Loading...
HISCOM ANNUAL REPORTS FY05 HISCOM Annual Reports e v s , - The Commonwealth of Massachusetts William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth Massachusetts Historical Commission JAt`! 0 5 2000 DEPT. Or P L 1%'%'G o: January 3, 2006 CT ;I?UNI?YCEI`;'.0'7,;e !T Jane Guy Assistant CD Director One Salem Green Salem, MA 01970 Dear Jane: The MHC has just completed its Certified Local Government evaluation for the City of Salem for the period July 1, 2002 to June 30, 2005. As you know, CLGs are formally evaluated by our office once every three years. The purpose of the evaluation is to verify that CLGs continue to meet the requirements for participation in the program. I am pleased to report that the City of Salem continues to meet the requirements for continued participation in the Certified Local Government Program. Keep up the great work! If you have any questions regarding the CLG evaluation or if I can be of any assistance, please feel free to contact me. Sincerely, Christopher C. Skelly Director of Local Government Programs 220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125 (617) 727-8470 • Fax: (617) 727-5128 www.state.ma.us/see/mhe SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION ANNUAL REPORT JULY 1, 2004 - JUNE 30, 2005 The Salem Historical Commission is a volunteer board ofSalem residents appointed by the Mayor. The Commission's mission is to provide regulatory design review within Salem's four designated local historic districts. The Commission also provides community-wide historic preservation planning assistance by promoting historic preservation awareness and by commenting on projects that may impact historic resources. Certificates Issued During the year July 1,2004 through June 30,2005,the Salem Historical Commission met regularly 22 times and had 3 site visits during which a quorum was present. In its capacity as Historic District Commission for 4 local districts,the Commission received 143 applications and filed a total of 166 certificates including: - 76 Certificates of Appropriateness; - 1 Certificates of Hardship; - 72 Certificates of Non-Applicability; - 8 Waivers of the Demolition Delay Ordinance; and - 9 Denials: 6 for Certificate of Appropriateness. 1 for Certificate of Hardship 1 for Certificate of Non-Applicability 1 for Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance Certificates issued are provided to the owner of the property,the City Clerk,the Building Inspector and are kept on file in the Department of Planning and Community Development according to address. A list of all Certificates issued can be found in the Certified Local Government Annual Report which is on file at the Department of Planning and Community Development and the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Minutes of all meetings are also available at the Department of Planning and Community Development. Commission Members The Commission is regularly comprised of seven (7) regular members and two (2) alternate members. In September, 2004, Rose Kilroy resigned from the Commission. Also in September, 2004, Hannah Diozzi was appointed to serve as a full member for a term to expire September 25, 2007, to replace Ms. Kilroy. In November, 2004, Douglas Desrocher was reappointed to the Commission for a term to expire March 1, 2007. In March, 2005, Commissioner Karam resigned from the Commission. Also in March,2005,Kathryn Harper was appointed to serve as an alternate member for a term to expire November 20, 2005, to replace Mr. Karam. There are currently no member vacancies. On June 1, 2005, Hannah Diozzi was voted in as the new Chair of the Commission and Lance Kasparian as the Vice Chair. Workshops/Seminars Doug Desrocher, Hannah Diozzi, Lance Kasparian and Jane Guy attended the following: • Massachusetts Historical Commission 2004 Statewide Historic Preservation Conference, Salem, MA, September, 2004 Hannah Diozzi attended the following: • Training lectures sponsored by Boston by Foot: The Architecture of the Federal City, Boston Architectural Center, April 2005. • Training lectures sponsored by Boston by Foot: The Architecture of the Victorian City, Boston Architectural Center, April 2005. Lance Kasparian attended the following: • Rhode Island Historic Preservation Commission Conference, April 2005 • Glass Painting 1800-1900 at the British Society of Master Glasspainter's conference, March 2005 • 16 hr. class entitled "The International Building Code -Fire Protection Concepts and Life Safety Concepts" provided by Code Access, Inc. (16 AIA cc units), August 2004 Survey & Planning Grant Proiects The City of Salem completed the Survey and Planning Grant project to develop a design guidelines manual for Salem's Urban Renewal Area, historic districts and major entrance corridors. Lance Kasparian and Jane Guy provided input into the project and participated in the review. In April, 2005, the City of Salem received an $15,000 funding award from the FY05 Survey and Planning Grant program to support a Point Neighborhood Preservation Plan for a total project cost of $30,000. Other Activities The Commission issued a letter of support for the Pickering Foundations application for Massachusetts Preservation Projects Funds for which they received a $20,000 grant. Larry Spang is serving as the Commission's representative for the Salem Redevelopment Authority's committee to redevelop the old Salem Jail. Lance Kasparian worked extensively with the Salem Common Neighborhood Association, who applied for and received a grant from the Essex National Heritage Commission to restore the Roger Conant Statue, the 3`d most photographed bronze in the country. The Commission voted to concur with the amendment to the Memorandum of Agreement for the Salem-Beverly Transportation Project to remove Stipulation#3. The Commission issued a letter of support for the nomination of the New Central Campus facility at Salem State College for a 2005 Preservation Award. The Commission issued a letter of support for the City of Salem's Massachusetts Preservation Projects Funds grant application for an elevator at City Hall. The Commission issued a letter of support for the City of Salem's grant application for street lighting on North Street. The City of Salem, the Department of Conservation and Recreation and the Essex National Heritage Commission, through the Massachusetts Heritage Landscape Inventory Program, issued the Salem Reconnaissance Report. Diverse priority landscapes including historic residential neighborhoods, parks and open space, Salem's coastline, burial grounds and cemeteries were identified by residents and community organizations and this report was created on how these community treasures can be preserved for future generations. Jessica Herbert participated in the project. This report was completed by Jane A. Guy on behalf of the Department of Planning and Community Development and the Salem Historical Commission. Respectfully s d Jane A. Gu Assistant Community Development Director Clerk of the Salem Historical Commission �r MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION CITY OF SALEM CERTIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT ANNUAL REPORT JULY 1, 2004 THRU JUNE 30, 2005 fr ryt l 4, CERTIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT ANNUAL REPORT CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS JULY 1, 2004-JUNE 30, 2005 PART A-ENFORCEMENT OF LOCAL LEGISLATION 1. Cases Reviewed 2. Sample Minutes 3. Sample Decision PART B -ADEQUATE AND QUALIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMISSION 1. Resumes 2. Membership 3. Professionals 4. Vacancies/Appointments 5. CLG Training Sessions/Workshops PART C -NATIONAL REGISTER PROGRAM PARTICIPATION 1. CLG Evaluations 2. Nominations 3. Public Hearings 4. Professional Expertise PART D- SURVEY AND INVENTORY OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES 1. Survey Forms 2. Survey Work 3. Inventory Status PART E-PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 1. Commission Meeting Dates 2. Open Meeting Law Compliance Statement 3. Accessibility of Minutes 4. Rules, Procedures, Guidelines PART F-FUNDING OF CLG ACTIVITIES 1. Local Funding 2. Survey and Planning Grant Funding 3. Other Funding This report was completed by Jane A. Guy, Assistant Community Development Director on behalf of the Salem Historical Commission and the Department of Planning and Community Development under the administration of Mayor Stanley J. Usovicz,Jr. APPLICATIONS REVIEWED 7/1/04-6/30/05 Page l NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE CONT') ADDRESS NAME ALTER./NEW CON.IDEMOL/NON-APP. DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS Meeting of 7/7/04: C 12 WINTHROP ST. PHILLIPS X MCINTIRE 6/2/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 PAINT COLORS N 6 SOUTH PINE ST. MASON X MCINTIRE 6/9/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 PAINT COLORS N 17 CAMBRIDGE ST. NEAI/WHHTOCK X MCINTIRE 6/15/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 PAINT COLORS C 8 REAR ESSEX ST. NASH X N/A 6/3/04 WDDO DENIAL 7/13/04 DEMOLISH HOUSE C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WDDO CONTINUE C 93-95 NORTH ST. SALVATION ARMY X N/A 6/10/04 WDDO WDDO 7/13/04 DEMOLISH 2 BLDGS. N 14 DALTON PKWY. SOWINSKI X MCINTIRE 6/2/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 ROOF N 58 DERBY ST. LOFFREDO X DERBY 6/2/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 FENCE CONTINUE GATE&ARBOR N 254 LAFAYETTE ST. MELLO TRUST X LAFAY. 6/14/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 DEMOLISH GREENHOUSE N 14 KOSCIUSKO ST. BARDWEUJCONNOLLY X DERBY 6/17/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/13/04 WINDOW N 3941 WASH.SQ. 39-41 WASH SQ.N CONDO. X WASH. 6/22/04 APPROP.CONTINUE ROOF Meeting of 7/21/04: N 4 CHESTNUT ST. KERR/INGHAM X MCINTIRE 6/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/22/04 PAINTING N 343 ESSEX ST. JENKINS X MCINTIRE 6/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 722/04 PAINT COLORS C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WDDO CONTINUE C 58 DERBY ST. LOFFREDO X DERBY 62/04 APPROP. CONTINUE GATE&ARBOR C 3941 WASH.SQ. 3941 WASH SQ.N CONDO. X WASH. 622/04 APPROP.CONTINUE ROOF N 370 ESSEX ST. SALEM PUBLIC LIBRARY X MCINTIRE 6/10/04 APPROP. APPROP. 7/22/04 SKYLIGHT REMOVAL,REPAIRS N 143 FEDERAL ST. SZWARTZ/WASHBURN X MCINTIRE 7/6/04 APPROP. APPROP. 722/04 FENCE N/A 722/04 STOOP C 10 GIFFORD CT. FOURNIER X MCINTIRE 6/1/04 APPROP DENIAL 7/22/04 WINDOWS N 69 BOSTON ST. VANCOTT/ARNOLD/MCARDLE X N/A 7/13/04 WDDO CONTINUE Meeting of 8/4/04: C 58 DERBY ST. LOFFREDO X DERBY 6/2/04 APPROP. CONTINUE GATE&ARBOR C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WOOD WDDO 8/5/04 DEMOLISH OF BUIDING PORTIONS CONTINUE ONE BUILDING PORTION C 3941 WASH.SQ. 3941 WASH SQ.N CONDO. X WASH. 6/22/04 APPROP.N/A 8/5/04 REPABUREPLACE SLATE ROOF N 131 FEDERAL ST. WRIGHTSON X MCINTIRE 7/8/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/5/04 CHIMNEY CAPS N 24 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTTRE 7/19/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/5/04 REMOVE VINYL SIDING,PAINT COLORS CONTINUE SHUTTERS WITHDRAWN FENCE N 69 BOSTON ST. VANCOTT/ARNOLD/MCARDLE X N/A 7/13/04 WDDO WITHDRAWN N 45 WARREN ST. BROWNELL X MCINTIRE 8/3/04 N/A DENIAL 8/5/04 PORCH EXTENSION Meeting of 8/18/04: N 87 FEDERAL ST, YOUNG X MCINTIRE 7/28/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/19/04 PAINT COLORS N 8 BOTTS COURT GOLDBERG/JUEDES X MCINTIRE 728/04 APPROP. CONTINUE PAINT COLORS N 18'/1 SUMMER ST. FAY/JORDAN X MCINTIRE 7/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/19/04 PAINT COLORS C 58 DERBY ST. LOFFREDO X DERBY 6/2/04 APPROP. DENIAL, 8/19/04 GATE&ARBOR C 24 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 7/19/04 APPROP. CONTINUE SHUTTERS N 1-17 ORNE SQUARE ORNE SQUARE CONDOS X MCINTIRE 7/22/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/19/04 GUTTERS&DOWNSPOUTS N 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER N 19 BROAD ST. MONTOURIS X MCINTIRE 72904 APPROP. CONTINUE IRRIGATION SYSTEM N 72 WASH,SQ.E SACHETII X WASH.SQ. 7/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/19/04 FENCE N 391.391 %ESSEX ST. ANDERSON/TUTTLE X MCINTIRE 8/2/04 HARD. CONTINUE 2ND EGRESS N 10 CHESTNUT ST. GERDINE/STRAUSS X MCINTIRE 8/2/04 APPROP. APPROP. 8/19/04 AC UNITS&GATE NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE { CONTI) ADDRESS NAME ALTER./NEWCONJDEMOL.INON-APP. DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS Meeting of 9/15/04: C 8 BOTTS COURT GOLDBERG/JUEDES X MCINTIRE 7/28/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 PAINT COLORS DENIAL 9/16/04 SHUTTER COLOR N 8-10 N.PINE ST. RING X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 PAINT N 14 CAMBRIDGE ST. BALLOU X MCINTIRE 8/4/04 APPROP. CONTINUE VINYL SHUTTERS C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WDDO CONTINUE ONE BUILDING PORTION C 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTI2E 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER C 19 BROAD ST. MONTOURIS X MCINTIRE 7/2904 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 IRRIGATION SYSTEM C 391-391 %v ESSEX ST. ANDERSON/TUTTLE X MCINTTRE 8/2/04 HARD, CONTINUE 2ND EGRESS N 405A ESSEX ST. CAMPBELL X MCINTTRE 8/27/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 FAQADE SIGN CONTINUE SIGN POST SIGN N 39 WARREN ST. HEALEY X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 CHIMNEY CAP N 104 FEDERAL ST. HART/CLEARY X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 PERGOLA&FENCE CONTINUE PAINT OF PERGOLA&FENCE N 94 FEDERAL ST. MCEACHERN X MCINTIRE 9/1/04 AJ?PROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 PAINT COLORS N 170 FEDERAL ST. GARDNER/POMERLEAU X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. CONTINUE PAINT COLORS N 328 ESSEX ST. MANNETTAMERRICK LLC X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DUE TO LACK OF QUORUM C 24 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 7/19/04 APPROP. APPROP. 9/16/04 SHUTTERS N 10 GIFFORD CT. FOURNIER X MCINTIRE 8/26/04 APPROP. CONTINUE WINDOWS Meeting of 10/6/04: C 170 FEDERAL ST. GARDNER/POMERLEAU X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP 10/12/04 PAINT COLORS N 3941 WASH.SQ. PERVIER,ETAL X WASH. 9/20/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 PAINT STAIR TREADS&HANDRAILS N 10 MONROE ST. HARTFELDER X MCINTIRE 9/21/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 PAINT COLORS C 14 CAMBRIDGE ST. BALLOU X MCINTIRE 8/4/04 APPROP. CONTINUE VINYL.SHUTTERS C 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER C 391-391 '/ESSEX ST. ANDERSON/TUTTLE X MCINTIRE 8/2/04 HARD. DENIAL 10/12/04 2m EGRESS C 10 GIFFORD CT. FOURNIER X MCINTIRE 8/26/04 APPROP. DENIAL 10/12/04 WINDOWS 2/2 DOUBLE GLAZE APPROP. 10/12/04 WINDOWS 6/6 SINGLE GLAZE C 405A ESSEX ST. CAMPBELL X MCINTIRE 8/27/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 SIGN POST SIGN C 328 ESSEX ST. MANNETTA/HERRICK LLC X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. CONTINUE FENCING N 180 FEDERAL ST. JENDRYSIK X MCINTIRE 9/02/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 SKYLIGHT N 127 DERBY ST. YOURELL ETAL X DERBY 9/2-9/14 APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 GUTTERS&DOWNSPOUTS N 23 WINTER ST. MCCOY X WASH. 9/14/04 APPROP. CONTINUE GUTTERS&DOWNSPOUTS N 41 CHESTNUT ST. JAGOLTA X MCINTIRE 9/14-920APPROP. APPROP. 10/12/04 CHIMNEY CAP N 55 WARREN ST. SALEM REALTY TR. X MCINTIRE 10/13/04 N/A N/A 10/13/04 REPLACE 2 WINDOWS Meeting of 10/20/04: C 14 CAMBRIDGE ST. BALLOU X MCINTIRE 8/4/04 APPROP. CONTINUE VINYL SITUTTERS C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WDDO CONTINUE ONE BUILDING PORTION C 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER C 328 ESSEX ST. MANNETTA/HERRICK LLC X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. CONTINUE FENCING C 104 FEDERAL ST. HART/CLEARY X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/25/04 PAINT OF PERGOLA&FENCE C 23 WINTER ST. MCCOY X WASH. 9/14/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1025/04 GUTTERS&DOWNSPOUTS N 1 CHESTNUT ST. LEBEL X MCINTIRE 9/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/25/04 DOWNSPOUTS N 38 WARREN ST. JENKINS X MCINTIRE 9/30/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/25/04 FENCE Meeting of 11/3/04: C 14 CAMBRIDGE ST. BALLOU X MCINTIRE 8/4/04 APPROP. DENIAL 11/04/04 VINYL SHUTTERS&PERMANENT REMOVAL APPROP. 11/04/04 WOOD SHUTTERS C 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 6/8/04 WDDO WDDO 11/04/04 ONE BUILDING PORTION C 4FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 729/04 APPROP. CONTINUE 11/04/04 DORMER C 328 ESSEX ST. MANNETTA/HERRICK LLC X MCINTIRE 8/30/04 APPROP. APPROP 11/04/04 FENCING N 8 WINTHROP ST. LIEBERMAN X MCINTIRE 10/15/04 APPROP. APPROP. 11/04/04 FENCE REMOVAL NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE CONT'D ADDRESS NAME ALTER MEW CON IDEMOL INON-APP DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS Meeting of 11/17/04: N 9 CHESTNUT ST. HAMILTON HALL X MCINTIRE 10/28/04 HARD. HARD. 11/19/04 WALL STABILIZATION N 6 BROAD ST. NALIPINSKI X MCINTIRE 10/28/04 APPROP. APPROP. 11/19/04 PORCH DEMOLITION,INSTALL FOOTINGS&FLOORING CONTINUE PORCH DESIGN Meeting of 12/1/04 C 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER N 38 FLINT ST. ROSENZWEIG X MCINTIRE 10/27/04 APPROP. APPROP 12/13/04 WINDOWS CONTINUE BAYBOW WINDOW N 324-328 ESSEX ST. OVERLOOK SALEM LLC X MCINTIRE 11/9/04 APPROP. APPROP. 12/2/04 QUOINS,TRIM,DOOR,FLASHING,GUTTERS CONTINUE DOORS,ROOF,DORMERS,CUPOLA,SKYLIGHTS, WINDOWS,FENCE N 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING Meeting of 12/15/04 C 6 BROAD ST. NALIPINSKI X MCINTTRE 10/28/04 APPROP. APPROP. 12/15/04 PORCH DESIGN C 324-328 ESSEX ST. OVERLOOK SALEM LLC X MCINTIRE 11/9/04 APPROP. APPROP. 12/16/04 ROOF CONTINUE DOORS,DORMERS,CUPOLA,SKYLIGHTS, WINDOWS,FENCE N 8 CHESTNUT ST. BUSTEED X MCINTIRE 11/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 12/16/04 GUTTERS,DOWNSPOUTS N 1 HAMILTON ST. L'HEUREUX/SHEA X X MCINTIRE 11/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 12/16/04 SHUTTERS,DEMOLISH GARAGE&PORCH,DOWNSPOUTS DRIP EDGE N/A 12/16/04 PAINT TRIM CONTINUE SKYLIGHTS,ROOF,COMPRESSORS,NEW PORCH C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING N 2 SMITH AVE. FARRELL X N/A 12/7/04 WDDO WDDO 12/16/04 DEMOLISH RESIDENCE Meeting of 1/5/05: C 4 FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE DORMER C 38 FLINT ST. ROSENZWEIG X MCINTIRE 10/27/04 APPROP. CONTINUE BAY/BOW WINDOW C 324-328 ESSEX ST. OVERLOOK SALEM LLC X MCINTIRE 11/9/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1/7/05 DOORS,DORMERS,CUPOLA,WINDOW,FENCE N/A 1/7/05 WINDOWS,DOORS,SKYLIGHTS C 1 HAMILTON ST. L'HEUREUX/SHEA X X MCINTIRE 11/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1/7/05 COMPRESSORS,FENCE,NEW PORCH N/A 1/7/05 SLATE ROOF,SKYLIGHTS CONTINUE ASPHALT ROOF C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING Meeting of 1/19/05: C 4FEDERAL COURT DUFOUR X MCINTIRE 7/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1/19/05 DORMER C 38 FLINT ST. ROSENZWEIG X MCINTIRE 10/27/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1/19/05 WINDOWS 12/29/04 APPROP. APPROP. 1/19/05 AWNING REMOVAL,PAINT COLORS C 1 HAMILTON ST. L'HEUREUX/SHEA X X MCINTIRE 11/29/04 APPROP. CONTINUE ASPHALT ROOF C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING Meeting of 2/16/05: C 1 HAMILTON ST. L'HEUREUX/SHEA X X MCINTIRE 11/29/04 APPROP. WITHDRAWN ASPHALT ROOF C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING N 131 DERBY ST. LEGON X DERBY 1/27/05 APPROP. APPROP. 2/18/05 PATIN.DECKS,SHUTTERS,SIDING,WINDOW BOXES, DOORS,REMOVE FENCE,GARAGE ROOF DECK,DOORS N 430 ESSEX ST. SCOTT X N/A 2/7/05 WDDO WDDO 2/7/05 DEMOLISH GARAGE Meeting of 3/2/05: C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE 'i 7 CONTD ADDRESS NAME ALTER./NEW CON.IDEMOL./NON-APP, DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS N 10 FLINT ST. TRECAUTIN/WISE X MCINTIRE 2/1/05 APPROP. APPROP. 3/3/05 PAINT COLORS N 26 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 2/10/05 APPROP. APPROP. 3/3/05 BATH VENT N/A 3/3/05 KITCHEN VENT Meeting of 3/16/05: C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WOOD CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING N 315-317 ESSEX ST. MORRIS X MCINTIRE 2/18/05 APPROP. APPROP. 3/23/05 SIDING,TRIM,STAIRS,PAINT N 26 HARDY ST. CONNELLY X N/A 2/24/05 WDDO WDDO 3/22/05 DEMOLISH GARAGE AND STAIRCASE Meeting of 4/6/05: C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING C 315-317 ESSEX ST. MORRIS X MCINTIRE 2/18/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/7/05 PAINT N 391 ESSEX127 FLINT 391 ESSEX ST. N.T. X MCINTIRE 3/8/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/7/05 PAINT,WINDOW,DOOR N 17'/:RIVER ST. BIEBESHEIMER X MCINIIRE. 3/21/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/7/05 FENCE N 131 DERBY ST. LEGON X DERBY 3/221/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/7/05 WINDOWS Meeting of 4/20/05: C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING N 135 FEDERAL ST. MORAN&POLITO X MCNTIRE 3/30/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/21/05 FENCE N 28 GOODHUE ST. NORTH RIVER CANAL LLC X N/A 4/12/05 WDDO WDDO 4/21/05 DEMOLISH REST OF BUILDINGS N R. CONANT STATUE CITY OF SALEM X WASH.SQ. 4/4/05 APPROP. APPROP. 4/21/05 RESTORATION Meeting of 5/4/05: N 266-268 LAFAYETTE MCCLEARN X LAFAY. 4/15/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/5/05 PAINT COLORS N 12 WINTHROP ST. PERRY;RUSSELL X MCINTIRE 4/13/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/5/05 FENCE&CLOTHESLINE REMOVAL N 10 FLINT ST. WISE&TRECAUTIN X MCINTIRE 4/13/05 APPROP. CONTINUE ALTER FENCE C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO CONTINUE DEMOLISH BUILDING Meeting of 5/18/05: C 10 FLINT ST. WISE&TRECAUTIN X MCDMRE 4/13/05 APPROP. DENIAL 5/20/05 ALTER FENCE C 35 BRIDGE ST. SGA REALTY TRUST X N/A 11/22/04 WDDO 6mths elapsed DEMOLISH BUILDING N 26 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 4/25/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/05 FENCE,RAILINGS N 24 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 4/25/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/05 VENT N I FORRESTER ST. CABOT X WASH.SQ, 4/26/05 APPROP. WITHDRAWN ELECTRICAL SERVICE APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/05 FACADE ALTERATIONS N 391 ESSEX/27 FLINT 391 ESSEX ST.NOM.TR. X MCINTIRE 4/26/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/05 SHUTTER DOOR,GATE,FENCE,BULKHEAD DOOR N 30 WARREN ST. CONSERVATORY C.T. X MCINTIRE 4/26/05 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/05 FLASHIGN,GUTTER N 39 WARREN ST. HEALY/RAYE X MCINTIRE 4/27/05 APPROP. CONTINUE FENCE Meeting of 6/1/05: C 39 WARREN ST. HEALY/RAYE X MCINTIRE 4/27/05 APPROP. APPROP. 06/02/05 FENCE N 35 WASH.SQ. O'SULLIVAN X WASH.SQ. 5/11/05 APPROP. CONTINUE A/C SYSTEM N 24 FORT AVE. DOMINION S.H.LLC X N/A 5/25/05 WDDO WOOD 06/02/05 REMOVE CHIMNEY Meeting of 6/15/05: C 35 WASH.SQ. O'SULLIVAN X WASH.SQ, 5/11/05 APPROP. CONTINUE 5/17/05 A/C SYSTEM N/A 6/21/05 A/C SYSTEM N 60 DERBY ST. ATWOOD X DERBY APPROP. APPROP. 6/21/05 CHIMNEYS N 35 FLINT ST. BOWDITCH PLACE X MCINTIRE 5/17/05 APPROP. APPROP. 6/21/05 LAMP POST N/A 6/21/05 ROOF DECK N 10 CHESTNUT ST. STRAUSS/GERDINE X MCINTIRE 5/27/05 APPROP. APPROP. 6/21/05 REAR PORCH ADDITION CONTINUE WALL REPLACEMENT N 110 DERBY ST. FOX X DERBY 6/13/05 N/A N/A 6/21/05 WINDOW&DOOR INSTALLATION i NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE - CONTD ADDRESS NAME ALTERJNEW CON.IDEMOL./NON-APP. DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS Non-meeting approvals: N 256&258 LAFAY.ST. GREYSTONE MANOR X LAFAY. 6/30/04 N/A N/A 7/7/04 ROOF N 260 LAFAYETTE ST. GREYSTONE MANOR X LAFAY.-, 6/30/04 N/A N/A 7/7/04 ROOF N 30 CHESTNUT ST. PHILLIPS X MCINTIRE 7/27/04 N/A N/A 7/28/04 REPLACE PILASTERSIFANLIGHT N 45 WARREN ST. BROWNELL X MCINTIRE 8/3/04 N/A N/A 8/3/04 REPAINTING N 16 HARDY ST, PRENTICE X DERBY 8/5/04 N/A N/A 8/5/04 ROOFING N 45 WARREN ST. BROWNELL X MCINTIRE 8/17/04 N/A N/A 8/17/04 REPAIR SUNPORCH AND FENCE N 6 BOTTS COURT SIRIANNI X MCINTIRE 8/18/04 N/A N/A 8/18/04 ROOFING&GUTTERS N 135 FEDERAL ST. MORAN/POLITE - X MCINTIRE 8/20/04 N/A N/A 8/24/04 REPAIR FENCE,REPAINTING N 402 ESSEX ST. NGO X MCINTIRE 8/23/04 N/A N/A 8/24/04 CLAPBOARD,REPAINT N 39 WARREN ST. HEALY X MCINTIRE 8/17/04 N/A N/A 8/30/04 REBUILD CHIMNEY&WALL N 170 FEDERAL ST. GARDNER/POMERLEAU X MCRGIRE 8/30/04 N/A N/A 8/30/04 REPAINTING N 180 FEDERAL ST. JENDRYSIK X MCINTIRE 9/2/04 N/A N/A 9/2/04 SKYLIGHT N 34 WARREN ST. FIRST SPIRIT.CHURCH X MCINTIRE 9/8/04 N/A N/A 9/8/04 REPOINTING N 142 FEDERAL ST. CLIFFORD X MCINTIRE 9/8/04 N/A N/A 9/8/04 FENCE REPAIR N 182 FEDERAL ST. DELISSIO X MCINTIRE 9/9/04 N/A N/A 9/13/04 GUTTERS,DOWNSPOUTS,REPAIRS N 19 CHESTNUT ST. BINNEY X MCINTIRE 9/14/04 N/A N/A 9/14/04 SLATE ROOF N 328 ESSEX ST. OVERLOOK SALEM LLC X MCINTIRE 9/16/04 N/A N/A 9/16/04 VARIOUS REPAIR/REPLACE N 150 FEDERAL ST. ARCH.OF BOSTON X MCINTIRE 9/21/04 N/A N/A 9/22/04 FACIA REPAIR,REPOWT MASONRY N 8WINTHROP ST. LIEBERMAN X MCINTIRE 9/30/04 N/A N/A 9/30/04 REPAINT TRIM N 29 CHESTNUT ST. WANNEMACHER X MCINTIRE 10/6/04 N/A N/A 10/7/04 REPAIR SLATE ROOF,SNOW GUARD&FLASHING N 13 CAMBRIDGE ST. SMART X MCINTIRE 10/7/04 N/A N/A 10/7/04 REPAINTING N 10 CHESTNUT ST. STRAUSS/GERDINE X MCINTIRE 10/7/04 NA N/A 10/7/04 RECONSTRUCT BRICK WALL N 182 FEDERAL ST. PARNASSA/OGNO X MCINTIRE 10/18/04 N/A N/A 10/18/04 REPLACE WINDOW N 5 FLINT ST. PEIRCE X MCINTIRE 10/20/04 N/A N/A 10/20/04 ENTRY REPAIRS N 155-157 FEDERAL ST. JARNIS/BUSO/HYPES X MCINTIRE 10/27/04 APPROP. APPROP. 10/27/04 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 156 FEDERAL ST. ARCHDIOCESE OF BOSTON X MCINTIRE 11/3/04 N/A N/A 11/04/04 ROOF&REPAIRS N 34 SUMMER ST. FITZGERALD X MCINTIRE 10/29/04 N/A 11/8/04 REPAIRS,REPAINT,ROOF N 38 FLINT ST. ROSENZWEIG X MCINTIRE 10/27/04 N/A N/A 11/10/04 WINDOW SASH N 38 FLINT ST. ROSENZWEIG X MCINTIRE 11/9/04 APPROP. APPROP. 11/10/04 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 359 ESSEX ST. ERRION X MCINTIRE 11/10/04 N/A N/A 11/10/04 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 76 FEDERAL ST. GORDON X MCINTIRE 11/24/04 N/A N/A 11/24/04 REPAINTING N 270 LAFAYETTE MANION/AHERN X LAFAY. 11/23/04 N/A N/A 11/24/04 WINDOW REPLACEMENT N 165 FEDERAL ST. CUNHA X MCINTIRE 11/30/04 N/A N/A 11/30/04 REFOOF REAR ROOF SECTION N 40 SUMMER ST. MENDEL X X MCINTIRE 1/10/05 N/A N/A 1/12/05 INSTALL DOOR,REPAINT,REPAIR ROOF N 125 DERBY ST. HUTCHINSON X DERBY 1/21/05 N/A N/A 1/24/05 CLAPBOARDS,TRIM,REPAINT N 180A FEDERAL ST. CONNELLY X MCINTIRE 2/1/05 N/A N/A 2/3/05 WINDOW REPLACEMENT N 10 FLINT ST. WISE X MCINTIRE 2/1/05 N/A N/A 2/3/05 VARIOUS REPAIRS N 26 CHESTNUT ST. O'CONNOR X MCINTIRE 2/10/05 N/A N/A 2/14/05 FRENCH DOOR WINDOWS,SKYLIGHTS NOT VISIBLE N 386 ESSEX ST. CLARKE X MCINTIRE 2/28/05 N/A N/A 2/28/05 VARIOUS REPAIRS N 27 FLINT/391 ESSEX ANDERSONITUTTLE X MCINTIRE 3/1/05 N/A N/A 3/3/05 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 117 FEDERAL ST. DUGUAY/RILEY X MCINTIRE 3/8/05 N/A N/A 3/14/05 WINDOW REPLACEMENT N 46 CHESTNUT ST. RANDALL X MCINTIRE 3/14/05 N/A N/A 3/14/05 SIDING REPLACEMENT N 80 FEDERAL ST. PEABODY ESSEX M. X WASH.SQ. 3/16/05 N/A N/A 3/16/05 SHUTTER RESTORATION N 12 WINTHROP ST. PERRY/RUSSEL X MCINTIRE 4/1/05 N/A N/A 4/1/05 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 88 FEDERAL ST. FERRETTI X MCINTIRE 3/10/05 N/A N/A 3/10/05 FIRE DAMAGE REPAIRS N 2 BOTTS CT. USOVICZ X MCINTIRE 4/11/05 N/A N/A 4/11/05 ROOF N 8CHESTNUT ST. BUSTEED X MCINTIRE 4/14/05 N/A N/A 4/14/05 REPAINT N 9 CHESTNUT ST. HAMILTON HALL X MCINTIRE 4/14/05 N/A N/A 4/14/05 REPAINT SHUTTERS N 6 FEDERAL CT. PEABODY X MCINTIRE 4/1/05 N/A N/A 4/13/05 STABILIZATION N 116 FEDERAL ST. LEACH NICHOLS C/A X MCINTIRE 4/20/05 N/A N/A 4/20/05 REPAIRS,REPAINT(HOUSE&FENCE) N 8 CARPENTER ST. NEWMAN X MCINTIRE 4/11/05 APPROP. N/A 4/20/05 REPLACE CHIMNEY,REPAINT N 30 WARREN ST. CONSERVATORY C.T. X MCINTIRE 4/26/05 N/A N/A 426/05 ROOF N 60 DERBY ST. ATWOOD X DERBY 4/25/05 N/A N/A 4/25/05 ROOF N 361 ESSEX ST. CLARKE X MCINTIRE 5/16/05 N/A N/A 5/16/05 FENCE REPLACEMENT N 22 BECKFORD ST. BURNS X MCINTIRE 5/11/05 N/A N/A 5/18/05 FENCE REPLACEMENT N 8 CHESTNUT ST. BUSTEED X MCIN77RE 5/25/05 N/A N/A 5/25/05 REPAINTING N 74 WASH.SQ. SHERR/TENBROECK/ALTAF X WASH.SQ. 6/1/05 N/A N/A 6/2/05 REPAINT,REPAIRS NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE CONTD ADDRESS NAME ALTER./NEWCONJDEMOL./NON-APP. DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS N 3& I '/: CAMBRIDGE CATALDO/KEARNEY X MCINTIRE 6/6/05 N/A N/A 6/7/05 FENCE REPLACEMENT N 120 FEDERAL ST. TWOHEY/LEVOBICI X MCINTIRE 6/21/05 N/A N/A 6/22/05 REPAIR HOUSEIREPLACE FENCE N 400 ESSEX ST. CROWLEY X MCINTIRE 6/21/05 N/A N/A 6/21/05 ROOF,GUTTER,REPAINTING N 397 ESSEX ST. RICCIARELLI X MCINTIRE 6/28/05 N/A N/A 6/29/05 FENCE REPLACEMENT N 80 FEDERAL ST. PEABODY ESSEX MUSEUM X MCINTIRE 6/30/05 N/A N/A 6/30/05 REPAIR TRIM,SHUTTERS,WINDOWS,REPAINT N 9 BROWN ST. PEABODY ESSEX MUSEUM X WASH.SQ. 6/30/05 N/A N/A 6/30/05 REPAINTING N 60 DERBY ST. ATWOOD X DERBY 6/30/05 N/A N/A 7/5/05 REPAIRS March 16, 2005, Page I SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES March 16, 2005 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on March 16, 2005 at 7:30 p.m. at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Chairman Kasparian and Messrs. Desrocher and Spang and Ms. Diozzi and Ms. Guy. 26 Hardy Street Sandra Connelly submitted an application to Waive the Demolition Delay Ordinance to remove a 2 car garage adjacent to the seawall and to remove a stair on the existing residence. The purpose is to renovate the existing two family into a one family and improve the view. Architect David Jaquith represented the applicant. Mr. Jaquith stated that the garage is a free standing 1920-30s concrete block garage. Mr. Kasparian agreed that the garage is a 20th century structure. Ms. Diozzi stated that she did not see any significance to the garage. Mr. Desrocher made a motion to waive the Demolition Delay Ordinance for the garage. Ms. Diozzi seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Kasparian asked if the Commission had the authority to act on the demolition of the stairs. Ms. Guy stated that if it does not require a demolition permit and would be included in the permit to renovate, she did not feel it would need a waiver. Mr. Jaquith described the renovation project and provided drawings of the proposed. Mr. Kasparian stated the he suspected there is some integrity to the stair, noting it was similar to a Beverly Jog. He asked if there was any way to integrate it into the design. Mr. Jaquith stated that he felt the stair was a later addition when the house was made a two family. Mr. Kasparian stated that there is precedent for this type of stair at the Crowninshield Bentley House. He added that the house may have been moved to this location. Mr. Jaquith stated that the owner has also indicated that the house may have been moved here. Mr. Kasparian proposed requiring that photographs of all four elevations be submitted to add to the inventory file. .ji March 16, 2005, Page 2 ` Mr. Jaquith stated that he can provide photographs as well as drawings of existing conditions. Mr. Spang suggested that the new addition be pushed back a bit so that it is not even with the main building. Mr. Jaquith stated that he would be willing to take another look at it, but noted that there is a rear set-back condition. Mr. Kasparian suggested retaining the main house fenestration and not changing the 2nd floor window. Mr. Spang made a motion to waive the Demolition Delay Ordinance for the stair, conditional that photographs of all four elevations and copies of existing condition drawings be submitted. Ms. Diozzi seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 315-317 Essex Street Stephen and Linda Morris presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install new trim products; 1 x 8 comerboards and 1 x 8 water table to the rear addition. The application states that the fascia board area will be built out per drawing to create an overhang, eliminating the runoff from the flat roof area. It is also to remove the aluminum siding on the main portion of the building and for paint colors too be Peyter Gray with white trim. Mr. Morris stated that the rear addition is cinder block slab and that he will have pine fascia, comerboards and watertable. Mr. Kasparian asked if the rear doors will be replaced. Mr. Morris stated that the existing will stay. Mr. Morris stated that the clapboards will help address settlement and drainage in the back. He stated that they have explored some areas under the aluminum siding and don't know to what extend the existing clapboards underneath can be salvaged. Mr. Kasparian asked if there will be changes to the main building windows or doors. Mr. Morris replied in the negative. Mr. Kasparian asked if the gutters and downspouts will remain. Mr. Morris replied in the affirmative. Mr. Kasparian asked if there will be any changes to the storefront. Mr. Morris replied in the negative. Mr. Morris stated that they will remove the vinyl siding, clapboard over the rear addition and add an overhang. The paint colors will be Pewter Gray, not Peyter Gray, with white trim. He added that the .032 gage cladded fascia and soffit will remain. He noted that he will have to restore the s� March 16, 2005, Page 3 trim to the windows in order to avoid a void and may need to refabricate the window sills. Mr. Spang asked if the rear addition was visible. Mr. Morris noted that it is visible from Summer Street between the buildings. Mr. Spang asked if the air conditioning unit will remain. Mr. Morris stated that he will leave it and put some trim around it. Mr. Spang asked if the addition will have a new roof. Mr. Morns replied in the affirmative but noted that they will use the same membrane on the overhang. Mr. Spang asked if the light fixture will remain. Mr. Morris replied in the affirmative. Mr. Kasparian stated that the old photograph shows window hoods on the second floor front windows and asked if it could be considered for reinstallation. Mr. Morris stated he was willing to reinstall the pediments. Mr. Kasparian asked if the signs will remain. Mr. Morris replied in the affirmative. Mr. Kasparian asked if the shutters will be removed. Mr. Morris replied in the affirmative. Mr. Kasparian asked if wood shutters will be put back on the front. Mr. Morris stated that he P may at a later date. Mr. Morris stated that a new staircase is needed in the rear. They will remove the existing steel stair, but keep the railing above. He stated that he will replicate what is there in wood, but will use balusters, 4" on center. Mr. Spang stated that the Commission typically wants the underside of the stair finished off. Mr. Morris noted that there is a condenser unit underneath and an air conditioning unit on the wall. He provided a post card showing the type of stair being proposed. He added that he did not know the condition of the foundation on the main house and whether or not there is a watertable underneath the siding. Ms. Guy stated that the Commission could approve the work, but still continue the application to the next meeting in case any approvals need to be changed based on what is discovered in the field. Ms. Diozzi made a motion to approve the following: Main building - Removal of synthetic siding and shutters. Repair/replace underlying wood clapboard siding, trim and watertable in kind. Reconstruct window casing and window pediments on front, second floor to match photo on 1967 inventory form. Side windows to match window casing on abutting properties, including reconstruction of windows sills, if needed. Option to install wood shutters on front faFade (to be hung so as to be operable and, when closed, of size to fill the window and hung to shed water ' ) March 16, 2005, Page 4 away from window). Existing synthetic fascia and soffit to remain. Paint colors - Pewter Gray clapboards, white trim. Rear addition-Installation of wood clapboards, fascia, cornerboards and water table to match main house. Construction of overhang per drawings submitted with roof to match existing. Remove existing steel staircase and install new wood staircase in same footprint and configuration (run, landing). Railing/baluster style per postcard submitted and to meet building code, baluster 4"on center. Entire to be painted Pewter Gray, with treads to be painted Battleship Gray. Paint colors - Pewter Gray clapboards, white trim. Application is continued to meeting of April 6`s in order to address potential issues discovered in the field. i Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 35 Bridge Street In continuation of a previous meeting, SGA Realty Trust submitted an application for Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance for 35 Bridge Street demolition in order to construct a new steel building. The applicant was not present. Ms. Diozzi made a motion to continue the application. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Guy stated that the City of Salem submitted a pre-application to undertake a Point Neighborhood Preservation Plan and has been invited to submit a full application. Mr. Kasparian signed a letter of support. There being no further business,Mr.Mangifesti made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Spang seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submitted, Jane A. Guy Clerk of the Commission ^i April 6, 2005, Page 1 ,c SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES April 6, 2005 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on April 6, 2005 at 7:30 p.m. at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Messrs. Desrocher, Mangifesti and Spang and Ms. Diozzi and new member Kathryn Harper and Ms. Guy. Mr. Desrocher chaired the meeting. 315-317 Essex Street In continuation of a previous meeting, Stephen and Linda Morris presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the aluminum siding on the main portion of the building, installation of clapboards and trim on the rear addition, stair replacement and paint colors. Mr. Morris stated that the color under the vinyl siding is Cottage Red and he would like to repaint the house in that color, with white trim and doors and shutters to be Chrome Green. He noted that the clapboards are in pretty good shape and that only one side will need replacement. He also found a brick foundation. Mr. Mangifesti made a motion to approve the paint colors proposed. Ms. Diozzi seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 391 Essex/27 Flint Street 391 Essex Street Nominee Trust submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors for the door and shutters to be black and the trim color to be White Dove. Also submitted was an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace an existing boarded over window on the south side with a 15 light door, with 3 light transom above and to replace an existing wood door on the east side with the 15 over 15 window salvaged and restored from the south side. The application notes that the opening in the brick is the same height and width for both and that they believe that the east side opening was originally a window. Blake Anderson, Peter Strout and Leslie Tuttle represented the applicants. Mr. Anderson stated that the window on the south side is currently boarded over and has a brownstone lintel across the top. He noted that the current door was added in the 70's. They will put in a divided light wooden Brosco door where the window is being removed. They will repaint the trim in white, shutters black and the door will black with white trim. The panel on the door will be black. It will have sealed glass with applied muntins, rather than true divided lights. He proposed M-6915 with low E glass. There was no public comment. 1 April 6, 2005, Page 2 Mr. Spang asked if the brick will be cut in the existing window location. Mr. Andersons stated that they will cut 2 %x feet from the bottom, but the height and width will remain. He noted that it will provide better access to the back yard. Mr. Spang stated that it is more appropriate to match the existing door on the house and having a panel on the bottom. Ms. Diozzi was concerned about the glue-on muntins. Mr. Anderson stated that temperature contractions cause the seal to break down in true divided light windows, causing them to frost over. Mr. Mangifesti stated that he would only be willing to approve a non-insulated true divided light window. Mr. Desrocher stated that he felt 15 lights was too contemporary. Ms. Tuttle stated that they would be happy to do a panel on the bottom half of the door. Mr. Desrocher stated that the Commission would need details on the door. Mr. Strout stated that it would be a standard Brosco door, with 9 lights, single glazed with 2 raised panels below. Mr. Mangifesti made a motion to approve the two applications as submitted with the new door to be a standard Brosco wood door, with 9 true divided lights, single glazed with 2 raised panels below. Ms. Diozzi seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Tuttle stated that they have an at grade bulkhead on a public sidewalk with an opening in the foundation. Mr. Strout noted that the Department of Public Works regulates the sidewalks. Ms. Guy stated that while the foundation part would be under the Commission's jurisdiction, the at-grade grating on the public property did not appear to be in the Commission's jurisdiction. 17 % River Street Frederick Biebesheimer IV presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace an existing fence. There are three existing sections of fence (noted in yellow on the plan provided), each in a different style that will be replaced with an open picket fence with a colonial cap, with a Brosco fence cap, painted the light cream color of the house. The height of the fence will be 44", with 2 'h" pickets and'/4" spacing. Posts will be 4" x 4" uncapped, set below the fence top. A drawing of the fence was provided, along with a catalog cut of the fence cap. April 6, 2005, Page 3 Mr. Biebesheimer stated that they are looking to consolidate all fencing and noted that it will be painted Cameo White. Mr. Spang suggested putting a board on top of the posts to prevent the grain from soaking up water. Mr. Spang made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 131 Derby Street Lewis Legon presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace the front 9 windows with Brosco true divided light, wood, double hung windows. Mr. Legon stated that the existing windows are vinyl replacements which he proposes to replace with wood, 2 over 2, single glaze. He stated that he also wants to come back to change the doors from the approved M-100 to a 9- lite or other option. Mr. Mangifesti stated that he would consider a door that provides more light and suggested that Mr. Legon submit an application. Ms. Diozzi made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 35 Bridge Street In continuation of a previous meeting, SGA Realty Trust submitted an application for Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance for 35 Bridge Street demolition in order to construct a new steel building. The applicant was not present. Ms. Harper made a motion to continue the application. Mr. Spang seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. There being no further business,Mr. Spang made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submitted, Jane A. Guy Clerk of the Commission June 15, 2005, Page 1 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES June 15, 2005 A meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on June 15, 2005 at 7:30 p.m. at 120 Washington Street, Salem, MA. Present were Messrs. Mangifesti and Desrocher and Ms. Diozzi, Harper and Herbert and Ms. Guy. 35 Washington Square In continuation of a previous meeting, Kathleen O'Sullivan submitted an aFTlication for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install an air conditioning system to the 3` floor unit at 35 Washington Square. Ed O'Sullivan represented the applicant. Mr. O'Sullivan stated that he has talked with the condo association about an interior solution and they are will to try that route through the back staircase and hallway. He also talked to the contractor and was told it is possible, but noted that they would still like an alternative approval in case it does not work out. For the exterior alternative,the contractor can drill into the wall just below the ornamental fascia, if needed. For the interior solution,they will enter between the brick and the granite foundation. J Ms. Herbert stated that she preferred not to approve an alternative if the contractor is pretty certain that an interior solution will work. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve a Certificate of Non-applicability for the installation of an air conditioning compressor with electrical and refrigerant piping to be located within the interior of the structure, so as not to be visible from the public way. Mr. O'Sullivan was concerned about potentially running into a problem and having to start the approval process over. Ms. Herbert suggested that the contractor make some test holes. Ms. Guy suggested approving the motion and then continuing the application to the next meeting in case a problem is discovered. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Desrocher made a motion to continue the application. Ms. Herbert seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 60 Derby Street David and Gina Atwood presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to re-parge the exterior of the chimney nearest English Street, to parge the chimney farthest from English June 15, 2005, Page 2 Street, to install chimney caps on both chimneys and to repoint as needed. Photographs of sample chimney caps were provided. Ms. Diozzi stated that a small portion of one chimney is visible from Derby Street and both are visible from English Street. Ms. Atwood stated that their contractor believes the unparged chimney may have been parged at one time. Ms. Herbert asked if they will leave them the color of the concrete or paint them. Mr. Atwood stated that he assumed they will be left natural. Ms. Harper stated that there are three or four parged chimneys in that neighborhood. Ms. Atwood stated that she preferred a copper cap, but that they could also have a steel cap or bricks with a cap on top. There was no public comment. Ms. Herbert stated that option B (bricked version) is kind of busy with its band of brick. Ms. Harper noted that the existing chimney has a band. Ms. Herbert noted that she preferred option B with a copper cap on top. Mr. Desrocher stated that the brick chimney looks shorter than the parged chimney, as though some of the bricks came off. Mr. Mangifesti asked if the brick band will be added to the second chimney. Mr. Atwood stated that there intent is for both chimneys to match. He stated that he preferred either option A(bricked version with no band) or B. Mr. Desrocher stated that option B's cap seems to overhang a lot more than the other versions. Ms. Herbert made a motion to install chimney caps on both chimney as per photograph B by going up a height of 4 bricks and adding a copper cap, retaining the existing brick band on one chimney and replicating the band on the second chimney. Copper cap to overhang no more than needed to protect band. Both chimneys to be fully parged and left natural in color. Repair and repoint chimneys as needed. When completed, both chimneys will look identical. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 35 Flint Street f June 15, 2005, Page 3 The Trustees of Bowditch Place Condominium submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for replacement of the area light located at the rear of the parking lot at the lobby entrance. The previous light fell down. The application is also for replacement of a roof deck. David Kitzmiller and Inga Milner represented the applicant. Ms. Herbert asked how many new light posts will be installed. Mr. Kitzmiller replied that it will be just one. Ms. Herbert asked the color of the post. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that it will be black. Ms. Herbert asked if it will be matte. Mr. Mangifesti stated that usually they are painted gloss, which will dull down. Ms. Herbert asked the material. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that he did not know. Mr. Mangifesti stated that it appears to be aluminum. Ms. Herbert asked the wattage. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that each of the two lamps will be 250 each, for a total of 500. Mary Simpson, 41 Flint Street, stated that she wanted to be sure that the light will not be thrown outward,just downward. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that there will be a lot less light than the previous lamp post. David Jaquith, 35 Flint Street, stated that he was in favor of the application. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that it is more of a decorative feature,than a need for light, and serves to indicate the location of the front door. Ms. Simpson stated that she was in favor of the light. Mr. Mangifesti made a motion to approve the light portion of the application as submitted. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Kitzmiller stated that the deck will not be visible from the public way and provided a drawing. Mr. Jaquith stated that the previous deck was barely visible in Winter and only from the cemetery on Essex Street. He added that, from the cemetery, you would not know which house had the deck. Mr. Mangifesti made a motion to approve the deck under non-applicability, conditional that it is non-visible from the public way. Ms. Herbert seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. l'1 June 15, 2005, Page 4 19 Chestnut Street Marshall Strauss and Elaine Gerdine presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to add a porch to the rear of the property similar in style and detail to the porch in the middle of the property (plans were provided). The application is also to replace a brick wall on Cambridge Street with a higher wall, not to exceed 6', using existing bricks. Mr. Strauss stated that the new porch will mimic the middle porch and will be located at the rear door which was recently approved and installed. Mr. Mangifesti stated that he felt it will look attractive and appropriate. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the porch as per plans submitted. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Gerdine stated that they forgot to bring the photo of the wall and noted that it is currently 4'l 0". The was once a filigree fence on top, but it is no longer there. They intend to reuse the granite cap and keep the existing columns. The only change is the raise in height. Mr. Mangifesti suggested that they contemplate rebuilding as is and putting something back on top. Ms. Gerdine stated that if that had the money, they would replace the cast iron fence. Ms. Herbert noted that the fencing on the property is a hodgepodge and suggested coming up with an overall fencing plan. Mr. Strauss stated that they were willing to continue the application, but would like advice on material. He noted that the mason would like to remove the entire wall, but noted that the granite foundation is solid. Ms. Herbert suggested considering all wood fencing and getting rid of the brick entirely. She suggested having the finials be consisted around the property and putting the two granite columns together to frame the driveway or together at the other end. Mr. Mangifesti noted that the granite posts are very difficult to move and that they may want to leave them in place as part of the history of the property. Ms. Herbert made a motion to continue the application. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 110 Derby Street June 15, 2005, Page 5 Dan and Lisa Fox submitted an application for a Certificate of Non-applicability to install a window off the kitchen and a French door off of the new office. The application states that neither will be visible from the street. Ms. Guy stated that she spoke to the applicant and also went by the property. The proposed location is on the side of the house,past the fence, inside the jog and past the existing window. She noted that the top half of the existing window is slightly visible from the street, although the opening between the two houses is very narrow. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms.Guy read a letter from BSC Group to Massachusetts Historical Commission(MHC)concerning a trench remediation project at 20 Pierce Avenue, to which MHC determined the project was unlikely to affect significant historical or archaeological resources. Ms. Guy read a letter from the MBTA in response to the letter sent by Mr. Kasparian regarding the Salem Signal Tower. Ms. Guy stated that Ms. Diozzi and Mr. Kasparian co-signed a support letter for the city's application to fund street lighting on North Street. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the minutes of June 1, 2005. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Herbert made a motion to approve the minutes of May 18, 2005. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Harper made a motion to approve the minutes of May 4, 2005. Mr. Mangifesti seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. There being no further business, Mr. Herbert made a motion to adjourn. Ms. Harper seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submitted, Jane A. Guy Clerk of the Commission Salem Historical Commission 120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978)745-9595 EXT.311 FAX(978)740-0404 CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction IDKI Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act(M.G.L. Ch. 40C)and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property• 3 1 5-3 t 7 Eccex Street Name of Record Owner: Stephen& Linda Moms Description of Work Proposed: Main building-Removal of synthetic siding and shutters. Repair/replace underlying wood clapboard siding, trim and watertable in kind. Reconstruct window casing and window pediments on front, second floor to match photo on 1967 inventoryform. Side windows to match window casing on abutting properties, including reconstruction of windows sills, if needed Option to install wood shutters on front favade(to be hung so as to be operable artd when closed ofsize to fill the window and hung to shed water away from window). Existing synthetic fascia and soffit to remain. Paint colors-Pewter Gray clapboards, white trim. Rear addition-Installation of wood clapboards,fascia, cornerboards and water table to match main house. Construction of overhang per drawings submitted with roof to match existing. Remove existing steel staircase and install new wood staircase in same footprint and configuration(run, landing). Railing/baluster style per postcard submitted and to meet building code, baluster 4"on center. Entire to be painted Pewter Gray, with treads to be painted Battleship Gray. Paint colors-Pewter Gray clapboards, white trim. Application is continued to meeting of April 6"in order to address potential issues discovered in the field Dated: March 23, 2005 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION The homeowner has the option not to commence the work unless it relates to resolving an outstanding ( g g violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals)prior to commencing work. l� Adequate and Qualified Local Government Commission PART B.1 Resumes for the two new Commission members are included. There are no updated resumes of existing members. PART B.2 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MEMBERSHIP As of 6/30/05, there are seven(7) Commission members and two (2) alternate members. PART B.3 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION PROFESSIONALS Professionals in Name Related Preservation Field Hannah Diozzi, Chair - Proprietor of architectural and historical walking tour company Lance Kasparian, Vice Chair X - Historical Architect Richard Stevens X - Renovation Craftsman Douglas Desrocher - Realtor Louis Mangifesti - Antique shop owner Larry Spang - Architect Jessica Herbert X- Developer of historic buildings, Realtor Michael Marcil, alternate -Non-profit management Kathryn Harper, alternate - Carpenter(licensed construction supervisor) PART B.4 VACANCIES/APPOINTMENTS In September, 2004, Rose Kilroy resigned from the Commission. Also in September, 2004, Hanna Diozzi was appointed to serve as a full member for a term to expire September 25,2007,to replace Ms. Kilroy. In November,2004,Douglas Desrocher was reappointed to the Commission for a term to expire March 1, 2007. In March, 2005, Commissioner Karam resigned from the Commission. Also in March,2005,Kathryn Harper was appointed to serve as an alternate member for a term to expire November 20, 2005, to replace Mr. Karam. Both Ms. Harper and Ms. Diozzi had expressed to the Mayor their interest in serving on this board. There are currently no member vacancies. On June 1,2005,Hannah Diozzi was voted in as the new Chair of the Commission and Lance Kasparian as the Vice Chair. PART B.5 CLG TRAINING SESSIONSIWORKSHOPS Doug Desrocher, Hannah Diozzi, Lance Kasparian and Jane Guy attended the following: • Massachusetts Historical Commission 2004 Statewide Historic Preservation Conference, Salem, MA, September, 2004 Hannah Diozzi attended the following: • Training lectures sponsored by Boston by Foot: The Architecture of the Federal City, Boston Architectural Center,April 2005. • Training lectures sponsored by Boston by Foot: The Architecture of the Victorian City, Boston Architectural Center, April 2005. Lance Kasparian attended the following: • Rhode Island Historic Preservation Commission Conference, April 2005 • Glass Painting 1800-1900 at the British Society of Master Glasspainter's conference, March 2005 • 16 hr. class entitled "The International Building Code - Fire Protection Concepts and Life Safety Concepts" provided by Code Access, Inc. (16 AIA cc units), August 2004 } HANNAH DIOZZI 20 Pleasant Street Salem, Massachusetts 01970 978-741-1154 EDUCATION Marymount College, B.A., Boston College, M.Ed. Boston by Foot Docent Training Course at Boston Architectural Center EMPLOYMENT Founder and proprietor- Salem Strolls, an architectural and historical walking tour company in Salem MA 2004 Program coordinator- Boston by Foot, Boston MA 1999-2003; responsibilities included volunteer scheduling, marketing, arranging group tours, database maintenance, committee and member support. Data analyst, researcher- Banker & Tradesman, Boston MA 1991-1999; duties included database maintenance, proofreading, statistical analysis, quality assurance, writing training manuals. Real estate broker- 1978-1990 COMMUNITY/VOLUNTEER WORK Medford MA Historical Commission - member 1994-2001 ; chairperson 1998-2001 . Worked with home and business owners, architects, attorneys, city officials, and the Medford School Building Committee to encourage the preservation of the city's historic heritage; and where applicable, to enforce the Historic District and Demolition Delay ordinances. Boston by Foot- Volunteer guide 199S-present; specializing in Colonial Boston/Heart of the Freedom Trail, Federal Architecture of Beacon Hill; Victorian Back Bay; also served as continuing education co-chairperson, and in that capacity developed and led tours of Historic Medford and the Salem Waterfront. St Joseph's Food Pantry, Salem MA - volunteer grocery distributor. Salem Common Neighborhood Association - board member. Salem Garden Club - member Mar 23 05 02: 51p r• � I ✓ Kathryn Harper 3 Allen Street Salem,MA 01970 Y / CAREER SUMMARY Education: Michigan State University Salem State College Profession: Carpenter (Licensed Construction Supervisor) Career related courses: Boston Architectural Center Wentworth Institute of Technology Northeastern University Building Technology Program North Bennet Street School WorWJob Experience: 1984-present— Westin Hotel Copley Square,carpenter on staff 1984-- Lindentree Construction(residential carpentry) 1983 — Stephen Till,Inc.(residential carpentry) 1982— Jan Wampler Architects(residential carpentry) 1980-81 —National Park Service: Salem Maritime Site Hartwell Tavern,Lincoln(restoration) Other restoration dt preservation projects 1980— Hewett Company,Framingham,(residential carpentry) 4 li it National Register Proeram Participation PART C.1 CLG EVALUATIONS COMPLETED There were no evaluations completed. PART C.2 NOMINATIONS There were no nominations prepared and submitted to Massachusetts Historical Commission. PART C.3 PUBLIC HEARINGS There were no public hearings regarding nominations held during the fiscal year. PART CA PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE No professional expertise was hired during this fiscal year regarding nominations. 1 Survey and Inventory of Historic Properties PART D.1 D.2 D.3 There were no survey forms produced or updated this year. There is no change in the status of the inventory in terms of its organization, storage, accessibility, etc. They are accessible for public view at the Department of Planning & Community Development located at 120 Washington Street. Public Participation PART E.1 COMMISSION MEETING DATES: July 7, 2004 July 21, 2004 August 4, 2004 August 18, 2004 September 4, 2004, site visit September 11, 2004, site visit September 15, 2004 October 6, 2004 October 20, 2004 November 3, 2004 November 17, 2004 December 1, 2004 December 15, 2004 January 5, 2005 January 19, 2005 February 16, 2005 March 2, 2005 March 16, 2005 April 6, 2005 April 20, 2005 May 4, 2005 May 18, 2005 June 1, 2005 June 15, 2005 PART E.3 ACCESSIBILITY OF MINUTES There has been no change in the accessibility of Commission minutes. They are accessible for public view at the Department of Planning&Community Development(located at 120 Washington Street). PART EA RULES, PROCEDURES, GUIDELINES There were no changes in rules, procedures or guidelines adopted by the Commission. OPEN MEETING LAW COMPLIANCE STATEMENT 1. All meetings of the CLGC have been open to the public. 2. A notice of the date,time and place of every meeting of the CLGC has been filed with the Clerk of the city or town in which the CLGC acts and a copy of such notice has been posted in the office of the Clerk on the principal bulletin board of each city or town at least 48 hours prior to the time of each meeting, excluding Sundays and legal holidays. 3. A record of every meeting, including executive sessions has been maintained by the CLGC, including the date,time, place, members present and actions taken at each meeting. 4. All executive sessions, if any, have been held in compliance with M.G.L. C. 39, Section 23B. 5. No chance meeting or social meeting has been used to circumvent the spirit or requirements of the Open Meeting Law or to discuss or act upon a matter over which the CLGC has supervision, control,jurisdiction, or advisory power. Date ���� Chairperson,CLGC Funding of CLG Activities PART F.1 LOCAL FUNDING The annual local funding budget appropriation under the authority of the Salem Historical Commission was $6,624 for personnel services and $1,609 for nonpersonnel expenses. PART F.2 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT FUNDING In April, 2005, the City of Salem received an $15,000 funding award from the FY05 Survey and Planning Grant program to support a Point Neighborhood Preservation Plan for a total project cost of $30,000. PART F.3 OTHER FUNDING No other public or private grants were received. i Other Activities The City of Salem,the Department of Conservation and Recreation �M •m,. and the Essex National Heritage Commission,through the �� ^^^��°��^°• Massachusetts Heritage Landscape Inventory Program, issued the Salem Reconnaissance Report. Diverse priority landscapes including historic residential neighborhoods,parks and open space, Salem's �.-- coastline,burial grounds and cemeteries were identified by residents and community organizations and this report was created on how these community treasures can be preserved for future generations. Jessica Herbert participated in the project. The Commission issued a letter of support for the Pickering ._ Foundation's application for Massachusetts Preservation Projects Funds for which the foundation received a$20,000 grant. Larry Spring is serving as the Commission's representative for the Salem Redevelopment Authority's committee to redevelop the old Salem Jail. Lance Kasparian worked extensively with the Salem Common Neighborhood Association,who applied for and received a grant from the Essex National Heritage Commission to restore the Roger Conant Statue,the P most photographed bronze in the country. Restoration to be completed in Summer,2005. The Commission voted to concur with the amendment to the Memorandum of Agreement for the Salem- Beverly Transportation Project to remove Stipulation#3. The Commission issued a letter of support for the nomination of the New Central Campus facility at Salem State College for a 2005 Preservation Award. The Commission issued a letter of support for the City of Salem's Massachusetts Preservation Projects Funds grant application for an elevator at City Hall. The Commission issued a letter of support for the City of Salem's grant application for street lighting on North Street. The City of Salem completed the Survey and Planning Grant ' project to develop a design guidelines manual for Salem's Urban Renewal Area, historic districts and major entrance corridors. Lance Kasparian and Jane Guy provided input into the project and participated in the review.