MINUTES - Regular - 12/19/2002 CITY OF SALEM 643
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
A Regular Meeting of the City Council was held in the Council Chamber
on Thursday, December 19, 2002 at 7.00 P.M. for the purpose of transacting any
and all business. Notice of this meeting was posted on December 13, 2002 at
9.22 A.M.
Council President Flynn was absent due to a family commitment.
Senior Member Leonard F. O'Leary presided.
Councillor Harvey moved to dispense with the reading of the record of the
previous meeting. It was so voted.
Councillor O'Leary requested a moment of silence for Mrs. Patricia
Carney, former Director of Constituent Services, who passed away.
Councillor Bencal requested a moment of silence for Mrs. Nora Giunta,
former Salem School Teacher, who passed away.
President O'Leary called upon Councillor Harvey to award the Kernwood
Golf Scholarships.
#890 — POLE LOCATION ON VICTORY ROAD
A hearing was held on the Order of Verizon and Massachusetts Electric
Company for a joint owned pole on Victory Road. Appearing in favor was Mr.
Richard Picone of Verizon. There was no one opposed. The hearing was
closed. Councillor Chuber moved that the permit be granted. It was so voted.
#891 — CONDUIT LOCATION FOR A T & T BROADBAND
A hearing was held on the Order of A.T. & T. Broadband for a conduit
location for 230 Essex Street. Appearing in favor was David Pabich, the building
Owner. There was no one opposed. The hearing was closed. Councillor
Chuber moved that the permit be granted. It was so voted.
#892 —APPT. T. JANE GRAHAM-DWYER TO COUNCIL ON AGING
The Mayor's appointment of T. Jane Graham Dwyer to serve as a member
of the Council on Aging was confirmed under suspension of the rules by a roll
call vote of 10 yeas, 0 nays, 1 absent. Councillors Bencal, Chuber, DeToma,
Driscoll, Furey, Harvey, Lovely, O'Keefe, O'Leary, and Sargent were recorded as
voting in the affirmative. Councillor Flynn was absent.
644 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
#893 — REAPPT. JOHN A. HARRIS TO COMMISSION ON DISABILITIES
The Mayor's reappointment of John A. Harris to serve as a member of the
Commission on Disabilities for a term to expire January 11, 2005, was confirmed
by a roll call vote of 10 yeas, 0 nays, 1 absent. Councillors Bencal, Chuber,
DeToma, Driscoll, Furey, Harvey, Lovely, O'Keefe, O'Leary, and Sargent were
recorded as voting in the affirmative. Councillor Flynn was absent.
#894 —APPT. CONSTABLE
The Mayor's appointment of Domingo Dominguez to serve as a Constable
for a term to expire November 19, 2003, was received and filed.
#895 —APPR. FIRE DEPARTMENT RETIREMENT ANTICIPATION
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Thirty Four Thousand Four Hundred Fifty
Two Dollars ($34,452.00) is hereby appropriated from the "Fund Balance
Reserved for Appropriation Free Cash" Account to the "Fire Department
Retirement Anticipation" Account in accordance with the recommendation of His
Honor the Mayor.
#896 —APPR. FIRE DEPARTMENT RETIREMENT ANTICIPATION
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Thirty Thousand Six Hundred Seven Dollars
and two cents ($30,607.02) is hereby appropriated from the "Fund Balance
Reserved for Appropriation Free Cash" Account to the "Fire Department
Retirement Anticipation" Account in accordance with the recommendation of His
Honor the Mayor.
#897 —APPR. VETERANS SERVICES VETERANS BENEFITS
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Thirty Thousand Dollars ($30,000.00) is
hereby appropriated from the "Fund Balance Reserved for Appropriation Free
CITY OF SALEM 645
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Cash" Account to the "Veterans Services Veterans Benefits" Account in
accordance with the recommendation of His Honor the Mayor.
#898 —APPR. FIRE DPEARTMENT RETIREMENT ANTICIPATION
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Twenty Nine Thousand Nine Hundred
Twenty Seven Dollars and forty four cents ($29,927.44) is hereby appropriated
from the "Fund Balance Reserved for Appropriation Free Cash" Account to the
"Fire Department Retirement Anticipation" Account in accordance with the
recommendation of His Honor the Mayor.
#899 —APPR. TREASURER - MUNICIPAL INSURANCE
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Twenty one thousand sixty dollars
($21,060.00) is hereby appropriated from the "Fund Balance Reserved for
Appropriation Free Cash" Account to the "Treasurer Municipal Insurance"
Account in accordance with the recommendation of His Honor the Mayor.
#900 —APPR. CEMETERY BURIAL
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Seven Thousand Six Hundred Dollars
($7,600.00) is hereby appropriated from the "Receipts Reserved Cemetery Sale
of Lots" Account to the "Cemetery Burial" Account in accordance with the
recommendation of His Honor the Mayor.
#901 — TRANS. PARKING DEPARTMENT BUILDING EQUIPMENT
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was referred to the
Committee on Administration and Finance.
ORDERED: That the sum of Five Thousand Ninety-Eight Dollars and
twelve cents ($5,098.12) is hereby transferred from the "Parking Department
Seasonal Labor" Account to the "Parking Department Building and Equipment
646 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Maintenance Account in accordance with the recommendation of His Honor the
Mayor.
#902 — SHADE TREE SALARIES OVERTIME
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was adopted under
suspension of the rules.
ORDERED: That the sum of Three Thousand Six Hundred Seventy
Dollars ($3,670.00) is hereby appropriated from the "Cemetery Sale of Vaults
Receipts Reserved" Account to the "Shade Tree Salaries Overtime" Account in
accordance with the recommendation of His Honor the Mayor.
#903 — EASEMENT TO BEVERLY COOPERATIVE BANK FOR LAND AT 315
DERBY STREET
The following Order, recommended by the Mayor, was referred to the
Committee on Community and Economic Development.
ORDERED: That the Mayor is hereby authorized to execute a Grant of
Easement for consideration of One ($1.00) Dollar, mutual covenants, and other
valuable consideration, going from the City of Salem to Beverly Cooperative
Bank for the right to pass and repass to and from the same by motor vehicle or
otherwise for the purpose of constructing, operating, and maintaining a drive-
through teller and automated teller machine structure with appurtenant
driveways, curbing, landscaping, drainage, lighting and other public
improvements on land known and numbered as 315 Derby Street.
#904 — (#787) — MAYOR'S VETO OF ORDINANCE AMENDING STREETS
AND SIDEWALKS-ADVANCE NOTIFICATION OF STREET CLOSINGS
The following Veto was received from the Mayor after the deadline of
Tuesday Noon. Councillor Bencal requested and received unanimous consent to
suspend the rules to allow the matter to come before the City Council. There
was no action taken for 7 days under the City Charter.
To the City Council
City Hall
Salem, Massachusetts
Ladies and Gentlemen of the Council:
CITY OF SALEM 647
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
I am returning with my VETO the Ordinance relative to street openings to
you.
I can clearly understand the nature of needed notification to neighbors and
their abutters in the case of any street closure. Advance notification of a street or
sidewalk opening that results in the street being closed makes a great deal of
sense.
I do not, however, believe that such an encumbered process is necessary
in all routine, non-emergency street and sidewalk openings that do not result in
the closure of any street to pedestrian or vehicular traffic.
I truly feel that the Ordinance should be re-written to reflect these points
and address the true nature of the problem.
With warm regards, I remain
Sincerely,
Stanley J. Usovicz, Jr.
Mayor
#905 — MAYOR SUBMITTING UPDATE ON THE P.I.L.O.T. PROGRAM
A communication from the Mayor, submitting an update on the P.I.L.O.T.
Program (Payment in Lieu of Taxes) was referred to the Committee on
Administration and Finance and Community and Economic Development.
#906 — BOARD OF HEALTH NEWSLETTER
A communication from the Mayor submitting an informational newsletter
from the Board of Health was received and filed.
#907 — COMMITTEE OF WHOLE MEET REGARDING S.E.S.D. AND SALEM
BEVERLY WATER BOARD REGARDING MEMBERSHIP CRISIS
Councillor Harvey introduced the following Order, which was adopted.
ORDERED: That the Committee of the Whole meet the week of January
6 with Salem's appointee to the Salem/Beverly Water Supply Board and the
other Board members, and Salem's appointee to the South Essex Sewerage
Board and other Board members, to discuss the pending crisis at both
authorities.
648 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
#908 — COMMITTEE MATTERS BE CARRIED INTO 2003
Councillor Lovely introduced the following Order, which was adopted.
ORDERED: That the attached matters, currently before the various sub-
committees of the City Council, be carried into 2003.
#909 — GRANTING LICENSES
Councillor O'Keefe offered the following report for the Committee on
Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs. It was voted to accept the report and
adopt the recommendation.
The Committee on Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs to whom was
referred the matter of granting certain licenses has considered said matter and
would recommend that the following be granted.
FORTUNETELLING Debbie Mitchell, 6 Hawthorne Blvd., Salem
Fatima Mitchell, 6 Hawthorne Blvd., Salem
Tammy Mitchell, 6 Hawthorne Blvd., Salem
JUNK DEALER Naumkeag Auto, 50R Broadway
SEAWORMS John Silva, 10 Almeda St., Salem
TAXI OPERATOR Ed Bielski, 2 Flint St., Salem
Brendall Castillo, 11 Meadow St., Salem
Juan Castillo, 535 Mountain Ave., Revere
Newri Garcia, 6 Ray St., Peabody
Ramon Gomez, 260 Washington St., Salem
Clifford Goodman, 22 Bertuccio Ave., Salem
Ramon Guerrero, 10 Prince St., Salem
David Jalbert, 12 Mt. Vernon St., Salem
Guillermo Javier, 8 Prince St., Salem
Kevin Melzard, 59 Goodale St., Peabody
Leonardo Road, 178 Beacon Hill Ave., Lynn
Santo Santana, 4 Prince St., Salem
Blair Schetrompf Jr., 36 Stanns Ave., Peabody
Juan B. Velez, 41 Ward St., Salem
LIMOUSINE North Shore Airport Limo, 10 Colonial Rd., Salem (5)
Jireh Car Service Inc., 201 Washington St., Salem (4)
CITY OF SALEM 649
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
#910 — (#826) — (#827) — USE OF SALEM COMMON
Councillor O'Keefe offered the following report for the Committee on
Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs. It was voted to accept the report and
adopt the recommendation.
The Committee on Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs to whom was
referred the matter of the following requests to use the Salem Common has
considered said matter and would recommend that the following be approved:
Tracy Leith, 6 Central St., Topsfield, July 12, 2003 (wedding)
H.A.W.C. Walk, April 27, 2003
#911 — (#539) — ORDINANCE AMENDING NOISE, LOADING AND
UNLOADING OF GOODS
Councillor O'Keefe offered the following report for the Committee on
Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs. It was voted to accept the report and
adopt the recommendation.
The Committee on Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs to whom was
referred an Ordinance relative to Noise, loading and unloading at retail
commercial operations, has considered said matter and would recommend that
the Ordinance be adopted for second and final passage as amended by the
Committee.
(#539) — ORDINANCE AMENDING NOISE, LOADING AND UNLOADING OF
GOODS
The Ordinance reads as follows:
In the year two thousand and two
An Ordinance to amend an Ordinance relative to Noises Enumerated
Be it ordained by the City Council of the City of Salem, as follows:
Section 1. Chapter 22, Section 22-2 (4), loading and unloading, manufacturing
activities, is hereby amended by adding the following:
Loading and unloading of boxes, crates, and containers at all commercial and/or
retail establishments
650 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Section 2. This Ordinance shall take effect as provided by City Charter.
#912 — (#502) — ORDINANCE, HOURS OF OPERATION, REQUIRING A
POLICE DETAIL AT CERTAIN ESTABLISHMENTS
Councillor O'Keefe offered the following report for the Committee on
Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs. It was voted to accept the report.
The Committee on Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs to whom was
referred the matter of Police Detail and hours of operation at retail
establishments (incorporating language of City Solicitor) has considered said
matter and would recommend that the matter be reported out with no
recommendation.
Councillor Lovely assumed the Chair for President O'Leary.
Councillor O'Leary resumed the Chair.
The Ordinance was adopted for first passage (with the Solicitor's
language) by a roll cal vote of 7 yeas, 3 nays, 1 absent. Councillors Bencal,
Chuber, Furey, Harvey, Lovely, O'Keefe, and Sargent were recorded as voting in
the affirmative. Councillors DeToma, Driscoll, and O'Leary were recorded as
voting in the negative. Councillor Flynn was absent.
Councillor Harvey moved for immediate reconsideration in the hopes it
would not prevail. Reconsideration was denied.
The Ordinance reads as follows:
(#502) — ORDINANCE, HOURS OF OPERATION, REQUIRING A POLICE
DETAIL AT CERTAIN ESTABLISHMENTS
In the year two thousand and two
An Ordinance to amend an Ordinance relative to Hours of Operation,
Retail Business Establishments
Be it ordained by the City Council of the City of Salem, as follows:
Section 1. Chapter 14, is hereby amended by adding the following paragraph to
Section 14-230, applicability to other establishments:
CITY OF SALEM 651
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
The City Council, by 2/3 vote may require the assignment of a private
detail officer of the Salem Police Department to any establishment operating
between the hours of 11.00 P.M. and 6.00 A.M. to insure the public health,
safety, and good order of the community. All costs associated with the police
detail shall be borne by the establishment.
Prior to voting on such requirement, the Council shall allow the
establishment the opportunity to be heard on the cause for such action. The
owner shall also have the right to be represented by counsel and have the
opportunity to examine any witnesses presented in support of such a
requirement. The Council shall provide written notice of the cause(s) for such
action at least ten (10) days prior to any vote taken. Included in said notice shall
be copies of any written complaints supporting this action.
In its order, the Council must specify the hours and days required for the
detail and how long it must remain in effect. (ie. 11.00 P.M. until 3.00 A.M.,
Friday and Saturday nights for the next 3 months) In any event, said order will
be subject to review on an annual basis.
Section 2. This Ordinance shall take effect as provided by City Charter.
#913 — (# 724) — HIGH STREET PLAYGROUND LIGHTING/FENCING
Councillor Furey offered the following report for the Committee on
Government Services. It was voted to accept the report and adopt the
recommendation.
The Committee on Government Services to whom was referred the matter
of the High Street Playground has considered said matter and would recommend
that the City Electrician, John Giardi, investigate the present lighting conditions in
the High Street playground to possibly realign lights and replace any defective or
damaged lights and to report back to Councillor Lovely.
And Further, that the Park and Recreation Board review fencing and
locking gates and parking needs especially for Pratt Street residents and to
report back to Councillor Lovely.
#914 — (#632) — TRAFFIC AND NEIGHBORHOOD ISSUES ON OSGOOD
STREET
652 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Councillor Furey offered the following report for the Committee on
Government Services. It was voted to accept the report and adopt the
recommendation.
The Committee on Government Services to whom was referred the matter
of Traffic Issues on Osgood Street has considered said matter and would
recommend:
1. No left hand turn (coming from Beverly)
2. No heavy truck traffic as recommended by Captain Callahan.
#915 — (#682) — (#713) — (#718) — (#719) — (#786) — REQUEST TO PURCHASE
VARIOUS PARCELS OF CITY LAND
Councillor Furey offered the following report for the Committee on
Government Services. It was voted to accept the report and adopt the
recommendation.
The Committee on Government Services to whom was referred the matter
of requests of various residents to purchase parcels of city-owned land has
considered said matter and would recommend as follows:
The process and legal procedure of purchasing the attached parcels was
discussed step by step to the purchasers of said properties by City Solicitor
Keenan and Councillor O'Leary. A time line of survey, legal advice, storm drain
regulations, etc. so residents could start the process and procedure.
#916 — REQUEST TO PURCHASE CITY LAND ABUTTING 16 BEACON
STREET
A communication from Mark Matkevicius to purchase city-owned land
abutting 16 Beacon Street, was referred to the Committee on Government
Services.
#917 — USE OF SALEM COMMON AND OLD TOWN HALL FOR NATIONAL
GUARD MUSTER
The request of Brigadier General Albert A. Mangone to use the Salem
Common on April 19, 2003 for a National Guard Heritage Muster and to use Old
Town Hall for a luncheon, was approved, and that the city waive all fees for the
events.
CITY OF SALEM 653
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
Councillor O'Keefe requested and received unanimous consent to
suspend the rules to allow General Mangone to speak.
#918 — COMMUNICATION FROM NORTH SHORE LABOR COUNCIL
REGARDING REMOVAL OF DOMINIC MARRAFFA FROM SALEM HOUSING
AUTHORITY
A communication from the North Shore Labor Council regarding the
removal of Dominic Marraffa from the Salem Housing Authority, was received.
Councillor Harvey moved to accept the letter and copies of the charges;
request an opinion from the City Solicitor regarding the proper procedures for the
Executive and Legislative Branch to follow; the Solicitor is to report back to the
City Council no later than January 9, 2003; that the Committee of the Whole
meet on January 9, 2003 at 6.30 P.M. with the Mayor; and if the timetable is
allowed by statute, that the hearing with Mr. Marraffa be held by January 22,
2003.
The motion was adopted by a roll call vote of 10 yeas, 0 nays, 1 absent.
Councillors Bencal, Chuber, DeToma, Driscoll, Furey, Harvey, Lovely, O'Keefe,
O'Leary, and Sargent were recorded as voting in the affirmative. Councillor
Flynn was absent.
Councillor Harvey moved for immediate reconsideration in the hopes it
would not prevail. Reconsideration was denied.
#919 -#923 — LICENSE APPLICATIONS
The following license applications were referred to the Committee on
Ordinances, Licenses, and Legal Affairs.
JUNK DEALER Frederick Hutchinson, 15 Robinson Rd.
SECOND HAND Compliments Resale Boutique, 132 Boston St.
CLOTHING
TAG DAY S.H.S. Boys Track, January 25, 2003
S.H.S. Winter Track, February 15, 2003
TAXI OPERATOR James R. Cloutman, 19 Rainbow Terr., Salem
Carlos M. Diaz, 40 Harbor St., Salem
Barbara J. Dorsey, 16 Crowninshield St. Peabody
Vincent Ercolano, 29 Hancock St., Salem
654 CITY OF SALEM
DECEMBER 19, 2002
REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL
John Mealey, 30 Grant St., Beverly
Hipolito Ozoria, 49 Harbor St., Salem
Domingo Perez, 12 Pope St., Salem
Nelson Sanchez, 298 Washington St., Salem
Jeffrey Schafer, 8 '/2 Daniels St., Salem
#924 —# 925 - DRAINLAYER/CONTRACT OPERATOR LICENSES
The following Drainlayer/Contract Operator license application was
granted.
J. Doyle Backhoe Service, 21 Poole's Ln., Rockport
#926 — CLAIM
The following claim was referred to the Committee on Ordinances,
Licenses, and Legal Affairs.
Paula Beaulieu, 2 Emerald Avenue, Salem
#927 — BOND
The following Bond was referred to the Committee on Ordinances,
Licenses, and Legal Affairs and return approved.
CONSTABLE Domingo J. Dominguez, 38 Peabody St., Salem
On the motion of Councillor Harvey, the meeting adjourned at 9.35 P.M.
ATTEST: DEBORAH E. BURKINSHAW
CITY CLERK