The URL can be used to link to this page

25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD - CONSERVATION COMMISSION Fla,54 - ds Wv fe&e�-s 2k _d Uooy/� tJer� �va.�+ 3 k h ��`� � "" renn�r► AM-28-2005 12:17 ORLRNDI & SWEENEY 617 376 0254 P.02iO4 v (,/d al,J. 'x 1. 617) 471-n99 A" A S—" pp //�� 3...A 617)3760234 Fiats. � W-1 or and Jweeneryr �C., Ji. B. ae.... .Atter .t J&W -7/w 1A slu temanf 1266 -74"am gso'rP"way, —" f05 RECEIVED ///✓ar 02169-4758 APR 2 S 2005 April 28,2005 DEPT.Of PLANNING& COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT VIA FACSIMLEE NO.: (9 78) 740-0404 Kevin Cornacchio,Chairman City of Salem Conservation Commission 120 Washington Street Salem,Massachusetts 01970 Re: 25 Winter Island Road,Salem,MA Dear Mr.Chairman: This office represents Edward M.Moriarty,Jr.and Joanne Scott,owners of 29 Winter Island Road, Salem,and we are writing to you concerning 25 Winter Island Road (hereinafter the Subject Property). Let me first state that our clients harbor neither ill will nor animosity towards Douglas and Jean Karam,owners of the Subject Property,and they are not opposed to the Karams previously stated plans for renovating the premises. I note that Ed and Joanne conveyed a small portion of their land to Mr. and Mrs. Karam so that the Karams could proceed with their plans to renovate the residence at 25 Winter Island Road. Nonetheless,our clients have a number of concerns relative to the actions recently undertaken upon the Subject Property and the impact those actions have had, and will have,upon the fragile environment in this area. Among these concerns is whether the actions to date have been undertaken with the appropriate oversight and guidance of all necessary authorities, including the Conservation Commission. Last month Ed Moriarty contacted me because he had serious concerns relative to Mr.and Mrs. Karam cutting down several trees that Ed believed were located on a right of way between his property and the Karams' property. I, in tum,spoke with Attorney Scott Grover who represents Mr. and Mrs. Karam. Attorney Grover indicated his clients had received permission from the Conservation Commission to clean up the area by removing various brush and"junk"trees. He further informed me that the area in between the two properties was a"paper street". I suggested to him that the cutting down RPR-28-2005 12:18 ORLRNDI 8 SWEENEY 617 376 0254 P.03iO4 Kevin Cornacchio,Chairman City of Salem Conservation Commission Page 2 April 29,2005 of five large maple trees,which Ed estimated were at least 50 years old,did not constitute cleaning up an area,and I also questioned his clients'authority to cut down trees on the area Attorney Grover maintains is city property. It was agreed by Attorney Grover and I that hereafter better communication would be exercised between our respective clients and the matter was dropped. We revisit this issue at the present time because it now appears this was not an isolated incident,but may be indicative of a pattern of conduct that the Commission should be mindful of in reviewing this matter. Next,we have the demolition of the residence upon the Subject Premises. This is the work that gave rise to the Conservation Commission's stop work order. We are mindful the Commission,through its agents,has conducted its own investigation and will not revisit facts concerning the same. However,we believe that the Commission should be aware that the Karams'application to the Zoning Board for which a Special Permit was granted indicated the work would involve the reconstruction and renovation of the existing structure. The application and plans submitted all reference the reconstruction, renovation of,and addition to,the existing structure. Please see North Shore Survey Corporation Plan submitted by the Karams to this Commission. Based upon the foregoing, there would appear to be a question,albeit,not for this Board,as to whether any Building Permit issued pursuant to the Special Permit is valid. What certainly is within the purview of this Commission,however,is the regulation of future actions upon the Subject Property. It is uncontroverted that the existing structure has been demolished,the work was accomplished with the use of heavy construction equipment,and the stockpiling of debris within the Buffer Zones for the Cove and the Salt Marsh. At this point,our clients respectfully submit that how we arrived at this juncture is not the issue for consideration. Certainly, it may have been a misunderstanding or lack of knowledge on the part of the Karams or their contractor. Again,however,this is not the critical issue that need be addressed by the Conservation Commission and other City Boards. Rather than review how these events transpired,our clients would prefer the focus be upon the appropriate response to those events. My clients respectfully submit the first line of inquiry should be a determination as to what,if any,damage has occurred to the Salt Marsh or the Cove as a result of the actions taken to date,taking into consideration the removal of trees,the demolition of the house,and the use of heavy equipment and stockpiling of debris upon the premises. In addition,nearly the entire house lies within the 100 foot Buffer Zone of the Salt Marsh as delineated on the North Shore Survey Corporation Plans submitted to the Conservation Commission. Thereafter, if then is a determination the Cove or the Salt Marsh have been affected the next question is a determination of what remedial action must be taken. Assuming the remedial action,if any, is accomplished, then we would suggest the Commission determine preventative or protective actions that must be undertaken by the RPR-28-2005 12:18 ORLRNDI 8 SWEENEY 617 376 0254 P.04iO4 Kevin Comacchio,Chairman City of Salem Conservation Commission Page 3 April 28,2005 Karams in connection with whatever construction the building commissioner determines will be allowed under the Special Permit previously granted. Again, our clients are not asking this Commission to act as a sanctioning body relative to the actions that have been taken to date, Rather they merely request that the Commission undertake actions it deems necessary to correct what has transpired,and set in place appropriate safeguards to insure future harm does not occur to either the Cove or the Salt Marsh. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. Very truly yours, Patrick J. Sweeney PJS:vb cc: Frank Taormina,Planner/Conservation Agent(Via Fax No. 978 740-0404) Edward J. Moriarty,Jr.and Joanne Scott 1G1D1i✓,IMMYpW 1Mf ICCb{M,MY6,b I TOTAL P.04 APR-28-2005 12:17 ORLANDI & SWEENEY 617 376 0254 P.01iO4 Orlandi and Sweeney Anomeys a!Law The Willard Building 1266 Furnace Brook Parkway, Suite 105 Quincy,Massachusetts 02169 Tel.No. (617)471-1199 Fax No. (617)376-0254 Fax Transmittal Cover Sheet DATE: April 28, 2005 RECEIVED TO: Sevin Cornaccitio, Chairman APR 2 8 1 fid City of Salem Conservation Commission DEPT.OF PLANNING& FAX NO: 978 740-0404 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FROM: Patrick J.Sweeney,Esq. OF ORLANDI AND SWEENEY,P.C. Re: 25 Winter Island Road,Salem,MA OUR FAX#: (617)376-0254 TOTAL NUMBER oFPAGES INCLUDING COYER SHEET: 4 SHOULD YOUHAYEANYQUESTIONS OR PROBLEMS WITH THIS FAX, PLEASE CALL: Ginger AT OUR REGULAR BUSINESS#(617)471-1199. REMARSS/MESSAGES: ry ' 0 CITY OF SALEM CONSERVATION COMMISSION April 15, 2005 Douglas and Jean Karam 91 Essex Street Salem, MA 01970 Re: Violation at 25 Winter Island Road Dear Mr. &Mrs. Karam: As you are aware, On December 30, 2004 you filed a Request for Determination of Applicability (RDA) with the Salem Conservation Commission for the addition of an existing deck and clearing of some site vegetation within the Buffer Zone of a Coastal Bank and within Land Subject to Coastal Storm Flowage. On January 13, 2005 the Salem Conservation Commission issued a Negative Determination for the proposed work within the buffer zone with the understanding (as shown on the approved plans dated 11/23/04) that minimal work would be performed within the buffer zone and therefore would not require the filing of a Notice of Intent (NOI). On April 13, 2005 it was brought to my attention that a considerable amount of site work was being performed at 25 Winter Island Road, potentially within the buffer zone. Following a site inspection, I observed a backhoe and a considerable amount of soil and boulders stockpiled within the buffer zone with no erosion control measures in place. In addition, to the above-referenced resource area on site, it was also determined that Salt Marsh also exists on site. The Salt Marsh also has a one hundred foot buffer zone, and the stockpiled material is located approximately 25 feet away. The work that is currently being performed has significantly altered the buffer zone and could potentially harm the coastal resource areas. At this time, the Salem Conservation Commission is directing you to stop all work, stabilize you site (by removing all stockpiled material and machinery from the buffer zone and return the buffer zone to its original grade), and file a Notice of Intent including all required submittal documents with the Salem Conservation Commission as soon as possible. 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 • TEL: 978.745.9595 FAX: 978.740.0404 ♦ WWW.SALEM.COM Should you have any question regarding this matter, please feel free to call me directly at (978) 745-9595 extension 311. Sincerely, ank a ina lanner/Conservation Agent Cc: Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Kevin Comacchio,Chairman Thomas St.Pierre,Building Commissioner Bruce Thibodeau, City Engineer/Director of Public Services Joseph Nerden,Asst. City Engineer IM �� ..- l Y.-..�eJw•�-". mss.�.,-w :..r aw-f'= .z,_a:�1 Jx'� z`-Y. !vM _ �'"Y�pr'�,r. s.z -"--+�•'C'•.. :. c* � ,.:. r. _ ,-sta l: .'s.�J�! -ss.'Y�'�.yrns; rFr- -.5 ' - ty�FTV�,'" 'Mfti 'lam,- ��i5�tiV^� Y�� ^�. 4 . ��wl ,•tl�f4{.y�T# 5 � si k!'.-K c f ./.r'' �Ns�"."�•a�'S •�+�!<_^�^"`+�4 Y d ,�"/ + Q 'r�llxry �M+i• 1...'^µ�W, - / -'xs?.a�.. h�A� - 1! moi. _SX �*'r au � C -.n•,!}'- •�--^ 'y^' :/( At $•s H' "e, Ft "Lt 'M ��>'i , J 1,• ® -x' s y R"A Ia 'wC " ` d.':-�c� x " ', '� ,�, a F: � c ` 4r r�" sr,sx• Y..L''i _'�i+,�tn+'� �C I" .w�'�t/ x!.�v. � 'd' s -;`+w-�`rx'y"f��'��ra}��✓a'°"�, Ycv+i�' � rl' �'� b �i-4 � �' �� .... 'r v?Yj[ , �"1:" %, •a� ,�, f .K ^c• .ft} qy- yR' £ rr �'� Vk'1S �sTMF^r"lY�P'Ya'rt'�'-y�J 7 � Y J •'�Y/�!�`r�9y{�b�r5��ur r F E �!. 'd �fx �.� �� ., - .�✓� F L �rte,4��$��•.�� y Y j � . _ r �� '° ' �•4 o-: i Xw �1 :z is ~... yA'1Y,.�^ •E ��7A`vfi�� /F iui n la E � y. xS'!7 F`�au 'I �'�^ j '� rM1�. � * r�� .�ri+ki.abb °�(��c? ��L�i'r` r ♦ x R.p ��.�/ -d iL,: a,' ( r 2�S r,44 F� .�. �� 1 ..i• l'r �,'�1 J aW 4 f ^ z 1 ,' _ r..} r!�p{:V�'• Y r fhr IZZMVW - ��'� •�'v'� �'Y 3r>•9 T?''4 � '"R�-U�.a� r �inw �rJ� ��i r+:. / - .r-� ,L. i sP�°�a a�-m .�:f s f f '.�' t:ak 3 �{• ( iee �y.f � ,d ; —i,�. , LL� r � Y � ��#SS�.,1•�� h} P 3L+K. +.� •wr^" ,r ��'.J rx.`r a�' ��+[t��r' `s�' _ rlo�• : � I��ry3 It a �� £'�� p .. rl, r' < � {b � 3' X'vwF ri, v � nr'�T1 f tto � . �'� 'Z'� .,/ ..• ys'.� J `< .Z� r ♦*. � `� Z.:Y�� i�^w°�XS+�.,, ..i,Aa` `'3 sY�;`�Y7�y r.�k.)j��✓3.3-ky� Zj s�p� y. Fi C �i ir+i • i � 4..^.� e 9 ri yy fN fyq c „� .z ^-4 �a b" �" �, 4,,,✓zy N rw t*r ��'�>y .. �,yr 5 'iz ,x b 4 "4 �^�"<`�• N r dr.n -c''r'k^��+y'.�`X"� '_..fG.' x�".'i. ' .x � � � �•,a��"{tr ., �1',!``^yyaz .:."�-S � = ;rte F (LbOki' s wt k b S 1 Y ,.�. r ,y�i`r/s} L t�Tat . taW Cyd X�' 1V U�P�yN f iGAs yr - w. s.,y1 ••. + t r ,,, <... t 's tr.r v � Y i3 .; '� t+ � tea •6 r� ♦ 4 vti /sT =^' �. fi 4V -T' !'- ' .i. .. 'a 'l of r�. /1 _�, d' f� I�f /0 I.l',� :'� � ✓.,,, ri- �- � �-`'� . '.°� }A,f�l 'r LJ.r t.. a�J µbo-�Yf .;a... '�Y� •�`�� q �:P V' ♦�•! 'r� \ ' '" ®..a Y \ '� i ~ ' b: Y �gn A �F�,I �•'�1� �!y .� oeI id'm� p L �{A�.„,l < d 3�. ! �a L�1 r�J �/ t ^ � -r a p'+ .rv"y"•.y a.''r �,?.i 7 S/ 1 r ii �, � 1 _T+ �Id 'A ;i � ` - � .. t { 7�7p'.f�e��_r ys.�•s—'1F7,.,�' � i, Ja ^l..i-lrl I r+S�'.a 5'}p� �i :�, 2a a�.s-.. � � __ ,. If, e��'µl,��s� �+a �e A (�✓Sgt l.r., .. ,.a..w�, L /�'��. )�i :1;�i�.�.!.....�"v.+i°A`.�.L, ' x �l..fti:� '`t� `l'`�✓ .,. r y �P � - .•, # � � , �' �'a �x� Ih' � a is ��, � `_ y �� 1.•o-= r([ �v.= (� .��•ri �.` t �1 '�.�... y- . _l- 4 qi rP : S tie - !: 4+ t .I A �r !• p�.j�} �` 3 F+ yy .rte of - \ ' eat✓ �� -� �e ti: r' ,;.Y W _ ,1 iY •LY ny Y' x 1 +, z ,r< u s. a, 4 I l h a 3 rRtj €` �•�.5 T za Yrs �✓ � s < , P'-'�� : ✓`� •w¢� � `<.F 'r y�4�1 .5 »\ E xF-T +�„gF�6R�"sa� '`�"'�`� _� - -atc��°,Q -- �' J _ "� ` s :.�nT-tuj"y;r"•y�' :� 9a Tt��'Ya.�.3y ``A� } } A.�.y f .S q C2K .a,2s`4.1" .",.. .!S K-'YrL �3 •SV.� kt �)Y� R �t f - .:4 �....- r y�r yY�yfi y. �' i.>ie - •i °'i3. `; 'r` \. �.ts'w."•`� `�-' fiFi'�,%rty.•...J/-. '�y�- r�4�''.f A � �c F '"-x 'ixt Y i "�v .:''�"..,d > "'ice at"`� ""t"ac•`- 'x``1, k i'c��.ysi� �S"- `1}�n t 'v •. L'v L ^�.' �1�'�+ f 'alfL' /� � .,-3• l��p r t r w + t u�.w �id•^J�� /1� �� n- ,.(! � t.� (.f 'j4h .h:��a 1 �¢(A^tC` �i ��t �1 �`�'� •a�l F c�'r+�.i `} ' �yS° iru � � r ie--."y �r m'�♦r 4y�iYir. S �.e r(� 4 A. � I _. .� .;'a / ��'' ✓,..ax-33J� Ai fir's'. "�t +�'r ��Yv��'-. �� }\ .,,`�„ '. '+yr, � a�riti..; 'AG�L` r' ��f �rt ��,_s a..^r,3�rCa�.F_ •` �.-.\s .^- ♦.wv �.,a,R v.., ^'��. yy �'^s+��`y,f� S �rL`�,.n ✓'I.."a�F%'F3y�f*�L"'��+ v��tt sT+ n tly '�Y � \ r � 3h i3 ' `�+'l-,• +'� w I� [ {� k� � -kyr �,S�J y � �T. � 4�+' !rt s� «',.:. z+r £✓ '�'vier' .tom+-t "',:,s +' '#,` ryJ f ! ra w ( y. _ff'gy'�M-� `� 'f J• .Y ✓.:ls+r .f' Y�Y I 74 ,✓Y �rJ�#; �� ;„" �,r�3}.�i_S t�S�(1� .> �, .z {# � �� -rd_a npa34�6i'l� _ -Y ft-��•. : P-�f. *�C �.>� �'�,✓e�� J� 3� - — - � „{ �L T•sja£,£a-l��"-r'43 j �1 i.3 -� J—�.t - �f €�`�{.4 t*'r 9ri1'3•,✓z �=� y('�d.l,� Sf�p ,Y° r'.i r4#F ker �" e (*"x 3 �J -t� -. .g.�6 �•do.'x Y a[s tiY 'r3r�f .,z_ `3f� Yi`. r 'f'Z�raOr. 1�y,A 4J�.3 qis .• 1^vdfl� '�' "' ""+7`l `' -�.„£ finv fj i^ �.• � r .. v. ''Vc f £ i� ."�'�ii^�' 1 �'f �' ,a•'. '�`�'"Z,f '� �-�`�'i �dt u• '�.,�i'� { Ft � ��,i- � �,�,�r��L �t,r rr��9_ {�ks.,—��h�f� ice,�l�r'�?�.�� . ��.F 7 1�ye�� $� �,�'�✓a^ fi 'rd �- � J�.pt}��C'"�o' b �Ss��-:}�Tz ry'� i k�/"t+ aY'�� ,('_Ef,•'`�t�r�,,�>w��#t�r�"'"�_�x wy 'may `�' �-��;.il 3s�✓J` t .a��Aiy� � .n+ � f"(' 'ft Ydf.%il .�uf 'k'� t f'lJ ,..t y'fa y r�'7,�N F ! � �I..1' f.trE ,�is1 �y. �r� f b d' ,,,,�p,+ it 4�i i r eY{+.s r-.� faj Y• ?h- F`i*i !> �."'>'+ "ry ri r�. 7 q'.r� f � � Gf 'i � I �y'��: •t i '.� fi%Jr�"�'3! ).(,.fid ti2+/� �r�.'rt^ `y}f.YJ�'r'�'�� C 8 •� ��,L, ,� ' r � J ". h Yr?�> f � t^ 1 '�t"7 �' ♦t v♦}. R,?4 f �' ,y-t., r h-� Y i i s rj .y( t 'lliy i� ♦ 1 � •bn ,f j�iTF -1^ ... - y � �'i d"L �''Q `r+�,".T>' 'ccAcp�"„� ty,.rr.Yfr .�✓Y. ''4,'^' 't}i.' „Jr ` ^vii r� .r+" ` ' v w i � e�- � L�:j t :'«�.y '�„� +-•esr „� ,yy ' L "z"4a7c•9t``� � �-'�y,`'"'� � -. �Y.:�k!; .?ya 1 `'. .7' '� n.�� ;i. xn •-'�'r�e�`".it°i�j>r3 r `ti h' '�.+' -.� ..e.t .B� /' } �<�� r.''a.,, a P'_fiY"• _ _ .�2 ..<_. .153.'ZCv�4�. �, �. r+"pa"^•°� ��'•.i;9 3 1 z� �r�ji. 'j,. . ?JI 5 13w��.,. �Aa_�/.•S� F`� , �•• y� k ` y�'� _F '�Rk•Y�' �f�$' a3 3'�� i�� h�,+cf-�.+u}z�, ,,'may � . ;V �'� ' Y�ta.b Y ��`+��r��`r'�� ih3 �',l '• \./;.` yy ��"'..yr ��.• '� � � �... tv, ';'any •'tea- xY y ��FL ' �r� ?^"'faf"�P�v Cc.n�moYm�� a $a MW �y's - 3 v 3 c3 ��•.YZ/s,. �.� r�Y�2;., "';•`,:' '� `�F�', F _. >� �� QiJi� �. hTu•.1-.'`� .aY �, ' }few" � �'%}.�p'}..K`4�'. � ^h�4',+�y��. .."r �Y.1 f'T' - '^L �✓ Y-`�'srt. ,�/' N✓'-�-i 5'f`. i yat �y.Y � `�l`Y-'�l• j �2 '� i .'�Q. '<+-..� J f > "s`1`4. �'N •fir 1 '. ..-. MR {\ . �z 2d I 110 g a � 7 � If Nf Oro At I Al ra t`C'` 1rtiF' fTr+ F•�'. M1'Try',.•�1 T �'Ny�r±# r 3 � � n6i � A4 � r{ rr� (�}•�{ __ st>ltiv 1(�,�a ,.'r�.rj-' u'h'r'�4~�i aw+' ,.n.� , A$ t r i •.y�r} b '� .`1��QS Yr� � ' w"r fr�Cf�Fr��.r,'� r4'�.`a1f,.�hv`'i�➢,Sk s't�Tjt� �� E'i T; N, y ap •r v v'� �`*a a fk. � nib!' 4X I. t+, 4 rh i,�[ +rL�\xie yt iC®✓td .4,f F, P.�'( `i`.7�?�yi51,y -ri..T "� SF r1. A^�1^'� rf Iq''r�._Y�,�r � �,tjh•f� t+ ,,%y. R ��X�i' �i' LIOUInj I L Ag ~ ;' - ... � i .+. r �r ,ter I r - •« �• —14-- � S,{..« rz r \'✓�r �f/" � � � '�*S 4� i � ,3 b � � t `� � r ,r. r v ro 4 y ✓ `5[��a S 3 ! ^ t 1.. °'2' a`Y ` `.Y 7+1 MW ? 'tr /' `r ` �S(,i' �. [ a� v �� r' �- s"�y� t �''J. '�� `.��51.•'R""ry'9y'{ � � Y" �` - sem. '�t � r1�:� �z � '"r yy [R„ ":.'.°'ai es m",� -!. 'i - Q "�y6FFr•(Y ±y+f'tYt. :- "�,.. aVf�,.�y1+ w•,wY y " k`�t :yx' Ott �.rr • y,. r '„ayYa� if SSvr Iawy`�,yI�b� ,61.3 ' Y�tis�./ y (� .3�,�4 f r�. ayA,. t ryi^�lr:,�.♦ ,t '-..s. �pp�.��'-$' �; 'fit".+. 1.-� /"' sw �� y�y�+,'�yp. •�Y 4 �r iT � 'w � t - r 's + w " MORf 6•"cse`%- }'k+ .�Z a. �. av 'sS ,,: 1. t.`i 'Lr.a. �.a (¢. Yw., _ �.<+ �' 'f�•r '�,c �.a Vh.'a �.-„,s � .gy..."s �yRS�337-�Y, ,,. +'�el •� 'ciY �� 'T - ~` e .�-� � '/S-td't �-6�� ei"erv-�'S� �/! .✓+.Ey ,�s�+t�i^ `” S�� i ;� r„'r.Y<.�w ""' ��'�cFC7 ty�. '{ '*�'r �"'� �,��' � �urc�.5�."t.,�w��'w - 'OM1-.�'K. •wa.tt�` �-^ „i ui��. � s = - fq � 4 �j'4��$ �'_ C,`Y�� h•.�� eF, �1:_ - L' �`'»r �� 9' c ��y'§tfi. � •�tib- ,� _� r -�dy-�. . Z: ,�a,,.�� '"nv"�s .�ys^'!�y`z„i�{•C'i x�a r�:�r��tA s�p �r� '�"'.� �y.' � a .=m'-'�?c'' �.,-`y j.F-�*s urt_.k.yk+yo Zk Z, � �t + j �rsaA�1.7�1�rt�M�J�nac9d�aA(� a '�'a ' 11 ' u y rfl!?��• r Ali, JOHN-DEERE Ty„kr� ��r , �,r,E , �•.. .r, wr It l 1 7°D �♦��,^'y` a J� ' - t '�+4"q�o�-- '*'Me"r.,�'-'"'r- -.L.:-'+x1 _..-, ri,�i _ '. 4. ` d �-- ,- .,�`�: ��.��"�. "��p-�+.-�-b•-rte,,,,'> ,� f }� ..g rte' ,� .rA `�`..� eesrn. i .� k>.�'j% �•+. li F r ♦ s.. •� # sss .� .r` V (""E `.g�C -e � ��ja'l ".."i�a�.a �y.�ns.�.2 `'��>.G�� e' .� jS..� '�f` °v �j+aa�e'x'r ��'� �*W.d',4r� �9w..^aa�� y_'`'a � �T`� �--: • f! ''+"" /i �� '-.a'nTW }Py,.., °Ys« 1.� l�1.�� *� `�i.'�j•Z�fi�L- ',r�Sy'ati"�r�S�; >��'- >_�r �`\,Y�� r,t�l%•^h?' q x 'rr Y r �€� r/ �J ya " 4r� ?y"3 x. j � '� ` '�.\/ ,4°. �� ._� ti �. r ' � �,,CS�kz ' �P�• I” ♦-c-.-!`� i� � �\ F 1� h�,'. 1 '1.`" sr �- .h � �,3,t / �� f �.�'� � '. ��,(�{�•�� a� ill �-F. 4 '711 =[rgi # �� ir�� " / .- ) U.V. `>• r 'I T'�'`Ar m�'r"�._ ��"`e;.�{ ` � i; 1'r`` �, . � �� r!•Qfk�. , :.rk'� rid �� aLa. .�� leL.." d`' ;�'?_C'A` K.' � J ♦ '�Y'�YL"i' li1k�SX' �' r ♦ .. r f ii kj ,•� y. i�'r�� _�y y r�•r L"�( a ��n r�ate', + ��•.r f s.>. '�` � .., � -•- Y'r �r�£/�`d'� z'r a_ s v4�R ¢ * .F r.rt�.,Y � r a -1 }�h'eir 9+� •�1'„F�if% a s�r ' - ' r '* 'r1.'�,l'}�`"��.�}'.J:t'l,,'�"{z✓ �"" �':rr�r �7pNT��,�i{�r r Y e:37►�f� � ;C1i�rt�r .��` Y,,. r�}Lp`•�i a T� 1 . / �rrf � ;Fr ;. %'s�.F a•tr r Surf �>. .� y' yS.MSil `aarr3 yt c.`Y�+,y `w` a/4jr A WE Ztv �, -. � yY.aS f^Gr4lt� � 1f j1(xk��i•� P 4' ♦J a /�.e,1r" N r Y ra a - yy '�'; .`, i ? r :ky- '•-- °a.+a3$ �".'s= s "O f *��}� V .J, CF N,---v l �}C�� e ! a�k ��ti��}� ��"'S' � v-�.vr�R rr rk "� �.�� '`"'�✓tr y�`74.+,— � �Lk� r. '"``Yifrft SyyC' . . i .. 3eR rt !J�[�L -si'�✓� r�J r�Y. 'Al p.iJ / ti: .Y � �;� al ri1°�'� � �F'a pW ' ..�' �,.' _1•'_';h'�Tp 1.�v ' y u F,•, r�.J Tray r J." i,�r ] - - J Y �"�� i .F'.E°'�',, s •-�-.7775 t .'mag. et-,t^ 77 ti+t! 'b" 3 .+r`.dS' ✓ 6K.t 3 i' �t- ,�,K ..r�r'F i j, e.+ .�• f1 �x..F� py 1 k p" s��. !.� �'._ f Y�;ryja' _'� I l� 1� YSW{�y a 2? .�i � rw' �� 1� �` � �• .a � W� r'`>,z n �'y�y f�� 'ED I "`i.sc t� a. �k, 1„r � g " t r tt� a`r c��g � ";'� �"�'p4• �4 rn d�'1 `s•' Y�� , dt�a>�� W-r3 Svr.� •, i r'II• s' � � Sr• .� i a �l n Z jr � y �s,G i �✓�� ' 'y.� i4'4s ��ti� aM` �4 � Y �ty�4_G� yts�y r x �y�?" 4 w n r!' „+ `R�i '•Id,'!`i 1`xo-' `u.�i +. 3 il � . t _ ' ...+e-�� vim' �y��'��'�- }}rr•.ryG4�.,ar=S�y �j,� � K / . . limil AR-1 �'�YTy3 1^Y C atvq��>_y �f fil F� e f.;;?3F 1sdt ,o e3 .9'•'^� rt "$ f',.mow . .:_ 9 OF a' .aT' .?. 'w �,. �'•_ y y¢'' y w" r.✓ Q+F .y y �'^:.� ^• yyk n `7 n�yF�� yly'� �16�,.. =y"A'. �✓� � _.� ; y�}�j+x.A t�"C:,t'.�Y—Mt� Y a 4y,. "5 ,F 3"" d .. � �' �y lKx, t ✓a s. . bo a '4' - t�a ru�i✓ .-�: ^ s v v, `S'.�} r- ' 1J�.-k a �>n. - ' 1� }� 4 mow; Ao,.k- I,- qy " > '.+1i y.✓ ,(r S�.,y l 6� +r ,� � "+�„��.o- i !` :.,bt \i.✓ l y� )p� :+ � ' � �; t vJ / /. ✓f, -.� f"-exp" 1 r+fe + 1 �S->'O sy r_'F > r dyr^'�Jl�/'C' ��4 L .FR7�� ✓'-6'r�' 7 lZ .>- E j ,�I -' �/„"=xr,.`✓+'a�''�A.�iZ - ,kA37 a- I`XZY T ;%✓gyp � "4' n � \. __._ c..Y .<r�'� (`'.h�y��"'� ��i. rfi• y F ��'`9-. ...�,J"�3...y� ,,/ `'#'f ! r�..ti" � RK^d ` [� f{� y � /} :4 S '07My��? 7" ^"�� AArQ Nt rs 1 ef _ ' c"7 {1 �� - �'✓l' c'.Y .sd3"i i t � 17 rk' s'� fs.C'a' G blk it i�1 a 'gyp �7 � W.' .$ n `r r F,"yJ' � w :/l`�! � +1� rte.^ �3.. T.4 h F( .sr, �•t ..,tr Z'146 . r€� 4� l �N. ^T T ^T /� �.� i Z1 R� {� $ i t*\\� !S ,�•�'Y '�5Y 41. Y .ay, �y qr �.J IT Vie. �fS' `y�..• �o R�`�'f'�-"�' � + V'.<� +. � [ 1 ''CV74♦ �r •. � ! s�n a ��i+-r�3 y `� > ,' � .� w �' i �� .{EF .'.•m � k' a '�; r � =. F�.-�( A� �� dr wf��`+�l F� �5: vi .{,y-�� '� ,{y. �s WfJW • } WS4. o, 'kr¢fnYJjj tNr$ i t -1 vlxi ??y� f�m4n ��i "Y 2*,RIO 4R�� 't� "t :�.�,,{�." RIO N�d�i�..��-F,;Sa� ru N ®.+✓.'K" L''r'/� "'�.�r '�sr~`+. '�� zip ��td� ��..:.�ewr - :d�i/ie'`S '�SYs�.� �i - ,•osty .f'� IKC:.ta.� }.. wv _ ..,_ - :a. ,.. c.. .. _- VI • � ar 34 NO IN _.. ww,jpjp Fgg y r � a,` � t � a " - l` r� i}hT113- �b�'�, y �, '� S po-+t MR ,±��rP _ern �` ti £ � J) ^• \ � ~�. �.� kk�,yh� y��. � wc. ��. . 9 p L (" �R y�q1x'" '"`e1L . tt 't' � :>�'A. i"+c� 7(* i'd"F £ ,.. p'R " •.,t, M. � i S/�r�tSga'4L • a�'.�_:ar�� v- q' e`"",�� t H p�[, d"1F ` ft5� 4 t N f cv r_ ron'j v ° r �- l � `��s'\ awi£S Y ' 71 66 t �y 'f I S � � 3'u". S°C'`�-�?4; � -.Rl E•.0 "Gh .. i 1 tx84h'�i•{ a- .a. r i. F tn�'�" R. '.4 t ♦y �A + 1' H < 'x r � Yv ..4 t .. xair... l -.ti.'l�1<ez' .... •4_ cf�)w`-,t.��3'.+.t"i:.�tit'1 i. '.ro.:."'�_+S x .T A Mll Vs yam¢, , :. ' � i'j�ly ,�.Y:(A � ,,,� .�+W4 w �¢' R' _ •Yr' 7 p ' �+ r ''e/'f t �,5.' �yn Lt � ,.'� i1'Y` I •� �. f .pC `. -N"ty,'�s- a "�J raj, r .�, �� e � 4:,} .�' ��• {" '� ^' f Il�elly+ +�j. h►`�i.CS lI,". .. f 4."f \ y +�+ -t r / �' 'i" ,�ia ��e11 ✓' � .u'��`�id: �w , y4r.�1� ✓-`i per, �:��j7�p ' { P. �ly�y'%e�" � �r 4 � `f'�' "� b �y '�• ''�'Y ? ;ii ,, Y�spy s �}y r,.o. #` '�?.. f=,. yytt "�. 'd��„�y'•,rF � - ��; y.",+.,a:�. RY � ,, .,1!..aY >. Ftry 'z.p � "��/✓Yiy Y..y_/,(�Y�',df' i' �t bK ."�'+r��Y,. . 'n*"S�A�4 �o-+ i � a s3 ' N'+� - _ "� f . _ r Y '.t Bt t f i I _� "��ii�,s"q��-'g+ �. yA,"G. "�krr _ `. y,.y•,, r,.� C'sT-� n�'� c a..yam: � r F •-r.� ��t+ ♦ meg. y:�$ - < 3z t .t A 'ir..i,'r�V' Lfl.,..gV'�'"''� .r'�.%�s2i".• ..�Y ...�.p. 'J R n Y +'-'ivy t'R �,^{HH•^^•11 NO'y��J -3am- �� J� � �� r r', 'srx -�x-�2� �' J D - a-y'.�6 y,.R.ti-r>�...•a.�pr s ��. rr.T „ � �ye Yv/l'.Yy+' r Yf 4-. ,�'.s•3%• Y^` "i'-�r-`ar "x �- 1 'fid -.,. t _ � etq�,4�9• a> .� D 11 fat �� rT^r tel. _� +:�dS 1 4Y y •n ��":,y_ � �ry'�A y 4:�J� L."iP-k s+e?• M� ,F.h" `�:. .. + a. `9 yy`.. s;�-._e 4"+lYr ♦ A4.0 } .,Y d..,F'�✓• iG-��yy�iF.v�e. '� �.�(.+'T�., A._ -, g�y.�z.'"ie ': $ ..r:w. °3. �`J. ^Y �yf��w _.^FI'"�. � �a•. {�..� tR s;r '. "1� M1i�"- .'� S �..& � >,i �i _i":,"Y}'. .yffr3:��,,wr��i6��'.. %^�`kr�Y'{� a '+�t�4-t�F.—'.�`� a.�a,� F +w; f �,yAj y�•L`c",iyt s;-y � ,n-�r Ai��t� ��d ,. � �fc. ria{�a�"�weF. _`zJy�i " •4M„Y�' .` Lf,,,/ 3 1.b ��rL 4 ,.1, . 4 r / '*r v . i v bE� :3e1. "� L•. f .y"f we ,y p / PE ��`' z�, ' �£ �;,� ,gyp`#y} s •� �` � � .t.�a'„�-!!f`�Rtfr1�o � ; � \ � s yA r,� �a'� i 3 !q{ffd r " 1. +. ' M-. •..«: � .'� "h'7 't a._ r e¢ a da"mS'"" .� t�kr� Y Y.rl�a �' � j'y '•' � � ,� j_�. .c. �� I.r ^` �+."�� '• � ,.smart al\a- i�r *"'. y O . r ��", y+ . >� �� r ��RY\�2yy a'.. . Ali •'.. n�'� r Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 1 - Request for Determination of Applicability Cirylrown Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 A. General Information Important: When filling out 1• Applicant: �/ forms on the _VD V ti 1'q S � J ea Ke e r4a VVI colo uter, se u key Name - E-Mail Address y y lsey 5 Ere to move your cursor-do not Mail'ng Address n use the return M1 pi 'I , m,4 . rKA- d{ 7o key. Cityrrown state Zip Code p7 / 2/2q r+ Phone Number Fax Number(if applicable) 2. Representative (if any): F Scoff bra v Contact Name E-Mail Address `ZZZ � �-ee-f Mailing Address S3 'e n4A 61 of cityrrown State Zip Code R7 d- 7 45- 6060 5 Phone Number Fax Number(if applicable) B. Determinations 1. I request the -T _ p,� make the following determination(s). Check any that apply: ConserOdtion Commission ❑ a. whether the area depicted on plan(s)and/or map(s)referenced below is an area subject to jurisdiction of the Wetlands Protection Act. ❑ b.whether the boundaries of resource area(s)depicted on plan(s)and/or map(s)referenced below are accurately delineated. 5 'c.whether the work depicted on plan(s)referenced below is subject to the Wetlands Protection Act. ❑ d.whether the area and/or work depicted on plan(s)referenced below is subject to the jurisdiction of any municipal wetlands ordinance or bylaw of: Name of Municipality ❑ e.whether the following scope of alternatives is adequate for work in the Riverfront Area as depicted on referenced plan(s). wyafq l.dm•rev.07/14/04. - Page t of 4 r Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 1 Request for Determination of Applicability Cityrrown Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 C. Project Description 1. a. Project Location (use maps and plans to identify the location of the area subject to this request): Street Address C4rrown m �� 4 10+5 z6 S z� Assessors ap/Plat Number Parcel/Lot Number b. Area Description (use additional paper, if necessary): ci tJS� J a L_ L OCG} -�' a J t7 to (,rr�.. 'er- t Co tJ1 e 161-A ',SI (n(7� 4t') Cay. Gt�d��pr��tr-es c 14 W t h-�.An/✓ l S LLill hL —moi�'C iM r 'i c. Plan and/or Map Reference(s): fl&+ (a w rr ) l-Rvo rQ CGt-�-{-oLd,z,Q � A)d J. Z 3;QJ /- Title l Title Date Title Date 2. a. Work Description (use additional paper and/or provide plan(s)of work, if necessary): �(� peU r c5 eef I�1 I .�, �vt� w � b n � ( l✓6 5� t wt oro J t'Irn v°r t{s GleOfA,3Y ok, �h IJ Lbs+tnh t wpatormt.doc•rev.07/14/04. - Page 2 0!4 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 1- Request for Determination of Applicability atyRow� Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 C. Project Description (cont.) b. Identify provisions of the Wetlands Protection Act or regulations which may exempt the applicant from having to file a Notice of Intent for all or part of the described work(use additional paper, if necessary). 3. a. If this application is a Request for Determination of Scope of Alternatives for work in the Riverfront Area, indicate the one classification below that best describes the project. ❑ Single family house on a lot recorded on or before 8/1/96 ❑ Single family house on a lot recorded after 8/1/96 ❑ Expansion of an existing structure on a lot recorded after 8/1/96 ❑ Project, other than a single family house or public project,where the applicant owned the lot before 8/7/96 ❑ New agriculture or aquaculture project ❑ Public project where funds were appropriated prior to 8/7/96 ❑ Project on a lot shown on an approved, definitive subdivision plan where there is a recorded deed restriction limiting total alteration of the Riverfront Area for the entire subdivision ❑ Residential subdivision; institutional, industrial, or commercial project ❑ Municipal project ❑ District, county, state, or federal government project ❑ Project required to evaluate off-site alternatives in more than one municipality in an Environmental Impact Report under MEPA or in an alternatives analysis pursuant to an application for a 404 permit from the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers or 401 Water Quality Certification from the Department of Environmental Protection. b. Provide evidence(e.g., record of date subdivision lot was recorded) supporting the classification above(use additional paper and/or attach appropriate documents, if necessary.) j wpafarmi.daa•rev.07/14/04. . Page 3 014 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection -Wetlands Cityrrown WPA Form 1- Request for Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 D. Signatures and Submittal Requirements I hereby certify under the penalties of perjury that the foregoing Request for Determination of Applicability and accompanying plans, documents, and supporting data are true and complete to the best of my knowledge. I further certify that the property owner, if different from the applicant, and the appropriate DEP Regional Office (see Attachment)were sent a complete copy of this Request (including all appropriate documentation)simultaneously with the submittal of this Request to the Conservation Commission. Failure by the applicant to send copies in a timely manner may result in dismissal of the Request for Determination of Applicability. Name and address of the property owner: t) 1A I4S. & d�a� Name LT 6�6eV 4r e e+ Mailing Address Sal�wt City/Town MA- State Zip Code Signatures: I also understand that notification of this Request will be placed in a local newspaper at my expense in a=a � with Section 10.05(3)(b)(1)of the Wetlands Protection Act regulations. g"', 17,&44- Signature 29Applicant Dates Signature of Representative(if any) Date ( wparormi.a«•rev.omaw. Page 4 of 4 V`r Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands 1 WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 A. General Information Important: When filling out From: forms on the SALEM computer,use Conservation Commission only the tab key to move To: Applicant Property Owner(if different from applicant): your cursor- do not use the Douglas&Jean Karam SAME return key. Name Name y�� 91 Essex Street 1 V ° Mailing Address Mailing Address Salem MA 01970 City/Town State Zip Code Citylrown State Zip—Coda- 1 ode 1. Title and Date (or Revised Date if applicable)of Final Plans and Other Documents: Plot Plan of Land 25 Winter Island Road November 23, 2004 Title Date Title Date Title Date 2. Date Request Filed: December 30, 2004 B. Determination Pursuant to the authority of M.G.L. c. 131, § 40, the Conservation Commission considered your Request for Determination of Applicability, with its supporting documentation, and made the following Determination. Project Description (if applicable): The addition of an existing deck and clearing of some shrubs in the northern portion of the property. Project Location: 25 Winter Island Road Salem, MA Street Address Cityrrown MAP 44 LOT 25&26 Assessors Map/Plat Number Parcel/Lot Number wpafor 2.doc•rev.7/13106 Page 1 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) The following Determination(s) is/are applicable to the proposed site and/or project relative to the Wetlands Protection Act and regulations: Positive Determination Note: No work within the jurisdiction of the Wetlands Protection Act may proceed until a final Order of Conditions (issued following submittal of a Notice of Intent or Abbreviated Notice of Intent)has been received from the issuing authority (i.e., Conservation Commission or the Department of Environmental Protection). ❑ 1. The area described on the referenced plan(s) is an area subject to protection under the Act. Removing,filling,dredging, or altering of the area requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 2a. The boundary delineations of the following resource areas described on the referenced plan(s)are confirmed as accurate. Therefore, the resource area boundaries confirmed in this Determination are binding as to all decisions rendered pursuant to the Wetlands Protection Act and its regulations regarding such boundaries for as long as this Determination is valid. ❑ 2b. The boundaries of resource areas listed below are not confirmed by this Determination, regardless of whether such boundaries are contained on the plans attached to this Determination or to the Request for Determination. ❑ 3. The work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s) is within an area subject to protection under the Act and will remove, fill, dredge, or alter that area. Therefore, said work requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 4. The work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s) is within the Buffer Zone and will alter an Area subject to protection under the Act. Therefore, said work requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 5. The area and/or work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s) is subject to review and approval by: Name of Municipality Pursuant to the following municipal wetland ordinance or bylaw: Name Ordinance or Bylaw Citation .p form2.doc•rev.7/13/04 Page 2 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) ❑ 6. The following area and/or work, if any, is subject to a municipal ordinance or bylaw but not subject to the Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act: ❑ 7. If a Notice of Intent is filed for the work in the Riverfront Area described on referenced plan(s) and document(s), which includes all or part of the work described in the Request, the applicant must consider the following alternatives. (Refer to the wetland regulations at 10.58(4)c. for more information about the scope of alternatives requirements): ❑ Alternatives limited to the lot on which the project is located. ❑ Alternatives limited to the lot on which the project is located, the subdivided lots, and any adjacent lots formerly or presently owned by the same owner. ❑ Alternatives limited to the original parcel on which the project is located, the subdivided parcels, any adjacent parcels, and any other land which can reasonably be obtained within the municipality. ❑ Alternatives extend to any sites which can reasonably be obtained within the appropriate region of the state. Negative Determination Note: No further action under the Wetlands Protection Act is required by the applicant. However, if the Department is requested to issue a Superseding Determination of Applicability, work may not proceed on this project unless the Department fails to act on such request within 35 days of the date the request is post-marked for certified mail or hand delivered to the Department. Work may then proceed at the owner's risk only upon notice to the Department and to the Conservation Commission. Requirements for requests for Superseding Determinations are listed at the end of this document. ❑ 1. The area described in the Request is not an area subject to protection under the Act or the Buffer Zone. ❑ 2. The work described in the Request is within an area subject to protection under the Act, but will not remove, fill, dredge, or alter that area. Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent. 3. The work described in the Request is within the Buffer Zone, as defined in the regulations, but will not alter an Area subject to protection under the Act. Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent, subject to the following conditions (if any). ❑ 4. The work described in the Request is not within an Area subject to protection under the Act (including the Buffer Zone). Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent, unless and until said work alters an Area subject to protection under the Act. wpaform2 dm•rev.7/13/04 Page 3 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) ❑ 5. The area described in the Request is subject to protection under the Act. Since the work described therein meets the requirements for the following exemption, as specified in the Act and the regulations, no Notice of Intent is required: Exempt Activity(site applicable statuatory/regulatory provisions) ❑ 6. The area and/or work described in the Request is not subject to review and approval by: Name of Municipality Pursuant to a municipal wetlands ordinance or bylaw. Name Ordinance or Bylaw Citation C. Authorization This Determination is issued to the applicant and delivered as follows: ❑ by hand delivery on by certified mail, return receipt requested on Date Date This Determination is valid for three years from the date of issuance (except Determinations for Vegetation Management Plans which are valid for the duration of the Plan). This Determination does not relieve the applicant from complying with all other applicable federal, state, or local statutes, ordinances, bylaws, or regulations. This Determination must be signed by a majority of the Conservation Commission. A copy must be sent to the appropriate DEP Regional Office(see Attachment)and the property owner(if different from the applicant). Signatures: January 13, 2005 Date wpaform2.d0c•rev.7/13/04 Page 4 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 D. Appeals The applicant, owner, any person aggrieved by this Determination, any owner of land abutting the land upon which the proposed work is to be done, or any ten residents of the city or town in which such land is located, are hereby notified of their right to request the appropriate Department of Environmental Protection Regional Office (see Attachment)to issue a Superseding Determination of Applicability. The request must be made by certified mail or hand delivery to the Department, with the appropriate filing fee and Fee Transmittal Form (see Request for Departmental Action Fee Transmittal Form) as provided in 310 CMR 10.03(7)within ten business days from the date of issuance of this Determination.A copy of the request shall at the same time be sent by certified mail or hand delivery to the Conservation Commission and to the applicant if he/she is not the appellant. The request shall state clearly and concisely the objections to the Determination which is being appealed. To the extent that the Determination is based on a municipal ordinance or bylaw and not on the Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act or regulations, the Department of Environmental Protection has no appellate jurisdiction. wpalo"2.dcc•rev.7/13/04 Page 5 of 5 I UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail Postage&Fees Paid LISPS Permit No.G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box • I I I I c3 I �o �--4 D Salem Conservation Commission Z O 2- 120 120 Washington Street,3rd H :� Salem,MA 01970 <n / M z N p z o M F1190 I II 1 SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY ■ Complete items 1,2,and 3.Also complete A. Signature item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. ❑Agent ■ Print your name and address on the reverse X 0 Addressee so that we can return the card to you. B. Receivedby-(.Footed Name) C. Date of Delivery ■ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece, -` or on the front if space permits. D. I li am rent from item 1? 0 Yes 1. Article Addressed to: 14 Y 9z er ery addre w: ❑No Department of Environmental Pr tection Jf1 Al iWERO - Wetlands & Waterw ys w - 5th Floor, One Winter Stree 3. s rvice Type V 4L" Certified Mail 0 Express Mail Boston,MA 32108 .O 0 Registered.. 0 Return Receipt or Merchandise ' 0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D. 4. Restricted Delivery?(Extra Fee) r 0 Yes 2. Article Number 7002 2410 0003 2794 6337 (transfer from service IabeQ PS Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-02-M-1540 UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE First-Class Mail Posta USPSge 8 Fees Paid Permit No.G-10 • Sender: Please print your name, address, and ZIP+4 in this box Uj as w zo N uJ Salem Conservation Commission Uj; aq 120 Washington Street 3rd R z Salem,MA 01970 Q 2E w 2E U f y� U W(" 1C - I SENDER: COMPLETE THIS SECTION COMPLETE THIS SECTION ON DELIVERY • Complete items 1,2,and ry Also complete A. nature item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired. 0 Agent ■ Print your name and address on the reverse I"' 0 Addressee I so that we can return the card to you. B. Received by(Printed Name) C. Date of Delivery ■ Attach this card to the back of the Tailpiece, or on the front if space permits. 1. Article Addressed to: D. Is delivery address different from item 1? 0 Yes (�` If YES,enter delivery address below: 0 No l'I Df7Jc,Ila, 4 1e ✓ay, GMMp�qj� �1 ✓ESSeX S� `'QY 910 O r �0.JAN 1 /rviceT e 10ertifi Mail 0 Express Mail 0 Regist0 Return Receipt for Merchandise ❑Insyreed Mail 0 C.O.D. 1! 34. Res rl tc&Deliver?(Extra Fee) 0 Yes -r 2. Article Number 7002 2410 0003 2794 6344 (rmnsfer from service laben I PS Form 3811, February 2004 Domestic Return Receipt 102595-02-Ma5ao: U.S. Postal Service.. CERTIFIED MAILrM RECEIPT (Domestic Mail Only;No Insurance Coverage Provided) For delivery information visit our website at www.usps.coma -. Ps Form 3800,June 2002.:, l See Reverse for Instructions Certified Mail Provides: zest-w-zo-seszot r. A mailing receipt aces eunr'ooee uaoj Sd ■ A unique Identifier for your mailpiece ■ A record of delivery kept by the Postal Service for two years Important Reminders: ■ Certified Mall may ONLY be combined with First-Class Malla or Priority Meila. ■ Certified Mail is not available for any class of international mail. ■ NO INSURANCE COVERAGE IS PROVIDED with Certified Mall. For valuables,please consider Insured or Registered Mail. ■ For an additional fee,a Return Receipt mar be requested to provide proof of. delivery.To obtain Return Receipt service,please complete and attach a Retum Receipt(PS Form 38111 to the article and add applicable postage to cover the fee.Endorse mailpiece 'Rehm Receipt Requested".To receive a fee waiver for a duplicate return receipt,a USPS®postmark on your Certified Mail receipt is required. ■ For an additional fee, delivery may be restricted to the addressee or addressee's authorized ag9ent.Advise the clerk or mark the mallpiece with the endorsement"RestrictedDefivery°. ■ If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt Is desired,0tease present the arti- cle at the post office for postmarking. If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt is not needed,detach and affix label with postage and mail. IMPORTANT: Save this receipt andpresent it when making an Inquiry. Internet access to delivery Information is not available on mail addressed to APOs and FPOs. U.S. Postal Servim. � CERTIFIED MAIL. RECEIPT - m m (Domestic Mail Only;No Insurance Coverage Provided) o' I 1 r` nl Postage $ I M Corded Pee 0 M Retum Redept Fee Postmark EZI (El dorsemerd Required) Here O Re6eloted Delivery Fee r-q (EMorsemeat Required) _ — fLl Total PoSfagr N Department of Environmental Protection MLNERO -Wetlands & Waterways 0 r 5ttt Floor, One Winter Street Boston,MA 02108 rr Certified Mail Provides: dest'w-do-sssdot ■ A mailing receipt (eva^aal flood aunr,OOK=0J sd ■ A unique identifier for your mailpiece • A record of delivery kept by the Postal Service for two years Important Reminders: ■ Certified Mall may ONLY be combined with First-Class Mails or Priority Malta. ■ Cer ined Mail is not available for any class of Irdemanonal mall. ■ NO INSURANCE COVERAGE IS PROVIDED with Certified Mail. For valuables,please consider Insured or Registered Mail. ■ For an additional fee,a Return Receipt may be requested to rovide proof of tlelivery.To obtain Return Receipt service,please complete end attach a Return Receipt(PS Form 3811)to the article,and add applicable postage to cover the fee.Endorse mailpiece"Return Receipt Requested".To receive a fee waiver for a duplicate return receipt,a USPSs postmark on your Certified Mail receipt is required. ■ For an additlonal fee, delivery may be restricted to the addresses or addressee's authorized ag9ent.Advise the clerk or mark the mailpiece with the endorsement"RestricfedVelivery". • If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt Is desired,Please present the arti- cle at the post office for postmarking. If a postmark on the Certified Mail receipt is not needed,detach and affix label with postage and mall. , IMPORTANT:Save this receipt andpresent it when making an Inquiry. Internet access to delivery information is not available on mall addressed to APOs and FPOs. =s' Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands 1 WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 A. General Information Important: When filling out From: forms on the SALEM computer, use Conservation Commission only the tab key to move To: Applicant Property Owner(if different from applicant): your cursor- do not use the Douglas & Jean Karam SAME return key. Name Name °VQ 91 Essex Street 1 Mailing Address Mailing Address Salem MA 01970 City/Town State Zip Code City/Town State Zip Code 1. Title and Date (or Revised Date if applicable)of Final Plans and Other Documents: Plot Plan of Land 25 Winter Island Road November 23, 2004 Title Date Title- Date Title Date 2. Date Request Filed: December 30, 2004 B. Determination Pursuant to the authority of M.G.L. c. 131, § 40, the Conservation Commission considered your Request for Determination of Applicability, with its supporting documentation, and made the following Determination. Project Description (if applicable): The addition of an existing deck and clearing of some shrubs in the northern portion of the property. Project Location: 25 Winter Island Road Salem, MA Street Address City/Town MAP 44 LOT 25&26 Assessors Map/Plat Number Parcel/Lot Number wpaforrn2 doc•rev.7113104 Page 1 of 5 I Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) The following Determination(s) is/are applicable to the proposed site and/or project relative to the Wetlands Protection Act and regulations: Positive Determination Note: No work within the jurisdiction of the Wetlands Protection Act may proceed until a final Order of Conditions (issued following submittal of a Notice of Intent or Abbreviated Notice of Intent)has been received from the issuing authority (i.e., Conservation Commission or the Department of Environmental Protection). ❑ 1. The area described on the referenced plan(s)is an area subject to protection under the Act. Removing,filling, dredging, or altering of the area requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 2a. The boundary delineations of the following resource areas described on the referenced plan(s) are confirmed as accurate. Therefore, the resource area boundaries confirmed in this Determination are binding as to all decisions rendered pursuant to the Wetlands Protection Act and its regulations regarding such boundaries for as long as this Determination is valid. ❑ 2b. The boundaries of resource areas listed below are not confirmed by this Determination, regardless of whether such boundaries are contained on the plans attached to this Determination or to the Request for Determination. ❑ 3. The work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s) is within an area subject to protection under the Act and will remove, fill, dredge, or alter that area. Therefore, said work requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 4. The work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s) is within the Buffer Zone and will alter an Area subject to protection under the Act. Therefore, said work requires the filing of a Notice of Intent. ❑ 5. The area and/or work described on referenced plan(s)and document(s)is subject to review and approval by: Name of Municipality Pursuant to the following municipal wetland ordinance or bylaw: Name Ordinance or Bylaw citation .p form2.doc•rev.7113/04 Page 2 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) ❑ 6. The following area and/or work, if any, is subject to a municipal ordinance or bylaw but not subject to the Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act: ❑ 7. If a Notice of Intent is filed for the work in the Riverfront Area described on referenced plan(s) and document(s), which includes all or part of the work described in the Request, the applicant must consider the following alternatives. (Refer to the wetland regulations at 10.58(4)c. for more information about the scope of alternatives requirements): ❑ Alternatives limited to the lot on which the project is located. ❑ Alternatives limited to the lot on which the project is located, the subdivided lots, and any adjacent lots formerly or presently owned by the same owner. ❑ Alternatives limited to the original parcel on which the project is located, the subdivided parcels, any adjacent parcels, and any other land which can reasonably be obtained within the municipality. ❑ Alternatives extend to any sites which can reasonably be obtained within the appropriate region of the state. Negative Determination Note: No further action under the Wetlands Protection Act is required by the applicant. However, if the Department is requested to issue a Superseding Determination of Applicability, work may not proceed on this project unless the Department fails to act on such request within 35 days of the date the request is post-marked for certified mail or hand delivered to the Department. Work may then proceed at the owner's risk only upon notice to the Department and to the Conservation Commission. Requirements for requests for Superseding Determinations are listed at the end of this document. ❑ 1. The area described in the Request is not an area subject to protection under the Act or the Buffer Zone. ❑ 2. The work described in the Request is within an area subject to protection under the Act, but will not remove, fill, dredge, or alter that area.Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent. 3. The work described in the Request is within the Buffer Zone, as defined in the regulations, but TTTCCC will not alter an Area subject to protection under the Act. Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent, subject to the following conditions (if any). ❑ 4. The work described in the Request is not within an Area subject to protection under the Act (including the Buffer Zone). Therefore, said work does not require the filing of a Notice of Intent, unless and until said work alters an Area subject to protection under the Act. wpalcrt Zdoc•rev.7113104 Page 3 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 B. Determination (cont.) ❑ 5. The area described in the Request is subject to protection under the Act. Since the work described therein meets the requirements for the following exemption, as specified in the Act and the regulations, no Notice of Intent is required: Exempt Activity(site applicable statuatory/regulatory provisions) ❑ 6. The area and/or work described in the Request is not subject to review and approval by: Name of Municipality Pursuant to a municipal wetlands ordinance or bylaw. Name Ordinance or Bylaw citation C. Authorization This Determination is issued to the applicant and delivered as follows: ❑ by hand delivery on by certified mail, return receipt requested on I 165 Date Date This Determination is valid for three years from the date of issuance (except Determinations for Vegetation Management Plans which are valid for the duration of the Plan). This Determination does not relieve the applicant from complying with all other applicable federal, state, or local statutes, ordinances, bylaws, or regulations. This Determination must be signed by a majority of the Conservation Commission.A copy must be sent to the appropriate DEP Regional Office (see Attachment)and the property owner(if different from the applicant). Signatures January 13, 2005 Date wpafo"2.doc•rev.7/13/04 Page 4 of 5 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Resource Protection - Wetlands WPA Form 2 — Determination of Applicability Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act M.G.L. c. 131, §40 D. Appeals The applicant, owner, any person aggrieved by this Determination, any owner of land abutting the land upon which the proposed work is to be done, or any ten residents of the city or town in which such land is located, are hereby notified of their right to request the appropriate Department of Environmental Protection Regional Office (see Attachment)to issue a Superseding Determination of Applicability. The request must be made by certified mail or hand delivery to the Department, with the appropriate filing fee and Fee Transmittal Form (see Request for Departmental Action Fee Transmittal Form)as provided in 310 CMR 10.03(7)within ten business days from the date of issuance of this Determination.A copy of the request shall at the same time be sent by certified mail or hand delivery to the Conservation Commission and to the applicant if he/she is not the appellant. The request shall state clearly and concisely the objections to the Determination which is being appealed. To the extent that the Determination is based on a municipal ordinance or bylaw and not on the Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act or regulations, the Department of Environmental Protection has no appellate jurisdiction. wpafo"2.doc•rev.7113104 Page 5 of 5 0 v CITY OF SALEM CONSERVATION COMMISSION City of Salem Conservation Commission Will hold a public hearing for a Request for Determination of Applicability under the Wetlands Protection Act, Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 131, Section 40 and Salem's Ordinance Pertaining to General Wetlands at the request of Douglas & Jean Karam, 91 Essex Street, Salem, MA 01970. The purpose of this hearing is for a determination regarding the addition of an existing porch within a Buffer Zone to a Coastal Bank at 25 Winter Island Road. This hearing will be held on Thursday,January 13,2005 at 6:00 p.m,in City Hall Annex,Room 313, 120 Washington Street. ?6caa . A . Cornacchio Chairman January 6; 2005 Please send bill to: Douglas & Jean Karam 91 Essex Street Salem, MA 01970 978-741-2179 120 WASHINGTON STREET, SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 TEL: 978.745.9595 FAx: 978.740.0404 0 WWW.SALEM.COM THE FOLLOWING IS/ARE THE BEST __ . -IMAGES FROIVLPOOR .._. . QUALITY ORIGINALS) mS �C(�� F L DATA City of Salem Department of Planning & Community Development Check/Cash Receipt and Tracking Form Please complete form and make two copies. Date Received 121 3p a Amount Received 4L5.0& Form of Payment Check Cash CHECK PAYMENTS: write check number CASH PAYMENTS: write client Initials Q Sign PermR Application Fee WConservation Commission Fee Payment received for 0 Planning Board Fee what service? Q old Town Hall Rental Fee Q Other Name of staff person receiving payment fah �C �e �na Additional Notes �fn /ryes x �+ S F6f1F �£ .iscyr %enyr 4�7�4 ppb / si l u x<E;"," � ., 1 u ''r �= i Sit �• � ..,, _ �,$ TINTI, QUINN, GROVER & FREY, P.C. 222 ESSEX STREET SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970-3705 WILLIAM J.TINTI TELEPHONE WILLIAM B.ARDIFF(1%5. 1995) tinti®Nntilaw.wm (978)7454M5 • (978)7442948 MARCIA MULFORD CINI WILLIAM F.QUINN WilliamFQuinn®aol.wm TELECOPIFR OF COUNSEL SCOTT M.GROVER (978)7453369 www.tintiiaw.tom emgrover®tintilaw.wm MARC P.FREY mpfrey®tintilaW.wm January 25, 2005 Mr. Thomas St. Pierre Building Inspector City of Salem 120 Washington Street Salem, MA 01970 Re: 25 Winter Island Road Douglas J. Karam and Jean Olsson Dear Tom: As follow-up to our recent conversation relating to the Board of Appeal's approval of the application for zoning relief at 25 Winter Island Road, I am writing to clarify our understanding that the approval allows the Karams to perform the following: 1. Reconstruct the house on the original footprint of the existing house, along with expanding the existing third half story to a full third floor which will not exceed the overall zoning ridge height requirement of 35 feet. 2. Provide front set backs that are: a. Front stairs: 5'0" b. Window bay: 6'0" The above dimensions are as shown on the plans that were submitted with the original application and approved by the Board. Thank you for your understanding and assistance with these clarifications. Very t y yours, AV. G/rgover' 0025 WINTER ISLAND ROAD 731-05 GIS #: 6338 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS 'Map: 144 Block: CITY OF SALEM Lot: 0025 Category: 434 Residential. addlti` Permit# 73105 BUILDING PERMIT Project# JS-2005-0790 Est. Cost: $30,000.00 Fee: $1,805.00 Const. Class: PERMISSION IS HEREBY GRANTED TO: Use Group: Contractor: License: Lot Size(sq. ft.): 13000 Groom Construction CONSTRUCTIO SUPERVISOR-060887 Zoning: IRI jOWner: DOUGLAS &JEAN KARAM Units Gained: - IApplieant: DOUGLAS &JEAN KARAM Units Lost: Dig Safe#: AT: 0025 WINTER ISLAND ROAD ISSUED ON: 01-Mar-2005 AMENDED ON: EXPIRES ON: 26-Sep-2005 TO PERFORM THE FOLLOWING WORK. DEMOLISH AND REBUILD PER BOARD OF APPEAL POST THIS CARD SO IT IS VISIBLE FROM THE STREET Electric Gas Plumbin¢ Building Underground: Underground: Underground: Excavation: Service Meter: Footings: Rough: Rough: Rough: Foundation: Final: Final: Final: Rough Frame: Fireplace/Chitmrey: D.P.W. Fire Health Insulation: Meter: Oil: Final: Clouse# Smoke: Treasury: Water: Alarm: Sewer: Sprinklers: THIS PERMIT MAY BE REVOKED BY THE CITY OF SALEM UPON VIOLATION OF ANY OF ITS RULES AND REGULATIONS. Signature: Fee Type: Receipt No: Date Paid: Check No: Amount: BUILDING REC-2005-001001 28-Feb-05 3478 $1,805.00 GeoTMS®2005 Des Lauriers Municipal Solutions,Inc. J CITY OF SALEM,.MA CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS CLERK'S OFFICE BOARD OF APPEAL 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR 'U' lOOU DEC 23 A N �y �� SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 L L STANLEY J. LISOVICZ, JR. TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 MAYOR FAX: 978-740-9846 DECISION ON THE PETITION OF DOUGLAS & JEAN OLSSON KARAM REQUESTING A SPECIAL PERMIT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD R-1 A hearing on this petition was held on December 15, 2004 with the following Board Members present: Nina Cohen, Chairman, Richard Dionne Bonnie Belair, Nicholas Halides and Steven Pinto. Notice of the hearing was sent to abutters and others and notices of the hearing were properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A. Petitioner requests a Special Permit to allow reconstruction and expansion of existing nonconforming structure for the property located at 25 Winter Island Road located in an R-1 zone. The provision of the Salem Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request for a Special Permit is section 5-3 (2) (8), which provides as follows: Notwithstanding anything to the contrary appearing in this Ordinance, the Board of Appeal may, in accordance with the procedure and conditions set forth in Section 8-6 and 9-4, grant Special Permits for alterations and reconstruction of nonconforming structures, and for changes, enlargement, extension of expansion, of nonconforming lots, land, structures, and uses, provided however, that such change, extension, enlargement of expansion shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood. In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests, guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health, safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants. A. Special conditions and circumstances exist which especially affect the land, building or structure involved and which are not generally affecting other lands, buildings or stuctures in the same district. B. Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve Substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the petitioner. C. Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and Without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. The Board of Appeal, after careful consideration of the evidence presented, and after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact DECISION ON THE PETITION OF DOUGLAS &JEAN OLSSON KARAM REQUESTING A SPECIAL PERMIT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD R-1 page two 1. The Petitioner's Douglas &Jean Olsson Karam own a nonconforming house and adjacent lot at 25 Winter Island Road. They wish to reconstruct the house for use as their family residence. 2. According to elevations and plans drawn by Peter Pickman Architects, their planned reconstruction will vary the terms of the Ordinance by expanding the side to within 7 feet of the lot line, and the front of the house to within 6 feet of the front lot line. 3. The planned reconstruction will not expand will not expand the overall height of the house, which is 32 feet, but by creating dormers will extend the roof to create a third floor where previously the house had 21rz . 4. The plans have been explained to the neighbors, all of whom support the Karam's plan. One neighbor, Jane Dionne attended the meeting in order to voice her support for the Karams. They also had the support of Joseph O'Keefe, Ward 7 City Councillor and Lucy Corchardo, Ward 1 City Councillor. 5. There was no opposition to the petition. On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at the hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows; 1. Literal enforcement of the provisions of the ordinance would involve substantial hardship on the petitioner. 2. The relief requested can be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. 3. The Special Permit granted can be granted in harmony with the neighborhood and will promote the public health, safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants. 4. Special conditions exist which especially affect the subject property, but not the district in general. On the basis of the above findings of fact, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted 5 favor and 0 in opposition to grant the Special Permit requested, subject to the following conditions; 1. Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statues, codes ordinances and Cl) regulations. �p T> �3 i DECISION OF THE PETITION OF DOUGLAS AND JEAN OLSSON KARAM REQUESTING A SPECIAL PERMIT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT 25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD R-1 page two 2. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relate to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to 3. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department shall be strictly adhered to. 4. Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. 5. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including but not limited to, the Planning Department. Special Permit Granted December 15, 2004 4, a"('5c 1' Nina Cohen, Chairman Board Of Appeal A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17, of MGL Chapter 40A, and shall be filed within 20 days after the date of filing of this decision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A, Section 11, the Variance or Special Permit granted herein shall not take effect until a copy of the decision, bearing the certification of the City Clerk that the 20 days have elapsed and no appeal has been filed, or that, if such appeal has been filed, that is has been dismissed or denied is recorded in the South Essex Registry of Deeds and indexed under the name of the owner of record or is recorded and noted on the owner's Certificate of Title. C-1 r ted D �3 F J I MAP 44 LOT 23 PAUL C. O'SHEA 15 WINTER ISLAND RD. "o \ IRON \0 O IRON _ ROD ROD 1.1' N26'46'30"E 0.9 SET 1.1' \ SET 60.00' N26'46'30"E 60.00' j \ PROPOSED ADDITION 0- oC °o INTO EXISTING PORC 0, MAP 44 LOT 24 z EXISTING 2 1/2 '0,\:5%, ZONE A2 \oo TERI KALGREN w STORY DWELLING ZONE B 0 L419 WINTER ISLAND RD. Iwo EXISTING DWELLING, °� c (0A \ 1 O o PROPOSED PORCH OPOSED PORCH= m f PROPOSED —QECK—STEPS 18.0 \ ADDITION ' _ M A 44 LOTS 25 ,& 26 ,iG0 o ARE 6000 t S.F. Al C' 60.00' iv N - 60.00' S26'46'30"W STAKE/ 26'46'30"W \ IRON NAIL SET D ROD OLE SET WINTER ISLAND ROD SET \ 7AASSgCH ZONING DISTRICT -\EESIDENTIAL 1 GAIL NOTES: REQUIRED EXISTING PROPOSED SMITH y No.35043 ¢ 1. LOT NUMBERS REFER TO CITY OF SALEM ASSESSOR'S MAPS. LOT AREA 10,000 6000± 6000± PLOT PLAN OF LAND "OgsREcrsrER��e' FRONTAGE 100' 120' 120' 2. ZONING DISTRICT — RESIDENTIAL 1. 25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD s0"ALL SALEM (� , 3. THE PROPERTY SHOWN LIES WITHIN FLOOD ZONE B AND FRONT 20' 10.2' 7.8' PREPARED FOR ZONE A2 (EL 10) AS DELINEATED ON THE FEDERAL SIDE 15' 18.0' 18.0' DOUGLAS KARAM & EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY MAPS. ' JEAN KARAM REAR 15' 0.9' 1.1SCALE 1 " = 20' NOVEMBER 23, 2004 4. EXISTING BUILDING HEIGHT = 32.9 FEET. NORTH SHORE SURVEY CORPORATION BLDG HEIGHT 35' 32.9' 31.6' 47 LINDEN STREET, SALEM, MA #2379 MAP 44 LOT 23 PAUL C. O'SHEA 00 15 WINTER ISLAND RD. ,p \ IRON IRONROD _ ROD 1.1' N26'46'30"E 0.9' SET 11' _ SET 60.00' N26'46'30"E \ 60.00' j \ m PROPOSED ADDITION- ° Ifo o INTO EXISTING PORC °� °°' z MAP 44 LOT 24 z EXISTING 2 1/2 2Oo\,60%.� , ZONE A2 � \o¢ TERI KALGREN w Ln STORY DWELLING ZONE B 0 1 0^ 19 WINTER ISLAND RD. lu o EXISTING DWELLING,' °o o ul \ CA PROPOSED PORCH o PROPOSED ROPOSED PORCH= rd ADDITION 707-77 7-7 —QECK—STEPS 18.0' ` ; ��:, _ - _ MA 44 LOTS 25 & 26 `spa u 'o ARE = 6000 t S.F. �1T0 60.00' S26'46'30"WIRON STAKE/ 26'46'30"W \ ROD NAIL SET DOLE SET WINTER ISLAND ROD SET \ ZONING DISTRICT -\tESIDENTIAL 1 �o GAIL q NOTES: REQUIRED \\ EXISTING PROPOSED SMITH N No.350A3 1. LOT NUMBERS REFER TO CITY OF SALEM ASSESSOR'S MAPS. . LOT AREA 10,000 6000± 6000± PLOT PLAN OF LAND pOgs�FcisTe°��„e'er 5��AL LANA 2. ZONING DISTRICT — RESIDENTIAL 1. FRONTAGE 100' 120' 120' 25 WINTER ISLAND ROAD �'>„� a SALEM 3. THE PROPERTY SHOWN LIES WITHIN FLOOD ZONE B AND FRONT 20 10.2' 7.8' PREPARED FOR ZONE A2 (EL 10) AS DELINEATED ON THE FEDERAL SIDE 15' 18.0' 18.0 DOUGLAS KARAM & EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT AGENCY MAPS. JEAN KARAM REAR 15` 0.9' 1.1 SCALE 1 ” = 20' NOVEMBER 23, 2004 4. EXISTING BUILDING HEIGHT = 32.9 FEET. NORTH SHORE SURVEY CORPORATION BLDG HEIGHT 35' 32.9'- 31-.6' 47 LINDEN STREET, SALEM, MA #2379