32 SUMMIT STREET - ZBA 32 Summit St. g
George J. Dubois -- -- — —_ _. -- --- -
V
L
J
(f itv of "Salem, f ttssar4usetts
0(4 Paxrb Df �Jr�ettl '84 AU6 -6 AIP :a
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF GEORGE J. AND STEPHANIE M. DUBOIS FOR A
VARIANCE FOR 32 SUMMIT STREET, SALEM CiT r
� .E
A hearing on this petition was held on July 25, 1984 with the following Board
Members present: James Hacker, Chairman; Associate Member Richard.A. Bencal,
Secretary, Scott Charnas, Messrs. Gauthier & Luzinski. Notice of the hearing
was sent to abutters and others and notices of the hearing were properly published
in the Salem Evening News in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws
Chapter 40 A.
The petitioner , owner of the premises, requests a variance from side and rear
setback requirements to allow them to construct a garage with a rear setback
of 21 feet and a side setback of 8 feet.
The Variance which has been requested may be granted upon a finding of the
Board that:
a. special conditions and circumstances exist which especially affect
the land, building or structure involved and which are not generally
affecting other lands, buildings and structures in the same district;
b. literal enforcement of the provisions of the Zoning Ordinance would in-
volve substantial hardship, financial or otherwise, to petitioner; and
c. desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the
public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the
intent of the district or the purpose of the Ordinance.
The Board of Appeal, with hearing the evidence presented at the hearing, makes the
following findings of fact:
1. No opposition was presented to petitioners' plan;
2. The unique topography and water runoff problems on this lot make
the construction of a garage within the requirements of the
Zoning Ordinance unreasonable and a hardship to the petitioners.
3. Construction of the garage would not substantially affect the
neighborhood in any way.
On the basis of the above findings of fact, and on the evidence presented at
the hearing, the Board of Appeal concludes as follows:
1. Special conditions affect this lot but do not generally affect
the district;
2. Literal enforcement of the ordinance would work a substantial
hardship upon petitioners by exacerbating the water runoff
PETITION OF GEORGE J . AND STEPHANIE M.
DUBOIS FOR A VARIANCE FOR 32 SUMMIT STREET, SALEM
page two '84 AUG -5 PC.
problems on the lot; C1Ty r r _ - - .I;:c�CE
3. The variances can be granted without substantial detriment
to the public good, and without substantially derogating from the intent
and purpose of the ordinance.
Therefore, the Board of Appeal voted unanimously to grant petitioner the
relief requested.
VARIANCE GRANTED } �
Scott E.Charnas, Secretary
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK
APPEAL FROh' THIS DECISION, IF ANY, SHALL BE MADE PURSUANT TO SECTION 17 OF THE VASS.
GENERAL LAMS, CH,A",PIER C2S. AHC SiiU- CE FILED V.CFn;N 20 DAYS AFTER THE DATE CF Fi LI;iG
OF THIS DLCSIJpN Itt THE CFn CE OF THE CFiY CLERA.
PURSANT TO i".ASSJ CIU'U'A'.. L,lV.S, COAPTEP, 'Js. S=C`i'N 11, THE VAMA'-ICE OF FPE"-'A:. P""IT
GRWJED HERE:']. Y:,T ' _.. . . -SHALL I If.:E EFFCC� ci:T�L A D�P'i OF TFIE-�CISi.;:,. CE.?.i lr THE -_i-
CITY;!DN CF THE CITY Ci ERn -i FL9T K DA73 HAVE :L.APC_D 6: ',r APF"",..L Hi:S BEEiI FI:-D,
UR TH'.T. IF SUCH AN APPAL II:.0 DEiiN R'Ji, WA' Il' ii^,S GEEi; riSNIII; E7 OR
REC=RDED IN TiE SOJ'iii ESSE' FE'i3iRS OF DEEPS AN-) I.-:D-
-ED C:4D-R THE :GP,::iE Lt -iiiE CtINER
OF RECORD OR IS BLCURDED AND IiCTEJ GN Tni 6ee7ERS dER11FICATE OF TITLE.
BOARD OF APPEAL
i N
Cit# u �r�e�n, caucl�iir##
G � ire Pepartntent �9enbyuartrra
aa+c
48 �ttfgvtte *tred
ROBERT J. CROWLEY
achief tt1em, �f du. 01970
Date: July 17, 1984
Salem Board of Appeal Re :32 Summit Street
City of Salem, Massachusetts George & Stephanie Dubois
One Salem Green Hearing Date: 7/25/84
Salem, Mass. 01970
Sirs : b
'i
As a result of public notice received concerning the Board of Appeal 3
hearing for the above listed name and aadress, the Salem Fire
Department, requests the following items to be placed on record.
1. The Salem Fire Department has no objection to granting of the Vari-
ance for construction of a garage at this location.
2. Smoke detectors have been installed and Certified as of 2/7/84.
Respectfully submitted,
Deputy Chiet. Davi J. Go gin
cc : file Salem Fire Prevention Inspector
Form #105A
Plot Plan
32 Summit Street, Salem, Massachusetts
(shown as #77)
Seale 1" = 100'
> _ 4j
3e �� \�/ X 000.
s
NO
ss V \�/ ODC O�
< 80
V�iy j
s2eo 'ry b s�� O
'3 /03
e TS^ 6.,
QSEMENT ��'s?i 5'S Ujc
s4 G.Jp J. s
Q.J 30
S3 sA 9e
i0C�
t.
Abutters :
1 . Edward L. Ronan, 30 Summit St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #78)
2. Richard P. Ciampa, 34 Summit St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #76)
3• Pierre A. Richard, 1 Richards Road, Salem, Mass.. (Shown as #80)
4. Chester J .. Blaszck, 31 Summit St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown .as #170)
5• William T. Burke, 3 South St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #171)
Plot .Plan
32 Summit Street, Salem, Massachusetts
(.Shown as #77)
Scale 1" = 100'
.. O m.
i co 6 / �o �\ S��Iis s O os
Rr . T O
o ,v, os,9' 0�\ 50 boy �q�rEa\
3�//Q / 8qm � ti� cr' > '�•s��
6
S
000` y , / B
/S O ap �^ X960
//9?a � �:s/69
>
> oo , O --s
n. 6 so
SE >I>
EA
�MEN7 /s2 O,
/ oGTti
'0 0396 ^q •1 • a�/ � r�
4
.s0 � � u � ,o q 3
r ,Guys.\ > 'S h�0�u h\��0� ////�/�)•�\� •'.
'0 &00
oo? hOe�
,5j bm 46 I� 'S•�q '.1 I '1'
V y� 9>
Abutters:
1 . Edward L. Ronan, 30 Surgmi,t St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #78)
2. Richard P. Ci.ampa, 34 Summit St. , Salem, Mass.. (Shown as #76)
3. Pierre A. Richard, 1 Richards Road, Salem, Mass. (Shown as #80)
4. Chester J.. Blaszck, 31 Summit St. , Salem, Mass. (.Shown as #170)
5. William T. Burke, 3 South St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #171)
Plot .Plan
32 Summit Street, Salem,, Massachusetts
(shown as #77)
Scale I" = 100'
A. ss • s
„ �V
/A,. sGo
ecJI
CV
• ° •v, ps/9.
. /6
A, ^^ flso
90 / O
TO
/s)2 �cOry l
2a3 ,c,3
0
`GT
U y 6
it
S4 V
O
t ��
Cc 9s\ r� o s h��iU h�0)
009 C"
S3G by 46. 9>• ,s4 }\
8 ` C 0
X P"
Abutters:
1 . Edward L. Ronan, 30. Summit St. , Salem. Mass. (.Shown as #78)
2. Richard P. Ciampa, 34 Summit St. ,: Salem, Mass, (Shown as #76)'
3. Pierre A. Richard, . ] Richards Road, Salem; Mass. (Shown as #80)
4. Chester J .. Blaszck, 31 Summit St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #170)
5. William T. Burke, 3 South St. , Salem, Mass. (Shown as #171 )
«a m.,;.a.:a.�s ..*�a..v:»•:� _wr..r:v,m,-. a.+,.T.-.zv�: :,...r..,..+t.... .«r.. ..x..:.....-r.:.,..,.H:.......
ti
l{' j
d
4
h z
i 1
-
d.
L-- 1
J F
3"- Y
' q
R �
116
Pq
i r g
t `
3
.S c, F'",1. tr Ji7 171
k
9 '
_ n r
i+ A
Y
a"Cry / r 'Y7t �F.