Loading...
7 PARADIS ROAD - ZBA :«; 7 Paradis Rd. a/k/a Vinnin SquA , Snell Realty. Trust' i s (giN of ttlem, � ttsstttljuse##s �Boura of 'Ap " 9` o d 00 r� DECISION ON THE PETITION OF SNELL REALTY TRUST FOR VARIANCES AND SPECIAL:11 tn PERMIT AT 7 PARADISE ROAD (B-1) u' A hearing on this petition was held April 21, 1993 with the following Board Members present: Richard Bencal, Chairman; George Ahmed, Francis Grealish Jr. , Stephen Touchette and Associate Member Arthur Labrecque. Notice of the hearing was sent to abutters and others and notices of the hearing were properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A. Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit to alter nonconforming structure and use, and a Variance from parking to allow retail department stores within a shopping plaza and other accessory uses located within a shopping plaza as provided in Art.V (5-2) (e) permitted uses in B-2 district. The property is located in the B-1 district. The provision of the Salem Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request for a Special Permit is section 5-3(j ) , which provides as follows: Notwithstanding anything to the contrary appearing in this Ordinance, the Board of Appeal may, in accordance with the procedure and conditions set forth in Section 8-6 and 9-4, grant Special Permits for alterations and reconstruction of nonconforming structures, and for changes, enlargement, extension or expansion of nonconforming lots, land, structures, and uses, provided, however, that such change, extension, enlargement or expansion shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood. In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests, guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health, safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants. The Variances which have been requested may be granted upon a finding of the Board that: A. Special conditions and circumstances exist which especially affect the land, building or structure involved and which are not generally affecting other lands, buildings or structures in the same district. B. Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would involve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to the petitioner. DECISION ON THE PETITION OF SNELL REALTY TRUST FOR A SPECIAL PERMIT AND VARIANCE AT 7 PARADISE ROAD, SALEM page two C. Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the Ordinance. The Board of Appeal, after careful consideration of the evidence presented, and after viewing the plans, makes the following findings of fact: 1. Ward 7 Councillor, Mark Blair spoke in favor of the petition. 2. The was some opposition to the petitioners plan. 3. Retail business has been at that location for many years. 4. To limit the petitioners only to the allowed B-1 uses would create a hardship as the structures, even as they currently exist, are more in harmony with a retail shopping plaza as opposed to the allowed uses in the B-1 district, which is the neighborhood business . 5. The property is located directly across from a 3-2 district and borders a residential district. On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at the hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows: 1. Special conditions exist which especially affect the subject property but not the district in general. 2. Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involve substantial hardship on the petitioner. 3. The relief requested can be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. 4. The Special Permit granted can be granted in harmony with the neighborhood and will promote the public health, safety, convenience and welfare of the city's inhabitants. Therefore, the Zoning Board of Appeal voted unanimously, 5-0, to grant the relief requested, subject to the following conditions: 1. Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, codes ordinances and regulations. 2. All construction shall be done per the plans and dimensions submitted. 3 . Petitioner shall obtain a legal building permit for all work done. 4. All requirements of the Salem Fire Dept. relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. S? S a �T = 0 DECISION ON THE PETITION OF SNELL REALTY TRUST FOR A VARIANCE AND SPECIAL PERMIT AT 7 PARADISE ROAD, SALEM page three 5. Petitioners shall meet the requirement of all city boards having jurisdiction, including, but not limited to, the Conservation Commission, the Board of Health and the Planning Board. 6. Proper addresses shall be obtained from the City of Salem Assessor. 7. There shall be no pick ups or deliveries between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m. , seven (7) days a week. 8. Dumpster is to be screened, as described by petitioner, with a six (6) foot high wood fence which is to be maintained in perpetuity. 9. Lighting in the rear of the buildings is to be done with sensitivity to the abutting neighbors and not directed towards the abutting properties. 10. The fence along that runs along Vinnin St. is to be repaired and maintained in perpetuity. 11. Landscaping is to be maintained along Maple Ave. , as per the plans submitted. 12. The exit across from Salem St. , is to be an exit only and a right turn only. 13. A minimum of 258 legal, on-site parking spaces are to be maintained. 14. The parking variance shall not relieve the petitioner of their responsibilities with regard to the Americans With Disabilities Act. Special Permit and Variance Granted April 21, 1993 Francis X. Grealish, Jr. , Secretary Board of Appeal r� z 71 Lis � T --a DECISION OF THE PETITION OF SNELL REALTY TRUST FOR A VARIANCE AND SPECIAL PERMIT AT 7 PARADISE ROAD, SALEM page four A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of MGL Chapter 40A, and shall be filed within 20 days after the date of filing of this decision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A, Section 11, the Variance or Special Permit granted herein shall not take effect until a copy of the decision, bearing the certification of .the City Clerk that 20 days have elapsed and no appeal has been filed, or that, if such appeal has been filed, that it has been dismissed or denied is recorded in the South Essex Registry of Deeds and indexed under the name of the owner of record or is recorded and noted on the owner's Certificate of Title. Board of Appeal n a �o 2r� m u, '` ,�"���T� (1�it� oaf �ttlem; �Httsstttljusefts aurb of Pal keet•mti dS May 4, 1993 YOU ARE HEREWITH ADVISED THAT AS OF THIS DATE THE DECISION OF THE BOARD OF APPEAL HAS BEEN FILED IN THE OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK TO GRANT THE PETITION OF SNELL REALTY TRUST FOR A SPECIAL PERMIT AND VARIANCE TO ALLOW RETAIL STORES WITHIN A SHOPPING PLAZA AT 7 PARADISE ROAD. BOARD OF APPEAL BRENDA M. SUMRALL CLERK OF THE BOARD � I A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK. Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17, of MGL Chapter 40A, and shall be filed within 20 days after the date of filing of this decision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to MGL Chapter 40A. , Section 11, the Variance/Special Permit granted herein shall not take effect until a copy of the decision bearing the certification of the City Clerk that 20 days have elapsed and no appeal has been filed, or that, if such appeal has been filed, that it has been dismissed or denied is recorded in the South Essex Registry of Deeds and indexed under the name of the owner of record or is recorded and noted on the owner's Certificate of title. Board of Appeal r• i 1 1' ■ � , • � ► Y r I I , � ' • 1 I7 n 1 • 1 % 1 n • • 1 _ 1 f39(5F l &F3 f TO ..__SA.LEr�_S.! y_ .FtCIALS. __P� z4✓�!rv_ING._'3ar9R�2,--'9pf� LS __ ._,___,9/11�o_?9�v.�a�vt�_E1-SE._�-f_AVt�r.C•_f_j.v_T_N-au.f_i.[�y To__HEHR._C�S�S.__._._-- - ..- - _-------,----5-'-VELE �ZE�Z..T_}?TK_us._t_.��s s��_C_C�sso�Zs�,�{✓v�-.aJ_Z-__flssr6nr�. _V_WA) SQUAfL� f(RE'f fel _. _. Ccucf�,vS Q KE; -ESt-I�EiuTS`t tHE LI 5.q.,__ P£ .---- . _ ._�.vH.EN Co.,�v�_►DFI��d�—Zt{_E__.6.2�. _M__l_N-6__0..�_�PERrv��S.__td���. I - s Tai � S_HaP C_o_ S�uEI_L_[2£A-zT�'_�f2uFT ✓u�a�N..ElZ� ).)vES ___TSF A.�Edi£�fZo� za R1�6�w{R�S_So tt��uv t.�v Sa S poi _...f}TI..m > _SEE-K---Y-au1R SuP�a_R GAJ STaf'P- N.S _�9Jl)y�' _�_---j-)c�aR2E_KF Lr-ENr_Li.L49 Us�.✓_�.-£SS E�__r4-!up__�.5 k_ 9J_You_J2— - -_ C>—R---E s�DeA2nA t �.ti�E _EPEE R e- _. crc��£-- ivcJK a�4cdfar�"�_c�-6sa. s Zo�u�,vJ�_ lNF V�.voF2S�/�U_��.rn1'_a1ZT$.dtC�..���6-vs I JvE�S ____ _��_k__Ea_IZ T�f�- Q'�Flcls](,.5_- _✓��b____GiuS.l..�uf�s _cs�sfl.i.E✓v_�_._�.�_-- _To__._- R_EcQ_ ✓u1�.ES tlF .rna2�i�NC �ct- _a_u_lZ_.�_ -__-- - --_r-fi )(PAY ICR S�o._T Hf_c-�T)'_9�_S-f}_��lM _r9.✓U�_—W_E_ ��VE.__ a1N —TO-- -11--,(Y\- d—_Q''v\_EWil-}E--U1-✓v✓v) N_ S_�.uf}IZ� - --- -_-___.(.UF _�Oa✓v'� _ SEF_ K .Td__ST-o�'__Q�2.Or3s71_�_u._C7. ----------- --- QuSI )MESS _.ffCTl utTy -.ZN. THE _.f e<E5> S_TH ZCAJEZ-,:�% _lJE /EK- _ a� THYfT- .. WILL, _ E USUR4Z THC CCAIT-NUE� V,4ZUE OF OvK __.__(} OmES >�✓U,O C3uJz 1UEt6H6af�H o0�O ff iv�o THS 9T 0-ALL fj LS (3 sJI FE- -GulRc THE Qu( FT OF�RL_ � VES PA6£ aT 3 _........._ _(Y1l1ucl _ ___=.Nctu�� _._-PR6u�s�a,�s...__►=a�_...-�-_N.E -�.aL_t-aWt.,v_6 --________.___._ __ ---_-.yap ._rnAy_�2�✓vT_-_�-a _ STo_�-__r9N���..�a�____c� .,---�v_y�__ WE_ftSk THAT_Y_o�iR___Rv�.Fs__a5Z__co.iv� �.T�.a �s _./�PhZy_.�_ So -GHAT- _ w! 6uT_ WE_flS_X�aR__�__13_u��=ER Zo.JuE(3Et�u�EN-__Q-uSt�vfSS_ ` K_rt}jflT-5t0�45Na�'Co S_JUE.LL—Rg41.VTR. -- -_ER,-_/ GREE--7rH T __ H.c-j_ f-VO_'R___ .ti-- SZ—SuCCES°Pte_ �°lN'�.GTfZ---- _WE_f_�.K_Tti.�{T_-CHEFP(ZbV1oE uS l�i«�. ZIH.�__/v�ClL1� �. i--'R6r_v pEKSoNH Wf—Cf�/V G�C.Z S_t6UL ------ __C�E ----2EsLf�UJb9-NrS _ N_D__ a.RE Zir►P_Q 7-7 _L7 1�fs3 t_v_2 N_7 -_...C)u rn ST f_ s_ T_n�Qv ._� ESI__To.__ E —ff_L R� _J�.a•1�EnVr._e Aju? Sa._wF _ S THS-T--ZT_ -_Nd - A.UE. _ Nj'.._dQumS�` PS _. L ocfl7£C o ru --CT> egjuc� TP)flT__--r-T _- /vdT•_. us4CZ ___. .oR _ AAJ E NTK8.NX-C -- - )'- . Fd R_ _�ivy'-- �R1 UE -_ __w► �u ba.w T�' 4� TNEy Rfi;ERs To S:�'CP ca, sN,( C- - KfALT -t-9 0-5T (TSSuCCfjSOC`�S Aivc) cK i,�516NS AE IT rnflY pfi 6,F 3 of - ------------- '(WHO FRO (.V\ P,4 J9:L IL w lcc t --t--�Jf—Slj-R-;CS-�-o r—,n\- -UG j T A cu ---fz (V-Z> ---R—uZa-4c& TA.K- c S., --T- A 3 L Z -c.vr T, yq S4� .T __-- _ .a"W-CY.-T- SE--A-To 2f-S 19 s si\j-C -SC -,---Aj rU0-,Y-., ASK CHO FcjTL)R-E Pu6Lic mE7�-71A)61 -co,,,Jc-,RAA N6 TO M)97r(,- � i( THely REFEKS -To sToP co, SHELL Rf-OL-tX TRUST QTS SOCIC:�S7 :SoRS ?qAJ\0 OK 79SS16N S ,qS /-r MRY lif-PLX, PflsF /I��q3 — TO_C1TYQF_SF} LEr� PLAA(✓O,)IJV6 f.3afrRl� ; EALS__. H Lzc>�BN�a r NE2 R eE. ) -rI�� 2_c- ---- S�Nst�£SZ1L1�--G.LIIi•^� �� PrZ mo Sys_Zl._ _ly Ri I<Ivow,v TO us /� S ZZ--4 r -��`�1 SS /—rn 7Ly �a-(Z srCc)�c 2,�:)j z.nr LOWA"IN Scffy� e� �t_oLZ�,v� fjUENuF ��PR�I SE R a,R � arPFIRAD).Sf ,$T.Tn1 {�LFrn iE—Z4-51Q –Ps=o��.LiE �J,1E— HAVE" Q,Nr61N Ca.ti1CFRrJS ALin i TSF P3 [ noNSI 1 ` t3(7TWEEN QUSIAJESS ANCl _ ( ES 'LD-E".Y�q- L _�Zo_PC! zt/—:z ) cv,R—NI1cE/aoRl3-eolz> . So .r£ of a\J R Co n)C 1`r_ Ja Ste_ — TRr� F IC L\TIER LATC NI T 41E1 EV4eR\_F -- (yo� SE.�_ t�li_m�'sS_; C� Rt� \TT1 Aiv� rn L_a S LI -FHS 4ESTf3.BLjsymF✓yY of f} PESZN, 1nr�NT �� 1 -Za_A) �Tw .v glUP S ) -cAm ft? PR o_PE& TYi, W�'�L� f L\Y q T� N E oT� RTS S o mF T �t� of fl SSE FN.g.nJ7 1 P2�£�z�S—�cr�vRE ENCRo4crl— ev_ 22 A L - .�] -------�-TJ,�2_.S.o,>v�'E-R.N.S._?�-�-�w�__��aSf__���i'E GRfJ✓�"irJ6 - -- Ty l�l _ s ( Art.V, S 5-2 SALEM ZONING ORDINANCE USE REGULATIONS (d) B-1 Districts. The following are permitted (e) B-2 Districts. The following are permitted uses in the neighborhood business districts: uses in the highway business districts: (1) All uses permitted in R-3 Districts, subject (1) All uses permitted in B-1 Districts, subject to all the provisions specified for each use. to all provisions specified for such uses, ex- (2) Grocery, fruit, vegetable and meat stores, cept that all residential uses are prohib- delicatessens. ited. (3) Bakeries,provided that all baked goods are (2) Restaurants and other eating places in sold at retail on the premises only, which alcoholic beverages may be served (4) Drugstores. on the premises. (5) Stores selling liquor,beer and wine for con- (3) Motels. sumption off the premises. (4) Automobile service stations, subject to the (6) Newsstands and variety stores. restrictions of section 7-2. (7) Dry goods and notions stores. (5) Offstreet parking and loading facilities and other accessory uses and buildings, pro- vided that such uses are clearly incidental (9) Florist shops, but excluding greenhouses. to the principal use. (10) Hardware stores. (6) Supermarkets. (11) Banks and savings and loan institutions. (7) Retail department stores located within a' (12) Barber shops and beauty parlors. shopping plaza. (8) Other accessory uses located within a shop- (13) Laundry, dry cleaning and pressing estab• ping plaza. lishments,provided that not more than five (5) persons are engaged in providing such (9) Research and development facilities. services. (10) Publishing and printing establishments. (14) Self-service laundries. (11) Warehousing and distribution. (15) Tailor and custom dressmaking shops. (12) Laboratories, provided, however, that no (16) Shoe repair shops. noxious odors are emitted. (17) Radio, television and appliance repair (13) General office buildings and other similar shops, provided that not more than three and related uses. (3) persons are engaged in performing such services. (f) B-4 Districts. The following are permitted uses in the wholesale and automotive business (18) Professional offices, medical and dental districts: clinics. (19) Restaurants and other eating places which (1) Automobile service stations, subject to the do not serve alcoholic beverages consumed restrictions of section 7-2. on the premises and including drive-in res- (2) Automobile, trailer and boat sales and ser- taurants and drive-in snack shops. vice. (20) Municipal buildings. (3) Plumbing,carpentry and sheet metal shops. (21) Off-street parking and loading facilities and (4) Printing establishments. other accessory uses and buildings, pro- vided that such uses are clearly incidental (5) Sale and storage of building supplies. to the principal use. (6) Warehousing. 12 of:-3 __TO��LEra ---- -ANc.—6 iv ya.ry E L.SE---14 �a..._._- __; S .nr£LL �Z£�-L:T�—s3uS�c2s�s.�S.�:�s'��5--�{✓.vp_a�2?9sSr6n�_. --Ct tU l-N,•vv_v_S c�4X ___.F3orn Tti REs»F�rs OF TF1 V(NN)JV 5OV6RE ARC-OI'sALE'rn - -- ---- w f 0k 'CQ C-_v_s1�EK Qt u c{R.e1 S Q_ �f F -�S1_D_E�u rN� � To s t-o 4 �. �o—S✓u�l�L_K _L TC�vu��_�ik�ELZ T.N�(iF.J.f)5�71��N1� TSE AREA Ffto ✓h Lay►/IwIA) ESQ S1=atxa C V ±J9A) GE. L�a._r g S i AMA 1JU>? rner2-E JR-4F-T0oSAT iLflL-1fLN+��R_a rn 4-K, �T- A R£A VR d- ca_L_Lt:-6 A Pka�E�LEp A n, �_V tru- :z - -.� a C�--�Q.u.�.)_�v.�SS�N�fR. STS_._._.V.?�f_�.4SZ3—�}.S-.�,.--�..���• _ _ I-{ E l.P VS E�T_��3 LI_.-�__i3_v�E./_z_'z �,N£S C���u_£E✓U _ N✓ I C4-A77-(4L PLZo,�F2_Ty ICU T tnnAa2Titt �� 6v3ESS R_EcQ�✓u 12�E�HE— ��oZ N Cta_u_,L? _. w -1�>9.v� ;s. u�JZ-� _.- -- ----------_(_UE___�a✓v�r _ _ ____.Q u S► N.ES.S-__ff_C7'i_u tTy Z N._ THF�_AKfIfS�TN�4 t.__��E_._Q USlN._FSS. --- ElusuueE _ THE _Ca✓jTI/UUva oLAK IUEl6PsoKH oao -1gmo TH.HT U-J L Z f} LS (3 S -9c- . -GU.f}K C THE QU\ CT < 'A), -oylv\CJVT OF L 1 UES Pf16E ar- 3 --- ---_y_au—rnAy_�rz.>4✓vT_ a ---- s NE_ZtF�_�y �_ -r cam-• __. -T_a sNC.I.L-1ZEf}LT_)'TTS��cC�ESS6.czS__�9�ur� a�R_�sSi_��vS_ j"jq_T.:SZ[�4 5_ 1.0_�C o Sib tE1.L�ZE$1J ��I � a Ago L�.IU�o��u_�NEI-6r�13a_�t�_aa_l� tt flryN G__S�EsTRu.,f�}. .N_f R aLe ES J LZj'f�S J#�f �-G EY__✓UfL_icl� 7 Tts THRauS7n'v t :Suc _i9S�McpQL. - QUyZ..�£[�.._�IJU�_t__1�.�'N��'S._ESL.��S�E_Rcs'Qrnfl9M'1N�_ PF717.1a,N�___. (Z). -RS$fl D iSE-_fl VE_ &fS-LP4CfMA L _-STR4.E� q t _EuTRffNC'�Cx�-d}y--_�a(i__79N�'___�Rl.l!_�.=lk�19..►I�v�QW _T�'-�----- � � THEy REFERS To S�� g-5�1o� ca, ��tFC.L Kf �L?�' rtRUS(' lTS SvCC�SS02S Ajuz) aK f�SS 16A)S As IT rv»y APPLY, - PR6-c 3 0f3 Q ---- _ __comm �T$E o£�T. 1_ EE._REfl2ESETI-SES_ o �}�F _.__NE_l_G_H _LSA_�_►iuG_�PL�9N __f�6acJT___.. Cx�tTH_�P_K_ay.1s' ta•n1-s.___.T'N-flT=?--.�i-F=1V�4.Rt_a�s..--------- - _ Ca�vCE'I�NzZ,_._ -- __._l�-� ____.S3 l,L a_lzJ 4�•�L1y�cZa?�L��9��'�C.-_��1._�-�v_,I�_o v�_o_:F� _. --_----_-- _. L.a,�_.D��v�_ _��.�4T£S_-�_N_�J. T�fZfS--Q.,N L�a�}-•D�nt__G C$RCS- - _E _QE_EO- �P_£_ V-��Sl1UgQE�S3v nnE_L�� ES - _��NU _—_(�dw JJ. _ �A�) � aF eL. —C--K ----- - -- i� ---�ac�-_�S_k.1N�_-Ec`rrnQZ�EES —fid ----RE�(zfl_l✓V_ __F(Z_o+ —£ _c SSI_V_E—Na S_E -J�J9 13-= --- W Sk .T HAT C _- _Pu[�L1C___rr_1�11v�S ca�ucfl�tilNG__Tt-HIS (Y1.fjT�ER, - - ._ THely FEFERS -To SToP qw- S H OP co, SAv ELL R4fXIX -tRUsT- zTs succ�ssoRs qn/\c) or, fs-v(: Ns vis rr mRy _ lgppLX. _ Ta= cry-Q -st� lFN. , P4nrrJr:_rG RQ� RC� � s ._ < 7-6 us /4S .STa� SSP, 7� n/ ti s� ✓! N S�U�X� LoJ21 �� . —gNC--� N4�, C'a AJCFRN 'C3o _—TeyE__—JK-CLj' ONS_ffiA:- EE N Q us I t,1�cS Arl F.ATE RS r LL , rH� 4EST79-BLjSymEN-r GIF 4 ---- PESZrntjENi__ urE1Z__ zaZ ✓j -- 1 L�Krc�_pl�y�T� RTC S o mE' TSE' oy- fl SRFE�n.F.AST E1t1T d n]CvEF7s t o Fnm --.-a7,)4 f .�o NCc�NS 'r11 �iT w.__�_��EaS7�F--;C�1 -f—Gx, $ff;7ifJ-6 - ----o F zS_LJy_SP r� Z_._ � Nl lis fr7 ?H i S ?�m� C vE--w�.0 L�C -A-.._c o r'E Qj _arc � c�.ss v nn\ Z w E c� ,�s 1T__�d� n� _�{,i✓� --- T_tF _H —�J3,1�� S :I.�ELL_ - fZTy RFP Rsi�T1 --- - _ S�s�-c-9-1-F—Ly. -� 1 - . I�PLf4VC s61 Ern . SG G ucl ---- 2- Pis s� gllslg3 7-0_—c1Q _St �Fry -- Pc Anr✓��nr� � a,�RQ; ,�PP� �.s __ - -_ 13 or HNEwl RQARn 7-/4-,'4T T_c -- SoNsi RIrJG G1111" -C)rlL PgRmT 70 S�7�LZ n2T ' T2uST.�<nvawnf a us 11-S MOP � SfiaP�aR fjV�/�uE a �PR-kD 5E 1i_� of 219.Rj9D)SSf __.—E�bn�--L,`l�-�.�S1-t�FnrS o� T1-l���L✓J_S.�U�9L�f�.�._£li-_ AVE OJjc--zo ca.,ucgF<PJS ABaJL_ THE M 5D O NS I f aq-TwFEN Q u ;I r.IF_.,S'S A MC> So n� o-v, (v\.j 1?- (7,o ,,.)CERu < ),q tJa TRf�-y-r- , L \ SE R _ LATE /U NT f-) 1-1 EVER\ Md ST A L 3 '�f(� ES?AB� IS}� p�FN7 QF f} p PeKT ' '�Ls a—cxwyt ------ ! L\KF i n nA E aT\ ATS S o mE' Tx/ O: ff KP-CE .e'u—, PR�£�12t116�ir1_URE C�CRo�crd .. �ltj d.N a L -- J�€ d THEA—�aNCJJS ______�7;��.tZ d_JLU$-✓V Cmc - - 00f __s> N C.1L _ wE.__G __—S_tT—r aw n/ �}✓v� Ty s 8 I-Pi P tits - __ L.Z—1 C,41 T/ � 1Jy cS�NrCc---13.��i1.^JOSS . ' Le1HiC� rnA go- _—�Oj��-Cit HAVE aNG� .�� � Co.�1CF2rJS - 7'HE {�L�}��s t� � •�F'r W EE.N Q u�1 r.1F"S'S A✓J� - -- ---(ZES I.PE.tjj j3 L __-- Soffit of a� R cd �cFR�r��f /'J6/S TR fyV-7- l< L\TSE_R LA 14E N I CZ t47 p F1 F VER�F!S , ----- o Q�j_m, iv_Z 6 S-(' ay- AL1 a - .–.-------- 'ESZr�,� NEN%_ u Za_N_fZw�f�,� �_ 1_rVSs 8 ✓U t� 2Es�Pf�USl��—P1�.CD PF�CCY ,& W �LSa_---- I S o ME' TLF' or f} cSKFF�.�i Pfd "EA_ztA(� crv.RE CNCRo�c.)1 . E a.nJ QurZ 2ES10��tp&�—_ L ___K 4C E_S-T_�°—c o rte. L� _-�rC °_GCBs ._._U N'Ta L -- w E _ _G�✓J_—s iT_-_�a� nJ_ �,�� __ __ �I A -- 2l,�' li i2 tom_ �/�✓ _ �-I' T COCL`�cti Pi96F of:-3 f gIFF1CIA LS.�--PiA✓v ))VN6 _604.Ko..,_>9�P_��}lS .- ___..___d___l�.N�O���U�a✓v�ELSE -_�-f�f V_!NS__�VTk�.oU✓_�_i.Ty To__.(-JE�R__C�SES. __ . __-_.-__----.._._.fl�✓�!,o__-ss SUE-_�f/_�m..�Ts z�v.S�LE"n'1___. _ __._________- ..-- _____A_. 6.vs vccsso.R s ✓vo -QRZ_.�9ssr -----___ 13Y�_��y___O_�L-l_EP.-_�US_1NFS.S_E'/_�TJ'LT_,?���t•L�_VLN✓_vC✓I/-5-�.(tR� JutSd�.T_H� l/��iry l�J S A R< 14R E"A _C"F Ais ___..___. cQ..ucE,�.Ns___o_��L��✓�.FSI.�E�uT-s__-��->`^H_E�v_�..�wv1�v_s�,_�f�KE�_.�_. -.--- _ ._W H f/_V. Co-✓vs To - s To S.HI.O_\P—C o.S✓uE L_L _L1 y T_f2u s��q n„�,aH_E1t3a1N_F_Ss�J �— _ h- N G_E,F_6_N�,RES rn er(ZE—RFs 1_o.EM1fLZ_—L f3N_ ��Z a!�_�E�¢n�1 ia1_6_C3-uSllu£SS Z CAZi u 0J2_—Yvu.R—I1ELf_> rz A _LY_i_,,9 Ka-.e)_6___-- E HELP US EJ{_._Za N C _e_CT u£E✓U___._.._ _ rC3.vs L_V Es.S.-_74�v o2 7 iC>Civ_T_ _L.._P_R.5:2.fj W�_LS-O------- ___ F ---__._Td__ R EC_a_�✓u 2 Z E----7 _NE- rnl�o 2_?_$N Com: _u_R _ u B _ ------ -___TA �._H_AVIC - _ _._O F_--_O U RS.ivc an1_�--.-.--_S A) ml -----.-------------_ __.___(.UFlJa✓v'� - sEFK-_T� __ST_o�_.Qi/_�..__0�357�.uC7------------ - _.R uSl nrEsS -i4CTI UIT� . ZN TIIF_ ..fh f#S __THA .__fl�E--6�SINFSS Z 6,uE o l u E F}S K . �a✓� _ .r9 S2EEmF,vZ"S .T_.H11T- EtisuR f -FHC CcA/rwuEz�) _ V>¢1_.uE OF CU)K _ i.-01n CS. �AlU ) OLK NFl6H3oKH ooJ2> lq&JO THgT U-A L Z I LS o. Sr9 FE- GwM 0 THE Qw C T Eti3'�yME�-t o lu L_ UES v.\S.iojjs __r=_0g ___._. 0 W E f S K THAT_-_Y_ou�--._RlU l.E S ._©R__Co,/vZ )T_�.a JU F}. Z�'_�_.. CZE N lSy-7R "__ - __.__o ✓_trLua��Y ,--.----- _ -- ___�__�U.�3_l.�c 25fAR- 'L . F&C-13LfrnS ��Prs� �-�flr.TAY--�-�T R��vr T_o_ __✓��Y_�ad � __Q� _----- ____� —_REs�UM_NlS_ _AN-� Crla�E��►P_o_t�7,4iv�C�Es1�'�2EfN.7. _-- __AurnE�s_ T�v Efl_�ro__ E� .... ...A.jW_N L_Ct)V_aL-ur��,__N 1�tI_._�LEZERy_ _l2�4�E QU�2C£(Z. _�!_N.6 i 1.,,�N,pyS __ECT _.CSEE...Hccoi+wr9M'I�v�__PETt17_o�v� _ (Z)_ _&flD1SE _. VE__TS _5vS'PEO --La �E . ._ RES_cPEnTJr�1L S'17ZEE7� _Sa__wE AA) _E N7'RfjNC�E _ Csu�j"J- Fa(3. _fl/v�'____,p21 (J� -_l1_� __19.x► N'�ocv TY_s� av- THEY (ZEfERS Td S 0P 9-Silo? C6, SNE—U- KfALTy 1-9uSF ms Ajuo oK JJs IT rnfly A . PI-Y) PR(5F 3 of 3 ------- .. . Q l�.�E__.0 S _TtJfiT_"tHEy ..N�fvE To . COASULT(., I-r-K__ - --comm �TtE£__O£_ ---T. 1.�EE.__RffZESE.TTy971UES _off �'}J.F__�_ _. ',(lj H. .QVw l.o,n1S_TH.R-T-7H j_lz�tN _��vE TtiE_ t3ICZf - _�._.p_U...M� U-�w s_P-1 uuu)N6.--TIRES_Ems. TR�cKS_ _NoT T�To_._:_6. a.__�4.,.rv1_ ------- ��, ffl .�LnLG_C 9 �— E _Q Ec _u��.P£ V��Tl _SZvS3EC�S3v nnE1ZLA£S -- __—fl�N.p ____pow �J o.�v_.__(Ua► sE. Ro.m-__ME`r 1 Jv ch_�-oq.-� ..... ----- ____J3�,iu��.n>6_ fillivs>. ,DdcY�S _-$sk1 N� ErnPLE£S fl_1✓v. .__F(Z6 �'K, �fsS1�tE__N�iSE -�S,N� --R�.iuGl✓�1.6_ a�'----�addZS - a3 A R.R4,L Toae-S E • .-- _-- _ __ _ _ __ .-____-__ - _ -- 13.�. _---W�--..RFsf'�cT�uLty__�SK.. TH�17" -_z4_ N61SfI�o�tjaa� REPtzESEn77yqT1 Ug 43F (Y))9 DE __. f�c c�f11zF' a � __7`�.✓v�'_ FvTU2E PU�(..l.0 . n,F'Fi1�v�S ca,!ucfn�UlivG THIS !�'lfl?tF�. THCX REFERS7o SToP 9- S+ oe co, SHELL RE'flLrty -'RU57 Z-TS SucCFssoRS iqN\C) of,., vis iT MRY . APPLY. _ CG- 7-0 :_CITPJrJ6. 13JLZf�; `}PPFAZ.S __ Q o R R r--). NY oTNE� r2 off 2(J iljzfE L,c - /�P__E"C1 S1U�L_Z_11CrZTY- TRUST, <NOWJU T� US w,� — �4(Z fl SPCCi�t X2 .,7 Sn! �1�,Af �) N ScYUf�R� �� l.0 _ ?P,Rw SE c. N 0T- PHR19D �&) E OJJ�6i.N � Ca.�fCFRPJS ��3Q�= T�iF(3ELYM.O-A-WH1 f a(7TwE'CJV QuS1 , JEIS ANS (ZESLDEN7v,,gL 1ZapE!�1�_ son-, C).F oil fz- Co n)CERN P c Ja S5�_ TRt�� FI< L \7TER LATAF Nice" jc) 4E EVER\—F� rnd Sj 4� AL1 rHC FST.6ALfSU rf\ Fn7T QF Pr PESZrr,f�,N�nNi ���ff� Zo_L����Tw��✓.� (3�5�_,N.tSS fZ�_sPE NTl Z�? PR o� W �l LS a I O n, E ��aT� HTc S o ME' -ry:e ' c) ff KP-cE" A T �.�C7iSLR E C n�c RQ A C--O�jf AJT o.ni Qv_k_P-67S lo Elm A n)E O R THE —G_oNCE1�N� --a_i— N_ Y- L-- ' 7H i S �17m,�,_i vE—iv cU L'c 5 8 I t Y �.` tic� ♦ > '' L '�y 4. i I I I i b 4 4 W ISIS qiq viI { i Li Cp kjo \i += w � ul m W. Jc 04 Z - b 10 ow l� L LI . �ilz �N1W W , 3 I , � LL lU Q 79 n 3,d q H m 3 3i N� w rQ _ ..0 ._LTF _zRL _� PSA-nl��lrr� -3AA-2-c)- : PPFAtS- -- ---3aH2rJ.�-19.Np _f3NY_UC1j�C�_�3.6f{�!Q rH_�iT�LS. ----- ---.. - ---Sn1FLL __RE/?ZTy �2v5Z,�<ivow�v ra us ras _ H4C2 s..v kjff.JAlJ.^J S�vf?Rc y—�ortt�,6 —"- --�VEJ�uFPRD�S _LZa-�f_Ror _ . FS2ans.� .– �-y� -S�S1.t���S oF�li£ U; es��L�n1 S ���_�,R�S-•_. __-_ E [3EL}illo N_ St1l �E'TWEE"n/ Q u,;) AJEMS A At -- -. RE Z, ENmfiLL P6!ZYy _S. tJ cu pl._nJEic6-(3OR0-00f -- Somt OF a�JdR_�A �ERJ`J { fifZ� JaSFS__ r L t TKA F STf9.BL j sQ m FiyY QF A P. E7- M, NT u_� QRZ _LaJ\J—7 4- �v (3�_ ?,nJtS� LI .Z—P_Fto.P�KL,&w —d Ls .0 wo uL Z —..-- i LAKE +o 1� y9T1AT� S o mcr TY� oy fit�ZEFr�.F�J P2EUEnrL n�S_ _URS - --- _--07-H4ER- ___s OAJr-EK.NS r -3- T w_�—J�PdS _, _T1 E 6R9nTifJF —o F—fi I S 'TLl IE. (.yj f.2 d CESS V NT) L W E .G ✓J_._S.1T_.-_�d�nJ nl _ {✓�.� .._ 77 a LO "to- - - 7-0= -CIT qF -sf�_lF _., __P_L,� nrr✓irf6 c,�; L�-- - - _—__--So - __ Ttl US 114 .r- O� �-S LR Ny 6rNEtZ--13.� I-Q Ss dal pry is.,Hlc7q J11R.Y r ' — _.—�QfZ s�eCif1� QERmT nr ULVA,, rN FjVEI�uE PER L5'�—LZ-�� ar P.ARAD)Sf SJ.� CfiL�nn _ 4� AVE c7AC-Z61NC Ca.�10ERPJS (3�sJ�— Nn VL —NIE16 0-0-0-R _o_ofJ_ . LATS /Ul G147 �1 E1qVER�(S �_- -- { P2 E�rSI �_�cr, v.R.E C u c Ro c,a o.N au 2 2E7s),O�- -- - -- --- T—jS- -Q�r USS c \_ S fr � S L it H T�m�— iv.E W�U � l 1KF -T C) GC. J ✓UCrc dF_ Hl S -- -_F r� oC'Ess -S NELL_._ E$LTy - �. R vr r _ _- 0 -- g rta qj city_ F - sRLer,,. , PL1q_nl1�-i^_f6 PILI�r.�� 4Nr�_- �NY_cTN_E�._�3a,4R1� _------—---- 2�aT� f<nJ6w/v 7-6 us fi_S -STap � S IaP 1 _�f_VE1�uE PP�QiyD-LS ___�Q_1f_P or 6f, c4 N co jJ CF R PJL9�311LL- -- EEN Q uY I AJF'cS A N� RS __> G, R1 f�4ND A L I , r K E STf1.BL 1 s} �Fn17 QF 14 PE rn AIJEN-- u.F E2 Za_N_ 257= jD_ JUL__ xrs _—L�1y s1S - S o ME' TYEEC Oi- 19 KP-FFAATI - P2c1E�rsEnJ7 o.nj_ei.. / 2 2ES1oE=A L _ --aTyEC� �oJ1�E NS "-1flT wE._—���aS d r1�E GRflnTirJ-6 - ----a.F fi_�J�_-5����=--f'�'�,,v1�S fi•t 7-'rl i S 'r�mF. v�£—w-�U L� arc c s_ u N7) Z w F c _s zr_--�dw _ { �✓� - - _s ------- _ Si sJCF.1��Ly_ v< s R 1 m 8 - -- - -�-- - - - - -�- le w TO-P THE EI.EcTQz) .OEFIcAt,S 06 SA EM AXOTHE. APPelwrf� .BOAJCa mEMpfJbS oP sALEr.�. ....... -- Bo �>J �_fniu�al3NmfjvBA2..._�daflRD..._.E�• FROI ._TVIE .Rt`SIPENU .Of-VINAAN !SQUAWE .Arun . . .. • �' _-THE__SURR01V�iN6� ._R'f'SIAENf1.Sl, _.NE16�1C3oRNe0D � � :.' °' ,-,-- � • X N. .SA LEr\. 7 1 . e � sE+zA1... .RES►AE�VfIA.I. _LA�uO ._ f.RaM. .�+a41N6.. ?OWER-f..7�._.. 4 �,3� ._._.ViNrVtN.__50.6ARf__..�H�9N6Eo..Zb _.. .[3USI,vd._,Z_dAlf LANA -.WE.-FEEL OVR 'Nf161jaaKHeaaD NAS-_6106A) Aw VP _ ALL wE CRAP 6iv6 091JA 4�AW wdvio t1x-{ s3 Ave <o Ino Le Ta . s6E .Ti4AT AJ0 MO.RC _ L,09k�o 4;S' TuRAI f20/v-% Rl 2-a-v6 ' Ta AruY OTH.E'R . TYPE ..O'F V 44-..1NEss (/SES ,No .R -(. , Q-2 .aR V'fgAL 5'�i Buz _..WE1?9T_Wf .HAVE roa 2Es7vR�fNT-f._ fiN+o.ER11N6__Es-CAB�►sHmENJCt_-9A1 VfN✓UIiJ ._Svur9RE. Nct�J, _GuE suHrorzT. rHE_ABurh�R . . n . `'. OF T015.._S7vr !tSHOP , .SwCU . RfALIV TgoST t8 fKoAFXTY.._-r#9AT . B#cKS ur To 09Ry901SE ffuENiF .r A) . .sTar ...such .Aw d 4)4un, ao A.ao _H16H pE'LI ufAY RAl-C .. FST>f&L iS-HM-C uTs' HS MC0dJV FLl:)-f, RURCCA Kiwc) 1pIz" HvT) :2:ZE)UruK\N pO,NuTs I KE'•iUVuCK)' FR\EP CH 14KE'JJJ. 71 ,Poi'EYES Ec� . , irRoM . m.ovw�6 .so SLoS� ' 23,. To R4�' 104F-. IAL PROPaE97v .WIF SEE THEIR 2Y ' Poj , T srw Iver w4ovrwc A <J mPS-rcRS' FRodv� EATIru6 .F STt6LISfilM6Nrs _oF Amy . klwo sa .cLoSf ..To THEIR Ho+r.Es.. . ALSO ..PAR bISf 4VFA/ 'fT �S • A . C 1 ry ..sTR.fET Awo s HdULO nraT HAvf z:r WE At_So Po tidr wHM" RFrrAua,9ATI ORWE-up sa , ArvO . m v6 T'MRovctl w l Ncidkr Tr?79 wI c OVOiNG ovZ EX 171>u G P�1Z�olsf tivF a� i4wy OTHER /�SIAFn7j'IRC STR+(�E • TO-_ C 17 �_L Z_ _-Z-Af k1!WA)I0J E(FU pjV_S 4� FRO —THE_(mcLATLO _Lf L A T IC A) 5Z HT Ci E 1 E'V_C�RC� S9LY 7H� L\V7 To Alq7 4-\ &LTC- .,SdME' T.42!E Ct —FrOOESS UN7) L _ -QC Z ce g"s -UJL urY -3 6 02 Y///l OJA /0 > a � P 9 GE t-e�� - -TOl__C --RNsuoca� -C,- CLO'Pli /44, 4 SPFC)r9L PERm T To - __ 51�1�L"Z- 11y_ T2 � S? �( ICNoW,v 7-6 US 14,-S — FOR- A SP-- f'E2m� 1..nrvlffA)t,^J Shu— ems, Lcrt��u� PiVE/�uE P,R�D�f LZ�tt Q.� yr P4LL19J))SS6- —__._.t'�o n�---Lk��_�ZES1 t��'N-�C7��-li-rc V 1 rJ•�✓J 54�.-���f,K-��i_— AVSONr- i N Ca bjcgAALS f UT �t��—J3£Lf}2L�S}j i ` �F rwEE.N 43 u;1 r�1FSS A NC�) =----SES I-D4-CNMA-i9 L _fs_z a�'IZaFF1C -\TTER LATE N (l ZNT �1FLEVCR\-F_�, m �T a->+ r L 1 TNS FSTf�.BL I symFnrY Q"� ,4 _ •. �✓v� 2£'s�f�L��.—PF�P��T�w��Ls a_c�,os�L�.------- { L�Kq TaomE' T :Eo:F flcSKEf PR Eurt�t�_�trU�� Cl1CRoAC.}I CAJ CL)R -- --- T-�5 -� �f1LSE' ct AIN L �c 2 ,v��tS frit -t'ri i S ?7m,v'. L�j_ -W cU Lv� dJF_ s --�,��, d_C�.SS _.__V NTl L __ w.E___G�1_✓_�--=sT_-"_�a�;.� rJ___�;n!� --- _-_ 17, - _ --- _ h i CIO _ � _^ - -8 ------- T�'- �Ty- �` S n uE' _PL/9 nrr✓ _rr G Q R_c��>2p _ —_SNE�Z_RPZT/__-�2�J.�"Z}�<Nownr 0 us 1- yPJvA-'r.N S(IUnR( . L ag �6-- dr P�1RflD)sf cr.YN S�L�M , ?wEE-iv F3 us l AJEIS A Nr�l - -- SO-n _QF a\J (L_ CdNCFB�1 � ATCftu6r57 -------Lv� ST_4 r 1 L ; THE ESTf�BL synJT aF ,4 J3�Zw�£i.1 ---�-✓U� 2Es > �E�U"'`� 1 �Z---P-P_,..Q_P�1�,.�ca f'�f_LS a�os�.L a --- 1mE- O: 19 6P-EEo gz-?j7 PRE1�Ears rt.6---- cr v R E_�NC o c.,1 � 0,A/ d ) j --.__1vE\-6rlRorr,�- o_d_rJ_w —_aTHEIZ_�oNr'EK.J�S . -r�-1 �,�wE__���aSf�—rt1�6R.fJ✓rin;:6� FTS, o C-'S S _. UNT I L W C _C JR ✓J S 1T d: v nJ_._ } n/.�.- - -- __ --_-_Tt�4�L __7"�i-__dUER ---- __S�uEll L__ �.E-�4LTy--_ RE'�LZ�s-�J�-�"l V�-S—E��•_- ------- -. si�rJ-cozy'. A v!c S R L N\ . 3 jo. y� '�: -ATE 07 I :E::R:. far L;r� GTITIC' IER P Qi /IAAITLy SOCA T IOii MOTION: -0 GRANT 29 SECOND 70 DENY I SECOND -0 RE-HEAR SECOND LEAVE TO WITHDRAW SECOND .0 CONTINUE SECOND TOLL CALL PRESENT GRA/NTT DENY WITHDRAW RE-HEAR CONTINUE RICHARD BENCAL v ^/GEORGE A. AHM€D L� rRimp ;. -TEPHEN T^UCNETTE :=OC::.TE :'EMBERS ARTHUR LABRECOUE ONDITIONS: a D " — ��—� c� � r CITY OF SALEM BOARD OF APPEAL _ 745-9595 Ext. 381 F' Will hold a public hearing for all persons inter- ested in the petition submitted by SNELL REALTY TRUST for a Special Permit to change nonconforming structure and use and a variance from parking at VINNIN ST.&PARADISE ROAD (R-2). Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY. APRIL 21, 1993 AT 7:00 P.M., ONE SALEM GREEN, second floor. RICHARD A. BENCAL, Chairman April 7, 14, 1993 SN23602 i DATE:......... ........... .._.. .. .._ .....__ . y�M,covpR4. ,. APPEAL CASE NO. __..._ . .. CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS: it The Undersigned represent that M is YdM the Ownera. of a certain parcel of land located atx3tiC Vinnin Street and Paradise Road 6 Zoning i t ict. B-1 . ; and said Parcel is affected by Section(s) . �_tW'. Sec: 6 . .and .Sec.. . . . . . . , ; of the Salem Zoning Ordinance mb�h'Bx/>i V61ommb . �cm����ca�caIDtsdmltiDdx�c�0acbcx . Plans describing the work proposed, have been submitted to the Inspector of Buildings in accordance with Section IX A.1 of the Zoning Ordinance. Direct Appeal 2 rna — M v m00 cn 6e! o rn .c o d o Uiu rn" G9 u' J c W.r m a. _ V to Lo G.p � C ca U The Application for Permit was denied by the Inspector of Buildings for the following reasons: Direct Appeal zbcecxraadgxsxgagdxDcgx�&ycx�Cex mactcuxxDcat aamd47 xgcgcecxksxxaxxas�cxxbcecxuacxmscxa8xxhecx Zoning Ordinance and the Building Code and order the Inspector ngs to approve the application fee permit to build as filed enforcement of said Zoning By-Laws and Building Code would practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship to the Undersi a ief may be granted without substantially dero- gating from ent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and Building Code for the gXl 6(Xs:0 aaX See Attached i Owner. Snell Realty Trust Address. P: 0. Box 369:Boston, MA 02101 Telephone. , 617/380,8218 Petitioner , Same as above March 30 , 1993 Akwiththe . kofthe . . . . . Date . T . . . . . B GeoIII Three copies of the application must be filedc ard of Appeals with a check, for advertising in the amount of $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . four weeks prior to the meeting of the Board of Appeals. Check payable to The Evening News. Applicant hereby petitions the Board of Appeals for the following: 1 . Special Permit for alteration of a nonconforming structure in accordance with Section 5-3( j ); Sec . 8-6 and Sec . 9-4 . 2 . Special Permit for a change of nonconforming uses, to wit, supermarket and retail department stores, to other noncon- forming uses, to wit, "retail department stores located within a shopping plaza" and "other accessory uses located within a shopping plaza" , in accordance with Sec. 5-3( j ) , Sec . 8-6 and Sec . 9-4 . 3 . Variance for parking in accordance with Sec . 9-5 . Present supermarket tenant and other tenants are vacating the Building and applicant wishes to rehabilitate the existing nonconforming structure with a new gabled hip roof, brick columns for the front colonnade, a clock tower, -and new exterior facia materials . The existing footprint and the existing gross floor area of the Building will not change. The existing nonconforming uses as a supermarket and retail department stores in a shopping plaza are nonconforming uses in a . B-1 zone under Sec . 5-2 (d) . The supermarket use will be discon- tinued and applicant wishes to lease the existing structure to shopping plaza retail department stores and other accessory uses . The alteration of the existing nonconforming structure and the change of nonconforming use will not be more detrimental than the existing nonconforming structure and uses and the special permit may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent and purpose of the zoning ordinance. Parking will be increased on the existing site from 242 to 258 spaces . Although not in conformity with present requirements of Sec . 7-3, the increase in parking will accommodate less intense uses than the present supermarket urae and an overall reduction in traffic volume currently generated by the site will result in improved parking and traffic flow. Enforcement of the ordinance as to parking requirements would involve practical difficulty and unnecessary hardship to the applicant and variance relief may be granted without substantially derogating from the intent and purpose of the ordinance. DATE:......... ....... .... .. _.. . ... .. ... ,. APPEAL CASE NO. .. _....... .. .. e 1 i��foU � _ . CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS: it The Undersigned represent that kat ' is MM the OwnerX of a certain parcel of land located at *XK Vinnin Street and Paradise Road S Zoning i xx ct. B-1 . ; and said Parcel is affected by Section(s) . . . .Sec. 6 . . . .Sec.. . . . . .. ; of the Salem Zoning Ordinance 4 6fic)b� Xi?EiE ( . x>ffic x�toet�kta� c: ,c dxngc Xkxbec Plans describing the work proposed, have been submitted to the Inspector of Buildings in accordance with Section IX A.1 of the Zoning Ordinance. Direct Appeal a r� W :rn 0 CD LdJ � m Cn i" o "yam 00 UL ma w The Application for Permit was denied by the Inspector of Buildings for the following reasons: Direct Appeal �xa�xuttdgxttxgxttdxtcgxat>ttycxgcasxxsxacasxxxgxttaacxdxa8xxgcRecxXsxsaxxxtt9cxxbcecxttec�sxa8 x�bcax Zoning Ordinance and/or the Building Code and order the Inspector ngs to approve the application fee permit to build as filed enforcement of said Zoning By-Laws and Building Code would practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship to the Undersi re ief may be granted without substantially dero- gating from ent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and Building Code for the gx�ecacscocascx See Attached Owner. Snell. Realty Trust Address. P: 0. Box 369: Boston, MA 02101 Telephone. , 617/380-8218 Petitioner , Same as above Date March 30 , 1993 Address. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Te phone. / . t ney Geo W. Atkins, III Three copies of the application must be filed the Se tary of the Board of Appeals with a check, for advertising in the amount of $ . . . . . . . . . . . . . } four weeks prior to the meeting of the Board of Appeals. Check payable to The Evening News. Applicant hereby petitions the Board of Appeals for the following: 1 . Special Permit for alteration of a nonconforming structure in accordance with Section 5-3 ( j )- Sec . 8-6 and Sec . 9-4 . 2 . Special Permit for a change of nonconforming uses, to wit, supermarket and retail department stores, to other noncon- forming uses, to wit, "retail department stores located within a shopping plaza" and "other accessory uses located within a shopping plaza" , in accordance with Sec . 5-3 ( j ) , Sec. 8-6 and Sec . 9-4 . 3. Variance for parking in accordance with Sec . 9-5 . Present supermarket tenant and other tenants are vacating the Building and applicant wishes to rehabilitate the existing nonconforming structure with a new gabled hip .roof, brick columns for the front colonnade, a clock tower, and new exterior facia materials . The existing footprint and the existing gross floor area of the Building will not change. The existing nonconforming uses as a supermarket and retail department stores in a shopping plaza are nonconforming uses in a B-1 zone under Sec . 5-2(d) . The supermarket use will be discon- tinued and applicant wishes to lease the existing structure to shopping plaza retail department stores and other accessory uses . The alteration of the existing nonconforming structure and the change of nonconforming use will not be more detrimental than the existing nonconforming structure and uses and the special permit may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent and purpose of the zoning ordinance. •t Parking will be increased on the existing site from 242 to 258 spaces . Although not in conformity with present requirements of Sec . 7-3, the increase in parking will accommodate less intense uses than the present supermarket ure and an overall reduction in traffic volume currently generated by the site will result in improved parking and traffic flow. Enforcement of the ordinance as to parking requirements would involve practical difficulty and unnecessary hardship to the applicant and variance relief may be granted without substantially derogating .from the intent and purpose of the ordinance. �.,...,_ Js ° \ 1A0 .� ao Oh6w JrF %JO O ti ,r 8 aap ° \°j \°�6op ��tig ' ' \a<\\\� JJ � woe ee n ao so h 5\0 (_ � s AN, t lb r-v r-0 1 a. v NV CF- A N REV. BY AVIS 10 '� JO \�00 \cb g J & �b !b Cb I q p All KiHll � 0 Op 50 \0435 9b 4,bo / O ZO C2 biN' u .,o CPgJ 56 O cb q Rp 5 � g� pp Co � ^^� 100 5 n-\ O 10 roe X�L i �p0 ti�L °. o O ...�` so lb (b C; �%a z 49 Z\p R EV. BY A V1. 0 0 -A V1 REV BY -b- REV. BY A lbkb REV. PAF KING By AVIS 10,N) ��191 ll�l�131 14,195 o C. LOTS 230 762,500 E 542 N N2 USED x 5 10,529 21 AC. , ....... m 0 6 4.ZIAC 0 P A R K I N G 90.5 ; IA ST /3,-504 ,1 1 1 i . I .4s 49.72. 4 19 DRAIN 629 9 O900 420 \0, 00 \ , e �F o t a 2r ra hQ \�O0"q yQ �/\ e0 26 9P • h 0 Al .fie EV 726Q/! uu 9L� 3p 7840 \ C' ,0O \7' q Oi9 166 ;701 SFS yO / JCA u° u�u 9 ,yc' o o0sy A s eA . tig06 °c �00y A �m �y R bo ��V// yy0 v to o :° on cy9Y d ,/ 6 990 O /b.O h0 ?� L 9 9ti °J 0 °`e / h b. 3 U y a 0 gO �o moo oe 9q \0 y hA /\/\j O AA9�� y96A O m°" QO �m �h�0/� 90 O \ e . . e \^6`1• 0 0 ao �\ ♦6+ 1iX O e W m . \ \\�� 'e �O uo • o \9600 b, s. 0 09 O • e h p�//�� ' \�Dy6Q0 y� N A ue. \p O'00 a s/' + ryO6 Q . uO o '' °O \�j6°0 (-0O9 6\900 4i4p! s u�h 00 �\�OO ° KIN° e o h1 �L600 OC) /p m 9p OO6 - _ .43 QO ° A6 °° yQ o ti \� y y u\u IVry ry�Q 0 GF °q,0� CIO tiyQ (ZI � /M 30-L 3 Qqq tiO00 �\0 e e u /•. 0 a 4 /9 h titi�Q ? POND . co . � '9u �� A69 � •, 95 n 230 . d 5 D . 30 �I. o I M30-L 3 m m m4.2/AC O c D 2/ 4 O P A R K I N G y 3,504 IAO /"iQ/ --' ry0s •°0 49.72 / 629 9 ONIN 900 v VN a ,2°"5 S POEM�Fp fio\ P�g��r P ti 0y �g ILI 'y0 596 06 9ti „q u F o�Q q \ ti 6tititi O'q P t a \6 tib 29 �° 9°ry �° q��w ,R 99 �0 99 y R_ gy �0s 696M0 Fq \�° ° Qtip 0 ti \00 \� 0i sJ J+O \0�pH6 JO / (y \2 s CFG /It O O ry q a� O� aJ r V \9'h \9 bq O p J° ' O° h6 J p e Q \ryti0 ?° ' aso O yIF m 6 q; ap � a 'O ° J6° r P A'K K IN e 'eq u q h6 5 yl/ e q q Joy h1 ta0 Jo Q / Oj ° ,� 9 r JO y/+^ry\4jDO y6° ti �° J0 (/ />b, 0() b� q lb (t; h °° qL J 61 so 'J 0 y° ° O \Qi h ha 09'Oy c 00 n00 q� W/i 000 2\0 ° 9 \/ O to 9 2�0a6y PARKING n ti�A6 14,195 r F 2 230 8667 T 5 � n ?3450 n °IP O I O (n P m n m o / 6 / o !, / ,yO 4 I P A R K I N G J S /3,504 SIT/- IAD / 49.72 6219 \ V�NNIN z 420.s S FLEM 0 S� Pry j6 0 �P BOARD OF ASSESSORS CITY HALL PAGE. DA 2 2 GO/ ......II,....... ...... 1� TTERS,,� 3 ... . ..... 3 .......... l�7 7 T1 JED ,A 4 SUBJECT PROPERTY: MAP: 20 LOT: 0006 BUFF. 6 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 0007 PARADISE ROAD 7 A55Lbbk-p OWNEK, zw4ECE 9 ROBBINS ARTHUR 8 ET AL TRS 100 PROPE-RrY�A-DDRESS —ASSESSED-OWNER MAIL-ING-ADDRESS 13 �4* 21 0229 0011 PARADISE AVENUE SHERLO REALTY CO INC P 0 BOX 369 REAL ESTATE DEPT 5 12 CAC)7!-JF-S7(IP—&-SHOP-COS-IUC BQSJ-QN-MA-02,1 1 16 13T7 .21 0228 0001 PARADISE ' ROAD. ARRIGO JOH14 A I PARADISE ROAD 4 JOSEPHINE SALEM MA 01970 9. DARKA-E. a-ELPI--&VE 12 16 MARIE 8SALEM MA 01970 21 17 22 2-1 02:30 0004 PARADISE ROAD SCANGAS JAMES ETALI BOX 317 (SALEM #1646) 2310 18 ...... - C10 -U-rS T X DEPT RA ricif PH m 02.7/,A 24 1 9 1 1- I"�.,,",I I I, , . . I, .... .. 2: CORP: .......I 2 000 ' PARADISE I MAR,, FOO 0 SEROAD; 20 ......."I'll,...... "LOUISVILLE, WA-0232, 72i64' .....................11,111" 1 'p, 1-1fx`lpnn4...... �Innd n,",'PA RA Ell Sr,,-,goA ri I 22 DANVERS MA 01923 29 •23 3 .2'0 0005 0006 PARADISE ROAD LAGER FAMILY REALTY TRUST THE 73-79 186TH ST 31 24 1 IIEP TR Pf USHING NY -1-1.366 32 I .. ....................... ........... ............. ..... .- . I ...............�b �I: I, 25: 1, e.-,,�,,�:,�SNEL . , S Tl, PlIO, BOX"'369 ',ATTN-REAL. :E51ATE 'DEPTI WOOO& TRUS 34 26 ................ ........... ............. '-ROL, ............ 1 -- 350 ,N , ,A 36 28 37 29 380 0 391 30 40 31 41 32 420 4 33 34 45 0 35 4 4 36 48• 37 1 ..... ..... ....... . 49 .......... 2,�........... ..........I 38 50 51 39 521............... 40 53 0 41 549 55 42 56 z 43 ...... 57 . ............I 5 44 8 % 59 45 ...... 60 46 61 47 62 0 :31 48 4 49 65 66 .......... 50 ........ 670 68 52 69 53 70 71 54 72 -777-777777-77--77-777 7 7-7 55 ---e--, 73 PETER 11. CARON 74 '6 CHIEF ASSESSOR J75 56 7, BOARD OF ASSESSORS CITY HALL PAGE- QAJ C'M 77 l..... DATE 0713843 2 3 CERTIFIE ER LIST 2 3 4 4 SUBJECT PROPERTY: MAP: 20 LOT: 0006 SUFF: 5 5 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 0007 PARADISE ROAD 6 6 ASSFRSFD 04INFR SNELL REALTY TRi ST 8 7 1 1 R S 7 ROBBINS FT AL%I TRS 0 9 —_1v1AP_L Lurcr PROPERTY ADDRESS —ASSESSEDPOWNE MA.IL.IN.G_ADDR 12, 10 13 1 1 4 30 0003 80.1 0001 TEDESCO POND PLACE Ul VONKRAUSE-WESTMACOTT RENATE I TEDESCO POND PL U1 15 12 NARBLEHEAD_MA_a1_9_43�1D_5_1 16 13 -7 17 0 0003 802, Z002�.TEDESCO,_POND: PLACE U2 SONDLER JEFFREY M.�-%,, 2 TEDESCO POND PLACE U2 14 �8 MARBLEHEAD MA 04945 15 13 IRON 0 PLA C_.=ht KRASK&R—GER 20 16 17 21 KRASKER JANE SWAMPSCOTT MA 0-1907 22 0 30 0003 804 0004 TEDESCO POND PLACE U4 LESHKOWICH MEREDITH 4 TEDESCO P014D PLACE U4 230 g 18 111APP.) PHPAD mA n-t9A5 241 POND li'SC!,-IEFTC%C)R:1 '"' 5 TEDESCO-,poNb,�.m., cE.10's" l�' 25 ........... ............... ............. . 'HEAVI,MA 0 26 IC 2 ............... ........ ....... 27 ­,j4­PT:LGRTLj, J 28 ox" ri,nflA l"r9'LyrqrQ`P6W 6' PI'ArF"'I 21 22 29 23 PAGLIARO CAROL A MARBLEHEAD MA 01945 30 • 30 0003 807 0007 TEDESCO POND PLACE U7 MEYERS MARVIN A 7 TEDESCO POND PL U7 310 24 .1945 32 TLE 77777773 ............. SCARPA .CARMEN�.,J ......... . 25 TEDESCO PC ........ T E D F,�,LC 60�E P0 N D! 8 21 .............. ....... ......... 34 HEAD HA..'[ 1945` 3 . .......... AARBLE ..............%" 27 .qr.011P0Nf) 'P1,Ar 'PRATTON 14 Tf I TAM' -%n nnn.-v:Ar?cp:­,,nnnq , TFr)F' 119, 28 FIANDACA CHERYL A MARBLEHEAD MA 01945 37 29 3 30 0003 810 0010 TEDESCO POND PLACE U10 CURLEY STEPHEN E 10 TEDESCO POND PL U10 30 30 PiARBLEHEAEL-MA 0-1945 40 31 -70 0003 811 0011 %TEDESCO POND PLACE U11 VEMIS ROXANNE 11 TEDESCO� POND PL U11 42 41 •32 MARBLEHEAD MA 0-1945 . 43* 33 -in nnn-t POND PIACE U12 RAJ kfUrrT RAEF-AF-1 F- 12 TEDESCO PON-D—EL—U-1-2 44 34 MARBLEHEAD MA 01945 45 35 4610 30 0003 613 0013 TEDESCO POND PLACE U13 LAGAN SCOTT A 13 TEDESCO POND PL U13 47 36 SAGAN JUI TE R MARaIFHEAD MA m949 481 37 I ' ' ­ POND PL' 'Uf4' 10 '0003:.%..814..,,,',....'.001%4 . TEDESCQ� FOND � PLACE U14 s VIEW T U' 49 1-44 TEDESCO 50 38 ........ REL 39 .I...... A ;MURPHY ,EDW Rr). ,J 'JR 1-R' ANIONA41-S 4HRISTU I T 0EH - 2 40 ELENI SALEM MA 01970, 53 41 54 • 21 0221 0000 MAPLE AVENUE LIRANTONAKIS CHRISTOS 18 MAPLE AVENUE 55. 42 cl 56 ......... .... ... ........ 57 A VEN UE -AMAPLE-A ' 'AVENUE ... 'l ��e t: 10, MAPLE 43 N VE .. ............... ......... • 'Eml•MA bl' 59 44 ........ JE -197 ANNE,' sm 45" _.�TE 60 Al S UPJ PJ E -A� 2 2 14T'IMAP TRUS 46 SARGENT ARTHUR C III TR SALEM MA 01970 61 47 62 21 0224 0006 MAPLE AVENUE COOK NATHAN H 11 6 MAPLE AVENUE 630 46 M S6LEP1_p1A 01970 64 49 7 AVENUE 65 4 N 15 MAPLE 'AYE .0 .......... SALEM MA 0497(i :6 7 5 1la 6a 52 69 53 54 72 ------- -77" 55 73 PETER M. CARON 7 74 1561_ CHIEF ASSESSOR 75 �71 091 0��vj�jld S S.oty z N�NN1t` 006 0 15 / ZL'617 sr r 1 dS s. 0 N I N a V d o °a, 0 � 0 p (n moi° F 7-0£W I a orbF� J 5 r 'a [999 ^ s ' _0£3 Z •�' / 4ti �� �sr A o S6/'bl 'JNINHVd tl0 'b wg tiw tib 0 NO d ; a pg titi . �/ �s C _ ° bwa O e O' -b / O�ti Ob a '" ♦w v � ,�y ry r' e� 0♦� p00'u �, Eb00 o O? y oh ti � 4 rir 4 / ° 0 00004 4 (P 41 rp' 00 -41 ✓ 0 o 0 y 4 ♦,L /�°r or D p9 6 �Lb ♦O , p� / oJ00 . m 0 O 94O 0 C � °r s Otl/� Og i 3 jO�Oti G OQp�y ^ o a°rO pyti 00 6 /ia. b i d9^,n 46�♦ a °O Qw0 + ppp♦ti g or o O y tw d,� a, g4 4 OOytp♦� QOy ,db 4 �o SHIN Y.Y d �♦ O y�7 ° 00 Off' pQ9^ 'L S °O 0r4 \O b , 4 f• 00. 0♦ tib 9 6ti90� p94♦ or °D 0�O� h // `c` 00/ y4 s,r p 9 0 Oro r �� Otiti♦ r 91 ♦O O ° s Og4�O Cr a °o s or C0 \4 00� °W �1\ QO rp♦ 6♦ a e0 ,p" b rp� ��Jr sr g9 . +0 g4 W °r �! s a tlb O O r a r > \W °r o O � ��c�� g4` \6♦es y by Q 04y� O < N/v or rr pg0♦ p�� M IN 4 b" !bp b ti 0y♦ �r • s 06 p� 4 oy O o yg6� 46 of -4, g6tl ♦ 66 ea njy o00 04 06 n °� 11191 �9/ 4�ip�♦VV roOO m' v' ti'�ti9 ✓ti♦ti tl y♦ �� + s �� gg d O 4 Og 1o" ?Abp 4 0 ln9/ O O 64 g eel) °r °y6y rO'. b� oy ° p p9� Og ` 4fb �^i� °r tl g00ti 401 O o� �`9/ 09�♦ btl /`/ 0i'/ J v �?a �O' a�� w 90w'� 9 Z 14 r, ° a r`d ° V O 24 as tO 9fl tl 6'A/oi o� o <cl� �4 9 I r r 11W 6, O o" "+ O 6� ♦ 40— m �4° tid OVZ oa � p 11 OtI5 Y_a 'r r 991 , O tl 6�ti\ O r �Jb 0b B L 0q.p11 oY °A 7714 b 0a g4�\ 009 b� rov009d 97' a and v� ` )o o' +O 6� Opti♦ �o ' �J eagZ°� °gal b 0cl es 09 �0� ,` o` 09 0 r� 4 o0 t asI 01 a� ez 'O, y�Zez + O tl09 \ +\ 4ti4 °LG + 6 w♦ l /o° Da��� �� ag 8 r �Z