Loading...
13 ARTHUR STREET - ZBA r 3 I'irNn�r S'�Yee�- v 1 I ' Zoning Board Proiect Stat» cho Address & Applicant: -R Date Submitted to BOA: o Bch R 4 Clerk Stamp: Variances Only - Constructive Approval Date. (100 days from filing) ❑ Abutters List Requested: ❑ Abutters Notice Sent: ❑ Notice to Abutting Cities & Towns, Councillors: ❑ Legal Noticeosted at City p Hall: 14 days before meeting) ❑ Legal Notice Emailed & Confirmed: ❑ Legal Notice Posted on Web: ❑ Agenda to Applicant: Applicant's email address or fax number to send agenda: Opened at Meeting: -- Continued Meetings: Extension Form(s) =g2ned & Clerk Stamped? Closed at Meeting: 2-0 Decision: Decision Filed. p�Ac2p f• after decision filed) Appeal Period Over: C (21"day Decision Sent to Applicant: Notice of Decision Sent to abutters, cities and towns, councillors: F ZBA ACTION FORM BOA'ItDdGIEIbIBER� .v; �tvIOTION",SICOTYD} „V_,CQ;TE3 Date: Rebecca Curran (Chair) 1 Mike Duffy Petitioner: Tom Watkins y Peter Co elan y Address: Jimmy Tsitsinos Jim Hacker(Alt. Paul Viccica(Alt.) S—o Conditions: Total: Petitioner shall comply.with all city and state statutes, ordinances, codes and regulations. All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building commissioner. ❑All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. 6/Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. E A Certificate of Occupancy is to be obtained. ��A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained. LJ Petitioner shall obtain street numbering from the City of Salem Assessor's Office and shall display said number so as to be visible from the street. IJ Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including, but not limited to,the Planning Board. ❑Unless this Decision expressly provides otherwise, any zoning relief granted does not empower or authorize the Petitioner to demolish or reconstruct the structure(s)located on the subject property to an extent of more than fifty percent(50%)of its floor area or more than fifty percent(50%)of its replacement cost at the time of destruction. If the structure is demolished by any means to an extent of more than fifty percent(50%)of its replacement cost or more than fifty percent(50%)of its floor area at the time of destruction, it shall not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of the Ordinance. 0 s�o��� covnrniSS�� n Rer/�e>� CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPE47AW,30 Aplot I`0 120 WASMGTON STREET♦SArEM,MASSACHos2Tts3M, MASLERS KR.BERLFYDR sc0j.L THi.E:97&745-9595♦ FAx:978-740-9846 - MAYOR August 3% 2017 Decision City of Salem Board of Appeals Petition of LORRAINE BOUCHER, requesting a Special Permit per Sec. 3.0 Table of Uses to allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit at 13 ARTHUR STREET (Map 23 Lot 35)(R-2 Zoning District). A public hearing on the above Petition was opened on April 19,2017 pursuant to M.G.L Ch. 40A, § 11 and continued to the following dates:May 17,2017,June 21,2017,July 19,2017 and August 16,2017.The hearing was dosed on August 16,2017 with the following Salem Board of Appeals members present Rebecca Curran (Chair),Tom Watkins,Jimmy Tsitsinos,Mike Duffy,and Peter A.Copelas. The Petitioner is requesting a Special Permit per Sec 3.0 Table of Uses to allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit Statements of fact: 1. In the petition date-stamped March 28, 2017 the Petitioner requested a Special Permit per Sec. 3.0 Table of Uses to allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit 2. Dean and Lorraine Boucher,presented the petition David Jaquith,project architect,was also present to discuss the proposed project. 3. The property is located in an R-2 Zoning District. 4. Currently, there is a primary building with two (2) dwelling units and a carriage house. The petitioner is proposing to convert the existing historic carriage house into a thud dwelling unit on the property. 5. The carriage house was renovated approximately 22 years ago with the installation of vinyl windows and vinyl siding. The £taming of the original structure is still exposed on the interior and the stone foundation still exists. The porch and concrete foundation were added, but pre-dated the current owners. 6. At the April 19, 2017 meeting the Board informed the applicant that the historic carriage house ordinance is a density bonus intended to restore historic structures. The Board expressed concern that the existing carriage house structure was significantly altered and no longer has traditional carriage house features on the exterior of the structure. 7. At the April 19, 2017 meeting the petitioner presented a map from 1911. As described in the Salem Zoning Ordinance, a historic carriage house is an accessory building originally built to house carriages, horses, or for use as a bam, that has been in existence since 1900 at its present location. The Board requested that the petitioner provide additional information to show that this building met the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance. City of Salem Board of Appeals August 30,2017 Project: 13 Arthur Street Page 2 of 4 8. At the April 19, 2017 meeting architect David Jaquith presented elevation plans for the proposed restoration of the structure. The proposed renovation would consist of new windows, barn doors, clapboards,and other elements to make the structure appear old 9. At the April 19,2017 meeting, the Board requested additional maps to demonstrate that the structure met the definition of a historic carriage house in addition to submission of proposed elevations for the Board to review prior to the meeting,and interior photos. 10. At the April 19,2017 meeting,John Farnsworth,a land surveyor from Lancaster,MA,testified that he searched aerial and topographic maps and did not find documentation prior to 1900 for this structure. 11. The public heating was continued to May 17, 2017 to allow the petitioner more time to provide additional documentation. 12. At the May 17, 2017 meeting, the petitioner presented a trap from Salem State University from 1897 that showed a stable behind the existing house. However,the map presented did not show the current carriage house structure in its current location. The Board requested additional information that may demonstrate that the structure met the definition of a historic carriage house as defined in the Salem Zoning Ordinance. c 13. The public hearing was continued from the May 17,2017 meeting to the June 21,2017 meeting. 14. At the June 21, 2017 meeting the petitioner presented a map from 1906 and 1907. There was an existing outbuilding on this map and the 1897 trap. The Board requested an opinion of the City Solicitor for a determination on whether the outbuilding could be considered a historic carriage house. 15. At the June 21,2017 meeting the petitioner requested a continuation to allow the Board to request an opinion from the City Solicitor on whether the property met the definition of a historic carriage house. The petitioner requested a continuation to the nem regularly scheduled meeting on July 19, 2017. 16. In a letter dated July 11, 2017,the City Solicitor provided an opinion and supplemental City Council meeting minutes from June 23, 1983 and February 23, 1984. Further, a property card from 1973 indicated that the property included a 320 square foot garage and 440 square foot barn. The property card information was consistent with the earlier maps provided by the applicant The City Solicitor concluded, based on the applicant's evidence and the City property card, that the current accessory structure meets the definition of a historic carriage house. 17. On July 19, 2017, the public hearing was continued to the August 16, 2017 public hearing due to a lack of quorum. No additional testimony was heard and no further discussion with the Board occurred on this date. 18. On August 16, 2017, the Board discussed the City Solicitor's findings and the criteria for a special permit The staff planner to the Historic Commission also reviewed the project and provided comments for the Board to consider. 19. The architectural design that is proposed is the conservation and architectural recreation of the historic features of the property rather than the preservation of existing architectural features. The Board requested that the petitioner consider working with the Historic Commission and find the original window openings and work with the applicant to design a more reasonable and nuanced architectural expression that is in keeping with the historic era of the building. 20. The requested relief,if granted,would allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit J City of Salem Board of Appeals August 30,2017 Project: 13 Arthur Street Page 3 of 4 21. At the public heating, thirteen (13) members of the public spoke in support and none spoke in opposition to the petition. The Salem Board of Appeals, after careful consideration of the evidence presented at the public hearing,and after thorough review of the petition, including the application narrative and plans, and the Petitioner's presentation and public testimony, makes the following findings that the proposed project meets the provisions of the City of Salem Zoning Ordinance: Findings for Special Permits: The Board finds that the structure meets the definition of a historic carriage house and the proposed use will not outweigh its beneficial impacts to the City or the neighborhood. 1. The social, economic, of community needs are served by the proposal as this project is a significant improvement to the neighborhood and is of economic value to the owner and community. 2. There are no impacts on traffic flow and safety, including parking and loading as the on-site parking requirements are met. 3. The capacity of the utilities is not affected by the project 4. There are no impacts on the natural environment,including drainage. F 5. The rehabilitation of the building and the creation of an additional dwelling unit conform to the existing neighborhood character. 6. The potential fiscal impact,including impact on the City tax base is positive. On the basis of the above statements of facts and findings,the Salem Board of Appeals voted five(5)in favor (Rebecca Cunan (Chair),Tom Watldns,Jimmy Tsitsmos,Mike Duffy,and Peter A.Copelas)and none (0) opposed to allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit,subject to the following berms, conditions and safeguards: Standard Conditions: 1. The Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes,ordinances,codes and regulations. 2. All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. 3. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to, 4. Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. 5. Petitioner shallobtain street numbering from the City's Assessors Office and shall display said number so as to be visible from the street. 6. Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. 7. A Certificate of Occupancy is to be obtained. 8. A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained 9. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including,but not limited to,the Planning Board. City of Salem Board of Appeals August 30,2017 Project: 13 Arthur Street Page 4 of 4 Special Conditions: 1. The applicant shall voluntarily apply to the Historical Commission and shall amend architectural plans in accordance with comments from the Commission on the proposed design.The intent of this is to ensure that the historic carriage house restoration will be done in a manner that is consistent with the historic character of the building including the windows,doors,clapboards,and architectural proportions that are appropriate to capture the historic character of this structure. 2. The project shall be worked on continuously and be complete no later than one (1)year after the issuance of a building permit Rebecca Curran c�,Chau Board of Appeals A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK Appral from this dninon,if aty,shall be made pumant to Sedion 17 of The Maaatbanttr General L"s Cbapkr 404, and shall befiled within 20 doyv of fikq of tbu deddan in the office;of The City Ckrk.Parsuant to the Masrachum tr General Lama Cbapkr 40A,Section 11, the Variance or Spedal Permit granted berm shat!not take effea anti/a ropy of the deacon bearing the avfrrate of the Gty Clerk bac been frkd wab the Essex South Re*y of Deedr. 4 CTTY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEALS 144tM PETITION FORM 1 \, CITY OF SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS h.•' '1 BOARD OF APPEALS - tla, 120 WASHINGTON STREET,3Ro FL (�a�RyAR 28 AM 9t 03 �C9R" SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 CITY CLERK Thomas St Pierre,Director of Inspectional Se CLERK Phone:978-619-5641 / Fax: 978-740-9946��� E�' MASS KimaERLEY DRISCOLL Erin Schaeffer,Staff Planner MAYOR Phone: 978-619-5685 /Fax: 978-740-0404 + r p-- TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS: The Undersigned represent that he/she is/are the owners of a certain parcel of land located at: t 8 � 1I �/ DEPT Or Address: ,n Zoning District: I�M, �NI1 y UEi `^ 1J(- 3 w�IaT ' An application is being submitted to the Board of Appeal for the following reason(s):This statement must describe what you propose to build,the dimensions,the zone property is in,and the zoning requirements.(Example: I am proposing to construct a 10'x 10'one story addition to my home located at 3 Salem Lane, in the R-2 Zoning District. The Zoning Ordinance requires the minimum depth of the rear yard to be 30 feet. The current depth o(my rear yard is 32 feet;the proposed addition would reduce the depth of the rear yard to 22 feet.) Tl UP 4" For this reason I am requesting: O Variance(s)from provisions of Section of the Zoning Ordinance,specifically from (i.e. minimum depth ofrearyard). What is allowed is (ft?sq ft?stories? %?), and what I amro osin i P P gs (ft?sq ft?stories?%?). 4A Special Permit under Section , of the Zoning Ordinance in order to ( )Appeal o the Decision of the Building Inspector(described below): O Comprehensive Permit for construction of low or moderate income housing(describe below): i Current Property Use:1UUPArre Lot Dimensions Included?( )Yes O No Wh (Example. Two Famil Home) y The Undersigned hereby petitions the Board of Appeals to vary the terms of the Salem Zoning Ordinance and allow the project to be constructed as per the plans submitted,as the enforcement of said Zoning By-Laws would involve practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship to the Undersigned and relief may be granted without substantially derogating from the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. CTfY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEALS PETITION FORM The following written statement has been submitted with this application: O For all Variance requests a written Statement of Hardship demonstrating the following must be attached: a) Special conditions and circumstances that especially affect the land,building,or structure involved, generally not affecting other lands,buildings,and structures in the same district; b) Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involved substantial hardship to the applicant;and c) Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good,and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. O For all Special Permit requests a Statement of Grounds must be attached.An application for a special permit for a nonconforming use or structure shall include a statement demonstrating how the proposed change shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood in accordance with Section 9.4 Special Permits. Such a statement should include reference to the following criteria: a) Social,economic,or community needs served by the proposal; b) Traffic flow and safety,including parking and loading; c) Adequacy of utilities and other public services; d) Impacts on the natural environment,including drainage; e) Neighborhood character;and 1) Potential fiscal impact, including impact on City tax base and employment. O For all Comprehensive Permits for construction of low or moderate income applicants should refer to M.G.L. Ch.40B § 20-23. Previous applications to the Board of Appeals involving this property have been submitted with this petition form. The Building Commissioner can provide documentation ofprevious applications to the petitioner or his representative. If different from petitioner. Petitioner: n w >ht tr L e 0- Property Owner: ot Li(� ��t �P_y�_ lk , Address: Z �M .� h � Address:-J3 A -/ it R P�1 Telephone: 2 I i,�s Telephone: W ��- /P�;3 Email:'l tN t, Yj �>e fin) no�/vim G,yp Email: t NLD OQI C �} 1,0� jM di C C'.d rhv Signature: L � Signature: (Attached consent tetter is also acceptable) Date:.. Date: If different from petitioner. Representative: A TRUE Address: ATTEST Telephone: Signature: Date: CITY CLERK DATE DPCD DATE This original application must be filed with the City Clerk. We, DEAN T. BOUCHER and KIM E. BOUCHER (formerly Kim E. Downey), Trustees of BOUCHER BOSTON STREET REALTY TRUST, under Declaration of Trust dated September- - 18, 1986, recorded Essex Registry of Deeds, Book 8518, Page 217, both of Salem Essex f2AxAeaaidssatiwxxV1x County, Massachusetts, grant to STANLEY J. MIKULSKI of 38 Monument Street,-Wenham, MA YOT with 11101`'4851ttOMPUUtU, to secure the payment of ---------------------Five Thousand and 00/100----------------------------- Dollars in one - years with 10.00 per centum interest per annum payable } as provided.in a. note of even date, ° the land m Salem'with'-,the buildings thereon, bounded and described as follows 'Lots?18 a,d 20 asIbhown on .,'Plan of a Part of D'e by"Farm4, Neer Castleb Hill,x''� ` ,Scala 10.)_feet-t,..en inrh, C.A._Pu nam, C.E.., Salem, Mass., 1878" recorded in - ,n Essex South District Registry of Deeds-on August 23,1878 at Book 1001, Leaf 300, being bounded and described as follows: u v w . NORTHERLY by Arthur Street, formerly John Street, .so called, eighty (80) feet; y .EASTERLY by Lot 22 on said plan aforesaid, one hundred (100) feet; w., SOUTHERLY by Lots 19 and. 17 on said plan, eighty (80) feet; and WESTERLY by Lot 16 on said plan, one hundred (100) feet. u Being the same premises conveyed to us as Trustees by deed of Stanley J. Mikulski, . dated April 27, 1990, to be recorded herewith. y Subject to a first mortgage to Heritage Co-operative Bank dated April 27, 1990,. - walso to be recorded herewith. - - y r M .. q 6 T 4 y 0 M L This mortgage is upon the statutory condition, ti foor-any breach,of which the mortgagee .ehall have the statutory power of sale. *IfM0 our hand and seal this 27th _ day of April - 1990- .- Trustee of Boucher Boston Street Trustee of Boucher Boston'Street Realty Trust Realty Trust �(iht�bmmOnlU¢tt�tOf�888Bd11t8C118 ' Essex sa. April 27, 1990 - Then personally appeared the above named Dean T. Boucher and Kim E. Boucher (formerly Kim E. Downey) Trustees as aforesaid - and acknowledged the foregoing instrument to be their free act and deed, 7 - before me, - Nwa y Puuic 7dmf]P9<ww" My commission expires 4/4/91 19 s -4 6SJ'Q 1TkLP�O_71�2_e__tJ_. ��1 �Lf�C2Qei�hatzl�lA�C1 L-TJ—D_o - eA�YLa�/C� O be AT— A I-4 1 J C x612 dpi ae_�79 U v s e {�a P F �l c eR��J�a C Lo✓�_ i Y , rr �1+ • l P ~ I sAINs ;f� ! i+alai. a, -PMEMO— saw � .. /I} eYlx�'v vla 3♦ ✓s ,fY ift";wO 11 fool P \ by •�� �Q. ,�9� l j+. Y � � ^. ..y. S+'i- ?ry.�'�:i� i. _ _ _ _ -9fa>�'_•":'�'�!?• .e•,.i£>P1��0'� ,. �_`:�?3s' 1 ? } IrAEG law ;nM � � `�'�/. . �� •, ��.�}a vim+' < y is a =ya _TnP�w' Pfi ,�yyyy YL t8m r i r ti i t / S k }+ }?Y AVE � 4 ems'" + 4,11 tie . e 1 /fes/ Fb • , aa•9 `y��Iy�. l s 'Ae Alir ` v R , •-+_.fix yam. 4- ..3;./..' yre„4.aR v i* JP .,o. i ren Wtss+ ►g S'". 3 x * -�r,.,t < r* .t e"as'` y kk ii`YTs .d .:r sa it" vIW , IF'}lf 4xa� o-s♦ rMCI i y 5 a4 f Y � ax ��•Y ,.s} Y'{,t t roK}}a C +�14" Axd � t + �h t �i` �i� f-. 'rs t 't ' tiaR £'pAk "Si A7r t t C 's iF' Y} 10,W � 6Y I is d1' s, 1JeX`c Iay y_ sup5m �{ 1 T g l• �j }� a� F} 7kiy s i t1 �7a x a 7 rir n ftr>kP 5i+sop Y a r.t ♦. ' ae ie, +6 et+Vc aYt; #'a r> �� .,, _.: T�>yd � Cik 3"� '�� t�a7Yi� yj�T,i� ♦ yr A � ♦ "eE -e, S t{i `3ig a T" t R14 k R! 14 q � +s�'t` ' 'AV ,t i. �� yr ♦ v T (hs 'fid' l 4 + v,S ,yp9 1� i x ,t ,4 �Y� #Q am7 �'. � �Y•;' r r<`7 r .t� �'}3e,7�g��{ �{ j, 2�R"5; it * �gaCtt !;. . 5j` S $ Al 14 a �+ '$jIf. lit' r"e l �r n a�biva �, e § s g k +ya�r��"�r'��� � t��P a �e >♦ ki � �='�S 's�r � � "� . � lilt yyae �' °.f Y "4�+P g+ kvLs.� �kn? yR 4 V. 44ix tixi�a..�c & ■ ' 10 y 4 r ' 4 # F"}Ylr7.> � a"" A.�*p.rY Ai3 ��♦x'��#by tryi ty #y '#,''4- ' t +rt is iaN iy ki �f'2 ° afi � y wfx tvc�jffs µ ;53# dal} •T}`'}�Y `- y, 10 #sf S��u �&r 4rhsi d' SL # }$r � t 1. �44 't4 tisk ±cfr t � $z aL 4 " tt Y4�2� E } r< t � . 7, Y >< S ^�".�rt"a.a �O�rY,...ayor,YJ,�„�.t{PtA� > x '. . 5y' yx a' 41 ¢ �� DI { U. i7. aTl'Y a i .4 1 t4.',tn5 110 d ' s #,a,.iT } 5 }` 3* r •. j x # s">lf� t: _ k f4 ")II "hitt,'" K �i5� E a test x ';,. $ }i itn c5ziiR °-BEY vaW � 4 a ` 1r ( a film ` '' ; 9y�rf � y3 SA y' tx'xj% i y� e $vY:y [� "k.i F 'CF\LEf SIY "7}.*�v"y�.h Y •AE.* +' {$ >ml `s' pi # Y >b}r iYI.•{ x .! Y1. Yeo .i."i4 Y.Y5 hwX Yj44", vk '}>Y � e€ z 1 r, #i +a b-5 i t l y.'e 1D o- t �§ iYt 4 Xk'aP +t '�iY R m 5' 4f , 5t>f> �q` e�v ,(1�„`k 'fM' t`>,� f-x{ S y �.kkRx' i{a MIN'"7^i. y YS^k4 }'3 b. i` ` I 4�'m' P PP i �^�.� H �'4� ��', T y$ 's'1f i, b a3•"- & s "r,r• �i5„ r.'rx; n•rt�+ e rn�+ s�°3�{'y* i � ?� F ^s+� f,��te W { iF_a st{tig " }5#ra to ��� Y + Y y F s - l� i •t .,ya* { " 4 S R S1 f '�..x yy,, t: p v i"},. t'�l� t k 4^ tt Ct y p" y �L{ i 'k5 ,' Y 5 x�i�i�m `5t �r1 t�}-Tk e . t r` t z • six °r 4 �z S4 �- �t 4 ;��^vyv ;"} "'`Yx� tic'n ,:t,�e }34i r➢f d 4(,,t 7s x61v 'fid ';It+"ti x�Gws ✓4 t s x} « �x k r rs k s! ae1i k v S n y, 'x$z sYYx .' >. y 4 yY f y`4 (1y J�aii {+Y y k pt t- 2 t -F a 4 px{ t eY �. '1�.1�R'4,c:y, 4�v,.•Ar- 3ra. est Te,T�I oa, lricl( bUild111 �saesroS sH��+>ye with bric14 k [ C or rnefial cornice I SK'fUGHTL16HTiN6 i lre wall; Q Inch , -= ❑ Toa sToaes Y oH�,r above root' a SKYLttfHTi16HTING ff •s r firtIREE ST,dRiE$ � P �12 , ► � f. y� t WSKYtGL_A Y 1. )i5Y "f rt k SIR W GES ABY RF fe este thickness , ofwall inInchesR '�- z �• 6 �iMall wtths�tt osrenln °°and size Iici�es A MY j +� _ 5��� e-• �� Wall wlfih�ot�l1F9 ^a p ngs4r��floorsaseslnaed ; asen. ln fw> `Y^ -v�>YF'b "9w. SbF r�§�.�r+;p ( c`r- x wl slnt ,iron ortln�claddo�fi= § k d' ✓ y .,.g"aa� L {2"rr' f �UU4��� � f r h. S r WN� r �at f^,rxt'vx.+F a s'-"s j{ SJ-$�a ts6.,xm`t'" lem ��, �R'uiRku�r, 3' '�''fi�.' ''�." *N: '.... F z 1 sy x�s "h Mfr73 'fir WATER`TAMK ' �penan isxwlth,wll ed ` !O` S " -NP, ti e e cadxpNI ICdCotIS I?U.t ' flfi 'il $ ;1 ( " . ^fid 4 j7 { vy Itf r�ewatfalle c ° rIc . A4 u 4 `' k � qjNO 74 A .a �` � aab �`• ? .:^,�' ri'�3 ',t`�` _ aid^ �� _ 3 e 7.40 Yffo ..` t� •.P u` 5 E hq,j*, 5,�. e P A4 AN P^{? � R i ,�,. ,: i• i.= �. �: : .gyp ,�� - " ��x►Yc � _ dr 0 jAkr 17 1 vL r X i y. ^& it $a"2 knew FAMMM AMOM T � Y rh •t d y� Y MWto .� IN iYh; $ � v y a e t F ' -.xT/r 4r� •.SV[�'[# Y-^ifM1.r:", r'k .in -+2k'� i$jp t tr _ ,.. ,F r ♦ °xy� , Z tN a , ARTHUR STREET Plan orientation From ..... � o FEAFARNswoRTH Essex-South District Registry of D N z w Engineering Associates (formeriy John Street as shown on g try J w Inoorporated (1986 Plan by C.A.Putnam,1878) Deed Book 1001,End .--i a Professional land Surve ors stryta-o-ww+dth f 1 CL- O F and Civil Engineers Y p . poi �•i .¢ : Z 35 Pine hill Road N 88� E S1deWalk O _ w D i Lancaster, MAO 1523 access 'i 200ft to Jefferson—y o 2 '(978) 368-7931 (voice) s e No. 13 LL 0 / Plan Title: o Wood-Frame Cn h 2-Siory 13 ARTHUR St. Unit 1& 1 ZONING BOARD of unit I&? o Dean T.Boucher, c owner, APPEALS FLAN 0 y$ Fj c t (owner is Applicant) r.7 C 8 r all ` ' ; Deed Bk 17393,Pg 64 - - n/f BERNARD Assessor's Parcel 23-0035-0 Located In the TOWN of: Contains:5,000+/-SgFt A % e AREA No.Il Arthur-St SALEM, MA r g „ g o0o a Par-ID: 23-0034-0 A Plan Prepared for: Owner of Pecord S Ft azo a,r,J SqFt Dean T. Boucher O �s a..a smnc , DF'aaMarion O DECK SHED a) Hypotheticalparking arrangement ' ' 13 Arthur Street,. Salem, MA I .5ft by 15. depicts Cars... 23ft L by IOft W ofouisdad See: Salem-Deeds, Book 17303, Pg 64 o r 2, Plan Book 1001, End of Book r�v, o _ SHED Lot N6.5 18 4 20 S 1� o fri, 12. t by 15.75'4. 3 0.79 no onndation I I certify that the buildings sh -on Data References Cone-Wall with Stockade Fence on fop are located° Ott the gI'ou s :PI Recorded so eas, Pr Part cr oe Dueeead.e cSaeAmLeEMn ii 5.1c9 ice[< -M1.CAPut aE "non O OpO Wesceeds6Heib( Oof 1/110 V6 Me d]B MAg23, 187e n/f COTE n/f LEVASSEUR No.22 Read-St No.16 Read-St John A. Farnsworth'} rev% /q n a=ti�wu i is - Par-ID: 23-0026-0 MA PL5 No 3803tj' 4 ri7," Plan No 17-0 I PARKING Par-1D: 23-0025-0 Plan 5';e:04-04-20 n Field: John A. Farnsworth,PL5 Note-Well,Nota-Bene: 2G March 2017 ' GRAPHIC SCALE Drawn/Calc:J.Farnsworth vo o a -•�w - - - -Units I&2 a2 are existing,plan > • - : check/Cert:J. Famsworbh � - o � -:o depicts location ofproposed corraienr,=arne arch Eng,neenn Aaeoc.20n Unit 43; 3-27-2017"r ( IN FEET ) B-Size at Scale l.lnch = 20 ft- - Sheet I of I ' #. kAsn P. 4, i r t y� 7 t, AL Y qqa� � ? � i It—i al WP .tj. t } G '�"" "" `• .i� °�$ P�P�I ��' .¢dam � s }p s w+ i i tl� i r 11 , dqP �. x w< AL s it e F 5 t 1 tY 4 i°Fk3 t" ttt 4 4 7} f* 9: 1 � r s [ fry yyS Y e d Yom. 5 4 ({ y fi t ffK w 4i > t.; �yx�� k� Bo- �•'} RECEIVED JUN 28 2017 DEPT O COMMUNH v4tT v� 5 8 y i Ik r x •i��f � � I.P.. r �. k. t 9 J t. Y y k' I i Y ALI `> t e1' t, } 9 1 r y_ 3 afli dj Si 4 , -41 VS s F ' a A - i S yc ` A4i ` 5: a� } ` � ;�a � `i t 75.>" fe"°^wv ,;,`v ��'k"� �",�1� ��y. g�y*y,�_ a• ;�'�<� r'�.s' '��3^"�.` �y xt�^q� Zt + t�• �'Si Y r u yam, .x., 4,X°'".^• J ,bye+ , '" pr fi t '�..t`3M4 .��T°�se!`3� �`�-_.� A 3 '� 'q��v\,@j e4s `•lv�p v i' � 6�AP� �6 ' �i��•, a q-ge�F+elad:+ ''ter . e '''•-,r ��'i;,j4m� k,,� � a}s�s �`��*� � rQi{ i f A it >± x I $ { I it — r1 �' a•;ii�� ,j±�� � � rh< �7��Ft sr !p} s i, •1 M ryyy ti ���i���� € nuycj i 91. 1 � »51i si 1� 11 , 9� tSr:a , { l 1 , �t • i nom" r�M, g aat; i 011Ok 4w, 3 (city Document, 1Vo, 26. OF THE INSPECTOR�OF BTJTLDINGS. { ; s he$oriorable the City Council of the C ty of Salem. -I have the honor to submit the anal le- NTL _4j e•Nom . q por ;of the Inspector of Buildings Since the first of Dee ber, 1900,aI have appved onehundxed and_ ninety-two ap �icaiaons for new biz�Wt ldxiigs, alteratigns and repairs; twelve applications ieq 41T . s eco ermus on from your board; one application !re using speezai rnussion from the City m„ "�Couneil, and thea rev f tixe, Mayor,°end;five,"applicatiozis re ng the aiprov of e Board,o Health?,as follows z t . .jPermita for rie we ink i;2 b Yv; 9'dditous to dw 44 "Other buildu 12 Additions to „ er wilding Brick buildin 1 Additions to ek uil ; Stables, Add itiaxi t i to " 5 Alterati � �y Mecellau 5 9ddi t' U ltld131�ya� 7 ' x as § r � tV7q I �1yNY � p 777 , 77 ��_ x tA `%`"." v $"� 'iv�, ��ra�*x°.• m ,` a T a"�r.,. *+"rgr.: * $, '=`x [' #'. ff a.x z Ctt ,f74C2L?rLeYLt lV 0. Qilf `'°� . ^r at '' '' _ a , $ ,mo=d ,+-n....:, ., -'c : n # , zs e .e ras � �. a;;`-;x '� ,c` �r?. �� » _: � ..; o� •. _ ' .. ,. ' ,,may ex�.�. A1�FPORT OF IN pECTOR UI! BUILDiNGrS. *� To the $anorable the Baty Council of the Citi'of Salem: EMIRN:—I have the` $honor to submit the annual re- G TL port of the Inspector of tuildings Since the first of l eeem- ter, 94 , I have: approved one hundred and forty-seven ap- plications fo new bu�ldngs, aterati�ons,6 arnd repairs ; eight . applications re�uniug special permission from your' board ;, = and five appheations � e�nar�' g the approval ofa the Board of I3eaIth : v Y permits for-new dwellings _ 6'7 a Additions to dwellings .. x 40 Other buildin s . Additions to ©cher build g Brick buildins - 3 "Additions to ' uildsn s 3 Stables & car a sbe .kAdditions to lice axa err ; sheds`'` 4 . Alterations ' irk Miseellaneotl5 I2L d3 ! Q w d ♦ {av z• +, r Additions j 7►,{+�5(��y�]q p Cfo� j�A.J19VCi1.34Y�Ts & ,.&ry � � s .k4pn9 t �i*y xx 4 14x' S o-. IV` , Y Four .. D Ward Five g . tsar Sze d ., SVS' o0 Irb e estimated cost of new buildings for hhicf ��s and swerl- grated during ` $5 the year is85,232.Op a p $101,326.p0, making a :total. of $68'Y,pS$ pp. alterations In the new dwellings, we have a total of 241 pternements '11 �ohow3ng Inds ,of buildings. s the 61 eight tenements . , • ,u, , •= k 9 1 of sit tenements ? k t r 3 of four tenements ., 24 of three tenements �Y 39 of two tenements , f one tenement X34 tenement BUiLDINCis 4 E There have been approved five>a Ings through the streets of thy' i TRE Twenty-four . "ermit� �� the suet �}} ;kTW g qx � F t 24 F1, ry The st mated#eostaof new,�buildings,for which er'mits wexe` w ted using the dear is $486,52t.601,; and Torp e aairs arid. 137,1U5.00,` ,making a total of lations�$ $"623,630;00. Shovingan41, crease in the value of new. `buildings over that ' Of 1905 of}$300,410.00, and in repairs .and alterations of 896•00; a total of $33$,306.00. m III the neve dwellings and additions made to buildings prev- iv Y erected and remodeled buildings we have a total of 170 tenements in the following kinds of buildings -,- 4 of 8 tenements each 3 15 « 3 E� « 24 c 2 cc 'Cc 33 « 1 « cc BUILDINGS MOVED. a • x. There have been approved fiveapplicaionsrto move build- '191 through the streets of 4 STREET RMI"TS� � 'lave granted sixteen permit`s do Accu yp ;of the streets o f r buildin g purposes'. k 31 r. y h k n p. p CiT4 - UAi1�v7 ANO. +i " $00 a The ap�?I1Cat10T1$ ,fOt,permita`we7:8 1e0a14ea Dal ent+wards of the arty as follows WI Liyg LIQ Ward O Ward TwOF Ward Three Waivi Four T% Nx. 9 CearalP I'lve u � ' The` 'estimated' cost of new' buildings for 4hieh were,granted ,during the year is $284,81,5.00 and fore + andialterations $72,860.00,making ,-to o ° `Inthe new dwellings•'and additions made tonidtn previously erected, we have ,a bi total of 157 aenem$nt �a; ._ f6ilowing,kinds=of buildings. r 4,of,e_ight,tenements' k 5 "`four 10 « three �4 'A '�= 4 n . + 434 t,wbN 35 °« one b•' • • Y�'CA� � �k F: 14 supplied by alterations in egis$in " Y g buildings ` l BUILDINGS MOVED. There have been approved three a luaaon pA pp buildings through the streets of the City, b � k� sJ..ibasJ*ay pL'pm hill eve rh4 been YtLT'ievM {/A �{S �1 (y'•yp�� u'i r �,%�� Sv �F os warda W �� ard . ' • z�v and Alf ` vee;� . 24 V> a n ' ed cost of new buildings for ,which permi^�ts 4ex The, I - ear. i; $ 92,195.002 and for repairs `aA� pg ; d' rl, the king.a. total` of $4:75,11 0.00, teratzons k� j` ' , , ade to buildin 'dwell�gs and add , . pxe- In the new tal of 1`73 tenements in the.fel_ viousIy erected, aV' m >c . lowing kinds of buildings ' . 14, z 8 tenexrientst each. o ' 6tene ` tints 'each. ` eaelL ;_ e of. 3` ten tint each. pfieln xtt 'eaCh. fki r ex ave been approved, fire Plica n move b . ough the streets d th, k seven permits have been w;. for � � �� to � , �" t x - �r €- s,3`*z '" C.'Y'rY .a�Cr�329,Fs11�, ��a• �3 ��'�s@'' "��: �.« `si;"^:.� I eiveci. tram.tla� dit f#ar resit$ were rec e wardsk f t ci 'asffvtlows � _ � 1° ° ° �0 F * a �. ' `§ 9 24 Wird,-Two 4 yl7atd "ane �. W ,rd ,Three � � � �. � 34. OW dour . a 109 . Wai d `Five 311 Vard ,Six s 289 The estimated -costa of new,buildings for which permits r is $819,330.00, and for repairs were granted during the yea 2nd alterations $211,950.00, making a total of $1,031,280.00. In the new dwellings we have a total of 277 tenements in the following kinds of buildings : , 4 of eight tenements 3 of six tenementsk$z 3 of four tenements 25 of three tenements x y s .✓yh.3 SO of two tenements - 40 of one tenement t r x 5 �40 t ° $U.ILDINGS MOV ' Ag There have b beer � a*"ppr e four tea' is huildm' f ' gs thraUO theistreets of the nWZ, s z TJ4 s . a. yK. �" ^... 3n +.• +fir'- '° ", sw' ,� r 4 49 "T " '� x ixsr�:e�iofe asi B zpra i r 283 " ' ry aA,yTlie upl'lic tions-for Perin' "Or®1se4ivod frorAx the fail-3 . t ' fext tcazds of,the,eity as follows.-- d 9� e aV . War as n Ward,Three'}. . . . . . 90 ard ward Fpm '$ P 189 aWard Six . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ' :The estimatedcost of new buildings foy which permits }' z were granted during the Year is $644AIOt ?and"fc r repair $ and f alterations $182,522, making a total o s 826,95 , In`tlie'nety'dwellings we have a dot I of, 04 tenements in the'.following binds of buildings 3iof sig ,tenements a i of four` tenements . . 4 � y 50 of three tenements .s " VO 46`of two tenements 92 40 of n tenement 304 BUILD There Fhave been approved apj lien A s tis` move bund- ° ugh the ,may 5 ' - perm ham o �u part of ae ; # ,,for, CITY OF SALEM MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEAL yJ, / 120 WASHINGTON STREET4SALEM,MASSACHUSPTT501970 TELE:978-619FjkJ7C9'78-740-04Q� - KIMBE AYLI. RISCO MO ' MAYOR s D A V Nib Al %t� jk" It• -- -- - City of sa1e%0 Ro6� ���bt ZoningBoardof AppealsSf5���r�f� � � �Gy �Jez iru✓ /Qv a /C }Sn�1)61 i'fM Will hold a pub) hearing for all persons interested in the petition of LORRAINIE BOUCHER, requesting a Special Permit per Sec. 3.0 Table of Uses to allow a historic carriage house to be converted into a dwelling unit at 13 ARTHUR STREET (Map 23 Lot 35)(R-2 Zoning District). The public hearing will be held on WED. April 19, 2017 at 6:30 PM, 3' F1o0120 WASHINGTON STREET, Rm 313. /� / n • //� �j� D� �Q // N> — 5 w,ltS Vcbecca Curran,Chair S ^, M') D 16 0Boa d of Appeals it elc� d2 Chah,p/ct-in PC( - Salem News: 4/5/2017 &41 017 2 4 S� 4 0JPI (IUox Q1CCI rf 4)119ry lJe4jc,/ !� �jalfi 1?ov�e,�ccr1 7 o��7o mA DeFalco Engineering Services Professional Land Surveyors & Civil Engineers 35 Pine Hill Road, Lancaster, MA 01523 603-566-4317 Cell Wednesday,August 16, 2017 Zoning Board ofAppeals c/o City Hall SALEM, MA Re: Dean Boucher, 13 Arthur Street, Salem, MA Dear Board Members, 1. I request the Salem ZBA enter the following into the Public Record regarding the Boucher submission, a project on their property at 13 Arthur Street, Salem, MA. 2. I , John A. Farnsworth, am a licensed Professional Land Surveyor and Registered Sanitarian, practicing and working in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts for some 50-years in 2018. 3. We opine that the 11 July 2017 City Solicitor's examination of the Boucher submission is very favorable to the instant 13 Arthur Street request for relief before the ZBA. 4. The City Solicitor has opined that six criteria are applicable for the issuance of a Special Permit. We put forward that the Applicant "hits on a six-cylinders " 5. The Boucher's have submitted to the ZBA, asking for relief we feel is grantable. 6. Herein we request previous favorable submissions and testimonies be incorporated in a favorable grant by the Board. John A. Farnsworth, M.S.C.E. MA-PLS, MA-RS i 13 Arthur Street, Salem, MA, ZBA Submission ELIZABETH M.RENNARD �n� {` ,, VICTORIA B.CALDWELL 07Y SOLICITOR y";� 4O,'� ASSISTANT CTIYSOLILTIOR 93 WASHINGTON STREET 93 WASHINGTON STREET SALEM,MA 01970 SALEM,MA 01970 TFL:978.619.5633 Tel.:978.619.5634 FAX: 978.744.1279 CITY OF SALEM FAX: 978.744.1279 EMAIL:13RENNAI D@G SALEM.COM KIMBERT FY L.DRISCOLL,MAYOR EMAIL:VCAUNC'ELL@sA i-w.COM LEGAL DEPARTMENT 93 WASI-HNGTON STREET SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 To: Erin Schaeffer, Planner From: Elizabeth Rennard,City Solicit4� Re: Legal Opinion—Historic Carriage Houses Date: July 11,2017 I am writing in response to your request for an opinion, on behalf of the Zoning Board of Appeals, relative to 1) the definition and intent of a historic carriage house provision within the City's Zoning Ordinance and 2) the interpretation of the definition of"historic carriage house".You have presented these questions in relation to a special permit application to convert a carriage house to a single dwelling unit at 13 Arthur Street (hereinafter"subject property"). To prepare this opinion, I reviewed the City Council and Planning Board records from 1983 through 1984 relative to the amendment of the Zoning Ordinance to include a definition of a historic carriage house and special permit allowing a single family unit within a carriage house as an . accessory to the principal dwelling. See attached. I also reviewed the City Assessor's records for the for the subject property as well as a City Atlas from 1897,provided by the subject property owner. As you will see from the attached City Council and Planning Board records, the definition and intent of the historic carriage house provision within the City's Zoning Ordinance was intended to "loosen the zoning requirements for historic carriage house uses"in the City (See June 23, 1983 City Council Order) and"insure their preservation" (see Feb. 23, 1984 Minutes of Joint Public Hearing on proposed zoning ordinance amendment). The definition of a historic carriage house,unchanged since its adoption in 1984,is"an accessory or outbuilding,originally built to house carriages, horses, or for use as a barn,that has been in existence since 1900 at its present location." You will note in the Minutes of the Joint Public Hearing that garages were to be specifically excluded. In my discussions with you,you have informed me that the Board of Appeals has interpreted the last portion of the definition"in existence since 1900 at its present location" quite literally. In the case before the Board now, the petitioner has demonstrated that there was an accessory or outbuilding on this property around 1900,but it is unclear to the Board if it was before 1900 and if it was originally built to house carriages,horses, or for use as a barn. I have reviewed the Assessor's data and spoke to the Assessor, Deb Jackson about this property. The current Assessor's card (attached)indicates the house was erected around 1895. The card states that the property contains a 320 s.f. barn with loft. However, the card also states that in 1999,a permit was issued for garage roofing and siding. Assessor's records (attached) from 1973 indicate the property included a 320 s.f. garage and a 440 s.f. barn (both 2 stories). I have also reviewed the City Atlas of 1897 provided by the subject property owner showing two structures on the subject property in 1897, the main house and a two story structure to the rear. The size of the structures is not indicated. I have concluded, after studying relevant records and reviewing the same with the City Assessor, that the current accessory structure is likely the same structure referenced in the 1973 Assessor records as a 440 s.f. 2 story barn.The dimensions are consistent with the plan submitted to the Board for the creation of a 423 s.f carriage house dwelling. As such, this structure would meet the definition of a historic carriage house, "an accessory or outbuilding, originally built to house carriages, horses, or for use as a barn, that has been in existence since 1900 at its present location." As you know,if the Board adopts this opinion, the Board has to find that the request meets the criteria of a special permit: o Social, economic or community needs served by the proposal o Traffic flow and safety,including parking and loading o Adequacy of utilities and other public services o Impacts on the natural environment,including drainage o Neighborhood character o Potential fiscal impact,including impact on City tax base and employment. Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions or concerns. o i CITY OF SALEM In City Council---------June 23, 1983 Amanre Ordered: That the City Solicitor draft a proposed zoning amendment that would rloos�fhe-,N ,zoning.requi.rements for historic carriage house uses in Salem, with a request that he consult both the Historic Commission and Planning Board in the drafting and to return such a draft to the City Council within 60 days to be acted upon. i In City Council June 23, 1983 Referred to Caimittee on Ordinances & Legal Affairs t ATIEST: JOSEPHINE R. FUSCO CITY CLERK E (Mg of 0allent ATTACHMENT B In the year one thousand nine hundred and eighty three An (Orhinaurr, amending the Zoning Ordinance to Permit the occupancy of Carriage Houses for Single Family Dwelling Units. Be it ordained by the City Council of the City of Salem, as follows: *rftll 1. The Zoning Ordinance of. the City of Salem, adopted on August 27, 1965, as amended thereafter, is further amended hereby as follows: �. by inserting at Section 11 B. in alphabetical order the following definition: - "Carriage House - An accessory or outbuilding originally built to house carriages, horses, or for use as a barn that has been in existence since 1900 at its present location." 2. by adding the following Special Permit Use to R-C, iR-1, R-2 and R-3 Districts: p "A Carriage house for use as a single family dwelling as an accessory use to a principal dwelling on the same lot provided that parking requirements are met." Section 2. This ordinance shall take effect as provided by the City of. Salem Charter and the provisions of Massachusetts General Laws., Chapter 40 A, Section 5. In City Council January 12, 1984 C. President to schedule hearing in February, 1984 i ATTEST: JOSEP.`IINE R. FUSCO CITY CLERK EE i , oM Salient, diffln737.aW4mleL1s t J A.4J.GLitA.11l{3 fi�NAM 2 .Y �4p Tt"rou�su�� (One p152[rem Gre2n, MINUTES OF JOINT PUBLIC HEARING RE- LATIVE TO CARRIAGE HOUSES---_ FEBRUARY 23, 1984 A joint public hearing was held with the City Council of the City of Salem in City Council Chambers on February 23, 1984, relative to an amendment to the Zoning Ordinance to protect historic carriage houses. Planning Board members present: Chairman Walter Power, Kenneth May, Normand Houle, Donald Hunt, and William Cass. Also present was Planning Board Aide Charles Frederiksen. i City Council members present: President Jean-Marie Rochna, Stephen Lovely, Leonard O'Leary, Joseph Centorino, John Nutting, Stanley Usovicz, and George McCabe. President Jean-Marie Rochna read the notice of the public hearing and intro- duced the councilors present. Planning Board Chairman Walter Power introduced the Planning Board members present. He noted the purpose of the hearing was in response to an interest expressedririgtheypreser----d -of_historie�carriage�h`ou many such carriage -��►-:r+-'-mss. -. houses are in a state of disrepair and, in order toTnsvrexther�p ervation there should be an incentive to do so. Mr. Power introduced Charles Frederiksen, _ Planning Board Aide, to give a brief overview of what is proposed. f Mr. Frederiksen stated that Historic Salem, Inc. did a survey of carriage ( house in three areas--Federal/Chestnut St. area, Salem Common, and Lafayette Street. It was found that carriage houses numbering in excess of 70 existed in those three areas alone. It was noted that the North Salem area was not surveyed, but it was felt several more existed in that area as well. Further, car`nage'house-siwereidefinedTas-out buildings--in existenceaprior to 1900 hich� wweieTused;;_sp cifically f gesaand ho ses Garages" wer" re-p £ically-excluded-.' In In and administering this ordinance, some sort of list would be drawn up by the Historic Commission and home- owners would petition the Commission to be included on the list if they felt their particular outbuilding would qualify. Mr. Frederiksen presented a map of the carriage houses presently surveyed. At present if you have a carriage house on your property which does not meet the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance, a variance would be needed to put a dwelling unit or single-family residence in the carriage house. This means goind before the Board of Appeal and proving a hardship exists for the variance to be granted. Most carriage houses presently do not meet minimum sideyard requirements. .Minutes of Joint Public Hearing--February 23, 1984 Page 2 Kenneth„May„explained the proposed zoning change in more detail. He noted the intent-of^theordi�na'- nce is3toTpreserye historic carr age'rhduses while avoiding-having•alarge soni.tlbeing divided yup-therefore iucr-easingfheTdensityz'of-ythe..original.parceY Mr. May made several suggestions relative to avoiding the increasing of the density for a particular parcel: 1: A date should be established beyond which a carriage house would not qualify, 2: A minimum area within the dwelling unit should be established in order to avoid the creation of too small a dwelling area; 3: Adequate parking must be provided for the the new residence in the carriage house on the same lot as a primary residence without reducing the spaces available; 4: Any Special Permit shall expire upon a fire or any other type of destruction of the structure; 5: The Planning Board and the Council should consider thatthere be no exterior changes to the structures without the ap- proval of the Historic Commission or the Board of Appeal; 6: The carriage houses cannot be added to or enlarged. t Walter Power stated the Planning Board will discuss this issue further and will comment to the City Council for their consideration. i Councillor Nutting asked if there was not adequate parking provided with the rehabilitation of the carriage house as a dwelling unit, could a varlance from _ parking be obtained and Mr. May replied in the affirmative. + Elizabeth Wheaton, Chairman of the Historic Commission, wished to be recorded in favor of the proposed ordinance, but felt very strongly, as Chairman of the Historic Commission that without design review, thebasis of the ordinance is without effect. Therefore, a design review component of the Ordinance should j be included. f Mr. Donald Coleman of 328 Essex Street spoke in favor of the proposal_ Dr. Richard Pohl, 335 Essex Street, spoke in favor of the ordinance. He feels the tax base. will be increased and preservation will be encouraged. Mr. John Carr, 7 River Street, spoke in favor of the proposal, Mrs. Katherine Marchand, Bott's Court, felt the ordinance should be structured and refined to a certain date. she feels she has a structure that would qualify, but it is strictly a "garage_" Mr. Lane Nielsen, 10 Monroe Street, spoke in favor of the ordinance. Martha Hodgman, a mem- ber of the Board of Directors of Historic Salem, Inc., spoke in. favor of the- ordinance on behalf of Historic Salem. Mr. Richard Thompson of 374 Essex Street, urged the Council to approve this ordinance. Meg Towey, Pleasant Street, s�oke in favor of the proposal with the amendments outlined by the Planning Board_ Mr. Steve Thomas questioned the amendment pertaining to destruction and asked if the structure was replaced exactly would this apply and Mr. Power replied it will be discussed by the Planning Board. Mr. William R. Burns, Jr., Beckford Street, spoke in favor of the proposal. Mrs. Joan Kelley and Mr. John Kelley, 3 Cambridge Street, wished to be recorded as opposed to the proposal. There being no further discussion, Councillor Lovely moved the hearing be closed. Having passed unanimously, President Jean-Marie Rochna declared the hearing closed at 7:30 p.m. Respectfully submitted, C Dale E. Yale, rk EXTERIOR INFORMATION BATH FEATURES COMME TS E_Type:12 -MulMnwar _Full Bath 2 Rating:Average WIP CHK BARN FOR LIVING AREA. 0 HY 1T -1&3146 - ABath: RaUig: s FFL (Liv)Units: 1 Total:l 3/4 Bath:1 . Rating:Average q 0 BMT 7 `Foundation: -BdddStone A30Bth� Rating: 3 goFPq BFP (53) C i Framel -Woad 1f2 Beth ating:. I Prime Wall 01 -Wood Shin Is AHBth RaI : Sec Wall. % .Oth Fu Rai g:' RESIDENTIAL GRID �Rool SWct:01 -Gable OTHER FEATURES 1st Res Grid J Desc:Line 1 #Units 1 !'Roof Cover.'01 -As halt Sh I Kits]2 ReBnr�t Aver a Level.)I lR DR D!KFR RR_BR'FB HB.LL 0 j I Coluc GREEN 'A Kds: Rating: Other I [View PDe'! r. Frill: Rah'dg: -_ ec GENERAL INFORMATION WSFIue: Raba : Lv 2 TOS Grade:C Ave she _ CONDO INFORMA I WIN lower- 2e BMT 28 Year Bit,1895 'EffYr Bit: Location: otals RMs 7 BRs4 BethS:2 HB r°s AIMUC: All%: Total Units: (816) Junsdict: Fact. > Fbpr REMODELING RES BREAKDOWN 1 k.___Oonst Mod: ExtedoC No Unit RMS +: BRs FL Lum Sum Ad: 4r— -- �.�_J. �-Name: I Interior., 1 T 4 M INTERIOR INFORMATION DEPRECIATION AAddddions: A3 Hffl-:oPlasterFunctional: Phystond:FR -Fair 44.% Kitchen: . -., i Prim Int Wal Functional: % ,Baths: . . .. _- 15 7 rSec lm Wan: Economig q �Plumbing q � RB) 4 ParitionI ._S e�cial: % Electdc: ' Totals -r '_ 157Prim Floors: Override: _ % HeaU .TothC _ 44.8% GeneraC SUB AREA SUB AREA DETAIL BsmntFir, ALC SUMMARY COMPARABLE SALES '� '"' so a-Avveiue�Il s—b }1 SQ `RatePmce11D T ! Uate Y :� .Sale price TS a3/4 Story ,.. -e 92.4 11105.220 Un r 97,2191 Area I Usbl ° 'Typo`OuTn :a Are dE-I 06- Basw$150:1110.00 _ —.`—. BMF Basement 679 26.300 17,860 I Electric: -T ical __ Size Adj.:167373667 -- FFL First Floor 679 105.220 71,441 i r _ __. Insulation: -T Typical Const Adj.:0.97990203 ! --- OFP Opeq Porch - - 76 - '19.500 -� 1,4821 Int vs Ext:S . Ad$ISO:105.216 -. _ -..... _. '.. _.�..1 ._.. EFP Enclos Porch 52 31.200 1,6221 - r Heat Fuel:2 -Gas v Other Features:100000 1 Heat T- e:03 -Forced HM -Grade Factor.1.00 ' _ ..... Neighborhood lnC 1.00000000 yv$iSO: AvRat9: %Heated•100 AC" C LUCfaaor.1.00 I— T� �(Ind.Va10 NeGSKetchetl Area:2,410 TotaC 189,624 °olar HW:NO Val vac NO AdpTotal:289625 Juns Factor: Before De�099.75 Size Ad 1603 Gross Area 271 Fiii r"a 1603 °kCom Wal %S rinkled Deprec�aUon 129752 S ecial Features0 VaUSu Net 66.35 IMAGE D�apreciated Total 159873 -:_ Final Total:159900 VaUSu SZAd 99.75 Asses 0 Patriot Properties.Inc >>C;ode AS URoESIYA RAID S¢elp'un 9ual'Conl Year , Udine 5, DeD LUC .:Fa_ PARCEL ID 23-0035-0 ITEMS -- °h .�I GNB Fa _ orValue JCatlUFaC Juris.Value 02 Frame.Shetl D�Y 1120 AV AV 1970 671 T 1 3-61 104 500 500 '132�amWlLoft"`D'Y_�q�fi3207r AV AV 1900 1500T i 408 104 _— 2,800 2,8pp ,�..:. . _ _. .—.. 102 -'Frame Shed D�Y 18X8 AV AV 1970 798T 36 104 300 app ` 1-4 w 8` yy,T�F , +a/ y f [More•�N [ Total Yard.ItemsfL_—_ 3600 (� _T'otalSLecia 23 0035 0 1 of I Residential TOTAL ASSESSED: 288,600 Map Lot Suffix CARD !6819! PROPERTY Salem YLOQAIM� PROCESS APPR& I Alt '0�� . $AL SUMMARY t LN Use Code Building Value yard items Land Size Land Value Total VMue— Legal Deicriptidn User Acct 131 !J1iTHUR STREET,SALEM_ 104. 159,900 3,690 0.184 125,100 288.600— OWNERSHIP jTw7T . ....... Omer 7:ROUGHER DEAN GIS Ref Owner 2: Ref Card" -001 0.184 125,100 —288.600 Entered Lot Size --7— Total 159,900 T6 I GIS R Total Parcel 169.960 3,600 0.184 lai0o, i Street I:73ARTHUR288,600 —Tots I Land:11 --- Patnot P Source:Market Ad'Cost I Total Value per SQ unit/Card:1180.04 /Parcel: Land'UnitT pe; 1 /22111 Properties Inc. Street 2: w ,7 Ins Date ij�w��Clty.SALEM PIOUS ASSESSMLNT Parcel ID 23-0035-0 USER DEF NED Ittmv-MA Occ: I CAhyl _Lq� Tax Y(I Use s'U 6ldliValue Yrd Ilems I Land Sim Lod Value Total Value Asses'd Value Notes Jfjw Id#1:32 2017 �104 FV 159.900 3600 .184 125,100 288,600 288,600IYear End Roll 1202016 Prior Id 2: Postal:01970-2801 Typed Date LIL PRINT PREVIOUS OWNER 2016 1101 FV 159,900 3600 .184 119,300 2u,800 282.800:Yearand 12/912015 —D --F— Ow ate f1me Prior Id If 3: n I.JMICHAUD LORRAINE P- 15 10.4. FV ---148190.0 .184 109,700 262,200 262.200jYear End R:U 12110014 ow - )04 — 07/10117 15:28:54 Prior Id#1 rie" 4 FV 123,400 3600 .184 109.700 236,700 n6,700, 20i 3 104 F� !Year End 13911 12/912013 Prior Id#2: Street 1 13 ARTHUR ST 117,200 3600 .184 109,700 230,500 230,500IYear End Roll 1112612612 L 2912 1104 FV i2ixx) -'.184 ii4,800 Prior Id#3 Twn/Cdy.-ISALEM ar End Roll 12128/2011 Date I Timepnorid#t: Stiprow.15MA 2011 1104 FV 135.400 3400 .184 117,400 256,200 256,200,lYear End 1211712010 0110072 Post.l:01970-2801 2616 1164_ FV 148,001) 3400 .184 V2.600 274,000 274,0001 1212212009 09:35:43 Prior Id#2: pault Prior Id#3:1 NARRATIVE DESCRIPTION SA-LE S INFORMATION TAX DISTRICT __.PAT ACCTS 6819 SRM :This Parcel contains.184 Acres of land mainly classified as rotor Legal Ref Type Date Sale Code -.Sae Prim : V Tat Vefif Assoc PCL Value Disc t -Conver B MICHAUD LORRAIN 24657-219 012005 Fami Notes _jLa r ,Two Family with a(n)Mulli Building Bulk about 1895, Y 1,000 No No Reved Dist Having Primarily Wood Shingle Exterior and Asphalt ShgI Roof 13OUCHER BOSTON 17393-67 715001 Ch gd>Awmt< 125,000 1 0 No No :Cover,with 1 Units,2 Baths,0 HalfBaths,1314 Baths,7 MIKULSKIS'ANLE 10414342 42717990 Other 85101))No No Year., LandReason: 4 Slit= 'QIHERASSESSMENTS BldReason; -----kTmnf_�­. WILDING PERMITS ACTIVITYLINNIFORMATION Dale Num 9, Commrnt PRIDIP Data Result By.—Fp---- TY-EACTORS_ 114 3 �_Al li/2212011 Measured PT T Item rode Dawn Item Code Descdp- 'J_ — 1 9/1999 1 67 C Z R2 RES TWO F IDD r4 6 7282011 Mader PT IPT o 3IV2000 Measured 2.77 PATRIOT Yn S&A990-Inspected FlCensus:— Exmpf ood Haz; _jqp 1 Level EETF— Street Cigna' Tm�l LAND SECTION 11negLo,,�hd. 7— LT Base I Alt Neigh Fact UseVaue Notes Bon No'of Units'" a Type Land Unit Price Ad .,'Neigh J_ Use Descri a� It 'th iff 1,17 k�Dth U. Cade munlia n Type- ton Fact i'pn Factor Valu Mod Value, Class" Value 1 104 TWOF Lod Code - may 1 8000 !Sq.Ft Site 0 IT EA 11.00 017; 125.130 164 TWO Family so Site 0 1.00 125,100 - _Par�,CeIILUC:Lf64 Two�F �7! Prim( amii�' NB6TcfEA I Total F 125,130 1 i Total L 25,100] Disclaimer:This Information is believed to be correct but is subject to change and is not warranteed. Database:AssessPro apro 2018 MAP NO. LOT NO. PROPERTY RECUR[)-CITY OF SA!-E-.-, (vN I* CARD NO. "IVFAORANDA 023 0035 0013 ARTHUR STREET DESCHENES ADELINE ET ALI RECOAD 01:OWNERSHIP DATE TE DATE SOGKTPAGE 113 ARTHUR ST ISALEM MA 01910 ;AC. S.F. 8000 VALUE Soo HOUSE 2300 BLD,, 200 VEiUFICATION OF IWAIECTION ASSESSMLNT R4GORO - ------ —L9 I in, in 7� 19 19 APPEAL DATA GARACE SC:W POOL VjIL. L..d ,f Chn � , buiftlingT COMM or,IND TOTAL VAL"rT BUI I-PING-, TOTAL71-y-.'LAND F07AL VALUE LAND BUILDINGS CONSTRUCTION A i CN. A So:.,'%1,1., ` VOL• 1, ?I J1 2 ]a pLA L I ZZ& ----------- P14O.'01*58APH PERNUT COMP,DATE 7.,;,l 9 LAND*:AI.UE COMPUTA FlOW, Ti;o; lk'l p', RENTAL EXPENSE ITEMS PROPERTY INFORMATION V.ICANCY LAND CLT I ATINC, 6LOC.COST —J '.7114C V —————— -T 1 V , oto- "4 m r � ti Fu 40 M1 �� �#�_ 1 =�':• �` -•r' 4-.3 4 'Ps a 'f _ IMF q JA 4u fit :m mc iA INV AR I �� a ��-'• �.. 3 s-�� 0. "t s "`' ".. *.e fes` '�r � M v � .r a. � "'a•'.«•.+ '�� ,� � �,M tom, � 4' �_ �s �,��, � p3 s1+F r-•:.s4 �_ .dry ° .a +.a i w '" '"x- _<' fS� a� + y§ `P Wg[� a�, � �� C 4'�� d � p "� a •-}pa � _ E N � �� s ". k` '� ye 3' .� � sp WR .61 Alc Cc, aPA•9F.(✓�� rL Y .; 'f Mi: i�t�k aN '{v'%3 y3- ."T".v�y,�' s � +� r � M� a.7v- = ARTHUR STREET Plan Orientation From .. 4 ��7wra FARNSWORTH (fonnerly✓ohn sover as shown on Essex-South District Registry of Deeds' Engineering Associates :Plan 0CA.Anna-,1878) Deed Book 1001,End incorporated (1986) i5afrRoWWidrh Professnd SurveyorsopIandngineersN 80ESidewalk gQ35i RoadFL—a-9200ft to Jefferson LancAO 1523(978) 931 (voice,)No. 13 - -__,..__ . _ _._� Pfan TitWHascmenr o1sAxTxuRst. ZONIBOARD ofk r Unit 1&2 o Dean T.Boucher,(owncr)zXa!i IowneruApptrmntJ APS PLAN' ,6 g e a= arrr' sDecd Bk 17393,Pg 64n/fBERNARDAssesser's Fa ce123 On35-o uo�ted 70WN of:m° AREA No.1l Arthur-St Contains:s,000+i-sgFt ;; v e e g 000 w Par-1D:23-0034-0 SALEM, MA .__--,--._____.�__._ _Y s v 5 a �-' U SgFt +I' a Plan Prepared for: Owner of Record ^ "' PARKING o "" " " '-'' Dean T. Boucher O p1K "" SHED Hypotheticalparking arrangement 13 Arthur Street, Salem MA r ,., A ¢ o foundari depicts Cars... 23ft L by]Oft W See: Salem-Deed+ 0 �, Book 17393, P G4 r '�b • J ZI SHED - Plan Book 100 1, End of Book i Lot Nos 18 k 20 10.75' nn ouMorion ) I certify that the buildings sh -on ^--_, __ _.........,. - I� Canc-Wntl with Stockade Pence on rnp are located"on the grou Data References: 1' exceeds Eft Heigh[ I +� -..e:re F 5,. �d,1e . oe + '„vrrn -�--- S 8 8O W 80 117.1a Pm f t roe lam,Ne W he Hill. t' Ic 100 Hict t ax CA Pot L.C. TIM LEVASSEUR off COTE / Fnnnsxbar rmv ln7e nmaAy a lnie k t No.22 Read-St No.16 Read-St ` I � John A. Farnsworth?, reeEe Par-1D:23-0025-0 Par-ID:23-0026-0 MA PL5 No. 38038''=11^q Plan No. 17-01-PAERUJG Plan Date:04-04-2017 1 Re1a: John A.Farnsworth,PL5 GRAPHIC SCALE Note-Well,Nota-Bene: 26 March 2017 a^ ^ 1^ 9^ Units 1&1 are existing,plan Drawn!2.1c.: ro :J.Farworth ;+ °0 g p &b kl Len:J.Pornsworth depicts location ofproposed cow¢,rnr A.,rcp.2017 Unit 43, 3-27-1017 ._....._._....,..__...,..___y ( IN FEET > B-Size at Scale ) Inch a 20 IL Sheet I of I II CITY OF SALEM ASSESSOR'S CERTIFICATION OF ABUTTERS AND "PARTIES IN INTEREST" BOARD/COMMISSION: Board of Appeals PROJECT SITE 13 Arthur Street ( 23-0035-0) DATE: 7/18/2017 DESCRIPTION OF REQUIREMENT: Parties in Interest: The applicant Abutters Owners of land opposite any street or way Abutters and abutters to abutters within 300 feet a Planning boards of abutting cities and towns This is to certify that the time of the last assessment for taxation made by the City of Salem, the names and addresses of those listed on the attached sheets are "parties in interest" (as defined by Massachusetts General Law Chapter 40A, Section 11) to the parcel(s) of land listed above as the project site. Assessor's Signature: Date: -7111117 Number of initialed pages attached: Once Certified,Return to: Erin Schaeffer Department of Planning and Community Development i _s .. � o� o ° 4 • OA/yO '.� 0 V° r.�.. ° Z 6✓,.,TR E7 HOR ON StR � �� fT ri�W.. CLOUT U M . ... t n'� STREET W11L9 I URRs---._ O kD /,,a i READ STREET rLF J J a VELAHO 51REE� Qa 0 300 69011 Pmte on 071194017 et 0106 PM f • d Parcel ID:23-0035-0 Parcel ID:23-0013-0 Parcel ID:23-0014-0 BOUCHER DEAN ROMAN CATHOLIC PETRINO RICHARD J 13 ARTHUR ST ST ANNES PARISH SULLIVAN MAUREEN M SALEM, MA 01970-2801 290 JEFFERSON AVENUE 8 STORY ST SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0015-0 Parcel ID:23-0016-0 Parcel ID:23-0017-0 MATTON WILFRED LOVELY STEPHEN P LEBLANC LIONEL PIERRE MATTON GLORIA JOAN B 21 READ STREET 10 STORY ST 14 STORY ST SALEM,MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM,MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0018-801 Parcel ID:23 0018-802 Parcel ID:23-0018-803 RAMIREZ DIOMARIS JACKSON CHRISTINE COOPER RICHARD A 15 READ STREET U15A 15 READ ST U15B RUSSO PAULA E SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM,MA 01970 17 READ ST SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0018-804 Parcel ID:23-0019-801 Parcel ID:23-0019-802 FRANCISCO LUIS F NADEAU GARY A HAGBERG JASON 17 READ ST U176 7 GALLOWS CIRCLE 4322 SCOTTS MILL COURT SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SAUGUS, MA 01906 Parcel ID:23-0019-803 Parcel ID:23-0019-804 Parcel ID:23-0019-805 DUFFY PAUL E JRV INVESTMENTS&MULTI BONAIUTO ALBERT F 3 MALLARD DRIVE 330 BROADWAY C/O ERIC YELLIN MEDWAY, MA 02053 LYNN, MA 01904 9 BELLEAU ROAD SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0019-806 Parcel ID:23-0020-0 Parcel ID:23-0021-0 MORALES JOSE ENRIQUE 7-9 READ STREET REALTY KANTOROSINSKI MIROSLAW 9 ALDWIN ROAD PALM THERESE TR 407 ESSEX STREET ROSLINDALE, MA 02131 3 HILTON STREET SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0022-0 Parcel ID:23-0023-0 Parcel ID:23-0024-0 10 MEADOW STREET, LLC BELIFORE LOUISE ASUNCION EDGER C/O ESSEX MANAGEMENT KLING ANDREW ASUNCION CECIL JOY 375 MAIN STREET 26 READ STREET 6 CHAMPLAIN ROAD HAVERHILL,MA 01830 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0025-0 Parcel ID:23-0026-0 Parcel ID:23-0027-0 LEVASSEUR ROBERT J COTE ANTOINE J THOMPSON K RICKY DORIS M ANITA M JULIE A 22 READ STREET 16 READ STREET 12 READ ST SALEM,MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM,MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0028-0 Parcel ID:23-0029-0 Parcel ID:23-0030-0 GONZALEZ HECTOR FAULLING THERESA Y KAULER SHANNON JIMENEZ LISA 278 JEFFERSON AVENUE 274 JEFFERSON AVE 10 READ STREET SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM; MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0031-801 Parcel ID:23-0031-802 Parcel ID:23-0031-803 272,JEFFERSON AVENUE UPDEGROVE SILVIA H DAVYDOVA OLGA GODERRE 272 JEFFERSON AV U2 272 JEFFERSON AVENUE,43 272 JEFFERSON AVENUE SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0031-804 Parcel ID:23-0031-805 Parcel ID:23-0032-0 OMALLEY KEVIN STEVENS KATHARINE A LEVESQUE JOSHUA R OMALLEY KATHARINE GODERRE MICHAEL P 268 JEFFERSON AVENUE 272 JEFFERSON AV U4 2 IVY LANE SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 PEMBROKE, MA 02359 Parcel ID:23-0033-0 Parcel ID:23-0034-0 Parcel ID:23-0036-0 DE LA ROSA MARIA BERNARD DEREK JOHN BLAISDELL MARC 3 ARTHUR STREET 11 ARTHUR STREET BLAISDELL STACEY SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 17 ARTHUR ST SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0037-0 Parcel ID:23-0038-0 Parcel ID:23-0039-0 SARHAN AYMAN GALLANT JEANNE PALOMBO GAIL A SARHAN SUHAYLE 2 CHAMPLAIN ROAD 5 LOONEY AVENUE 4 CHAMPLAIN ROAD SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0040-0 Parcel ID:23-0041-0 Parcel ID:23-0070-0 KOT JERZY R BELANGER RENE ARMAND GARCIA LUCY KOT ANNA B BELANGER MARGUERITE M PENA ANGEL DE JESUS 19 TAMARACK LANE 25 WILLSON STREET 18 WILLSON ST PEABODY, MA 01960 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0071-0 Parcel ID:23-0072-0 Parcel ID:23-0073-0 JACKSON DANA K DONOVAN PAUL ANDERSON BEN J JACKSON LINDA M DONOVAN PATTI A ANDERSON LISA J �qq 20 WILLSON ST 191/2 WILLSON ST ?el!AM Pb*N-RAAD /0 /laYQfHS . SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0074-0 Parcel ID:23-0075-0 Rcel ID:23-0076- ARTHUR STREET REALTY LORRAINE RYAN C BE KE ENECKE TZORTZIS JOHN(fZORTZIS 8 ARTHUR STREET DHIMITRI H C 10 ARTHUR STREET SALEM, MA 01970 6 APP REE LAN SALEM, MA 01970 N TH READING, MA 1864 Parcel ID:23-0076-801 Parcel ID:23-0076-802 Parcel ID:23-0076-803 BAHNAN NISREEN N MAZEIKA MARTHA SCHELL HEATHER L TOBY GARABET G 6 ARTHUR STREET U2 6 ARTHUR STREET U3 9 SCHOOL HILL LANE SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM,MA 01970 NORTH READING,MA 01864 Parcel ID:23-0078-0 Parcel ID:23-0079-0 Parcel ID:23-0080-0 BOYD PAUL LEBLANC DANIEL J MCGRATH SEAN 4 ARTHUR STREET 210 JEFFERSON AVENUE 264 JEFFERSON AVE SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0081-0 Parcel ID:23-0082-0 Parcel ID:23-0083-0 BEGI MIRASH KJR REALTY TRUST ELLIS JOHN H JR 260 JEFFERSON AVE ROMAN JAMES R/ROMAN 178 LOWELL STREET SALEM, MA 01970 37 HUNT CIRCLE PEABODY, MA 01960 MASHPEE,MA 02649 Parcel ID:23-0084-0 Parcel ID:23-0085-0 Parcel ID:23-0086-0 w MALLARD HERBERT A MOUTSOULAS ALEXANDER S LEMELIN ROBERT E 7 WILLSON STREET 5 PINE STREE CAROLANN .. SALEM, MA 01970 - PEABODY, MA 01906 15 WILLSON STREET SALEM,MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0087-0 Parcel ID:23-0088-0 Parcel ID:23-0092-0 GREENBERG MICHAEL T GIRARD JAMES P BOORACK DAWN C GREENBERG ALEXANDRA JANE SOPHIA M FOSTER RICHARD D 17 WILSON ST 19 WILLSON STREET 259 JEFFERSON AVE SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0093-0 Parcel ID:23-0094-0 Parcel ID:23-0095-0 HARRISON ELAINE M LEE MARGARET E C E B REALTY TRUST 261 JEFFERSON AVE 263 JEFFERSON AVE BISCAIA PAUL TR SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 267 JEFFERSON AVE SALEM, MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0096-0 Parcel ID:23-0097-0 Parcel ID:23-0098-0 271 JEFFERSON AVENUE MCLAUGHLIN MICHAEL R ROMAN CATHOLIC KARAMBELAS NIKOLAOS TR 33 LIBERTY HILL AVENUE ST ANNES PARISH 54 PAUL AVE SALEM, MA 01970 290 JEFFERSON AVENUE W PEABODY, MA 01960 SALEM,MA 01970 Parcel ID:23-0099-0 Parcel ID:23-0240-0 Parcel ID:23-0243-0 ROMAN CATHOLIC BUONFIGLIO JOHN P SANTOS MANUEL J ST ANNES PARISH BUONFIGLIO CYNTHIA L SILVA DIANA F 290 JEFFERSON AVENUE 28 READ ST 19 ARTHUR STREET SALEM,MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01970 SALEM, MA 01960 Parcel ID:23-0246-0 280 JEFFERSON AVENUE THACH BOSOLAKHANA TR 280 JEFFERSON AVENUE , SALEM, MA 01970 w ®AViD F. s� JAQUITH n NO.2883 692 RGY:IeV. MA Via O 2017 9 Ma 2017 i 1MZ ' d a 01 P m v � Q + U 0< i wa o Qui ... _. co Im u) as ani < r _ � m ro (A 4 F- � d Cru cry ,Q } _ Q � � u v MAY 16 1017 DEPT OF p NN!W:K_ CDMMUNITY DE VELOPp,,,L;yT y `-.. ARTHUR STREET Plan Orientation From ..... FARNSWORTH FE !� Engineering Associates (formerly John Street as shown on Essex-South District Registry of Deeds 1 1 Incorporated (1986 ) Plan by C.A. Putnam, 1878) Deed Book 1001, End Professional Land Surveyors 50ft R-o-W Width and Civil Engineers , N8�o 80, — Pinee HIII Road 1V Sidewalk Lancnc aster, MAO 1523 access i 200ft to Jefferson (978) 3G8-7931 (voice) No. 13 Wood-Frame Plan Title: 2-Story p 13 ARTHUR St. ZONING BOARD of w/Basement ON z 3 Unit 1& 2 0 Dean T. Boucher, ( owner) .� r l (owner is Applicant) APPEALS PLAN ,a tE oo QeC Deed l3k 17393,Pg 64 Assessor's Parcel 23-0035-0 W IL Cn �f ,� n/f BERNARD Contains : 8,000+/- SgFt Located In the TOWN of: a AREA No. 11 Arthur-St SALEM , MA o c g 000 Par-ID: 23-0034-0 fir, U a Plan Prepared for: Owner of Record a z a Unit#3 SgFt is on a Stone PARKING Dean T. Boucher p ~ 'r p DECK Foundation SHED 0 Hypothetical parking arrangement 13 Arthur Street, Salem, MA access 1 .Sjt by 15. depicts Cars ... 23 L b 10 W 011-0 ofoundati p y See: Salem-Deeds, Book 17393, Pg G4 Plan Book 1001 , End of Book 21 SHED 4 , Lot No.s 18 * 20 N v, 12. by 15.75' N Q o 75, no oundarion / I certify that the buildings sh -on Data References: Conc-wall with Stockade Fence on top are located" on the grou See: Plan Reccrc(ed 5o-Essex Deeds, 5ALEM �f p pp Tx, $4 .4 Pian of a Part of Derby Farm, Near Castle till, S 80� VV exceeds,6ftHeight 801 _ . . _ eb- ~ V _tf X519 p Scale 100 feet to an ec inch,C.A. Putnam, C.E., t,Qa FdF�8�oA % Salem, Mass, 1878, recorded 23, 1878 n/f LEVASSEUR n/f COTE No. 22 Read-St No. 16 Read-St John A..Farnsworth`','°; pEati° FE.A: tARNSWURTIi ENGIN[ERiNG A55C)CIATF.;� Par-ID: 23-0026-0 MA PL5 No. 3803 "^�'I R. �`"��~ Plan No. 17-0 I- PARKING Par-ID: 23-0025-0 Pian oat-_: 04-04-2o 17 Field: John A. Farnsworth, PL5 Note-We11, Nota-Bene: 26 March 2017 GRAPHIC SCALE Drawn/ Calc: J. Farnsworth 20 0 to 20 40 so Units 1 & 2 are existing,plan Check/ Gert: J. Farnsworth depicts location of proposed COPYRIGff FaFarnsworth Engineenng Assoc. 2017 Unit #3, 3-27-2017 ( IN FEET ) B-Size at Scale ee� I Of 1 inch = 20 it i EDAR F,. r ;*,Y e .A rce �ar4yyq ,;... . a - �,- pia ..,y :Te�,w'h' ar �U v�6 !d7 lO�* f,,.`w A3F?e T §3. .c...<•.: C I?AVSD F +� ; �`'� �< "�.,��� ; �, f r � ,�{ 3. �. �"' a�+ `� riVs � �� ;� uv y` u 9 !!c ri ��� §.. � p�' �� �� JflQUITt•i '�'�" � � �3 �'�• •' a� �. a � 'a� `_ s, ,���: ..... F r� � s� "k Aa. 4�` }� l� No.2853 � A .+ ..k ��� R4Y:•.�+y,(4�R a., .vx ,�} .# t�.+v { ° .' ' ^. ,:;t H`+.' i, ,t<?.. s ''.i �uK� ..�4f•` . � - �i� �'� Pc •ay � i.�"� •,� x ���! 'n •T.'y, r,�..,`�g"$'i . ` *` ' : � _ O '�, U � , t�ir r ¢''�dS.:,.',."•sy�z �� t � 4 +tr":"�`'� Tµ� '�da'}+f�r�'�� z '� .@� �..�•r`b '� �+.. t �•T�. Ft^ J'Cy A �tr $'FIs _ ' i �' " n .�6��, `'t J' 1�..«:.-•'°"F pn ©2017 14 M a,y 2017 �, x ti" '« � v � e X27 �."., �A • :.r C.V„f �. EtFI '�+ � �C,yE<Iy #� y �"� s imLu �� qqtl!Q fill a. ' It � �• $^ P .�, �, r �s. t,. -'M.'" 4O 'fJ(� A r' �;E,Fi T ,,�; s �,� t '��� �{��, `. ;. � Ua � ��G i as A/ r� �fy ,� UL•r t - WA p�,l. A t a zw•,p.,, 4 �?Oj pfNf £ �'. D. yD�atrt .� '. s g a: Q ,f ' '' ' �• 6 �� � ` ':# , q; .� - ¢' ' 0 m 626 t' : �.� � �` wx..y W.. Z` `1`. r��� � • " �aE 'f �3"rF«. ;i, `�#�, 6 k x 4 � � \ �� , .�q h '. ,� g � .'� •* n �P 3'f k$ Y.F �` �# �� S � T §�A '3'..n 4 �A� �` Y 1 W ���' J r , a. tX O -� ,�.' v ¢x v' , .,_ }0 .• . r m t P.,r�,+;k ' +E ,,,'w z;. y F $ 5 �.!i u../ La U ,phi a n3 , 4' �i'f � � "• 8�� ,>� t�pt � '� �'� � ate. '� V %ate tr` �� ��q � -� gy ci 4R k" r ��•.' 4 + I i s #` 2 �,l x 4f"q't� � g :r.,_ w- x �i 5. a tis b. < 0 SIJ Jc 0q, Q .< Q U ' �. �` � r'" 'aA�`ya, -' °5:.,`r ,�. " a=il �3* ' d�i(j�'''yf `�• r q:'"y, r+ E`r . i+'a' q � J' � °" „� '� �. .rm �. ,.r � �Q�.'�`'�g p B ,_.,`?" � �, .,y¢- �,e K �'� l4 .1. •4- .�J O z Ua 00 q •. . s _ ��ti i�r.&e + :.��,yam ��,�: ��'AR'`y.,�1+'�' '�i� `'�' f&� :c�`y ,�+1}Y� �L' r :�`!la„ ��,�: � pGd`+�,^+u'§ �"�i. s�'� 1 �.�^;, !�� i�... .` a� y 1 ..... ... : ; .. � }, ,�g •� a �,�q��".+ �'�X'� ' � x � ( 7. ��l� `s�R���u"S� �, F � x� u';. .41 �'� t .r'v' ,..,� r� �<`k'!~����+�§X."'�< �:u , 'S't"5. '�. �•St' .r�f.n a� ,�> ... M� 6 ,4� a-' Y� �';A' � ! f� ,b(, ms's_ r n T{y_�. te�vcl.I. ATLAS OF THE CITY OF SALEM 1897 �aAR��'� OF JAQUITL. 2853 'M'r } Ra+ lew A yf .+3NYr Mr9 — -_.— . _. ------ _.:�/r'aR✓ ^w < <=i X' t. .= S,`s".¢w ®' f . - — - � ©2017 t 9 Yay 2017 10 h L --- I - L N =te a 3 U co Q' x __ �� �Lf 1 _✓�✓�� _. G i..•.li Y..L� rrC%%.j - -a'' ad.M ! .�^-. " 3 ,/ Go' •L.. U t0 �N aGm; M 1 -c� 0 a � aQ -4-jv , , cn ca � QUA _� � C)LU _! O .t + 3: J N an O ` o LU U Lu E p u... w l/llos - a - /ink ?ia t✓iNtr r 6iV = TTT - t��y **r— Wtv _ Fwt.tus ' _ _. L.-� iL -fL . { L ,i C. ke*AR�h,�? DAVID r. r jAOUrrr No.2853 z3 ;"� Fiov:ley.%4A t.J i ,RSH 4f YIP:r © 2017 9 ma 2017 y's-syr Wo o •.l co �aC�pV ® N V' eyy CA d) rT- 0wa ce Q16u< o� O o Q v-5 co 1. CJ 4) m: E M LU vv-LSI 7�a Are ^e + Q u M� O a m ' a q U � 4,0-- 0 I 1� i J_ e sob • V� Conversion of Historic Barn to a o Dwelling Unit C) for Dean and Lorraine Boucher 13 Arthur Street, Salem, Massachusetts ~ 4 rC� DAVID F. JAQUITH , AIA ARCHITECTS Architects + Planners + Landscape + Urban Des! n 8.1 RAILROAD AVENUE, ROWLEY, MASSACHUSETTS 019F -' Jaguitharchitects@mac.com 978-948-2005 i w,,�i Irj1Ili'�d� +dirt 5✓ tie+ ,'75 r rix .r o ,y, 24} r• �,s' 'yf w �,5,.- Allk# _ r4� s. $� y4 t9C8,'+` ! .t a",f hl 1 5/(YS'A_in 4a:y +l � ,I � , 1,Sfl ,Iy ir'J oil, P P' f 59 d V a� rj r z ,>* r,.dr z fi ! j � �p r p ""'<4. �'�`+ - , �\ Y f ..K �3 n9 '"�` ,, R> ,.. ipi r, s p? 3' S.. +ry �H 1 y+•• t;4t4 a f ti.R'.i�,.j " yrs, 4 _..,,...� ,.+.+.•.`t# ::. s• 'y°+eY '7f.. �iL� .n,:` �r zst ,� d t�i 'l7Fl. f,. ryk�I."n f�J 7a �>_P � � r ... . - „„,,,m,6, G Jt ";,.+.', iy? -n, '' Ys -•+` d rr xahR@� t,4 is �R �'• k'-s1} qT '�5Y7 ,! iti ie�: s � p pd• " nr % � r+ e'3�"�-�°.�L`d 40. �-_ � �v,Y�"'—��nY;t•" i� i V A .,��».yi.'A'�}n�y. � �H//.�•w'FC Y�g ti', bn J:C+AS fy/ �1 Za`f�:-s •.`�',b`. r'tH "'� s.lif��'S" r�I�`:�r �ar'j4t,' 0.,MEW .z. 'r ■i F St tP�sd0% apt 44 y..i` - t 1p�- '3ds,„, }t• .. M —Alf S L_.: �` 2 fin GdS J� +• ���' S r. y +'_' 3. �rx Not / r € CIO .y., , 7j, ate r , N qOLLJ 5 f q �7 ff ;f' a pry.s5 f .fir �'s �, r y.n • t .Y t ' t-pi k "j, y°.d 'r 3%t . f ,�j• �f� dj."•1i, '�S ! f ,.�4N a. • s a t �: .6r T'r, , �:. .�y n p� a, a>'F�. v 6� ;;uY,,�r�C`5 #•ek'i � � � 5 I IN lip ,�5's�11 .9..,,,..� �i Yyy'}4>. 35�tj i^ �lS' "rff��e�js •�""t if" 'n: w 5 {.q^��,,Q�I{�^ 'a N y tom"• rr�pf �� .!S (���j-,f„ .(` 'h p Y'�,F.�i �ypl}rly�tiy y �{ LU fA,�f � � �%kq tw*i T � 4";SN Ay��I..�• 'tFB8 Ft\ !� � f3� ' �S'Y��' LP SW'^T"'lt � f� }. ' 1 "d ;•s :� T .i• � f!C } ✓ v'^4 ar '�S'at� ��'y�; y fist + , s1 : , 5 .; I srrrc^ s to• 'iyiCyd .�.-- �r...tii'V�+ ` R ._.t- ,+-y.... ry• �,l i..� ."n2-.,-x'".an ,#°•v Syr."4' ! 5 } # a.u8.ti 58`i .a" yuF-wi,t�9 `r1... Se'f, iir$ TSA 'sxsmxar,mr.k v"..-r! ..n '®udp"�, f + Y SY +r bj • • ..n f h - ,.r`:^ 0.1 r .nPm7 ay.•_ :r^c_ r�fr.. '+( ,v s� .. 'i {� � ,y,.,,�.<-^..4 tP t ,�;1v.QG�" ePf. - � �mv.e. uF F �' � I�3 a>Ys'w: sraw � s e iln�"�� _ � •. '�a ;i ,f�;�.{. %ar .d f r 'C `�j y."�^+.,� z.'"a• �'�� '„vw f �'• i m Via... � -.'3 g�9 �3 ..�s'�� • .• keY+j� R S \�.t u3 mPp. i•. 111 �.� af' l3+^ 4 �� k Yr Q �'� 't a .[ 'i 'i•�Y. �, , t,e ' k� { � ti� x�r�+. 3. ^6 <?a; '� � i i1 mx a, 5 � ' ,�", x,^✓c+'+ a"-Y ¢.i v nd4: r4 F a� f r, �'. wcs A.d � tA . t +N •�A d"wi'4gj M129' +(i ��yle,p y k; • • _ �' :, r# 1 `• A 'x-_a... y �S'{j ','«� d riyf""St ,'ell x , �. rt` A y} f�, .'!� £wr .� kir`f � j, ; • v ;i S j<,� a .+'++-t . lf Y •a z �'� � Y e'C to i'N`' z a, rf� 'S. .* •� � x Y,t �ri v �( `+Y ri, s ... X r� .}l�'r'Y r"� �' 'R •,Q.f r xi. � �5� � v Y-'1 r 7. �b 1 t 1 • war II t ' ,;s; RW t 40 ; lily 3MAN i. r'�f', .` . i` F.%'y• n ..+1't 1., 1�+4-'+ f f�+rd ".�.-y s..+i ;r. *tw,�•'3 � ♦r •��•1+.'• ��rs •�e .r � rC++� �' � �`E t'� � rl�`s✓fry„,�y ��# yr . �, . � . svA! �/�l ��'� H "� � � i • ,7i}� �. • Fid :� y� �f 3#^+- ..'f ` +Gl • a ”' ^• .,moi... a � c: �. , < +rA�$F,.I-+L "'r'°`�` t.'S, ^►' L 11e � P `'� �. prv.,/ + ;f rte• ; ` r r,. r+i "� " j•/ a , Akk , _• _.� # art. / S`f+.:i/N ..+F 7 ��>� �� :�.` • NY'."'�X1 .t t ♦� :.. •i aR•x.�' +� , .Y+a.!�tt.,J ,F" i.�'. x y t• s • -t, p �•.. 1�.. fir..xIR♦c "••�'y,�; I 1 L 'ld`,..•J' �. Otty ^�/�jt �`• Fd " ,4iR „*{7 Ni •�4r • Y �' > . 'L n'�`Y�t r' } Zi 1 1 I ;� , ` �'�t" .. . � � • � �a fir: kc ctx`kj„f k *r� �,t +�' , � qw3^ '� �`' � �'ar *.s« *� � �'*�'�}�•��`x�-�'� � `.,�}���r �����'..�-v �r'��,z.s, r Gid � 3+ � y& - { '�5 � - � � ��`ty'y.���:�'"=y `U��'���.��ya`�, 1�g^ �}M L �.t• � '��Tp�'�"j e � i ..TT�a +r�X r 'W ,..q rRJ`" AtGryHT�'e9cxz{r '' a ' ti a�Ra�yi' >sy N f a . � Y r, � � ��n� w � 3 t A C.ti� ..n "' 28 �"x � nt "'vim �,�� ✓� w a r r� �{ K` s$SyFs dc'�a ` ° a • x a�<k �' '�,�s,�`�,.�.� tz'k� `.�, �� »� .a �.'sc' x..;� :."^ ^{ e <: u. ��mpz'c✓�t/„M. • ^ :?' k„ �+�." e r �m'£m� :7 a as "�'�+"°'� f 'S xF � +`.� -� }'� r'`�iy -.''% (t r '✓'"'a f e*�cr% "tf-� `� �'�s s f r"''f�t�^s'Ar. � #'.+r'P.._�'.�_�o� sL•Yis"?s ,k r x of aT" .. F _ d% '`` M - xa,�'+u tie^ 4� �'.' E giq - :c Sy n'gvx- r � �m= m. � e - �ti4'•"'� ^,x''x 'xFa`v c� ! y. Arev x` o-oal i .. ^`'.. � +'" ..� .+ s *v'St r• 7G�S:.` �`t;�ta&,w WY�,r..� .��ra � C � � �g >Kt�,gs We � �.. kx s.. z• f�t'C a '"'.�" �� �+.a$�4 -'� r �r � s v4 ' r 3 g a{�� s � _ � -�'nr w, r �pja�t A,� �, s. �d A r �F-•x.� 4�' S'i r�.i>+�Mc' ,�' e x.� pzx ' d a . y A � ��,'as r t ,� �,. t �:�.� ✓ 'r � xtYx�� ^� t"' �� �'�x'�^�iW���,ra,F ye '3%w�'tts � i z r s .Q 5. , v,>F }Jt�t i� 3,rf..�R:fv✓t s Jr': - � �" t �"•� s . x @ '3e': s ax. x. �Nc i ���.r'""kw�"r'`£�frn� �c#". �z�Yf^ j): -..: � _� : > , "�"y �' �..r� .r -•An .. c. �f.� r-'c .,.c+ a" '�``'-�*.' 3 . � r '.. 'R-'c�'�' 4 �'�'4+.. .. � d S �.� �) �4'✓ Y L w.f u. & i�.�.Y ���G�V�:L� t �R ""Yr�'Ij ` ^i _ '�M1'>•" Sa .e`er "� �+j N" 1`' �d`Yy_ Y -'S pn 5. �, b T ..�ti xLt. br ✓� 4^ � Y 6 "''1'. :� a F a zt a"^'cR" �es�.mi rnr7 2� 'fik x ++ ±. k+ is-t •d .r n -Yk Us.'Sr yr x� xa .•'r v :?' o .. M t ""s^wrr a-'`}p$, r '�� , �vr x e c FEAIncorporatedFARNSwoRTH Essex-South District Re ist Engineering Associates (formerly John Street ns shown on g n' of Deeds (1986 ARTHUR STREET Plan Orientation From ..... Plan by C.A.Putnam, 1878) Deed Book 1001, End o Professional Land Surve rs 5Q/t R-o-W WidthY and Civil Engineers N 880 E Sidewalk 80, nc Pte 23 HIII Road 23 1 200ft to Jefferson - Lancaster, MAOI(voice.)access (978) 368-7931 (voice) No. 13 — — y Wood-Frame C Plan Title: 71 -story — — a w/Basement UO o Unit1& 2 a ZONING BOARD of ° LF7' _� t� APPEALS PLAN O Z e Wo o o h° n/f BERNARD Located m the TOWN of: j 3 x AREA v No. 11 Arthur-St SALEM , MA .e N g 000 Par-ID: 23-0034-0 a - , 13 ARTHUR St. o � � o Plan Prepared for: Owner of Record za .r £ S gFt +/- a Dean T. Boucher, (owner) Q ca c --` (owner is Applicant) Dean T. Boucher rn,Cx o O / Deed Bk 17393;Pg 64 O SHED1 3 Arthur Street . Salem MA 1Sft by 15. Assessor's Parcel 23-0035-0 6)dt tiso)oundati + Contains : 8,000+/-SgFt 5ee: Salem-Deeds, Book 17393, Pg 64 �, r is ar a stale 2' Plan Book 1001 , End of Book b M I certify that the buildings shown here-on LotNo.5 15 * 20 are located " on the groundwn 0.75Fit Data References: Conc-Wall with Stockade Fence on top _ ��. _ g 5ee: Plan Recorded Se-E9sex Deeds,SALEM S p p o �I 7 exceeds tift lleight 8 0I' �7 JOHN A! � Plan of a Part of Derby Farm Near Castle Ydl, - O O VV o v� ARNSWORTH t S=ale 100 feet to an rich.C.A. Putnam,C.E., - _ Salem Mass 1878 rewrded Aeo 23, 1878 n/f COTE ` I/ n/f LEVASSEUR - -No. 16 Read-St John A. Farn5p ) ,� 1' ,.:;_; No. 22 Read-St LP., Paz-ID: 23-0025-0 Par-ID: 23-0026-0 MA PLS No: 3 J -� ' Plan No 17-01 Budd-Location Plan Date: 03-26-2017 Field: John A. Farnsworth, PLS Note-Well, Nota-Bene: 2G March 2017 GRAPHIC SCALE F Drawn/ Calc: J. Farnsworth zo o 10 N w Units 1 & 2 are existing,plan Check/Cert: J. Farnsworth depicts location ofproposed COPYPJGHT Farnsworth Engineenny Assoc. 2017 / 1 Unit#3, 3-27-2017 ( IN FEET ) B-Size at Scale 1 inch = 20 ft. Sheet I of Io�pr C044-pr MO),�/A A