SURVEY REPORT iq aq s u 2� �orZ-r
� - _ _ _ � —
2011 Salem Historical Conunission
Filed Meeting Notices
p
't, � X w� moi/ i'Z+�'6j ie•�� �♦ w,�j' ��I i f;'
<('�•e����aN�gqCCSa '�<'/ t ,��l�jy� ' 3f'1 Y�_ � ry�r.
SALEM
HISTORIC RESOURCE
SURVEY
�.;
IILIi Ire
90
_ Rolrot
la Ul
Compiled for the
Salem •• Department
the Massachusetts
• •
Historical Commissionby
Northfields Preservation
Assoc
• ate s
1989
1
SALEM HISTORIC RESOURCE SURVEY 1989
PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND METHODOLOGY
The goal in conducting a comprehensive survey of several areas of
Salem was to complete the city's inventory in order to facilitate
planning and preservation efforts. Survey work in Salem had been
ongoing for many years, conducted by volunteers from Historic Salem,
Inc. , Salem Planning Department staff, and preservation consultants.
Five areas had been identified as still remaining to be surveyed: Salem
Willows, Stage Point, South Salem, North Salem and Gallows Hill. By
identifying and evaluating the buildings, sites structures, burying
grounds and areas in these remaining areas it will be possible for
continue the preservation planning process with a clear body of
information.
The project was conducted by Nortbfields Preservation Associates
using the standard criteria and methodology of the Massachusetts
Historical Commission.
Review of Existing Survey Material and Resources
The first step in conducting the survey was a thorough review of
existing inventory forms, research previously done, and examination of
the documentary resources available. Salem Willows and Stage Point had
not been surveyed, so forms did not exist for those areas. Several
generations of forms prepared by volunteers and others beginning in the
late 1960s exist for North Salem.
z
Debra Hilbert, the former preservation planner for the Salem
Planning Department conducted surveys of selected areas of North and
South Salem between 1984 and 1986. . In North Salem, completed inventory
forms existed for most of Buffum and North Streets and most of the area
bounded by North, Foster, Felt and Orae Streets. In addition, partial
forms with photographs existed for a substantial number of properties.
These forms were completed as part of the project, using the 1984-1986
photographs in most eases. These forms are identified as having been
prepared by Debra Hilbert and Northfields Preservation Associates, and
the earlier date is indicated on the form when the building was not
re-photographed.
South Salem had not received the early volunteer attention of the
North Salem area, but had also been partially surveyed by Debra Hilbert.
A local historic district was established along Lafayette Street in
1985, and the immediately surrounding area thoroughly surveyed. Some
side streets had partial forms prepared, and as with North Salem these
were completed and identified as a joint effort with earlier work dated
as such.
Gallows Hill had many volunteer-prepared forms which were
insufficiently detailed to meet present MHC standards. After the survey
was underway, additional inventory forms completed in 1978 by Historic
Salem, Inc. were located. These focused on Boston Street, and were more
thorough. Associated with the project under which they were prepared
was extensive research through census records, tax records and other
sources. Based on the number of resources in this area and the other
four survey areas it was determined that the Gallows Hill area should be
3
surveyed at a future date when these materials could be thoroughly
integrated into the project.
Windshield Survey
Preliminary property lists were prepared through a visual
assessment of all properties in the original five survey areas.
Assisted by maps previously used in Debra Hilbert's North and South
Salem surveys, assessors' maps were marked, indicating the style of each
building in the area, and marking buildings to be placed on the
preliminary list. During the windshield survey buildings were selected
based on criteria relating to architectural significance. They must
retain substantial integrity of location, design, setting, materials,
workmanship, feeling and association. These properties must also be
associated with a master, or represent a significant, distinguishable
entity whose components may lack individual distinction. Generally
buildings to which synthetic siding had been applied, whose windows had
been replaced, or which had otherwise been inappropriately altered were
omitted from the list unless they possessed particular signficance for
other surviving architectural features or strong historical
associations.
Further fieldwork was conducted to photograph and to prepare
descriptions of all listed buildings not previously photographed and/or
described.
Research
Research concentrated on three main objectives: 1) to evaluate the
visual and architectural significance of each property, 2) to document
4
the role played by previous owners and occupants in the development of
the community, and 3) to clarify local development patterns using
information gained from the existing architectural styles and historical
sources.
Most extensive use was made of maps and atlases, city directories,
records of building permits, and the photograph collection of the Essex
Institute. Deed research was used primarily in the Salem Willows area,
with deed research associated with house sign reports prepared by
Historic Salem, Inc. used where available.
An exceptional and neglected resource exists in a city storage area,
namely plans for the rebuilding of the large area of Salem destroyed by
fire in 1914. Within these surveyed areas, Stage Point and part of
South Salem were obliterated by the fire, and reconstruction occured
rapidly in the 15 years that followed. Approval by the Salem Rebuilding
Commission was required of all plans for buildings during the period of
reconstruction, and plans remain in storage. These uncatalogued
documents were reviewed as thoroughly as was possible, given their
random arrangement, and poor condition. We strongly recommend that this
material be removed to a more stable location where it can be preserved
and catalogued. Further study would be likely to yield additional
information on Salem's reconstruction. This collection also. includes
plans for other areas of the city, which are well worth further study.
Also related to the fire were the extensive records of the Salem
Rebuilding Commission on file at the Essex Institute.
Once fieldwork and research were completed, MHC survey forms were
compiled with maps, photographs and statements of architectural and
5
historical significance. Each form was given a number based on the
previous numbering system used for Salem inventory forms-- the form
number is the assessors map and lot number. Areas were given letters.
All the properties were plotted on a base map to show their relative
location in the city.
The survey identified 18 areas, 493 individual buildings, 1
structure, 1 object, 4 streetscapes and 3 landscapes that are
significant in local, state or national history and retain their
physical integrity.
Recommendations
At the completion of the survey National Register criteria were
applied to the properties, resulting in a list of recommendations for
individual and district nominations. These are found at the end of the
report.
SURVEY AREAS
A brief account of the locations, and types and conditions of resources
in the five survey areas follows.
Salem Willows - The Salem Willows area surveyed consisted of Juniper
Point and Winter Island, both of which are bounded by water, with the
exception of the southwestern boundary, Memorial Drive. Juniper Point
consists of the Salem Willows Park and a dense concentration of
cottages, most dating from the late 19th century. Southwest along
Columbus Avenue are early 20th century houses constructed for year-round
use.
6
The survey identified 60 properties in this area: 2 areas, 59
buildings, and 1 landscape. This area retains a high degree of
cohesiveness and integrity. Winter Island includes a smaller area of
turn-of-the-century cottages, less intact and interspersed with later
construction. Also in this area and previously surveyed are Fort
Pickering (listed on the National Register), and Fort Lee (previously
recommended as eligible for the National Register) .
North Salem - The survey area was bounded approximately by Highland,
North, Woodside, Appleton, and Orne Streets, the North River, Mason and
Tremont Streets. The area includes several major early thoroughfares
with buildings surviving from the 18th and early 19th centuries (North
Street, Mason Street, School Street) . Originally common lands known as
the North Fields, the area remained farmland until suburban development
began during the mid and late 19th century. This suburban growth
continued until the Depression and beyond in the northeastern section of
North Salem.
In addition to earlier inventory forms, the survey identified 177
resources in North Salem: 4 areas, 169 buildings, 3 streetseapes and 1
cemetery. While the area contains strong concentrations of 19th and
early 20th century buildings, with several notable exceptions (see
Southwick Street, Form R, Buffum Street and Dearborn Street) , synthetic
siding, alterations, and, to a lesser degree, infill construction make
most areas of North Salem too inconsistent for the establishment of
districts. However, seven buildings appear to be individually eligible
for the National Register. In some cases these buildings are fine and
7
intact examples of styles common in the city's areas of early dense
development, but rare in North Salem. Such properties (see 40 Felt
Street, 28 School Street) might not be individually eligible in an area
like Salem's McIntyre district, but are more significant in an area
where little Federal construction has survived so intact.
Stage Point - Boundaries of this survey area were the B. & M. Railroad
tracks, Washington Street and the South River Canal, Salem Harbor, and
Holly and Leach Streets. The Stage Point area, with the exception of a
few surviving blocks developed in the late 19th century and bounded by
Canal, Cypress, Cabot and Roslyn Streets (see Pre-Fire Area, Form I) ,
was destroyed by the Salem Fire of June, 1914. All construction in this
area dates from the subsequent period of reconstruction, and the area as
a whole is discussed on the Fire Area form (See Form D).
The survey identified 126 resources here: 7 areas, 117 buildings, 1
landscape and 1 object. With one exception, areas and properties
recommended as eligible for the National Register all relate to the
early 20th century redevelopment: a dense concentration of workers'
apartments (Ward and Peabody Streets, Form E), affluent single family
housing (Fairfield Street, Form H) . While other residential areas
retain characteristic examples of the modest single and multi-family
housing constructed in this area between 1914 and 1929, there is a high
percentage of altered building, most commonly those with synthetic
siding.
outh Salem - Abutting the Stage Point area to the north, the South
S
Salem survey area was bounded by the B. &. M. Railroad tracks, Holly and
8
Leach Streets, Salem Harbor, and the Marblehead and Swampscott town
lines. Development patterns in South Salem were parallel to those in
North Salem. The area was early used as common lands, the South Fields,
developing with farms and large rural estates. Beginning in the 1860s
major subdivision of estates began (see Derby and Messervy Estates Area,
Form 0) and the area developed rapidly in the subsequent decades. The
northern portions of the area (north of Loring Avenue) were nearly fully
developed by the turn of the century, while development of the southern
area (see Pickman Park Area, Form L) did not begin until the 19105, and
has continued to the present.
In addition to earlier inventory forms, the survey identified 158
properties in South Salem: 5 areas, 150 buildings, 1 streetscape, 1
landscape, and 1 structure. South Salem, which now includes the local
Lafayette Street Historic District, holds four potential National
Register districts as well as seven individually eligible buildings.
Much of the residential development retains a high degree of integrity,
I
and includes Salem's greatest concentration of intact late 19th and
early 20th century architecture. It also contains significant
institutional complexes at Salem State College (Form N) and the Loring
Villa/Convent St. Chretienne (Form R).
Gallows Hill - The boundaries of the Gallows Hill area are Ord Street,
the Peabody line, the Railroad tracks, Goodhue, and Boston Streets,
Highland Avenue, Proctor, Bemis, South and Wall Streets. Inventory
forms were not completed for this area, although a preliminary list of
9
145 properties was prepared, photographs were taken and architectural
descriptions begun for part of the area.
NATIONAL REGISTER RECOMMENDATIONS
The National Register of Historic Places is the nation's official
list of buildings, districts, sites, structures and objects worthy of
preservation for their importance in American history, architecture,
archeology, engineering, and culture. It is administered by the
Massachusetts Historical Commission on behalf of the United States
Department of the Interior. Listing on the National Register provides
honor and recognition to important historic properties without limiting
the owners' use of these properties.
In order for a property to be listed on the National Register, it
must possess integrity of location, design, setting, materials,
workmanship, feeling and association. In addition, it must meet one or
more of the following criteria at the local, state, or national level:
A) Association with events that have made a significant contribution
to the broad patterns of our history;
B) Association with the lives of persons significant in our past;
C) Embodiment of distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or
method of construction or representation as the work of a master, or
possession of high artistic values, or representation of a significant
and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual
distinction;
10
D) Likelihood of yielding information important in prehistory or
history.
The National Register generally will not include cemeteries,
religious buildings, structures that have been moved, reconstructed
buildings, or properties that have achieved significance within the past
50 years. However, such properties may qualify if they are integral
parts of a district or meet certain additional criteria.
Through a formal review process (Section 106) listing on the
National Register provides limited protection from adverse effects of
state and federally-supported projects. Owners of income-producing
properties on the National Register may take advantage of certain
federal tax incentives for substantial historic rehabilitation.
Buildings that are owned by a municipality or by a private, non-profit
organization may be eligible to compete for matching grants for
restoration through the Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund.
Inclusion on the National Register does not interfere with a
property owner's right to alter, manage or sell the property using
private funds. However, if state or federal funds or permits are used
to alter the property, the alterations will be reviewed for
appropriateness by the Massachusetts Historical Commission. Listing on
the National Register does not mandate a specific use for a building,
nor does it require that a building be open to the public.
6 property may be listed on the National Register either
individually or as part of a district. Nomination to the National
Register is only accomplished through a formal process that details the
11
history and significance of the property or properties. The consent of
the owner or majority of owners is also required before an individual
property or a district can be listed.
The survey identified the following 10 districts which appear to
possess the integrity and significance necessary to qualify for listing
on the National Register of Historic Places:
Salem Willows (Form A) - The Salem Willows area is Salem's only resort
area, containing a high concentration of summer cottages constructed in
a range of late 19th century styles, as well as an area of early 20th
century suburban housing. The area is close to the present South Essex
Sewerage District treatment plant, and may be affected by plans for a
secondary sewage treatment plan in the area. National Register status
would afford some protection of the historic integrity of the area by
requiring state review or Section 106 federal review of the impact of
any project supported by state or federal funds or receiving any other
state or federal support (e.g. permits, licenses, loans).
Ward and Peabody Streets (Form E) - This area of three and four-story
brick apartment buildings merits further study for listing as a district
of workers housing adjacent to the large Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills
complex (also eligible). The area is the densest concentration of
substantial apartment buildings constructed immediately following
Salem's devastating 1914 fire. The area is historically significant for
its use for workers' housing and its early association with Salem's
large French Canadian population. Listing on the National Register
12
would allow the use of investment tax credits for the rehabilitation of
these buildings.
Fairfield Street (Form R) - Rebuilt following the Salem fire of 1914,
the Fairfield Street area is dominated by large, high-style Colonial
Revival houses in a variety of materials including brick, cement, stucco
and clapboard. Similar to Warren Street to the west (not in the survey
area), Fairfield Street contains residences of Salem's affluent, and
includes houses designed by several Boston architects. National
Register status would raise local awareness of and interest in these
buildings.
Loring Villa/Convent St. Chretienne (Form %) - This complex consists of
the mid-19th century estate of Dr. George Loring and the later
institutional buildings associated with its expansion by the Convent St.
Chretienne. The Loring Estate originally encompassed much of South
Salem including the present Pickman Park area, and is a rare surviving
example of the country houses which originally existed in the area. The
property is now used as the South Campus of Salem State College. As
state-owned property, listing on the National Register (and therefore
the State Register) would provide some protection from alteration or
destruction by allowing a review process to occur prior to any work that
would effect the area's historic character.
Naples and Savoy Roads (Form M) - Dating from the 1910s and 1920s, this
small, self-contained suburban development contains excellent examples
of middle-sized residences in a variety of architectural styles, and
13
reflects Salem's early 20th century development patterns. Establishing
a National Register district here would increase public awareness.of the
calibre of these resources.
Salem State College (Form N) - The Salem State College complex contains
a notable core group of buildings dating from 1896 through the early
20th century, and is historically significant as the city's only
institution of higher education. As with the Loring Villa/Convent St.
Chretienne area, listing on the National Register (and therefore the
State Register) would provide some protection from alteration or
destruction by allowing a review process to occur prior to any work that
would effect the area's historic character.
Derby Estate Area (Form 0) - This area, consisting of a four-block
section of Lafayette Street and flanking sections of the parallel Linden
Street and Summit Avenue with their side streets, is representative of
the massive growth of Salem in the mid to late 19th century that spurred
i
the subdivision and development of former farmlands and large estates.
The core of the area is the existing Lafayette Street Historic District
(local); it and the adjacent areas retain substantial integrity, and
illustrate a variety of architectural styles of the mid to late 19th
century. While preservation tools are already in place with the
existence of a local district here, listing of a larger area on the
National Register would increase awareness of the significance of the
adjacent streets in addition to the core of Lafayette Street.
14
Southwick Street (Form R) - This one block district contains a row of
notably intact mid-19th century houses, most in the Greek Revival style,
presenting an unusually uniform streetscape. The area was occupied
early by workers in Salem's leather industry. National Register listing
would enhance community awareness and appreciation of this pristine
street, encouraging its residents to protect its character.
Previously Recommended:
Dearborn Street
Buffum Street
Further study
Along with the Ward and Peabody Street area, the following two areas and
10-14 Lynch Street may be eligible for the National Register as examples
of workers housing built immediately after the 1914 fire. They were all
designed by the Boston architectural firm %ilham and Hopkins in.an
attempt to provide low-cost, quality workers' housing, and remain
largely intact.
Prince St. Place (Form J)
Salem Rebuilding Trust Area (Form S)
15
In addition, the following 18 individual properties appear to
possess the degree of integrity and significance required to qualify for
listing on the National Register:
Salem Willows:
Form 44-36 Plummer Home for Boys 37 Winter Island Rd.
Stage Point:
i
Form 33-198 23 Gardner St.
Form 34-474 Saltonstall School 211 Lafayette St.
Form 33-258 Walter R. Bigelow House 220 Lafayette St.
North Salem:
Form 16-319 George H. Devereaux House 1 Devereaux Ave.
Form 27-609 18 Felt St.
Form 27-601 James Brooks & John Bell House 40 Felt St.
Form 27-519 19 Larchmont St.
Form 17-274 3 Ridgeway St.
Form 27-19 28 School St.
Form 17-24 100 School St.
South Salem:
Form 21-34 19 Cedarcrest Ave.
Form 32-374 Almy House 395 Lafayette St.
Form 32-375 399 Lafayette St.
Form 32-168 Dixey Morgan House 416 Lafayette St.
16
Form 32-167 418 Lafayette St.
Form 31-215 Benjamin G. Hathaway House 452 Lafayette St.
Form 33-663 Edmund P. Balcomb House 4 Ocean Ave.
Further study:
Form 34-191 10-14 Lynch Street
Previously recommended -
Fort Lee
Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills/Shetland Properties
SOURCES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY
MAPS AND PLANS
Hopkins, G. M. Atlas of Salem. Philadelphia, 1874.
McIntyre, H. Map of the City of Salem. Philadelphia, 1851.
Plans at the Essex County Registry of Deeds: bk. 1 , pg. 30; bk. 1,
P-15.
Putnam, Charles, surveyor. Plan of House Lots of the E.S. Poor
Estate in Salem and Peabody. Boston, 1883. On file at the
Essex Institute.
Richards. Atlas of Salem. 1897.
Salem Board of Health, Map of the Burned District of Salem, June
1914.
Walker Lithograph and Publishing Co. Atlas of Salem. Boston, MA:
1911.
VITAL STATISTICS
United States Census Report, 1910.
LOCAL RECORDS
Essex County Registry of Deeds
List of Houses Built in 1848, on file at the Essex Institute.
Salem Building Permits 1871-1889, on file at the Essex Institute.
17
Salem Building Plans
Salem City Directories
Salem Rebuilding Commission Plans
Salem Rebuilding Commission. Regulations for the Erection of
Buildings within the Burnt District of Salem. Salem:Newcomb
and Gauss, printers, 1914.
Salem Rebuilding Commission. Report. Salem: Newcomb and Gauss,
printers, 1917.
Salem Rebuilding Trust. "Detailed Report of the Secretary." Mss. ,
1915.
Salem School Reports, 1930-31
SECONDARY SOURCES
Candee, Richard. Atlantic Heights." Portsmouth Marine Society,
Publication 7. Portsmouth: Peter E. Randall, Publisher.
Dennis, William. .Salem Evening Observer, 6/29/1912.
Donnell, Robert Phippen. "Locational Response to Catastrophe: The
Shoe and Leather Industry of Salem after the Conflagration
of June 25, 1914." In Essex Institute Historical
Collections, 113: 105-26, 1977.
Johnson, Claire. "Domestic Architecture in Victorian Salem: A
Lafayette Street Sampling." Essex Institute Historical
Collections, vol. 115, number 3, July 1979.
Little, Nina Fletcher. "Corne, McIntire, and the Hersey Derby
Farm." Antiques.
Lycette, Ronald L. , ed. A Salem Chronicle: The Evolution of a
College. Rowley: Rowley Printing, 1982.
Mrozowski, Stephen, at. al. Salem, Massachusetts: An
Archaeological Survey of the City. June, 1988.
Parley, Sidney. "Northfields." In the Essex Institute Historical
Collections, vol. 48.
Pinkham, Harold A. , Jr. "Winter Island: Its Use and Abuse."
Essex Institute Historical Collections, Vol 118, July 1982.
"Salem Has Had 32 Mayors Since Its Incorporation: Brief Sketches of
All." On file at the Essex Institute.
Salem Willows Merchant's Association Souvenir, 1929.
Smith, J. Foster. "Stage Point and Thereabouts." In Essex
Institute Historical Collections, 66: 1, 1930.
Symonds, E.B. "Old Northfields." In The Salem Observer, 1916. The
Plummer Farm School of Reform for Boys on Winter Island, Salem
Harbor. Boston: Farm School Press, Printers, 1884.
Tolles, Bryant. Architecture in Salem. Salem: Essex Institute,
1983.
18
OTHER
Essex Institute Photo Collection
Historic Salem, Inc. House Reports: 40 Felt Street, 24 Grove Street, 53
Ridgeway
Street, 18 Orne Street, 452 Lafayette Street, 387 Lafayette
Street, 18 Laurel Street, 23 Linden Street, 25 Hancock
Street, 14 School Street, 4 Beach Avenue.
Interview with Gary Moore, Winter Island Park manager.
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 1
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------ ------------------------------------------------------
A Salem Willows Area
C Winter Island, U.S. Coast Station
D Fire Area
E Ward & Peabody Sts. Area
F Saltonstall Parkway Area
G St. Joseph's Church Area
H Fairfield St. Area
I Pre-Fire Area
J Prince St. Pl. & 51-59 Dow St. Area
K 262 Loring Avenue, Loring Villa/Convent St. Chretienne
L Piekman Park Area
M Naples and Savoy Roads Area
N Salem State College
0 Derby and Messervy Estates Area
P Phillips and Irving Streets Area
Q Dunlap Street Area
R Southwick Street Area
S Salem Rebuilding Trust Area
16-285 10 Irving Street
16-302 81 Tremont Street
16-305 73 Tremont Street
16-319 1 Devereaux Avenue
17-8 101 Tremont Street
17-24 100 School Street
17-31 21 Bradford Street
17-41 6 Bradford Street
17-50 2 Bradford Street
17-51 5 Balcomb Street
17-53,54,55,56 9-15 Balcomb Street
17-68 7 Goodell Street
17-77 51 Highland Street
17-80 59 Highland Street
17-85 50 Lovett Street
17-102 41 Highland Street
17-108 29 Oakland Street
17-113 19 Oakland Street
17-127 30 Oakland Street
17-137 4 Granite Street
17-139 235 North Street
17-151 17 Highland Street
17-154 11 Highland Street
17-165 5 Granite Street
17-176 225 North Street
17-179 212 North Street
17-183 3 Woodside Street
17-190 17 Woodside Street
17-193 25 Woodside Street
17-196 41 Fairmount Street
17-199 14 Woodside Street
17-203 6 Woodside Street
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 2
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------- ------------------------------------------------------
17-207 208 North Street
17-208 206 North Street
17-211 3 Nursery Street
17-213 7 Nursery Street
17-218 202 North Street
17-219 198 North Street
17-220 196 North Street
17-235 209 North Street
17-239 7 Oakland Street
17-240 9 Oakland Street
17-242 15 Oakland Street
17-249 30 Balcomb Street
17-252 24 Balcomb Street
17-258 26 Northend Avenue
17-274 3 Ridgeway Street
17-285 195 North Street
17-286 197 North Street
.17-288 201 North Street
17-291 205 North Street
17-303 30 Symonds Street
17-311 21 Symonds Street
17-318 68-70 School Street
17-320 9-11 Chandler Street
17-321 13 Chandler Street
17-322 224-228 North Street
21-34 19 Cedarcrest Avenue
21-158 464 Loring Avenue
21-193 5 Elm Avenue
21-217 11 Maple Avenue
21-228 1 Paradise Road
22-133 55 Moffatt Road
26-67,68 11-11 1/2 Mason Street
26-77 19 Mason Street
26-78 21 Mason Street
26-81 27 Mason Street
26-105 54 Mason Street
26-203 24 Japonica Street
26-260-263 1-5 Barr and 28 Mason Streets
26-266 9 Barr Street
26-272 19 Barr Street
26-281-283 37-41 Barr Street
26-285 45 Barr Street
26-286 43 School Street
26-286 45-47 School Street
26-309 22 Mason Street
26-310 18-20 Mason Street
26-316 5 Buffum Street
26-331 18 Barr Street
26-335 10 Barr Street
26-355 7 Randall Street
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 3
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------- ------------------------------------------------------
26-356 5 Randall Street
26-377 15 R Franklin Court
26-381 18 Foster Street
26-384 6 Foster Street
26-393 5 Foster Street
27-6 44-46 School Street
27-14 44 Barr Street Extension
27-16 50 Barr Street Extension
27-19 28 School Street
27-22 47 Buffum Street
27-31 9 Symonds Street
27-37 10 Chandler Street
27-53 39 Buffum Street
27-55 21 School Street
27-57 29 School Street
27-69 8 Mead Court
27-78 141 R North Street
27-102 12 School Street
27-106 171 North Street
27-107 173 North Street
27-108 177 North Street
27-111 5 Symonds Street
27-117 183 North Street
27-120 181 North Street
27-122 16 Symonds Street
27-126 5 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-127 9 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-128 11-13 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-134 15 Fairmount Street
27-136 16 Nursery Street
27-140 8 Nursery Street
27-144 186-186 1/2 North Street
27-147 182 North Street
27-148 180 North Street
27-156 15 Nursery Street
27-158 19 Nursery Street
27-163 32 Fairmount Street
27-168 29 Nursery Street
27-171 57 Appleton Street
27-179 58 Appleton Street
27-193 18 Fairmount Street
27-195 14 Fairmount Street
27-197 10 Fairmount Street
27-200 19 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-202 27 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-206 43 Appleton Street
27-209 36 Appleton Street
27-212 2 Liberty Hill Avenue
27-216 168-168 1/2 North Street
27-221 9 Appleton Street
.. c
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 4
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
----------- ------------------------------------------------------
27-223 13 Appleton Street
27-232 31 Appleton Street
27-244 3 Stodder Place
27-248 146-146A North Street
27-264 33 Upham Street
27-268 10 Orae Street
27-283 5 Osborne Street
27-284 7 Osborne Street
27-310 18 Osborne Street
27-311 16 Osborne Street
27-312 12 1/2-14 Osborne Street
27-315 8 Osborne Street
27-316 19-21 Osborne Street
27-319 7 Harris Street
27-333 2 Harris Street
27-340 12 Harris Street
27-351 20-22 Orne Street
27-352 18 Orne Street
27-381 30 Orae Street
27-386 38 Walter Street
27-392 27 Dearborn Street
27-406 69 Orchard Street
27-436 19 Orchard Street
27-447 18 Southwick Street
27-449 8 Southwick Street
27-450 6 Southwick Street
27-461 29-31 Foster Street
27-464 37-39 Franklin Street
27-474 10 Moulton Avenue
27-485 3 Lee Street
27-488 9 Lee Street
27-497 96 Orchard Street
27-499 92 Orchard Street
27-503 72 Orchard Street
27-509 37 Dearborn Street
27-512 3 Larchmont Street
27-517 15 Larchmont Street
27-519 19 Larchmont Street
27-528 26 Lee Street
27-554 35 Felt Street
27-575 42 Larchmont Street
27-580 1 Claremont Road
27-601 40 Felt Street
27-609 18 Felt Street
27-610 4 Felt Street
27-630 7 Moulton Avenue
31-20 13 Pickman Road
31-22 19 Pickman Road
31-37 9 Moffatt Road
31-38 17 Moffatt Road
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 5
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------ ------------------------------------------------------
31-39 23 Moffatt Road
31-47 180 Loring Avenue
31-49 160 Loring Avenue
31-53 7 Station Road
31-81 114 Loring Avenue
31-82 112 Loring Avenue
31-95 111 Loring Avenue
31-100 135 Loring Avenue
31-112 1 Grant Road
31-134 211 Loring Avenue
31-138 225 Loring Avenue
31-159 6 Cleveland Road
31-160 8 Cleveland Road
31-233 Lafayette Street Sea Wall
31-315 257 Loring Avenue
31-318 1 Pierce Road
32-20 71 Loring Avenue
32-62 265 Canal Street
32-66 70 112 Loring Avenue
32-67 70 Loring Avenue
32-76 40 Loring Avenue
32-84 26 Loring Avenue
32-85 24 Loring Avenue
32-86 22 Loring Avenue
32-87 20 Loring Avenue
32-88 16-18 Loring Avenue
32-90 10 Loring Avenue
32-114 4 Charles Street
32-116 104 Linden St.
32-136 67 Loring Avenue
32-162 20-22 Raymond Avenue
32-163 18 Raymond Avenue
32-166 420 Lafayette St.
32-167 418 Lafayette St. '
32-168 416 Lafayette St.
32-171 412 Lafayette St.
32-176-181 ,191 ,202- 68-90, 73-93 Linden Street
32-192 40 Wisteria Street
32-200 15 Forest Avenue
32-214 450 Lafayette St.
32-215 452 Lafayette St.
32-220 5-7 Forest Ave.
32-228 321 Lafayette St.
32-229 323 Lafayette St.
32-231 331-333 Lafayette St.
32-233 5-7 West Avenue
32-234 11 West Avenue
32-235 13 West Avenue
32-245 6 Bristol Street
32-308 4 Loring Avenue
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 6
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
---------------- ------------------------------------------------------
32-321 8 West Avenue
32-322 6 West Avenue
32-324 343 Lafayette St.
32-326 349 Lafayette St.
32-327 353 Lafayette St.
32-328 357 Lafayette St.
32-329 359 Lafayette St.
32-336 13-15 Savoy Road
32-337 17 Savoy Road
32-340 25 Savoy Road
32-347 20 Naples Road
32-349 14 Naples Road
32-353 4 Naples Road
32-354 2 Naples Road
32-355 379 Lafayette St.
32-356 381 Lafayette St.
32-370 385 Lafayette St.
32-371 387 Lafayette St.
32-374 395 Lafayette St.
32-375 399 Lafayette St.
32-381 407 Lafayette St.
32-383 413 Lafayette St.
32-387 419 Lafayette St.
32-405 24 Savoy Road
32-415 361 Lafayette St.
32-416 363 Lafayette St.
32-417 375 Lafayette St.
33-15 15 Holly St.
33-47 44 Linden Street
33-56 83 Ocean Avenue
33-78 9-9 1/2 Meadow Street
33-98 19 Laurel Street
33-106 18 Laurel Street
33-120 & 119 2 & 4 Hazel St.
33-121 25 Roslyn St.
33-144 99 Canal St.
33-149 44 Roslyn St.
33-150 40-42 Roslyn St.
33-160 & 161 51-53 & 55-57 Hancock St.
33-177 25 Hancock St.
33-178 27 Hancock St.
33-180 & 181 31 & 37 Hancock St.
33-196 24 Cabot St.
33-197 22 Cabot St.
33-199 23 Gardner St.
33-200 29 Gardner St.
33-205 14 Hancock St.
33-206 12 Hancock St.
33-211 208 Lafayette St.
33-212 204 Lafayette St.
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 7
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
L ------------------- ------------------------------------------------------
33-225 17-19 Gardner St.
33-228 23 Cabot St.
33-229 25 Cabot St.
33-231 & 232 16 & 18 Roslyn St.
33-233 10-12 Roslyn St.
33-257 224 Lafayette St.
33-258 220 Lafayette St.
33-260 214 Lafayette St.
33-261 210 Lafayette St.
33-263 7-7A Hancock St.
33-265 11 Hancock St.
33-269 18-20 Holly St.
33-270 16 Holly St.
33-274 4 Holly St.
33-278 236 Lafayette St.
33-280 230 Lafayette St.
33-282 7 Roslyn St.
33-283 9 Roslyn St.
33-285 13 Roslyn St.
33-286 15 Roslyn St.
33-292 5 Hazel St.
33-303 12 Laurel Street
33-327 34 Linden Street
33-331 22 Linden Avenue
33-332 20 Linden Avenue
33-335 9 Laurel Street
33-339 13 Linden Avenue
33-346 1 Holly St.
33-347 3-3 1/2 Holly St.
33-348 5 Holly St.
33-349 1 Linden Avenue
33-351 5 Linden Avenue
33-359 23 Linden Avenue
33-361 27 Linden Avenue
33-364 58 Ocean Avenue
33-367 50 Ocean Avenue
33-375 1 Laurel Street
33-376 3 Laurel Street
33-377 5 Laurel Street
33-380 41-43 Linden Avenue
33-386 8-8A Forest Avenue
33-388 10-12 Wisteria Street
33-409 315 Lafayette St.
33-426 287-291 Lafayette St.
33-427 293 Lafayette St.
33-428 301 Lafayette St.
33-431 42 Ocean Avenue
33-448 3 Willow Avenue
33-451 7 Willow Avenue
33-454 12 Summit Avenue
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 8
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------- ------------------------------------------------------
33-455 10 Summit Avenue
33-459 2 Summit Avenue
33-468 235-239 Lafayette St.
33-483 63-65 Leach St.
33-494 16 Lafayette P1.
33-496 225 Lafayette St.
33-499 233 Lafayette St.
33-500 223 Lafayette St.
33-501 9 Lafayette P1.
33-503 17 Lafayette P1.
33-520 215 Lafayette St.
33-541 105 Leach Street
33-547 116 Leach Street
33-561 6 Glover Street
33-572 25 Green Street
33-587 5 Summit Avenue
33-588 3-5 Eden Street
33-602 7 Summit Avenue
33-610 9 Messervy Street
33-612 15 Messervy Street
33-619 17 Willow Avenue
33-630 22 Willow Avenue
33-633 16 Willow Avenue
33-644 15 Glendale Street
33-646 25 Glendale Street
33-648 14 Glendale St.
33-650 6-8 Glendale Street
33-655 30 Ocean Avenue
33-656 24 Ocean Avenue
33-657 22 Ocean Avenue
33-658 18 Ocean Avenue
33-659 16 Ocean Avenue
33-661 10 Ocean Avenue
33-663 4 Ocean Avenue
33-670 22 Shore Avenue
33-673 17 Shore Avenue
33-684 5 Ocean Avenue
33-685 9 Ocean Avenue
33-688 15 Ocean Avenue
33-689 21 Ocean Avenue
33-695 18 Ocean Terrace
33-718 39 Summit Avenue
33-743 32 Clifton St. , Timothy Pickering House
33-743 32 Clifton Avenue, Forest River Park
34-1 36-38 Gardner St.
34-6 26 Gardner St.
34-7 18 Cabot St.
34-8 16 Cabot St.
34-22 10 Gardner St.
34-34 11 Fairfield St.
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 9
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------ ------------------------------------------------------
34-40 16-18 Leavitt St.
34-44 193-195 Lafayette St.
34-45 184 Lafayette St.
34-49 15 Cedar St.
34-54 39-41 Cedar St.
34-58 10-12 Fairfield St.
34-62 2 Fairfield St.
34-69 65 Canal St.
34-75 12 Cabot St.
34-78 4-6 Cabot St.
34-107 2 Cedar St.
34-112 152-154 Lafayette St.
34-114 7-9 Cherry St.
34-156 39 Prince Street
34-161 108 Congress St.
34-171 85 Leavitt St.
34-174 44 Pingree St.
34-175 40 Pingree St.
34-183 25 Perkins St.
34-184 29 Perkins St.
34-185 31 Perkins St.
34-190 75 Palmer St.
34-191 10-14 Lynch St.
34-194 73 Congress St.
34-196 81 Congress St.
34-202 63-67 Palmer St.
34-204 34 Perkins St.
34-216 90-92 Congress St.
34-223 35 Park Street
34-242 10 Dow St.
34-245 163 Lafayette St.
34-246 167 Lafayette St.
34-250 13-15 Palmer St.
34-259 286 Washington St.
34-279 8-10 Porter St. Ct.
34-288 11 Pond St.
34-299 248 Washington St.
34-301 17 Canal St.
34-303B 124-132 Lafayette St. (Monument)
34-303A 124-132 Lafayette Street (Park)
34-312 6 Park St.
34-322 17-19 Salem St.
34-339 64-64 112 Harbor St.
34-367 19 Harbor St.
34-371 33 Harbor St.
34-387 14-18 Peabody St.
34-388 12 Peabody St.
34-389 8-10 Peabody St.
34-400 86-88 Lafayette St.
34-407 1 Ropes St.
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 10
Report: Final Property List
Map Number--------- STREET
---------- ------------------------------------------------
34-409A 257 Washington St.
34-409B 259 Washington St.
34-410 1-3 Harbor St.
34-412 108-122 Lafayette St.
34-413A 100 Lafayette St.
34-413B 104-106 Lafayette St.
34-414 92-96 Lafayette St.
34-430 73 Lafayette St.
34-434 1 Peabody St.
34-436 25 Peabody St.
34-473 199-201 Lafayette St.
34-474 211 Lafayette St,
44-3 1 Lowell St.
44-25 25 Winter Island Rd.
44-27 29 Winter Island Rd.
44-28 35 Winter Island Rd.
44-36 37 Winter Island Rd.
44-40 19 Columbus Ave.
44-42 27 Columbus Ave.
44-44 35 Columbus Ave.
44-46 1 Dustin St.
44-49 2 Dustin St.
44-51 61 Columbus Ave.
44-53 6 Lowell St.
44-54 65 Columbus Ave.
44-58 92 Columbus Ave.
44-59 43 Bay View Ave.
44-60 14 Juniper Ave.
44-92 77 Bay View Ave.
44-94 81 Bay View Ave.
44-104 1 High Street
44-105 105 Bay View Ave.
44-108 32 Beach Ave.
44-114 140 Bay View Ave
44-115 136-138 Bay View Ave.
44-116 130 Bay View Ave.
44-118 126 Bay View Ave.
44-119 122 Bay View Ave.
44-121 116 Bay View Ave.
44-122 112 Bay View Ave.
44-124 106 Bay View Ave.
44-127 100 Bay View Ave.
44-130 92 Bay View Ave.
44-135 80 Bay View Ave.
44-137 74 Bay View Ave.
44-141 48 Bay View Ave.
44-143 42 Bay View Ave.
44-145 30 Bay View Ave.
44-147 44 Columbus Ave.
44-155 10 Columbus Ave.
T
File: FULLLISTNUMERIC Page 11
Report: Final Property List
Map Number STREET
------------------- ------------------------------------------------------
45-33 3 Sutton Ave.
45-35 7 Sutton Ave.
45-43 21 Sutton Ave.
45-44 15 Bay View Ave.
45-47 97 Columbus Ave.
45-48 101-103 Columbus Ave.
45-52 117 Columbus Ave.
45-56 12 Beach Ave.
45-58 6-8 Beach Ave.
45-59 4 Beach Ave.
45-61 3 Beach Ave.
45-62 5-7 Beach Ave.
45-65 13 Beach Ave.
45-71 102 Columbus Ave.
45-72 96 Columbus Ave.
45-77 16 Beach Ave.
45-89 160-200 Fort Ave. , Salem Willows Park
45-92 25 Beach Ave.
45-93 152 Bay View Ave.
45-94 148 Bay View Ave
File: SouthSalemList Page 1
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP #
------------------------------------------------------ --------------------
6 Bristol Street 32-245
265 Canal Street 32-62
19 Cedarcrest Avenue 21-34
4 Charles Street 32-114
6 Cleveland Road 31-159
8 Cleveland Road 31-160
32 Clifton St. , Timothy Pickering House 33-743
32 Clifton Avenue, Forest River Park 33-743
Derby and Messervy Estates Area 0
3-5 Eden Street 33-588
5 Elm Avenue 21-193
5-7 Forest Ave. 32-220
15 Forest Avenue 32-200
8-8A Forest Avenue 33-386
15 Glendale Street 33-644
25 Glendale Street 33-646
6-8 Glendale Street 33-650
14 Glendale St. 33-648
6 Glover Street 33-561
1 Grant Road 31-112
25 Green Street 33-572
287-291 Lafayette St. 33-426
293 Lafayette St. 33-427
301 Lafayette St. 33-428
315 Lafayette St. 33-409
321 Lafayette St. 32-228
323 Lafayette St. 32-229
331-333 Lafayette St. 32-231
343 Lafayette St. 32-324
349 Lafayette St. 32-326
353 Lafayette St. 32-327
357 Lafayette St. 32-328
359 Lafayette St. 32-329
361 Lafayette St. 32-415
363 Lafayette St. 32-416
375 Lafayette St. 32-417
379 Lafayette St. 32-355
381 Lafayette St. 32-356
385 Lafayette St. 32-370
387 Lafayette St. 32-371
395 Lafayette St. 32-374
399 Lafayette St. 32-375
407 Lafayette St. 32-381
413 Lafayette St. 32-383
419 Lafayette St. 32-387
412 Lafayette St. 32-171
416 Lafayette St. 32-168
418 Lafayette St. 32-167
420 Lafayette St. 32-166
450 Lafayette St. 32-214
File: SouthSalemList Page 2
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP S
------------------------------- --------------------
452 Lafayette St. 32-215
Lafayette Street Sea Wall 31-233
1 Laurel Street 33-375
3 Laurel Street 33-376
5 Laurel Street 33-377
9 Laurel Street 33-335
19 Laurel Street 33-98
12 Laurel Street 33-303
18 Laurel Street 33-106
105 Leach Street 33-541
116 Leach Street 33-547
1 Linden Avenue 33-349
5 Linden Avenue 33-351
13 Linden Avenue 33-339
23 Linden Avenue 33-359
27 Linden Avenue 33-361
41-43 Linden Avenue 33-380
20 Linden Avenue 33-332
22 Linden Avenue 33-331
34 Linden Street 33-327
44 Linden Street 33-47
68-90, 73-93 Linden Street 32-176-181 ,191 ,202-6
104 Linden St. 32-116
67 Loring Avenue 32-136
71 Loring Avenue 32-20
111 Loring Avenue 31-95
135 Loring Avenue 31-100
211 Loring Avenue 31-134
225 Loring Avenue 31-138
257 Loring Avenue 31-315
4 Loring Avenue 32-308
10 Loring Avenue 32-90
16-18 Loring Avenue 32-88
20 Loring Avenue 32-87
22 Loring Avenue 32-86
24 Loring Avenue 32-85
26 Loring Avenue 32-84
40 Loring Avenue 32-76
70 Loring Avenue 32-67
70 1/2 Loring Avenue 32-66
112 Loring Avenue 31-82
114 Loring Avenue 31-81
160 Loring Avenue 31-49
180 Loring Avenue 31-47
464 Loring Avenue 21-158
262 Loring Avenue, Loring Villa/Convent St. Chretienne R
11 Maple Avenue 21-217
9-9 1/2 Meadow Street 33-78
9 Messervy Street 33-610
15 Messervy Street 33-612
File: SouthSalemList Page 3
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP
------------------------------------------------------ --------------------
9 Moffatt Road 31-37
17 Moffatt Road 31-38
23 Moffatt Road 31-39
55 Moffatt Road 22-133
Naples and Savoy Roads Area M
2 Naples Road 32-354
4 Naples Road 32-353
14 Naples Road 32-349
20 Naples Road 32-347
5 Ocean Avenue 33-684
9 Ocean Avenue 33-685
15 Ocean Avenue 33-688
21 Ocean Avenue 33-689
83 Ocean Avenue 33-56
4 Ocean Avenue 33-663
10 Ocean Avenue 33-661
16 Ocean Avenue 33-659
18 Ocean Avenue 33-658
22 Ocean Avenue 33-657
24 Ocean Avenue 33-656
30 Ocean Avenue 33-655
42 Ocean Avenue 33-431
50 Ocean Avenue 33-367
58 Ocean Avenue 33-364
18 Ocean Terrace 33-695
1 Paradise Road 21-228
Pickman Park Area L
13 Pickman Road 31-20
19 Pickman Road 31-22
1 Pierce Road 31-318
18 Raymond Avenue 32-163
20-22 Raymond Avenue 32-162
Salem State College N
13-15 Savoy Road 32-336
17 Savoy Road 32-337
25 Savoy Road 32-340
24 Savoy Road 32-405
17 Shore Avenue 33-673
22 Shore Avenue 33-670
7 Station Road 31-53
5 Summit Avenue 33-587
7 Summit Avenue 33-602
39 Summit Avenue 33-718
2 Summit Avenue 33-459
10 Summit Avenue 33-455
12 Summit Avenue 33-454
5-7 West Avenue 32-233
11 West Avenue 32-234
13 West Avenue 32-235
6 West Avenue 32-322
File: SouthSalemList Page 4
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP $
------------------------------------------------------ -------
8 West Avenue 32-321
3 Willow Avenue 33-448
7 Willow Avenue 33-451
17 Willow Avenue 33-619
16 Willow Avenue 33-633
22 Willow Avenue 33-630
10-12 Wisteria Street 33-388
40 Wisteria Street 32-192
- i
File: StagePolntList Page 1
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP #
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
23 Cabot St. 33-228
25 Cabot St. 33-229
4-6 Cabot St. 34-78
12 Cabot St. 34-75
16 Cabot St. 34-8
18 Cabot St. 34-7
22 Cabot St. 33-197
24 Cabot St. 33-196
17 Canal St. 34-301
65 Canal St. 34-69
99 Canal St. 33-144
15 Cedar St. 34-49
39-41 Cedar St. 34-54
2 Cedar St. 34-107
7-9 Cherry St. 34-114
73 Congress St. 34-194
81 Congress St. 34-196
90-92 Congress St. 34-216
108 Congress St. 34-161
10 Dow St. 34-242
Fairfield St. Area H
11 Fairfield St. 34-34
2 Fairfield St. 34-62
10-12 Fairfield St. 34-58
Fire Area D
17-19 Gardner St. 33-225
23 Gardner St. 33-199
29 Gardner St. 33-200
10 Gardner St. 34-22
26 Gardner St. 34-6
36-38 Gardner St. 34-1
7-7A Hancock St 33-263
11 Hancock St. 33-265
25 Hancock St. 33-177
27 Hancock St. 33-178
31 & 37 Hancock St. 33-180 & 181
51-53 & 55-57 Hancock St. 33-160 & 161
12 Hancock St. 33-206
14 Hancock St. 33-205
1-3 Harbor St. 34-410
19 Harbor St. 34-367
33 Harbor St. 34-371
64-64 1/2 Harbor St. 34-339
5 Hazel St. 33-292
2 & 4 Hazel St. 33-120 & 119
1 Holly St. 33-346
3-3 1/2 Holly St. 33-347
5 Holly St. 33-348
15 Holly St. 33-15
4 Holly St. 33-274
File: StagePointList Page 2
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP 0
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
16 Holly St. 33-270
18-20 Holly St. 33-269
9 Lafayette Pl. 33-501
17 Lafayette Pl. 33-503
16 Lafayette Pl. 33-494
73 Lafayette St. 34-430
163 Lafayette St. 34-245
167 Lafayette St. 34-246
193-195 Lafayette St. 34-44
199-201 Lafayette St. 34-473
211 Lafayette St. 34-474
215 Lafayette St. 33-520
223 Lafayette St. 33-500
225 Lafayette St. 33-496
233 Lafayette St. 33-499
235-239 Lafayette St. 33-468
86-88 Lafayette St. 34-400
92-96 Lafayette St. 34-414
100 Lafayette St. 34-413A
104-106 Lafayette St. 34-413B
108-122 Lafayette St. 34-412
124-132 Lafayette St. (Monument) 34-303B
124-132 Lafayette Street (Park) 34-303A
152-154 Lafayette St. 34-112
184 Lafayette St. 34-45
204 Lafayette St. 33-212
208 Lafayette St. 33-211
210 Lafayette St. 33-261
214 Lafayette St. 33-260
220 Lafayette St. 33-258
224 Lafayette St. 33-257
230 Lafayette St. 33-280
236 Lafayette St. 33-278
63-65 Leach St. 33-483
85 Leavitt St. 34-171
16-18 Leavitt St. 34-40
10-14 Lynch St. 34-191
13-15 Palmer St. 34-250
63-67 Palmer St. 34-202
75 Palmer St. 34-190
35 Park Street 34-223
6 Park St. 34-312
1 Peabody St. 34-434
25 Peabody St. 34-436
8-10 Peabody St. 34-389
12 Peabody St. 34-388
14-18 Peabody St. 34-387
25 Perkins St. 34-183
29 Perkins St. 34-184
31 Perkins St. 34-185
File: StagePointList Page 3
Report: Final Property List
ADDRESS MAP #
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
34 Perkins St. 34-204
40 Pingree St. 34-175
44 Pingree St. 34-174
11 Pond St. 34-288
8-10 Porter St. Ct. 34-279
Pre-Fire Area I
39 Prince Street 34-156
Prince St. P1. & 51-59 Dow St. Area J
1 Ropes St. 34-407
7 Roslyn St. 33-282
9 Roslyn St. 33-283
13 Roslyn St. 33-285
15 Roslyn St. 33-286
25 Roslyn St. 33-121
10-12 Roslyn St. 33-233
16 & 18 Roslyn St. 33-231 & 232
40-42 Roslyn St. 33-150
44 Roslyn St. 33-149
St. Joseph's Church Area G
17-19 Salem St. 34-322
Saltonstall Parkway Area F
Ward & Peabody Sts. Area E
257 Washington St. 34-409A
259 Washington St. 34-409B
248 Washington St. 34-299
286 Washington St. 34-259
File: SalemWillowsLst Pa$e 1
Report: Final Property List
STREET MAP U
------------------------------------------------- ---------------------
15 Bay View Ave. 45-44
43 Bay View Ave. 44-59
77 Bay View Ave. 44-92
81 Bay View Ave. 44-94
105 Bay View Ave. 44-105
30 Bay View Ave. 44-145
42 Bay View Ave. 44-143
48 Bay View Ave. 44-141
74 Bay View Ave. 44-137
80 Bay View Ave. 44-135
92 Bay View Ave. 44-130
100 Bay View Ave. 44-127
106 Bay View Ave. 44-124
112 Bay View Ave. 44-122
116 Bay View Ave. 44-121
122 Bay View Ave. 44-119
126 Bay View Ave. 44-118
130 Bay View Ave. 44-116
136-138 Bay View Ave. 44-115
140 Bay View Ave 44-114
148 Bay View Ave 45-94
152 Bay View Ave. 45-93
3 Beach Ave. 45-61
5-7 Beach Ave. 45-62
13 Beach Ave. 45-65
25 Beach Ave. 45-92
4 Beach Ave. 45-59
6-8 Beach Ave. 45-58
12 Beach Ave. 45-56
16 Beach Ave. 45-77
32 Beach Ave. 44-108
19 Columbus Ave. 44-40
27 Columbus Ave. 44-42
35 Columbus Ave. 44-44
61 Columbus Ave. 44-51
65 Columbus Ave. 44-54
97 Columbus Ave. 45-47
101-103 Columbus Ave. 45-48
117 Columbus Ave. 45-52
10 Columbus Ave. 44-155
44 Columbus Ave. 44-147
92 Columbus Ave. 44-58
96 Columbus Ave. 45-72
102 Columbus Ave. 45-71
1 Dustin St. 44-46
2 Dustin St. 44-49
160-200 Fort Ave. , Salem Willows Park 45-89
1 High Street 44-104
14 Juniper Ave. 44-60
1 Lowell St. 44-3
I
File: SalemWillowsLst Page 2
Report: Final Property List
STREET MAP S
------------------------------------------------- ---------------------
6 Lowell St. 44-53
Salem Willows Area A
3 Sutton Ave. 45-33
7 Sutton Ave. 45-35
21 Sutton Ave. 45-43
25 Winter Island Rd. 44-25
29 Winter Island Rd. 44-27
35 Winter Island Rd. 44-28
Winter Island, U.S. Coast Station C
37 Winter Island Rd. 44-36
Y �^
File: NorthSalemList Page 1
Report: Final Property List
STREET Map Number
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
9 Appleton Street 27-221
13 Appleton Street 27-223
31 Appleton Street 27-232
43 Appleton Street 27-206
57 Appleton Street 27-171
36 Appleton Street 27-209
58 Appleton Street 27-179
5 Balcomb Street 17-51
9-15 Balcomb Street 17-53,54,55,56
24 Balcomb Street 17-252
30 Balcomb Street 17-249
1-5 Barr and 28 Mason Streets 26-260-263
9 Barr Street 26-266
19 Barr Street 26-272
37-41 Barr Street 26-281-283
45 Barr Street 26-285
10 Barr Street 26-335
18 Barr Street 26-331
44 Barr Street Extension 27-14
50 Barr Street Extension 27-16
21 Bradford Street 17-31
2 Bradford Street 17-50
6 Bradford Street 17-41
5 Buffum Street 26-316
39 Buffum Street 27-53
47 Buffum Street 27-22
9-11 Chandler Street 17-320
13 Chandler Street 17-321
10 Chandler Street 27-37
1 Claremont Road 27-580
27 Dearborn Street 27-392
37 Dearborn Street 27-509
1 Devereaux Avenue 16-319
Dunlap Street Area Q
15 Fairmount Street 27-134
41 Fairmount Street 17-196
10 Fairmount Street 27-197
14 Fairmount Street 27-195
18 Fairmount Street 27-193
32 Fairmount Street 27-163
35 Felt Street 27-554
4 Felt Street 27-610
18 Felt Street 27-609
40 Felt Street 27-601
5 Foster Street 26-393
29-31 Foster Street 27-461
6 Foster Street 26-384
18 Foster Street 26-381
15 R Franklin Court 26-377
37-39 Franklin Street 27-464
File: NorthSalemList Page 2
Report: Final Property List
STREET Map Number
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
7 Goodell Street 17-68
5 Granite Street 17-165
4 Granite Street 17-137
7 Harris Street 27-319
2 Harris Street 27-333
12 Harris Street 27-340
11 Highland Street 17-154
17 Highland Street 17-151
41 Highland Street 17-102
51 Highland Street 17-77
59 Highland Street 17-80
10 Irving Street 16-285
24 Japonica Street 26-203
3 Larchmont Street 27-512
15 Larchmont Street 27-517
19 Larchmont Street 27-519
42 Larchmont Street 27-575
3 Lee Street 27-485
9 Lee Street 27-488
26 Lee Street 27-528
5 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-126
9 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-127
11-13 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-128
19 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-200
27 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-202
2 Liberty Hill Avenue 27-212
50 Lovett Street 17-85
11-11 1/2 Mason Street 26-67,68
19 Mason Street 26-77
21 Mason Street 26-78
27 Mason Street 26-81
18-20 Mason Street 26-310
22 Mason Street 26-309
54 Mason Street 26-105
8 Mead Court 27-69
7 Moulton Avenue 27-630
10 Moulton Avenue 27-474
141 R North Street 27-78
171 North Street 27-106
173 North Street 27-107
177 North Street 27-108
181 North Street 27-120
183 North Street 27-117
195 North Street 17-285
197 North Street 17-286
201 North Street 17-288
205 North Street 17-291
209 North Street 17-235
225 North Street 17-176
235 North Street 17-139
File: NorthSalemList Page 3
Report: Final Property List
STREET Map Number
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
146-146A North Street 27-248
168-168 1/2 North Street 27-216
180 North Street 27-148
182 North Street 27-147
186-186 1/2 North Street 27-144
196 North Street 17-220
198 North Street 17-219
202 North Street 17-218
206 North Street 17-208
208 North Street 17-207
212 North Street 17-179
224-228 North Street 17-322
26 Northend Avenue 17-258
3 Nursery Street 17-211
7 Nursery Street 17-213
15 Nursery Street 27-156
19 Nursery Street 27-158
29 Nursery Street 27-168
8 Nursery Street 27-140
16 Nursery Street 27-136
7 Oakland Street 17-239
9 Oakland Street 17-240
15 Oakland Street 17-242
19 Oakland Street 17-113
29 Oakland Street 17-108
30 Oakland Street 17-127
19 Orchard Street 27-436 .
69 Orchard Street 27-406
72 Orchard Street 27-503
92 Orchard Street 27-499
96 Orchard Street 27-497
10 Orne Street 27-268
18 Orne Street 27-352
20-22 Orne Street 27-351
30 Orne Street 27-381
5 Osborne Street 27-283
7 Osborne Street 27-284
19-21 Osborne Street 27-316
8 Osborne Street 27-315
12 1/2-14 Osborne Street 27-312
16 Osborne Street 27-311
18 Osborne Street 27-310
Phillips and Irving Streets Area P
5 Randall Street 26-356
7 Randall Street 26-355
3 Ridgeway Street 17-274
21 School Street 27-55
29 School Street 27-57
43 School Street 26-286
45-47 School Street 26-286
File: NorthSalemList Page 4
Report: Final Property List
STREET Map Number
---------------------------------------------------- ------------------
12 School Street 27-102
28 School Street 27-19
44-46 School Street 27-6
68-70 School Street 17-318
100 School Street 17-24
6 Southwick Street 27-450
8 Southwick Street 27-449
18 Southwick Street 27-447
Southwick Street Area R
3 Stodder Place 27-244
5 Symonds Street 27-111
9 Symonds Street 27-31
21 Symonds Street 17-311
16 Symonds Street 27-122
30 Symonds Street 17-303
73 Tremont Street 16-305
81 Tremont Street 16-302
101 Tremont Street 17-8
Salem Rebuilding Trust Area S
33 Upham Street 27-264
38 Walter Street 27-386
3 Woodside Street 17-183
17 Woodside Street 17-190
25 Woodside Street 17-193
6 Woodside Street 17-203
14 Woodside Street 17-199
SALEM FY89 SURVEY AND
PLANNI G GRANT COMPLETION
REPORT
COMPILED FOR THE
SALEM PLANNING DEPARTMENT
AND THE MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL
COMMISSION BY NORTHFIELDS
PRESERVATION ASSOCIATES 19_90
SALEM FY89 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT COMPLETION REPORT
Background and Project Description
The survey and planning project was designed primarily to complete,
evaluate and reorganize the inventory of Salem s historic resources. Survey
work had been conducted intermittently from 1967 to the present, with a
concentrated effort by the Salem Planning Department beginning in 1984 to
complete the survey in areas of the city not previously covered.
At the start of this year's project several remaining areas were identified
that had not been surveyed; Gallows Hill, Castle Hill, and West Salem
(primarily the Highland Avenue area). Completion of the survey of these
areas was Phase I.
The existing inventory included approximately 3400 properties, consisting
of several generations of survey forms prepared between 1967 and the
present. These forms were located at both the Massachusetts Historical
Commission (MHC) and the Salem Planning Department, however, neither
office had a complete set or an index of the existing material. The level of
documentation varied considerably, and the numbering system was
problematic. The inventory had never been mapped in its entirety.
By far the largest component of the project was the reorganization of this
material. It was indexed, renumbered, and mapped, with copies of missing
forms supplied to the Salem Planning Department and MHC. An evaluation
of the existing survey was done in the course of the reorganization.
The final phases of the project involved the evaluation of National Register
and local historic district designations. Existing district boundaries were
examined and recommendations prepared for their expansion in several
2
cases. Recommendations were also made for potential new National Register
or local historic districts and for properties potentially eligible for individual
listing on the National Register,
Survey Completion
The FY88 Survey project, also conducted by Northfields Preservation
Associates, had identified Gallows Hill as the last remaining area with a large
amount of survey work left to be completed. The area had been surveyed in
1978 by Historic Salem Inc. (HSI), resulting in adequate documentation of
Boston Street, (the principal street through Gallows Hill), and insufficient
documentation of the adjoining neighborhood. A related research project
undertaken c. 1978 by HSI involved extensive research on the Gallows Hill
area through census records, tax records and other sources. This material is
on file at the Salem Planning Department. Using much of the historical
research prepared by HSI and following standard MHC survey methodology,
124 inventory forms were prepared for Gallows Hill and other scattered
resources in the areas of Castle Hill and West Salem.
The project scope called for 200 inventory forms, which were not needed,
so additional photography was done to complete existing forms. In some
cases adequate forms prepared by HSI in the Boston Street area did not have
photographs, so photographs were taken and added to approximately 30
1978 forms. Survey forms prepared in 1978 and 1979 for Downtown Salem
as part of a Multiple Resource Area nomination to the National Register also
needed photographs, and approximately 40 new photographs were taken
and added to existing forms for Washington, lower Federal and lower Essex
Streets.
The methodology for the areas surveyed was as follows:
3
Windshield Survey
Preliminary property lists were prepared through a visual assessment of
all properties in the remaining survey areas and a review of the adequacy of
existing forms for the Gallows Hill area. During this phase buildings were
selected based on criteria relating to architectural significance. They must
retain substantial integrity of location, design, setting, materials,
workmanship, feeling and association. Generally buildings to which
synthetic siding had been applied, whose windows had been replaced, or
which had otherwise been inappropriately altered were omitted from the list
unless they possessed particular significance for other surviving
architectural features or strong historical associations.
Further fieldwork was conducted to photograph and to prepare
descriptions of all listed buildings.
Research
Research concentrated on three main objectives: 1) to evaluate the visual
and architectural significance of each property, 2) to document the role of
previous owners and occupants in the development of the community, and
3) to clarify local development patterns using information gained from the
existing architectural styles and historical sources. Most extensive use was
made of maps and atlases, city directories, records of building permits, and
the historical research prepared by HSI in 1978.
Once.fieldwork and research were completed, MHC survey forms were
compiled with maps, photographs and statements of architectural and
historical significance. Each form was given a number based on the new
numbering system and all properties were plotted on the set of base maps
developed as part of the survey organization (see below). Areas were given
letters.
4
The survey identified and recorded 4 areas, 108 individual buildings, 2
structures, 4 objects, 2 streetscapes, 1 cemetery, and 3 landscapes that are
significant in local, state or national history and retain their physical
integrity.
Survey Organization
At the start of this project Salem's survey was virtually useless. There
was no complete index available. It was not fully mapped. Neither the MHC
nor the Salem Planning Department had a complete set of inventory forms.
In order to make this extensive resource usable and accessible, a major
reorganization was essential. Inventory forms had been prepared by a wide
variety of individuals and organizations beginning in 1967. Not only did
their quality and level of documentation vary widely, but there had been
several generations of forms prepared for many properties.
The first step in the reorganization was to develop a complete list of all
properties for which inventory forms existed at either location. All partial
inventory lists were consolidated and alphabetized. Every form at the
Planning Department and at the MHC was checked against this list, with new
lists generated of all additional forms at one or both locations. The list also
included the year each form was prepared.
This process made it apparent that there were major gaps in the
-inventory at both locations. The Salem Planning Department was missing
approximately 50 forms found at the MHC, while the MHC lacked
approximately 600 forms existing at the Planning Department. Copies of the
forms found only at the MHC were made to complete the Planning
Department's inventory.
5
Throughout the reorganization, frequent discussions occured with Lestra
Litchfield at the MHC concerning organization, numbering and mapping
details that would make the system compatible with the MHC's MACRIS
(Massachusetts Cultural Resource Information System) computerization
project.
Hundreds of the inventory forms not found at the MHC were those
prepared by HSI in 1978. In many cases the MHC did not have all inventory
forms prepared for a property when multiple forms existed. With MHC staff
we concluded that forms to be submitted to the MHC must have at least two
of the following: photograph, architectural description, and historical
significance. Where several generations of forms existed, the latest or most
complete was selected to be copied. Ultimately approximately 450 Planning
Department forms were photocopied and the originals submitted to the MHC.
The index is broken down into the following lists:
Areas and Streetscapes
Buildings
Cemeteries
Parks and Landscapes, Structures, Objects, Sites
Included in the index of buildings are all properties identified as part of
streetscapes, as well as all buildings located in local or National Register
districts. A key to abbreviations used on the index is found with it. In some
cases_where more-than one inventory form exists for a given property, the
MHC will not have all versions, but only the latest and/or most useful.
Where others are listed on the index they can be found at the Salem
Planning Department. Lists contain the following information:
ADDRESS - Usually a street address, occasionally indicates a
general area only.
6
FORM - New inventory form number is shown here. Each
property has its own number. Areas and streetscapes are
designated by letters. Numbering for buildings begins with 1;
cemeteries with 800; parks, landscapes, structures and objects
with 900.
HISTORIC NAME -Provided when it appeared on the inventory
form.
MAP # - Salem assessor's map and lot numbers. These were
formerly used as inventory numbers.
AREA - Eleven geographical areas were identified, and are
indicated here.
FORM YEARS - Years for which inventory forms or other types of
designation (National Register or local historic district) exist.
TYPE - This indicates inventory form type (building, area,
cemetery, etc.) as well as National Register or local historic
district designation. Where more than one type applies they are
given in chronological order corresponding to the dates under
Form Years.
Prior to the reorganization, the inventory was numbered using Assessor's
map and lot numbers. The MHC's MACRIS computerization project required
that all properties included in the inventory be renumbered. The new
numbering system runs from 1 to 3578. Numbering begins with the
property with the lowest Assessors' map and lot number. New numbers and
geographical designations were added to all inventory forms at the Planning
Department and at the MHC.
A set of base maps were prepared on Assessor's maps locating all
properties included in the inventory, showing district boundaries for local
7
and National Register districts, and identifying individually listed National
Register properties.
Survey Evaluation
The quality and completeness of documentation on inventory forms varies
considerably depending on when a form was prepared, and by whom.
Generally the earlier forms were less complete, due largely to the less
stringent approach taken to survey in the late 1960s and 1970s. Work
completed in the 1980s was prepared by consultants or Planning
Department staff with expertise in historic preservation, and is generally
thorough.
Geographical Areas
BRIDGE STREET - In 1978, HSI prepared streetscape forms and some B
forms in this area. These generally included photographs, some maps, brief
architectural descriptions, and no historical information. A comprehensive
inventory of the area was completed by a consultant to the Salem Planning
Department under an MHC Survey and Planning Grant in 1985.
CASTLE HILL - Work was completed by Northfields Preservation Associates
for the Salem Planning Department as part of this year's Survey and
Planning Grant project.
CENTRAL SALEM - This geographical designation includes the commercial
area in.Downtown Salem,.the.residential area included in the McIntire
Historic District and residential areas south of the historic district. The area
includes inventory forms from 1967-1968, 1974-1975, and 1978-1979. In
general, the work from 1967-1968 and 1974-1975 was in the residential
areas, and was of similar quality. Most forms have an adequate photograph,
8
a map, and minimal architectural and historical information. The forms in
the McIntire Historic District need to be updated.
Downtown Salem was surveyed in 1978-1979 by Historic Salem Inc. and
the Salem Redevelopment Authority staff in conjunction with the
preparation of a Multiple Resource Area nomination to the National Register.
In many cases, two survey forms exist from this phase; the HSI form having
historical and architectural information, and the Salem Redevelopment
Authority form having a good photograph and occasionally a brief contextual
statement. These forms need to be used together.
DERBY STREET - This area includes survey forms from 1967, 1973, 1977,
1980, and 1985-1986. Buildings surveyed in 1967 and 1973 are located
within the Derby Waterfront Historic District (local and National Register).
These forms generally have adequate photographs, maps, and minimal
architectural and historical information. A small number of buildings on
several side streets (Becket, Daniels, Hardy) was surveyed in 1977 and 1980.
A 1986 Survey and Planning grant resulted in the completion of survey in
the area, primarily on side streets. This included new forms for some
buildings previously surveyed. Survey forms on Derby Street itself should
be updated.
GALLOWS HILL - In 1978, HSI did survey work in this area. B forms
generally have accepatable photographs, and no maps, Most have brief
architectural descriptions which vary in accuracy, and some have a limited
amount of historical information. More detailed historical information was
collected for Boston Street forms. Streetscape forms for this area generally
included photographs, no maps, brief architectural descriptions, and no
historical information. Additional work was completed by Northfields
9
Preservation Associates for the Salem Planning Department as part of this
year's Survey and Planning Grant project.
NORTH SALEM - Inventory forms exist for this area dating from 1978, 1986
and 1989. In 1978, HSI did survey work west of North Street. A small
number of B forms was prepared, generally having accepatable photographs,
and no maps. Most have brief architectural descriptions which vary in
accuracy, and some have a limited amount of historical information. The
majority of the HSI forms for this area were streetscapes, which generally
included photographs, no maps, brief architectural descriptions, and no
historical information. This material was of limited use, and has been
updated ( 1989).
A 1986 Survey and Planning grant funded survey work east of North
Street, which was conducted by the Planning Department. Additional work
was completed by Northfields Preservation Associates for the Salem
Planning Department as part of the 1989 Survey and Planning Grant project.
SALEM COMMON - Inventory forms for this area were prepared in 1967,
1972, and 1987. While the two early generations of forms are
characteristically sketchy in historical and architectural information, the
inventory for the area was completed and updated by the Salem Planning
Department and Northfields Preservation Associates under a Survey and
Planning Grant in 1987.
SALEM WILLOWS - Work was completed by Northfields Preservation
Associates for the Salem Planning Department as part of the 1988 Survey
and Planning Grant project.
SOUTH SALEM - Survey work in this area was conducted in 1985 by Salem
Planning Department staff and completed in 1989 by Northfields
Preservation Associates, both under Survey and Planning Grants.
10
STAGE POINT - Work was completed by Northfields Preservation Associates
for the Salem Planning Department as part of the 1988 Survey and Planning
Grant project.
WEST SALEM - Work was completed by Northfields Preservation Associates
for the Salem Planning Department as part of this year's Survey and
Planning Grant project.
Local and National Register Recommendations
This report makes recommendations concerning existing and potential
historic designations in Salem, however prior to putting these
recommendations into effect, a thorough examination of other related issues
needs to occur. Priorities for any of these changes need to be set in the
context of a comprehensive preservation plan for the city. Should the Salem
Planning Department receive a Survey and Planning Grant for FY90 to
complete a preservation plan, these questions should be addressed.
Existing Districts
There are currently 9 National Register Historic Districts in Salem (the
State Register lists several other districts, all of which have been
incorporated within the boundaries of the larger districts listed below):
BAKER'S ISLAND LIGHT STATION - The possibility of a district
encompassing all of Baker's Island should be explored.
CHARTER STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are
appropriate.
CHESTNUT STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are
narrower than those of the McIntire Historic District (local), and a
larger area is clearly eligible. Boundaries of the existing local district
11
should provide a starting point for expansion, but some potentially
eligible properties were identified outside either existing district.
Areas of particular note that should be considered include the east
side of Summer Street (5-23, and from Gedney Street to 61),
Winthrop Street (up to 5 and 12), Broad Street and the adjacent
streets to the south, and the west end of Warren Street.
CROMBIE STREET DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are appropriate.
DERBY WATERFRONT HISTORIC DISTRICT - Cross streets between
Hawthorne Boulevard and English Street, extending south from Essex
Street, contain a dense concentration of buildings spanning the 18th
and 19th centuries. They vary in integrity, but the alterations are
largely reversible, consisting
primarily of synthetic siding and occasional window replacement.
Possible expansion of the district to include this area should be
considered in conjunction with the comprehensive preservation plan.
DOWNTOWN SALEM DISTRICT - These boundaries are generally
appropriate. Possible expansion might include the north side of Essex
Street extending to North Street.
FEDERAL STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are
appropriate.
GEDNEY AND COX HOUSES - Existing boundaries are appropriate.
SALEM COMMON HISTORIC DISTRICT - The FY86 Survey and Planning
project examined these boundaries, and made recommendations for
expansion. These are still appropriate, and are attached at the end of
the report. They include additions on Boardman, Briggs, Forrester,
and Pleasant Streets.
12
The State Register lists several local districts which were ultimately
consolidated into the McIntire Historic District. Salem currently has four
local historic districts, which are:
DERBY WATERFRONT HISTORIC DISTRICT - Cross streets between
Hawthorne Boulevard and English Street, extending south from Essex
Street, contain a dense concentration of buildings spanning the 18th
and 19th centuries. They vary in integrity, but the alterations are
largely reversible, consisting
primarily of synthetic siding and occasional window replacement.
Possible expansion of the district to include this area should be
considered in conjunction with the comprehensive preservation plan.
One approach to this would be to merge the Derby street and
Washington Square Historic Districts.
LAFAYETTE STREET HISTORIC DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are
appropriate.
MCINTIRE HISTORIC DISTRICT - Existing boundaries are generally
appropriate. 5-23 Summer Street should be considered for addition
to the district.
WASHINGTON SQUARE HISTORIC DISTRICT - The FY86 Survey and
Planning project examined these boundaries, and made
recommendations for expansion. These are still appropriate, and are
attached at the end of the report. An alternative approach, which
should be considered, is to merge the Derby Street and Washington
Square Historic Districts as discussed above.
13
Recommended New Designations
For all district recommendations, see attached maps of proposed new
districts for general boundary recommendations. Final boundaries should be
determined at the time documentation is prepared for new or expanded
districts.
NATIONAL REGISTER DISTRICTS
Survey work undertaken in the past few years-has resulted in the following
recommendations for district designation:
Buff um Street
Dearborn Street
Derby Estate Area
Fairfield Street
Loring Villa/Convent St. Chretienne
Naples and Savoy Roads
Prince Street Place
Salem Rebuilding Trust Area
Salem State College
Salem Willows
Ward and Peabody Streets
Winter Island
INDIVIDUAL NATIONAL REGISTER:
152 Boston Street - Bell-Reith House- Georgian
175 Boston Street
19 Cedarcrest Avenue
14
I Devereaux Avenue - George H. Devereaux House
18 Felt Street
40 Felt Street - James Brooks and John Bell House
23 Gardner Street
29 Grove Street - Ledge Hill
30-36 Grove Street - Harmony Grove Cemetery Caretaker's House
29 Highland Avenue - Former Salem High School
211 Lafayette Street - Saltonstall School
220 Lafayette Street - Walter K. Bigelow House
395 Lafayette Street - Almy House
399 Lafayette Street
416 Lafayette Street - Dixey Morgan House
418 Lafayette Street
452 Lafayette Street - Benjamin G. Hathaway House
19 Larchmont Street
10-14 Lynch Street
4 Ocean Avenue - Edmund P. Balcomb House
3 Ridgeway Street
28 School Street
100 School Street
POTENTIAL LOCAL DISTRICTS
Buffum Street
Dearborn Street
Downtown Salem
Fairfield Street
Naples and Savoy Roads
15
Salem Willows
16
iZp Pv st—D ']OWN—i Dww L,0C A c, t 5To121C D ►5 i TZ LT
ZO
POS `PJ y1 JPS `' SOJS 5 g�\OGE v m y \� 20? vs OZ 00PP yS�P
LEDGE HI L v m
PARK 5v BRIDGE i m £ pr=O o PPS (
s0 a0 5 q
Ott .' . a ST n�a ASHINGTON v�
�� T SOUTH
FD
\w O Cn C
MAscry 'S' . ;,� y �G q �.q N
RIVER ST r�'l r ,-'ia ;'� E .LFI R�✓'�, ..O 00 9.� 9ZG+� AFt
S ?, 9q N
N 3 3
`I /cC 00 5A[D�
0 `Na o�PP �5 -1 -• N oo W DER Q w
C� o S7
I V4gN�.`^g90i 0 0�e SO'OiNCr GHE NA OP�9 SS NHIGH 9 T O 8 ST PEWP RD
V ST ST
0
sow 5T c � v MILE s m
O', MT. 5 HARBOR ST
'fy� TpN ST M4SSP 9
T %I- STU1
O R, yq0 V NO T <> pOg q Sl. >� P LVNOHa T
S S 9 01 ¢ 5 x z
j' W T PPE + y9� EHDIG Y �5 '47 m ST A z
Is' O �P �P y h0 N S Op ST' of DOW s p
pPPY' ; �Ca 9,y�19�S .� vRES��NIN P O� e5T v N m
LANGDO tOH O S S q O,P / 5t PpRTER m Z
I•MAHy-t3; pPRKcW ocA O OPI'Jmp JP�.�EPQa� SrCSV'OPEGPopGS SARGI ¢uVS,c�FNRf 941 PALMER
f m Oq ACHSOry P ;P� v EDP q9 ST
T m L T
; HILLSIDE u 9C1 ST PJB YPRES ppIRF1ELD ST CHASE ST IT
(34
AVE Igo "iZcs pqP LYME
ST
15
HERITAGE= U� q0 m 2 v ARD
NE ST
O
h OF ST SALTONSTP PIO EER
HH.L5\0 ,4• OL 4 NPNDOLK '1 v PKWY TER PL
`\ co 'pF(Q �� W 2 r �3 LPFPY ETIE yT
• \ C9r O 1< � oo
` S SERTUGU >' Z y a <f
\ \� SALEM HOSPITAL p ROSLY N- 41 LEPOH m 4py
` sT z s sr
1 \ S�, HPUL r HOLLY v EDEN ST N N
\ ST •� r r 3 .1
MCSSERVYr ES RVY GT
AVE
�lp,� Iyq Opl, Z ST m WILLOW I
i
INVENTORY FORM- CONTINUATION SHEET COMM itK� oim_NOr—
MASSACHi1SMS HISTORICAL COMKISSION Salem
.� cea �ecretary, Boston
Property Name: Derby and Messervf
Estates Area
Indicate each item on inventory form which is being continued below.
DDS ° I 010000 "o � a
® (j E ZQ D
C, Li DOCJO w )
W
(� Iss Ll -+ e N d 1
8 90 Z L L] TEN �L S U❑
oe-i LOS O ME55 RV ST
0 p D �1[IC a
p _0 0 £ bi �£ a n�TO5 r O a ppo
LAUREL O tj.� ILLO ► v
Q 013 12.o �.F D DLO �a
W ST 1] t V. 51 �3 N D s �/
t71�L1 m TQC)M a C O � S ,� (�
_1_, QQ f a
rn �'��VI�`�Q d TOc. � Q 111155550 9 J
CEAN
1
LIJL)
w ap 13 °���o�aa¢ \3 t'3 LZ 2 LJ
x T
It am poaom ��
ZO
u o o Pc'
AT LAhTK O\�
I���
Staple to Inventory form at bottom
INVENTORY FORM-CONTINUATION SHEET C m; __
MASSACEIUSETTS HISTORICAL CO!MISSION SALEM . -
Off;�Q—of tbC c,Zrye Boston -
Property Name: Salem Willows
Indicate each item on inventory form which is being continued below.
SKETCH MAP
WILLOW
PARK
SEE -89
co
LUMBus nG
ci
}
1
y OL COVE
v'
G � L
d
1G �
G
a P •
Staple to Inventory form at bottom
FORMA - AREA Area Letter Form numbers 1n this Area
MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION
BO BOYLSTON STREET, BOSTON, MA 02116
ML
Salem
;r r of Area (if any) Salem
_ ; ebuilding Trust Area
A�
'F .nt Use Residential
Y �
a al Date or Period 1915
■
u _ i
a1 Condition Good
ge Approximately 3 . 3 acres .
• Debra Hilbert and
area indicating properties within it. Recorded by Northfields Preservation Assoc,
Number each property for which individual
inventory forms have been completed. Organization Salem Planning Dent.
-abet streets including route numbers, if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date June 1986 and July 1989
sheetspaif ce his not suff cient).
R
o Dq
an aN
h\ HgYtrAeD r L
q27 N
Qr D
<O 21-441
0O � S
T T
Oh
f
UTM REFERENCE
USGS QUADRANGLE
SCALE
ORM A - AREA Area Letter Form numbers in this Area
,AAS.SACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION
30 BOYLSTON STREET. BOSTON. MA 02116
Salem
�\ of Area (if any) Salem State College
int Use College
sal Date or Period 1897-1960
a
al Condition Good
ge 18.85 acres
area ndicating proper es n Debra Hilbert and
Number each property which individual eco by „nT+, f;p, ,G pTeap -r on a� nc.
inventory forms have been completed. Organization sale, p,ann;na Dpnt
Label streets including route numbers, if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date June- 1986 and J111U. 19A
sheet if space ere i not sufficient).
L
F
P J
A t
RM REFERENCE
SGS QUADRANGLE
CALE
FORM A - AREA Area Letter Form numbers in this Area
32.- 34t"►, 3-F`1, 353, 3
MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION l 33(0, 33-1, IP40, 4o5�
80 BOYLSTON STREET. eoSTnN- Ma-rA9-1ic I -11 Le, I755, :57,
Salem
I 056000 CIS
if Area (if any) Naples and
Savoy Roads
I
t Use Residential
�4 /V\
1 ' __ - r f• �J.it I-)IJ L Jf .T I: � . .
1 Date or Period c.- 1910-1920
- 1 Condition Good
e Approximately 15 acres
ar a n Ca ng properties within it. Recorded by Northfields Preservation
Number each property for which individual Associates
inventory forms have been completed. Organization Salem Planning Dept .
Label streets including route numbers, if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date - July 1989
sheetspail�space his not sufficient).
4UbLJ
a CaG � �
Z
Pn
i o,o
3
(n a32 a�lo a I S
SIVA\ GQ 0 rJ 0 -0 0 p w
------------
5T
5 3
UTM REFERENCE
USGS (QUADRANGLE
SCALE
`ORM A - AREA Area Letter Form numbers in this Area
MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION K
Salem
of Area (if any) T.orin0 Villa/
icent St_ Chretienne
int Use Educational
1 Date or Period c. 187o-1918
at Condition Good
. 9e 22.35 acres
-=erCn-map.—uraw a general map of the —
area indicating properties within it. Recorded by Nor h ieldc Preservation Assoc
Number each property for which individual
inventory forms have been completed. Organization Salem Planning Dent.
Label streets including route numbers, if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date JU17. 1989
sheetspa�t�ce ere is nosufficient).
N `r
G
O� �y
rt
UTM REFERENCE
USGS QUADRANGLE
SCALE
TORN A - AREA Area Letter Form numbers in this Area
3A- 389, 355, 387
HASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION
30 BOYLSTO_N STREET. BOSTON. MA 02116
Salem
�. of Area (1f any) ward and Peabody
6 - _ streets
ant Use Apartment buildings
-al Date or Period . 1914-17
al Condition Fair
age Annroxiinately 3 acres .
area indicating properties within it. Recorded by lgi ,thfig ds Preservation Assoc
Number each property for which individual
inventory forms have been completed. Organization 'Salem Planning Debt.
Label streets including route numbers,.if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date July, 1999
sheetspace eere is not sufficient):' o
P i?6P�OD
T � 1
UTM REFERENCE
USGS QUADRANGLE
SCALE
FORM A -.AREAArea Letter Form numbers in this Area
MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION '•
80 BOYLSTON STREET. BOSTON��MA 02US' • ``
�^ 1 Salem
Of Area (1f any) Fairfield Street'
r r - 2 and 15 Cedar Street
•' ✓ .4
nt Use Residential
�.
al Date or Period 1914-15
al Condition Excellent
ge Approximately 2 .acres
area indicating proper es w, uilu rded by 'Northfields Preservation Assoc.
Number each property for which individual
inventory forms have been completed. ' " Organization Salem Planning Dept:
Label streets including route numbers. if
any. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date July 1989
sheet if space here is not sufficie ).
1:� G� L
ca
sr
Qav QrqHappy .
o IT
D a p T.
a ss
fA1 R-i%�O,.D
n r
UTM REFERENCE
USES QUADRANGLE
SCALE
:ORM A - AREA Area Letter- Form numbers in this Area
MUCHUSETTS HISTORICAL^d0*ISSI0N
IO. BOYLSTON. STREET* BOSTON, MA _02116
{ '
of Area (if any) Prince Street Place
57-SQ now Street
`nt Use
al Date or Period ,g, S
al Condition
ge Approximately one acre
irea ded by
hlmber each property for which individual
inventory forms have been completed. Organization Salem Planning Dept.
.abel streets including route numbers, if
my. Indicate north. (Attach a separate Date July, 1989
sheet space ere is not sufficient).
p 'VT
t Q
N
C.
ITU REFERENCE
ISGS QUADRANGLE
SCALE
1�r Sia Imo-) (INV
�-" 193A 1bNO LLVN l(tgapgWwo-,2g , '1S N �09.?J�l3a-
-� N
O
z
--'
�o 0
c�
C F
Z � s�
CA
O S
2 3 �
d �
V
C'
d_
b'.EYORT ON EXPANSION OF WASHINGTON SQUARE LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT BOUNDARIES''
Based on the survey of the Salem Common neighborhood conducted as part of .'
Salem's FY 86 Survey 6 Planning Grant, expansion of the Washington Square
Local Historic District boundaries was found to be justified. Two'differen
approaches are possible.
Conservative Boundaries - marked on map in red
The conservative boundaries are focused more narrowly around the Common.
properties included are predominantly Federal in character (intensive developiynt
of the Common as a residential neighborhood began in the Federal period) and -
largely intact. These properties were excluded from the origfnal distryet.not".'; ;" `'
for architectural or historical reasons, but because the origingl .bQuAdarlaa _ -r
appear to have a political basis. Many property owners on the east side of that,+
Common did not want to be subject to the regulations of Chapter 40C. The propqud"
conservative boundaries would correct earlier omissions and create a district `. ;
based on solid architectural and historical grounds.
�
Liberal Boundaries - marked on map in blue fF,1•�{'„�
These boundaries would pick up more streets on the north and east sides of the
Common. Those streets running off Washington Square North are largely Federal
in character, with some Victorian infill, but several of them have been altered.
Most of the alterations consist of the application of synthetic siding.
In many cases, however, building trim is intact so the integrity of the
structures is not destroyed. In other words, the changes here are largely
reversible. The boundary on the north side also includes the Howard St. Cemetery
and the Essex County Jail (1811-1813, 1884/5), one of the oldest correctional
facilities in the United States still fulfilling its original function. Beyond
its architectural merits, the jail will likely be the subject of development in
the 1990's and incorporation into the local historic district will provide a
means of preserving the complex's architectural integrity.
The streets off the east side of the Common have a more heavy mix of Federal .
and Victorian structures. As with the north side, a number of buildings
have undergone reversible changes which do not compromise their architectural
character. Of particular interest is Boardman St. , which contains a strikingly
uniform collection of late Victorian eclectic single and two-family wooden
houses built between 1879 and 1890. Also included here is the St. Nicholas
Russian Orthodox Church, ranked as one of the finest Byzantine Revival
ecclesiastical buildings in New England and a likely candidate for the National
Register.
4.
Generally, the idea behind the blue boundaries is to incorporate more of the
structures representing the 19th century development of the neighborhood and to
have some control over the Federal period houses which, although altered, are ^'
likely 'to be developed in the next few years, giving Salem's intense real
estate climate. By their inclusion in a local historic district, the Historical }
Commission could encourage historically sensitive renovations for these structures.' .:':
The liberal boundaries are so inclusive that a separate Washington Square rogoak
Historic District Commission may be necessary for the district's
Prepared by: Debra Hilbert, Salem Planning Department
Rim Withers Brengle, Northfields Preservation Associates
y
FY 86 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT
CRITERIA FOR EXPANSION OF THE SALEM COMMON NATIONAL REGISTER DISTRICT
Upon completion of the Salem Common survey in early June, 1987, the
current boundaries of the Salem Common National Register District were
examined to determine if expansion was warrentd. Largely these
boundaries were found to be sound and sensible. In a few locations,
however, the boundaries seemed arbitrary.
On the east side of Pleasant Street, the district ends at Spring Street.
Numbers 17, 19-21 , and 23-25 Pleasant Street are consistent in style and
level of detail with other building included within the district
boundaries and seem eligible for inclusion. Also, on Briggs Street, the
district ends with #10 on the south side of the street and includes none
of the properties on the north side. Although several of these
buildings are sided, the trim is intact. Some of the intermediate
buidings are Victorian, but that is not inconsistent with other streets
in the district (for instance Pleasant St. ) and towards the east end
there are some good Federal period examples. Extending the boundaries
on this street to include . 29-31 Briggs and 18 Briggs would make more
sense than the present seemingly random cut-off point.
If these changes where the only ones in questions, expansion of the
district would not be worthwhile. Boardman Street, however, merits
serious consideration. The houses on this street, built between 1879
and 1890, form a strikingly uniform collection of late Victorian
eclectic single and two-family houses which altogether constitute an
architecturally significant group. While distinctly different from
anything else in the district, they represent a late development in the
Salem Common neighborhood and should be included as evidence of the
evolutionary growth of this part of Salem. Also, by extending the
district to the end of Boardman Street, the St. Nicholas Russian
Orthodox Church (1908) at 64-66 Forrester Street could also be included.
This building is a rare example of 'Byzantine R'e6ival ecclesiastical Y
architecture in New England. It survives in good condition, and even
appears individually eligible for the Register.
I631
I
FY 86 SURVEY AND PLANNING GRANT, City of Salem
List of Recommended Additions to Salem Common National Register District
Prepared by: Debra Hilbert, Salem Planning Department
Kim Withers Brengle, Northfields Preservation Associates
Boardman St. Briggs St. Forrester St. Pleasant St.
-5-7 13 64-66 17
9 17 19-21
11 19 23-25
13 21
15 23
17 25-27
19 29-31
21
23
25 12
27 14
29 16
31 18
33
35
37
39
4-6
8
10
12
1231
14.
i8
20
22
24
26-28,
30
32
34
36
38
40
ot
�� jK.\ 1.r'� /`� ;�'L. `� �d ,♦ •• _ `•\ ��` ��Tl-•:r V r ..`�_._ G h {!'�,:I4-.-.rl:;'�5 \. �,n'....'I-..I ♦ _ rFn$ 'ai' $,.
s �%-. / ,, K .y:� `��� � - 1 ' !.16°..i t-^Vd� rte'"--. . i •:z .I.f.,. •r ��_. �,_.�� ` e !. �i'�
tom'V.
ry7,\, �. 1 F�16 .��H�, r 1 •�hll_SJI w3553 N• :r ... ..;:�. { .J �. _.... .. �.-.. Y
at:�u +n � � 171tti514 sl•»v �/_ VN -{.�=Jy y.. �, i �1{q 'a ,,.j� h J F �7Bc
O \\ -R� p t \ ��-�e I .'L�¢jJ�.to� + r /14• �. T•. t4b s �� .
• ......
.y ' fi� � r� � i',,1'.. 2 'yc 6 ' dam` — �' �•� .w. .a 1 �i� �.�,�� "�-
. 4
c rel _ O `� R t �" '?• \ - ,. '' Y .or 1 { J ii .a 7;�� i Y tsar 'xM
�� �rP
$ •dr'. :K \ A` '�R� F •?�^- '-C/'`\ �• a __ ` { •`° J /
`i
� a� �•�• ���' O `'4 ... .j V *.+ 1i � M� _ !. •«J r' ___tea
W .� � %r �,' ^ it a• - � ! j O �� .i• � r<' Fi GI —� . . . . .
/ :; � �� ... O .. •�.� � �� � is I•,-•r
, ��, 1 T /' ' ♦ ..N it - I r K yyv�,� ,
r elf ♦ry ' ♦. � �� �.J 1 1 . !A +A k" "t*
tie' , v E'+ �� ••• r r ^°�' ��• ' .� 'y xr i x:.
�• '•h��`Jfr � • i��"••`' ,-��- - - . `° , �: +�.. \� ~baa�.} iy�cy x:
pp, f�� y�. �� r�! 'jt \ 1 `4 M` •r• t . F ` � iO �-. i �e �-�1•
("'i •`,'• ``l;`Y. r t I• .: .�• _ /r'� � V ,.e '1 � "a Abe ��\: r.� ... 1 � .� // i.. R�r� °^
�y t�\?� .s � L-`•�• °' �%jf .F r ♦ y:'r, r i,, r. ,i; ,� �• V l r $,11J !, _ ,s Y.r<.° �+ ^Te t,
.� � ',.�` r"`t+ •r, `,Y' � ' ` _,11' • ♦ •d � 1F d ♦¢ ` rr vY
e•� l •'f' \ - rd' \ a
All
;,tr1 �_� O<� �'[� .6. Ui `P' F 4� r ���' y �. � �s �s \ �• �. .'i�,i
�♦ � �'` �C . ; rrI tfr'.. �• r� 4^'• 'i ,i'! /•. \\ .✓ / 1Igt ' s
sei'1f $VM53SCV f7lUtS�Cl
- ..... .. :err. (�/•�J S113Sf1HOVSStlW 1431VS d0 A110 ..1�f1� ✓ov/ulu� w71sS - ' !C k,^,
r VC♦• y 'E`L`Y
)tJlf!(/ iy�'fJj� ).f ''fb uoWWo♦
: �`,