Loading...
HISCOM ANNUAL REPORTS I - - FY07MSCOM � \ ANNUAL REPORTS 1 9Z& 6)0flWWnWea" 0 � Jtate. &me, 00&oyz, ✓Lmac/ w&&02133 RECEIVED APR 1 9 2007 DEPT.OF PLANNING& April 11,2007 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Donald Preston President Habitat for Humanity North Shore 215 Maple Street Lynn,MA 01904 Dear Mr. Preston: The Massachusetts Historical Commission is pleased to recognize historic preservation efforts in Salem by selecting 18 Crombie Street to receive a 2007 Massachusetts Historical Commission Preservation Award. Tania Hartford, Economic Development Program Director for the City of Salem,nominated this project. The Massachusetts Historical Commission sincerely appreciates all efforts to preserve the Commonwealth's valuable historic and cultural assets. This collaboration between Habitat for Humanity and the City of Salem demonstrates a significant commitment to historic preservation that goes well beyond what is normally expected. It is for this outstanding achievement that we have selected the restoration and rehabilitation of 18 Crombie Street for this distinctive honor. On behalf of the Massachusetts Historical Commission, I applaud this outstanding contribution to historic preservation. A ceremony honoring this year's awardees will be held on Thursday evening, May 31, 2007. Details about the early evening ceremony are forthcoming. Once again,congratulations. Sincerely yours, WILLIAM FRANCIS GALVIN Secretary of the Commonwealth Chairman,Massachusetts Historical Commission xc: Tania Hartford, Economic Development Program Director,City of Salem Raul Rodriguez and Roberta Hussey Hannah Diozzi,Chair, Salem Historical Commission SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION ANNUAL REPORT JULY 1, 2006 - JUNE 30, 2007 The Salem Historical Commission is a volunteer board of Salem residents appointed by the Mayor. The Commission's mission is to provide regulatory design review within Salem's four designated local historic districts. The Commission also provides community-wide historic preservation planning assistance by promoting historic preservation awareness and by commenting on projects that may impact historic resources. Certificates Issued During the year July 1,2006 through June 30,2007,the Salem Historical Commission met regularly 21 times and had one site visit during which a quorum was present. In its capacity as Historic District Commission for 4 local districts,the Commission received 151 applications and filed a total of 161 certificates including: - 70 Certificates of Appropriateness; - 2 Certificates of Hardship; - 82 Certificates of Non-Applicability; - 5 Waivers of the Demolition Delay Ordinance; and - 2 Denials: 1 for Certificate of Appropriateness, and 1 for Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance. Certificates issued are provided to the owner of the property, the City Clerk and the Building Inspector and are kept on file in the Department of Planning and Community Development according to address. A list of all Certificates issued can be found in the Certified Local Government Annual Report, which is on file at the Department of Planning and Community Development and the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Minutes of all meetings are also available at the Department of Planning and Community Development and, beginning July 1, 2006, on-line on the City's website www.salem.com. Commission Members The Commission is regularly comprised of seven (7) regular members and two (2) alternate members. Laurie Bellin was appointed to the Commission in July, 2006 after expressing an interest in serving on the Commission. David Hart was appointed to the Commission in July, 2006 after expressing an interest in serving on the Commission. Larry Spang changed from a full member to an alternate. Kathryn Harper changed from an alternate to a full member. As of June 30,2007,current members are Hannah Diozzi(Chair),Jessica Herbert(Vice Chair), Douglas Desrocher,Larry Spang,Kathryn Harper,Laurie Bellin and David Hart. There are two di vacancies; one for a full member and one for an alternate member. Workshops/Seminars Larry Spang obtained Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Certification from the U.S. Green Building Council. Jessica Herbert attended a lecture series at Colonial Williamsburg, including one on woodworking and one on period gardens. David Hart attended the following: • Boston Society of Architects - Preservation Committee Monthly Meetings, 9/06- 6/07 (lectures on variety of topics) • Lecture, Historic New England, "Asher Benjamin, Architectural Designs", 9/28/06 • "Nooks and Crannies" tour of Beauport, Gloucester, MA, Historic New England, 9/27/06 • Portsmouth,NH, 10/7/06 & 10/8/06 tours of: o Rundlett May House o Jackson House o Moffat Ladd House • Visited 2006 restoration of Louis Kahn's museum building at Yale University, February, 2007 • Newton Historical Society, tour of historic houses, May, 2007 Survey & Planning Grant Projects The City of Salem received$15,000 in FY06 Survey and Planning Grant program funding for a reuse study of the U.S. Coast Guard Administration Building on Winter Island(total project cost of$35,000). The grant project was completed during this fiscal year. In May, 2007, the City of Salem received a notice of funding award in the amount of$18,000 from the FY07 Survey and Planning Grant program to conduct a Neighborhood Architectural Conservation District study to begin in FY08. Other Activities The Commission provided letters of support for: • City of Salem application for a Survey and Planning Grant for a Neighborhood Architectural Conservation District study; • City of Salem application for Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund for rehabilitation of the Coast Guard barracks on Winter Island; • Salem Public Library application for Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund for slate roof and copper balustrade repair; and • 2007 Preservation Award from Massachusetts Historical Commission for 18 Crombie Street. The Commission provided comment letters for: • Pedrick Store House project for the Salem Maritime National Historic Site; • Salem Jail redevelopment project; • North Street Reconstruction Extra Work Order; • J. Michael Ruane Judicial Center/Salem Trial Courts; and • Bridge Street Reconstruction - 25% Submission Drawings. This report was completed by Jane A. Guy on behalf of the Department of Planning and Community Development and the Salem Historical Commission. Respectfully submitted, Jane A. Guy Assistant Community Development Director Clerk of the Salem Historical Commission �`�� J n m y m C7 � _ r x � � m � � � � N O � � � z � � � m m � � o � � � N � (� z � � � � o 0 z CERTIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT ANNUAL REPORT CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS JULY 1, 2006 -JUNE 30, 2007 PART A - ENFORCEMENT OF LOCAL LEGISLATION 1. Cases Reviewed 2. Sample Minutes 3. Sample Decision PART B -ADEQUATE AND QUALIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMISSION 1. Resumes 2. Membership 3. Professionals 4. Vacancies/Appointments 5. CLG Training Sessions/Workshops PART C - NATIONAL REGISTER PROGRAM PARTICIPATION 1. CLG Evaluations 2. Nominations 3. Public Hearings 4. Professional Expertise PART D - SURVEY AND INVENTORY OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES 1. Survey Forms 2. Survey Work 3. Inventory Status PART E -PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 1. Commission Meeting Dates 2. Open Meeting Law Compliance Statement 3. Accessibility of Minutes 4. Rules,Procedures, Guidelines PART F - FUNDING OF CLG ACTIVITIES 1. Local Funding 2. Survey and Planning Grant Funding 3. Other Funding PART G - OTHER ACTIVITIES This report was completed by Jane A. Guy,Assistant Community Development Director&Clerk of the Salem Historical Commission,on behalf of the Salem Historical Commission and the Department of €� Planning and Community Development under the administration of Mayor Kimberley Driscoll. Salem Histo��Commission J Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 TYPE OF WORK NEW NON- APPLIC CERT CERT DATE OR CO ADDRESS OWNER NAME ALTER CONST. DEMO. APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED DESCRIPTION Meeting of 7/5106: Bates House Condo — N 262 Lafayette St. Assoc. x Lafay. 6/16/2006 Approp. Approp. 7/6/06 paint colors Meeting of 7119/06 N 78 Derby St. Showatter x Derby 6/7/2006 Approp. iApprop. 7/20/06 Paint,door replacement Carriage N 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. Continued Conversion of carriage house to single family N 14 River St. Madigan x McIntire 6/27/2006 Approp. jApprop. 7/20/06 Window replacement;withdrew 1 window N 377 Essex St. McCarthy x McIntire 6/28/2006 Approp. Approp. 7/20/06 Porch replacement N 142-148 Derby St. Reardon R,T. x Derby 7/5/2006 Approp. Approp. 7/20/06 lAwning ed ContinuPaint colors N 65 Jefferson Ave. Olive R.T. x N/a 7/11/2006 WDDO WDDO 7/20/06 Demolish building N e y as ows i x e y pprop. on inue Addition Site visit 7/22/06 Carriage C 138 WNW Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. Continued Conversion of carriage house to single family C 142-148 Derby St. Reardon R.T. x Derby 7/5/2006 Approp. Approp. 8/7106 *Paint colors-storefront portion continue paint colors-residential portion Meeting of 8/2/06 C 142-148 Derby St. Reardon R.T. x Derby 715/2006 Approp. Approp. 8/7/06 *Paint colors-residential portion(same certificate) N 57 Summer St. Ritchie,Hogan x McIntire 7/17/2006 Approp. Approp. 8/7/06 Paint colors C 92 Derby St. Paskowski x Derby 6/23/2006 Approp. Non-App. 817/06 Addition,roofing Approp. 817106 Change roof color Leach/LaChapelle& Approp.& Demolish lean-to,optional removal of transoms, N 19 1/2&21 Broad St. Zissulis x McIntire 7112/2006 Non-App. Approp. 8/7/06 replacement of stairs with porch/stair N 358-358 112 Essex St. Krueger x McIntire 7/17/2006 Approp. Approp. 817/06 Roof replacement N 15 Williams St. Schutte/Coale x n/a 7/20/2006 WDDO No Action Buiding declared unsafe by B.1. Carriage C 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. Continued Conversion of carriage house to single family Meeting of 8/16/06 N 58 Derby St. LoRredo x Derby 7/21/2006 Approp. Approp. 8/17/06 Paint colors N 2 River St. Luecke,McIntosh x McIntire 7/31/2006 Approp. Approp. 8/17/06 Paint colors Carriage C 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x NIA 6/8/2006 House Ord. Approp. 8/17/06 Remove door,repair roof Continue Conversion of carnage house to single family N 7 Cambridge/9 Chestnut Hamilton Hall,Inc. x McIntire 7/25/2006 Hardship Hardship 8/17/06 Fire sprinkler system connection N Hardship Withdrawn Fire sprinkler test connection Non-applic. 8/17/06 Drain installation N 28 Chestnut I. Hams,Lippman x McIntire 7/28/2006 Approp. Continue I I Aluminum gutters Non-applic. 8/17/06 Gutters&downspouts in kind N 2 Prospect Ave. L'Heureux x n/a 8/3/2006 WDDO Continue Demolition of house N351—a—f yetfe t. a em Lafav6ev. x n a 0 ontinue emo con oc of urrrr --- Meeting of 9/06/06 Page 1 Salem Histon' w)commission Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 TYPE OF WORK NEWNON- APPLIC CERT CERT DATE VORCOIJ ADDRESS OWNER NAME ALTER. CONST. DEMO. APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED I DESCRIPTION N 161 Summer St. _(Dawes/LeoNGlover x McIntire 8/21/2006 Approp. 'Approp. 9/8106 [Paint colors C 28 Chestnut St. -Hams,Lippman x _ McIntire 7/28/2006 Approp_ Continue Aluminum gutters -- �Non-applic 9/8/06 gutters =C±2 Prospect Ave. L'Heureux x n/a 8/3/2006 WDDO �No waiver issued-Letter of support sent to move house -- N 1377 Essex St. McCarthy/Partners x McIntire 8/3/2006 Approp. N _{Ix McIntire 8/15/2006 Approp. Approp. 918/06 Paint colors,porch alterations __I_ ___ Non-applic 9/8/06 Clapboards,French door N LJ —A St. MCCleam x Lafay. 8/4/2006 Approp. Approp. 9/8/06 French doors ---- N Cook _ x_ N/a 8/14/2006 WDDO WDDO 9R/O6 Demolition of garage N ve. RTD Nominee R.T. x N/a 8/24/06q WDDO WDOO 9/6/06 Demolition of budding C aem—Ca Dev. x a 8/8/2006 VVDIDIT ContinueDemotion offormerc u rr Meeting of 9/20/06 L N 30-32 Beckford St. 30-32 Beckford St.R7 X McIntire 9/5/2006 Approp. Approp. 9/26/06 'Painting C 28 Chestnut St. Harris,Lippman x McIntire 7/28/2006 Approp. Continue Aluminum gutters N 39-41 Washington Sq.N _Sucher/Caries x Wash.Sq. 8/25/2006 Approp. Approp. 9/26/06 Downspouts N 86 Essex St. Salem Housing Auth. x Wash.Sq. 8/31/2006 Approp. Approp. 9/26/06 Remove snow fence N 178 Fetleral SL Konstadt x McIntire 9/5/2006 Approp. Approp. 9/26%06 Roofing&fascia -- N inter t. ayet x as q. —975/2006 pprop. prop. —972 umerous a eratwns Meeting of 10/4/06 N 57 Summer St. Ritchie/Hogan x McIntire 9/15/2006 Approp. Approp. 10/10/06 Carriage WA 6/8/2006 — C 138 North/2 Dearborn St. PelletierlOverberg x House Ord. Continue Conversion of carriage house to single family C 126 Winter St. --Chayet x Wash. Sq. 9ffiMDV APP_r0P. Approp. umerous a terahons Meeting of 10/18/06 Carriage C 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. 4fountain, Conversion of carnage house to single family C 28 Chestnut St. Harris,Lippman x McIntire 7/28/2006 Approp. Aluminum gutters C 26 Winter St. Chayet x Wash.Sq. 9/5/2006 Approp. 0/20/06 Fencing,Flagpole,paint --- _ fountain,vents/pipes N 105 Federal St. Hayward x McIntire 929/2005 Approp. /20/06 Paint,fence alterationN 421 Essex SL Balich x McIntire 10/2/2006 Approp. /20/06 Various alterationsN aye a gleam x a ay. prop. e Meeting of 11/1106 N 1135 Derby S I FDana x Derby 10/10/2006 Approp. Approp. 11/3/06 Paint colors ANe Derby SL_ x Derby 10/10/2006 Approp. Approp. 11/3/06 (Paint colors,add band molding&trim detail Carriage North/2 Dearborn St. rg x _N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. Continue Conversion of carnage house to single family Fencing,gatesfountain,vent pipes,alterations to inter St. x _ Wash.Sq. 9/5/2006 Approp. Approp. 11/3/06garage kitchen atldition approval inter St. _ x Wash.Sq. 10/16/2006 Approp. Approp. 11/3/06 Wood skylight continue Veluxskylight -- Essex St. Salem Athenaeum x McIntire 10/172006 Approp. Approp. 11/3/06 Handrail �S?: - aP skowski x --- — e y -o prop. pprop. teratwn o store roma i iddTon— - Meeting of 11/15/06 N 41 Washington Sq. N Pervier etal x Wash.Sq. 10/20/2006Approp. Approp. 11/20/06 Door paint color - Page 2 Salem Histo n Commission 'J Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 TYPE OF WORK NEW NON- APPLIC CERT CERT DATE OR CO ADDRESS OWNER NAME ALTER. CONST. DEMO. APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED DESCRIPTION Carriage C 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Pelletier/Overberg x N/A 6/8/2006 House Ord. Withdrawn Conversion of carriage house to single family C 23 W nter St McCoy_ x Wash.Sq. 10/16/2006 Approp. Withdrawn tVelux skylight N - I x 11/2/2006 N/a N/a 11/20/06 IRoof,shutters,painting_ C 288 Lafayette St. I McCleam x __ Lafay. 10/2/2006 Approp. Approp. 11/20/06 deck N x Lafay. 10/25/2006 Approp. Continue I French doors N 107-Federal St. Mculeam x Mc nbre Wipprop pprop ffP2b/06 Sign Meeting of 12/6/06 N 23 Winter St. McCoy x Wash.Sq. 11/20/2006 Approp. Approp. 12/7/06 I Shutter color C 288 Lafayette Sl. McCleam x Lafay. 10/2/2006 Approp. Continue French doors N 57 Warren St. Braizier x McIntire 11/20/2006 Approp./NA Approp. 12/7/06 Alteration of side porch C 33 La ayf efie St. a em a ay. ev. x n a /S ema /0�Demo i tI"i on o7 ohurc�— - Meeting of 1/17/07 Nf-Peter tam em RWev:Auth. x --n/a 0 WDOCF—--27ZM7—Uernolitiono am Meeting of 2!7/07 N104 Federal I. Cleary/Hart x McIntire 1/3/2007 Approp. Approp. 2/8/07 snowguard,gutters,downspouts N21 Winter St. Maher x Wash.Sq. 1/3/2007 Approp. Approp. 2/8/07 Downspouts,fence removal x Non-App. 2/8/07 windows,fascia,soffits,vent N roa t. eL acHLaChypel� x c nbm ili pprop. Appr0p. VOW 1510CK window Meeting of 2/21/07 N 255,257&259 Lafayette Lafay.Court Condo. x Lafay. 2/5/2007 Approp. Approp. 2/26/07 paint colors N 109 Derby St. Milman x Derby 2/1/2007 Approp. Approp. 2/26/07 paint,windows,vent N 22 Chestnut St. Barrows/Cohen x McIntire 2/5/2007 Approp. jApprop. 2/26/07 Various alterations N ssex t. asig is x c n reApprop. Appr0p. ign,window alteration Meeting of 3/7/07 N 14 River St. Madigan x McIntire 2/19/2007 Approp. Approp. 3/8/07 Replace shingles with clapboards Meeting of 3/21/07 _ N 12-14 Carpenter St. Hansen x McIntire 2/22/2007 Approp. Continue Second egress N 6 Chestnut St. McLean x McIntire 2/28/2007 Approp. Continue Replace window&door with French door N 119Fowlerbi. Bean x McIntire 3/5/2007 Approp. Approp. 3/22/07 New addition Meeting of 4/4/07 C 268 Lafayette St. McCleam x Lafay. 10/2/2006 Approp. Approp. 4/5/07 French doors C 12-14 Carpenter St. Hansen x McIntire 2/22/2007 Approp. Continue Second egress C 6 Chestnut St. McLean x McIntire 2/28/2007 Approp. Approp. 4/5/07 Replace window&door with French door N 34 Chestnut St. Historic Ne Chw England x McIntire 3/14/2007 Approp. Approp. 4/5/07 Sign N 60 Derby St. Atwood x Derby 3/15/2007 Approp. Approp. 4/5/07 Window replacement N 123 Federal St. Maguire x McIntire 3/19/2007 Approp. Approp. 4/5/07 Second egress Meeting of 5/2/07 C 12-14 Carpenter St. Hansen x McIntire 2/22/2007 Approp. Denial 5/3707 JSecond egress N 31 Chestnut St. Wrightson x McIntire 4/17/2007 Approp. Approp. 5/4/07 gutters,fence replacement,removal of arbor&lattice Meeting of 5/16/07 No public heenngs Page 3 Salem Histori, Commission Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 TYPNEW E OF WORK gppLlC CERT CERT DATE OR CON ADDRESS OWNERNAME ALTER. CONST.(DEMO.( APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED DESCRIPTION Meeting of 5/6/07 N61 R Summer St. Colford x McIntire 5/15/2007 Approp_Approp. 6/11/07 (window sills,repainting- 24 epainting 24 Fort Ave(storage tank 8-- - —� — ----- -_---- -- -- N fire wall) Dominion Salem Harbor x n/a 5/21/2007 WDDO WDDO 6/11/07 Demolition of tank and firewall N 10 Summer St. Hilary Realty Trust x McIntire 5/22/2007 Approp. continue Paint colors N 38 Washington Sq.S Sneddon x McIntire 5/10/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/11/07 Window alterations N 140 Derby St. Murphy x Derby 5/14/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/11/07 window replacement,paint colors N/A 6/11/07 Repair rake returns N 254 Lafayette St. Legon x Lafay. 5/21/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/11/07Paint colors n/a 6/11/07}window repair/replacement continue (3rd floor deck railing,rear shed 8 deck N 15 Warren St. Miller/Rieder_ x McIntire 5/21/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/11/07 Clapboard replacement,paint coors,wall/step replacemen Hardship 6/11/07 Handiplank clapboards on rear ell N/A 6/11/07 Repair trim board,skinboard 8 windows Meeting of 6/20107 _ C 10 Summer St. Hilary ReaoTrustx McIntire 5/22/2007 Approp. Approp 6/21/07 Paint colors N 10 Broad St. Friary McIntire 5/9/2007 Approp. Approp 6/21/07 Paint colors 14 River St. Trainor/MMclnfire 6/4/2007 Approp. Approp 6/21107 Paint colors N 3 Lynn St. 6randt/RoMcIntire 6/5/2007 Approp. Approp 6/21/07 (Paint colors C 254 Lafayette St. Legon Lafay. 5/21/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/21/07 install 3 rear decks non-vis;repair/replace clapboards C n/a 6/21/07 window repair/replacement,alter 1st floor rail C continue 3rd floor deck railing N 59 1/2 Summer St. Baron McIntire 5/30/2007 n/a - - replace fence N i 5/30/2007 Approp. approp. 6/21107 replace fence,add gate N 35 Broad St. Viccica/Sides x McIntire 5/29/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/21/07 replace chimney,install chimney cap N 22 Chestnut St. Cohen/Barrows x McIntire 5/31/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/21/07 lAlter roof 8 overhang,install 3 vents N 41 Flint St. Simpson x McIntire 6/4/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/21/07 Install gates N 16 Chestnut St. McLean x McIntire 6/4/2007 jApprop. Approp. 6/21/07 Install transom N 20 Chestnut St. Schooley x McIntire 6/5/2007 Approp. Approp. 6/21/07 Install fencing Non-Meeting t, 242 Lafayette St. LaBonte x Lafay. 7/1012006 Non-App. Non-App. 7110/06 Repainting,roof/railing on porch N 14 Beckford St. Griffin x McIntire 7/13/2006 Non-App. (Non-App. 7/17/06 Roof color N 260 Lafayette St. Greystone Manor x Lafay. 6/9/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 7117/06 Repairs N 8 Hamilton St. _IFrothingham I x McIntire 7/24/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 7/25/06 Roofing,flashing 8 copper edge 2NN 30 Broad St. BeneventolDougwillo x McIntire 7/26/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 7/26/06 Gutter replacement - -- 28 Chestnut st. Harris/Lippman x McIntire 712812006 Non-App. Non-App. 8/1/06 Roof replacement N395 Essex SL lAuaette 1-am.LT x McIntire 8/7/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8!7/06 Repainting N 78 Derby St. I Showalter x Derby 8/16/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8116/06 Reroof Page 4 Salem Historca(Commission Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 TYPE OF WORK NEW I NOW APPLIC CERT CERT DATE OR CON ADDRESS OWNER NAME ALTER.I CONST. DEMO. APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED DESCRIPTION N 125 rby St. Bruce x 1 8/21/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8/21/06 N 391 Es ex St. Sas o _ x _Mcln iYe 8/ 21/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8/21/06 epaiplacement nting N 74 Derby St./5 Beckett PI. Haven/Stutz x Derby 1 8/29/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8/29/06 Reshingle roof N 21 Flint St. Dufour _ x McIntire 8/24/2006 Non-App. Non-App. B/29/O6 Roof&Bashing replacement Various repairs,alteration of roofing,install a/c N 26 Winter St. Chayet x x Wash.Sq. 9/29/2006 Non-App. Nan-App. 8/31/06 units/generator,alter basement entrance N 100 Federal St.U3 DiPesa x McIntire 8/31/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 8/31/06 Replace skylights&repair roof N 30-32 Beckford St. Frank-Offen x McIntire 8/30/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 9/1/06Repair masonry,repaint N 55 Summer St. Mount x McIntire 9/1/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 9/5/06 Repainting N 2 Botts Court Usovicz x McIntire 823/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 9/5/06 Repainting N 110 Derby St. Fox x Derby 9/26/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 9/26/06 Replace clapboards,repaint N 15 Beckford St. Copelas x McIntire 10/3/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 10/3/06 Repainting N 17 Beckford St. Copelas x McIntire 1013/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 10/3/06 Repainting N 4 Pickering St. Smith x McIntire 10/4/2006 Approp. Approp. 10/4/06 Roof replacement N 122 Federal St. Twohey x McIntire 10/4/2006 Non-App. 'Non-App. 10/4/06 Clapboard/trim replacement,repainting N 103 Federal St. Pitman x McIntire 10/4/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 10/4/06 Roof replacement N 12 River St. Nugent x McIntire 10/1112006 Non-App. Non-App. 10/11/06 Roofing N 328 Essex St. Loring-Emmerton C/A x McIntire 10/25/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/1/06 Chimney/valleytvent/slate repairs N 385 Essex St. Grace Church x McIntire 11/2/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/2/06 Roof replacement N 5 Flint St. Pierce x McIntire 11/62006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/6/06 Sill repair N 3 River St. Von Bruns x McIntire 11/62006 Non-App. Nan-App. 11/6/06 Repairs,repaint N 19 North St. Poppe x McIntire 11/14/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/14/06 window&siding replacement,repainting N 74 Washington Sq.E Shen/renBroeck/Altaf x Wash.Sq. 11/15/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/15/06 Reconstruct widows walk balustrade,repair roof — N 386 Essex St. 386 Essex SL RT x Mclnfire 11/30/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/30/06 Repairs N 107 Federal St. McCleam x McIntire 1025/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 11/1/06 replace skirt boards N 31 Wash.Sq. Doering x Wash.Sq. 11/30/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 12/5/06 Roof replacement N 107 Federal St. Micciche/McCleam x McIntire 12/6/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 12/6/06 Replacement of glass panes N 30-32 Beckford St. Frank-Offen x x McIntire 1217/2006 Non-App. Non-App. 1217106 Alter headers/sills,repair sills-1fascia N 300 Lafayette St. Goggin x Lafay. 1/32007 Non-App. Non-App. 1/4/07 gutters,trim repair/replace N 10 Hamilton St. Paul/Kelly x McIntire 1/11/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 1/11107 gutters,porch steps,shutters N 31 Wash.Sq. Doering x Wash.Sq. 1/22/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 1/22/07 columns N 396 Essex St.#2 Brown x McIntire 2/1/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 2/2/07 Di—re-j TV dish N 109 Derby St. _ Milman x Derby 2/1/2007 Nan-App. Non-App. 2/7/07 shingles,flashing N 86 Essex St. Salem Housing Au_th. x Wash.Sq. 2/122007 Non-App. Non-App. 2/14/07 awnings N 76 Federal St. Gregory Gordan x McIntire 3/5/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 3/5/07 satelite dish _ N 9 Chestnut St. Hamilton Hall x McIntire 3/6/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 3/6/07 repair gate N 29 Chestnut St. McGrane x McIntire 3/12/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 3/14/07 Slate roof,roof ridge,gutters,downspouts N 80 Federal St. _ Peabody Essex Museum x McIntire 4/5/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 4/5/07 Repairs to trim,shutters,windows;repainting N 398 Essex St. Casiglia x McIntire 4/9/2007 Non-App. 'Nan-App. 4/9/07 Clapboard repair/replacement N 31 Chestnut St. Wrightson x McIntire 4/16/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 4/19/07 Gutters,roofing N 4 Federal Court Digris/Washburn x McIntire 4/24/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 4/24/07 Repainting_ N 30 Broad St. Benevento/Dougwillo X McIntire 5/1/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/1/07 Roof replacement N 40 Warren St. Copelas x McIntire 5/12007 Approp. Approp. 52/07 Replace asphalt shingles N 41 Chestnut St. Jagolta x McIntire 5!7/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/7/07 Front porch Page 5 fes, lv Salem Historic Commission Applications Reviewed 7/1/06-6/30/07 �- FNIE1OFWORK NON-I APPLIC ' CERT CERT DATE OR COJ ADDRESS OWNER NAME ALTER. CONST. DEMO.I APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED DESCRIPTION N 100 Derby St. Shea _� _ _ x McIntire 5/8/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/8/07 Clapboard&windo repair N 169 Federal St. Charette x McIntire 5/9/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/9/07 Roof replacement _ __ —I ._ N 60 Derby St. Atwood z Derby 5/9/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/9/07 1Clapboards,sills&flashing replacement N 28 Beckford St. Stauffer x I McIntire 5/9/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 519/07 Trim roofing,repainting N 159 Derby St. Nathan x Derby 5110/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/10107 Roof replacement N 167 Federal St. Gordan z McIntire 5/17/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/17/07 Downspout replacement N 24 Chestnut St. Storella x McIntire 5/17/1987 Non-App. Non-App. 5/17187 Roof replacement N 145 Federal St. Kleiderman x McIntire 5/21/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/21/07 Roof&skylight replacement N 337 Essex St. Salem Athenaeum x McIntire 5/21/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/21/07 Downspout replacement N 97 Derby St. Jordan x Derby 5/21/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/22/07 Repair/replace back porch N 34 Chestnut St. Historic NE x McIntire 5/21/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/22/07 fence repair,repainting N 12 Broad St. Austin x McIntire 5/29/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/29107_chimney repair N 131 Derby St. Halter x Derby 5/30/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/31/07 Siding replacement N 25 Chestnut St. Appel/Collins x McIntire 6/4/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/4/07 Molding,fascia,soffit,fence repair/replace. N 3 Federal Ct. Olson x McIntire 6/7/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 617/07 Repainting N 1 Cambridge St. Schopf x McIntire 6/8/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/8/07 Repainting N 89 Federal St. Dwyer x McIntire 5/22/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 5/22/07 Repainting N 72 Wash.Sq.E Sachetti x Wash.Sq. 611112007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/11/07 Repainting N 98 Flint St. 3 corners realty trust x n/a 6/18/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/19/07 Roof replacement,cemerboard repair _ N 83-85 Derby St. Savickey x Derby 6/26/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/26/07 Replace Gaphoartls,tnm&repaint N 8 Lynn St. Murtagh x McIntire 6/27/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 6/27/07 Repainting N 144-145 Federal St. LaRoche/Ouellette x McIntire 1 7/2/2007 Non-App. Non-App. 1 7/2/07 1Fence&gate Page 6. July 5, 2006, Page 1 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION ( � MINUTES July 5, 2006 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on July 5,2006 at 7:30 p.m.at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Ms. Diozzi, Ms. Herbert, Mr. Desrocher and Ms. Harper and Ms. Guy. 262 Lafayette Street The Bates House Condo Association submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors. The body will be Louisburg Green, the trim will be Impressive Ivory and the door will be Boston Brick. Present were trustees James Waldinger and Susan Mulak. Ms. Harper asked if trim will include casings, soffits, columns and baluster railings. Mr. Waldinger replied in the affirmative. Mr. Desrocher made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Ms. Herbert seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Guy requested an amendment to the approved June 7, 2006 minutes, under Other Business, second paragraph to read: ( } For 10 Gifford Court,Ms. Guy stated that since there seems to be a solution for secondary egress and the Commission will be asked to issue a Certificate ofNon-applicability. Ms. Herbert will provide a drawing of the proposed solution. In addition,the owners will be asked to provide a request that the Commission rescind its Certificate of Hardship. In this way, there will be no basisfor the complaint and it will be withdrawn. Ms. Herbert made a motion to amend the minutes as requested. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. There being no further business,Mr. Desrocher made a motion to adjourn. Ms.Herbert seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submitted, JaneG Cien July 19, 2006, Page 1 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION 1 MINUTES July 19, 2006 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on July 19,2006 at 7:30 p.m.at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Ms. Diozzi, Ms. Herbert, Mr. Desrocher, Mr. Spang and Ms. Harper and Ms. Guy. 78 Derby Street John and Janel Showalter presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors and door replacement. The Body will be China Aster. The trim will be Linger/Wild Oats and the doors will be Delieata/India Trade. Ms. Showalter stated that they will use India Trade and Linger. Ms. Herbert asked if the finish will be flat or eggshell. Ms. Showalter stated that it would be flat. Ms.Herbert made a motion to approve the colors as presented in flat finish. Mr.Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms' Showalter stated that their door is damaged. They propose to go from the lights of glass on top to 2 lights with bullseye glass. A catalog cut of Bullion door was provided. Mr.Desrocher made a motion to approve the colors as presented in flat finish. Ms.Herbert seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 138 North/2 Dearborn St. Thomas Pelletier, Cynthia Pelletier and Kellie Overberg submitted an application for exterior alterations to a carriage house including replacement of windows, changing 3 doors to windows, installation of new door and installation of a/c vents and pipes through the Carriage House Ordinance. Ms. Herbert asked if the main house is a condominium. Mr. Pelletier stated that they are rental, but the plan is convert the main house and the carriage house to condos. Ms. Herbert asked if the siding on the carriage house is original. Mr. Pelletier stated that it is the original flat board. He stated that it is a post and beam structure with no foundation. It is currently on pilings and they propose to lift the structure and dig a full basement. It will house one unit,which has already been approved by the Board of Appeal. He added that he hopes to remove the vinyl siding of the main house. He stated that they are proposing Anderson windows, for which the window sizes are standard. They would be wood,vinyl-clad with permanent grills inside and out,with a spacer. He noted that the Anderson windows have a closer mullions size to what is currently on the house than Pella Windows. They will keep the casings and just replace the sash. He asked for guidance on appropriate doors. Ms. Harper asked if the existing windows were salvageable. Mr. Pelletier stated that the bottom windows may be, but the top need to be casement windows in order to get legal egress. July 19 2006 Pae 2 , S Ms. Herbert asked if they could install skylights for egress instead of altering the original windows. Mr.Pelletier stated that they would not work for legal egress. Ms. Herbert suggested a moveable interior stair to access the skylights to create a legal egress as has been done previously. Mr. Spang asked if code will allow them to keep the two small windows since they will be on the property line. Mr. Pelletier stated that he did not know. Ms. Harper suggested restoring the windows on the first floor and allowing casement on the second floor. Mr. Pelletier stated that he would have to install storms on the first floor to make the windows air tight. He noted that the building is 30' off the street and that you would not be able to tell the type of material. Mr. Pelletier stated that it appears the existing door opening may have had a transom. Ms. Herbert stated that she would like a site visit and to see a sample of the proposed Anderson window. Mr. Spang stated that the Commission has been grappling with finding an energy efficient, yet appropriate, window. He stated that he was willing to let the owners start digging the foundation. He stated that the applicant should consider window repair. He added that he commended the owners for the level of effort they are going through to preserve the building. Helen Sides, Broad Street, stated that Boston Sash of Chelsea makes a true divided light window which can be seen at Grand Banks in Gloucester. She also suggested energy panels. Ms. Herbert made a motion to continue the application to the next meeting,pending a site visit on Saturday,July 22nd at 8:00 a.m. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 14 River Street Stephanie Trainor Madigan and Daniel Madigan presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for replacement of windows that are mostly 2 over 1 with Brosco authentic divided light 6 over 6 windows with optional historic sill nosing/connector and insect screen with flat casing and option for Low E energy panel. One first floor window may not be authentic divided light due to irregular size. Ms. Diozzi read a letter in support from April Kabbash and Chris Harwell, 15 River Street. Mr.Madigan stated that the two basement windows have already been replaced and that they eventually will apply to replace shingles with clapboard. They would like to use exterior a-panels and remove the storms. He added that the jalousie window would be changed to a vinyl clad,double glaze window,but he was willing to come back for approval of that change. Ms. Sides asked if the windows will remain the same size as existing. Mr. Madigan replied in the affirmative. Mr. Spang asked if they considered moving the jalousie window around the corner. Mr. Madigan replied that it would probably not look right. Ms. Herbert stated that she felt that the window replacing the jalousie should at least be in line with the door. Mr. Spang stated that the energy panel should be clear glass, not low e. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the window replacement with 6 over 6 true divided light, single glaze, July 19, 2006, Page 3 wood windows with clear glass,with the thicker sills,with the option of a clear glass energy panel. The motion does not include replacement of the jalousie window. Mr. Spang seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 377 Essex Street Maureen McCarthy presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to demolish the existing porch and construct a new porch. Present was Ms. McCarthy's husband, Frank Simmons, and architect Helen Sides who provided drawings of the proposed new porch and examples of similar porches in the district. Ms. Sides noted that portions of the porch are visible, but that there is no straight view. Ms.Guy noted that the Commission has approved similar railings as is proposed for the first floor of the porch in order to meet building code height. Mr. Spang stated that he preferred only one horizontal rail on the top with longer balusters. Mr. Spang made a motion to approve the application as submitted,but with the second floor porch railing design to be similar to the first floor railing,but with longer verticals. Ms.Herbert seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 142-148 Derby Street Reardon Realty Trust submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors and an application for a Certificate of Non-Applicability for the installation of an awning. Paint colors will include Fez, JDiva,Tempura and Grand Canyon. The awning has already been installed and painting has begun. Present were Jennifer Reardon and Brian Casey. Mr. Casey provided a sketch of the color scheme and summarized the history of the colors previously on the building. He stated that his scheme is to bring the colors of the more Victorian era and point out the Italianate features on the main building. Ms. Herbert stated that Fez looks very fluorescent orange. Mr. Casey stated that they have not finished all the coats, but noted that it is brighter in the sunshine. Ms. Diozzi stated that Tempura doesn't look the same on the building as on the chip. Mr. Casey stated that he check the chip to the color painted and that it is a match. Mr. Spang stated that he drove by and felt it looks very bright and modem. Ms. Reardon stated that the front only has one coat, not the proposed three coats. Ms. Herbert stated that she felt the modern window trim of the storefronts should be darker. Ms. Reardon stated that there will be window boxes in front. Mr. Casey stated that they are natural mahogany. Ms. Herbert stated that she felt the body color should be toned down to blend more with the awning and felt that the awning looked fine. July 19, 2006, Page 4 Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the awnings as installed. Mr. Spang seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Reardon stated that they are using a higher quality paint, so it won't fade as soon as the last painting, but noted that with the amount of sun and the location near the water, it will still fade. Ms. Diozzi stated that instead of Diva, she suggested County Redwood. Mr. Spang stated that he liked the strategy of separating the house portion from the commercial portion,but was not sure that Diva accomplished it. Ms. Herbert suggested that instead of Diva,using Georgian Brick and instead of Grand Canyon, usng Audobon Russet. Ms. Reardon suggested a site visit. Ms. Herbert made a motion to continue the application to a site visit on Saturday, July 22nd and then to the meeting of August 2"d. Mr. Spang seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 65 Jefferson Avenue The Olive Realty Trust submitted an application to waive the Demolition Delay Ordinance to demolish 65 Jefferson Avenue. Owner Robert Dunham and architect Dennis Gray were present. Mr. Dunham stated that the building is on wood piles. He hopes to develop the property in 1-2 years. Ms. Guy noted that there is no survey form on file,but that the Assessor's records show the date of construction as 1890. Ms. Herbert asked when the building was purchased. Mr. Dunham stated that he purchased it 3 to 4 weeks ago and that it is a liability. The sprinkler is partially taken apart and there are people and animals entering the building. Mr. Spang asked the zoning. Mr. Dunham replied that it is industrially zoned. Mr. Desrocher asked if there are any architectural details on the interior. Mr. Gray stated that it is mill type framing and that they could sell the salvage. Ms. Herbert suggested demolishing the newer sections and securing the rest. Mr. Gray stated the older sections are the most deteriorated and that the wood piles are rottd. Ms. Harper made a motion to waive the Demolition Delay Ordianance. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 92 Derby Street t.� John Paskowski submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the construction of an addition at 92 Derby Street. July 19, 2006, Page 5 Michael Lutrzykowski,architect representing the applicant, requested a continuance. Ms.Herbert made a motion to continue the application to the next meeting. Mr.Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the minutes of June 21, 2006 with the following change: • Page 2, Paragraph 3, Sentence 1 - Add"of the foundation"to the end of the sentence. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Harper made a motion to approve the minutes of July 5,2006 with the amendment that Mr. Desrocher made the motion to adjourn, rather than Mr. Spang. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. There being no further business,Mr.Desrocher made a motion to adjourn. Ms.Herbert seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfu y tted, Jane . Guy Clerk f the Commission August 2, 2006, Page I SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES August 2, 2006 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on August 2, 2006 at 7:30 p.m. at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Ms. Diozzi, Ms. Herbert, Mr. Desrocher, and Ms. Bellin and Ms. Guy. Ms. Diozzi welcomed new member Laurie Bellin and stated that there was only a bare quorum of four members, which would require all four votes in favor to pass any motion. She stated that applicants could request a continuance. 142-148 Derby Street In continuation of a previous meeting, Reardon Realty Trust submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors. Present were Jennifer Reardon and Brian Casey. Mr. Casey stated that they would withdraw the color Diva and replace it with Mexicana. He provided a new concept plan showing the placement of the colors. Ms. Herbert asked the proposed color for the doors. Mr. Casey stated that all doors would be Spanish Tile. Ms. Herbert asked the color for the side of the house. Mr. Casey stated that all shingles will be Grand Canyon. Mr. Herbert stated that she thought the changes worked well. Ms.Herbert made a motion to approve paint colors for the residential portion of the building to be Grand Canyon for the 2nd and 3rd floor shingles, Mexicana for the cornerboards and eaves and Spanish Tile for all doors on the first floor level. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 57 Summer Street Judith Ritchie and Elaine Hogan presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors. The application states that the body will be Gentle Tide,the shutters will be Mountain Laurel and the trim will be Navajo White. Ms. Ritchie stated that they would like to change the body color initial proposed to Mystic Green,the shutters to Olympic Pine and the trim to Glacier White. Ms. Diozzi asked why they did not like the Navajo White. Ms. Ritchie replied that is seems a little too yellow. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the paint colors as amended. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 92 Derby Street In continuation of a previous meeting, John Paskowski submitted an application for a Certificate of '. Appropriateness for the construction of an addition at 92 Derby Street. Also present was Michael Lutrzykowski, architect. A petition in favor of the proposal was signed by residents of 3 White Street and 26 Becket St. Mr.Lutrzykowski stated that the Board of Appeal has approved the Yd floor extension which will be 13'6"by 33' August 2, 2006, Page 2 6". It is not visible from the street, but they will still be using Brosco windows, matching the paint colors and rebuilding porches with 3"on center spacing. l Ms. Herbert stated that she went by the site and it is not visible. Mr. Paskowski stated that he also wants to reroof the main house. Ms. Herbert asked if the roof will remain the same, including color. Mr. Paskowski replied in the affirmative, noting that he read in the Boston Globe,that to keep cool, roofing should be light. Ms. Herbert stated that she strongly encouraged black or charcoal gray. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve a Certificate of Non-applicability for the construction of the addition as being non-visible from the public way. Mr.Desrocher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve a Certificate of Non-applicability to reroof in the existing green color. Ms. Bellin seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness to reroof in black or charcoal gray,3 tab asphalt. Ms. Bellin seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 19 % and 21 Broad Street David Leach,Laurie LaChapelle and Judith Zissulis submitted an application fora Certificate of Appropriateness > to remove a lean-to from the rear and, depending on the condition of the windows and surrounding woodwork, the removal of two windows above. An application for Non-applicability was also submitted for removal of non- visible concrete/brick stairs and replacement with double wide back porch and stair similar to unit 21 %s. Drawings were provided. Ms. Herbert asked if there was a transom at 21 %over the door previously, noting that it appears there was once one there that has since been removed. Mr. Leach stated that he did not know. Ms. Herbert asked if they want to keep the transom. Mr. Leach stated that the door is separate from the transom and, if rotted,they will remove. Ms. Herbert asked about the door. Mr. Leach stated that it will remain. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve a Certificate of Appropriateness for the demolition of the existing lean-to, to replace molding in kind as needed,to retain the existing door and with the option to remove both transoms if needed with either both to remain or both to be removed. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Herbert encouraged the installation of a storm panel at 21 to match the storm panel at 19 %. Ms. Herbert stated that she felt what is being constructed will be seen when the lean-to is removed. Mr. Desrocher asked if the proposed porch will be basically the same as 21 '/z except double wide. Mr. Zissulis stated that it is essentially the same, but the steps will come straight out instead of to the side. Mr. Leach stated that it will be 12' wide, no less than 3' deep, but not more than 4' dep. August 2, 2006,Page 3 Mr. Desrocher made a motion to approve the replacement of the concrete/brick stairs with a wood porch and stair per drawing submitted, painted to match the house trim. Ms. Bellin seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 358-358 % Essex Street Thomas and Elaine Krueger presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to repair/replace the entire roof. The metal roof will be shingles. Mr. Krueger stated that the contractor has suggested architectural shingles due to durability. Ms. Herbert stated that the Commission typically approves 3-tab in black or charcoal gray. Ms.Herbert made a motion to approve roof replacement with black or charcoal gray,3-tab roofing with the option to put in a ridge vent and the option to repair/replace skylights in kind. The motion is also to repair/replace rubber roof as needed. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Krueger noted the SPNEA came out in 1983 and their analysis showed that in 1728,the front was barn red and the sides were natural. 15 Williams Street Leo Schutte and Lucia Coale submitted an application for a Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance for the removal of a barn. Ms. Guy noted that since the application was submitted, the barn has been declared unsafe by the building inspector and ordered removed. Ms. Herbert noted that the barn has been demolished. 138 North/2 Dearborn St. In continuation of a previous meeting, Thomas Pelletier, Cynthia Pelletier and Kellie Overberg submitted an application for exterior alterations to a carriage house including replacement of windows,changing 3 doors to windows, installation of new door and installation of a/c vents and pipes through the Carriage House Ordinance. The applicants were not present. Ms. Herbert stated that at the site visit the owner stated that he would prepare new drawings. Ms. Herbert made a motion to continue the application. Ms.Bellin seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Guy stated that she received a request from Sheri Rozenzweig to extend her certificates for window replacement for two years. Mr. Desrocher made a motion to approve the request. Ms. Bellin seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Guy stated that she received notice that the House of Seven Gables is being studied by the National Park Service for potential designation as a National Historic Landmark. August 2, 2006, Page 4 There being no further business,Mr.Desrocher made a motion to adjourn. Ms.Herbert seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. l - Respectfully submi ed Jane A. G Clerk oft a Commis n IF \� 1 Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978) 745-9595 EXT 311 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ ReconstructionAlteration ❑ Demolition Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act(M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property' 19 '/ and 21 Brand Street Name of Record Owner: David Leach&Laurie LaChayelle: Judith Zissulis Description of Work Proposed: Demolition of existing lean-to. Replace molding in kind as needed. Retain existing door. Option to remove both transoms if needed(either both remain or both be removed). Encourage installation of storm panel at 21 to match storm panel at 19 %2. Replace concretelbrick stairs with wood porch and stair per drawing submitted,painted to match house trim. Dated: August 7. 2006 SALEM HISTORICAL COOM�MISSION By: 1�� le homeowner has the option not to commence the work(unless it relates to resolving an outstanding ``--violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings(or any other necessary permits or approvals)prior to commencing work. 1 Adequate and Qualified Local Government Commission PART B.1 There are no updated resumes of existing members. PART B.2 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MEMBERSHIP As of 6/30/07, there are five (6) Commission members and one (1) alternate member. PART B.3 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION PROFESSIONALS Professionals in Name Related Preservation Field Hannah Diozzi, Chair Proprietor of architectural and historical walking tour company Douglas Desrocher Realtor Larry Spang, alternate Architect Jessica Herbert X-Developer of historic buildings, Realtor Kathryn Harper - Carpenter (licensed construction supervisor) Laurie Weisman (Bellin) -Attorney David Hart -Architect PART BA VACANCIES/APPOINTMENTS • Laurie Bellin was appointed to the Commission in July,2006 after expressing an interest in serving on the Commission. • David Hart was appointed to the Commission in July,2006 after expressing an interest in serving on the Commission. As of June 30, 2007, there are one full member and one alternate member vacancies. PART B.5 CLG TRAINING SESSIONS/WORKSHOPS Larry Spang obtained Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Certification from the U.S. Green Building Council. David Hart attended the following: • Boston Society of Architects - Preservation Committee Monthly Meetings, 9/06-6/07 (lectures on variety of topics) • Lecture, Historic New England, "Asher Benjamin,Architectural Designs", 9/28/06 • "Nooks and Crannies" tour of BeaupoM Gloucester, MA, Historic New England, 9/27/06 (J 0 Portsmouth, NH, 10/7/06 & 10/8/06 tours of: —\ o Rundlett May House o Jackson House o Moffat Ladd House • Visited 2006 restoration of Louis Kahn's museum building at Yale University, February, 2007 • Newton Historical Society, tout of historic houses, May, 2007 LAURIE ELLEN WEISMAN 396 Essex Street Salem,MA 01970 (978)745-1699 Admitted to Practice Law in Massachusetts and Rhode Island EDUCATION SUFFOLK UNIVERSITY LAw SCHOOL,Boston,MA J.D. Cum Laude,June 1990. Class Rank: 53/318 Managing Editor,Suffolk University Law Review, 1989-90 Staff Member,Suffolk University Law Review, 1988-89(three articles publishe Winner, 1988 McLaughlin Appellate Advocacy Competition Dean's List 1987-88, 1989-90 UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS,Amherst,MA B.A. Magna Cum Laude,Communications Studies,September 1983 Thesis: "For No One,"an original screenplay University and Departmental Honors,Commonwealth Scholar,Dean's List Full tuition paid by Massachusetts State Honor Scholarship Exchange Program 1981-82: University of Kent,Canterbury,England EXPERIENCE October 1995 STATE ETHICS COMMISSION,Boston,MA /\ to present Senior Staff Counsel. Direct the investigation and prosecution of alleged conflict of J interest violations. Interview subjects and witnesses under oath. Compile and asses evidence. Draft complex legal and factual memoranda. Present cases to and argue b the Ethics Commission. Conduct all aspects of adjudicatory proceedings. July 2003 ESSEX COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE,Lynn,MA to August 2003 Special Assistant District Attorney. Spent two months with Lynn DA's office prosecuting cases. Conducted trials,bail hearings and evidentiary motion hear: September 1992 FERRITER,SCOBBO,CARUSO& RODOPHELE,P.C.,Boston,MA to October 1995 Associate. Participated in all phases of civil and criminal litigation. Researched con legal issues. Drafted motions,memoranda,pleadings and appellate briefs. Argued motions in court and before administrative tribunals. September 1991 HONORABLE RONALD R. LAGUEUX to August 1992 Chief Judge,United States District Court,District of Rhode Island Judicial Law Clerk. September 1990 HONORABLE FLORENCE K. MURRAY to August 1991 Associate Justice,Rhode Island Supreme Court Judicial Law Clerk. September 1983 BBN COMMUNICATIONS CORPORATION,Cambridge,MA to August 1987 Technical Writer/Editor. Wrote,edited and produced technical manuals. ASSOCIATIONS: 1998-2001,Mass. Bar Assn: Public Law Section Council member;Section Review `I editor � J A (Note: For a more comprehensive CV and project lists, refer to http://www.dmharchitects.com) DAVID M. HART. AIA - Principal,Architect 104 Federal Street Salem, MA 01970- 9787452172 1970- 9787452172 Education: Architectural Certificate, Boston Architectural Center, 1974 B.A., University of Connecticut, 1960 Former Adjunct Professor, Boston University Former Instructor, Boston Architectural Center Former Instructor, University of Vermont Professional Experience: Mr. Hart is a nationally recognized architect who established his own practice in 1977 and has been on the forefront of historic preservation and building conservation technology. He served as the first Director of Consulting Services for the Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities, and supervised the development of appropriate procedures for testing, repairing and conserving materials of historic structures. He is recognized for his work with large historic churches and institutional buildings, particularly their sensitive development and adaptive use to contemporary standards. He is also recognized for historic planning work on large-scale, multiple building projects. Current and past projects which he has been involved with include: - Project Conservator, Central Artery/Third Harbor Tunnel, Boston, MA (1990 APA Outstanding Project Award, New England Chapter) - Pennsylvania Avenue National Historic Site, Washington, DC (1988 Presidential Award) - Fort Trumbull State Park,New London, CT Restoration of 1849 Fort, Batteries and Historic Buildings - Preservation Society of Newport County,Newport,RI Administrator of Facilities Management Plan using specially designed Software file format. x - Groton Town Hall, Groton, MA Exterior restoration and interior renovation. - Parkman Bandstand, Boston Common, Boston, MA. (1998 William Smith Award, Mass. Architectural Access Board) (1998 Preservation Award, Boston Preservation Alliance) - Pollard Library, Lowell,MA. (1995 Preservation Award, Lowell Historic Preservation Commission) 1 . - South Church, Andover,MA. Steeple Repair and Restoration. (1995 Preservation Award Massachusetts Historical Commission) Restoration of Historic Revere Beach Pavilions & Bandstand (1991 Preservation Award, Massachusetts Historical Commission) l Y J r ,r i Prior to establishing a partnership in 1985 with Paul J. McGinley, he conducted his own practice as David McLaren Hart&Associates. He is currently in private practice as Principal, David M. Hart Enterprises, 2003 to present rofessional Affiliations: ommonwealth of Massachusetts Registered Architect#4317 tate of Connecticut, Registered Architect #ARI.7978 erican Institute of Architects #30029516 CARB Certified (National Council of Architectural Registration Boards alem, MA Planning Board, Past Member oston Society of Architects member Historic Resources Committee ational Trust for Historic Preservation ociety of Architectural Historians ssociation for Preservation Technology, Past Secret /Treasurer ociety for the Preservation of New England Antiquities reservation Society of Newport County (Rhode Island), member, Properties Committee eneral Services Administration (GSA) National Register of Peer Professionals Program WGaiaxy x 1 National Register Program Participation PART C.1 CLG EVALUATIONS COMPLETED There were no evaluations completed. PART C.2 NOMINATIONS There were no nominations prepared and submitted to Massachusetts Historical Commission. PART C.3 PUBLIC HEARINGS There were no public hearings regarding nominations held during the fiscal year. PART CA PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE No professional expertise was hired during this fiscal year regarding nominations. L� Survey and Inventory of Historic Properties PART D.1 D.2 D.3 There were no survey forms produced or updated this year by the City of Salem. There is no change in the status of the inventory m terms of its organization, storage, accessibility, etc. They are accessible for public view at the Department of Planning& Community Development located at 120 Washington Street. a Public Participation PART E.1 COMMISSION MEETING DATES: July 5, 2006 July 19, 2006 July 22, 2006 - Site visit August 2, 2006 August 16, 2006 September 6, 2006 September 20, 2006 October 4, 2006 October 18, 2006 November 1, 2006 November 15,2006 December 6, 2006 January 17, 2007 February 7, 2007 February 21, 2007 March 7, 2007 March 21,2007 April 4, 2007 May 2, 2007 May 16, 2007 June 6, 2007 June 20, 2007 PART E.3 ACCESSIBILITY OF MINUTES There has been no change in the accessibility of Commission minutes. They are accessible for public view at the Department of Planning&Community Development (located at 120 Washington Street). PART EA RULES,PROCEDURES, GUIDELINES There were no changes in rules, procedures or guidelines adopted by the Commission. \, OPEN MEETING LAW COMPLIANCE STATEMENT 1. All meetings of the CLGC have been open to the public. 2. A notice of the date, time and place of every meeting of the CLGC has been filed with the Clerk of the city or town in which the CLGC acts and a copy of such notice has been posted in the office of the Clerk on the principal bulletin board of each city or town at least 48 hours prior to the time of each meeting, excluding Sundays and legal holidays. 3. A record of every meeting, including executive sessions has been maintained by the CLGC, including the date,time, place, members present and actions taken at each meeting. 4. All executive sessions, if any, have been held in compliance with M.G.L. C. 39, Section 23B. 5. No chance meeting or social meeting has been used to circumvent the spirit or requirements of the Open Meeting Law or to discuss or act upon a matter over which the CLGC has supervision, control,jurisdiction, or advisory power. '7�L"'k s Date Chairperson,CLGC Funding of CLG Activities PART F.1 LOCAL FUNDING The annual local funding budget appropriation under the authority of the Salem Historical Commission was $6,710 for personnel services and $1,609 for non-personnel expenses. PART F.2 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT FUNDING The City of Salem received$15,000 in FY06 Survey and Planning Grant program funding for a reuse study of the U.S. Coast Guard Administration Building on Winter Island(total project cost of$35,000). The grant project is was completed during this fiscal year. In May, 2007, the City of Salem received a $18,000 funding award notice from the FY07 Survey and Planning Grant program to conduct a Neighborhood Architectural Conservation District study to begin in FY08. PART F.3 OTHER FUNDING The City applied for a Save America's Treasures grant from the National Park Service for the renovation 1 and restoration of the Winter Island Administration Building. Funding awards have not yet been announced. No other public or private grants were received for preservation projects. PART G OTHER ACTIVITIES The Commission provided letters of support for: • City of Salem application for a Survey and Planning Grant for a Neighborhood Architectural Conservation District study; • City of Salem application for Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund for rehabilitation of the Coast Guard barracks on Winter Island; • Salem Public Library application for Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund for slate roof and copper balustrade repair; and • 2007 Preservation Award from Massachusetts Historical Commission for 18 Crombie Street. The Commission provide comment letters for: • Pedrick Store House project for the Salem Maritime National Historic Site; • Salem Jail redevelopment project; • North Street Reconstruction Extra Work Order; • J. Michael Ruane Judicial Center/Salem Trial Courts;and • Bridge Street Reconstruction -25% Submission Drawings. r S.�