �a ^ !t,. LNA,wi"<If'IPA LPAPI B[l1Y Plf Aall Yll Et A0.00 COVER SHEET "-• " •'� AD N WAI I TYPFS, Nri7cl, FRAAEING, RFHFOA FS D1.01 DEMOLITION PLANS AND ELEVATIONS SITE SURVEY �^ Al 01 PROPOSED PLANS AND ELEVATIONS ( 2 -' _ �, AT 02 PROPOSED PLANS AND ELEVATIONS — r mn X, Al 03 PROPOSED PLANS AND ELEVATIONS IWn Y 72,2017 A2.01 INTERIOR ELEVATIONS - erYu. 1106 VARIES e j Wwnrme COVER SHEET LOCATION PLAN AO 00 FINISH SCHEDULE V114F-t KO. FINISH rvlalnonlw a au ee°le xa wPawol. ROOM NO. ROOM.NAME y m pri�me�Ion Xolrino Ixali�cwP m FLOOR BASE WALLS CEILING °.. w =IMz by wl°rll °°I n pr°pe w q m am°I lire°va4 2 d pal° mmt.n .mew 105 HALL t-1 PED WD PTD GWp (PT-I) /Pip WD lnl"rye°' ° I my o..ry`mmrlener I..e °e°m..Xrwe WAINSCOT (PT-2) PI-3 v°waT len pel'remllnwEemll wfNw Ino gllm�°nl am em enLL N° m'�. wpr 106 POWDER ROOM i-1 PID 1Yv pm W 15COiGWB l(PT 2ro WICt PL-3 mn Ine rorX°nw K.n°I I Me utAl4cl,nmblI u=X Gaweytiea a "o' 11rel,"lXft-X ltl.'m�w•olwr�'al'wo:.•'I 10] MUD ROOM T-i pip µq PTD OWE) (PT-1) / PTD WD PT S WA114SCOT (PT-2) �r a:re.`gmerwm"n «a.'nq. Cobrell/.ones Rewlance 'rarrl't�°rrnv a°1 55 Warton Street .1.q nwte:a lmn .�nq err°em•') re wl a°.m w.,•.°r � ......e°a e.la vrI t.& rlu wn w w PTO GWS S¢IBIIIr I� °•°°°I.mp.q•_.•_..°.=rn.p. r MGM FINISH LEGEND w t. a . m I:r Pro WDRIL .artanm �`e.ryrm s.R`u a°°' m s°IlMnefur nl PIDWDRAIL MATERIAL TYPE MANUFACTJRER MODEL /COLOR °°ann« wm mrm ."Itt:`1ai,:l .m m°m u. AI - )-n- (???) xxxxxxxxx xxxxxxxx%xxxxxx �mlmHe b.mn ill.for m.,emu.nl mm.,,e,v GPTO wD T-1 STONE 11LE 11,wmmbb w-Ibt �"k- WAINSCOT,M. PT PAINT(INTERIM) BENJAMIN MOORE WALL COLOR --- 5. - wIa sm -,rtueu.amw dl n.Im..pr ornel.,..a sm 1, IT Gm OVERPxA �" PT-2 PAINT(INTERIOR) BENJAMIN MOORE TRIM COLOR --- m ab.toe m:wrr apm;bl n rm,Nallm of alwWs mans anal 9TUD FRAMING ° °-r t9 mb:hoe° q of m`wwuµal°,1m.e'm I,I: n Ulty In ne PT44Pro ML MISTING INSUILA IX IN PT-3 PAINT(INTERIOR) BENJAMIN MOORE LEILINf, COLOR --- ALL WHITE? OR BATHROOM CLO COLOR? ° w.aP..e WAW9WT M STUD CAVRY TO REMAIN PT-4 PAINT(INTERIOR) BENJAMIN MOORE EGGPLANT COLOR OF FRONT DOOR -- cw a 1..awm.ar..a+w.a°..111..1..,:°m,..a.m>,wr•.«ta.nn r °`A°r« NATp1 EISTG Pro N9- I i FARnNG PfO G1VB /-EISTWG Wp SLIFATMING PT-5 PAINT(INTERIOR) BENJAMIN MOORE GRAY COLOR FOR MILLWORK IN LIVING ROOM e Cmlra:a 1,to P. ql n.emmy ro.kw«,pa.t P,aaP yolxrw.. aASE papFILE,TYP_ r FMLSN AT KNrCIFN TO (BELOW EXISTING CLAPBOARD Ne erne..,°r yal:e:w.tm awtlw..at me nw.a.net wr.am Y.u. ; ( SIWNG).RETNN SOEATHING F PT-.b PAINT(EXTERIOR) BENJAMIN MIME EXTERIOR 800v--a w.° ) RENNN POSSIBLE A55UBSTRATE FON 91 aanmy oey.11nwt.ry tm wawa.roe TILE FLOOR.TIBg3Ei� r I\ ENISTINGFOOM NEWGWB SHIM TO CREATE PT-] PAINT(EXTERIOR) BENJAMIN MOORE EXIEPIORIRIM - a=nae=1 a«t. mages a'm..p.mxtua.an anflM l.mr.e XV M. MORTAR 1 BASEATIQTCH M LEVEL SURFACE FIXi NEW(YIB. rnw.lm°m ` ° i, N 5T-1 STONE AAB SLATE XX%%xxx...XXXXX L RE .m•0, alai-P anile ma rm a lm�m<m io M< 1'PLAM'D BUBPLOOR I F \ ol�oln.rmmnn alM1`0ea:lmim nvmaw`a er ne(ve`u nq n v.w.as DOOR SCHEDULE I.Wrlraclw 1° pnpnu 1°Ne a n11 m nE pulpmenl furnlµ°a namlw°.em Dft b,..w SIZE FRAME eal W nnl anal)pe° °W 4*eyr.1 1.1. on Kb nv noire 1°•°n .1na.bt.':AIN H.X91-1 a«omm�s).Srw.gl^einq al l,.ee .1(..rwa W N i TYPE FRAME FRAME ° w DOOR N0. DOOR MATERIAL FINISH REMARKS Ott-°rwnpnmr m'«1µa nel Toone to p. MATERIAL FINISH wk"a"" '"°°"" "'• °`" �1WALL TYPE 1 WALL TYPE 2 me salPmw mm,e.mtwy.wwa ma]w nw.,nq lw m Iprt a `. '%� INTERIOR SOLID WO PANEL DOOR, MATCH EXISTING mrom.cam, . . c 106 T$ T$ 1311' Di WO /GLASS PT-2 WD PT 2 DOORS. TR. a.cml.«1m mw p.m•..m b..ma nHw mala.m ww...w.a.m.:M mm,1«Wan. R aEmammtl MnclMt ma F a mmne rntNmt eiM me m m 107A T$ T$ T-SIP 02 w0 /GLASS Pi-4 IND FT-] FULL-LIGHT N9 STORM DOOR; MATCH EXISTING n . FRONT DOOR. N.cmX«lw mm ma.rmn°aem mu wary=mmm:tlw aI.m m rime. aayia�- rel nrlsaOi•`w°a°m w.ia It�el"witaa°1".i WD GLASS PT-4 WD PT-4 FULL-LIGHT MARVIN ULTIMATE WD EXTERIOR. mpb w•=eolma o .11.same°la 10]B 2d T$ 1-SM' D3 / INSWING OOGR tt�alt,.,,l Illmbll—1t, pw. Do a,ll.°1rr«u eea�m...a.�°et al .Imewaa P-1°atvl°I cwnYucllen. 6.Canlmel,1°tnw°°gN,tl°n SI au epee,lam -.tbeaan MOI o 10,lbIor ,,.,mew ae oov,wnt.`�r1 ot'.Kb,w.°.P,-,1rye NDOW SCHEDULE poem. SIZE FRAME tl.wit« m u amyl. .e= e u = «I,wom . WINDOW WINDOW ',.ea.`l e u 11- a.an•.°ry..1 1..e NO. MATERIAL FINISH REMARKS ^�aewlµal me el pp��meaw a Iww In.XK.I.own.1mq e' W M FRAME FRAME wn:wwl..1 mnq ama tm Inelntma.wawa.. Xe MATERIAL FINISH wnl m w mr.an=m.w =wm^ur11r..'rw'a�.' wu..tw':. t.m,.n mL wm.vy WI YS GRP WO / CLASS PT-] WD Pi-] MARPT PT VIN ULTIMATE TRUE DIVIDED MIGHT Wp WINDOW natnrtuma.acaa w°raga arc.ra omni. le.wr,«lw m maarr.,me«mmrat..Iu K.xc,Hr.mr;nq,w.er«n.a uulgrr m°m.R nnenr.rclw mwwl..q Ir say..-I W2 241? BS WD /GLASS PT-] WJ PT-2' PT- lb Pi MARVIN ULTIMATE TRUE DIVIDED LIGHT WD WINDOW mtarle.e'n lnlma.nq ml. -1 eroowe Noire: Iq.eM w,wb. a«I°.ear Xl me.ua,.m.mm q.....e Ito:n mwq.a t. amm p .Hn..e. ww=rw,wlR.a b,Arn.'It . 20.C °i°pa EelennlnM M c xrnalinna 1111 axr m,wa 1° If(�M M9n"I='ial tq 21 ale le.. °4ul e ;'M11...1.1 N.b.a « 1 «o JONES ' r 22 6W 1.m Mnnm 1°.1 1,Ira°e,N,.lam=. �II+ III I I III 10 De by Sq.Suite,INC 10 Denby Sq.Suite 314 seleln.MA 01970 2x8 ROOF JOST AS —(2)-2x10 LEDGER LECKGER ATTACHED TO 978.744'5200 ExISYG WALL WW W.jOn¢SaIGI.CDRI FOUNDATION WALL I (2)-2%8 HIP RIDGE 2X8 ROM JOIST AT 16 _ O.C.. TIP- I . - - - (3)-2X6 HEADER. AT WINDOWS AND AND DOORR S. TTP. MAY 12,2017 wst...m _ 1106 VARIES FoonNc (BELOW) - -- - - -- r WALL TYPES, 0 JOISTS AT 12' 3" STONE SHELF 2x1 SEE LANDSCAPE DWG$ 0-C. TTP FRAMING,NOTES, FOR ADD'L INFO ON SCHEDULES CHANITE STAIR FOOTING THIS LOCATION /� 3� IL�INDATION PLAN a )FLOOP, FRAMING 5'�ROOF FPAMING AO 01 Cottrell I Jones Residence 56 Warren Street Salem,MA _ . Lim; I-TTI °-_ IhFgII��1I ILII--�I1Ip�� _ e >- - _ _ -- _ T' - - r —I l '11 LL_Y LJ IJJ — ffp I _ I -Ff�-1-__ F - J k}� L _ j N - - a L Ili-�j�_ti� .. Y 1 'f�1 LI - - - —__ ' -- ---------- --- fi Ili T 7 1 'II ISyF��1; IL I - - JI IILJ - F - — Q 44- a SOUTH ELEVATION, DEMGLITION EAST ELEVATION, DEMOLITION DEMOLITION NOTES. ELEVATION: 1 GENERAL: ALL DEMOLISHED MATERIAL TO BE REMOVED FROM THE PROPERTY AND PROPERLY DISPOSED OF, UNLESS NOTED AS SALVAGED MATERIAL BELOW SEE SITE PLAN FIXE DEMOLITION OF SITE FEATURES. LANDSCAPE - -- ELEMENTS. AND OTHER EXTERIOR WORK. 1. REMOVE EXISTING EXTERIOR WALL. ROOF, DOOR, BOOKING, CEILING, LIGHT FIXTURE, SHELVING, STAIR. 1 2. SALVAGE EXISTING WINDOW AND DOOR AND DELIVER TO OWNER. - - 3. REMOVE EXISTING WIDE PLANK WOOD CLAPBOARD SIDING. SALVAGE FOR RE-USE IN ADDITION. 4. REMOVE EXISTING TRIM SALVAGE FOR RE-USE IN ADDITION. j_ _ 5. REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW. BLOCKING. AND TRIM. OPENING WILL BE - LEFT AS ACCESS TO CRAWLSPACE OF ADDInON. _ I rw I T Wwrc�>�n I I JONES I Jones Architecture,Suit. INC I- Saturn. Derby Sq- 3N St em.MA 01970970 878.744.5200 I 66 yiwvjonasarrh.com DEMOLITION NOTES, PLAN: GENERAL'. ALL DEMOLISHED MATERIAL TO SE REMOVED FROM THE O �L PROPERTY AND PROPERLY DISPOSED OF, UNLESS NOTED AS TTT SALVAGED MATERIAL BELOW. SEE SITE PLAN FOR DEMOLITIO14 OF SITE FEATURES, LANDSCAPE ELEMENTS, AND OTHER EXTERIOR WORK. LF I. REMOVE EXISTING EXTERIOR WALL. ROOF. DOOR, FLOORING. CEILING. LIGHT FIXTURE, SHELVING. STAIR. 2 REMOVE EXISTING DOW.$ AND HARDWARE SALVAGE Afro DELIVER TO OWNER. 3 REMOVE EXTERIOR WALL AS INDICATED, NOTE THAT DURING _ II KITCHEN RENOVATOR THIS NEW OPENING WAS PREAOUSLx i 1 ! ` - FRAMED WHILE WALL WAS OPEN (HEADER, JAMB. AND SILL). un 4 REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SALVAGE AND DELIVER TO OWNER _ �L MAY 12,2017 REMOVE EXISTING WALL BELOW WINDOW DOWN TO FLOOR PLATE I �- _ -. 1T1 L PREP OPENING FOR NEW FLOORING AND THRESHOLD. REMOVE _I � 7 meWcx M�Wex cu.- EXISTING TRIM FROM BOTH SIDES OF WALL AND SALVAGE FOR REUSE IF POSSIBLE -- 1108 VARIES 5_ REMOVE EXTERIOR FLOODLIGHT RETAIN EXISTING ELECTRICAL FOR NEW FIXTURE E REMOVE EXISTING t"TERIDR WIDE PLAMR WOOD CLAPBOARD SIDING DEMOLITION MERE NEW ADDITION WILL ABUT EXISTING BUILDING SALVAGE FOR REUSE _ _ _ PLANS AND 7. REMOVE EAISTNG MANTEL FROM AROUND FIREPLACE REMOVE _ ____ EXISTING TILE HEARTH. PREP FLOOR FOR NEW HEARTH AND ELEVATIONS FIREPLACE FOR NEW WE CASEWORK. L pOi DI DEMO FLAIYI D1 01 Cottrell/Jones RasitlenDe 55 WBffMn Street Salem,MA V DE NEW EFVE INTO EXISTING FIVE _ _ t 3'-TAB BLACK ASPHALT 3-TAB BLACK ASPHALT SHINGLE, TYP_ SHINGLE. TYP, I - IZ PID WD EAVE, MATCH PLO WO EAVE. MATCH _. Pl➢ WD TRIM, MATCH 3'�A _8• EXISTING. TIP. EXISTING. TYP EXISTING - -- - PTD MR GDTTEE AND IT�� rT DOWNSPOUT TE NEW EAVE INTO ��I��I�I�I�� I... I I PTD W9 CLAPBOARD. E E%IPTING EASE J Ir..- '14.1 -- LYI—LFII I:. E%PIDING. HOP m MATCH - III -11( ppq . PWD CLAPBOAP.D. 8 EX6TNG. I _ � _ EXPOSURE. MATCH a; I — — - EXISTING. TYP. C '� PTD WD CORNER TRIM. MATCH EXISTING, PTD W9 CORNER TRIM. ✓EXISTING, TTP. PTD WD TRIM, MATCH MATCH E%I$TING, iTP L _ - EXISTING. TVP. __ ________—_____ GRANITE VENEER - _- • - GRANITE VENEER BILCO CLASSIC SERIES MARNN VLTIMATE NEW GRANITE STAIR; NEW GRANITE STAIR; PTD 51E BULKHEAD DOUBLE-HUNG TRUE SEE LANDSCAPE DWGS SEE LANDSCAPE DWGS PTD WD TRIM, MATCH WOOD WINDOW FOR ADDL INFO FOR ADDL INFO EMSTING, TYP. MARNN INSWING NLL— WOOD STORM DOOR; 7 LIGHT WOOD DOOR. FULL MATCH EXISTING FRONT LIGHT STORM DOOR DOOR (MATCH FRONT DOOR) a SOUTH ELEVATION, PROPOSED (DEAST ELEVATION, PROPOSED 211 1 —I F j It JONES , 1103 N� I ,4f _ dROdl - I I" t0. EXISTING PRIMARY Jones AltllitBCGInT,INC Tw ELECTRIC SVC TO _ g REMAIN TD herby Sp.Suft970 3N PRo`nDE NEW 1-1/' \}1} _ Selem,MA DT970 THICM ST-1 SLAB: NP , 4'-0• SZE AFTER DEMO ,I� � --' SEC AO OIY ES,WTP - 978.744.5200 I � 1 1- -I WC, OFC wxw.jonasarch.wm SUN - _ _ - R,@M ] EDVIGER . I. MROOM J, __ C ROOM_ L__1011 10, , VN, FOR] L_ I - 1 '� PlD WD FENCE AND GATE qE p HALL H - - - VANITY AND MEOICIIVE im 7 - - CABWET, pFGI N � -- - 0 NEW Pro wD I � m CASEWORK — n 'm MUD w 1UPCHEN -a107 Y 100 I 101 B-INCH. OF01 L� ° � �W ih MAY 12,2017 -. — - ME w PTD WD rmu+nye caa CASEWORK NOS VARIES A PROPOSED EAVE LINE (ABOVE) PLANS AND EXISTNG WINDOW WELL _ NEw 81,70CLNEW GRANITE STAIR; ELEVATIONSTO REMAIN m SERIEP PTD SSEE LANDSCAPE DVIGSBULLHEAD DOFOR ADDL INFO - EXISTING EAVE ,INE - - �_�PE-USE E3ISTNG CURB \ (ABOVE) + - }S SUPPORT FOF NEW AlO q A311�0s RULE HEAD H �.FP,�1P f_)�.ELI �L�1I`I # ALL FUR14IT IFE SHOWN ' p'-]' TO PEFEREI4CE CHILI. - - - -- Cottrell I Jones ResIdeece �r Sa W .M Sheat 9demM A 3-TAB BLACK ASPHALT - 1 SHINGLE. TTP. PTO WD EAVE, MATCH 7 • -' -- EXISTING, TYP. _ WD PID EXPOSURE. MP EXISTING.TRIM. _ F MATCH EXISTING, TIP. !_ Plp WD CLAPBOARD, 8' I� —. - _ P10 WD fENCEGPND MATCH '910 FLVOP FRAMING _ I GRANITE KNEED, BET GRANITE VENEER DOUBLE-HUNG TIMATRUE EST TRIM, MATCH NEW GRANITE STAIR; �ON STONE SHELF ARYN SEE LANDSCAPE DWG$ CIP CONC FOOTINOOTN G AND PTO WE TRIM, MATCH Koo WINDOW FOR ADDL INFO FOUNDADON WALL EXISTING iYP. REMOVE EXISTING AREAWAY WINDOW, RETAIN TNNN OPENING L AS ACCESS TO CRAW-SPACE AND PIPE CHASE sNORTH ELEVATION, PROPOSED SECTION CENTER LIGHT FIXTURES OVER CENTERLINE OF WINDOW AS INDICATED CENTER LIGHT FIXILRESON WALL JONES = N CENTER IUr FIXTURES C • N Jones Architecture,INC AB IrvmDATED GVER 10 Derby Sq.Suits 3N WINDOW MUWDNS ) �i 10 Derm.MA .Suit _ CENTER LIGHT FIXTURES CENTER FIXTURE OVER ,LT_ -" C1970 OVER CENTERLINE OF WI CENTERLINE OF FRENCH --- WINDOW AS INDICATED 878744.5200 000R5 AND FlOPPOSITE W .joNBaffich.GOlil REPLACE LA �1 _ ��TER ALL Ll- '-'I% 'f URES IN AC e ISI NO. CONFIRM LAYOUT III ARCHITECT PRIOR TO — I TO FINALIZING. JJJ I I � I Qe LIGHT RxRIRE SCHEDULE SCHEDULE I MARE PRDNOED BY INSTALLEO Bl MA140FACTURER FIXTURE DIMMER REMARKS _ I [71 -l G t SWITCH AND CONDUIT FOR D Ot -I FIXTURE ARE INSTALLED, B CONTRACTOR (CAN) TES / N MITRACTOR TO INSTALL D AND F FIXTURE, PRONOED BY OWNER- C CONTRACTOR LK ART) AS - 1 ] MAY 12,2017 EXISTING SWITCH,BACK BOX, AND CONDUIT IN ,i T$ D OWNER CONTRACTOR (KITCHEN TABLE) NO I - N� PLACE AT LOCATIONS DESIGNATED ON RCP 110 r - _ _ 8 VARIES E CONTRACTOR (PowDER LAv) YES CENTER LIGHT FIXTURES PROPOSED ON WALLEXISTING SWISH. BACK DESIGNATED AND CONDUIT IN _ PLANS AND F CONTRACTOR (REAP ROOD) (MOTION DETECTOR') NO PLACE Al CCH. BACK AUX. AND N PCP ti f i� — SEE ELEVATIONS OM ER OEP CONTRACTOR REBTGRATIgd MODERN FILAMENT SCONCE NO SifB AMBER SOUIRPEL-CAGE FlLAMEHT R _ TECTU E DRAWINGS HARDWARE ITEM X68050001 BP$ INCANDESCENT BULB _ _ F E Gs roR — EXTERIOR LIGHTING A l 02 � POWER AND LIGHTING j i — — - _ Cottrell/Jones Reaitlence 55 WarrennStrfteet Salem.MA EXISTING HOUSE III it V, = I (BEYOND) ADDITIM. LARGELY -- - � CO NEW FE FENCEE (BE(BEY@JD) FLAT BOARD WD FENCE, UNPAINTED WN CATTT P rQy II I I i 1 I i i i )i �, r• I I l I E. EXISTING GRADE AT HREAR PROPERTY LINE EXISTINGGRADE AT HOUSE SE (BEIDND) FLAT BOARD WD GATE 8t((• TY, r'1SOUTH ELEVATION, FENCE w.ra JONES .- Jones Architecture,INC 10 Derey Sq.Su Be 3N Salem,MA 01970 978.744.5200 w Jonewreh.com MAY 12,2017 1108 VARIES PROPOSED PLANS AND ELEVATIONS Al 03 —PTO GWB, TTP PTO WD CROWN TO MATCH PiD WG TRIM TO MATCH EMS1ING, TTP. —N PTD WO CASEWORK EXISnNG WINDOW CASING. TYF. t - = 55 Ware Streelesldence i ul Salem,MA IF'I I i1 PTO WD T-I-C,WAINSCOT, —ROUGH OPENING HEAD. JAMB) VIAS RASE, AND CHAIR RAIL FRAMED IN EXISTING WALL AS P4FT OF PPCQN5TENOUS CONSiRUCTOLIN N, � 1 SQUTH cUUTH PRDIECT 9 —MUD —MUD �1t fll.tw KITCHEN Pio WD CROWN TO MATCH EXISTING, TVP. VANITY AND MEDICINE PTO GWR, TYP. .—PTD WD TRIM TO MATCH EXISTING DOOR PTO WD TRIM TO MATCH NEW PM ND CASEWORK CABINET. OFLI /� CASING, TYP EXISTING WINDOW CASING, TYP. — ——] PTD GWR. ff L P47 PTD WD 1-I-G I,:ATCN PTD WD T G WAINSCOT, ftUNIAL RAp1AtOP, MATCH JONES WAINSCOT, RASE, AND "� � � WAINSCOT, BASE. AND BASE, AND CHAIR RAIL EXISTING KITCFIEN RADIATOR CHAIR RAIL CHAIR RAIL Q��-{ C EAST 6 W� v N� E ST 10 Derby Sq.Suilc 10 Derby Sq.Suile 3N tvre POWDER vA I� 6 HALL 7 HALL 8 tQ-tv MALL Salem,MA 01970 978.744.5200 E%IS➢NC 1ti Alll"ail NEW Pio ND CASEWfIRK, MANTEL, ANO PTD WD CROWN TO MATCH WNM'")Ona%lCtl'COm FIREPLACE SURROUND EXISTING, TYP. PTD WE TRIM TD MATCH EXISTING —PID WD TRIM iD MATCH _ pDOR CASING, TW. EXISTING WINDOW CASING, TYP. r i j _ - - Mill - IIID II I I ONE MAY 12,2017 —. - — .. ■ 1106 VARIES INTERIOR J ELEVATIONS 1 L WC. bFCI RUNTAL RADIATOR, MATCH E-OLNG MASDNR: EXISTING KITCHEN RADIATOR A2 01 �� E;, . i � � _- �z wE� ST �3 r�oRTIo,�ER • • i _ "•.... +.ice � "gFem.. - .. . - .:.. _..:•. .--rte..,. s Aye w 1: la 4 t { .. .:. pp=: riA •♦ -I `� 7 N �I1 G ��•-� � � ��.� viii • •• • • •• • • • • • •• • q. P l r '� •QTS ' Z.W T i I f•:� 4 k T�� •Y• r n, � r ,li r lit - _ low PMS' - Existing Conditions ................... .............. ............. ................................................................................................................................................................................. 'pr 7 1'r 55 Warren St; existing aluminum clad basement bulkhead (left) and mudroom/vestibule (right) 55 Warren St; existing aluminum clad basement oulkhead (left) and mudroom/vestibule (right) Existing Conditions ................ ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ ' r 55 Warren St; location of proposed addition along east side at driveway ow -rr_ l Y 55 Warren St; location of proposed addition --- kitchen window (at left) will be door into mudroom Existing Conditions ...................................................-... ................................................................................................................ ........................................................... 55 Warren St; location of proposed addition --- kitchen window (at left) will be door into mudroom (left) 55 Warren St; existing watercourse and corner trim will be matched in proposed addition, as indicated on proposed elevations / \ (right) 55 Warren St; existing eave detail will be matched in proposed addition, as indicated on proposed elevations General Note. Paint colors of the proposed addition and fence will match body and trim colors of the existing house. Precedent • Similar dutch colonia with garriDrel roof: sunroom volume at left, entry/mudroom volume at right. Similar dutch coloniE i with gambrel roof; entry/mudroom volume at right. V 1 f yip h 4 �� i �� ♦ T� 'r x�� FA _ Aj, 1, a 4 • • • • • •• • •• • -4 1417 y � X11 _K i !: ( a low _ New Rear Entry Sconce ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................... Proposed sconce at rear entry: Restoration Hardware Modern Filament Sconce 6-1/2"W x 7-3/4"D x 13-1/4"H Bronze Finish Squirrel-Cage Filament Incandescent Bulb This is the same fixture that flanks either side of the front door facing Warren St (as pictured below). The photo at left is a stock photo frcm the RH website. v nL Front entry facing Warren Street (bottom), cetail photos of existing light fixtures. New Windows ................................................................................._............................................................................................................................................................. ULTIMATE DOUBLE HUNG NEXT GENERATION NO DETAIL OVERLOOKED Engineered for performance and designed to inspire,each aspect o:the Ultimate Double Hung Next Generation Window was made with purpose. Our engineers conside- every detail from the most innovative features to the mos-minute subtleties,all because the windoN<_ in your home help illuminate the most important parts of you-Ife. INTERIOR FEATURES AND PERFORMANCE RICH WOOD INTERIOR INTERIOR SHADES Offers beauty and warmth with Integrate seaml,, . into the nine wood species and ten window without vu,ble cords interior finish optionsor pulleys,The fit is precise with virtually no light bleed. NARROW CHECKRAIL _ EXCLUSIVE AUTO LOCK Provides a sleek aesthetic at 1'5/16" Activates when the sashes a,, to maximize daylightopening while '1 maintaining historical accuracy. r oleo,lock'mn the window FIRST-RATE ENERGY TILT WASH EFFICIENCY Allows easyaccess toexteriorglass Meets ENERGY STAR"'standards for cleaning and maintenance. In energy efficiency with multiple glass options for various regions, climates and weather needs. RETRACTABLE SCREEN A screen option that easily SASH BALANCE retracts out of sight when not in SYSTEMS use and provides smooth, quiet Enables smooth operation at the operation. largest sizes. Proposed window, Marvin Ultimate Double Hung, muntin pattern to -hatch existing windows as shown in proposed elevations. Authentic divided light upper sash. Paintable wood interior and exterior. New Door ( Rear) ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................ CONTEMPORARY DOOR DOORS DESIGNED TO LET THE VIEW BE THE STAR Modern residential design is fluid,dynamic and open.Marvin'"Contemporary Inswing and Outswing Doors coordinate with 4 3/a inch narrow stiles and rails to let more light pass unhindered through more glass. And the view is edged in 90 degree square glazing bead on the interior profile where glazing meets wood fo- a sleek, crisp look. Its an outstanding combination of simple clean lines, maximum light anc flexioility. INTERIOR EXTERIOR CONTEMPORARY DOOR HARDWARE Match the lines of the Marvin Contemporary Swinging Door with elegantly styled,complementary hardware characterized by a square escutcheon and modern level profile.Available in Matte Black,Dark Bronze, Oil Rubbed BronzePvu, or Satin Nickelwe Square escutcheon.Striking,modern lever profile. Proposed door, Marvin Ultimate Double Hung, as shown in proposed elevations. Paintable wood interior and exterior. Door is over 95 feet from the Dalton Pkwy at the rear elevation of the house. www.jonesarch.com 1? New Fence and mate. ............................................... ..................................................................................... ................... ....... ........ ............................................. t. boo Precedent for pa'nted wood fence. Flat cap, flat board. Paint in our case will match existing trim color of existing house. Unfin shed wood fence at back property line will be left to weather, turning silver. New Fence and Gate ........................................................................................................................................ .......................................-.................................................... ............ 'VV 4 .II— _- -II - i t I i a _ Precedent for painted wood fence. Flat cap, flat board. Paint in our case will match existing trim color of existing house. Unfinished wood fence at back property ine will be left to weather, turning silver. Spm— FORM pm FORM B -BUILDING LHD 3/3/81 Assessor's number USGS Quad Area(s) Form Number 25-173 Salem HU 687 Town Salem Place(neighborhood or village) Central Salem s , a , Address 55 Warren Street " Historic Name Patrick Mullin House Uses: Present Residential Original Residential Date of Construction 1925 Source Salem City Directories Style/Form Dutch Colonial ti Architect/Builder Parker&Walsh, architects Exterior Material: Foundation Stone �s Wall/Trim Wood Clapboard n� :1:° `�'' V ,• x Roof Asphalt Shingle • •. ,. , Outbuildings/Secondary Structures ° , �• none � ,o • r + • ly' Major Alterations (with dates) none 3 , + � • r"" A W W/ Condition good °•_ Moved ® no ❑ yes Date loss Y ems,""^ :_•� •°'��_ / Acreage less than one acre Recorded by Lisa Mausolf Setting setback from street on residential street lined by Organization Salem Planning Department post-1914 buildings Dat= nrf� 1997 j Follow mossachusetts Historical Commission Survey Uanual instructions for completing this form. aur. n 5 1991 MASS. HIST. COMM. Vg-7 BUILDING FORM ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION Describe architectural features. Evaluate the characteristics of the building in terms of other buildings within the community. Resting on a mortared stone foundation, 55 Warren Street is a two-story Dutch Colonial residence sheathed in wide, wooden clapboards and capped by the gambrel roof which is characteristic of the style. Brick steps and a concrete walk edged in brick lead from the sidewalk to the central entrance. Marking the entrance is an arch supported by Roman Doric columns. The sidewalls of the porch are latticed. Built out from the entrance porch is a multi-paned,glass vestibule. The front door is flanked by sidelights. To each side of the entrance is a tripartite window consisting of a central 6/1 window,flanked by two 4/1 sash. Other windows on the building include paired 6/1 windows and smaller 6/1 individual windows. The single-story sun porch to the west of the main block is lit by continuous 6/1 windows. The shed dormer spanning the front roof slope is lit by three 6/1 windows. A semicircular opening lights the side gable. A gravel driveway is located to the west of the house. A fluted iron hitching post topped by a horse's head is located adjacent to the curb in front of the house. HISTORICAL NARRATIVE Describe the history of the building. Explain its associenions with local(or state,,history. Include uses of the building and the role(s) the owners/occupants played within the community. This house was constructed in 1929 for Patrick and Elizabeth Mullin. Patrick Mullin was a grocer with a store at 1 Butler Street. The house was acquired by Frank and Mary Brophy in 1944. Frank was the owner of Munroe and Amold-Merritt Express, Inc. at 426 Essex Street. The Brophy family continued to own the property until the mid 1980s. According to the 1979 inventory form and data provided by Mary Brophy, the date of construction(I 925)is inscribed on the interior ch,,nney and the building was designed by Parker and Walsh,arctitects. BIBLIOGRAPHY and/or REFERENCES Hopkins, G.M. Atlas of Salem. Massachusetts. Philadelphia: 1874. McIntyre,Henry C.E. Man of the City of Salem. Philadelphia: 1851. Richards, L.J. Atlas of the City of Salem Massachusetts, 1897. Salem City Directories, 1836-1970. Salem Historic Resources Survey, 1979. Sanborn Insurance Maps, 1890, 1906, 1950, 1957, 1965, 1970. [Massachusetts State Library]. Tolles, Bryant F., Jr. Architecture in Salem: an Illustrated Guide. Salem: Essex Institute, 1983. Walker Lithograph and Publishing Company. Atlas of the City of Salem Massachusetts. Boston: 1911. ✓ Recommended for listing in the National Register o_Historic Places. If checked,you must attach a completed National Register Criteria Statement form. Massachusetts Historical Commission Sf l-- (097 Community Property Address 220 Morrissey Boulevard Boston, Massachusetts 02125 Salem 55 Warren Street Area(s) Form No. Fu 11 687 National Register of Historic Places Criteria Statement Form Check all that apply: ❑ Individually eligible VEligible 9gly in a historic district ❑ Contributing to a potential historic district ❑ Potential historic district Criteria: ❑ A ❑ B ❑ C ❑ D Criteria Considerations: ❑ A ❑ B ❑ C ❑ D ❑ E ❑ F ❑ G Statement of Significance by: Lisa Mausolf Justify criteria that are checked in the above sections: A good example of the Dutch Colonial style,the Patrick Mullin House at 55 Warren Street retains a high degree of integrity of location,design, setting,materials,workmanship,feeling and association. Characteristic of the style,the house is capped by a gambrel roof with a full shed dormer spanning the front slope,a Colonial-inspired,columned entrance porch and sunporch to the side. Like its post-fire neighbors on the south side of Warren Street,the house would be a contributing element to a National Register historic district if the boundaries were reconfigured to coincide with the existing locally designated district. i ¢0 T Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction �K Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act(M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Propertv: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: Richard Jones &Naomi Cottrell Description of Work Proposed: Use of granite in lieu of brick for stair and cheek wall material at the front stoop and for the stair at the sidewalk edge, elimination of the vestibule and trellis structure additions,reduction of the size of the front stoop to be consistent with the original construction of the house, adding a full light painted wood storm door with glass/screens at the front door. Work as per exhibits presented. Dated: December 17 2015 SALEM HISTORICAL,-q0MMISSION By: ?1atesto The homeowner has the option not to commence the work (unless it rolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. Once completed,please submit a photographs) of the final result(maximum of four-i.e. one photograph of each affected fa(ade). THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals)prior to commencing work. Date Stamp CLEC 0 12015 —� DE . OF PLANN;NG& Salem Histofzcal Commission COM UNITY DEVELOPMENT 120 WASHINGTON STREET.SALEM.MASSACHUSETTS 01970 For Office Use Only (976)619.5585 FAX f978)740-0404 APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance, application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness for: ❑ New Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Sign ❑ Other District: ❑Derby Street ❑Lafayette Street f vlcIntire ❑Washington Square Address of Property: ppVV "�L, OF-f) Name of Record Owner(s): C-0 � l t-, a .t L Owner Mailing Address:�_� I Description of Work Proposed Pleasc I)Pe orxlhlt cicatlj: AttacG additional sleets, as necessarn. Arl t4tivV1 I Konz L 3 Name of Applicant: ' 1 Ur�_1/y m Owner ❑Contractor ❑Tenant ❑Other: Signature: Date: r 1 5 Tel. #: ( Z S�Z E-mail Address:_ iC ,C� t1 r C ^ Certificate will be mailed to the owner unless otherwise indicated here: Certificate should be mailed to: Name Mailing address: City: State:_ Zip: ATTACHED DOCUMENTATION FF An application will not be considered complete unless all work items are thoroughly describedand the application includes all information needed for the Commission to make a determination. Failure to submit a com lete a lication may result in a continuation to a future meetinjz, Recommended information includes: rr Photos of existing conditions, taken from all public ways Site plan showing location of improvements Elevation drawings of the existing conditions and proposed improvements Drawings of details and other special conditions, including profiles Description,photographs, and/or catalog cuts of proposed materials (please bring to the meeting product samples, if appropriate) Dimensions(i.e. height of fence, size of pickets and posts, etc.) N VLb 'til c� i� Cl'Co P�C� n� Paint color samples, if applicable (no less than 2"x2") N/A Location and size of all mechanical equipment, such as transformers, HVAC equipment, f V A electrical service and meters, and proposed screening Description of Work Proposed SOLUTIONS A survey of period homes on Warren, Broad, and CONTEXT Chestnut show a wide range of solutions for front stoops such as this - granite, brick, wood, wood with This 1925 Dutch Colonial home has a front stoop made granite or brick piers - etc. For both stairs, we would of brick cheek walls, and brick treads and risers. The like to use granite in lieu of brick so we do not recre- front entry is framed by two columns, pilasters, and an ate the mortar joint on the flat problem. Cheek walls arched canopy structure, typical of the period. At some would be a veneer granite with a 3" thick solid cap. We point in the life of the home, the front stoop was ex- would use a split face panel at the cheek wall, and are tended and a wood and glass vestibule was added un- requesting approval to use a Rockport granite that is der the arched canopy structure. You can see that this akin to the original foundation granite in color. Be- was a later addition because the brick type and pattern tween these cheek walls we would use a single piece of change along the length of the cheek wall. At the time Swensen granite for each tread/riser. Flat work be- of this addition, the treads and risers were also moved tween the two sets of stairs and at the landing will be a further out to allow for the vestibule. At some point bluestone. in the life of the home trellis structures were added to either side of the entry between the front columns and In addition to addressing the failure of the brick work, pilasters. we would like to eliminate the vestibule and trellis structures as part of this renovation, and pull back the There are three risers and an additional set of brick front stoop to the original size that it was when the cheek walls at the sidewalk edge. Between these two home was built. To replace the intent of the vestibule sets of stairs there is a concrete sidewalk with brick from a performance standpoint, we would like to add a edging. The existing foundation of the main house is full light wood storm door with glass/screens, painted rock-faced granite. with the same eggplant trim color used on the existing front door. PROBLEMS In summary, we are seeking approval of the following: In both cases, the brick work is deteriorating. At the lower stair near the sidewalk, large portions of the 1. Use of granite in lieu of brick for stair and cheek brick tread are loose. The brick risers are also failing. wall material at the front stoop and for the stair Although we had hoped to address this in the spring at the sidewalk edge. 2016, the deterioration has accelerated in the last cou- 2. Elimination of the vestibule and trellis structure ple weeks and we are concerned about waiting through additions. the winter. At the front stoop, there is significant step 3. Reduction of the size of the front stoop to be cracking in the cheek wall where the original cheek wall consistent with the original construction of the meets the addition. The treads and risers at the stoop house. are also failing, although not as quickly as the lower 4. Adding a full light painted wood storm door stair. The horizontal use of brick in instances like this with glass/screens at the front door. allows for water penetration at mortar joints on the flat, which results in freeze-thaw cycles within the wall con- struction. We believe this to be the root of the problem with the deterioration of the brick. Moreover, the vestibule that was added at some point in the life of the home is poorly constructed: the door does not work well, only opening 60 degrees given the slope of the floor, and the roof has water penetra- tion issues. It does not provide any benefit in terms of heating the home. It is also too small to function effec- tively as a vestibule, particularly with the door opening inward, and makes it difficult to move in and out of the front door. Proposed Site Plan, Parcel WARREN STREET AREA OF WORK--' \: L O 7 I o cz i i W 0 i i Dq� T0N ; pgRKwA X Proposed Site Plan, Enlarged to Area of Work granite cur maple post mapl p O BRICK CITY SIDEWALK S 7•_2.. SOLID GRANITE RISERS - - - GRANITE VENEER WALLS WITH CAP PATH - T-2" 1'-51TYP .., i6'Ironl setback — - SOLID GRANITE RISER \GRANITE VENEER WALL WITH CAP o y 0 p b n t Existing and Proposed Warren Street Elevation ® Ll EXISTING VESTIBULE BRICK STEPS BRICK CHEEK WALLS EXISTING FRONT ELEVATION 1 EXISTING WOOD DOOR AND SIDELIGHTS TO REMAIN WOOD STORM DOOR - SOLID GRANITE RISERS -. GRANITE VENEER WALL WITH CAP PROPOSED FRONT ELEVATION 2 Existing and Proposed Side Elevation EXISTING TRELLIS ® BRICK CHEEK WALLS II BRICK STEPS (BEYOND) 1_ EXISTING SIDE ELEVATION 1 ITI GRANITE VENEER WALLS WITH CAP / GRANITE STEPS (BEYOND) L PROPOSED SIDE ELEVATION 2 Existing and Proposed Warren Street Elevation Ll E ® ® ® NN� ® ® EXISTING VESTIBULE M BRICK STEPS JIM BRICK CHEEK WALLS EXISTING FRONT ELEVATION 1 EXISTING WOOD DOOR AND SIDELIGHTS TO REMAIN ® ED�� WOOD STORM DOOR LUJ SOLID GRANITE RISERS r � GRANITE VENEER WALL WITH CAP PROPOSED FRONT ELEVATION 2 Existing and Proposed Side Elevation EXISTING TRELLIS ® BRICK CHEEK WALLS BRICK STEPS(BEYOND) EXISTING SIDE ELEVATION 7 �7® GRANITE VENEER WALLS WITH CAP GRANITE STEPS(BEYOND) PROPOSED SIDE ELEVATION 2 Proposed Section ® 3"THICH GRANITE CAP GRANITE STEPS T'R,127,TYP. 0 PROPOSED SECTION 3 Proposed Material Palette y` 1 } r wr t. > '� f'^a3i�� - •€ "I I} s+'.l�`F�€ �i.�•'^rNo t f f ` I This photo is of a similar palette of materials at 75 Warren Street.At left you see original granite foundation, similar in color, texture, and finish treatment to our foundation at 55 Warren Street. We are proposing that the cheek walls for both the front stoop and the stair at the sidewalk be a Rockport granite very similar to this material. The tread/user would be a Swensen granite, with an eased edge, matching what we see here as a planter edge. The bluestone flat work would match the flatwork as seen in the foreground of this image. SOLUTIONS A survey of period homes on Warren, Broad,and Chestnut show a wide range of solutions for front stoops such as this-granite,brick, wood, wood with granite or brick piers-etc.For both stairs, we would like to use granite in lieu of brick so we do not recreate the mortarjoint on the flat problem. Cheek walls would be a veneer granite with a 3"thick solid cap. We would use a split face panel at the cheek wall,and are requesting approval to use a Rockport granite that is akin to the original foundation granite in color.Between these ' cheek walls we would use a single piece of Swensen granite for each tread/riser. Flat work between the two sets of stairs and at the landing will be a bluestone. In addition to addressing the failure of the brick work, we would like to eliminate the vestibule and trellis structures as part of this renovation,and pull back the front stoop to the original size that it was when the home was built. To replace the intent of the vestibule from a performance standpoint, we would like to add a full light wood storm door with glass/screens,painted with the same white trim color used elsewhere on the house. In summary, we are seeking approval of the following: o Use of granite in lieu of brick for stair and cheek wall material at the front stoop and for the stair at the sidewalk edge. o Elimination of the vestibule and trellis structure additions. o Reduction of the size of the front stoop to be consistent with the original construction of the house. o Adding a full light painted wood storm door with glass/screens at the front door. Richard M.Jones.AIA, LEED AP BD+C Director Jones Architecture, Inc. 10 Derby Sq,Suite N3 Salem, MA 01970 o:978.744.5200 m:617.834.7652 1. C From: Naomi Cottrell<naomi Camichellecrowley-la.com> Subject: Re:55 Warren St/Salem Historical Commission Date: December 16,2015 4:54:46 PM EST To: Richard Jones<rick@jonesarch.com> Naomi Cottrell,LEED AP Michelle Crowley Landscape Architecture 281 Summer Street 6th Floor Boston MA 02210 P:617 338 8400 C:617 5714726 F:617 203 9033 michel lecrowley-la.com On Nov 30,2015,at 3:05 PM, Richard Jones wrote: Jane- Good afternoon.This is an email about my house,not Hamilton Hall,for a change! We have some issues that have just come to light with our from steps. I had hoped to make it to next spring before having to deal with this,but the deterioration of the brick treads and risers has really accelerated in the last two weeks,with large sections of the brick tread simply falling apart.With winter coming,we'd like to deal with this now before B gets any worse,and before the ground is completely frozen. As is typical of projects like this in old homes,there is a little bit of scope creep-once we started talking about solving the immediate problem of the failing brick,it became what makes sense to do at the same time because to go back and do it later is inefficient and costly. So,wha: probably starts as a hardship gets muddier. I stopped by the office today,but understand you are not in Amy(?I think that was her name)was very helpful.She gave me forms for a Certificate of Hardship and a Certificate of Appropriateness and recommended that 1 reach out to you to confirm which Is best for our project We will of course produce drawings and photographs,but I have outlined a narrative below. Thanks and please feel free to call me to discuss if you need to. Rick CONTEXT This 1925 Dutch Colonial home has a front stoop made o1 brick cheek walls,and brick treads and risers. The front entry is framed by two columns,pilasters,and an arched canopy struc'ure, typical of the period.At some port in the life of the home, the front stoop was extended and a wood and glass vestibule was added under the arched canopy structure. You can see that this was a later addition because the brick type and pattern change along the length of the cheek wall.At the time of this addition, the treads and risers were also moved further out to allow for the vestibule.At some point in the life of the home trelds structures were added to either side of the entry between the front columns and pilasters. There are three risers and an additional set of brick cheek walls at the sidewalk edge.Be'ween these two sets of stairs there is a concrete sidewalk with brick edging. The existing foundation of the main house is rock-faced granite. PROBLEMS In both cases,the brick work is deteriorating.At the lower stair near the sidewalk,large portions of the brick tread are loose. The brbk risers are also failing.Although we had hoped to address this in the spring 2016, the deterioration has accelerated in the last couple weeks and we are concerned about waiting through the winter.At the front stoop, there is significant step cracking in the cheek wal' where the original cheek wall meets the addition. Tre treads and risers at the stoop are also failing,although not as quickly as the lower stair. The horizontal use of brick in instances like this allows for water penetration at,mortar joints on the flat, which results in freeze-thaw cycles within the wall construction. We believe this to be the root of the problem with the deterioration of the brick. Moreover, the vestibule that was added at some point in the life of the home is poorly corstructed.,the door does not work well,only opening 60 degrees given the slope of the floor,and the roof has water penetration issues. It does not provide any benefit in terms:�f heating the home.It is also too small to function effectively as a vestibule,particularly with the door opening inward,and makes it difficult to move in and out of the front door. . . . - -_ - .- _,� .�� .�.� .._.� -moi J �_ n - �. � :.ori+'-a��C.-= '` w �: 1 :r'. �/ ..w ,+� � �s� r�: �`' -F' i e .d i — =a � �- L_ i "�u moo- _a�..�„�..� _ �= y�.�t��-�� I _ 0. �. 1 i � � i �- 4' JF gL+ OMA ri- ' � v I t, mxy k c' ty ,Sl r� iw . 7 Ir � , 4 S A _ -..`L. i 1.:• _ y .I ,<• .:moi•!8°' -. 71 3i 1 sJ _,rte=��' .�r . _ -�-• � . _- . . �"- ', _ - _, ter.-�•L�. � + � ' , j� •• • • • • • • • • • a ,R1 F i r i Al m 1 49A r� Itt n� ` �14�'� '. ` .0 Existing Conditions Photos _s P J 1 J Deterioration of existing brick st3i s r: +r- Change rn brick cclor and coursing between original cheek wall(top of image, under column), and addition (bottom of image) i '1 r�. e' V`; _ �.1- �^ " �.� . . �. f �. } s �� ''. S.. t ,�,gx. > Y. 'b � +4�,.a �^ c � 1 �4 'g�,f�e ht?f, � rr �s r a '�� r �.,�� ' ''fig n f ,. zk�. �' rE n � - - �- ... �. �- J � � Y � yC�'.mom- \ �.� i_�' .. i �1 � �. . r Tom. r - c y - l ------------ l Proposed Wood Screen/Glass Door I Scr n, cre n/Storm Door Designs Profiles m N 0 0 N nLI �2 Tempertd 14� v _ V a EAll m Ime l N 9 [ c a ppEcmer p O V� 1 _` SCT10SCT-20 SCT--30 SCT-40 Profile 61.2 1tium.622 E � - E N n n I I � E -- 'M ?� w 2 E Rewuu.• E P7g°On Uxu.I � wa1e661 aofile W 2 j4 SCC-10 SCC-20 SCC-30 SCC-40 1 � 1 in $: U� I ° @ � Oa. � I�IIIF�IIII� a LJ I I N N V Pmfilr 6a 2 Pm51e 65.2 S-10 S-20 S-30 S-40 options Traditional Screen/Storm Screen Doors moor b 4 .p'p.mt r N.R� In � I tin ,e o_ I I °4EE >a = U ,% ^ S 3�9 uw w.ewa�a 5R-11 SCDt] 591 592 Full View RounJ Top Fu V,-Round Top Fb11V.aGe iCRq On flat dimensions.41m-stiles and top ail,7"boewm rat,and 61/x°lock rail All measvr'e,ents shown in,rhes See our web srte at.vww.upstatedooccom for additional irformation. Proposed Wood Screen/Glass Door Customso .�� S , Doors e Hardwood screen/storm doors add a classic,elegant look to a home.They add character and charm to create a closed-in porch. Upstate Door's innovative design is the easiest to prepare for all seasons.A home- owner can easily change the screen sash to the storm sash with only a few twists of a screwdriver. Imagine hardwood screen/storm doors on your porch. 4 Upstate's Custom Screen/Storm Door Construction ♦ Our doors are stile and tail construction available in I'A", 13/fl"or 1314' thickness. Custom thicknesses available on request. ♦ We use Solid,Pattern-Grade South American Mahogany,Spanish Cedar,Douglas Fir, White or Red Oak to ensure beauty,strength,and durability over time. ♦ All screen/storm doors are glued and doweled with a marine epoxy to withstand the worst weather. ♦ Paint-grade panel edges are pre-primed before assembly so every comer is covered. ♦ All paint-grade screen/storm doors arc primed and sanded,ready to be painted,while stain-grade doors are finish sanded, ready to be stained. ♦ Solid brass Spreader Bar option is available for Full View design. ♦ All designs are available in screen and screen/storm doors. ♦ Many glass options available ♦ Fine hardware solutions ♦ Pre-finishing service on stain grade doors Visit our website for more design ideas! Our Custom Door Experts will be delighted to assist you in developing your project. "Upstate Door manufactures a high quality product. First rate." �IS1112c )e Door 6ofuflorls I .PI SpCATIONS - .VW. Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition EK Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address- of Property- 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: Richard Jones and Naomi Cottrell Description of Work Proposed: Ecterioa-paint colors: Borly- California Paint Organic White (A-13) Trina- California Paint Sugar Sugar(DEW380) Dated: October 10, 2013 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION B32��ie,t*V) C The homeowner has [lie option not to commence the work (unless it relates to resolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. I'l-IIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildin.-s (or any other necessary permits or approvals) prior to commencing work. ^i1.'YT{fit Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET.SALEM,MASSACHUSET IS 01970 (97H)6195685 FAX t978i 740 o106 p�Ati°U� APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance, application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness for: ❑ New Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration Ll Demolition ■ Painting ❑ Sign ❑ Other District: []Derby Street El Lafayette Street ❑McIntire ❑Washington Square Address of Property: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner(s): Naomi Cottrell and Richard Jones Owner Mailing Address: 55 Warren Street, Salem, MA 01970 Description of Work Proposed (Please include required scale drawings,paint chips, catalog cuts and/or samples ofbiaterial proposed, where applicable.) We request a certificate of appropriateness to paint the existing wood siding and trim the following colors. Body (siding) - California Paint Organic White A-13. Trim - California Paint Sugar Sugar DEW380. 11 W, 1 . 1 mustinclude photosofeidshingconditions, taken from pubhc Name of Applicant: Richard Jones & Naomi Cottrell MOwner ❑Contractor Tenant Other: Tel. 4: ((�H)978.594.5202 / E-mail Address: rick@jonesarch.com ( erti/cfflM 1911h7.78c3Q-165 Domer unless othenrise indicated here: Certificate should be mailed to: Name Mailing address: City: State:_Zip: IN ALFL, J r l i F' L I n ii 5 DEW380 Sugar Sugar ♦ 1 View of 55 Warren Street as seen from the sidewalk Salem His - • • • 55 Warren Street Application for of •• may.. �•' r•' v, T h View of 55Warren Street as seen fromDalton Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 0• V DAL TON PA RK wA Y =so. O' Hne n•r IN ST Nal£ 1 N F BdiND Na fW r 3 O4 AREA 11.333 S S.F. 1' Ay5 t z' IYY e RS J gee mW _ emmT WARREN STREET Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.09.16 1 _ t x r i _ 5 View of 55Warren Street as seen fromacross ApplicationSalem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street I a 'F 3, ��yG ip '/l1N Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS ft is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑O Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property- 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: Naomi Cottrell & Richard Jones Description of Work Proposed: Removal of all existing tvltite ctluminnn: siding to expose wooclett clapboards underneath. Approval includes airy repair work necessaryfor the wooden clapboards, provided that all work is in-kind curd there is no material or design change. Owners will apply for paint colors in a fitture application for a Certificate of Appropriatness. Dated: August 26, 2013 SAL HISTORICAL COMMISSION By: pn The homeowner has the option not to commence the work (unless it relates to resolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals) prior to commencing work. �Ug U , �® Salem Historical Commission Apr 62013 �`HMUIv��Arq��`G4 VF�MFn,. APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance. application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of'Appropriateness for: New Construction Moving Reconstruction Alteration ■ Demolition Painting - Sign _ Other District: - Derby Street ❑Lafayette Street McIntire Washington Square Address of Property: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner (s): Naomi Cottrell and Richard Jones Owner Mailing Address: 55 Warren Street, Salem, MA 01970 Description of Work Proposed (Please include required scale ch-cm ings, paint chips. catalog cUIS and,br.camples gfmaterial proposed inhere applicahle.) The house is a wood frame, center entry Dutch Colonial dating from 1925, built after the Salem fire. It has a stone foundation and 3-tab black asphalt shingle roof. At some point in the past, the body of the house was overclad in 8" exposure white aluminum siding, which is showing its age - it is pitted and discolored. When the siding was applied to the body of the house, all existing wood trim was left exposed - rakes, fascias, sills, aprons, trim boards, entry vestibule, etc. - and have been painted several times over the years. We are seeking permission to remove the existing white aluminum siding and expose the original 8" exposure wood clapboard siding both in order to facilitate energy efficiency improvements, and to restore the house to its original finish material. This summer we plan to blow in insulation in the exterior wall by removing individual wood clapboards, drilling holes in the substrate, blowing in insulation, repairing the hole in the substrate, and then re-installing the original wood clapboard. Pending budgetary constraints we will either paint the house later this fall or next summer. Once we see the condition and character of the existing wood clapboard, we will study historic paint color options, and return to HSC at a future date for a certificate of appropriateness to paint the house in a particular palette consistent with the time period of the original house. Apphcations mustm' dude photos of e)dsting conditions, taken from aH public ways. Name of-Applicant: Richard Jones & Naomi Cottrell MOwner IContractor ! iTenant Other: Tel. #: (H)978.594.5202 / E-mail Address: rick@jonesarch.com CertiJica�M�c�l1he.i834 i�tcGiS!?e oivner unless ohernise indicated herr: Certificate should be mailed to: Name Mailing address: City: State:_Zip: V Dq L TON Pq RK w4 Y a a.vw H-1 — �wc BWMD CW JIUM I ,a, i e - ISD lly ovens J WARREN STREET Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 1 M it , .:Y• � .4t Y �. iib d 1• c . 7,... w 4 `.� _ K 4 _ __ •ice+_ `. 'M..�� , Historical ��- View of 55 Warren Street as seen from across Warren Street Salem • • 55 Warren Street Application for • of Approriateness 2013.08.05 �z s_ all, - - - View of 55 Warren Street as seen from the sidewalk Note beneath the window at left where we have removed 1-1/2 courses of existing aluminum siding to reveal the existing wood siding beneath. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 3 y y9 . 4 � y f.�. �f •r a l r , _ � tom.., 1•� -WeZ _ t }. 00 Nei � � �r`�— �•e�- ,mow � ��y,�� S•'��View of 55 Warren Street as seen from the sidewalk Salem His - • • • 55 Warren Street Application for of Approriateness I I: I �4 1 1 1 1 �J� 1 /1 rl 1 View of 55 Warren Street as seen from the sidewalk Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 5 4- - i View of 55 Warren Street as seen from Dalton Parkway Similar to several other housees on Warren Street toward the Essex end, our lot is a through-lot with visibility from Dalton Parkway. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 6 � . e 4 , 7 J Detail of eave and rake at end of existing gambrel roof and sunroom The existing wood detailing was retained when the body of the house was overclad in aluminum. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 7 Detail photo of existing aluminum siding (left and bottom)and wood siding beneath (right and top) You are also seeing the original wood sill of a window at the top of the image. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 8 N =- Detail photo of existing wood clapboard showing 7-0 to 8"exposure, typical. The dark wood band seen at the top of the image beneath the existing wood sill would be removed when we paint the house - this is a nailer for the aluminum siding and is not original. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 9 i Y ' l 'i Detail view at entry vestibule facing Warren Street Existing aluminum siding (at right) compared with existing wood siding (at left), which was never overclad with aluminum, presumably because of the tight dimension. Note also green aluminum shutter(at top right), all of which will be removed with the siding. Salem Historical Commission 55 Warren Street Application for a Certificate of Approriateness 2013.08.05 10 �:rontulr Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF NON-APPLICABILITY It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: Construction ❑ Moving Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other Work as described below does not involve an exterior architectural feature or involves a feature covered by the exemptions or limitations set forth in the Historic District's Act(M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: Richard ionec & Naomi Cottrell Description of Work Proposed: Replacement of existing black, 3 lab asphalt roof with new black 3-lab asphall roof. No changes in color, malarial, design, location or outward appearance. Non-applicable due to being in kind maintenance/replacement. Dated: Mav 3, 2011 SAL AL COMMISSION B The homeowner has the option not to commence the work (unless it relates to resolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits From the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals) prior to commencing work. -� t-"R 4 RECIE. � ED • , , MAY 0 3 2011 DEPT. OF PLANNING& COMMiUNI iY DFVFL;:IPMENT Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET.SALEM.MA 01970 (978)745-9595 EXT.311 FAX(978)740-0404 APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF NON-APPLICABILITY Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance,application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Non-Applicability for: Construction Moving Reconstruction Alteration Demolition Painting Sign Other as described below. District: Original Building Construction Date, if known: l Address of Property: Name of Record Owner(s): L(PY(YLD J O ME, jJA-o I Corrrze L L Description of Work Proposed: �►�i'�4CE -77th Sl�'(.�5 1,v�77-� � —%�6 ,�L9-C� SN�v6cEs. Signature of Owner: \ Tel. 4: Mailing address: ST City: Q�V "��` State:_Zip: MA -- D / 9-7t ((LL �77�3jS"�� PROCEDURES FOR FILING APPLICATIONS A. Be prepared to apply for approvals well in advance of commencing any exterior work. Before making my changes to the exterior of a property in an historic district,the owner should call or visit the Commission representative at the Department of Planning&Community Development to discuss proposed alterations and to determine the category of the application(Appropriateness,Non-Applicability or Hardship). B. The Commission normally meets on the first and third Wednesdays of each month and notices are posted at City Hall. The meetings are held at 120 Washington Street,3rd floor,and begin at 7:30 p.m. All meetings are open to the public and any person is entided to appear and be heard on any matter before the Commission before it reaches a decision. C. An application for a Certificate of Appropriateness or Hardship must be received by 3:00 p.m.on the Monday 16 days before the meeting in order to make the agenda. An application for a Certificate of Non-Applicability may normally be added to the agenda up to the day of the meeting. In some cases,a Certificate of Non-Applicability maybe issued by the Clerk,without review by the full Commission,after notifying Commission members and allowing 24 hours for my objection. There is no fee for any applications. D. All applications for Certificates of Appropriateness or Hardship require a public hearing. Notice of the hearing must be posted with the City Clerk 14 days before the hearing and abutters must be notified in writing. Commission staff will handle these procedures. A public hearing is not required for a Certificate of Non-Applicability. E. Applications most be submitted by the owner of the property. A contractor for the owner,at the owner's request,may submit anapplication on the owner's behalf. In case of a tenant,a waiverof the owner's appearance maybe granted at the discretion of the Commission if it is requested by the owner. F. All applications must include three to four 35mm photographs of existing conditions. No certificates can be issued prior to receipt of photographs. G. An application will not be considered complete unless all work items are thoroughly described on scaled drawings and include specifications regarding dimensions, materials, and my other information needed for the Commission to visualize the changes in order to make a determination. Applications for paint colors should include a paint chip or chart. The following items should be included in your drawings as applicable: I. Site plan showing location of improvements; 2. Elevation drawings of the specific improvements; 3. Details/profiles(i.e.moldings,fence caps,cornices,vents,etc.); 4. Materials(Le.wood,brick,eta); 5. Dimensions(i.e.size of trim);and 6. Transformers,heat pump and condenser locations,electrical entries and meters,lamp posts,stove pipes. H. At the hearing,the Commission will discuss the application with the applicant or his representative,hear the abutters and take a vote. Owners having professional consultants such as architects or contractors are urged to have them be present at the hearing. If the application is approved, a Certificate will be mailed to the mailing address provided on the application and copies will be sent to the City Clerk and Building Inspector. Please note that the application can be continued until the next meeting if the Commission deems necessary(i.e.for reasons of incomplete drawings,to perform a site visit,etc.). In any case,the Commission must make a determination within 60 days from the date the application is received,unless the applicant waives that requirement in writing. L A property owner or a contractor cannot receive a building permit unless a Certificate has been issued. Please be sure to obtain appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings(or other necessary permits and approvals)prior to commencing work. 1. The homeowner may opt not to commence the work approved(unless it relates to resolving an outstanding violation). Work commenced must be completed within one year from the Certificate date unless otherwise indicated. K. The City of Salem reserves the right to inspect the project to determine compliance with the conditions set forth in the Certificate issued. Violations A person commencing or completing work to the exterior of a building in an historic district without the necessary approval ofthe Commission is subject to fines of up to$500 per day from the date of violation. The Commission is not responsible for an owner's neglect to inquire about necessary City permits and approvals. All records are public and we will confidentially assist you ifyou are concerned that someone in your neighborhood is in violation. Assistance The Commission's guidelines are available for viewing at the Salem Planning Department and the Salem Public Library. 'the guidelines provide examples of what is historically appropriate(or inappropriate)for Salem's neighborhoods including trim,siding,doors,fences,gutters,masonry,paint colors, parking solutions,porches,roofing,satellite dishes,secondary egress,skyhgbts,utilities,windows,etc. These guidelines help you understand what changes are likely or unlikely to be approved. The Commission supports your efforts to improve your property and can guide you on historical appropriateness. Further information,in the form of books,articles and pamphlets,City-wide architectural inventories,and photographs,are available at the Historical Commissions office at 120 Washington Street. For more information,contact the Clerk of the Commission,Jane Guy,at the Salem Planning Department, 120 Washington Street,Salem,MA 01970,978 745-9595,Ext.311. Ile"•ION 1 I� AI A d�l Yi r t�v 00 G,y�g voP Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)745-9595 EXT. 311 FAX (978) 740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF NON-APPLICABILITY It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving Reconstruction ❑ Alteration O Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other Work as described below does not involve an exterior architectural feature or involves a feature covered by the exemptions or limitations set forth in the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property: 55 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: 55 Warren Street Salem Realty Trust- Marie Allard. trs Description of Work Proposed: Replace two wood(2"floor bedroom) windows in kind- wood, single glaze, true divided light, 6 over 1, non- insulated clear glass. No changes in color, material, design or outward appearance. Non-applicable due to being in kind replacement. Dated: October 13, 2004 SALEM HI�STORICA4COMMISSION By. The homeowner has the option not to commence the work (unless it relates to resolving an outstanding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals) prior to commencing work. n r . ® •s qqRk R� 7101 7 It: room i � lilt 24SEP04 CUS ONE HOUR, PHOTO 4 fill, OiGHd dOOH 3NO S00 POd3SVZ KZ# LOO s t OlOHd df10H 7-10 Sf13 1 OdTPh Hip # BOO .�o RECEIVED OCT 13 2004 �p DEPT.OF PLANNING& COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Salem Historical Commission 120 Washington St. ,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)745-9595 EXT 311 FAX(978)740-04C4 APPLICATION FOR A CERTIFICATE OF NON-APPLICABILITY Pursuant to the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Chapter 40C) and the Salem Historical Commission Ordinance, application is hereby made for issuance of a Certificate of Non-Applicability for: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Sign ❑ Other as described below. District-. '' " Building Construction Date, if known: Address of Property: h (,,Na'' ILQ t Name of Record Owner: c�� VISI IJ v7 (- Description of Work Proposed: r �2.�G�� ti✓rG�4� Q Signature of Owner: Tel. #: " Mailing address: T City: State Zip�i� PROCEDURES FOR FILING APPLICATIONS A. Be prepared to apply for approvals well in advance of commencing any exterior work Before making any changes to the exterior of a property in an historic district,the owner should call or visit the Commission representative at the Salem Planning Department to discuss proposed alterations and to determine the category of the application(Appropriateness,Non-Appl icabiLity or Hardship). B. The Commission normally meets on the fust and thud Wednesdays of each month and notices are posted at City Hall. The meetings aro held at 120 Washington Street,3rd floor,and begin at 7:30 Pro. All meetings are open to the public and any person is entitled to appear and be heard on any matter before the Commission before it reaches a decision. C. An application for a Certificate of Appropriateness or Hardship must be received by 3:00 p.m on the Monday 16 days before the meeting in order to make the agenda An application for a Certificate of Non-Applicability may normally be added to the agenda up to the day of the meeting. In some cases,a Certificate of Non-Applicability may be issued by the Clerk,without review by the full Commission,after reuiving signatures of approval from an officer and a member of the Commission. There is no fee for any applications. D. All applications for Certificates of Appropriateness or Hardship require a public hearing. Notice of the hearing must be posted with the City Clerk 14 days before the hearing and abutters must be notified in writing. Commission staff will handle these procedures. A public hearing is not required for a Certificate of Non-Applicability. E. Applications must in submittal by the uwuu of the property. Iii case of a tenant,a waver of the owaQ's appearan"may be granted at the discretion of the Commission if it is requested by the owner. F. All applications must include three to four 35mm photographs of existing conditions. N3 certificates can be issued prior to receipt of photographs. G. An application will not be considered complete unless All-work items are thoroughly described on scaled drawings and include specifications regarding dimensions, materials, and any other information needed for the Commission to visualize the changes in order to make a determination- Applications for paint colors should include a paint chip or.chart The following items should be included in your drawings as applicable: 1. Site plan showing location of improvements; 2. Elevation drawings of the specific improvements: 3. Details/profiles(i.e.moldings,fence caps,comites,vents,etc.); 4. Materials(i.e.wood,brick,etc.); 5. Dimensions(i.e.size of trim);and 6. Transformers,heat pump and condenser locations,electrical entries and meters,lamp posts,stove pipes. H. At the hearing,the Commission will discuss the application with the applicant or his representative,hear the abutters and take a vote. Owners having professional consultants such as architects or contractors are urged to have them be present at the hearing. If the application is approved, a Certificate will be issued,mailed to the applicant and copies will be sent to the City Cleric and Building Inspector. Please note drat the application can be continued until the next meeting if the Commission deems necessary(i.e.for reasons of incomplete drawings,to perform a site visit,etc.). In any case,the Commission must make a determination within 60 days from the date the application is received,unless the applicant waives that requirement in writing. I. A property owner or a contractor cannot receive a building permit unless a Certificate has been issued or the applicant has a letter Emm the Commission stating that the change involved is not subject to the Commission's jurisdiction. Please be sure to obtain appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings prior to commencing work J. The City of Salem reserves the right to inspect the project to determine compliance with the conditions set forth in the Certificate issued. Violations A person commencing or completing work to the exterior of a building in an historic district without the necessary approval of the Commission is subject to fines of up to$500 per day from the date of violation. The Commission is not responsible for an owner's neglect to inquire about necessary City permits and approvals. All records are public and we will confidentially assist you if you are concerned that someone in your neighborhood is in violation. Accicfnnrr The Commission's guidelines are available for viewing at the Salem Planning Department and the Salem Public Library. The guidelines provide examples of what is historically appropriate(or inappropriate)for Salem's neighborhoods including trim,siding,doors,fences,gutters,masonry,paint colors, parking solutions, porches, roofing, satellite dishes,secondary egress, skylights,utilities, windows,etc. These guidelines help you understand what changes are likely or unlikely to be approved. The Commission supports your efforts to improve your property and can guide you on historical appropriateness. Further information,in the form of books,articles and pamphlets,City-wide architectural inventories,and photographs,are available at the Historical Commission's office at 120 Washington Street. For more information,contact the Clerk of the Commission,Jane Guy,at the Salem Planning Department, 120 Washington Street, Salem,MA 01970,978 745-9595,Ext.311. Rev.9/01