44-46 JEFFERSON AVENUE - ZBA (2) 44-Jefferson Ave. R-1
vv
Augusto DaCunha-Petitioner I
Ernest Fratangelo-Owner
6-2
i
�J
i
�+Wmry R OF P'Sp c c ®c
oT 11� BOATSSESSORS
i
0 93 WASHINGTON STREET,CITY HALL,SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 (617)744-0660
ABUTTERS
feccm�
APRIL 14, 1983
TO: 44 JEFFERSON AVE ASSESSED OWNER: CHRISBE REALTY TRUST MAP 25 LOT 386
ERNIE FRATANGELLO JR
MAP LOT LOCATION ASSESSED OWNER / MAILING ADDRESS
25 654 53 JEFFERSON AVE NEWARK BOXBOARD CO ✓ SAME AS LOCATION
24 112 59 JEFFERSON AVE HIA PEARL 'CORP ✓ P 0 BOX 250
/ BRAINTREE, MA 02184
25 388 38 JEFFERSON AVE T.E.ANDRESEN INC / / SAME AS LOCATION
25 387 42 JEFFERSON AVE JOSEPH MARFONGELLI/✓ " "
25 384 48 JEFFERSON AVE JOSEPH INGEMI JR ✓ " "
25 383 50 JEFFERSON AVE LUIGIA D'ISSO / " " "
r 400 25 CALABRESE ST GEORGE & SOPHIE HASHEM.✓ 11
25 399 23 CALABRESE ST ANNA YAROSH ✓ "
25 398 21 .CAL-ABRESE ST RITA HIGLEY ✓ "
25 397 19 CALABRESE ST LOUIS & ,ANITA ROBICHEAU "
25 396 17 CALABRESE ST VINCENT J. FURFARO ✓ 106 MARGIN ST
SALEM, MA 01970
CITY OF SALEM
BOARD OF APPEAL
745-0215
Will hold a Public 2learing for all persons in-
terested in the petition submitted by AUGUSTO
DACUNHA for a Variance or Special Permit to
allow the premises at 44-46 JEFFERSON AVE.
(R-1) to be used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant.
Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 16, 1983 at 7:00 P.M., 2nd floor, -
ONE SALEM GREEN. -
BRENDA M.SUMRALL,Clerk .
Nov.2,9,1983
CITY OF SALEM
BOARD OF APPEAL
745-0215
Will hold a Public hearing for all persons in- -
terested in the petition submitted by AUGUSTO
DACUNIIA for a Variance or Special Permit to
allow the premises at 4446 JEFFERSON AVE.
(R-1) to be used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant.
Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 16, 1983 at 7:00 P.M., 2nd floor,
ONE SALEM GREEN.
BRENDA M.SUMRALL,Clerk
Nov.2,9,1983 -
CITY OF SALEM
BOARD OF APPEAL LZ
745-0215
Will hold a Public hearing for all persons in-
terested in the petition submitted by AUGUSTO
DACUNRA for a Variance or Special Permit to
allow the premises at 44-46 JEFFERSON AVE.
(R-1) to be used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant.
Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 16, 1983 at 7:00 P.M., 2nd floor,
ONE SALEM GREEN.
BRENDA M.SUMRALL,Clerk
Nov.2,9,1983
CITY OF SALEM <?y
BOARD OF APPEAL
7450215
Will hold a Public Hearing for all persons in-
terested in the petition submitted by AUGUSTO
DACUNI3A for a Variance or Special Permit to -
allow the premises at 4446 JEFFERSON AVE. r
(R-1) to be used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant.
Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 16, 1983 at 7:00 P.M., 2nd floor, -
ONE SALEM GREEN.
BRENDA M.SUMRALL,Clerk
Nov.2,.9,1983
CITY OF SALEM
BOARD OF APPEAL
7450215
Will hold a Public'Hearing for all persons in-
terested in the petition submitted by AUGUSTO
DACUNHA for a Variance or Special Permit to
allow the premises at 44-46 JEFFERSON AVE.
(R-1) to be used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant.
Said hearing to be held WEDNESDAY,
NOVEMBER 16, 1983 at 7:00 P.M., 2nd floor,
ONE SALEM GREEN.
BRENDA M.SUMRALL,Clerk
Nov.2,9,1983
6 )
146
-.�• ret _
nzz
393 3�� ra°j 0'BR 1 EN
♦�� ��B�a B�Ao 39/ �O
SQUARE., . j
652
38,450
yo
pp
r
396
`Br ..,' �_.�Ae ,�' J 4
rA
1.7
398k o A
$ 36�✓ 1 p B6Z5 h
6450
� rn_
3S9 0 `�
r 366 68
ro,Boa "
" a - •' 400 t
Q..�
"C
ET N
# art
,
1 -
.�•.� � �y«�� yy� e.����� _ .x9530 7 �•��
Y l -
'an9c t. Vis♦ �
COON,
t
rv- p
s C to of S$aljem' Aaseachus0ts
'j8�'cpmrE� � �UV `� ' iS �(74�� �[XE �E}taTfIlSEt[f �QdlfLjlIaLYE25
Zama A-PX:,mm, i R[CEIV-FD HASS.. 48 ` 1afttVmt° *=et
a4ief CITY OF SALEM, m, ems- 8137a - -
Date: November 16, 1983
Salem Board of Appeal Re: Augusto DaCunha
City of Salem, Massachusetts 44-46 Jefferson Ave.
one Salem Green Hearing Date : 11/16/83
Salem, Ma. 01970
Sirs:
As a result of notice received concerning the Board of Appeal
hearing for the above listed name and address, the Salem Fire
Department, requests the following items to be placed on record.
1 . The Salem Fire Department has no .objection to use and occupancy
of the premises as a Donut Shop/Restaurant, subject to the
z provisions listed below:
A. A fixed fire extinguishing system shall be required for
commercial cooking equipment, installed at this occupancy.
B. An approved hood and duct system shall be installed .as
required by the Mass. State Building Code and the Salem Fire
Cdde.
C. A local fire alarm system shall be installed as approved by
the Salem Fire Marshal.
D. Use and occupancy shall be contingent upon issuance of
a Certificate of Occupancy, before opening for business.
Respectfully submitted
Captain David J. Go in
�- cc : Building Inspector Salem Fire g"_arshal
file
Form # 105
APPEAL CASE NO. .. .. . . . . .. .. .. .. . . . ... . .
r Vii# of 'Sttlem, Aussar4usetts
t
J Plarb of Appeal
TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS:
The Undersigned represent that he is .are the owners of a certain parcel of land located
at NO. . . . . . . . . .44-46.Jettex4Qn. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . .Street; Zoning District. R . . .
. . . . .
. . . ; and said parcel is affected by Section(s). . . . .. .. . . . . . . . .
of the Massachusetts State Building Code.
Plans describing the work proposed, have been submitted to the Inspector of Buildings in
accordance with Section IX A.1 of the Zoning Ordinance.
CD
r' --tr -
m
tq
The Application for Permit was denied by the Inspector of Buildings for the following
reasons: Direct Appeal substitution of non-conforming use
The Undersigned hereby petitions the Board of Appeals to vary the terms of the Salem
Zoning Ordinance and/or the Building Code and order the Inspector of Buildings to
approve the application fee permit to build as filed, as the enforcement of said
Zoning By-Laws and Building Code would involve practical difficulty or unnecessary
hardship to the Undersigned and relief -nay be granted without substantially dero-
gating from the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and Building Code for
the following reasons:
Petitioner wishes to substitute a restaurant/coffee .and donut shop for the present
non-conforming fruit/produce and delicatessen located in a store .in an ,R1 District
at 44-46 Jefferson Street, Salem, Massachusetts
Owner."ne*t .Fr4tan qko . .. . .. .. . . .. . . . .... . .
Address."4.LYgri .Stteec,•.�ynt,M .N,j .
Telephone..543:2427. . ... . .. . .... . .... . .. . .. . ..
a
Petitioner. .A,4gggto P., Dacucnha _. . , _„ • .. . . .
Address. .41.Kanr4gk Aveque,•}�edggr�,.rus._ 02155
Date. Actobex. 5.,. 1983. . . . . . Telephone 396-1617
. . .... . . .. .. . . . . ..
By. . 49�1
Three copies of the application must be filed with the Secretary of the Board of
Appeals with a check, for advertising in the amount of. .. . ... . . . . ... ... . . .. .. . . .
four weeks prior to the meeting of the Board of Appeals. Check payable to The
Evening News.
. � ;. r„x, ^mtf.x a• -` s to r�� r �;.p— p,.
_.`,; .: _._cva.�<.�iv.,.�sznr,.•n'as-tt.w..�....,xm-u--'?t_.-.:_�. . ..,..,,>:.,.rt,.i's?�•»�za�i.r.M' ^.s�`_'�Utt. .:�.^.2='_a.. .�c'f�,';a-s. may. .9�..rsv"".�_�.a� a�'='
4• 1
F '
r
i.
r
t, w
NO.................................... ti
PETITION TO BOARD OF APPEALS
LOCATION
t
i ................. ..............................................
PETITIONER.Au�usa.a..]'.....1]aCunha . �F
ADDRESS.k.1-Haucock..A.ue.............. °3€
Medford, MA. 02155
CONDITIONS 7
........................................
PETITION APPROVED.................... ❑ s''
DENIED...................... Cl i
.............................. 19.........
�a I
4�'CONOyy
of itt1Em, Aassar4usetts
a
Pourb of Appvd
• �rOuuxe
December 20, 1983
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN THAT AS OF NOVEMBER 30, 1983 THE
DECISION OF THE BOARD OF APPEAL HAS BEEN FILED IN THE OFFICE
OF THE CITY CLERK TO DENY THE PETITION OF AUGUSTO DACUNHA FOR
A SPECIAL PERMIT TO ALLOW A RESTAURANT/COFFEE & DONUT SHOP AT
44-46 JEFFERSON AVE.
BOARD OF APPEAL
Brenda M. Sumrall, Clerk
IASS-
APPEAL FROM THIS DEC IF ANY, SHALL BE 1^.ADE PURSUANT TO SECTION E OF THE t<FILIN
GENERAL LA`;VS. CHAPTER 808, AND SIIALL 6E FILED WITHIN 20 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF FILING
SEC;IOpI 11. THEcVPS 1,CBEAR:i;Pr rl{iL CERT.IT
C'r THIS DECISION I J THE OFflCE OF TYIE CITY CLE1?' .
p:;,3SANT TO ii.A88. EE":ERf,L LA:S. CHAPMR BGII,
FRA;II ED HEREI21. SHALL NO! MAKE EFFEf,7 U^iT!L A COPY OF THE D.::
CRAAIIGN OF THE CITY L'.LERi( THAT 20 DAfS HAVE ELAPSED AND NO APPEAL HAS DEEM FITS
OR THAT, IF SUCH AN APPEAL HAS BECPI RLE, THAT IT HAS BEEN DlStidSSEp OR DEi;IED IS
RE:: HAT, IN THE SOUTH ESSEX REGISi RY OF DE"tDS AND INCEXED UNDER THE tJAIdE OF THE OWNER
OF RECORD OR IS RECORDED AND NO ON THE OWNER'S CERTIFICATE BOARDOFAPPEAL
DATE OF HEARIN p7 ,
PETITIONER
LOCATION
v
MOTION: TO GRANT b Jay; SECONDED
TO DENY SECONDED
LEAVE TO WITHDRAW SECONDED
ROLL CALL ABSENT PRESENT GRANT DENY WITHDRAW
SCOTT CHARNAS Y
JAMES HACKER (/
DOUGLAS HOPPER
EDWARD LUZINSKI /
JOSEPH PIEMONTE
ASSOCIATE MEMBERS
RICHARD BENGAL
ARTHUR LABRECQUE
DISCUSSION & CONDITIONS:
_ fit ofSalem, �24EassaClIusetts
... �' Pourb of �yyyeal '83 NOV 30 1
^•arae w:,
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF AUGUSTO DACUNHA (PETITIONER) , RNPSs E
FRATANGELO (OWNER) FOR A VARIANCE OR SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 44-46'
JEFFERSON AVE. , SALEM -
A hearing on this petition was held on November 16, 1983 with the following
Board Members present: James B. Hacker, Chairman; Messrs. , Charnas, Hopper and
Piemonte. Notices of the hearing were sent to abutters and others and notices
of the hearing were properly published in the Salem Evening News in accordance
with Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A.
Petitioner requests a Variance or Special Permit to use the premises as a
restaurant/coffee and donut shop. The premises were last used as a fruit/produce
and delicatessen in this R-1 district.
Since it is a Special Permit that is needed and not a Variance, the provision of
the Salem Zoning Ordinance which is applicable to this request is Section V B 10
which provides as follows:
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary appearing
in this Ordinance, the Board of Appeal may, in
accordance with the procedure and conditions set
forth in Section VIII F and IX D, grant Special Permits
for alterations and reconstruction of nonconforming
structures, and for changes, enlargement, extension or
expansion of nonconforming lots, land, structures,
and uses, provided, however, that such change, extension,
enlargement or expansion shall not be substantially more
detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the
neighborhood.
In more general terms, this Board is, when reviewing Special Permit requests,
guided by the rule that a Special Permit request may be granted upon a finding
by the Board that the grant of the Special Permit will promote the public health,
safety, convenience and welfare of the City's inhabitants.
The Board of Appeal, after considering the evidence presented at the hearing,
makes the following findings of fact:
1 . Petitioner's plan was opposed by some neighbors;
2. Use of the premises as requested will cause an odor as a byproduct of
baking which will substantially interfere with the neighbors use and
enjoyment of their own properties;
3. Use of the premises as requested may serve to bring back a rat
population to the neighborhood which plagued neighbors when the
premises were used as a fruit/produce and delicatessen ` tore.
S
DECISION ON THE PETITION OF AUGUSTO DACUNHA FOR A
VARIANCE OR SPECIAL PERMIT FOR 44-46 JEFFERSON AVE.
On the basis of the above findings of fact and on the evidence presented at the
hearing, the Board of Appeals concludes as follows:
.1 . The Special Permit requested cannot be granted without substantial .
detriment to the public good;
2. The requested relief will not promote the health, safety, convenience or
welfare of the city's inhabitants.
Therefore, the Board of Appeals voted unanimously against granting petitioner's
requested relief.
The Petitioner's request for a Special Permit is hereby denied.
Cn
Scott E. Charnas, Acting Secretary
w v .
H L t AO° PurS•ANT TO S« i U E cs
r V . AND tiq� E r E� - h:i.l 20 DAYS ArTc3 •HE EAI
"' 1; �� Dr .J3 I TH. OFFICE OF THE CITY Clc"rc' .
J
rS' i ` '� L.'.a Gr+�Pi ER SCE °E' '±
F i �ii.1t 11 THE VA AMANCE �i -
'' - ''. S{ LL ,.1 T.:"c EF,ECr UNTIL A CCPV Of THE c• Clol r -
i
CIiY CIER•; ii'Ar 20 DAYS HAVE - _
�F: cUt: CEJ r1!].N� A?fir L h+'t i_ _
tH .fi APPEA! Ii" D-EN FILE. Tl-.A-.- IT HA°
IN THE SOJTH ESSEX n �
REGISTR'f OF DEEDS ANDL`IOEXED URD ? F"
`
OR 'S RECORDED AND NOTED ON THE OY/NER'S CERTIFICATE Or TOLE'.."'...c cF
. - - BOARD OF APPEAL
A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE
CITY CLERK
f
MINUTES - NOVEMBER 16, 1983
page two
43 Essex St. - Continued
Daniel Benson, 44 Essex St. , agrees with all these objections, many times this
garage is operating well into the evening. There isn't any room there as it is,
it is very noisy, any increase in use would cause additional suffering. Also
opposed for the same reasons: Pat Miller, 48 Essex St. , Bob Welles, 42 Essex St.
Derek Kavanaugh, 72 Essex St. , Bert Karanish, 64 Essex St. and Walt Ratar, 42
Essex St. In Rebuttal: Ralph Sciavone, to keep with the Historical aspect of
the neighborhood, we went to great expense to renovate, we are willing to get
rid of the tanks which will save on the fire insurance that the neighbors pay, all
we are asking for is four cars, we have let the neighbors use our lot for parking
when they needed to. During the day we park our trucks across the street. John
Collins, I have come to work many mornings and have had no place to park. Mr.
Hacker asked about the cars they are working on, are they on the street. Mr.
Collins said sometimes if we have no room on the lot. Councillor Nowak, I have
had only one complaint and that was taken care of, these fellows have done a good
job. I am sure if you asked Mr. McIntosh, the Building Inspector, he could tell
you he has never had any complaints. Mr. McIntosh said he did have one complaint
about parking but it turned out not be them. Mr. Piemont, the garage is already
there, isn' t it possible to keep your own equipment on your own lot. If we were
to accept this, would like to see some restrictions, such as not parking truck on
street. Mr. Charnas, not sure we can do that. Mr. Hopper, they don't have enough
parking for the business they are doing, to increase this is not a good idea, not
compatible with neighborhood. Mr. Hacker, this encroaches on the neighborhood.
Mr. Charnas made a motion to grant the petition. Mr. Piemonte seconded. VOTING
IN OPPOSITION TO THE MOTION: Mr. Charnas, Mr. Hacker, Mr. Hopper. VOTING PRESENT:
Mr. Piemonte. PETITION DENIED.
44-46 Jefferson Ave. - Augusto DaCunha (Petitioner) Ernest Fratangelo(Owner)
Petitioner is requesting a Variance/Special Permit to allow the premises to be
used as a Donut Shop/Restaurant in this R-1 district. Mr. Charnas read the
application and a letter from the Fire Marshal stating they had no objections as
long as the Fire Code was met. Mr. White represented the petitioner, we are here
to substitute one non-conforming use for another. This is under a Purchase and
Salem Agreement, if it is granted it will comply with all the codes. Mr. DaCunha
showed pictures of the property and explained the renovations he plans to make.
There will be parking for approximately ten cars, will have about twenty two seats.
Will have six employees plus two bakers, three employees and one baker per shift.
Mr. Charnas told him he need a minimum of eight parking spaces. Mr. White explaine
they may run into problem because of the ledge, no sure how many we will be able
to get. Mr. DaCunha said the dumpster will be in the rear of the building. Some
of the neighbors said there was a rat problem there at one time. The hours of
operation would be 6 to 11 . Speaking in Favor: Charles Dubrow, 14 Puritan Ave.
Marblehead, I have driven through that area for years, there are many businesses
there, this would be compatible. Ernest Fratangello, owner of the property, tried
to sell the property for a Machine Shop, that was denied, the Donut Shop will be
good in the neighborhood. Speaking in opposition: Gerry Yarosh, speaking for
her mother Anna Yarosh, 23 Calabrese St. and for Rita Higley, 21 Calabrese St. ,
there is a ledge problem, I lived there for many years, the rat problem did exist,
it does not exist now. Any blasting will cause problems, this is not the area
for a donut shop, concerned about the odors from the donut shop. In rebuttal:
Mr. White explained the bakers set there own hours, the doughnuts could be baked
perhaps three or four in the morning. Hearing closed. Mr. Piemonte, concerned
about the waste that could attract rats, also concerned about the parking. Mr.
Charnas asked what happens should there turn out to be a rat problem, what does
the health department do. Mr. McIntosh explained about baiting. Mr. Hacker, this
is a residential zone, but there is a lot of businesses there. I don't think they
will be able to get ten parking spaces in because of the ledge.
MINUTES - NOVEMBER 16, 1983
page three
44-46 Jefferson Ave. - Continued
Mr. Charnas made a motion to grant the petition, Mr. Hopper secor
OPPOSITION TO THE MOTION: Mr. Charnas, Mr. Hacker, Mr. Hopper, I
PETITION DENIED
Off Dove Ave. & Jefferson Ave. - Shaughnessy Hospital
Petitioners are requesting a Variance to allow area at the intersection of Dove
Ave. and Jefferson Ave. to be used for parking. This is an R-2 district. Mr.
Charnas read the application. Mr. Al Levesque, Chairman of the Building and Space
Department of Shaughnessy, represented the petitioner. He explained the hospital
wanted to lease this area from New England Power Co. to take care of the overflow
of parking. People have been parking on Dove Ave. and Jefferson Ave. , this is
a problem, Dove Ave. is very narrow and it interfers with the fire lanes. This
will just be temporary, they are hoping to get something permanent, but will not
be able to before the snow comes. We are hoping to get a couple of dozen cars.
No one appeared in favor. In opposition: Mr. George Gagnon, 17 Bertuccio Ave. ,
what guarantee do we have there would be no noise. Mr. Hacker asked how close
their property was to this area. About 20 - 50 feet. Mr. Levesque explained
most parking will be during the day, we would be willing to limit the hours, it
would be from 6 to 6. Mr. Piemonte asked if they restricted them to no night
hours if that would satisfy their objection. Mr. Gagnon asked about access. Mr.
Levesque said the access would be from Jefferson Ave. Hearing closed. Mr.
Charnas made a motion to grant the petition and allow this area to be used for
parking on condition it be used only between the hours of 6:00 a.m and 6:00 p.m.
seven days a week, to be used only by out-patients and hospital staff, only good
as long as the hospital leases the property, no improvements, especially paving,
are to be done on the property. Mr. Hopper seconded. UNANIMOUSLY GRANTED
3 River St. - Anthony Scoglio f
Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit to convert an existing two family
dwelling into a two unit condominium in this R-2 district. Mr. Charnas read the
application and a letter from the Fire Marshal. Attorney John Tierney represented
the petitioner. He explained,many renovations have been done and the property
has been upgraded. This will have no effect on low or moderate income persons.
The house is now vacant, it is a two family and will remain two family. The
tenants moved our in December 1982. There are two parking spaces available. We
will comply with the Fire Code. Mr. Scoglio showed on the plans where the parking
spaces were located. Speaking in favor: Paul Willis, 4 River St. , the work that
has been done is good, I am concerned about the Historic Commission's conditions.
Mr. John Carr, 7 river St. , member of the Historic Commission, said the Commission
wants them to put wood shutters, there are some other conditions,which are Public
Information, but could not recall them all right now. This building does seem to
be occupied now, this does not effect my support. Carol Willis, 4 River St. , would
like to see the house finished, I am in favor. Carol Caron, 7 River St. , they
have done a tremendous job, but it should be completed. No one appeared in
opposition. Attorney Tierney explained that the house was not occupied, the
people they think live there are only security people. Mr. Carr, for the past
ten years this has been a single family, it may have been two family prior to that.
The parking is piggyback, the first floor was occupied till about a month ago,
this still has nothing to do with my support. Paul Willis, the tenant down stairs
lived there till about a month ago, there is someone living upstairs now. Mr.
Charnas, I am concern whether there is a tenant there, I am concerned whether
proper notice was given. Att. Tierney, there are no tenants, they are security
people. Mr. Piemonte asked if they could submitted a notorized statement to this
affect. Mr. Hacker, in view of this, would like to continue this till this next
i,.
rl f
t � � Imo• 1 �• � ` �
`•lry`�1 IIF \ \ tit IS 'Z q lam
'k , m N�i•si•sem:�-- �'`:;
• � C- .�- o � 1' ` .. � �� i– :�',I– � `l
ki
Ont u 4
o T
t1,lYlTla` \ � v9 - = - �4 �, `�s, �` �----� �N7/•S/ZO"s✓— i
1 N ioo 00
hl
I
6'Qk;Jw,.'ss :.ii9''N:� .. s�fh%' r :'v tw_ _:r�� : i d. '- •- e �'. �9 ',/�,r-Q i.-'"i'�:.li^.+ :.� '..�tiow_? ,�. iY ri :
.y- :ay. Ip,. ri.. ,....m'lrii'l,e •..e•'•t ,i .. ...,. ,�i,i f� ,_r. -,.. ,y .,a .fi !a.M..� r;- :.'. ...,' .'.. ' .6 �Y'�.' 1 'Fnla0. ry.w. 1�`wa ; e+ifC.fa'ef.. Y.oS.A k.�.,i,. ..q..i4} ii .P.vy.'\• Y -¢3;" �
'd f i' !i'} 4 �: ..1 : i .. } Y�E' y. e.•13' 1 a v:�t., r,. T..I� �o �.ify -+. ?: {{ ��'� .:: ��dt e. ' x ,. f� t �, Il x,.j�•• .✓ { S ..I. �'I 'if'•;4 f y54 .
� xt.:. 31 .:t•.: ;P } tt ,. ,, .i I ?`1 '. } . 7`
j( .,
y �' I .{;,� �«:.
:
- -- - _ ._
. \•
Z.
' /e '3'/ /lydi�zs/ ss�/� C ;�✓ D . )
}
14500
..t iII
�� f
�
h p 411 \ T
', � h D n � :roe � •: .�,,
EZ � , a �a
/JS 00 � I 57tS �•� '
.•a.rr
A,
..��/j
GO.•/re,/LOW/A+/,,c
da/!dl pG..Sx Zr/P. . fbr,'arTfo �6n F a��rn�, •S.,cro� = s
3�cy�,A✓.vit/�,�A.t'O wi/h .Le1 C/i��pise/of tl,�:'�,%^,•i•• '� �"
.. ._ I; :4
_..•_ti.,J_� ^ Z.l±.p« 'f I:IP rl.AN NAR VFKV RF.I IIIL^F•11• FUR 't'
��" I^ /- CupRF.C•1 HCf jj ,,(i RCF.Ug1GU'Ab Orl k1l,
L+r,F•• NLS:,?��'.L3?`�� `'��
QY•+,V/J/h•. W,/,�V/.'y/���J��f,�7,",U��,d/,jJ g' -
/
�G aA OF
ii7
54 L
w.:v/ /.L0. �.�.19 !' M.K./-Q•P G� - '.
ZI IL
1/
..F ;Bawl Ones :( E571E Sr��rrSlrer,�r/e.r. ,ti '
1. 11 • nt ' [t/ FYl 7?,/.,1�vt•YL./ �{:,ff i�'�1S. tr��
02 IPE i i i I 0 N OF A v �- V SjD JAC UN H ff Fo/2 �
V/sAry ( �� old
! )ku G-/V
!I
1 '2 i ' 7 in�_/'L{Y�eirTr a ✓oL�i aa�o a ✓ J/z�'�� .Oc./w, � �/- l �
VSIl -I 0. I a- ft?
_ — H'r`�_J .Wit, 'a J �' J� a J �t. vV ' N�✓4Pi
+ i S a
d, U4/Li NLv�1i VJ ! 0 (.� b -fn O �lln�nHf p�
w4
;
I
Tb
I T �
0 0K aJ 6� � �f��� n /- acl-141
o ow , ro ;L
re to 1_y t-eyi�
oLJ w (�
GCS / 0
it �Ikoum1 -I
I
'4
- -- ------------- ------- -
I
- - - - - -'-. - - --- -- - ---� - � ----
f�
I
Coa Liu r QJ ��9wJ
IT
eon
/ I
i!
ij
ft
'1
i
i
f —
't _
I
i ll
��
TI
APPEAL CASE NO. .. .. . .. . .. .. .. .. . . . ... . .
(1li#g >z# Iem, �zss �hxzP##s
pnarb of Appeal
TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS:
The Undersigned represent that heis are the owners of a certain parcel of land located
at NO. . . . . . . . . .44 4.6 Jrefferanv. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .Street; Zoning DistrictJ4. . .
. . . . . . . . . . . ; and said parcel is affected by Section(s). . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .
of the Massachusetts State Building Code.
Plans describing the work proposed, have been submitted to the Inspector of Buildings in
accordance with Section IX A. 1 of the Zoning Ordinance.
row :� co
NS> CZD - T
m ys, rnn
The Application for Permit was denied by the Inspector of Buildings for the following
reasons: Direct Appeal substitution of non-conforming use
The Undersigned hereby petitions the Board of Appeals to vary the terms of the Salem
Zoning Ordinance and/or the Building Code and order the Inspector of Buildings to
approve the application fee permit to build as ,filed, as the enforcement of said
Zoning By-Laws and Building Code would involve practical difficulty or unnecessary
hardship to the Undersigned and relief may be granted without substantially dero-
gating from the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance and Building Code for
the following reasons:
Petitioner wishes to substitute a restaurant/coffee and donut shdp for the present
non-conforming fruit/produce and delicatessen located in a store in an Rl District
at 44-46 Jefferson Street, Salem, Massachusetts
Owner rrnest Fratangelo . .... . . . . . .. . . ... ....
Address 124 Lynn Street,.Lin, MA. ..
Telephone.A9!-2997 . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . . . . .. . .
Petitioner. Augusto P. DaCunha
Address. 41 Hancock Avenue, Medford. MA . 02155
Date. Actoper, 5p. XM. . . . . . Telephone.. . 396 -1617
Three copies of the application must be filed with the Secretary of the Board of
Appeals with a check, for advertising in the amount of. .. . . . . . . . .... . . .. . . .... . .
four weeks prior to the meeting of the Board of Appeals. Check .payable to The
Evening News.
k",
id5f� j�
. 4 75i y4r'l t4 ° b5 {xp4 jtk�tle�c}e nt_ SIT } i - V 1i' ktm
}+�*�
Iw
NO .........
PETITION TO BOARD OF APPEALS
LOCATION
................................................................
PETITIONERA149u§X,Q..Pa.-I Quaba {cr :t
21
ADDRESS....41...Uan cark...AvA...,.......
Medford, MA. 02155
' ................................................. - .`. ' "! Z .. U] � fey i - '^�0'x^^�`G
I
CONDITIONS
u o
.................
1. ...
a
• .................
.................................................................
PETITION APPROVED. ......... ❑ ;
l.' C i
DENIED..
.................. ....... . 19.........
(ritg of �'ttlem,
r
�4'�'�u�rv• i �.E 11}U" parlmext �eaaq=rfers - -
VIP', ire �e
��
James renxan '� 49 ?.1afaU tte L rEet
CITY 0; 5AL o�Sttlem, B137II
Date: November 16, 1983
Salem Board of Appeal Re: Augusto DaCunha
City of Salem, Massachusetts 44-46 Jefferson Ave.
One Salem Green Hearing Date: .11/16/$3
Salem, Ma. 01970
Sirs:
As a result of notice received concerning the Board of Appeal
hearing for the above listed name and address, the Salem Fire
Department, requests the following items to be placed on record.
1. The Salem Fire Department has no objection to use and occupancy
of the premises as a Donut Shop/Restaurant, subject to the
provisions listed below:
A. A fixed fire extinguishing system shall be required for
commercial cooking equipment, installed at this occupancy.
B. An approved hood and duct system shall be installed .as
required by the Mass. State Building Code and the. Salem Fire
Cude.
C. A local fire alarm system shall be installed as approved by
the Salem Fire Marshal.
D. Use and occupancy shall be contingent upon issuance of
a Certificate of Occupancy, before opening for business. .
Respectfully submitted _
Captain David J. Go ein
cc: Building Inspector Salem Fire ? ars-al
file
Form n 105
I
I
i�
h
r�
�I -
j
c
----- ;-- -- - - - - -tl- . _ --
--- - - ------- - - --�i ---
f�
_.-- - - I _
r - - -- -- -- -- _,---- ---- --- r---- - ----- - -