The URL can be used to link to this page

HISCOM - BUDGET, ANNUAL REPORTS FY99 Hiscom - Budget, annual reports _ I I � � r SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION ANNUAL REPORT JULY 1, 1998 - JUNE -30, 1999 Ladies and Gentlemen: L Certificates Issued During the year July 1, 1998 through June 30, 1999, the Salem Historical Commission met regularly 23 times and had five site visits during which a quorum was present. In its capacity as Historic District Commission for 4 local districts, the Commission filed: - 79 Certificates of Appropriateness; - 0 Certificates of Hardship; - 89 Certificates of Non-Applicability; - 2 Waivers of the Demolition Delay Ordinance; and - 8 Denials including: - 5 for a Certificate of Appropriateness; - 0 for a Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance; - 2 for a Certificate of Non-Applicability; I for a Certificate of Hardship; and - 1 Preliminary denial for a Waiver of the Demolition Delay Ordinance. Certificates issued are provided to the owner of the property, the City Clerk, the Building Inspector and are kept on file in the Salem Planning Department according to address. A list of all Certificates issued can be found in the Certified Local Government Annual Report which is on file at the Salem Planning Department and the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Minutes of all meetings are also available at the Salem Planning Department. H. Commission Members As of 6/30/99, there are six (7) Commission members and one (1) alternate. Appointed members are Helen Sides, Chair; Douglas Kelleher; Vice Chair; Lance Kasparian, Deborah Guinee, Douglas Karam, Richard Stevens, Douglas Desrocher and Louis Mangifesti. Douglas Desrocher was appointed to the Commission on March 11, 1999 as a full member replacing Robert Jellison who resigned from the Commission in January, 1999. Louis Mangifesti was appointed to the Commission on May 13, 1999 as an alternate member. He fills the vacancy left by Kathleen Maark who stopped attending meetings in April, 1997. There is currently one alternate member vacancy. M. Workshops/Seminars Helen Sides and Douglas Karam attended Build Boston in November, 1998. Douglas Kelleher attended MHC's "Making Connections" Conference, Sept. 25, 1998. IV. Preservation Awards On the evening of Thursday, May 20 1999,the Salem Historical Commission presented its 1999 Preservation Awards at the Historic Salem, Inc. Annual Meeting held at the National Park Service Visitor's Center. The recipients from local historic districts were: • 144-146 Federal Street, (Robert Ouellette & Michaeline LaRoche) Excellence in Restoration • 7 Carpenter Street, (James Nicholson& Bart Bussink) Excellence in Renovation • 24 1/2 Winter Street, (Paul & Sasha Durand) Excellence in Fence Construction • 19 Flint Street, (Gary & Barbara Wuertz) Excellence in Restoration • 4 Carpenter Street (Cynthia Duda) Excellence in Restoration • 337 Essex St. (Salem Athenaeum) —Preservation Award for Preservation and Maintenance (roof replacement) (the project utilized Massachusetts Preservation Project Funds matching grant funding) Honorable Mention Awards: • 53 Summer Street (Dolores Nangle), Exterior Rehabilitation From outside local historic districts, the recipients are: • 8 Forrester St. (Michael & Michelle Parr) Preservation Award for Painting (the project utilized funds provided by the Salem Planning Department's Housing Rehabilitation Program which is funded by the Community Development Block Grant) • 49 Ocean Ave (Jean Townsend) Preservation Award for Painting • 23 Summer St. (Walter and the late Joyce Cook) Exterior Renovations Honorable Mention Awards: • 51-53 Washington Sq. (Ellen Dixey)Excellence in Restoration • 32 Forrester Street (Larry & Diane Sinclair) Preservation Award for Painting V. Other Activities The Commission issued letters of support for an application by the Salem Planning Department for a Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund (MPPF) grant for the restoration of the windows at City Hall, for an application by the Saint Nicholas Russian Orthodox Church for a MPPF grant, for Historic Salem, Inc.'s MPPF grant application for a pre- development study of the Bowditch House and an Essex National Heritage Area grant application by the North River Historic Neighborhood Association to undertake a National Register nomination for the Bridge Street neck area. The Commission approved a plan for handicapped access to the Salem Post Office and continues to remain an interested party in the expansion of the Peabody Essex Museum, the MBTA garage design and the Salem Beverly Transportation Project. The Commission reviewed and commented on plans for improvements to the Carlton, Witchcraft Heights and Salem High Schools and for construction of the new K-8 school. The Commission commented positively on the proposed painting of the marketplace stalls being done through the Market and Tourist Commission. This report was completed by Jane A. Guy on behalf of the Salem Planning Department and the Salem Historical Commission. Respectfully submitted, Ja A. Guy Cl k of the Salem storical Commission J l J / / J r / Jl ANNUAL REPORT CITY OF SALEM CERTIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT JULY 1, 1998 THRU JUNE 30, 1999 CERTIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT ANNUAL REPORT CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS JULY 1, 1998 -JUNE 30, 1999 PART A-ENFORCEMENT OF LOCAL LEGISLATION 1. Cases Reviewed 2. Sample Minutes 3. Sample Decision PART B -ADEQUATE AND QUALIFIED LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMISSION 1. Resumes 2. Membership 3. Professionals 4. Vacancies/Appointments 5. CLG Training Sessions/Workshops PART C -NATIONAL REGISTER PROGRAM PARTICIPATION 1. CLG Evaluations 2. Nominations 3. Public Hearings 4. Professional Expertise PART D- SURVEY AND INVENTORY OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES 1. Survey Forms 2. Survey Work 3. Inventory Status PART E-PUBLIC PARTICIPATION 1. Commission Meeting Dates 2. Open Meeting Law Compliance Statement 3. Accessibility of Minutes 4. Rules,Procedures, Guidelines PART F- FUNDING OF CLG ACTIVITIES 1. Local Funding 2. Survey and Planning Grant Funding 3. Other Funding PART G-MISCELLANEOUS 1. Preservation Awards This report was completed by Jane A. Guy,Assistant Community Development Director on behalf of the Salem Planning Department and the Salem Historical Commission under the administration of Mayor Stanley J. Usovicz,Jr. APPLICATIONS REVIEWED 7/1/98-6/30/99 Page 1 NEW OR TYPE OF WORK APPLIC. CERT. CERT. DATE CONT'D ADDRESS NAME ALTER/NEW CON/DEMOL/NON-APP. DISTRICT DATE APPLIED ISSUED ISSUED COMMENTS July 1, 1998 meeting: .. C 7 CARPENTER ST. NICHOLSON ETAL X X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP CONTINUE FACADE TREATMENT,WINDOWS,REPAIRS,PAINT N/A 7/5/98 FACADE ALTERATION ' C 134 FEDERAL ST. NICHOLSON X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP. CONTINUE GARAGE&PORCH RAILINGS N/A 7/5/98 FACIA REPAIR APPROP. 7/5/98 WINDOW REPLACEMENT C 5 HARRINGTON CT. LUSSIER X MCINTIRE 5/14/98 HARD. CONTINUE VINYL WINDOWS C 54 TURNER ST. 7 GABLES X DERBY 6/1/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/5/98 SIGNAGE N 6 ANDOVER ST, NICHOLAS X MCINTIRE 6/8/98 APPROP. APPROP 7/5/98 VARIOUS IMPROVEMENTS N 18 BROAD ST. PICKERING X MCINTIRE 6/16/98 APPROP. CONTINUE N 4 S.PINE ST. SILVIA X MCINTIrE 7/1/98 N/A N/A 7/5/98 ROOF July 15, 1998 meeting: N 10 HATHORNE ST. BROOKS X MCINTIRE 6/2/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/16/98 PAINT COLORS N 385 ESSEX ST. GRACE CH. X MCINTIRE 6/29/98 APPROP. APPROP. 6/29/98 PAINT COLORS - C 7 CARPENTER ST. NICHOLSON ETAL X X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP CONTINUE FACADE TREATMENT,WINDOWS,REPAIRS,PAINT C 134 FEDERAL ST. NICHOLSON X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/16/98 GARAGE ROOF CONTINUE PORCH RAILINGS C 5 HARRINGTON CT. LUSSIER X MCINTIRE 5/14/98 HARD. CONTINUE VINYL WINDOWS C 18 BROAD ST. PICKERING X MCINTIRE 6/16/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/16/98 GAZEBO DEMOLITION N 110 DERBY ST. 7GABLES X DERBY 6/17/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/16/98 WINDOW BOXES N 3 CAMBRIDGE ST. KELLEY X MCINTIRE 6/17/98 N/A N/A 7/16/98 FENCE X APROP. APROVED UNDER N/A N 19 FLINT ST. WUERTZ X MCINTIRE 6/22/98 APPROP. APPROP. 7/16/98 VARIOUS IMPROVEMENTS N 23 WARREN ST. GAULL X MCINTIRE By 6/29/98 APPROP.APPROP. 7/16/98 FENCE N 301 LAFAYETTE ST. GALARIS X LAFAY. By 6/29/98 APPROP.OUT OF JURISIDICTION(SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR RECONSTRUCTION AFTER FIRE DAMAGE N 74 WASHINGTON SQ. SHERR X WASH. 6/29/98 APPROP. N/A 7/16/98 GARAGE N 15 CAMBRIDGE ST. GUINEE X MCINTIRE 7/15/98 N/A N/A 7/16/98 REPAINT August 5, 1998 meeting: N 4 SOUTH PINE ST. SILVIA X MCINTIRE 7/14/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/6/98 PAINT FENCE N 181 FEDERAL ST. LALLY X MCINTIRE 7/9/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/6/98 PAINT CHANGE,SHUTTERS C 7 CARPENTER ST. NICHOLSON ETAL X X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP CONTINUE PAINT,DOORS APPROP. 8/6/98 FACADE TREATMENTS,FENCE C 134 FEDERAL ST. NICHOLSON X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP. WITHDRAWN RAILINGS N 2 BOTTS COURT USOVICZ X MCINTIRE 7/21/98 APPROP. APPROP 7/21/98 HAND RAILINGS N 10 HAMILTON ST. PAUUKELLY X MCINTIRE 7/16/98 APPROOP. APPROP. 8/6/98 FENCE X 7/16/98 N/A N/A 8/6/98 REAR LANDING N 9 CAMBRIDGE ST. COYLE X MCINTIRE 7/21/98 APPROP. N/A 8/6/98 FRONT STEPS N 274 LAFAYETCE ST. RONAN X LAFAY. 7/20/98 APPROP. CONTINUED August 19, 1998 meeting: C 7 CARPENTER ST. NICHOLSON ETAL X X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP CONTINUE PAINT,DOORS C 274 LAFAYETTE ST. RONAN X LAFAY. 7/20/98 APPROP. CONTINUED N 28-28'/1 BROAD ST. MORGAN X MCINTIRE 7/21/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/25/98 PAINT CONTINUE EXTERIORSTAIR ily N I10 DERBY ST. 7 GABLES X DERBY 7/23/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/25/98 SIGN N 2813ECKFORD ST. STAUFFER X MCINTIRE 7/28/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/25/98 GUTTERS,DOWNSPOUTS N 144-146 FEDERAL ST. OUELLETTE X MCINTIRE 8/3/98 N/A N/A 8/25/98 REAR FAI)ADE AL'T'ERATIONS X APPROP. APPROP. 8/25/98 PAINT, WINDOWS CONTINUE WINDOW&DOOR ALTERATIONS 75 WARREN ST. CHAFE X MCINTIRE 8/3/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/25/98 STONE WALL September 2, 1998 meeting: N 319 ESSEX ST. SCHUERGER X MCINTIRE 8/12/98 APROP. APPROP. 9/3/98 PAINT COLORS C 7 CARPENTER ST. NICHOLSON ETAL X MCINTIRE 4/29/98 APPROP DENIAL 9/3/98 PAINT,DOORS C 274 LAFAYETTE ST. RONAN X LAFAY. 7/20/98 APPROP. CONTINUED C 28-28 9n BROAD ST. MORGAN X MCINTIRE 7/21/98 APPROP, N/A 9/3/98 STAIRCASE C 144-146 FEDERAL ST. OUELLETTE X MCINTIRE 8/3/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/3/98 WINDOW&DOOR ALTERATIONS N 35 WASH.SQ. DOERING X WASH. 8/6/98 APPROP. CONTINUE TRASH ENCLOSURE N 164 FEDERAL ST. BIMBO X MCINTIRE 8/10/98 APPROP. N/A 9/3/98 GARAGE REPLACEMENT CONTINUE GARAGE DOORS N 29 CHESTNUT ST. WANNEMACHER X MCINTIRE 8/12/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/3/98 GARAGE ALTERATIONS N l l CAMBRIDGE ST. FLAHERTY X MCINTIRE 8/17/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/3/98 FENCE N 61 SUMMER ST. PELLETIER/OVERBERG X MCINTIRE N/A N/A 9/3/98 WINDOWS,ROOF SKYLIGHT CONTINUE WINDOW September 16, 1998 meeting: C 5 HARRINGTON CT. LUSSIER X MCINTIRE 5/14/98 HARD. CONTINUE VINYL WINDOWS C 274 LAFAYETTE ST. RONAN X LAFAY. 7/20/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/17/98 FENCE/GATE C 35 WASH.SQ. DOERING X WASH. 8/6/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/17/98 TRASH ENCLOSURE C 164 FEDERAL ST. BIMBO X MCINTIRE 8/10/98 APPROP. N/A 9/17/98 GARAGE DOORS N 153 FEDERAL ST. YALE X MCINTIRE 8/21/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/17/98 SHED ALTERATIONS N 61 SUMMER ST, PELLETIER/OVERBERG X MCINTIRE N/A CONTINUE WINDOW APPROP. APPROP. 9/17/98 PAINT,VENTS APPROP. CONTINUE WINDOW September 19,1998 Site visit: C 61 SUMMER ST. PELLETIER/OVERBERG X MCINTIRE N/A APPROP. 10/8/98 KITCHEN WINDOW APPROP. DENIEAL 10/8/98 BATHROOM WINDOW October?, 1998 meeting: N 47 OCEAN AVE. AMC,INC. X LAFAY. 9/18/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 PAINT COLORS C 5 HARRINGTON CT. LUSSIER X MCINTIRE 5/14/98 HARD. CONTINUE VINYL WINDOWS N 55 SUMMER ST. MURRAY X MCINTIRE 9/4/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 PAINT COLORS N/A N/A 10/8/98 PORCH,SHUTTERS,CLAPBOARDS,MOLDING N 300 LAFAYETTE ST. GOGGIN X LAFAY. 9/10/98 APPROP. CONTINUED N 7 CARPENTER ST.NICHOLSONBUSSINK X MCINTIRE 9/17/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 PAINT CONTINUED DOORS N 15 RIVER ST. PETERSON/DEAN X MCINTIRE 9/21/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 GUTTERS,DOWNSPOUTS,ICE SHIELD N 35 FLINT ST. BOWDITH CONDOS. X MCINTIRE 9/22/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 LIGHT POLE CONTINUED AWNING N 61R SUMMER ST. PELLETIER/OVERBERG X MCINTIRE 9/22/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/8/98 DOORS N 80 MARGIN ST. FITZGERALD X MCINTIRE 10/6/98 WDDO WDDO 10/8/98 GARAGE DEMOLITION October 21, 1998 meeting: i C 5 HARRINGTON CT. LUSSIER X MCINTIRE 5/14/98 HARD. DENIAL 10/22/98 VINYL WINDOWS C 300 LAFAYETTE ST. GOGGIN X LAFAY. 9/10/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/22/98 PORCH RAILING C 7 CARPENTER ST.NICHOLSONBUSSINK X MCINTIRE 9/17/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/22/98 FRONT DOOR C 35 FLINT ST. BOWDITH CONDOS. X MCINTIRE 9/22/98 APPROP. APPROP, 10/22/98 AWNING j N 120 ESSEX ST. PEABODY ESSEX X WASH.SQ. 9/30/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/22/98 FENCE N 0 N.PINE ST. GEARY X MCINTIRE 10/5/98 APPROP. APPROP, 10/22/98 FENCE N 115 FEDERAL ST. MELIS X MCINTIRE 10/1/98 APPROP. APPROP. 10/22/98 LOUVER November 4, 1998 meeting N 10HATHORNEST. BROOKS X MCINTIRE 10/13/98APPROP. APPROP, II/5/98 WINDOWS N/ USSINK X MCINTIRE 10/19/98 APPROP. APPROP. 11/5/98 FAQADE ALTERATION November I8, 1998 meeting: ! N 9 WARREN ST. WATHNE X MCINTIRE 10/26/98 APPROP. APPROP. 11/19/98 GUTTERS N 78 WASH.SQ.E SKOMURSKI X WASH. 11/2/98 APPROP. APPROP, 11/19/98 ROOF N 74 WASH.SQ. SHERR X WASH. 11/18/98 N/A N/A 11/19/98 WINDOWS/DOOR N 8 BROAD ST. BLIER X MCINTIRE 10/8/98 N/A DENIAL 11/19/98 DOWNSPOUTS N 6 CAMBRIDGE ST. BEDELL X MCINTIRE 10/29/98 APPROP. APPROP. 11/19/98 GUTTERS,CLAPBOARDS,PAINT i December 2, 1998 meeting: ! N 174 FEDERAL ST. WALLACE X MCINTIRE 11/20/98 N/A N/A 12/3/98 SECONDARY EGRESS N 8 BOTTS COURT MERRY X MCINTIRE 11/17/98 APPROP. APPROP. 12//3/98 DECK COLOR I i January 6, 1999 meeting: N 57 SUMMER ST. RITCHIE/HOGAN X MCINTIRE 12/15/98 APPROP. APPROP. 1/7/99 CLAPBOARDS,PAINT N 6 NORTH PINE ST. GRUNDY X MCINTIRE 12/21/98 APPROP. APPROP. 1/7/99 WINDOW REPLACEMENT DENIAL I/7/99 WINDOW REPLACEMENT ` N/A 1/7/99 WINDOW REPLACEMENT N 174 FEDERAL ST. WALLACE X MCINTIRE 12/21/98 APPROP. APPROP. I/7/99 WINDOW RELOCATION N 9 CHESTNUT ST. HAMILTON HALL X MCINTIRE 12/7/98 APPROP. APPROP. 1/7/99 EXHAUST PIPES,REMOVE DOOR January 20, 1999 meeting: N 0 N.PINE ST. GEARY X MCINTIRE APPROP. 1/21/99 AMEND FENCE CERTIFICATE N/A 1/21/99 DOOR&THRESHOLD N 155 FEDERALST. JARNIS/BUSO X MCINTIRE 1/6/99 APPROP. APPROP. 1/21/99 WINDOW ALTERATION February 3, 1999 meeting: N 155-189WASH.ST. VAN NESS DEV. X N/A 1/11/99 WDDO CONTINUE February 17,1999 meeting: N 132 ESSEX ST. PEABODY/ESSEX X WASH.SQ. 2/2/99 APPROP. APPROP. 2/18/99 SIGNS,BANNERS,FENCE PAINT March 3, 1999 meeting: N 155-189 WASH.ST. VAN NESS DEV. X N/A 1/11/99 WDDO Prel.Den. 3/5/99 Demolition of structures March 24, 1999 meeting: N 302 LAFAYETTE ST. 302 LAF.ST.SRT X LAFAY. 2/23/99 APPROP. APPROP. 3/25/99 PANEL REMOVAL,PAINT COLORS N 58 DERBY ST. PHOENIX RET X DEBBY 2/26/99 APPROP. APPROP. 3/25/99 REMOVE CHIMNEY,EXTEND PREVIOUS CERTS. N 144-146 FEDERAL ST. LAROCHE/OUELLETTE X MCINTIRE 3/3/99 APPROP. APPROP. 3/25/99 VENTS,GUTTERS,DOWNSPOUTS,BULKHEAD N 45-53&59 BOSTON ST.SUNCOR DEVEL. X N/A 3/23/99 WDDO WDDO 3/25/99 DEMOLISH BUILDINGS April 7, 1999 meeting: N 262 LAFAYET TE ST. BATES CONDOS - X LAFAY. 2/23/99 APPROP. CONTINUED N 6 CAMBRIDGE ST. BEDELL X MCINTIRE 3/11/99 APPROP. CON'T'INUED N 0 N.PINE ST. GEARY X MCINTIRE 3/22/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/8/99 DOOR,WINDOW BOX N 3 LYNN ST. BRANDT/ROKA X MCINTIRE 3/23/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/8/99 SIDING April 21. 1999 meetine: April 21, 1999 meeting: C 262 LAFAYETTE ST. BATES HOUSE X LAFAY. 2/23/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/22/99 PAINT COLORS C 6 CAMBRIDGE ST. BEDELL X MCINTIRE 3/11/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/22/99 FACADE ALTERATIOSN CONTINUE OPTIONAL N 12 BROAD ST. ENGEL X MCINTIRE 4/5/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/22/99 ROOF REPLACEMENT _ CONTINUE OPTIONAL COLOR N IA CAMBRIDGE ST. KEARNEY X MCINTIRE 4/5/99 APPROP. APROP. 4/22/99 GUTTERS&DOWNSPOUTS N 12 CHESTNUT ST. WYKE X MCINTIRE 4/5/99 APPROP. APPROP. 4/22/99 FENCE ALTERATION May 5, 1999 meeting: - N 175 FEDERAL ST. MECHE X MCINTIRE 4/16/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/6/99 PAINT COLORS N 6&8 HAMILTON ST. LATTA R.T. X MCINTIRE 4/19/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/6/99 FENCE CONSTRUCTION N 10 HATHORNE ST. BROOKS X MCINTIRE 4/16/99 APPROP. DENIAL 5/6/99 LAMPPOSTS N 19 FOWLER ST. BEAN X MCINTIRE 4/20/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/6/99 CHIMNEY CAP C 6 CAMBRIDGE ST. BEDELL X MCINTIRE 3/11/99 APPROP. DENIAL 5/6/99 OPTIONAL FACADE ALTERATION(BAY) C 12 BROAD ST. ENGEL X MCINTIRE 4/5/99 APPROP. CONTINUE OPTION ROOF COLOR N 392 ESSEX ST. BAILEY X MCINTIRE By 5/5/99 N/A OUT OF JURISIDICTION(SUBSTANTIALLY SIMILAR RECONSTRUCTION AFTER FIRE DAMAGE) May 19, 1999 meeting: N 6 ANDOVER ST. NICHOLASIROURKE X MCINTIRE 4/22/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/99 PAINT COLORS N 49 SUMMER ST. SAMRA X MCINTIRE 4/30/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/99 PAINT,DOWNSPOUTS,REPAIRS N 23 WARREN ST. GAULL X MCINITRE 4/23/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/99 FENCE CONSTRUCTION N 35 FLINT ST. BOWDTTCH CONDOS X MCINTIRE 4/29/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/99 FENCING N 25 WARREN ST. CHAFE X MCINTIRE 5/3/99 APPROP. APPROP. 5/20/99 FENCE,PAINT,REPAIRS,WINDOWS BOXES N 21 CHESTNUT ST. KSANDER X MCINTIRE 5/3/99 APPROP. CONTINUED N 13 CHESTNUT ST. ZAIDO X MCINTIRE 5/5/99 N/A DENIAL 5120/99 WINDOW ALTERATION June 2, 1999 meeting: C 21 CHESTNUT ST. KSANDER X MCINTIRE 5/3/99 APPROP. APPROP. 6/3/99 BALUSTRADE N/A 6/3/99 ROOF AIR CONDITIONING UNIT N 13 CHESTNUT ST. ZAIDO- X MCINTIRE 5/11/99 APPROP. APPROP. 6/3/99 WINDOW ALTERATION N 10 HATHORNE ST. BROOKS X NICINTIRE 5/13/99 APPROP. WITHDRAWN STAINED GLASS WINDOWS June 16, 1999 meeting: N 42 CIIESTNUT ST. GREER X MCINTIRE 5/28/99 APPROP. CONTINUED APPROP. 6/17/99 PORCH CONSTRUCTION(APPROVED AT SITE VISIT) N 149 FEDERAL ST. ARCHAMBAULT X MCINTIRE 5/19/99 APROP. APPROP. 6/17/99 GATE REINSTALLATION NON-MEETING APPROVALS: N 6 BOTTS CT. PETERSON X MCINTIRE 7/1/98 N/A N/A 7/1/98 REPAINT N 121 FEDERAL ST. LENNEY X MCINTIRE 6/30/98 N/A N/A 7/1/98 ROOF OF ADDITION N 8 KOSCIUSKO ST. NEMIROUSKY X DERBY 7/7/98 N/A N/A 7/7/98 REPAINT N 9 CHESTNUT ST. HAMILTON HALL X MCINTIRE 7/7/98 N/A N/A 7/7/98 REPAIR PEDIMENT N 6&8 HAMILTON LATTA RT X MCINTIRE 7/13/98 N/A N/A 7/13/98 REPAIR WOOD TRIM,REPAINT N 50 DERBY ST. CORNEAU X DERBY 7/30/98 N/A N/A 7/30/98 OVERHANG,COLUMN,ROOFING AT FRONT DOOR N 22 CHESTNUT ST. COHEN/BARROWS X MCINTIRE 7/22/98 N/A N/A 7/22/98 REPAINT N 27 BROAD ST. PUTNAM X MCINTIRE 8/11/98 N/A N/A 8/11/98 ROOFING,CHIMNEY FLASHING N 56 WASH.SQ. . DUBRULE X WASH.SQ. 8/12/98 N/A N/A 8/12/98 PAINTING N 15 HATHORNE ST. PAULI X MCINTIRE 8/27/98 N/A N/A 8/27/98 WINDOW PANES,REPAINT X MCINTIRE 8/27/98 APPROP. APPROP. 8/27/98 ROOF N 38 WARREN ST. BOYLES X MCINTIRE 8/26/98 N/A N/A 8/26/98 REPAIINT N 278 LFAYETTE ST. PLAMONDON X LAFAY. 8/25/98 N/A N/A 8/25/98 REPAINT N 47 OCEAN AVE. AMC,INC. X LAFAY. 9/2/98 N/A N/A 9/2/98 VARIOUS REPAIRS N 32 BROAD ST. GLASS X MCINTIRE 8/13/98 N/A N/A 8/14/98 REPAIRS/REPAINT N l HARRINGTON CT. CLEVELAND X MCINTIRE 8/20/98 N/A N/A 8/25/98 PORCH N 313 ESSEX ST. HELLER X MCINTIRE 8/24/98 N/A N/A 8/25/98 REROOF N 78 FEDERAL ST. ALLA X MCINTIRE 9/15/98 N/A N/A 9/15/98 CHIMNEY N 263LAFAYETPE ST. GIANOULIS X MCINTIRE 9/11/98 N/A N/A 9/11/98 REROOFING N 6 SOUTH PINE ST. BUCHANAN X NICINTIRE 9/18/98 APPROP. APPROP. 9/21/98 ROOF N 7SOUTH PINE ST. TARNOWSKI X MCINTIRE 9/21/98 N/A N/A 9/21/98 REPAINT N 8CHESTNUT ST. BUSTEED X MCINTIRE 9/21/98 N/A N/A 9/21/98 FENCE N 132 ESSEX ST. PEABODY ESSEX X WASH.SQ. 10/13/98 N/A N/A 10/13/98 REROOFING N 8 BROAD ST. BLIER X MCINTIRE 10/8/98 N/A N/A 10/8/98 REPAIRS,REPAINT N 8 BECKFORD ST. CASSELLA X MCINTIRE 10/21/98 N/A N/A 10/21/98 REPAINT N 78 WASH.SQ. SKOMURSKI X WASH.SQ. 11/2/98 APPROP APPROP 11/2/98 ROOF N 17 BECKFORD ST. COPELAS X MCINTIRE 10/30/98 N/A N/A 10/30/98 WINDOWS N 262 LAFAYETTE ST. BATE HOUSE CONDO X LAFAY. 11/2/98 N/A N/A 11/4/98 ROOF N 7 SOUTH PINE ST. TARNOWSKI X MCINTIRE 11/9/98 N/A N/A 11/9/98 ROOF N 8 BOTTS CT. MERRY X MCINTIRE 11/18/98 N/A N/A 11/18/98 PORCH N 174 FEDERAL ST, WALLACE X MCINTIRE 11/19/98 N/A N/A 11/19/98 ROOF N 25 WASHINGTON SQ. GAGNON X WASH. 11/23/98 N/A N/A 11/23/98 SHINGLES N 24'/1 WINTER ST. DURAND X WASH. 12/7/98 N/A N/A 12/7/98 RANGE EXHAUST,SIDING N 174 FEDERAL ST. WALLACE X MCINTIRE 12/8/98 N/A N/A 12/8/98 ROOF2odhalf N 171 FEDERAL ST. GERBUTAVICH/SABUTIS X MCINTIRE 12/14/98 N/A N/A 12/15/98 WINDOWS N 17 NORTH ST. ELKS LODGE X MCINTIRE 1/5/99 N/A N/A 1/5/99 SIGN REPLACEMENT N 144-146FEDERALST. LAROCHE/OUELLETTE X MCINTIRE 1/20/99 N/A N/A 1/20/99 DECK CONSTRUCTION N 24'/1 WINSTER ST. DURAND X WASH.SQ. 2/17/99 N/A N/A 2/17/99 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 6CAMBRIDGE ST. WANGBEDELL X MCINTIRE 3/11/99 N/A N/A 3/12/99 WINDOWS N 6 BROAD ST. NALIPINSKI X MCINTIRE 3/17/99 N/A N/A 3/17/99 CLAPBOARDS,REPAINT N 10 HATHORNE ST. BROOKS X MCINTIRE 3/18/99 N/A N/A 3/22/99 WINDOWS N 7 HAMILTON ST. KEACH RLT X MCINTIRE 3/24/99 N/A N/A 3/24/99 FLAT ROOF N 3 LYNN ST. BRANDT/ROKA X MCINTIRE 3/23/9 N/A N/A 3/23/99 TRIM,MOLDING,REPAINT N 31-35 WARREN ST. PHILLIPS TRUST X MCINTIRE 3/26/99 N/A N/A 3/26/99 REPAIRS/REPAINT N IACAMBRIDGEST. KEARNEY X MCINTIRE 4/5/99 N/A N/A 4/5/99 REPAIRS/REPAINT N 22 BECKFORD ST. BURNS X MCINTIRE 4/21/99 N/A N/A 4/22/99 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 30-32 BECKFORD ST. FRANKS-OTTEN X MCINTIRE 4/14/99 N/A N/A 4/14/99 RELOCATE PORCH N 6CHESTNUT BUSTEED X MCINTIRE 4/20/99 N/A N/A 4/20/99 REPLACE ROOF N I1 WARREN ST. MURPHY X MCINTIRE 4/16/99 N/A N/A 4/20/99 REPAIR SHUTTERS,REPAINT N 175 FEDERAL ST. MECHE X MCINTIRE 4/8/99 N/A N/A 4/8/99 REPAINT ' N 6 SOUTH PINE ST. BUCHANAN X MCINTIRE 4/29/99 N/A N/A 4/29/99 PAINTING,REPAIRS N 126 FEDERAL ST 126 FEDERAL C.T. X MCINTIRE 5/10/99 N/A N/A 5/10/99 ROOF REPLACEMENT N 143 DERBY ST. THERIAULT X DERBY 4/26/99 N/A N/A 4/26/99 ROOF SHINGLE REPLACEMENT N 143 DERBY ST. THERIAULT X DERBY 5/12/99 N/A N/A 5/12/99 REPAINTING N 4 HAMILTON ST. JOHNSON X MCINTIRE 5/27/99 N/A N/A 5/27/99 REPAINT N 100 DERBY ST. STAGNARO X DERBY 5/26/99 N/A N/A 5/26/99 REPAINT N 1 PICKERING ST. LOCKE X MCINTIRE 6/14/99 N/A N/A 6/14/99 BRICK WALL N 29-35 WARREN ST. TR./PHILLIPS X MCINTIRE 6/1/99 N/A N/A 6/1/99 CHIMNEYS N 2CHESTNUT ST. SALINAS X MCINTIRE 6/15/99 N/A N/A 6/15/99 ROOF REPLACEM4ENT N 8N.PINE ST. MAIER/PUCKETT X MCINTIRE 6/8/99 N/A N/A 6/14/99 WINDOWS N 395 ESSEX ST. AUDETTE X MCINTIRE 6/14/99 N/A N/A 6/14/99 REPAINTING N 5 N.PINE ST. WIDLER X MCINTIRE 6/11/99 N/A N/A 6/14/99 SIDING,FACIA,ENTRY WOOD,DOOR N 357 ESSEX ST. BASH/SZYBIAK X MCINTIRE 6/7/99 N/A N/A 6/7/99 REPAINTING N 48 CHESTNUT ST. CONNELLY/BRAT!' X MCINTIRE 6/9/99 N/A N/A 6/9/99 REPAINTING N 172 FEDERAL ST. WALLACE X MCINTIRE 6/3/99 N/A N/A 6/7/99 ROOF,VENTS,CHIMNEY N 395 ESSEX STREET AUDETTE X MCINTIRE 6/14/99 N/A N/A 6/14/99 REPAINT N ll CAMBRIDGE ST. FLAHERTY/GERARD X MCINTIRE 6/21/99 N/A N/A 6/22/99 REPAINT N 48 CHESTNUT ST. CONNELLY/BRAIT X MCINTIRE 6/24/99 N/A N/A 6/24/99 REPAINT N 134 FEDERAL ST. NICHOLSON X MCINTIRE 6/24/99 N/A N/A 6/24/99 REROOF N 34 CHESTNUTST. PHILLIPS TRUST X MCINI'IRF 6/23/99 N/A N/A 6/23/99 REPAINT N 180 DERBY ST. BROOKHOUSE X DERBY ST. 6/22/99 N/A N/A 6/22/99 REROOF N 1 ANDOVER ST. EICHMANN X MCINTIRE 6/29/99 N/A N/A 6/30/99 REPAINT N 76 FEDERAL ST, GORDON X MCINTIRE 6/28/99 N/A N/A 6/28/99 REPAINT t May 19, 1999, Page 1 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES MAY 19, 1999 A regular meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on Wednesday, May 19, 1999 at 7:30 p.m. at One Salem Green, Salem, MA. Present were Chairman Sides, Messrs., Desrocher, Stevens and Kasparian and Ms. Guy. Also present was new alternate member Louis Mangifesti. Mr. Kelleher, Mr. Karam and Ms. Guinee arrived later in the meeting. 6 Andover St. Jeffrey Nicholas and Kerry Rourke presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors at their home at 6 Andover St. The colors will be per the paint chips attached to the application (trim 4954,siding gold per chip, door—Country Redwood. Ms. Rourke stated that they are changing the trim from pure white to off white,that the gold body is similar to what is presently there and that they are changing the door color form black to rust. Mr.Nicholas stated that they also want to remove the plastic shutters. Mr. Kelleherjoined the meeting at this time. Chairman Sides asked about the color of the window sash. Mr. Kasparian noted that it is black in the photo. Ms. Rourke stated that it will probably be the off white. John Carr, 7 River Street, stated that he was in favor of the paint colors and shutter removal and suggested that the owners remove the accretion on the front door which obstructs the view of the beautiful center entrance. Ms. Rourke stated that they will not be removing it for another year and will be painting it for now. Ms. Guinee joined the meeting at this time. Mr. Kelleher suggested giving the option of painting the sash the door color. Mr. Kasparian stated that both were appropriate but that he preferred the creme. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted with the option to paint the sash either the trim or door color. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Karam abstained from voting. 49 Summer Street Teji and Patricia Samra presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors and to replace a rear downspout and window caulking. The body will be Tradition Ivory and the trim will be white. Mr. Samra stated that the windows will be the trim color and that they want to change the body from the proposed color of Tradition Ivory to Western Reserve Beige. The fence will stay the same and the door will stay green. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the paint colors. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. Mr. Samra asked if they could replace the wood downspout with aluminum. Mr. Kasparian asked the visibility. Mr. Samra stated that the top can be seen from Broad Street. May 19, 1999, Page 2 Mr.Kelleher made a motion to approve the repair of window caulking and replacement of the rear wood downspout with wood or aluminum. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 23 Warren Street James and Paula Gaull presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a wood fence along the back perimeter of the property. The fence will be approximately 8' high (noting that their land is 24" below the abutting neighbors) and will match the height of the existing fence. The fence will be approximately 8'8" at its highest point, but the land slopes and it will be about 18" shorter than that at its lowest point. Height will be approximately 6'8" from Broad Street neighbor's lot. Ms. Gaull stated that they have now decided to drop the fence about P because it will look too tall. Therefore, it will step down from the other fence approximately 1'. Tom Pelletier, 42 Broad Street, stated that he would like to continue the proposed fence across 19 Warren and 42 Broad. William O'Neil, 19 Warren, was in agreement. Ms. Guy stated that the two owners will need to apply so that there is proper abutter notification. Mr. Karam made a motion to approve the application as submitted with the amendment that the fence drop down approximately P from what was proposed. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 35 Flint Street The Bowditch Condominium Association submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace a wrought iron gate on the left side of the building and to add gates at the end of Fowler Street on the condo property line. Drawings were submitted. David Jaquith represented the condominium association. Mr.Jaquith stated that the reason for the Fowler Street gates is due to the city plowing on the grass last winter and people cutting through the property. The fence/gate will go from the dumpster to the comer of the house. There will be a knox box for the gate for the Fire Department. Both sides will have the good side and it will be stained to match the other. The second gate is by 33 Broad Street and will match the lower stair rail. Mr. Kasparian suggested capping the bollards with a pressed steel or cast iron shallow dome rather than just see a concrete cap cut off pipe. Verna Friedman, 35 Flint Street, stated that she was in favor of the application. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted with the bollards to have pressed steel or cast iron shallow dome caps. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 25 Warren Street Francis and Elizabeth Chafe presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a 6' fence across one half of the driveway and around partial side and back of property. The gateway door to be hung on a trellis and car gate installed. Fence to be universal board with colonial caps on posts to match existing fence. Color to be the same(gray)as existing fence. The application is also to paint the house gray and shutters black, repair/replace rotting or damaged woodwork on house, fence,post caps and stairs, remove antennas from roof,affix window boxes to front and side of house and remove tar in backyard and installing a brick walkway along the driveway. May 19, 1999, Page 3 Ms. Guy stated that the antenna removal and paving materials are not within the Commission's jurisdiction. Mr. Kelleher questioned if they were painting the synthetic siding. Ms. Chafe replied in the affirmative and noted that they are not ready to remove it and that it has oxidized. Ms. Chafe stated that the shutters will be black and that the new fence across the driveway will have a removable fence panel for the winter in order to recreate the two car spaces. The fence will go between the second and third windows from the fence post to a new post at the house. They propose to replace the lot line fence with fence of same design as new driveway fence with second section from street side lot line to have combination taper and first section to be lower height curved board so as to utilize existing post at street. The door will be China Aster. They won't touch the window sash at this time. Paula Gaull, 23 Warren Street, stated that she was in favor of the application. Ms. Chafe stated that windows boxes will be installed on all first floor windows. Mr. Karam made a motion to approve the paint color and repairs. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. Ms. Chafe stated that the new fence will be curved board capped fence, 6' tall at its highest point, 13' across with a 3' gate and a 1-` panel and three posts. The panel will have one scallop. The gate will have a reversed scallop. Chairman Sides stated that she preferred the gate have no scallop. Mr. Karam noted that it is a fixed section of fence that is removable. Ms.Chafe stated that the lot line fence will be 6' and the front two panels at the driveway will slope to the front post which is remaining. Mr. Kelleher felt that all the 6' fencing should be the same, all scalloped. Ms. Chafe stated that the second panel from the street will be a combination taper as a transition. The fencing will have colonial caps, be unpainted and will go all along the back of the property. Mr. Karam felt the fence portion of the application was extremely confusing without a drawing. Chairman Sides preferred the fence be painted or have a solid stain. Mr. Kasparian was in agreement. Ms. Chafe stated that she was willing to have it painted and provided a paint chip(Cornerstone)to paint the fencing and window boxes. Mr. Karam made a motion to approve a scalloped fence per the sketch with the whole fence stained Cornerstone. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. Ms. Chafe stated that the window boxes will be on the front windows;the first two windows on the driveway side and the two windows on the other side. There will be metal or wooden brackets underneath. Mr. Kasparian made a motion to approve the paint colors. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 21 Chestnut Street Bruce and Maura Ksander presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to place an air conditioning May 19, 1999, Page 4 unit on the roof and to restore the roof balustrade which was removed in the 1960's. The air conditioning unit will be a Carrier model number 38 TRA which is 40"high, 35"wide and 30"deep. It will be painted black and placed within one foot of the fire wall to block the view of the unit from the west. The balustrade will further hide the view of the unit. Mr. Ksander provided an historic photograph of the balustrade and a sample of a recovered baluster found in the attic. The request approval to proceed with the unit installation contingent upon balustrade installation to follow. Mr.Ksander stated that they could make the balustrade higher. Mr. Kelleher preferred the balustrade be replicated as per existing photograph and sample. Mr. Karam suggested using two smaller units instead of one larger air conditioning unit. Mr. Kasparian felt the applicant should come back with details on the balustrade. Mr.Ksander stated that the unit will be located one foot from the firewall and toward the center of the roof. He stated that he could put up a rod to mark the height for the next meeting. Mr. Karam made a motion to continue the application. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 13 Chestnut Street Paul & Patricia Zaido submitted an application for a Certificate of Non-applicability to reduce the size of a rear window. Ms. Guy stated that the window can be seen from Cambridge Street and the applicants have filed for Appropriateness for the next meeting. Mr. Stevens made a motion to deny the application. Mr. Karam seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. 149 Federal Street Joseph Archambault was present to request that his Certificate of Appropriateness be amended for his fence so that the gap can be 3/8"instead of 2"and therefore he would not have to take every picket off. Mr.Archambault supplied a photograph as an example of how the fence would look. Mr. Karam made a motion to approve the amendment. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Mangifesti abstained from voting. Other Business Ms. Guy provided copies of the plans for the Carlton, Salem High School, Witchcraft Heights and the new K-8 School projects. Mr. Kasparian made a motion to send a letter thanking the School Building Committee for the plans and to request additional details on the Carlton Street School as the design progresses. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Guy stated that she issued Certificates of Non-Applicability for 126 Federal Street(roof)and 143 Derby Street(repainting). Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the minutes of 3/24/99. Mr. Desrocher seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. May 19, 1999, Page 5 Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the minutes of 4/7/99. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the minutes of 4/21/99. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the minutes of 5/6/99. Mr. Stevens seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms. Guy stated that she issued two letters of support for grant applications for the Bowditch House pre- development project and for to complete a National Register nomination for the Bridge Street neck area. Ms. Guy provided a memo and paint chips from the Market and Tourist Commission for the painting of the Marketplace stalls. Mr. Kelleher suggested sending a letter saying it looks great and thanking them for the information. There being no further business, Mr. Kelleher made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. RespeIG ub d Jane aClerkommission March 24, 1999, Page 1 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES MARCH 24, 1999 A regular meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on Wednesday, March 24, 1999 at 7:30 p.m. at One Salem Green, Salem, MA. Present were Chairman Sides, new member Douglas Desrocher, Messrs. Kelleher and Karam and Ms. Guinee and Ms. Guy. 302 Lafayette Street 302 Lafayette Street Salem Realty Trust, Steve Anezis Trustee, presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to paint the doors, shutters, deck slates, rails and pillars in Rushmore and to remove the plywood that covers the railings and slats. Chairman Sides asked what was underneath the plywood. Mr. Anezis replied that the slats under the porch should be the same as what is visible on the side. Ms. Guy provided a Building Survey form which showed what was previously existing. Chairman Sides asked if the shutters were vinyl and would be able to hold paint. Chairman Sides suggested that the white stay white rather than introduce a second clolor on the porch. Mr. Karam was in agreeement. Chairman Sides stated that the base of the porch and shutters could be black or Essex Green and the door could stay white or be black or Essex Green Mr. Anezis asked if he could keep the porch decking in grey. Chairman Sides replied in the affirmative. David Goggin, 300 Lafayette Street, stated that he was in support of the application. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the removal of the plywood panels over the porch rails and base and for the following paint colors: Doors either white or(black or Essex Green), shutters black or Essex Green, porch decking repaint in existing grey, porch based slats only in black or Essex Green and repaint white trim. Mr. Anezi asked if the paint colors could apply to the rear porch as well. Mr. Kelleher replied in the affirmative. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 58 Derbv Street Phoenix Real Estate Trust, Thomas Bubier and Andrew Perkins trustees, presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the rear chimney and to request a 12 month extension to the Certificates issued in May and April of 1997. Mr. Perkins stated that the interior floor space will improve without the chimney. Mr. Kelleher stated that not rebuilding the chimney is a small sacrifice to see the building rehabbed. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted with the roofing to match existing. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 144-146 Federal Street Michaeline LaRocher and Robert Ouellette presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install two 4" round bathroom vents and two 3"x10"oven vents, painted the body color of the house,to replace existing aluminum gutters and downspouts on kitchen els and bump-out and two 8' half round gutters over the entrances March 24, 1999, Page 2 on the main house with no downspouts and to replace the bulkhead to match the existing one, with 1 x 4" beaded batten door. Chairman Sides asked the gutter material. Mr. Ouellette replied aluminum or galvanized. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 45-53 & 59 Boston Street Sancor Development submitted an application to Waive the Demolition Delay Ordinance to remove and dispose of the buildings on the site. Jeffrey Beal represented the applicant. Chairman Sides stated that it was regrettable to loose the 1914 building. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Guy stated that she issued Certificates of Non-Applicability for 10 hathorne St. (2 windows), 6 Broad St. (clapboards), 3 Lynn St. (trim, molding, paint) and 7 Hamilton Street(flat root). Comission members submitted some nominations for preservation awards. Mr. Karam stated that he was concerned about the poor tree planting job recently undertaken by the State along Bridge Street as part of the By-pass project. There being no further business, Mr. Kelleher made a motion to adjourn. Mr. Karam seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submitted, Ja u Cle of the Commission August 19, 1998, Page I SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MINUTES AUGUST 19, 1998 A regular meeting of the Salem Historical Commission was held on Wednesday,August 19, 1998 at 7:30 p.m.at One Salem Green,Salem, MA. Present were Chairman Sides,Messrs. Kelleher,and Stevens and Ms. Guinee and Ms. Guy. Mr. Kasparian entered later in the meeting. 110 Derbv Street The House of Seven Gables,through the Hawthorne Hotel,submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for sign installation at 110 Derby Street. The wooden sign will be attached to the building above the entrance door on Derby Street with a black iron bracket. Drawings were provided. Peter Grenier, representing the Hawthorne Hotel, brought in a sample of the sign material. Mr. Stevens made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 28 Beckford Street Richard and Jane Stauffer presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace gutters and relocate downspouts at their home at 23 Beckford Street. A gutter sample was presented. Mr. Stauffer stated that only the longest fagade's gutter's will be replaced. Mr. Kasparian joined the meeting at this time. Ms. Stauffer stated that the brackets will not be visible. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. 28-28 '/ Broad Street Veronica Morgan presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for paint colors and to construct an additional staircase from the second to the first floor of the rear of the house. The body color#1 will be K4,the body color#2 (birdtail shingles on top front elevation)will be K5,the trim color 43 will be K35,the stairs color#4 will be L 17,the doors color 5 will be K16 and the brick will be natural if possible or will be color(MIO?)to approximate the natural brick color. Storms, screens and screen doors will be white. Drawings showing color placement and staircase location were provided. Ms. Morgan stated that the brick is presently painted,that some has peeled and that some won't come off. She would like to change the color proposed in the application from the brick color to color 44 for the foundation. For the doors, she would like to redo the oak and apply clear polyurethane or else go with color 95. Aluminum storms and sash will be painted white. Chairman Sides suggested have the painted remove what he can on the foundation and leave what he can't to eventually wear off. Mr. Kasparian stated that he was not sure the mauve tones relate to the state because they are all kind of middle tones. Ms. Morgan noted that the sun will lighten the tones in a year. She would like to change the color proposed in the application for the stairs for the risers to be in the trim color#and the treads in Dillweed. Ms. Morgan stated that planned on requesting a change in stair configuration in the future. Charles Galvin,5 Warren Street, stated that the colors were fine. . Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the paint colors as submitted with amendments that the applicant have the option to keep the door natural or paint K16,the option for the foundation to be unpainted or to be L 17 and for the stairs to be August 19, 1998, Page 2 Dillweed. Ms.Guinee seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Ms.Morgan stated that she will be converting the house to two condominiums in the future. It is currently three legal units. She would like to add a stair from the second to the fust floor. Mr. Kasparian stated that he preferred to encourage the cleaning up of facades by the removal of staircases and felt that even the existing stairs were inappropriate. Chairman Sides did not feel it was significant because of the existing stairs. Mr. Karam stated that Mr. Kasparian's point is to question elaborating more on what shouldn't be there. Mr. Kasparian stated that it is a later addition that is not sympathetic and that he would not want to add to it. Ms. Morgan stated that it won't be seen. Chairman Sides stated that if it is not visible, it is mute,and suggested a site visit. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to continue the stair and deck pending a site visit on Saturday at 9:00 a.m. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion, all were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Galvin stated that he had no difficulty with the application. 144-146 Federal Street Robert Ouellette& Michaeline LaRoche presented an application for a Certificate of Non-Applicability to remove one window and door("A" in photo)and replace with a 6' French door to the Flint Street side,kitchen ell and to extend the second floor bumpout down to the first floor level and relocate on existing window to the first floor. The work is not visible from the public way.- Mr. Kelleher made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Ms. Guinee seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. The homeowners also submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to 1)replace the first floor windows with 6 over 6,true divided light sashes with balances: 2)to paint he house yellow with white trim:3)to install a new palladian window unit on the gable end of the driveway side kitchen ell,facing the yard(Narroline double hung#2832 center window with#CTN28 circle top,flanked by two Narroline double hung 92032):4)to remove a window and door on the driveway side kitchen and replace with one 6' x 6'8" French wood gliding door,with 15 light colonial grilles;and 5)to remove center window on 2n°floor bump out. Mr. Ouellette stated that the first floor windows are too far gone and also need replacement.Chairman Sides asked if they will be the Brosco true divided light units with storm panels. Mr.Ouellette replied in the affirmative,that they will be the same units as approved for the second and third floor. Mr. Ouellette stated that the door will be Essex Green and that he may apply for shutters later. The body will be Dorset Gold and the trim, including the windows,will be Navajo White. Chairman Sides asked if the palladian window will be true divided light. Mr.Ouellette stated that it will be Anderson unless he finds something else comparable. Chairman Sides stated that, if it is visible, it would need to be true divided light,and that the Commission should confirm its visibility. Chairman Sides asked when the bump out was added. Mr. Ouellette believed it was in the 1920's. Frances Clifford, 142 Federal Street, stated that the applicants are doing a marvelous job and that she supports their application. Mr. Kasparian made a motion to approve items I &2(first floor windows and paint). Mr. Karam seconded the motion,all j 1 August 19, 1998, Page 3 were in favor and the motion so carried. Mr. Kasparian made a motion to continue items 3,4 and 5 pending a site visit on Saturday. Mr. Kelleher requested that the motion be amended to continue the public hearing to the site visit. Mr. Kasparian so amended the motion. Mr. Kelleher seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 25 Warren Street Frank and Beth Chafe presented an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness to build a free standing, flat stone, retaining wall to use as a garden bed along the length of the house. The wall will be 33' x I' x I'. A sample photograph was provided. Ms. Chafe stated that the wall will be 2' in width in the back and will come about I"above the basement windows. They will drop down the gutter to minimize its visibility. Paula Gaull,23 Warren Street,stated that she was in support of the application. Mr. Kasparian made a motion to approve the application as submitted. Mr. Karam seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Salem Post Office Andrew Stein and William Moncrief of the United States Postal Service(USPS)and Swapan Roy and Partha Biswas of Stellar Corporation were present to discuss the handicapped access design for the Salem Post Office. Mr. Stein stated that the new design preferred by the Commission could undermine the roots of the tree and may require road excavation,thereby pushing out the project a year. The transformer may have to be moved,the City would have to create a curb cut and the project cost would likely increase by 30%. Chairman Sides felt it was still a better alternative than putting a ramp on the front of an historic building. Mr. Karam felt that more people,able and disabled,will use the ramp from the side and that able will not use the ramp if on the front. Mr. Roy stated that 17' feet of extra ramping will cause additional hardship on person in a wheelchair. Mr. Kasparian stated that in the front,the person in a wheelchair would also have to go across the street and through two curb cuts. Chairman Sides suggested that the USPS have an arborist look at the tree. Mr. Kasparian stated that there may be a way to use fill to create a terrace which could eliminate some portion of the ramp and save the tree. Mr. Kasparian noted that the Salem Post Office is the biggest,most architecturally significant civic building in the city. 7 Carpenter Street In continuation of a previous meeting,James Nicholson and Bart Bussink submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for door alterations and paint color. The applicant was not present. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to continue the application. Mr. Kasparian seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. 274 Lafayette Street In continuation of a previous meeting,John Ronan submitted an application for a Certificate of Appropriateness for fence l August 19, 1998, Page 4 construction as has already been completed at 274 Lafayette Street. The applicant was not present. Mr. Kelleher made a motion to continue the application and to send a letter to the applicant. Mr. Stevens seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Other Business Ms. Guy stated that she issued Certificates of Non-Applicability for 27 Broad Street(roofing,chimney flashing), 56 Washington Square(paint)and 32 Broad Street(repairs). There being no further business, Mr. made a motion to adjourn. Mr. seconded the motion,all were in favor and the motion so carried. Respectfully submi d, lan uy CI ofthe: ission vb��0 T '�°C/y1N8 Salem Historical Commission ONE SALEM GREEN, SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (978) 745-9595 EXT.311 FAX(978)740-040,' CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS It is hereby certified that the Salem Historical Commission has determined that the proposed: ❑ Construction ❑ Moving ❑ Reconstruction ❑ Alteration ❑ Demolition ❑ Painting ❑ Signage ❑ Other work as described below will be appropriate to the preservation of said Historic District, as per the requirements set forth in the Historic District's Act (M.G.L. Ch. 40C) and the Salem Historic Districts Ordinance. District: McIntire Address of Property: 23 Warren Street Name of Record Owner: James & Paula Gaull Description of Work Proposed: Construction of wood fence along back perimeter of property to match existing cedar fence (behind fish pond) in design. Fence will be approximately I 'lower in height from existing fence. Dated: Mav 20. 1999 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION By: The homeowner has the option not to commence the work (unless it relates to resolving an outs anding violation). All work commenced must be completed within one year from this date unless otherwise indicated. THIS IS NOT A BUILDING PERMIT. Please be sure to obtain the appropriate permits from the Inspector of Buildings (or any other necessary permits or approvals)prior to commencing work. Adequate and Qualified Local Government Commission PART B.1 The Commission has provided available information for its two newest members. PART B.2 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION MEMBERSHIP There are currently six (7) Commission members and one (1) alternate. PART B.3 SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION PROFESSIONALS Professionals in Name Related Preservation Field Helen Sides - Chairman X - Architect Douglas Kelleher, Vice Chairman X - MA Highway Dept. Lance Kasparian X- Historical Architect Deborah Guinee - Nurse Douglas Karam - Construction Engineer Richard Stevens X- Renovation Craftsman Douglas Desrocher - Realtor Louis Mangifesti - Antique shop owner PART B.4 VACANCIES/APPOINTMENTS Douglas Desrocher was appointed to the Commission on March 11, 1999 as a full member replacing Robert Jellison who resigned from the Commission in January, 1999. Louis Mangifesti was appointed to the Commission on May 13, 1999 as an alternate member. He fills the vacancy left by Kathleen Maark who stopped attending meetings in April, 1997. There is currently one alternate member vacancy. PART B.5 CLG TRAINING SESSIONS/WORKSHOPS Helen Sides and Douglas Karam attended Build Boston in November, 1998. Douglas Kelleher attended MHC's "Making Connections" Conference, Sept. 25, 1998. HE,8 G4 -77 101•�pr,i �..��i. .,♦. . .+�.� CITY OF SALEM. MASSACHUSETTS STANLEY J.USOV1CZ.JR MAYOR RESUME BOARD/COMMISSIQN NAME: Douglas G. Desrocher ADDRESS : 22 Briggs Street Salem, MA 01970 TELEPHONE: Home 745-8794 Business 740-0123 OCCUPATION : Residential Real Estate, Broker/Owner of "Desrocher Real Estate, of Sale WHERE EMPLOYED - (IF RETIRED, STATE PREVIOUS) : Self employed EDUCATION: Salem High School, North Shore Community College CIVIC/FRATERNAL ORGANIZATIONS : Former Treasurer for Kiwanis of Salem - 1990-1995 Salem Knights of Columbus, Salem Chamber of Commerce Board. OTHER AFFILIATIONS: North Shore. Association of Realtors - Grievance Committee, Salem High School Mentor Program, Salem Common Neighborhood Association, North Shore Paddlers. PERSONAL INTERESTS/ACTIVITIES: Family and friends, community activities, sea kayaking, hiking, running, vollyball, camping. BOARD OR COMMISSION MOST INTERESTED IN (STATE REASON) : Historical Commission. To assist in the preservation of Salem's architectural heritage, and to serve my community. MISCELLANEOUS COMMENTS: I am a Salem property owner and a life long resident with strong family ties. Currently enrolled in the Entrepreneurial Training Program with an anticipated graduation in March, 1999. SALEM CITY HALL•93 w^SP0"GTOt4 STREET'3ALEK MASSACHUSETTS 01970-3592•979/7459595•FAX 97W7449 z Desrocher Real Estate, of Salem 92 North Street Salem,MA 01970 June 3, 1998 Greater Salem Association of Realtors 105 Water Street Danvers, MA 01923 Attention: Linda Skory Dear Linda, My name is Douglas G. Desrocher, I have been a realtor since 1989 and I'm proud to say a lifelong resident of Salem. I was born in Salem Hospital on January 17, 1963, and because of my 35 plus years living in Salem, I have met many of its residents. I presently own and reside at 22 Briggs Street, which is directly off of Salem Common, and enjoy the many historic and antique aspects of my own lovely neighborhood. I am no stranger to service to my community. In 1989, I ran a Salem Road Race to raise money for a local young child with a rare intestinal disorder. I was an active member of the Salem Kiwanis from 1990 to 1995, as Treasurer and Vice President Elect, as well as being a member of its Board of Directors. I have been a member of The Salem Chamber of Commerce since 1996 and have over this past winter been inducted as a board member. I also give to my community more directly by being a "mentor", through the Salem High School Meritor Program. I'm fortunate to be working with two boys, one 17 years of age and the other 11 years. Both have endless potential to be wonderful assets to our community and all around good people. I believe I have quite a bit yet to offer, and as a fresh young opinion on the Salem Historical Commission, I will be able to contribute. My father by trade is a cabinetmaker, so quality and craftsmanship has always been respected and appreciated by me. I am very aware that I do not hold any titles or certificates that might prove a superior knowledge of antique and historical properties, but I know that I do posess a strong foundation for an opportunity such as this,with an added respect for my community and its people, and of course, a great appreciation for the gift that we have in Salems'historic beauty. I do hope I will be strongly consider Sincerely, Douglas G. D her i Desrocher > Real Estate, of Sateen BUS`(SW) 74o-0123 RES.- (508)745-8794 yet PAGEFL-(508).3965959 �6 RECEIVED MAR 15 IL` o9 CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS Salem Planning Dept, STANLEY J. USOVICZ. JR. MAYOR March 11, 1999 To the City Council City Hall Salem, Massachusetts Ladies and Gentlemen of the Council: I appoint, subject to Council confirmation, Douglas G. Desrocher to serve as a member of the Salem Historical Commission for a term to expire March 1, 2002. He will replace Robert L. Jellison who has resigned. Mr. Desrocher is a life-long resident of Salem currently residing at 22 Briggs Street. He is the Broker/Owner of Desrocher Real Estate of Salem with an office at 92 North Street. His affiliations include the Salem Chamber of Commerce, recently inducted as a board member, the North Shore Association of Realtors, the Salem Common Neighborhood Association, and he served as Treasurer for Kiwanis of Salem from 1990-95. He graduated from Salem High School, North Shore Community College and, he is currently enrolled in the Entrepreneurial Training Program, graduating this month. Additionally, his community activities include serving as a mentor through the Salem High School Mentor Program, serving as a member of the Grievance Committee on the North Shore Association of Realtors, and he is a member of the Salem Common Neighborhood Association. He enjoys sea kayaking, hiking, running, volleyball, camping and participating in all community activities. Mr. Desrocher has stated that he is very interested in assisting in the preservation of Salem's architectural heritage, and a great appreciation for the gift that we have in Salem's history. He has been nominated as 'a candidate for membership on the Commission by the Salem Board of Realtors in fulfillment of the requirement of the composition of the Commission under M.G.L. Chapter 40C Section 4. Mr. Desrocher has a great deal of respect for our community and its people, and I am pleased to recommend confirmation of his appointment. Very truly yours STANLEY J. USOVICZ, Mayor SALEM CITY HALL•93 WASHINGTON STREET•SALEM.MASSACHUSETTS 01970-3592•9781745-9595•FAX 9781744-9327 CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS STANLEY J. USOVICZ. JR. - MAYOR RESUME _ / � l BOARD/COMMISSION NAME : !�UlS /V, ADDRESS : 3/� ESSEX ST , �� LC'o� �l( /� • O ( �j7G TELEPHONE : Home 7�7 G`�73 Business OCCUPATION : AN77e.?&E,WHERE EMPLOYED EMPLOYED - (IF RETIRED, STATE PREVIOUS) : (gC�.4/�- f�vrE �4 Arai 4�vES EDUCATION : gS {QED. /;l Fa 5S s Coc dll� /4zT M f 1Wj9 f44_0 S _. A SS✓••1 0-77 e s C vLc� L� 6/�GG� / � ti CIVIC/FRATERNAL ORGANIZATIONS : P�,QBoo�- �4� /kus-�,v. ,4!�S7aa�c Sirs c� OTHER AFFILIATIONS : 14 Al /leer 13ssec c/fiFn7eA .l'g �� PERSONAL INTERESTS/ACTIVITIES : BOARD OR COMMISSIOON MOST INTERESTED IN (STATE REASON) : 144SrQA--ec (foM " I MISCEnnLLANEOUS COMMENTS : /Ct�-/N �7i-L� �STD lute �Q�'SE'ic.l�if-/ ✓ J?'�`�- I Tf�tc� L o.YGa/NG /�/laG'/� S W17H.cl 7`l"e C/771. SALEM CITY HALL•93 WASHINGTON STREET•SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970-3592•9781745.9595•FAX 9781744-9327 3 e n ED �p n g CITY OF SALEMMASSACHUSETTS STAN F4Nk�"�' �' P I. May 13, 1999 To the City Council City Hall Salem, Massachusetts Ladies and Gentlemen of the Council: I appoint, subject to Council confirmation, Louis N. Mangifesti to serve as an alternate member of the Historical Commission for a term to expire March 1, 2000. He will replace Kathleen L. Marck whose term has expired. Mr. Mangifesti lives at 311 Essex Street in Salem, and he is the owner of Blair House Antiques located at 1 Front Street in Beverly. He received his Bachelor of Science Degree from the Massachusetts College of Art and his Master of Fine Arts Degree from Assumption College in Worcester. He is a member of the Museum of Fine Arts,the Peabody/Essex Museum, the Gardner Museum and a charter member of the Danvers Art Association. In addition, he is a member of Historic Salem, Inc. and the Danvers Historical Society. Mr. Mangifesti is sincerely interested in the preservation of Salem's rich historic environment. His thorough knowledge and expertise in the realm of antiquities, art and architecture make him a highly qualified candidate for membership on the Historic Commission, and I am pleased to recommend confirmation of his appointment. Very truly STANLEY J. USOVICZ, JR. Mayor SJU/smc SALEM CITY HALL•93 WASHINGTON STREET•SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970-3592•9781745.9595•FAX 978/744-9327 National Register Program Participation PART C.1 CLG EVALUATIONS COMPLETED There were no evaluations completed. PART C.2 NOMINATIONS There were no nominations prepared and submitted to the MHC. PART C3 PUBLIC HEARINGS There were no public hearings held. PART CA PROFESSIONAL EXPERTISE There was no professional expertise engaged concerning National Register nominations. Survey and Inventory of Historic Properties PART DA D.2 D.3 There were no survey forms produced or updated by the CLG. There is no change in the status of the inventory in terms of its organization, storage, accessibility, etc. Public Participation PART E.1 COMMISSION MEETING DATES: July 1, 1998 July 15, 1998 August 5, 1998 August 19, 1998 August 22, 1998 — Site visit September 2, 1998 September 16, 1998 September 19, 1998 — Site visit October 7, 1998 October 21, 1998 November 4, 1998 November 18, 1998 December 2, 1998 January 6, 1999 January 22, 1999 February 3, 1999 February 17, 1999 February 27, 1999 — Site visit March 3, 1999 March 24, 1999 April 7, 1999 April 21, 1999 May 5, 1999 May 6, 1999— Site visit May 19, 1999 June 2, 1999 June 16, 1999 June 17, 1999 — Site visit OPEN MEETING LAW COMPLIANCE STATEMENT 1. All meetings of the CLGC have been open to the public. 2. A notice of the date, time and place of every meeting of the CLGC has been field with the Clerk of the city or town in which the CLGC acts and a copy of such notice has been posted in the office of the Clerk on the principal bulletin board of each city or own at least 48 hours prior to the time of each meeting, excluding Sundays and legal holidays. 3. A record of every meeting, including executive sessions has been maintained by the CLGC, including the date, time, place, members present and actions taken at each meeting. 4. All executive sessions, if any, have been held in compliance with M.G.L. C. 39, Section 23B. 5. No chance meeting or social meeting has been used to circumvent the spirit or requirements of the Open Meeting Law or to discuss or act upon a matter over which the CLGC has supervision, control,jurisdiction, or advisory power. L20/9 CI Date Chairperson, CLGC Public Participation PART E.3 ACCESSIBILITY OF MINUTES There has been no change in the accessibility of Commission minutes. They are accessible for public view at the Salem Planning Department. PART EA RULES, PROCEDURES, GUIDELINES There were no new rules, procedures or guidelines adopted by the Commission. t Funding of CLG Activities PART F.1 { LOCAL FUNDING The annual local funding budget appropriation under the authority of the Salem Historical Commission was $6,200 for personnel services and $1,721 for nonpersonnel expenses. PART F.2 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT FUNDING The City of Salem did not receive funding from the Survey and Planning Grant program PART F.3 OTHER FUNDING There were no other public or private grant funds received for preservation activities. } Miscellaneous PART G.1 ` PRESERVATION AWARDS 1 On the evening of Thursday, May 20 1999,the Salem Historical Commission presented its 1999 fPreservation Awards at the Historic Salem, Inc. Annual Meeting held at the National Park Service Visitor's Center. The recipients from local historic districts were: • 144-146 Federal Street, (Robert Ouellette & Michaeline LaRoche) Excellence in Restoration • 7 Carpenter Street, (James Nicholson& Bart Bussink)Excellence in Renovation • 24 1/2 Winter Street, (Paul & Sasha Durand) Excellence in Fence Construction • 19 Flint Street, (Gary & Barbara Wuertz) Excellence in Restoration • 4 Carpenter Street (Cynthia Duda) Excellence in Restoration • 337 Essex St. (Salem Athenaeum) —Preservation Award for Preservation and Maintenance (roof replacement) (the project utilized Massachusetts Preservation Project Funds matching grant funding) Honorable Mention Awards: • 53 Summer Street (Dolores Nangle), Exterior Rehabilitation } From outside local historic districts, the recipients are: • 8 Forrester St. (Michael & Michelle Parr) Preservation Award for Painting (the project utilized funds provided by the Salem Planning Department's Housing Rehabilitation Program which is funded by the Community Development Block Grant) • 49 Ocean Ave (Jean Townsend) Preservation Award for Painting • 23 Summer St. (Walter and the late Joyce Cook) Exterior Renovations Honorable Mention Awards: • 51-53 Washington Sq. (Ellen Dixey)Excellence in Restoration • 32 Forrester Street (Larry & Diane Sinclair) Preservation Award for Painting