NAUMKEAG STEAM COTTON MILLS NR NOMINATION D
YNAUMKEAG STEAM COTTON MILLS
r
StTTS *�
� Iso
r AIMISSX
August 30, 1993 �m",onWealthh to
Richard Oedel
Chairman
Salem Historical Commission
One Salem Green
Salem, Mass. 01970
RE: Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills
Dear Mr. Oedel:
The Massachusetts Historical Commission is in receipt of your recent letter
requesting the withdrawal of the nomination of the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills
to the National Register of Historic Places. A similar request has been
received from Mayor Harrington. As a certified local government, the Salem
. Historical Commission has the right to withdraw nominations if there is a
concurrent request from the chief elected official. We therefore will withdraw
the nomination from consideration.
Sincerely,
re
B. McDonough
Sistoric Preservation Officer
ExecutiveDirector
Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Neil J. Harrington, Mayor, City of Salem
Robert I. Lappin, Shetland Trust
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street,Boston, Massachusetts 02116 (617) 727-8470
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael J.Connolly,Secretary
SCJ TS * �
July 19 , 1993 O MISSNO QQ�
onWealtlt toy
Shetland Trust
Robert I . Lappin, Tr.
P.O. Box 986
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Mr. Lappin:
We are pleased to inform you that the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mill
Historic District, Salem, Massachusetts, will be considered by
the Massachusetts Historical Commission for nomination to the
National Register of Historic Places. The National Register of
Historic Places is the Federal government's official list of
historic properties worthy of preservation. Listing in the
National Register provides recognition and assists in preserving
our Nation' s heritage.
Listing of this property provides recognition of the community' s
historic importance and assures protective review of Federal
projects that might adversely affect the character of the
property. If the property is listed in the National Register,
certain Federal investment tax credits for rehabilitation and
other provisions may apply.
Listing in the National Register does not mean that limitations
will be placed on the properties by the Federal government.
Public visitation rights are not required of owners . The Federal
government will not attach restrictive covenants to the
properties or seek to acquire them. If a property is listed in
the National Register, the owner may do anything with it that
he/she wishes, unless state or federal funds, permits, or
licensing are used, or unless some other regional and/or local
ordinance or policy is in effect.
In Massachusetts, properties nominated to the National Register
are automatically listed on the State Register of Historic
Places . There are no limitations, public visitation
requirements, or restrictive covenants for private properties
included in the State Register. State Register properties owned
by municipalities and nonprofit organizations may compete for
state restoration grants .
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street,Boston, Massachusetts 02116 (617) 727-8470
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael J.Connolly,Secretary
--.. .. .-. -. -
You are invited to attend the meeting of the Massachusetts
Historical Commission, at which the nomination will be
considered. The Commission will meet on Wednesday, October 13 ,
1993 at Massachusetts State Archives, Boston, Massachusetts at
1: 00 P.M. The Commission meeting is a public meeting and all
interested parties are encouraged to attend. If you have special
needs, and would like to attend the meeting, please contact the
Commission, and staff will make any arrangements that are
necessary.
Attached please find a notice that explains, in greater detail,
the results of listing in the National Register and that
describes the rights and procedures by which an owner may comment
on or object to listing in the National Register. Should you
have any questions about this nomination before the Massachusetts
Historical Commission meeting, please contact me at this office .
Sincerely,
ith B. McDonough
Executive Director
State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
Enclosures : NR Criteria & Rights of Owners
CC: Chairperson, Salem Historical Commission
Claire W. Dempsey, Preservation Consultant
Jane Guy, Salem Historical Commission
�..Cuvur4
pr TP\
Y 1
o.
Salem Historical Commission l
ONE SALEM GREEN,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(508)745-9595 EXT.311
August 19 , 1993
Ms . Judith McDonough
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02116
RE: Pending National Register Nominations
Dear Ms . McDonough:
At its regular meeting of August 18, 1993, the Salem
Historical Commission voted to support the nominations for Fort
Lee, Winter Island National Register District, St. Nicholas Russian
Orthodox Church and the Salem Willows National Register District as
eligible for listing on the National Register of Historic Places .
Pleased be advised that, in light of Shetland Trust ' s objection to
listing, the Commission voted not to support the nomination of
Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills at this time and reluctantly withdraws
its opinion of eligibility.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
THE SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
Richard Oedel
Chairman
M.cONWp1�
A
y
T�Rf^HWe u°+�5�
CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS
NEIL J. HARRINGTON
MAYOR
August 20, 1993
Judith McDonough
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02116
RE: Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills nomination to the National
Register of Historic Places
Dear Ms . McDonough:
As Chief Executive Officer of the City of Salem, I am writing
in opposition to the nomination of Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills for
listing on the National Register of Historic Places . I am
supportive of Shetland Trust's objection to listing and recommend
that Massachusetts Historical Commission not proceed with suph
nomination.
Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
Sincerely,
Neil J. Harrington
Mayor
t
SALEM CITY HALL • 93 WASHINGTON STREET SALEM. MASSACHUSETTS 01970 • 508/7459595 FAX 508/74 4 9327
r'
,,, JTS
� o
-7 *COQ ~ ve¢��*
July 19, 1993 AIISSl Cq!�
-o,-12manWealth {0
Shetland Trust
Robert I . Lappin, Tr.
P.O. Box 986
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Mr. Lappin:
We are pleased to inform you that the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mill
Historic District, Salem, Massachusetts, will be considered by
the Massachusetts Historical Commission for nomination to the
National Register of Historic Places . The National Register of
Historic Places is the Federal government' s official list of
historic properties worthy of preservation. Listing in the
National Register provides recognition and assists in preserving
our Nation' s heritage.
Listing of this property provides recognition of the community' s
historic importance and assures protective review of Federal
projects that might adversely affect the character of the
property. If the property is listed in the National Register,
certain Federal investment tax credits for rehabilitation and
other provisions may apply.
Listing in the National Register does not mean that limitations
will be placed on the properties by the Federal government.
Public visitation rights are not required of owners . The Federal
government will not attach restrictive covenants to the
properties or seek to acquire them. If a property is listed in
the National Register, the owner may do anything with it that
he/she wishes, unless state or federal funds, permits, or
licensing are used, or unless some other regional and/or local
ordinance or policy is in effect.
In Massachusetts, properties nominated to the National Register
are automatically listed on the State Register of Historic
Places . There are no limitations, public visitation
requirements, or restrictive covenants for private properties
included in the State Register. State Register properties owned
by municipalities and nonprofit organizations may compete for
state restoration grants .
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street,Boston,Massachusetts 02116 (617) 727-8470
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael J.Connolly,Secretary
You are invited to attend the meeting of the Massachusetts
Historical Commission, at which the nomination will be
considered. The Commission will meet on Wednesday, October 13 ,
1,993 at Massachusetts State Archives, Boston, Massachusetts at
1 : 00 P.M. The Commission meeting is a public meeting and all
interested parties are encouraged to attend. If you have special
needs, and would like to attend the meeting, please contact the
Commission, and staff will make any arrangements that are
necessary.
Attached please find a notice that explains, in greater detail,
the results of listing in the National Register and that
describes the rights and procedures by which an owner may comment
on or object to listing in the National Register. Should you
have any questions about this nomination before the Massachusetts
Historical Commission meeting, please contact me at this office.
Sincerely,
ith B. McDonough
Executive Director
State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
Enclosures : NR Criteria & Rights of Owners
CC: Chairperson, Salem Historical Commission
Claire W. Dempsey, Preservation Consultant
Jane Guy, Salem Historical Commission
SHETLAND PROPERTIES, INC.
27 CONGRESS STREET
P.O.BOX 986,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
508-744-0556 SALEM
617-289.2506 BOSTON
617-596-1186 BOSTON
508-744-2078 TELECOPY
SHETLAND PROPERTIES Direct• 508740-4400 SHETLAND FUND
OF SALEM LIMITED PARTNERSHIP ( ) LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
SHETLAND INVESTMENTS 1 SHETLAND FUND II
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
August 2 , 1993 VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
Ms . Judith B. McDonough
Executive Director
State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02116
RE: Objection to Listing of Shetland Properties on the
National Register of Historic Places as the Naumkeag
Steam Cotton Mill (or Cotton Company) Historic District
Dear -Ms ., McDonough:
I am in receipt of your letter of July 19 , 1993 regarding
consideration of the Shetland Office and Industrial Park,
Congress Street, Salem, Massachusetts for nomination to the
National Register of Historic Places.
I certify that Shetland Trust, of which I am trustee, is the
sole owner of the above-described property.
The buildings that make up this property have been altered on
a continuing basis to accommodate new uses . Major renovations
and new construction have resulted in a fundamental change to
the historic appearance of the complex.
Shetland Trust .hereby exercises its right under the National
Historic Preservation Act and 36 C.F.R. 60 . 6 (g) to OBJECT to
the listing of its property on the National Register of
Historic Places as well as on any state register of historic
assets . This objection is grounded in the severely negative
impact on job creation such a listing would have as a result
of the Trust' s inability to rehabilitate its property freely
and economically.
very truly yours,
SHETLAND TRUST
RECEIVE®
Robert I . Lappin AUG 0 4 1993
Trustee Salem pladmng Dept
RIL/lmp
Ms . Judith B. McDonough
Massachusetts Historical Commission
August 2, 1993 Page 2
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
ESSEX, ss . August 2, 1993
Then personally appeared the above-named Robert I. Lappin, and
acknowledged the foregoing to be his free act and deed, before
me,
Notary Public
My Commission Expires :
RIL/lmp
cc: Neil Harrington, Mayor, City of Salem
William Luster, Planner, 'City of Salem
William J. Tinti, Esquire
SHETLAND PROPERTIES, INC.
27 CONGRESS STREET
P.O.BOX 986,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
508-744-0556 SALEM
617-289-2506 BOSTON
617-596-1186 BOSTON
508-744-2078 TELECOPV
SHETLAND PROPERTIES SHETLAND FUND
OF SALEM LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
SHETLAND INVESTMENTS - (ham SHETLAND FUND II
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
March 22 , 1993 VIA FAX
Mr . Neil J . Harrington
Mayor, City Of Salem
City Hall
93 Washington Street
Salem, MA 01970
Dear Mayor Harrington:
The accompanying notice to you from the Massachusetts
Historical Commission dated March 12 , 1993 , of intended
submission of our property for inclusion in the National
Register, continues to concern us . I assume March 12 was
prior to the meeting at which you withdrew our nomination, but
without something in writing from the Commission we will be
uneasy .
Please take necessary action to help us in obtaining this and
let me know the actual status of the situation.
Thank you for your continued assistance.
Sincerely,
SHETLAND PROPERTIES OF SALEM LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
By its sole General Partner SHETLAND PROPERTIES , INC.
Robert I . Lappin
President
RIL/lmp
CC: William Luster, Planner, City Of Salem F�
n
� Oep�
SF,TTS * �
d n
N
0l
�c �Mrss%0 Q��
0m"lonWealth toy
ELIGIBILITY FOR NATIONAL REGISTER LISTING
TO: MAYOR NEIL J. HARRINGTON
FROM: MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION
DATE: MARCH 12, 1993
The Massachusetts Historical Commission is writing to inform you that the
following property has been voted eligible for inclusion in the National
Register of Historic Places (36 CFR 60) by the Commission acting as the State
Review Board. By law, a property is afforded protection from adverse effect
caused by Federally funded, licensed or assisted projects when it has been
voted eligible for inclusion in the National Register. The nomination form
will now be submitted to the National Register Office, National Park Service
in Washington, DC for final review. If the National Register Office lists the
property or determines it eligible for listing in the National Register, it
will automatically be included in the Massachusetts State Register of Historic
Places (950 CMR 71) . The State Register parallels the National Register in
providing protection from State actions. For more information, you may wish
to refer to your original notification letter or contact the Commission's
National Register staff. When we have received the determination of the
National Register Office, you will be advised.
PROPERTY/ADDRESS DATE VOTED ELIGIBLE
NAUMKEAG STEAM COTTON MILL MARCH 10, 1993
HISTORIC DISTRICT, SALEM
Massachusetts Historical Commission,Judith B. McDonough,Executive Director, State Historic Preservation Officer
80 Boylston Street, Boston, Massachusetts 02116 (617) 7278470
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael]. Coonoll}', Secretary
G� p
June 11, 1993
Jane Guy
Preservation Planner * 0 �` * �U • &Y
Salem Historical Commission -7 'IM j S SI ��C� ��/P
1 Salem Green oyh to t/n �
l/ U
Salem, MA 01970 "ton Wealth
Dear Ms. Guy:
As you know, the National Register nomination for the Naumkeag Steam.Cotton Mill Historic District, Salem,
Massachusetts has been rescheduled for consideration by the State Review Board on Wednesday, October 13,
1993.
Federal regulations require that the State Historic Preservation Officer notify property owners of pending
Review Board consideration in Certified Local Government communities 60-170 days before the date of the
meeting so that they may comment on the action. Those regulations also require that owners' names and
addresses be obtained no more' than 90 days before the date of the notification letter. We depend on the
nominating party to check local property records, and provide us with updated owner information.
In the case of small districts such as this, we notify each property owner individually. Therefore, you
should submit the owners' list typed on mailing labels. In addition to the owner's name and address, the
label should reference the property address and district name. Labels are enclosed.
Sample: Mr. and Mrs. Robert Jones
P. O. Box 7
Anytown, Massachusetts
RE: 7 South St.
Any Area National Register Historic District
Please complete the mailing list in triplicate (enough labels are provided) and return it to this office no
later than July 19, 1993. If you cannot meet this deadline, please let me know as soon as possible.
Sincerely,
Betsy Friedberg
National Register Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Chairperson, Salem Historical Commission
Neil J Harrington, Mayor, Salem City Hall
Enclosure: mailing labels
Massachusetts Historical Commission,Judith B. McDonough,Executive Director,State Historic Preservation Officer
80 Boylston Street,Boston,Massachusetts 02116-4802 (617) 727-8470 Fax: (617)727-5128 TDD: 1-800-392-6090
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael J. Connolly,Secretary
�StiTTs �,�j
June 11, 1993 t�
o N
Jane Guy
Preservation Planner * Co , 0�
Salem Historical Commission
1 Salem Green
Salem, MA 01970 0;>1"lonWealth to
Dear Ms. Guy:
As you know, the National Register nomination for the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mill Historic District, Salem,
Massachusetts has been rescheduled for consideration by the State Review Board on Wednesday, October 13,
1993.
Federal regulations require that the State Historic Preservation Officer notify property owners of pending
Review Board consideration in Certified Local Government communities 60-120 days before the date of the
meeting so that they may comment on the action. Those regulations also require that owners' names and
addresses be obtained no more than 90 days before the date of the notification letter. We depend on the
nominating party to check local property records, and provide us with updated owner information.
In the case of small districts such as this, we notify each property owner individually. Therefore, you
should submit the owners' list typed on mailing labels. In addition to the owner's name and address, the
label should reference the property address and district name. Labels are enclosed.
Sample: Mr. and Mrs. Robert Jones
P. O. Box 7
Anytown, Massachusetts
RE: 7 South St.
Any Area National Register Historic District
Please complete the mailing list in triplicate (enough labels are provided) and return it to this office no
later than July 19, 1993. If you cannot meet this deadline, please let me know as soon as possible.
Sincerely,
Betsy Friedberg
National Register Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Chairperson, Salem Historical Commission
Neil J Harrington, Mayor, Salem City Hall
Enclosure: mailing labels
Massachusetts Historical Commission,Judith B. McDonough,Executive Director,State Historic Preservation Officer
80 Boylston Street,Boston,Massachusetts 02116-4802 (617)727-8470 Fax: (617)727-5128 TDD: 1-800-392-6090
Office of the Secretary of State,Michael J. Connolly,Secretary
€f
t NPS Form 10-900 OMB No. 10024-0018
(Oct. 1990)
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Registration Form
This form is for use in nominating or requesting determinations for individual properties and districts. See instructions in How to Complete the
National Register of Historic Places Registration Form(National Register Bulletin 16A). Complete each item by marking "x" in the appropriate box or
by entering the information requested. If an item does not apply to the property being documented, enter "NIA" for "not applicable." For functions,
architectural classification, materials, and areas of significance, enter only categories and subcategories from the instructions. Place additional
entries and narrative items on continuation sheets(NPS Form 10-900a). Use a typewriter, word processor,or computer,to complete all hems.
1. Name of Property
historic name Natmtkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District
other names/site number Peguct Mills, Shetland Properties
2. Location
street & number 35 and 47 Congress Street ❑ not for publication
city or town Salem ❑ vicinity
state MA code 025 county Essex codenn.To zip code g1970
3. State/Federal Agency Certification
As the designated authority under the National Historic Preservation Act, as amended, I hereby certify that this ❑ nomination
❑ request for determination of eligibility meets the documentation standards for registering properties in the National Register of
Historic Places and meets the procedural and professional requirements set forth in 36 CFR Part 60. In my opinion,the property
❑ meets ❑ does not meet the National Register criteria. I recommend that this property be considered significant
❑ nationally ❑ statewide ❑ locally. (❑ See continuation sheet for additional comments.)
Signature of certifying otfciaVTitle Date
State of Federal agency and bureau
In my opinion,the property ❑ meets ❑ does not meet the National Register criteria. (❑ See continuation sheet for additional
comments.)
Signature of certifying official[Title Date
State or Federal agency and bureau
4. National Park Service Certification
I hereby certify that the property is: Signature of the Keeper Date of Action
❑ entered in the National Register.
❑ See continuation sheet.
❑ determined eligible for the
National Register
❑ see continuation sheet.
❑ determined not eligible for the
National Register.
❑ removed from the National
Register.
❑ other, (explain:)
Natunkeaa Historic District Salem MA
Name of Property - County end State
5. Classification
Ownership of Property Category of Property Number of Resources within Property
(Check as many boxes as apply) (Check only one box) (Do not include previously listed resources In tcount.)
L'S private ® building(s) Contributing Noncontributing
❑ public-local ❑ district
❑ public-State ❑ site 6 t buildings
❑ public-Federal ❑ structure sites
❑ object
structures
objects
F Total
Name of related multiple property listing Number of contributing resources previously listed
(Enter"N/A" if property is not part of a multiple property listing.)
In the National Register
6. Function or Use
Historic Functions Current Functions
(Enter categories from instructions) (Enter categories from instructions)
Mill Office
Factory
7. Description
Architectural Classification Materials
(Enter categories from instructions) (Enter categories from instructions)
Art Deco foundation Concrete
walls Concrete, Brick,
Glass, Wood
roof Asphalt
other
Narrative Description
(Describe the historic and current condition of the property on one or more continuation sheets.)
Nawnkeag Historic District Ra7enn MA
Name of Property County and State
8. Statement of Significance
Applicable National Register Criteria 'Areas of Significance
(Mark"x" in one or more boxes for the criteria qualifying the property (Enter categories from instructions)
for National Register listing.) _Industry
® A Property is associated with events that have made Architecture
a significant contribution to the broad patterns of
our history.
❑ B Property is associated with the lives of persons
significant in our past.
® C Property embodies the distinctive characteristics
of a type, period, or method of construction or
represents the work of a master, or possesses
high artistic values, or represents a significant and
distinguishable entity whose components lack Period of Significance
individual distinction. 1914-1938
❑ D Property has yielded, or is likely to yield,
information important in prehistory or history.
Criteria Considerations Significant Dates
(Mark "x" in all the boxes that apply.)
Property is:
❑ A owned by a religious institution or used for
religious purposes.
Significant Person
❑ B removed from its original location. (Complete if Criterion B is marked above)
❑ C a birthplace or grave.
El D a cemetery. Cultural Affiliation
❑ E a reconstructed building, object, or structure.
❑ F a commemorative property.
❑ G less than 50 years of age or achieved significance Architect/Builder
within the past 50 years. Lockwood, Greene & Co
Philip Horton Smith
Narrative Statement of Significance
(Explain the significance of the property on one or more continuation sheets.)
9. Major Bibliographical References
Bibliography
(Cite the books, articles, and other sources used in preparing this form on one or more continuation sheets.)
Previous documentation on file (NPS): Primary location of additional data:
❑ preliminary determination of individual listing (36 €5I State Historic Preservation Office
CFR 67) has been requested ❑ Other State agency
❑ previously listed in the National Register ❑ Federal agency
❑ previously determined eligible by the National fl Local government
Register ❑ University
❑ designated a National Historic Landmark ❑ Other
❑ recorded by Historic American Buildings Survey Name of repository:
# MA Historical Comm. , Salm Planning Dept.
❑ recorded by Historic American Engineering
Record #
Naulmkeag Historic District Salem MA
Name of Property County and State
10. Geographical Data
Acreage of Property ?q-1 anrPa
UTM References
(Place additional UTM references on a continuation sheet.)
1 Lll q -14 J 1 7 9 L 1 � 9 g 1 9 3 u 13 14 15 1113 10 14 ,71018141010�
Zone Easting Northing Zone Easting Northin
2 a o o Q l e 0 8 $ $ 4 1 1314 ,418 ,7101 I4i7I$� 4 2f 4
❑ see continuation sheet
Verbal Boundary Description
(Describe the boundaries of the property on a continuation sheet.)
Boundary Justification
(Explain why the boundaries were selected on a continuation sheet.)
11. Form Prepared By
namettitle Claire W. Dempsey
organization Salem Planning Department date July 1992
street & number One Salem Green telephone 508-745-9595
city or town Salem state MA zip code 01970
Additional Documentation
Submit the following items with the completed form:
Continuation Sheets
Maps
A USGS map (7.5 or 15 minute series) indicating the property's location.
A Sketch map for historic districts and properties having large acreage or numerous resources.
Photographs
Representative black and white photographs of the property.
Additional items
(Check with the SHPO or FPO for any additional items)
Property Owner
(Complete this item at the request of SHPO or FPO.)
name
street & number telephone
city or town state zip code
Paperwork Reduction Act Statement: This information is being collected for applications to the National Register of Historic Places to nominate
properties for listing or determine eligibility for listing,to list properties, and to amend existing listings. Response to this request is required to obtain
a benefit in accordance with the National Historic Preservation Act, as amended (16 U.S.C. 470 et seq.).
Estimated Burden Statement: Public reporting burden for this form is estimated to average 18.1 hours per response including time for reviewing
instructions, gathering and maintaining data, and completing and reviewing the form. Direct comments regarding this burden estimate or any aspect
of this form to the Chief, Administrative Services Division, National Park Service, P.O. Box 37127, Washington, DC 20013-7127; and the Office of
Management and Budget, Paperwork Reductions Projects(1024-0018), Washington, DC 20503.
(►M, nl�ApyFY NO ICMWt1
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number _ 7 Page I _ Nauokeag Historic District, Salem MA
Description of the Naunkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills Historic District consists of six buildings
on 29.1 acres, located on the south shore of the South River where it meets
Salem Harbor. The parcel is shaped as an inverted L, with the long stem
running north-south along the shore of the Harbor, the short stem east-west
along the river. Just off shore is the end of Derby Wharf and the Derby
Lighthouse (NR 1987) . In addition to the harbor, the long stem has Palmer
Cove forming its southern border and Pingree Street its western border.
The short stem runs east-west, joining the long stem at its northeast end,
with Congress and Lynch streets forming the west and south borders respectively.
The reinforced concrete manufacturing buildings are oriented on the lot in
a comparable configuration. The largest building, the Weave Shed, occupies
the bulk of the long stem, while the three other manufacturing and storage
areas, smaller and oriented in a perpendicular direction, occupy the short
stem, the Cotton Storehouse closest to the South River, followed by the Spinning
Mill in the center, and the Cloth Room below. The two smallest buildings
in the complex, the Office and Pequot House, are located close to Congress
Street on either side of the Spinning Mill, forming the entry/public area
of the mill complex.
This area, known as Stage Point, is part of the larger portion of Salem,
south of the South River, that was developed intensively for the first time
in the 19th century as the location of manufacturing and processing plants.
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Conpany purchased the land in 1841 from the city
of Salem, construction began in 1845, and the textile manufacturer remained
here until the company relocated in 1954. During the end of the 19th century,
as the plant expanded with the construction of more buildings, the irregular
shore line of this area was filled in and regularized and, over time, the
rises in the land surface were flattened. This area was part of the large
expanse of the City which burned in 1914. The roughly rectangular shape
Stage Point takes today is the result of rebuilding after the fire. At that
time the street pattern in front of the mill was altered as well: the Union
Street Bridge and Union Street, which turned to run to the west after the
bridge crossing, were removed. The new bridge was constructed further inland
to the west, as the South River was filled in and the new extension of Congress
Street extended to meet it. The area around the mill was then surrounded
by a right angled grid of streets rather than the mix of angles and directions
that preceded the fire (Smith 1930: passim) .
On those streets the Naunkeag district is surrounded by housing constructed
after the fire under the direction of the Salem Rebuilding Commission.
Established to over-see and encourage the rebuilding of the enormous fire
continued
N�6�mn lOm4�
(►Mi W�Mnorr Mo. t0lL011
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Page 2 Naumkeag Historic District, Salm MA
area, the commission endeavored to limit the fire-prone elements as rebuilding
progressed, setting rules for construction that determined the character
of the landscape today. Its French-Canadian character is asserted in the
large complex of St. Joseph's Roman Catholic Church. Though the church was
not rebuilt until 1949-50, the parish worshipping in the basement of the
earlier building, the Presbytere and the Ecole were rebuilt in 1917 and 1921
respectively, and the block remained a focus of neighborhood activities.
The commission set a number of limitations to new residential construction,
chief among them being to encourage fire-proof construction materials and
techniques, to limit all residential buildings to four stories and under,
and to limit any housing for more than two families to 2' stories and under.
The Naumkeag Company rebuilt housing for its workers in the vicinity, notably
the group of stucco buildings on Prince Street Place, designed by the noted
reform housing firm of Kilham and Hopkins. This group of two-story, stuccoed
buildings relate closely to other of the firm's work to bring quality housing
to the low-cost market. Both Peabody Street and Ward Street reflect the
high priority of the commission for fire-proof housing in the small-unit,
low-cost category. Here are clustered the three- and four-story masonry
apartment blocks that replaced the highest density housing of the pre-fire
era. These buildings, of brick and ornamental concrete block, exhibit a
range of elaboration in their finish detailing and many retain significant
visual integrity. All buildings in the neighborhood were not constructed
of masonry, however, and frame construction was allowed for one- and two-family
houses, the least restricted category of buildings. Most of these were fitted
with slate roofs, addressing the chief concern of the fire hazard presented
by wood shingles. In addition, many are "two deckers," resembling the three
decker in all formal elements except accommodating two units rather than
three, which were outlawed by the commission, a response to the criticism
of the earlier form by housing reformers. Although some of the buildings
are neglected, the Stage Point neighborhood around the Naumkeag Steam Cotton
Company Historic District may also be eligible to the National Register of
Historic Places. See Candee and Hardwicke 1987 and Salem Rebuilding Commission,
1917.
The Great Fire of 25 June 1914 destroyed nearly all of the previously
existing mill complex except for two buildings from the earlier complex survived
the fire, a four-story concrete warehouse (Storehouse No. 1) built in 1906,
and probably demolished in 1987, and a former gas container used as a Storehouse
No. 10, demolished during the new construction after the fire (Associated
Factory Mutual, 1914) . Four new buildings were constructed in 1915; one
of these, a single story brick boiler house that formerly stood on the river
side of the Weave Shed, was demolished, probably in 1988. The Storehouse,
Carding & Spinning Mill, and Weave Shed survive. The addition of a Cloth
continued
Nos rem iosw�
fMe7 fig iyawr Mr Io 74
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Page 3 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Room to the Weave Shed dates to 1924. All of these buildings were constructed
in the most innovative material available to mill engineers at the time of
their construction, reinforced concrete, by the region's premier firm
specializing in industrial buildings, Lockwood, Green a Co. of Boston. In
addition to the manufacturing and storage facilities the company constructed
an Office, apparently of more common brick and steel frame construction.
The last building added to the complex was the Pequot House, a reconstruction
of a First Period residence built in association of the city's 1930
Tricentennial celebration. A single non-contributing building is included
on the site, a four-story parking garage was added along Pingree Street in
1989.
When Lockwood, Greene designed the new mills for Naumkeag, reinforced
concrete had only recently been introduced to the textile industry, and this
complex became a model of the new technology. Concrete had many desirable
properties for industrial buildings, most importantly its ability to resist
compression and to be molded into a wide variety of shapes. When reinforced
by the insertion within it of steel rods and/or thin plates, its ability
to resist tension is improved. The resulting product is very strong and
has the added ability to resist fire since the steel is shielded from heat
and flames by the cover of concrete. Photographs of the structure under
construction show on-site fabrication within molds of dimensioned timber
and plywood, removed when the concrete hardened to form the floors of the
structure. Each concrete slab floor was supported around the perimeter by
piers and by large mushroom-shaped columns, supporting the entire frame of
the building. By contrast the walls had only to support their own weight,
so each was constructed of brick and glass, known as curtain walls.
The buildings constructed in 1915 demonstrate the new aesthetic of modern
architecture applied within the industrial sphere. The large rectangular
buildings are constructed with flat roofs. Each elevation received equal
ornamental treatment, and the largest proportion of each wall was composed
of brick infill and glass windows, read as a large expanse of dark void between
the strong horizontals marking the floors. Brick provided contrast to the
pale concrete and was used between the concrete piers to determine the window
size and shape, and thus varying with the function of the building. In the
Carding and Spinning Mill, the need for natural light suggested the use of
large glass windows composed of large lights in dark metal sash which greatly
increased illumination to the building's interior. At the Weave Shed the
sawtooth roof let in large amounts of northern light, and the walls thus
needed only small windows. Similarly, the Cotton Storehouse was constructed
for safety with only small openings. In contrast to the most "modern" of
factories at the time, these buildings were treated with ornament in a small
continued
N�6 fpm IOPOf'.
��Mi 0111 A M Nb. 10M ,I
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 page 4 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
number of areas: where the roof form allowed it, a parapet provided a terminus
to the building's elevation, and while it was usually straight, on the tall
connector between the Weave Shed and the Spinning Mill, and in several locations
on the Spinning Mill itself, stepping of the parapet provided visual contrast.
Indeed the Spinning and Carding Mill itself received the largest amount
of ornament, and was the dominant visual element of the complex. The four-story
Mill is the highest in the complex, sited close to the street, and extends
to 725 feet in length and 140 feet in width. Each facade is treated with
projecting towers, the largest the front stair tower, with four smaller ones
along the south long wall and two smaller ones on the north or harbor facing
wall. These towers contain the stair wells and toilets, allowing large expanses
within the rooms necessary to accommodate large numbers of large machines.
The towers are also the location of brick detailing that provides ornament
to the complex, in particular the stepped parapet and clocks of the entry
tower. when the new mill went into production in 1916 it included 101,925
new spindles, and was subsequently increased to 163,312. During renovation
the metal sash were replaced with new large-paned fixed sash.
The Storehouse, a five story warehouse, was built parallel to the river
along the South River, a long trapezoid measuring 500 feet in length, about
50 feet wide at the east and about 115 feet at the wider west end. Its
river-facing north facade is composed of thirty bays, divided by concrete
piers, joined across the the top of the wall by a classically derived cornice;
a small square window in the center of each bay lights the raised basement.
As originally constructed similar small windows were located in the top center
of each bricked bay, small openings being the traditional and effective method
in storage of so flammable a material as raw cotton. In the renovation of
the building for commercial uses, the brick has been removed from between
the concrete piers and replaced with fixed sash.
The single story Weave Shed covers over nine acres of the site, located
on the Salem Harbor side of the lot, with its long dimension running north-south
or perpendicular to the Storehouse and the Spinning & Carding Mill. In
footprint the building presents a large rectangle at the south, measuring
about 625 feet by 420 feet, with a smaller rectangular ell set flush left
or west on the north wall, measuring 580 feet by 220 feet. The shed was
built in two stages (Dick 1951:15) , the first section probably the southern
one, covering seven acres, which was quickly expanded to the present nine
with the construction of the northern addition. On its northwest corner
a small four story tower is connected to the Spinning Mill by an enclosed
and elevated bridge. In profile the weave shed takes the emblematic sawtooth
roof form, with parallel dormers running east west across the building, letting
continued
Noe Pw tDYpt.,
(eM' ale MNwv No t(W{tDle
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Sectlon number 7 Page _S— Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
light into the weave rooms. Here were housed over 4000 looms. During the
recent remodellings, large windows have been added to the water-side elevations
and the dormer windows have been covered. In 1924 the Company added on to
the weave shed, constructing the single-story, 322 by 110 foot Cloth Roan
to the northwest side of the weave shed. This low building was constructed
with a flat roof.
The Naumkeag Office is seldom mentioned in the enumeration of new buildings
constructed for the company but appears on maps and in photographs quite
early. The two-story, hip-roofed rectangle has a central single-story entry
porch and is constructed of brick. Its facade is composed in three parts,
a four bay section at each end marked by the stepped parapet, with the central
section composed of seven bays of triple windows; its side elevations are
three bays wide. The cornice is treated with patera along the line of
contrasting stone that marks the parapet, surrounds all the openings, and
marks the belt course of the water table along the raised basement.
In 1930 the company constructed the frame building known as Pequot House
to serve as reception and exhibit space. Constructed to suggest First Period
architecture, the building resembles most closely the John Ward House. Built
in 1685 and expanded soon thereafter to assume the familiar center-chimney,
lean-to form, the Ward House is owned by the Essex Institute, and was restored
in 1910 by George Francis Dow. The architect of Pequot House was Philip
Horton Smith (1890-1960) , who practiced in Boston and throughout the north
shore. The gable-roofed structure rises to two stories with a high attic,
a pair of facade gables, and a rear lean-to, and construction photographs
suggest its construction was, at least in part, based on timber framing
techniques. Its facade was lit with small windows in a symmetrical five
bay, center entry configuration; the west window in the second story on the
north side has been replaced with a large plate glass picture window. It
differs from the Ward House in its greater dependence on symmetry, its use
of double hung rather than casement windows, and variations in the overhang
locations.
In 1954 the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company closed the Pequot Mills and
relocated to their southern base outside Spartenburg, South Carolina. Two
years later it was purchased by 9165 Corporation, in 1959 by Shetland Industries
Center, and in 1969 by Shetland Properties. It is now operated as a combined
commercial and office complex known as the Shetland Office Industrial Park.
Alterations to the complex associated with the change in use are small in
number. Much of the complex has been painted white, so that many of the
contrasting brick panels are no longer a visual element in the design scheme.
Window replacement has occurred as well, including opening the windows of
continued
".e tom,oaoF, GW Nwwr ne ,o..m,.
r..e;
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 7 Pape Naumkeag Historic District, Salem, MA
the Cotton Storehouse and the Weave Shed, covering the Weave Shed dormers,
and replacement of the windows elsewhere with large-paned, fixed sash. Although
these alterations are "unfortunate," in the words of the Massachussetts
Historical Commission staff, they are not deemed sufficient to compromise
the buildings' integrity.
end of part seven
NIS h,m 10iG4� 411♦(a.y Mo. tOM(Ot1
(moi
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Sectlon number
R Page 1 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Significance of the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District is a complex of
six buildings constructed between 1915 and 1930 to house the offices and
manufacturing buildings of the long-standing Salem textile manufacturer.
Constructed after the Great Fire of 1914 destroyed the mill and its surrounding
neighborhood, the company employed the eminent industrial architects, Lockwood,
Green & Co. of Boston to rebuild their complex, the largest integrated plant
at the time of its construction, and employing the innovative technology
of reinforced concrete. The company had operated in the city since 1845,
and during the early 20th century this mill was by far its largest employer,
with a payroll of 1600, including one third of all city wage earners. Naumkeag
Steam Cotton Company Historic District meets criteria A and C at the local
level. Although some alterations have been made to the building during its
conversion to offices as Shetland Properties, they have not compromised the
integrity of the large complex. Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District
retains integrity of location, setting, design, materials, workmanship, and
association.
The site of the district is on a peninsula formed by the South River
on the north and Salem Harbor to the east and the south, a small area earlier
known as Stage Point. The portion of Salem lying below the South River,
and within which Stage Point lies, was not early developed. The area's name,
and its apparent most common early use, was for stages on which to dry fish.
It was the site of a marine railway, shipyard, and wharves at the end of
the 18th century, and was acquired by the town in 1781 from its Tory owner
William Brown. The town rented out the area and charged fees based on the
tonnage of the vessel to allow ships to be graved and sheathed there (Smith
1930: 2,7,8) .
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company was established in Salem in 1839 when
a group of local merchants took their profits from the maritime trade and
invested them in the rising cotton manufacturing business. Coastal cities
like Salem, Newburyport, Portsmouth, and Boston were relative late-comers
to the textile boon, lacking the necessary source of water power on which
so many of the pioneering manufacturers had relied. When steam power became
a reliable alternative these sites became more viable and, while real estate
within them might prove more costly, the presence of services and an open
rental housing market made the construction of tenements, store, churches,
and meeting halls to support the mill employees unnecessary. The chief
investors, Nathaniel Griffin and David Pingree, hired the engineer Charles
T. James to consult them in their endeavor. James was an advocate of steam
power manufactories where he believed a higher quality textile could be
continued
N�6 bm 1WW�
(4M, Cub Appw�'M. 10NW11
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number R Page Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Produced, as well as a proponent of their location within port cities where
they could take advantage of the existing urban infrastructure. Naumkeag
was among the first, if not the first, of the textile manufacturing companies
in Massachusetts to use coal-fired steam engines to power their machinery,
and manufacturers in the other cities would soon emulate then (Dick 1951:
passim; Dunn 1981: 2; Smith 1930: 11-13)
In 1841 the area at the mouth of the South River adjacent to Salem harbor
was purchased by David Pingree who thought the site ideal for the steam-powered
textile manufacturing plant planned by his partner Griffen and designed by
James. Convenient to the wharves and the water for transportation, the mill
would also benefit from the ambient humidity needed to dampen fibers in in
cotton manufacturing (Smith 1930: 9-11) . Construction on buildings began
by 1845 and was in production by 1847, with an 1849 capitalization of $700,000.
Naumkeag remained successful and innovative throughout the 19th century,
expanding its plant on filled land around the point with the construction
of more buildings on the site. The plant was expanded in 1863 and again
in 1868, with accompanying capitalization increases to $1,200,00 and $1,500,00.
The plant eventually included twenty buildings of standard slow-burn mill
construction. During the 1890s the company changed its product focus from
a variety of cotton fabrics to a sheeting specialty. The company was the
first to cut and hem sheets for the domestic market and to promote their
product directly to the consumer, eliminating the traditional commission
merchant at the turn of the century (Dick 1951: 16) .
In June of 1914 the company's plant was by far the largest loss in the
fire that swept through South Salam and burned a total of over 250 acres.
Damage to the City was enormous, destroying 1600 buildings valued at
$14,000,000, and leaving 14,000 homeless. Naumkeag's experience in this
fire proved important to the company, and to manufacturers and insurers alike,
for two of the small number of buildings to survive the fire were storehouses
within the plant that demonstrated improved fire proof technologies.
Storehouse No. 10, a former gas container and thus circular in form and brick
and fire-proof in material, had double doors that protected its contents
of bales of raw cotton. Storehouse No. 1 was a recently-constructed building
of reinforced concrete, built in 1906 from designs by Lockwood, Greene, whose
materials proved resistant, and whose system of automatic shutter closing
protected the contents of finished cloth. The intact survival of this building
and its contents was credited at the time with impressing the advantages
of this new material on the industry at large and "gave considerable impetus
in the region to reinforced concrete construction," according to a subsequent
company president (Dick 1951:14) .
continued
we.omi ioaw.
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 3 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Not surprisingly then the Naumkeag officials choose to employ reinforced
concrete in their new construction, and hired the engineering firm of Lockwwod,
Greene as their engineers to accomplish "a very complete rebuilding along
modern lines" (Dick 1951:14) . Although used in Europe throughout the late
19th century, early U.S, efforts to build with reinforced concrete began
with the work of Ernest Ransome at the turn of the century in California
and New Jersey. Interestingly "his most impressive work" was "the remarkable
plant" he designed for the United Shoe Machine Company in Beverly. Dating
to 1903-05 this outstanding complex introduced the technology to the region.
Ransome's leading position was soon supplanted by Albert Kahn and the work
he completed for the auto industry in the Detroit area. In 1906 Kahn
collaborated with his brother's Trussed Concrete Steel Company and Lockwood,
Greene to produce the Geo. N. Peirce Plant in Buffalo, producing a booklet
on the project "whose planning principals laid the foundations for factory
design for several decades." Many of the features of the plant's design
made their way into New England and the textile industry, including the siting
of buildings and work-places along "lines of circulation determined by the
flow of work" and lighting from roof dormers that freed factory design from
the limitations of light provided by wall windows (Hildebrand 1974: 28-43) .
Lockwood, Greene & Co. was one of the nation's premier engineering firms,
specializing in the design and construction of textile manufacturing plants
when Naumkeag first hired them. The Company traced its roots to the work
of pioneering textile mill designer David 44hitman in the second quarter of
the 19th century in Rhode Island and Maine, and the A. D. Lockwood Co. of
the 1870s and 1880s in Boston and Providence. As Lockwood, Greene & Co.
after 1882, the firm built textile facilities throughout New England and
were among the first to assist in the development of southern textile
communities. Naumkeag had hired Lockwood, Greene first in 1906 to build
Storehouse No. 1, one of only two of their mill buildings to survive the
1914 fire, and the same year undertook their important Peirce-Arrow project.
They employed then again in 1909 for work at their South Danvers bleachery,
the same year Lockwood, Greene constructed their important commission for
the Maverick Mills in East Boston, believed to be the earliest textile plant
to employ reinforced concrete construction. In both the Peirce and the Maverick
projects the firm employed the concrete beam and girder method of construction.
They were however beginning to adopt the floor and mushroom column system
of C. A. P. Turner of Minneapolis; this method they employed at the Pacific
Mills in Dover NH and the Massachusetts Cotton Mills storehouse in Lowell,
both built in 1909. Their reinforced concrete work for Naumkeag was said
to have been the largest spinning and weaving plant at the time of its
construction. Later the company continued to diversify their designs beyond
textile mills, and moved into textile company management and ownership, a
continued
N�6 tom t0Y04.,
PMi dl�MMw'No. IGMi011
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 4 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
move closely related to their financial problems and liquidation in 1928.
Thereafter the firm returned to its engineering specialty ad while continuing
to diversify, returned to a position of prosperity and prominence. See Condit
1961: 151-194 and Lincoln 1960.
Because the building had been well insured the company received about
$4,000,000 as their settlement. They completely rebuilt their plant and
purchased new equipment to outfit it. Although they retained the name "steam"
in the name of the company, the rebuilding was accompanied by a switch to
electric power. When the fire occurred, the company had only recently ordered
new Draper looms and with these were able to quickly return to manufacturing
by buying the yarns they initially needed from other mills. They were back
in operation by 1916.
Their ability and willingness to rebuild here, particularly as other
manufacturers were beginning to see the advantages of the South for textile
manufacturing, meant the construction of a "rational" factory. In the place
of twenty buildings of many dates, the company soon had a smaller set of
larger buildings, each dedicated to specific activities and machines associated
with cotton manufacture, and each designed especially to suit the activities
within it. In the Cotton Storehouse the large 500-pound bales of cotton
are taken from their compressed jute wrapped state and blended and cleaned,
by mixing alternating handfuls of many cotton types as the raw material is
fed through to the breakers. They moved through the building from the street-
side end on the west to the opposite harbor side. once the material has
passed through the breakers, openers, and cleaners it is blown through to
the picker room in the next building, entering at the harbor end of the Spinning
and Carding Mill. Here the pickers perform the next level of cleaning,
producing a thick lap of cotton to enter the carding machines. The wire
covered rollers comb through the cotton to align the fibers in a single
direction, and the thin sheet produced is then gathered into a one inch strand
called sliver and coiled into tall cans. From here a series of
ever-faster-rolling drawing frames pull the sliver fibers into increasingly
finer sliver, and combining at each stage more slivers into increasingly
dense but parallel strands of fiber. This process is continued when the
sliver enters the roving frames and a twist is added to the strand. The
final and fastest pulling, and added hard twisting, is provided by the ring
spinner. Filling yarns are now ready for weaving while warps must next be
tied into longer lengths, then starched and dressed in the slasher. Each
floor within the mill held a special portion of these tasks and machines.
Fran there the yarns entered the huge Weave Shed through the enclosed bridge.
Here over 4000 Draper loons with Northrup batteries took the warp and yarns
and produced sheeting in a variety of widths. From the Weave Shed the cloth
continued
Noe Pp 1pfOL,
1�% WI NMw�'M. Ip1r x1/
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 8 Page 5 Naumkeag Historic District, Salm MA
moved to the Cloth Roan where it was inspected and prepared for finishing.
From there the gray goods were shipped to the company's dying facility.
The company had acquired in 1909 the Danvers Bleachery, a company operated
since the 1840s by Theophilus Walker and located in the former South Danvers,
later known as Peabody. Here the company took the goods, bleached them,
seared excess nap, dyed some, smoothed and finished them prior to cutting,
hemming, and packaging. (Jarvis 1929, 1934: passim)
Throughout its history the company was known for its use of innovative
technology, from its first willingness to experiment with steam, through
the adoption of successive new types of machinery, new construction materials,
and finally its conversion to electricity. Although research in the company
records available at Harvard's Baker Library Special Collections has not
been undertaken in detail, secondary evidence suggests that further research
will bare this out. The company had the funds and the willingness to not
only rebuild their factory but to replace and update the machinery for it.
They are known to have adopted the newest and most automated of textile
machinery, the ring spinner and the Draper Loom with Northrup battery. Each
machine offered the mill owner the advantage of decreasing the attention
required of the worker to the individual machine, and resulting in the "stretch
out," the increased number of machines per worker, and the "speed up," the
quickening of the machines' speed and output, that characterized labor relations
of the early 20th century. The company paid close attention to the working
of their machinery, with a policy to replace it before, it become old and
inefficient (Jarvis 1929: 15) .
Naumkeag remained innovative in their marketing practices as well, renaming
the plant as Pequot Mills in honor of the muslin and percale sheeting and
the finished sheets they produced. In the second quarter of the 20th century
the company was expanding its product line beyond white muslins and percales
to include colored sheets in seven colors as well as to add sheets with hems
in color. By the second quarter of the 20th century the plant used 60,000
pounds of cotton per day and produced 25,000 miles of sheeting per year (Jarvis
1929: 8, 26) . The company again expanded its capitalization, to $2,250,000
in 1915, to $3,000,000 three years later, and with the offering of a 100%
stock dividend, to $6,000,000 in 1923. The company claimed to maintain the
"best possible working conditions." Their management style was perhaps not
so "modern. " Until altered in the middle of the 20th century, when the company
needed a new president "it was said that all the directors had to do was
to move up the men in successive positions and hire a new office boy" (Dick
1951:16) .
continued
urs ram ioaou.
Ms; UW ne++.+r Ns. iaMsoir
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number Q Page Naumkeag Historic Destrict, Salem MA
Resear on workers and work at the mills remains to be undertaken in
the rich Naumkeag Company records on file in the Archives Division of Baker
Library at the Harvard Business School. Dunn claims that examination of
them suggests early employment of Irish workers, who were subject to the
tight discipline of company paternalism that has cane to characterize life
in 19th century textile manufacturing communities. Workers were young, rarely
stayed more that a year, and had their religious lives and leisure time
subjected to company rules stressing temperance, piety, and industry (Dunn
1981:3-4) . As in so many similar communities the French Canadians soon followed
the Irish into the mills, and the neighborhood of the Naumkeag Mills was
characterized as a French Canadian one by the turn of the century. The parish
of St. Joseph's, formed in 1873 to minister to this group, had only just
built a new church and related buildings on Lafayette Street between Harbor
and Dow streets to the west of the mill when the fire swept through the
neighborhood (Jalbert 1877) . Although the company was beginning to employ
Poles within the mill, most of them lived in two more distant ethnic
neighborhoods, west of Webb Street near Collins Cove and by the Harbor along
Derby Street (Borkowski 1977) . The company supplied some housing, but as
was common in urban settings, the proximity of the speculative housing and
rental market added variety to the housing alternatives. Although few images
of the area survive from before the fire, descriptions of the fire and its
rapid spread through this section of the town emphasize the flamability of
the wood shuloles used in the roofs of the three-deckers and the large tenements
of the area.
The central business district had been spared, but the 1914 fire had
destroyed large industrial and residential portions of the city and left
10,000 people homeless. The city quickly appointed the Rebuilding Commission
to oversee and encourage rebuilding in the burned zone. What for so many
was a tragedy became an opportunity for planners and reformers, fearful because
Salem "before the fire was fast on the way to become a city of ugly and unsafe
wooden three and four deckers" (Salem Rebuilding Ccandssion 1917: 6) . At
the time of the fire the city's building code was fragmented and inappropriate
for the emergency, so many of the commissions efforts were aimed at devising
a code, in stages for the fire zone, and finally one for the entire city.
The commission designated six classes of building, including separate
restrictions for residential, commercial, and industrial buildings. They
established the greatest restrictions on residences designed to acconnodate
large numbers of people, arguing the greater number of lives at risk required
it. By contrast they placed no restrictions on one and two family houses,
the favorite housing form of period reformers. While the commission had
briefly considered providing designs for home builders, this was determined
to be too expensive and likely to produce too uniform a landscape. In addition,
continued
M�6�pmt0Y0f., OW♦yYn.r IA IONC01,
IMl,
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number_ Page 7 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
the consulting architect commented on the choice of a modern style for the
area that "while we would miss the Colonial work, mere reproduction of it
would not be the real thing" but only a "mere servile copy" (Salem Rebuilding
Commission 1917: 24) . In the Stage Point area the buildings of the post-
fire era present a fine collection of apartment blocks, two-family, and
occasional single family residences demonstrating the improvements to working-
class housin, proposed by the commission. The fire hit hard at Salem's
important e",nic working class neighborhoods, and it is not surprising that
residents of the fire zone objected to the expense of the rebuilding
requirements. Ironically the commission claimed its greatest concern was
to encourage safe construction while encouraging rebuilding, and so their
codes for the fire zone were eventually replaced by even more stringent
city-wide codes after their three-year term expired. Naumkeag entered into
the rebuilding effort with the construction of housing by Kilham and Hopkins,
and of course, with their decision to rebuild their new factory in Salem.
Although the company continually emphasized its efforts to provide a
safe work environment, during the early 20th century the plants suffered
strikes by its work force. In 1918 strikes in protest of mill working
conditions and living conditions brought the establishment of Local 33 of
the National Amalgamation of Textile Workers, with organizational help from
the Central Labor Committee from New Bedford MA and Manchester NH (Dunn 1081:4,
reference to Naumkeag Company Records) . This short-lived radical union was
formed after the 1919 Lawrence strike to take up the efforts of the
International Workers of the World, no longer a viable organization after
federal efforts to eradicate it in the years following the 1912 strike.
Recognition of the union by the company and the right to arbitrated collective
bargaining were the goals of that strike, according to some sources (Nyman
1934: passim and Cox 1939: passim for this and subsequent strike-related
material) . -ubsequently reorganized as a unit of the more main-stream United
Textile Workers of America, American Federation of Labor, the closed shop
was successful in bringing improvements to the mill. But by the late 1920s,
when competition and adverse conditions in the cotton textile industry were
mounting for northern owners, tensions between management and labor increased,
and the conpany felt that the union had come "to dominate industrial relations"
(Nyman 1934; 7) . In 1927 the company and the union signed a Cooperative
Agreement designed to assure negotiation between the two parties in an effort
to avoid strikes.
Much of the problem between the two was apparently attributable to the
industry-wide issue of adjustment to new technologies. At Naumkeag, the
emblem of these changes was adoption by the company of the Draper loom with
Northrup battery, a more automated machine, allowing the company to increase
continued
Hrs ram roaoo� aw Nrwv rw rw.00rr
Iwe;
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number $__ Page a — Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
the number of loans each worker operated. In 1928 the company proposed a
stretch out, which, although they claimed it would bring higher wages, would
also mean a reduction in the number of workers. The union turned the offer
down and, after a 60 day negotiation period, labor and management signed
the Joint Research Agreement. This agreement would allowing experts hired
by the company to assist management and workers in the evaluation of alterations
brought on by changing technology in the work place. The agreement, known
throughout the industry, attracted attention to the company, as many hoped
it would be successful in avoiding the violent strikes that tore through
industrial communities during this period.
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company was at the height of its popularity
when it constructed Pequot House, their effort in the celebration of Salem's
tercentenery. They built the house as a First period replica and furnished
and interpreted it as a demonstration of everyday life at that time. While
New England -t large, and Essex County in particular, led the nation in its
growing interest in the national past, few communities could match the efforts
at research, restoration, and reconstruction attempted in Salem. Led by
the Essex Institute and the efforts of George Francis Dow, the early years
of the 19th century saw increasing research and identification of historic
resources within the city. Salem early on focused on its 17th century history,
and many of the activities associated with the tercentenery were associated
with that century. The building was designed by the architect Philip Horton
Smith (1890-1960) , who practiced alone and as part of the firm of Smith and
Walker in Wenham and Boston. Smith's Salem designs and numerous and include
a large portion of Colonial Revival designs. Among these we may note the
bandstand in Washington Square (1926) , the design of the Hawthorne Hotel
(1924-25) , Grace Church, Episcopal (1926-27) , the expansion of Salem High
school (1927-28) , the Tabernacle Church (1923-24) , the U.S. Post Office
(1932-33, NR 1986) , the Holyoke Mutual Insurance Company (1935-36) . Smith
was also involved in restoration and renovation projects, including the Old
Town Hall and Market (1933-34) and the Salem Five Cents Savings bank (1950) .
He lived in the Benjamin Blanchard House at 134 Federal Street, a three-story
frame Federal period house with an added porch by Samuel McIntyre (Tulles
1983: passim) .
The mounting problems posed by the depression, however, soon brough
a return to u:rscord between labor and management at Naumkeag. Textile
manufacturers, in response to increased competition and lower profits, sought
to reorganize work in their factories for greater efficiency, altering job
heirarchies and responsibilities as well as wages. Workers, concern about
traditional work loads, status, and compensation, were fearful of how these
changes would effect their job conditions and income. The Naunkeag Experiment
continued
Ma'am�WODa OWN Mrrwv Mo. IpM1011
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number R Page ° Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
as the joint research agreement was known, had little to offer the worker,
however, ac--rding to reports of subsequent activities at the plant. Designed
to bring the worker into the decision-making process, the plan seemed to
be merely a strategy to obtain only the payroll reductions and reorganization
management needed to increase profits. With discharges and demotions of
mill workers, and curtailed hours for those who remained, wages did not after
all increase and the plant was still operating at a loss. The union initially
agreed to wage reductions as an emergency measure, winning the concession
that research would be halted. But soon wages were reduced substantially,
and the company announced it would open up research activities at the bleachery.
In May of 1933, after a vote of 982 to 182, the union went out on strike.
The strike lasted until July in spite of the claim by the president
of the United Textile Workers union that the strike was illegal. For a brief
period in May and June, Ann Burlak, "the Red Flame," came to work with the
strike committee. Two incidents of violence occurred during the strike,
a shooting and a stoning that left their victims hurt but not seriously injured.
Both state and federal arbitrators were called in, and a new union leader
merged during the strike, Wilfred T. Levesque, as the union was reorganized
with no affiliations. The mill agreed to many of the union's demands, including
a halting of the research procedure for the purposes of stretch outs, and
wages were rescheduled. When this agreement expired, the failure to come
to terms led to another strike, of ten weeks in August, September, and October
of 1935. Tne return to work came with an agreement to take back the strikers,
to meet seniority and forty-hour week demands, but not wage increases. Two
wage increases were followed by a wage reduction by 1938. At that time,
the mill was described as employing 2000 workers in two shifts, with a 60-
40 split between women and men, of whom 65% were French Canadian, 30% Polish,
with the balance divided among the Irish, Italians, and Greeks. 905 belonged
to the union and were paid wages between $13 and $19 per week.
In spite of sporadic labor problems, Naumkeag was among the textile
manufacturers who remained in New England when many were closing and relocating.
Then, in July of 1950, seeing the direction of change within the industry,
the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company purchased a plant in Whitney South Carolina,
a community about four miles from Spartansburg. The brick mill building
was a fraction of the size of the Salem plant, but indicated the direction
planned for the company. In 1954 the company closed its Salem plant, which
was purchased by the 9165 Corporation and then in 1959 by Shetland Industries.
Like other large complexes, it appears that the buildings were subdivided
and small portions leased to manufacturing operations until the late 1960s.
During the 1970s the company was renovated and combined office space with
light industry. As Shetland Office Industrial Park, the Naumkeag Steam Cotton
Company remains an important feature in Salem's historic landscape.
end of part eight
N�6 dam tOWF, Wt Npvw'la. IONODII
f►M;
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number in Page Nauunkeag Historic District, Salm MA
Boundary Description
The boundaries of the Nauunkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District are
indicated on the attached Cit of Salem Assessors Maps 34 & 40, lot 448.
Boundary Justification
The parcel sescribed above is that historically associated with the Naw keag
Steam Cotton Company plant.
end of part ten
N�6 lawn tp y04�
f►M) f1W MYwr No rONiDt1
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 9 Page 1 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Bibliography
Associated Factory Mutual Fire Insurance Co. Salem Conflagration and
Destruction of the Naumkeaq Steam Cotton Company. By the Inspection
Departfh-nt. Boston, 1914.
Borkowski, Elizabeth. "One Hundred Fifteen Years in Salem." In Adele I.
Younis, "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study," Salem
State College, 1976-77.
Candee, Richard M. and Greer Hardwicke, "Early Twentieth-Century Reform Housing
by Kilham and Hopkins, Architects of Boston." Winterthur Portfolio
22 (1987) , pp. 47-80.
Condit, Carl. American Building Art: The Twentieth Century. New York:
Oxford University Press, 1961.
Cox, Frank L. "Experiment in Union-Management Cooperation at the Pequot
Mills." Typescript of ca. 1939 on file at the Essex Institute.
Dick, Rudolph C. Nathaniel Griffen (1796-1876) of Salem - and his Naumkeag
Steam Cotton Co. New York: The Newcomen Society in North America, 1951.
Dunn, Tim, "Naunkeag Steam Factory." Typescript dated 25 March 1981 at the
Salem Planning Department.
Essex Institute Photograph Collection.
Gerstle, Gary. Working Class Americanism: The Politics of Labor in a Textile
City, 1914-1960. New York: Cambridge University press, 1989.
Hildebrand, Grant. Designing for Industry: The Architecture of Albert Kahn.
Cambridge: The MIT Press, 1974.
Jalbert, Philip E. "The French Canadian in South Salem MA." In Adele I.
Younis, "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study," Salem
State College, 1976-77.
Jarvis, Clive. The Story of Peguot. Boston: The Berekely Press of Boston
for the Naumkeag Steam Cotton any, 1929 and 1934 editions. Also
unauthored edition under same title, different format and content, 1949.
continued
r+.e ram iwoo-. aN Mw.r„a. �a.aoi,
United States Department of the Interior
National Park Service
National- Register of Historic Places
Continuation Sheet
Section number 9 Page 2 Naumkeag Historic District, Salem MA
Bibliography continued
Lincoln, Samuel B. Lockwood Greene, The History of an Engineering Business,
1832-1958. Brattleboro: The Stephen Greene Press, 1960.
Nyman, Richmond C. Union-Management Cooperation in the Stretch Out.. .
New Haven: Yale University press, Institute of Human Relations, 1934.
Salem, City of. Public Records: Assessors Records, Building Inspectors Records,
Planning Department Historic Resources Inventory, Salem Rebuilding
Commission Report, Newcomb and Gauss, Printers, 1914.
Sanborn Fire Insurance Company. Atlas of the City of Salem. Multiple years
including 1906 and subsequent updates.
Smith, J. Foster, "Stage Point and Thereabouts." Historical Collections of
the Essex Institute 66 (1930) , pp. 1-20.
Stone, Orra. History of Massachusetts Industries, 4 vols. Boston: S. J. Clarke,
1930.
Tolles, Bryant J. Architecture in Salm: An Illustrated Guide. Salem: Essex
Institute, 1983.
Ware, Caroline. The Early New England Cotton Manufacturer: A Study in
Industrial Beginnings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. , 1931.
Younis, Adele L. , ed. "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study."
Salm State College, 1976-77. Ten Volumes typescript on file at the
Essex Institute.
end of part nine
s
v
3 a
5 Q
� s
2,?A.4 41L447
unoo� ►.�o}� � A
0
It.wv r,LULt �„
� ss
7V
•-ren r.-i turn°
NA[IISEAG STEAM COTTON MILLS HISTORIC DISTRICT, SALEM, MA
DISTRICT DATA SHEET
Map # MHC # Name Address Date Style Type Status
1 Spinning & Carding Mill 35 Congress Street 1915 Art Deco B C
2 Catton Storehouse 35 Congress Street 1915 --- B C
3 Weave Shed 35 Congress Street 1915 --- B C
4 Cloth Roan 35 Congress Street 1924 --- B C
5 Office 47 Congress Street 1915 Art Deco B C
6 Pequot House 35 Congress Street 1930 Colonial Revival B C
A parking garage Pingree Street 1989 --- B tdC
B = Building
St = Structure
Si = Site
C = Contributing
NC = Non-contributing
i
r a:. • 1 � , 1
w
C
yy0� • 1 -C
Oji , r
NMI
ME �
_L\ �■ _� _� �■ {111 'N/ 1 /
F y'
I -
Y
,
a
x
.r
!I
a
It'; r'
I t r
i
I
II
II �
i ' �
a ,
• ��r�ts �-
1,
r
i
v � .
4+
V ,.+ ,�•1^� � ,�"�..e.E^'Z�:�� gam. � � •�� 5 { ,�.,% �� ��
,�, � �'"- .-«�� ara._ �•_ s {rte
I J
��._ __��� t�.n.� as I i - •I
Rte ; J r r
5'1
t '
,y 4 , i �J i,�,i . ' f,r�, ' •
J ..r•�e � 5 l -' 4
. ! � ^ ` _� - �.�.��' it �; 'n J§- L� �� � ��•_��!'` •
_ y V
17
al
a _4
If
i
F _
"o iii
j q
/ Eat
QP
-`= VL 0
tlt+ A.Og sv.
ua /' S✓!� " Ylt 7 I(<f ,j.2� Fl+i i t
J
y
1
t
a
! s .
Y
F �q
1 }
T3
V ,
Rrumry —4
193 er s^ /
I _ �✓ J // -.� a°e !' ��, r c� 1 < sr I, r.
IfVs sPo
r eac moi/ t,r r ��. -i
� � ' ♦ NloCkeret � ;�� hthouse
Beacha ospital Poir
Goff Course S L i 1 R - 6C Woodiury
$ fte+/a Phyg / _ V9r im` Y
point y�a- r PQ' Point
t
l- 1 amp y r/ 5
Aa
`. dirik
nwootl ty�Q \ Tuc – -____
-1
Point
olf Cours _ a N\5 // Lobster
I
E
Salem Neck
Q
-
si ) . + :- •.• . '°j Juniper
Point
lauau
egg 4
,Poe j
V/ G •_ p (Abbot
IiRock ez
s 0�1�
and o.�
` v
subs ? /
on Rck '-,(Y enrig ( �.,
G 'r•' � :707 g, f •00'-. Fdwerpyp �Boat Ramp
Hede
Ali *Rock ZI Rock
h
�
i i y' Commo i' Salem Terminal let
vVhaif 3 SOUTH Wellman
-CH t F _ Cloutman Ledge
2 Point
*�Juen
'ri storNaugus x
� YcaF Site r-�.- �
� I
I�G1vlV4 'y�(q'1 �'�^ iaM Cbf}Do60
u to Wharf ,k,er"✓/1
.e
Light3447564708gIO
r
Z: 19 gSg5 6004,{700090
ong Pot
Im r 3: 11q 3-455 130`t70L5400
•
9T °e 4. Iq 344 570 47r) ,34?-0
Subsra t• 7__ " s '+,Palmer
a/l .'*Point _ /
�Wa er
S .' C 0 r T'+. ♦ O f"�
�y d.
For t G r l9
. t �v.
Park �Pickerijrg
Point
v al`
Golf Course Sch.2.1 n '1- , o ,z ,� �f Seh
,1 r� IC`s^'
343 344,1 s--PscOlT 5KM 45 5P� 30 347
3 4 SCALE 1:25 000 500 o
1 CENMETER ON THE MAP REPRESENTS 250 METERS ON THE GROUND
2 CONTOUR INTERVAL 3 METERS IGpe G
SF,T TS Iy
��v js0
d c
y� MISS10
onWealth
•m O
ELIGIBILITY FOR NATIONAL REGISTER LISTING
TO: MAYOR NEIL J. HARRINGTON
FROM: MASSACHUSETTS HISTORICAL COMMISSION
DATE: MARCH 12, 1993`
The Massachusetts Historical Commission is writing to inform you that the
following property has been voted eligible for inclusion in the National
Register of Historic Places (36 CFR 60) by the Commission acting as the State
Review Board. By law, a property is afforded protection from adverse effect
caused by Federally funded, licensed or assisted projects when it has been
voted eligible for inclusion in the National Register. The nomination form
will now be submitted to the National Register Office, National Park Service
in Washington, DC for final review. If the National Register Office lists the
property or determines it eligible for listing in the National Register, it
will automatically be included in the Massachusetts State Register of Historic
Places (950 CMR 71) . The State Register parallels the National Register in
providing protection from State actions. For more information, you may wish
to refer to your original notification letter or contact the Commission's
National Register staff. When we have received the determination of the
National Register Office, you will be advised.
PROPERTY/ADDRESS DATE VOTED ELIGIBLE
NAUMKEAG STEAM COTTON MILL MARCH 10, 1993
HISTORIC DISTRICT, SALEM
Massachusetts Historical Commission,Judith B.McDonough,Executive Director, State Historic Preservation Officer
80 Boylston Street, Boston, Massachusetts 02116 (617) 7278470
Office of the Secretary of State, Michael J. Connolly,Secretary
r
SHETLAND TRUST
P. 0. Box 986
Salem, MA 01970
✓dQo�'
i
February 1 , 1993
Ms . Judith B. McDonough
Executive Director
State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
80 Boylston Street
Boston, MA 02116
RE: Objection to Listing of Shetland Properties on
the National Register of Historic Places as
the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mill (or Cotton
Company)„Historic District
Dear Ms . McDonough:
I certify that Shetland Trust, of which I am trustee, is the
sole owner of the above-described property which you have
indicated to me is being considered for nomination to the
National Register of Historic Places .
Shetland Trust hereby exercises its right under the National
Historic Preservation Act and 36 C.F.R. 60 . 6 (g) to OBJECT to
the listing of its property on the National Register of
Historic Places as well as on any state register of historic
assets . This objection is grounded in the severely negative
impact on job creation such a listing would have as a result
of the Trust' s inability to rehabilitate its property freely
and economically.
very truly yours ,
Robert I . Lappin .
Trustee
Ms . Judith B. McDonough
Massachusetts Historical Commission
February 1 , 1993
Page Two
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
ESSEX, ss . February � , 1993
Then personally appeared the above-named Robert I .
Lappin, and acknowledged the foregoing to be his free act and
deed, before me,
Cd/zl�i, Lam( • ���-fa
Notary Public
My Commission Expires :
RIL/lmp .
cc: Neil Harrington, Mayor, City of Salem
William Luster, Planner, City of Salem
William J. Tinti, Esquire
I ,
t -
V Q
December 30, 1992 r.
le
Ms. Jane Guy * QQ 4
Preservation Planner -Y A I S SZo tC�
Salem Historical Commissiont
One Salem Green O mOnWealtlt
Salem, MA 01970
\J,04q-�-
Dear Mjs GW.
The National Register nomination for the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Historic District, Salem, Massachusetts has
been scheduled for consideration by the State Review Board on Wednesday, March 10, 1993.
Federal regulations require that the State Historic Preservation Officer notify property owners of pending
Review Board consideration 30-75 days before the date of the meeting so that they may comment on the
action. Those regulations also require that owners' names and addresses be obtained no more than 90 days
before the date of the notification letter. We depend on the nominating party to check local property
records, and provide us with updated owner information.
In the case of small districts such as this, we notify each property owner individually. Therefore, you
should submit the owners' list typed on mailing labels. In addition to the owner's name and address, the
label should reference the property address and district name. Labels are enclosed.
Sample: Mr. and Mrs. Robert Jones '
P. O. Boz 7
Anytown, Massachusetts
RE: 7 South St.
Any Area National Register Historic District
Please complete the mailing list in triplicate (enough labels are provided) and return it to this office no
later than January 8, M. If you cannot meet this deadline, please let me know as soon as possible.
In an ongoing effort to increase public awareness, the Massachusetts Historical Commission will be placing
draft versions of the nomination in a local library. Please provide us with the name and address of the
most appropriate library and its head librarian.
Sincerely,
Betsy Friedberg
National Register Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Claire Dempsey, Preservation Consultant
Chairperson, Salem Historical Commission
Neil J. Harrington, Mayor, City of Salem
Enclosure: mailing labels
Massachusetts Historical Commission,Judith B.McDonough,Executive Director, State Historic Preservation Officer
80 Boylston Street,Boston,Massachusetts 02116 (617) 727-8470
} , Office of the Secretary of State,Michael J. Connolly,Secretary
BOARD OF ASSESSORS
CITY HALL PAGE ,
SAL. 111. MA 01970
q I ,,� Dail i
2
ERS, LYST ......
2
-ll,,- ,.,,cERT V1 UT-7
0-AS ........
1E E
3
4
4 SUBJECT PROPERTY. LOT.- -j 5
05 IDROPERTY ADDRES" t 601
6 ASSESSED OWNER
7 .. ..... ...... 9
8 0 :00 1
9 MAP LOT SUFF PROPERTY ADDRESS ASSESSED OWNER MAILING ADDRESS 12
10 13
0 11 34 0448 0047 CONGRESS STREET SHE1-LAND TRUST P 0 BOX 986 :4 o
5
12 LAF'�'IN ROBERT I TR SALEM MA 01970 16
13 42 0020 01100, MEMORIAL DRIVE SALEM C17Y OF .17
0 14 ... . . . . Is*
ST NICHOLA S' RUSSIAN 64 ,F-ORRFSfE R S T R ECT,'
FF
1 �� o0ti-f000x" 0
15 2
�'4,1 -Z116'
16 GREEK CATHOLIC CHURCH SALEM 11A 01970 21
2,
017 41 0219 202 0064 FORRESTER STREET ST NICHOLAS RLISSIA14 ORTHODOX 64 FORRESTER STREET230
GREEK CATHOLIC CHURCH SALEM MA 01970 24
25
........... ......
2 7
26
...........
2
. .......... ... I ....
..........
21 1 .............. 28
22 29
0 23 3010
31
24 32
......... ......... .
..... .....
26
........1.- 30
0
27
61
26 37
0 29 380
39
30 40
31
0 32 420
43
33 44
34 45
35 4610
0 47
36 481
37
49
.. ... .....
50
51 0
38
..........
39: ... .......
52
40 ;3
0
41 54o 'm
55
42
56
43' ......
.................. .
57
%
44 58
59 0
45
........... ........ 1.4.%',%'1
% 60
46 61
0 47 62o
63
48 64
49 1. .....
65
e.. .......
50
....... :710
68
52 69
0
053 71
7
54 72
55
7
F-TETE 3
5 S R 74
A S S E!l,' 0
0 CHID
75 0
75
7 7
1. Name of property
Naumkeag Stearn Cotton Company Historic District
other names: Pequot Mills, Shetland Properties
2. Location
Congress and Lynch streets at South River
Salem
Masachusetts 025 Essex 009 zip code 01970
3. Classification
Private Ownership
Category: Buildings, six contributing, one non-contributing
4.
5.
6. Function or Use
Historic Function: Mill
Current Function: Office, Factory
7. Description
Architectural Classification: Art Deco
materials: foundation: concrete
walls: concrete, brick, glass, wood
roof: asphalt
other:
S. Statement of Significance
A and C at the State Level
Criteria Exception: none
Areas of Significance: Industry, Architecture
Period of Significance: 1914-1954
Architect: Lockwood Greene & Co. , Philip Horton Smith
9. Bibliography Attached
10. Geographic Data
Acreage: 29.1 acres
UT6:s:19.344750.4708910
19.345000.4708880
19.345130.4708400
19.344870.4708420
Boundary Description: The boundaries of Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills
are indicated on the attached Assessors Maps 34 & 40, lot 448.
Boundary Justification: The parcel described above is that historically
associated with Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills.
11. Prepared by Claire W. Dempsey
Three historic views, sketch map, and district data sheet attached.
Naumkeag steam cotton company Historic District: Description
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Mills Historic District consists of six buildings
on 29 acres, located at the point of land where the South River meets Salem
Harbor. The parcel is shaped as an inverted L, with the long sten running
north-south along the shore of Salem Harbor. Just off shore is the extension
and the end of Derby Wharf (NR) and the Derby Lighthouse. In addition to
the harbor, the long stern has Palmer Cove forming its southern border and
Pingree Street its western border. The short sten runs east-west, joining
the long sten at its northeast end, with the South River forming its northern
border, and Congress and Lynch streets forming the west and south borders
respectively. The reinforced concrete manufacturing buildings are oriented
on the lot in a canperable configuration. The largest building, the weave
Shed, occupies the bulk of the long sten, while the three other manufacturing
and storage areas, smaller and oriented in a perpendicular direction, occupy
the short sten, the Cotton Storehouse closest to the South River, followed
by the Spinning Mill in the center, and the Cloth Roan below. The two smallest
buildings in the complex, the Office and Pequot House, are located close
to Congress Street on either side of the Spinning Mill, forming the entry/public
area of the mill complex.
This area, known as Stage Point, is part of the larger portion of Salem,
south of the South River, that was developed intensively for the first time
in the 19th century as the location of manufacturing and processing plants.
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company purchased the land in 1841 from the city
of Samel, construction began in 1845, and the textile manufacturer remained
until the company relocated in 1954. During the end of the 19th century,
as the plant expanded with the construction of more buildings, the irregular
shore line of this area was filled in and regularized, and over time, the
rises in the land surface were flattened. In 1914 this area was part of
the large expanse of the City which burned, and thus all of the complex
post-dates that event. The roughly rectangular shape it takes today is the
result of rebuilding after the fire. At that time the street patetrn in
front of the mill was altered as well, and the Union Street Bridge, and the
associated Union Street which turned to run to the west after the bridge
crossing, were removed. The new bridge was constructed further inland to
the west, as the South River was filled in and the new extension of Congress
(5rvmifh 19SOtp( On M)
Street extended to meet it. A The area around the mill was then surrounded
by a right angled grid of streets rather than the mix of angles and directions
that preceeded the fire. A On those streets the mill is surrounded by housing
constructed at that time under the direction of the Salem Redevelopment Trust
which endeavored to limit the fire-prone elements as rebuilding progressed,
setting rules for materials, heights, etc., that determined the character
of the landscape today. Expand.
The Great Fire of 25 June 1914 destroyed nearly all of the previously
existing mill complex and a surrounding neighborhood. Two buildings from
the earlier complex survived the fire, a four-story concrete warehouse
(Storehouse No. 1) built in 1906, and demolished , and a former gas container
used as a Storehouse No. 10, demolished during the new construction after
the fire (Associated Factory Mutual, 1914). Four new buildings were constructed
in 1915; one of these, a single story brick boiler house that formerly stood
on the river side of the Weave Shed, has been demolished; the Storehouse,
Carding & Spinning Mill, and Weave Shed survive. The addition of a Cloth
Roan to the Weave Shed dates to 1924. All of these buildings were constructed
in the most innovative material available to mill engineers at the time of
their construction, reinforced concrete, by the region's premier firm
specializing in industrial buildings, Lockwood, Green of Boston. In addition
to the manufacturing and storage facilities the company constructed an Office,
apparently of more common brick. The last building added to the complex
was the Pequot House, a 1930 reconstruction of a First Period residense built
in association of the city's 1930 Tricentennial celebration. A single
non-contributing building is included on the site, a four-story parking garage
was added along Pingree Street in 198-.
When Lockwood, Greene designed the new mills for Naumkeag, reinforced
concrete had only recently been introduced to the textile industry, and this
complex became a model of the new technology. Concrete had many desirable
properties, its ability to resist compression and to be molded into a wide
variety of shapes. When reinforced by the insertion within it of steel rods
and/or thin plates, its ability to resist tension is improved. The resulting
product is very strong and has the added ability to resist fire since the
- 2 -
steel is shielded from the heat and flames by the cover of concrete.
Photographs of the structure under construction show on site-construction
of the concrete walls within molds of dimensioned timber and plywood, removed
when they hardened to form the floors of the structure. Each concrete slab
floor was supported around the perimeter by piers and within the building
by large mushroom-shaped colamns, supporting the entire frame of the building.
By contrast the walls had only to support their own weight, so each was
constructed of brick and glass, and known as curtain walls.
The buildings constructed in 1915 demonstrate the new aesthetic of modern
architecture applied within the industrial sphere. The large rectangular
buildings are constructed with flat roofs. Each elevation received equal
ornamental treatment, and the largest proportion of each wall was composed
of brick infill and glass windows, read as a large expanse of dark void between
the strong horizontals marking the floors. Brick provided contrast to the
pale concrete and was used between the concrete piers to determine the window
size and shape, and thus varying with the finction of the building. In the
Carding and Spinning Rooms, the need for natural light suggested the use
of large glass windows composed of large lights in dark metal sash which
greatly increased light to the buildings' interior. At the weave Shed the
sawtooth roof let in large amounts of northern light, and the walls thus
needed only small windows. Similarly, the Cotton Storehouse was constructed
for safety with only small openings. In contrast to the most "modern" of
factories at the time, these buildings were treated with.ornament in a small
number of areas: where the roof form allowed it, a parapet provided a terminus
to the building's elevation, and while it was usually straight, on the tall
connector between the. weave Shed and the Spinning Mill, and in several locations
on the Spinning Mill. itself, stepping of the parapet provided visual contrast.
Indeed the Spinning Mill itsefl received the largest amount of ornament,
rr
and was the dominant"visual element of the complex.
The Storehouse, a five story warehouse was built along the South River,
a long trapezoid measuring 500 feet in length, 50 feet wide at the east and
about 115 feet at the wider west end. Its river-facing north facade is composed
of thirty bays, divided by concrete piers, joined across the the top of the
wall by a classically derived cornise with a marking each bay; a small square
- 3 -
window in the center of each bay lights the raised basement. As originally
constructed similar small windows were located in the top center of each
bricked bay, small openings being the traditional and effective method in
storage of so flammable a material as raw cotton. In the renovation of the
building for commercial uses, the brick has been removed from between the
concrete peirs and replaced with fixed sash.
The four-story Carding and Spinning Mill was built parallel to the
storehouse, and extends to 725 feet in length and 140 feet in width. Each
facade is treated with projecting towers, the largest the front stair tower,
with four smaller ones along the south long wall and two smaller ones on
the north or harbour facing wall. These towers contain the stair wells and
toilets, allowing large expanses within the roans necessary to accomodate
large numbers of large machines. The towers are also the location of brick
detailing that provides ornament to the complex, in particular the stepped
parapet and clocks of the entry tower. when the new mill went into production
in 1916 it included 101,925 new spindles, and was subsequewntly increased
to 163,312. During rennovation the metal sash were replaced with new large-
paned fixed sash.
The single story Weave Shed covers over nine acres of the site, located
on the Salem Harbor side of the lot, with its long dimension running north-south
or perpendicular to the storehouse and the carding & spinning mill. In
footprint the building presents a large rectangle at the south, measuring
625 feet by 420 feet, with a smaller rectangular ell set flush left or west
on the north wall, measuring 580 feet by 212 feet. The shed was built in
two stages (Dick 1951:15) , the first section the southern one, covering seven
acres, which was quickly expanded to the present nine with the constrcution
of the northern addition. On its northwest corner a small four story tower
is connected to the Spinning Mill by an enclosed and elevated bridge. In
profile the weave shed takes the emblematic sawtooth roof form, with thirty
eight parallel dormers running east west across the building, letting light
into the weave roans. Here were housed over 4000 looms. In 1924 the Company
added on to the weave shed, constructing the single-story, 322 by 110 foot
Cloth Room to the northwest side of the weave shed. This low building is
also constructed with a sawtoothed roof?
- 4 -
The Naumkeag Office is seldom mentioned in the enumeration of new buildings
constructed for the company but appears on maps and in photographs quite
early. The two-story, hip-roofed rectangle has a central single-story entry
porch, and is constructed of brick. Its facade is composed of three parts,
a four bay section at each end marked by the stepped parapet, with the central
section composed of seven bays of triple windows; its side elevations are
three bays wide. The cornise parapet is treated with patera along the line
of contrasting stone that markes the parapet, surrounds all the openings,
and marks the belt course of the water table along the raised basement.
In 1930 the company constructed the frame building known as Pequot House
to serve as reception and exhibit space. Constructed to suggest First Period
architecture, the building resembles most closely the John ward House, built
in 1685 and expaned soon thereafter to assume the familiar center chimney,
lean-to form, owned by the Essex Institute, and restored in 1910 by George
Francis Dow. The architect of the building was Philip Horton Smith (1890-1960) ,
who practiced in Boston and throughout the north shore. The gable-roofed
structure rises to two stories with a high attic, a pair of facade gables,
and a rear leanto, and construction photographs suggest its construction
was, at least in part, based on timber framing techniques. Its facade was
lit with small windows in a synmentrical five bay, center entry configuration;
the west window in the second story on the north side has been replaced with
a large plate glass picture window. It differs from the ward House in its
greater dependance on symmetry, its use of double hung rather than casement
windows, and its use of an overhang on the facade as well as the side
elevations.
In 1954 the Naumkeag Stram Cotton Company closed the Pequot Mills and
relocated to their southern base outside Spartenville South Carolina. In
19 it was purchased by and is presently known as Shetland Properties, operated
as a combined commercial and office plant. Alterations to the plant associated
with the change in use are small in number. The entire plant has been painted
white, so that many of the contrasting brick panels are no longer a visual
element in the design scheme. Window replacement has occurred as well,
including opening the windows of the Cotton Storeroom, and replacement of
- 5 -
the windows elsewhere with large-paned, fixed sash. Although these alterations
are "unfortunate," in the words of the Massachussetts Historical Commission
staff, they are not deemed sufficient to ccmprcmise the buildings' integrity.
- 6 -
Naumkeag Steam: Significance
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District is a complex of
six buildings constructed between 1915 and 1930 to house the offices and
manufacturing buildings of the long-standing Salam textile manufacturer.
Constructed after the Great Fire of 1914 destroyed the mill and its surrounding
neighborhood, the company employed the eminent industrial architects, Lockwood,
Green of Boston to construct the spinning mill and weave shed, the largest
integrated plant at the time of its construction, and employing the innovative
technology of reinforced concrete. The company had operated in the city
since 1845, and during the early 20th century this mill was by far its largest
employer, with a payrole of 1600, including one third of all city wage earners.
Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company Historic District meets criteria A and C at
the State level. Although some alterations have been made to the building
during its conversion to offices as Shetland Properties, they have not
compromised the integrity of the large complex. Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company
Historic District retains integrity of location, setting, design, materials,
workmanship, and association.
The site of the district is on a penninsula formed by the South River
on the north and Salem Harbor to the east and the south, a small area earlier
known as Stage Point. The portion of Salem lying below the South River,
and within which Stage Point lies, was not early developed. The area's name,
and its apparent most common early use, was for stages on which to dry fish.
It was the site of a marine railway, shipyard, and wharves at the end of
the 18th century, and was aquired by the town in 1781 from its Tory owner
William Brown. The town rented out the area, and in addition charged fees
based on the tonnage of the vessel to allow ships to be graved and sheather
there. (Smith 1930: 2,7,8)
The Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company was established in Salem in 1839 when
a group of local merchants took their profits from the maritime trade and
invested than in the rising cotton manufacturing business. Coastal cities
like Salem, Newburyport, Portsmouth, and Boston were relative late-comers
to the textile boom, lacking the necessary source of water power on which
so many of the pioneering manufacturers had relied. When steam power became
- 7 -
a reliable alternative these sites became more viable, and while real estate
within then might prove more costly, the presense of services and an open
rental housing market precluded the construction of tenements, store, churches,
and meeting halls to support the mill employees. The chief investors, Nathaniel
Griffin and David Pingree, hired the engineer Charles T. James to consult
then in their endeavor. James was an advocate of steam power manufactories
where he believed a higher quality product could be produced, as well as
a proponent of their location within port cities where they could take advantage
of the exisiting urban infrastructure. Naumkeag was among the first, if
not the first, of the textile manufacturing companies in Massachusetts to
use coal-fired steam engines to power their machinery, and manufacturers
in the other cities would soon emulate then. (Dunn 1981: 2, Smith 1930:
11-13)
In 1841 the area at the mouth of the South River adjacent to Salem harbor
was purchased by David Pingree who thought the site ideal for the steam-powered
textile manufacturing plant planned by his partner Griffen and designed by
James. Convenient to the wharves and the water for transportation, the mill
would also benefit from the ambient humidity needed to dampen fibers in in
cotton manufacturing (Smith 1930: 9-11) . Constructing on buildings began
by 1845 and was in production by 1847, with a 1849 capitalization of $700,000.
Naumkeag remained successful and innovative throughout the 19th century,
expanding its plant on filled land around the point and the construction
of more buildings on the site. The plant was expanded in 1863 and again
in 1868, with accompanying capitalization increases to $1,200,00 and 1,500,00.
The plant included twenty buildings of standard slow-burn mill construction.
During the 1890s the company changed its product focus, from a variety of
cotton fabrics to a sheeting specialty. The company was the first to cut
and hen sheets for the domestic market and to promote their product directly
to the consumer, eliminating the traditional ccnrdssion merchant at the turn
of the century (Dick 1951: 16) .
In June of 1914 the company's plant was by far the largest loss in the
fire that swept through South Salem and burned a total of over 250 acres.
Damage to the City was enormous, destroying 1600 buildings valued at
$14,000,000, and leaving 14,000 homeless. Naumkeag's experience in this
- a -
fire proved important to the company, and to manufacturers and insurers alike,
for two of the only buildings to survive the fire were storehouses within
the plant that demonstrated improved fire proof technologies. Storehouse
No.10, a former gas container and thus circular in form and brick and fire-
proof in materal, had double doors that protected its contents of bales of
raw cotton. Storehouse No. 1 was a recently constructed building of reinforced
concrete, built in 1906 from designs by Lockwood, Greene, whose materials
proved resistant, and whose system of automatic shutter closing protected
the contents of finished cloth. The intact survival of this building and
its contents was credited at the time with impressing the advantages of this
new material on the industry at large, and "gave considerable impetus in
the region to reinforced concrete construction," according to a subsequent
company president (Dick 1951:14) .
Not surprisingly then the Naumkeag officials choose to employ reinforced
concrete in their new construction, and hired the engineering firm of Lockwwod
Greene as their engineers to accomplish "a very complete rebuilding along
modern lines" (Dick 1951:14). Although used in Europe throughout the late
19th century, early U.S. efforts to build with reinforced concrete begin
with the work of Ernest Ransome at the turn of the century in California
and New Jersey. Interestingly "his most impressive work" was "the remarkable
plant" he designed for the United Shoe Machine Company in Beverly. Dating
to 1903-05 this outstanding complex introduced the technology to the region.
Ransome's leading position was soon supplanted by Albert Kahn and the work
he completed for the _auto industry in the Detroit area. In 1906 Kahn
collaborated with his brother's Trussed Concrete Steel Company and Lockwood,
Greene, to produce the G$D. N. Peirce Plant in Buffalo, producing a booklet
on the project "whose planning principals laid the foundations for factory
design for several decades." many of the features of the plant's design
made their way into New England and the textile industry, including the siting
of buildings and workplaces along "lines of circulation determined by the
flow of work." and lighting from roof dormers that freed factory design from
the limitations of light provided by wall windows. (Hildebrand 1974: 28-43)
expand re Lockwood, Greene
Because the building had been well insured the company received about
$4,000,000 as their settlement. They completely rebuilt their plant and
purchased new equipment to outfit it. Although they retained the name "steam"
in the name of the company, the rebuilding was accompanied by a switch to
electric power. When the fire occured, the company had only recently ordered
new Draper loans, and with these were able to quickly return to manufacturing
by buying the yarns they initially neede from other mills. They were back
in operation by 1916.
Their ability and willingness to rebuild here, particularly as
manufacturers were beginning to see the advantages of the South for textile
manufacturing, meant the construction of a "rational" factory. In the place
of twenty buildings of many dates, the company soon had a set of larger
buildings, each dedicated to specific activities and machines associated
with cotton manufacture, and each designed especially to suit the activities
within it. In the Cotton Storehouse the large 500-pound bales of cotton
are taken from their compressed jute wrapped state and blended and cleaned,
by mixing alternating handfuls of many cotton types as the raw material is
fed through to the breakers. They moved through the building from the street-
side end on the west to the opposite harbor side. Once the material has
passed through the breakers, openers and cleaners it is blown through to
the picker room in the next building, entering at the harbor end of the Spinning
and Carding riill. Here the pickers perform the next level of cleaning,
producing a thick lap of cotton to enter the carding machines. The wire
covered rollers comb through the cotton to allign the fibers in a single
direction, and the thin sheet produced is then gathered into a one inch strand
called sliver and coiled into tall cans. From here a series of
ever-faster-rolling drawing frames pull the sliver fibers into increasingly
finer sliver, and combining at each stage more slivers into increasingly
dense but parallel strands of fiber. This process is continued when the
sliver enters the roving frames and a twist is added to the strand. The
final and fastest pulling, and added hard twisting, is provided by the ring
spinner. Filling yarns are now ready for weaving while warps must next be
tied into longer lengths and starched and dressed in the slasher. Each floor
within the mill held a special portion of these tasks and machines. From
the mill the yarns entered the Weave Shed through the enclosed bridge, and
- 10 -
finally entered the Cloth Roan. From there the grey goods were shipped to
the company's dying facility. The company had aquired in 1909 the Danvers
Bleachery, a company operated since the 1840s by Theophilus Walker, and located
in the former South Danvers, later known as Peabody. Here the company took
the grey goods, bleached them, seared excess nap, dyed some, smoothed and
finished then in a series of pricess prior to cutting, hemming, and packaging.
(Jarvis 1929, 1934: passim)
Throughout its history the company was known for its use of innovative
technology, from its first willingneww to experiment with steam, through
the adoption of successive new machinery, new construction materials, and
finally its conversion to electricity. Although research in the company
records available at Harvard's Baker Library Special Collections has not
been undertaken in detail, secondary evidence suggests that further research
will bare this out. The company had the funds and the willingness to not
only rebuild their factory but to replace and update the machinery for it
as well. They are known to have adopted the newest and most automated of
textile machinery, the ring spinner and the Draper Loom with Northrup battery.
Each machine offered the mill owner the advantage of decreasing the attention
required of the worker to the individual machine, and resulting in the "stretch
out," or increased numer of machines per worker, and the "speed up," or
quickening of the machines speed and output, that characterized the labor
relations of the early 20th century. The company paid close attention to
the working of their machinery, with a policy to replace it before it become
old and inefficient (Jarvis 1929: 15) . Naumkeag remained innovative in their
marketing practices as well, renaming the plant as Pequot Mills in honor
of the muslin and percale sheeting and finished sheets they producted. In
the second quarter of the 20th century the company was expanding its product
line beyond white muslins and percales to include colored sheets in seven
colors as well as to add sheets with hems in color. By the second quarter
of the 20th century the plant used 60,000 pounds of cotton per day and produced
25,000 miles of sheeting per year (Jarvis 1929: 8, 26). The company again
exanded its capitalization, to $2,250,000 in 1915, to $3,000,000 three years
later, and with the offering of a 100% stock dividend, to $6,000,000 in 1923.
The company claimed to maintain the "best possible working conditions."
Their management style was perhaps not so "modern." Until the middle of
- 11 -
the 20th century when their policy was modified, when the company needed
a new president "it was said that all the directors had to do was to move
up the men in successive positions and hire a new office boy" (Dick 1951:16) .
Information about workers and work at the mills is scarse. Dunn claims
that examination of Naumkeag Company records on file in the Archives Division
of Baker Library at the Harvard Business School suggest early employment
of Irish workers, who were subject to the tight discipline of company
paternalism that has cane to characterize life in 19th century textile
manufacturing communities. Workers were young, rarely stayed more that a
year, and had their religious lives and leisure time subjected to company
rules stressing temperance, piety, and industry. (Dunn 1981:3-9) As in
so many similar communities the French Canadians soon followed the Irish
into the mills, and the neighborhood of the Naumkeag Mills was characterized
as a French Canadian one by the turn of the century. The parish of St.
Joseph's, formed in 1873 to minister to this group, had only just built a
new church and related buildings on Lafayette Street on the between Harbor
and Dow streets, just to the west of the mill, when the fire swept through
the neighborhood. (Jalbert 1877) Although the company was beginning to employ
Poles within the mill, most lived in twc ethnic neighborhoods, west of Webb
Street near Collins Cove and by the Harbor along Derby Street. (Borkowski
1977) The company supplied some housing, but as was common in urban settings,
the proximity of the speculative housing and rental market added variety
to the housing alternatives. Although few images of the area survive from
before the fire, descriptions of the fire and its rapid spread through this
section of the town emphasize the flamability of the woad shingles used in
the roofs of the three-deckers and the large tenements of the area.
Although the company continually emphasized its efforts to provide a
safe work environment, during the early 20th century the plants suffered
strikes by its workforce. In 1918 the strike in protest of mill working
conditions and living conditions brought the establishment of Local 33 of
the National Amalgamation of Textile Workers, with organizational help from
the Central Labor Committee from New Bedford MA and Manchester Mi (Dunn 1081:9 ,
reference to Naumkeag Company Records) . Recognition of the union by the
company, with the associated right to arbitrated collective bargaining, was
- 12 -
the real goal of that strike, according to some sources (Cox 1935: passim
for this and next three paragraphs). As a unit of the United Textile workers
of America, American Federation of Labor, the closed shop was successful
in bringing improvements to the mill. But by the late 1920s, when competition
and adverse conditions in the cotton textile industry were mounting for northern
owners, tensions between management and labor increased, and the company
felt that the union had cane "to dominate industrial relations" (Cox 1935).
In 1927 the company and the union signed a Co-operative Agreement designed
to assure negotiation between the two parties in an effort to avoid strikes.
Much of the problem between the two was apparently attributable to the
adoption by the company of the new Draper loon, a machine that was supposedly
automatic, allowing the company to increase the number of looms each worker
operated. In 1928 the company proposed a "stretch out," which, although
they claimed it would bring higher wages, would also mean a reduction in
the number of workers. The union turned the offer down and, as a result
of the 60 day negotiation period, labor and management signed the Joint Research
Agreement, that would allowing experts hired by the company to assist in
the evaluation of alterations brought on by changing technology in the
workplace. The agreement, known throughout the industry, attracted attention
to the company, as many hoped it would be succesful in avoiding the violent
strikes that tore through industrial communities during this period.
The Naumkeag Experiment as it was known had little to offer the worker,
however, according to reports of subsequent activities at the plant. Designed
to bring the worker into the decision-making process, some might say to co-opt
the worker, the plan seemed to many as a ruse to obtain the payroll reductions
and reorganization management needed to increase profits. With discharges
and demotions of.mill workers, and curtailed hours for the remaining workers,
wages did not after all increase, and the plant was still operationg at a
loss. The union initally agreed to wage reductions as an emergency measure,
winning the concession that research would be halted. But soon wages were
reduced substantially, and the company announced it would open up research
activities at the bleachery. The company wanted workers to operate 29 rather
than 20 loons, claiming their competition required as many as 39 looms per
person. In May of 1933, after a vote of 982 to 182, the union went out.
_. tJ-
The strike lasted until July, in spite of the claim by the president
of the United Textile union that the strike was illegal. For a brief period
in May and June, Ann Burlak, "the Red Flame," came to work with the strike
committee. Two incidents of violence occurred during the strike, a shooting
and a stoning that left their victims hurt but not seriously injured. Both
state and federal arbitrators were called in, and a new union leader emerged
during the strike, Wilfred T. Levesque, as the union was reorganized with
no affiliations. The mill agreed to many of the union's demands, including
a halting of the research proceedure for the purposes of stretch outs, and
wages were rescheduled. When this agreement expired, the failure to cane
to terms led to another strike, of ten weeks in August, September, and October
of 1935. The return to work came with an agreement to take back the strikers,
to meet senority and forty-hour week demands, but not wage increases. Two
wage increases were followed by a wage reduction by 1938. At that time,
the mill was described as employing 2000 workers in two shifts, with a 60-
40 split between women and men, of whom, 65% were ethnically French Canadian,
30% Polish, with the balance divided among the Irish, Italians, and Greeks.
905 belonged to a union and were paid wages between $13 and $19 per week.
Pequot House was the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company's effort in the
celebration of Salem's tercentenery. They built the house as a First period
replica, and furnished and interpreted it as a demonstrations of everyday
life at that time. S4hile New England at large, and Essex County in particular,
led the nation in its growing interest in the national past, few, communities
could match the efforts at research, restoration, and reconstruction attempted
in Salem. Led by the Essex Institute and the efforts of George Francis Dow,
the early years of the 19th century saw increasing research and identification
of historic resources within the city. Salem early on focused on its 17th
century history, and many of the activities associated with the tercentenatry
were associated with that century. The building was designed by the architect
Philip Horton Smith (1890-1960), who practised alone and as part of the firm
of Smith and Walker in Wenham and Boston. Smith's Salem designs and numerous
and include a large portion of Colonial Revival designs. Among these we
may note the bandstand in Washington Square (1926) , the design of the Hawthorne
Hotel (1924-25) , Grace Church, Episcopal (1926-27) , the expansion of Salem
- 14 -
High School (1927-28), the Tabernacle Church (1923-24) , the U.S. Post Office
(1932-33, NR?) , the Holyoke Mutual Insurance Company (1935-36). Smith was
also involved in restoration and rennovation projstcs, including the Old
Town Hall and market (1933-34) and the Salem Five Cents Savings bank (1950) .
He lived in the Benjamin Blanchard House at 134 Federal Street, a three-story
frame federal period house with an added porch by Samuel McIntyre.
In July of 1950, seeing the direction of change within the textile
manufacturing industry, the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company purchased a plant
in Whitney South Carolina, a community about four miles from Spartansburg.
The brick mill building was a fraction of the size of the Salam plant, but
indicated the direction planned for the company. In 1954 the company closed
its Salem plant.
r7
- IS
Biblography
Associated Factory Mutual Fire Insurance Co. Salem Conflagration and
Destruction of the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company. By the Inspection Department.
Boston, 1914.
Borkowski, Elizabeth. "One Hundred Fifteen Years in Salem." In Adele 1.
Younis, "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study," Salem State
College. 10 vols.
Cox, Frank L. "Experiment in Union-Management Co-operation at the Pequot
Mills." Typescript of ca. 1939 on file at the Essex Institute.
Dick, Rudolph C. Nathaniel Griffen (1796-1876) of Salem - and his Naumkeag
Steam Cotton Co. New York: The Newcanen Society in North America, 1951.
Dunn, Tim, "Naumkeag Steam Factory," Typescript dated 25 March 1981 at the
Salem Planning Department.
Essex Institute Photography Collection.
Hildebrand, Grant. Designing for Industry: The Architecture of Albert Kahn.
Cambridge: The MIT Press, 1974.
Jalbert, Philip E. "The French Canadian in South Salem MA." In Adele 1.
Younis, "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study," Salem State
College. 10 vols.
Jarvis, Clive. The Story of Peguot. Boston: The Berekely Press of Boston
for the Naumkeag Steam Cotton Company, 1929 and 1934 editions. Also unauthored
edition under same title, different format and content, 1949.
Lincoln, Samuel B. Lockwood Creene, The Hisotry of an Engineering Business,
1832-1958. Brattleboro: The Stephen Greene Press,
Salem Rebuilding Commission Report, City of Salem, 1914.
Smith, J. Foster, "Stage Point and Thereabouts." Historical Collections of
the Essex Institute 66 (1930) , pp.
Stone, Orra. History of Massachusetts Industries 4 vols. Boston: S. J. Clarke,
1930.
Ware, Caroline. The Early New England Cotton Manufacturer: A Study in
Industrial Beginnings. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. , 1931.
Younis, Adele L. , ed. "Graduate Immigration Seminar: A Bicentennial Study."
Salem State College, 1976-77. Ten Volumes typescript on file at the Essex
Institute.
NAU'WW STEAM COTTON MILLS HISTORIC DISTRICP, SALEM, MA DISTRICP DATA SHEEP
Map fl MHC $ Name Address Date Style Type Status
1 Carding a Spinning Mill Congress Street 1915 Art Deco B C
2 Weave Shed Pingree Street 1915 --- B C
3 Cotton Storehouse Congress Street 1915 --- B C
9 Cloth Roan Congress Street 1929 --- B C
5 Office Congree Street 1915? Art Deco B C
6 Pequot House Congress Street 1930 Colonial Revival B C
A parking garage Pingree Street ? --- B NO
B= Building
St= Structure
Si= Site
C= Canntributing
NC= Non-contributing
s
� S �
3
Q �
uioo� L,49r + A
0
-117A P.�j
swx � � ke i `
n + t w ?M 5, .✓�y.r7` r S S� .i�"7 "`Y` Xi^•p -U J =2w '��.,
-Kr. L .x
EGS 4` � a 1"�' yt$ " � e 4 +'t •p 2.'k .rN' •^i 'Yek-t+ .t� L : '` 1Z,SSS SY t� E 9 3''ee.T
-dc T^ a '' r (' • •�"a'"^'!" r 3<�' ..+ nt^` n": i `^ .
i 4- �F i£ 4. �u�S,+s�+���f3 i " b^7. '�' ti�k5" -4.• fj��i t:,�,�` � S e w .
u ea•S2% "'Y{SS'lw,j,'' "t at Fn� ,..,, '.
as `y2 L4 1 C. 5a„i� a •�'^. a4r Taa� C' nw 3"'o- "�`A R•9'..•s s p q -,E ? -�E'
a .:� r 4 R i-+Vea � � - � T M a tWf� t �Z F•�,}_xfy t'+'.�'•, r y .,.3�.
- }�iw :•?'v +G "[ .`.�� b,. E ..w y �+�++$:3-Vr• '�p�<� u, 1 �;
IF
F. sV
+ h�t.•111.d•f
-
Sa
6 !'
'} �_ �]'�•.u.. .. Ito F '
o"- Y
.. —""``fit"
• .st :iiiiii .. xr w��a�ea } . .:t •w. .� o
i t
Is+ yLR1ra RMa.ACp. i,
.r. * r+e''"',• _ t rye
•t .. -_ #" t1 Y V _'�: F. ••Vt1:. i--r^�\�!' a t!R»
+
•ww.. •,.t !R _ _ . a1�.^�Y6i.L0! 4triK.'Etwa,� �'gC`�tl!3'.A"•.�':.�'� +'ct1•.Xe'a+uttra'Eeien•' 'r
1 t
�. 1 �,✓t".
* • 77
t . !3 it `.. � ��?..
1� D_
ski M-A
..,���, `3 to 4 r -
ss�
' L
F i4 ' 4 ilii :. � ' ftli r
rt �*y.
ts-
xFt
�a -% +4 k'L i,t,•S">• S Il�� '" y g`� t� v * V .,• ' s Y
Tw t
F $ .px. •�. 1 3
• v 9 L f.K-,.. ar a 4 N S.1 � a �ay Y s 4+asCt d
m.
- o
r
h. '.0 ..=.. .... '.S
XVV
l t
r-
1 d
7pp
tj
v. .iii { •y{'Jk �{ r �.
rCc
y�
F :
5e'TYk�v� >`•i S*'� �'"�iP9-fi�iP-an•.r r a a nre :^. va.:i �`�^`f-`ly ^ Y _
-
>V
h =T 5M ..e
MR
,....ir+.fs—sap r'11tith '+ '_' ....'�,-k.°,�T x�Yb Acc ;mee• � G. p�+;L� <�Qht Sx
a
z ..
n. s s- f t � • i I I ��1 Y y�:.
t
a jvy'ffs _ '. I ,a•'t-(hty:t¢,: 4 :. � .. 'I . �.}�S�i4>'�,
' 11r
it h
h y
rE
0�...;•� e.�,,�e�' Y ":..ti"� 3 ::_4` r g `.1;'� .s" �a :c'`'� °s.p. f.::',� �; :.'�'.'` :�i�'-ww � .,,,. --.
!!....` `^�, r + - z•s yv sl a-. i f § a ` r 'r � K<n-- 7'v i- > ,
�s.i. a .. x� N` 4 > � ,�� t K .g�� rt i•e 'Ja.w.rria ' �r n L�}e�'�n`�'4-iri ' s, x' s
�: .:-"� f?"r..t "$C�.x, �'a 42 r � ^.'fiy r'" ; f r• �cr t e4+�- �' �.S n ,st` '
fr
r�
Wi
Fqt
Ft � }
} t ' Y
p 7*lt'
al
r _ 1
x',,. nrnrr
r
I V,
IL A
Im
5 is r' �9th ,sH,.�„A�>�-•,rlrRir���1, f .Y.t/ �i � t f � r, t v I
Vt!..
- .. .yea '.pifj _ F •^
1
r ' •L,
•.` 1j_�
1
• ! ,I( �+'.Tib f _ _ _
��• psi ff�/�
�S N
S
9
9
�J
I
1
a.
ly
1 ' yy f
;�, '��T�1
Ila '
i t
• { tui
1' 4,1u
I 5
I
}
i'
9
9
S
S
� S
s N �
8
S
V-
t P
j _J,j
bit
'ATM m
i mow. �� i � � #* /_.:•-.
I
�7i Irr: jt F .
I �
tb ��•�I .�� � .� f! �8J
Q y o ® - c. • I j .�
dP.
�a �a �■ �a >I�
_ � ���--�s.._�JI a n•�I...�. ••Ai
P _
3
:fi,
S �
� S
s
N
c��