SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION CORRESPONDENCE 2015 Sa:Corr7espondence
Commissio
1
iVERSAL®
UNV-12113
MADE IN USA
SUSTAINABLE MIN RECYCLEO
FORESTRY CONTENT 10%
-
INITIATIVE
camrae R,Saammg POSTCONSUMER®
w .sfarogmm.arg
SFI-011w
r
y
E
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
August 5, 2015
William Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125-3314
Re: Congress and Ward Apartments
Congress and Dow Apartments
Salem, MA
Dear Secretary Galvin:
The Salem Historical Commission would like to express its support for the North Shore
Community Development Coalition's request for Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation
Tax Credits to rehabilitate eight properties located in the Historic Point Neighborhood of
Salem.
The Point neighborhood of Salem contains the largest collection of early 20th century
multi-family residential structures in the city. This area was rebuilt after the Great Salem
Fire of 1914 under the direction of the Salem Rebuilding Commission, a city commission
established to ensure safe building practices and reform multi-family housing. Despite
some contemporary alterations, the Point's Colonial Revival brick apartment buildings
still retain their decorative brick corbelling and classical cast stone details and contribute
to the historic streetscape patterns unique to the Point. Restoration of the eight buildings
owned by the North Shore CDC on Congress, Ward, Palmer, Dow and Perkins Streets
will aid in the revitalization of this historic neighborhood and will maintain and improve
important affordable housing options for the community.
The Salem Historical Commission encourages the Massachusetts Historical Commission
to look favorably on the North Shore CDC's application for Massachusetts Historic
Rehabilitation Tax Credits.
Since
Jessica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
t
b
RECEIVED
AUG 0 3 2015
DEPT.OF PLANNING&
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
July 29, 2015
Kimberley Driscoll
Chair, Board of Trustees(and Mayor)
Salem Public Library
370 Essex Street
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Capt.John Bertram House(Salem Public Library),SALEM,MA MPPF#4052
Dear Mayor Driscoll:
As Chairman of the Massachusetts Historical Commission, I am pleased to inform you that the above-
mentioned project has been selected for a matching allocation of$60,000 from the Commission's Round
21: Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund(MPPF).
Due to the competitive nature of the program and limited funding,your award may differ from your
requested amount.Please note that the grant is subject to reauthorization of the capital accounts and the
availability of sufficient allocated funds. The Office of Administration and Finance must first allocate the
Commission's Round 21 Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund Grants. The Massachusetts Historical
Commission (MHC)will not be liable for any amount or loss caused by the non-reauthorization or non-
allocation of said funds.
If said funds are reauthorized and allocated,the Commission will provide 50:50 matching funds for
repair and replacement the deteriorated brownstone trim and repointing of the brick masonry.
The project as scoped involves a quantity of masonry repointing.A formal historic mortar analysis may
be required in order to accurately match the original mortar.
This allocation is contingent upon the successful execution of the following steps,all of which must be
completed before construction or pre-development work can begin:
1. Consultation with MHC Grants Division and Technical Staff to complete the full plans and
specifications for project work items or to develop the pre-development Request For Proposals
(RFPs). Please note that the MHC may require changes from the scope of work or budget as
presented in your application in order to meet the program guidelines and funding allocation.
Please note that September 30,2015 is the deadline for final approved construction documents or
final approval for pre-development RFPs.
220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125
(617) 727-8470 • Fax: (617)•727-5128
www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc
2. Execution of a grant contract with the Massachusetts Historical Commission is a program
requirement.It will define the grant-assisted project under applicable laws and regulations and
include either plans and specifications or an RFP,a budget, and timetable for the full scope of
eligible and approved work items.
3. The grants staff will convene a workshop for Local Project Coordinators(LPCs)and other
project participants on Wednesday,August 12,2015 from 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM in the MHC
offices at the Massachusetts Archives Building in Boston. LPC attendance at this scheduled
workshop is a requirement of the proeram.We also encourage the attendance of other project
team members, such as architects,preservation consultants, or engineers.Please contact the
MHC grants staff to confirm that you will be attending.Also,please come to this meeting
prepared to schedule preliminary site visits with assigned MHC grants staff to finalize a mutually
agreeable scope of work for your MPPF project.These site visits should preferably be scheduled
prior to the end of July and will require the attendance of your architect/engineer for all
development projects.
Please respond in writing to Brona Simon,Executive Director and State Historic Preservation Officer,
MHC,by August 12,2015 with your intention to accept the grant allocation and meet with appropriate
MHC personnel.
A Local Project Coordinators' Manual will be distributed at the meeting. Directions to the Archives
Building can be found on the MHC website at: htti)://www.see.state.ma.us/mhc/mhcloc/mhcloc.htm.
The Commission looks forward to working with you toward the successful completion of your project.
We sincerely hope that this grant allocation will help you to achieve your preservation goals.
Sincerely,
William Francis Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman,Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Salem Historical Commission
Nancy Tracy,Director, LPC
M
1
r 4 1
FE= _
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
July 29, 2015
Kara McLaughlin
Executive Director
House of Seven Gables Settlement Association
115 Derby Street
Salem, MA 01970
RE: House of Seven Gables, SALEM,MA,MPPF 94054
Dear Ms.McLaughlin:
As Chairman of the Massachusetts Historical Commission,I am pleased to inform you that the above-
mentioned project has been selected.for a matching allocation of$45,500 from the Commission's Round
21: Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund(MPPF).
Due to the competitive nature of the program and limited funding,your award may differ from your
requested amount. Please note that the grant is subject to reauthorization of the capital accounts and the
availability of sufficient allocated funds. The Office of Administration and Finance must first allocate the
Commission's Round 21 Massachusetts Preservation Project Fund Grants.The Massachusetts Historical
Commission(MHC)will not be liable for any amount or loss caused by the non-reauthorization or non-
allocation of said funds.
If said funds are reauthorized and allocated,the Commission will provide 50:50 matching funds for the
reinforcement of the summer beam and floor joists above the Dining Room allowing public access to the
Dining Room Chamber on the second floor.'
This allocation is contingent upon the successful execution of the following steps,all of which must be
completed before construction or pre-development work can begin:
1. Consultation with MHC Grants Division and Technical Staff to complete the full plans and
specifications for project work items or to develop the pre-development Request For Proposals
(RFPs). Please note that the MHC may require changes from the scope of work or budget as
presented in your application in order to meet the program guidelines and funding allocation.
Please note that September 30,2015 is the deadline for final approved construction documents or
final approval for pre-development RFPs.
2. Execution of a grant contract with the Massachusetts Historical Commission is a program
requirement. It will define the grant-assisted project under applicable laws and regulations and
220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125
(617) 727-8470 • Fax: (6 17) 727-5128
www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc
include either plans and specifications or an RFP, a budget,and timetable for the full scope of
eligible and approved work items.
3. The grants staff will convene a workshop for Local Project Coordinators(LPCs)and other
project participants on Wednesday,August 12,2015 from 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM in the MHC
offices at the Massachusetts Archives Building in Boston.LPC attendance at this scheduled
workshop is a requirement of the urogram.We also encourage the attendance of other project
team members, such as architects,preservation consultants, or engineers.Please contact the
MHC grants staff to confirm that you will be attending.Also,please come to this meeting
prepared to schedule preliminary site visits with assigned MHC grants staff to finalize a mutually
agreeable scope of work for your MPPF project.These site visits should preferably be scheduled
prior to the end of July and will require the attendance of your architect/engineer for all
development projects.
Please respond in writing to Brona Simon,Executive Director and State Historic Preservation Officer,
MHC,by August 12,2015 with your intention to accept the grant allocation and meet with appropriate
MHC personnel.
A Local Project Coordinators' Manual will be distributed at the meeting.Directions to the Archives
Building can be found on the MHC website at: http://www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc/mhcloc/mhcloc.htm.
The Commission looks forward to working with you toward the successful completion of your project.
We sincerely hope that this grant allocation will help you to achieve your preservation goals.
Sincerely,
L
Welham Francis Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealt
Chairman,Massachusetts Historical Commission
cc: Salem Historical Commission
DECEIVE®
AUG 112015
nEPT.OF PL4NNWO R
`
August 12,2015 The Commonwealth of Massachusetts COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
SusanArena William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth
Architectural Historian Massachusetts Historical Commission
EBI Consulting
21 B Street
Burlington,MA 01803
RE: Telecommunications Installation on Eastern Bank
217-221 Essex Street, Salem,MA;MHC#RC.23937
EBI Project Number: 61144726
Dear Ms.Arena:
The Massachusetts Historical Commission(MHC)has reviewed the information you submitted,received July 13,
2015,and comments from the Salem Historical Commission, Salem Design Review Board,and the Salem
Redevelopment Authority concerning the revised proposed project referenced above. The subject property at 217-
221 Essex Street,historically known as the Hoyt Block,is located within the Downtown Salem Historic District and
is listed in the National and State Registers of Historic Places. After a review of the information submitted,MHC
staff have the following comments.
The revised proposed Verizon project consisting of the installation of four tall exposed antennas with vertical and
diagonal bracing at the southwest corner of the subject property rooftop,two antennas to the penthouse,and other
associated equipment is described in the informational packet that was submitted to this office,received July 13,
2015.
At this time,the MHC is concerned that the height,location,and diagonal bracing of the antennas proposed for the
southwest comer of the subject property will be visually obtrusive from at least one major thoroughfare within
Salem and will alter the character of the building. The MHC requests that the project proponent explore the
feasibility of locating the antennas proposed for the southwest comer of the subject property rooftop to another
location on the rooftop or to enclose to antennas within a stealth chimney enclosure. Relocating a portion of these
four antennas and placing the remaining antennas within stealth flue pipes and/or a smaller stealth chimney may also
provide an effective alternative that would preserve more of the historic architectural characteristics of the rooftop.
Please submit a copy of the above requested information to Jessica Herbert,Chairperson, Salem Historical
Commission, Salem Historical Commission, 120 Washington Street,Salem,MA 01970. The MHC looks forward
to receiving and reviewing the comments of the Salem Historical Commission.
These comments are offered to assist in compliance with Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act of
1966,as amended(36 CFR 800),and M.G.L.Chapter 9,Section 26-27C,as amended by Chapter 254 of the Acts of
1988(950 CMR 71.00). Please do not hesitate to contact meat this office if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
Ryan T.Maciej
Preservation Planner
Massachusetts Historical Commission
xc: Salem Historical Commission
Jane Guy,City of Salem
220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125
— (M-7) 727 84 0 Fax:—(617)-727�5 128 — — ---
ww%v.sec.state.ma.us/mhc
,00 1
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
August 20, 2015
William F. Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman, Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
RE: Rev. John J. Gray House/Saint James Rectory, 161 Federal St., Salem
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits
Dear Secretary Galvin:
I am writing to you to express my support for 161 Federal Street, LLC's application for
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for the Rev. John J. Gray House/ Saint James
Rectory project in Salem.
Constructed in 1889,the Saint James Rectory was designed for and owned by Reverend John J.
Gray, pastor of Saint James Church located across the street. Until recently the building had
continuously served as the rectory for the Church since its construction. The building is an intact
Italianate style residence with Eastlake inspired details including decorative window caps and
paneled lintels.
161 Federal Street, LLC's project will involve converting the building to a new residential use.
As proposed new residential rental units will be created within the building while preserving the
key interior architectural details and retaining all exterior architectural elements, including
removal of several modern alterations and restoring those areas to the original historic detail.
The building is located within the McIntire Historic District, a local historic district subject to
design review and approval by the Salem Historical Commission. The project has received
approval from the Commission for its exterior design.
I encourage you to look favorably upon the application for state historic tax credits for this
important project.
Sincerely,
J� `C, � 7
Jessica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
Federal Communications Commission RECEIVED
W _ Washington, DC 20554 V
s AUG 2;4 M5
°pMMiss o�
Informational Notice of Section 106 Filings DEPT.,OF PLANNWO i
15ate:D8i1P��
Reference Number: 876606
Jane A Guy,Assistant Community Development Director
Salem Historical Commission
Salem City Hall
One Salem Green
Salem,MA 01970
The following new Section 106 filing has been submitted:
FILE NUMBER: 0006914763
TCNS Number: 129183
Purpose: Collocation Submission Packet
Notification Date: 7AM EST 08/17/2015
Applicant: T-Mobile USA
Consultant: EnviroBusiness,Inc.d/b/a EBI Consulting(EBI#6115003890)
Positive Train Control Filing Subject to Expedited Treatment Under Program Comment: No
Site Name: Salem Housing Authority/4BSM002A
Site Address: 27 Charter Street
Detailed Description of Project:EBI 6115003890;
Collocate wireless telecommunications antennas on an existing building with no proposed ground disturbance.
Site Coordinates: 42-31-16.1 N, 070-53-27.7 W
City: Salem
County: ESSEX
State:MA
Lead SHPO/THPO: Massachusetts Historical Commission(Deputy SHPO)
Consultant Contact Information:
Name: Sarah L Graulty
Title: Architectural Historian
PO Box:
Address: 21 B Street -- -
City: Burlington
State: MA
Zip: 01803
Phone: (207)210-2535
Fax:
Email: sfarley@ebiconsulting.com
NOTICE OF FRAUDULENT USE OF SYSTEM, ABUSE OF PASSWORD AND RELATED MISUSE
Use of the Section 106 system is intended to facilitate consultation under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act and
may contain information that is confidential,privileged or otherwise protected from disclosure under applicable laws.Any person
having access to Section 106 information shall use it only for its intended purpose.Appropriate action will be taken with respect to
any misuse of the system.
Page 1 of 1 FCC 813
April 2014
9 l E`mss* '.�...d ht"J D
JUL 13 2015
DEPT. OF PLANNING&
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
July 8,2015
Gerald L.McCarthy
North Shore Heritage Associates,Inc.
64 Holten Street
Danvers,MA 01923
RE: North Shore Heritage, 184 Lafayette Street,Salem,MA;MHC#RC. 53087
Dear Mr.McCarthy,
Thank you for the additional information submitted regarding the above referenced projects, received at this office on July 1
and July 2, 2015. The staff of the Massachusetts Historical Commission (MHC) has reviewed the information submitted and
has the following comments.
The projects consist of refinancing existing bonds for the property at 184 Lafayette Street in Salem using funding from the
Massachusetts Development Finance Agency (MDFA). The information indicates that the project will also include the
addition of a fire escape and chimney cap,and repair work to the balcony and masonry.
It is the opinion of MHC staff that the property at 184 Lafayette Street in Salem(SAL.2160)may meet the criteria of eligibility
for listing in the State and National Registers of Historic Places.
The MHC understands that the project is in the early phases of development and that architectural plans are not yet available.
Review of MHC's files and the information submitted indicates that the proposed project will have "no adverse effect" (950
CMR 71.07(2)(b)(2)) on the property at 184 Lafayette Street in Salem (SAL.2160), provided that the following condition is
met: plans and specifications for the proposed rehabilitation be submitted to the MHC for review and comment when they
become available.
These comments are offered to assist in compliance with Massachusetts General Law Chapter 9, section 26-27C (950 CMR
71). If you have any questions,please contact Linda Santoro at this office.
Sincerely,
Brona Simon
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
xc: Steve Chilton,MDFA
Salem Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard, Boston, Massachusetts 02125
(617) 727-8470 • Fax: (617) 727-5128
www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc
0
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 ,
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
August 20,2015
William F.Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman, Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston,MA 02125
RE: Rev.John J. Gray House/Saint James Rectory, 161 Federal St.,Salem
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits
Dear Secretary Galvin:
I am writing to you to express my support for 161 Federal Street, LLC's application for
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for the Rev. John J. Gray House/ Saint James
Rectory project in Salem.
Constructed in 1889, the Saint James Rectory was designed for and owned by Reverend John J.
Gray, pastor of Saint James Church located across the street. Until recently the building had
continuously served as the rectory for the Church since its construction. The building is an intact
Italianate style residence with Eastlake inspired details including decorative window caps and
paneled lintels.
161 Federal Street,LLC's project will involve converting the building to a new residential use.
As proposed new residential rental units will be created within the building while preserving the
key interior architectural details and retaining all exterior architectural elements, including _
removal of several modern alterations and restoring those areas to the original historic detail.
The building is located within the McIntire Historic District, a local historic district subject to
design review and approval by the Salem Historical Commission. The project is currently before
the Commission for initial exterior design review,with the fust round of approvals completed.
I encourage you to look favorably upon the application for state historic tax credits for this
important project.
Sincerely,
Jessica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
co
��rn�rt
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
October 21, 2015
Community Preservation Committee
120 Washington Square
P Floor
Salem,MA 01970
Members of the Community Preservation Committee:
Thank you for the opportunity to provide input into the FY16 Community Preservation Plan annual
update.
The Commission is thrilled to see that many of the projects awarded fiscal year 2015 Community
Preservation Act funds were historic resource projects. Salem's rich history and significant number of
historic resources provides the foundation for an enriching quality of life for its residents, as well as the
basis for a strong tourist industry. Consequently, we feel it is important for historic preservation to
continue to be a strong focus of the CPC.
As such, we also strongly support the on-going use of CPA funds for private entities whose proposed
projects meet the review criteria. The City of Salem is fortunate to have an impressive stock of
historically significant buildings,many of which are maintained by private and non-profit groups. There
is precedent in other CPA communities, such as Quincy,Newburyport, Gloucester,and Plymouth, to
allow the use of funds for buildings not owned and maintained by the municipality. Given the high cost to
maintain historic buildings and the important role that these buildings have in the identity and economy of
Salem,we feel it is important that they continue to be considered eligible projects.
We look forward to seeing the completion of the current CPA projects and the preservation of many more
important historic resources to come.
Sincerely,
,>
Jessica Herbert �'�
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
Enclosure
David M. Hart Enterprises
104 Federal Street Salem,Massachusetts 01970 978.745-2172
davidatsalem@comcast.net Fax 978.740.0085
October 22,2015
Natalie Lovett
Planning Department
City of Salem,MA 01970
Subject: CPA/CPC awards
Natalie:
I recently did a little research concerning the awarding of CPA/CPC funds in cities that are
somewhat similar to Salem in Massachusetts. I used the Community Preservation Coalition's
database available on their web site. I first spoke with Katherine Roth,Associate Director.
She indicated that indeed,the act had been established to award funds to private non-profit
entities as well as public agencies.
The statistics on the accompanying chart were derived from their database that is available
on their web site. I researched awards for historic preservation for only the year 2014. The
data indicates quite a few cities award a substantial persentage of projects to private non-
profit entities.
I also included Federal and State agencies that award Tax Credits and Grants to private
non-profit entities.
Sincerely,
David M.Hart,AIA,Principal
cc
Architecture, Planning, Historic Preservation
M/Galaxy 3738
Agency Program Award to private
non-profits?
National Park Federal Tax Credit Yes
Service Program
Commonwealth of State Tax Credit Yes
MA Program
Commonwealth of Grants in Aid Yes
MA (Massachusetts
Historical
Commission)
Commonwealth of CPA/CPC
MA
CPC Awarding Total Number of Number of
agencies by city, Awards,Year Awards to private
selected as 2014, Historic non-profits, Year
similar to Salem Preservation 2014, Historic
Preservation
Quincy, MA CPA CPC 50 25
Newburyport, MA CPA CPC 50 24
Gloucester, MA CPA CPC 27 21
Plymouth, MA CPA CPC 16 13
Provincetown, MA CPA CPC 23 4
Salem, MA CPA CPC 5 0
CPA/CPC information taken .from Community Preservation Coalition' s web site
database. (Note: The database is being updated and is not available until
10/26/2015).
Community Preservation Coalition
10 Milk Street, Suite 810
Boston,MA 021.08
Phone: (617) 367-8998
Katherine Roth, Associate Director
DMH 10/22/2105
. o
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
December 14, 2015
William Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125-3314
Re: Congress and Ward Apartments
Congress and Dow Apartments
Salem, MA
Dear Secretary Galvin:
On Behalf of the Salem Historical Commission, I would like to express our continued support for
the North Shore Community Development Coalition's request for Massachusetts Historic
Rehabilitation Tax Credits to rehabilitate eight properties located in the Historic Point
Neighborhood of Salem.
The Point neighborhood of Salem contains the largest collection of early 20`h century multi-
family residential structures in the city. This area was rebuilt after the Great Salem Fire of 1914
under the direction of the Salem Rebuilding Commission, a city commission established to
ensure safe building practices and reform multi-family housing. Despite some contemporary
alterations, the Point's Colonial Revival brick apartment buildings still retain their decorative
brick corbelling and classical cast stone details and contribute to the historic streetscape patterns
unique to the Point. Restoration of the eight buildings owned by the North Shore CDC on
Congress, Ward, Palmer, Dow and Perkins Streets will aid in the revitalization of the historic
Point neighborhood and will maintain and improve important affordable housing options for the
community.
The Salem Historical Commission encourages the Massachusetts Historical Commission to look
favorably on the North Shore CDC's application for Massachussetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax
Credits.
C el
t.s6ica Herbert, Ch it
Salem Historical C mission
s
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 1, 2015
Helen Sides, Chair
Community Preservation Committee
City of Salem
120 Washington Street, 3rd Floor
Salem, MA 01970
RE: CPA funding—Charter St. Burial Ground
Dear Ms. Sides:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing to support the City of Salem's application for
Community Preservation Act funding for the Charter Street Burial Ground Preservation and
Improvement project.
Located on Charter Street in the heart of Charter Street National Historic District, the 1.47 acre
green space is the City's oldest burial ground. Charter Street Burial Ground is also a highly
visible, well documented site that is visited by tens of thousands of tourists per year. The
integrity of the headstones are increasingly threatened by freeze/thaw damage, deterioration of
marble and limestone due to acid rain, and compaction of pathways and new cut-through
pathways created by visitors. More urgently, vandalism is a significant and direct threat to the
preservation and protection of the historically significant headstones and tombs. One of the most
effective ways to deter vandalism is to maintain and enhance conditions of the burial ground.
Through this project, the integrity of the headstones, tombs, and pathways will be preserved,
restored and significantly improved to protect this National Historic Site.
Charter Street Cemetery has an extraordinary array of headstones and tombs from the 17th, 18th
and 19th centuries and is an important connection to local, regional and nationally significant
citizens including Nathaniel Mather, Chief Justice Benjamin Lynde, Governor Simon Bradstreet,
Samuel McIntire, and Nathaniel Bowditch. Headstones and tombs of early settlers are also
located here, including the marker of Captain Richard More (d. 1696 or 1698) whose gravestone
is the only one of a Mayflower passenger known to exist. In addition, headstones and tombs are
examples of exceptional pieces of artistry from well- known carvers of the time. Gravestones
here often show unique carvings of winged skulls, winged faces, urns and willows completed by
the Lamson family or the Old Stone Cutter of Boston.
Page 2
April 1, 2015
In 2002, the Massachusetts Historical Commission and the City supported a "Burial Ground
Planning Project" a plan and extensive site assessment to preserve and protect the City's oldest
burial grounds. From 1993-2002, the City has made a commitment to support the conservation of
83 of the 200 + headstones and tombs. With the support of the Community Preservation
Committee we hope to continue to "retain the burying grounds' historical integrity while at the
same time maintaining their accessibility" to work toward the goals of the Burial Ground
Planning Project of 2002. Support from the Community Preservation Committee funds will be
necessary to complete the project. While the City has been able to allocate funding to the
restoration over time, there are still significant preservation and improvement needs.
We encourage Community Preservation Committee to look favorably upon this funding request.
Thank you for your consideration.
Since Y,
i
r
essica Herbert
Chair
g0 T
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 1, 2015
Helen Sides, Chair
Community Preservation Committee
City of Salem
120 Washington Street, 3rd Floor
Salem, MA 01970
RE: CPA Funding - Salem Common Fence
Dear Ms. Sides:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing to support the City of Salem's application for
Community Preservation Act funding for the Salem Common Fence Restoration project.
The 19`h century Common fence, is a rare civic example of cast iron fencing. Not only does the
fence define and protect the Common, but its simple, graceful and uniform lines serve as a
transition from the open green space of the Common to the blocks of Federalist and Greek
Revival homes beyond. The Salem Common itself is abounding with history; it is located within
both a local and National Register district and was the site of the first muster of the East
Regiment, Massachusetts Militia, which marked the beginning of the National Guard of the
United States.
In past years, the City has made a commitment to restoring the Salem Common fence to its
original condition. With assistance from the CPC and grants from the Massachusetts Historical
Commission, the City has completed both an existing conditions survey of the fence, as well as a
two phases of restoration. Ongoing support from the CPC will be integral to completing this
multi-year project.
We encourage Community Preservation Committee to look favorably upon this funding request.
Thank you for your consideration.
Since
Jessica Herbert
Chair
. o
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
March 19, 2015
Helen Sides, Chair
Community Preservation Committee
120 Washington Street
Salem, MA 01970
Re: Application for CPA Funds: Conservation and Restoration of Historic Artwork
Dear Ms. Sides:
The Salem Historical Commission is in support of the City of Salem's application for
Community Preservation Act funds for the conservation and restoration of three portraits
and frames residing in the City Hall Council Chambers. As part of the City of Salem's art
inventory, the portraits serve as an important reminder of the men who have played a
significant role in Salem's history and of the artists who painted them. It is therefore
important that these works of art receive proper care and maintenance.
Of special note is the portrait of John King painted by Salem's own Frank Benson, one of
America's foremost American Impressionist painters. He began his career painting
portraits of distinguished families and murals for the Library of Congress. He enjoyed a
distinguished career as an instructor and department head at the School of the Museum of
Fine Arts, Boston and was a founding member of the Ten American Painters,American
Academy of Arts and Letters and The Guild of Boston Artists.
Art brings beauty and a sense of enjoyment and pleasure into our world, makes our world a
better place and has the ability to transport us to a different time and place. The portraits
allow us to gain historical perspective and understanding- creating an important link to
our past and allowing us to appreciate different periods in history and their impact and
significance in our world. To conserve and restore these works of art to their original
brilliance ensures that future generations will have access to this collection
Please help preserve these important works of art by approving the City of Salem's request
for funding. I thank you for your consideration.
Sin ly, f�
esslca Herbert
Chair
;CO T
1 d
�^ur�
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
May 21, 2015
William F. Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman, Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
RE: Rev.John J. Gray House/Saint James Rectory, 161 Federal St., Salem
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits
Dear Secretary Galvin:
I am writing to you to express my support for 161 Federal Street,LLC's application for
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for the Rev. John J. Gray House/ Saint James
Rectory project in Salem.
Constructed in 1889, the Saint James Rectory was designed for and owned by Reverend John J.
Gray, pastor of Saint James Church located across the street. Until recently the building had
continuously served as the rectory for the Church since its construction. The building is an intact
Italianate style residence with Eastlake inspired details including decorative window caps and
paneled lintels.
161 Federal Street, LLC's project will involve converting the building to a new residential use.
As proposed new residential rental units will be created within the building while preserving the
key interior architectural details and retaining all exterior architectural elements, including
removal of several modern alterations and restoring those areas to the original historic detail.
The building is located within the McIntire Historic District,a local historic district subject to
design review and approval by the Salem Historical Commission. The project is currently before
the Commission for initial exterior design review, with the first round of approvals completed.
I encourage you to look favorably upon the application for state historic tax credits for this
important project.
Sincerely,
ssica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
�0 T
Salem Histot ical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(979)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404 -
May 6, 2015
Brona Simon
Executive Director& State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, Massachusetts 02125
RE: MPPF Application—The House of the Seven Gables—Restoration of second floor spaces
Dear Ms. Simon:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing to support the application for a Round 21 Massachusetts
Preservation Projects Fund (MPPF) grant for restoration of the second floor spaces of the Turner
Ingersoll Mansion (a.k.a. The House of the Seven Gables). First built in 1668, The House of the Seven
Gables has been open to the public for educational and historic tours for over 100 years. Visited by over
90,000 people a year, this non-profit institution supports its social contributions to the immigrant
community with the proceeds from tours of the mansion, which was restored in 1910 by founder
Caroline O. Emmerton and architect Joseph Chandler. The House of Seven Gables Campus is a
National Historic Landmark District that includes three first period houses, as well as the birthplace of
Nathaniel Hawthorne. It is a major contributor to Salem's cultural heritage.
The House of the Seven Gables Settlement Association is planning a restoration of second floor spaces
within the original mansion structure. This proposed project seeks to combine needed structural re-
enforcement, removal of early 208i partitions and preservation/restoration of early room treatments and
finishes to increase available interpretive space, as well as public access. The restoration of these spaces
to an earlier configuration will open up the entire second floor of the original structure to the public for
the first time and enable the institution to share a more complete interpretation of this venerable mansion
and the lives of its inhabitants.
The Salem Historical Commission finds that this project is consistent with applicable goals and
standards surrounding the preservation of our regions architectural heritage. The Salem Historical
Commission enthusiastically supports this project as a valid contribution to local historical preservation.
We encourage Massachusetts Historical Commission to look favorable upon this funding request. Thank
you for your consideration.
Sinc y,
Jessca a e1Y rt
Chair
The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
William Francis Galvin, Secretary of the Commonwealth H
Massachusetts Historical Commission . ,.
APR 2 3 2015
DEPT. DE P.„4MN!ING
COMMUNItY Gc.rF=I-YPPotEM
April 21, 2015
Jessica Herbert
Chair
Salem Historical Commission .
120 Washington Street
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Preservation Award Nomination of James Treadwell
Dear Ms. Herbert:
Thank you for nominating James Treadwell for a 2015 Preservation Award. The
Massachusetts Historical Commission received many exceptional nominations this year,
making the selection process particularly competitive and difficult. We regret to inform
you that the Commission did not select James Treadwell to receive an award this year.
We appreciate and thank you for your support of historic preservation in Massachusetts.
The well-preserved historic fabric of our Commonwealth significantly enhances the high
quality of life we enjoy here.
Once again, thank you for submitting this nomination.
Sincerely,
Brona Simon
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard,Boston; Massachusetts 02125
(617) 727-8470 • Fax: (617)727-5128
www.sec.state.ma.us/mhc
0
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 27, 2015
William Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125-3314
Re: Congress and Ward Apartments
Congress and Dow Apartments
Salem, MA
Dear Secretary Galvin:
On Behalf of the Salem Historical Commission, I would like to express our continued support for
the North Shore Community Development Coalition's request for Massachusetts Historic
Rehabilitation Tax Credits to rehabilitate eight properties located in the Historic Point
Neighborhood of Salem.
The Point neighborhood of Salem contains the largest collection of early 20`h century multi-
family residential structures in the city. This area was rebuilt after the Great Salem Fire of 1914
under the direction of the Salem Rebuilding Commission, a city commission established to
ensure safe building practices and reform multi-family housing. Despite some contemporary
alterations, the Point's Colonial Revival brick apartment buildings still retain their decorative
brick corbelling and classical cast stone details and contribute to the historic streetscape patterns
unique to the Point. Restoration of the eight buildings owned by the North Shore CDC on
Congress, Ward, Palmer, Dow and Perkins Streets will aid in the revitalization of the historic
Point neighborhood and will maintain and improve important affordable housing options for the
community.
The Salem Historical Commission encourages the Massachusetts Historical Commission to look
favorably on the North Shore CDC's application for Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax
Credits.
Sincer y,
Je 'ca Herbert, Chair
Salem Historical Commission
Jane Guy
From: Jane Guy
Sent: Thursday, April 16, 2015 8:54 AM
To: Andrew Shapiro
Subject: 109 Lafayette St.
Please be advised that the Salem Historical Commission reviewed the submission for the storefront improvement
project at 109 Lafayette Street (Witch Dr.)and did not have any comments.
Jane A. Guy
Assistant Community Development Director
City of Salem
Department of Planning & Community Development
120 Washington St., 3rd Floor
Salem, MA 01970
978-619-5685
(F) 978-740-0404
0quV(a)salem.com
www.salem.com
1
CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS
A
DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL
MAYOR
120 WASHINGTON STREET ♦ SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970
LYNN GOONIN DUNCAN,AICP TELE:978-619-5685 ♦ FAX:978-740-0404
DIRECTOR
April 7, 2015
Ms. Jessica Herbert, Chair
Salem Historical Commission
c/o Dept. of Planning & Community Development
120 Washington Street
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Storefront Improvement Project: Fagade Renovation and Signs at 109 Lafayette Street
Dear Ms. Herbert,
I am writing to request comment from the Salem Historical regarding a fagade renovation for a
commercial business, which is being assisted with US Department of Housing and Urban
Development's Community Development Block Grant funds, through the City of Salem's
Storefront Improvement Program. The business, "Witch Dr.", is located at 109 Lafayette Street,
which is within the Point Neighborhood National Register District. As a requirement of federal
funding, the City is seeking Salem Historical Commission comment on the project.
The business owner plans to change the appearance of his storefront from an enclosed and shingled
fagade,to an open retail window system. The applicant will also install new backlit signage on
both elevations of his storefront, which will resemble his store's brand/logo. Materials to be used
include aluminum framing around the windows, clear glass, and polished granite for the base—all
will match existing storefront systems. Signage will have an aluminum face, backlit with LED
lights.
Enclosed are drawings for the new storefront denoting dimensions and materials. Also included
are drawings and photos of existing conditions.
I respectfully request that the Commission provide any comment within 30 days. Thank you for
your time and consideration.
Sincerel
i
Andrew-Slla ' o
Economic Development Planner
Enclosures
Jane Guy
From: Andrew Shapiro
Sent: Wednesday, April 15, 2015 3:27 PM
To: Jane Guy
Subject: For Tonight's HisCom Meeting
Hi Jane-
Thanks again for your help covering the Witch Dr. item before the Historical Commission this evening. I spoke with the
store owner and he told me that he will be there,so that should help if any feedback is given or if adjustments are
requested.
Here are the primary factors that I think the Commission should keep in mind and would help if you conveyed:
1.The new storefront windows (with grey aluminum millions)and granite base will match three existing storefronts in
.the same building (to the left of the Witch Dr.).
2.All proposed signage complies with the city's sign ordinance and the backlit style of sign will not have light shining
through the sign. Backlit signage is an acceptable form of signage per the City's Commercial Design Guidelines.
If you have any questions before the meeting, feel free to shoot me an email or call me on my cell: 240-643-3683.
Thanks,
Andrew
Sent from my Phone
1
Examples of Back-Lit Signage
The applicant proposes for new signage to be back-lit / halo-lit, which will entail
having opaque black typeface with LED lighting behind the sign. No light will be
seen shining through the sign, only behind and around the sign. Below are a
three examples, including one found in Salem (the Village Tavern on Essex Street).
The lighting will be white, while the typeface will be black.
The City of Salem's Commercial Design Guidelines recommends this form of
lighting as one acceptable lighting solution, as shown on the following page.
!, e
• t �5 Pi 4 e
PS 1
�yu., wi*.
]'All r 1 '. itam i
[2 d
gl
llo Irl
Existing Store aa,` Existing Store Witch Dr. Store .:
e-i�a mcicl � -
lll M'a•. X#v�i. Iw""a f:. 9'$�
a W
IZL
�9MdM.
Proposed Floor Plan Scheme - 4
109 Lafayette Si.Salem MA
Gienapp Design
Witch Dr.
Associates,LLC
395.34 Architects
, w Perspectives of the retail establishments
next to Witch Dr., which is situated on the
corner of Lafayette and Ward Street.
Note the window system storefronts of
the other retail shops vs. Witch Dr.'s
closed-in shingled storefront .
-I-L
S
-. .
2 Elevation
1 109 Existin Floor Level r-s^ 1s'-n•
Existing Floor Plan and Elevation
109 Lafayette St.Salem,MA
Gienapp Design
Witch Dr. Associates,LLC
39534 Architects
• - DesignScheme - 4a 109 Lafayette St Salem,MA
DesignGionapp
yy REVERSE UT CHANNEL LETTERS
w xax Ili. Pv,unaM _
� 1 -10 mwsumrva t
is
k,s.
L:-',
- EW-A
i 1',r85A.k FROMT VIEW
s•-g•• s'-e•• I, Side Elevation
4 Floor Plane 5
0.
114
Limitof New Work
Existing coping to remain SioE ViEw
9•_11••
Existing brick to remain
_ L t
_ J
L
New ingrtalada,custom _
-- - -
lettering with LED lighting
behi
- a ntl(see image above)
Existing Soffit, F210 to remain
Pz
Newaluminum frame antlto mtch clear glass shorefrontto matohexistiem neighboringstorebpnt systems
Z.-10••
- - _ FxistinB bock to remain
f
Existing pier to remain
;Zworm 7r-7
New polished granitesi lbs
_ to match existing bases at
neighboring storefronts
1 Section-Ent Elevation 2 Section-Left Side n Section-Right Side
1/4..=1-1)"
Exterior Elevation- Main Facade
109 Lafayette St.Salem,MA
Gienapp Design
VYtch Dr. Associates,LLC
395.34 Architects
y ,L
I I
Street View of Witch Dr Store
109 Lafayette St.Salem,MA -
Witch Dr. Febmary 26,2015 - Gienapp Design
Associates,LLC
395.34 Architects
1 w • t
ib e •.!a Er ai eb'y a&31 a imea �. • y�#p
-!?I« �Z<X4 sit 1) a! ■ Aa r i • � �( S::I(
._ _ ■e* �a gni=x# yo #.l�+.t - � _... G� .
z,
. 0
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 15, 2015
Brona Simon
Executive Director & State Historic Preservation Officer
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, Massachusetts 02125
RE: MPPF Application —City of Salem— Dickson Memorial Chapel at Greenlawn Cemetery
Dear Ms. Simon:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing to support the City of Salem's application for Round 21
Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund (MPPF) grant for the restoration and preservation of
Dickson Memorial Chapel. The Chapel is located within Greenlawn Cemetery and is the City's only
High Victorian Gothic work of architecture and retains much of the original Gothic details.
Constructed in 1892, the Chapel and its original elaborate conservatory, was gifted to the City of
Salem, from resident Walter Scott Dickson in memory of his wife, Georgianna. The generosity of
Mr. Dickson also was responsible for many other improvements to the cemetery in the late 191h
century including the Dickson Bridge over the Fountain Pond and the Dickson Steps. Recently,
Greenlawn Cemetery was added to the National Register of Historic Places.
The goal of this project is to stop water and weather infiltration and to restore some of the
building's deteriorated historical fabric in order to ensure its protection and continued use for
memorial services for years to come. Specifically, funding from MPPF would be used to repair and
restore the exterior and interior masonry, install window glazing panels to protect the stained glass
windows, improve downspouts and other structural improvements.
We encourage Massachusetts Historical Commission to look favorable upon this funding request.
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerel ,
Jes a Herbert
Chair
. oxo
n
�nnv8 f
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 15, 2015
William F. Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman,Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
RE: Lynn & Boston Electric Railroad Company Car Barn,3 Webster St., Salem
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits
Dear Secretary Galvin:
I am writing to you to express the support of the Salem Historical Commission for Renewal
Ventures LLC's application for Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for the
redevelopment of the Lynn &Boston Electric Railroad Company Car Barn project in Salem.
Constructed in 1887 by the Lynn & Boston Electric Railroad Company, the Car Barn is a unique
example of the industrial architecture built in Salem during the late 19`x' century. Located within
the primarily residential Salem Common neighborhood, the red brick industrialbuilding has been
underutilized and in a state of continued deterioration for the past several decades.
Renewal Ventures' project will involve converting the Car Barn into six dynamic residential units
while preserving the building's unique industrial character. The project will include the
installation of historically appropriate and energy efficient windows and repairs to the
deteriorated masonry exterior, including reintroducing large wood doors to the original trolley car
bays. Once completed the building will be a positive contribution to the Salem Common
residential neighborhood and the greater Salem community.
We urge the Massachusetts Historical Commission to continue its support of this work by looking
favorable upon this application.
Since y
Jessica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSIONr
eONO1T f
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET,SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 15, 2015
William F. Galvin
Secretary of the Commonwealth
Chairman, Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston,MA 02125
RE: Joshua Ward House, 148 Washington St., Salem
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits
Dear Secretary Galvin:
I am writing to you to express the Commission's support for ZXE,LLC's application for
Massachusetts Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credits for the restoration of the Joshua Ward House
project in Salem.
The three-story, building is an example of an early brick Federal-style house in Salem. Built
between 1784-1787,the house is closely associated with notable architect Samuel McIntire. The
interior of the building maintains much of the original woodwork and finishes, including the
oldest surviving example of the type of staircase used by McIntire. In 1789,when Washington
visited Salem,the then General requested to stay at the Joshua Ward house. When originally
constructed, prior to filling of the tidelands,the house would have had a commanding view of the
oceanfront.
The house underwent a major restoration between 1978 and 1979. In recent history,the property
has been largely vacant and unmaintained. ZXE, LLC's project involves restoring the house's
original features and utilizing the existing interior layout to convert the building into a boutique
hotel. Once completed, the project will bring vitality and attention back to this truly historic and
important structure in Salem.
We urge the Massachusetts Historical Commission to continue its support of this work by looking
favorable upon this application.
Sinc ely,
Jessica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
;CO -
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(978)619-5685 FAX(978)740-0404
April 15, 2015
Ms. Brona Simon
Executive Director&Deputy SHPO
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
RE: MPPF application—Salem Public Library
Dear Ms. Simon:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing in support of a Massachusetts Preservation Projects Fund
application to address serious brownstone deterioration at the Salem Public Library at 370-372 Essex Street.
The Library, located within Salem's McIntire Historic District,was erected in 1855 as the home of Salem's
illustrious and philanthropic Captain John Bertram. The Italianate Palazzo style building became a public
library in 1889 as a gift to the city from Captain Bertram's heirs. To this day it remains active and heavily
used. The Form B survey form completed in 1995 describes Italianate features which include quoins and
broad, overhanging,bracketed eaves.
Recently,while preparing a survey of building conditions to support a new Round 21 MPPF grant application,
preservation architect John Goff discovered evidence of serious brownstone deterioration on the building that
raised some new public safety concerns. Specifically,it appears that the extreme weather conditions associated
with the 2014-2015 winter have caused dangerous cracking to occur in the 1855 brownstone belt course
situated above the first floor level in the East wall of the landmark. Because the library's east elevation faces a
sunken courtyard that is connected with the Children's Room, and typically is used heavily on warm weather
days,there is concern about the potential for brownstone layers(about 1 inch thick)dropping two full floors or
about 20 feet into the courtyard below. As a result,the Courtyard has been closed until safety concerns are
addressed.
The Salem Historical Commission urges the MHC to support full funding for the Salem Public Library's
Round 21 application for a grant to remediate this emergency situation,while also allowing for a broader range
of preservation issues to be addressed
We hope ill look favorably upon this application.
Si orely,
Jessica Herbert,
Chair
The 2015 problem belt course lies above the first
floor level, and is currently comprised mostly of
old brownstone that dates from 1855. It has
experienced about 160 years of weathering and
\= decay.
In other areas where the brownstone was
_. deteriorated in the 1980s,the old stone was
replaced with "cast stone"—a much more
durable and less friable form of modern precast
u �pti ' concrete.
M Similar upgrade& replacement is recommended
here as well.
n " d �t@.
sGn'w
'vYM,
b
Ky([ \ by
S 4
4� v No serious problems yet with
"t lower belt course that is now
more modern and a much
1 , stronger precast concete.
View of spalling brownstone belt course on East Elevation looking up from near SE comer of library—
wide view showing location of"problem"belt course is high up... above the first floor level.
4-13-15 photo#50 by John Goff
5
.� a 6'� eY$m• R' �a4 R.
u
V*
fW
,� ��, _ .p ten-+ 0.°,u,,�.1.+ "± sm a� tc.•
-------------------------
'_ ^5 v�`cC W +.'?r�r 'q"`xf�� `y"^fi!+� M<'�• m
fie-
= r
View of spalling brownstone belt course on East Elevation
looking up from near SE comer of library
4-13-15 photo#49 by John Goff
4
BELT COURSE termination
block at extreme south end l"
,,. also shows bad structural
7—
cracking situation
t.F I
BELT COURSE facing_
East—with problems Ilk
visible from below l
i
� �I
Is 9
' a
_,. .- ............
Fr a
Iqr'E
View of spalling brownstone belt course on East Elevation looking up from near SE corner of library:
view showing cracking in adjacent brownstone blocks---all installed with edge of stone strata facing up so
that water easily penetrates and causes spalls especially when subject to winter freeze-thaw cycles
4-13-15 photo#52 by John Goff
6
t.
a 1�
03,
s7,=
�y ^ 'h .+.""•,r --w �.>� . { �rt N+�'w.y� mow..... �. * V�, t
1
r f
View of spalling brownstone belt course on East Elevation
looking up from near SE corner of library
4-13-15 photo#47 by John Goff
« nn,.. s
'�GfV�+v xwo. f akar �a< 'kf E.v'UY� Yt
View of spalling brownstone belt course on East Elevation
looking up from near SE corner of library
4-13-15 photo#48 by John Goff
3
,
y M1
i 4.0
5 d f
I`
5
IIIT.
�s. •.moi ..x. .r
Front(south)elevation 4-13-15 photo#7 by John Goff
fi �,
} v
The 160 year old natural brownstone used in the Salem Public Library's 1855 construction has long been
subject to erosion and weather damage. This is a Front portico detail—badly eroded--view looking NE at
left rear pilaster base 4-13-15 photo#29 by John Goff
2
. o
Salem Historical Commission
120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970
(976) 619-5685 FAX(970)740-0404
January 22, 2015
Helen Sides,Chair
Community Preservation Commission
120 Washington Street, 3`d Floor
Salem, MA 01970
RE: Restoration of Brick Sidewalks within Local Historic Districts
Dear Ms. Sides:
The Salem Historical Commission is writing to you in support of the proposal to restore brick
sidewalks within the local historic districts. Brick sidewalks are a defining characteristic of
historic neighborhoods and we strongly encourage their restoration whenever possible.
Over the years,there have been large sections of brick sidewalks replaced with concrete
throughout the local historic districts, notably in the Cambridge Street area. The introduction of
contemporary concrete sidewalks detracts from the historic streetscape and is not visually
compatible with the architecture of the surrounding buildings. Restoration of the brick sidewalks
will preserve and protect the distinctive character of the neighborhood.
Sincerely,
ssica Herbert, Chair
SALEM HISTORICAL COMMISSION
Salem
Redevelopment
Authority
June 19,2015
Ms. Susan Arena
Architectural Historian
EBI Consulting
21 B Street
Burlington,MA 01803
RE:Proposal to install telecommunications equipment on the roof of 217 Essex Street in Salem
Dear Ms.Arena:
At its meeting on July 9,2014,the Salem Redevelopment Authority(SRA)voted 5-0 to approve a June 25,2014 Design Review
Board(DRB)recommendation to approve the installation of telecommunications equipment at 217 Essex Street(Verizon Wireless
Antennas)as presented in plans dated 6/30/14 and in photo simulations presented at the SRA meeting. The SRA has approval
authority over any exterior visual elements being installed or placed upon buildings within the City of Salem's Urban Renewal Area,
in which 217 Essex Street is located. The DRB provides a recommendation to the SRA on decisions that it makes.
At an initial meeting of the Salem DRB on May 28,2014,the project applicant provided a proposal noting the installation of four out
of a total of six antennas to be installed within a 15' tall fiberglass chimney that would resemble the brick of the existing building.
Members of the DRB objected to this technique for concealment,noting specifically that the proposed chimney appears too large and
is angled in an awkward way. Members asked whether the chimney could be shortened and/or moved elsewhere on the roof. An
engineer present at the meeting noted that it could neither be shortened or moved due to the density of the buildings in the area,which
affects the quality of signal distribution. The DRB requested that the applicant return with a proposal that instead shows exposed
antennas,feeling that they would blend in more appropriately with other antennas already present on the roof and not be concealed
into what they felt was an awkward and conspicuous structure.
At a second meeting of the DRB on June 25,2014 the applicant presented the Board with a proposal that showed exposed antennas
mounted to steel braces. The Board expressed concerned that the braces were quite visible and asked that the applicant lower them as
much as possible(at least 2')against the backdrop of the roof parapet,and that the braces be painted a"warm grey"color. The project
was voted through with a favorable recommendation as presented,noting the request to have the braces lowered.
The SRA did not provide further comments to the applicant during its July 9,2014 meeting,where it ultimately approved the project.
The decision resulting from that meeting is attached.
At this time the SRA does not anticipate having the applicant return to provide a revised project proposal,especially given that the
original proposal showing a faux chimney element was rejected by the DRB.
If you have any questions about the review and approval process for this project,I may be contacted at 978-619-5685 or
ashapiro@salem.com.
Respectfully submitted,
Andrew Shapiro „
Economic Development Planner
Staff to the Salem Redevelopment Authority and Design Review Board
Enclosure
Cc:Ryan Maciej,Massachusetts Historical Commission
Natalie Lovett, Salem Historical Commission
- f
} Pre s e r va t f on atwork JAN
DEPT. OF _p.
COMMUN!T;DEVELOP"JIcNT
HISTORIC
SALEM INC
December 18, 2015
Ms. Brona Simon
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
Re; Section 106 and MGL 27—C reviews
Dear Ms. Simon:
Historic Salem, Inc. (HSI) respectfully requests the opportunity to participate in'all '
Section 106 review process for every project in Salem subject to a'Section 106 review;
in accordance with 36 CFR 800.2(c)(6) of the National Historic Preservation Act. Given
our longstanding involvement in the preservation of historic resources in the City'of
Salem, we are greatly interested in every project that may have potential impacts
on Salem's historic resources.
HSI also requests to be considered an interested party under 950 CMR 71.07 (3) with
respect to any project subject to review pursuant to MGL Section 27—C. It is our
understanding that as an interested party HSI would receive copies of all
correspondence among participants.
Historic Salem, Inc. has been the preeminent citywide preservation advocacy
organization in Salem since 1944. Historic Salem, Inc.'s mission is to ensure that the
historic resources of Salem, which are the key to its identity, its quality of life, and its '
economic vitality, are preserved for future generations, and that new development
complements the historic character of the City. Historic Salem, Inc. has been
instrumental in.saving numerous historic properties, including the ca. 1675 "Witch
House'; (Jonathan Corwin House), the ca. 1805 Bowditch (home of the famed
astronomer.and mathematician, Nathaniel Bowditch, author of"The New American
Practical Navigator"), the Wendt House at 18 Crombie Street,the Pope House at 69
Boston Street, and the Old Salem Jail. Historic Salem, Inc. manages Salem's Most
Endangered Historic Resources Program, and maintains a House Plaque Program,
which has provided research for more than 700 historic structures in Salem.
9 North Steot P.O_[3ox 865 ;, Salem. N1 0 19 70
V 978.745,0799 1 F 973.744.4536 -
• info eihistoricsalcm.org i wwr.historicsalem.org
Thank you very much,
Jennifer Firth
President
Historic Salem, Inc.
Cc: Kimberley Driscoll, City of Salem Mayor
Jessica Hebert, Chair, Salem Historical Commission
Lynn Duncan, Salem City Planner
F
}
t i
r
'¢ Pc s rva t i on at .m.o r k JAN 04 i_�,i.3,-'13) LP
f
- DEPT.OF PLANNING&
COMMUNITY UF_VELOPMENT
HISTORIC
SALEM INC
December 18, 2015
Ms. Brona Simon
Executive Director
Massachusetts Historical Commission
220 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
Re; Section 106 and MGL 27—C reviews
r
Dear Ms. Simon:
Historic Salem, Inc. (HSI) respectfully requests the opportunity to participate in all
Section 106 review process for every project in Salem subject to a Section 106 review,
in accordance with 36 CFR 800.2(c)(6) of the National Historic Preservation Act. Given
our longstanding involvement in the preservation of historic resources in the City of
Salem, we are greatly interested in every project that may have potential impacts
on Salem's historic resources.
HSI also requests to be considered an interested party under 950 CMR 71.07 (3) with
respect to any project subject to review pursuant to MGL Section 27—C. It is our
understanding that as an interested party HSI would receive copies of all
correspondence among participants.
Historic Salem, Inc. has been the preeminent citywide preservation advocacy
organization in Salem since 1944. Historic Salem, Inc.'s mission is to ensure that the
historic resources of Salem, which are the key to its identity, its quality of life, and its
economic vitality, are preserved for future generations, and that new development
complements the historic character of the City. Historic Salem, Inc. has been
instrumental in saving numerous historic properties, including the ca. 1675 "Witch
House" (Jonathan Corwin House), the ca. 1805 Bowditch (home of the famed
astronomer and mathematician, Nathaniel Bowditch, author of"The New American
Practical Navigator"), the Wendt House at 18 Crombie Street,the Pope House at 69
Boston Street, and the Old Salem Jail. Historic Salem, Inc. manages Salem's Most
Endangered Historic Resources Program, and maintains a House Plaque Program,
which has provided research for more than 700 historic structures in Salem.
9 'North Street 1 P.O. Box 865 Salcm, MA 01970
V 975.745.0799 I F 978.744.4636
infog1JjStoricsalc1J1.ori tvu s�'.historicsalem.ori
Thank you very much,
Jennifer Firth
President
Historic Salem, Inc.
Cc: Kimberley Driscoll, City of Salem Mayor
Jessica Hebert, Chair, Salem Historical Commission
Lynn Duncan, Salem City Planner