The URL can be used to link to this page

207 HIGHLAND AVE/DAVITA - B-16-497 & C/O E NSTRUCTIbN LLCENNINGSCIRY, MA 01960-3568Z8- 1-0511 I N CL LLS' F- cj) F-- Z Z 0 FILM l na m I d architects,Inc. architects 1 planners 1 Interiors '1 vr9inla Avenue,Suite 202 _ Providence,Rhode Island 02905 - T:401.435.3532 1 F:401.435.3712 vemv.nemd.com Inemd@nemd.com U 6 a s FIRE ALARM NOTES 1.E.C.SHALL PROVIDE CIRCUIT BREAKER LOCK-ON DEVICES FOR FACP CIRCUIT. - 2.E.C.SHALL FURNISH AND INSTALL REMOTE INDICATING LIGHTS/TEST SWITCHES FOR DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS. - 3.REFER TO FLOOR PLANS FOR EXACT NUMBER OF DEVICES AND CANDELA RATINGS. - - - 4.COLOR CODE PER THE LATEST EDITION OF APPLICABLE MASSACHUSETTS FIRE LAWS. 5.SPLICES WILL NOT BE ALLOWED.WIRENUTS WILL NOT BE ALLOWED. 1 6.RED PAINTED TERMINAL CABINETS ❑BOXES WITH LOCKABLE COVERS SHALL BE PROVIDED AT ALL JUNCTION POINTS. z 0.AFC FIRE ALARM/CONTROL CABLE TOPE MC [UL LISTEDUMAU BE USED ABOVE CEILINGS AND IN CONCEALED AREAS WHERE ACCEPTABLE TO THE LOCAL AUTHORITO HAVING JURISDICTION. EXPOSED AREAS SHALL BE EMTEPAINTED PER ARCHITECTS DIRECTION.ALL CONDUCTORS SHALL BE A MINIMUM OF D16AWG SOLID COPPEROTOPE THHNDI•HWN OR TFN. - z ALL WIRING SHALL RUN CONTINUOUSLDI FROM DEVICE TO DEVICE. a O THE CONTRACTOR AT COMPLETETION OF THE FIRE ALARM SOSTEM SHALL TEST THE ENTIRE SOSTEM PER THE LOCAL LL o NOTE: FIRE DEPARTMENTS REOUIREMENTS.THE CONTRACTOR SHALL REPLACE OR FIX AND PART OF THE SOSTEM NOT w h - REFER TO PLANS FOR ACTUAL PROPERLO WORKING.' TOPICAL NOTIFICATION CIRCUIT OUANTITO OF DEVICES. ITOP❑ - - O THE MINIMUM SEPARATION BETWEEN THE OUTGOING AND RETURN FIRE ALARM CIRCUITS SHALL BE A MINIMUM OF - = 7_771 I - - - - 1-FOOT VERTICALLO AND 4-FEET HORIDONTALLO IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS OF NFPA-[12. - - - 10.ALL FIRE ALARM SDSTEM COMPONENTS O MOUNTING HEIGHTS SHALL COMPLO WITH ADA REQUIREMENTS. - - - 11.E.C.SHALL PROVIDE AND AND ALL AUXILARO EOUIPMENT IN ORDER TO PROVIDE A COMPLETEEPROPERLD FUNCTIONING i SOSTEM.COORDINATE REDUIREMENTS WITH LOCAL MANUFACTURERS REP. J NOTE: c : REFER TO PLANS FOR ACTUAL 12.ALL FIRE ALARM STROBE SIGNAL DEVICES SHALL BE SONCHRONIOED TDPE DEVICES AND COMPLD WITH ADA DUANTITO OF DEVICES. ITEP11 - REOUIREMENTS. -. _ as 13.NO T-TAPPING OF FIRE ALARM WIRING SHALL BE ALLOWED. LTOPICALO J a i � 1 14.ALL FIRE ALARM WIRING O RACEWAO SHALL BE SUPPORTED BO THE BUILDING STRUCTURE AND SHALL NOT BE LOCATED H 8 `� - i H73s AS TO BE DAMAGED BD BUILDING USE. = mCD - 00 DUCT SMOKE 15.WEATHER-PROOF KNOX-BOX FURNISHED AND INSTALLED ON THE EXTERIOR OF THE BUILDING BO E.C.COORDINATE 0 m $ O -� T T DETECTOR IN BOTH EXACT LOCATION WITH LOCAL FIRE DEPARTMENT. ,. ToPICAL ADDRESSABLE LOOP SUPPLU AND RETURN Cu - - .- - - DUCTS.❑'OPICALE] 16,ALL SMOKE DETECTORS SHALL BE MOUNTED ON THE CEILING AND UL LISTED FOR CEILING MOUNTING AND LOCATED 999 NOT LESS THAN 12-INCHES FROM AND WALL.DETECTORS SHALL NOT BE IN A DIRECT AIR FLOW NOR CLOSER THAN 3-FEET i - FROM AND AIR SUPPLO DIFFUSER. QOPIiCALD 1 O UL LISTED INSULATED THROATOSET SCREW CONNECTORS SHALL BE USED WITH MC CABLE INSTALLATIONSLILLAMP - CONNECTORS ARE NOT ALLOWEDO A CABLE CUTTING TOOL WITH CONTROLLED DEPTH OF CUT SHALL BE USED IN ALL MC CABLE INSTALLATIONS. - / 111 FAULT ISOLATION MODULES SHALL BE INSTALLED FOR EVERD 25 DEVICES AND IN NO CASE SHALL THE LENGTH OF AN WIRE CONTROL MODULE J Q - - AREA BE DISABLED BO A WIRE-TO-WIRE SHORT CIRCUIT FAULT EXCEED 200'IN AND ONE DIRECTION.WHERE A SINGLE - - TO OVERRIDE KEOLESSCONTRr CIRCUIT SERVES MORE THAN ONE FLOOR�AULTISOLATION MODULES SHALL BE INSTALLED TO PREVENT AWIRE-TO-WIRE DOORS.IT:.OPICALO SHUT DOWN HVAC O TFICA ION PEROOCALS PROVIDE IE RADIO ADDRESSABLE UNITS WHEN FIRE - SHORT CIRCUIT FAULT ON ONE FLOOR TO DISABLE THE CIRCUIT ON ANOTHER FLOOR.'. (n NOTIFICATION PER LOCAL STANDARD IE RADIO BOXO FIRE ALARM MASTER BOX OR DIALER.COORDINATE WITH AHJ. ALARM IS ACTUATED. (n M SOSTEM 130 ALARM _ 10.N/A - EST OR EDUAL 20.WIRING FOR THE FIRE ALARM SDSTEM SHALL BE CLASS"A"dNCLUDING THE WIRING BETWEEN MONITOR MODULES AND J 11 SPRINKLER DEVICES. Q Q Q - zovm 21.REFER TO THE SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE"SEDUENCE OF OPERATION"AND ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. _ NOTE: _ Q THIS SCHEMATIC IS FOR INFORMATIONAL 22.DUCT SMOKE DETECTORS AND TAMPER SWITCHES SHALL ANNUNCIATE SUPERVISOR❑TROUBLE. �_ W BATTERIES PURPOSES ONLO TO THE CONFIGURATION _ GROUND PER CODE. OF THE SOSTEM.THIS SCHEMATIC DOES J NOT INDICATE ALL DEVICES.REFER TO 23.TWO INDICATIONS OF ALARM ARE REQUIRED FOR SPRINKLER SDSTEM: MAIN FLOW O DONE. W Q Q NOTE 24 ON THIS DRAWING. 24.E.C.SHALL PRODUCE A MANUFACTURER'S COMPLETE FIRE ALARM SDSTEM ONE-LINE DIAGRAM AND ADDRESS PLAN V) TEPICAL FIRE ALARM SCHEMATIC DURING THE SHOP DRAWING SUBMITTAL PROCESS. NOT TO SCALE N -G+ i O Z to � i LL J I .1H OF MAssq - 2 RAYMOND W.�G •� DUSSEALUT III m j ELECTRICAL PISTE S PROJECT« 13046 I FA100 i T i I I i — II w� Z I F I OO - nlelmldarchitects,Inc. TEAM 11 A — architects I planners i Interlom li PTEMM OEN MEN I ADMIN R.O. VICE CLINIC MED 142 141 AREA DIRECTOR PRES. COORD -I� PREP t Virginia Avenue,Suite 202 136 135 134 122 — —{ 121 Providence,Rhode Island 02905 T.401.435.3532 1 F:401.435.3712 - ° 15 75Cd 15 75Cd o'l I w vnemd.com inemd@nemd.com / / — I 77O OFFICE � o� 15/75cd l��ta 143 1 RTU-6 :15/75cd 15/75cd1 ABOVEz50CORRIDOR - - - - - - - - - -133 CHURCH WORK NTRANCE 15/75cd ® 132 15/75cd o 15/75cd CORRIDOR ° 15/75cd CLG 0 ® PPE HOOKS 144 u HOYER LIFT �� _ — n X X EXAM I - - - - 0� �X,0�X� 131 - - - - - - °�" / \6 3( NURSE F LAB 15/75cd ® PREP 123 BUSINESS 124 L. OFFICE CHARTS a - 126 125 COATOf HOOKS — J N TEAMMATE ® L — ° TEAMMATE ® WOMEN ® °oo CO IDOR I /75cd. ENTRANCE 47 N � 15/75ca � 129 CORRID4RcdCLOCK fJAr CONFERENCE 145 ° 15/75c 1 15/75cd 146 MEN - HUDDLE 3 i 0 128 , 75cd 0 — 0 — 15/75cd d p F � — �� CLG - �� ( BIO I .y d N Q 0 0 TRASH O 4 I ' TEAMMATE QP I' II m olllre I cc 1 HOME WAITING/PR 151 � I NURSE _ 15/75cd I E°� 152 ® i _ @ 15/75cd CRASH N DIE CART N — — — — I N WAITING u ��J 000 RI ®D I r - - _ u, EMERGENCY ® CORRIDOR y5/75cd 1 1 > 1 w EGRESS ® 153 RTU-1 RTU-2 ® —� i °iO ; 0 15/75cd ABOVE RI RTS RTSABOVE I [ —. I ' BIO NEW ADDRESSABLE: FIRE ALARM CONTROL PANEL TO SERVE PATIENT ISI I TRASH 15�/^5cd ' � DAVRA SPACE. PROVIDE MODULES TO INTERFACE WITH PREP _�L�— CLG 15/75cd polo o�0 15/75cd 15/75cd ��° EXISTING HOUSE FIRE ALARM SYSTEM. ALARM ON ONE I — D° °IO D o SYSTEM SHALL AC1nVATE AN ALARM ON THE OTHER. 104 — 1 ]. f l Ell I� HOME I HOME HOME FEC i a STOR TRAINING 3 TRAINING 2 TRAINING 1 �l ' E •WELCOME" L 158 157 156 155 LIDA ® TREATMENTcc VESTIBULE ® - FLOOR a 101 mo) 1 105 .L L 0° ® 15/7504 L4 MAIN i — ENTRANCE ❑ El El El SN OF MgSSq pC RAYMOND W.�G ¢, DUSSEALUT III m - - m ELECTRICAL t, � INVIA /////A ICTVAL�" 1 FIRE ALARM PLAN — WEST FA101 SCALE: 1/4"=1'-0" PROJECT# 13046 - FA101 = III ' 1 , v i. T - i r THIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF"NEMD ARCHITECTS, INC." UNAUTHORIZED USE OF ANY KIND, INCLUDING USE ON OTHER PROJECTS, IS PROHIBITEDI71 Iii � - �.. , �= - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - _ �_ � ,.�, ...�� _ Z7 _ o z — ❑ On 'I I - o - ILI ❑ a I CIO UI- - V V 47U\ 000 to F , fD _ L -I_ IIL (ice IrI I - - - - - J I rl',I r - - - - Ll LA ❑ A � 10 L L �E2� _ o in r_ i m N o Q01 i f c f � FTl ami ❑ _ _� Cam zz CD o Crol) ma or— za\ TI N � z Nm ® � N m ❑❑ ❑❑ ® ❑ foN— - ❑ M I❑ Z _ ❑❑Z o ❑❑ z \ anpn N D _ Ay N r II Ay U U, Z Oplf I Z Z II SZ O '\y' N N m N N m V 114 D ® i D 0 Z rn Cn I I I II I I I II I I i II I I I I II I I - - - -I � _ _ _ _ _ _ � I 1 { I i I I i a STAMPS SHEETnTLE I PROJECT OWNER(DBIA{ ISSUED MN-DY-YR DRAWN CHECKED CONSULTANT ARCHITECT I CLIENT p - CONM��y Fire Alarm Pian DaVita Dialysis DVA Healthcare of ISSUED FOR CONSTRUCTION 11.20.15 n�e�m�d architects o y 1 RFI RESPONSE/COORDINATION 12.11.15 o x -n c �N �_ Salem Northeast Dialysis 03313 Massachusetts 2 DPH MODIFICATIONS A q o n A�Z 207 Highland Avenue clo Wile Healthcare Partners,Inc. d r 1 Virginia Avenue n oco Salem,MA ProectAddress1 CNGIN G,�I QSERVICES g o jN Providence,RI 02905 y a Project Address 141V uzN WqM ysw, rA�,M=76 T. 401.435.3532 N � ;:L Cn S113`+� Tei1 11711&7 9 Paxm011965-2984 C? E. nemd@nemd.com H SHEETNO. N - nemd#15012 � J 1 i i - Certificate Number: B-16-493 Permit Number: B-16493 Commonwealth of Massachusetts City of Salem This is to Certify that theAuto Sales/S Building located at Building Type 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE in the .....................................City of Salem .............................................................................................................................. ................................................. Address Town/City Name IS HEREBY GRANTED A PERMANENT CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY DA VITA DIALYSIS CENTER This Permit is granted in conformity with the Statutes and Ordinances relating thereto, and expires ...............................Not Appticabk..........._................. unless sooner suspended or revoked. Expiration Date Issued On: Thursday, May 04, 2017 Commonwealth, of Massachusetts fi. Citv of Salem s 120 Washington St,3rd Floor Salem,MA 01970(978)745-9595 x5641 Return card to Building Division for Certificate of Occupancy EE PAI No. B'1783 PERMIT T O BUILD ,'EE PAID: $4,152.00 DATE ISSUED: 2/8/2017 This certifies that NEW CREEK II LLC C/O KIMCO REALTY CORP has permission to erect, alter, or demolish a building 3-25 PARADISE ROAD Map/Lot: 200008-0 as follows: Other Building Permit RETAIL FIT-UP & REDESIGN OF 7,000 SF RETAIIL SPACE PARADISE PLAZA: TITLE BOXING CLUB J Contractor Name: JAMES J. WELCH DBA: JAMES J. WELCH CO., INC. Contractor License No: CS-094200 2/8/2017 Building Official Date This permit shall be deemed abandoned and invalid unless the work authorized by this permit is commenced within six months after issuance.The Building Official may grant one or more extensions not to exceed six months each upon written request. All work authorized by this permit shall conform to the approved application and the approved construction documents for which this permit has been granted. All construction,alterations and changes of use of any building and structures shall be in compliance with the local zoning by-laws and codes. This permit shall be displayed in a location clearly visible from access street or road and shall be maintained open for public inspection for the entire duration of the work until the completion of the same. The Certificate of Occupancy will not be issued until all applicable signatures by the Building and Fire Officials are provided on this permit. HIC #: 'Persons contracting with unregistered contractors do not have access to the guaranty fund'(as set forth in MGL c.142A). Restrictions: Building plans are to be available on site. All Permit Cards are the property of the PROPERTY OWNER. s i Fr' Commonwealth of Massachusetts {. q City of Salem 120 Washington St,3rd Floor Salem,MA 01970(978)745-9595 x5641 ` Return card to Building Division for Certificate of Occupancy Structure CITY OF SALEM BUILDING PERMIT PERMIT TO BE POSTED IN THE WINDOW Excavation ° Footing INSPECTION RECORD Foundation Framing/ Mechanical 7 / Insulation INSPECTION: BY DATE Chimney/Smoke Chamber Final 1r,A Plumbing/Gas Rough:Plumbing / „ f Rough:Gas 6,G, t2 , r7' Final Al of Electrical Service Rough ,.,/�LJf t� Final Z &e— �` CR'� ,C / -W Aot. 1 /` e D artment �� V V�VN / G /1///i i ,�`v L-6 J j/6 Prelim! k � 6�"` (! Final LiON q� Hea th Department Preliminary Final Certificate Number: B-17-83 Permit Number: B-17-83 Commonwealth of Massachusetts City of Salem This is to Certify that theShop Center Building located at ................................................................................... Building Type 3-25 PARADISE ROADithe .....................................CtyofSalem............................................... ...................................................................................................... ....................................................................... dress Tmn/City Name IS HEREBY GRANTED A PERMANENT CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY Unit #1 TITLE BOXING CLUB This Permit is granted in conformity with the Statutes and Ordinances relating thereto, and expires Not Applicable ....... unless sooner suspended or revoked. E)piration Date 64'11 - Issued on: Thursday, May 04, 2017 Certificate Number: B-17-83 Permit Number: B-17-83 Commonwealth of Massachusetts City of Salem This is to Certify that the .................................................................Shop..Center Building......................................................... located at Building Type ....................................................................._3-25 PARADISE ROAD....................................................................... in the .....................................City,of Salem ................................................ . ................................................. Address Town/City Name IS HEREBY GRANTED A PERMANENT CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY Title Boxing Unit #2 TITLE BOXING CLUB This Permit is granted in conformity with the Statutes and Ordinances relating thereto, and expires ...............................ONoLApplicaNe unless sooner suspended or revoked. Expiration Date Issued On: Thursday, May 04, 2017 Certificate Number: B-16-493 Permit Number: B-16.493 Commonwealth of Massachusetts City of Salem This is to Certify that the ..............................................................Auto Sales/S Building located at Building Type ................................................................_207 HIGHLAND AVENUE in the .....................................City of Salem ......................................................................................................... ................................................. Address TavNQty Name IS HEREBY GRANTED A PERMANENT CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY DA VITA MLYSIS CENTER This Permit is granted in conformity with the Statutes and Ordinances relating thereto, and expires ...............................Not Applicable unless sooner suspended or revoked. E)Virsbon Date Issued On: Thursday, May 04, 2017 �r Final Construction Control Document To be submitted at completion of construction by a Registered Design Professional for work per the 81 edition of the Massachusetts State Building Code, 780 CMR, Section 107 Project Title: DaVita Healthcare Dialysis Salem Northeast 03313 Date: May 10, 2017 Permit No. Property Address: 207 Highland Avenue, Salem,MA 01970 Project: Check(x)one or both as applicable: New construction X Existing Construction Project description: Conversion of existing vacant space into dialysis clinic-with all necessary upgrades Including new parking, walls,finishes, pumbing, lighting, HVAC and modifcations to structural system I,Joanne O'Connell-Foster,MA Registration Number:7913 Expiration date:Aug. 31, 2017,am a registered design professional, and I have prepared or directly supervised the preparation of all design plans,computations and specifications concerning: X Architectural Structural Mechanical Fire Protection Electrical Other:Describe for the above named project. I,or my designee,have performed the necessary professional services and was present at the construction site on a regular and periodic basis.To the best of my knowledge,information,and belief the work proceeded in accordance with the requirements of 780 CMR and the design documents approved as part of the building permit and that I or my designee: c 1. Have reviewed,for conformance to this code and the design concept,shop drawings,samples and other submittals by the contractor in accordance with the requirements of the construction documents. 2. Have performed the duties for registered design professionals in 780 CMR Chapter 17,as applicable. 3. Have been present at intervals appropriate to the stage of construction to become generally familiar with the progress and quality of the work and to determine if the work was performed in a manner consistent with the construction documents and this code. Nothing in this document relieves the contractor of its responsibility regarding the provisions of 780 CMR 107. Enter in the space to the right a"wet"or electronic signature and seal: .. 73 A ct" 0w Of MP5" Phone number:401.435.3S32 Email:joanneo@nemd.com - Building Official Use Only Building Ofciat Name: Permit No.: Date: Version 06_11 2013 �ONeIYq Commonwealth of Massachusetts 3 - Citv of Salem U01 120 Washington3rd Floor Salem,MA01970(978)745-9595x5641 Return card to Building Division for certificate of Occupancy Permit No. B.16_493 PERMIT TO BUILD FEEE PAPAID: $19,800.00 DATE ISSUED: 5/17/2016 This certifies that SALEM 4 PROPERTIES REALTY TRUST has permission to erect, alter, or demolish.a building -. 207.HIGHLAND AVENUE Map/Lot: 130002-0 '1 asfollows: Repair/Replace RENOVATION TO EXISTING BUILDING; FIT OUT FOR DIALYSIS CENTER. EXTERIOR : NEW ENTRANCE, WINDOWS, ADD AN AWNING; STRUCTURAL SUPPORT FOR NEW ROOFTOPS INTERIOR:IRTV'S, FLOORING, LEVELING SLAB FOR SHEET VINYL, VCT & CARPET, PAINT & MILLWORK THROUGHOUT—- Contractor Name: KEVIN LAHAH DBA: Timberline Construction t Contractor License No: CS-091591 5/17/2016 Building Official Date This permit shall be deemed abandoned and invalid unless the work authorized by this permit is commenced within six months after issuance.The Building Official - may grant one or more extensions not to exceed six months each upon written request. All work authorized by this permit shall conform to the approved application and the approved construction documents for which tl is.permit has been granted. All construction,alterations and changes of use of any building and structures shall be in compliance with the local zoning by-laws and codes. r This permit shall be displayed in a location clearly visible from access street or road and shall be maintained open for public inspection for the entire duration of the work until the completion of the same. __-_/ ( The Certificate of Occupancy will not be issued until all applicable signatures by the Building and Fire Officials are provided on this permit. HIC#: 'Persons contracting with unregistered contractors do not have access to the guaranty fund-(as set forth in MGL c.1 42A). Restrictions: Building plans are to be available on site. All Permit Cards are the property of the PROPERTY OWNER. Commonwealth of Massachusetts ` City of Salem 120 Washington St,3rd Floor Salem,MA 01970(978)745-9595x5641 Return card to Building Division for Certificate of Occupancy IM Structure CITY OF SALEM BUILDING PERMIT Excavation PERMIT TO BE POSTED IN THE WINDOW ` Footing INSPECTION RECORD Foundation Framing Mechanical Insulation INSPECTION: BY DATE Chimney/Smoke Chamber Final Q l� 5 1 30 _ _ /YA/9 /�O l7 0'*AL Plumbing/Gas �/a��l � L��Er✓c� p� > �.,(/(r� l® � ��/� �� Rough:Plumbing Rough:Gad„ Final/ t! Electric I Pay Servicer � / Rough' /y Final /a/C` //t/ J //JG'� (/%✓/�Cj/� G/2Pv.�] G�«ci �! G/t—L e Depart ent Y-21 uND� 65`12.9 U u0 /=adz �G;✓d:�/3 a odd GG��Oz,C� G . rFinal a r // 2 Health Department 7 Preliminary J,ra ✓�./� J, /�j /T ? /-T3 Ike lv � /a � /1 S— /-2 C /-z7 /.2 � i � � � r— ",al /'/! /yi /Y d° . !�+� �iZN All/M�1 �✓G/� l/Z{rt..s— y- vi= .Q''�/�Q' 4741 i i pro olrgt2 CITY OF SALEM9 MASSACHUSETTS PUBLIC PROPERTY DEPARTMENT 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR } C SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 EW�P' TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 EXT. 380 KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL FAX: 978-740-9846 MAYOR Attorney Stefano D'Agostino 101 Tremont Street, Suite 712 Boston, Massachusetts 02108 February 28, 2012 Re: Public Records Request- 207 Highland Avenue Dear Attorney D'Agostino: Enclosed please find the records you requested in regards to the special permit application for a methodone treatment clinic on Highland Avenue. I certify that these are true copies of Zoning Board of Appeals records. The files included are: Meeting agendas frau the 9/15/10, 11/17/10 and 12/15/10 Zoning Board of Appeals meetings Meeting minutes from the 9/15/10, 11/17/16 and 12/15/10 Zoning Board of Appeals meetings Compact disc recordings of the 11/17/10 and 12/15/10 Zoning Board of Appeals meetings (please note that these are data CD's and can be listened to on a computer only) A copy of the entire file folder, including all application materials Unfortunately, one of the audio files you requested is damaged (the September 15, 2010 ZBA meeting). We were unable to open or copy this file. Therefore, that audio session has not been included and you will be reimbursed $5.00. This will be sent to you as soon as the check can be processed. If you have any questions or concerns regarding the enclosed material please do not hesitate to contact me'. Yours truly, l �igcziIX7--r- Thomas J. St. Pierre Director of Inspectional Services `Y,�connr.+.aa CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS fT BOARD OF APPEAL - a 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR y1N _ / a SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 MmE ooP FAX: 978-740-9846 KIMBERLEY ORISCOLL MAYOR ME E TING NOTICE BOARD OF APPEALS MEETING September 15, 2010 - 6:30 P.M. YD FLOOR, ROOM 313 - 120 WASHINGTON STREET SALEM,NIA �( G' Ro Z1\1 SLea1, z 1.11r AGENDA 1. Approval of Malates - August 13, 2010 meeting. 2. CO11[in led from JLay 21, 2010: Public hearing: Petition of DILULLO ASSOC., INC. seelwng a Variance to reduce the number of required parking spaces on the property located at 142 CANAL STREET[I]. 3. Continued from JLdy21, 2010: Public hearing: Petition of ROBERT JACKSON seeking a Special Permit to demolish ud reconstruct a noticonfom ung single or two familystucture for the propenylocated at 30 COLUMBUS AVENUE [R-1]. 1. Public hearing: Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee),seek ng a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) on the property located at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE [R-2]. 5. Old/New Business 6. Adjournment This no, lee poste .1 o CR Hall a 1,13In, ,��1.:,��. on Y �<, �<I' 9 �-Qc10 at %: 04 A 11 0 ZtJA A V1 of 41,0 1,, City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals Minutes of Meeting Wednesday, September 15, 2010 A meeting of the Salem Zoning Board of Appeals ("Salem ZBA") was held on Wednesday, September 15, 2010 in the third floor conference room at 120 Washington Street, Salem, Massachusetts at 6:30 p.m. Chose present were: Robin Stein (Chair), Becky Curran, Beth Debski, Rick Dionne, and Jimmy Tsitsinos (alternate). Absent were: Annie Harris and Bonnie Belair (alternate) Also present were: Tom Devine, Interim Staff Planner, and Thomas St. Pierre, Building Commissioner. .Stein opens 11ye meeting at 6:30 p.m. Approval of minutes Stein notes that not enough members present at the 8/18 meeting are present tonight and suggests reviewing the minutes at the nest meeting. Stein moves to review the 8/18/10 meeting minutes at the 10/20/10 meeting, seconded by Dionne and approved unanimously. Continued from July 21, 2010: Public hearing: Petition of DILULLO ASSOC., INC. seeking a Variance to reduce the number of required parking spaces on the property located at 142 CANAL STREET [I]. Stein recuses herself from this item and Debski presides. Devine notes that Dan Dilullo has submitted a letter requesting to continue. Dionne moves to continue the public hearing at the 10/20/10 meeting, seconded by'I'sitsinos and approved unanimously. Continued from July 21, 2010: Public hearing: Petition of ROBERT JACKSON seeking a Special Permit to demolish and reconstruct a nonconforming single or two family structure for the property located at 30 COLUMBUS AVENUE [R-1]. Stein recuses herself from this item and Debski presides. Mr.Jackson requests to continue due to having only 4 voting members. Curran moves to continue the public hearing at the 10/20/10 meeting, seconded by Dionne and approved unanimously. Public hearing: Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee), seeking a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) on the property located at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE [R-2]. 1 John Keilty, 40 Lowell St.,Peabody, attorney for the applicant, said they are petitioning to use 207 Highland Ave. as a medical clinic—specifically as a methadone center. This would provide counseling, dosing, and related services. If approved, the center will lease 7,000 sq. ft. of the former Hillcrest building. The organization operates 12 centers in other communities. The treatment is for recovering addicts, not active users. We require periodic urine samples. We expect to eventually treat 250-300 clients in Salem. Right now we treat 80-100 Salem residents at our Peabody location. We expect to have 25 full and part time employees. Dosing hours would be between 5:30 and 10 am. We looked at seven other sites, and we understand the concerns regard ng the Canal St. site. Dionne asks how long a client receives methadone. Robert Potter,Vice President for Development for the applicant, said there is detox for six months to wean a client off and an individual may need a maintenance program. The average user with five years experience with heroin tries other treatments first and will need 12 to 18 months of methadone treatment. Dionne asks if they use a twelve step program. Potter said they offer space to Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous. We are specialized, so we refer to other facilities for such things as AIDS, mental health, and alcohol. Keilty said we have had community advisory boards to meet and see what we are doing right and wrong. Curran asks about nighttime security. Potter says the facility is alarmed per DEA regulations, and the dispensary is secured. Nurses have panic buttons and remote controls and the lot would be locked. Curran asks if the clients are impaired by the methadone. Potter says that on the right dose, there is no impairment. We evaluate a client throughout treatment and work with him or her to make realistic goals. Curran asks about traffic volume. Potter says highest volume is in the morning. We have a high tech system to get people in and out quickly. Curran asks where the closest residential neighbors are and Potter identifies the locations on the plan. Stein notes that the clinic would only use part of the building. Fred Massa, broker for the property, said they are looking at other commercial uses and many are by right in the B-2 zone. Steins asks how much parking there will be. Massa says 31 spaces. Stein notes that there would be 25 employees. Massa notes that the employees would be full and part time. Debski asks if 250 clients would come in during the morning. Keitlty says the would not all come at the same time. And not all will come in single cars. Keilty says there are 44 spaces for 300 clients in Peabody. Debsi asked if the proximity to the school is an issue with many students walking and bus stops nearby. I"think this would generate more traffic than other uses. Do you share space with other tenants in other locations? Potter says they do. We are well managed and owned by doctors. Stein opens rp the issue to tbepublic. Patricia Liberti, 3 Lions Lane, said she is concerned about traffic congestion. I am concerned that the Cloister Condominiums were never notified. This is too close to residential neighbors and the school. A member of the public said she is concerned with security. Where do clients go if they are kicked out of the building? Potter says they only spend a small part of their time focused on difficult clients. If someone uses, we work harder with them. Police would be involved if someone is violent. 2 'ferry McCabe, manager of New England Veterinary Clinic, 204 Highland Ave., asks if people who are not enrolled in the clinic show up, where will they go? Will they come to our veterinary pharmacy? Potter says it is a police issue. Chuck Puleo, 5 Freeman Rd., says people live nearby and he is concerned about the early morning hours. We don't allow retail to operate that early. The service entrance was never designed to be an entrance. This is too close to the schools. A member of the audience says this is not an appropriate location near residences and schools. There is no need for this since there are clinics nearby. This is for profit and the success rate is not high. You are essentially creating long term addicts. Arthur Theophilopoulos, 24 Valley St., says he is opposed to the clinic. My family uses the nearby bus stops and I am concerned about addicts taking buses and walking through the area. My business will lose customers. I think the existing locations are enough. Phillip Blaskovich, 8 Admirals Lane, said methadone is not a cure. It is just trading one addiction for another. They have high rates of hepatitis and HTV. This is too close to the school. John Sullivan, 205 Highland Ave., asked if 250 clients is the minimum needed to make money. Potter said they don't share that information. Chuck Barton, 26 Marlborough Rd., said the risks outweigh the benefits when you concentrate so many addicts in a residential area near a school. And it doesn't matter whether it is for profit. A member of the public expresses concern about homes and businesses without security. Burglaries could be a problem. Potter says the goal is to keep people motivated to fight their addition. If they don't work at it, they are terminated from the program. Marsha Gerber, 24 Bengal Lane, said the petitioner is overly optimistic. What about those who fail treatment? They can break into homes. Potter said many clients will come from Salem. It is better to have them in treatment then out using. Erin Higgins, Lafayette St., asks about people who take methadone home. Potter said that under federal piles, only those who are clean for 6 months can take it home. It can be very motivating, but it you fail, you are back to square one. Laura Lanes, 13 First St., said she is opposed to the proposal. In my experience, addicts are dishonest. Todd Siegal, 28 Brittania Circle, submitted police logs for the Chelsea and Lynn locations. The Chelsea clinic had 66 calls and the Lynn clinic, not affiliated with the applicant, had 180. Judges do not allow anyone in drug court to use methadone. A member of the audience asked if people will hang out at the facility before it opens. Potter said his patients don't do that because the monitors don't allow it. It would be a violation of our policy. 3 Stephen Burrell, 10 Britannia Circle, asked if the crash gates cover all entrances and noted that people can't cross the divided highway to the bus stop. This is a bad area for traffic alone. Massa said the crash gates will be internal. Jack Carroll, 205 Highland Ave., asked what the payment policy is for methadone. Potter said we bill through insurance, and if it is private pay, we bill monthly. Mark Burns, 15 Aurora Lane, said he is concerned about traffic. People brings friends and family to the Lowell location. Sandy McMahan, 2 Madeline Ave., said people have covered most of my concerns. I worry that you can't cap it at 250. You could end up with many more than that. This is a poor location. Theresa Nadeau, 7 Gallows Circle, said her kids travel this area before school. I know users. They take half of their methadone and sell the other half and get others addicted. A member of the audience said she is concerned about addicts going into area businesses. I don't see the benefit of this. I am concerned that some patients are homeless and will loiter in the neighborhood. You could put this in Shetland Park. A member of the audience said he is concerned about all the bad proposals that can damage our neighborhood. I am concerned about having addicts in the community. I agree with the comments of others. This is not appropriate for the location. How was the previous application rejected? Keilty said it was withdrawn. The audience member said he is concerned about loss of investment in the community. Mica Deutz, 4 First St., asked what the noise level will be on weekends. I am concerned about the condition of the street, pedestrian safety, and illegal u-turns. Do your clinics increase crime. Potter said it has been studied, and they lead to a decrease in crime. A member of the audience said he is a recovering addict and thinks the petitioner does not know what he is talking about. There is no need for methadone when getting clean. You dose up, not down, and people become a slave to the clinic. They can't go on vacation. I am concerned about crime at this location. Rachel Dorhety, 7 Fust St., said she is concerned about the kids in the housing authority property. What about children going to the clinic with a parent? Potter said it is encouraged and there is a play area for them. Dorhety said an AUL restricts child-related uses there. Massa said the AUL has to be remediated. Paul Prevey, Ward 6 Councilor, said he is opposed. This is not something we want for Salem as we try to market the city. A member of the audience said he is aware of a big problem. We are losing more people to drugs than wars. I am aware addicts are working on recovery. I do know there are positive results from methadone. 4 Amy Albert, 8 Lightening Lane, said she is opposed due to the traffic and addicts it would bring to the neighborhood. I am worried about this in conjunction with other proposals for the neighborhood. Todd Mover, 8 Pope St, said he is concerned about property values. Scott Morgan, 7 Savona St., said it is outrageous to propose this near the schools. I am concerned about property values and I think the applicant will profit from taking our value away. This will bring in over 200 zombies each day and I demand that the board oppose it. Sean O'Brien, 10 Mooney Rd., said he is concerned about addicts driving. Will they be clean the first day they drive there? lam concerned about the school children.. How much revenue will the city make? A member of the audience said he is concerned that that facility would have room to grow. I am opposed. I see the benefits for the realtor, the lawyer, and the for-profit business, but none for the city. This is in an entrance corridor and a tax-generating business would be preferable. Jean Pelletier,Ward 3 Councilor, said the owners do take MassHealth, despite their claim that they take no state or federal funds. I am concerned about the patients who would never come off the methadone. Up to 300 children live nearby. This is a bad location and it will overburden police. Joan Lovely, Councilor at Large, said she is opposed. I have received many emails and talked to many people. We need a different location. They could expand at the Cummings Center. Meghan Romanovitz, 90 Ocean Ave., said the police are strained with the growing college. Traffic is an issue at the Peabody location. Why not go to Cummings Center? I don't think we have the need. I know addicts who won't touch methadone. Julie Pelletier, 39 Hazel St., asked where people go between dosing and counseling. I am concerned about them milling around. Potter said they might go to work and come back. Addicts sill have lives and I don't see them waiting around 2 hours. A member of the audience asked if the urine samples are supervised. Potter said there is a heat sensitive tab on the container and there are other ways to tell if people are using. The audience member said she is concerned about addicts moving into the city. It is wrong to broaden the tax base with this kind of business. A member of the audience said she supports clinics as a nurse, but not necessarily as a parent and a homeowner. What guarantee do you have for the safety of the neighborhood? Potter said once a patient is offsite, he has no control. The patients have their own lives and children and want to get on with their fives. I am more concerned about active users. The audience member asked if the applicant will put up money for more police or to fix the road. Martin Miseandino, 13 First St., said the proposal degrades Hillcrest's 25 years. I am concerned with traffic. The petitioner has been held responsible for a crash victim and failing to monitor a patient. I am concerned about losing interest from homebuyers. This doesn't serve community needs, it has 5 traffic problems,will destroy neighborhood character, and will harm the local economy. If you approve this, you can limit the use. We will ask they no methadone is distributed at the location. Teassie Riley Goggin, 9 Wisteria St., said she is perplexed that Boston's prestigious medical community couldn't run a methadone clinic well. Potter said Boston now has well run clinics. Goggin asked what makes success. Potter said it would mean operating within a community without problems. Luis Gukowski, 29 Mooney Rd., asked what the rest of the building will be. Massa said it is unknown and there are no specific plans. A member of the audience asked what stops the clinic from expanding if the rest of the space can't be rented. Stein said they would be limited to the space in their plan. Steven Pinto, Councilor at Large, said that in hearing the public response, he is adamantly opposed to the clinic. John Ronan, Ward 5 Councilor, said he authored the zoning amendment to require this kind of clinic to have a public hearing,giving neighbors a chance to be heard. The man who spoke in favor of this is a lobbyist. Everyone else is in opposition. I saw a house near the previously proposed site sitting on the market while there were rumors of the clinic coming. The clinic can't do background checks on its patients. Methadone is more addictive than heroin and requires treatment every day, tethering addicts to the clinic. The situation with the Peabody clinic is bad, with people sleeping in the doorways of nearby businesses. Addicts will move into the neighborhood. The neighboring apartments are already hard to rent. The board only needs one legitimate reason to reject the special permit, and there are many reasons. Some states don't even allow these clouts. We are already served by nearby clinics. The council is opposed. A member of the audience said he is totally opposed. It is bad for the neighborhood and businesses. The board should visit other methadone clinics. Stan Poirier, 8 Cottage St., said the neighborhood is in strong opposition and I recommend denial. Pelletier asked Mr. Potter to restate his position with the company. Potter said he is Vice President of Development and Communications, in charge of finding new sites. Pelletier asked if Potter thinks this is the right site. Potter said yes. Sean O'Brien said you can't sell drugs within 1000 of a school. Stein said she doesn't think that would apply. Michelle Knox, 23 Cavendish St., said this is not an isolated location. It is near a school. Addicts can drive to appointments like the rest of us do. The police will be strained with violent criminals and pedophiles in my neighborhood. If it is safe,why do nurses need panic buttons? Please reject the petition. Jerry Ryan,Ward 4 Councilor, said he is completely opposed. I haven't heard from anyone in support it. This will ruin the neighborhood's quality of life. There is no good place to put it. T'lie council appointed you and you can stop this. 6 Stein said I have many question I want to ask. We will not vote on this tonight. It is routine practice to give applicants a chance to address issues raised at a first meeting and we treat all applicants equally. Tsitsinos said all of his concerns have been stated. Debski said traffic impact is a big issue. We need a traffic study. Stein said we would want a traffic study to show the higher possible number of clients. Debski said parking looks like it is inadequate. I would like comments from the police, fire, and school departments, and I would like to see the plan to address the AUL.; I am concerned about the building's other future tenants and their parking needs. Stein said we haven't heard much about the actual community need and we need to balance interests here. We should consider a cap on the number of patients. Curran said that for a special permit,we have to make sure costs don't outweigh benefits. I am not convinced you can meet that threshold. I am concerned about traffic flow and whether this addresses a community need, as well as housing values. If you address these concerns,we can figure this out. Stein said she doubts we can come to enough of a balance to approve this. Keilty asked to continue to the November meeting so they can hire a traffic consultant. Dionne moves to continue the public hearing at the 11/17/10 meeting, seconded by Stein and approved unanimously. Debski moves to adjourn, seconded by Stein and approved unanimously. Meeting adjourned at 9:05 p.m.. Respectfully Submitted, Tom Devine Interim Staff Planner In addition to the applications before the Board and related materials, the following documents are referenced in these minutes and are available at the Department of Planning and Community Development. Police log for Chelsea methadone clinic Police log for Lynn methadone'clinic Minutes approved by the Board of Appeals 10/20/10. 7 ecu ure.�a CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS pr` �Tm BOARD OF APPEAL 7 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR SALEM. MASSACHUSETTS O 1970 '•pYB�� TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 ( FAX: 978-740-9846 KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL MAYOR N t� MEETING NOTICE r}� BOARD OF APPEALS MEETING November 17, 2010- 6:30 P.M. NATHANIEL BOITDITCH SCFIOOL CAFETORIUdYl 79 IULLSON STREET, SALEM MA un (NOT 120 WASHINGTON STREET AS USUAL) � Robin Stein,Chair AGENDA 1. Approval of Mirnaes - October 20, 2010 meeting 2. PUblic hearing: Petition of FIRST CHURCH IN SALEM, seeking a Variance from minimum rear yard depth ;and a Special Perm t to extend a nonconforming sticture,and requesting a finding that no additional off-street parkiiig is required, to constnrct an addition on the property located at 316 ESSEX ST.,Salem,MA[R-2]. I 3. Public herring:Petition of MADELINE JACKSON appealing a decision of the building inspector regardutg the properties located at 3 BEDFORD ST, and 76 PIERPONT ST.,Salem, NIA[R-1]. {. Request of NORTH RIVER, LLC for extension of a Variance previously issued for the property located at 23 GOODHUE ST. [NRCC]. 5. Continuation of Public hearing: Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALT I I CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee),seeking a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) on the property located at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE [R-2]. 6. Old/New Business 7. Adjoununent p+k yip �fAil N. City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals Minutes of Meeting Wednesday, November 17, 2010 A meeting of the Salem Zoning Board of Appeals ("Salem ZBA") was held on Wednesday, November 17, 2010 in the third floor conference room at 120 Washington Street, Salem, Massachusetts at 6:30 p.m. Those present were: Beth Debski (chairing the meeting), Becky Curran, Rick Dionne, and Jimmy Tsitsinos (alternate). Those absent were: Robin Stein (chair),Annie Harris and Bonnie Belair (alternate). Also present were: Danielle McKnight, Staff Planner, and Thomas St. Pierre, Director of Inspectional Services. Debski opens the meeting at 6:40. Debski announces that due to an illness, Chair Robin Stein is unable to attend this evening. She explains that when only four members of the Board are present, the Board always gives the applicant the option to continue the petition until the next meeting, and that Attorney Keilty had indicated he wished to continue to December 15, 2010. Several residents ask why the petition could not simply go ahead; Debski and Dionne reiterate that the applicant has the right to go before a full Board if they choose. Several questions were answered regarding scheduling the December meeting. The Board confirmed that in the case of a snow emergency, the hearing would be postponed. Curran moves to continue the matter to December 15, 2010, seconded by Dionne and approved 4-0. Public hearing: Petition of FIRST CHURCH IN SALEM, seeking a Variance from minimum rear yard depth and a Special Permit to extend a nonconforming structure, and requesting a finding that no additional off-street parking is required, to construct an addition on the property located at 316 ESSEX ST., Salem, MA [R-21. Attorney Bill Quinn presents the petition. He explains the church is not currently handicap accessible, and they wish to upgrade the facility so that the church and day care can be more easily used. He says the building is unusually large and sits at the back of the site. In order not to disrupt the meeting hall facility, they want to put the addition in the rear. He explains the addition would be 30-40 feet away from any residences. Attorney Quinn introduces the project's architect, Patrick Guthrie, who indicates the site plan (tided "Fust Church Salem, 316 Essex St., Salem,NIA," prepared by Menders,Torrey & Spencer, Inc., 123 North Washington St., Boston, MA, dated August 15, 2009, available at in the Salem Building Department and hereby incorporated as part of these minutes). He explains that this addition will improve daily access and provide universal access to the church. He shows the location of the addition in relation to the parking area at the rear and the existing garden, explaining that entry could be from either side; people will be able to enter at grade and take the elevator up instead of having to take the stairs. St. Pierre observes that this is a well-prepared plan, saying the applicant has managed to create handicap accessibility while preserving the "flavor" of the historic building. Guthrie notes that they had previously received a determination of no adverse impact from the Historical Commission. He 1 shows the floor plans, roof plans and elevations and explains that the material used will be stucco, the same as the 1927 addition, noting this will give them a chance to clean up the stucco on the parish house. Debski opera the issue arp for public comment. Mary Richards, 6 Federal Court,is a member of the church. She asks about the location and dimensions of the addition in relation to the garden and asks if the building has a nonconforming setback. Attorney Quinn answers that the setback isn't nonconforming in that direction—it's 32 feet, and the legal requirement is 30. He clarifies that the rear setback they have asked for relief from is being modified from 10.2 to 8.7 feet. Tbere erre no fiaYher comments;Debski closer the public comment portion of the heating. Attorney Quinn summarizes the hardship argument he set forth in his application: due to the shape of the lot and the topography of the land, strict enforcement of zoning would create a financial hardship. St. Pierre notes that the project does not increase any of the indoor space that would increase the parking requirements. Board members note that the project is appropriate and consistent with zoning. Dionne moves to grant the petition with seven (7) standard conditions, and also to affirm that no additional parking is needed on the property due to the addition, seconded by Curran and approved 4-0 (Curran, Dionne, Debski and Tsitsinos in favor, none opposed). Public hearing: Petition of MADELINE JACKSON appealing a decision of the building inspector regarding the properties located at 3 BEDFORD ST. and 76 PIERPONT ST., Salem, MA [R-11. Ms.Jackson and her daughter,Laura Ridley, present the appeal. Ms. Ridley says Mr. Denis, the neighbor at 3 Bedford Street, put in a driveway on Ms.Jackson's property line, and that St. Pierre had sent a letter to him saying the driveway was illegal. A lawyer was then hired, and Ms.Jackson received a letter saying the driveway was legal after all. Ms. Ridley says Mr. Denis parks his truck right by Ms.Jackson's bedroom window and the diesel fumes enter the house. She has been told the driveway must be five feet from the property line. She says Mr. Denis has been kind enough to not park his truck there most of the time. However, she says Mr. Denis has not gotten a variance for the driveway, so she doesn't want it used at all. She says she feels having this driveway so close to the property devalues the house and asks what the distance must be by law. Debski notes that this is on a corner lot. The Board examines photos provided by Ms. Ridley (on file in the Building Department and hereby incorporated as part of these minutes) showing the driveway's proximity to 76 Pierpont St. St. Pierre explains that when this issue first came up, he looked at the off street parking regulations and inadvertently used those applicable to entrance corridors, which require a 5-foot buffer. However, in this district, only a 2-foot buffer is required. He says there is nothing in the zoning ordinance that would prohibit this driveway. 2 Attorney Michael McMahon, 583 Chestnut St., Lynn, representing Mr. Denis, hands the Board a packet of information (on file in the Building Department and hereby incorporated as part of these minutes), containing photos of the driveway, a police report filed about an incident involving Ms. Jackson and Mr. Denis, and a petition from neighbors in support of Mr. Denis's driveway. He says the driveway and house have been the subject of multiple inspections and meet all requirements with regard to this Board. He states that Mr. Denis has a gas-powered vehicle, not a diesel one. He says the reason he has used that driveway in the recent past is because he had 3 significant lumbar back fusions—he would park the truck there when bringing in groceries, etc. and then usually move it. He says the driveway is not on Ms.Jackson's property and shows a photograph of a stake from a survey that was done. He says Mr. Denis has attempted to make peace by grading and landscaping portions of his property. Ms. Ridley comments that it's fine to have 11 signatures from neighbors in support of Mr. Denis, but they aren't the ones living with the driveway. Mr. Denis, 3 Bedford St., says the driveway used to be gravel, but then was hottopped. The city put in curbstones in 1980. Ms. Ridley refers to a previous ZBA petition, 12 Clark St.,which required a variance to have a second driveway, and asks why the same does not apply to this property. St. Pierre explains that in the recodified zoning, driveway width is limited. However, he says he must use the old zoning ordinance to evaluate this property, since it was in effect at the time the driveway was put in. The old zoning did not limit driveway width. Debski comments that this is a legal driveway that needs no relief from the Board of Appeals. Curran moves to uphold the Building Inspector's decision, seconded by Dionne and approved 4-0 (Debski, Dionne, Curran and Tsitsinos in favor, none opposed). The Building Inspector's decision stands and the request for appeal is denied. Curran moves to adjourn the meeting, seconded by Debski and approved 4-0. Debski adjourns the meeting at 7:42 p.m. Respectfully submitted, Danielle McKnight, Staff Planner Minutes approved by the Board of Appeals 12/15/10 Decisions November 24, 2010 Decision City of Salem Board of Appeals 3 Petition of MADELINE JACKSON requesting a reversal of Director of Inspectional Services' decision to allow a second driveway on the property located at 3 BEDFORD STREET, abutting 76 PIERPONT STREET, Salem, MA (R-1 Zoning District). A public hearing on the above petition was opened on November 17, 2010 pursuant to Massachusetts General Law Ch. 40A, Sec. 11. The following Zoning Board of Appeals members were present: Elizabeth Debski (chairing the meeting), Rebecca Curran, Richard Dionne, and James Tsitsinos (alternate). The petitioner, Madeline Jackson, sought a reversal of the Director of Inspectional Services' finding that a second driveway on the abutting property, located at 3 Bedford Street, is legal. The Board of Appeals, after careful consideration of the evidence presented at the public hearing, and after thorough review of the Petition submitted, makes the following findings of fact: 1. Madeline Jackson is the owner of 76 Pierpont Street, which abuts 3 Bedford Street, owned by James Denis. 2. Ms.Jackson and her daughter, Laura Ridley, presented the appeal at the hearing. 3. 3 Bedford Street is within the Residential One-Family Zoning District. 4. 3 Bedford Street is not located within the Entrance Corridor Overlay District. 5. There are two driveways on 3 Bedford Street, one of which is located more than two feet, but less than five feet, from Ms.Jackson's property line, and is the subject of the appeal. 6. The petitioner is requesting reversal of a finding made by the Director of Inspectional Services that the second driveway conforms with the City of Salem Zoning Ordinances and may remain without any relief from the Board of Appeals. 7. At the hearing, Mr. Denis' attorney, Michael E. McMahon, spoke in opposition to the request to appeal. He presented a petition with ten signatures in support of allowing the driveway to remain. 8. At the hearing, the Director of Inspectional Services stated that driveways must be within five feet of an abutting property line within the Entrance Corridor Overlay District; however, outside the Entrance Corridor, the required distance from abutting properties is two feet, and Mr. Denis' driveway meets this requirement. On the basis of the above findings of fact, including all evidence presented at the public hearing, including, but not limited to, the Petition the Zoning Board of Appeals concludes as follows: 1. The driveway located at 3 Bedford Street nearest to 76 Picrpont Street is legal and may remain. The decision of the Director of Inspectional Services regarding this property is upheld. 4 In consideration of the above, the Salem Board of Appeals voted, four (4) in favor (Curran, Dionne, Tsitsinos, and Debski) and none (0) opposed, to uphold the Director of Inspectional Services' decision allowing the driveway on 3 Bedford Street to remain. Elizabeth Debski Salem Zoning Board of Appeals A COPY Of THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CITY CLERK Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of the Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A, and shall be filed within 20 days of filing of this decision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to the Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A, Section 11, the Variance or Special Permit granted herein shall not take effect until a copy of the decision bearing the certificate of the City clerk that 20 days have elapsed and no appeal has been filed, or that, if such appeal has been filed, that it has been dismissed or denied and is recorded in the South Essex Registry of Deeds and indexed under the name of the owner of record or is recorded and noted on the owner's Certificate of Title. November 24, 2010 Decision City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals Public hearing: Petition of FIRST CHURCH IN SALEM, seeking a Variance from minimum rear yard depth and a Special Permit to extend a nonconforming structure, and requesting a finding that no additional off-street parking is required, to construct an addition on the property located at 316 ESSEX STREET, Salem, MA [R-21. A public hearing on the above Petition was opened on November 17, 2010, pursuant to Mass General Law Ch. 40A, § 11. The hearing was closed on November 17, 2010 with the following Zoning Board of Appeals members present: Elizabeth Debski (chairing the meeting) Richard Dionne, Rebecca Curran, and James Tsitsinos (alternate). Petitioner seeks Variances pursuant to Section 4.1.1, a Special Permit pursuant to Section 3.3.3, and a determination that no additional parking is needed pursuant to Section 5.1.3, of the City of Salem Zoning Ordinances. Statements of fact: 1. Attorney William Quinn represented the petitioner at the hearing. 5 t 2. In a petition dated September 23, 2010, petitioner requested a Variance and Special Permit to construct a 24' x 24' addition at the rear of the First Church in Salem, in order to make the facility handicap accessible and increase interior storage space. 3. The building on 316 Essex Street houses the First Church in Salem's religious meeting house and associated religious and educational facilities, offices and programs, including a day care program on the she second floor of the Church,which currently is not handicap accessible. 4. At the November 17, 2010 hearing, the Inspectional Services Director stated that the project did not increase any of the indoor space that would increase the parking requirements. 5. At the November 17, 2010 hearing, several residents and members of the Church's congregation attended in support of the project. No members of the public spoke in opposition to the project. The Board of Appeal, after careful consideration of the evidence presented at the public hearing, and after thorough review of the plans and petition submitted, makes the following findings: 1. Special conditions and circumstances exist affecting the parcel or building,which do not generally affect other land or buildings in the same district, as the lot is oddly shaped and the topography is such that the proposed improvements would be cost prohibitive if the zoning code were strictly enforced. 2. Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent or purpose of the zoning ordinance, as the proposal improves accessibility to the facility and does not create a need for additional parking. 3. The applicant may vary the terms of the Residential Two-Family Zoning District to allow for the addition to the First Church of Salem as proposed. 4. In permitting such change, the Board of Appeals requires certain appropriate conditions and safeguards as noted below. On the basis of the above findings of fact and all evidence presented at the public hearing including, but not limited to, the Plans, Documents and testimony, the Zoning Board of Appeals concludes: 1. A Variance from rear yard setback is granted to allow for the addition to the church facility, as shown on the submitted plans. 2. A Special Permit is granted to expand the currently nonconforming church building, as shown on the submitted plans. 3. The project does not trigger the need for additional parking on the site. In consideration of the above, the Salem Hoard of Appeals voted, four (4) in favor (Curran, Debski, Dionne and Tsitsmos) and none (0) opposed, to grant petitioner's requests for a Variance, a Special 6 Permit and determination that no additional parking is required, subject to the following terms, conditions, and safeguards: 1. Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, ordinances, codes and regulations. 2. All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. 3. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. 4. Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. 5. Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. 6. A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained. 7. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including, but not limited to the Planning Board. Elizabeth Debski, Salem Board of Appeals A COPY OF THIS DECISION HAS BEEN FILED WITH THE PLANNING BOARD AND THE CTTY CLERK Appeal from this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of the Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A, and shall be filed within 20 days of filing of this decision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to the Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 40A, Section 11, the Variance or Special Permit granted herein shall not take effect until a copy of the decision bearing the certificate of the City Clerk has been filed with the Essex South Registry of Deeds. 7 NDI a� Ct, 4doT CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEAL ,! 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR r f� C SALEM. MASSACHUSETTS 01970 D� TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 KIMBLRLEY DRISCOLL FAX: 978-740-9846 MAYOR ggppt nn MEETING N(Y1'ICE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS MEETING December 15, 2010- 6:30 P.M. City Hall Annex, 120 Washington Street)Room 313 Ord Floor) Robin Chair y� 3 CORRECTED AGENDA 1. Approval Of Minutes - October 20, 2010 ;nd November 17,2010 meeting 2, Puhlic hearing'Petition Of JOHN NyrfIARFF requesting Variance, frcnn uti sown Ion area, lot ridth/[rvntagq and front yard setbacks, to subdivide the property located at 434 LAFAYETTE STREET into six(6) single-family house lots (R-1 zoning district). Proposed access s from RAY MOND C'OeVTINUE TO rAAi Yt9 20 it TERRACE. APPLICANT 9EQUES S TO 3. Request of NORTH RIVER, LLC for extension of a Variance previously issued for the propertylocated at 28 GOODHUE ST.[NRCC Zoning District]. 4. Continuation of Public hearing; Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee),seeking a Special Permit for the operation of a med cal clinic (methadone center) on the propertylocated at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE [B-2 Zoning District]. 5. Public (tearing; Petition of EXPRESS AUTO BODY, INC, seeking a Special Permit to change one noncnnformingluse D another n order to convert the existing building located at 162.168 BOSTON ST to an auto body shop (I Zot ing to another 6. Public hearing;Petition of JOSH GILLIS,seeking a Variance from rear yard setback, nonconforming structttre, in order to enclose and roof over a 12'x 1IT' porch on the secondpstotryof he exist ng two- family home on the Property located at 7 UNION ST. (R-2 Zoning District). 7. Public hearing: Petition of WILLIAM WHARFF, seeking a Special Pernrit to change One nonconfomting use to another, and a Variance from lot area per dwelling unit,in order to convert a three-unit bed and breakfast to three individual dwelling units, ori the Property located at 51.53 WASHINGTON SQUARE NORTH (R-2 Zoning District). J' LJICV�'C\V bUSincss dj `) e. . outlunenC t r11 In n exe ;�I ,.�1 1'A _. City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals APPROVED Minutes of Meeting Wednesday, December 15, 2010 A meeting of the Salem Zoning Board of Appeals ("Salem ZBA") was held on Wednesday, December 15, 2010 in the third floor conference room at 120 Washington Street, Salem, Massachusetts at 6:30 p.m. Those present were: Robin Stein (chair), Beth Debski, Becky Curran, Rick Dionne, Bonnie Belair (alternate) and Jimmy Tsitsinos (alternate). Those absent were: Annie Harris. Also present were: Danielle McKnight, Staff Planner, and Thomas St. Pierre, Director of Inspectional Services. Stein opens the meeting at 6:38 p.m. Review of October 20, 2010 minutes: Dionne moves to approve, seconded by Stein and approved 5-0 (Dionne, Debski, Curran, Belair and Stein in favor, none opposed). Review of November 17, 2010 minutes: Dionne moves to approve, seconded by Curran and approved 4-0 (Dionne, Curran, Debski and Tsitsinos in favor, none opposed). Public hearing: Petition of JOHN WHARFF requesting Variances from minimum lot area, lot width/frontage, and front yard setbacks, to subdivide the property located at 434 LAFAYETTE STREET into six (6) single-family house lots (R-1 zoning district). Proposed access is from RAYMOND TERRACE. Attorney Scott Grover requests to continue the petition to the January meeting. Debski moves to continue the petition to January 19, 2011, seconded by Stein and approved 5-0 (Curran, Dionne, Stein, Debski, Belair in favor, none opposed). Request of NORTH RIVER, LLC for extension of a Variance previously issued for the property located at 28 GOODHUE ST. [NRCCI. Goodhue St. —Correnti requests to extend the previously issued variances, explaining the financing for the project has been difficult, but they wish to go ahead with the project. Stein says she has no problem with approving, but asks when the Board first approved. Correnti says 2006. Stein says she thinks the law has changed recently and thinks they may not need approval to extend the Variance. Correnti says he thinks it's still needed. Dionne moves to approve extending the Variance for six months; seconded by Stein and approved 5-0 (Curran, Dionne, Stein, Debski, Belair in favor, none opposed) Continuation of Public hearing: Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee), seeking a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) on the property located at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE [B-2 Zoning District]. Attorney John Keilty, 40 Lowell St. Peabody presents the petition. He explains they are seeking a Special Permit to operate a medical clinic, specifically a methadone clinic. He says I i they have provided information about the clinic and how it operates, identified how many operations are run by his clients, and given testament to how the dosage takes place. Since the first hearing, they have submitted the AUL, soil tests, stats from state dept. of public health showing the need for addiction services in Salem, a traffic study, and information about the clinic. He refers to a tenant neighboring another center run by his client; he says this letter attests to the fact that there have been no incidents or threats to the neighbors. He also refers to the memo submitted by Chief Paul Tucker of the Salem Police attesting to the need for such a clinic and that there was no undue burden on the police departments of other communities where his client's clinics are operated, nor was there an increase in crime. He stated that Chief Tucker noted that if the facility were cited, the police would work to keep the area safe. Arty Keilty referred to the traffic study done by Ken Cram, which reports that the traffic in the area—studied during the clinic's peak period and the current peak period on Highland Ave. —also covered crash data. He said Highland Ave. seems to be becoming safer, exhibiting fewer crashes than in previous years. He said the study also examines similar facilities in neighboring cities. They applied these data using worst case scenarios—and came to the conclusion that there would be minimal impact. He said they have elected not to limit access to the parking lot. In response to concerns that clients may arrive very early and might queue up early, a crash gate was proposed—but now they are proposing its elimination, to enable anyone coming at early hours to have complete access to the parking lot. Queueing then should not be an issue on Highland Ave. He says their co- tenant, a church, has no problem with sharing the parking lot since their peak hours are different. He says this is a facility of 7300 SF, with 300 clients expected. There would be 110 additional spaces—a total 144 parking spaces available at all hours during the day. He says this would have previously been allowed by right before a zoning amendment in Sept., which was passed in response to his client's previous attempt to locate on Canal St. He believes this was passed in good faith, and the council intended to give the city the chance to review such projects, and not discriminate against methadone facilities. He says he believes they have shown the community need for the services, and its lack of negative impact on the project. He says if not granted the Special Permit, they will appeal the denial. He says this has happened in other communities, costing cities and towns money, and says the Board must weigh the evidence presented. Debski asks if the church would take the remainder of the space in the building? Arty Keilty says they probably would not use the entire rest of the space, but the broker is close to landing the church as tenant. Curran: traffic study talks about 300 patients per day; you expect this? Can it be capped? Keilty says it could be capped if the Board wanted to pursue that, and it would take about a year to get to 300 clients. He says if things go as planned, they could ask for an amendment. Curran: would there be a policy about no sleeping in parking lot? Keilty says yes, though there have been no reports of people sleeping in parking lots in other communities. Stein opens the issue up for public comment Miguel Andreattola, 9 Red Jacket Lane, says his children go to the nearby schools, and he is concerned about this location, since the children walk by the site on their way. Fie believes this is a public safety issue. 2 Maria Andreattola, 9 Red jacket Lane, says the location is not appropriate because of proximity to schools. Sandra McMahon, 2 Madeline Ave., says that capping the clients sounds unrealistic and a housing complex is nearby. If clients are waiting to be counseled, they are waiting around in Dunkin Donuts and other local places; they will be lingering, especially if they arrive on the bus and need to wait around to be seen. She does think this will be a public safety issue. Dorothy Hayes, Essex St., opposes because she feels it will be a public safety issue. She says they won't serve people who have fallen off the wagon, so where will those people go? She knows people who have these facilities near them and says discarded needles are a problem. She is also concerned about traffic during peak commuting hours. Also, she says clients will be drowsy and then will drive away. Marty Miseranduno, 13 First St., said it was reported in paper that 17 or 18 people from Salem would be using clinic —where would the rest come from? Stein: currently, Salem people are using the Peabody facility. She does expect people would come from other communities. Keilty says the focus is serving Salem citizens, but they will not be exclusive. His statistics show there are as many as over a thousand who are being treated in opiate facilities from zip code 01970. Miseranduno says the applicant has had two incidents, one resulting in a death, from getting methadone and then driving. He says in Peabody on Rt. 1, a costumer drove away after getting treatment; he is concerned that the people running the business are not doing a good job controlling this situation. He says this places an undue burden on police. Keitly says the clients are allowed to drive away. Miseranduno says he is concerned about traffic. Hedy Thibaut, 15 First St. is concerned about noise and drowsiness about methadone. She asks what the business incentive is to get these people off methadone,given that the business is for profit? She says she is concerned about the neighborhood, including children. Veronica Ehrlich, 29 First SI'., opposes the project, saying it will lower property values and will be a detriment to the neighborhood. She says she and other taxpayers will move if this is approved. She also asks about trash and dirt that will be generated by the clinic. Todd Siegel, 28 Brittania Circle, says he is a criminal defense attorney. Fie says at the first meeting, he handed the Board call for service logs from Chelsea and Lynn Police depts.. — he says police were called over 100 times in each city. He says Keilty's assertion that there will be no strain on community services is incorrect. He says there was recently a death in Revere; the driver was on his way to a methadone clinic and killed a woman. He cites another accident caused by a methadone clinic client in Peabody. Fie also opposes the project on the grounds that a for-profit business has no incentive to get people off methadone. 3 Tom Furey, Councillor at Large, 77 Linden St., says the process of bringing in a clinic has not been open. He says no one knew about the original proposal on Canal St. He says the ZBA has to now put up with the residual effect of not having a committee and public involvement in siting the facility. He says if there is such a need for this clinic, this should not have been dealt with in this fashion. He refers to the schools and residential neighborhoods nearby. Says he hopes the board denies. Amy Alpert, 8 Lightning Lane—president of her condo association— 108 units — representing group says they are opposed. She says the Chelsea location Keilty referred to is in a remote area, nota residential neighborhood. She also opposes the project on the grounds that the clinic is for-profit. Judy Cohen — 15 Flying Cloud Lane—president of the Sanctuary Association, says her organization and their neighbors are opposed on the grounds of safety concerns. Pat Liberti, 3 Lions Lane, says it is a dangerous area, especially for school children. She says the clinic's operation hours are the same as school hours. She says leaving the site is very difficult, and it goes straight into a residential area. She's a nurse and thinks methadone treatment does not really treat addiction. She opposes the site proposed. Lou Zikowski—opposes because of location of schools. Rick Johnson, 13 River St., opposes because of public safety hazards. He says they're being asked to put a great deal of trust in clinic's operators and clients. He says if this is a fee for service operation, we can assume they are looking to promote dispensing higher dosages. He also says clients driving after dosing is a concern. Paulette Puleo, 5 Freeman Rd. —opposes because of proximity to schools and danger to children. She says there is a bus stop at the end of her street and she's concerned clients would use it frequently. She understands there's a need but this is the wrong site. Councillor Steven Pinto —55 Columbus Ave., opposes because the business is for profit;he doesn't deny that people need help,but feels impacts to quality of fife and impacts to neighborhoods would be too great. Todd Siegal says the courts do not send people for this treatment. David Pelletier, 12 Crombie St. — He opposes because the clinic is for-profit and will want as many clients as possible. Theresa Nadeau— 7 Gallows Circle—She says she and her husband own a number of properties in the area and they are strongly opposed. Arther Theoplilopoulus, 24 Valley St., says he is concerned about children, since clients may be in an altered state and pose a threat. He also doesn't thunk this makes economic sense and it's not needed in Salem— there are other chnics who can take these patients. 4 Megan Romanovitz, 90 Ocean Ave. says at the last meeting it was discussed that clients may be able to take the drugs with them and fill prescriptions— the drugs could be sold and this poses a threat to children. She says there already is a methadone clinic in Salem on Mason St. run by HES. She says this would be the second one and this doesn't make sense. Michelle Knox, 32 Cavendish Circle, is opposed. She says criminal background checks aren't run on clients, so perhaps dangerous people would be attending the clinic. She is concerned about proximity to schools. She says in Sept. —if someone shows without appointment or too high to be treated, and they would be escorted from property, but the client's operator does not take responsibility for these individuals. She also says there are discrepancies in information about the hours of operation. She says people typically do not seek treatment in their own community, so how will people come in from other communities, and how will they be taken home? She is also concerned about traffic. Rachel Doherty, 70 First St, is opposed— this is very close to her home. Pequot Highlands apartments has 250 units, and the back part of the site is about a tenth of a mile; it's in very close walking distance from the apartments. Also very close to Hawthorn apartments,which are even closer. She says the proposal isn't appropriate for a residential area. She is also concerned about traffic. Tony Germain, 15 Ravenna,is opposed. He says it will destroy neighborhood. He says the city should maintain its tourist and historic character Jim Rush, Ocean Ave., is opposed. He says the number of residents needing the clinic has changed. He refers to a Salem Gazette article this year—Mr. Potter quoted as saying it was a good business decision to come to Salem. He says this is about money, not helping people. He also says Potter's quote that they will be in Salem eventually flies in the face of the citizens here who are opposed. He says the city councilors, opposing this project, represent the people of Salem. However, he says the applicant does not care about this. He says the applicant is threatening litigation. He says this is a quality of fife issue. He says no one has been corning to these meetings who is in favor of the project. He says Salem does not need a methadone clinic. Jim Hacker, 4 Mayflower Lane, opposes the project and echoes comments said. He says adverse effects of proposal must not outweigh benefits; he says this project would not benefit neighborhoods. He says he lives in Mariner Village,with 108 units, and says this amounts to about a quarter million dollars a year in taxes. He says if they lose even ten percent of value, that would be a great loss to the city. He asks the Board to consider then when approving the special permit, there are standards that the permit granted shouldn't be more detrimental than what's in place. Ricki Hacker, 4 Mayflower Lane, also opposes. She says public transportation to the clinic— bus runs one way— must cross Highaldn Ave. to get return bus. She is concerned about children in the area. Councillor Paul Prevey,Ward G, opposes clinic. He points out in addition to negative impacts, looking at whole picture of Salem, what makes the city unique— this is a very small city to have a clinic. He feels the impact to Salem would be tremendous—not like some 5 other cities that could more easily absorb such a facility. Things are often crammed in; only 8 square miles. Always a challenge with business corning into city and not negatively impacting residents;we must look at what makes Salem livable and growable. He says Salem doesn't have a large business base;we do rely on businesses for tax base—business will look at things that will impact new potential businesses — this will detract from Salem's appeal for new businesses. Many improvements have been made in the city; this would have a negative impact instead. Councillor John Ronan—Ward 5 —opposes clinic. He says councilors disagree about many issues, but all love Salem and want to do what's best for the city. But all agree on this issue. He says this is not something Salem wants. He refers to standards articulated in the zoning ordinance in its introduction. He points particularly to promotion of appropriate land use in the city. He says council passed an ordinance allowing a clinic in Salem if they could demonstrate that grounds of Special Permit would be met. The proposed use's benefits must outweigh impacts to city and neighborhood. However, the benefit is not to the applicant's private benefit—it's supposed to be for the city. He says the city gets very little benefit— less than one quarter of one percent of the population of Salem needs this facility. He says many clinics are state sponsored,but this one is not. He also points out that if a resident of Salem needed treatment, they could go to the two clinics in Lynn, others in neighboring cities. He says no place in Salem is further than a 10 minute drive to one of these other facilities. He says he met with Mr. Potter during last proposal. He says he is concerned about take-home dosages. He looked up regulations with regard to this—he says these are carefully regulated by statute. He reads from Federal statute. He says these are allowed under certain conditions and at certain time intervals. He says in later years of treatment, patients need to only report once or twice a month to center. He says adverse effects to neighborhoods clearly outweigh saving a small number of Salem residents the trouble of driving to another facility. Jerry Ryan, Ward 4 Councillor—he says he has not heard anyone in favor. He has heard from many constituents who are opposed. He objects to the siting of a for-profit clinic. He says their ultimate goal is to make money. He says the Board should not let the threat of litigation guide their decision, but instead should put themselves in the shoes of the neighbors who are dealing with this proposal. Stan Poirier, 8 Cottage St., opposes. He says this should not be considered. He strongly urges the Board to vote against. He,says if the applicant chooses to sue, his tax dollars couldn't be better spent opposing. Councillor Arthur Sargent urges Board to consider quality of life in Salem neighborhoods. He says the more he hears about this, the more he believes it should be in a hospital setting. There should be a staff present in case of a medical problem. Also,in case of anv problems there would be a security staff present. if someone tried to leave in the wrong condition, it would be easier to prevent drivers. Urges Board to turn this down, even knowing there could be litigation— there would be burden on applicant to appeal,rather than neighbors having to pay for an appeal if approved. Councillor Bob McCarthy says the public has spoken loud and clear in opposition. Concurs with Mr. Hacker and his colleagues — reminds Board of standards needed to issue Special 6 Permit. He says- needs are already being met in clinics elsewhere. He says he has not heard that the other clinics are at capacity. He says if other clinics were turning away Salem residents and the need was not being met, he might feel differently. He says the clinic hasn't demonstrated that need isn't being fulfilled elsewhere. He says if it came to the point where Salem residents weren't being served, let them come back—but right now the need wasn't demonstrated. He feels it would be a detriment to the neighborhood. Councillor Jean Pelletier asks Keilty expresses concerns about the hours of operation and also comments that it would be unsafe for children walking in the early morning in this area. He is concerned about cars leaving site and heading toward First St. He refers to Attorney Keilty's threat about appealing and says the burden of proof should be on the applicant. He says the applicant was trying to intimidate Board. He says Bob Norton, president of Salem Hospital, spoke with the councilor; he had a clinic at hospital, says it got out of hand. He says police were going there daily. He says the hospital ended their clinic because they didn't see a benefit to running it. He says he hopes the Board will deny the SP for the greater good of the neighborhood and the city. Stein closes the public comment portion of the hearing. Stein reviews letters received for record: there is one from Women's Life imaging center. Co tenants with a clinic nm by applicant. The letter says there have been no issues. Stein says not all letters will be read in entirety but are on file. She notes they are available for review. Curran is concerned that until dose is right, a user has the potential to be drowsy. Since they can't park there,would they be in the neighborhood? Keflty says they had not stated they couldn't park. The crash gate no longer proposed. If drowsy, the client would be kept inside facility. Similar to giving blood, people are kept until they are steady on feet. Stein asks questions about the traffic study. She says she noticed identified peak hours 7:30 to 8:30 on Highland. If there are 300 clients, how many will come before 7:30? If 5-8 is peak dispensing time, how many are coming between 7:30 and 8:30? Keihy: 174 trips during peak operating hour in Peabody and Chelsea. Stein: when you say during peak hours, is it 174 in that one hour? Ken Cram of Land Strategies,which performed the study, says they gathered several weeks' worth of data from CCRC, data showed their peak was 5:30 to 6:30— roughly —about a quarter of total trips occurred. Assuming a worst case scenario, they matched up peak hours. Stein asks for clarification various points in the traffic study which Cram provides. Stein asks about a provision in the lease that others couldn't use parking spaces. Keilty: our 33 spaces complies with zoning, so other 111 spaces beyond the crash gate are available to remaining space in building. Stein says that one of factors is traffic and parking she doesn't think 33 spaces are adequate. Trips are very concentrated because of type of service. Her concern is if something else goes in rest of site— how would we weigh that? Debski is also concerned about that. 7 Stein says one of her issues is that 33 is even remotely adequate. What would safeguard be, if the board approved, that more spaces would be dedicated? Keilty says he can say with assurance they would have access to all spaces. Stein asks if that's a risk the landlord is willing to run? Fred Massa, broker says the parking requirements already exist on site if building were full. Church would occupy 12,000 SF. Debski: are there other prospective tenants? Massa: yes, prospective commercial, and no larger parking needs than already exist. Keilty: the clinic's significant use time is over when other commercial uses would open. Keilty says at the Sept. hearing, they stated that they were treating 100 from Salem in Peabody, then suggested they couldn't guarantee they'd all come back to Salem for treatment because of issues of travel to work, etc., and people not wanting to be treated in their own community. He assumed 20 or so people wouldn't come back to Salem. He says they identified at least 600+ Salem people in need of services. He says it's true that as Ronan stated, they have choices, there is another facility in Salem. Many people were surprised to find out there's one on Mason—this gets to our issue that these facilities don't cause the kinds of problems people speculate about. Debski: what is your incentive to get clients off methadone? How long are people in treatment? Potter: average patient we see is late 20s, blue collar, has been addicted to Oxy or heroin. If using 5 years, about 12-18 months. Sometimes people stay in treatment longer, but this is a personal and not a business decision. Can detoxify at any time, their goal is to get people drug free. Drug treatment is long term and people do sometimes relapse, this is not a quick fix. Keilty: incentive is to be successful. Stein asks about take-home prescription. What is your policy? Potter: federal policy allows to close one day a week, but this isn't good medicine. Fed regs are more lenient—we need to see someone min 6 months. To be eligible, need to keep all appointments, safe home environment, clean urine, no legal issues, etc. One bottle is given in child safe bottle. Must bring bottle back or goes back to 6 month track. This is an incentive to do well and not have to attend clinic every day. Much more restrictive at CSAC than on Fed level. Stein: peak hour is 26% of your business. Potter says there is one nurse's line to confirm people are going to work. Stein—you stop dispensing at 8? Potter—it depends —it's a slow operation to start. As population grows, latest is 11 but these facilities are larger. Stein: getting sense of traffic — most if not all is done by 8 a.m.? Potter—yes. Debski is very concerned about proximity to schools. She notes the school dept. did not comment—we don't have their input. Do you have other facilities located near schools? Potter—yes, one is from B&D properties —owns 10,000 SF building. 5,000 SF next door is girls dance studio. A day care center then came in. Owner's daughter has a consignment shop there. Over 10 years there has never been an issue. Keilty: near public schools? Potter—yes, in Chelsea. 8 Debski— these are supervised settings—here you have kids walking along First in an isolated neighborhood and then down Highland. Schools start at 7. Potter—all facilities have play areas because mothers come with children. Stein: my issue isn't kids being around—it's kids walking to school with the amount of traffic. I don't doubt that drug use is a problem and we need to offer a variety of treatment opportunities —need to be fair to people who need services. Concern I have with this location is the traffic numbers. You are taking first st. from 20 to 77 trips. Adding 57 in an hour. At 300 people— this would almost triple traffic on First St. There are a lot of kids that walk there— I'm concerned about the traffic and the walking, not the proximity of methadone. Unfortunate that your peak hour coincides with school starting. This is near three schools. Curran doesn't think the benefit outweighs the negative impact. It's a strange site —zoning does allow as a SP use—but the topography is such that it's isolated within the residential area as opposed to business area— there are parking and traffic issues. She is concerned about the schools and timing, and parking issues related to everyone coming at once. I don't support this and don't support that benefit outweighs. A small percentage of the community needs it, and the impact on the neighborhood is very great. Debski: it disrupts the neighborhood character. The impacts outweigh benefits. This is a prime location on Highland—if there were retail uses from that these neighbors could benefit from, that would be great. Stein didn't know that HES was operating a site on Mason. Potter—perhaps a private doctor is dispensing,but there is no actual clinic. Tsistinos: what about the hospital? Potter- hospital didn't express interest in having clinic there. Curran: we also have a confect between residential uses and proposed use. Stein gives Keilty an opportunity to respond; says they have clarified everything they've been asked to. Curran moves to grant the petition, seconded by Dionne, and unanimously denied (Debski, Stein, Dionne, Curran, and Tsitsinos opposed, none in favor). Documents & Exhibits: • Application, dated 8/26/11 • AUL and soil test information, dated 3/3/96 • Traffic Impact and Access Study, dated 11/'12/'10, prepared by Land Strategies, LLC • Data from state dept. of public health submitted by Community Substance Abuse Centers, dated 11/10/11 • information packet about die proposed clinic. • memo submitted by Chief Paul Tucker, dated 11/8/10 9 Public hearing: Petition of EXPRESS AUTO BODY, INC, seeking a Special Permit to change one nonconforming use to another in order to convert the existing building located at 162-168 BOSTON ST to an auto body shop (I Zoning District). Attorney Peter Martino, 986 Saratoga St., East Boston, representing Express Auto Body Inc. presents the petition. He says the past use of the property was a mill works building, most recently used to manufacture windows. Mr. Chavez intends to run an autobody shop. Currently a warehouse. 6-8 cars expected. Repair of auto body parts and bumpers is primary part of business. No room on property for cars to be parked. Debski clarifies this is the old Jeffers Lumber. Stein asks about ventilation; Martino says there is a good ventilation system. All work would be done inside, must meet all codes for fire, fumes, etc. No exterior work. Cars would not be parked on street or at exterior of building. Carlos Farias says there will be four employees. Curran: are there two principal uses on one lot? Board asks for clarification on which building this is and how it's accessed. i Stein: how many uses on site now? St. Pierre: there's a third building. Mill in back, but off to left of lot toward Boston St, in driveway there's a steel building, 10 yrs old,in addition. The problem is the owner is putting a lot of uses on the site. We need to determine if there's enough parking. But he hasn't defined parking. Access, adequacy of parking are issues with special Permit. Cars can't come in because of elevation, have to go onto a common right of way and into back of mill building to come in and out. Martino: mill would have had same issue of traffic. As far as we're concerned, we won't have people parking—if cars would be repaired, they would come into the shop. Curran: wouldn't there be a lot of juggling of cars that happens outside? Martino explains that cars would be entering the building. Could not park on street. Stein: under new recodification, what does this fall under? St. Pierre: motor vehicle general and auto body. He also notes that with this kind of use, he is concerned about parking situation—if this were the only use, no problem, but need clarification of other uses and parking on site. Board members also ask for a site plan. Are there two or three principal uses? St. Pierre: for your client's sake, if he's renting from Mr. Cucurull, he needs to have these defined. 1 Martino: we will get this defined and then submit a site plan. Stein opens the public comment potion of the bearing. Bob Brophy, 165 Boston St. asks questions about parking—where is employee parking? Where would Uhaul and Hertz employees park? Says there will be more congestion, also says they want to change the nonconforming use of the property. St. Pierre says this is actually 164. St . Pierre then clarifies this is refers to 164 map 16, lot 0190, the lumber yard property only. Stein closes public comment portion Applicant requests to continue to January 19, 2011. Curran moves to continue, seconded by Dionne and approved 5-0 (Curran, Dionne, Belair,Debski and Stein in favor, none opposed). Documents & Exhibitions ■ Application dated 11/18/10 and accompanying undated drawing • Assessor's plate of 164-168 Boston St. Public hearing: Petition of JOSH GILLIS, seeking a Variance from teat yard setback, and a Special Permit to extend a nonconforming structure, in order to enclose and roof over a 12'x 11'4" porch on the second story of the existing two-family home on the property located at 7 UNION ST. 7 Union St. —Marcus Springer, 319 A St., representing Josh Gillis, who is also present. He says they are renovating and expanding the property at 7 Union St. Says current house was built around 1885, addition exists to south of house, not sure when it was made. Does not meet current setback requirements. Want to enclose the second floor porch to create a family room off kitchen. Easiest way is to go up on current foundation and walls. Says they have provided the existing plans of house, as well as elevations. Stein: just closing existing porch? Yes. Curran: in historic district? Springer—no. Curran asks for clarification on window details; Springer explains. Stein opens public comment portion ofpetition;no one bete to comment, she closes it. Stein says this is minimal relief. Board asks about roofline —Springer explains they are following line of existing addition. Curran moves to approve the petition with 7 standard conditions: 1 I. Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, ordinances, codes and regulations. 2. All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. 3. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. 4. Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. 5. Exterior of the building is to comply with the submitted plan. G. A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained. 7. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including, but not limited to, the Planning Board. seconded by Dionne and approved 5-0 (Belair, Debski, Stein, Dionne and Curran in favor, none opposed). Documents & Exhibitions: • Application dated 11/19/10 • Plans dated 11/18/10 Public hearing: Petition of WILLIAM WHARFF, seeking a Special Permit to change one nonconforming use to another, and a Variance from lot area per dwelling unit, in order to convert a three-unit bed and breakfast to three individual dwelling units, on the property located at 51-53 WASHINGTON SQUARE NORTH (R-2 Zoning District). Attorney Scott Grover presents the petition. St. Pierre says a Special Permit for Bed and Breakfast has been in place since 1999. Attorney Grover says they want to convert back to the residential use it was prior to 1999. Says the building is very large — the unit is 5000 SF, which is much larger than most units in the area. He says the current zoning would not even allow one unit based on lot area per dwelling unit required. He says parking requirements are met. He says access from Pleasant St. Ave is easy, and five of spaces are allocated to unit 2, which is the inn. For the 3 units proposed, they have enough spaces already. He speaks about the benefit to the neighborhood of having a commercial use converted to a residential one. Curran: would these be 2 bedroom units? 1 Grover— 3 floors, one unit per floor,Wharff- unit size would be about 1300 SF each. Similar space to what we did at the Elk's —similar finishes, etc. No exterior work, stairs. Stein: we're always happy to see a residential use reestablished in a residential neighborhood. Stein opens the issue up forpublic comment Barbara Swartz, 47 Washington Square north, says she fully supports, saying it would be good for the neighborhood Richard Wise, has next door unit, supports, saying the change from inn to residential owners would improve neighborhood. Stein closes public comment portion Stein: the benefit to neighborhood is great— there is a hardship because of the size of building versus size of lot. Debski moves to grant petition with 8 standard conditions: 1. Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, ordinances, codes and regulations. 2. All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. 3. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. 4. Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. 5. Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. 6. A Certificate of Occupancy is to be obtained. 7. Petitioner shall obtain street numbering from the City of Salem Assessor's Office and shall display said number so as to be visible from the street. 8. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including, but not limited to the Planning Board. Mr. Wharff explains why exterior finishes cannot match current finishes exactly; Board says this is fine, they just have to be in harmony, seconded by stein and approved 5-0 (Belair, Dionne, Stein, Curran and Debski in favor, none opposed). Documents & Exhibitions: Application dated 10/27/10 1 ■ Plan dated 1/21/99 • Undated photographs Debski moves to adjourn, seconded by Dionne, all in favor. Meeting adjourns at 10 pm. Respectfully submitted, Danielle McKnight, Staff Planner Approved by the Board of Appeals 2/16/11 l b APPENDLX Traffic Count Data Seasonal Adjustment Worksheets Crash Data Worksheets Traffic Growth Data Trip Generation Worksheets Capacity Analysis Worksheets Traffic Count Data i PRECISION ,ghland Avenue(Route 107) D A T A .vest of 1st Street INDUSTRIES,ILC City, Slate: Salem, MA ro.eo.im 6e W,MA 01503 Client: LandSlrate iesl K. Cram W01.SOS 411 AI Ne Fox 3t!8545.1114 102358 A Volume 9 d.o„ende:w 4odiim< Site Code: 10-038KC $tart L9 pyg � Conibina0 2U Cct-10 TimeAM. P_M.____.... ._._.�A_M—._� _.._P.M__. AM P_M_.__.._.— ._ Wed _- 3 224 44 252 75 476 12:00 12:15 22 198 36 234 58 432 12:30 19 206 34 288 53 494 12:45 '12 84 240 868 19 133 254 1028 31 217 494 1896 01:00 18 195 19 263 37 458 01:15 15 207 24 247 39 454 01:30 5 192 14 238 19 430 01:45 8 46 191 785 14 71 261 1009 22 117 452 1794 02:00 10 218 6 242 16 •160 02:15 8 211 7 262 15 473 02:30 10 225 4 271 14 496 02:45 5 33 234 888 8 25 230 1005 13 58 464 1893 03:00 2 193 8 247 10 440 03:15 9 217 6 271 15 488 03:30 2 219 6 283 8 502 03:45 6 19 219 848 9 29 291 1092 15 48 510 1940 04:00 6 217 12 290 18 507 04:15 11 264 9 316 20 580 04:30 9 205 22 289 31 494 04:45 17 43 193 879 15 58 324 1219 32 101 517 2098 05:00 18 199 19 312 37 511 05:15 22 209 31 296 53 505 05:30 34 229 39 311 73 540 05:45 69 143 228 865 52 141 292 1211 121 284 520 2076 06:00 65 192 54 251 119 443 06:15 79 189 88 226 167 415 06:30 128 208 115 231 243 439 06:45 182 454 227 816 157 414 208 916 339 868 435 1732 07:00 170 192 189 185 359 377 07:15 196 172 258 173 454 3.15 07:30 196 171 212 142 408 313 07:45 7.37 799 124 659 226 885 142 642 463 1684 266 1301 0800 214 124 228 170 442 294 08:15 250 135 264 152 514 287 08:30 203 114 166 106 369 220 08:45 205 872 126 499 228 886 129 557 433 1758 255 1056 09:00 197 119 219 119 X116 238 09:15 169 85 190 131 359 216 09:30 165 94 179 78 344 172 09:45 212 743 73 371 191 779 116 444 403 1522 189 815 10:00 189 73 207 98 396 171 10:15 I80 58 216 72 396 130 10:30 190 56 195 63 335 119 10:45 179 738 74 261 201 819 57 290 380 1557 131 551 11:00 180 59 233 67 413 126 11:15 132 46 248 65 430 111 1030 164 37 239 53 403 90 11:45 226 _ 752_ _ 45 187 . -_210 930 _ 52 237 436 _ 1._682 97 424 .. _-. . .._.-.-......-_ .__.._ _..._ ... - - Total ---1726 7926 - 5170 9850- —9896 17576-- Percent 37.8°/ 45.1% 52.296 54.9% Day Total 12652 14820 27472 Peak 07:45 03:30 07:30 04:t5 07:30 04:15 Vol. 904 919 9110 1243 1327 2102 P.H.F. 0.904 0.870 0.881 0.959 0.889 0.906 Paye I I .oghlandAvenue(Route 107) PRECISION ,vest of 1 st Street D A T A City, State:Salem, MA INDusrRles,uC Client: LandStrategies/K. Cram orr,e zog481,3901 99 F'1.505 5'1134 r.n.,n dau,cn�eu,erp.elk�o,� 102358 A Volume Site Code: 10-038KC Time Hine 1M P.M. h.M, P.M 1.}.f. —_.__ 1'2:00 ..._._ 18 209 g�---_ _ z43 ae—_ n 2 .._--T"" .. . 12:15 30 193 25 239 55 432 12:30 12 211 22 241 34 452 1245 18 88 221 834 26 133 222 945 44 221 443 1779 01:00 15 199 19 239 34 438 01:15 18 203 24 231 42 434 01:30 '16 217 20 269 36 486 01:45 7 56 201 820 9 72 210 949 16 128 411 1769 02:00 8 234 6 254 14 488 02:15 6 204 9 272 15 476 02:30 3 203 7 283 10 486 02:45 12 29 236 877 7 29 228 1037 19 58 464 1914 03;00 5 202 11 231 16 433 03:15 9 217 13 280 22 497 03:30 4 208 8 300 12 508 03:45 6 24 215 842 5 37 299 1110 11 61 514 1952 04:00 4 203 9 304 13 507 04:15 14 174 10 304 24 478 04:30 10 174 15 273 25 447 04:45 29 57 239 790 23 57 305 1186 52 114 544 1976 05:00 25 187 27 318 52 505 05:15 29 227 32 272 61 499 05:30 39 244 49 309 88 553 05:45 49 142 216 874 .57 165 256 1155 106 307 472 2029 06:00 67 207 66 301 133 508 06:15 86 197 72 256 158 453 06;30 105 221 126 228 231 449 06:45 1.55 413 228 853 143 407 230 '1015 298 820 458 1868 07.00 179 '180 207 218 386 398 07:15 197 177 • 254 181 •151 358 07:30 193 182 228 168 421 350 07:45 242 811 170 709 229 918 151 718 471 1729 321 1.127 08:00 224 1.53 225 157 449 310 08:15 203 131 257 163 460 294 08:30 216 150 204 125 420 275 08:45 211 854 114 548 219 905 101 546 430 1759 215 1094 09:00 190 104 216 109 406 213 09:15 204 89 201 116 405 205 09;30 188 100 214 103 402 203 09:45 204 786 100 393 189 820 88 416 393 1606 188 809 10:00 161 86 209 96 370 182 10;15 191 66 218 73 409 1:39 10:30 177 61 219 64 396 125 10:45 193 722 89 302 208 854 47 280 -101 1576 136 582 11:00 218 80 231 74 449 154 11:15 199 62 214 74 413 136 11:30 182 39 254 77 436 116 1145 185 784 34 215 220 919 56 281 405 1703 90 496 ..._...-- Total. -.-.4766 -__._..._._'-.-8057 5316 9638 ----'-10082 _.__ - _----176— Percent - 176Percent 47.3% 45.5% 52.7% 54.5"/ Day Total 12823 14954 27777 Peak 07;15 - 0.1:45 07:30 03:30 07:30 04:45 Vol. 885 897 939 1207 1801 2101 P.H.F. 0.914 0.919 0.913 0.993 0.956 0.950 Page 2 -t Street PRECISION south of Highland Avenue(Route 107) D A T A City, State: Salem,MA INOUSTRIES,LLCa,b.n„z01 n,•nm„Hn mw, Client: LandSlrategies/K. Cram 1��Ln•:inn Je 1.1494 F 51!0545.I>N .1.....ronin«om 102358 8 Volume Site Code: 10-038KC 9 - Comb ned 1.0-Oct-10 ------- -- rime _ A..L N25._..__.__ A.3 N.$ A.5 P.M. 12:00 _.'_ ,Z__—_ ....�_ coed 12:15 I —3p--- 30 1 14 2 .14 12:30 I 33 0 5 1 38 12:45 1 5 22 110 3 7 3 27 4 12 25 137 01:00 1 18 3 7 4 25 OI:15 2 25 1 3 3 28 01:30 I 25 0 7 1 32 01:45 0 .t 27 95 0 4 6 23 0 8 33 118 02:00 0 18 1 9 1 27 02:15 0 27 1 0 I 27 02:30 0 37 3 5 3 42 0245 0 0 45 127 0 5 5 19 0 5 50 146 03:00 1 30 0 5 1 35 03:15 0 37 0 5 0 42 03:30 1 47 0 7 1 54 WAS 0 2 30 144 0 0 16 33 0 2 l6 177 04:00 0 42 0 12 0 54 04:15 0 38 0 13 0 51 04:30 1 37 0 13 1 50 04:45 2 3 34 151 0 0 13 51 2 3 47 202 05:00 2 34 0 7 2 41 05:15 2 50 1 14 3 64 05:30 6 .J5 0 9 6 54 05:45 8 10 .11 170 1 2 12 12 9 20 53 212 06:00 10 26 5 16 15 42. 06:15 19 27 1 7 20 06:30 29 26 2 12 34 06:46 32 00 16 95 1 0 31 38 07:00 50 29 1 6 41 33 99 22 136 07:15 42. 21 1 7 51 36 4 113 25 07:30 57 15 2 9 59 07:45 64 213 22 87 3 7 9 29 67 ').20 31 31 118 08:00 35 13 2 7 37 20 08:15 44 13 7 1.1 51 27 08:30 48 10 2 9. 50 19 08:45 26 155 19 55 4 15 10 40 32 170 29 05 09:00 23 10 a 2 31 12 09:15 27 7 3 5 30 12 09:30 27 10 2 5 29 15 09:45 24 Jul II 38 l 17 2 14 28 118 13 52 10:00 23 :1 2 7 25 11 IONS 24 9 6 3 30 12 10:30 13 3 2 2 20 10 t0:-15 26 91 0 27 3 13 3 1529 104 9 42 11:00 23 d .1 0 27 f 0 II:IS '_'0 0 2 1. 22 10 11:30 25 4 2 3 27 7 11:45 .+4 102 2 t0 4 1� 7 20 38 114 9 36 ...-.�._.._ __....... ... _._. 91 354 875 D169 .__ Percent 39.6% 75.9% 101% 21.1 Day Total 1899 445 2344 Peak 07:00 05:00 08:;5 03:45 07:00 05:15 Vol. 213 170 21 54 220 213 P.H.F. 0.832 0.850 0.656 0.844 0.821 0.832 Page I —t Street PRECISION , hland Avenue Route 107 A T A south of Highland ( � INDUSiRIES,LLC City,State: Salem,MA ro 3.v301 Ee,11 ,M9 01503 Client: l.andSlrategies/K. Cram OR12eWA4813o99 Fax Wil 5451234 102358 B Volume Site Code: 10-038KC Slnrt NB SB Cobined 21OcF10 m rim1 A.b1. P.M._ A.M. P,M, A)A, .._�2t00 _... ....._ 2 _............ .... ....25 ._ ...._.-.._...._ fi .._.____ _.._.....7..._.--._._. .A 32 12:15 1 25 1 4 2 29 12:30 1 25 1 4 2 29 12:45 1 5 24 99 0 6 5 20 1 13 29 119 01:00 2 24 6 6 8 30 01:15 2 20 0 3 2 23 01:30 2 22 1 8 3 30 01:45 1 7 32 98 0 7 4 21 1 14 36 119 02:00 0 23 0 6 0 29 02:15 0 41 1 9 1 50 02:30 0 44 0 3 0 47 02:45 0 0 39 147 1 2 4 22 1 2 43 169 03:00 0 29 2 3 2 32 03:15 0 39 0 5 0 44 03:30 0 40 0 10 0 50 03:45 1 1 42 150 0 2 9 27 1 3 .51 177 04:00 2 25 0 8 2 33 04:15 0 41 1 10 1 51 04:30 1 45 1 14 2 59 04:45 2 5 35 146 1 3 10 42 3 8 45 188 05:00 3 40 0 10 3 50 05:15 2 35 0 11 2 46 05:30 6 32 2 12 8 44 05:45 4 15 32 139 0 2 10 43 4 17 42 182 O6:00 9 24 1 8 10 32 06:15 23 31 0 16 23 47 06:30 28 37 0 10 28 47 06:45 36 96 '19 111 1 2 8 42 37 98 27 153 OT.00 47 30 U 9 47 39 07:15 35 24 3 10 38 34 07:30 48 16 3 18 51 34 07:45 59 189 20 90 6 12 8 45 65 201 28 135 08:00 44 16 2 5 46 21 08:15 51 11 5 9 56 20 08:30 35 12 2 8 37 20 HAS 32 162 5 44 7 16 6 28 39 178 11 72 09:00 20 4 4 5 24 9 09:15 26 14 3 6 29 20 09:30 17 '15 4 4 21 19 09:45 28 91 6 39 2 13 7 22 30 104 13 61 10:00 23 9 6 8 29 17 10:15 34 5 8 7 42 12 10:30 34 4 2 4 36 8 10:45 27 118 6 24 3 19 3 22 30 137 9 46 11:00 15 2 2 6 17 8 11:15 21 5 5 2 26 7 1130 10 3 6 5 16 8 11:45 16 62 0 10 2 15 5 18 18 77 5 28 .. - _...... --- ----_... ... .. ................ ......... ..—Total__._.751 ... -._.._._.. 1097.___.. __._._-- _....-...- 352 852 Percent 88.1% 75.7% 11.9% 24.3% Day Total 1848 453 2301 I Peak 07:30 04:15 09:30 05:30 07:30 0415 Vol. 202 161 20 46 218 205 P.H.F. 0.356 0,894 0.625 0.719 0.838 0.869 Page 2 PRECISION D A T A N/S \Eirtbonxioll Road/ Crab s Way INDUSIRIFS,LLC e Name : 102358 (; v�n x301 IIO,MA 0bal F-/\X': Ftighl Ild rArenue (Route 107) Drew WRaAI39-N F,io inc<um"'i Site Code : 10-038KC C tq, Stare: 1 dent, iALA 5r1cr Dare li)/21/2010 ("henr. [ fnrl.Straregies/ K. Cram Page Da L emups Znfed Carso Heavy AN,los Marlborough Road Inghland Aveu,e(Rcule f07) raters Vay� Hlyhhmd Av nue lRouta107) _. Fia n Nath Fran E ist Fram Sowh From W sl snrtnme RI,I,yr rnm L,; IumL- inrr,C-u;-R[ unu_m_ rzR L":_- rAT- Re n1 - 'trm ;4 ... 4 0- 5�.15 �.�U f uln. io70 05:00 APA 9 -2 - I 5 17 - 05:15 AM 9 5 2 5 29 0 0 0 4 1 5 27 15 0 102 05:30 AM 20 7 5 8 28 4 0 2 11 4 11 39 27 0 166 05:45 AM 27 12 5 _,.._9_39__2_,_,__, 0 2 18 8 __,_I7 46 39 0 224 _. 7olal 65..... �8 _. ..13 27 113 8 0 __.__8-__._37 13 38 127 88 ... 1 ...... ..562. 06:00 AM 34 9 10 16 41 3 1 4 1'I 7 21 62 60 0 279 06'15 AM 35 11 9 8 GI 3 0� 3 18 13 11 75 80 0 307 06'30 AM 66 13 11 12 121 7 0 3 20 14 19 117 80 1 484 06:45 AM 88 29 30 18 95 9 1 1 .54 22 34 124 73 0 578 Tu1al 223 G2 _--60 .54 ,.. 318 ..._.22 .._..- 2l it ---103v 9G - -85 _...378 27J._..,,.- 1 1648 07:00 AN' 99 23 45 20 152 34 137 4 0 1 617 26 01 3 56 27 22 162 91 01 _. 07:45 AMI .107.__.. 35 ..._.. 30 28_.... „ 118__._ 26__Q .._- R__.__._63 .. 19.�..... 50 _ 199 too _... ._..__.._.883 07:15 AM 116 27 36 I 28 202 16 0 4 37 18 2g 101 gp p 7 Total 451 114 164 ILI64 07:30 AM 129 29 5I-- 103 659 80 01 22 208 d4 10 135 h59 335 0 .3014 0800 AM08:15 701 36 27 72 147 26 0 7 56 28 aM1 160 113 0 785 ft30 AM 102 41 281 34 157 26 0 18 fi0 48 56 13B 102 U 810 OB 30 AM 87 45 19 27 166 23 1 20 52 J7 I 40 158 92 1 768 08 45 AM 89 J4 29 21 151 28 0 18 3b 50 70 158 106 0 796 Total 379..._.. 156 _..- 103 it t...._._ 621 ....103 "...1 C 63-__..-204 107-` 220 _.1314 413 ._. 1. .-.... 159.. 09:00 AM 78 54 25 28 146 25 0 20 56 46 79 138 80 0 775 09 15 AM 74 38 25 30 132 21 0 13 55 66 62 127 82 0 725 09:30 AM 69 37 231 42 152 27 O I 24 46 it 58 144 108 0 771 _. 09 45 AM 70 34 23 •11 106 22 0 25 49 53 _ B2 123 104 0 712 -Total 291 If>3 _ 06 h11 536 95 .0 82 ..... "`-- 74 206 200 2G1 532 374 0 ....... _ ..983 10:00 AN 1 50 79 2t 38 I55 35 0 24 45 77 65 128 72 0 149 10'15 Atvl i9 13 19 25 113 26 0 18 39 46 67 1: 108 0 721 10.30 AM 81 37 24 36 164 34 (0 27 38 57 67 t44 82 1 792 10'45 AM 91 32 32 24 1 19 29 0 27 __90 571 _ G7 12A 75 1 738_ Total 271_..-. 151 95 123_._..... 611 12q .0�...._, .08 152 1 37. .. 266 574 J37......._ ` . ........... ... .1000 Grand Total 1680 072 532 662 2658 432 3 280 910 7631 1005 2844 1820 5 14366' UPrah % 58 J 2J J t8 4 14 6 74 I 11.2 0.1 14 3 46.8 3g.1 17.7 50.1 32.1 0 1 Total -% 117 17 3.7 3.9 19 9_ 3 0 I9 6.3 53 7 19.8 127 0 l a11, rs 1648 657 -525 548 -- 2725 A08 3 267 890 738 -_- 974 2127 178A - 4 17002 Ca;xs 98 1 97 8 98 7 97 5 95 3 94.4 1. 100 95 1 97.8 96.7 96 9 95.9 98 2_80 96.8 Heavy Vohiclos 32 I S 7 I l i 133 D1 0 - 13 20 25 31 117 32 1 --464` %Heavy V,thclas 19 2.2 1.3 25 47 5.6 0 4.6 2.2 33r 3.1 4.1 18 20 3.2 PRECISION 0 A T A INDUSTRIES,LLC File Milne 102358 N/,S: NhclboroU�1,11 K(xld/ Finders WJY loaealm U,,1m,MA 011101 F'/A': ffighbild Avenue (Route t071 Site (:ode 10-038K(" Start L)-jte [0/21/201.0 State: Salcm? NIA (Atent: LatidStratcgies/ K. Cram Page No 2 F"',to, Hi,Ml�ec!A�enua(ROUW 1 7) klariborwlph-��ead ---j"---High-land pN-ven,je(Route 107) In I F,nt-n odh Fwn East so'A- Flon,West Ti nn Rlil -�-'o Int iauf-f u-N L'�� Lu%,,,L 11 T' -T in, 'W1 J- T0-11 :is,-PA-Peak I ljt I P�li Hour A Y511 FIQ 0 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07:30 AM 129 29 53 211 27 158 26 0 211 3 56 27 86 22 162 91 0 275 783 07:45 AM 107 35 30 172 28 147 26 0 201 6 63 19 88 so 199 100 0 349 810 08:00 AM 101 36 27 164 32 147 26 0 205 7 56 26 89 54 160 113 0 327 785 08:15 AM 102 41 28 171 34 157 26 0 217 18 411 126 56 138 0- 29.6 810 -1 41i----138 6�4 406 0 1247 1188 --FO(31 V111"Ine 6§i 7 18 121 609 164 b M4 ti4i App.Total 61.119.2 14.5 73 12.5 0 87 60.4 30.8 14.6 52,8 32.6 0 ---- ------ -- 9'4- 1.066- 984 FiH-F -M-1865 651 .851 '890 6 OCO fil-641-- j§6-6--ffj i ---3065 9�fj �7� .9�3 625 .772 .813 .828 .898 .000 .893 Cars -45i IW-I M--767 119578162 3 %Cars 98.6 97.9 98-6 08.5 98.3 94.9 98.1 0 95.8 94.1 97.9 94,2 96.4 95.1 97.6 98.0 0 97.4 97.1 llcavyV,,hidn 6 3 2 11 2 31 2 0 35 2 5 7 14 9 16 a 0 33 93 1.11 2.1 1A 1,5 1.7 5.1 1.9 0 4.2 5.9 2.1 5.8 3.6 4.9 2.4 2.0 0 2.6 2.9 PRECISION 0 A T A N/.'.'): Madlurenugh Road/ Trulers \\11r, 1NOUSrR1ES,LLC kle N:une : 102153 C P.anos for ff d,P, lA 01SOJ FAV: 111 t;141af1d -\vcnrle (IVOLLCf l )]) 08,18 Ir rax.500545.1134 ,SiteCode : 10-I)-8KC erg.n-.d.,r.,rrm,e.n:�mtnl..rr,,,, 'l "OIU ("ittr, titalc: S111cm, %l:A Sian Dace Chow I..aTldsrrnlegics/ K. Cron) Pegs N0 : l _...._... _ Gmups-Printad-Can Marlbomuyh Hoad Ilignlsnd Alenue(ROU: 101) Traders Way Hiyhiind Avenue(Boole 101j From North Form Ensl _ Fm rnSouth From West _ _ Start T rna RI�jM rl r r_L_Lnfl Riyhl�_Rrru�_ Leff IJ-Toni R'glu __rhnr Celt_ _Right ihm(- 'Lefl� fl Fu_r, _1_nl_._folnl 05:00 AM 9 2 1 5 - 17 2 0 '1 4 0 4 14 7 0 66 05:15 AM 9 4 2 5 28 0 0 0 4 1 4 23 15 0 95 05:30 AM 20 6 5 8 27 2 0 2 11 4 11 34 27 0 157 05:45 AM 27 12 5 8 __ 38 2 _ 0 2 18 8 _ 17 43 39 0 219 _.. . Total u5-- 211---.IJ __.^<6 110 6 0 537 -_ - .0 38_.--114 88 0 .............537.. 06:00 AM34 9 10 16 40 3 1 4 11 5 20 61 59 0 273 06.15 AM 35 10 9 A 58 3 0 3 18 12 9 72 GO 0 297 06:30 AM 1 65 12 10 12 118 6 0 3 19 141 17 113 79 1 169 _06.45 AM, 85-„_..__,.,.P8, 30 18..__86,___,__,9 I __ 1 ____51____ 20_ 34 _121 _ 72_ _ 0 556 Total 219 59 59 54 302 21 2 11- 99 51 80 367270 1 1595 - 07:00 AMI 97 23 45 20 149 11 0 8 50 18 32 131 53 0 637 07 15 AM ILII 115 25 96 2G 197 i6 0 4 3G 17 29 155 90 0 746 07:30 AM 128 28 53 25 148 25 0 2 54 27 21 159 90 0 760 07,15 AM 106 34 30 28 140 25 0 _ 6 62 18 _ 49 197 100__ 0 ___ 795 Total) 146'-- 110 1134 99 -_'634 __-77 _ _..0 20 202 80 131 642 333 _ --0 2938 08:00 AM . 99 36 27 32 142 28 0 7 56 22 52 155 109 0 763 08 15 AM 100 10 2G 34 118 26 0 17 58 d6 51 IJ2 99 0 777 0830 AM 85 45 191 27 158 20 I 19 52 ^6 40 153 69 1 745 OB 45 AM 82 34 29 _.__20____146 28 0 18 35 _ 55 67 _149 104 0 767_ !oral- 3ti6 ---155- lilt 113 594 100 -- 1 - - 51 261 -- I59 210 569 ...101 - 1 -- 3052 09.00 AM 74 53 05l 26 134 24 0 18 56 45 79 t28 80 0 742 09:15 AM 74 38 24 28 125 19 0 13 53 65 61 122 78 0 700 09:30 AM 68 37 21 41 139 26 0 22 15 41 58 135 105 0 7:38 09 45 AM_ 70___ 3 t_ 23 _ 11 97 22 0 L_2J_ 48 53 60 115 103 0 689_ � �.195-'- 91 0 76 202 20a�-_ 58� _�500 S56 ---0 --2A60 Tula! 286 162 `93 1013 1000 AM 50 37 '137 t50 33 0 24 14 75 65 125 69 0 730 10 15 AM 46 13 19 24 139 24 0 IA 38 45 64 131 105 0696 10:30 AM 80 37 24 35 158 32 0 26 37 54 66 1(11 82 1 773 10 45 AM 90 30 31 24 143 24 0 26 30 57 64 118 74 1 712_ ....._...._ ...... .. .. __ I._... 259 515 330 2 2911 Total 266 ....._-147 � 95 120 590 113- 0 -_�� 94 149 231' Grand Total 1648 657 525 5,141 2725 -108 3 267 890 739 974 2727 1788 41 13902 Apprr-h% 58.2 23,2 13.6 14.9 74 11.1 0.1 -14.1 47 38.9 17.7 49.6 32.6 0.1 Total% 11.9 4.1 3.8 3.9 19.6 2.9 0 1.9 6.4 5.3 7 19.6 12.9 0 rl Wbnrouyh Ro rd IliJnhnf Alen fe(Roiln 10/) rale 5-4Vay MI3hIdniA enue(Ro Ie10/) From North _ From Ea 1 f From South From Vest _s.,t r me R1gm[-Th,,,-(_-3.a L r �_R 1bt I h 1. .n 1 u -� r I. el)m r, [_'"�:n I Park lfurrAvfysi F.nm 05.00 AM to 11:15 AM-P?eh l oft - Psak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM - 07:30 AIM 128 28 53 209 25 148 25 0 198 2 54 27 83 21 159 90 0 2701 7110 WAS AM 106 31 30 170 28 140 25 0 193 6 62 I8 86 49 197 t00 0 348 195 08.00 AM 99 :36 27 1132 32 142 26 0 200 1 56 22 .95 52 L55 109 0 316 763 08:15 ANI 100 l0 26 Ir-6 34 14A 26 0 208 17 46 121 51 1.12 99 0 282 777 o1aIV,hlme 433 IJA 136 /07 119 578 102 0 799 32 230 111 375 113 643 396 Il 1214 1095 ,App Total 612 195 102 _ 149 723 128 0 8.5 61 3 901 113 03 _328 0 _ _- I HF -0-TG „ti3 -.ii t2 846 875 06 'Al .000_ r100 .171 `727 . .614 075 1 332 316 913 000 677 '.97f PRECISION D A T A N/S: NIarlborougl4 Road/ I'l-Aders Wad; NuusTates,uc Dile dame 102358 (; v.( e1),301 u:dm,mA 0151)3 FAV: Iligliland Avenue (Route 107) nmrpabn4alM9Fix:ab8s45u34 Sltcnide : 10-038KC Emad:d;namyueur u Vtitle mm Cit}-, Statc: Selcm, NIA Start pate : 10/2l/201U Client: LandStrategics/ IC C;ratn Page No : l r,rau a Pn iter] Heavy/uhMlaf -. _ PAarFrom NodhnaC liignlano Avenue E(linule 107) FromTraders ay 119hIanA horn a(st 107) From lyrlh _ From East _ From Sooh Frnm West _.. ...._.9 [ L,. _ nn+ !L _ RI�11-_.fhru lett Uil rn InL 7or;tl� __ 05:00 tAM Ri h01 rt r0_ ._�.e00 Ri I0 1hr0�Le0 U_010 Rlght.l_ T,. 0 0 1 1 _----6- 05:15 AM 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 4 0 0 7 05:30 AM 0 1 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 9 _05:45 AM 00 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0_ 0 _ 5 Total 0_'-_ 2 _........0. .. _...._ 1 3 ..............0_.._.-0 2 13 0 I 25 06:00 AM 0 0 0 0 1 0 U 0 0 2 1 1 1 0 6 06:15 AM 0 1 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 1 2 3 0 0 10 06:30 AM 1 1 1 0 3 1 01 0 1 0 2 4 1 01 15 06'45 AM3 1 0 0 9 _ 0 0 0 3 2 0 3 1 0 22_ Total h 3 I 0 -- 16 1 0 U 4 ...5 5 it 3 0 53 07:00 AM 2 0 0 0 3 1 0 1 2 2 2 6 1 0 20 07:15 AM 1 2 0 2 5 0 0 0 1 1 0 6 0 0 18 07:30 AM 1 1 0 2 10 t 00 I 1 2 0 1 3 1 0 23 07:45 AM 1 1 0 D 7 1 0 0 1 1 1 2 0 ..'__....__25 3 ..._0._-2 * _.0 ....__.. J -----11 2 15 0 78 08:00 AM 2 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 4 2 5 4 0 . 22 08'15 AM� 2 1 2II 0 9 0 0 1 '2 2 5 6 3 0 33 08:30 AM 2 0 0 I 0 U 3 0 1 0 1 0 5 3 0 23 08:45 AM 7 0 0 t 1 5 0 0 0 1 1 3 9 2 0 29 Total tJ_..._.. 1 ._....._2 .............. 17 .........0 . _. ..... O 2 ..._.3_ 8.._._..--10 25 ----- .jZ_..� 010 09:00 09:00 AM 4 1 0 2 '12 1 0 2 0 1 0 10 0 0 33 09:15 AM 0 0 1 2 7 2 0 0 2 1 1 5 4 0 25 0930 AM 1 0 2 1 13 1 0 2 1 0 0 9 3 0 33 09 I5 AM 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 2 1 0 2 8 1 0 23 ._.._. .. _.__..__. .lt _;t ._ 0..._._ fi ....._._4__.._2__. 302.. 8........ ......0.._-_.lilt Total 5...._.... 1 .__..�. .._.._ 5 1000 AM 02 0 1 5 2 0 0 1 2 I 0 3 3 0 19 10:15 AM 3 0 0 'I 4 2 U 7 3 0 25 1030 AM 1 0 0 1 u 2 0 1 1 3 1 3 0 0 19 10:45 AM 1 2 i 0 6 5 0 1 0 0 3 _ 6 1 0 26 Total 5 4 1 _0_ __._ ..._._. 21 ... ..._i .._.0.__-2 -- 0 7' . . 19 7_..._.. . .0___...__.._89... Grand Total 32 15 7 14 133 24 0 13 20 2.51 31 117 32 1 1 464 Appfch% 59,3 27.8 13 8.2 77.8 14 0 224 34.5 4.3.1 17.1 64.6 17.7 0.6 Total% 6,9 3.2 1.5 3 28.7 5.2 0 2.8 4.3 5.4 6.7 25.2 6.9 0.2 ( hi a borealh Road Highlrn.lMsm,e(Rotoo 107) I InU¢rs'Nry Ill lhlm6 Av LLe(Rebte IU/l Frr n_Nonh From Eut F 1)m South Frrm Vast 1f4,r4-Hour pTna -1-Fiipt l Ih I L It l r _ _ R ghl, mru I Lelt l u* rn,� L .�M l n r l_,L II l „-7777.�ml t rnri_ I it j Il iun� r Int c+U'1 rrc n )5)0 Ata I>I19 IS AN PeA I or 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 08:45 AM 15 0 25 _ 0930 nM 1 ._. f) ._.. 2 ..._..3 _ I 13._- ? ..._. 0 _�5i .. .? ...? ._.. 0 3L._ �__._'� _. a �._ ..10 .__....33 N App. ictal 15 6,2 3 I6 6 d7 4 - 0 47 4 36.,1 27.3 8.7 71.7 19.6 0J6 120 talalViWmo 19 I h 3 11 � 4 33 IN � 188 1:8 78.7 85 0 36.i 0 PHF .d29 250 .375 571.1 !SU .712. 500 000 83I _.500`.500 150 g7563 .01)ci 821 100 I '. PRECISION D A T A V/S. IAlatlborough Ltold/ 'I'rnders \l''ay IN0U5'FRIES,LLC File Mime : 102378 (: P./\�-• Pro nI 01111a MA 01913I lighand Avenue (Route 107) oma 504a81 321e nlk sOx;.Is 1114 SiteCode It)-I)3$j�C' Cu ~tate: Salem, DfA em e.1- Ia n r•r+"n rnrrmn Start Date : 10/21/2010 (Ticar. I.andStrate"ics/ Li. C:rs1-1-n Page Ni) ----- ._ _ r r_ups Pn It lfPeds end Bi y,,lo9.-_ . MadhlraMo Road Hiphh NAvenua IRoula 107) - Tradars WayTH)�ilw�d Avnuo(Rome 1-07) Frmn nlonh F am E1sSa Ih __OS Op ANI 0Por �hru L tl ThorM .. _. .t __..– �� o0 0 0 0 0 o n o 0 0 0 o 0 0 05:15 AM 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 05,30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 005:45 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total 0 0 .._-._..o._- --0 0 .. 0 ._ _Q. ._--0 tl � 0... 06:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06:15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 i 0 2 0 0 0 0 3 06:30 AM 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 I 3 06:115 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 -- f Total 0—� --Z __ _�_-_--�- 0 --- 1_....- 0 __-_...0 —_- 0700 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 07 15 AM 0 0 0 U 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 1 13 07:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 07:45 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 p -,. p p 0 Total 0 0 0 0. _.--.-_O.. _ -...0._.—...0 4. -�. –_.Q —I 12 p -. ...___.�-__ 0 3 08:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 U 0 1 U 0 0 1 0 2 p p 4 0815 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 U 0 1 0 0 0 0 3 09 30A 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 0 U 0 0 0 i 0 0845AM 0 0 0 1 0 U U I 0 0 0 _ OI 0 0 0 0 2 Total _0._ �' ' 0-.-.._. 1 l _o.- 1 ........-p y ....__._O_0 _.�_..-_. ._ _ _..... __. _. 0 2 .U---O ...._. _ .. 09:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 2 6 09.15 AMI 0 0 U 0 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 3 09:30 AM 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 g 09 4s AAI 0 0 0 0 0 0 o z 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 0 3 Total 0 ..__.Q __�..--2 0.... 0 _.......-0 7._.-.-- _..__. - 3 __....0._ _6 _._.p_. 0 -. _.._ ......z. 17 10.00 AM 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 3 10 'I5 AM p 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D 0 0 0 0 0 p 10.30 AM 0 0 0 I 0 1 0 4 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 1045 AM _U 0 0 1 0 0 U 1 0 0 0 0 f 0 0 -q– Grind g ..Total U— -`-6 0-....._..... 2 .._._.O-_. .. . I_"___._.�---�.�—. 0 0 0 3 0 Grand Total I 0 0 0 7I 0 2 0 3 0 t 1 29 2 2 0 d I 71, Flpprrh% 0 0 0 100 0 9 p 921 (1 3.2 3.2 93.5 25 25 U SO Total% 0 0 U 9.9 0 2,8 0 32.4 0 1.4 t.4 40.8 2.8 2.8 0 5,6 .. I d63 augn Rl3A fli lhWn•1 n nut lR wt_IU7) h 11 rs A 17 _. Fmm Nndh Fro 1 E xl Froin)oi In _3k I igltl,nnl 4vr,me(Route l)7) 11 Hour for Entire IVO AM 1. - Frrnn t rk How Arm n Berms at 06:30 AM d;I r n I r is( r;m 1 rn r l:,Ii P n [_.v_•_ )nr f TtirG l n l '9r,l 3�1_eo—n.6i] y,ro FrcnOo.O AN Io f9 t�AU P,, 1-ni1 --- 06:30 AM 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 U I 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 3 06:45 AM 0 0 0 0 0 I 0 U 0 I I 0 0 0 4 4 0 0 0 0 oil 0T 00AM 0 0 0 U 0 U 0 0 I t 0 0 1 0 1 U 0 0 0 0 '2 07:I�AM 0 0 0 U 0 U _ 0 0 2 2 0 0 .0 10 10 0 0 0 1 cialy 0 U 0 I 1 0 0 0 5 5 .. 0 0 - , 1 14 .. I'i I .-.p. 0 -� — .13 0 100 _ 0 0 U 100 I__ 0 0 6.7 93.3 50 0 0 50 2 �3 l l006-1--2w- - 0 5001 tat PHP o0o 6607-000 250 250 UOD 00O 000 02$ Cr2S .000 000 25U 1J0 .375 250 000 000 75 PRECISION D A T A INDUSTRIES,LLC NQS: NGual��orol_1gh Road/ Graders \t';1}' ('ilt Nnlne : 102358 C OU don ial 0,1o,tAA 01513 ]-',��V: Highlandl�Velltle (RQLI tL` [07) aI0[e:W9 8 1994 F9d:SUF 545 1)14 vire Codl` 10-1�3E{IV(. GinaJ:dolureQueflsraprlillcmm City, Stare: Salem, NfA Start Date : ll)/^-l/2oto Client 1.a nd'itrategies/ K. Cram I?age No : 1 - - - Manho nu h Ro3r3- Rl6nl ll tba AV,11 FE[_U ne L y :_n Fii9nl j_re,(,,,S w'y1 . . W yhIW I TIryf10 Aaenue tRou1e 107) 9 � 3 From N)dh _ f a n East from SuWh F'm' Weyl _ Stan T a R qht r„Tn u _ Lell 7• s_ ... ._ -_ i L111 l ll'r . .� yv li 7ni.Molal Peak Wom AnaCyvs F om 05.00 AIA to 1045 AM f oak I a1 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07:30 AM 129 29 53 211 27 156 26 0 211 3 56 27 86 22 162 91 0 275 783 07:45 AM 107 35 30 172 28 147 26 0 201 6 63 19 88 50 199 100 0 349 810 08:00 AM 101 36 27 164 32 147 26 0 205 7 56 26 89 54 160 113 0 327 785 08 15 AM 102 41 28 171 34 157 26__ 0 217 16_ G 0-_ 48 126 56 138 102 0 296 810 Tory Volunta --4-3-914-1-1-3-8--7-1-8- 104 0 834 34 235 120 389 182 659 406 0 1247 7188 App Total 61.1 19.8 19.2 11.5 73 12.5 _ _0 8.7 60.4 30.8 14.6 52.8 32.6 0 _ _. - _ _ __ _ .000 .893 .851 .490 n61 .472 933 -,625 772 813 828 .898 .984 PHF .851 . 136.651 ,964 laoo 000 Cars 433 138 136 707 119 578 102 �0 !99 - 32v 230 113 775 179 643 398 0 1214 3095 ".L Cars 98.6 97.9 08.6 98.5 98.3 94.9 98.1 0 95.8 94.1 97.9 94.2 96.4 95.1 97.6 98.0 0 97.4 97,1 )lcuvy veMcle•, 6 3 2 11 2 31 2 0 35 2 5 7 t4 9 16 8 0 33 93 n�.w eini;w, 1.4 2.1 1.4 1.51 1.7 5.1 1.9 0 4.2 5.9 2.1 5.8 3.61 4.9 2.4 2.0 0 2.6 2.9 majtlNaquuh mad Cul I., Tolal J 0 4 IS 28 /iy tt6_U STI--116'L. -136 6 7 _ 1 4191 141[, I?A� I o -' W hl ThLoll Peak Hour Data � ro Nro c^ a I a by ulN p North V,aF IIL r8nglns of il(tUP • �„ Cars r 12:1 8� .' rr �•- I'IZ ..� P1C.N�Vgn1 les _ I ��g N v -, o O.- IOOO�f ~9 1I I I � raft 1hol 12uahl IIJ .a� 12 I l S 2 l ] .113 )J51 '18, /6I Old 1'1 Tolil el PRECISION D A T A N ti: Dunkin t)onuts/ E[alvtfwule Squ:uINOUSTRIES,UC'e Dile Nau1c : 102358 LI ROltov irn O Fail al 15 1 �A\%: f-lil;hland :Avenue (Route l07) rror.,seansleen9 r.Ksaesr_Ian Site Code : lq-0381<C f.crad tiara=naeso'rvoAillcmm City, Stare: Salem, rblA Start COs[e L0/21/201) Clicut: L.andStratgics/ K. Ccarn Page No ; 1 brouII Pnnl d CCs-Ilea vy V9hu Ina Dunkin DonuLJ Pup Poys ( HI hlnnd a107) Hiwlhmne Square Moan yhland Ave.nue llo ulB l0/1Dr,veway From East ay From West North From South ' _ Uri rime 'tlLi thnr loll Rjht I_-,_ (hr L_,Lr;flL Il Thr_ -y Ri�M1I '�h:u�Le Riypl Thru LUII LTirn InC�TOt_I� 05:00 AM 0 0 0 0 24 i 0 3 0 0 0 23 U 0 51 05:15 AM 0 0 0 0 35 6 0 2 1 1 1 27 0 0 73 05'30 AM 1 0 1 0 42 5 0 1 0 3 1 42 1 0 97 ,,. ___.__0.5:45 AM 0 01 1 45 12 0 5 0 0 2 49 0 0 115_ ..Total 1 0 _._...,_2 _....-L._I18..._-24 0 -1-1 1 4 4....__.141.--1--_..0 . 338 O6 00 AM 1 i 0 355 4 1 7 0 4 1 71 2 0 150 06:15 AM 7 1 3 8 65 15 0 8 5 2 2 88 0 0 204 08.30 AM 11 5 4 14 118 15 0 8 6 3 3 138 0 U 325 06:4.5 AM 8 1 7 12 114 25 0 12 5 _ 6 _ 2 157 2 _ _0 351 ...._.. _-- .___ .._. ....... __......154_ 4 0 1030 Toial... 27 _.8.. 14 37 952 59 1. JS_...___.1G t5 8 07:00 AM 14 0 13 27 167 34 0 20 6 3 6 187 4 0 481 07:15 AM 22 4 9 24 186 37 0 16 3 9 6 197 1 0 514 07:30 AM 22 2 7 29 217 28 0 21 1 9 I 5 213 5 0 559 0745 AM 23 3 12 28 _1 U6 53 0 32 4 8 7 221 11 2 570 _- _ Total O1 ..._.-. 9------i I16 736 152 ---4---a9 --'id 29�_-�24 818 21_._.......__2 2124 08:00 AM 18 5 14 26 168 ,53 0 36 1 15 15 204 3 1 559 08:15 AM 33 2 '13 28 191 51 1 44 9 9 10 179 8 1 579 08:30 AM 25 4 11 t0 182 50 0 44 9 12 3 188 9 1 548 08:45 AM 20 311 17 157 49 0 34 7 13 7 _ 193 8 0 519 Tolnl I 96 _.... 11 ...191 . ..81.____698 .. ......20� 1 158 28 1s��35 �. .764 26._...._ 3 _.._..2205 09:00 AM 17 3 15 13 181 65 0 35 8 24 9 174 14 1 559 09'15 AM 18 1 17I 12 143 57 0 39 4 23 12 135 7 3 471 09:30 AM 17 0 7 16 182 47 0 67 5 18 17 169 5 0 550 09:45 AM 17 2 9 10 _ 146 60 1 59 4 3G 13 149 8 0514 Total 69 6 491 51 652 229 I - - �00 21- I01 -- 51 r27 34 t ._.._._.2i)94- 10:00 AM 11 4 9 12 171 57 43 5 37 14 155 10 0 534 7 172 :18 44 3 9 14 176 5 0 540 .......... '0.56 AM 45......._...._ 111 _.,.2? GO 05.1 198 _2 30 0_i.._. 17�.-_.._._-I6 1�6.I fly I56 2...._.... 0 ___422.. 5 ..3 I 1662 Grand Total 321 -18 176 332 3227 865 3 660 94 3141 171 3449 1I1 10 9781 Apprch% 58.9 8.8 32.3 7.5 72.9 19,5 0.1 61.8 8.8 29.4 d.fi 92.2 3 0.3 Total% 3.3 0.5 1.8 3.4 39 8.8 0 6.7 1 3.2 1.7 35.3 1.1 0.1 Cars 318 48 170 33I 3078 832 3 6>7 94 304 164 3307 110 9 9395 / Cars 99 1 100 96.6 99 7 95 4 96.2 100 95 100 06 8 95 9 95.9 99.1 90 96.1_ _.. __- _... ..... .__. . . .-_� Heavy VvhIc103 3 0 6 I 149 33 0 33 -0 10 7 142 1 1 - 3Cg F.H a.y Vehicles 0.9 0 3.4 03 46 3.8 0 5 0 32 41 4.1 09 10 39 i I PRECISION D A T A N/S: Dunkin Donuts/ (lalvthocne Sc uare INOUS1RIEs u.c e0.oe.m1 nedlnrnA 91501 l'ilc Nrm1c : 10)235 l3 E/\$': F[i 111nne1 eAccnuc (ltoutc 1117) o1Nce:508.4811999 n,e;5089451714 Sitc Codc : U)-038K(': Cirtr,State: Sa1cm, NIA �,:,Ihenv,remrem Dank<om St>ut Date : 111/21/2010 Client: LandStrategics/ K. (:;ram Pagc No : 2 0 mkln Danulsr P R boys `- - _ Oliv wa hl ghh9ml Avanne( oule U7Rl Ilawthorne SIu.nr hlaut y ) Driveway H uhland Avenue(Route 107) _ - Fram NaM From fast m_m South rn,n wait St�rt Tlrne } Roial A Ob-00 AU5 th11 R L_i.,aa Rlym ❑vu Lal1 (/-*u y--� _._... _',-�'— -- — ��k Ibur,Ln.Uysls Furn M to 10:45 AM-Peak I el I n R R -'fnm I (�1 t rus R hl -Thm L fl U Tu o:;a .n1.rami Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins x107:30 AM 07:30 AM 22 2 7 31 29 217 28 0 274 21 1 9 31 5 213 5 0 223559 07:45 AM 23 J 12 J8 28 166 53 0 247 32 4 8 44 7 221 11 2 241 570 08:00 AM 18 5 14 37 26 168 53 0 247 36 1 15 15 204 3 1 223 559 08:15 AM 3- _ 2 13 48 28 191 51 1 271 _ 44 9 9 _62 10 179 8 1 198 519 _..... _..... _---'—._ ❑nal voluma 98 12-- 46- ---154 ---11-1 -142-1 85 - --1 - -1019199 IS 41 189 37 877 27 4 -885 2267 -'1=ApP.- 823 7.8 299 107 _71.4 118 _ 0.1 _704 7.9217 42 92.3 3.1 0.5 ___ -_PHF 727 600 821 .802 957 .855 879 .250 948 - .756 417_883 _-762 617 024 .614 .500 Cars 96 12 A4 15? 111 703 179 -� 1 994 :129 15 - 918 .979 %4 C �6E� 2188 ars 100 100 95.7 98.7 IN 94.7 98.8 100 95.7 97.0 100 97.6 9 .4 946 96.9 100 100 96.9 96.5 Heavy vemae% 0 0 2 2 0 39 6 0 45 4 0 1 5 2 25 0 0 27 79 un,yy Wln[I•,n 0 0 4.3 1,3 0 5.3 3.2 0 4.3 3.0 0 2.4 2.6 5.4 3.1 0 0 3.1 3.5 PRECISION D A T A N/S: Dunkin DOIILIIS/ I Iawl6orne Square INDUS IMES,LLC l eeer„)m nema,WWsm file Name 1023,58 B I_VW: Ifigh1(111C1 ,wenuc (R(AHC 107 rani 5as4311ow F11.5035IS1214 Site Code : 10-038KC _nail docneiptnn:Ppd0lcmrn ;ill', State: Salem, bf.:A Start Date : 10/21/2011,1 ( lient: C:InLISrcatekii's/ Lam. CraD1 Page M) : I iDands/ _ Groups Prbtt&1-cam Dunkn F p goys Hialdan4 Avarme ,_ 51__R_hr.ne [hy Ghia (RoLuetefl rr107I)l _ nt !'gN- anU Arornue(Rouan te t-t 107'U)h Dn WaFn Fast DrivewayFomNorth From South Fmnt Wesl Right 05:00 AM Th 2 - 0 o 21 05:15AM 0 0 Intini al I 0 34 5 0 2 1 I 1 23 0 0 67 05:30 AM 1 0 1 0 39 5 0 1 0 3 1 37 1 U 89 055_45 AM 0 0 1 __ 1 44 8 0 4 U 0 1 47 0 0 106 Total 1 0 2 1 141 18 0 9... ......__1 •C.--. 3____128.____....�_____0 .__ 309 06:00 AM I I 0 2 53 131 6 0 4 1 n8 2 0 142 06:15 AM 7 1 3 8 63 14 0 7 5 1 2 86 0 0 197 06:30 AM 11 5 4 14 1 14 14 0 7 6 3 2 132 0 0 312 0645 AM 8 1 7 12 105 24 0 105_ _4 _ 2 .._,.__154 2 0 334_ Total 8 27 ��--�� 14 07:00 AM 14 0 13 27 162 32 0 13 6 3 6 180 4 0 q85 07:15 AM 22 4 9 24 184 36 0 15 3 1 6 191 1 0 502 07:30 AM 22 2 7 ^_9 205 28 0 20 I 8 5 206 5 01 538 07:45 AM '23 3 11 28 __158 5'1 0 _ 29 •l 8 7 217 11 __2 552 q--` .10 -"'-- 10f3-- 709 147 --0 �82 -- 1J ----20 24 794 27 2 2057- 08:00 AM' 18 5 1:3 26 162 5111 36 1 15 14 200 3 1 545 08:15 AM 33 2 13 28 178 d9 'I 11 9 9 9 169 8 1 553 08:30 AMI 23 4 11 10 177 48 01 43 9 12 3 183 8 1 532 ..-----08:45 AM _ _ 11 17 149 48 U 31 7 13 6 tA4 8 0 .. 497 To ..tal 94'20 14 3 .......-id 81........... 666 ....196 1 154. ........__._26 49. .... 32.._. __796' 27 3 L .__..2127 '� � 09.00 AM 16 3 141 13 164 63 0 34 8 22 9 1 12 14 'I 09 IS AM 18 1 16 I'2 135 5.5 0 37 4 23 11 131 7 2 452 09:30 AM I/ 0 7 116 169 47 0 65 5 18� 17 156 5 0 522 ,. 09 45 AN 17 2 _, 8 10 137 60 1 56 4 35 12 139 8 ....... ._...... _......... .........._ ------- ,14 489_ Total) (i8 6 45 SI 605 19. .....5. ' 3q....-.. -1 588 1908 10:00 AM -17 4 812 162 54 0 d2 5 36 30 12 149 6 14 150 10 0 514 10:15 AM 9 5 6 15 142 55 0 39 7 1 476 10:30 AMI 15 2 5 17 167 46 0�43 3 39 14 172 5 0 528 2 10:45 AM 6 0 10 151 36 0 36 _ 1 10 9 150 2 0` 413_ _.-.- ._. "7o1a11 _.. 17__.. 11 ....._-21 622 191 _. i7 160 , 15 115_......_ 19 ..._621 >8--- I -- Grand Total I 318 .18 170 1 3.31 3073 832 3I 627 94 3041 164 3307 110 9 9;795 Apprch% 59.3 9 31.7 7.8 72.5 IE 0,1 61.2 9.2 297 4.6 92.1 3.1 U.3I Total% 34 0.5 1.8 3.5 32.8 8.9 0 6.7 1 3.2 1.7 35.2 1.2 0.1 Ha\ F a ry o blain !{ lhlanA Av n o(Raue 1071 Ih me f Di -Way Dn w Iflan]Flven ta(4nr le 107) Froin Fast Fin / 1 I IO 15V.I F Y, t Our11 _ o n 1_ i Sl rtr FLI 1 rhrl 1 a1 .�-LitJhri rtrol p ❑ rw m R10i� t [. t11 Z7h11 ❑rut Lll U�rn� r I� itL Tn01� p l4 ur Ana175sFwn)5 WAS1m -' -" -' Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07 30 AM 22 2 7 31 29 205 28 0 2621 20 I 4 29 5 206 5 0 216 07 15 AM 23 3 11 37 2A 158 51 0 23! 29 4 8 =t l 1 7 217 11 2 532 552 030 .. 18 5 13 38 26 182 51 0 0J9 :36 I 15 14 200 3 I 2,61 515 OB IS AM � 33 2 13 .181 28 118_ 49 1 156 44 9 9 62 _ 9 IU9 8 I 187 _ 553_ r„t;tl 1 Tot 36 12 - J.1 152 Ill 7U� I/9 1 994 129 15 -10 I N4 '35 192 27 4 9aA` ?198 App, total 1 (i3 2 / ) 28 9 1 I _70.7 I8 0.1 741 8 2 2 t 71 1 92.3_ 3 1 05 1'FIF 1 727 u00 .848 !92 I 957 .857 677 250 94A i 733 1 I7- -.687 712 . 625 912 ti 1,1 500 7(15 .409 I PRECISION D A 'f A N/S: Ihlnkin Donors/ I lawthonle Square INDUSCRIES,LLC File Name : 102158 B F,/W: flighland Avenue (Route 'Will :509 107) Ho-uo4Pol 1Berlin,MA elsol SOP,101.3999 Fan;0e-SM1[1?14 Site Code [moil:def r,uX,t,-,dlk corn City, State: Sa(crn, SIA Start Date : 10/2[/3010 Client: 1,midStrategies/ K Cram Page No : I 0unkm Do_�_mlSl Pa fr�u�s Pr nled-Hr,a V hlUes OnYs Hight Hawthorne Square Main Dhrnway envetua( oa Driveway Highland Avenue(Rmrla lW) flm _ Froinlh From East From South Front Wast Slori dune Ri hl it ru LOR Fii IIi thr r ''loft U-turn -- RL ht thru Laft Ri hl_ _.—_hr.l L• "" oso6A t o 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 o i o o-,-, 05:15 AM 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 6 05:30 AM 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 8 05_45 AM 0 0 0 0 1 4 0 1001 2 0 0 9 7olal .0 0 0 5 6 0 2 0 0 _ _.._�_.—._.-f3 0 6 .__....._-27 06:00 AM 0 0 0 1 2 1 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 0 g 013.15 AM 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 1 0 1 0 2 0 0 7 0630 AM 0 0 0 0 4 1 0 1 0 0 1 6 0 0 j3 106 45 AM 0 0 0 0 9 1 0 2 0 2 0 3 0 0 17 Total -0 0 �0 1 17 4 0 0 0 6 --�-45 07:00 AM 0 0 0 0 5 2 0 2 0 0 0 7 0 0 16 07:15 AM 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 1 0 2 0 6 0 0 12 07:30 AM 0 0 0 0 1^_ 0 0 1 0 1 0 7 0 0 21 07:45 AM 0 01 0 8 2 0 3 0 0 0 4 0 0 18 ..— Total 0 0 _ .._.._..-1 -..-6-.. ,27 _.5 0.. . 7 6 31 0 24 0 -_.0 - 67 08:00 AM 0 0 1 0 6 2 0 0 0 0 1 4 p p 11 08:15 AM 0 0 0I 0 13 2 0 0 0 0 1 t0 0 0 26 08'30 AM 2 0 0 I 0 5 2 0 1 0 0 0 5 1 0 16 08.45 Atil 0 0 Orr 0 8 I _,0� 3 0 0I 1 9 p p 22 ..._Total _. 2..._...... 0 .....i 0__.... 92 ......7 6 ..... _. . ..28 1 ...._. 0, ....._...__�...- e 09:00 AM 28 09:45 AM 0._ 00 3 0 J7 0-_...__4.13____..9 ....__O _._.. 6 . _.._.[0__.W. .��OI _.._....... 25 09.15 AM 0 0 1I 0 8 2 0 2 0 0 1 4 0 1 1g -III— 01 8 0 3I 2 39 0 1 idij" I og 10:00 AM 0 01 0 9 3 0 1 0 1 0 .5 0 0 20 10:15 AM 0 0 0 0 6 2 0 3 0 0 0 9 0 0 20 10'30 AM 0 0 0 0 5 2 0 1 0 0 0 4 0 0 12 1045 AM 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 6 0 0 9 Total 0..._...__ 0 ........,. 0....._._.. 21 _..7 0 ._._.._ 7 ...._0 i ......._.. 0 24 p_...___ 0 GI Grand Total 3 0 6 16.7 0.5149 33 0 33 0 10 7 142 1 1 386, 13 0 A Total% 30.8 0 61.8 0.3 98.6 8.5 0 I 78.5 0 22.6 I 1.8 36.8 0.3 0.3 I Uunkln Lunula Pc Nos "" " "- - — P Y N r chutta S�uara M,n highland en BlRau!e 10]) H U v�waY prna uY Highland Av n a(Rtalo 107) F m Won Fim Fit _.I_ From Hest j._ .. Fron Nh _ v I _L 1 -[ 1 ._3. 1 _ i C I�r a o RI m n r o L u l -.,1 ,11 Ih 1 l u r,i R.r t rrr t va rTT l u I h 1 1 P�•alHo.r.\nplysiv rrnnea 00 AM to I01�r1.1 P,akloff - -- - Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 09:00 AM 09:00 AM t 0 1 2 0 17 2 0 10 I 1 0 2 3 0 12 0 0 12 36 r 09'15 AM 0 0 I 1 0 8 2 0 10 2 0 0 2 1 4 0 I 6 19 09:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 13 0 0 13 2 0 0 2 0 13 0 0 13 28 09 M15 AM 0 0 1 1 0 9 0 0 9 3 1 t 10 00 11 '25 rolal Vol�nrtr I 1 0 3 .1 0 N i 0 51 (� -8 _ _U_. .3 .- 11 .. 2 _ 39 -_ 0. ..._.1.._ 17 led Apo rota) _ 25 0 75 0 9 .2 7.8 0_ 1 72,7 0 27.3 t8 92.9 0 2.4 _ PHF 250 .000 __750 500 pop ,691 ,500 .000 671 �`fi67 u00 .375 u88 .500 .150 000 .250 808 X50 PRECISION D A T A N/S: Dunkin Donuts/ 1-hrwhorne Square INDUSTRIES,LLC I�i(e [ ame : 1(1235 3 C3 R0,o-tat aerlln.MA n1 Snl F.,' \V`. tate: altl :Avenue (Rtiutc f(17) afn<esae.�etlua9wnsoasns_rala Site Code : 10-03sK(i Cit}', State: Salem, 6L'A au:darerenu¢rIr�2Rnulc enm Start Date : 10/21/2010 Client L.audStrarcgies/ K, Cram Page No : I f ._ Im d PAs mrd Bjey sunkin Donuts/Pup Boys Driveway 1liyhlvul Avenua Route f07 ""'-I ) Hawth me Square Main Driveway Hiyhiand Avenue(Route 707).From flonh _ F m East_ Frnm South _ Fron Wnsl �t rrt TlRI ht ihm� Left PeaRL ht Thru LIR FeIN Right Thru 05.00 AJO p —�.__ 1. . ._ ) f��n I —ae ts0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 00lel0t05:15 A0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 005:30 A0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 005:45 A0 0_ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Tot .. 0 .. 0 _....0 0 0 _�-.._..-.. 0 z..... 0 _.._..0 0 'I 0 0 0 0 ..._.....,_._3. 06:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 p p 2 06'15 AM 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 I 9 06:30 AM 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 5 _06:415 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 q Total 0 0 0 2 0 —`�--�—� 0 -� — b ._._.. 7 Q..__ 0. .._.o_.."-- 2 ZO 07:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 07:15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 07:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 177 15.4M 0 1 0 0 __ 0 I 0 0 0 1 0 0 T6610 'i 0 0 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 1 0 p-- --Z __..._�- 08:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 4 OII.15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 3 '6 08:30 AM 0 0 0 O I 0 0 0 5 0 0 U 1 0 0 0 2 g 08:45 AM 0 0 0 I 0 0 0 1 I 0 0 0 0 0 1 p p 3 .._iotil 0 0. ._O —__n__ 1 ._ . �. _... �..._._-._p-- 0 --._......3 _ 0.......... 2 ..0.. 5L_._._..._.Z i.. 09:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 3 5 09 15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 6 0 0 p 0 '9 09:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4 0 0 0 1 p p p 0 5 09 45 AM U 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I 1 _._. ,..._._. .,. .. .. _.__._ I Total "p"---_0 ..�_._— _.......Q_ p .._.....0. 8 ..._ 0 ._......._0_..0 9 i- ? 10:60 AM o 6 0 2 0 0 o z 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 q 10:15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 1030 ANI 1 0 0 1 0 I 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 p p 5 .......,. 10:45 AILI 1 0 __0 2 0 0 0 ._l. ___._0 -.__. 0 0 ..._.._._0 _ 0 0 ..-_0 0 3 Total U 0 0 5 _—...p..-1 10 0 . Oi 0 2 0-._.._.. p ... 0.-___._O __-__..19 Grand Total I 0 1 0 ,8I 0 2 f 13 0 0 0 23 0 2 0 12 92 APPrah% 0 11.1 0 98.9 0 4.3 2.2 93.5 0 0 0 100 0 1.1,3 0 857 Total% 0 LI 0 87 0 2.2 Li +16.7 0 0 U 251 0 '2.2 0 131 f Dwlkln Donn/Pep Bays Jn nvay ( tl )pj\rd Av nue(a nriel0r) 4inlh�meSlu^r9 t/tn Dmewry-1 )Ilyhlg��{gvanua 107) From North I true Ftt fret Sodh I From Nest I Irt Fir n4 I a.)hl) hqr r ( f�(P f 1 p,r_. R n11 l f'.tri ro 1 F Iv „ fY7n1 l fpry- Peek ru i,it 1 p Is}� P rhtT t�r� t fl rF'eRn 1 e H rAiair3n,jhI oSVe ALIto1 r 0.,51 rc:+kr X11 - Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 08:30 AM 0930 AM D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 5 5 U 0 0 1 1 o 0 0 08 15 AN 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 1 I 0 0 0 0 0 U 2 2 7 00 00 'l 0 0 1) 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 U 0 U 0 0 0 U 2 2 0 0 0 3 3 5 ._09_151\1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 U 0 0 6 _....6 0 0 0 0 0 p rnelvn mr U 0 0 -1 ....�I 0 U 0 - 0 9 ..._.0 0 0 9 g 0 f ._. _ . :.A'p rmn 0 0 0 100 0 0 0 100 0 5- 6 ... ..25. U 0 0 100 U 16.7 0 83.3 _ .1700 ODU 000 250 --- ,r '- 2501 000 AUO 000 LIO 150 1000 000 1 000- 375 375 000 2517 000 417 500 '3"4 PRECISION D A T A N/S: Dunkin DUIIUrS/ ElawthorneScuare INDUSTRIES,LLC I Nile Name : 1(12359 13 L/\ti': Hi,gtllRnd.Avenue (Route IO%) Olfil saa+a i9an1ta:�oasi°si12aa Ena Ldatareouemaspollle com 51TC (.Ul1C 10-U391\(, ( He State:: Luti dem 6L1 Starr Date : 10/21/2010 ( holt LandStrlte.>icsI K. Cram Page No : I PenF u-1 Dunkin-r)--w onNwsVarPop ylh pnoys .:.. Il_ghls._ne Avx_nlEue(R.-Vu�le 1 0/) Ht rwl-hIIFo hO Pain Frnm Easm ay RI)hHi)hl3n Avenue e(Ro ui tet 107) ,OSouth Frro s AnaystinnOS:00 AM 11 10:15 AM Peak loll Lall tTialrtx0� nhrulf _l r,.a Inl.i.�lal Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07:30 AM 22 2 7 31 29 217 28 0 274 21 1 9 31 5 213 5 0 223 559 07:45 AM 23 3 12 38 28 166 53 0 247 32 4 8 •14 7 221 11 2 241 570 08:00 AM 18 5 14 37 26 168 53 0 247 36 1 15 15 204 3 1 223 559 08:15 AM 33 2 13 •18 26 191 51 1 271 44 9 9 62 10 179 8 1 198 iVlal Volume 98 12 46 154 111 742 185 1 1039 133 IS 41 189 --579 %1pp total 62.3 7,8 29.9 _ 10.7 71 A 17 8 0.1 70A 1.9 21.7 4.2 92.3 3.1 0.5 885 22fiT PHF 727 .600 821 _802 957 855 873 .250 ,948 .756 •117 683_ ---- J62 .817 .924 614 500__918 -_ .979 Cars 98 12 14 152 111 703 i79 ----1 994 129 15 M1O 164 35 792 27 •1 858 2188 Gars I00 100 95.7 98.7 100 94.7 96.8 100 95.7 97.0 100 97.6 97.4 94.6 96.9 f00 100 96.9 96.5 llv-IgV codes 0 0 2 2 0 39 6 0 45 4 0 1 5 2 25 0 0 27 79 vl�.•.r✓eral.. 0 0 4.3 1,3 0 5.3 3,2 0 4.3 3.0 0 2.4 2.6 5<{ 3.1 0 0 3.1 3.5 DuoW. 'a"$1 P,lp Boys maway Out In Total t 52 _ J _ 5 _307 2 Right rhru Len _.. _.-_ Peak Hour Data I�ml$ N-ole r t- I 3." io 11 �v..Ninl Nnllh r 1 4.s`�wl Nnl- Peak Hour 0 71ns Vt OLIeA s 22 N.W 11 I �... .I .. CosIJ IWrn6 Lail rt n2 jhf Lle I� 17' I5�1(f(1j 1 I t i;i4 1,7 Cut m fnlsl J PRECISION D A T A S: Ist Street INDUSTRIES,LLC File M;une : lU^_35R �A Iighland Avenue (Route 107) eae6„8m st F.nta cisan 4xmnsnasnua•+R r,x,snxsa,lu° Site (,ode 10-038k<: CIn Statc: Salem, NIA c •mi^,trrp,uuCLD�s St-act Date : 10/21/21)U) Client LandSt (tC,;iCS/ K. Crain Page No : I Ut St VIhItIRI NI bland Aienue Roula tOY -- ( ) ist Streit - Hyhlo dAvanue-(R.09 107) __ Frem East From Sa ilh __ Fmm West SNtl imn -- TMv -- LeR- Rl h1I LaR __ RI hl Thru Int Total ._._ .. _- 3 0 . .J 0.. 05:00 AM 23 0 28. ..— -_....._.__._ _... 05:15 AM 38 0 1 0 054 05:30 AM 51 0 g 31 70 0 2 42 101 ..._.__.----.----...,...,__OS,45AM 58 0 _ 9 _ 0 0 - ..... 122 Tnlal 170 0 19 p --- 2---- 156 __.___.. .____._47 347 06:00 AM 12 0 10 0 1 76 150 O6:I S AM 84 0 22 0 0 89 195 06:30 AM 155 0 30 0 0 147 332 _ O6_45 AM t61 0 37 0 Total l_ ...._.._ 463 -..._._. _.0 ..._ ..--09. 0. ..._._._._—?—._ . 175 _._ . 3 _____ 75 487 1052 07:00 AM 2.10 0 56 0i 208 505 07:15 AM 266 0 39 0 4 217 526 07:30 AM49 0 58 0 2 232 541 07:4.5 AM 251 0 50 _ 0 __ 7 __ 240 Total ___...._. 1006..._. _.._—0 ..203 0 14 897 ..... ....___.__548 2120 08:00 AM 243 0 50 0 3 248 164 08:15 AM 273 0 55 0 2 228 549 08.30 AM 201 0 33 0 3 225 - p 176 0 18 0 1 226 421 retal 893 o I e. o — - 09.00 AM180 0 24 0 4 216 424 09:15 AM 180 0 27 0 3 208 418 0930 AM 227 0 20 0 4 228 479 09 45 AM _ 199 0 210 •141_ ._..Total 786 a -- 98 _.—___O 19......___._...__. 862 _ __._ ��1762 10:00 AM 2430 31 0 6 190 470 10.15 AM 218 0 40 0 6 200 482 10 30 AM 250 0 38 0 5 204 q97 24 0 .......... ...... 1. 198 ...total ._.......... 931 ._ 0 .__._. 133._ _....._......01. .._.... 16 .-._.. 792 . 18715 1 Grand Total 4249 0 706 0 64 4121 9140 Apprch%^ 0 0 100 0 1.5 98.5 ._._..__..._... Total% 46 5 0 7.7 0 0.7 45.1 _.....Cars 4066 _-_....._._.. 0 . -..... __.. ..-..... 6 87 6 61 __,_,__95 7 0 97.3 0 95 3 196 8796 Hr avy Vehicles 103V.__.—.. 0 .__t.9.... .__._0 _...._.-_ 3 ...-..... .._..165 _ %Heavy Vehicles 4.3 0 2.7 0 4 7 d l 370 PRECISION N .LOUSTRIESC File Nmiie 102358 A S: ISt Street L'O.Oue 1018edin,/AA a1SOS !. !!'' Ci./\C`: Ili};hlantl .\t�rnue (Itl,iutelU7) nu�r�so�ulaMnr,r,nasis.u» SRe C.1)lie : 10-113SK(. Vl..�•k J,urcqunrrr'rPdilkmm Smrt Dare 10/21/21m) City,Sh1tc: Salmi, MA Client: ['ngc Ni) 2 L:u1LISira1egie:/ K.Ca:1111 : -- IN9nland Avenue lna ile 107) Iz13tra91 4liptimnA Fronueest 107) From East From South From West �'-� - Fih Ort Thai A TOlal Lit,Total _. t rglaf SS---- �____. .Stan r'nte Toru LeN 1e lobi _iAyM ___ Left App_—. J_ __ _4.._ _ .P�_. L �, -- Peak Hour Analy.,n From I- AM to 1010'.YS AM Peak I of I Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07:30 AM 249 0 249 58 0 58 2 232 274 541 07:45 AM 251 0 251 50 0 50 7 240 247 548 08:00 AM 243 0 2.13 50 0 50 3 248 251 544 08:15 AM 273 o 273 .55, 0 55 2 _.228 230.,. 558 _... total Volume - 1016 0 1018 213 0 213 14 948 982 2'191 _.._.....%APP_Total _.100 _U 1010 ... _._.o 1.5„ 98.5.. __ PHF .930 .000 _930 __ .918 „ ,__:000 .918 ____. 500__ _958 ___956 _982 -` ..._.Cars -�-875- 0 979 210 0 210 14 922 736 2121 %Cars 96.0 0 96.0 98.8 0 98.6 100 97.1 97.1 98.8 Heavy Vehicles 41 0 41 3 0 7 0 26 26 70 %Heavy Vehicl0a 4.0 0 4.0 1.4 0 1.4 0 2.1 2.7 7.2 1 PRECISION D A T A 5: lst tirrea t INouSTRIES,LLC File Name : 102358 A I!O.Onx101 A11IIn.M.1 01501 PfighbrldAVCnnC (Route f07) o:n<c:;ee48n999F,.:50854Gu14 Site C.ode : 10-03SK(:; en�edn.,r�a9erl,�naek`0m Start 1)atc 10/Zf/20fU (:itv,Strtc: Snlcul, MA Client I.aud5trth, ics/ 1<. ("MITI No : l Groins Pdnled Cvs _ _ – Rn)blandAionue(Routo107) 1st Street HI{bland Soo.W.nt 107) From East From Soulh FromW st �rart time thm.I Lek Right r—��tt ... Rq0 _ thru._._.._ InL Tnral 0 3 0 0 25 50', 05:15 AM 36 0 1 0 0 27 64 05:30 AM 48 0 6 0 2 37 93' 05:45 AM _52 0 __—.—_....8 _-0 _ 0 .—__.._. .52. ._....—_.___112. Total --- 158 0 18 0 2 141 :319' 10 o 1 14 145 8 Igo OG IM _._.._,._.. _. 60 ....._..__ .0. 35 _0 2..__..__.___l724731— _ 360 ..--10161 U6 15 AM 82 0 !6 1 Ob 4TAM 414 Q1-" - -- 9 0 0 141 721 07:00 AM 236 0 54 0 0 109 489 07:15 AM 259 0 38 0 4 210 511 07:30 AM 237 0 58 0 2 227 524. 07:45 AM 243 0 40 __.-...._.___—.1 _._ 7 `.__.233 __._..__ 531 —,--Total 975 0 198 0 13 869 2055 08:00 AM 235 0 50 0 3 243 531 O9 15 AM 260 0 >4 0 2 219 535 I 08 30 AM 193 0 31 0 3 220 447 08.45 AM 164 0 '_-.18 0 1 _....._.._ 214 __ 397, _..-. ?olal I ......._.852 ......_._ ....__. 153 0 9 890 _..1910' 09:00AM l 172 0 24 0 4 202 402 09:15 AM 170 0 26 0 I 3 201 400 0 19 0 L 3 213 4-47 09:30 AM 212 ._ ._... Total ...._____.._745 __._�..._.0. 93...... . .........01 ............._ 16 . id 815 ......._ ._--1667 0945 AM 189 0 24 0 6 1! 18 9 416 10:00 AM233 0 29 0 6 184 452 10:15 AM 209 0 40 0 fi 189 I 444 10 30 AM 142 0 38 0 5 199 I` 484 10:45 AM1 ._..-.......210 --......._ 0 -_..... _.22..._ ._.._.0 1 T�ttal 894 0 129 0 18 T62I 1807 Grand Total 4066 0 687 01 61 3950 8770 Apprch% 100 0 100 0 1.5 98.5 Total% 46.4 0 7.8 0 0.7 45.1 "- .....H lhnnU Avenge ltof le lU/) - IlSliael _ T —Ileihla ue(Ro 0100 -- ' rt 1 oven W L From Eat From South From.',Vst I_rc I, P.D.lot ll R gi r l ndlj ( p4 ii ur.4r ay>aMcm O5�0U 46110 IoA5AMI-Peat lot Peak Hour for Entire Intersecllon Begins at 07:30 ANI 07:30 AM 237 0 2371 58 0 58' 2 227 2:9 524 0745 AM 2'13 U 243 48 0 =188 7 233 240 531 1 08:00 AM 235 U 235 50 0 50 3 243 216 531 U8'.I5 AM _ 260 .__._ 54 0 .54 2 219 221 _535_ total Volulne ~ 975 0 975 210 0 210 -14 922 9361 2121 A rot Tl __,__100 _._ 0 100 0 1.5 98.5 PP— — - -- PHF 938 .000 .l38 .905 .000 :905 500 _ 919 _ __..951 _991 PRECISION D A i A INDUSTRIES,LLC hie Naote : 102355 iA S: I5t Street no.eo,ant 0e11m,41A WSW EAV: [lighland Avenue (ROLIte 107) "'OEn;i%addUevuE.N,:S095 4 U1 1 3 e Site Code : I0-038 K(. Ci State: Salem, 1M A Statt Dme : 10/21/2010 ci t Client: l.:trulStrategics/ K. Cram Page No __. Groups Prinmd tR Ist stueet ...IoeOtt HI9hlantl Aven West 10 i) hr1. Ili lh T hems-lRouhe107) D D D -...-- -! 5 Toth Fmm Cast hIT— ILnO _-Thm LgX J -- - 05.00 AM 05:15 AM 2 D 0 0 0 05:30 AM 3 0 05:45 AM __ ......... 6. _._ 0 -_ ..__..._ 0-"`--- 3 __._...._ 1_0 12. 0 __....._ _. _..'.__'-. -6'- p 15 28 06:00 AM 3 0 0 00 2 5 0615 AM 2 0 0 0� 0 3 5 O6 30 AM D 1 0 0 0 6 11 6.45 AM, 10 0 2 0 0 3 15. ._Total 19 0 3 0 0 14 .-.36 16 15 07 00 AM 4 0 2 0 _._...__....� 28 0715 AM 7 0 9 -00I 0 7 07 30 AM 12 0 2 0 0 _ r �. 0 0 0 5 1 Tdtal 31 0 08:00 AM 8 0 0 0 0 5 13 08:15 AM 13 0 1 0 0 9 23 08:30 AM 8 0 2 0 0 5 15 08:45 AM12 _......_.. 0 -_..---'-� --------- 0 1° _..-.....__._....__ ...__..... ...._..._ 0 _._..-75 09:00 APA8 0 0 0 0 14 22 09'15 AM to 0 1 0 0 7I 'Id 09.30 AM 15 0 1 0I 1 15 32 D9:45 AM 10 0 1 0 ....._-- 1 . --- 47 95 1000 AM 10 U 2 0 0 6 18 1015 AM 1 0 0 0 0 11 18 1030 AM 8 0 0 O) 0 5 13 10'45 AM -.._.__..._._12 .__..__. 0. __.._2 D 0_.....—_�__8.. _ ._._._....22.. ........ .............__ "Total 37 q Y1 ,. Grand Total I 183 0 10 0 3 165 370 Apprch 16 100 0 100 0 1.8 98.2 Total% 49.5 0 5.1 0 0.8 44.6 _- -'- - III�hM1�Avem. -ulg I07) Fr riva Ist 1071 o Swt - J From East From Souln From West - Start Time Thm l LaX l_ ADp_TOIiI C Riyhl]_-, LBH[ App tool Rl:lit[ __ Thru_[ App Tutal i,__ InL!"lal,[ TRN HO r Analysts From 05 110 AAI t0 10A5 AIA-Peak 1 Jt 1 Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 08:45 AM I2 0 0 0 0 - 12 12 2i 08:45 AM 12 0 09:00 AM 8 0 8 0 0 0 0 14 1-1 22 09:1 AM 10 0 IU 1 0 1 0 7 7 ID 09:30 AM IS 0 ..___._. 15 _.__.1.____—� . .._.._.__..�.. _1__.—_..15 _._16 ..._.__- 12 .- __.. _. J5 2 0 2I I 18 •19 'J6 'r Total Vulwne 45 0 2 98 vj App.Total 100 0 100 0 -.. - -- PHf .150 .000 .750 .500 .000 .500� :250 .tl00 _ .766 _ .750 i rc PRECISION D A T A St:eer INOusTRIE5,1.1-C File Name : t02353 rA ill).3�u101 nedm,mn ors0e L'/\V: f Ili ltland Avenue (Kt'rutC l07) arar�:;na,l8r-�o99 r„rSrlx,ws 1204 Site Code t0-038Kc Emelt:dmamnu 01,MAA 01501 013', State: Salem, MA Start Date : 10/21/'2010 (lcnt LamlStratcgics/ K. Caant Page No : I 0roupf Pr nttd Peds and Oicrilef ilyhPfnd F om F(Routs 109) Ism Soot Highland Ave.vVla t le IU7) FIOm Fasi Fmm South Frnm YVest ..glad AM _ rr r T -!,: _.yi dl�)-_`=rTt - anis - al'<�hL_ Fn�l,( _w1 eas. hv rgh1, 05:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 - 0 0 0 05:15 AM 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 05:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 ---05:45 AM ..--.._0_.��_ .__a.. ._. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 total ----- - 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 ..-.._...0 6--------Z- 06:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06:15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 2 06:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 06.45 AM,_ �.____..--.. ...Q__._____0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total 0 0 0 0 0 --.-. 2 Q---._.__O_._._.0 _._..._-._.. 2 07:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 07:15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 - _--_0 _- - 0 ----- I 07:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 _ 07:45 AM - 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 0 .. . 08:00 AM 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 '2 08 15 AM 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 08:30 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 08:45 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -........ -...-... Total...._---.. ......i _-___. -... 0_.....____ U 0 0 ,- 2 .............0 .-_._......-..-1 -._.-_- 0 ...-......._-....-1 0900 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 09 15 AM 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 09 30 AM U 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 __0945 AM 0 0 _ 0 0 0 1 0 0 . ,,0( 1 _._...— _._._,._._ I Total . 0 _. 0 0 ._._..-..- 0 0 g Q--._....-0 . - - 0 _-____.-__-5. 1000 AM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1015 AM 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 2 10 )0 AM I 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1015 AM 0 0 D 0 0 2 0 0 0 2 Total2 0 0 ...._-. 0 ................ 0 .___. 3 ...._.. 0 -....--.._0- --.—._..._0 _-.....-.-...5 Grand Total 4 0 O I 1 0 16 0 1 0 22 App, ch°'0 too 0 0 5.9 0 94.1 0 100 0 Total% 18.2 0 0 4.5 0 72.7 0 4.5 0 -- -Hl9nhn lAv melF�oul 101) � Isl at"rent � HUI Innl A2unuo fRsl _ F n n East Fr i i 4purh Flow Nest I, Skirt rm0 ihN I_ JR I f'r 1 App_.Tulnl. '1_. �nft- l R { 15�,t(fp, rohl ,Rlglrl.,� fr m t ..,.- f f¢f Appr I -h 1 �olal_l P.A HwrMnlysus FromOF,)O AM 10 o:45 A.1 Pdekt ifi Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07.30 AM0 0 0 01 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0 07:45 AM 1 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 2 08:00 APA. 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 I 0 1 1 2 _. 09:15�1P.1. -_'—I _ f)_--- 0 ..-._..1 ..P_... 0_ -,--_ 1 _ I 0 0 0 0 2 Total volume 2 0 6 2 6 0 S 3 0 1— 0 - ....._ 1 ..-.__ -__3 ',,App.Total 1 100 0 0 _ 0 0 100 0 100 0 _ PhIF ,500 000 .000 ��500 .000 0U0 750 .7J0 1 .000 150 000 250 - .750 PRECISION D A T A S: IS[ Srrcct INDUSTRIES.LLCile N;unc : 102358 ;1 er•.oat 101 50,a MA m s0i C/V` ': I-119111and ,Accnue (Route 107) orate a08,4aI"199 r.,.:M.54s¢34 Site Code 10-0581<c(.il?l, 5tute: Salem, NIAEm�IP&tureRuntscspolllcmrn Starr [date tO/21/^_U10 Client [..nnd8tcaecgies/ K. Qa°T Page N o : 1 - Hlq - - hnA AvenuO(RJ 10101) hlane Avenin(Roma 07) _- 'I sI SlrOet HI Ih a, Frorn Fast _ t rn_m Sm lm From WV t Slml time -__ Thm _.__ Lon --. PN 9 j r A T>til .. PI hl .,_t,eh I Fpp. rotnl _ Hight ThrU A_.._..Tnlal inl,r01nJ POak I/Our Malysis prom OSa70 Ahl la tO SIS��M--Pe.'rk Inll ��_— R Peak Hour for Entire Intersection Begins at 07:30 AM 07:30 AM 249 0 249 58 0 58 2 232 234 541 07:45 AM 251 0 251 50 0 50 7 240 247 548 08:00 AM 243 0 243 50 0 50 3 248 251 544 ._08.15 AM 273 (l, __.__... 273. __._ 55..____._._.. 8________ 55 ___-_.___-?__229 ....._.___234 558 Total Volume __-1018 ---- - p�_ 1016 213 0 213 14 940 962 21st _°r4 APP Total 100 0 _ 100 0 _,-__ 1.5 98.5 PHF ___ 930'_ A00 __,930_ _.918---.000------- 918- .500 .958 ---- .958 ____882 Cars 9.0 0 9.0 8.6 0 8.6 14 922 9.3 2121 %9 Cars s8.0 0 98.0 98.8 0 98.8 100 97.3 97.3 98.8 Heavy Vehicles 41 0 41 3 0 3 0 28 28 70 Heavy Vehicles 4.0 0 4.0 1.4 0 1.4 0 2.7 2,7 3.2 I Peak Hour Data ylrl IEE I ... .- ' . Prvak Hour rla0me a(47 30.Ah � 21� m I I� Can; r- 1 ( 30 .�m I I/ 1-11 Right r 0 210 I _ Rr till ,; Rll --1•'' 7 I ! 1 glt22i Out In rouI i Seasonal Adjustment Worksheets SECTION 1-CONTINUOUS COUNTING STATION MONTHLYAVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC STATION 35-BEVERLY-RTE.128-NORTH OF BRIMBLE AVENUE YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 40,000 42.7220 43,414 47,496 49,010 55,111 54,830 54,453 49,541 46,632 46,086 44,140 47,7843 0% -5% 4% -3% 2% -5% -2% -1% 1% 5% 0% 1% 0% 06 40,160 40,405 45,147 46,084 50,124 52,245 53,561 54.000 49,983 48,920 46,034 44,596 47,605 5% 5% -2% -1% 2% -596 0% 1% 1% 0% -1% -7% 0% 07 42,000 42,541 44,243 45,757 50,896 49,531 53,663 54,422 50,516 49,004 45,465 41,565 47,4,37 1% -2% -5% 1% -4% 2% -6% -8% -8% -14% -14% -3% -5111. 08 42,261 41,630 42,213 46,145 48,637 50,306 50,358 50,045 46,660 41,991 39,012 40,257 44,960 -81/1 0% 9% 1% 0% -2% 2% -4% -2% 15% 12% 4% 09 39,011 41,648 46,000 46,511 48,741 49,470 51,273 - 48,153 45,721 48,212 43,754 41,813 45,859 STATION 550-PEABODY-RTEA-NORTH OF LOWELL ST. 234,759 233,0'76 YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 42,000 41,328 41,928 46,353 47,000 45,000 43,207 43,133 44,632 44,742 43,480 43,557 43,663 06 -3% -1% 5% -3% -7% 2% -1% 2% -1% -2% -2% 1% -1% 40,910 40,568 43,840 44,805 43,655 45,703 42,838 44,074 44,277 44,022 42,524 43,890 43,459 '-5% -1% -3% 4% 8% 3% 3% 1% -1% 1% 1% -5% 00% 07 38,866 40,669 42,661 43,204 466,954 47,202 44,243 44,521 43,975 44,388 42,915 41,485 43,425 4% 0% -1% 3% -3% -3% -1% -2% 0% 1% -1% 0% 0% O8 40,432 40,617 42,102 44,626 45.673 45,559 43,651 43,782 43,893 44,663 42,446 41,581 43,252 -1% 2% 00% -1% -1% -1% 0% -2% 0% -1% -2% 0% -190 09 40.000 41,446 41,996 44,100 45,374 44,907 43,496 42,968 44,065 44,345 41,766 41,591 43.005 STATION 555-LYNNFIELD-RTE.1.95(128)-SOUTH OF PEABODY C.L. 222.760 217.004 YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 07 110,037 110,533 116,022 98,943 123,989 132,918 114,422 117,773 102,313 F---ly4.ZM F---1 4,M102,580 113,000 11 ,578 STATION 4121 -WAKEFIELD-RTEJ-95(128)-NORTH OF MAIN ST.,LYNNFIELD YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR OS 121,060 123,706 126,123 131,584 133,994 141,724 141,915 144,207 132,848 129,681 127,645 120,655 131,257 -1% -2% 2% -3% 0% -2% -1% 1% 3% 5% 2% 7% 1% 06 119,913 120,945 129,096 127,666 133,642 139,442 140,232 144,990 137,237 136,029 129,586 128,662 132,287 3% 0% -2% 2% 3% 1% -1% -1% -1% 1% 0% -8% 090 07 123,351 120,806 126,808 129,816 137,203 140,469 139,311 143,711 136,527 136,892 129,084 118,600 131,882 1% -3% -4% -2% -3% -4% 46% -4% 3% -3% 08 119,901 119,664 121,000 130,595 132,990 135,156 137,048 138,854 131,468 129.000 124,118 121,830 128,469 4% 6% 2% 2% 1% 2% 1% 2% 3% 4% 8% -5% 2% 09 124,527 126,780 123,641 132,958 133,890 137.601 138,343 141,803 135,433 134,159 134,042 116,062 131,605 STATION 5059-LYNNFIELD-RTE.1-95(128)-SOUTH OF WALNUT ST. YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 123,000 124,429 126,076 132,009 133,651 142.230 143,487 143,923 134,619 130,383 128,237 123,088 132,093 -29, -3% 2% -29'0 1% -2% -2% 3% 8% 4% 1% 20% do 06 120,114 121,263 128,965 129,608 134,368 140,019 141,022 148,631 144,809 136,084 129,832 125,931 133,587 -2% 0% -2% 0% 2% 0% -1% -4% -5% 4% -1% -8% -1% 07 117,133 121,846 126,992 129,596 137,538 140,559 139,001 143,187 138,210 140,904 128,461 116,088 131,626 0% -4% -5% 1% -2% -3% -2% -5% -5% -8% -3% 1% -34.0 08 116,752 116,844 121,000 130,257 135,050 135,960 136,783 135,786 131,841 i%9.000 124,210 117,217 127,558 536,371 524,666 fTe,,S=esrun�-EO D�Tm A-V,DT - - - - Page 1 of 1 -- - _ - - - - Crash Data Worksheets 71 I; if -11 if if I I I if a # if_ 1 11 11 JI il.72 51 17-r 5 1505 15 N is if it I If U I I I J 1 It t It as pit W 'F vo It If I E-111f till I I lof 11 1111 lilt Ifil It 111 N, Y V I F S I v S? s Y y y y I 71 It ul It f I It • L' i . eft � r f, k t: Ia; a kN �� a aVol w 'A ap_p AT i :5' ? s'' lid 5i IIA" '. Hilla a 1 i d d l d t sS If c A <i it. 9 69 ifai4 � l f! tl�gp -ill i1 1191 It a Hill ill it M IL111 Jul 11j,l } 1t4 It S 1 Y j 1:6, f 1I f}} .il,sI ARM ¢Hilt $ l ; it � � ! 1 !� i�:etti�ir tis; ;itsitsi�;e; { " in x i� ie• ig (u 3 Pn =.a is• n n,li eis,� t;rri+id :Ir,.!ti� :r,grl1 tNil ry'1 Ae r g 1tg1�4 r1�1P ,1 VIA T p Al LLL L C ii`q {S. d)4 .]9 �9 pyjyjyj�q ,li � r � ; 1 , phi � � ;� •'� � � � }� I1 o�, n n o n u n - •� e i u o t f 4 il, f, �7 3 � r r � a •i a 5 A of jf t aft tfsal �gf ti Ii_ iia 7f9 n ai = +�� aa4 ii ,�a }iia '4(% so s v 1; 1 r a a v a r �' 'i°� ig v s" to �c : 1n 91 i it it I i1 f id iQ ! i1 ii iQ } i iQ Ii _til�I ii i� �� io �i Vii! fl U10 fit sit c l ,41; ,Qi �i a i . s� J'' f►! ; f4Q 1.1 f fQ it fit!411 1t .l ! i i trt.} i i ; Jill ur i ; i CRASH RATE WORKSHEET CITY/TOWN : Salem, MA COUNT DATE : Oct-10 MHD USE ONLY DISTRICT: 4 UNSIGNALIZED : SIGNALIZED : X Source#� - INTERSECTION DATA - ............................................_._.....................................................................; MAJOR STREET : Highland Avenue ST# MINOR STREET(S) : Marlborough Road/Trader's Way ST# ST# ST# ST# O INTERSECTION North " INTERSECTION DIAGRAM REF# (Label Approaches) Peak Hour Volumes APPROACH : 1 2 3 4 5 Total Entering DIRECTION : EB WB NB SB Vehicles VOLUMES (AM) : 1,247 834 389 718 3,188 " K " FACTOR : 0.073 APPROACH ADT : 43,671 ADT=TOTAL VOLI"K"FACT. TOTAL# #OF AVERAGE ACCIDENT F: 49 YEARS : ACCIDE TS (A ) : 16.33 ............................................................................................................ CRASH RATE CALCULATION : 1.02 RATE = I A- 1.000,000) (ADT-365) Comments : CRASH RATE WORKSHEET CITY/TOWN : Salem, MA COUNT DATE : Oct-10 MHD USE ONLY DISTRICT: 4 UNSIGNALIZED : �� SIGNALIZED : I� " Source#� INTERSECTION DATA .................................. MAJOR STREET: Highland Avenue ST# MINOR STREET(S): Hawthorne Square Driveway/PEP Boys ST# ST# o ST# C] ST# INTERSECTION North INTERSECTION DIAGRAM (Label Approaches) REF# C7 Peak Hour Volumes APPROACH : jiE2 4189if 5 Total DIRECTION : Entering Vehicles VOLUMES (AM) : 2,234 " K " FACTOR : 0.073 APPROACH ADT: 30,603 ADT=TOTAL VOU"K"FACT. TOTAL#OF #OF AVERAGE #OF ACCIDENTS : YEARS : ACCIDENTS (A ) : F2,67 .............................. CRASH RATE CALCULATION : 0.24 RATE _ (A ' 1.000.000) (ADT'365) Comments : CRASH RATE WORKSHEET CITY/TOWN : Salem, MA COUNTDATE : Oct-10 MHO USE ONLY DISTRICT: 4 UNSIGNALIZED : �� SIGNALIZED : Source# '.INTERSECTION DATA . . . . ........................................... MAJOR STREET: Highland Avenue ST a MINOR STREET(S) : First Street ST a C� ST# o ST# ST N O INTERSECTION North INTERSECTION DIAGRAM (Label Approaches) REF k C� r p Peak Hour Volumes APPROACH : PE84-1 2 3 4 jj DIRECTION : WB—7NB SB VOLUMES (AM) : 979 1,027 213 0 i " K " FACTOR : 0.073 APPROACH ADT : r 30,397 ADT=TOTAL VOLT"K"FACT, TOTAL AVERAGE h!OF ACIDENTS : YEARS : a ACCIDENTS (A) : 1.33 ..................................................................... CRASH RATE CALCULATION : 0.12 RATE _ (A• 1.000,000) (ACT'J65) Comments : 'rraftic Growth Data SECTION I-CONTINUOUS COUNTING STATION MONTHLY AVERAGE DAILY TRAFFIC STATION 35-BEVERLY-RTE.128-NORTH OF EPRABLE AVENUE YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 40.000 42,720 43,414 47,496 49,010 55,111 54,830 54,453 49,541 0% -5% 4% -3% 20/ _5;p 46.632 46,086 41,140 47,786 06 40,160 40,405 45,147 46. '2% -1% 1°l0 5°l0 040 l96 p?.084 50.124 52,215 53,561 54,000 49,983 48,920 46,034 41,596 17,6055 07 42,000 42,541 44,243 45,757 50,896 S% 0°.6 1% 1% 0% 4% ,56 041. 49,531 53,663 51,-8% 50,516 4-14% 4-14% 41,565 47,467 1% -2% -5% 1%0 -490 2% -G°i -8% -8% -1490 -1490 08 42,261 41,630 42,213 46,145 48,637 50,306 50,358 50,045 46,660 41,991 39,012 40,257 -8% 0% 9% 1% 0% -2% 2% -4% -2% -14,980 09 39,011 41,648 46,000 46,511 48,741 49,470 51,273 48,153 45,721 15 i0 12% 4`i° 2% 44.212 43,754 41,813 45,859 STATION 550-PEABODY-RTE.1-NORTH OF LOWELL ST. 2005 to 2009 Growth= _4.0329% YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 42,000 41,328 41,928 46,353 47,000 45,000 43,207 43,133 44,632 44,742 43,480 43,557 43,663 -3% -1% 5% -3% -7% 2% -1% 2% -1% -2% -2% 1% 06 40,910 40.968 43,840 44,805 43,655 45,703 42,838 44,074 44,277 44,02 42,524 43,890 43,459 -5% -191 -3% -4% 8% 3% 3% 1% -l% 1% 1%° -5% 096 07 38,886 40,669 42,661 43204 46,954 47,202 44,243 44,521 43,975 44,388 42,915 41,48525 4/0 0% -1% 3% -3% -3% -1% -2% 0% 1% -1% 0% 43,4_0 08 40,432 40,617 42,102 44,626 45,673 45,559 43,651 43.782 43,893 44,663 42,446 41,581 43,252 -1% 2% 0% -1% -1% -1% 0% -2% 040 09 40,000 41.446 41,996 44,100 45,374 44,907 43,496 42,968 44,065 44,345 41,766 41,591 43,005 STATION 595-LYNNFIELD-RTE.1-95(128)-SOUTH OF PEABODY C.L. 2005 to 2009 Growth= -1.9580% 07 YJAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 110 037 110,533 11 6.022 98,943 123,989 132.918 114,422 117,773 102,31E3 124,000 102,580 113.000 113,878 STATION 4121-WAKEFIELD-RTE.1-95(128)-NORTH OF MAIN ST.,LYNNFIELD YR JAN FE6 MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 05 121,000 123,706 126,123 131,584 133,994 141,724 141,915 144,207 132,848 129,681 127,645 120,655 131,257 -1% -2% 2% -3% 0% -2% -1% 1°/ 3% 5% 2% 7% 1% r6 119,913 120,945 129,096 127,666 133,642 139,442 140,232 144,990 137,237 136,029 129,586 128,662 132,287 3% 0% -2% 2% 3% 1% -1% -1% -1% 1% 0% 07 123,351 120,806 126,808 129,810" 137,203 140,469 139,311 143,711 136,527 136,892 129,084 118,600 131,882 -3% -140 -5% 1% -3% -4% -2% -3% A% -6 -4% 3% -3% 08 119,901 119,664 121,000 130,595 132,90 135,156 137,048 138,854 131,468 129,000 124,118 121,830 128,469 0 09 124,527 126,780 123,0641 132,958 133,890 137,601 138,343 141,803 135,433 134.159 134,042 116,082 131.605 STATION 5099-LYNNFIELD-RTEA-95(128)-SOUTH OF WALNUT ST. 2005 to 2009 Growth= 0.2652% YR JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC YEAR 0 123,000 124,429 126,076 132,009 133,651 142,230 143,487 143,923 134,619 130,383 128,237 123,088 132,094 -2% -3% 2% -2% 1% -2% -2% 3% 8% 4% 1% 2% 1% 06 120,114 121,263 128,965 129,608 134,368 140,019 141,022 148,631 144,809 136,084 129,832 125,931 133,387 -2% 0% -2% 0% 2% 0% -1% 4% -5% 4% -1% -8% -1% 07 117,133 121,846 126,992 129,596 1337,538 140,559 139,01 143,187 138,210 140,904 128,461 116,088 131,626 08 116,70% 116,844 121000 130,257 135,050 135,960 136,783 135,786 131,841 129,000 124.210 117,217 127,558 2005 to 2008 Growth= -3.433990 Average Gro.Th = cSTR-ATO:SAT. 'Paged of - - - - - MART Proposed Retail, Salem MA Land Use Code (LUC) 814 - Specialty Retail Center Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) - 8th Edition Average Vehicle Trips Ends vs.: 1,000 Sq. Feet Gross Floor Area [ndependent Variable(X): 22.02 ksf AVERAGE WEEKDAY DAILY T= 44.32 * (X) T = 44.32 * 22.02 T= 975.93 T= 976 vehicle trips with 50% ( 483 vpd)entering and 50% ( 488 vpd) exiting. WEEKDAY MORNING PEAK HOUR OF Adjacent Street Traffic(No Data) T= 1.032 '1 (X) (Rate based on ratio of AM/Daily for LUC 820 to Daily Rate for LUC 814) 'f= 1.032 * 22.02 r = 22.73 f= 23 vehicle trips with 6l%( 14 vph) entering and 39% ( 9 vph)exiting. WEEKDAY EVENLYG PEAK HOUR OF ADJACEN'r STREET TRAFFIC T= 2.71 * (X) "f= 2.71 * 22.02 T= 59.67 I = 60 vehicle trips with 44% ( 26 vpli) entering and 561/0 ( 34 vph)exiting. SATURDAY DAILY T= 42.04 * (X) T= 42.04 * 22.02 T= 925.72 T= 926 vehicle trips with 50% ( 463 vpd) entering and 50% ( 463 vpd)exiting. SATURDAY MIDDAY PEAK HOUR OF GENERATOR(No Data) T = 3.6518 " (X) (Rate based on ratio of PNI/Daily ror LUC 920 to Sat Daily Rate for LUC 314) T= 3.6518 * 22.02 T= 80.4[ T= 80 vehicle trips with 52'%( 42 vph)entering and 48% ( 38 vph)exiting. 3 I l-R:nes < e9k [fill, Salem, iIVIA Lund Use Code (LUC) 210 - Single-Family Detached housing Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) - 8th Edition Average Vehicle'rrips Ends vs: Dwelling units Independent Variable(X): 23 LaT=0.92Ln(X) + 2.71 R2 =0.96 LnT=0.92 Ln 23 +(2.71) La T=5.59 T= 263.93 'r= 263 vehicle trips with 50% ( 134 vpd) entering and 50%( 134 vpd)exiting. WEEKDAY MORNING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET TRAFFIC T= 0.70 " (X)+ 9.74 R'=0.96 T= 0.70 0 23 + (9.74) 'r= 25.34 'r= 26 vehicle trips with 25% ( 7 vph) entering and 75%( 19 vph)exiting. WEEKDAY EVENING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET"TRAFFIC LnT=0.90Ln(X)-F0.51 R'=0.9t LnT=0.90Ln 7 + (0.51) LaT=3.33 T= 27.99 'r= 23 vehicle trips with 63%( 13 vph) entering and 37%( 10 vph) exiting. SATURDAY DAILY Ln'r=0.95 Ln (X) + 2.59 R'=0.92 LrT=0.95 Ln 7 + (2.59) Ln T=5.57 'r= 262.10 'r= 262 vehicle trips with 50% ( 131 vpd) entering and 50% ( 131 vpd) exiting. SATURDAY MIDDAY PEAK HOUR OF GENERATOR T= 0.39 * (X) F 9.56 R1=0.91 T= 0.39 ' 23 + (9.56) 'T= 30.03 T= 30 vehicle hips with 53% ( 16 vph)entering and 47% ( 14 vph)exiting. Sunday Daily 'r= 3.34 * (X) - 13.31 R`= 0.94 T = 3.34 * 23 - 13.3t 210-1.1NFIS i Hill, Salem, MA Land Use Code (LUC) 210- Single-Family Detached housing Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE)- 8th Edition Average Vehicle Trips Fnds vs: Dwellins units Independent Variable (X): 23 T = 190.01 T= 190 vehicle trips tvith 5o%( 95 vpd)entcring mid 50%( 95 vpd) exiting. Sunday, Peak Hour of Generator LnT=091 Lit(X)+0.35 R" = 0.37 LnT=0.91 Ln 23 +0.35 LnT= 3.'_0 'r= 24.61 I'= 25 vehicle trips with 53`/.,( 13 vph)entering and 47%( 12 vph)exiting. 210-UNrI'S 405 Highland Avenue, Salem, NIA Land Use Code (LUC) 210 - Single-Family Detached housing Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (rm) - Sth Edition Average Vehicle'rrips Ends vs: Dwelling units Independent Variable(X): I l Ln T=0.92 Ln(X)+ 2.71 R''=0.96 Ln T=0.92 Ln 11 +(2.71) Lu T=4.92 T= 136.46 T= 136 vehicle trips with 50%( 68 vpd)entering and 50%( 68 vpd)exiting. WEEKDAY NIORNING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET TRAFFIC 'r= 0.70 * (X) +9.74 R'` =0.96 T= 0.70 * 11 + (9.74) T= 17.44 T= 17 vehicle trips with 25%( 4 vph)entering and 75%( 13 vph)exiting. WEEKDAY EVENING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET TRAFFIC Ln'r=0.90 Ln(X)+0.51 R,=0.91 LnT=0.90 Ln 7 + (0.51) Ln T=2.67 T= 14.41 "r= 14 vehicle trips with 63%( 9 vph)entering and 37% ( 5 vph)exiting. SATURDAY DAILY Ln'r=0.95 Ln(X) + 2.59 R'=0.92 Ln.T=0.95 Ln 7 +(2.59) La T=4.87 T= 130.06 'r= 130 vehicle trips with 50%( 65 vpd)entering and 50% ( 65 vpd) exiting. SATURDAY MIDDAY PEAK [[OUR OF GENERATOR 'r= 0.89 *(X)+9.56 R'=0.91 "r= 0.89 '" 11 x (9.56) 'r= 19.35 ,r= 19 vehicle trips with 53% ( 10 vph)entering and 47% ( 9 vph) exiting. Sunday Daily T= 8.84 * (X) - 13.31 R`' =0.94 'r= 8.84 * II - 13.31 210-UNITS Osborne Hills, Salem, INIA Land Use Code (LUC) 210 - Single-Family Detached housing Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) - 8th Edition Average Vehicle Trips Ends vs: Dwelling units Independent Variable(X): 119 Ln T=0.92 Ln(X)+ 2.71 R`=0.96 LnT=0.92 Ln 119 +(2.71) LnT=7.1t 'r= 1220.23 T= 1,220 vehicle trips with 50%( 610 vpd)entering and 50% ( 610 vpd) exiting. WEEKDAY MORNING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREE'F'FRAFFIC 'r= 0.70 '" (X) + 9.74 Rz=096 T= 0.70 * 119 +(9.74) T= 93.04 T = 93 vehicle trips with 25%0( 23 vph)entcring and 75%( 70 vph) exiting. WEEKDAY EVENING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET TRAFFIC Ln'r=0.90 Ln(X)+0.51 R'=0.91 LnT=090 Ln 7 + (0.51) Ln T=4.51 T= 122.83 'r= 123 vehicle trips with 63%( 77 vph) entering and 37%( 46 vph)exiting. SATURDAY DAILY LnT=0.95 Ln (X)+2.59 R-=0.92 Ln 'r=0.95 Ln 7 + (2.59) Ln'r=7.13 T= 1249.09 'r= 1,250 vehicle trips with 50%( 625 vpd)entering and 50%( 625 vpd)exiting. SATURDAY MIDDAY PEAK HOUR OF GF,NERA'rOR T= 0.89 * (X)+ 9.56 R,= 0.91 'r= 0.89 * 119 F (9.56) 'F= 115.47 T= 115 vehicle trips with 53% ( 61 vpli) entering and 47% ( 54 vph) exiting. Sunday Daily T= S.34 '" (X) - 13.31 RL = 0.94 T= 3.84 '" 119 - 13.31 210-UMTS Chapel Hill, Salem, INIA Land Use Code (LUC) 210 - Single-Family Detached housing Source: Institute of Transportation Engineers (ITE) - 8th Edition Average Vehicle'rrips Ends vs: Dwelling units Independent Variable(X): 26 Ln'r=092 Ln (X) + 2.71 R`=0.96 Ln T=0.92 Ln 26 + (2.71) Ln T=5.71 T= 301.10 T= 302 vehicle trips with 50%( 151 vpd) entering and 50% ( 151 vpd)exiting. WEEKDAY MORNING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET'rRAFFIC T= 0.70 * (.X)+9.74 R'=0.96 T= 0.70 * 26 +(9.74) T= 27.94 'r= 23 vehicle trips with 25%( 7 vph)entering and 75%( 21 vph) exiting. WEEKDAY EVENING PEAK HOUR OF ADJACENT STREET TRAFFIC Ln'r=0.90I.a (X)+0.51 R-'=0.91 Ln'r=0.90 Ln 7 +(0,51) L.nT=3.44 'l'= 31.26 r= 31 vehicle trips with 63%( 20 vph)entering and 3TYo( 11 vph)exiting. SATURDAY DAILY Ln T=0.95 Ln(X)+ 2.59 Rz =0.92 Ln T=0.95 La 7 + (2.59) Ln T=5.69 T= 294.47 T= 294 vehicle trips with 50%( 147 vpd) entering and 50% ( 147 vpd) exiting. SATURDAY MIDDAY PEAK HOUR OF GENERATOR "r= 0.39 * (X)+ 9.56 R" =0.91 T= 0.39 * 26 + (9.56) 'r= 32.70 T= 33 vehicle trips with 53'Yo( 17 vph) entering and 47% ( 16 vph) exiting. Sunday Daily 'r= 3.34 * (X) - 13.31 RZ =0.94 'r= 3.34 '" 26 - 13.31 2 l ll-UV I"rS Trip Generation Worksheets Chelsea - 10/12/10 Dosing Dispensing Main Station 2 Station 3 Dispensing TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 4 3 6:00 to 6:15 AM7 12 10 16 38 6:15 to 6:30 AM 18 23 19 6:30 to 6:45 AM 60 17 8 5 30 135 6:45 to 7:00 AM 9 20 11 40 168 7:00 to 7:15 AM 120.265823 10 14 36 166 7:15 to 7:30 AM 12 10 g 7:30 to 7:45 AM 31 13 11 3 10 24 1311 7:45 to 8:00 AM 7 9 7 23 114 8:00 to 8:15 AM 10 2 11 23 101 8:15 to 8:30 AM 14 17 31 101 8:30 to 8:45 AM 17 22 39 116 8:45 to 9:00 AM 19 14 33 126 9:00 to 9:15 AM 15 23 38 141 9:15 to 9:30 AM 14 0 14 124 9:30 to 9:45 AM 13 6 12 31 116 9:45 to 10:00 AM 4 6 15 25 108 10:00 to 10:15 AM 12 8 7 27 97 10:15 to 10:30 AM 12 8 10 10:30 to 10:45 AM 12 30 113 6 13 31 113 10:45 to 11:00 AM 7 3 8 11:00 to 11:15 AM 18 106 0 1 1 80 11:15 to 11:30 AM 0 1 1 51 11:30 to11:4SAM 0 11:45 to 12:00 PM0 0 20 12:00to12:15PM 0 2 0 1 1 2 251 31 104 246 632 Chelsea- 11/03/10 Patient 5:45 to 6:00 AM Visits TOTAL Cum. 1 6:00 to 6:15 AM 1 6:15 to 6:30 AM0 85 6:30 to 6:45 AM 85 6:45 to 7:00 AM60 0 86 7:00 to 7:15 AM 60 145 0.254386 7:15 to 7:30 AM61 0 145 7:30 to 7:45 AM 61 121 7:45 to 8:00 AM47 0 121 8:00 to 8:15 AM 47 108 8:15 to 8:30 AM52 0 108 8:30 to 8:45 AM 52 99 8:45 to 9:00 AM0 99 59 59 111 L 9:00 to 9:15 AM 0 111 9:15 to 9:30 AM 52 52 111 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 111 9:45 to 10:00 AM 52 52 104 10:00 to 10:15 AM 0 104 10:15 to 10:30 AM 49 49 101 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 101 10:45 to 11:00 AM 49 49 98 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 98 11:15 to 11:30 AM 3 3 52 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 52 11:45 to 12:00 PM 0 3 12:00to12:15PM 0 3 570 0 0 0 570 Peabody- 11/01/10 Patient Visits TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 95 95 6:00to6:15AM 0 6:15 to 6:30 AM 85 85 6:30 to 6:45 AM 0 180 0.32316 6:45 to 7:00 AM 62 62 147 7:00 to 7:15 AM 0 147 7:15 to 7:30 AM 48 48 110 7:30 to 7:45 AM 0 110 7:45 to 8:00 AM 25 25 73 3:00 to 8:15 AM 0 73 8:15 to 8:30 AM 29 29 54 8:30 to 8:45 AM 0 54 8:45 to 9:00 AM 45 45 74 9:00 to 9:15 AM 0 74 9:15 to 9:30 AM 48 48 93 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 93 9:45 to 10:00 AM 45 45 93 10:00 to :10:15 AM 0 93 10:15 to 10:30 AM 72 72 117 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 117 10:45 to 11:00 AM 3 3 75 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 75 11:15 to 11:30 AM 0 3 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 3 11:45 to 12:00 PM 0 0 t2:00 to 12:15 PM 0 0 557 0 0 0 557 2 0 an Peabody- 11/02/10 Patient Visits TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 97 97 6:00 to 6:15 AM 0 6:15 to 6:30 AM 71 71 6:30 to 6:45 AM 0 168 0.315197 6:45 to 7:00 AM 45 45 116 7:00 to 7:15 AM 0 116 7:15 to 7:30 AM 35 35 80 7:30 to 7:45 AM 0 80 7:45 to 8:00 AM 27 27 62 8:00 to 8:15 AM 0 62 8:15 to 8:30 AM 39 39 66 8:30 to 8:45 AM 0 66 8:45 to 9:00 AM 47 47 86 9:00 to 9:15 AM 0 86 9:15 to 9:30 AM 40 40 87 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 87 9:45 to 10:00 AM 52 52 92 10:00 to 10:15 AM 0 92 10:15 to 10:30 AM 80 80 132 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 132 10:45 to 11:00 AM 0 80 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 80 11:15 to 11:30 AM 0 0 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 0 11:45 to 12:00 PM 0 0 12:00 to 12:15 PM 0 0 533 0 0 0 533 Peabody-11/03/10 Patient Visits TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 97 97 6:00 to 6:15 AM 0 6:15 to 6:30 AM 56 56 6:30 to 6:45 AM 0 153 0.276673 6:45 to 7:00 AM 43 43 99 7:00 to 7:15 AM 0 99 7:15 to 7:30 AM 35 35 78 7:30 to 7:45 AM 0 78 7.45 to 8:00 AM 36 36 71 8:00 to 8:15 AM 0 71 8:15 to 8:30 AM 53 53 89 8:30 to 8:45 AM 0 89 8:45 to 9:00 AM 47 47 100 3 9:00 to 9:15 AM 0 100 9:15 to 9:30 AM 65 65 112 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 112 9:45 to 10:00 AM 55 55 120 10:00 to 10:15 AM 0 120 10:15 to 10:30 AM 66 66 121 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 121 10:45 to 11:00 AM 0 66 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 66 11:15 to 11:30 AM 0 0 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 0 11:45 to 12:00 PM 0 0 12:00to12:15PM 0 0 553 0 0 0 553 Peabody-11/04/10 Patient Visits TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 100 100 6:00 to 6:15 AM 0 6:15 to 6:30 AM 83 83 6:30 to 6:45 AM 0 183 0.317158 6:45 to 7:00 AM 55 55 138 7:00 to 7:15 AM 0 138 7:15 to 7:30 AM 27 27 82 7:30 to 7:45 AM 0 82 7:45 to 8:00 AM 25 25 52 8:00 to 8:15 AM 0 52 8:15 to 8:30 AM 55 55 80 8:30 to 8:45 AM 0 80 8:45 to 9:00 AM 60 60 115 9:00to9:15AM 0 115 9:15 to 9:30 AM 60 60 120 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 120 9:45 to 10:00 AM 52 52 112 10:00 to 10:15 AM 0 112 10:15 to 10:30 AM 52 52 104 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 104 10:45 to 11:00 AM 1 1 53 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 53 11:15 to 11:30 AM 1 1 2 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 2 11:45 to 12:00 PM 6 6 7 12:00 to 12:15 PM 0 7 577 0 0 0 577 Peabody- 11/05/10 4 e, Patient Visits TOTAL Cum. 5:45 to 6:00 AM 33 88 6:00 to 6:15 AM 0 6:15 to 6:30 AM 70 70 6:30 to 6:45 AM 0 158 0.266892 6:45 to 7:00 AM 64 64 134 7:00 to 7:15 AM 0 134 7:15 to 7:30 AM 32 32 96 7:30 to 7:45 AM 0 96 7:45 to 8:00 AM 39 39 71 8:00 to 8:15 AM 0 71 8:15 to 8:30 AM 59 59 98 8:30 to 8:45 AM 0 98 8:45 to 9:00 AM 60 60 119 9:00 to 9:15 AM 0 119 9:15 to 9:30 AM 65 65 125 9:30 to 9:45 AM 0 125 9:45 to 10:00 AM 59 59 124 10:00 to 10:15 AM 0 124 10:15 to 10:30 AM 56 56 115 10:30 to 10:45 AM 0 115 10:45 to 11:00 AM 0 56 11:00 to 11:15 AM 0 56 11:15 to 11:30 AM 0 0 11:30 to 11:45 AM 0 0 11:45 to 12:00 PM 0 0 12:00 to .12:15PM 0 0 592 0 0 0 592 Average 0.288 5 ALA, Capacity Anal is Worksheets Lanes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road ' 119/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 4�, t to 11* 1 LaneGroul " ° E9k`9TtE9 ��t GV `NgR7X'pgNB��s NBtt ` LS731 = ,SAY,. . 8 Lane Configurations h 4f i' 1 ff r fi d r Volume(vph) 406 659 182 104 609 121 120 235 34 138 141 439 1900 1900 1900 1900 deal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1200 170 0 Storage Length(ft) 300 110 230 180 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 1 Storage Lanes 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 Taper Length(ft) 2500 Lane Util.Factor 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 0.95 01850 1.00 1.00 01850 Flt Protected 0.950 Frt 0.850' 0.850 0.950 0.950 0.997 0.973 Said.Flow(prot) 1770 3539 1538 1770 3438 . 1583 Q 950 0 999 1524 0 018873 1599 Flt Permitted 0.950 0.950 Said.Flow(petro) 1770 3539 1538 1770 3438 1583 . 1618 1759 tYes 0 1823 159 Right Turn on Red Yes Yes 9 72 132 123 120 Said.Flow(RTOR) 30 30 30 Link Speed(mph) 30 789 1063 1110 Link Distance(ft) 605 25.2 Travel Time(s) 13.8 17.9 24.2 Peak Hour Factor 0.90 0.83 0.81 0.95 0.96 0.89 0.63 0,93 0.47. 0.65 0.86 0. 85 Heavy Vehicles(%) 451 794 225 09 634 136 90 253 72 212 64 516 Ad).Flow(vph) 10% Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 451 794 225 109 634 . .136 171 272 72 . 0 376 516 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Left Right Left Left Right Left L12 Right Left Lit Right Median Width(ft) 12 120 0 0 Link Offset(ft) i6 18 i6 16 Crosswalk Width(ft) Two way Left Tum lane Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 . 1.09 1.05 1. 00 1.09 Turning Speed(mph) 15 9 15 9 15 1 2 1 Number of Detectors 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 Detector Template Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left TRight 100 Leading Detector(ft) 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 20 Trailing Detector(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Position(ft) Detector 1 Size(h) 20 6 20 Ex 6 Ex Ex 6 Ex Ex 6 20 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 1 Channel. Detector 1 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Queue(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0..0 0.0 0.0 0.04 0.0 Detector 2 Position(ft) 94 94 94 9 6 6 Detector 2 Size(ft) 6 CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 2 Type CI+Ex Detector 2 Channel 0 0 0 0 0.0 Detector 2 Extend(s) 0.0 m+ov Turn Type Prot Perm Prot Perm Split pm+ov Split p Protected Phases 5 2 1 6 8 8 1 4 4 5 Permitted Phases 2 6 8 4 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page I r . .canes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough arlb Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour orouyh Road 11/9/2010 -• ~ t .'f'. `'E8�2�`.rz-!/)18�'�''�yVg� �IVBR?"+' Detector Phase a NB ' R SB :S6rSg Switch Phase 5 2 2 1 6 6 8 8 1 4 4 5 Minimum Initial(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0' Minimum Split(s) 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 Total Split(s) 37.0 51.0 51.0 16.0 . Total Split(%) 30.0 . 30.0 25.0, 25.0 16.0 33.0 33.0 37.0 29.6% 40.8% 40.8% 12.8% 24.0% 24.0% 20.0% 20.0% 12.8% 26.4% 26.4% 29.6% Maximum Green(s) 32.0 46.0 46,0 11.0 25.0 25.0 20.0 20.0 ' 11.0 ' 28.0 28.0 32.0 Yellow Time(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 All-Red Time(s). 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 Lost Time Adjust(s) 0.0 0.0 H 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Lost Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Lead/Lag Lead Lead Lead Lag Lag Lead-Lag Optimize? Lag Lag Lead Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3,0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3,0 Recall Mode None None None None None None . Max. Max None Max Max None Act Effct Green(s) 32.0 373 37.3 19.5 24.8 24.8 20.0 20.0 39.5 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.26 ' 0.30 0.30' 0.16 0.20 0.20 0.18 0.16 0.32 26'0 60.0 v/cRatio 0,99 0.75 0.41 0.39 0.93 0.33 0.66 0.97 Q14 0.22 0.48 Control Delay 87.5 43.9 15.3 54.7 69.8 12.1 62.5 98,1 4.7 0.92 0.62 Queue Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0,0 76.2 12'6' Total Delay 87.5 43.9 15.3 54.7 69.8 12.1 62.5 98.1 4,7 6.0 0. 76 LOS F D B D E 6 .2 12.66 Approach Delay , 52.9 E F A E 8 Approach LOS 59.0 73.2 D qua E E 39 4 Inler$Waoi�{JY�tr11,Fn+rti n�;. 'K �4�' it Area Iype: Other Cycle Length: 125 Actuated Cycle Length: 124.8 Natural Cycle:90 Control Type:Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum v/c Ratio:0.99 Intersection Signal Delay:53.9 Intersection Capacity Utilization 83.4% Intersection LOS:ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 e E S lits and Phases: 3:Hi hland Avenue&Marlhorou h Road -► m2 r�si 04 w : 03 33 J6 s 25s 37 .`>,r.,, ice', . : ...+- .: 30 is' Proposed CSAC 11/9/20102010 Exisling Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 2 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road ' Queues 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour l o •-- t � 1 �' 1 Lane EB_l" ?�EBt' E$ii?s'W�� VV�q: IhBRr >'�E �lf�It, : 81,1 NW' -4 -5� 516 104 1111111111111"-634136 171 272 72 376 Lane Group flow(vph) 451 794 225 0.99 ' 0.75 0.41 0.39 0.93' 0.33 0.68 . 0.97 0.14 0.92 . 0.62 vlc Ratio' Control Delay 87.5 43.9 15.3 54.7 69.8 12.1 62.5 98.1 4.7 76.2 12. Queue Delay 0.0- 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0' 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Delay 87.5 43.9 15.3 54.7 69.8 12.1 62. 2 5 98.1 4.7 300 12.6 10 Queue Length 50th(ft) 366 _ 305.' 56 80'.. ` 267 . 11 138 ' 232 0 300 110 Queue Length 95th(ft) #584 305 91 #173 #377 64 146 #983 416 0 030 150 Internal Link Dist(ft )' 525 709.; 170 200 Turn Bay Length(ft) 300 110 230 180 Base Capacity(vph) - 454 ,1304 650 277 0 689' 413 259. 281 532:` 40 832 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Starvation Cap Reductn , 0 0 0 0 0 0 Spillback Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Storage Cap Reductn Reduced vlc Ratio. 0.99 0.61 0.35 0,39 0.92 0.33 0.68 0.97"; 0.14 0.92 0.62 hl # 95th percentile volume exceeds capacity.queue may be longer. Queue shown is maximum after two cycles. Synchro 7. Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 3 1ICM Signalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 r to/inen � EBS A. .;E9 " E9t �WBEfgura�ions mr-w 6Ra �NBtw "FTdT, NOft 13�?• SM LaneCon1 r* Volume(vph) 408 659 182 104. 609 121 120 235 34 138 . 141 4314 9 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Total Lost act r 5.0 . 5.0 5.0 5.0 . 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Lane UGI. Factor 5.0 . 5.0 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1,00 0.95 0.95 1.00 Fitt 1.00 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.00 0.85' 1.00 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.00 Flt Protected 0,95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 1'� '- 0.85 Said.Flow(prof). 1770 3539 1538 1770 ' 3438. ' 1583 1618 ' 1759 1524 0.97 1.00 Fit Permitted 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1,00 0.95 1.00 1,00 1822 1599 Said.Flow(perm) 1770 3539 1538 : 1770 3438 1583 16181759 1524 Adj. 0. . Flow(vph) 1822,, 1599 0.97 1.00 Peak-hour factor,PHF 0 90 0 83 0 81 95 096 0.89 0.63 0.93 0.47 0.65 0.86 0.85 Adj. 451 794' 225 109 . 634 136 190 253 72 212 164.' RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 0 93 0 0 518 Lane Group Flow(vph) 451 794 132 log 634 40 171 272 23 0 378; 452 Heavy Vehicles 1%) 2% 2% 5% 2% 5% 2°/ 6% 2% 6% 40, 2% 1% Turn typo Prot Perm Prot Perm S Ill + Protected Phases 5 2 1 6 P pm ov Spl 4 pm+oJ Permitted Phases 8 8 1 5 Actuated Green,G(s) 32.0 37.3 37.3 19.5 24.8 24.8 20.0 20.0 39.5 28.0 60.0 Effective Green,g(s) 32.0 37.3 37.3 19.5 24.8 24.8 20.0, 20.0 39.5 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.26 0.30 0.30 0.16 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16 0.32 28'0 ;` 60.0 Clearance Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 0.22 5.6 Vehicle Extensions 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 5.0 S.0 Lane Grp Cap(vph) 454 1058. 460-` 277 683 315 259 282 482 ; 3.0 3.0 v/s Ratio Prot c0.25 0.22 0.06 c0.18 409 769 We Ratio Perm 0.11 c0.15 0.01 c0.21 0.15 v/c Ratio 0.09 0.03 0.011. 0.13 Uniform Dela ,di 099 0.75 0.29 0.39 0.93 0.13 0.66 0.96 0.05 0.92 0.59 Y 46.3 39.5 33.6 .47.3 49.1 41.1 49.2 52.0 29.6 47.3 23.5 Progression Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Incremental Delay,d2 40.3 3.0 0.3 0.9, 18.8 0.2 12.5 45.3 0.0 1.00 1.00 Delay(s) 86.6 42.6 33.9 48.3 67.9 41.3 61.7 97.3 29.6 75.5 24.6 Level of service F D C D E D E F Approach Delay(s) 54.8 E - C Approach LOS. , 0 61.E 76.0 C 46.1 nlerseaUloll im8nrY1� YT1'�2 3TaSt{r1; xA E ck � 55 D HCM Average Control Delay 57.2 '4 HCM Level of Servicer HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 0.95 E Actuated Cycle Length(s) 124.8 Sum of lost time(s) Intersection Capacity Utilization 83.4% ICU Level of Service 20 0 Analysis Period(min) 15 E c Critical Lane Group ) Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 4 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road Timing Report, Sorted By Phase ' 111912010 2010 Existin I Weekday Mornin Peak Hour r ;,2:,.. ". < Movement WBL EBT SBTL EBL WBT NBTL LeadlLag Lag Lead . Lead Lag (: Lead-Lag Optimize Recall Mode.: ., None None Max None None Max Maximum Split(s) 16 51 33 37 30 25 Maulmum Spllf(%) 12.80A : 40.8% .:`26.4%" 29.6% 24.0% ' 20.0°b Minimum Split(s) 9 20 20 4 20 20 q . 4 4 '' q 4'„ q ' . Yellow Time:(s) �! i 1 1 1 1 1 All-Red Time(s) 4 4 . 4 4 4:';: 4r Minimum Initial(s) 3 3 3 3 3 3 Vehicle Extension(s) 3 3 3 3. 3 3 Minimum Gap(s) Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Time To Reduce(s) 0 0- 0 0 Q 0 Walk Time(s) Flash Dont Walk(s) Dual Entry No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Inhibit Max Yes Yes Yes' Yes Yes - Yes Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 End Tune(s) 67 51 100 37 67 0 Yield/Force 08(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 YielNForce 08170(s) 62 46 95, 32 62,-, 120',.: Local Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 Local Yield.W 62 ' 46:'.:. 95_: 32' 62" 120 Local Yield 170(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 - Cycle Length 125 .. ControlType: .` Actuated-Uncoordinated Natural Cycle 90 Splits and Phases, 3:Hi hland Avenue&Marlborou h Road me 10 a5a6, 37 e Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday(Morning Peak Hour Page 5 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 6; Highland Avenue & West Owy. 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 Lane Configurations to T? P Volume(vph) 979 0 0 1027 0 1 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Lane Util.Factor 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 Frt 0.865 Flt Protected Said. Flow(prot) 3505 0 0 3471 0 1644 Flt Permitted Said. Flow(perm) 3505 0 0 3471 0 1644 Link Speed(mph) 30 30: .30 Link Distance(ft) 651 303 265 Travel Time(s) 14.8 6.9 6.0 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles(%) 3% 0% 0% 4% 0% 0% Adj.Flow(vph) 1020 0 0 1104 0 1 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 1020 0 0 1104 0 1 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Left Left Right Median Width(ft) 12 12 0 Link Offset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(ft) 16 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane Headway factor. 1.00 1.00 1.00, 1.00 1.00 - 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 9 Sign Control Free Free Stop Area Type:\ Other . Control Type:Unsignalized intersection Capacity Utilization 37.1% ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 Proposed CSAC 11/912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 6 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 6: Highland Avenue & West DWy. 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11i912010 t'overiient k EBfWmagrzarn Lane Configurations ?A ?� Volume(vehm) 979 0 0 1027 0 1 Sign Control Free Free Stop Grade 0% 0%, 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly Row rate(vph) : 1020 . 0 0 1104 0 1 Pedestrians Lane Width(ft) Walking S- IUs) Percent r :1e Rigwtr ;e(veh) pe None None M a;an storage veh) Upstream signal fR) 651 pX,platocr 0.86 0.86 0.86 vC,conf' HAI 1020 1572 ' 510 „onf vol „age 2 conf vt. vGu,unhlecked vol 703 1344 112 tC,sing!;:(s) 4.1 6.8 ' 6.9 tC,2 st,l IF(s) 2.2 . 3.5 . 3.3' 100 100 100 a{ 779 128"- 799 Dire e t r.a+fs a 1 � �"7�1 11V 2 tJ9 M "1inM a� �i" Volume Total Ar- 340 . 552 552 1 Volume Left 0 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 0 0 0 ; 1: cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 799 Volume to Cz' :ity - 0.40 0.20 0.32 0.32 0.00 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 Control Delay(s) 0.0 OA 0.0 0.0 9.5 Lane LOS A Approach Delay(s) 0.0 . 0.0 9.55 Approach LOS A A w(.n-T++^:mn °i,MXP!.,fM^' bi>r3,' IriterseCRod SUnlntarY��'4f��d�`r tr Average Delay 0.0 Intersection Capacity Utilization 37.1% ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 7 ' Ganes, Volumes, Timings 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. _ 11/9/2010 I /► 1s tane;Grou t ,, . t2,ENS t?8 twEBR AVB _4V8 _$1V9' _. l •/ RRR L f3t3 , HaNBRy.. st-BU�e;"581' SB, Lane Con Figurations 1 ��, 1 t? r P Volume(vph) 27 800 37 185 731 iiT 41 15 133 48 is Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Storage Length(ft) 225. 0 : 250 Storage Lanes i 310 280 ` 280 100 100 Taper Length(ft) 25 0 1 1 0 1 1 Lane Will. Factor 25 25 25:`: 25 25 25 0 Frf 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 100 1.00 Fit Protected 0.993 0.850Said0.965 0.850 0.950 0.950 0,867 Fit P Flow(prof) 1805 3477 0 1752 3438 1615, 0 1807 1568 0 736;. 1847 Flt Permitted 0.950 0 Said.Flow(pens) 1805 3477 1750 0.672 0.709 Right Turn on Red 0 1752 3438 1615 0 1258 1568 1295 1647 0 Said.Flow(RTOR) Yes Yes Yes 6 117 69 Yes Link Speed(mph) 30 120 Link Distance(ft) 30 _ 30 30 Travel Time(s) 17.9 651 330. 14.8 270 Peak Hour Factor 0.92 0.92 0.92 0.95 0.95 0.95- 0.78 0.76 0.78 0.80 06.1 0.80 Heavy Vehicles(%) 0% 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0°h Ad).Flow(vph) 29 870 40 195 769 117 54 20 175' 15. 120 Shared Lane Traffic(%) 58 Lane Group Flow(vph). 29 910 0 195 769 117 0 74 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No 58 No No .: 0 Lane Alignment; Left Left Right Left Left Right, Left Left Right LeftLeft No Median Width(ft) 12 12 Right Link Offset(ft) 12 12 Crosswalk Widlh(ft) 16 0 0 0 Two way Left Tum Lane 16 16 16 Headway Factor Turning Speed(mph) 15 g 15 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Number of Detectors 1 2 9 15 9 15 g Detector Template Left Thru i 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 Leading Detector(R) 20 100 Left Thor Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Trailing Detector(ft) 0 0 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 Detector 1 Posi6on(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0. 0 0 Detector 1 Size(ft) 20 6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex 20 a 20 20 6 20 20 6 Detector 1 Channel CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 1 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Queue(s) 0.0 0.0 . 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Delay 00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 0 Detector 2 Position(ft) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 ao 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0,0 94 Detector 2 Size(ft) 94 94 94 Detector 2 Type 6 6 6 CI+Ex CI+Ex 6 Detector 2 Channel CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 2 Extend(s) 0.0 Turn Type ProtP0.0 0.0 0.0 7 4 Protected Phases ro3 8 f Perm Perm pm+ov Perm 2 3 Permitted Phases 6 8 2 2 6 Proposed CSAC 1 Ii9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 8 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Du4y. , a 11/9/2010 2010 ExistingWeekdayMornin. Peak Hour ` 1 4/ Canei;'rou ,: a ° DLE�� g` V�6C"eW& WBE� x,108 IVB 2 ,2` �3ff...._S 6 3 . .ag` 9. � a d 8 . . Detector Phase 7 4 Switch Phase 4.0 4.0 . 4.0 4.0 .. 4.0' 4.0 4.0' Minimum Initial(s).:, 4.0;,. 4.0 '. Minimum Split(s) 8.0 20.0 8.0 20.0 20.0 20'0 20.0 8 0 20.0 20 0 Total Split(s) 12i0a. .46.6 0.0 ; `27.0 610,. 61 0 ., 27 0„ 27.0 27 0 . 27 0: . 27 0 0 0 Total Split(%) 12.0% 46 0% 0 0% 27.0% 61 0% 61 0% 27.0% 27.0% 27.0% 27,0% 27.0% 0 0% Maximum Green(s)": ... 8.0i 42.0 ' ` ; 23.0 ; 57.0,_",' 57.0 "23 0; 23..0` 23 0 ,;1' 23 0 23 0 Yellow Time(s) 3.5 3 5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3,5 3.5 All-Red Time(s) 0.5,' 0.5 0.5 0.5 `, 0.5.', 0.5 ` . 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Lost'rime Adjust(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 40 4.0 4A 4.0 4.0 : 4.0 4.0 : 4.0 4.0 .,. 40, 4.0` 4.0 Total Lost'Time(a). Lead Lag Lag Lead Lead/Lag Lead Lag. Yes Yes Yes' Yes ; Lead-Lag Optimize? Yes Yes - 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 Recall Mode None. � None,' None ' None`.`-. None' None.'.' .None None'_ None ' None 5 0 5.0 5.0 5.0 50 5.0 11.0:' .110 Walk Time(s) 1 t Q 11.0 11.0 : 11.0 11.0 ., Flash Dont Walk(s) ''_' 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Pedestrian Calls(#/hr) 13.1 .40.0' 40.0 ': 9.4 23.3" 9.3:.; 9.3 Act Effct Green(s). 7.1; 24.6 ' 0.12 0.43 0.23 0.70 0.70 0.17 0.41 0.16 016 , Actuated g/C Ratio 0.36,1, 0.26 ` 0.27 ..:. 0.36.,;, 0.13_' 0.60, 0.48..;:: 0.32; 0.10 VIP Ratio 31.2 8.4 29.4 11.0 Control Delay 30.9 15.7 27.0 6.3 20 0,0- 0.01` 0.0.,;.:; 0.0' " Queue Delay 0.0 0.0" 0.0'' ; 0.0: 0.0 . 270 6.3 2.0 31.2 8A 294 110 Total Delay 30.9 15.7 C . A ,.. A C A' C B 15.2 16.6 9.6 Approach Delay 16.1 B. 6 ;" B . A Approach LOS _4 Area Type: Other:" Cycle Length:100 Actuated Cycle Length:56.8 Natural Cycle:60 Control Type:Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum vlc Ratio:0.60 Intersection LOS:B Intersection Signal Delay: 13.2 '" ICU Level n Service A Intersection Capacity Utilization 53.3% Analysis Period(min) 15 " Splits and Phases: 7:Hi hland Avenue&PEP Bos DINY. -*o4 a7 4-ue - 12sR 127s. Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 9 Queues 2010 Existing Weekday Mornina Peak Hour 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 11/9/2010 7V*1M?A nw"Mm WEB Lane Group Flow(vph) BR TIM2,169MM"BM 78 91 M� 29 910 V/c Ratio 195 7611: 1117 74 175 58 135 0.13 0.60 0.48 0.32 0.10 0.36 0.28 0.27 0.36 Control Delay 30.9 15.7 27.0 6.3 2.0 31.2 8.4 29.4 11.0 Queue Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0,0 0.0 0.0, 0.0 0.0 Total Delay 30.9 15.7 27.0 6.3 2.0 31.2 8.4 29.4 11.0 Queue Length 50th(R) 9 121 58 39,� Queue Length 95(h(ft) 0 23'_ 20 18 , 4 Internal Link Dist(ft), 39 238 148 137 20 62 53 41 Turn Bay Length(R) 225 709 250 571 248 52 � I . 190, Base Capacity(Yph) 284 310 280 loo 2608 793 3132 1482 569 1017 586, 811 Starvation Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 Spillback Cap Reductn 0 0 0 00 Storage Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 Reduced v/c Ratio 0.10 0.35 0.25 0.25 0.08 0,13 0.17 o.10 0.17 I LIM 1 M4 m 1 2 M- 43 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 10 n Capacity Analysis 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. HCM Signalized Intersectio I IJ9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour t III \W -4/ gum"'off '86ra, ayt"V7 a 7" , 60 7 MOLE" �:LOKN*�MMN M, ,%qT%,_,t8FK M' to 96 Lane Configurations 46 12 27 800 37 185 731 111 411 , 15 133 1000 1900 1900 Volume(vph) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 4.0 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0, 4.0 Total Lost time(s) 4,0 4.0 4.0 0,95 1.00 100 too 1,00 1.00 Lane Lill.Factor 1,00 0.95 1.00 1,00, 0.85 1.00 0.85 1.00 0.87 Ftt 1.00 , 0.99 1.00 . 0,96 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 Fit Protected 1805 3479 11752 3438 1615 1807, 1568 1736 1641 Said.Flow(Prot) 0.95 1,00 1�00 0.67 1.00 0.71 100 0.95 1.00 1259 1568 1295 1647 Fit Permitted 2 3438 1615 Laid.FlOW 3 1 In 1 1805 3479 175 080 080 080 8rmL-"" 0.76 6 0 U., _L 0 2 0�9�20 95 095 0.95 Peak-hour factor, PHF 0.92 40 195 769 117 54 20 175 58 15' 120 Adj.Flow(vph) 29 870 0 0 42 0 0 46 0 105 0 RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 3 0 a 74 129 58 30 a Lane Group Flow(vph) 29 907 0 195 769 75 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% Heavy Vehicles 01/( 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% Prot Prot Perm Perm pm+ov Perm 6 Turn Type 3 8 2 3 4 Protected Phases 7 8 2 2 6 Permitted Phases 73 20.4 7.3 7.3 Actuated Green,G(s) 2.4 27.8 13.1 38.5 385 7.3 20.4 7.3 7.3 13.1 38.5 38.5 Effective Green,g(a) 2.4 27.8 0.12 0.34 0.12 0.12 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.04 0.46 0.22 0.64 0.64 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Clearance Time(a) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 1 1 3.0 3.0 3.0 � Vehicle Extensions 3.0 10 2 1607 381 2199 1033 153 66 157 200 3 Cane Grp a (vph) 7 0.04 0.02 vis Ratio Prot 0.02 c0.26 c0.11 0.22 0.05 c0.06 0.04 0,04 vis Ratio Perm0.48 0.20 0,37 0.15 vIc Ratio 0.40 0.56 0.51 0.35 0.07 24.7 114.1 24,3 23.7 10 4 5. . uniform Delay.d1l 28.2 11.8 20.7 100 1,00 1,00 1.00 Progression Factor 11.00 1.00 1.00 1,00 1.00 3.7 0.5 1.2 0.1 0.0 2.4 0.2 1.5 0.3 incremental Delay,d2 319 12.2 21.9 5.1 4.1 27.1 14.3 25.8 24.0 . Delay(s) B A A C C C Level of Service C 8.0 18.1 24.5 12.9 Approach Delay(s) A B C Approach LOS -tl"VmMl� atM,'gumr�ar� tea. B HCM Average Control Delay 12.2 HCM Level Of Service HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 0.54 12.0 Actuated Cycle Length(s) 60.2 sum of lost time(9) A Intersection Capacity Utilization 53.3% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 c Critical Lane Group Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 1119010 2010 Existing Weekday morning Peak Hour Page I I miming Report, Sorted By Phase 7: 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 11/9/2010 Phase.9 h6-07'so ir " V7TrrmmTTM' �,r �.j Movement NbIL W8L EST SBTL i Vvb I LeadlLag Lead LagLead Lag Lead-Lag Optimize Yes Yes Yes Yes Recall Mods None None None None None. None. Maximum split(s) 27 27 46 27 12 61 Maximum split 27.0% 27.0% 46.0% 27.0% 12.0% 61.0% Minimum Split(s) 20 a 20 20 8 20 Yellow Time 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3,5 All-Red Time 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Minimum Initial(s) 4 4 4 4 Vehicle Extension 3 3 3 3 Minimum Gap(s) 3 3 3 3 3 Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 3 Time 0 0 0 me To Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 Walk Time(s) 5 5 Flash Dont Walk 5 Dual Entry I Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Inhibit Max Yes Yes Yes Start Time(s) Yes Yes yes 0 27 54 0 27 39 End rime(s) 27 54 0 27 39 Yield/Force Offs) 0 23 50 96 23 35 96 Yield/Force Off 170(s) 12 50 85 12 35 85 Local Start Time(s) 0 27 54 0 27 39 Local Yield(s) 23 50 Local Yield 170(s) 96 23 35 96 12 50 85 12 35 85 Cycle 1-11119(rin Control Type lVV Natural Cycle Actuated-UncoordInated 60 S fits and Phases: 7:Hit hland Avenue& PEP So s owy. o2 003 ---►0-114 tv 060' - 'A Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro7- Report Page 12 12: Highland Avenue & East Dvvy- Lanes, Volumes, Timings 111912010 2010 Exiing Peak Hour Al a r+ BL W81' NBC ; NB5 Mss r t anal ane Grow_ "� ESI i, �� ?f Lane Configurations 979 0 0 1027, 0 1 Volume(vph) ' 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Ideal Flow(vphpl) AM Lane U111.Factor 0.95 0.95 1.00 . 0.95 1.00 0.865 Ft Flt Protected., Said. Flow(prol) 3471 0 0 3505 0 1644 Flt Permitted." 3471 0 0 3505 0 1644 Said. Flow(perm) 30 30 30 Link speed(mph) 303 45 258 Link Distance(ft) 1,0 5.9 Travel Time A - 6.9 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles(%) 4% 0% 0% 3% 0% 0% Adj.Flow(vph) 1020 0 0 1104 0 1 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 1020 0 0 1104 0 t Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Leo Lea Right Median Width(ft) 0 ` 0 0 0 Link OHsei(fl) 10 _ t6 16 Crosswalk Width(fl) Two way Left Turn Lane 1.00 : 1.00 1.00 1.05 tA9 Headway Factor, 1.00, Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 Free Slop Sign Control Fres s w- ag Ill I m rsec�d�ir es . ,I r I . Area Type:, Other Control Type:Unsignalized ICU Level of Service A Intersection Capacity Utilization 37.1% Analysis Period(min) 15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 13 tiCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 12: Highland Avenue & East Owy. 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 1119/2010 Lane Configurations }A }} r Volume(vehlh) 979 0 0 1027 0 1 Sign Control Free Free Stop Grade 0% 0% 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) 1020 0 0 1104 0, 1 Pedestrians Lane Width(ft) Walking Speed(itis) Percent Blockage Right turn Flare(veh) Median type None None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(ft) 954 pX,platoon unblocked 0.91 0.91 0.91 vC,conflicting volume 1020 1572 510 vC1,stage 1 cont vol vC2,stage 2 conf vol vCu,unblocked vol 822 1429 261 lc,single(s) 4.1 6.8 6.9 tC, 2 stage(s) IF(s) 2.2 3.5 3.3 p0 queue free% 100 100 100 cM capacity(vehm) 742 116 678 D(r�iand°L'an"'e�k�` ,��"�B�"1-�"fr�B�"'"wWei'��W9.2N�'i;�' , "i��;�s,`�a,ar •+��d 1 Volume Total 680 340 552 552 1 Volume Left 0 0 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 0 0 0 L cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 676 Volume to Capacity 0.40 . 0.20 0.32 0.32 0.00 Queue Length 95th(it) 0 0 0 0 0 Control Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 10.3 Lane LOS B Approach Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 10.3 Approach LOS B Inter9eC6011::5ummary ;k' r *n , VCs"`"yzs7elr[rxz� w cwt , m �za}wYrcrTTr F p ' Average Delay 0.0 Intersection Capacity Ufilization 37.1% ICU Levet of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 14 Lanes, Volwnes, Timings 14: Highland Avenue & First Street 11912010 2010 Existing Weekdayg MorninPeak Hour �ane Gaup fi� � Lane Configurations Volume(vph) 965 14 0 1027 0 213 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Lane Uhl.Factor 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 . Frt 0.998 0.865 Fit Protected Said. Flow(prof) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1627 Fit Permitted Said. Flow(perm) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1627 Link Speed(mph) "1 30'— 30 Link Distance p' 25.8 33 868 9 7 Travel 11m k Peak Hr .cl 96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heav,, O's(9 0% 0% 4% 0% 1% Adj.-.,gar(v,h) 4190r 15 0 1104 0 232 Shared Lane Trick('Ya} Lane Grr—i Flo,: (vph) 0 0 1104 0 232 Enter P' Interse( No No No No No Lar, t "ght Left Lett Left Right Median WIL, 0 0 0 Link Offset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(it) 16 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor : 1 '0 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 9 Sign Control Free Free Stop RE, Area Type:; Other Control Type:Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Utilization 47.0% ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min)15 Proposed CSAC 111912010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7• Report Page 15 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis '14: Highland Avenue & First Street 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 80'r-W,EM.W. Lane Configurations Volume(vehil14 TT 965 0 1027 0 213 Sign Control Free Grade Free Stop 0% 0% 0%_ Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly now rate(Vph) 1005 15 0 1104 0 232 Pedestrians Lane Width(it) Walking Speed(fiVs) Percent Blockage Right turn flare(veh) Median type None None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(it) 999 pX, platoon unblocked 0.92 0.92 0,92 vC,conflicting volume 1020 1565 510 41,stage I cont vol vC2,stage 2 cont vol vCu,unblocked vol 842 1436 287 tc,single(s) 4.1 6.8 6.9 tC. 2 stage(s) tF(s) ., 2.2 3.5 3.3 pO queue free% 100 100 65 CM capacity(vehlill 730 116 654 DIrBI . C1 11111 1, i volume Urne Total 670 300 0172 002 232 Volume Left 0 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 15 0 0 232 cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 654 Volume to Capacity 0.39 0.21 0.32 0.32 0.35 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 40 Control Delay(s) 0.0 Lane LOS 0.0 0.0 0.0 13.5 Approach Delay(a) 0. 8 Approach LOS 0 0.0 13.5 B 1.3 0 77 Average Delay °TMn Intersection Capacity Utilization 47.0% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 A Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2010 Existing Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 16 1 i Lanes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlboroughl/9/2010 Ro,"d 2015 No-Build aekday doming Peak Hour \ l r l 1 ! 4- ` 1 t l ' BL E@T OR WbW B A ;1� F ._° � B a$ . ..ST6r anee �� q 9r Lane Configurations 1 f? Volume(vpn) 445'1, 657 '' 136 ;�-'131: ., 251` 37 >',. 1631 155 °- 488 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 110:.,-'19000 1900 200 3� , 110 230 180 ,' 0 1 0 1 Storage Length(ft) 1 1 1 1 1 Storage Lanes 25 X25 25,. :25 25 " 25 .25 Taper Length(ft) , , 25; Lane Util.Factor 00 1.00 0.95 100 100 0 95 1,00 0.95 0.95 0 850 ' 100 1.00 01850 � : 0854 t ,_- 0850 - z Frtr E " 0.950 0.950 0.996 0.972 Flt Protected 0.9501758 Said.Flow(prot) ` - 1770 3539 61538 q,. 1770 ' 3438 15811. 0.950 ` 0.996 1524 0 0,972 15,99 Flt Permitted 0.950 0.950 Said.Fidw(perm) 1770. 3539 ' :1538 . 1770 . 3438 ' 1583 1818'` 1758 f 1Yes 0 1821 :.1Yes Right Turn on Red Yes 79 105 . 124`. 125 � ,. - 30 Said.Flow(RTOR):. `' 30 30 30 Link Speed(mph) .1063 605' 789'; 25 2 Link Dlslence(ft) a 13.8 17.9 24.2 Travel Time(s) Peak l Time acror. 0.90: 0.83.' 0.81 0.95 0.98 ;, 0.89 0.63 0.93 0.47 0.65 ;' 0.86 0.85 Heavy Vehicles(%) 2% 2% 5% 2% 5% 2% 6% 2% 6% 1% 2% 1% 494 908 '.,` 241' 117 684 153 ` 208 270 79 ` 2511; -' 189.::: 574 Ad):Flow(vph) 10% Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group:Flow(v Oh) 494' 908' ` 241 117 . 684,4 153 = 187 ;' 291 19 0 431 574 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No No Na No t Lane Alignment' ". Left.` . Left'c` Right . '`Left°"" : L12 , Right "z'- Left" ', .Left, Right> Left L12 Right Median Width(ft) 12 0, 0 0 Link Offsel(R)" 16 t6 16 16 Crosswalk Width(ft) Two way Left Tum Lane Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 100 1.00 100 1.00 1.00 1.000 15 9 2 1.00 1.00 1.000 - 15 . ,_ 9. 15 1 Turning Speed(mph) 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 Number of Detectors 1 2 Detecior,Template Left Thm " Right left , ThN Right Left_ Thru Right Left . Thru Right Leading Detector(ft) 20 100 20 . 0 2 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 20 0 0 0,. . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Trailing Detector(ft).`; -. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 0 Detector t Position(R) 20 20 6 20 20. 6 20: 211 6 20 Detector 1 Size(ft) 20 CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex 8 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector I Channel - 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector i Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector t Queue(s)- 0.0 0.0` 0.0 0.0 ' 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 . . 0.0 0.0 0,0 .: Detector i Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 94 0 0 0.0 00.4 0.0 0.0 94 0.0 Detector 2 Position(ft)`. ' 94` 6 6 6 6 CI+Ex Oe Detector 2 Ty Size(q) CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex tectcr 2 Ty '.. , Detector 2 Channel 0.0 0,0 0.0 Detector 2 Extend(s) 0.0 m+ov Prot Perm Prot Perm Split pm+ov Split 4 p 5 Turn Type 1 6 8 8 1 Protected Phases 6 2 6 8 4 Permitted Phases 2 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 1 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 4, 1 t �► 1 ✓ LaneG'r�'s?�t`'��`�?��` .)�'�Bt""� EBl'"��i"fB,t2 "" x,91181 �iN91��'•'4'06R`.� TN9LNBT`��'' BR�TSpI:�.c = (;afi"��r,58� Detector Phase 5 2 2 1- 6 6 8 8 1 4 4 5 Switch Phase Minimum Initial(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0'' 4.0 4.0 4.0 . 4.0 ., ` 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Minimum Split(s) 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 Total Split(s). , 37.0 , 51.0; 51.0 ,- 16.0 30.0 30.0 ;:, 25.0 25.0 16.0 33.0 33.0: . 37.0 Total Split(%) 29.6% 40.8% 40.8% 12.8% 24.0% 24.0% 20.0% 20.0% 12.8% 26.4% 26.4% 29.6% Maximum Green(s) . 32.0 ,: 46.U: 46.01'. 11.0 25.0 -"z. 25.0 - 20.0;- 20.0' 11.0 '28.0 . :_ 28.0' 32.0 Yellow Time(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 All-Red Time(s) 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1,0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 Lost Time Adjust(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Lost Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0, 5.0 5.0. 5.0 5.01 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Lead/Lag Lead Lead Lead Lag Lag Lag Lag Lead Lead-Lag Optimize? Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 Recall Mode None None, None. None None None. Max Max None Mai Max : None Act EBct Green(s) 32.0 40.9 40.9 16.1 25.0 25.0 20.0 20.0 36.1 28.0 60.0 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.26 0.33 0.33 0.13 0,20 0.20 0.16 0.16 . 0.29 - 0.22 0.48 vlc Ratio 1.09 0.78 0.41 0.51 0.99 0.37 0.72 1.04 0.16 1.06 0.70 Control Delay 112.7 43.0 16.8 61.4 82.9 13.8 66.6 114.2 . 4.8 106.8 : 15.4 Queue Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Delay 112.7 43.0 16.6 61.4 82.9 13.8 66.6 . 114.2 4.8 106.8 15.4 LOS F D B E F B E F A F B Approach Delay 60.1 69.2 82.7 54.6 Approach LOS E E F D ,� 7¢ Irl Area Type: Other Cycle Length: 125 . Actuated Cycle Length: 125 Natural.Cycle: 130 Control Type:Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum v/c Ratio: 1.09 Intersection Signal Delay: 63.9 Intersection LOS: E Intersection Capacity Utilization 89.9%, ICU Level of Service E Analysis Period(min) 15 Slits and Phases: 3:Hi hland Avenue&Marlborough Road -►02 1001 04 ' 08 51 a I Its s. 133 s. 25's 1 05 ~06 3T.s ?. 308 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 2 Queues 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 11/912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour t 1 Lane GrCfr r: .. :8�1 lrB1b' V 8WW8_ff% f7Bt Mf�MB. S Lane Group Flow(vph) 494 908 241 117 684 153 187 291 79 431 n_574 v/c Ratio 1.09 . 0.78 , 0.41 0.51 0.99., 0.37 0.72 1.04 0.16 1.06 0.70 Control Delay 112.7 43.0 1&6 61.4 82.9 13.8 66.6 114.2 4.8 106.8 15 4 Queue Delay.' 0.0':. 0.0': ' 0.0 0.0 0.0 '- 0.0 'er' 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 00 Total Delay 112.7 43.0 16.6 61.4 82.9 13.8 6 51 114.2 2611 4.8 -382 15.4 41 Queue Length 50th(it),.. -450. 345`:.- 68 90 293",, 19:, 152 268 , ' 0 -382 188 Queue Length 95th(ft) #663 358 109 #190 #424 77 160 #455 0 #545 188 Internal Link Dist(it) ;: 525 709", 983- 1030 < Turn Bay Length(it) 300 110 230 180 170 200 Base Capacity(vph) 453" 1302 644 ... 228.,. 688: 417 : 259 281 498 ' 408 822 Starvation Cap Reductn0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Spillback Cap Reductn 0 0 0 01 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Storage Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reduced v/c Ratio:- 1.09, - 0.70: 0.37 0.51 0.99 0.37. 0.72 _'1.04 0.16 1.06 0.70 Volume exceeds capacity,queue is theoretically intinite.' Queue shown is maximum after two cycles. p 95th percentile volume exceeds capacity,queue may be longer:, Queue shown is maximum after two cycles. Proposed CSAC 1119/2010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 3 EICM Signalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/912010 mo'verilen Lane Configurations Volume(vph) 445 754 195 111 657 _. 136 131 . 251: 37- 163 155 488 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 19001900 1900 1900 19 Total Lost time(s) 5.0 5.0 00 19005.0' 5.0. 5.0 5.0,;' - 5.0 Lane Util. Factor 5.0 5.0 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 Fit 1.00' 1.00 0.85•, 1.00 1.00. 0.85 ' 1.00 : 1.00 0.85 1.00 0.85' Flt Protected 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.97 1.00 Said.Flow(prof): 1770- 3539 1538 1770 : 3438; 1583 1618 "x'1758: 1524 .1820_ 1599 Flt Permitted 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.97 1.00 Said.Flow(perm) 1770 3539 1538 1770' 3438 1583 1618' 1758` 1524 1820 1599 Peak hour factor,PH 0.90 0.83 0.81 0.95 0.96 0.89 0.63 0.93 0.47 0.65 0.86 0.85 AdJ.Flow(vph) 494 908 241 117 684 153 208 270 79 251 180 574 RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 0 83 0 0 100 0 0 56 0 0 55 Lane Group Flow(vph) 494 908 158 117 684 53 187 291 23 0 431 519 Heavy Vehicles 2% 2% 5% 2% 5% 2% 6% 2% 6% 1% 2% 1% Tum Type Prot . Perm Prot Penn Split pm+ov Split Protected Phases 5 2 pm+ov 1 6 8 8 1 4 4 5 Permitted Phases 2 g •. . g Actuated Green,G(s) 32.0 40.9 40.9 16.1 25.0 25.0 20.0 20.0 36.1 28.0 60.0 Effective Green,g(s) : 32.0 40.9 40.9 16.1 25.0 ,, 25.0 20.0 20.0 36.1 28.0 60.0 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.26 0.33 0.33 0.13 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16 0.29 0.22 0.48 Clearance Time(a), 5.0' 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0: 5.0 5.0: 5.0'! 5.0 Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3 0 3 0 5 0 5.0 Lane G Ca h 3 0 3 0 Grp P( Pv 1 453 . 1158. 503 . 228 , 688- 317 . 259 = 281: 440 . 408 . 768 v/s Ratio Prot c0.28 0.26 0.07 c0.20 0.12 c0.17 0.01 c 408 768 v/s Ratio Perm, 0.10 0.03 . 0.01 vlc Ratio 0.115 1.09 0.78 0.31 0.51 0.99 0.17 0.72 1.04 0.05 1.06 0.68 Uniform Delay,d1l 46.5, 38.1 31.5 50.8 49.9 41.4 49.9 52.5 .. 32.1 Progression Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 48.5 25.0 Incremental Delay,d2 69.0.- 3.6 0.4 1.9 32.7 0.3' 16.0 63.2 . 0.0 60.2 1.00 2 4 ' Delay(s) 115.5 41.6 31.9 52.7 82.6 41.6 65.9 115.7 32.1 108.7 27.4 Level ofService,Delay F 0 C 0 F D E F C F C Approach Delay(s) 62.4 72 4 671 62.3 Approach LOS E E72. Iriter$8Ct)Off:`SOfrinB[V�'•,',%»;Stt"""'��tti '.; ;"4""` :> ' t'�' ` '. '"1`5�`� a Kr HCM Average Control Delay 68.0 NCM Level of Servlce E HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 1.05 Actuated Cycle Length(s) 125.0 Sum of lost time(s) 20.0 Intersection Capacity Utilization 89.9% ICU Level of Service E Analysis Period(min) 15 c Critical Lane Group Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7• Report Page 4 Timing Report, Sorted By Phase 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Mornin, Peak Hour pp e� At r _ L Rih.�y�TM11 r FJFry'{SE 2.Si.�. .'i.R3.- Movement VOL EBT SBTL EBL WBT NBTL Lead/Lag Lag Lead': Lead Lag Lead-Lag Optimize None None Max None None Max Recall Mode Maximum Split(s) 16 51 33 37 30 25 Maximum Split C16) 12.8% 40.8% 26.4% 29.6% 24.0% 20.0% Minimum Split($) 9 20 20 9 20 20 Yellow 11me(s) 4 44 4 4 4 All-Red Time(s) 1 1 1 1 1 1 Minimum initial(s) 4 4 4 4 4 . 4 Vehicle Extension(s) 3 3 3 3 3 3 Minimum Gap(s) ' 3 3 3 3 3 3 Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Time To Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0- Walk Walk Time(s) Flash Dont Walk(a) Dual Entry No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Inhibit Max Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 End Time(s) 67 51 100 37 67 0 Yield/Force Off(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 Yield/Force Off 170(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 Local Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 Local Yield . 62 46 95 32 62 120 Local Yield 170(s) 62 46 95 32 6y�2 120 ' '.aN: JR S 5 3" " n om¢ s., Cycle Length 125 Control Type Actuated-Uncoordinated Natural Cycle 130 Splits and Phases: 3: Hi hland Avenue&Madborou h Road o9 Irk m1 e4 11iso, `33 e• ' .. .. . SIs ; . as . . ~a6 1Z 130sc , Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 5 Lines, Volumes, Timings 6: Highland Avenue & West Dwy. 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 1119/2010 Laee�E?rou""'R�"'�'rr..• a')'��si�`!' �BR��iV'Bl"� V1)E'��3N L�'�N9Fi� Lane Configurations fp Volume(vph) 1051 14 0 1099 0 . 9 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 .1900 Lane Util.Factor 0.95 . 0.95 1.00 0.95: 1.00" 1.00 Frt 0.998 0.865 Flt Protected Said. Flaw(prot) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1644 Flt Permitted Said.Flow(perm) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1644 Link Speed(mph) 30 30 30 , Link Distance(it) 651 303 265 Travel Time(s) 14.8 6.9 6.0 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles(°h) 3% 0% 0% 4% 0% , 0% Ad!. Flow(vph) 1095 15 0 1182 0 10 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 1110 0 0 1182 0 10 Enter Blocked Intersection No • No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Left Left Right Median Width(ft) 12 12 0 Link OHsel(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(ft) 16 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 9 Sign.Control .' . Free Free. , Stop•..'•, - 18UIJ 18N.t4w .�" � 3'' Area Type Other Control Type:Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Utilization 39.5%. ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 6 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 6: Highland Avenue & West Dvvy. 11 i912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour lovemen ' Lane Configurations fA TT Volume(vehm) 1051 14 0 1099 0 9 Sign Control Free Free Stop Grade, 0% 0% 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) 1095 15 0, 1182 0 10 Pedestrians Lane Width(ft)' Walking Speed(f 1s) Percent Blockage Right turn flare(veh) None Median type None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(e) 651 PX,platoon unblocked 0.83 0.83 0.83 vC,conflicting volume 1109 1693 555 vC1,stage 1 conf vol vC2,stage 2 cpnf vol vCu,unblocked vol7301431 .1 14. 64 4 tC,single(e) 4.1 6.8. 8.9 tC,2 stage(s) 2.2 3.5 3.3 IF(s) 100 100 99 p0 queue free% 736 106 827 cM capacity(vehm) k r P yxry gra ^v u " "' ;,. ... t;�� Y1 P= Volume Total 730 380 591 591 10 Volume Left 0 0 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 15 0 0 10 cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 827 Volume to Capacity 0.43 0.22 0.35 0.35 0.01 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 1 Control Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 9.4 Lane LOS A Approach Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 9.4 Approach LOS A .,,.ya, ntersecUart dir maryu Average Delay 0 0 A Intersection Capacity Utilization 39.5% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC I V912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 7 i Lanes, Volumes, Timings 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy, 2015 talo-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 TWO a "�NJ117 L�� FIBf* iVBRf�S��L�St 'S6 Lane Configurations q }� 1 }t r Volume(vph) 27 879 37 192, 796 111 41 15 140 46 12- 96 ": . Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900, 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 0 250 Storage Length(ft) 225 . 310 280 280 100 Storage Lanes 1 - '. 100 0 1 1 0 Taper Length(ft) 1 1 0 25 25 25. 25 25 Lane Util.Factor 25. 25 25 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Fri ". 0.994 Flt Protected 0.950 0.850,' 0.850 0.867 0.950 0.965 0.950 Said.Flow(prof) 1805 3481 0 1752 3438 1615 0 1807, 1568 1736 1647 0 Fit Permitted 0.950 0.950 0.647 Satd.Flow(Perm) 1805 3481 0 1752 3438 1615 0 1212 1568 0 295 1647 Right Turn on Red Yes Yes 0 Said.Flow(RTOR) 5 Yes Yes Link Speed(mph) 30 11T 52 120 Link Distance(ft) 789 30 30 30 Travel Time(s) 17.9 651 328 270 14.8 7.5 6.1 Peak Hour Factor 0.92 0.92 0.92 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.76 0.76 0.76 0.80 0.80 0.80 Heavy Vehicles(%) 0% 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% Ad]. Flow(vph) 29 955 40 202 838 117 54 20 184 Shared Lane Traffic(%) 58 ' ,15. 120 Lane Group Flow(vph) 29 995 0 202' 836. 117 ' 0 74 184 58 135 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left -- Left Right Left Left Right Left Left Right Left' Left . Right Median Width(ft) 12 Link Offset(ft)' 0 12 12 12 6 Crosswalk Width(ft) 16 0 Two way Left Tum Lane . 18 166 16 Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 15 9 15 9 15 9 15 Number of Detectors 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 1 9 Detector Template Left Thru Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Leading Detector(ft) 20 100 20 too 20 20 100 20 20 100 Trailing Detector(R) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0. 0, 0 Detector 1 Positlon(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Size(ft) 20 6 20 6 20' 20 6 20 20 6 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 1 Channel Detector 1 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Queue(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 2 Posillon(ft) 94 94 94 Detector 2 Size(ft) 6 6 94 Detector 2 Type CI+EX 6 6 Detector 2 Channel CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 2 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 Turn Type Prot0.0 Pro! Perm Perm pm+ov Perm Protected Phases 7 4 3 8 2 3 Permitted Phases 6 3 2 2 6 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 No-Build IA/eekday Morning Peak Hour • oynchro 7- Report Page 8 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys 111 D20. 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 1 F- 3 : 6� WBGyBfNTBt�,sVkF) F1fJ9 . 586 "58E6�SB Detector Phase ` T;.'. 4 3 Switch Phase 4.0" 4.0:, 4.0 4.0 4.0' 4.0, 4.0 4.0 :. Minimum Initial(s)- 4.0 4.0' Minimum Split(s) 8.0 20.0 8.0 20.0 20,0 20.0 20.0 8.0 20.0 20.0 Total Split(s).' 12.0 48.0 0 0, ., 27.0; 61.0- , 610 ,; 27.0.;,. 27.0: 27A 27.0 : 27.0 - 0.0 Total Split(%) 12.0% 46.0% 0.0% 27.0% 61.0% 61.6% 27.0% 27.0% 27.0%23.0 2 23 0 2 23,0 0 0% Maximum Green(s) 8.0 42.0'"_` 23.0,• 57.0 ` 57.0 ° 23.0. 23.0 23.0 23.0 23.0 Yellow Time(s� 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3 l 5 3.5 3.5 All-Red Times), 0.5 0.5 , 0.5 > 0.5` 0.5 ` . 0.5 0.5 . 0.5 ` 0.5 0.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 00 0.0 0,0 0.0 0.0 00 0.0 Lost Time Adjust(s) 4.0 4.0 ' 4.0' 4.0 4.0 4.0 Total Lost Time(s) : 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4 0' . . Lead Lead/Lag Lead Lag Lead Lag Lag Yes Lead-Lag Optimize? Yes Yes Yes Yes. Yes Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 Recall Mode None None None , None None, None' None None . None None Walk Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 50 Flash Dont Walk(s) 11.0 11.0 : 11.0 11.0 11.0 11.0 11.0 Pedestrian Calls(#/hr) 0 0 0 0 0 7.2 27.3' 13.7 43.5 43.5; 9.6 24.1' 9.5 .' 9.5 Act Etfct Green(s). 0.16 0.40 016 0.16 Actuated gIC Ratio 0.12 0.45 0.23 0.72 072 0.39 . 0.2a: 0.28' .. 0.37 vlc Ratio : 0.14. 0.63 0.51 0.34 0.10 33.3 16.1 291 6.2 1.8 34.5 10.7 31.8 117 Control Delay 0.0 0.0; 0,0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Queue Delay ' 0.0 0.0' 34.5 10.7 31.8 11.7 Total Delay 33.3 16.1 29.1 6.2 1.8 C B C B LOS C B C 98 A, 17.5 17.8 Approach Delay 16.6 8 g A Approach LOS: B e. z Area Type: Other' Cycle Length: 100 Actuated Cycle Length:60.4 Natural Cycle:60 Control Type;Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum vlc Ratio:0.63 Intersection LOS:8 Intersection Signal Delay: 13.8 ICU Level of Service 8 Intersection Capacity Utilization 55.8% Analysis Period(min) 15 Splits and Phases: 7: Highland Avenue&PEP Bos Dw . o3 z2 27 g as s 27 s 27 a 126':; fitsi: , Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 11/912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 9 Queues 7: Highland Avenue PEP BOYS Dwy. 2015 No Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 t LaineGi M"Ir oil !',M.rar-;.3T7w,299L4,!P M IE . Lane Group low(Vph) 29 995 202 v1c Ratio 117 74 184 58 135 0.14 0.63 0.51 0.34 0.10 0.39 0.28 0.28 0.37 Control Delay 33.3 16.1 29A 6.2 1.8 34.5 10.7 31.8 11.7 Queue Delay 0.0 00 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Delay 33.3 16.1 29,1 6.2 18 34.5 10.7 31.8 11.7 Queue Length 50th(R) 10 141 64 44 0. 24 28 19 5 Queue Length 95(h(ft) 41 271 164 151 19 65 67 56 43 Internal Link Dist(ft) 709 571 248 Turn Bay Length(ft) 225 250 310 190, 280 too Base Capacity(vph) 269 2495 750 3033 1438 519 962 555 774 Starvation Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 Spillback Cap Rel 0 0 0 0 0 0 Storage Cap Reductin 0 0 0 0 0 Reduced v/c Ratio 0.11 0.40 0.27 0.28 0.08 0.14 0,19 0.10 0.17 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour ----------------- Synchro 7- Report Page 10 HCM Signalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dvby. 11/9/2010 2015 No Build Weekday Mo rning Peak Hour 1 ,... . 1Ng Vg1-�1.�a"1t!N ".N6 �fovemen .tom'" €il" t@ , :. ORsWe' T� t p Lane Configurations 1H ?f 15 140 46 12 96 Volume(vph) 27 879 37 192 796 900 41 . Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 19.0 1900 i 4.0, 1 4.0 1 4.0 194000 1900 Total Last time(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0- 4.0 4.0 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Lane Uft Factor 1.00 1.00' 0.85 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.87 Fit 1,00 0.99 0.96 1.00 0.95 1.00 Flt Protected 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 : ` 1752, 3438 1615 ` 1807: 1568 1736 1647 Satd.Flow(prof) 1805 3481 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.65 1.00 0.71 1.00 Flt Permitted 805 1.00 1211 1568, 1295 1647 Satd:Flow erre 1805 3481 1752" 3438 1615 Peak-hour factor,PHF 0.92 955 0 40 202 838 0.95 0117 0'54 0.20 184 0 58 0 55 O 20 Adj.Flow(vph) 0 106 0 0 40 0 0 35 RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 3 0 0 0 74 149 58, 29 0 Lane Group Flow(vph) 29 992 0 202 838 77 HeavyVehicles % 0% 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% Prot Prot Perm Perm Pm+ov Perm 6 Tum Type 3 8 2 3 Protected Phases 7 4 8 - 2 2 8 Permitted Phases137 419 41.9 7.4 21.1 7.4 7.4 2.4 30.6 . . Actuated Green,G(s) 7,4 21,1 7.4 7.4 Effective Green,g(s) 2.4 30.6 13.7 41.9 41.9 0.12 0.33 0.12 0.12 Actuated giC Ratio 0.04 0.48 0.22 0.66 0.66 , 4.0 4.0 4.0 . 4.0 4.0. 4.0 4.0 4.0 Clearance Tim4.0 e{s) 3 0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 30 3.0 Vehicle Extensions 3.0 3.0 1q1. 618 150 191 [ane Grp Cap(vph) 68 1672 377 2261 1082 0.05 0.02 vis Ratio Prot 0.02 c0.29 00.12 0.24 0.05. c0.06 0.04 0.04 vis Ratio Perm 0.54 0.37 0.07 0.52 0.24 0.39 0.15 vIc Ratio 0.43 0.59 26.5 15.5 28.0 25.3 30.0 12.0 22.2 4.9 3.9 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Uniform Delay,di Progression Factor 1 5 01 0.0 3.5 0.2 1.7 0.4 Incremental Delay,d2 4.3 0.6 23.5 5.0 3.9 30.0 15.7 27.7 25.7 Delay(s) 34.2 12.6 C a C C Level of Service C B C A A 19.8 26.3 Approach Delay(s) 132 8.2B C Approach LOS B A +1Wge t4'w$ fi Inter§echo4 summa � HCM Average Control Delay 12.6 HCM Level of Service HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 0.57 12.0 Actuated Cycle Length(s) 63.7 Sum of lost time(s) B Intersection Capacity Utilization 55.8% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 c Critical Lane Group Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 11 Timing Report, Sorted By Phase 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 2015 No-Build Weekrning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 t. J 159ase NUmServT .3 '_ PAovement " � � rt , NBTL W8L EBT SBTL EBL WBT " ' LeadlLag Lead La Lead-Lag Optimize g Lead Lag Recall Mode Yes Yes Yes Yes None None None None None None Maximum Split(s) 46 27 12 61 Maximum Split(%) 27.0% 27.0% 46.0% 27.0% 12.0% 61.0% Minimum Split(s) 20 8 20 20 8 20 Yellow Time(s) 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 All-Red Time(s) 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Minimum Initial(s) 4 4 4 4 4 4 Vehicle Extension(s) 3 3 3 3 3 3 Minimum Gap(s) 3 3 3 3 3 3 Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Time To Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Walk Time(s) 5 5 5 Flash Dont Walk(s) 115 Dual Ent 11, it 11 Entry Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Inhibit Max Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Start Time(s) 0 27 54 0 27 39 End Time(s) 27 54 0 27 39 0 Yield/Force Off(s) 23 50 96 23 35 96 Yleld/Force Off 170(s) 12 50 85 12 - 35 85 Local Start Time(s) 0 27 54 0 27 39 Local Yield(s) 23 50 96 23: 35 96 Local Yield 170(s) 12 50 85 12 35 85 InFer a�ctTor�Summa „ "r,+ , .._ jt' 1pip '; ,, �zs Avi Cycle Length 100 a" + ' •.abL aF £. J r ;.> Control Type Actuated-Uncoordinated Natural Cycle 60 �:,o* s and Phases: 7:Hip hland Avenue S PEP Bo s D 0 o3a4 9Yt,, ' :.. i" a6 f07 F 112x:.. 08 i Proposed CSAC 11/g/2010 2015%.Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 12 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 12: Highland Avenue & East D*. 11/912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour. I l ! '- 1 t:anedroGTFMtt Lane Configurations ?T' Volume(vph) 1060. 0" 0 1099 0 1 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 LaneMFactor 0.95. `r 0.95 1.00 0.95, 1.00 01.00 .865 Frt Fit Protected v Said.Flow(Prot) 3471 0 0 3505 0 1644 Fit Permitted; Said.Flow(perm) 3471 0 0 3505 0 1644 . Link Speed(mph)..,: .30 30 30 Link Distance(ft) 303 45 258 Travel Time(s) 6.9 1.0 ' 5.9 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles(%) 4% 0%.' 0% 3% 0% 0% Adj.Flow(vph) 1104 0 0 1182 0 1 Shared Lane Traffic(°h) 1 Lane Group Flow(vph) 1104 0 0 1182 0 Enter Blocked intersection No No No , No No, No Lane Alignment LeftRight Left Left Left Right f Medlan Width(ft) 0 0.. Link Offset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(fQ 16 16 18' Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor. 1.00 11.000 1.05' 1.00' : 1.05' 1. 00 Turning Speed(mph) Free Stop: Slgn Control Free $� ty Area Type. Other 1' Control Type:Unsignalized ICU Level of Service A Intersection Capacity UUlizaticn 39.3% Analysis Period(min) 15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 13 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 12: Highland Avenue & East Dwy. 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 119/2010 Lane Configurations }p }} r Volume(veh/h) 1060 0 0.1 1099 0 } Sign Control Free Free Stop Grade;' 0% .. 0%: . 0%, Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 093 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) 1104 0 0. 1182 0" i Pedestrians Lane Width(ft) Walking Speed(Ws) , Percent Blockage: Right turn flare(veh) Median type None None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(ft) 954 . pX,platoon unblocked 0.88 0.88 0.88 vC,conflicting volume . 1104 1695 . 552" vC1,stage 1 cont vol vC$stage 2 conf vol vCu,unblocked vol 836 1511 206 tC,single(s) 4.1 6.8 6.9 tC, 2 stage(s) IF(a)'. 2.2 3.5 '. 3.3 p0 queue free% 100 100 100 cM capacity(veh/h) 706. 99= 707 o�recbon`Carta z x EIS i"' R11,01 T.x. 'I�� ' '� fi .�.a :.. Volume Total k t.. 736 368 . 591 591 1' Volume Left 0 0 0 0 0 VolumeRight 0 - 0:: ." 0 0 1 cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 707 Volume to Capacity. 0.43 " 0.22 0.35 0.35 0.00 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 Control Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 10.1 Lane LOS B Approach Delay(a) 0.0 OA 10.1 Approach LOS B Inter98C�ui�'�11mn�arY'icc i "''i'�w' `' 'gt y +.'�fg' 5a�' er Average Delay 0.0 Intersection Capacity Utilization 39.3% ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7• Report Page 14 14: Highland Avenue & First Street Lanes, Volumes, Timings 11/912010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour LanaG�aup;; "' `^ HB� �Bi�° lN '�!&7�tTBl1�� c Lane Configurations f�' Volume(vph) 1040 20 0 1099 0 224 deal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Lane Util.Factor 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 0'865 Frt 0.997 Fit Protected Said.Flow(prot) 3496 0 0 3471 0 1627 Flt Permitted Satd.Flow(perm) 3496 0 0 3471 0 1627 Link Speed(mph) 30 30 30, Link Distance(ft) 45 1133 868 Travel Time(s) 1.0 25.8 19.7 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles 1(%) 3% 0% 0%. 4% 0% 1% Adj.Flow(vph) 1083 21 0 1182 0 243 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 1104 0 0 1182 0 243 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Left Left Right Median Widtti 0 0 0 Link Offset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Widtill 16 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Headway Factor 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 9 Sign Control Free Free Stop In[�Pse"tr�tPdftr�`ir�ri� �...YK.. �r. Area Type: Other Control Type:Unsignalized ICU Level of Service A Intersection Capacity Utilization 49.9% Analysis Period(min) 15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 No-Build Aleekday Morning Peak Hour Page 15 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 14: Highland Avenue & First Street 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour i 1119/2010 y l • *- 4% /► Movement , ?- "EgT,.gr zG!? rdGer Lane Configurations Volumeveh/h A ( ) 1040 20 0 109999•. 0 224 Sign Control Free Free Stop Grade . 0% 0% 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) 1083 21 0 1182 0 243 Pedestrians Lane Width(ft)' Walking Speed(ft/s) Percent Blockage Right turn flare(veh) Median type None None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(ft) 999 pX,platoon unblocked 0.88 0.88 0.88 VC,conflicong volume 1104 1685 552 VC 1,stage 1 cont vol vC2,stage 2 conf vol vCu,unblocked vol 854 1511 229 IC,single(a) 4.1 6.8 6.9 IC, 2 stage(s) IF(s) 2.2 3.5 3.3 p0 queue free% 100 100 65 cM capacity(veh/h) : 702 100 686 r7G1immo Volume Total 722 382 591 591 . s A e Volume Left243 0 0 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 21 0 0 243 cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 686 Volume to Capacity 0.42 0.22 0.35 0.35 0.35 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 40 Control Delay(s) Lane LOS 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 13.1 B Approach Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 131 Approach LOdSS B inlefae<"bon'§�(nm�i' "�' •��?°+;w"Pz�'`�i�axr -`�r�`nr :,°-�""�`b�`j�"�'�yfk 1 �""'s.�✓'. `1"�` -+r Average Delay 1 3 ' ' �� Intersection Capacity Utilization 49.9% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 A i Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 16 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlboroughl/9/2010 Road 2015 Build WeekJaY Mo Ing Peak Hour 1 -A r 4, 4% t Lane Grot x � .r go PB w- eM., Lane Configurations ri tf it R tt tr 9 d t' volume(vph) 445 754 195 111 657 136 175' ' 283 37 175 155 48 Ideal Flow(vphpq 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 19000 19000 1900 1900 Storage Length(ft) 300 110 230 1 i 1 0 1 Storage Lanes 1 25 25 25 25 25 Taper Length(ft) . 25 25 25100 Lane U61.Factor 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.850 0.850 0.850 :'; , . 0.850 Frt 0.950 0.950 0.996 0.971 Flt Protected 0.950 1756 Said.Flow(prot) 1770 . 3539 1538 1770 3438 1583 16180 996 1524 0 0 979 1599 o.950Flt Permitted 0.950 0.950 1538 1770 1583 1618 1758 1524 0 1819 1599 Said.Flow(perm) 1770' 3539 Yes Yes Right Turn an Red Yes 78 60 Said.Flow(RTOR) 124 125 . 30 Link Speed(mph) 30 30 30 1063' 1110 789 Link Distance(ft) 605 24.2 63 25.2 Travel Time(s) 13.8 17.9 Peak Hour Factor 0.90 0.83 0.81 0.95 0.96 0.89 0.63 0.93 0.47 0.65 0.86 0.85 Heavy Vehicles(%) 2% 2% 5% 2% 5% 2% 6% 2% 6% 1% 2% 1% Adj.Flow(vph). 494 908' 241L 117 684 153 2078 283 79 269 180 574 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 494 908 241' 117' 684 153 250- ` 311 79 . 0 449 574 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Left, Right Left Left Right Left, L12 Righf Leff L'�Right Median Width(ft) 12 120 0' 0 Link 0110 16 16 Crosswalk Width(ft) 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.09 1. 05 1.00 1.09 1.05 1.00 1.09 Turning Speed(mph) 15 9 15 11 Number of Detectors 1 2 1 1 , 2 Detector Template: Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left' Thru Right Left Thru Right Leading Detector(ft) 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 20 Trailing Detector(ft) 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Position(ft) 20 20 8 20 20 6 20 10 6 20 Detector 1 SIZe(ft) 20 8 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 1 Channel 0.0 Detector 1 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 U 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Queue(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector i Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 00.04 0.0 0.0 00.04 0.0 Detector 2 Position(ft) 94 94 6 T 6 6 Detector 2 y e(ft) 6 CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex Detector 2 Type . CI+Ex . Cetector 2 Channel 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 2 Extend(s) 0 0 m+ov Turn Type Prot Perm Prot Perm Split 8 pm+o1 Split 4 p 5 Protected Phases 5 2 1 6 4 Permitted Phases 2 6 8 Synchro7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 1 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 2015 Build Weekda MorningPeak Hour 11/9/2010 a-. t /� �► ane Gr"oii'"�T�� ., �;E�C ��t' �di�!��'1�ib�.G�F �fz �lBl� -„1�eF�` `Nt3 ' • ; t;�'�°' Detector Phase 5 2 2 1 Switch Phase 6 6 ' 8 8 x 1 4 4 5 Minimum Initial(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0. 4.0 4.0 ' 4.0 Minimum Split(s) 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 20.0 20.0 9.0 Total Split(s) 37.0 51.0 51.0: 16.0 30.0, 30.0. 25.0 25.0: 16.0 33.0 33A 37.0 Total Split(%) 29.6% 40.8% 40.8% 12.8% 24.0% 24.0% 20.0% 20.0% 12.8% 26.4% 26.4% 29.6% Maximum Green(s) 32.0: 46.0 46.0 .. 11.0 25:0 . 25.0 20.0 20.0 - 11.0 28.0 Yellow Time(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Z2.0 4.0 8.0 34.0 All-Red Time(s) 1.0 1.0. 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 . 1.0 Lost Time Adjust(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Lost Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 5,0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 . 5.0 5.0 Lead/Lag Lead Lead Lead Lag Lag Lag Lead-Lag Optimize? Lag Lead Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 Recall Mode None None 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 . None None None None, Max Max Nang Max Max None Act Effct Green(s) 32.0 40.9 40.9 16.1 25.0 25.0 20.0 Z0.0 36.1 Max 60.0 Actuated gIC Ratio 0.26 0.33 0.33 0.13 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16 0.29 22 v/c Ratio 109 0.78 0.41 0.51 0.99 0.37 0.97 1,11 0,16 110 0.48 Control Delay 112.7 43.0 16.6 61.4 82.9 13.8 100.1 133.5 5.2 120.5 10.727.3 Queue Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Delay . 112.7 43.0 16.6 61.4 82.9 13.8 100.1 133.5 5.2 120.5 17.3 LOS Approach Delay F 60.D1 B E 692 B F F A F B Approach LOS E .E 104.6 62.6 F E Inlers9 llor i�ilrimary• <6< s "t air as "A { ��r'7 Area Type Other ` L" "� S*k Mll M21 , "m Cycle Length: 125 Actuated Cycle Length: 125 Natural Cycle:130 Control Type:Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum v/c Ratio: 1.11 Intersection Signal Delay: 69.4 Intersection LOS: E Intersection Capacity Utilization 91.2% ICU Level of Service F Analysis Period(min) 15 S lits and Phases: 3: Highland Avenue&Marlborou h Road u2 51 s 001 04 ue ..... :. •.. 16'ss .. 339 d5 ~06 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 2 Queues 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Mornin Peak Hour r '- k_ 1(( pt P 1K �r rg,�' . _ (3 Lane16 u _ 1 a. 79 449 574 Lane Group Flow(vph) 494 908 241 117 684 153 250 311 vk Ratlo:.: 1.09 0.78. 0.41 0.51 0.9& 0.37 : 0.97 . 1.11 0.18 1.10 0.72 Control Delay 112.7 430 16.6 61.4 82.9 13 8 100.1 130.0 , 0.01 `:120.0'"0.5 10.0 Queue Delay 0.0,` off. 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 0 `. Total Delay 112.7 43.0 16.6 61.4 82.9 13 8 1001 133.5 5.2 120.5 17.3 Queue Lengih 50th(ft)' -450 345, 68' _.' "90 293' 19 ) 213 ' .-302 , 1 '` ' -412. 158 Queue Length 95th(ft) #663 358 109 #190 #724 77 209 983 0 1030'.4577 208 7 Internal Link DI(it) ,. 525 '. 170 200 Turn Bay Length(ft) 300 110 230 180 Base Capacity(vph), 453' 1302. 644: 228 688 417 259 2111 494 ' 407' 799 Starvation Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Spillback Cap Reductn` 0 _ 0 0 0 0 0 0 ' . 0 00 0 . Storage Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reduced vlc Ratio 1.09; 0.70 0.37 0.51 0.99 ` 0.37 0.97 t,i t 0.18' 1.10 0.72 TII Yj:S u`"` .fi: .,t'iH. . f xr:s�. s,. 1,13 Volume exceeds capacity,queue is theoretically infinite;= - Queue shown is maximum after two cycles. # 95th percentile volume exceeds capacity,queue may be longer.- Queue shown is maximum after two cycles. Synchro 7• Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 3 1 , H'CM Signalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road 2015 Build Weekda g MorninPeak Hour 11/9/2010 4, i `• ! rAofemenF' .v "r Y y" EI3C E8t1 E� W9C w , W hIf3L Nf NBf Lane Configurations q t'f A 4tr �l Volume(vph) 445 754 195 111 657 136 175. 263 37 175 155 488 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Total Lost time(s) 5.0 5.0 . 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Frt Lane Util.Factor 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.00 0.85 1.00 1.00 0.85 1.00 Fit Protected 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 ON 0.85 Said. Flow(prot) 1770 3539; 1538- 1770 3438 : 1583 1618 1755 1524'. 1819 1599 Fit Permitted 0.95 100 1,00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 Said.Flow(perm) 1770 3539 1538 1776 3438 1583 1618 1755 1524 1819 0.97 1.00 1590 Peak hour factor,PH F 0.90 0.83 0.81 0.95 0.96 0.89 0.63 0.93 0.47 0.65 0.86 0.85 Ad).Flow(vph) 494 908 241 117 684 153 278 283 79 269 180 574 RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 0 83 0 0 100 0 0 54 0 0 31 Lane Group flow(vph) 494 908 158 117 684 53 250 311 25 0 Heav Vehicles % 2% 2% 5% 2% 5% 2% 6% 2% 6% 1% 2% 5% Tum Type Prot Perm Prot Protected Phases 5 2 Penn Split pm+ov Split pm+av Permitted Phases 1 6 8 8 1 4 4 5 Actuated Green, G s 2 6' 8 4 O 320 40.9 40.9 16.1 25.0 25.0 20.0 20.0 36.1 28.0 60.0' Effective Green,g(s) 32.0 . 40.9 40.9 16.125.0 25.0 20.0 20.0 36.1 . 28.0 60.0 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.26 0.33 0.33 0.13 0.20 0.20 0.16 0.16 0.29 Clearance Time(s) 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 . 5.0 9.0 0.22 O&8 Vehicle Extensions 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 5.0. 5.0 Lane Grp UP(vph) 453' . 1158 . 503 228 : 688 317 259 281 440 07 3.0 v/s Ratio Prot c0.28 0.26 0.07 c0.2007 768 v/s Ratio Perm . O. Co.c018 0.01 c0.25 0.18 v/c Ratio 0.10 0.03 0.01' 109 0.78 0.31 0.51 0.99 0.17 0.97 1.11 0.08 0.18 Uniform Delay,di 46.5 38.1 31.5 50.6 49.9 41.4 52.2 52.5 3s•1 1'10 0.71 Progression Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1,00 1.00 48.5 125.6 .00 Incremental Delay,d2 69.0 3.6 0.4 1.9 32.7 0.3 47.7 85.4 0.1 75.5 13.0 Delay(s) 115.5 41.6 31.9 52.7 82.6 41.6 99.8 137.9 32.2 124.0 28.6 Level of Service F D C D F D F F Approach Delay(s) 62.4 72 4 C F C Approach LOS E E 110.0 70.5 F E itlt9rsec�0"1�'"S'Gmm'"" .-p-`fmvt,k ::. r �`rZj,, ,,.,5. ;' `` tc. ' "' 'FM,h.gK.ti;�� fr7 HCM Average Control Dela Y 73 7 HCM Level of Service HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 1.07 E Actuated Cycle Length(s) 125.0 Sum of lost time(s) Intersection Capacity Utilization 91.2% ICU Level of Service Z0.0 Analysis Period(min) i5 F c Critical Lane Group Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 4 3: Highland Avenue & Marlborough Road Timing Report, Sorted By Phase 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 1,1 .41 _•_5s Movement WBL EBT SBTL EBL WDT NBTL Leadilag .'' Lag Lead Lead Lag Lead-Lag Optimize Retail Mode_ None : None ` Max None; None Max Maximum Split(s) 16 51 33 37 30 25 Maximum Split(°k)', 12.8% . 40.8% ` 26.4 29.6°b 24.096 ' 20.0% Minimum Split(s) 9 20 20 4 20 20 y 1. £ Yellow Time(s) 4.: q - q 4 '- q q>` , All-Red Time(s) 1 1 1 t t 1 ., .., , , Minimum IhiBal(s) 4, 44 q3 3 3 3 3 3 Vehicle Extension(s) 3 3 3 3 Minimum Gap(s) 3 3 Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Time To Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Walk Time(s) Flash Dont Walk(s):•: Dual Entry No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Inhibit Mai- `. Yes Yes . YesYes: Yes Yes Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 End Time(a) 67 51 .. 100 37 67': 0 Yield/Force Off(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 YieldlForce Off Willis) 62` 46 95 32 62 120.:` Local Start Time(s) 51 0 67 0 37 100 LocaFYield`(a} ' 62 46 1 95 32' 62' 120`. '. Local Yield 170(s) 62 46 95 32 62 120 3 ^ .: p`fM N. .. : . . 25 Cycle Length 1 oordinated Control Type ' Actuated-Unc Natural Cycle 130 S lits and Phases: 3:Hi hland Avenue&Mariborou h Road ma 04 I-,-,'0o2 �I pl ,... i:' p _. - , �. tats 33 e. -- Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 5 Lines, Volumes, Timings 6: Highland Avenue & West Dwy. 2015 Build Weekday morning Peak Hour 1119/2010 ----------- Lal 1 G ) E�1" =91 ;?VTI GUBf 1G81 N6R Lane Configurations }}. Volume(vph) 1128 14 0 1129 0 9 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Lane Util.Factor 0.95 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00`° 1.00 Frt 0.998 Fit Protected 0.865 Satd.Flow(prof) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1644 Flt Permitted Satd.Flow(perm) 3499 0 0 3471 0 1644 Link Speed(mph) 30 30 30 Link Distance(ft) 651 303 265 Travel Time(s) 14.8 6.9 6.0 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0,92 Heavy Vehicles(%) 3% 0% 0% 4% 0% 0% Adj.Flow(vph) 1175 15 0 1214 0 10 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vi 1190 0 0 1214 0 10 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Left Left Right Median Width(R) 12 12 0 Link Offset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(ff) 16 16 16 Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor, 1.00: 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 . Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 g Sign Control . Free Free': Stop Area Type Other Control Type:Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Utilization 41.6% ICU Level of Service A Analysis Period(min) 15 r Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 6 HCM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 6: Highland Avenue & West Dwy. 111912010 2015 Build Week Jay Morning Peak Hour }E �BWB� N y t4lovem kq { 4. Lane Configurations tl► ?? Volume(vehm) 1128 14 0 .1129 0 9 Sign ControlFree Free Stop Grade Ooh 0% 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flovy rate(vph) 1175 15 6 1214, 0 10 , Pedestrians Lane Width(ft) walking Speed(ftls) Percent Blockage Right turn flare(veh) None Median type None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(ft) : 651 pX,platoon unblocked 0.81 0.81 0.81 1190 1789 595 vC,conflicting volume vCt,stage 1 cont vol vC2,stage 2 cord vol 760 1502 24 vCu,unblocked vol 41 6.8, 6.9 tC,single(a) ., tC, 2 stage(s) 2.2 3.5 . 3.3 IF(e) 100 too 99 PO queue free% 93` 851 cM capacity(vehm) 696 0.. fin&' Volume Total.. 783 . 406 � 607. _ 607. 10' Volume Left 0 0 0 0 0 volume Right 0 15.,. 0 0: 10.: cSH 1700 1700 1700 1700 851 volume to capacity 0.46 0.24 0.36 0.36 0.01 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 1 Control Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 9.3 A Lane LOS 0.0 9.3 Approach Delay(s) . , 0.0 Approach LOS ,� g Average Delay 0.0A Intersection Capadty Utilization. 41.6% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 Synchro7- Report Proposed CSAC 11/912010 2015 Build weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 7 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 2015 Build Weekda MorningPeak Hour 11/9/2010 , " ' Lane Configurations q rp3 � `u= 8 $8L' WW",'SS� Volume(vph) 27 936 37 222 796 111 41 15 160 46 12 96 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Storage Length(ft) 225 0 250• 310 280 Storage Lanes 1 0 1 280 100 100 Taper Length(ft) P5 1 0 1 1 0 Lane Util. Factor 25 25 , 25 - 25 25 25 Y5 1.00 0.95 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.0 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 0 1.00 Frt 0.994. Flt Protected 0.950 0.850 0.850, 0.667 Said. Flow rot 0.950 0965 0.950 (P ) 1805 3481 0 ' 1752 3438 1615 0 1807 1568 1736 1647 0 Flt Permitted 0.950 0.950 Said.Flow(perm) 1805 .3481 0 1752 3438 . 1615 0 0.618 657 . 1568 0.709 1647. Right Turn on Red Yes 0 Said.Flow(RTOR) Yes Yes Yes Link Speed(mph) 30 , 117 42. 120 Link Distance(ft) 789 30 30 30 Travel Time(s) 17.9 651 328 270 Peak Hour Factor 14.8 7.5 6.1 0.92 0.92 0.92 0.95 0.95 0.95 0.76 0.76 0.76 0.80 0.80 0.80 Heavy Vehicles(%) 0% 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% Adj.Flow(vph) 29 1017 40 234 838 . 117 54 20 211 58.- 15 . 120 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flaw(vph) 29 1057 0 234 838 117 0 74 211 58 . 135 0 Enter Blocked Intersection No No No No No No No No No No No No Lane Alignment Left Left Right Left Left Right . Left Left Right Left Left Right Median Width(ft) 12 12 Link Oftsel(ft) 0 12 12 Crosswalk Width(ft) 166 0 0 Two way Left Turn Lane 6 16 16 Headway Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Turning Speed(mph) 15 9 15 9 15 Number of Detectors 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 9 15 2 g Detector Template Left Thru Left Thru Right Left Thru Right Left Thru Leading Detector(ft) 20 100 20 100 20 20 100 20 20 100 Trailing Detector(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Position(ft) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Detector 1 Size(ft) 20 6 20 6 20 20 6 20 20 Detector 1 Type CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+E6 Detector 1 Channel Detector 1 Extend(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Queue(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Detector 1 Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0,0 0.0 0.0 Detector 2 Posiffon(ft) 94 0.0 0.0 0.0 94 Detector 2 Size(ft) 6 94 94 Detector 2 Type CI+Ex6 6 Detector 2 Channel CI+Ex CI+Ex CI+Ex i Detector 2 Extend(s) 0.0 00 . Turn Type Prot 0'0 0.0 Protected Phases Prot Perm Perm pm+ov Perm 7 4 3 8 2 3 Permitted Phases 8 2 6 2 6 Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 8 a ' 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. Lanes, Volumes, Timings 111912010 2015 Build WeekdayMornin, Peak Hour l l 1 f +- t 1 t Ntti r NB EBIwSem E' e'��^w9wWwr3it NST s Lane.�rbu 3 8 8 2 p 3 6 8 I Detector Phase 7 4 Switch Phase Minimum Initial(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4. Prlinimum Split(s) 8.0 20.0 8.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 8.0 20.0 20.0 Total Split(s) 12.0' 46.0 0.0 27.0 61.0 61.0 27.0 27.0 27.0 27.0 27.0 0.0 Total Split(%) 12.0% 46.0% 0.0% 27.0% 61.0% 61.0% 27.0% 27.0% 27.0% 27.0% 27.0% 0.0% Maximum Green(s) 8.0 42.0 23.6 57.0 57.0' 23.0 23.0 23.0 23.0 23.0 Yellow Time(s) 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 3.5 All-Red Time(s) 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Lost Time Adjust(s) 0.o o.o o.o o.o a.o o.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Total Lost Time(s) 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Lad Lead/Lag Lead Lag Lead Lag Lag Yes Lead-Lag Optimize? Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Vehicle Extension(s) 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 nNone None None None 3A 3A 3A 3.0 Recall Mode None None None None None None 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 5.0 Walk Time(s) 11.0 . 11.0 11.0 11.0 11.0 11.0 Flash Dont Walk(s) 11.0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Pedestrian Calls(9/hr) 0 9.6 9.6 9.7 25,9 Act Effct Green(s) 7.1 29.7 15.4 47.3 47.3 Actuated gIC Ratio 0.11 0.46 0.24 0.73 0.73 o15 0.40 015 015 Ratio 0.14 0.66 0.56 0.33 0.10 0.43 0.32 0.30 0.39 vjc Co 35.6 17.3 30.8 6.0 1.7 38.5 12.4 34.4 12.5 Control Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Queue Delay 0.6 0.0 Total Delay 35.6 17.3 30.8 6.0 1.7 38.D 12.a 34.0 12 B LOS D B C A A 19.1 8 17 10.4 19.1 Approach Delay B B 9 B Approach LOS X47--au2N+"r'rer § 1x1 � 4� Int oSi meN" ' �< s eh 70 Area Type: Other Cycle Length: 100 Actuated Cycle Length:64.5 Natural Cycle:60 Control Type:Actuated-Uncoordinated Maximum vlc Ratio: 0.66 Intersection LOS:B Intersection Signal Delay: 14.8 ICU Level of Service B Intersection Capacity Utilization 59.1% Analysis Period(min)15 Splits and Phases: 7: Hichland Avenue&PEP Bas Dw . 0� ► 04 46 270 . 27s . : . s 12,; ]SIR Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 9 111 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 2015 Build Weekday MorningPeakHou 11/9/2010 S:18:111 Lane Group Flow(vph) 29 1057 234 838 7 74 211 58 135 v/c Ratio 0.14 0.68 0.56- 0.33 0.10 0.43 0.32 0.30 0.39 Control Delay 35.6 17.3 30,8 6.0 1.7 38.5 12.4 344 12.5 Queue Delay 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Total Delay 35.6 173 30.8 6.0 1.7 38.5 12.4 34.4 12.5 Queue Length 50th(ft) 11 166 83 45 0 27 40 21 5 Queue Length 951h(ft) 43 308 191 151 19 69 84 59 44 Intemal Link,Dist(ft) 709 571 248 Turn Bay Length(R) 225 250 310 280 100 190 Base Capacity(vph) 249 2380 696 2921 1390 460 898 514 727 Starvation Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 6 0 Spillback Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Storage Cap Reductn 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reduced vic Ratio 0.12 0.44 0.34 0.29 0.08 0.16 0.23 0.11 0.19 I IMT- Aw-M o! Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 10 HCM Signalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys X2010 2015 Build Weekday Morninq Peak Hour EBL rngem %MV17 Lane Configurations I fib 1 796 111 41 15 160 46 12 96 Volume(vph) 27 936 37 222 Ideal Flow(vphpi) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Total Lost time(s) 4,0 4.0 4.0. 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Lane Util.Factor 1.00 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Frt 1.00, 0.99 1.00 1.00: 0.85 1.00 0.85 1.00 0.87 Fit Protected 0.95 1.00 0.95 1.00 100 0.96 1.00 0.95 100 Said.Flow(prot) 1805 3482 1752 3438 1615 1807 1568 1736 1647 Fit Permitted 0.95 1.00 0.95 100 100 0.62 100 0.71 1.00 said.Flow erm 1806 3482 - 1752 3438 1615 1156 1568 1295 1647 Peak-hour factor,PHF 0.92 0.92 0.92 0.95 0.95 0,95 0.76 0.76 0.76 0.80 0.80 0.80 4 20 2`11 58 15 120 Adj.Flow(vph) 29 1017 40 234 838 117 50 0 28 0 107 0 RTOR Reduction(vph) 0 3 0 0 0 38 Lane Group Flow(vph) 29 1054 0 234 838 79 0 74 183 58 28 0 Heavy Vehicles 0% 3% 5% 3% 5% 0% 2% 0% 3% 4% 0% 0% Turn Type Prot Prot Perm Perm pm+ov Perm Protected Phases 7 4 3 8 Permitted Phases a 2 Actuated Green,G(s) 14 32.9 15.4 45.9 45.9 7.6 23.0 7.6 7.6 Effective Green,g(a) 2.4 32.9 15.4 46.9 45.9 7.6 23.0 7.6 7.6 Actuated g/C Ratio 0.04 0.48 0.23 0.68 04 .68 0.11 0.34 0.11 0.11 4.0 4.0 4�O 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 4.0 Clearance Time(s) 3.0 3.0 Vehicle Extensions 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0- 1687 397 2324 1 UWZ 130 624 145 184 Lane Grp Cap(vph) 64 0.07 0.02 v1s Ratio Prot 0.02 c0.30 C0.13 0.24 0.05 c0.06 0.05 0.04 We Ratio Perm v1c Ratio 0.45 0.63 0.59 0.36 0.07 0.57 0.29 0.40 0.15 Uniform Delay,all 32.1 12.9 23.4 4.7 3.7 28.6 16.5 28.0 27.2 Progression Factor 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 10.4 .00 Incremental Delay,c12 5.0 0.7 2.2 o'! 0.0 5.6 0.3 1.8 Delay(s) 37.1 133 25.7 4.8 3.8 34,2 16.7 29.8 27.6 Level of Service 0 B C A A C 3 28.38 21 8. . Approach Delay(s) 14.3 C Approach LOS B A C I Mln'?i HCM Average Control Delay 13.6 HCM Level of Service HCM Volume to Capacity ratio 0.61 Actuated Cycle Length(a) 67.9 Sum of lost time(3) 12.0 Intersection Capacity Utilization 59.1% ICU Level of Service B Analysis Period(min) 15 c; Critical Lane Group Proposed CSAC 11/912010 2015 Build Weekday'Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 11 Timing Report, Sorted By Phase 7: Highland Avenue & PEP Boys Dwy. 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 , t ?iia BIm�erv � 2' ? )43s J, '1111'r aA.tz-�fi. a w Vx��fF'af �R� .perti 1 aX§�Ji'; Movement NBTL WBL EBT SBTL EBL WBT Lead/Lag Lead Lag Lead . Lag . Lead-Lag Optimize Yes Yes Yes Yes Recall Mode None None None None-, None None Maximum Splits ( ) 27 21 46 27 12 Maximum Split(°h) 27.0% 27.0% 46.0% 27.0% 12.0%' 61.0% Minimum Split(s) 20 8 20 20 8 20 Yellow Time(s) 3.5 3.5 3.5 3,6- 3.5:, 3.5'' All-Red Time(s) 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 Minimum Initial(s) 4 4 4 4 4 . 4 Vehicle Extension(s) 3 3 3 3 3 3 Minimum Gap(s). 3 3 3 3 3 3 Time Before Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Time To Reduce(s) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Walk Time(s) 5 5 5 5 Flash Dont Walk(s) 11 11 11 11 Dual Entry Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Inhibit Max Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Start Time(s) 0 27 54 0 27 39 End Time(s) 27 54 0 27 39 0 Yield/Force Off(s) 23 50 96 23 35 96 Yield/Force OB 170(s) 12 50 85 12 35 85 Local Start Time(s) 0 27 54 0 .27 39 Local Yield(s) 23 50 96 23 : 35 96 Local Yield 170(s) 12 50 85 12 35 85 ioieFse6 rt, m'" Cycle ,':. � Length -:, , 100 Control Type Actuated-Uncoordinated Natural Cycle 60 S lits and Phases: 7:Hi.Mand Avenue&PEP Bo s Dw . a2 ,. 469, m7 ~oA .. Proposed CSAC I UT2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 12 12: Highland Avenue & East Dwy. Lanes, Volumes, Timings 11/912010 2015 Build Week Jay M ng Peak Hour -ans�iou ._ Iff- 4f tr Lane Configural ons Volume(vph) 1050 87- 0 >-.1129' 0: 81 Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1-00 Lane IFactor 0.95 0.95 1.00' 0.95 r 1.00.' 0.865 Frt 0.988 Fit Protected Said.Flow(Prot) 3440 0 0 3505 0 1644 Fit Permitted.< Said.Flow(perm) . 3440 0 0 3530 30 1644 Link Speed(mph)': 30 Link Distance(it) 303 45 258 Travel Time(s) 6.9 1.0 5.9 Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Heavy Vehicles(%) 4%` OS, 00A 3% 0% 0% Adj. Flow(vph) 1094 91 0 1214 0 95 Shared Lane Traffic(%) Lane Group Flow(vph) 1185 0 0 1214 0 95 Enter Blockedlntersecton No No No. No No No Lane Alignment Left Right Left Left Left Right Median WId1h(ft) 0 0 0: Link OBset(ft) 0 0 0 Crosswalk Width(ft)= 18 18 is- Two way Left Turn Lane Headway Factor 1.00 1.00'' 1.00'- 1.00- 1.00 1.000 Turning Speed(mph) 9 15 15 Sign control Free Frees4toa { Iri�e 31ti Area Type:.:, Other _ Control Type:Unsignalized ICU Level of Service A Intersection Capacity Utilization 43.8% Analysis Period(min)15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 13 ( H'CM Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 12: Highland Avenue & East Dwy. 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour 11/9/2010 >sn. ibvement - x Brts' €9RgVVg'; VlB)N *TVB v Line Configurations ip idBFi Volume(veh/h) 105087 0 1129 Sign Control Free Free Free 0 877 Stop Grade 0% 0% Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) Pedestrians 1094 91 0 1214 0 95 Lane Width(fl) Walking Speed(IUs) Percent Blockage Right turn flare(veh) Median type None Median storage veh) None Upstream signal(it) 954 pX,platoon unblocked 0.84 0.84 0.84 vC,conflicting volume' 1184 vC1,stage 1 conf vol 1746 592 vC2,stage 2 conf vol vCu, unblocked vol 846 tC,single(s) 1512 143 tC, 2 stage(s) 4.1 6.8 6.9 IF(s) 2.2 p0 queue free% 100 100 87 CM capacity(veh/h) 674 95 746 due"otr^ a ,. E �? ESC r WeiItit mom. Volume Total 729 455 607 607 f Volume Left 95 0 0 0 Volume Right 0 cSH 91 0' 0 95 1700 1700 1700 1700 746 Volume to Capacity 0.43 0.27 0.36 0,36 0.13- Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 11 Control Delay(s) 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 10.5 Lane LOS Approach Delay(s) 0.0 B Approach LOS p 0 0 10.5 IM InMfsecrToniSummx. 5t 9< prr ?. ttT� Average Delay �.4 Intersection Capacity Utilization 43.8% ICU Level of Service Analysis Period(min) 15 A Proposed CSAC 11/9/2010 2015 Build Weekday IIIilOfning Peak Hour Synchro 7- Report Page 14 Lanes, Volumes, Timings 14: Highland Avenue & First1Street 2015 Build Weekday' Mornin Peak Hour 11 10MVIF''I u: Lane Configuratons Volume Oph) 10601 77 ';' 0 1129 0'. Ideal Flow(vphpl) 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 1900 Lane Uti1.Factor, 0.95s, 0.95-,- 1.00 0.95 1A0 0,865 Frt 0.990 Flt Protected= 3477 ` 0 0 3471 0 1627 Said. Flow(Prot) Flt Permitted 34771 0 0 3471 0 1627 Said.Flow(perm) 30 30 Link Speed(mph)v 30; , 45 1133 868 Link Distance(ft) 25.8 Travel Time(s). ,., i 1.0 , Peak Hour Factor 0.96 0 96 0.93 0.93 0.92 0 .92 Heavy Vehicles(%)' ;' 3°/¢ 0%' 0% -, 0%` ,v' 4%:` ; - Adj.Flow(vph) 1104 80 0 1214 0 243 Shared Lane Traffic(°6),, Lane Group Flow(vph) 1184 0 0 1214 0 243 Enter Blockedlntersection No: No No ,' , NO:, No:, No Left Right Left Left Left Right Lane Alignment 0 9 0 ' 0% ' Median Width(ft) .,;.': % ' Link Offset(ft) 16 ' ": 18. 16% , Crosswalk Width(ft) Two way Left Turn Lane Turning Speed 1"00 100 9 15 :1.00",15 -1.00• 1.05; 109 Headway peed(mph) Free Stop; sign Control Free ' a L W! t ( r e Area Type:: 4 1, 1502,111 "other Control Type Unsignalized ICU Level of Servlce A Intersection Capacity uplizatlon 52.3% . Analysis Period(min)15 Synchro 7- Report Proposed CSAC 111912010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Page 15 HLIvl Unsignalized Intersection Capacity Analysis 14: Highland Avenue & First Street 2015 Build Weekday Mornin Peak Hour 2010 4% EB1 EBRD r ABuTm BIT Configurations Lane Conti IMEM Volume(veh1h) TT it Sign Control 1060 77 0 1129 0 224 Grade Free Free Stop Peak Hour Factor 0% 0% 0% 0.96 0.96 0.93 0.93 0.92 Hourly flow rate(vph) 1104 80 0 1214 0.92 Pedestrians 0 243. Lane Width(ft) Walking Speed(fits) Percent Blockage Right turn Rare(veh) Median type None None Median storage veh) Upstream signal(ft) 999 PX,Platoon unblocked 0.89 0.89 0,89 vC,conflicting volume vC 1, stage I conf vol 1184 1751 592 vC2,stage 2 coni vol vCu, unblocked vol tC,single(a) 955 1593 288 tC, 2 stage(s) 4.1 6.8 6.9 IF(s) PO queue free% 2.2 3.5 3.3 CM capacity(vehih) 100 100 61 646 89 632' Z iolume coral 736 "a out 607 243 Volume Left 0 0 0 Volume Right0 80 0 cSH 0 243 Volume to Capacity 1700 1700 1700 1700 632 0.43 0-26 0.36 0.36 0.39 Queue Length 95th(ft) 0 0 0 0 45 Control Delay(s) Lane LOS 0-0 0-0 0.0 0.0 14.2 Approach Delay(s) 0.000 14.2 Approach LOS . ,vmdqu Delay Intersection Capacity Utilization Analysis Period(min) 5Z3% ICU Level of Service A 15 Proposed CSAC 1119/2010 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour -------------- Synchro 7. Report Page 16 "Zoning Board Project Status Sheet Address & Applicant: �. v7 I �r4 G �� i Cd� l ({-L-� C� Date of Submitted to BOA: Clerk Stamp: ,1 - 3 (, - to �( Abutters List Requested: 7 , -rp � Abutters Notice Sent: 2s Notice to Abutting Cities & Towns -ll�'-cv Legal Notice Faxed & Confirmed: Agenda to Applicant: -(O -CO 12-1?/(,0 Opened at Meeting: q f- o Continued Meetings: 1, - . -j -w izli5�ia Extension Form Signed & Clerk Stamped? Decision: Decision Filed: z o Appeal Period Over: Decision Sent to Applicant: zl2 rl Irl Notice of Decision Sent: z Zg io C,W-V-s - Iz �zglL� 11C Cilh�s r-F-vuYts -lili.�l,� CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEAL 120WASHINGIONSMEE1 *Sz\Ilznt,,'Vl,\-SSA(-TIL.ISEI"lsO[970 TFi-E:978-619-6685 # FAX:978-740-0404 bVkyos Notice of Decisions At a meeting of the Cry of Salem Zoning Board held on Wednesday, December 15, 2010 at 6:30 p.m. at the 120 Washington St.,, Salem, MA, the Zoning Board of Appeals voted on the following items: Petition of JOSH GILLIS, seeking a Variance from rear yard setback, and a Special Permit to extend a nonconforming structure, in order to enclose and roof over a 12' x 11'4" porch on the second story of the existing two-family home on the property located at 7 UNION ST, Salem, MA (R-2 Zoning District). Decision: Granted Filed with the City Clerk on December 28, 2010 Petition of WILLIAM WHARFF, seeking a Special Permit to change one nonconforming use to another, and a Variance from lot area per dwelling unit, in order to convert a three-unit bed and breakfast to three individual dwelling units, on the property located at 51-53 WASHINGTON SQUARE NORTH, Salem, MA (R-2 Zoning District). Decision: Granted Filed with the City Clerk on December 28, 2010 Petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) Pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on the properryat 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (former Hillcrest automobile dealership) [132]. Decision: Denied Filed with the City Clerk on December 28, 2010 7hiq ayicr is Icbgsor in wnpluixe wth t1xilassad.wats Coxxil Law, Qipter 40,1,Satias 9& 15auticlasraxrnlrrirecrcuiutlydxrmplax Ipp:11s, shill femade pinsaint to(Impt,,r 40,1,Savai 17,atkNAS/efij(tj zzjjj)jij 10 tjmfiv)jt1x(bite UnJ)thetk6ion uLsfilal zath the City Ck,k. � I ' I ^c �o I n .+ All t la.�i<�i: ` I w C SgMI, AskIf not Ong iYq i v }jrz�1$b{xy, I vim' I •':xl.. I I I I 1 I I I 1 1 1 1 I LIi 'c r.:1; b:tLt,i�I I ASSESSORS' OFFICE CITY Y BALL SALEM, ��UU1970 S/ / I i o J-v i O I I 24 ol 7 l4iW5 %p 2 2130, 14-S&97 %, 75 99 14 Al .)4 2 ol P -- -------------- .................. 14M 00.......... 14 ZVI 69 7- 0 NSe LAI, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Cllt Jr; SALEM A SSORs' OFFICE 111///0 CITY OF SALEM � ASSESSOR'S CERTIFICATION OF ABUTITERS AND "PARTIES IN INTEREST,, BOARD/COMMISSION: Zoning BoardofAppeals HEC„ 'M•r ^' PROJECT SITE: 207 llighland Ave. (13-0002-11 ) AUG 3 12010 DEPT OF P• �., n�. DATE: S/30/10 C0Mn3;1N1 , L DESCRIPTION OF REQUIREMENT: Parties in Interest: 'rhe applicant Abutters Owners of land opposite any street or way Abutters within 300 feet Planning boards of abutting cities and towns This is to certify that the time of the last assessment for taxation made by the City of Salcm, the names and addresses of those listed on the attached sheets are "parties in interest', (as defined by Massachusetts General Law Chapter 40A, Section l l) to the parcel(s) of land listed above as tile project site. Assessor's Signature:14U Date: 30 /!J Number of initialed pages attached: pl Once Certified, Return to: Department of Planning and Community Development •':.50Nr i! 1 o Srrlr nt ril(rs nc loot tls 1.'(')�)CI1 (" IC:\V(.'I' New Property Search Property Record Care 450 feet _ ©FIELD Property ID 13 0002 0 ...} �.. N Andress 2077HIGH OHIGHLAND AVENUE wner HILLCREST REALTY TRUST II T' �V Property ID 13_0012 0 4FIRST STREET D'•°net SAF HAWTHORNE COMMONS LLC \ Property ID 130004_0 AJdres, 201-205 HIGHLAND AVENUE r r rn"ner SAF HAWTHORNE COMMONS LLC Property ID 13_0001_0 \. " i Address 204 HIGHLAND AVENUE Owner 204 HIGHLAND AVE REALTY TRUST ProPerty 10 13_0002_0 Address 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE ti. Owner HILLCREST REALTY TRUST II Property lD 05_0124_ 0 Addl res, 218-222 HIGHLAND AVENUE � � t . \ ` ointa, 300 - R Us Add/Rev..ee At Add r Abrdter .. D Parcels tontFrrecls •9 .: 3B �e� r Remove Ey C Target Parcels LJ o i51 G- '_1 Scale I 49 Pert It ualom City 41x119,3 Wll n), un Slmet,$olenr,AIA 019;0 City l9dl Hourz o(Opnrafiano M1lonWr Tue.�nPhono_014.:::5-r,..ny A fy45VMneu1°Y'AM'IPM Thnr.day NAM.TPM PI blay;!Afa-I'Ptl Site deergned by 1pi,ro_ 13 0012 0 SAf HANITIORPIE MMONS LLC 3645 RUFFIN a D SUITE 310 SAN DIFGO. A )2123 130004 0 SAFHAWTHORNF,COMMONS LLC 3645 RUFFIN ROAD SUITE 310 SAN DIEGO,CA 92123 13 0001 0 204 HIGHLAND AVE REALTY TRUST 30 CYPRESS HOLLOW BLUFFTON,SC 399094528 130002 0 HILLCRESTREALTYTRUST II 10713RIMOAL AVE REVF.RLY,MA 01970 O8 0124 0 HERMAN PROPF.RTIES,LLC 220 HIGHLAND AVENUE SALEM,MA 01970 08 0141 0 SECOND PICKWICK TRUST THE 875 EAST STREFT TEWKSI3URY,MA 01876 118 0123 0 PEP 13OYS-MA N NY MOH& 3111 WESTALLEGHENY AVE PHILADELPHIA,PA 19132 1 Pine I of I Danielle McKnight From: Danielle McKnight Sent: Tuesday, December 07, 2010 2:49 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: December 15, 2010 ZBA meeting - methadone clinic petition Dear Resident: l'he December 15, 2010 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting regarding the 207 Highland Ave. petition (methadone clinic) will be held at 120 NVASHINGTON ST., 3rc1 floor conference room ( 13) (1101 at the Bowditch School, where the November 17, 2010 meeting took place). YOU received this message because you signed in at the November 17, 2010 ZBA meeting. Danielle McKnight Staff Planner Department of Planning and Community Development City Hall Annex 120 Washington Street Salem, MA 01970 (978) 619-5685 diiicknight@salem.com 12115;21110 _ _ _ _ __ -02(j gm waxen "lem-AW—mwo: t-s A M-W: Wen Tum-, Dew Vs:dmt -w TINDumObs !"MMud vApo,, S T.. etl._e "Aad"" INGTON cu fmb�' t"j z3A F Nc— cmere fj:njg'� A55 129 4 S, ey jQ75: 219 Start _e:e �, City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet f Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date _— Name Mailing Address Phone # E-mail A 4,/J et.S plc. oQ MC J . 4 Mnyb ►ow�� J 9x=7�CSlG 16 1 ` Vcf� _ � � 1 �r pN 175 FJ— l CJ Nage uF e_ b.:.e City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet 9F/91,�K� Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date 11 —/-1-L_1 /0 Name Mailing Address Phone # E-mail r� eft NIX G t5 me 9��- 5 �- "S dyet ( I.�I%� �� F� ksr Sr �700� ?7,�1 boy-Selo �t� r /I� 6` 7 CA'40fI r�cs� C,Q y l�,74__ A -1 wi �ki�t �fa�tr3T �— C.5 Twvrey94 ea �a 14l e 97�-�v� 3x73 17 G Page of� City Meeting of Salem — Meetin Sign-In Sheet Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date ame Mail* g AddressPhone # E-mail 6 p�N �! Zv 5 �J��G I!�/�✓D�o tl� c d cc \ „h 6✓olH sir nurrci v 1-2 z p�lf{rZk: a�fE�iti /.� C�ERN�/ST �� 77 �4v3 �ntc2rvlE Sj itis . Of�� 5 c.. ✓I�1 �6 (J�C � 4J-lE�f�ilr} �� , F1� S ' (i e-� �G`� �`r�� 4dZ�C' e wily a ' - , Pagc_� of _� T . City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet 9� �hlvg� Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date Name Mailing Address Phone # E-mail / . t n Yl iSe incl X10 13 I D Ifs 71-1 I/ &00(0 / nhCOSCv -E'�� Hj �ci `1S �vl•.a �evs L4�,� C,.}S �_(Cr _a r` 8 Lee Street 0/970 2,r11 978 7S-�S9� Ut'Rcn1 'c a C?46Q4; 29 F,'asl` s t q 7e 7 wt l Page I or_=l_ CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEAL 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR 4ita SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 �s9F � TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 �Mrve oo FAX, 978-740-9846 KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL MAYOR City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals 978-619-5685 Will hold a continued public hearing for all persons interested in the petition of COMMUNITY I-IEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Tahle of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on the property at 207 FIIGFILAND AVENUE (former Hillcrest automobile dealership) [132]. Said continued hearing will be held on WEDNESDAY December 15, 2010 at 6:30 p.m. at 120 WASHINGTON ST., 3i1 floor conference room (313) (not at the Bowditch School, where the November 17, 2010 meeting took place). Robin Stein Chair V CITY OF SALEM ASSESSOR'S CERTIFICATION OF ABUTTERS AND "PARTIES IN INTEREST" BOARD/COMMISSfON: Zoning Board of Appeals PROJECT SITE: 207 Highland Ave. (13-0002-0 ) DATE: 8/30/10 DESCRIPTION OF REOUIREMENT: Parties in Interest: The applicant Abutters Owners of land opposite any street or way Abutters within 300 feet Planning boards of abutting cities and towns This is to certify that the time of the last assessment for taxation made by the City of Salem, the names and addresses of those listed on the attached sheets are "parties in interest" (as defined by Massachusetts General Law Chapter 40A, Section 11) to the parcel(s) of land listed above as the project site. Assessor's Signature: Date: Number of initialed pages attached: Once Certified, Return to: Department of Planning and Community Development SU, (Il(rurn�rl UNIr (ivtl ^uh ur 4lfariaclnnr ltl x fl)�l�l'('�' IC AIrC t' "Y. .' t> .Flf � (LmS.rkw fktstw{lt,AYa}yg I New Property Search Prnpery Record Card f�FIEIP 450 feet ^' Property l0 13_0002 0 y, N Address — V 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE Owner HILLCREST REALTY TRUST II Properly 1013_0012_0 .Address 4FIRST STREET I Owner SAF HAN4HORNE COMMONS LLC Property ID 13_0004_0 \, '\. , Address 207-205 HIGHLAND AVENUE ^^ Owner SAF HAWTHORNE COMMONS LLC r,< ^ Properly lO 13 0001 0 \' n Address 204 HIGHLAND AVENUE 204 HIGHLAND AVE REALTY TRUST Property l0 13_0002_0 Address 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE Owner HILLCREST REALTY TRUST II Property ID 00_0124_0 Atldress 218-222 HIGHLAND AVENUE \ Search I' Distance 300 fl AddI Rn rove Add • Ahu0er, ^� ,� .. o Pvctlp kol lu Pvr'els • �— 1-, Mallin r Remove(•Tal Jef Parcels • ao . "0 :+"�U o3t9 C- 9 --� Export scale 7"= 450 rt Salem Oity Hall:J1 VV spin9Wn Street.SaWln,MA01970 r:ily Ilall gourv'n(Operalion:C1ombV,lnnctln PA wVg 110sdly gAiA� Y 1 emlay➢gM..IPM riuuvaaY HMA-)pM1l Piaay eAhl-I_Pti sne anip„xa er anm:;:'a. °n°IT+.io CITY OF SALEM MASSACHUSETTS BOARD OF APPEAL 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR SALEM• MASSACHUSETTS 01970 P` rnErt��r TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL FAX 978-740-9846 MAYOR City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals 978-619-5685 Will hold a continued public hearing for all persons interested in the petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the S:dem Zoning Ordinance, on the property at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (fonner Hillcrest automobile dealership) [132]. t Said continued hearing will be held on WEDNESDAY November 17, 2010 at 6:30 p.m, at the NATHANIEL BOWDITCH SCHOOL CAFETORIU VI, 79 WILLSON ST., (not at 120 Washington St. as usual). h, Robin Stein Chair °I 11�� 1-t CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978_619-5685 WILL CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 Will hold a continued public hearing for all persons interested in the petition Of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation Of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning continued Ordinance, on the property at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (former Hillcrest automobile dealership) [B2]. Said earing will be held on SCHOOL CAFETORIUM,E 79 WILSON (not at 120 Washington 0St. asausual)NR bin BOWDITCHStein Chair SN 11/3, 11/10/10 Appeared in: The Salem News on 11/03/2010 and 11/10/2010 Back CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 WILL CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 976-619-5685 Will hold a continued public hearing for all persons interested in the petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on the property at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (former Hillcrest automobile dealership) . Said continued hearing will be held on WEDNESDAY November 17, 2010 at 6:30 BOWDITCH SCHOOL CAFETORIUM, 79 WILSON ST., (not at 120 Washington St. as usual) )Robin Stein Chair SN 11/3, 11/10/10 p.m. at the NATHANIEL Appeared in: The Salem News on Wednesday, 11/03/2010 ©ack I 1 r CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 WILL CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 Will hold a public hearing for all persons interested in the petition &COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE, INC. (owner) andHEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic(methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3,Table of Principal andAccessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on theproperty at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (formerHillcrest automobiledealership) [62). Said hearing will be held on WEDNESDAYSeptember 15, 2010 at6:30 p.m. 3rd floor conference room 120 WASH INGTONSTREET, ROOM 313. Robin Stein Chair SN -- 9/1, 9/8/10 Appeared in: The Salem News on 09/01/2010 and 09/08/2010 Back t t City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals 978-619-5685 Will hold it public (tearing for all persons interested in the petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on the property at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (former Hillcrest automobile dealership) [132]. Said hearing will be held on WEDNESDAY September 15, 2010 at 6:30 p.m. 3'd door m conference roo120 WASHINGTON STREET, ROOM 313. Robin Stein Chair Please publish on: September I, 2010 and September 3, 2010 Remit bill to:: John R. Keilty, Esquire 40 Lowell St.. Peabody, MA 0 196 973-531-7900 CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 WILL CITY OF SALEM ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 978-619-5685 Will hold a public hearing for all persons interested in the petition &COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE, INC. (owner) andHEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic(methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3,Table of Principal andAccessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on theproperty at 207 HIGHLAND AVENUE (formerHillcrest automobiledealership) [132). Said hearing will be held on WEDNESDAYSeptember 15, 2010 at6:30 p.m. 3rd floor conference room 120 WASHINGTON STREET, ROOM 313. Robin Stein Chair SN -- 9/1, 9/8/10 Appeared in: The Salem News on Wednesday, 09/01/2010 Back CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS m BOARD OF APPEAL 7 120 WASHINGTON STREET, 3RD FLOOR yelp SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 Nw ii TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 `�%MruE Wil FAX: 978-740-9846 KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL MAYOR r/I City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals 973-619-5685 Will hold it public hearing for all persons interested in the petition of COMMUNITY HEALTH CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CARE RESOURCES, INC. (lessee) requesting a Special Permit for the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) pursuant to section 2.3, Table of Principal and Accessory Use Regulations, of the Salem Zoning Ordinance, on the property at 207 1-II0-I1-AND AVENUE (former Flillerest automobile dealership) [62). Said hearing will be held on WEDNESDAY September 15, 2010 at 6:30 p.m. 3"' floor conference room 120 WASHINGTON STREET, ROOM 313. Robin Stein Chair �� 1lQ C�.�i� C•ZO ��' 5 City of Salem — Meeting Sig ) Board: Zoning Board of gwj� �' Date 2 / �J' SIA Name Mailing Address Pho UM ell � . r `E l�Jd ]Y{ -�5 �- Mc•S�n,�S 1L Jbv.z„5� f� --�=,�zL n4/Ti�S �lr/7Z/iCO.P/9�N lti�ci'C�i{i Ir ('-i{'CGS I' ✓�,�-��',� �� (%a- tea- 9�� _7�� ,��ri! ma�Skfn�:k 7Y X69% 22! 2X341 Jfc/Ally ��LGj GI�CUlS C t. Mili5,--):3`/.) r - F 2zL `i 3o -lf,�l I. ✓/9G�L'+� /ylit�/fi/,yy !/� f R it d.�i C'7 /jf`1 / � 178 ed--L , ��r1/�,1�/'�(./�(• •rVG,r�� YP19r ori, '� �, i , — , , S� 7;�12 M it D C b .Vl.tr l Ica �i �10� `d6 J'l1 .tZJZ P:Ige � of . City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date Name Mailing Address Phone # E-mail I 7f Ooh? f ✓�7i�Prt,Y.4no 1.3 ]^i(�S� ,�51 z `7� 7`%ydlp 1Ylc�rhn . m Senc��nc� f er;Ar7nMISfQ,�iv\o 13 ;z tL �/ rinnJiDnns/roj�J�rVD Fj+. /)C e y 2�_ , ed q?? / 7y/- 2y35 41 P o,.,casr„ 745-622_7 (1 7c� �/ CSS 5T � �Ir'''�� / IV.�k►'e�ct�� la��ti�iil. l� //) ,F P!, Ave 1nn1``II 2 I�11 1 1 1 l ` iF- 7/c/15--71�v�� EUPus X51 ryC'Acr-c 11�<�I` Ulh\ z�iR1.11i7 l \ LL`l l.'.\I � 7 �1�i.' tY� - .I l�L IYI�1T 7 4.)`t cr 1 ,, ' 1 , l ,t' s�rti -s rcS r) �7 L� ?76 7Yo Y v1Q rA �lyn°`ACQ��E� of`7 HL L\ a vl �n�ryfilc�fc�� , . 1. 7 tib ✓;-�'�( lj U�C �/�w�`�Lli,,y`Ivl/) �� lz f� Ju[ E`tz T LYG `f 7 ('7yl - 56 c�� oTC�w� 4c,z�i/z of _L A`u—�A City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet Board: Zoning Board of Appeals Date Name Mailing Address Phone # E-mail LLD COLufrRuS AJc' `}7e 71/0 Of/72 H sT sr Iarc .�h �� Jrnb+ cCcs 9 7F 7`F� ) b --�� Od urr /0 r; 7� G C i - 2u .UXe test /.l') b G F q C (A � 64 A )I C. �v >f 7 O` Ab Av -S , {> yL 1 ,V, .gin. �(I'lc_ .V-Ack,�k/j C—7 Scecc-L,,�. 3(4- �7csf rtkv/ Pa;e of `��uYI11T�� vl ? City of Salem — Meeting Sign-In Sheet Board: Zoning Board of Mn� Appeals Date Z / e� Name Nlailin Address Phone # E-mail 10 MmrL,-,j � '711y- 1 7 0 M2le17g '}"Y1 Lvl.... I C7 (�.itic-I m n i Corry Sh 4 �F - 74r _ ti � a i .Z1. IL Akc, y 0 3 2 �a�enclt sh / CUSP CO �„Ml�l« �t � ( 't3o7r�s voiki LQ u AN 3L _7TO V if D/1e,�! ire.✓ �oS //i 91 7 Jfi1y/: 1i7� 7 VS-1 .=_.---------- . . Crelr 9��'l Flo uuv 3 � /�S i�JP/��Cf/J/. f LA 14 leo F �//1 h{wi /� +Zltcoc -t Lc ( ✓, J' u � l ��I t((fi'V c�C'tc i�'OJI�, t-u•�� U lc `(91 �CU'�Yl<uCf�� ;}�onl�Jri�� Lpfrf.��oTs7 t stomer base a plus. Pay -" rpnlpf lagon.com expert. mms1X. Ex[h0ege; 1$fiAdsM1m9rpn POKER TABLE,dab,re40. hev1 ¢e.Company truck, paid 51.,Salem,91&115-0717 - ibis poker/game table,530, heaj motion,holidays, health& O Both In vood condition.. - iota ental insurance, 401(k). A19,01/�U/1 RUG., Coll Ron,97&5323Ni.. q and resume: HVAC Re I2X15;AUTUMN SHADES; tition tmes P.O.Box 665,orpaac Roll-Off Driver Good Condition SI00_ KITCHEN TABLE,38'x b" JACI 301825. CDL B Must have experience - with d CHAIRS - 'deeb &references Call 978-9773177 " (6D3) 329-5S3D. ,distressed black, in excellent Ids SKILLED TRADES` condhmn.Maving ,1fi "P,a°� STABLE HELP . SPA-Equlpment• Pedicure Call(970)37&Id95 8E In Boxford Mornings lam fo PIE : choir facial steamer,OF mo- p JOBS! weeken 4ay,So week,onchine lots more.All like new ;FIMS1 AU/l' Na Resume? No Problemt weekend dov.Some.experl0 Cal$�dr defalls60389&3621.- MA ,ionto Match assigns a pro- pace nelpkl,but willing to KITCHEN toble,round(leaf trictll essl0nal to handmo ch each train.Call 97&3171826 Wil AND Wil FIT +MORE r expands to-Yell, laminated -Si lob seeker with each .Wllwilh 7conirallers torr• butcher black with.].ladder held) employer! Ying case,'MII FIVAlian M$ back chain;$10; 2 Bentwood II This B o FREE service! VALENTINE;,.. chaeb Fitness Ultimatum.. chairs$5; ice box,pine,"Circ NOV/ {imply create your prolile by 81 KEBARTAS=. 15 games some not opened. 1900's$200•(970)6865022. tc'" 6:301 "phone or online pnd,for the bought In February,kids do- 'LOVE SEATS: blue denim THAI nex190.days,our prafossIOn•, Nallonal Collection Agency nTplay $40000 SCHq will match your Profile fo in Lawrence,MA 1T access) -with matching pillows$250& Is growing rapidly;` Call 91&/23.1617•- . blue'vOlte striped$225;Maple RIUN employers wno are hiring, - - leave a message Coffee Table$50;Gloss chao- Salej right navel•. Needs 70 moonyY motivated' dellen blue&white,flS.Ex• 1 CREATE YOUR PROFILE &career orlenfafed WOODSTOVE Lakewood- cell &1745159 NOW. Full-Tim Debt Collector, "AlrTlgh6 fire brick lined, BY PHONE OR WEB Experience preferred,. . 5500.00 or best offer.- S N-dt FREEf � but not necessary. . � . Call(60)189&/575- ' EGAL NOTICE S 1-86021-8985, W110"g to vomaggreelYe& WooOsiovE,Russo $lO — money motivated individuals g toe holden,wrou0hl"a CITY OF SALEM L- a WeoBerdbonui potive etlat, $10 eochl harvest table,whi ZONING BOARD nprihafbmfon.com/monsfer unlimited bonus pokntla6 8 wood grain, l.' . OF APPEAL? No Resume Neededl Paid training,medical/dentol Call(60))4in,U OF APPEALS - :all the automated phone pro- Insurance, 40IK,&more. , ti ling system or use our con Professio...... liable ZENITH Transoceanic Shor "- holda continued BOA' venient Online form today so candidates need only apply. Wave Radio,excellent condi public. hearing for all Thal our professionals can get Resume to:resume8v�kd.del Nam,$400. - persons Interested in the started matching You with Attn:Me Scott elision o} COM in the App emPlPYers that are hiring . .• 1978)28}2210: . P N HEALTH CARE,INC. NOW! ' 150 GALLON REP,TIL (owner). and HEALTH on Choose from one of the fol. TANK.$150. ' at to lowing main lob codes to en CALL(607)362.442 CARE RESOURCES, Schaj ter Your information: INC.(lessee)requesting { Ads In This Classification Are 143 •Building Professional o al , a Special Permit for the to as WORK WANTED •Building Prolesslonal 3.30 NOT HELP WANTED clink:operationmof a medical petNl+ •Construction A# - FREE SWIVEL ROCKER. clinic (methadone ten- the I •Manukc. furinp Ndl- CALL(978)3624791 ter)pursuant to section la monster ® FREE TO GOOD HOME - 2.3;Table o} Principal 71 AMESBURY:PCA' fer77 yr. 2 beautiful all black cats, and Accessory Use Sire altl high functioning women. daub pawed,bronar.6 Regulations, o1 the Sa- 6 hours.per week,Monday sister both fixed all shots tem Zoning Ordinance, anSP r ThBla 1KCIee•Ifle4 evening; I weekend day: Must go together never been on the property x1207 Must be kind;patlent with Apart Coll(976)28121M the A 8 sing nt6lfkBN HIGHLAND AVENUE Positive attitude and have a IM� p18Ca north of BONOn car. Call (918)3%7138 • KAWAI ORGAN Free,YOU (former Hillcrest auto- ResCh up}p rpgg pick up,Model EM mobile dealership)fB21. a S ahOppen WMAOM COMPANION for elderly Cott 603442-78M Said continued hear cord woman needed In Manche& ing wilt be,.held on 6.2.8 0814 Pool TABLE 7,Ov Brunn WEDNESDAY Novem- -ren,MA;1 avernl9htf per wick.Good cood!f1on. You 'week, $50/night. No heavy fgrml '� move.Ca1160&3626/10,. bar 17, 2010 at 8:30 1 lifting required 97886i12i} tion '_ r:'la-SiItL - P.M.-at the NATHANIEL OflOeCt 011 DANVERB:Experienced SLEEP SOFA.FREE BOWDITCH SCHOOL NI Z crr anrceProu.aer aeeun SEALY pNcadl local PCA needed for disabled GOOD CONDITION,. CAFETORIUM; - 79 for vie wsrw.nlemmsVaean mom,8 P.m.to 10 P.M.Week. (978)4619N WILSON ST; (not, at entls all shNh. 97&7741581, 120 WashingSt: as meeNq 1.800.9'17.9'100 TRAVERSE RODS ton new& usual). Mldd FREE RENT&utilities for unopened:0) 131240'Brass ing, I FOX 1.800.927.9400 -shared componiordCare4lver rad.(1)21nch wooden while - Robin Stein Street) .services for elderly woman, traverse rod about 8.5 N. Chair 019491 '1TLe ynkmlce•. Call Ipswich. Female preferred. (e)pieces Archifrac-3 at0 ff SN-11/3,11/10/10 SN-11 Coll]BIfi714LW 6 I of S.5 N.(603)77&9424 J I f 6 Familk Man ke •. _ - CMillpc DeYiile 19N 57.500 IAUBUC NOTICE - Essex R RECLINER,CHAIRCatNat Microsoft XP 2G hard CONSUMERS: YeIlow,LabPups Call 803) _ 13 a MG U�.2 36 Fede per;excellent condition blue down.517 RAM;,SI00_Coll . . Rendr Naw.Yellow,I mole,l LEGAL NOTICE §43 mace mace is given Salem.N cloth, stale of the art power 978-36IMS/. .. - female.ISYshots 6 health IiN,purchased for 5450 Nov. -----�'— All ads ip oris class{6calian certificates:$600,d03'BHi-9980 —�-- of a 401 water (978)71 7„2009. Asking S300. Call DELL WIRELESS LAPTOP �— TOWN OF. CerfificaUrn applicationNOTICE OI John,(978)374-7054. NOTEBOOK Fast CPU.IGB nm moor 10 pope* AL NO 1,CE - M�Bk�� for the Ferry Landing FOR APPC = 'Ram.Big Nord Drive.Fresh 'ClassifieduormecNon'mat ****** � CONSERVATION Dredging Prole"S -by OF ADMIN SOFA Clavian Mmcus 3 Per- Install:Wi~XP Pm. covers the North Share,Mer CRY OF SALEM- . COMMISSION the City of Bevaity, 191. son sofa flowered print while wireless Ready.Warks . rimack Valley aM So- AK,YELLOW LABRADO ZONING BOARD' - The Marblehead Con- Cabot Sheet• Beverly, ESi background$350 Chart.Sam =Gram.980.COII 91s9869R7 . New Hampshire. Mq 01915 to conduct In the Es Moore wingbacklonni 57(10 IN� Adsuppeanagmthissedial PUPPIES.Champion sl OF APPEALS servation. Commission Land- Gary GTI Craslev Radio CD/cassette,. GHz mG.HD imp RAM may prmw not deliver to Health testing?n bolt) :97S-B19-5685 wi0 hold a public her- dredging o Ferry turntable 560 1978)539-104 •.. Wlndaws%P Internet ready. this entire market. ems.Crate trained,lead Will hold a continued In begirming at or after Ing. Cabot Sheet al Late of:S9 —�- include smonilor,.mouse ken Crate Ready piblic Bearing for aB 715 PM rm November Beverly, MA. Additional 0191 A. � f.Aff sceakers printer.. Excellent Prim may reflect o'Lm their new hwnes Willard persona"Wasted j& 2010 on a.Notice Isdormatron:•may be Date of C 'condition 5100.9Bd86uI93 = .delivery area only and may of Intent filed by -SOFA LOUIS XV STYLE- for details. 197817663 petitions W COMMUNI- Scott obtained from Vine As- 0427/2 SOFA LOUIS XV STYL - -�— be higher for an ubmileel de- fteelooXyl TY HEALTH CARE.INC. Noward for the Pm' sociates- A Division of To all Perri Iwery area, l 8rid HFJUTH wed demolition of an GZA GeoErnironmen- cried in the at condition, tight home - -;►; T T.T T .ATTENTION.' l tal Inc., 372 Merrimac Jack Leier Larson tabnc ATTENTION! CARE .s pESOURCES, existing dwelling end tinned estate. 6'm33*hx31'd.Will entad ADS Whits category mush &yipip ATTENTION' replytag ro INC.llessee)rezluastiri9 the rwnstnscrior of a Sm of NewburyPOr4 has been i photos. 5500.9105769171 show_Prices by cubes feel. C0�-- N PSR ma 7B 46S uestln that -- Half 9 cord o M a.N.and a QIL, SERVICE LMA Only Imur ad onamS?o�t'0V a Sped new dwelling and e- 14 019Wr e ) cO� LL enatus of i STOVE,GE Elechic tante. 'and is l70 cu.ft.=..,, a Check for shipping and You operators of a friedical sociated motappurtenancesStreet in ment Written Sm.MICROWAVE GE white .LLow COO Needing Oil ung Bern pack the: clinic lmethadone s et 150 Frosd $inset m mends should be sent, MA or some of wall unit 550.5x8'RUG,,cast BEST SEASONED Firewood LMW Reliable Delivery ' difference. ter)pursUanS to section an:-arm subject to the o DEP-DW W. 1 Winter able person be' design 525.Antique Reducim- 1 w.:CaM 5791 IR cord 5195. *Pay by UKrk a a Also Eowore when resporib 2.3..Table sof Principal Wetlands ,Protection Shaet, Boston,- .MA ed administrate machine$10.Con Salem MA, (128 8 Oil it).No.Shore- _ ggary Use - and tha Marblehead 02100 within 21 days of estate to serve. 97870767011 '/Merrimack Storage Rocks .order 2�N7 O CODOILmm ire ro tlassrfied•ods mat askAct roue Surety ,� Available.Avanab a Call You ropaBble�� -., �--- i Ra<.NIeNp^s•of the Se- Wetlands Protection this notice. Any 9 Upright Freezer 71.5 cu.ft. '- HOME HEATING,OIL 4.59: tem Zoning'Ordinance- B ew. of ten persons,any ag- IF VOU DES excellent cenddiail SM shat- FIREWOOD:.Seasoned 5799; — � at 207 r n or any OBJECT TM low well pump with sank hot- Kiln-uied,5397:Green 5290 -' North Shore.Coce Aon, pUS1 SHEPHERD PUPS, in the pmPertY Plaits aril iniamator grieved Perms M YOU OR YOU r cud;(I79.cu.ff.).Wood 'Newburyonn, Call for low Blue Merle, Parents on HIGHLANDlFllerest ENi LIE am available for inspee- govemmenSal body.,, Queen size Bed with forme per .price.9788T-71W premises.male 8 female. .tion at the Town of Mat private organization with TORNEY MUS1 complete, 3 yrs:old paid -.Pellets 5we Deliver WOM i RendY 1V70$7509157069®3. blamed _Engi A WRITTEN AF $1,069 sell S100.Queen size Bricks.We Delver! North SIMS OIL — mobile dentinued hear rieerim9 amandate to protect the ANCE IN SAID C bed spread S7. (978)53WM east Nursery 9785356550 Said eorrtirnsed hoar” Department, 7 Widger environment who sub- ---�— FIREWOOD-SEASONED' •.Call for Today's Price BEAGLE PUPS,mak ' win be held on Dep VACUUM CLEANER;KI Hardwood D-g9clSand. 161.C'ul,. female, AKC registered, Ing DAY _ Road.Marblehead.1 b mils wmlen comments AT. SaTEN lem ON 0 With rug snampon kit,used B.Solit.Pellets 439Hon 978-531-0447 peal the DePpot- Dlaclubrown. 5150 each. oWer�N�52010 al 8.30 ba n the Lowar Level moment's. Certification. THE MORNING ORNINGCi Reody to go.91834-3391 only o new times 5950 Coll ' .170 ro ft.=�_978777 7210 �—" p�m,At the NATHAN Room at Failure to submit written .AM)ON:11/22/20 anytime,9785381022 jn. ohn's Oil BEAUTIFUL Bengal kitten, Bm SCHOOL gig-Mary_Mey.MunleF--�.mn•ams before,the WfTT1E3.S. .' PATRICK 6 SONS - ]. ,,. 4585850:; - WASHERSDRYER QUALITY FIREWOOD Haiae heatmgdl.Dyed Red .Y,pavgthaiiwcdsaa^s=� CAFETORttSM -.m pal Building, 7 Widger end of the public t.»rr Anne SaI thisRC both Mm'tag Notice _ , iW9e hmdwvnd.Semoned_ :.ON Roan opt a^ilm'�e Coll 6938188136. WILSON ST.. (hot Road.Marblet�.MA mars period may result ustiee of wNfl'P"molent caMitm - CpIi 60}8°e Are Fuel AMISMrte Welcome a roclivttatsthnacWan 120 Washingori Stas Wither Haug.Chairman in the waiver of any Date:October 7.2t pontlaadinawasher =-- a'"'".lohnsoil'com — usual. . - Marblehead riyIT to an adjudicatory , Pamela Casey Ol electric dryer - QUALITY GUARANTEED BENGAL QUEEN CATS Ftoptn Stein conservation hearing. Register of Pro Se99.9783174495 Seasotxd Mrdwond tirewaad, 978-777-4205OKI iarMe - Commission SN-11/10/10 SN-1 1/1 ono �-- -•16'hand spill.Call Mike �--•— .�5pp60781�e8136 '- Chair . WASHER B ELECTRIC ,>�.KovalMuk 97&1M-9ee7. :.ROYAL OILS attradrvecais@raaccom SN-1113,11110/10?, SN 11/10/10 �— DRYER,Heavy duty,large - 1E ,70^45 _ conicity S371lsd wdl sesw QUALITY SE.450NED a CHIHUAHUA ret Electric stove N'Wide - HARDWOOD Fir?wand•cut u ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS PETITION FORM I)NI)l P411 CI'1'y 017 SALE%% NL\SSACl`IusE-i'rs ZONING BOARD OF: PPEALS2 b 4 ... 120 WASHINGTON STREET,31to FLOOR -171..01970 SALE,%I,,\LkSSACFIU1;E :jiight,Staff Planner I'honias St. Pierre, Building Inspector od� t.978-619 5683/f.973-7"10-0404 1) -7-10-0404 t. 78-619-5641/f.978-7-10-9846 'roTIIE BOARD OF APPEALS: The Undersigned represent that he/she is/are the owners of a certain parcel of land located at: Address: 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, MA — Zoning District: 82 Zoning District An application is being submitted to the Board of Appeal for the following reason(s): This statement mist describe what you propose to build, the dimensions, the:oneproperly is in, and the zoningrequirenzents. Lrapiple. lamproposing to construct a 10'x l0'one story addition to my home located at 3 Salem Lane, in the R-2 7oning District The Zoning Ordinance requires the minitnion depth of the rear yard to be 30ficet. The current depth ofirry rear yawl is 32 feet," the proposed addition ivoiddreduce the depth of the rear yard io 22 feet. The applicant seeks a special permit for the operation of a medical clinic within the B2 Zone. The newly adopted Zoning Ordinance provides for such development to be allowed by special permit from the Zoning Board of Appeals. The total land acreage is 3.348 acres. It is the site of the former Hillcrest automobile dealership. The applicant is intending to use approximately 7,300 square feet at the rear of the premises as a medical treatment clinic(Methadone Center). Thirty-One(31) parking spaces will be available to the clientele plus 4 additional handicapped spaces. For this reason I am requesting: O Variance(s) from provisions of Section_of the Zoning Ordinance,specifically from (i.e. inininutin depth of rear yard). What is allowed is (fl.7sqft?stories? %?), and what I am proposing is (ti?sq ft?stories? Yo?). (X)A Special Permit under Sectiorill 3.0 (B)af the Zoning Ordinance in order to allow a medical clinic in a 62 Zone. ( )Appeal of the Decision of the Building Inspector(described below): File Current Use of(lie Property Is. Are the lot dimensions included on the plan? (example. Two Fondly floiney--ormer Automobile Dealership (X) Yes O No rVa because — I'lic Undersigned inclersigned hereby petitions the Board of Appeals to vary the terms of the Salem Zoning Ordinance and allow the Project to be constructed as per the plans submitted,as the enforcement of said Zoning By-Laws would involve practical di Ificulty or UnuCCCS.5,ity hardship to the Undersigned and relief may be granted without substantially derogating troin the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS PETITION FORM The following written statement has been submitted with this application: ( I For all Variance requests a written Statement of Hardship demonstrating the following must be attached: a) Special conditions and circumstances that especially affect the land,building,or structure involved, generally not affecting other lands,buildings,and structures in the same district; b) Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involved substantial hardship to the applicant;and c) Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good,and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. ( )For all Special Permit requests a Statement of Grounds must be attached. An application for a special permit for a nonconforming use or structure shall include a statement demonstrating how the proposed change shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood in accordance with Art. V, §5-3. Such a statement should include reference to the following criteria: a) Social,economic,or community needs served by the proposal; b) Traffic flow and safety, including parking and loading; c) Adequacy of utilities and other public services; d) Impacts on the natural environment, including drainage; e) Neighborhood character;and 0 Potential fiscal impact,including impact on City tax base and employment. Previous applications to the Board of Appeals involving this property have been submitted with this petition form. The Building Commissioner can provide documentation ofpreviots applications to the petitioner or his representative. Community Health Care,Inc.(Operator) Ifdifferenifrom petitioner: Hillcrest Realty Trust II Petitioner. Health Care Resources,Inc.(Lessee) Property Owner: Ralph Cerundolo Trustee 125 North Elm Street,Westfleld,MA Address: 207 Highland Avenue,Salem,MA 01970 Address: (617)786-9196 c/o Fred Massa,Broker(617)459-4094 Telephone: Telephone: �v� A Signature Signatu (Attached consent letter is also accep a le) August 17,2010 August 17,2010 Date Dale /f different from petitioner: John R.Keilty, Esquire A TRUE Representative: ATTEST 40 Lowell Street,Peabody,MA 01960 Address: Telephpnf: (978)531-7900 f ZSig, m a ; August 17,20107 I/ Date DATE SUBMITTED TO BOARD OF APPEALS: CI'T'Y CLERK Tlric )ri,ginnl application nrtl.rt he/filed uith die City C(rrk. Special Permit Statement of Grounds Applicant: Ilealth Care Resources, Inc. (Lessee) / Community Health Care, Inc. (Operator) Property Address: 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, MA The property is located on a total of 3.348 acres of land. The property has excellent access ability from Highland Avenue, a divided highway. The property is formally an automobile dealership which created much more demand upon traffic flow. The premises is equipped with more than adequate parking and loading facilities. The utilities currently servicing the site are more than adequate. There will be no impact caused by new construction upon the environment or any neighborhood area. The use would create a broadened taxable base and the creation of 15 newjobs. Aug 23 10 05:51p 9789275555 p.1 To Whom it May Concern: 1,the undersigned,do hereby given authority to John R. Keilty, Esquire to appl for a special permit from the City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals. This authorization allows Attorney Keilty to execute the Special Permit Applica ion on behalf of the owner of the property at 207 Highland Avenue, Salem,Massachusetts and we understand that the Special Permit Application is a request for a Special Permit to ape ea Medical Treatment Clinic,specifically a Methadone Center at 207 Highland Avenue in em, Massachusetts. Executed this 'day of August,2010. Hillcrest Realty Trust II BY: I I i i 1 1: I � if I 1 . I I r.rrnlq 1 . urr � Ij I. : i I:- 11 I I I I i I I 1 � I e ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS PETITION FORM +��cort ra tni CI"IY OF SALEM, bL16SACFIUSET7S ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS 2b A n. 120 WASHINGTON STREET,3nn FLOOR '�' S 2 'v SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS 01970 F J f ...^"°'",T Danielle bfcrnight,Staff Planner '17homns St.Pierre,Building lnspd5tctlt ; �F�tNhVkt�OyP t.978-619-5685/f.978-740-0400 1978-GI9-5641/f.978-740-9846 TO THE BOARD OF APPEALS: The Undersigned represent that he/she is/are the owners of a certain parcel of land located at: Address: 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, MA Zoning District: B2 Zoning District An application is being submitted to the Board of Appeal for the following reason(s): This statement nntst describe what you propose to build, the dimensions, the zone property is in, and the zoning requirements. Example: 1 am proposing to construct a 10'x 10'one story addition to my home located at 3 Salem Lane, in the R-2 Zoning District. The Zoning Ordinance requires the minimrnn depth of the rear yard to be 30 feet. The current depth of my )-car yard is 32 feet; the proposed addition would reduce the depth of the rear yard to 22 feet. The applicant seeks a special permit for the operation of a medical clinic within the B2 Zone. The newly adopted Zoning Ordinance provides for such development to be allowed by special permit from the Zoning Board of Appeals. The total land acreage is 3.348 acres. It is the site of the former Hillcrest automobile dealership. The applicant is intending to use approximately 7,300 square feet at the rear of the premises as a medical treatment clinic(Methadone Center). Thirty-One(31)parking spaces will be available to the clientele plus 4 additional handicapped spaces. For this reason 1 am requesting: O Variance(s)from provisions of Section of the Zoning Ordinance,specifically from (i.e. minimnnr depth of rear pard). What is allowed is (ft?sq ft?stories? %?), and what 1 am proposing is (/1?sq ft?stories?%?). (X)A Special Permit under Sectionll 3.0 (B)of the Zoning Ordinance in order to allow a medical clinic in a B2 Zone. ( )Appeal of the Decision of the Building inspector(described below): The Current Use of the Property Is: Are the lot dimensions included on the plan? (example: Two Family Home former Automobile Dealership fx) yes O No n/a because The Undersigned hereby petitions the Board of Appeals to vary the teens of the Salem Zoning Ordinance and allow the project to be constructed as per the plans submitted,as the enforcement of said Zoning By-Laws would involve practical difficulty or unnecessary hardship to the Undersigned and relief may be granted without Substantially derogating from the intent and purpose of the Zoning Ordinance. ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS PETITION FORM The following written statement has been submitted with this application: ' ( )For all Variance requests a written Statement of Hardship demonstrating the following must be attached: a) Special conditions and circumstances that especially affect the land,building,or structure involved, generally not affecting other lands,buildings,and structures in the same district; b) Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involved substantial hardship to the applicant;and c) Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good,and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the purpose of the ordinance. ( )For all Special Permit requests a Statement of Grounds must be attached. An application for a special permit for a nonconforming use or structure shall include a statement demonstrating how the proposed change shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood in accordance with Art. V, §5.3. Such a statement should include reference to the following criteria: a) Social,economic,or community needs served by the proposal; b) Traffic flow and safety, including parking and loading; c) Adequacy of utilities and other public services; d) Impacts on the natural environment,including drainage; e) Neighborhood character; and 0 Potential fiscal impact, including impact on City tax base and employment. Previous applications to the Board of Appeals involving this property have been submitted with this petition form. The Building Commissioner can provide documentation of previous applications to the petitioner or his representative. Community Health Care,Inc.(Operator) if different from petitioner: Hillcrest Realty Trust II Health Care Resources,Inc.(Lessee) Ralph Cerundolo,Trustee Petitioner: Properly Owner: P Address: 125 North Elm Street,Westfield,MA Address: 207 Highland Avenue,Salem,MA 01070 , Telephone: (617)786-9196 Telephone: c/o Fred Massa,Broker(617)459-4094 Signature Signatu (Attached consent letter is also ace a e) August 17,2010 August 17,2010 Date Date If different from petitioner: A TRUERepresentative: John R.Keilty, Esquire ATTEST Address: 40 Lowell Street,Peabody,MA 01960 Telephone: (978)531-7900 Signafiire // �.August 17,201' 1,/ Date DATE SUBMITTED TO BOARD OF APPEALS: CITY CLERK This original application/nest be filed with the City Clo'k. Special Permit Statement of Grounds Applicant: Health Care Resources, Inc. (Lessee) /Community Health Care, Inc. (Operator) Property Address: 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, MA The property is located on a total of 3.348 acres of land. The property has excellent access ability from Highland Avenue, a divided highway. The property is formally an automobile dealership which created much more demand upon traffic flow. The premises is equipped with more than adequate parking and loading facilities. The utilities currently servicing the site are more than adequate. There will be no impact caused by new construction upon the environment or any neighborhood area. The use would create a broadened taxable base and the creation of 15 new jobs. Aug 23 10 05:51p 9789275555 p.1 To Whom it May Concern: 1, the undersigned,do hereby given authority to John R.Keilty,Esquire to appl for a special permit from the City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals. This authorization allows Attorney Keilty to execute the Special Permit Applica ion on behalf of the owner of the property at 207 Highland Avenue, Salem,Massachusetts and we understand that the Special Permit Application is a request for a Special Permit to opera e a Medical Treatment Clinic,specifically a Methadone Center at 207 Highland Avenue in em, Massachusetts. rs: Executed this ' 'day of August,2010. Hillcrest Realty Trust II Buz ' I ;,A'M AN/1 y i i ra �y i i ` I' I ly it I Id i, I JOHN R. KEILTY, Counselor At Law Telephone (978) 531-7900 40 Lowell Street Facsimile (978) 531-2479 Peabody, MA 01960 E-Mail KeiltyLaw©verizon.net August 24, 2010 Board of Appeals City of Salem 120 Washington Street, 3`d Floor Salem, MA 01970 Attn: Danielle McKnight, Staff Planner Re: Variance Application 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, MA Dear Ms. McKnight: Please be advised that I represent Community Health Care, Inc. and Health Care Resources, Inc., the petitioners for a Special Permit from the City of Salem Zoning Ordinance as it applies to the property at 207 Highland Avenue, Salem, Massachusetts. Submitted herewith are the following instruments: 1. Check in the amount of$75.00 as application fee; 2. Check in the amount of$75.00 as recording fee made payable to the Registry of Deeds; 3. Check in the amount of$2.00 as certified copy fee made payable to the City of Salem; 4. Application for Variance x 9; 1�� 5. Plan of Land x 9. The Plan is small and difficult to read A4hi"everdI-4;ys I will have full sized plans and will submit them to the Board. Kindly schedule this application for hearing at your earliest convenience. Thank you for your anticipated cooperation. Vey dy yours, �6r� � � R. Keily , Es uire .IRK/emb Enclosures ✓ ^? —,� , ..,� i]r't'C i`.i- i i/clivii•iC (. City of Salem Department of Planning & Community Development Check/Cash Receipt and Tracking Form Please complete form and make two copies. Date Received 5?- a j _I C) Amount Received _ Form of Payment Check /(, I q ❑ Cash ❑ Sign Permit Application Fee ❑ Conservation Commission Fee Payment received for what ® Planning Board Fee/ ZBA service? ❑ SRA/DRB Fee ❑ Copies Other: Name of staff person receiving t payment Additional Notes DATE INVOICE AMOUNT 53__179 . JOHN R. KEILTY, ESQUIRE 113 Counselor at Law 40 LOWELL STREET N� 6391 PEABODY, MASSACHUSETTS 01960 PDOLLARS AMOUNT OAT TOTHE ORDER OF aGSS AMT. IDESCflIPTION NE AMOUNT ()Eastern SIGNAL" ()Eastern Bank -Lynn. MA 11001639111' 1:0113OL7981: 60 004538911' Original Check and Form: DPCD Finance Copy 1: Client Copy 2: Application File City of Salem Department of Planning & Community Development Check/Cash Receipt and Tracking Form Please complete form and make two copies. Date Received S —/ U Amount Received Form of Payment ® Check/C sv ❑ Cash ❑ Sign Permit Application Fee ❑ Conservation Commission Fee Payment received for what Planning Board Fee/ service? ❑ SRA/DRB Fee ❑ Copies ❑ Other: Name of staff person receiving payment �e' i Additional Notes JOHN - – R• KEILTY, ESQUIRE DATE Cuunselora(Lgw INVOICE AMOUNT JO LOW ELL STREET 53 179 PEABODY, MASSACHUSETTS D1960 A' 1-13 PAMOUN7 - N2 16390 0 E TO E OR OF.. GgOSS AML OESCgIPDOLLARS . TION , NET AMOUNT �U Eastern flank _Lynn, MA �• ..Mti.. II.O i 6 3 901r• ISD + + // AUkI0R1 SI NAID _._-_.___._._R '. 30 & 79gr• 60 0045389 Original Check and Form: DPCD Finance Copy 1: Client Copy 2: Application File City of Salem Department of Planning & Community Development Check/Cash Receipt and Tracking Form Please complete form and make two copies. Date Received —� Amount Received �S Form of Payment Check/6,3 ❑ Cash ❑ Sign Permit Application Fee ❑ Conservation Commission ^Fee Payment received for what Planning Board Fee service? ❑ SRA/DRB Fee ll ❑ Copies ❑ Other: Name of staff person receiving payment Additional Notes JOHN R. KEILTy, ESQUIRE GATE NVOICE AMouNr Counselor at law 93-179113 40 LOW ELL STREET PEABODY, MASSACHUSETTS 01460 No 16389 PAM OUNT OAT TO THE OADER.OfDOLLARS .GROSS AML OESCRIPTION NET AMOUNT d Eastern Bank - r Ui GSIGNA qE 01016389110 9:0j130179a1: 60 0045389 ✓ rr,'Pgln;ai Check and Form: DPCD Finance : Client : Application File CITY OF SALEM, A/LkSS./kCHUSETTS � � BOARD OF APPEAL 9 O, 120 W AAI INM ON M RCG'I ♦S,V..EA1,iNIASSAcficsi:rrs 01970 'Fi J.r:978-7.15-9595 ♦ FAX;978-740-0404 j^ AInvoa ��:� Ln `' Y - PROJECT EXTENSION REQUEST Date:_ (Applicant/ ttorney) respectfully request that the Salem Zoning Board of Appeals extend the deadline For action on the project located at - (," 4 to j�' (Prof t Address) (Date) Sincerely, (Si tore) �" 1 V (Name) LBA ACTION FORM BOARD MEMBERS MOTION SECOND VOTE Date: ��© Robin Stein (Chair) Rebecca Curran Petitioner: �� , h ;,�_ �f _� / Elizabeth Debski Annie Harris Address: d67 Richard Dionne { Bomtie Belair(Alternate) / ' 19 �� )/j� tie JimmyTsitsinos (Alternate) T Conditions: Total• ❑Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, ordinances,codes and regulations. ❑All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. ❑All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. ❑Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. ❑Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. ❑A Certificate of Occupancy is to be obtained. ❑A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained. ❑Petitioner shall obtain street numbering from the City of Salem Assessor's Office and shall display said number so as to be visible from the street. ❑Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission havingjurisdiction including, but not limited to, the Planning Board. ❑ Unless this Decision expressly provides otherwise, any zoning relief granted does not empower or authorize the Petitioner to demolish or reconstruct the structure(s) located on the subject property to an extent of more than fifty percent (50%)of its Floor area or more than fifty percent(50%)of its replacement cost at the time of destruction. If the structure is demolished by any means to an extent of more than fifty percent(50%) of its replacement cost or more than fifty percent (50%)of its floor area at the time of destruction, it shall not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of the Ordinance. l S p Po i i 0 0 q ,f" e s d �aro �� -- �yy5 _ CssC-k Sfi'ee7� dP�vsP�C 3 � v J CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS r a �. ... BOARD OF APPEAL ��/MLVPU�C11.< 120WASHIN( roNYrseci ♦ S,�i.cni,Al�ssv Iha197 Kwffi iu i v Diusco,i, FF. [ 978-745-9595 ♦ I-\s 978-7 11-�'tOM1�'1t1� ;� 2: 9�� VIA1'OR I PROJECT EXTENSION REQUEST Date: (Applicant/Attorney) respectfully request that the Salem Zoning Board of Appeals extend the deadline for action on the project located at r ?/ 1 to (Projec ddress) (Date) Sincerely, nature) (Name) Access Studd k Propasecf coym�nunity� } Substance Abuse Center , High16h d Avenue ;5 Salem; Nfassachusett ` tF November 12 2010°:: it' tit Prepared for Community Health Care%,_Irc Quincy, Massachusetts , P,rep6r,e'd y ,i Land Strategies, LLC; 17Three Center p(aza i c rs., i >n �..v�.:x""!"�i k •.6d;�{.�`'F .J7: �`... .... Su�te'421F ,'� �x ;f wk i `i,. i y � Mewl wme,ExchR�e�iSx,.+�Y.eC.nlyk�ipr�W�k.yP,MSN.T ,x' � ..y r v - BostarwMA02108�; TABLE OF CONTENT'S _Section 'C'itEe Pn�e 1 [ntrochictii�ii I Existing Traffic Conditions 3 3 22015 Na-Buildsiid BuildT"fioCouditioiid to 4 CapacityAAnalysis. 17 5 R=mmendatigns and Conclusion 22 f FIGURES Title ...... . P-1 I 'Site Locatiou Mag 2 2010 8xisting Weekday Mcwnitig Peak-Rour TtaWlc Vijlqme.g 7 3 2015 No-Build Weekday. Morning peak.1jout T.Ittlie,Volulms 12 4 2015 Build Weekday Nfonnijjg,Ptak-FlourTraffic Volumes 16 41 X� 3 r T Y NQ SQR a - -; F � c EM MIOI ilml '�� tFPy�� •,��,-� ` kT q RC1 3.' f , �•�32' 3 i � i ' z r- 550 F MWF S i 3 r N ``�.JV Scale: 1"=Sao-- Community oo"Community Health Figure t Care Center CSAC n�r�rroawsi» I mPmnritumiiiiemia -- . �.wWdMM w I runaatm 1 Fenaaatvo Salem, MA Site Location Map First Street First Street is a two-lane, local collector roadway under the jurisdiction of the city of Salem. First Street traverses the study area from Highland Avenue in a southerly direction, where it then hams westerly and terminates at Traders Way. There is no posted speed limit on First Street. Land use along First Street is primarily residential. Intersections Highland Avenue,Traders Way and Marlborough Road Traders Way intersects Highland.Avenue from the south and Marlborough Road.intersects from the north to form this four-legged,signalized intersection. The Highland Avenue eastbound and westbound approaches each consist of an exleursive left-tum lane, two through lanes and an exclusive right-tum lane. The Traders Way approach consists of an exclusive left-turn lane and a shared left-tum/through lane, with ohannelization provided for right-turns. The Marlborough Road approach consists of a shared through/left-tum lane and an exclusive right-turn lane. Concrete sidewalks exist along both sides,of Highland Avenue, along the Traders Way approach and both sides of Marlborough Road. Crosswalks exist across all approaches. There is an MBTA bus stop on the Highland Avenue westbound approach. The intersection is controlled by a three- phase traffic signal with a protected lead phase for Highland Avenue eastbound left-tums and aprotected lag phase for Highland Avenue westbound left-turns. Land use in the area consists of a mix of retail uses, Highland Avenue,PEP Boys Driveway and Hawthorne Square Driveway The Hawthorne Square driveway intersects Highland Avenue from the south and the shared PEP Boys, Dunkin Donuts and Tritonwash driveway intersects from the north to form this four- legged, signalized intersection. The Highland Avenue eastbound approach consists of an exlcusive left-turn lane and two through lanes permitting right-turns, The Highland Avenue westbound approach consists of an exicusive left-tum lane, two through lanes and an exclusive right-tum lane. The PEP Boys driveway approach consists of a ?vide approach, which was generally observed to be used as an exclusive left-turn lane and a shared through/right-tura lane: The Hawthorne Square driveway approach consists of a shared through/left-tum lane and an exclusive right-turn lane. Concrete sidewalks exist along both sides of Highland Avenue and along the Hawthorne Square approach to the intersection. A crosswalks exists across to westbound approach. There is an META bus stop on the Highland Avenue westbound approach and on the Highland Avenue eastbound departure leg of the intersection. The intersection is controlled by a two-phase traffic signal with a protected phase for Highland Avenue eastbound or westbound left-turns Land use In the area consists of a mix of retail uses. Highland Avenue and First Street First Street intersects Highland Avenue from the south to form this three-legged, unsignalized intersection. The Highland Avenue eastbound approach consists of two through lanes,permitting right-turns. The Highland Avenue westbound approach consists of two through lanes. Highland Avene is median divided at First Street, restricting access to First Street to right-turns only. The First Street approach consists of a single Kine, permitting right-hams only. Concrete sidewalks exist along both sides of Highland Avenue and along the First Street approach to the intersection. First Street is under STOP-sign control. Land use in the area consists of a mix of retail and residential uses. 4 Lamm?Kase,nu,nairIcT�on..,na G�LL nos 11%10 Table 1 E.XIISTLYG TRAFFIC-VOLUME SUMMARY" Wc.kday WcAdny Morning Rack Flour Weekday Evening Ptak Hour TrAlrC Y}:itlie K Directional Traffic K. Dfreel+dnut Locadoti Volume° Voltltnt` Factor' VNtri@ulion, Vglumz Flctoc DLalribulion Higlil and Avenue toot of Art 27,600 1,004 7,3 51-3"6.tVB 1-091 7,657.5%wa Fihst Street-youth of I'lighhuldAvaute 2,300 227 9.9 919%NR 101 11,7 77.11dN6 'T'"-way IrutYc rolump °Daily udffiici."mclt in vduyle paddy, f'xpltm4d In ieluclex pa Iuwu: '1'crcenr„f r4ailp hralrrc w1ume;1010w P:cum filming 0he Beak kputr 'Pmcdt ofpmk'hLrtU vohnn0 in the predomindhn db tdotl ofnnwh NBm du'IltUpuoir159,a wuth6omid;EB-aa.'tblWucl;Vl6 aivkrtllndiNk '. ri I.: W:L AC Sf4m.:AbilafiMR;prIN'uJ dy d/1'LL I'i>ID:.trs Highland Avenue was recorded to carry approximately 27,600 vehicles per day (vpd) during average month conditions in front of the site. During the weekday morning peak hour, 2,006 vehicles per hour (vph) were recorded, and during the weekday evening peak hour, 2,091 vph were recorded. First Street was recorded to carry approximately 2,300 vpd during average month conditions in front of the site. During the weekday morning peak hour, 227 vph were recorded,and during the weekday evening peak hour, 201 vph were recorded. PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION The Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority(MBTA)provides bus service to the study area by way of Bus Routes 450, 450W and 456. Bus Route 450/45OW begins at the Salem Depot, travels along Highland Avenue and ends at Haymarket Station or Wonderland Station. Bus Route 450 runs between 5:40 AM and 1:16 AM on weekdays; between 630 AM and 12-32 AM on Saturdays and between 8:30 AM and 11:50 PM on Sundays. Bus Route 456 begins at the Salem Depot, travels south along Highland Avenue to Route 129 and ends at Central Square in Lynn Bus Route 456 runs between 7:00 AM and 4:20 PM on weekdays. Bus stops are provided at the intersections with Hawthorne Square and at Marlborough Road. MOTOR VEHICLE CRASH DATA Motor vehicle crash data for the study area intersections and roadways were obtained from the MassDOT database for 2006 through 2008, the most recent three-year period for which data is available. The motor vehicle crash data was reviewed to determine crash trends in the study area. A summary of the data is provided in Table 2. As shown in Table 2,the intersection of Highland Avenue,Marlborough Road and Trader's Way has a crash rate greater than the MassDOT District average. However, the crash data also indicates downward trend in crashes. This is most likely a result of the recent signal hnprovements implemented by MassDOT along the Highland Avenue corridor. PLANNED ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS Officials for MassDOT and the City of Salem were contacted regarding roadway improvements planned for the study area intersections. No improvement projects were identified that would increase capacity at the study area intersections. 8 1:i10.JJ8 KC S,;ao,hN1TnIFde,pvn,aW lKuneTUY ilM-Ola SECTION 3: 2015 NO-BUILD AND BUILD TRAFFIC CONDITIONS To determine the impact of site-generated traffic volumes on the roadway network under future conditions, baseline traffic volumes in the study area were projected to the year 2015. Traffic volumes on the roadway network at that time, in the absence of the proposed project, would include existing traffic,new traffic due to general background traffic growth,and wiffic related to specific developments by others expected to be completed by 2015. Consideration of these factors resulted In the development of 2015 No-Build traffic volumes. Anticipated site-generated traffic volumes were then superimposed upon these No-Build traffic flow networks to develop 2015 Build conditions. 2015 NO-BUILD TRAFFIC VOLUiYIES Traffic growth on area roadways is a function of the expected land development in the immediate area as well as the surrounding region. Several methods can be used to estimate this growth. A procedure frequently employed estimates an annual percentage increase in traffic growth and applies that percentage to all traffic volumes under study. The drawback to such a procedure is that some turning volumes may actually grow at either a higher or a lower tate at particular inter- sections. An alternative procedure identifies the location and type of planned development, estimates the traffic to be generated,and assigns it to the area roadway network. Thisproduces a more realistic estimate of growth for local traffic. However, the drawback of this procedure is that the potential growth in population and development external to the study area would not be accounted for in the traffic projections. To provide a conservative analysis framework, both procedures were used. to L A 053 KC 511.1 MA'.Trnlirftcporn nnJ firyrn\11VS I Itfi;ftbc� o�p Bo1a 4445-�# OUAKW TRITONDON(/75WASH X136 657 `' H1GIUNOAVENUE (ROUiE107) rn o � -796111 J-192 * t-1099 X1099 w*_1099 (, 27� � (0. 1051 ► ► 1060-195 879—a a 0 1.4 i (� 1040 ► (� N 37 rn 6 O: 20 N N v' h sflE HAWWORNE a &XMREw-U u a a a E _v Y d n a 0 J �N Not to Scale - DS�TTEG Community Health Figure 3 Care Center, CSAC ?a o,w Salem MA 2015 No-Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Traffic Volumes (7:30-8:30 A.M.) Table 4 PROPOSED TRIP GENERA'T'ION SUMNIARY New Trips Darty: 662 Weekday it forning Peak Hour. Entering 87 Exitine 87 Total 174 As shown in Table 4, the site is projected to generate 174 vehicle trips (87 vehicles entering and 87 vehicles exiting)during the weekday morning peak hour. Trin Distribution The directional distribution of the vehicular traffic approaching and departing the site is a function of population densities, the location of employment, existing travel patterns, similar uses,and the efficiency of the existing roadway system. The trip distribution for the CSAC was developed based on a gravity model prepared using available Census data for those communities included in the immediate area (Salem, Peabody, Swampscott and Lynn). Based on the distribution of population within the area, arrival and departure patterns for project-related traffic were estimated and adjusted,if appropriate,based on known local factors such as locations of other opportunities. The assignment of site-generated traffic to specific travel routes was based on observed trate flow conditions on available routes, and the assumption that most motorists will seek the fastest and most direct routes to and from the site. Table 5 sim inarizes the expected trip distribution. Table 5 PROPOSED TRIP DISTRIBU'T'ION Route Direction Percent of Trips highland Avenue East 35 Highland Avenue West 51 Marlborough Road North 14 TOTAL 100 14 LU013 KC NJ fiU-IVtI'%S I'0610 h'u J PEP O- Boys. Op QQQ}}} DUNpN' 7R/TON o DOALgS WASH i CO 4-1.36 1111 � N�� N � sl /� 4--657 04 v f--796 HIGHUNDAVENUE fmimion ► ► j'111 �► —222 a '*-1129 x-7129 '--1129 445-} t r► 27, 1138 ► 7060 r 754—► LOrn� 946—► �_ I 74 i 87� 70�� r 195 v N r� 37: .r N c h ifj Q' 3 SflE HAWrH0 SOLARREORNEarntc s u Y O D J �N Not to Scale ILANDSTRATEGIESI —� --��,�,,,,..m,,,,,,�,,,,,M Community Health Figure 4 a�AKQO �Qlm Care Center, CSAC "`�wdam I een w o�m I aen w:uiso Salem, MA 2015 Build Weekday Morning Peak Hour Traffic Volumes (7:30—8:30 A.M.) f' unsignalized intersections are also provided in the 2000 Highway Capacity Manual. Table 7 summarizes the relationship between level of service and average control delay for the critical movements atunsignalized intersections. Table 7 LEVEL-OF-SERVICE CRITERIA FOR UNSIGNALIZED INTERSECTIONS$ Average Delay Resulting (seconds per vehicle) Level of Service 10.0 A 10.1 to 15.0 g 15.1 to 25.0 C 25.1 to 35.0 D 353 to 50.0 p >50.0 p 'tligllway Capacity- Manual; Transporiation Research Board;Washington,DC;2000;page 17-2, Signalized Intersections Levels of service for signalized intersections are calculated using the methodology and procedures described in the 2000 Highway Capacity Manual. '1$e methodology assesses the intersection based on type of signal operation, signal timing and phasing, progression, vehicle mix, and intersection geometries. Level-of-service designations are based on the delay per vehicle. Table 8 summarizes the relationship between level of service and delay. The calculated delay values result in level-of-service designations which are applied to individual lane groups, to individual intersection approaches, and to the.entite intersection. Table 8 LEVEL-OF-SERVICE CRITERIA FOR SIGNALIZED LNTERSECTIONS° Delay per Vehicle Resulting (Seconds) Level of Service <10.0 A 10.1 to 20.0 Il 20.1 to 35.0 C 35.1 to 55.0 D 55.1 to 80.0 E >80.0 F 'Highivay Capnciry,Llanual; Transportation Research Board; Wnshiogton, DC . ;2000;page 16.2. i 18 4110411 Rr Selvr.MAvrmiTm�agyrce.ma nawdans uum ax Table 10 WEEKDAY MORNING UNSIGNALIZED LEVEL-OF-SERVICE ANALYSIS SUHMARY 2010 Bascliue MIS No-Build 2U 15 Build Critical-Movement/ Peak Hour Demand' V/C° Delay° LOS^ nmmd V.!C Delay LAS Demand VIC Delay LAS h7ghkmaPAvemaeand — -- Flirt Street•. Right-tram Afovemenn Jrom Ferse Sheer 213 D.35 13.5 B 224 035 13.1 H 224 0.39 14,2 H Highland Aveeme and.Slte Driveway: Right-lura 6fov narnh - - •• •• 87 0.13 10.5 B 111ghlandAwnue and Rem1l Driveway: - Right-turn Atownour JFom dnveway -- -. 9 0.01 9.4 A 9 0.01 9.3 A 'Demand ofcritical inowan no io vehicles per hear. 'Volume-totapacity ratio. Delay in seconds par vehicle, °L.eyel of.iavica Mehland Avenue at First Street Under 2010 Existing weekday morning conditions, the critical movements(lght•tum movements from First Street)at this unsignalized intersection currently operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under future 2015 No-Build conditions, these movements are projected.to operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under 2015 Build conditions,with the project,the critical movements am modeled to continue to operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Highland Avenue at Site Driveway(East Driveway) Under 2010 Existing weekday morning conditions,the critical movements(right-tum movements from First Street)at this unsignalized intersection currently operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under future 2015 No-Build conditions, these movements are projected to operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under 2015 Build conditions, with the project, the critical movements are modeled to continue to operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Ifiehland Avenue at West Driveway Under 20.10 Existing weekday morning conditions,the critical movements(right-turn movements from First Street)at this unsignalized intersection currently operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under future 2015 No-Build conditions, these movements are projected to operate at LOS B during the weekday morning peak hour. Under 2015 Build conditions, with the project, the critical movements are modeled to continue to operate at IAS B during the weekday morning peak hour. 20 LM 031 KC Salva MA%Dtffm\Rupoas mud fgivalrbtS I10610,do SECTION 5: RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSION The proposed project, the CSAC, is expected to generate approximately 174 vehicle trips (87 vehicles entering and 87 vehicles exiting)during the weekday morning peak hour. An analysis of traffic operations at t Y he study . P dy area intersections indicates es that the proposed project does not r n a significant J result gmficant im act to operating perating conditions. RECOMMENDATIONS The final phase of the analysis process is to identify the mitigation measures necessary to mini_ mize the impact of the project on the transportation system. The proponent has made a commit- ment to implement the mitigation measures listed below. Highland Avenue and Existing East Driveways Currently,the East driveway operates under STOP control,but the driveway has no STOP sign or pavement markings. It is recommended that a STOP sign and STOP bar be installed on the driveway approach to Highland Avenue. CONCLUSION Review of the proposed development and access plan shows that in relation to roadway capacity, traffic safety, and traffic impacts upon the surrounding roadway network, the proposed project will have a minimal impact on existing traffic conditions. With the proposed access, in conjunction with the mitigation measures described above and maintaining adequate sight distance from the driveway, sate and efficient access can be provided to the clientele of the proposed development and to the motoring public in the area. 22 L1w.03e KC Salem MAm.,irnRepr"uq fpurdn.lY Ofiln.,:ov i r r , SalemNews.com, Salem, MA /am,ary s, 2011 Appeal planned in denial of clinic Company still pursuing a methadone center in city By iblallbem K Roy Staff writer SALEM—'Che company that wants to put a methadone clinic in Salem is going to court over the Zoning Board of Appeals' denial oC a spacial permit for a proposed clinic ou i lighlaud Avenue. Jack Kcilty, lawyer for the Quincy-based Community Substance Abuse Centers, said his client decided yesterday morning to pursue an appeal. "I personally like our chances," said Keilty, who plans to file the appeal in Salem Superior Court in advance of a Jan. 17 deadline. The five-member Board of Appeals voted unanimously last month against granting a permit for a clinic at the former site of Hillcrest Chevrolet. Members argued that,the facility would generate too much traffic during peak hours in an area that has a number of schools, including the high school. Citing a traffic study provided by the clinic, Chaitwoman Kobin Stein said at the board's Dec. 15 meeting that the clinic would almost triple traffic on First Street during peak hours. But Kedty said yesterday that the board could have done more to mitigate the impact of the increased traffic. It could have attached conditions to the permit, adjusting the clinic's operating hours, for example, that mould have addressed board members' concerns. Community Substance Abuse Centers wants to open a clinic to dispense methadone every morning and provide counseling to recovering drug addicts. It a lready operates a facility off Route 1 in Peabody and began looking in Salem last spring.' A'he company was initially interested in a Canal Street location but met intense opposition from neighbors and the city's elected officials. Community Substance Abuse Centers eventually dropped its plans for the Jeffery Brothers Furniture building and turned its attention to Highland Avenue, which Keilty described as a "Far superior" site. Over the sununer, hnwc:Ner, the citl• amended itS .>.ouing ordinance to require ficiliries like a methadone clinic to receive a special permit before opening in the city. The change put Community Substance Abuse Centers before the Zoning board of Appeals with its I lighland Avenue proposal. 'Che clinic would offer patients daily doses of methadone, a synthetic narcotic administered to chminate withdrawal symptoms when an addict stops taking heroin or other opiates. About 300 patients would receive methadone treatments, mainly between 6 and 8 a.m. As happened with the original plan for Canal Street, neighbors of the Highland Avenue site came out in united opposition. Marty Miserandino, a First Street resident, said yesterday that neighbors are prepared to do what they can to ensure the appeal does not succeed. The clinic, according to Miserandino, would change the character of the neighborhood. "The neighborhood has spoken, plain and simple," he said. "We don't want it." 64embcrs of the Board of Appeals, including Stein, could not be reached for comment. Neither could City Solicitor Beth Itennard. City Councilor Jean Pelletier, who represents the ward where the clinic is proposed,wasn't surprised that the company behind it is contesting the board's denial. "They have every right to (appeal)," Pelletier said. "I didn't think it was over by any means, but I think the board made a just decision, and I think it will be upheld." The court cnuld uphold the appeals hoard's decision or send it hack to the hnard with instructions, Keilry said. I Community Substance Abuse Centers will continue to investigate other sites but wants to preserve its stake in the ffighland Avenue location, the lawyer said. The city is attractive because it is home to a population that would use the clinic's services. "We have targeted Salem," Keilty said, "and we would like to be there." SalemNews.com, Salem, MA Oecember 161, 2010 No methadone clinic in Salem Board rejects substance abuse center with unanimous vote 13y Sioae N. Galunq Staff Writer SALEM— No methadone clinic will be coming to the site of the former Flillcrest Chevrolet. The Zoning Board of Appeals unautimously denied a special permit for Quincy-based Community Substance Abuse Centers last night,drawing a round of applause from a packed meeting room. "Wc will sleep better tonight," said resident Michele Knox,who has lived on nearby Cavendish Circle for 1 t years and works from home. For more than two hours, the five-member board heard from residents who railed against the prospect of a clinic in an area they described as heavily residential and too close to Salem I ligh, Collins Middle School and Bowditch fi,lcmcntary School. Some, like Marty Miscrandino, threatened to leave Salem if the clinic were to move into the Highland Avenue location. "I'm seriously going to put my house on the market if this is approved," the I st Street resident said. "We've come here as it united city to say we don't want this." Others expressed concern about the number of cars that the clinic wOLld bring to the area. "I don't see how this does not impact trill tic," Essex Street resident Dorothy I-tayes said. No one spoke up for the project except the company's attorney,Jack Keilty, who led off the meeting with an overview of the project. He said that although he expected testimony to be "emotion;tl, yi,, ILal and passionate," he had yet to hear any hard evidence of an increase of crime or impact on safety. "'Phis isn't ;t popularity contest," lie told the board. Rather, their vote was one for serious deliberation. FIe also indicated that a rejection of the special permit would put the city at risk of litigation. r Madeline Avenue residentfim Rush said the issue was common sense. Ile took :um at Keilty's threat of a lawsuit. "If they want to go to litigation, I say that's a fight worth having," he said. For board Chairwoman Robin Stein, the largest stumbling block for her approval was the number of cars leaving the proposed clinic onto side streets at prime clinic hours in the early morning. "The peak hours are Amost tripling traffic on lst Street," she said, responding to a traffic study provided by the clinic. While Stein said the community needed to be I:ur to people who require the clinic's service, she was troubled by the location's impact on traffic and its potential impact on students walking to school during the clinic's busiest hours. Fellow board member Rebecca Curran expressed concern over parking and traffic. She said she didn't think the bcncfit ouavcighed the detriment to the neighborhood. Member Elizabeth Debski also noted that the high school started around the peak hours of the clinic. "I really think this disrupts the neighborhood character," she said. 'Ihe board's decision was welcomed by Ward 3 Councilor Jean Pelletier. "I'm very happy with it," said Pelletier,who represents the area near the proposed clinic. "If they want to appeal, that's their right." Councilor at-large Steve Pinto called the vote "great," especially with all five members' opposition. "That made a lot of people happy," he said. Keilty said last night that he is unsure whether the clinic would appeal the board's decision or consider another site. r Salem 1ve�y -corn epm S AIA ti I�&ember 14 2010 ' Salern, 1tilethado ne cl n'c goes bef N,Fla,ieIV cu1,n� ore the ZBA to Staff writer morrow, SALLikI_IheLoning Board methadone clinic r, 13o` t n FIi of APPeals is scheduled ghland avenue. to hold, The a hearing tomorrow on hearing was Postponed from last the proposed month when Chainvo The clinic r'per;rtor, the formert-°rnmu man Robin Stein took ill. Jeffery broth mty Health [nc., is the neighborhood u Brothers Fu Name corn the F uproar in tare building on Can. PanY that tried former Hill Chevrolet Since then aI Stre CU Open a hevrolet site. , they have filed a net, before abando methadone - nin P arnic at Jack u proposal to offer metha Plan, ,mrd J- Keiity, a IaYt done treat Present) Ter who represents t mens at y treats betivecn 80, he clinic would offer mPlay, has saki in the withdrawal •yin [° a lady do... o0 s alemC`h �n[s at its Peabo y F.ac.1. at comm Flealth (. p, tients muni s P ms when , of d an addict stn °e' a synthetic �' an Indic' ire stops takin narcotic administered n of the need. The T°morrow's meetin g heroin or other o i, St. '1'Itat g will be heldP ates• t° eliminate came as a surprise to at the board's clinic, bast month Ward 3 usual meetin the meeting1.Ouncilor can , g Place, the Ci cvas sch I elletier, who n' [Mall Annex at 120 eduled at Bowditch represents Washington The councilor esti School, the area din P,ton mated that he receive °I' which is in th surroun g the expected a large turnout. Flc d about 20 ho �t neighborhood. is near schools. noted that the phone calls; neighborhood is home a dozen e-mails °❑ Peileticc °me to many children the heariu said the 60, n and the g and board's decision shouldproposed clinic come down to It's my hope that the Public he. "Peo le h board will: alth, safety and well-being. p ave leg rim-rte caner. tet in a way that benefits ms. I m n the nc ghborhoo Ultimately, n rheirside." �. the decision d and the city Overall,,,rests with the board, > he said. "he'll Pelletier noted. just have .r � - tOsee, Ile said. "ft's the board's call." S, SalemNews.com, Salem, NIA Deremher 14, 2010 Methadone clinic goes before the ZBA tomorrow By Stade N. Galang Staff Writer SALEM —The 'honing Board of Appeals is scheduled to hold a hearing tomorrow on the proposed methadone clinic on Ifighland Avenue. The hearing was postponed from last month when Chairwoman Robin Stein took ill. The clinic operator, Community Ilealth Inc., is the same company that tried to open a methadone clinic at the former jeffery Brothers Furniture building on Canal Street, before abandoning their plans amid a neighborhood uproar in June. Since then, they have filed a new proposal to offer methadone treatment at the former Hillcrest Chevrolet site. Jack Keilty, a lawyer who represents the company, has said in the past that Community F tealth Care presently treats between 80 and 100 Salem residents at its Peabody facility, an indication of the need. The clinic would offer patients daily doses of methadone, a synthetic narcotic administered to eliminate withdrawal symptoms when an addict stops taking heroin or other opiates. Tomorrow's meeting will be held at the board's usual meeting place, the City Hall Annex at 120 Washington St. That came as a surprise to Ward 3 Councilor jean Pelletier, who represents the arca surrounding the clinic. Last month, the meeting was scheduled at Bowditch School,which is in that neighborhood. The councilor estimated that lie received about 20 phone calls and a dozen e-mails on the hearing and expected a large turnout. He noted that the neighborhood is home to many children and the proposed clinic is near schools. Pelletier said the board's decision should come down to public health, safety and well-being. "It's my hope that the board will act in a way that benefits the neighborhood and the city overall," he said. "People have legitimate cnnreme. I'm nn their sifle." Ultimately, the decision rests with the board, Pelletier noted. "We'll just have to see," he said. "It's the board's call." CITY OF SALEM MASSACHUSETTS '! DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Knmr:w.ev Dals<:oi-1- Pvkwt< LvNNGOONND(NmiXN,AIC' 120WASHINGTONSTME-r ♦ SALEM,MASSACHUSL-1'fS 01970 Dnu:croa TELE:978-619-5685 978-740-0404 MEMORANDUM TO: Chief Paul Tucker, Dr. William Cameron, Lt. Erin Griffin FROM: Danielle McKnight,Staff Planner DATE: September 28, 2010 RE: Proposed Methadone Clinic — Board of Appeals Application I am enclosing a copy of the site plan and application made by Community Health Care, Inc. and Health Care Resources, Inc. to the Salem Board of Appeals requesting a Special Permit to operate a methadone clinic on 207 Highland Avenue. While the Planning Department doesn't normally route Board of Appeals applications to your departments, the Board of Appeals specifically requested comments from you given concerns expressed by members of the community. I would be grateful if you could review the application and send anycomments back to me, preferably by October 15. Concerns the Board of Appeals heard at its last meeting were: File The site plan contains internal crashgates. Pdice• Members of the public felt the clinic would attract criminal behavior, negativelyaffecting the community and placing undue strtut on the police force. Concerns were also raised about security at the facility itself. Sdirxzls: Members of the public were upset by the proximity Of the proposed clinic to schools and were concerned about the safety of students walling past the clinic along Highland Avenue. Thant:you in advance for taking the time to review this application. Please let tire know if you have questions about the project, and I can contact the applicant for the information. Page l uF I Danielle McKnight From: ptucker@salempd.net Sent: Monday, November 08, 2010 3:11 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Proposed Clinic Issues Thank you for the opportunity to address some of the issues surrounding the application of Community Health Care Inc, to operate a methadone clinic at the proposed Highland Avenue site. As you may know, I appeared at a community meeting several months ago where another site was discussed. My remarks at the time centered on two themes, the first is that there is clearly a need for treatment options for individuals that struggle with addiction. 'Phe second was that the police department was not in a position to discuss the relative merits of one site over another,however if a site were chosen, the department would be interested in working with the proper authorities to ensure the safety and security of the public as well as the patients and employees. When the idea of a clinic was first proposed for the Canal st.site, members of my staff conducted a survey of police departments that have interacted with clinics in the municipalities that they serve. While some reported a few minor Police related issues, most said there were no problems associated with the clinic operations. I also met with the director of the facilities and he outlined the security steps undertaken at each of the clinic locations and relying on his representation he answered all of the questions I had at this time. I am not unmindful that it was criminal activity,that being drug use,that has patients needing the methadone and that there is no guarantee that people involved in criminal activity will not participate in the clinic's program. That being said,the same would hold true for people going downtown to attend District and Superior Court after running afoul of the law. Whatever the outcome of the permitting process, the Salem Police department will strive to maintain our commitment to keep all citizens safe and secure. Please feel free to contact me with any concerns as you move forward and let me know if[can bent any further assistance. Paul F. Tucker Chief or Police 11/8/2010 NOV 05 2010 DEPT OF PL?NN ING& Zoning Board of Appeals COMMUNITY DI:, I.7PMEN1 City Clerk -3 iD '. So City Nall Ci ; '' C;i9• t1q 93 Washington Street Salem, MA 01970 1 am writing to voice my support for opening a new methadone treatment clinic in Salem. Drug addiction has become an epidemic on the North Shore and we need more than just one treatment clinic in the area. The clinic in Peabody-was treating up to 600 patients at one point and now estimates that it is treating approximately 100 Salem residents. I realize no community wants a Methadone treatment center in their town, but I do believe that Community Substance Abuse Centers (CSAC) have tried to work with the people by listening to their concerns. Because of what the citizens had to say about the safety of the location CSAC found a new location amongst commercial property on a 2 lane main street that would have less traffic concerns. The company would be moving into a building where they will operate out of the back with a separate exclusive parking lot surrounded by gates. lack Keilty is quoted as saying "It isolates us...We're trying to create our own little enclave." Salem residents also voiced concern about having these clients driving on their streets. If 100 Salem residents are being treated in Peabody and Chelsea they must already be driving the streets of Salem. I believe if the clinic was off Highland Ave more Public transportation may be used to get back and forth to the clinic. There is also the possibility of less loitering while waiting for a counseling session scheduled for later in the day because they could go back to their own homes to wait for their next appointments. With the epidemic proportion of drug abuse comes the need for more drug treatment centers. I believe that residents in a city as large as Salem should not have to leave their own community to receive help. Donna Dzielnik 5 Garden Road Peabody, MA 01960 Telephone 978-532-2383 NO '1'7 10 02:13p bob patter 617-786-9169 p.2 -- f3 M rvl4 n.v e- Tla/S c r�i Cly'✓C JP//v G O r?JfI,TL "t OJ O/ c T o7Nc R o�tAT� O^/ A Ot1r cis SOMcS ST/c. c //v - - -zerv1, Sept - ,it3.G H �"l8 ACJDn�� C, /c 1/\-30� G:- 71A ARJG-. R3�fl/cT3 w/Lt. 6 - _ . ._ . rvG. b /3rL _ Avg 7?1��_1� MESO) cHTrp�.� GvU� . — v!��E2 Aron F I p w�v y� , i ,s T ref E Fri 7?l Cp NM v n�rr> '770 I 54`- /�i//S t ve rYwC�— �rv� ESf' c,fJ � cy i / S d�JHn 1 W /� Ep / 3 '7 I-IF �3LMpST L/ yen2S . H/9 e'.na 1. 771 r7/v Ft to 3.71 &.07-- I A-)I C y4 r,) r` r^fcny1171rrv(r-- -- cam.. NAd� /'JGF1V Ctt �1 _] • ��lsAi/ ✓t FV rr.af e/r L"L4D' vC�5' - GvTE,y. Ctcttna ,,:,,- lfOuT r-4 (E T7-t/913 ivy FSE(_ THE MrJ/+V FEH (L � 71-1E P'. e&?OEr.. 75 1= sA , 1 s THI-9 T /r TN.Er� is .. G d„v c- r Nuv 17 10 02:13p bob potter 617-7965169 p,3 Pc Fc�, wHE tl o,euE SPC c7 A.)Cr _0^3 ,� _ ^ 1cy r3,9S2 s� t1 iv7-0 ... J- CA1v c C_ o u RvG Rcir�lri - _ S wo i i Rv ti Acs. M 1✓/V-3.. 0, _. ,_ C .S. ,9 •C � t1A v� ,.vE,f� _ ANC J2 ,)G 4C7-/-v-,7- I. - a?uc E Iry Piq cE ; v loge 4 Ll 1v TS, /JlLG /uo7" 19f' c p WEAOR __nTt�6 - _ o_ .. . 19nay � /3vs� 1v��.. ]�.�E � .._ . /d.�•,, U/n>> C- s7v �E't .cTL Y fl,e(: !V U/ 14LL0 W rya !L7 _. .. - GONUCRs� f} /VOTE ,Cf t1CMi+U AT7Lv�� F W Ori9. TJ-/ G-V _ _. N01 y Vs> t�7 Si�ic;v Y..� - ._ r�+E�1cA3'�o� _ ,� tiw s7.1/7•S ; T, — - T)4 ^ C -) . sr S Co ZlNfJ7 -1; pJ,.I(- VV E-4 Gt'Lbc:;a ^SE=CT lrvfr. _G • 44.s CLT N1TT- TO 0 TZ LI�G� L y. w-iced C�lFF62eJJ �A�-G figpn/r iv,)I T741f©fJl GT/On1 3 _ . TzJ O!7/ SVY� Si fjiv ec ;- Nc�l :j vsT oprtj -1� tRv� v Nod 17 10 02:13p bob potter 617-786-9169 p.4 ew P MvCtr._ .T-O _. NZE�'L)O iT r�N O Pf r^-3/ Ofv QV /,Ll D ! 2OT. . D - C ori M q,v,7-�ir i T -- �-- ._-j-HE vlNEN . ,4N 04p;j`1T6 rrtnA� CT £ t3C? ,WJE L� AJIRTr cI AT_ __. &C)0�0 Cil /J?r✓ GIN . TD_ Ti9 r cage ,-wLE _ .. �. Q,� C,ve. w"133. N.&c/�S. TWO Se of vs „a � E cc T�-►E.M - A Lcrr ©-� . - - _ VV E-: ✓Sf Co_ME ._9C-T)u� . 77446rvG-? a7vl�AJ`G �t3A�c.i� IAD LC �>✓ vi e �� Ta �' f. 1 ,°OSIT? v S:.-rep _ aduc%�Ln_ iSA7�j E2 _. r4N � ...--- R�1+, ?q I _C_34.1 CiL.EF1N.- f3/V�_ /rV R.�tU U �,2 / , r ..—. 710 E4.y __ _ . SlNcEQELrE�i - L . t .. Plige I of 2 Danielle McKnight . . . .. . . . . . . .. From: John Adelman bohnadelman @yahoo.com] Sent: Tuesday, December 14, 2010 3:03 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Community Health Care Dear Ms. McKnight: I will not be able to attend the meeting for Community Health Care, should there not be a scheduling conflict, I would attend the meeting. Below, in the body of the text is what I would say at a Public Meeting, had I been able to attend. Dear fv(s. McKnight, Staff Planner and Thomas St. Pierre, Building Commissioner: and also ZBA: Robin Stein Chair` May 1, 2010 Richard Dionne Secretary July 1, 2009 Elizabeth Debski Vice Chair July 1, 2009 Annie Harris June 1, 2009 Rebecca Curran May 1, 2010 Bonnie Belair Alternate June 1,2010 Jaynes rsitsinos Alternate May 1, 2010 Dear Zoning Board of Appeals: If this were a Diabetes Clinic; Cancer Treatment Center; or Heart Health Center would you treat it differently? This is a health care facility for people disabled or handicapped due to their health; not their MORALITY. Any decision of the Board; this or any other as a result of Stigma due to the class or disease; class or handicap or disability violate two sets of Laws: Americans with Disabilities Act and because the City of Salem receives Federal Tax Dollars, Section X04 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. There is a chance of loosing Federal Funding for violating Section 504 ofthe Rehabilitation Act. SAIMHSA, is the group ofthe United States Health and Human Services deparhnent, which supports this type of health problem. There are plenty of reasons to treat the weak and poor; differently than the rich and the powertitl, but as civilized people, we accept protections for some people who need protection of 12.'I4/2010 y Page 2 of 2 Law. Any decision other than accepting the plan; is disadvantaging 100 patients of Community Health Care. Yes, they are taking medication prescribed by a physician. In addition to medication they receive other treatments, required for their condition. If'a Cancer; Heart, or Diabetes patient needed services in Salem, would you treat the Petition to the ZBA differently? If there would be no objections to Cancer; Heart; or Diabetes treatment; there should be no allowance for objection for Addiction Treatment. Respectfully Submitted, VIA EMAIL John Adelman Phone: 1 -978-744-6466 Fax: 1 -978-336-5911 27 Charter Street, 1006 Salem, MA 01970 f 1=, 14,'_1 izHOAR,Massachusetts Organization for Addiction Recovery 30 Winter St.,3r`' Floor, Boston, MA 02108 Toll Free: 1-877-423-NIOAR or 617-423-6627 Fax 617-423-6626 Online: www.moar-recoverv. M E-Mail: MOARfranna aol com s 1 SPEAKING OUT FOR ADDICTION RECOVERY! organization activating its mission to organize recovering individuals,fanhilies, ti10AR is a statewide recovery community and friends into a collective voice educating the public abort the value of recoveryfrom alcohol and other addictions. We envision a society where addiction is treated as a significant public health issue and recovery is recognized as valuable to our communities. We collaborate with allied organizations to improve prevention, treatment, and recovery support services. o Massachusetts ranks among the top 5%ofstates for alcohol and drug use among adults and youth (NSUDH) o From 2001-1004, the MA Bureau ofStfbstance Abuse Services ftfrtding was cut by nearly 50%. Now to The 9 Leadership Mental Health and Substance Abuse Committee Chairs Representative LizMafiaand Senator Jennifer Flanagan; Assistant Majority Leader Senator Tolman;Senate President Therese Murray; House Speaker Robert DeLeo; MA Bureau of Substance Abuse Services with MOAR, MA Campaign for Addiction Prevention,Treatment,and Recovery;Coalitions; Parent Groups; and You! Your Voices are BeingHeard! 1010 MA Bureau of Substance Abuse Services Budget Makes History with Alcohol Tar to Prevent Cuts Now MOAR Than Ever We Need Unite To Prevent Future Cuts, & Protect Our Services Seak Out for Addiction Prevention Treatment and Recove Su ort Services to Protect 0 3 Recovery High Schools in Springfield, Boston, and Beverly with graduations 0 2(Worcester& Brockton) Statewide Adolescent Crisis Stabilization Units—a 25 bed detox with follow tin o New male Highpoint New Bedford rehabilitation unit for men, who are (section 35)civilly committed o Highpoint's Tranquility inn New Bedford, Women's Section 35, hasbeen at full capacity for over 2 years o More alcohol and other drug education in public schools o Alcohol and other drug screening, treatment referral in 7 hospital emergency rooms and beyond! o Approximately S2.7 million more in long-term, residential, addiction recovery service contracts 0 6 Regional Clinical Support Services, (rehab for post detox or that does not require medical detox) 0 6 Regional Recovery Support Centers with a variety of support services are in the plans o Office of Youth and Young Adult Services with Family Involvement o Diversion(residential treatment vs imprisonment) for low level offenders 7`f What Still Hurts and What MOAR Do We Need 3265 Overdose Deaths manifest 2002-2007 and NARCAN is being piloted to keep people alive & Future policies guided by 1010 O.rvcontin Commission, MA Strategic Plan with coalitions to make the following a reality o Strategic Prevention Framework Action to address drug overdoses as well as underage drinking o Good Samaritan Campaign to reduce drug overdose deaths by removing barriers to calling 911 o improved prescription monitoring, Safer storage of prescription medication, Disposal for unused pills o Community, parent and teacher education; family intervention and support; school counseling o Jail Diversion; Rehabilitation vs Recidivism o Increased Access Throughout The Continuum of Care...with MOAR to do in 2010 for 2011........ NIOAR Joins United We Standfir Public Health to increase Revenues and Protect All Public Health Services, MICAS, DiA Coalition for Addiction Services, and Campaign fordddiction Prevention, Treatment, and Recoverv. The Cfu»paign is a united voice seeking protection and enhancement of substance abuse services with a budget proposal succeeded in repealing the state tax exemption on the sale ofalcohol products sold in stores. We want to keep the Alcohol Sales Tax and dedicate funding for necessary substance abuse services ' f Educate your elected legislators about theimpon nee of services for your tinnily,communis ' Let them know the alcohol sales tar is helping maintain services and needs to be dedicated for substance abuse services. SalemNews.com, Salem, MA November 18, 2010 Methadone meeting delayed Residents irate as illness pushes off decision on Salem clinic 13y Stade N. Calang staff writer SALLM—A temperature of 102 degrees kept Zoning Board Chairwoman Robin Stein from last night's meeting, but she wasn't the only one feeling the heat. Her absence allowed Jack Keilty, the attorney for a Quincy company's proposed methadone clinic at the former Hillcrest Chevrolet on Highland Avenue, to postpone his application for a special permit until next month. Still, he and the remaining board members heard an earful from some disgruntled residents who showed up prepared to speak and now decided to blurt out questions. About 70 people had attended the meeting in the cafetorium of the Bowditch School. Marty Miserandino, who sat in the front row, asked what would happen if the board went ahead with the hearing in spite of Keilty's request. Some,like him, are parents and had to juggle schedules and hire baby sitters, he said. "Four votes are needed to pass the petition," Vice Chairwoman Elizabeth Dcbski said. "FIe has a right to be heard by the full board." Debski explained that Stein had phoned her at 5 p.m. Sick with the flu, the chairwoman had hoped to feel better but didn't, and she worried she would infect others, said Debski, who fielded most audience questions. "I had no way of knowing she said. "I apologize. Things like this happen." Kcilty told the crowd that he expected strong opposition and the absent chairwoman should have the chance to hear the tenor of their comments. "I don't have to go forward without the full board," he said. Some opponents worried the postponement or weather would diminish their numbers at next month's meeting. Others simply lamented the possibility of a clinic at all. 'Che applicant, Community I lealth Care Inc., already treats between 80 and 100 Salem residents at the company's facility in Peabody, indicating 11 demand for such services in the Witch City, Keilty said at a previous meeting. Methadone is a synthetic narcotic, which is administered to eliminate withdrawal symptoms when an addict stops taking heroin or other opiates. Miserandino, who lives on 1st Street, said his home is only 100 yards from the property where the local clinic is proposed. F[e has a 21/2-year-old and his wife is expecting their second child. "(I'he chnic's)going to change the whole character of the neighborhood," he said after the board went on to its next agenda item. b[iserandino was concerned about a growing divide between the thriving downtown and the outskirts where he lives. The presence of a clinic is going to undermine the city's strides toward revitalization. "It's a shame to see so many great things happen in Salem that the mayor is touting," Miserandino said, ".. and then the city has to deal with trash like this." Swampscott resident John Kelliher said the neighborhood where the proposed clinic would be sited is residential. He worried how the clinic would affect nearby Salem Woods,where he walks his dog. "The most important thing is the children and the people living on Highland Avenue," he said. Salem resident'Cerri Nadeau said traffic on Highland Avenue is already difficult,even without any methadone patients who might queue up for the medication. She said she must wait through nearly five light cycles daily to get out Cherry [-[ill Avenue and onto the bus Route 107 to take her children to school y "Any little thing that goes on affects it," she said. Even so, there is a bigger problem she sees with a methadone clinic. Nadeau said three family members have battled opiate addictions and take methadone, "I see them when they take their dosage," she said. "People are going to be like that on the streets." a SalemNews.com, Salem, MA November IS, 2010 Board expects a crowd on clinic Company plans methadone center on Highland Avenue By Staaie N. Galwig Staff Writer SALEM— Bracing for a capacity crowd at a hearing for a proposed methadone clinic, the Zoning Board of Appeals has moved its Wednesday meeting from its usual downtown space to Bowditch School. "We have to allow people to come in," board member Richard Dionne said. "It's good to have the public input." 'rhe hearing was continued from September when Westfield-based Community Health Care's proposal to open a clinic in,the former Flillcrest Chevrolet location drew so many residents they Flowed out of the meeting room and into the hallway. '17te for-profit company is requesting a special permit from the "Zoning Board that would usher in a clinic on Highland Avenue, the company's 14th. If Wednesday's meeting is anything like the last on the methadone clinic, it's sure to be heated. At some points, angry residents shouted out to the board, particularly when they realized no vote would be taken. Attorney Jack Keilty, who represents the company a]so known as Community Substance Abuse Centers, said the clinic will present addiction numbers from the state's Department of Public Health. It also expects to share the results of a traffic study on Ifighland Avenue and other information related to opening a clinic. "We're going to show what the need is from the perspective of how many opiate addicts (there are)," he said. Kcilty said the company has already identified 100 Salem residents at its other locations, though not all would move to a Salem location. Within a year, the clinic could grow to as many as 300 patients. Some of Community F[calth s clinics have twice that number, Keilty said. Keilty said the majority of patients would receive their doses of methadone, a synthetic narcotic that acts as I substitute for more harmful opiates like heroin, between 5 and G a.m. '1'he early hours would ensure patients could get to their jobs and take their children to school. + yTf�. • n 1. The company will discuss how it anticipat traffic. es its clients will queue up to limit the impact on Highland Avenue Second attempt It's the second time the company has tried to open a clinic in Salem. flitter opposition to a Canal Street location prompted Community Health Care to back away from leasing space in the former feffcry Brothers furniture building. Keilty said the Zoning Board may impose conditions with its special permit, but generally must provide a good reason to deny it. "I think we can show from an objective standpoint it fulfdls the criteria of the special permit," he said. "It's an allowed use by special permit." Keilty said the company had looked at other locations around Salem but has decided the Ifighland Avenue location is ideal. "We thought this one was the best for a number of reasons," he said. 'They include the commercial zoning and the relative isolation of the clinic, the attorney said. "Although the immediate neighbors think it's a horrible site,we think it's isolated," he slid. "We think we can control safety." Keilty contends not everyone is repelled by the idea. A church group has approached them about becoming another tenant in the building, he said. Keilty said he hopes to have some patients at the meeting who can share their story with residents. Ile said patients who depend on methadone must also be i Participate. n a recovery program of some sort or they can't "Generally, it's not an alternative to an addictive life," he said. "ft's the beginning of a new, productive life." The company has rarely had occasion to open in a community without severe opposition, but once it starts receiving patients, it becomes largely invisible to the general public, he said. Dionne said it's possible the board could decide Wednesday to grant or deny the clinic's special permit. 'file company also has the option of continuing its hearing to the later meeting. Untitled Our great country was founded on the premise of life,liberty,and justice, not for only the select few who can afford it, custom made. And now,two hundred years later, we are sinking into a bottomless pit of moral and ethical decadence. 1 was a child of fourteen when 1 heard these stories. My friends were children of seventeen and eighteen years,sent into combat to battle against other children. This brought me back to the stories 1'd beard about my father's parents who immigrated to the United States to escape the genocide. And, what were these wars really about? What is any war about? War is about control.Control is Power,and power is money.And the love of money is at the root of all that is evil. And so, now 1 am watching a different war. A much more insidious kind of war.A war that is waged on our children from the time they are old enough to recognize and understand the spoken word and recognize product logos. The brainwashing that tells children what is or is not important, what is and is not worth lighting for begins early. There is no real censorship,no real prohibition of that which is not wholesome,and fit for consumption. Profanity and vulgarity are part of the trademark; the more notorious and obscene,the better. Media and the corporate market Place push their wares in a most sensationalized light,glorifying the sweets which erode the spirit. Thus wehave gangs and gang wars,crime rates that are only rising.Drug and alcohol abuse that is glamorized and called entertainment. And,if America can win two world wars,why can't she win a war on drugs?Who's really profiting from the assault on our society? President John Kennedy was assassinated just before he was about to expose the CIA's bringing drug cartels into the United States. When these questions were posed to a former Salem Mayor,suggesting ways to win the drug war,tbe answer was that although these ideas could have an impact on drug abuse,they didnot create jobs. We wouldn't need all the law enforcement and judiciary. The truth,and as usual,it is related to money. We abolished the alcohol tax.An greatly needed source of revenue in our founderin econom used to help support substance abuse programs. g Y,part of which was And now a methadone clinic for profit? They say it is people with families who need this; regular people who live regular lives. I have met two of these "regular" people in Salem,they are not using methadone to get off of heroin. They have been living on methadone for years, at the taxpayers' expense. When will the negative capitalizing stop? Haven't the feudal money loving misery mongers profited on the misery of others long enough? Isn't it time to say NO to profiteering at the expense of those who can least afford it? The most deadly sin of the seven deadly sins is greed. Creed is the mother of all sin. Page 1 t ll t t rv...d .....e...ww. �:1...+.we.,e�...a�h._...>}.._va_.,rX....+.a.W...a uiwiv�(.Y:tw r..m..awv.+.. ...Wa...4.:.•.. �„�, _. Natalie Barker 2 Cavendish Cir nen Salem,MA 01970 CEPC )oi ��►.�,�-�.� C�l�!�. cl�,,,� �- Chi: �' (I�ll�{ � s 44� Danielle McKnight From: EGriffin Sent: Thursday, November 04, 2010 7:33 AM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: RE: former Hillcrest site Hold the presses......I have the plans, SFD will need access thru the proposed "crash gate",. ., a key, or code, (in the k'nox box) for the lock will Work.....posted no parking signs along the sides of the building without marked spaces.._ .. Thanks for your patience Erin -----Original Message----- From: Danielle McKnight Sent: Wednesday, November 03, 2010 9:55 AM To: EGriffin Subject: RE: former Hillcrest site Hi - which site is that? I'll know it by the arldress...I'm not familiar with the Hillcrest history. Thanks, Danielle Danielle McKnight Staff Planner Department of Planning and Community Development City Hall Annex 120 Washington Street Salem, MA 01970 (978) 619-5685 dmcknightn salem.com <mailtodrnr knidht('Dsalem.com> From: EGriffin Sent: Tuesday, November 02, 2010 8:21 AM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: former Hillcrest site Danielle, I've scoured the office and have not found the propsosed devlopment plan for this site.... do you have another copy, or if it's easier I can meet you at your office and review the plans that you have......let me know what works best for you.... Thanks Erin t MO' R, 11assachusetLs Oltgani ationJhr,ldt iction Recovery 30 Winter St., 3rd Floor, Boston, INIA 02108 Poll Free: 1-877-423-HOAR or 617-423-6627 Fax 617-423-6626 '� Online: www.tnoar-recovery ore E-Mail: IViOARfran(a`aol com SPEAKING OUT FOR ADDICTION RECOVERY! 1 �� 2110;t R i a statewide collective contvoice educating organization activating its mission to organize recovering individuals,fcunilies, and friends into acal/ective voice edccc ating rhe public•about the value of recoveryfrom alcohol and l other addic•ti\ns. iVe envision a society where addiction is treated as a.significant public health issue and recovery is recognized as valuable to our communities. We collaborate with allied organizations to improve prevention, treatment, and recovery support services. o Massachusetts ranks among the top 5%o states for alcohol and ch-lig use among adults and vouth (NSUDH) o From 1001-2004, the 11A Bureau(01thstance Ahu•se ServicesJitnding was cut by nearly 50%. Now Thanks to The 9 Leadership of Mental Health and Substance Abuse Committee Chairs Representative Li Malia and Senator Jennifer Flanagan; Assistant Majority Leader Senator Tolman;Senate President Therese Murray; House Speaker Robert DeLeo; MA Bureau of Substance Abuse Services with MOAR, NIA Campaign for Addiction Prevention,Treatment,and Recovery;Coalitions; Parent Croups; and You! Your es are Being 1010 MA Bureau of Substance Abuse Services Budget Makes History with Alcohol Tax to Prevent Cuts Now AIOAR Than Ever We Need Unite To Prevent Future Crus, & Protect Our Services S eak Out for Addiction Prevention Treatment and Recove Su art Services to Protect 0 3 Recovery High Schools in Springfield, Boston, and Beverly with graduations 0 2(Worcester 8c Brockton)Statewide Adolescent Crisis Stabilization Units—a 25 bed detox with follow up o New male Highpoint New Bedford rehabilitation unit for men, who are (section 35)civilly committed o Highpoint's Tranquility Inn New Bedford, Women's Section 35, has been at full capacity for over 2 years o More alcohol and other drug education in public schools o Alcohol and other drug screening, treatment referral in 7 hospital emergency rooms and beyond! o Approximately S2.7 million more in long-term, residential,addiction recovery service contracts 0 6 Regional Clinical Support Services, (rehab for post detox or that does not require medical detox) 0 6 Regional Recovery Support Centers with a variety of support services are in the plans o Office of Youth and Young Adult Services with Family involvement o Diversion (residential treatment vs imprisonment) for low level offenders What Still Hurts and What MOAR 3265 Overdose Deaths manifest 2002-2007 and NARCAN s ben g piloted o We to keep people alive & Future policies guided by 2010 O.evcondn Commission, MA Strategic Plan with coalitions to make the follmving a reality o Strategic Prevention Framework Action to address drug overdoses as well as underage drinking o Good Samaritan Campaign to reduce drug overdose deaths by removing barriers to calling 911 o Improved prescription monitoring, Safer storage of prescription medication, Disposal for unused pills o Community, parent and teacher education; family intervention and support; school counseling o Jail Diversion; Rehabilitation vs Recidivism o Increased Access Throughout The Continuum of Caro,..with iMOAR to do in 2010 for 2011........ NIOAR Joins United We Stand feu Public Health to increase Revenues and Protect Ail Public Health Services, MCAS, ViA Coalition for Addiction Services, and Carttpaign for:addiction Prevention. Treatment, and Recovery. The Campaign is a united voice seeking protection and enhancement of substance abuse tax services with a budget proposal succeeded in repealing the state exemption on the sale of alcohol products sold in stores. We want to keep the Alcohol Sales Tax and dedicate finding for necessary substance abuse services You can Help-See How I"ducale Ymu elected legislaurs shout the imporCmce ul'sm ices fiir your timiily. eunnumity. and you. " Let Ihem know the alcohol sales lox is helping maintain services and needs to be dedicated tlsr substance abuse services. Page I of I Danielle McKnight From: CharC [char_cl@yahoo.comj Sent: Thursday, September 16, 2010 5:09 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Proposed meth clinic on Highland Ave Hello, I'm a resident of Green Dolphin Village Condominium behind the Shaws Plaza in Salem. I'nn writing to request that you pass this email on to Chairman Robin Stein as I was unable to attend the recent meeting of 9/15. I am OPPOSED to the proposed methadone clinic on Flighland Ave. I'm deeply disturbed that this area of Salem has yet another quality of life battle to tight as we continue to tight the expansion of the Transfer station. I am an original owner at Green Dolphin Village, having lived here 10 years now. It's incredibly sad and disappointing to see the area go down the dumps so rapidly since I first moved here 2000. On a daily basis I drive by the Shaws/Home Depot plaza only to find more and more out of work imigrants haning around the Shaws parking lot soliciting themselves for work. I basically can no longer shop at Market Basket because the primary first spoken language is now Spanish NOT English. And I constantly have to remind myself that my address is in fact located in the United States of America. Now we can look forward to the 'low' end version of Marshall's, AJ Wright, moving into the Shaws plaza as well. I've traveled all around the world and never'expected' that the areas I visit become my culture or ethnenticity, and I'm appauled that we are being expected to here more and more. A Drug Clinic just around the corner from these already downward spiraling areas will only add to the decline and safety of our neighborhoods. Not to mention our plumeting property values not only due to the economy but also due to the proposed expantion of the Transfer Station! When is it going to stop'? As a nearby property owner to Highland Ave and Tax Payer of Salem, I urge you to reconsider the damming effects this clinic will have on an already declining area/neighborhood. Sincerely, Charlene C Green Dolphin Village Property Owner 9/17/2010 4 Red Jacket Lane Salem, MA 01970 RW EC I V September 16, 2010 SEP 20 2010 DEPT. OF PIANNING& COMMON[)IGcVEWP. Ms. Stein, My name is Lance Sobelman and I live at 4 Red Jacket Lane in Salem. I attended last night's zoning board meeting and only knew a little about the planned methadone clinic prior to the meeting. I grew up in Swampscott and two years ago bought a townhouse in Salem right before I got married to my wife. My wife and I are planning on having children in the near future and when I told my wife about last night's meeting she became scared of the possibility of living so close to the proposed clinic. She told me that if the clinic is approved she wants to put our house on the market immediately as this would not be the type of neighborhood she would feel comfortable raising a family. I could not agree with her more. We love where we live right now. We brag to our friends and family how great it is to live so close to the beaches, supermarkets, a Home Depot, our bank, and even Wal-Mart as it's so convenient for us. I would no longer be able to brag about how great it is living in our neighborhood is a methadone clinic was permitted less than a half-mile down the road. As mentioned at the meeting last night, traffic would be increased on I" Street and as well in the Trader's Way shopping Center area. Needless to say, the individuals frequenting this clinic would not be the type I would feel comfortable having around my neighborhood seven days a week especially since my wife works from home and will hopefully be raising our children there as well. I went by the clinic in Peabody this morning and it was a total zoo from a traffic and parking perspective. You and your fellow Board members should make an unannounced surprise visit and witness the congestion and overflow for yourself. Please reject this application for a permit because my wife and I do not want to leave the home we love and will do so if this site for the clinic is approved. S Lance Sobelm Page I of I Danielle McKnight From: Ivy Ringhoff[IRinghoff@heartsonfire.com] Sent: Wednesday, September 15, 2010 3:35 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: VOTE NO ON METH CLINIC Good afternoon, Please forward to Chairman Robin Stein: It has come to my attention that there could potentially be a methadone Clinic moving into the vacant Chevy Hillcrest site on Highland Ave. PLEASE do no let this happen! I live on Valley Street and take the MBTA bus to work in Boston every day, and believe I would be very affected by this- it is my neighborhood! Please Vote against this!!! Warm Regards, Ivy Ringhoff Hearts On Fire p: 617-912-53 f: 617-204-4491 u c�huffl�Dhe�rtsonhre com r 9/16/2010 Pagc I ut I Danielle McKnight From: Melissa Dumont (wildcatht2@yahoo.comj Sent: Wednesday. September 15, 2010 1:52 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Opposition to Meth Clinic on Highland Avenue Hello, Ms. McKnight. If you would be so kind as to pass a copy of this email along to Chairman Robin Stein, I would greatly appreciate it. Thank you. Dear Chairman Stein: I wholeheartedly oppose a methadone clinic at the Hillcrest Chevrolet site on Highland Avenue. Bringing this type of clientele to Salem will be a very bad decision. Not only are there schools in the area, but it is someone's neighborhood. Would youlike a meth clinic in your neighborhood? I really don't think that you would. People who need methadone should be getting help from a rehabilitation center and not be handed a free high. I can think of thousands of other ways to help people with our taxes instead of giving someone the okay to get high, and especially in my neighborhood. It's completely unacceptable. There is already too much crime in our city and surrounding cities, so please do not add to the problems. We should making our community better and not worse. Thank you for your time. Melissa Dumont P;ige I oh I Danielle McKnight From: john irving UohnirvingI@earlhlink.net] Sent: Wednesday, September 15, 2010 2:10 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: I oppose the clinic Dear Mr. McKnight. Please pass this email to Mr. Robin Stein. I oppose the Methadone clinic, anywhere near the area I live in, the commerce of the area will be affected long term, and as such the quality of the area overall, this is a negative move in growth for this or any area, these clinics should be set in areas that are outside mainstream, an Industrial park perhaps, on a bus route that is reachable, but not in the vicinity of schools and homes, I for one can tell you if there had have been a methadone clinic where it is being proposed, I WOULD not have bought the property I did in 2008. A consideration was the tone of the area and future development in a positive way, not this.....please find a suitable area to treat these unfortunate human beings, do not inflict their mistakes on use!. Keep it out of Salem please. Thank John.lrving 18 Verdon Street Salem MA 01970 9!16/20 10 Danielle McKnight From: melissainnes@comcast.net Sent: Tuesday, September 14, 2010 1:12 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Hillcrest chevy Good afternoon, As a mother of 14 month old twins and a resident of Salem I would like to state that I am against the proposed methadone clinic to go into Hillcrest Chevy on Highland ave. I understand that patients have a right to treatment but at what cost. In this economy, businesses are struggling. The suggested site would prevent many residents from shopping at the local stores on Highland Ave. I am concerned about the safety of my family and property, as I reside at Hawthorne Commons. My husband and myself are unable to attend ,the meetinh tomorrow evening. Please consider this email as our voice as Salem residence. Thank you for your time. Regards, Melissa & Robert Innes Sent from my Verizon Wireless alackBerry Danielle McKnight From: gstrekalov[gstrekalov@mos.orgj Sent: Tuesday, September 14, 2010 7:28 PM To: Danielle McKnight Dear Board of Appeals, I live with my wife and daughter in Hawthorne Commons, 205 Highland ave. unit 3202, Salem, MA 01970. I am strongly opposing the plan to open a methadone clinic in our neighborhood. I don' t want to compromise the safety of my wife and daughter around this clinic. We have a lot of children in our community who deserve to be raised in a safe and friendly environment. Please share my *strong opposition* with the community, since I am not able to attend the meeting. Sincerely yours, Gennady Strekalov l Page I of I Danielle McKnight From: john irving Uohnirvingl@earthlink.netj Sent: Monday, September 13, 2010 8:37 AM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Clinic Dear Mr. McKnight. I whole heartedly oppose the Methadone Clinic site, this will bring the tone of the whole area down, and stunt any further improvements that are taking place in the area, the new shops etc over the last couple of years has improved the area and commerce on Highland Ave, this will be a big step backwards. A methadone clinic does not belong in an area where young people are schooled. Along with the proposed Garbage site expansion, that also does not belong in a residential area. Perhaps the Clinic should be sited further South, the further the better for Salem, there are shops and gas stations in Lynn selling drug items such as, Precision scales, necklace's of imitation crack rocks, bongs large and small. Put the clinics in the communities that encourage and profit from this detestable human weakness, do not export the consequences to other communities, certainly not anywhere near a School or Residential area. Yours Sincerely John.lrving 91;13/2OI0 Page I of I Danielle McKnight From: Frank Ryan [fnryan@comcast.net] Sent: Monday, September 13, 2010 12:48 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: meth clinic Please pass along to Chairman Stein my request that the Board NOT approve a Methadone clinic so near to my home, either now or in the future. I live at 70 Whalers Lane in Salem. Thank you. Frank Ryan 9/14/2010 Pagel of I Danielle McKnight From: s5t@comcast.net Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 11:13 AM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Clinic! To: Ms. McKnight Please tell chairman Robin Stein not to approve clinic on Highland Ave.. Kids that go to school are expose to enough that is around them. Children who are young and do not understand are going to ask questions of why people are hanging out on the street and around the clinic. Living around a garbage dump is enough now this. Please Chairman Robin Stein do not approve of the clinic!!!!! Sincerely, Suzanna Turyn s5tgcomcast net Ali 13i?01 U ti P;i�u I of I V I Danielle McKnight From: Frank Morrill [f.morrill@comcast.net] Sent: Sunday, September 12, 2010 7:37 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: usnic I...and all of my neighbors here in Mariner Village...are 100 percent opposed to a drug school in our neighborhood. If you have a vote....vote it down...or...send these comments to the party involved.....who has the vote. This guy who wants to put this place in amongst us....where is he from ? Has to be a lot of money in it...for him. � I3 'Ulu September 10, 2010 i Many Reasons for rejecting the proposed site for a Regional Methadone Center As a concerned health professional, parent and Salem tax payer, I urge the City of Salem Zoning Board of Appeals to deny a Special Permit as requested by Community Health Care, Inc. (CHC, Inc) for the proposed operation of a regionalized methadone center at the former Hillcrest automobile dealership at 207 Highland Ave. for many reasons. Salem High School, Farrell Court, Piquoit Highland Apartments and Hawthorne Commons Apartments are within 1000 ft. of the proposed methadone center. Clearly a thickly populated area and more populated than the Canal St. site. From a Public Health perspective in the fight to curb childhood obesity, this site would be another barrier for pre-teens and teens to walk to Salem High and the Middle School, as they would have to walk by the regional methadone clinic or by the patients waiting at the bits stop. Politics aside, Salem continues to be without a permanent credentialed Health Agent, who could review specific data on this issue and render a professional opinion. In conjunction with the Salem Police, she/he then could monitor the site for safety of the public's health. There is a conflict of interest in a "for-profit methadone clinic". Companies profit from the unfortunate people attending these clinics. Methadone is supposed to be short-term transitional drug. There is no incentive for these companies to get people weaned off methadone. This type of medical clinic should be held at Salem Hospital for those 100 or so Salem residents who require treatment. "if you provide it they will come". CHC, Inc stated at the last proposed site that 100 Salem residents attend Peabody's methadone clinic daily. If this Highland Ave. facility was to treat Salem residents only t would be in full support knowing the need for such treatment centers, however 300-'? patients per day will be overwhelming to these neighborhoods. This would result in an undue concentration of medicated people and car traffic in the Ward 3 & 4 neighborhoods. Neighborhood safety and security should be first and foremost. As you know in Ward 3 a regional transfer station was approved a short distance from this proposed regional methadone clinic location which will be transporting garbage in 30 large trucks (10-30 ton trucks) daily in Wards 3-4. Up the street a little further in Ward 4 is the proposed Lowes & Wal-Mart project which is predicted to bring an additional 2000 cars per day onto Highland Ave. And there are several fully permitted residential developments that are not built yet in Wards 3 & 4. The demographic profile of Salem in 2007 is that of a medium-lower income status (household median incomes of less than $52,701). Community injustices can be considered to occur when a community— regardless of their racial, ethnic, and/or class-based demographic profile— is very burdened by the presence To whom it may concern, I am writing in regards to the potential methadone clinic being located at the former Hillcrest Chevrolet building. I plan on attending the public hearing on September 15, 2010 to express my grave concern about locating the clinic at this site. There are many students, especially high school and middle school that walk past that site every morning. By locating a methadone clinic at this spot, they would be putting children's safety at risk. How can anyone seriously consider this an appropriate site located right next to a high school? This is also next to a very busy grocery store that services a high degree of elderly people. I believe it is going to increase our crime rate, and I also believe it will increase automobile accidents on this already very busy stretch of road. If you look at the treatment process- how they use methadone - the high risk of death, the addictiveness of it based on research, it's as hard - actually harder to get off it then Heroin. Your basically trading one drug for another. I don't think we need that here. Neighborhood safety and security should come first and foremost. I look forward to hearing back from you with your views on this issue. I am very upset and concerned for the well being of our neighborhoods and for the safety of the children of Salem. Thank you, Louis Zukowski 29 Mooney Rd I'a�c I ul- 1 Danielle McKnight From: Frank Morrill tf.morrill n comcastmet) Sent: Friday, September 10, 2010 7:28 PM To: Danielle VICKnight Subject: Fw: druggies...... Please do. -see note below ----- Original Message----- From To: 'F rutk Morrill' Sent: Friday, September 10, 2010 5:55 PM Subject: RE: druggies...... r I ilr� ill 'CI In VOfe on ill �• I- ll rI !1(1r,)f'`i11 IU ,�IJ:Jl.L11 I .''i i;lll r(l{I 111:1], Wilf1[ tU >(?fl(.I ilf' 1( 1L;1� i)OE1r'll, 11 �� I,tiIP NI( hrliN li, dmcknight Salem Com. rind 1 rl yOUI t7n1f7:('lll , (u (-halt!11 fil i�piilYl .`)CCirl. w111 I)l-' d[te11 CI111G lol' Wednio{iLl�/, jri.I)i( it I) !I IIt h "1(. '(</I IfI 0P110'il[irrll i IIOU 11 rl Cli l .I 1it:. li _ ':;.9t Ir irl,J i':. .• 1. ...( �... .....-. I From: Frank Morrill [mailto:f.morrill@Conicast.not] Sent: Friday, September 10, 2010 5:09 PM To: ]call. Lovely@Verizon.net Subject: druggies...... Joan....please....do not vote for a drug place at Hillcrest....there is plenty of room for it at the end of your street. If I were a resident of one of those apartments....across and behind...I would go ballistic. How about Salem Willows ? Only fooling.....but...we do not need a druggie re nab here in Salem. Thr druggies got to where they are on their Own....let them kick it on their own ...now. 9.'1 .1."()I I I i 7 Danielle McKnight From: Frank Morrill tf.morrill@comcast.netj Sent: Friday, September 10, 2010 7:26 PM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: usrnc Miss...or....Madam................took carefully at the location of the proposed drug clinic....apartments across and in back of Hillcrest now. I live about a half mile from there...and....we DO NOT WANT the place located in a residential area. And so close to schools ..also. And just down the street from the high rise...with a lot of kids living there. Again....WE DO NOT WANT IT HERE...or.....anywhere in Salem. Thank you for your NO VOTE...........................semper fi...... 010 • 9 SALEM SCHOOL DEPARTMENT BUS SCHEDULE 2010-2011 A.M. BUS NO. 1 A.M. BUS NO. RUN #1-SALEM A.M. BUS NO:3 RUN #I-SALEM HIGH-6:40 A.M: RUN#1-HORACE MANN/ HIGH-6:40 A.M. 6:35 Jefferson cc Read St 6:40 Tremont St @ School St6:37 Jefferson Preston Rd SALTONSTALL-6:40AM 6:42 Highland St @ Cushin St 6:40 Loring Ave @ Station Rd 9 6:40 (S Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest 6:41 Loring Ave Harrison Rd 6:43 North St @ Symonds St 6:44 Loring Towers 6:44 Ome St @ Larchmont Rd6:46 Loring Ave @Lincoln Rd 6:42 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest (S 6:46 Dearborn St @ Lee St 6:52 Loring Ave @ Rainbow 6:43 Loring Towers 6:47 Dearborn St @ Upham St 6:54 Lafayette St @ Clifton 6:45 First t Traders Wcry 6:49 Mason St @ Buffum St 6:56 Lafayette St @ Ocean Ave 6:46 PequoHighlands 6:51 Mason St @Tremont St 6:57 Lafayette St @ Leach St 6:48 73 Marlborough Road 49 6:53 Boston St @ Grove St 6:58 Lafayette St @Leavitt St. 6:50 Marlborough Rd @ Vista Av Scenic 6:55 Boston St. @ Hanson 7:05 Drop SAL E/NHIGH SCHOOL 6:520 Gallow's Marlboro Hill g Circle Hill 6:56 Proctor St at Mansell Prkwy RUN#2 WITCHCRAFT! 7:00 Essex St @ May Street BOWDITCH- 7:10 A.M. 6:586:55 Ord St S Butler St 7:10 Drop SALEM HIGHSCHOOL 7:l5Broad @ Hawthorne St 7:00 Boston St @Rawlins St RUN#2 COLLINS MIDDLE 7:18 Broad St c Summer St 7:00 Boston St @ Mansell SCHOOL.7:12.A.M. �' 7:03 Proctor St @Mansell Parkwa 7:08 Highland Avec Thomas Cir 7:23 Derby St @English St 7:05 Proctor St @D Highland Ave @' S Essex St @Bentley St. 7:12 Ravenna @ 7:06 Essex St @ Botts Court Barcelona 7:26 Washington Square East c� 7:14 Ravenna @Madeline Forester 7:06 North St @ Lynde St 7:15 Old Village Drive @ Indian Hill 7:28 Essex St @Webb St 7:07 North St @ Foster St 7:l8 Barnes Rd @Barnes Cir 7:30 Bridge St @ Arbella 7.08 North St @ Dearborn 7:20 Barnes Rd @ Clark St7:09 Dearborn St @ Lee 7:31 Bridge St @ Osgood St 7:21 Clark St @Clark Ave g 7:l 1 Dearborn St @ Felt 7:33 Bridge St @ Thorndike St 7:13 North St @ Garden Ter 7:22 Pequot Highlands 7:34 Bridge St @ March St 7:25 Marlborough @Orleans 7:36 Bridge St @ Conant St 7:14 Oakland @Balcomb (Salts) (Turn fn) 7:15 Balcomb St @ School St 7:l6 Mason St @ Barstow mBroad 7:40 Broad St @Summer 7:27 Marlborough @ Verdon 7:42 Bd St c O (Come Out) @ pp Hawthorne St 7:17 Mason @ Oak 7:28 Marlborough Rd @ Greenlawn 7.44 Proctor St @ Pope St 7:20 Jefferson @ Ocean Ave West :48 Proctor St @ Highland Ave 7:22 Jefferson Ave @ Arthur St 7:29 Marlboro Rd @ Outlook :50 highland Ave cr) Almeda 7:25 Jefferson @ Preston 7:33 Marlboro Rd @ Sable Rd 7:53 Drop BOWDITCHSCHOOL 7.30 Drop MORA CE LIA(VVts) 7:34 Rockdale (tb Belleview 8:05 Drop WITCHCR4FT 7:35 Ord St @ Shillaber StHE/GHTSSCHOOL SCHOOL 7:38 Boston St @ Hanson St 7:33 Lafayette St. @ Raymond 7:41 Boston @ May (2 Bowditch) 7735 Drop SALTONST,4LL 7146 Drop�COLLItVS MIDDLE SCHOOL SCHOOL RUN #2 WITCHCRAFT SCHOOL RUN#3 BOWDITCH SCHOOL CARLTON 7:37 A.M: 7:50 A.M 7:39 Congress St @ Palmer St 7:52 Congress St @ Palmer St 7:40 Congress St @ Harbor St 7:54 Congress St @ Harbor St 7:43 Derby St @ Central St 8:00 .Jefferson Ave @ Winthrop 7:45Bridge St @ Oliver St 8:08 Drop BOWDITCH SCHOOL 7:50 Drop C,ERL TO/V SCHOOL 7:52 Bridge St @ Northey St 7:55 Essex St (r,) May St 7:57 Valley St @ Cherry Ilill Ave 7:59 Valley St ct) Parlee Salam scnooL oepartment 8:05 Drop WITCHCR,I FT - 1 - 8/27/10 SALEM SCHOOL DEPARTMENT BUS SCHEDULE 2010-2011 A.M. BUS NO. 7 A. M. BUS NO. 8 A.M. BUS NO. 9 RUN #l-HORACE MANN/ RUN #I RUN#1 BENTLEY/ BENTLEY/CARLTON 6:45A.M. BENTLEY/SALTONSTALL/ BATES SCHOOL-6:40 A.M. 6:49 Boston St @ Federal St HORACE MANN SCHOOL-6:40 6:40 Jefferson @ Ocean Ave We: 6:51 Ord St @b Butler St A.M1 6:41 Jefferson Ave @ Arthur St 6:53 Essex St @ May St 6:41 Essex St c Ma St 6:57 Broad St 02. Summer St y 6:42 Jefferson Ave @Story St 6:42 Proctor St @ Highland Ave 6:43 Jefferson Ave @ Preston Rd 6:58 Lafayette @ Dodge 6:44 Proctor St @ Mansell Parkway 6:45Rainbow Terrace@ Raymonc 7:00 Jefferson Ave @ Laurent St 6:46 Boston c Watson 7:08 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest Ave 6:48 Aborn @Ord 6:47 Loring Ave @Broadway 6:50 Loring Ave @Station Road 7:10 Loring Ave @ Loring Hills Ave. 6:50 #139 Marlboro Road 7:15 Loring Towers 6:51 Loring Ave @ Harrison Rd 6:52 Dibiase St @ Buena Vista 6:52 Loring Ave @ Oakview Ave 7:25 Raymond Rd @ Rainbow Ter 6:54 286 Highland Ave 6:53 Loring Ave @ Cedarest 7:28 Lafayette @ Rainbow Ter 6:59 Barnes c Barnes 7.30 DropMORA AIANN @ 6:55 Loring Towers 7:00 Clark St @Barnes 6:58 Loring Ave @Chandler SCHOOL 7:05 Pequot Highlands 7:02 Cleveland Rd @ Grant Rd 7:31 Lafayette St @ Leach St 7:12 Bridge St @ Carpenter 7:07 Jefferson @ Parallel 7:34 Mill Hill 7:15 Bridge St @ Lemon St 7:08 Jefferson Ave @ Wheatland S 7:38 Congress St @ Palmer St 7:17 Bridge St @ Conant St 7:09 Jefferson Opp Francis 7:40 Congress St @ Harbor St 7:28 Bridge St. @ Osgood 7:10 Broad St @ Orne Sq 7:42 Essex St @ Bentley St 7:20 Drop BENTLEYSCHOOL 7:1 l Broad St @ Summer St 7:44 Drop Bentley School 7:24 Columbus Ave c Bayview 7:45 Webb St c Bridge St @ y 7:21 Derby @Union St @ S 7:25 Essex St @ Webb St 7:23 Derby St @ Daniels St 7:46 Drop CARLTON SCHOOL 7:30 Congress St @ Harbor St 7:25 Derby St @ Webb St 7:32 Mill Hill 7.•28 Drop BENTLEYSCHOOL 7:30 Leavitt St @ Prince St 7:32 Columbus @ Bayview 7.40 Drop SAL TONSTALL 7:36 Bridge St @ Conant St 7:45 Hazel St @ Ocean Ave 7:38 North St @ Dearborn St 7.47 Drop MORA CE MANN 7.•40 Drop BATES SCHOOL SCHOOL RUN#2 COLLINS MIDDLE RUN #2 SALEM ACADEMY SCHOOL-7:40 A.M. CHARTER SCHOOL7i50 A.M 7:44 Felt St @ Claremont 7:50 Jefferson Ave @ Cloutman St 7:45 Dearborn St @ Orchard St 7:59 Loring Towers 7:46 Dearborn St @ Upham St 8:05 Loring Ave @ Rainbow Ter 7:48 North St @ Stodder Place 8:15 Drop SALEAl ACADEAlY 7:50 North St @ Garden Ter CHARTER SCHOOL —r:53 Highland St @ Cushing St 7:55 School St @ Barstow St 7:58 Mason St @ Buft un St 7:59 Boston St @ Grove 8:00 Flint St @ Federal St 8:05 Drop COLLLVS AIIDDLE SCHOOL .Salem School Department _ J 0/27/(0 SALEM SCHOOL DEPARTMENT BUS SCHEDULE 2010-2011 P.M. BUS NO. t P.M. BUS NO. 2 RUN #I-BENTLEY RUN #l-BENTLEY SCHOOL-1:50 P.M. SCHOOL-1:50 P.MI P.M. BUS NO.3 1:50 Pick-Up BENTLEYSCHOOL 1:45 Pick-Up BEN ' P M #1-BATES SCHOOL-1:50 I:52 Webb St @ Collins St f:50 Lafayette St cr) Dodge St L•53 Bridge St @Conant St y �' b 1:50 Pick-Up Bates I:51 Lafayette St @ Leavitt St 1:53 North St at Dearbom St 154 Bridge St @ Lemon St 1:53 Congress St @ Palmer St L•55 North St @ Foster St I:54 North St g, Mason Street L•55 Congress St @ Harbor St 1.56 Essex St c O 1.56 North St @ Dearborn St 2:00 Boston St Federal St @ Opposite Botts 1:57 North St c Garden Ter ° 1:58 Broad St @Phelps @ 2:05 Abom @ Ord 1:59 Oakland St @ Balcomb St 2:10 Ord St @ Butler St 2:00 Broad St at Summer St 2:01 Balcomb @ School St RUN#2 WITCHCRAFT 2:03 Lafayette St @ Dodge St. 2:04 Mason @ Barstow SCHOOL 2t25.P.M1 (Point Day Care) 2:06 Mason @ Tremont -Ia5 Pick-UP IV/TCHCRAFT 2:05 Mill Hill 2:08 Mason St Opposite Flint St 2:30 139 Marlboro Road 2:06 Lafayette St. t. Hancock 2:09 Flint St @ Federal St 2:08 Ocean Ave St. @Holly St c Watson St 2:31 73 Marlboro Rd 2:IO Ocean Ave @Hazel 2:10 Boston St @ 2:33 Marlboro Rd @ Verdon St 2:14 Congress St @ Palmer St 2:14 Butler St. @ Nichols St. 2:34 Marlboro Rd @ Orleans Ave 2:15 Congress St @ Harbor St 2:16 Essex St @ May St 2:35 Barcelona @i c Savona 2:17 Boys and Girls Club 2:19 Broad @ Summer 2:36 Barcelona @Ravenna Ave RUN #2 BOWD[TC[t 2:37 Barcelona c Madeline 2:18 Derby St @ Webb St SCHOOL 2c21 P,M 2:38 Ravenna Ave @ Pyburn Ave nSt 2:20 Columbus @ Bayview 2:21 Pick-Up BOWDITCH 2:41 Barnes Rd Bames Cir 2:24 Webb St @Coll SCHOOL c' 2:25 Bridge St @ Conant St 2:42 Barnes Rd @ Clark St RUN#2 CARLTON SCHOOL 2:23 Broad St @ Winthrop 2:43 Clark St @ Clark Ave 2:24 Jefferson Ave @ Winthrop 2:48 Pequot Highlands 2:30 Pick-Up St WashiRL ngton NS Squar 2:25 Proctor St @ Ifighland Ave RUN#3 COLLINS MIDDLE 2:36 Essex s @Washington Squar 2:26 Proctor St @ Pope St SCHOOL 2:50 P.M' 2:38 Congress St @Harbor 2:28 Tremont @ Grove 2:50 Pick-Up COLLINS/6IIDDLE 2'42 Congress St @ Palmer 2:30 Mason St @ Buffum St 2:55 Lafayette St @Leavitt St 2:45 Lafayette St @ Holly (Leach) 2:32 Mason St @ Tremont St 2:58 Congress St @Palmer St 2:55 Loring Ave @ Station Rd 2:49 Loring @ Rainbow Ter 2:35 Boston @ Grove 3:00 Congress St @ Harbor St. 3:05 Loring Ave @ Carol Way 2:38 Boston St @ Watson St Run #4 SALTONSTALL 2:40 Ord St totButler St @ 3:05 3:10 Loring Towers 2:42 Ord St @ Shilaber St 3:05 Pick-Up Sa1[oirstal! 3:13 Loring Ave @ Chandler 3:12 Congress St St 2:44 Belleview Ave @ Carollton 3:15 Congress St @ Halrbor St. 3:19 Jefferson Ave @opposite Rea. 2:48 Circle Hill Rd @ Rockdale Ave 3:20 Lafayette St to. Derby St 2:49 Marlboro Rd Opposite Scenic 3:25 Fort Ave @ Winter Island Rd 2:50 Marlboro Rd @ Orleans Ave 3:28 Columbus @ Bayview 2:55 Highland Ave @ Thomas Circle 3:33 Fort Ave @ Memorial 2:58 Ravenna Ave @ Madeline Ave 3:35 Webb St @ E. Collins 3:03 Barnes @ Clark Ave 3:37 E Collins @ Opposite Beacon 3:45 Jefferson @ Preston (Salts) 3:47 Loring Ave @ Station Rd 3:49 Loring Ave @ Harrison Rd 3:50 Loring Towers Salem School Department 5 8/27/10 SALEM SCHOOL DEPARTMENT BUS SCHEDULE 2010-2011 P.MI. BUS NO. 7 RUN#1-I(ORACE MANN P.N1. BUS NO. 8 RUN#4 SALEM ACADEMY SCHOOL-2:05.P.MJ RUN #I-HORACE MANN CHARTER'SCHOOL-4:05 P.M 2:05 Pick-Up HORACE MANN SCHOOL-2:05P.tMi' SALTONSTALL LATE BUS SCHOOL 2:05 Pick-Up MORA CE/MANN 4:10P.M Drop area-Lafayette St- 2:09 Canal @ Meadow 2:08 Loring Ave @ Moffatt Rd Loring le Ave Highland.Ave 2:12 Mill Hill 2:10 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest Witchcraft: 2:13 Leavitt @ Harrison 2:12 Loring Ave @ Loring Hills 4:05 Pick-Up SALEAI ACADE/V, 2:14 Congress St @ Palmer St 2:15 Loring Towers CHARTER SCHOOL 2:15 Congress St @ Harbor St 2:18 First St @ Traders Way 4:10 Pick-Up Saltonstall 2:17 Lafayette St @ Derby St 2:20 Pequot Highlands 4:13 Lafayette St @ Laurel St 2:20 Webb St @ Bridge St 2:23 Marlborough Rd @ Scenic 4:15 Lafayette St @ Ocean Ave RUN#2 CARLTON RUN #2 WITCHCRAFT 4:17 Loring Ave @ Rainbow Ter SCHOOL`2:25 P.Md SCHOOL 2;25 P.M4:20 Loring Ave @ Moffatt Rd 2:25 Pick-Up CARLTON SCHOOL 2:25 Pick-Up WITCHCRAFT 4:22 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest 2:35 Boys and Girls Club SCHOOL 4:24 Loring Ave @ Loring Hills 2:45 Jefferson @ Margin 2:28 Summit @ Crescent Dr 4:25 Loring Towers 2:47 Jefferson @ Winthrop 2:30 Proctor St @ Pope Street 4:30 First St @ Traders Way 2:48 Jefferson @ Ocean Ave West 2:33 Highland @ Proctor(HM) 4:33 Pequot Highlands 2:49 275 Jefferson Ave 2:38 Congress St @ Palmer St 4:35 Clarke St @ Clark Ave 2:51 Essex St @ Warren St 2:40 Congress St @ Harbor St 4:40 Marlboro Rd cD Home St 2:53 Boston @ Federal 2:45 Lafayette St @ Dodge St 4:43 Gallows Hill @ Circle Hill 2:54 Boston @ Grove 2:47 Mill Hill 4:45 Belleview Ave @ Brentwood 2:55 Boston @ Rawlins RUN#3 COLLINS MIDDLE 4:47 Puritan Rd @ Pioneer Circle 2:57 Proctor @ Pope St SCHOOL*,'-2:50 P:M 4:48 Ord St @ Bedford 2:59 Proctor @ Highland Ave 2:50 Pick-Up Collins Riddle School 4:50 Ord St @ Shilaber SALTONSTALL@3:05 P.M. 2:55 Boston St @ Nichols St 3:05 Pick-Up SALTONS TALL 2:58 Boston St @ Watson St 3:08 Essex St @ Botts Court 3:00 Mason St(cD Tremont St 3:10 North St @ Lynde St. 3:00 School @ Buffum 3:12 Dearborn St @ Lee Street 3:10 Dearborn @ Upham 3:14 Dearborn St @ Felt St. 3:15 Dearborn St @ Orchard St 3:l5 North St @Garden Ter (Salts) 3:16 Felt St @ Claremont 3:l 7 Oakland @ Balcomb 3:17 North St @ Garden Ter 3:l9 Mason St @ Barstow 3:20 Oakland St @ Balcomb St 3:20 Mason @ Flint 3:25 Flint St @ Federal St 3:23 Proctor St at Pope St 3:25 Proctor St at Highland Ave 3:27 Valley St @ Gallows Hill 3:37 Gallowshill @ Circle Hill 3:28 #73 Marlboro Rd (Salts) 3:30 Barnes @ Clarke St 3:'31 First St. @ Traders Way 3:35 Pequot Highlands (Salts) Salem School Department - 7 - 8/27/10 SALENI SCHOOL DEPARTMENT BUS SCHEDULE 2010-2011 P.M; BUS NO. 12 P.M. BUSNo.B P.IYI. BUS No. 3 RUN #1-SALEM HIGH North Reading Transportation North Reading Transportation SCHOOL-2:05 P.M RUN#4SALEAIACADEMY, Run #3SALEMACADEAlY 2:10 Pick-Up SALEMHIGH Charter School'=4:05P.M., Charter School4:05PM SCHOOL SALTONSTALL LATE BUS SAL TONSTALL SCHOOL LA 2:15 Congress @ Palmer 4:10P.MDrop area-Lafayette St- BUS 4:.10PM 2:17 Lafayette St @ Leach St Loring,4Ge-Highland Ade H itlows-Bridge St-North Salem- 2:18 Lafayette St @ Ocean Ave Witchcraft Boston St areas; 2:22 Loring Ave @ Rainbow Ter 4:05 Pick-Up SALEjV ACADEAIY 4:05 Pick-Up Salem Academy RUN #2 BOWDITCH CHARTER SCHOOL Charter School SCHOOL 2:25 P.M' 4:10 Pick-Up Saltonstall School 4:10Pm Pick-Up Saltonstall Scht, 2:25 Pick-Up BO{YDITCH 4:13 Lafayette St @ Laurel St 4:05 Columbus Ave @ Bay view SCHOOL 4:15 Lafayette St @ Ocean Ave 4:08 Webb St @ East Collins St 2:27 Wilson St @ Champlain 4:17 Loring Ave @ Rainbow Ter 4:10 Bridge St @ Pearl St 2:29 Jefferson Ave a Read St 4:20 Loring Ave @ Moffatt Rd 4:13 North St @ Mason 2:30 Jefferson Ave @ Preston Rd 4:22 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest 4:16 Dearborn St @ Larchmont Rc 2:32 Loring Ave @ Moffatt Rd 4:24 Loring Ave @ Loring Hills 4:19 North St @ Liberty Hill Ave 2:33 Loring Ave @ Harrison Rd 4:25 Loring Towers 4:22 Balcomb St @ Oakland St 2:35 Loring Ave @ Cedarcrest 4:30 Traders way @ First Street 4:24 Balcotmb St @ School St 2:37 Loring Ave @ Carol Way 4:33 Pequot Highlands 4:26 Tremont St @ Grove St 2:40 Loring Towers 4:35 Clarke St @ Clark Ave 4:28 Mason St @ Oak St 2:45 Pequot Highlands 4:40 Marlboro Rd @ Home St 4:30 Federal St @ Flint St 4:43 Gallows Hill Rd @ Circle Hill 4:31 Federal St @ Boston St 4:45 Belleview Ave @ Brentwood 4:33 Ord @ Butler St 4:47 Puritan Rd @ Pioneer Circle 4:35 Proctor @ Pope St 4:48 Ord @ Bedford St 4:37 Proctor St @ Highland Ave 4:50 Ord St @ Shilaber 1 4:39 Jefferson Ave @ Wilson St 4:40 Jefferson Ave @ Ocean Ave *Note: This bus will have to West accommodate late bus students from Saltonstall. */Vote: This bus will have to Stops may change on day-to- accommodate late bus student day basis. from Saltonstall. Stops may change on day-to- day basis. Salem School Department - 9 - 9127110 Chelsea Police Department Page: 1 Sele�tjve Search From: 09/14/2007 Thru: 09/14/2010 0000 - 2359 Printed: 09/14/2010 ForDate: 09/17/2007 - Lfonday Call Number Time Call Reason Action 07-35527 1137 Medical Aid NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4D Abboud, Michael Post: D1 Dunn, Brian - For Date: 09/20/2007 - Friday 07-37062 1146 Disturbance - General BROUGHT TO STATION Location/Address: [CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Noftle, Edward For Date: 10/28/2007 - Stmday 07-41032 0929 Alarm Burglar ALARM ACCIDENTAL/DEFECTI Location/Address: DEP. YOUTH SRRV/SPECTRUM/ENTRY - 175 CRESCENT AVE Apt. #1ST Post: D4B O'Brien, Joanne Post: D4B O'Brien, Joanne Post: D4 Noftle, Edward Post: D4B O'Brien, Joanne For Date: 11/03/2007 - Saturday 07-41832 0842 Alarm Burglar ALARM ACCIDENTAL/DEFECTS Location/Address: [CH 3553 DSS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4A Krasco, William Post: D3 Sanchez, Miguel For Date: 11/05/2007 - Monday 07-42092 1132 Medical Aid REMOVED TO HOSPITAL Location/Address: [CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Rijos, Rafael For Date: 11/06/2007 - Tuesday 07-42205 0708 Disorderly Conduct PEACE RESTORED Location/Address: (CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: L1 Bonita, Eugene Post: L2 Rijos, Rafael For Date: 11/12/2007 - 2donday 07-42986 1112 Alarm Burglar ALARM ACCIDENTAL/DEFECTI Location/Address: (CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 O'Brien, Joanne Post: D4D Gonzalez, Efrain For Date: .11/30/2007 - Friday )7-45355 0811 Trespass / Unwanted Person PERPETRATOR(S) GONE Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D3 Mojica, Sammy Post: D1 Rossetti, Richard or Uate: .L2/04/3007 - Tuesday 7-45954 1713 Alarm Burglar ALARM ACCIDENTAL/DEFECTI r Oli Selective Search From: 09/14/2007 Che Se09 P 20 Oe Department / 0000 - 2359 Printed: 09/14/2010Page• 2 Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT.AVE Post: F3 Capistran, Joseph Post: F12 Rivera, Felix Post: FL7 Betz, David For Date: 02/10/2008 - Sunday 08-5518 1050 Alarm Burglar NO ECESS Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT179 CRESC NT AVE Post: D2 Belanger, Robert Post: D1 Bunk, John Post: D4 Noftle, Edward For Date: 02/18/2008 Monday 08-6560 1041 Alarm Burglar ALARM RESET Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERSS- 175-CRESCENT AVE Post: D4E Marcus, Jason Post: D4D Mojica, Sammy For Date: 03/15/2008 - Saturday 08-10423 VICE 1950 House / euaiaeas Check Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS NO POLICE 7ERCRESCENECESS NT AVE Post: F4B Ortiz, Anthony McCarthy, Paul For Date: 03/24/2008 - Monday 08-11637 0700 Informational MESSAGE/ DELIVERED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 1075 E RES ENT AVE Post: L3A Moschella, Robert For Date: 03/25/2008 - Tuesday 08-11835 0841 Harassment BACK CE Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERSN SER75 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4D Mojica, Sammy Post: DLB Noftle, John Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Location Change: [CH L0000015] CHELSEA POLICE HEADQUARTERS - 19 PARK ST [Modified: 03/25/20080950] Refer To Arrest: 08-457-AR Arrest: BOSSI,--JOSEPH JR Address: 4 SQUIRE RD Apt. #128 REVERE, MA DOB: Charges: ASSAULT WEAPON 'or Date: 03/28/2008 - Friday 8-12378 1537 Investigation Detective ONLY Location/Address: 175 CRESCENT AVE BACK IN SERVICE Post: FDEL3 Delaney, Daniel Or Date: 03/29/2008 - .Saturday 3-12470 0716 Suspicious Person NO Location/Address: -[CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS SUCH PERS CR SACENBE FO T AVE Post: L4F Riley, Jr, Thomas Post: L4E Abboud, Michael Post: L4D Grayson, Bernard Post: L3A O'Brien, Joanne Post: L1 Bonita, Eugene v - ------------ Selective Search From: 09/14/2007 1Th use 9/14o220010e Department men 9 Printed: 09/14/2010 Page: 3 For Date: 03/31/2008 - Monday 08-12772 1007 Arrest Warrant Service Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CE T RS E- 1 5NEGATIVE CR SCENT AVE Post: D4A Vega, Carlos Post: D4D Mojica, Sammy Post: DL8 Noftle, John For Date: 04/02/2008 - Wednesday 08-13069 0930 Weapons / Firearms Violations REPORT TO BE FILED Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D2 Krasco, William Post: D4 Noftle, Edward Post: L4J Torres, Jose Post: DL3 Butler, John Refer To Incident: 08-1521-OF For Date: 04/09/2008 - Wednesday 08-14085 0855 Motor Vehicle Stop ARREST Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: DS2 Tyre, Jr. , Golden Post: D2 Belanger, Robert McLain, Thomas Refer To Arrest: 08-549-AR Arrest: SPERA, LUCIANO Address: 3A LISBON ST MALDEN, MA DOB: Charges: WARRANT MISDEMEANOR DEFAULT - Docket & Chg in Narr UNLICENSED OPERATION OF MV For Date: 04/18/2008 - Friday 08-15484 1057 FIRE- MUTUAL AID BACK N SERVICE Location/Address: (CH 355) COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS 175 CRESCENT AVE Apt. 61 For Date: 04/29/2008 - Tuesday 08-17150 0904 Emotionally Disturbed Persons REPORT TO BE FILED LOcation/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D2 Krasco, William t Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Post: DL8 Noftle, John Refer To Incident: 08-1948-OF ?or Date: 05/21/2008 - Wednesday )8-20507 1342 Medical Aid REPORT FILE Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS TO BE CRESCENT AVE Post: D4E O'Connor, Mark Post: D2 Bunk, John Post: DL8 Noftle, John Post: DS14 Mojica, Sammy Refer To Incident: 08-2312-OF x Date: 05/23/2008 - Friday 3-20778 0710 Disorderly Conduct/PAST NO ARY Location/Address: [CH 355) COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NEC R SCENT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael .Selective search From: Chelsea P Police Department 0000 - 9 Page: 4/ Printed: 09/14/2010 For Date: 08/11/2008 - Monday 08-33649 1119 Trespass / Unwanted Person NO POLICE SERVICE NECESS Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Marcus, Jason Post: D2 Krasco, William For Date: 08/15/2008 - Friday 08-34238 0901 Trespass / Unwanted Person NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Farden, Jason Post: D2 Krasco, William Post: DL8 Noftle, John For Date: 09/01/2008 - Monday 08-36852 0742 Suspicious Person REPORT TO BE FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Refer To Incident: 08-3896-OF For Date: 09/12/2008 - Friday 08-38689 0930 Weapons / Firearms Violations REPORT TO BE FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Refer To Incident: 08-4118-OF 08-38662 1234 Assist Other Agency BACK IN SERVICE Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael For Date: 10/12/2008 - Sunday 08-43165 1034 Trespass / Unwanted Person ARREST Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4B McLain, Thomas Post: D4 Noftle, Edward Refer To Arrest: 08-1868-AR Arrest: AGUILAR, JOSE ISAIAS Address: 379 CRESCENT AVE Apt. 41 CHELSEA, MA DOB: loom Charges: TRESPASS DISORDERLY CONDUCT For Date: 12/10/2008 - Wednesday' )8-51223 2206 Alarm Burglar ALARM ACCIDENTAL/DEFECTS Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: F4B Farden, James Ortiz, Anthony Post: F3 Krasco, William Sanchez, Juan 'or Date: 12/19/2008 - Friday 8-52313 1102 Medical Aid NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: (CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4E Laft, Richard ar Date: 12/2.1/2008 - Wednesday Selective SearchFrom: 09/14/2007TCee uOsePoo lice Department / / 0000 - 2359 Printed: 09/14/2010 Page - 5 08-52946 0900 Assist Other Police Department NO Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 179 CCR SACENT AVE Post: D4D Bunk, John Farden, James Post: DL2 Ostler, Daniel For Date: 01/30/2009 - Friday 09-3973 0849 Suspicious Person NO Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NECESS NT AVE Post: DL8 Noftle, John Post: D2 Moschella, Robert Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Post: DS14 Mojica, Sammy For Date: 02/04/2009 - Wednesday 09-4665 0936 Medical Aid REPORT FILED Location/Address: [CH 3553 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS T017H8 CRESCENT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Post: DL7 Noftle, John Refer To Incident: 09-475-OF 09-4676 1037 Assault (Past) REPORT FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS T01785 CRESCENT AVE Refer To Incident: 09-477-OF For Date: 02/09/2009 - Monday 09-5409 1047 Collision with Motor Vehicle NO Y Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NECESSRESC NT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael For Date: 04/29/2009 - Wednesday 09-17253 1339 Emotionally Disturbed Persons NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D1 Morabito, Michael Post: D4 Sanchez, Juan Post: DS14 Mojica, Sammy For Date: 05/29/2009 - Friday 09-21773 1006 Assist Other Agency REPORT Location/Address: [CH 3871 METHADONE CLINIC - 175 CRESCENT AVEO BE FILED Post: D4E Arsenault, Tracy Post: D2 Belanger, Robert Refer To Incident: 09-2185-OF For Date: 07/15/2009 - Wednesday )9-29434 1012 Alarm Holdup Panic Duress NO Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT 5 C EAR NT AVE Post: D4H Rossetti, Richard Post: 04E Sanchez, Juan Post: D4B Dunn, Brian Post: DL7 Noftle, John Or Date: 07 /21/2009 - Tuesday 9-30495 1412 Alarm Burglar NO Y Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NE ESSACRESC NT AVE Post: D4E Sanchez, Juan Selective Search From: 09/14/20070 Th uS e09/14 20 oe De00000t men 9 Printed: 09/14/2010 Page : y F Post: D4 Arsenault, Tracy f For Date: 07/23/2009 - Thursday 09-30781 1109 Threats BACK Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS N SERVICE- 175 CRESCENT EB ICRESCENT AVE For Date: 08/07/2009 - Friday 09-33328 1339 Disturbance - General REPORT FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS TO BE CRESCENT AVE Post: D3 Arsenault, Tracy Refer To Incident: 09-3283-OF For Date; 08/21/2009 - Friday 09-35548 1334 Medical Aid REPORT FILED Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS TO17B5 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Casucci, Augustus Post: DL7 Noftle, John Refer To Incident: 09-3485-OF For Date: 10/23/2009 - Friday 09-45484 0833 Disturbance - General NO RY Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 17x5 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4B Arsenault, Tracy Post: D4 Marcus, Jason Post: D1 Morabito, Michael For Date: 11/03/2009 - Tuesday 09-47259 1000 FIRE- Master Box Plug Out FIRE - pection Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS A1775 CRESCENTComple AVE For Date: 11/21/2009 - Saturday 09-49819 0847 House / Business Check NO ECESSY Location/Address: (CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 179 CRESCENT AVE Post: D413 Guido, James For Date: 11/28/2009 - Saturday 09-50759 0658 Disturbance - General NO Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NECESSARY5 CRESCENT AVE Post: L2 Rijos, Rafael Post: L4 Ramirez, Emilio For Date: 12/25/2009 - Friday )9-54535 0625 Trespass / Unwanted Person NO Location/Address: (CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 179 CRESCENT AVE Post: L4A Casucci, Augustus Post: L2 Rijos, Rafael or Date: 11./29/2009 - Tuesday 9-55037 1258 Assist Motorist IL ACTIN Location/Address: (CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CETERS D- Cl VS CR SC8 T AVE Post: D42 Marcus, Jason par Se be ct,ive Search From: 09/14/2007 0 Th uS e09/1'4/2010 De 0000t- 2359 3 9 Printed: 09/14/2010 Page : Post: D2 Addonizio, Michael For Date: 01/17/2010 - Sunday 10-2426 0938 Check Person's Well Being Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS PERPETRATOR(S)I5CRESCENT AVE Post: D4 Bunk, John Sweeney, Keith Post: D3 Arsenault, Tracy For Date: 01/24/2010 - Sunday 10-3397 1043 Check Person's Well Being UNFOUNDED Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D2 Belanger, Robert For Date: 03/03/2010 - Wednesday 10-8637 1347 Threats REPORT E FILED Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS -r0175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D2 Addonizio, Michael Gonzalez, Hector Refer To Incident: 10-884-OF For Date: 03/15/2010 - Monday 10-10471 1753 Alarm Burglar Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS RS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: F4D DiGaetano, Roger Post: F38 Camacho, Fernando Post: FK9A Capistran, Joseph For Date: 03/25/2010 - Thursday 10-12073 0909 Restraining Order - Service Location/Address: NO[CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT1718 CRESCENT NT AVE Post: D2 Sweeney, Keith Post: D2 Sweeney, Keith Post: D4B Arsenault, Tracy 10-12157 1821 Alarm Burglar Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT RE CEPECAVE Post: FK9A Noftle, Edward Post: F4G Vega, Carlos For Date: 04/15/2010 - Thursday 10-15504 1118 Check Person's Well Being Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS REPORT NECESS5 CRESCENT AVE Post: DK9C McLain, Thomas Post: D48 Dunn, Brian Post: DL3 Butler, John LO-15505 1122 FIRE- MEDICAL Location/Address: [CH 355] COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS T- TRANSPORTEDCRESCENT AVE Fire Unit: ENG3-Pumper-CHELSEA ENGINE 3 Manned By ID's: 290 295 309 Fire Unit: LAD2-Aerial-CHELSEA LADDER 2 Manned By ID's: 255 315 Post: DW Butler, John or Date: 07/15/2010 - Thurrday I Chelsea Police Department Page: 8 Seleot;_ve Search From: 09/14/2007 Thru: 09/14/2010 0000 - 2359 Printed: 09/14/2010 10-30325 1018 Disturbance - General NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4B Severe, Joseph Post: D3 Gonzalez, Hector For Date: 07/25/2010 - Sunday 10-32005 1012 Assault (Past) REPORT TO BE FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4E Marcus, Jason Post: D3 Gonzalez, Hector Refer To Incident: 10-3220-OF For Date: 08/06/2010 - Friday 10-33891 1110 Parking Violation NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE For Date: 08/20/2010 - Friday 10-36081 0936 Animal Complaint NO POLICE SERVICE NECESS Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE For Date: 08/25/2010 - Wednesday 10-36837 1252 Disturbance - General BACK IN SERVICE Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D3 Gonzalez, Hector For Date: 08/27/2010 - Friday 10-37163 0932 Disturbance - General NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: D4A Bunk, John Post: D4 Stutto, Joseph For Late: 08/31/2010 - Tuesday 10-37697 0718 Malicious/ Wanton Destruction NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTER - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: L4B Left, Richard Post: L4C Ramirez, Emilio For Date: 09/02/2010 - Thursday 10-38110 1127 Larceny REPORT TO BE FILED Location/Address: [CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Refer To Incident: 10-3824-OF For Date: 09/03/2010 - Friday 10-38272 1022 Assist Other Police Department NO REPORT NECESSARY Location/Address: (CH 3551 COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS - 175 CRESCENT AVE Post: DAB Arsenault, Tracy CAI) IncidentScarch Results Page 1 of e. TCAID Incident Search Results ' v6.01.0002 J 93 Search :kgain Go To Sql Statement CAD Search Results Incident# Date/Time Location Incident Type 10052194 09/13/201007:12:55 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL /00447/4 08/27/2010 17:34:44 33 CAROLYN RD ALARM 10045660 08/14/2010 01:22:58 21 CAROLYN RD NOISE 10039107 07/15/2010 07:10:33 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 1.00361.12 07/02/2010 06:45:51 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 10035276 06/28/2010 09:27:54 41 CAROLYN RD MVA ACC 1.0029955 06/04/2010 12:06:11 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 10024973 05/13/2010 09:20:45 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 10019886 04/17/2010 08:42:48 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 1001_t3260 04/09/2010 08:20:30 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 10017013 04/03/2010 10:32:35 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 10015498 03/26/2010 08:55:37 43 CAROLYN RD 911 HANG 1001.2445 03/12/2010 11:14:50 43 CAROLYN RD UN GUEST 10007569 02/12/2010 08:44:30 CAROLYN RD INVEST 1.0007216 02/10/2010 06:13:50 CAROLYN RD SERVE PA 10006717 02/07/2010 13:26:12 43 CAROLYN RDALARM 10002977 01/17/2010 04:13:09 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM IQ002794 01/16/2010 12:00:27 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9075072 12/26/2009 10:00:15 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 9074974 12/25/2009 15:19:31 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9072928 12/14/2009 09:04:45 CAROLYN RD DISTURB 9070650 12/01/2009 21.19:50 33 CAROLYN RD ALARM 90693.49 11/25/2009 07:16:34 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 9068435 11/20/2009 08:45:41 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 9068212 11/19/2009 05:13:24 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 906226_8. 10/20/2009 09:37:52 CAROLYN RD SERVE PA 9059089 10/04/2009 07:53:37 43 CAROLYN RD FIGHT 9051.045 08/27/2009 16:44:48 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9050735 08/26/2009 06:53?2 45 CAROLYN RD MVA ACC 9043169 07/24/2009 04:26:11 33 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9039359 07/07/2009 00:07:54 33 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9037563 06/29/2009 09:11:35 43 CAROLYN RD 911 HANG 9028983 05/23/2009 18:57:33 43 CAROLYN RD ALARiM I N N y http://(Ic(ilyn/QED//cadpartner/cad97/search/srchresultS.Jsp 9/1 i/?0111 CAD Incident Scorch Results Page 2 of 3 a 9024770 05/05/2009 10:04:44 43 CAROLYN RD 911 HANG 0017924 04/03/2009 08:16:46 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 9016392 03/26/2009 13:30:08 41 CAROLYN RD VANDALS 9010216 02/23/2009 17:20:18 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 9009848 02/21/2009 16:41:34 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 0009_627 02/20/2009 13:38:21 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 90047.77 02/16/2009 06:35:22 43 CAROLYN RD UN GUEST 9005589 01/31/2009 16:50:33 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 90.6(8(02. 01/11/200907:15:27 43CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 9000511 01/03/2009 21.25:35 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 3073516 12/28/2008 08:40:36 43 CAROLYN RD THREATS 3073103 12/27/2008 17:05:42 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8078014 12/25/2008 11.15:07 CAROLYN RD OTHER SV 8076.484. 12/17/2008 08:22:48 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL, 8071665 12/02/2008 10:21:24 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 30728 LO 11/27/2008 15:42:37 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8072812 11/27/2008 15:13:32 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8072756 11/27/2008 05:32:10 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM _506971.9_ 11/12/2008 07:21:23 43 CAROLYN RD MEDICAL 8067577 11/01/2008 15:11.52 CAROLYN RD OTHER SV 8057957 09/19/2008 07:08:24 33 CAROLYN RD ALARM 80574.74 09/16/2008 21:03:37 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8055865 09/10/2008 06:06:46 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8044849 07/25/2008 17:10:17 CAROLYN RD CK AREA 8043038 07/18/2008 02:29:45 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 3035758 06/18/2008 10:30:16 43 CAROLYN RD 911 HANG 363.5757 06/18/2008 10:29:17 43 CAROLYN RD 911 HANG 5035147 06/15/2008 22:36:36 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 5032410 06/05/2008 08:06:02 43 CAROLYN RD FIGHT 5(25240 05/05/2008 10:36:18 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 3025236 05/05/2008 10:04:41 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 8023.861. 04/28/2008 22:40:17 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8023233 04/25/2008 21:51:02 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8019038 04/07/2008 05:45:45 42 CAROLYN RD REC PROP 8011449 02/29/2008 10:53:05 CAROLYN RD MV STOP 7066071 10/23/200709:50:19 33 CAROLYN,RD VANDALS 7--65$59 10/22/2007 08:58:05 43 CAROLYN RD ESCORT 7�64815> 10/17/2007 11:27:54 CAROLYN RD CK PER 7058629 09/19/2007 08:26:37 CAROLYN RD CK AREA 7058441_ 09/18/2007 07:40:12 43 CAROLYN RD FIGHT SOL Statment Used in Search select distinct cadinclog.inenum, cadinclog.dtreceived, cadinclog.stnum, cadinclog.stnameI, httl)://(IeLilyn/QED//caclpartner/cad97/search/srchresults.js1) 9/1 5/1)()1 n aucn[ search Kesults Page 3 of 3 cadinclog.iretype, nbrincidents.incnum pincnum, nf5incidents.incnum tincnum from cadinclog, outer nbrincidents, outer nf5incidents where ((cadinclog.dtreceived between "2007-09-01 00:00:00" and "2010-09-15 23:59:59")) and (cadinclog.stnameI like "CAROLYN RDW) and nbrincidents.cadincnum = cadinclog.incnum and nf5incidents.cadincnum =cadinclog.incnum order by cadinclog.incnum dese; Set[rel[ Ag.[iu Number of Incidents Listed 73 h y y f http://(Ic(llyn/Q E3D//cadpartner/cad97/search/srchresul ts.jsp 9/15/2010 t-fw Incident Search Results Page i of 4 ,IMCAD Incident Search Results v6.01.0002 1211 r � r 1r �t C3 Search Again Go To Sql Statement CAD Search Results Incident# Date/Time Location Incident Type 10052318 09/13/2010 19:06:11 11 CIRCLE AVE LARCENY 10_049464 08/31/2010 06:32:26 11 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 10046372 08/17/2010 11:29:41 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 10043383 08/04/2010 00:33:01 CIRCLE AVE UNK PROB 10043010 08/02/2010 06:47:45 11 CIRCLE AVE MVA W/PI 10042836 08/01/2010 10:11:50 11 CIRCLE AVE DOMES*2* 10039371 07/16/2010 11:34:22 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 10038939 07/14/2010 13:42:34 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 10038899 07/14/2010 10:15:38 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 10030889 06/08/2010 10:18:49 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 10027700 05/26/2010 07:23:41 11 CIRCLE AVE MVA H&R 10027268 05/24/2010 10:09:18 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 10020226 04/19/2010 05:51:13 11 CIRCLE AVE ALARM 10018896 04/12/2010 10:44:47 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT 10018481 04/10/2010 10:46:26 11 CIRCLE AVE THREATS 10015497 03/26/2010 08:52:30 11 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 10013148 03/14/2010 08:46:07 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 10009703 02/24/2010 08:00:04 11 CIRCLE AVE A&B 10007315 02/10/2010 19:37:34 CIRCLE AVE INVEST 10006397 02/05/2010 13:56:56 11 CIRCLE AVE LARCENY 10003156 01/18/2010 10:50:18 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT 10000900 01/06/2010 10:06:00 CIRCLE AVE SERVE PA 10000572_ 01/04/2010 08:00:29 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 9074759 12/24/2009 11.52:13 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 9071680 12/07/2009 10:15:13 CIRCLE AVE MV PROB 9069066 11/23/2009 10:49:51 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 9066574 11/10/2009 12:34:49 2 CIRCLE AVE CON/SCAM 906313_2 10/24/2009 10:39:56 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT 9061537 10/16/2009 10:51.36 CIRCLE AVE CK AREA 9061535 10/16/2009 10:48:48 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 90615341 10/16/2009 10:48:22 CIRCLE AVE CK AREA 9061524 10/16/2009 09:23:34 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 9051=129 08/29/2009 10:54:01 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT F F F F littp://gccilyn/QED//ea(lpartnerfcad97/search/srcliresultS.jSp 9/15/2010 (-SAD Incident Search Results � Page 2 of 9048790 08/17/2009 18:34:17 CIRCLE AVE 4$259 08/15/2009 09:51:57 CIRCLE AVE ORD VIOL 9 9047540 08/12/2009 11:00:39 11 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP B&E 9U439)7 07/27/2009 10:35:36 CIRCLE AVE OC PAST L 9043924 07/27/2009 10:35:08 CIRCLE AVE LOCKOUT OTHER SV 9038967 07/05/2009 09:37:34 CIRCLE AVE LOCKOUT 9074 06/18/2009 09:58:49 11 CIRCLE AVE 38 ASS AGEN 9034053 06/14/2009 09:49:38 11 CIRCLE AVE 9031732 06/04/2009 10:36:15 CIRCLE AVE MV 9029916 05/27/2009 14:58:25 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 9028630 05/22/2009 11:15:40 11 CIRCLE AVE STOP 902707905/18/2009 11.10:27 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT MEDICAL 9024371 05/03/2009 09:26:32 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 9018921 04/08/2009 07:47:34 11 CIRCLE AVE MVA ACC 9018840 04/07/2009 19:10:26 11 CIRCLE AVE ALARM 9018749 04/07/2009 11:12:44 11 CIRCLE AVE OTHER SV 48 04/03/2009 10:41:24 11 CIRCLE AVE 90179 MEDICAL 9017930 04/03/2009 08:43:23 11 CIRCLE AVE SUSPIC901617LARCENY 9 03/25/2009 09:36:41 11 CIRCLE AVE [S 9_(.)0646102/05/2009 06:23:24 11 CIRCLE AVE LARCENY CJ 9004738 01/27/2009 10:38:49 11 CIRCLE AVE GUEST 9002354 01/14/2009 07:30:56 11 CIRCLE AVE 9111 HANG 911 HANG 8078848 12/30/2008 08:37:10 CIRCLE AVE CK AREA 3078692 12/29/2008 10:50:15 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8078671 12/29/2008 08:23:37 11 CIRCLE AVE 3078336 12/27/2008 10:56:57 11 CIRCLE AVE AREA 8070353 11/15/2008 07:23:23 11 CIRCLE AVE THREATS MEDICAL 8060987 10/02/2008 09:02:49 13 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 8059009 09/23/2008 20:20:52 22 CIRCLE AVE 987 305709/19/2008 11:03:08 11 CIRCLE AVE MED 8057749 09/18/2008 10:45:58 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL CAL MV STOP $0572 09/17/2008 14:16:32 CIRCLE AVE 58 MVA ACC 8057290 09/16/2008 08:06:17 11 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 8056331 09/12/2008 06:59:21 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 3054456 09/04/2008 08:35:19 CIRCLE AVE OTHER SV 8050787 08/20/2008 08:35:13 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 3046444 08/01/2008 08:41:10 11 CIRCLE AVE 911 HANG X046019 07/30/2008 13:00:00 11 CIRCLE AVE LARCENY 8042484 07/15/2008 16:10:18 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 11035976 06/19/2008 10:06:13 l l CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 8034734 06/14/200815:52:48 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP ;Q32411 06/05/2008 08:06:23 CIRCLE AVE EIGHT 3030443 05/28/2008 10:11:21 CIRCLE AVE NIV STOP http;//ge(Ilyri/QED//cadpartner/cad97/sem-cll/srchresultS.jSp 0n ciin CAD Incident Search Results � Page 3 of 4 8030413 05/28/2008 07:40:24 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 802_9.229 05/23/2008 1 1:1 1 :07 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 5028773 05/21/2008 10:50:04 11 CIRCLE AVE FIGHT 8028538 05/20/2008 10:03:05 11 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8028529 05/20/2008 09:03:10 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 8027602 05/16/2008 09:33:20 CIRCLE AVE OTHER CR 3026911 05/13/2008 11:03:29 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8023514 04/27/2008 00:53:11 11 CIRCLE AVE ALARM 8023011 04/24/2008 21.55:38 11 CIRCLE AVE/OR 43 CAROLYN RD ALARM 8022849 04/24/2008 07:06:45 11 CIRCLE AVE VANDALS 8022460 04/22/2008 16:08:36 CIRCLE AVE OTHER CR 8023203 04/21/2008 10:11.07 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 8021247 04/17/2008 09:31.33 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 8020383 04/13/2008 11:43:24 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8018625 04/04/2008 08:47:47 7 CIRCLE AVE THREATS 8016994 03/28/2008 11:10:41 11 CIRCLE AVE CK PER 8016555 03/26/2008 10:15:20 11 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 9015115 03/19/2008 10:59:42 11 CIRCLE AVE MVA H&R 8012948 03/08/2008 08:33:41 11 CIRCLE AVE MV FOUND 8011176 02/29/2008 13:22:25 11 CIRCLE AVE ALARM 8011040 02/27/2008 10:48:33 l CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8009834 02/21/2008 09:58:28 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8008867 02/16/2008 11:56:45 CIRCLE AVE MV STOP 8008219 02/12/2008 16:17:50 11 CIRCLE AVE LARCENY 8007341 02/08/2008 07:04:38 CIRCLE AVE MVA ACC 8006258 02/02/2008 10:06:37 11 CIRCLE AVE MVA ACC 8004779 01/25/2008 11:38:06 11 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 8004770 01/25/2008 10:42:05 11 CIRCLE AVE DISTURB 8004551 01/24/2008 09:53:11 11 CIRCLE AVE CK PER 8001518 01/08/2008 15:40:17 2 CIRCLE AVE 911 HANG 7078266 12/22/2007 09:52:06 CIRCLE AVE CK AREA 7068645 11/04/2007 08:21:00 CIRCLE AVE SERVE PA 7064400 10/15/2007 10:36:53 CIRCLE AVE MV FOUND 7064379 10/15/2007 08:48:18 CIRCLE AVE OTHER SV 7062264 10/05/2007 11:24:28 CIRCLE AVE CK AREA 7061611 10/02/2007 08:46:57 CIRCLE AVE MVA ACC 7060269 09/26/200714:54:38 CIRCLE AVE MV PARK 7059790 09/24/2007 10:16:48 2 CIRCLE AVE MEDICAL 7057117 09/12/2007 07:57:42 l CIRCLE AVE CK PER 7056741 09/10/2007 11:29:26 CIRCLE AVE P&W SQL Statment Used in Seat-ell Fselectstinct cadinclog.inenLim, cadinclogAtreceived, cadinclog.stnu n, cadinclog.stnamel, FhttP://cledlyn/QED//ca(lp,irtner/cad97/search/srcliresults.jsl) F CAD Incident Search Results Page 4 of 4 cadinclog.inctype, nbrincidents.incnunt pincmim, nf5inoidents.incnum hncnum from cadinclog, outer nbrincidents, outer nf5incidcnts where ((caclinclog.dtreceived between "2007-09-01 00:00:00" and "2010-09-15 23:59:59")) and (cadinclog.stnameI like "CIRCLE%") and nbrincidents.cadincnum = cadinclog.incnum and nt5incidents.cadincnum =cadinclog.incnum order by cadinclog.inenum dese; ill Search Again Number of Incidents Listed 116 t I http://ge(Iiyn/QED//cadpartner/cad97/search/srchrestilts.'Js " p o/� v�nin ' Page I of A, Danielle McKnight From: Natalie Femino [carmen0l @verizon.net] Sent: Saturday, March 19, 2011 7:52 AM To: Danielle McKnight Subject: Letter to Zoning Board of Appeals Dear Nils, ) CKniOlt, I ant not sure if I r\ ill be able to atlend tyre next meeting, so I wanted to pass along my thqughts via this ICttCC. I do riot know whether or not it is procedure for the letter- to etterto be read at the rneetillU. but thirt woulc] be my request if that is the case. Also agrin, if it is usw-rl procedtu-c, can the letter be noted in the comment scclion in Lhe minutes that are posted on Che. website'' I nut osSurnin!(I you will pass tyre letter along to die board but if there is a different procedure to follovin order for inc to get it to them by the meeting, could you please let tare know \vh1 it that is? ,Also could you confirm receilat of this email? (I ani never 100"4) cerlain that an email vcaelres its dcslirLlliorr.... :-) ) l hLink you. Natalie femino Linden St. Salem, \dA 0970 Dear ovil)efs of the Zoning; Boar& I work in the rental health field. l have been observing the "battle," between Salem residents and proponents of the iWethadone al.ri"far. several weelts ago, .1 was driving ,oast tha proposed Toca lion on Highland Alrenuel 117in'sin, q about the issue and decided to finally write arIfJ express iYI,Y thoughts on the ina:tter, C,oincideiatafly, I .sent a tetter to the Editor a r 311,v Jays bel7r,e Me news was publish-o3d °`hat t` a a ;1 i7ic villas Win 1; n lap, a al of arae Zonij l oa- rd s rejection of the ,oerrnit, /21/?011 Page 2 of I would like to encourage people to think about this issue from a perspective of logic rather than fear and ignorance and stereotypes. Methadone treatment is for people who have become addicted to opiates which includes prescription pain ..nedication. The stereotype of the "7unlsie" mai/ still :apply in a few instances but the majority of people now dealing with this type of addiction is you and me........ friends, family members, co- workers, neighbors....people of all ages, colors and occupations, from students to doctors to CEOs to elderly people. There is Intek shame associated with addiction, tli ;refore it is still shrouded in secrecy, so l guarantee that you know .a nd care about someone right now who is, has been or 1vvrill a ndd ctad to opiates. There are many resiclerlts %vilo Sup[)()F1 and/or arc neutral about the clinic being location in Saletn' but typically people wh_o are positive and educated about a subject ace 111uch less vocal than people who are negative and fcarilil....wc hear Al the reasons people give who oppose the clinic but most ot. those reasons are based on fear and ignorance - not on facts. t:)�Icause cif the j1i<]gmCIt, negativity, anger <nId vehemence of the pcoplc vvlio object to the clinic, there are many who are afi,aid to speal< out in support oNl'Ic clinic....people vvlIo are friends or faniily members and pcoplc who are clients ol., the clinic and ashanicil, ['Cm ful or cmbarrassecl to come forward and speak because of Clic ton(:_ tid itatI_Irc of the oblcctions and Ieiar of hov,v they will be Pave 3 oro treated ....The reaction ofthe people whip oppose the clinic 0111y perpetuates the shame and embarraSsr�le[It ofpeop(e who are getting help with addiction or people who want to get help but are fearful of the stigma and judgment that is being denrronstrated by the opposition to the clinic. One 0011c common objections to the clinic IS that it is a If:or profit' agency alld their motives are only money driven..... For profit does not autorrnatically mean that they are not working in the best interest of the client~ or that they are not helping hundreds of people get clean and sober. That objection is again based on assumptions and stereotypes of 'for profit' organizations. There are many for profit compLI'lles or organizations that provide help or services for all kinds of*pr;ople. I would encourage city officials and the zoning board to take an anonymous survey ofALL residents of Salem to get a more realistic Idea ol, Iroiw tialerrn really feels about tile clinic...then you will truly k:iobv ifyou are representing the majority ot' Saleni residents. For people wlro are opposed already or- people who are I_Intiurc, Do Rot let your fear and ignorance rule your decision mLdcing...approach the Subject as ifyou have no preconceived Ideas, feelings or knowledge....do some research, look at the ILICtS incl Figures, rf_search oil tyre web and look at how this organiz"Ition manages its clinic, take in ALL of,* the intorrnation anal in this instance do not let your c;motions and. fC'a s rule your intelligence. 'There are many facts offered by the clinic that SPCcitically refute concern;; brit those facts are ignored in f;:Ivor of feelings based on fear and steroctypes. .1f all'� r l��c �iO l is nrOpo-sed in Sale" -r,)r if this arpe,ai is lovo r,a.o1 encourage people to the Subject fro.rn j 1.�e'is�d3�+a r7 raay'! 3/21/2011 Page 4 of vers e `five W't�hout PreeOnceived notions... think about the number of people that are being helped who are clean and seiner and Preductive members of society because Of their treatment, l see it every day with clients. One day it could be our son or daughter, husband or wife...perhaps it already is and YOU just Font lfnew it. 'Thank you foI you ' time and consiciecation of my thcniglats, NatahE) Fernino 3/2)112011 M- Natalie Barker -' - - 2 CaveMish dr. - -- Salem.MA 019706853 5 i 9 1 a f ��gu�ulr,I„�D CITYOF SALE , MASSACHUSETTS nBOARD OF APPEAL q!\1 _.1�!to 120 WASHINGTON STREET', 3RD FLOOR / SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 "SHINED”' TELEPHONE: 978-745-9595 KIMBERLEY ORISCOLL FAX' 978-740-9846 q MAYOR 21"1 " `o �.` ii• December 23, 2010 Decision City ol'SalcnT Zoning Board Of Appeals PL'HHUH of CCIAIMUNITY IIEALTI-I CARE, INC. (owner) and HEALTH CME RESOURCES, IrW (lessee), seeping a Special Permit fbr the operation of a medical clinic (methadone center) on the property located at 207 1`1111WILAND AVENUE 113- 2 Zoning District(. A public hearing on the above Petition was opened On September 15, 2010 pursuant to \•lass General I.aw Ch. 40:A, j I I. The hcarin�" was continued to November 17, 2010 and December 1 5. 2010. The hearing was closed on December 15, 2010 with the Following Zoning Board of Appeals members present: Robin Stein, Rcbecca Curran, Richard Dionne, Elizabeth Dcbski, James Tsitsinos (alternate), and Bonnie Belair (alternate). I'etitioner seeks a Special Permit pursuant to Section 113,0 (B) of the City of Salem toning Ordinances. Statements of fact: L Attorney John R. Kcilty represented the petitioner at the hearing. 2. In a petition duce-stamped August 26, 2010, petitioner Community Health Care, Inc. (Operator) and I-lealth Care Resources, Inc, (Lessee) requested a Special Permit under Section II 3.0 (B) of the Salem Zoning Ordinances to allow a medical Clinic within the Business Highway Zoning District. 3. The petition states that the property is owned by I lildarst Rcalty Trust CII (Ralph CI-nndolo, Trustee), �e110 submitted a IWWr with the petition authorizin "'Hylo execute the Special Permit oil behalf of the petitioner. g Attorney 4. 'I'he proposed nmdical clinic, a methadone Center, is proposed to be located in a Portion Ofthe vacant building that formerly housed an auto dealership at 207 Highland ,Avenue. No exterior construction is proposal. AI the he:uin, on September 15, 2010, numerous members ofthe public spoke in opposilion 10 IhC proposal, cnin-w concerns About crime and traliir net,cly inlpaciing the nearby l"Idential naighborhOOLls. Other ConCiresscd by ntentbcrs of the public Crns asl were the proximity of the facility to the nearby schools, I"Hial lenges ofclicnts driving after having receival methadone doses, and � z negative effects on the area's economy if the center's presence discouraged patronage of local businesses. G. .Also at the September 15, 2010 hearing, one member of the public spoke in support of the petition, citing the need to provide treatment for drug addicts. 7. In response to resident comments, Board members requested additional nlormation of the petitioner, including a traffic study, the Activity and Use L-imitation and cleanup documentation for the property, and information demonstrating the need for it methadone clinic in Sale Departments. m. Board members also said they wished to hear feedback from the Salem Police, Fire and School S. "fhe hearing was continued to November 17, 2010 and then to December 15, 2010. 9. Fifteen individuals and/or households submitted letters to the Board in opposition to the project. 10. The Board received four letters in support of the project. I I. 'fhe Board received feedback on the plans from Lieutenant Erin Griffin, Fire Marsball, and Chief of Police Paul Tacker. The Board also received a traffic study completed by the applicant. 12. At the December 15, 2010 hearing, numerous members of the public again spoke in opposition (o the proposal, including City Councillors Steven Pinto, Thomas Furey, Arthur Sargent, Robert and Paul Prevey. iblcCartlry, "can Pelletier, Jerry Ryan, ,loll,, Ronan, I_. ,At the December 15, 2010 hearin„ served by clithe Board also reviewed information submitted by the petitioner docuenting tile numb e cr ofpcople in Salem currently nics on neighboring mcommunities. l he Board of Appeal, atter careful consideration of(he evidence presented at the public hcarin�, unit utter thorough review of(he plans and petition submitted, makes the lullowing findings: The Special Permit cannot be granted without substantial detriment to the surroundin_� neighborhood; wbilo the need for a methadone clinic exists or' a small numbcr of residents, this benefit does not outweig Sh the ne"auive impacts that would be imposed on the adjacent residential arca. Such negative impacts include greatly increased traffic on First Street and other local roadways. The Board specifically cited, as an example, the applicant's projection that 26%, of the 300 e.epec(ed Clients would arrive Jurui� it mornim; peak hourof T 0 to S:30, and during this (ince the prnjcctcd nLIMIlm ofri,hi-hand turns Item I lighlund \,ocnuc to First Su'ceI would go Iron, 20 to 77 turns during weekday peal: morning hours (7:30 a.m. (o S:30 a.m.). 'I'llis represents more than triple the projected number of turns in the no-build scenario. The Board noted that this specific increase, in addition to other increases in traffic on local roads, would pose a clanger to pedestrian children walking to school, since the facility's peak hours would coincide with the opening hours of three schools in close proximity to the site. In addition to the increased traffic during peak hours, the Board was concerned if),[( the remaining 74'% ofthe facility's expected business, which was expected to occur by 1 1 :00 a.m., would also pose traffic problems on local roads. 'fhe Board also noted that parking would be problematic since such a large proportion arrivingofclients would be around the same time. ?• The Board finds that the use would not be harmonious with the residential character of the adjacent neighborhood. 3. The Board also noted that the location on Highland Avenue would be better suited for retail and other business uses that would enhance the adjacent neighborhood and serve It greater number of residents. On the basis of the above findings and all evidence presented at the public hearin Including, but not linnited to, the Plans, Documents and g Appeals concludes: testimony, the Zoning Board of • A Special pernnit to allow a medical clinic in the Business Highway Zoning District is not granted. In consideration of the above, the Salenn Board foFf\ppeals voted -0 (Stein, Cw ran, hbski, Dionne and fsitsinos) opposed to the petition. 'File petition is denied. Ehctbeth Dcbskl Salenn Board of Appeals A C'OI'1'UP TI Illi OL<'ISION HAS 131 17N PILLD 1V1'nl THE I'LAiNNIiNO IIo,M)AND'[111:(Ily CLISRK Appeal Iium this decision, if any, shall be made pursuant to Section 17 of the Nfassaclwseus General Laws Chapter 4oA. and shall be filed within 20 days of filing of this derision in the office of the City Clerk. Pursuant to the Vlussachusrits General taws Ch;tpler 40A, Section I I, the Vnrimter or Special Permit gr:uncd herein shall not take rl&ct until a cupy of the derision bearing the c'rrtilicate of the City Clark hats heen filed ailll the Esser South Itegisuy of Deeds. +�td.��l ZBA ACTION FORM BOARD MEMBERS MOTION SECOND VOTE 6y,eln Date: Robin Stein-(Chair) ( 1 40 Rebecca-Curran ( 4/J D`Petitioner• Elizabeth-Debski ( 1 0 COmrnk �P� (q22 Annie-Harris ( ) Address: , /\�50rtr �s Richard-Dionne Bonnie Belair (Alternate), )p?— N cth ('.q `Stlem Jimmy.Tsitsinos,f 1 , I t�qv )00 In.lzy (Alternate) ( T N� Conditions: 6-15PI 1 ('{'ne+GIO e� 6 Iinic l Cjw_ha�Ae (Or, Total: T Petitioner shall comply with all city and state statutes, ordinances, codes and regulations. �— All construction shall be done as per the plans and dimensions submitted to and approved by the Building Commissioner. All requirements of the Salem Fire Department relative to smoke and fire safety shall be strictly adhered to. Ll Petitioner shall obtain a building permit prior to beginning any construction. ❑ Exterior finishes of the new construction shall be in harmony with the existing structure. A Certificate of Occupancy is to be obtained. {, A Certificate of Inspection is to be obtained. LI Petitioner shall obtain street numbering fiow the City of Salem Assessor's Office and shall display said number so as to be visible from the street. Petitioner is to obtain approval from any City Board or Commission having jurisdiction including, but not limited to, the Planning Board. ❑ Unless this Decision expressly provides otherwise, any zoning relief granted does not empower or authorize the Petitioner to demolish or reconstruct the structure(s) located on the subject property to an extent of more than fifty percent(50%)of its floor area or more than fifty percent(50%)of its replacement cost at the time of destruction. If the structure is demolished by any means to an extent of more than fifty percent(50%)of its replacement cost or more than fifty percent(50%)of its floor area at the time of destruction, it shall not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of the Ordinance. 1 : x 1 � r, 7,+� 1�-�r�iYa�r.1"•,�, ?/ec L 11 by ravrs TZZYW4, , ,K14�?ia' k4y� 4V r/ n I P El ri , , 1617)]]60549 4 Cus roU 1' powan o: I6P)5t380tl1 , y W. �y W. 14R 5 i�4 � INC. lol FWN.".: 161])631.6104 4 T - SULTANTS e S( A icl s : (617)]76-1950 �{ R1rA� A 1x "s,f r FrNv AON,MENTAL CON n1fL)FO RD ST •SUAERVILLE,NAA02I43 WArl R.l,ff.:1 (617)62};115 61 623-a •I'm'161716294929 irl G.,06 (61])]76-0716 Al,AA'KeagM1: (61>))]6-05'!B �t - 02an 1.Mille' (617)77G OJ 79 n March 3, 1996 Mr. Olivier Humbert Hillcrest Chevrolet 207 Highland Avenue Salem,NLA01970 Re: Soil and Groundwater Testing RTN 3-12517 LES Project 9497-124 207 Flighland Avenue, Salem Dear Mr.Humbert: This letter is a summary of the additional soil and groundwater analysis completed on the above referenced property. The additional soil and groundwater analysis was completed in order to establish additional background level's for the bioremediation project being planned for the subject property. The soil sampling was completed on Friday, February 21, 1997 in the interior of the building on the site, in the vicinity of TES monitorin6 well IES-5, where the largest quantity of contamination was encountered. The sampling was performed by Technical Drilling Services (TDS), of Leominster, MA using a tractor mounted geo-probe unit. Soil sampling was attempted in eleven locations (IES-6 through IES-16) in the vicinity of monitoring well IES-5 (See Figure 2). The sampling was conducted in locations where the greatest amount of contamination would likely be present. The borings were advanced one to eight feet in each of the locations. Refusal was encountered at various depths in seven of the borings advanced on the site. 'the soil samples were screened for Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC's) ushag at Thernno Cnvironmental Organic Vapor Meter (OVM) Model 580B. Soil sample screening revealed elevated levels of VOC's(d-22 ppul) in the majority of the soil samples were collected. Five of the soil samples were immediately forwarded to IF.A Laboratories of North Billerica, MA and analyzed for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (TPI ) (by EPA Method 8100). The analysis revealed elevated levels of TPH in all of the samples analyzed. The following Table I is a summary of the soil sample analysis. IU oI(J:r -f rt-AIROPEYvr,11 ✓f'1 Hr'd .-(I I'll HnU'i. f1 r7 ] IR :rI Ui 05114 (960) '21 1010 f❑ phlt K 2 Ill 6A 1T6KLT .MANl Hf I CK art' II vl HY E13101 603)°41 '.73 �� FS,f N.w'1 C-Pill'lur Alp.Vr)Pr IUI]MiW Hf W,<--1. ra4ti1 CIUf -HN Y1)RK 11"15.1`1-04211941.4 " �V1i. Olivier Flumbert 3 March 3, 1996 On February 27, 1997, groundwater samples were collected from monitoring wells IES-1, IES-2, CES-3, IES-4, and CES-5, previously installed by IES on the subject site (See Figure H2 for Monitoring Well Locations). The NAPL in each of the wells was gauged, and the groundwater samples were analyzed for the presence of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (EPA 418.1). The results of the groundwater sampling and analysis are sunuuatized in the Following Table 2. Laboratory results, the chains of custody, and laboratory certifications are included in Attachment 'B"of this submittal. TABLE 2 Gruuudwater'festing Results I 1}1,0"1nr�tlrlU}Ts `� IF1#(ttift� a ![f P141tt 0(F:Lasa �� ' �T[Elhtlt�ltit¢�3�'� lES-1 2/97 BQL 50 0 99.85 10/96 BQL 50 0 99.25 5196 NT 50 0 99.83 i 10/95 NT — 50 0 NM L/S_2 2/97 19 50 0 100.42 10/96 121 50 trace 9831 5/96 NT 50 6.96 97.69 I 10/95 35100 50 16.8 NM LES-3 2197 8.0 50 0 100.54 10/96 12.4 50 0 100.04 5/96 NT 50 0 I00.84 10/95 NT 50 0 NM IES-4 2/97 ti 2 50 0 100.51 10196 16.8 50 0 100.00 5/96 NT 50 0 100.59 10/95 3,150 50 0.36 NM IES-5 2/97 43 So 3.00 99.72 I 10/96 2,100 50 9.72 99.31 5/96 NT 50 20.4 100.02 10/95 812,000 50 27.6 NM NT=Not Tested BQL=Betow Leborutny Quontl nttun Dwit jiNh[=Nut Dleusured MCP Method 1>DEP cleamup Standards %� 4 I E S, INC. f\'G'. Olivier 11'umbert 4 Meunh 3, 1996 r All of the levzls of 1PFl, and separate phase oil decreased significantly in all of the wells on the Subject site. However, 3.00 inches of separate phase oil remains in monitoring well IES-5 on the subject site. No elevated levels of TPK above Method I Standards, remain in any of the monitoring wells on the subject site. However, the presence of separate phase oil in monitoring well IGS-5 on the subject site, confirms the necessity of additional remediation. IES is pleased to have been of service to you and should you have any questions about this report, please do not hesitate to contact our office. Respectfully Submitted, LES,Inc. Steven A. Erickson Daniel G,Jaffe Staff Geologist President i :i i ii I , I I E S9 INC. tit<r'ar ` n n. IU d >r . - F' �All, OIL-WATER SEPARATOR p �`� r 'Sk rt1•�' PAVED PARKING jii ��-M i t� �� C�I��)Y'l°y ,��j•f*'?�'�.C,v�r��+tY'.. ��r0v"r ° 9 7�P Rtw ii f �p'�„pJ^� �,i�4� • ' Q I � 1& r ��s, V,}r l��hv�5'��7Y i� L (100.42) OR t c LEO 1 ' � � Q.J il. • 9n AREA OF q EXCAVATION IES-3i f 100.54) I PAVED PARKING 0.3 PAVED PARKING ` LEGEND •.• FORMER UNDERGROUND STORAGE TANK P GEO-PROBE SAMPLING LOCATION MONITORING WELL <} TEST BORING QUARE SGROUNDWATER FLOW SQUARE SHOPPING PLAZA DIRECTION INDICATOR (xx.x) GROUNDWATER ELEVATION BENChiMARK=100' t��+��S��S;� s Sr v »•, �, f ! �. J -�k , �1k1 t'a'r° �j�•�' °� 5>�L 63, a�+I r Y�F 4 •t' Zau Y7 r ,�, 1 ��v f �i�,�zS��+�{"�� {'� Sy�i� :te.a i$ c�fikrCj�� ) f ?2°F4Y7� $ ,a @ Wr> � S �vk.N w`bI rGne��r��ft�a i i aw�t W vat •��`+ .�1'F S�-a A OIIKl Of417Juu.Le•t 1—id P. 1"", (417)776 8519 I S, I �. Cosmo D.Upohium:—(617)621888; J Kerry A-,. (617)77611$78 ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS IOhfIR niRnro-. (617)62}6204 263 IIWI CIRe fi'. SOMERVILLE,MA 0243 Sreven A.rrihsm' ;W)7761950 1617)621CIxY] . FAX 1(W)fi;9.:HN r—"d R cqucm ;61716215168 IE4nCy.AO�CObI Uunlel Glue (617)7762715 tlrlcr,I Milirn (617)T760829 September 15, 1999 Mr. George Leiicsque Salem Health Department Salem City Ball 93 Washington Street Salcm, MA 01970 Re: Response Action Outcome(RAO) 207 Highland Avenue Salem, MA RTN 3-12517 Dear Mr. Levesque: IES, Luc, of Somerville, SLA has completed a Response Action Outcome (RAO) Statement for the above referenced site, To accordance with the Massachusetts Contingency Plan (310 CMR 40.1403(3)(1)), notice must be given to the Chief Municipal Officer and the Board of Health in tne'Powu in which the disposal site is located. Based on the implementation of an Activity and Use Limitation (AUL), the Class B-2 RAO stated that a condition of "No Significant Risk" of harm to health, public welfare, and the euvirotnueniW has been achieved for the site, in accordatice with 310 CMR 40.0973(7). - Additional information regarding the LSP Evaluation Opinion and the Response Action Outcome Statement can be obtained from the DEP's Northeast Regional Office at 205A Lowell Street iu Wilmington, MA, or directly from IES, Inc. at 265 Medford Stiect in Somerville, MA. If you or any member of your staff should have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact this office. Respectfully Submitted, IES, Inc. ,a Daniel G. Jaffe, L/Sp President !F_401 Cunneuicut AIR C-NE ExECui'IVE CENTER•20 LINO9ERCH DRIVE.HARTFORD,CONNECTICUT 06111.18 601 724-1020 Its"(New Nampshire.942 n.%i 5 rREEr.MANCHESTER,NEW HAMMFURE 01101.(iA 1)641 6173 '•� IF)of PJe,v Yo$REPUBLIC AIRPORT-1100 VIEW I11CIIWAV.rARAIINCOALC,NEW YORK 117.15-(i161 420-9518 1 i `ullusuus uepartment of Environmental Protection ",� Bureau of Waste Site Cleanup BWSC-113 — ACTIVITY & USE LIMITATION (AUL) TRANSMITTAL FORM Releace Tracking Number a Pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1056 and 40.1070-40.1084(Subpart J) I Z N OF DISPOSAL SITE AND PROPERTY SUBJECT To,.. A. LOCATIOUL: ❑ S/ Disposal Sile Name: all°C Rd3 GNC V/,•aLFr Street: '_10-/ 141ew Cq., �Vfiv�C City?awn: L'rLocation Aid: O Z 9 Yr/ —ee Address 0(property 5ubjed to AUL,If different Iran above. Street: ZIP Cede,_�!7f� Cit//T ZIP Code: Check bora If this Disposal Site is Tier Classified. If the Dispeaal Site subject to Ire AUL is also subject to a Tler I Permit,provide the Pan Number: Related Release Tracking Numbers affected by this AUL; BFORM IS BEING USED TO: (check one) Submit a certified copy of a Notice of Activity and Use Limitation,pursuant Io 310 CMR 40,1074(complele all sections of this tonn). { IJ Submit a certified COP/of an Amended Notice of Activity and Use Limitation,pursuant to 310 Cl4R 40.1001(4) (complete all sections of this form). Submit a certified copy of a Termination of a Notice of Activity and Use Limitation,pursuant to 310 CMR 40.108](3) (complele all sections of this form). Submit a ceRiOed copy Of Grant of Environmental Restriction,pursuant to 310 cMR 40 1071,(complete all sections Of this form). !� Submit a cenifietl copy of an Amendment of Environmental Restriction,pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1081(3)(Complete all sections of this form). Submit a conirieo copy of a Release of Environmental Restriction,pursuant to 310 C61R 40.1083(2)(complele all sections of tftls farm). You mull attach all supporting documentation(Ortho use of form Indleated,Including copies of any Legal Notices and Noticea to Public..tlala required by 310 CMR 40.1400. C. AUL INFORMATION: / I Date AUL was recorded and/or registered with Registry of Deeds and/or Lard RegisheIn Ofrlee: I%WP 15 10^ tior r55 S Name of Registry of Deeds and/or Land Registmtlon Otfiw where AUL%ns rmotded anww r eglstared: Ssr Book and Page Number and/or Document Number ofrecorded and/or registered AUL:R/ 154 V r ,cTn 5.jar(% D. PERSON SUBMITTINGAUL TRANSMITTAL FO CdRM: 4a�647S6 6fcc T ,3428.?2 j Name of Organization: rb(.Cr r Ssf✓,w Name of Contac: f?" StreetTdla: . vr : _�f/t N/FN Lo,.d Clt/fTovn: JAL/, . v State: i"YJ— ielephone: (7�'— �Yt(^ J7 LI zipcade: D� syo FAX:(apllonal) --- E. OWNER OF PROPERTY,IF NOT PERSON SUBPAITTING AUL TRANSMITTAL FORM; Provide a mailing address for tiro owner of the property If that person Is not submitting the AUL Transmittal Form. Provide addressee for additional owners on an attachment, (lama o1 Ggsncmicn: _— Meme of Contxcr. ---- Strael' Title: Cry/Tusm: _ Telepnc Stale: ZIP Code: :.e� ' E"t- FAX,(optlana0 i Za sea Y,.190 ' Do,Vol.:L'far This Form Page I of 2 r f f wd:pai anent Ot Environmental Protection BWSG113 Bureau Of Waste Site Cleanup ACTIVITY & USE LIMITATION (AUL) TRANSMITTAL FORM Release Tracking Number i s Pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1056 and 40,1070-40.1084(Subpart J) �'I�2St7 F. RE TIONSHIP TO DISPOSAL SITE OF PERSON SUBMITTING AUL TRANSMITTAL FORM: (check one) lu RP ar PRP Specify yYOwner �� Operator '--i Generator (111 Transporter Omtt RP w PRP: Fiduciary,Secured Lender or Munkipalay mllh Exempt Statue(as defined by M.G.L.0.21E,s.2) Agency or Public Utility on a Rlgm or Way(as defined by M.G.L.e.21E,it,50)) Any Other Person Submitting AUL Specify Ralatbnsnip: O. CERTIFICATION OF PERSONS BMITTING AUL TRANSMITTAL FORM: L` I. pO aaest under the pains and penalties of Perjury(1)that I have personally examined and am Iamdlar to,tthe information contained in Is submittal, nc[uding any and all documents accompanying this tensa l norm,n that,based on my inquiry of those individuals[immediately responsible for obtaining the information,the material Information contained in mis submittal Is,to the best of my knoMeege and belief,true,accurate and compfel ,and(1111)that I am fully authorized to make this attestallon on behalf of the entity to responsAthlKsub . Inhe fpHsson or an' o vmosa hal(Nls submittal Is maria ams aware[hat mere are significant penalties,Including. but not les a mpnsmI nt r wi f l itting false,Inaccurate,or Incomplete mformalion. u 5y' 71ne: ....—.. For: Fn r1ccatff— GNB✓Z„"C, /� /g (print come of Person or entity recorded in Section D) Date; Enter address of person provfcing certification,it different from address recorded in Section D: Strcet'. cicff OM: State; ZIP Cada: Telephorit Ext.: FAX'(optional) _ YOU MUST COMPLETE ALL RELEVANT SECTIONS OF THIS FORM OR DEP MAY RETURN THE DOCUMENT AS INCOMPLETE, IF YOU SUBMIT AN INCOMPLETE FORM,YOU MAY BE PENALIZED FOR MISSING A REQUIRED DEADLINE,AND YOU MAY INCUR ADDITIONAL COMPLIANCE FEES. Rrnsed'J3A5 00 Not Alter This morn page 2 of? I t i I ` Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Waste Site Cleanup B W S C•1 14 MwACTIVITY& USE LIMITATION (AUL) OPINION FORM Release Trackin Pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1070-40.1084 9 NumDor (Subpart J) 'E S�7 '–� COMPLETE THIS FORM AND ATTACH AS AN EXHIBIT TO THE AUL DOCUMENT TQ BE RECORDED AND/OR REGISTERED WITH THE REGISTRY OF DEEDS AND/OR LAND REGISTRATION OFFICE. J A. LOCATION OF DISPOSAL SITE AND PROPERTY.SUBJECT 70 AUL: Disposal Site Nsme: /HILL Crsrr Gly-y2„I,f� Street Lo 7 CiryRovm: _S/�lF.vi Location Aid: Address ofro ny LIP Code P Pe subject la AUL,it different Than abova. Slreet Cityrrvem: ----- BTHIFORM IS (check BEING USED TO: — ZIP Code: cne) ' Provide the LSP Opinion for a Notice of Activity and Use Limitation,pursuant to 310 CMR40,1074(complete alf saalons of this form). Provide the LSP Opinion for an Amended Notice of Activity and Use Limitation.pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1081(4) (complete 24 SM60M Of this form), LJ Provide the LSP Opinion for a Termination of a Notice of Activity and Use Limitation,Pursuant to 310 CMR 40 i Icomplalc all sections of Infix farm). u . 083(31 Protide the LSP Opinion for a Grant of Environmental Restriction,pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1071,(complete all sections of this form). Provide the LSP Opinion for an Amendment of Envlronnxntal Restriction,pursuant l0 310 CMR 4O,IOg1 to"). Provide ne LSP Opinion for a Release of Environmental Restriction,pursuant Io 3f 0 CMR dO.1003 2 �)(Wmplde all sections of this C. LSP OPINION: O(cemPDd@ all sections of this form). 1 attest under the pains and penalties of pOrjury Watt have accompanying tilt submittal. In my Professional opinion and Judgment Cased upon appticatlon or(i)Uta standard submittal, 1, care in 009 and all documents a the personatty examined and am familiar wit this aubmstal,Including any and all documents &IR 4. j aPpucable Provisions of 309 CMR 4.02(2)and(3),and(Iii)Urn pmNsions s e u CMR 4.03(5),to the hest of da d My of care n 0.Information and belie) > ASece'on B ln6caros That a Nodco of gcWlty and Use Limn'"I is b"repls"It dnmor mcronled,the Act iqly subiect of this submittal s beim with 310 CMR 40,107 j)b_ A Pro4dcd In eccordan<e wdh the applicable provisions of M.G,L.C.21 E end 370 CMRand Use LXkOainitsd til�w that t is the 4I )( ) If Section B indicates that an Amended Notice ofACW - 1 that is the subject of this submidaIT)IS Dain r Mand Use Limitation b being mpshred end/w ramrdad,the Actidtyand UseLMilation complies with 010 CMR 40.1080(U and 4O.110a1��In aocordamOwffh the aPPlicable ProMslona of M.G.L.c.21E and 31OCMR 40.0000 and(ig - tSocilon iiali"thtistheresshataidssutwn aal1 Novice ofAcW/ry and Use Umdadon is beingm(p'stemd anar mcwdad the Activity and Use LimRatim that Is the sub)ect o!this subnlltal O Is being provided in accordance ttiththe applicable proNabns of M.G.L.C.21E and 310 CMR 40.0000 sub! (til complies win 310 CMR 4O.1 OB3o)(a), > it Sech'on Bin�icafos thole Grant If Resfrlcgonis being Algisisred and/or recorded,the Activity end Use Utnhatl subject of MR 40 i 071((0 u being prodded in accordance nit the applicable provisions o!M.G.L.c.21 E and 310 CNIR 40.0000 and(1)complies 1 with 310 CMR illomhal 1(1)(b); on that is the > d Sacroan B inWwres mat an gmandmvnf to a Omni ofEnvhwrmonht Restrlcrmn is being mgsfered and/armcaroad,Ne Acl'mty and Use Um"alion that Is the sub,'eet of this sutM,ttal(I)is being Provided In accordance Mh to applicable Provisions of M.G.L a.21 E and JI0 CMR 40.01)00 and(")Compll•s weh 310 CMR 4C.i 0000)and 40 loaf(1); d SePdon B lndaBlBs fhe(a R0e43e of Grant of Envirenmvnhl Res Wcdon b being ngsremd and'afmcordad the A mal o the subject 10 C R 40.1 al(i)is ).x0 provided in accordance with to appicin,provisions of M.G.L.c.21E and 310 CMR tu.0000 and (ii)complies with 370 CMR 4O.IOB3(3)(a). cdvitf and Use Limitation I Ise,inaucumla or materially incomplete.aware Ihat significant penalties may result faIse. Including. es ing,but trot Ilmded to,possible finand Imprisonmml,it xubm4 information wnlch I know to Ce Check here 11 the Rbspsnse Arton(s)on which Ihfs o nion is Wised,it any,are(were)suq'act to an order s issued by DEP or EPA. If the Cox Is checked,you MUSattach s statement IJnmi a Ire a M 9 PPhca c Provisions Ih reaf.and'cr aPPmral(s) SECTION C IS CONTINUED ON THE NEXT PAGE. Revised S'&Q5 - fka Nof Alton this Form Page I of 2 Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection BWSC-114 Bureau of Waste Site Cleanup -- ACTIVITY & USE LIMITATION (AUL) OPINION FORM (Release TmcWng Number Pursuant to 310 CMR 40.1070-40.1034(Subpart JI C. LSP OPINION: (continued( Lsp Name: t;,_4�a rsL lr- ,9FFTZ }' tJ;•k a LSP W. stamp'. }j rl� FF M epnone' o I' 7 76-' 7 /�� ✓� 7 FAX JAFFE H LSP 51 nature; No.2747 ISE Dale: J� r og/lE P .i4'rr' YOU MUST COMPLETE ALL RELEVANT SECTIONS OF THIS FORM OR DEP MAY FIND THE DOCUMENT TO BE INCOMPLETE. i I I ReNcN S'Y}5 Do Not Alter This Folrn2 Page t or. „- i:o CJIR: DEPA.Ri11E; f U'r ESVI:iOPt 11 till r L PROTE(71Va Fnrn 105 i =CF._QE6CIMTY ANn t ISE t RfITATION Nf G c. 21 E, §6 and,to CMR 40.0000 Disposal Site Name: Hillcrest Chevrolet DEP Release Tracking No.(3)' 3-12517 t This Notice of Activity and Use Limitation ('Notice') is made as of his day A110ust l9 9y by(Yame and address of current property owner(:)),togeth19 day ofer wih hisRterlyOr successors and usips(ccilective!y'Owner') `A`fTNESSE;H� '•vh:REAS;valpn Ca�undolot�ra-,e of Owner), of S v _lv (Town/City) E'=max Pat;a, %W (State)(is)(are)tSe owner(:)m`ee simple of(that)[hose) cena.n parcel(:) oC (vacar[f land located m e=t Nfusach�sens unth the buildings i.d improvements here-,( Pro c ogn/Cty),, _ ua County. I tt'T'—EqS•u•said Prcei(s)of land,whuch is:note particularly bounded and described in Ex`,ibit i .'� at:aahed hereto and made a pa.: hereof('Property') is subject to this Notice of Activity and Use i,uala9cn. T.-.ep:ops:/is::.own ensplan(;a,7rd�ar.Lor::gist red herewith)(rcorded and/crd in cssea Coucry RegistryoL D-- diLacd Regisrscon Office in Plan Book o G o.pjan2«gism:: 1� as Twd Court Plan No.203049 ['•v'F�REAS, a porion of the Property('Porion of aha Prepery)is more specifically subject to C•is Nodce of Activity and Use Llmitacen. The Poricn ofhe P;ope.•ry is more particularly bounded and described in Ex4ibit A 1,aaachcd hr.eso and made a par,hereof. The Portion ohhe,Property is o toun en a plan(to be recordCJregisaered h erewith)[:<corded and/or re --erect le Feao-, DrdU[.,and Regisvation Office in Plan Beok252' PIan21'?LIQ( County Registry of �r u Land Court Plan No. 20304A r K"•�C.EAS,r}.e Property[PorScn of-.,.e Pro;C; 11 cor.,prises[allI oQ a disposal site u the result of a re!eue of oil and/or hazardous mateial. Exhibit H is a sketch plan showin;thuela;ionshte of the (IFraPe.' [P0nien f the pro Perry] subject to this Notice of Aniviry and Use 0Lvin,ation io the boundaries of said disposal site(to the=ent such boundaries have been established). Exhdbit 8 is attached hereto and made a pan hereof.];and - W'H—'QZkS,one or more ruporae actions have been selected for(the Disposal Site)(Pcnion of the Disposal Site)in accordance with Nf.G.L• c.21E('Chapter,21E') and the Musachusetu Contingency R ?lar,310 CN 40,0Ce0('N(Cp') Said response acnions are bared upon(a)the restriction of human access to and contact with oil and/or hazardous material in soil (and/or groundwater(and/or(b)the restriction of c:ruin activities ooyrring In,on,through,over or under the[Property)(portion of the property). The basis (or such resanctions is set Forth in an Activity and Use Limitation Opinion ("AUL Opinion'), dated 2219. (which is attached hereto as Eslubit C and made a part hereof); NOW.TEERI=PORE,notice is hereby given that the activity and use Emitu!ons set forth in said AUL Opinion are u follows: 1. ?"rtnirted 4-i vY s d Li SIF rth' t AIII G t that (set-( one) (a condmen of No Signifipnt Risk to h<ilth, safee. Public AUL Opinion provide environment eslsts for any foreseeable period of time)(no substantial hazards 'CII (pursuant ane sa ope CNCR 40,Ction of th so long as ani of the following activities and uses occur on he (PropenryJ[portion of the Property). (i)Any use'.vhich does not disturb the building foundation over the contaminated area. Pi) ;and .Any use II the building after implementing proper precautions 7rg/9s 3 10 0AR . 170A Form 1075: continued (ui) Such other activities or uses which.in the Opinion of an LSP,shall present no greater risk of harm to health•safety,public welfare or the envirommern than the activities and uses set rcrth in this Paragraph. 2. 4e•wir'es + d [r e 1 c ' ' Activities and uses which are inconststem wrth the objectives oC this Notice oC Activity and Use Limivadon, and which, if unplcalcmcdat the(Property][Portion of the Propem], may result in a sign scant risk of hum to health, safety,public welfare or the:nvirotarnent or in a substantial hued, are as follows: C,) The excavation and disturbance of soil, or any construction activities beneath the concrete floor under the building,without using workers who are adequately protected and trained; and implementing federal and state occupational, health and safety requirements, including, but not limited to 129 CFR 1910.120. i. lltil'Parinns+rid f'n d4'bt S F nh' Ih rn n Ifappticable,obligations and/or conditions to be undertaken and/or maintained at the[Property] (Portion of the Propenyj to (select one)(maintain a condition of No Significant Risk][eliminate a substantial hazard]as set funh in the AUL Opinion shall include the following: Any construction within the area of the AUL, including dishubanc0 o`Ilie concrete 0) Noor of the building or the underlying soil.shall be done by workers who are adequately protecled and hained in implementing federal and stale occupational, health and safety requirements,including but not limited to 129 CFR 191020. (ii)Any soil generated must be disposed of in accordance with applicable laws, 4. Prnnneed Ch+ .' qInd Uses. Any proposed changes in activities and uses at the CPropenYj (Portion of the Pfopehyj which may result in higher levels of exposure to oil and/or hazardous material than currently exist shall be evaluated by an LSP who shall render m opinion.in accordance with 310 CNM 40.1080 of seq., as to whether the LS?who&l changes rend will (select one) [present a significant risk of harm to health, safety, public welfare or the errr,ronment] (will invalidate the conclusion that no substantial hazards remain]. Any and all requirements set forth in the Opinion to meet the ebjemive of this Notice shall be satisicd before any such activity or use is commenced. 5, Vhrien t•F R e p n� The aaivitids,uses and/or exposures upon which chis Notice is based shall not change at any time to cause a significant nsk of harm t0:heath,r safety,public wet6rq or the environment or to create subuandal hazards due to exposure.to ail' and/cr hazardous mmterial without the prior evaluation by an LSP in accordance with 310 CMR 40.1030 at req.,and without additional response actions,ifneces to achieve or mai condition oCNo Significant Risk or to eliminate substantial hazards. nrain a, L`the activities,uses,and/or exposures upon which this Notice is based change without the Prior evaluation and additional response actions determined to be necessary by an LSP in accordsnce with 310 LMR 40.1080 ei seq.,the owner er operator ofthe[Property](Portion of the Propatyj subject to this Notice at the time that the activities,uses and/or exposures change, shall comply with the requiremens set forth in 310 Choi 40.0020. I 6. lneomon'nn In n ed �/ r i I Tia Notice shall be incorporated either to lull or by reference into all deeds, easements, mortgage, leases, licenses,ccotpancy mgesmens or any other instrument of transfer,whereby an interest in and/or I right to use the Property or a portion thereof is conveyed. Owner hereby authorizes and consents to the firmg and recordation and/or registration of this Notice,said Notice to become effective when exeemcd under sea]by the undersigned LSP,and tecorded and/or re itered with the appropriate Registry(es)orDeeds and/or Land Registration office(s), 7/28/95 t in ra,a . ions 8 ,v +10 C.`.I R.: DE PAR P IED7 OF CPTV IROtdMcNT'AL PROTECII ON Form 1075, continued "TINESS the exeeutien hveoFunder seal uhis Od day of / 19- / Owt (� / . COt.L\10TTATALTH OF MASSAChUSZ TS t� 19,7" Tnen personal) h:u'her Fre Y are me,d the above named -act and deed before me, and acknotty/ledged the foregoing to be CHRISTINE GAUDREAULT / t NOTARY PU6LIC Notary Public hycmmlcn es4vw hla.2:,iSJ My Commission Expires: Tnc undersigned LSP heresy certifies shat hJshe extcuted the a''orzsaid rk[iviry and Us< hed he Plortiwttor Ac!vi y udvUse Li'eto as treutonEis Consistenhibit C t with the ermerset Forts in in i/her Limitation Opinion. his/her Opinion this ry and Use Late: LSP CO""[OMt'EALTH OF Lt4SSACHUSETTS 19 Then PerwrulhY appeared the above named his/her Free act and deed before me, and acknowledged the foregoing to be v/aary Pt t -f,Co - 'i"Expires: Upon recording.return to: /� _ 7, S� (T'ame and address of OwTef) 1200 t Certify this to be a• trUe and accurate Copy." jf the original This 'LQ Cay of 1999 D23/95 110 CMR- 17r>a CHRISTINtE 0AU'DREAULT NOTARY PUBUC 1"�ccnvq�e;lUYes Msx U.:tzll uitclaim Dee Ralph Cerundolo, individually and as Trustee of Hillcrest Realty Trust,under declaration Of trust dated July 8, 1985 and recorded at Essex Page 341 and filed with Essex South South District Registry of Deeds at Book 7824 Registry of the Land , CertiticateofTitle No. 54838 for consideration oflethan One Hundred and No 2 Court as Document No. 203049 on xx/ Dollars granted to Ralph Cerundolo, Of of Hillcrest Realty Trust II d an dated 0 ) 1998 to be recorded with Essex South District Registry of Deeds herewith and filed with South Registry District of the Land Court herewith. gust 24 WITH QUITCLAIM COVENANTS The land with the buildings and improvements thereon, situated in Salem, Essex County, bounded and described as follows: PLEASE SEE EXHIBIT A ATTACHED HERETO, AND MADE A PART HEREOF, hereto. The consideration for this conveyance being less than $100.00, no deed tax stamps are affixed For Grantors Title, see deed filed with Essex South District Registry of Deeds in S Page 250 and filed with Essex South Registry District of the Land Court as Document No. 203048, CertiticateofTitleNo. 54838. ent o. li illo nR:alY l}cn nlyb,ym<n tl'll.<.Im II.R,n,n P.•.,In iu µ a FINE "utanR: 109138 UNREGISTERED LAND .Armmz1 NAPPEL )FRO" DFM BOac_ It 114x fl IN ��-- PAGE:�` EWER ANR yA'ONGS RANK PLUI BOOP I{p PACE 43 ��--- PLIUM nwasue wT(�5_9 859 PPLUC RA PM RUNOOLO o1 IVIM OU REC/STERED LAND M18: 08/20/99 —`-- ILGOITRATiON ---� SGIR: x'•'00' BOOk 157 CLR77Fia 0A ryM.12460 :ABa—` FLOOD IU ZARD /NFOR.VATfON PLAO xUYOER PLOUO YAP COMMMETTY NO.: 01 TOT(91; 5 h_=� PANEL.0035 B � on C ASSESSORS .VM Dmm 09/_p� /ai gym WP: BUOCIE P.MiCIL 11ORTCAGE INSPECTION PLAN 207-209 IIICHLAND AVENUE, SALEM- MA N/F PEOUOT ASSOCIATION - aIR.4J' CX I • I I I 1 W LOTS 5,6,A&B 9.304 ACRES I � I 1 g NA SALE% REALTY TRUST 1 T ` I C AiEXi OF VAT IiV` I ( /1 i I n ( II ansa' I •.1 MORTGA iAax woo HIGHLAND AVENUE USE ONLY rC E RESULT OF TAPE MEASUREMENT, NOT THE AEGUIi TRUMENT SURVEY AND IS OEP.'IFIED TO THE TITLE COMPANY VNO A90VE LISTED AT;0RNEY ALIO LENDER. �UTij}�1�TG^7��y��. NO DECOEO EASEMENTS IN THE A90YE REFERENCED i IDA�LuiEs,5qc NCROACHMENTS KITH RESPECT TO RUILDUIGS SNCEDED ISO000) aiREEi. WALPPLE. MA O2G97 r EIDEPT AS SHOWN. CO TAX-(.SC3XSR-4S11ION OF THE DWELLING SHOWN DOES NOT FALL WITHIN A SPECIAL FLOOD HAZARD ZONE. vyAW OF THE LOCATION Of THE DWELLING AS Sh'OAN HEREON EITHER MARIO NAS LV COMPLIANCE WITH THE LOCAL ZONING 9Y- ( DOMINIC EFFECT WHEN CONSTRUCTED ('WITH RESPECT TO STRUCTURAL MAN DANICI 1 N4 19641 -�I � SETOACN REQUIREMENTS ONLY), OR IS EXFMPT FROM VIOLATION 'rkW,9i[0.� E ENFORCEMENT ACTION UNDER MASS. G.L. TIRE VII, CHAPTER ADA, n- • ''MAL.LAM- SECTION 1. C,ENE.RAL NOTES: (1) TEa In;lvatl:nf .nate c:e» /rLa/-a8' ��• I*algcSa nepeetun ;ap, tuner made b :nen era En �° '0eic of my ina.IKie, .n lxmeli<n, and ;dial (11 Oedara9ena ar. made !a Ina clime "anal elendmd of ttre of reRhtvld land Ia... Ix un in prepuNng deed daxnpoana a far ed tllmt cnly n of UIM Date. >°^ praCM119 b 4csaceWaatls o, lot canfi9ymVon q,aY S. uEmmplifEea ey,l ee flN<I Mt (4) '/er RGatlpn{ (�) 'hi1 plEe waf PCI mE�a !Y M]Y'u(17 pfi,m Y 1 m eccurara inet"In i Waty I'ne tvn<roima, buidiq arm;; 'xU. mt xlYv{y, LOCATIONS 55 Fiskfryy Street 628 Center Street Hartfc:d,CT. Chicopee,MA 01620 01013 - (860)247-8300 (413)746-0051 . (860)548-7325 Fax (413)746-0368 Fax Community 125 North Elm Street 297 Pleasant Street Y . ..' _..�r-+�— - 01085 Ala eld,D1A Northampton, UIU85 (413)566600 01060 (413)562-8360 Fax (413)584-2404 - -,Substance l S Nb..c a c P (413)585.8631 Fax ." .ta _. .2 ..-•� . - 10 Kilburn Street New Bedford,NIA - 177 Shelburne Road - H 111 lllbuse= 02740 Greenfield,D1A - SU8 979-1122 - - ( ) - 01301 (508)979-]126 Fax (413)774-3321 Centers .. _.:..� (413)774-335 Fax - - 200 Route 108* � � - .� � ^ -- Somersworth,NH 175 Crescent Avenue 03878 Chelsea,11L1 (603)953-0077 • 02150 (603)953-0078 Fax (617)889-8779 .. " . .. (617)889-9568 Fax 323 Derry Road* - Hudson,NH 20 Tower Office Park 03051 Wall urn,hIA - (603)595-3399 . 01801 (603)579-2734 Fax (781)933-0700 (781)9384004 Fax 177 Shattuck Way Newington,NH ' 172 Newbury Street 03801 - - Peabody,D1A (603)436-0448 --„ _. „., _. .�..-...*...._. .. --s" . 01960- - (603)436-0668Fax (978)535-9190 _ . . (978)535-9093.Faz • .. : , .s a"- :z., + rwr . . 2300 Congress Street*Portland,ME . . HOURS &SERVICES wloz (207)221-2292 Community Substance Abuse Centers - � �- _.,.. (207)221-2297 locations are open seven days a week, !' three hundred and sizly five days a year. Hours and services vary by location. www.csaehelp.com *dba Merrimack River Medical Services - Please contact the Center nearest you for more inforination. at I Islas - - Y A ...,yr^§Iw.Ys, 5{iyq .iuA.a t+,e•3. »'+Sf!r s -,.�,�._y.- r.ih^ ,..,,..'.:.w .....v��.�vN:-::. '..w«r.."'t+:. '. . .. .�+. dui' -+'.ir.. .. #-+--ur?....h. .a.+.K ' -.;..,V♦,eis_.inr...,.. -yya, .+ ♦nca+t....tie_,+>�..a+-a a-`t<..r-ir+-. «.,^, ... �nn,«v-d ...e. CSAC is a private, outpatient program, specializing in the treatment of narcotic addiction. Services are confidential and professional. We seek to assist every individual in achieving a drug free lifestyle. Mission Community Substance Abuse INTAKE AND EVALUATION MEDICATION ASSISTED TREATMENT Centers (CSAC) is committed to improving the quality of life of Patients interested in services may call any of our Eligibility for methadone maintenance requires patients centers and discuss their interest and eligibility with an have a documented history of opioid dependence of at each substance abuser intake counselor. If appropriate an intake appointment least one year,unless medically compromising by providing efficient, effective will be scheduled to complete a comprehensive circumstances exist. Patients who are pregnant or have assessment. Patients will identify goals,and, in other medical complications such as AIDS are given priority treatment in a therapeuticassessment. with a counselor, begin to outline admission. Methadone dose and length of stay vanes environment that promotes a course of treatment. ASAM certified doctors and according to individual need. Maintenance patients attend dignity and respect. mid-level practitioners will complete physicals and group and individual counseling sessions,working toward suggest an appropriate medical regimen. Referrals goals related to drug free,independent living. Patients will be made for those with serious medical and/or may be provided the responsibility of self administering psychiatric problems which allow for concurrent medication as treatment criteria are met.CSAC is treatment whenever possible. committed to offering alternative medications for the Philosophy treatment of opioid addiction to our patients,and will inform them of new medications as they become available in our CSAC maintains a commitment to programs. high quality, individualized Treatment with Buprenorphine(Suboxone,Subutex)may be treatment. We believe that all available at some locations for medical withdrawal or people are capable of change. Our medication assisted treatment. goal is to provide prompt, professional service to assist MEDICAL WITHDRAWAL STAFFING AND FEES patients and their families in improving their quality of life CSAC provides outpatient medically supervised through treatment of issues related withdrawal treatment for opioid users. Patients are given CSAC staff is composed of trained and certified to substance abuse. decreasing doses of methadone in order to remain physicians,mid-level practitioners, nurses,social comfortable while learning to live a drug free life. workers and counselors. Many staff members are bi-lingual and bi-cultural,and they all have The length of medical withdrawal depends on the experience working with chemically dependent needs of the individual but does not exceed six months. persons.Substance abuse services are often Withdrawal patients attend groups and individual covered by insurance. Each third party payer is counseling,and are closely monitored by nursing and unique;CSAC will assist in determining eligibility. medical staff. Treatment is affordable and self payment arrangements can be made. Fees include individual, group,,and family treatment as well as medical and nursing services. I Sumner 2008, Volume 7, Issue I r" Substance Abuse Treatment ,f��@�1 / 0 i 0 9, Treatment and Detoxification Protocols OxyContin" is a powerful medication that contains a patient addicted to diverted pharmaceutical opioids is any much larger amount of the active ingredient, oxycodone, less likely to benefit from medication-assisted treatment than other prescription opioid pain relievers. Whereas most people who take OxyContin as prescribed do not than the patient addicted to heroin. become addicted, those who abuse their pain medication Some patients who are opioid addicted who have very or obtain it illegally may find themselves becoming good social supports may occasionally be able to benefit rapidly dependent on, if not addicted to, the drug. from antagonist treatment with naltrexone. This treatment works best if the patient is highly motivated to participate Two types of treatment have been documented as most in treatment and has undergone adequate detoxification effective for opioid addiction. One is a long-term, from the opioid of abuse. Most patients who are opioid residential, therapeutic community type of treatment, and addicted in outpatient therapy, however, do best with' the other is long-term, medication-assisted outpatient medication that is either an agonist or a partial agonist. treatment. Clinical trials using medications to treat opioid Methadone is the agonist medication most commonly addiction have generally included subjects addicted to prescribed tion diverted pharmaceutical opioids as well as to illicit heroin. Buprenotph ne s he o i Parti treatment in this country. al agonist Therefore, there is no medical reason to suppose that the the Food and Drug Administration for opioid addiction n treatment. The guidelines for treating OxyContin addiction or Other CSAT Resources dependence are basically no different from the guidelines Prescription Medications: Misuse,Abuse, the Center for Substance Abuse Treatment(LSAT) uses Dependence, and Addiction, Substance Abuse for treating addiction to or dependence on mry opioid. Treatment Advisory, May 2006, Volume i, Issue 2. However, because OxyContin contains higher dose levels NIS987 of opioid than are typically found in other oxycodone- containing pain medications, er dosages of methad Pain Management Without Psychological or buprenorphine ne may be needed lto appropriately treat one Dependence:A Guide for Healthcare Providers, patients who abuse OxyContin. Substance Abuse in Brief Fact Sheet, Summer 2006, Volume 4, Issue L MS993 Methadone or buprenorphine may be used for OxyContin addiction treatment or, for that matter, treatment for SAMHSA Resources addiction to any other opioid, including the semisynthetic opioids. Medication-assisted treatment for prescription To find a substance abuse treatment facility opioid abuse is not a new treatment approach.A study near you, visit the Substance Abuse Treatment of people entering methadone maintenance treatment Facility Locator at http://www.Hndtreatment. programs conducted in several States found that samhsa.gov. Call the Substance Abuse and oxycodone was the prescription opioid medication used Mental Health Services Administration, Substance most frequently by people whose drug of choice was Abuse Treatment Hotline at 1-300-662-FIELP for heroin and who abused prescription opioids.4 substance abuse treatment referral information. Continued On t$fee J summer 2008,OxyCuntin Ii • Substance Abuse Treatment� �� . ....... ................... ....... A V I oxyContinRD Frequently Asked Questions ._rontinnedfran page 2 What is the difference between addiction to and Q: Why are so many crimes reportedly associated with dependence on OxyContin? OxyContin abuse? A: When pain patients take an opioid analgesic as A: Many reports of OxyContin abuse have occurred in directed,or to the point where their pain is adequately rural areas that have housed labor-intensive industries, controlled, it is not abuse or addiction.Abuse occurs such as logging or coal mining.These industries are when patients take more than is needed for pain control, especially if they take it to get high. Patients who take often located in economically depressed areas, as well. p` Therefore, people for whom the medication may have espe medication in a manner that grossly differs from a been legitimately prescribed may be tempted to sell h sician's directions are probably abusing that drug • t t patient continues to their prescriptions for profit. Substance abuse treatment pseek excessive pain medication providers say that the addiction is so strong that people is achieved, the patient may be will go to great lengths to get the drug, including robbing after pain management cies and writing harmag false prescriptions. addicted. Addiction is characterized by the repeated, p hWhat is the likelihood that a person for whom compulsive use of a substance despite adverse social, will become addicted' p'Y'r s cholo6ical, and/or physical consequences.Addiction OxyContin is prescribed is often(but not always) accompanied by physical . dependence, withdrawal syndrome, and tolerance. A: Most people who take OxyContin as prescribed do not Physical dependence is defined as a physiologic state of become addicted. According to the National institute on Drug Abuse adaptation to a substance.The absence of this substance and a review on oxycodone,opioid analgesics can be used to treat pain safely with proper medical produces symptoms and signs of withdrawal. Withdrawal managementfi•7 syndrome is often characterized by overactivity of the One review found, "A multitude of studies indicate that physiological functions that were suppressed by the drug and/or depression of the functions that were stimulated the rate of opioid addiction in populations of chronic b the drug. Opioids often cause sleepiness, calmness, pain sufferers is similar to the rate of opioid addiction and constipation,id opioid withdrawal often includes within the general population, falling in the range insomnia, anxiety,diarrhea, flulike symptoms, restlessness, of t to 2 percent or less."} tearing, runny nose,yawning, sweating, muscle spasms, In short, most individuals who are prescribed OxyContin, back aches, abdominal cramps, and vomiting. or any other opioid,will not become addicted, althoughsometimes develop a physical p they may become dependent on the medication and will Pain patients, however, may situ need to be withdrawn by a qualified physician. Individuals dependence during treatment with opioids.This is not an addiction.A gradual decrease of the medication dose who are taking the medication as prescribed should over time, as the pain is resolving,brings the former pain continue to do so, as long as they and their physician anent to a medicatioedication. This is the difference n-free state without any craving for dillappropriate P agree that taking the medication is a medically pp repeated doses of the m way for them to manage pain. between the patient treated for pain who was formerly dependent and has now been withdrawn from medication ...continued on page G U y _ yth E �F t f 5 R JR5 _v}�� Substance Abuse Trea(menf Stunlner 2008,OCyCVpI A O Y I S C] _Treatment and Detoxification Protocols ...continued from page J The information in this issue a OxyCon providers determine whether a tin can help "As substance abuse treatment professionals, we have patient requires treatment the responsibility for learning as much as we can about for opioid addiction. If treatment is necessary, methadone OxyContin and then providing appropriate treatment or buprenorphine may be used for withdrawal. For certain for people who are addicted to it. Appropriate treatment patient populations, including those with many treatment will nearly always involve prescribing methadone, failures, methadone or buprenorphine is the treatment of choice.] buprenorphine, or, in some cases, naltrexone,"says H. Westley Clark, M.D., J.D., Director of CSAT. It is important to conduct a careful preliminary assessment "Programs that do not offer medication-assisted treat- to determine whether medication-assisted treatment ment will need to refer patients who are addicted to with methadone or buprenorphine would be appropriate for a patient. This assessment can be done in a hospital OxyContin to programs that do,"he adds. emergency department, central intake unit, or similar place. The preliminary assessment should include the following areas:' • Determining the need for emergency care We have the responsibility for • Diagnosing the presence and severity of opioid dependence learning as much as we can • Determining the extent of alcohol and drug abuse about OxyContin, • Screening for co-occurring medical and psychiatric and then providing appropriate conditions p Evaluating an individual's living situation, family and treatment for people who are social problems, and legal problems. addicted to it." The final assessment of an individual's eligibility for H.Westley Clark, M.D.,J.D. medication-assisted treatment must be completed by Director, CSAT experienced staff of an opioid treatment program. Federal regulations on eligibility for admission to opioid pharmacotherapy exist.I Three Ways To Obtain Free Copies of CSAT Products: 1. Call SAMHSA's Health in formation Network(SHIN)at I-877-SAMHSA-7(1-877-726-4727) (English and Espanol), TTY(hearing impaired) I-800-487-4889 2. Visit SHIN's Web site, http://www. samhsa.gov/shin. 3. Access products on line at httP:Hlvww.kaP.samhsa.gov Sumner 2008,Volumc 7, Issue I Substance Abuse Tre•tm•nf ADVISOR OxyContin'o Frequently Asked Questions ...anainuedfrom page 3 tments, other than at trea and the patient who is opioid addicted: The patient addicted t eatment,should be provided to itndividuals addicted to diverted pharmaceutical opioids continues to have a severe and uncontrollable craving that almost always leads The major ty of U.SyCeatment facilities do not offer A to eventual relapse in the absence of adequate treatment. medication-assisted treatment. However,because of This uncontrollable craving for another"rush"of the drug the strength ss OxyContin and its powerful addiction differentiates the patient who has.completed detoxification potential, medical complications may be increased by for opioid addiction from the patent being treated for pain who is not opioid addicted.Theoretically, a person quickly withdrawing individuals from the se to OxyContin drug. Premature who abuses opioids might develop a physical dependence withdrawal may cause individuals to relapse but would obtain treatment in the first few months of use or to seek heroin. In addition, these individuals, if abuse,before becoming addicted. injecting drugs, may also expose themselves to 111V and this case, supervised hepatitis C. Most people addicted to OxyContin need withdrawal (detoxification) followed by a few months of imedication-assisted treatment. Even if individuals have abstinence-oriented treatment might o sufficient o t for the patient who is not addicted to but who abuses opioids. been taking OxyContin legitimately n manage pain, they If, however, this patient subsequently relapses to opioid should not stop taking the medication all at once. Instead, abuse,then that behavior would support a diagnosis of their dosages should be tapered down until medication is opioid addiction. If the patient has several relapses to no longer needed. Professionals who work in a drug-free he or she will require long-term treatment or abstinence-based treatment facility should refer patients opioid abuse, for the opioid addiction. (See the section titled Treatment to facilities where they can receive appropriate treatment. and Detoxification Protocols on page 4 to learn more about (See SAMHSA Resources on page 4.) a treatment options.) ............................ Notes 3. Fisher, F. B. (2004). Interpretation of"aberrant" 1. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. (2005). drelated behaviors.Journal q/American Pkysicicaus Initial screening, admission procedures, and assessment Intru t Swe nus. 9(l) 25_28. techniques. In Y/e(1iccrtion-assisted treaaoent for opioid 4. National Drug Intelligence Center. (2004,April). addiction it, opioid treatment programs(pp. 43-61). Pharmaceuticals. In National drag threat assessment Treatment Improvement Protocol 43, DHHS Publication 7004. Johnstown, PA: Author. Retrieved October 2, No. (SMA)05-4048. Rockville, MD: Substance Abuse 2007, from littp:town, PA: Author. Retrieved /8731/ October and Mental Health Services Administration. 2. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. (2006). 8731p.pdf Detoxification and substance abuse treatment. Treatment Improvement Protocol 45, DHHS Publication No. (SNIA) 06-4131. Rockville, bID: Substance Abuse and Mental Continued on page t Health Services Administration. Substance Abuse Treatment axu — s.:Y jVews for the Treatment Field � 3b A OXYCONTIN®: Y R . PRESCRIPTION DRUG ABUSE-- 2008 REVISION F OxyContimk) Frequently I'M From the CSAT Director Asked Questions r by H. westley Clark, M.D.,1.D., M.P.H.,CAS, PASAM Q: What is OxyContin? OxyContin"was initially heralded as a miracle A: OxyContin is a semisynthetic opioid analgesic medication that allowed patients with chronic pain prescribed for chronic or long-lasting pain.The to resume a normal life. Unfortunately, the abuse medication's active ingredient is oxycodone, of OxyContin continues to grow.According to the which is also found in medications such as r National Survey on Drug Use and Health, misuse Percodan'"' and Tylox1o. However,OxyContin t . of OxyContin among people in the United States contains between 10 and 80 milligrams (mg) of ficantly increased every year oxycodone in a timed-release tablet. Painkillers ages 12 and older signi ' ' from 2002 to 20069 In 2006, approximately 4 million such as Tylox'D contain 5 mg of oxycodone people ages 12 and older reported using OxyContin and often require repeated doses to bring about for nonmedical uses at least once in their lifetime, pain relief because they lack the timed-release ' and more than 500,000 were new nonmedical users.° formulation. Among youth, although past-year use oFOxy2 0 flow is Ox Contin used? in { in the 12th grade decreased from 5.5 percent in 2005 Q: > y O C. to 4.3 percent in 2006, it increased among 8th graders A: OxyContin, also referred to as 'Ox , from 1.3 percent in 2002 to 2.6 percent in 2006. Drug Killer," "Ox " "Oxy Catton," "Ory80;' and Abuse warning Network data indicated a 17-percent `kicker" on the street, is legitimately prescribe) increase in emergency hospital visits for nonmedical as a tinted-release tablet, providing as many as use of oxycodone products from 2004 to'2005J0 12 hours of pain relief. It is often prescribed for cancer patients or those with chronic, long-lasting Because of this increasing misuse of OxyContin in tin. The benefit of the medication to people who the United States, it is important for professionals on Suffcr from chronic pain is that they generally need the front line of substance abuse treatment to have to take the pill only twice a day, whereas a Dosage x the facts about OxyContin, its use and abuse, and of another medication would require more frequent how to treat individuals who present for treatment of of OxyContin use and abuse. Perhaps these individuals {. ._cun(innrd on page ion(uuled nn page 2 k. s9r, f $qe �P $ t s Sa �,,d, ''' ,fps "4. •Frf h° 1 Y r x 4p., ti of-,i}"^ e �f. y,. n " a y' '3s ,d n �•tr} r +E 4r 4x':Y� GSC ,ash > sgT 4a .a"�•., ( , , 1 n ', Gt j � ♦ x a 5. p�.e x 5 '�, v � Y ! . f 7,. )' . .t�1�� f^ art)� *Sr �i 7 �Y 3'N`a�t�(n i'sA;•F�°'S �` ...�F. ��,'��{.. 4.°. ... .... 1v.+.a.w r..�� f,/."'�r.��fY Cf�r�i...f."�i�]9R_"�Yx$Ki.'Y.'"e"..a...-.w3��tiw�.93u�+t£ •m' .its 'ta.+'_3'-°r.:..•r7rn,.�mu�r�.a- Summer 2008, Vulumc 7, Issue I Substance Abuse Treatment IAO i l S (Jfq y .............. ......... ........ ..... .................. . .... . .................. From the Director OxyConting Frequently Asked : _ct�nti,n,eei,t�n,y„ntcot e, q Y Questions ...continue(Ohmn front cover are taking medically prescribed OxyContin to manage use to control the pain. The goal of chronic pain treatment pain and are concerned about their physical dependence is to decrease pain and improve function. on the medication. Perhaps they are young adultswho thought that OxyContin was a"safe” recreational drug Q: flow is OxyContin abused9 because, atter all, doctors prescribe it. Possibly changes A: People who abuse OxyContin either crush the tablet in the availability or quality of illicit opioid drugs in and ingest or snort it or dilute it in water and inject it. the community have led to abuse of and addiction to Crushing or diluting the tablet disarms the timed-release OxyContin. action of the medication and causes a quick, powerful Whatever the reason, OxyContin is being abused, and high. Those who abuse OxyContin have compared this people are becoming addicted.And in many instances, feeling to the euphoria they experience when taking these people are young adults unaware of the dangers of heroin. In fact, in some areas, the use of heroin is OxyContin. Many of these individuals mix OxyContin overshadowed by the abuse of OxyContin. with alcohol and drugs, and the result is all too often tragic. Q: flow does OxyContin abuse differ from abuse of Abuse of prescription medications is not a new phenom- other pain prescriptions? enon. There have long been concerns about abuse of A: Abuse of prescription pain medications is not new. Percocetg, hydrocodone, and a host of other medications. Two primary factors, however, set OxyContin abuse apart What sets OxyContin abuse apart is the potency of the from other prescription drug abuse. First, OxyContin is a medication. Treatment providers in affected areas say powerfid medication that contains a much larger amount that they were unprepared for the speed with which an of the active ingredient, oxycodone, than other prescription OxyContin"epidemic"developed in their communities. pain relievers. It was designed as a controlled release It is important to be prepared for the increasing number tablet. However, by crushing the tablet and either ingesting of clients who are dependent on OxyContin. This revised or snorting it or by injecting diluted OxyContin, people issue of the original Substance Abuse Treatment Advisory who abuse the opioid feel its powerfid effects in a short on OxyContin: time, rather than over a 12-11our span. Second, great profits can be made in the illegal sale of OxyContin. A 40-mg pill • Answers frequently asked questions about OxyContin • Provides general information about semisynthetic costs approximately e by prescription, yet it may sell for whi$40 h the street, depending on the area of the country in opioids and their addiction potential • Summarizes evidence-based protocols for treatment which the drug is sold. • Provides resources for further information. OxyContin can be comparatively inexpensive if it is For more information about OxyContin abuse and legitimately prescribed and if its cost is covered by ., 1. insurance. However, the National Drug Intelligence Center treatment, see the resource box on p. e 4. Feel free to reports that people who abuse OxyContin may use heroin copy the information in the Substance Abuse Treatment Advisory and share it with colleagues so that they, too, f their insurance will Prescription because heeo longer pay for their OxyContin can have tine nnost current information about this critical) roin is less expensive than Y important topic. 7 OxyContin that is purchased illegally.+ ._continue,lon page i L p,yd +1• . tq. _.}t f4 k �4 �'. f t4"s^:,tC.`e3 l�'� � (, .f Substance Abuse rreutment Summer 2008, t�ryCoillI ADVI S o Ry ............................. ....... ................... ................... . . . Notes ...continued horn Paye 6 5. National Drug intelligence Center. (2004, August). Itrtelligenee bulletin: OxyContin diversion, availability, and abuse. Johnstown, PA:Author. Retrieved February 20, 2008, from http://usdoj.gov/ndlc/ pubsl0/10550/10550p.pdf Treatment Improvement 6. National institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA). (2006, Protocols (TIPs) and June). Prescription pain and other medications Collateral Products [Electronic Versionj. NIDA InjbFacts. Retrieved Addressing Opioid Addiction October 2, 2007, from http://drugabuse.gov/ infofacts/PainMed.html Treatment 7. Riley, 1., Eisenberg, E., Muller-Schwefe, G., TiP 40 Clinical Guidelinesfor the Use of Drewes, A. M., &Arendt-Nielsen, L. (2008). Oxycodone: Buprenorphine in the Treatment of Opioid A review of its use in the management of pain. Current •4ddic1i0n (SMA) 07-3939 Uedical Research and Opinion, 24(l), 175-192. Quick Guidefor Physicians Based on 8. Rosenblum,A., Parrino, M., Schnoll, S. H., TIP 40 QGPT40 Fong, C., Maxwell, C., Cleland, C. M., et al. (2007). Prescription opioid abuse among enrollees into K4P Keys for Physicians Based on methadone maintenance treatment. Drug and rt lcolnnl TIP 40 KAPT40 Dependence, 90(l), 64-71. TiP 43 Medication-Assisted Treatment for Opioid 9. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Addiction in Opioid Treatment Programs BKD524 Administration, Office of Applied Studies. (2007). Quick Guidefor Clinicians Based on Results from the 2006 National Survey on Drug Use TIP 43 QGCT43 and flealth: lVational findings. NSDUH Series II-32, DHHS Publication No. (SMA) 07-4293. Rockville, K4PKeyrforClinicimnsBased on MD: Author. TiP 43 (SMA) 07-4108 10. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services TIP 45 Detoxication and SubstanceAbnse Administration, Office of Applied Studies. (2007). Treatment BKD541 Drug Abuse Warning Nenvork. 2005: National Quick Gulde for Clinicians Based on estimates u%thug-related emetgency department TIP 45(SMA) 06-4225 visits. Rockville, MD: Author. Retrieved August 16, 2007, from http://dawninfo.sanihsa.gov/files/ Quick GuidefijrAdministrators Based DAWN-E D-20115-Web.pdf. on TIP 45(SMA) 06-4226 KAP Keys for Clinicians Based on TiP 45 (SNiA) 064224 a '? WE 11 'Er�" M i a R summer 2008, Volume 7, Issue I Substance Abuse Treatment A � C1 R Y ................................................................ ... Substance Abuse Treatment Advisory Substance Abuse Treatment Advisory published on an as-needed basis for treatment providers—was ritten and produced under contract number 270-04-7049 by the Knowledge Application Program(KAP), Venture oJo f 1BS Intemational, Inc.,and The CDM Group, Inc., for the Center for Substance Abuse Treatment (CSAT), Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration(SAMHSA), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services(DHHS). Disclaimer: The views,opinions, and content expressed herein do not necessarily reflect the views,opinions, or policies of CSAT, SAMHSA, or DHHS. No official support of or endorsement by CSAT, SAMHSA, or DHHS for these opinions or for particular instruments, software,or resources is intended or should be inferred. Public Domain Notice:All materials appearing in this volume except those taken directly from copyrighted sources are in the public domain and may be reproduced or copied without permission from SAMHSA/CSAT or the authors. Citation of the source is appreciated. However, this publication may not be reproduced or distributed for a fee without the specific,written authorization of the office of Communications, SAMHSA, DHHS. his publication may be downloaded or ordered Electronic Access and Copies of Publication:T http://www.samhsa.gov/shin. Or,please call SAMHSA's Health Information Network at 1-877-SAMHSA-7 (1-877-726-4727)(English and Espatiol). Recommended Citation: Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. (2008). OxyContin�: Prescription Drug Abuse-2008 Revision. Substance Abuse Tieatnent;advisory, Volume 7, Issue 1. Rockville, MD: Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. A� A Life In the Community for Everyone DHHS Publication No. (SMA)08-4138 / � "nta�Ger `�t� .,ubiiance Abnsea J Printed 2008 u.e.o.wnm,mwwmma nemn e.,.,cn ............. ............... ........ Sign up for SAMHSXS eNetwork Today! The Substance Abuse and biental Health Services Administration's(SAbIHSA's)eNetwork is your personal link to SAMHSA for the latest news about grants, publications, campaigns, programs, statistics, and data reports. Join the eNetwork and indicate your areas of interest. You'll receive up-to-the-minute information that's important to you—right in your inbox. Visit http://Nvlvw.santhsa.gov/enetwork and click Join the eNetwork. f NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES have shown persistent withdrawal other means. This may be because clogging the blood vessels that signs for many months. Heroin the patient in pain is simply lead to the lungs, liver, kidneys,'4 Withdrawal is never fatal to seeking relief of pain and not or brain. This can cause infection otherwise healthy adults, but it the rush sought by the addict. or even death of small patches can cause death to the fetus of a pregnant addict. of cells in vital organs. Immune At some point during Contin- What are reactions to these or other conta- uous heroin use, a person can the medical ininants can cause arthritis or become addicted to the drta other rheumatologic problems. Sometimes addicted inclivid ials complications of Of com:se, sharing of injection Will endure many of the with- chronic heroin use? equipment or tlrids cull lend drawal symptoms to reduce their to some of the most severe edical consequences of consegrcnce.s of heroin abuse— call again for the drug so that they chronic heroin injection infections with hepatitis B and C, cin again experience the rush. use include scarred 1lIV, and a host of other blood- Physical dependence and and/or collapsed veins, bacterial borne viruses, which drug the emergence of withdrawal infections of the blood vessels abusers can then pass on to their symptoms were once believed and heart valves, abscesses to be the key features of heroin sexual partners and children. (boils) and other soft-tissue addiction. We now know this infections, and liver or kidney How does heroin may not be the case entirely, disease. Lung complications since craving and relapse can (including various types of abuse affect occur weeks and months after pneumonia and tuberCUIUSIS) pregnant women? withdrawal symptoms are long may result from the poor health gone. We also know that patients condition of the abuser as welleroin abuse during preg- with chronic pain who need as from heroin's depressingN114ated nancy and its many associ- opiates to function (sometimes effects on respiration. Many of (e environmental factors over extended periods) have few thmY be e additives in street heroin a g' lack s prenatal care) have if any problems leaving opiates include substances that do not en associated with adverse after their pain is resolved b consequences including low Y readily dissolve and result in birth weight, an important risk factor for later developmental .: delay. rylethadone maintenance combined with prenatal care and a comprehensive drug treatment Short-Term Effects: Long-Term Effects: program can improve many of is 'Rush" the detrimental maternal and x Addiction neonatal outcomes associated a Depressed respiration ' Infectious diseases, for with untreated heroin abuse, • Clouded mental functioning example, HIV/AIDS and although infants exposed to a Nausea and vomiting hepatitis B and C methadone during pregnancy • Suppression of pain 7 Collapsed veins typically require treatrnent for • Spontaneous abortion a Bacterial infections withdrawal symptoms. In the 7 Abscesses United States, several studies A Infection of heart lining have tOunCI buprenorphine to and valves be equally effective and as safe. ;2 Arthritis and other as methadone in the adult out- rheumatologic problems patient treatment of opioid dependence. Givcn this efficacy NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES o e e e e e e e e • e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e What are the long-term effects of heroin use? U, Z. nc of the most dctrimencil tel ill effects of heroin ' , �' ""` . '- - rk �� •• otic is addiction thclf. x t �zL Adchduon is a chronic relapsing y disease, charxte rued by coil' seeking and use, pulstve drug <,. ' �, t `� •�. �,,. `+ �`•� '�3'i � �, and by neurochemical and molecular changes in the hrun. 3s ��.: -:r:• Heroin also produces profound degrees of tolerance and physical tJ 1 +,:>3 �•! n 1 I I I I . , r • r I y,y�. dependence, which are also 4� T powerful motivating factors for as compulsive use and abuse. As �; _=��•" with abusers of any addictive a� drug, heroin abusers gradually spend more and more time and 1 1 I I I I energy obtaining and using the drug. Once they are addicted, ' 1 r 11 1 I 1 1 r I the heroin tlxisers' primary 1 j P , .� � I I 1 �•: - purpose in lite becomes seeking and rising drugs. The chugs literally change their brains and their behavior. What are the it threes the brain so rapidly. physical dependence develops With heroin, the rush is usually immediate (short- accompanied by a warm flushing with higher closes of the drug. of the skin, dry mouth, and a With physical dependence, the term) effects of heavy feeling in the extremities, body adapts to the presence heroin use? which maybe accompanied by of the drug and withdrawal •ooh after injection Cor svm Moms occur if use is nausea, vomiting, "In(l severe reduced abruptly. Withdrawal itching. ., inhalation), heroin crosses ilia occur within a few hours the blood–brain barrier In After the initial effects, abusers Y usually will be drowsy for several after the last time the drug is the brain, heroin is converted to morphine and binds rapidly to hours. dental function is clouded taken. tiymptans of withdrawal opioid receptors. Akwsers typically by heroin's effect on the central include restlessness, muscle and report feeling a surge of plcasur nevous system. Cardiac function bone pain, insomnia, diarrhea, slows. Breathing is also severely vomiting, cold flashes with goose able sensation—a "cosh." The hum )s ("Cold turkey") and leg intensity of the rush is a function slowed, sontetimcs to the point I of how much drug is taken and of death. Het (A(f is a movements. iA-l:yor withdrawal p articular risk on the street, symptoms peak between Z I and how rapidly die drug enters the where the amount and purity of hu ors after the last dose of brain incl binds to rhe natural the drug cannot be �iccurately heroin incl subside after about a opioid receptors. Heroin is week. f lowever, some people particularly addictive because known. NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES I 11111t-rig; patients to Stop using heroin (alio other opt ties) and return to p r ' more stable and productive lives. �• .> Methadone dosages must be carefully monitored in patients who are receiving antiviral therapy for E Ily infection, to avoid $ potential medication interactions. }� A New Medication for Treating Opiate Addiction i ■ First medication developed to treat opiate addiction in the Saprenorphine and other privacy of a physician's office. ■ Binds to same receptors as morphine, but does not produce medications the same effects. 13tprcnorphine is a particularly ■ Offers a valuable tool for physicians in treating the nearly attractive treatment for heroin 900,000 chronic heroin users in the U.S. addiction because, compared ■ As of March 2004, 3,951 U.S. physicians were eligible to with other rnedie'tLions, such as prescribe buprenorphine to patients. methadone, it causes weaker opiate effects and is less likely The Story of Discovery to cause overdose problems. 1 ■ First synthesized as an analgesic in England, 1969. Buprenot'phine also produces ■ Recognized as a potential addiction treatment by NIDA a lower level of physical depen- researchers in the 1970s. clence, so patients who discon- tinue the medication generally ■ NIDA created Medications Development Division to focus have fewer withdrawal symptoms on developing drug treatments for addiction, 1990. ■ NIDA formed an agreement with the original developer to than do those %vho stop taking bring buprenorphine to market in the U.S., 1994. methadone. Because of these; ■ Buprenorphine tablets approved by the FDA, 2002. advantages, buprenorphine tnry he appropriate for use in a wider variety of treatment set withdrawal symptoms which have emotional reactions. Most tings than the currently available peak ra to 72 hours after the last important, methadone relieves medications. several other tried- peak dose and disappear within the waving associated with heroin ications with potential for treating clI 7 to 10 clays, to be followed by a addiction; craving is a ina;or fn`heroeurret tly under ioverdose orrnvestig:tion longer term abstinence syndrotne reason for relapse. Among of general malaise and opioid methadone patients, it has been byINI11 Dld. n to methadone craving. found that normal street closes of heroin are ineffective at pro- and buprenorphine, other drugs programs aimed at reducing the severity of p g during euphoria, thus making the withdrawal symptoms can be Methadone treatment has been the use of heroin more easily used for more than 30 years to presa'ibed. Clonidine is of some extinguishable' benefit holt its use: is limited clue effectively and safely neat opioid IN lethadotie's effects I:ut tow' to side effects of sedation and addiction. Properly prescribed w six times as long as those of methadone is not intoxicating or heroin, so people in treatment hypotension. Lufexi adr a ren sedating, and its effects do not need to take it only once a clav. wally acting alpha 2 adrenergic onist, was launched in 19)2 interfere with ordinary activities Also, methadone is medically safe ag even when used continuously specifically ftx symptomatic such as driving a c:u'. "the tried- <<oin,, ication is taken orally and it for 10 years or more. Combined relief in patients undo:., k suppresses narcotic withch'awal with hehavioral therapies or opiate withdrawal. Naloxone for 2-i to 0 hours. P:uicnts counseling and other supportive Mid naltrexone are ntcclications are abli� to tierccive pain and services, methadone c'nahles that also block the effects of NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES 1 , r I , 1 r , tends to he more effective when heroin abuse is identified early. The treatments that follow vary drugalluse.gov/M depending on the individual, but methadone, a synthetic opiate that blocks the effects of heroin i '''% ``'` and eliminates withdrawal symptoms, has it proven record •iiRi• of success for people addicted to heroin. Other pharmaceutical approaches, such as buprenor- phine, and many behavioral therapies also are used for treating heroin addiction. Buprenorphine Stare:highlighted mrrentlyhave is a recent addition to the array [TN Nodes inplare. of medications now available for treating addiction to heroin ;and other opiates. This medication among adults, current studies aur Injection drug users (IDUs) is different from methadone attempting to establish the safety represent the highest risk group in that it offers less risk of and effectiveness of buprenor- for acquiring HCV infection; addiction and can be prescribed phine in opioid-clependent an estimates! 70 to 80 percent of in the privacy of a doctor's pregnant women. For women the 35,000 new HCV infections office. Buprenorphine/naloxone who do not want or are not able occurring in the United States (Suboxone) is a combination to receive pharmacotherapy for each year are aunong IDUs. drug product formulated to their heroin addiction, detoxi- NIDA-funded research has minimize abuse. fication from opiates during found that drug abusers can , , , pregnancy can be accomplished change the behaviors that put Defoxifliatlon with relative safety, although the them at risk for contracting HIV Detoxification programs aim likelihood of relapse to heroin through dntg abuse treatment, to achieve safe and humane use should he considered prevention, and community- withdrawal from opiates by mini- based outreach programs. They rnizing the severity of withdrawal Whyare heroin can eliminate drug use, drug- symptoms and other medical related risk behaviors such acs complications. The primary users at special needle sharing, uu unsafe sexual objective of cletoxification is to risk for contractingpractices, and, in turn, the risk relieve withdrawal symptoms of exposure to I-IIV/AIDS and while patients adjust to a drug- HIV/AIDS and other infectious diseases. Drug free state. Not in itself a treatment hepatitis B and C� =abuse prevention and treatment for addiction, detoxification is a • are highly effective in preventing useful step only when it leads Broin users are at risk for the spread of 1-IIV. into long-term treatment that is contracting FI V, hepatitis C either drug-free (residential or (HCV), and other infectious What are the ou(patient) or uses medications diseases, through sharing andas part of the treatment. The best reuse of syringes and injection treatments for documented drug-free treatments eatents paraphernalia that have been heroin addiction? are the therapeutic conununity. used by infected individuals, residential programs lasting 3 to variety of effective treat 6 ninths. or through unprotected sexual mems uc avail tole for contact with an infected person. heroin addiction. bcatment Eltal.�Itatis charalcteuizled by ;acute NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES heroin in the past year, and the Detroit, Los Angeles, Newark, heroin use anumg aciclictecl group that representecl the high- New York, and San Francisco. users seeking treatment; in many est number of those users were e CEWG areas, heroin injection is that, t, older. The survey reported How is heroin used? reporteclly on the rise, while that, from 1995 through 2002, the • :uuural number c)F new heroin eroin is usually injected, heroin inhalation is cleclining. However, certain groups, such users ranged from 121,000to sniffed/snorted, or smoked. � 164,000. During I as White suburbanites in the this Period most Typically, a heroin abuser new users were age 18 or older may inject up to four times a Denver area, report smoking or (on average, 75 Percent and inhaling heroin because they b', P clay. Intravenous injection pro- most were male. In "2003, 57.4 vides the greatest intensity and believe that these routes of Percent of past year heroin usersadministration are less likely to most rapid onset of euphoria lead to addiction. were classifiecl with dependence (7 to 8 seconcls), while intra- on or abuse of heroin, and an With the shift in heroin abuse muscular injection produces a estiPatterns comes an even more mated 231,000 persons Pa received treatment for heroin relatively slow onset of euphoria diverse group of users. In recent! abuse. (5 to 8 minutes). When heroin }ears, the availability of higher According to the Monitoring is sniffed or smoker!, peak purity heroin (which is more effects are usually Felt within 10 suitable for inhalation) and the the Future susTey, N[DA's to IS minutes. NIDA researchers nationwicle annual survey of decreases in prices reportecl in have confirmed that all forms many areas have increased the drug use among tine Nation's of heroin achninistration are 8th-, 10th-, and 12th-graders, appeal of heroin for new users addictive. heroin use rewho are reluctant to inject. matined stable From Injection continues to he Heroin has also been appearing 2003 to 2004. Lifetime heroin the predominant method of in more aftluent communities. use measured 1.6 percent among 8th-graders and 1.5 percent among loth- incl 12th-graclers , The 2002 Drug Abuse W:unulg Network (DAWN), which collects data on drug-related hospital emergency clepartanent (ED) 100 Inhaled Injected episodes from 21 metropolitan 90 ;(tells, reported that in 2002, 80 heroin-relatecl ED episocles 70 numberecl 93,519. 60 NlDA's Comnunlity Epidenlio- 50 Icgy Work Group (CEWG), which provides information about the 40 nann'e and Patterns of d30rug ' use in 21 areas. reported in its 20 December 2003 publication that 10 k heroin wasnlentionecl as the 0 i primary drug of abuse for I:uk e Atlanta L.A. Miami/ Minneapolis/ New York San South Florida St.Paul city Fronristo portions of drug abuse treatment alllrlissl(>ns til llattrmol'e, Boston, Samte:(oamurim,(pidemiologyWork Gump,TDA,December 2003,1'01.11, 'Iodides first half 2003 data from r1mallenr fnodmes. 1 NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES • • o 0 0 o e e o 0 0 o e o e o e o e e o e o e o e o e o e o 0 0 o e o e o o e o e e o e e o e o o e o e e o 0 o e o 0 0 0 o e e o 0 o e e o o e Glossary References Addiction:A chronic,relapsing disease, Community Epidemiology Work Group.Epidemiologic Trends Maas,U. Kanner,E.;WeingarFJesse,B.;Schafer,A;and in Drug Abuse, Vol.II,Proceedings of the Community Obladen,M.Infrequent neonatal opiate withdrawal characterized by compulsive drug seeking and use and by neurochemical and molecular changes Epidemiology Work Group,December 2003.NIH Pub. following maternal methadone detoxificafion during in the brain: No.04-5365.Bethesda,NO:NIDA,NIH,DHHS,2004. pregnancy./Pennot Med 18(2):111-118, 1990. Agonist:A chemical compound that mimics the Dashe,J.S.;Jackson,G.l.;Olscher,D.A.;Zone,E.H.;and Mathias,R.NIDA survey provides first national data on drug action of a natural neurotransmitter to produce a Wendel,G.D.,Jr.Opioid detoxification in pregnancy. abuse during pregnancy.NIDA NOTES 10:6-7,1995. biological response. Obstet Gynecol 92(5):854-858,1998. Narcotic Messinger,U.S.;Dauer,C.R.;Das,A.;Seiler,R.;tester,B.M.; Dale,V.P.;Nyswunder,M.E.;and Kreek,M.1,No Analog:A chemical compound that is similar to kdAh iMed 118(4):304-30rcotic . Lagasse,L.L.;Wright,LL;Shankman,S.;Bodo,H.S.; blocae. rcntern another drug in its effects but differs slightly in its Smeriglio,V.L.;Langer,J.(.;Beeghlg M.;and Poole, chemical structure. Goldstein,A.Heroin addiction:Neurology,pharmacology,and W,K.The maternal lifestyle study:cognitive,motor,and Antegonist:A drug that counteracts or blocks policy.J Psychoacfive Drugs 23(2):123-133,1991. behavioral outcomes of cocaineexposed and opiate.. the effects of another drug. Hughes,P.H.;and Rieche,0.Heroin epidemics revisited. exposed infants through three years of age.Pediatrics Buprenorphine:A mixed opiate agonist/ FpidemiolRev 17(1):66-73,1995. 113(6):1611-1685,2004. antagonist medication for the treatment of heroin Hulse,G.N.;Milne,E.;English,D.R.;and Holman,C.D.J. National Institute on Drug Abuse."Heroin."NIDA Capsule. addiction. The relationship between maternal use of heroin and NIDA,1986. (raving methadone and infant birth weight.Addiction A powerful,often uncontrollable desire 92010571-1579,1997. Nafional Institute on Drug Abuse.IDUs and infecfious for drugs diseases.NIDA NOTES 9:15,1994. Detoxification:A process of oflovring the Jonsson,L.M.;SvikisF D.;Lean;andPoladi,P.;Rutigliano,P.; and Hackermon,E Pregnancy and addiction; National Institute on Drag Abuse.Monitoring the Furore, body to rid itself of a drug while managing the a comprehensive core model.Journal of Substance National Results on Adolescent Drug Use,Overview of Key symptoms of withdrawal;often the first step in a Abuse Treatment 13(4):321-329,1996. Findings 1004.NIH Pub.No.05-5726.Washington, drug treatment program. Fentanyl:A medically useful opioid analog that Jarvis,MA;and Schnoll,S.H.Methadone use during prep OC Supt.of Docs.,U.S.Govt.Print.Off.,2005. is 50 times more patent than heroin. noncy.NIDA Research Monograph 149,58-77,1995. Novick,U.M.;Richman,B.L;Friedman,J.M.;Friedman, Johnson,R.E.;Jones,H.F.;and Fischer,G..Use of I.E.;Fried,C.;Wilson,J.P.;Townley,A.;and Kieek,M.J. Meperldine:A medically approved'opioid avail buprenorphine in pregnancy:patient management and The medical status of methadone maintained patients in able under various brand names(e.g.,Demerol)• effects on neonate.Drug and Akohol Dependence treatment for 11-18 years.Drug and Alcohol Depend Methadone:A long-acting synthetic medication 70(2):587-5101,2003. 33(3):235-245,1993. shown to be effective in treating heroin addiction. Jones,H.E.Pmctical Considerations for the Clinical Use Physical dependence:An adaptive physiological of Buprenorphine.Science 8 Practice Perspech'ves Office of Applied Studies.Results from the 2003 National ,2004. Survey on Drug Use and Health:National findings. 2(2):4-20 state that occurs with regular drug use and results DHHS Pub.No.(SMA)04-3964.SAMHSA,2004. in a withdrawal syndrome when drug use is Kometsky,(.Action of opioid on the braircewaid system. stopped;usually occurs with tolerance. In:Ropoko,R.S.;and Sorer,H.;eds.Discovery Of Novel Office of National Drug Control Policy.Heroin facts Rush:A surge of euphoric pleasure that rapidly Opioid Medications.National Institute on Drug Abuse and figures.Rockville,MD,2004.Available of follows administration of a drug. Research Monograph 147.NIH Pub.No.95-3881. www.whitehousediugpolitygov/drugfoct/heioin/index.htrnl. Tolerance:A condition in which higher doses of Washington,DC:Supt.of Docs.,U.S.Govt.Print Off., Sabel,K.NIDA's AIDS projects succeed in reaching drug a drug are required to produce the same effect 1991,pp.32-52. oddim,changing high-risk behaviors.NIDA NOTES as during initial use;often leads to physical Kreek,M.J.Using methadone effectively:Achieving goals by 6:25-27,1991. dependence. applicafion of laboratory,clinical,and evaluation research on Mthdrowah A variety of symptoms that occur and by development of innovative programs.In:Pickens, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services aneAdmint Tends ober use of on addictive drug B reduced or stopped. R.;Leukefeld,C;and Schuster,CR.;eds.Improving Drug Off ice of Applied Stud es.Emergency Department Trends _ Abuse Treatment National Institute on Drug Abuse From the Drug Abuse Warning Network,Final Estimates Research Monograph 106.Washington,OC Supt.of 1995-2001.DHHS Pub.No.(SMA)63-3780. Oars.,U.S.Govt.Print.01T,1991,pp.245-266. Rockville,MD:SAMHSA,2003. NIDA Lewis,J.W.;and Walter, t Buprenorphine:Background to its Swan,N Research meat. 104 longterm benefits of development as a treatment for opiate dependence.In: methadone treatment.NIDA NOTES 9:1,4-5, 1994, Blaine,J.D.,ed.Buprenorphine:An Alternative for Opiale are.National Institute an Drug Abuse Research Woods,J.H.;France,C.P.;and Winger,G.D.Behavioral NATIONAL INSTITUTE Depende ON oauG ABUSE Monograph 121.DHHS Pub.No.(ADM)92-1912. pharmacology of buprenorphine:Issues relevant to its Washington,D(:Supt:of Docs.,U.S.Govt.Print.Off., potential in treating drug abuse.In:Bloin,J.D.,ed. NIH Publication Number OS 4165. 1992,pp.5-I1. Buprenorphine:An Alternative for Opiate Dependence. National on Drug Abuse Research Monograph Printed October 1997;Reprinted September 2000; Lury,J.;Nikolcou,V.;and Beam,J.Is opiate detoxifimtian 121.DHHS Pub.No.(ADM)92-1912.Washington,DC Revised May 2005. unsafe in pregnancy?J Subst Abuse Treat Su t of Docs.,U.S.Govt.Print.Off., 1992,pp. 12-21. Feel free to reprint this publication. 24(4):363-361,2003. P � r NIDA RESEARCH REPORT SERIES morphine, heroin, and other use, and to increase skills in opiateWhere can get s. As antagonists, they are coping with vau'ious life stressors. especially useful as antidotes. Both behavioral and pharinaco- further scientific Naltrexone has long-lasting logical treatments help to restore information about effects, ranging from 1 to 3 clays, a degree of normalcy to brain depending on the dose. function and behavior, with heroin abuse and Naltrexone blocks the pleasurable increased employment rates addiction? effects of heroin and is useful in and lower risk of HIV and other treating some highly motivated diseases and criminal behavior. 3lo learn more about heroin individuals Naltrexone has also r and other drugs of abuse, been found to he successful inWhat are the contact the National Clearing- preventing relapse by former . . house for Alcohol and Drug opiate addicts released frons opioid analogs Infornnation (NCADD at prison on probation. • 7 1-800-729-6686. Information an their dangers? specialists g p cialists are availahle to help Behavioral therapies ou locate information and P Dto IUg allalOf),5 aI'e' ClnenllCal yAlthough behavioral and conlpowulS that are similar resources. pharmacologic treatments can be other drugs in their Fact sheets, including extremely useful when employed effects hnt differ slightly in their hYbi-acts, on the health effects alone, science has taught us that chemical structure. Sonne analogs of heroin, other drugs of abuse, integrating both types of treat- are produced by pharmaceutical land other drug abuse topics are ments will ultimately be the connpanies for legitimate nnedical available on the NIDA Web site (www.dr most effective approach. There reasons. Other analogs, some- ugabuse.gov), and are many effective behavioral times referred to as "designer" can be ordered free of charge in treatments available for heroin drugs, can he produced in illegal English and Spanish frons addiction. These can include laboratories and are often snore NCADI a[ www.health.org. residential and outpatient dangerous and potent than the approaches. An important task original drug. Two of the most Access information is to match the hest treatment commonly known opioid on the Internet approach to nneet the particular analogs are fentanyl and nneperi- • What's new on the NIDA Web site needs of the patient. iNforeover, cline (nnarketed under the brand • Information on drugs of abuse several new behavioral therapies, naune Dennerol, for example). • publications and communications such as contingency nnanaigement Fentanyl was introduced in (including NIDA NOTES) therapy and cognitive-hehavioral 1968 by a Belgian pharmaceutical • Information on clinical trials through CTN interventions, show particular company as a synthetic narcotic • Calendar of events promise as treatments for heroin to he used as all analgesic in • links to NIDA organizational units addiction, especially when sul,,ical procedures because of • Funding Information(indudingprogram applied in concert with phot' is minimal effects on the heart, announcements and deadlines) inacotherapies. Contingency Fentanyl is particularly (lith emus 0 Links to International eb s y pa y g links to related Web sites (access to nnanagenlent therapy uses a because it is 50 tines more Web sites of many other organizations voucher-based system, where potent than heroin and can in the field) patients earn "points" haled rapiclly stop respiration This is on negatve drug tests, which not a problem dung sui;gic.rl r , they c.un exchange for itenhs procedures because machines • that encourage healthy living. arc used to help patients hrearthc Cc«nitve behavioral in[erven- On the street, however, users tions are designed to help have been found Clad with [11 r n modify the patient's expectations needle used to inject the drug and behaviors related to clrirg shill in his or her ar111. Forum A Community-Centered Solution for Opioid Addiction 'Iethadone Maintenance Treatment (MM1 ) Stewart B. Leavitt, PhD, Editor, Addiction Treatment Forum Addiction to heroin and other opioids poses become productive tax-paying citizens in their serious problems for communities, families, and communities. Yet, the merits and effectiveness of individuals. Solutions sometimes seem uncertain, addiction treatment in general and MMT in difficult, and controversial. particular have not been universally understood During more than 40 years since its develop- and accepted. ment, methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) This booklet focuses on the evidence-based con- has helped millions of persons in recovery from clusions and educated commentary of credible opioid addiction; allowing them to improve their sources to provide a current and balanced per- health, redeem their family and social lives, hold spective on the treatment of opioid addiction with down steady jobs or return to school, and generally methadone. Facts & Consequences of Opioid Addiction in America rr r •/ y Understanding Addiction As A Brain Disease At one time, drug addiction was viewed as a failure of willpower or a flaw s sort of moral character. It was not recognized as a disease of the brain, in the same t :. way that mental illnesses previously were not viewed as such. Medical authori- ties have now accepted drug addiction as a chronic, relapsing disorder that � I alters normal brain function, just as any other neurological or psychiatric illness. Its development and expression are influenced by genetic, biological, psychoso- cial, and environmental factors. Outwardly, drug addiction is often characterized by impaired control over continued drug use, compulsive use despite harmful consequences, and/or intolerable drug craving." Addiction to opioid drugs is particularly insidious because the brain producesAddiction tragically its own opioid substances (e.g., endorphins) that are vital for survival. In effect, tricks the brain into the brain is "tricked" by external, short-acting opioid agents into responding as thinking opioid drugs if they are biologically essential. Once addiction sets in, brain chemistry becomes are needed for unbalanced, and the person becomes physically, emotionally, and mentally opioid drug survival.dysfunctional unless more o P g is regularly taken._Chronic opioid abuse causes physiologic derangements lasting months or years after the last drug- taking episode. So, even if opioid-abstinence is eventually achieved, relapses are common without ongoing therapy of some sort." 2 c. Many public officials and healthcare providers have expressed a strong bias favoring "drug-free" treatment and eschewing the use of my medications Dedication free during recovery.' However, such therapies for opioid addiction alone cannot stabilize the chemical upsets associated with addiction and return brain therapies alone function to a more normal state. cannot stabilize The common stereotype depicts opioid-addicted persons as social misfits the chemical and outcasts; however, such addiction is common throughout all segments of upsets Of Opioid society and in every community., Widely available and affordable access to addiction. effective, community-based clinics providing methadone maintenance for the disorder provides a viable solution for helping to stem America's opioid-drug addiction crisis. Heroin Continues To Take A Toll In the most recent reports, nearly 4 million Americans were classified as dependent on or abusing illicit substances, and heroin addiction has continued G`4r as a major concern.' Heroin is derived from opium — as are morphine and codeine—a product of the poppy plant and classified as an opiate narcotic. A broader term, 'opioid," encompasses opium by-products and the many synthetic drugs (such as, oxycodone, hydrocodone, propoxyphene, and others a, including methadone) with properties similar to opium.:,' The White House's Office of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP) has estimated that there are more than 800,000 untreated chronic heroin users in the United States, although this number is probably undercounted.' Data on ad- missions to substance abuse treatment programs indicate that heroin dependence has surpassed cocaine in some cases to become the most common diagnosis behind alcoholism. Of interest, admissions for heroin use via inhalation have + been increasing due to its higher purity.'' High-purity, low-price, Reports from drug enforcement agencies indicate that during the past 2 heroin appeals to decades heroin has become 30 times less expensive while its purity has increas- ed more than 10-fold. A heroin "fix" can be purchased for as little as $S and its Youth, resulting in purity exceeds 70% in some major cities?" Availability of low-cost, high-purity addiction, the spread heroin has fostered increased use, since it can be smoked, snorted, or otherwise of serious diseases, inhaled without the need for injection needles. This has attracted many new and fatal drug users among youth, white, and middle class pop ulations.=' Their experimen- OUerdoses. tation eventually leads to injection and more severe addiction, and miscal- culations of drug purity have led to fatal overdoses.'" The impact on public health has been severe. A typical intravenous-heroin abuser may inject 4 or more times each day and this has been associated with many serious communicable diseases, including: HIV/AIDS, hepatitis B and C, and tuberculosis. More than a third of all adult and adolescent AIDS cases reported in the U.S. have been associated with injection drug use. The preva- lence of hepatitis C among intravenous-drug users ranges up to 90%,'" and two-thirds may be infected with hepatitis B.'° Drug abusers are from 2 to 6 times more likely to contract tuberculosis than nonusers," and almost half of the patients in some opioid addiction treatment programs have positive tuberculin skin tests.' Finally, during the 1990s, heroin-related emergency department visits more than doubled and the annual death toll increased by 74%.1,11 k Forum 3 Opioid Analgesics Are A Major Concern One of the most troubling and increasing problems facing American commu- nities is the abuse of opioid analgesic medications (painkillers), which has been associated with addiction, drug overdoses, and deaths. The prevalence of prescription-opioid abuse has surpassed illicit drug abuse."" For example, in 2002 an estimated 4.4 million persons took pain relievers for non-medical purposes, compared with 3.9 million persons who abused an illicit substance, such as heroin, cocaine, etc.' Because methadone has become more widely prescribed as a potent °xycodone ,r s and cost-effective analgesic, it has been misused along with other o i- U. Id oids like oxycodone, hydrocodone, and morphine." Consequently, p throughout the past decade, there have been sharp increases in hospital Methadone r& emergency department visits associated with opioid analgesics (see Morphine a graph)," and also an upsurge in widely publicized overdose deaths attributed to these drugs. Hydrocodone i As with any other opioid drug, methadone can be dangerous and °" life-threatening if improperly used, and there have been long-standing con- Increases in emergency cerns about the diversion of methadone for illicit purposes.ls However, in 1995, department visits. a distinguished committee assembled by the Institute of Medicine concluded that, "the actual level of abuse and harm from illicit methadone falls short of its hypothetical potential for abuse... and is small relative to heroin and cocaine."19 Still, there were increasing reports of methadone-associated deaths in some communities during 2001 to 2003. MMT clinics were blamed as the source of oivt:I iLa drum. dnd Ment is a cost et,°r;rve:>,dau Mt v4 L&r dr--- that,shn•lld he curtailed." In response, an expert panel convened by the governmern; ` Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) unanimously concluded that opioid analgesics in general, most often combined with other drugs or alcohol, were the major source of the problems. Methadone itself was documented as the sole and direct cause of death in relatively few cases, and the greatest source of the 11130t01da my Her17%nly. '. drug came from its prescription by physicians as a painkiller; not from 2� MMT clinics." In fact, MMT programs provide a valuable service to their communi- N ties by treating residents who, for one reason or another, become he o tends Herotn.t addicted to opioid painkillers. In one study, more than 80% of patients thehen P � I n Heroin flz35%\\\ admitted to MMT programs had been using prescription opioid medica- tions at higher than therapeutic dosages, with or without heroin (see pie graph).'° Nearly half had started their addiction by first misusing analgesics and 24% were being treated solely for opioid-analgesic dependency. The majority of patients initiated opioid use due to ongoing pain problems, rather than recreational use.d0 However, experts have cautioned that fears of producing dependency on opioid medications should not deter their appropri- ate prescription for patients in pain who would benefit From them. Pain is seriously undertreated in the U.S. and reducing the availability of opioid analgesics would exacerbate that problem." t 4 How Methadone Maintenance Treatment (MMT) Works eu 3 yY Maria Beneficial Effects Of Methadone For Opioid Addiction Methadone was developed by German scientists in the late 1930s. It was � •. approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 1947 as a x painkiller, and by 1950 oral methadone also was used to treat the painful r 4 symptoms of persons withdrawing from opioids, usually heroin.19,21,22 r ! , In 1964, researchers at Rockefeller University, New York –headed by Vincent Dole and Marie Nyswander– believed that opioid addiction was a "metabolic disease" that altered brain function and made it difficult for patients to remain drug-free.'O," Dole's team discovered that an ongoing, daily dose of long-acting oral methadone — maintenance treatment—offered a number of beneficial effects allowing otherwise debilitated opioid addicts to function more normally • (see box).1:.16.:3 t, 7 An adequate maintenance dose of methadone does MMT was viewed as corrective therapy, rather than as a "cure" for opioid not make the patient feel addiction, and it had no or only limited efficacy in treating dependence on "high"or drowsy, so the other substances of abuse." Dole wrote, "the most that can be said is that patient can generally carry there seems to be a specific neurobiological basis for the compulsive use of on a normal life. Daily heroin by addicts and that methadone taken in optimal doses can correct the drug-seeking to "feed a habit"ceases. disorder."" Oral methadone has demonstrated a favorable safety profile when properly A Methadone can betaken prescribed and used. No serious adverse reactions or organ damage have been once dailymouth withoututthe use of injection specifically associated with continued methadone use extending more than 20 u ears in some patients. Ii nor s �PffPr#f 'h dF B0 /nlnlrrtY"'—� '. �,. a� -b+ ';. •y_:.::�..° R-�1• ;#.255-sW�dt- ,. i exposui.: .o aiseases -ke I iln-,'appear during early days of treatment and are easily managed. hepatitis and HIV. Women stabilized on methadone generally have more healthful pregnancies Methadone's and their newborns do not suffer any lasting adverse consequences.15E6Further- gradual. long- more, methadone at appropriate dose levels does not hinder a patient's intel- lasting effects eliminate lectual capacities or abilities to perform work tasks." drug hunger or curving. Adequate methadone dosing is critical for therapeutic success. Dole's J There is little change in original research discovered that 80 to 120 milligrams of methadone per day, tolerance to methadone on average, was an effective dose. Dozens of studies since then have demon- over time, so it does not strated that dosing in that range results in superior treatment outcomes, such take more of the drug to achieve the same results. as better retention of patients in treatment and less illicit drug use.93611 For a variety of reasons —such as, high tolerance to opioids, physical condition, J Euphoria-blocking effects mental status, concurrent medications, or prior use of high-purity heroin — of methadone make taking many patients require much higher daily methadone doses for treatment illicit opioids undesirable. success; sometimes exceeding 200 mg/day or more.616,79 Patients maintained on I3 Used properly, methadone inadequately low doses are much more likely to use illicit opioids and respond is generally safe and poorly to therapy.ta nontoxic, with minimal In 1997, an independent panel of experts convened by the National side `ff`cts' Institutes of Health (NIH) to reach a consensus on effective treatments for opioid addiction concluded that, "Of the various treatments available [for opioid addiction], MMT, combined with attention to medical, psychiatric, and socioeconomic issues, as well as drug counseling, has the highest probability of being effective. 3 C 4 Forum . .. . 5 Ongoing AIMT Is Essential & Cost Effective, But Capacity Is Insufficient Time in treatment is a critical factor for addiction recovery. Typically, Persons leaving methadone-maintained patients mustattend a treatment program each day to receive their oral dose of methadone; however, stable and compliant patients are MMT and not usually allowed to take home a number of doses, thus reducing their clinic visits.330 pursuing further Appropriate psychosocial therapy and other support services are integral compo- treatment are T. nents of ongoing MM almost certain The NIH Consensus Panel" and others" concluded that patients treated for to relapse, with fewer than 3 months in MMT generally show little or no improvement. Studies potentially fatal have routinely demonstrated reductions in illicit opioid use of up to 80% or more after several months, with the greatest reductions for patients who remain in Consequences. treatment more than a year.'19 1033 Patients often require MMT indefinitely, as would be expected with any chronic medical condition. Once a patient has been stabilized on MMT, withdrawal from methadone carries substantial risks'33 Virtually all who abandon MMT and do not pursue further treatment eventually relapse 34 and potentially overdose.13 Unfortunately, MMT is not available for all who might benefit, even though the number of patients in treatment has grown steadily and incrementally through the years (see graph)."'-16 In 2004, there were about 1,100 MMT programs in 44 states; however, program capacity was 12; sufficient to serve only a small fraction of opioid-addicted persons in this country who needed it; especially considering the additional num- bers of persons addicted to opioid analgesics.'" 1968 1973 1987 1991 1963 1999 2002 ,200A- Methadone treatment is a cost effective alternative to incarceration or hospitalization.1,14.30 Studies have shown that it costs about $42,000 per year to leave a drug abuser untreated in the community, $40,000 if the offender is incarcerated, and only about $3,500 for MMT31 Furthermore, the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) has reported that among MMT participants illegal activity declined by 52% and full time employment increased by 24%.3 Patients in MMT also earn more than twice as much money annually as opioid addicts not in treat- ment, which can enhance their value as taxpaying citizens in the community.,, An often-quoted study of 150,000 patients— the California Drug and Akohol >�_. Treatment Assessment(CALDATA) — found that for every $1 spent on addiction treatment more than $7 in future costs were saved (see graph). MMT was determined to be the lowest-cost, most effective treatment modality for opioid 1wf �4 addiction; whereas, programs offering only opioid detoxification showed no osrM long-term benefits at all.' Deaths and illness associated with addiction are financially draining on society. $Ta Untreated opioid addicts have a death rate 3 to 4 times greater than patients in Addiction treatment methadone treatment.13 1 Furthermore, studies have consistently shown that the Provides a 700% return risk of communicable infections - HIV, hepatitis, tuberculosis- is significantly on investment. reduced by MMT, even in the absence of complete illicit-drug abstinence.11038 If methadone clinics are closed communities pay a price. One study found that the costs for crime, justice system (e.g., arrests), and welfare services in a community that closed its MMT program were 17% higher when compared with a locality with an ongoing MMT clinic.' t i 6 - . MMT Criticisms, Concerns, And Regulation " Past Practices And Misperceptions Have Hindered Progress Through the years, MMT has fostered some negative attitudes and actions by critics. A segment of public opinion has opposed the use of methadone for .� P treating opioid addiction and political initiatives have been enacted or proposed `s a to thwart access to MMT.3900 Many persons still perceive opioid dependence as a self-controllable "bad habit," and dismiss MMT as an ineffective, addictive- narcotic substitution therapy."19 „ However, it has widely and authoritatively been recognized that methadone is not merely a substitute for illicit opioids, and MMT does D-01 simply replace one addiction with another.1,11,11,15.37,39.41 Although methadone can cause physical Methadone provides dependence, its steady and long-term action in the brain contrasts sharply with a stable existence the disruptive cycle of "highs" and "lows" produced by short-acting opioids that lead to addictive behaviors.915'^93 Methadone substitutes a stable existence that replaces high-risk, for one of compulsive drug seeking and taking, criminal behavior, chronic self-destructive addictive unemployment, and high-risk sexual and drug-use behaviors.' behaviors. Unfortunately, during the early days of MMT there were problems as a result of rapid clinic expansion in the face of decreased funding 14 A govern- ment report found that clinic policies, goals, and practices varied widely,'•41 90 and departures from recommended methadone doses, adopting a as "less is more" approach, had pervaded many programs.' Surveys since )a ` j �3 ` ces�e 1988 have observed that a majority of U.S. MMT clinics oncep rovided 65 70 4�jy average methadone doses far below the 80 mg/day recommended 80iexY minimum" There have been improvements more recently, with most pro- 55 € grams achieving average doses of 80 mg/day or more (see graph). How- 45 - , ,.. � �° e, "S'r 9s^ 0 n ever, man y patients still receive inadequate amounts of methadone,","and 1999 3999 1993 1998 1988 2003 ; they often respond poorly to treatment, just as would any individuals prescribed insufficient drug therapy for a chronic medical disorder.',-" Revised Regulations And Accreditation Promote "Best Practices" MMT has been a tightly controlled medical specialty in the U.S. and regulations methadone itself is a highly regulated drug.91 Fairly recently, in 2001, oversight allow for of MMT programs was transferred to SAMHSA's Center for Substance Abuse more flexible Treatment (CSAT). Revised federal regulations emphasize improved patient care methadone and increased healthcare practitioner discretion in meeting patients' needs; dosing and particularly, allowing more liberal methadone dosing and permitting qualified patients to take home doses for self-administration.'° However, state and local take home regulations may be more stringent; and they are in some cases. privileges. r As a component of the regulations, MMT programs must successfully complete an accreditation process similar to that required of much larger healthcare organizations. Best-practice guidelines and standards have been developed, reflecting the latest evidence promoting excellence in the treatment of opioid addiction. Results to date indicate that MMT program accreditation has been successful in improving patient care, safety, and treatment outcomes." Forum , I Meeting Challenges for Change In Communities Quality care for opioid-dependent persons also involves promoting their + 32 � reintegration, acceptance, and ongoing recovery from addiction in their communities. Toward those ends, MMT staff seek to develop an understanding �I Of community values, needs, and resources; and, they strive to work collabora- tively with community leaders and organizations at all levels. Addiction treatment is sometimes viewed as a form of social welfare. How- }Y=f x ever, from an MMT perspective, such treatment is a medical service that beyond benefitting opioidextends -addicted patients. Public safety, health - � ` , and eventu- ally the local economy often are the greater beneficiaries of methadone 5 � maintenance treatment."' r,-f;;� � ,F, 7 rw Expanding Treatment There is a provision in the revised federal regulations for office-based ` Physicians, who have formal arrangements with established MMT programs, to provide methadone maintenance.'o°' This has been widely endorsed by govern- .. # ment' ." and medical"°6 organizations. It is estimated that at least 7% of patients in MMT clinic programs are sufficiently stable to be served in this manner— f : called methadone "medical maintenance" — and it would make additional MMT clinic capacity available for opioid addicts awaiting treatment. However, this approach has not been widely accepted and implemented. In 2002, another opioid drug, buprenorphine, was approved by the govern- ment for prescription by qualified community-based physicians to treat opioid Stigma, prejudice, addiction."" However, it has been recognized that "buprenorphine is unlikely and misunderstandings to be as effective as more optimal-dose methadone, and therefore may not be surrounding methadone the treatment of choice for patients with higher levels of physical dependence have served as [on opioids]."3 "Also, without the close monitoring, psychosocial therapy, and other support provided by MMT clinics, the long-term benefits of buprenorphine obstacles to persons for some patients could be questionable. who would otherwise Overcoming Stigma, Prejudice, And Misunderstandings enter treatment, to The World Health Organization and others have recognized that the stigma, doctors who might do more in treating prejudice, and misunderstandings surrounding persons with addictive disorders is a major barrier to their treatment and proper care." In particular, these neg- O/JIOId addiction, ative pressures have served as obstacles to persons entering methadone treat- and to legislators ment, to doctors in treating opioid addiction, and to legislators and public and public health health officials who could otherwise do more to make MMT widely available. officials who could Past policies have placed too much emphasis on protecting society from methadone and not enough on protecting communities from the epidemics of do more a make MMT ava addiction, violence, and infectious diseases that MMT can help reduce." ilable. Rather than embracing MMT as a solution, some short-sighted communities have rallied against the opening of new MMT clinics—even in the midst of ever-increasing opioid addiction problems— and forcing their citizens to travel hours each day to other locales for methadone treatment. Hopefully, better, evidence-based information and education will succeed in overcoming all of the barriers facing MMT for the benefit of patients, their families, and their communities. References 27.Payte 1T Ki ET.Principles of methadone dose determination.In: Parrino t 1. Neuroscience of Psychoactive Substance Use and Dependence.Geneva: Protocol(TIP)Series 1.Rockville, t G U.S.Department t Health and MW.State Methadone Treatment Guidelines.Treatment Improvement World Health Organization;2004. 2. Nestler El,Malenka RC.The addicted brain.Scientific American. March Human Services;Center for Substance Abuse Treatment;1993:47-58 DHHS 2004. Pub#(SMA)93-1991. 3. Office of National Drug Control Policy(ONDCP).i icy Paper:Opioid 28.Gordon N8.The c#Z.Chemical tional tDependency Research Workiial of the methadone ng Grourson. Agonist Treatment.Washington, DC:Office of National Drug Control The New Monograph The New Vork State Office of Alcoholism and Substance Abuse ServicesP Policy;March 1999, December 1994:43-46. 4. Lewis D.Treatment works-the truth please.Brown Univ Digest Addict 29. Leavitt S8.Methadone dosing&safety in the treatment of opioid acidic- Theory Application. 1998;17(4), tion.Addiction Treatment Forum(special report].2003.Available at: 5. 2002 National Survey on Drug Use and Health MSDUH).Washington, DC: http,/Aw .atforum.com. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration;2003. 30.Federal Register.Opioid drugs in maintenance and detoxification treatment 6. Heroin;Get The Facts.Albany,NY:New York State Office of Alcoholism of opiate addiction;final rule.2001 (Jan 17);66(11):4085.42 CFR Part S. and Substance Abuse Services(OASAS); 1997. 31,Payte JT Khuri ET Treatment duration and patient retention.In:Parrino 7. Kauffman JF,Woody GE.Matching Treatment to Patient Needs inMIN state Opioid Protocol(TIP)Series to Trreatment Guide lines.Departm net improvement Substitution Therapy.Treatment Improvement Protocol(TIP)Series 20. Human Services;Center for Sub Health and Rockville, MD:U.S. Department of Health and Human Services;Center for DHHS i(SMA)93-1991. stance Abuse Treatment;1993:119-124, Substance Abuse Treatment;1995.DHHS Pub#(SMA)95-3049. B. New data show opiates take lead over cocaine in treatment admissions 32 Parrino M .State Methadone Treatment Gu delines.7reatmentends.In: WParrino MIN.Overview:current treatment (press release).Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Improvement Protocol(TIP)Series 1. Rockville,MD:U.S.Department of Services;August 26, 1999. Health and Human Services;Center for Substance Abuse Treatment;1993 9. Nadelman E,McNeely J.Doing methadone right. The Public Interest. 1-9.DHHS Pub#(SMA)93-1991. 1996;123:8393. 10.Zweben JE,Payte 1T.Methadone maintenance in the treatment of opioid 33.PAmerican ublic policy statement on methadone treatment.Chevy Chase, MD: ety of Addiction Medicine; 1991, dependence;a current perspective. West)Med. 1990;152:588-599, 34. Rosenblum A,1 Magu a S,Joseph H.Ambivalence toward methadone treat- I1.National Drug Threat Assessment 2004.Washington,DC:National Drug ment among intravenous drug users.J Psychoactive Drugs. 1 Intelligence Center, U.S.Department of Justice;April 2004. 35. Methadone treatment survey reveals 56%more patients 991;23(1):21- enr 12.Heroin Abuse and Addiction.National Institutes on Drug Abuse(NIDA) methadone treatment than previously reported(press release], in New York, Research Report Series;October 1997.NIH Pub#97-4165. NY:American Methadone Treatment Association;April 8, 1999. 13.Methadone Associated Mortality.Report of a National Assessment. 36. Data on file,Mallinckrodt Inc.,St.Louis,MO. Rockville,RockvMD:Center for Substance Abuse Treatment;2004.Publication 37,Krantz Ml,Mahler PS.Treating opioid dependence.Growing implications No. vine, for care.Arch Int 14.Infectious diseases and drug abuse.NIDA Notes.August 1999;14(2):15.NIH 38.Leshner Al.Drug abuse researchhelpscurt, I the spread of deadly pub#99-3478. infectious diseases.NIDA Notes, 1999;14(2):3-4.NIH Pub#99-3478, 15. Payte 1T Zweben JE, Martin J.Opioid maintenance treatment.In:Graham 39.Ehlers S.U.S.Congress panders anti-methadone bill(press release]. AW,et al.,eds.Principles of Addiction Medicine.3rd ed.Chevy Chase,MD: Washington,DC:Drug Policy Foundation;February 19, 1999. American Society of Addiction Medicine;2003:751766. 16. Effective Medical Treatment of Opiate Addiction.NIN Consensus 40 ProvidenceSubstance,RI:sPRNewswiere,May 24,11999 methadone(press release). Statement. 1997(Nov 17-19);15(6):138.Bethesda,MD:National Institutes of Health. 41.Methadone maintenance:some treatment programs are not effective; 17.Zacny J,Bigelow G,Compton P.et al.College on problems of drug greater federal oversight needed.Report to the chairman,Select dependence taskfwce on prescription opioid non-medical use and abuse: Washington,DC:Committee on US?General Accounting cs Abuse and Office;House 0Rpobgentatives Position statement.Drug Alcohol Depend.2003;69:215-232. GAO/HRD-90-104. 18.Percentage increase in hospital emergency department visits associated 42.McCaffrey BR.Heroin access spurs need for methadone.USA Taday. with opioid analgesics, 1994-2001.Washington, DC:Substance Abuse and January 25, 1999. Mental Health Services Administration);2002.DAWN Series D-23,DHHS Publication No.(SMA) Administration),, 1. 43.D'Aunno T,Pollack HA.Changes in methadone treatment practices;results 19.Rettig RA,Yarmolonsky A(eds).Federal Regulation of Methadone from a national panel study, 1988-1000.JAMA.2002;288(7):850-856. Treatment.Committee on Federal Regulation of Methadone Treatment; 44. Leavitt 58.Dosage survey 2003:upward trends continue.Addiction Division of Biobehavioral Sciences and Mental Disorders;Institute of Treatment Forum.2003;12(2).Available at:httptlwww.atfofum.com. Medicine(IOM).Washington, DC:National Academy Press; 1995. 20.Brands B, Blake 1,Sproule B,Gourlay D, Gusto U.Prescription opioid abuse q5. Improving quality and oversight of methadone treatment(press release], in patients presenting for methadone maintenance treatment.Drug Alc Washington,DC:Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration,Center for Substance Abuse Treatment;July 22, 1999. Dep.2004;73:199-207, 21.Payte JT A brief history of methadone in the treatment of opioid depen- q6. Methadone Chicago maintenance America,Medical'Assoce ciation; 1995.Police of No. dente:a personal perspective.J Psychoactive Drugs. I nt of 3(2):103-107. Delegates.Chico H-95.957. Y 22.Joseph H, Stan<IiH 5,Langrod 1.Methadone maintenance treatment 47.About Buprenorphine Therapy.Bethesda,MD:Substance Abuse and (MMT):a review of historical and clinical issues.Mt Sinai J Med.2000;67 Mental Health Services Administration;2004. (5-6):347-364. f 23. Dole VP.Implications of methadone maintenance for theories of narcotic addiction.JAMA. 1988;260:3025-3029. 24. Kreek Ml.A personal retrospective and prospective viewpoint.In:Parrino F;rum MW.State Methadone Treatment Guidelines.Treatment Improvement Protocol(TIP)Series 1.RockvilleMD:U.S.Department of Health and Human Services;Center for Substance Abuse Treatment;1993:133.143. DHHS Pub#(SMA)93-1991. 25.Joseph H,Appel P.Historical perspectives and public health issues.In: IS published by: CIIf1C0 Communications, INC. Parrino MW.State Methadone Treatment Guidelines.Treatment Improvement Protocol(TIP)Series 1.Rockville,MD:U.S.Department of P.O. Box 685 Health and Human Services;Center for Substance Abuse Treatment; 1993:11-24 DHHS Pub#(SMA)93-1991. Mundelein, l7 60060 26. Stine SM,Greenwald MK, Kosten TR.Pharmacologic therapies for opioid Oc 2004 Stewart B. Leavitt, PhD addiction. In:Graham AW,et al, eds.Principles of Addiction Medicine. 3rd ed.Chevy Chase,MD:American Society of Addiction Medicine;2003: 735-750. o manu(4Uurer of methadone 8 not is made possible by an rexo1n4n41 grant from Mallindradt Inc, May 2004 " COMMUNITY SUBSTANCE ABUSE CENTERS 1 628 Center St.,Ste.2 Chicopee.NIA (1113746-0 (4 13)746-0CSAC/Salem os1 , MA (413)746-0368 fax November 10, 2010 125 North El in St. Westfield, NIA 01085 Documentation of Need: (413)568-6601 (413)562-836(fax The attached data is from the Massachusetts Department of Public Health, 297 Pleasant St. Bureau of Substance Abuse Services. Nunhmnplon,MA 01060 (4 13)584-2404 (413)585-8631 rax The data documents admissions of Salem residents to in patient and out 177 Shelburne Road patient public funded treatment programs for addiction. Greenfield, MA(1301 ' (4 13)774-3321 The tracking is by Salem zip codes for the last two years and 6 months into (4 13) 774-3345 fax this year. 10 Kilburn Street The admissions for"heroin and other opiates" indicates a yearly increase in New Bedford,MA 02740 (508)979-1122 Salem. (508)979-1126 fax The total admissions are 762. 20 Tower office Park Woburn, MA 01801 (78 1)933-0700 (78 it 938-4014 fax In addition, there are over 100 Salem residents that are presently traveling to 175 crescent Ave. CSAC's Peabody. MA clinic for out patient addiction treatment. Chelsea, MA 02150 Understandably, some of these patients may be included in the numbers (617)889-8779 presented above. (6I7)889-9568 fax 55 Fishl'ry St. Hartford,CT 06120 (860)247-8300 (860)548-7325 fax 323 Merry Rd. Hudson, NH 0305 (603)595-3399 (603)579-2734 fax 200 Route 108 .Sonterswonh.NH 0.1878 _ (603)953-0077 (603)953-0073 fax 172 NeWbury St. Peabody,MA 01960 (978)535-9190 (978)535-9093 fax 177 Sh:muck Way Newington, Nil 113801 (603)416.0448 (603).136-0668 lax -'300 Congress SI. P(1nl:md. ,ME 04102 (207)221-'''92 (_'07) 221-2297 fax http://mebmail.verimacom netmail/driver?nimierdc��e-- to—na—it&fn: Y F �y vert,on Print Subject RE: RE: RE: Salem,NIA request From: Hanchett,Andrew(DPH)<Andrew.Hanchett@state.ma.us> Sent: Oct 6, 2010 09:18:07 AM To: bobepotter@verizon.net $LIPPE=REMS-Total is NII or zero IRotiys ann t i enrollments by primary drug Py2008 01910 FY2009 - FY2010 Total Alcohol 341 327 3—& �— i j Marijuana 32 29 1,057 I Crack/Cocaine 62 65 126 44 41 147 Heroin 154 216 241 611 Ochs Opiate___I 43 44 55 142 None 10 9 8 27 Oitier 7 13 Ms�ng 22 42 2 2 2 6 Prima Dru 01971 ry 9a � 651 684 ...823 2x153 Almhol I 3 4 3 t0 ', ! Marijuana 1 0 2 tAa Cocame 2 3 1 0 3 Heroin 1 4 3 j Otheropiates 1 0 0 9 i 1 None ----- 0 ( 0 1 O___ _._-----_, 0 0 1 1 I— ' Prima ----ry prays -- 8 1 Total 9 10 27 AICohal 344 331 392 1,067 I Marijuana 1 33 29 j Crack/Cocaine 64 67 129 ___ 45 41 150 Herotn 155 220 244 6.19 I Other Opiates 44 44 55 I None 143 j Other - 10 9 9 28 7 13 23 43 !�Mlssing --: 2 2 L_. -- 2 6 I Pnmary Drugs 833 659 693 2,135 Oct 6, 2010 — ----_. _ __. 1 8:58:22 AM Dreu Hanchett Director RSAS Data Analytics and Decision Support Massachusetts Department of Public I-lealth 250 Washington St. 3rd Floor >4 D Impact ®fPrevention reatrnent "MEN • 20 million Americans need treatment for alcohol and drug problems — Only 20% receive care • 80% of Addicted Americans are in need of treatment a Space available for only 15% of Opiate Addicted Americans to be in treatment e Society can pay now or pay more later; but we already pay too much in terms of: - Public Health (HIV, Hepatitis C, etc.) - Law Enforcement, Crime, Prison and Court - Lost Job Productivity - Workers Compensation - Deterioration of Societal Priorities v Each $1 invested in alcohol and drug prevention saves $5.60 m Each $1 invested in alcohol and drug treatment saves taxpayers $38 ®st Effectove Hess 6NNNEM • The latest evidence based research found for every $1 .00 spent on methadone maintenance treatment there is a future savings of $38.00 due to factors such as a reduction In criminal activity, hospitalizations, ER admissions, and unemployment [Zarkin et. Al 2005] • Average annual crime-related costs to societyfell by $8,600 per patient following treatment [Koenig et, 1999] ® Medical costs are reduced due to the reduction in patients getting infected with HIV/AIDS and Hepatitis. Getting patients off of the streets not only will save medical dollars but will address a major public health and Safety issue. - The cost of lifetime treatment of one HIV infected person is over $200,000 - The cost of treatment for Hepatitis C with liver transplant is astronomical. 4 out of 10 U.S. AIDS deaths are related to drug abuse. Average Costs Per Year For One Heroin Addict (Adapted from New York State Division of Substance Abuse Services, 1991 by Dole and DesJariasis) In Methadone Residential Maintenance On-Street Incarcerated Treatment Program $50,000 $40,000 $30,000 $20,000 $10,000 • Heroin Residentia Drug-Free reatment 0 MMTP 'i Community substance Abuse Centers Methadone and Pregnancy i METHADONE AND PREGNANCY Treatment of the pregnant opiate(narcotic/heroin) addicted patient is critical to the well being of both the mother and the baby. The coordinated care by the patient's medical providers is essential. This team of physicians should include an Addictionologist, Obstetrician, and Pediatrician. Treatment must be focused on assuring that the mother, and therefore the fetus, is not subjected to opiate withdrawal. Cain /ications v o late withdrawal and untreated Opiate(Azvecnffdgenc Burin re nan • Spontaneous Abortion (Miscarriage) • Abruptio Placenta (Tearing away of the lining of the womb) • Premature Labor(Delivery of premature baby) • Increased Risk of Infection (HIV/AIDS; Hepatitis; TB; Endocarditis; etc.) • Retarded Fetal Growth (Low Birth Weight; Small Head Circumference) • Long Term Developmental and Cognitive Impairment of the Newborn Treatment of the pregnant opiate addicted patient has been shown to reduce both the short term and long term complications inherent in babies born to untreated mothers. Premature delivery, miscarriages, infections, retarded growth and development impairment are all reduced significantly with methadone treatment. Are the Babies Born Addicted? It is true that babies born to both heroin addicted mothers and to methadone treated mothers usually need treatment to prevent the neonatal withdrawal/abstinence syndrome. The Purpose of methadone treatment during pregnancy is to prevent the complications usually associated with the continued use of heroin. The objective of methadone treatment of the pregnant mother is not to prevent the symptoms of neonatal withdrawal but to decrease the incidence of maternal and fetal complications of heroin use during pregnancy. In fact, studies have shown, providing the baby is appropriately medically treated after delivery, the severity of withdrawal of the baby is not related to development outcome as measured at 1-2 years of age. Babies born to heroin addicted mothers also require treatment post delivery, but have a significantly higher incidence of both short term and long term medical and developmental complications. There are several reasons for the better outcomes of babies born to mothers treated with methadone. Methadone is an oral medication usually administered only once daily, and due to its long duration of action, the fetus and mother do not experience the deleterious effects of narcotic/heroin withdrawal. Heroin is a destabilizing drug that requires frequent daily use. Mothers in methadone treatment receive health screening, psycho-social counseling, ongoing f obstetrical care, and are much less likely to abuse heroin and other drugs, thereby reducing the k increased risk of medical complications(HIV/AIDS, Hepatitis, etc.) It is also been shown that mothers in methadone treatment are much less likely to abuse drugs post-partum and therefore bond more closely with their babies. Treatment of the post-partum mother continues after delivery with on going monitoring, including laboratory screening to detect illicit drug use. II S s s 8 & DPROPERTIES LLC 72 LD DERRY ROAD HUDSON, NH 03051 TEL: 603.882-0527 FAX: 603-598-6786 November 1, 2010 To Whom It May Concern: Please be advised chat Merrimack River Medical Services has rented spat: from B & D Properties for approximately 10 years. During that time there has dabeen dance studio, and day care center and presently a family run consigchildren's been a a shop. During this time, we have had no problems with the clinic being adjacent to these other tenants. B & D Land Development Inc. Richard Tate, Owner i Community Substance Abuse Centers Leadership Team Matthew Davis, M.A., CADAC, LMHC, received his Masters degree in counseling psychology from Lesley College in 1984. He began working in the addiction field in 1979 in an outpatient substance E abuse program with inner city youth. In 1986 he began serving in an administrative capacity within narcotic treatment programs until 1998 when he became Director of Ambulatory Services for a multi service substance abuse treatment agency where he worked on the integration of methadone treatment into multiple treatment modalities. In addition he has served as both secretary and treasurer of the Mass Methadone Treatment Providers Association and since 1985 has been a member of the adjunct faculty at Lesley College graduate school teaching courses in addiction across the country. Alan Dayno, M.D., received his medical degree from Temple University School of Medicine in 1978. He is board certified in Internal Medicine and certified by the American Society of Addiction Medicine. He has been a Director of Emergency Medical Services and since 1984 he has worked both inpatient and ambulatory addiction medicine. He is a founding party in 1989 Community Substance Abuse Centers, a narcotic treatment organization that now operates ten facilities in three states and since 1989 he has served as Co-Medical Director. He also serves as one of only two expert Medical Consultants for the CARF Methadone/LAAM Treatment Program Accreditation Project and is a medicaadvis Massachusetts Coalition of Addiction, Pregnancy and Parenting. l or to the Edward J. Blain, MEd., received his Master's degree in counseling psychology from Temple University in 1981. He began working in the addiction field in 1979, beginning in an administrative capacity in 1983 when he ran an inner city poly-substance abuse center. He has served on numerous state and federal committees for the improvement and advancement of addiction treatment. In 1989, he was a founding member of Community Substance Abuse Centers, a narcotic treatment organization that now operates ten facilities in three states. In addition to his role as Chief Executive Officer, he was Vice President of the Massachusetts Methadone Treatment Provider Association and has consulted with the Center for Substance Abuse Treatment (CSAT). He received the Dole-Nyswander national award and Francis E. O'Brien Massachusetts recognition award in 2003 in recognition of his work advocating for addiction treatment. Steven Kasse/s, M.D., received his medical degree from Wayne State University School of Medicine in 1976. He is board certified in Emergency Medicine and certified by the American Society of Addiction Medicine. He has served as Chief of a Department of Emergency Medicine and as a member of the Board of Directors of the American College of Emergency Physicians. He began his work in addiction medicine in 1984 at an urban inpatient and ambulatory addiction treatment facility. In 1989, he became a founding member of Community Substance Abuse Centers, a narcotic treatment organization operating ten facilities in three states. He currently serves as Co-Medical Director of Community Substance Abuse Centers, as well as one of only two expert Medical Consultants for the CARF Methadone/LAAM Treatment Program Accreditation Project. Robert Potter, M.Ed., received his Master's degree in counseling from Boston University in 1976. He began working in the addiction field in 1973 at Boston City Hospital as an administrator for the Narcotic Addiction Treatment Program. He has presented several workshops at the national methadone treatment conference and in various community settings. Mr. Potter has extensive experience in community education pertaining to narcotic treatment and the development of services for this Population. He has taught at the college level and continues to do clinical work with narcotic addicts. Norma J. Reppuccl, B.A., R.N., is a graduate of Boston City Hospital School of Nursing. She has worked as a registered nurse since 1971. She received her Bachelor's degree in 1984 from the University of Massachusetts. She has worked in a variety of medical and behavioral health settings. Ms. Reppucci was honored by her peers in 1997, when she received the Dole-Nyswander award for excellence and contribution to the field of narcotic treatment. She has lead numerous initiatives for the improvement and advancement of addiction treatment including Chair of the national methadone workshop committee, executive member of the Massachusetts Methadone Provider Association, consultant for the Center for Substance Abuse Treatment (CSAT), and board member for a community health center. { CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS r% ,�; .�;.';�� RULES AND REGULATIONS February 2008 ARTICLE I. ORGANIZATION L Officers At the first regular meeting in May, the Board shall elect all officers of the Board to include a Chairman, Vice Chairman, and Secretary. Alternates do not participate in this act except where an alternate member has been designated to act as a member of the Board under Section 5 of this article. If a vacancy should occur during the term of an officer the Board shall, at the next meeting after the vacancy occurs, elect a replacement to serve until the next reorganizational meeting. 2. Chairperson: Powers and Duties The Chairperson shall vote and be recorded on all matters coming before theBoard. Subject to these rules, he/she shall decide all points of order, unless over-ruled by a majority of the Board in session at the time. He/she shall appoint such committees as may found necessary or desirable. In addition to powers granted by general laws and ordinances, and subject to these noes and Board, supervise the work of further instructions of the Board, the Chairperson shall transact the official business of the ercise general supervisory powers.the Secretary, request necessary help, rect the work of all di subordinates, and exHe/she shall, re each meeting, report on all official transactions that have not otherwise come to the attention of the Board. 3. Vice Chairperson. The Vice Chairperson shall act as a Chairperson in case the Chairperson is absent, disabled or otherwise unable to perform his duties. 4. Secretary The Secretary shall be a member of the Board, designated by the Board. The Secretary shall read the petition and all correspondence relative to the petition before the public portion of the hearing, 5. Alternate i<4embers The Chairperson of the Board shall designate an alternate member to sit on the Board in case of the absence, inability to act or conflict of interest on the part of any Board member. In the event of a vacancy on the Board, the Chairperson may designate an alternate member to act ash member of the Board until som vacated term. Alternate members sit cone is appointed to 611 the unexpired portion of the occur. all be called on a rotating basis to fill vacancies as they i 6. Clerk of the Board Subject to the direction of the Board and its Chairperson, the Clerk shall be responsible for all of the clerical work of the Board including typing and filing of all written decisions and correspondence, letters, etc. Also, the postings of the Boards agenda in compliance with state and local laws and ordinances; sending of all notices required by law; receive and time stamp all applications; keep dockets and minutes of the Boards proceedings; compile all required records; maintain all necessary files and indexes and call the roll at all Board meetings. 7. Building Inspector The Salem Building Inspector, or his representative, shall be present at all meetings of the Board and shall make his recommendations regarding matters before the Board. 8. Conflicts of Interest In any situation where a Board member has worked on the preparation of plans or drawings or otherwise participated in a case submitted to the Board and in situations where a Board member has a direct and significant financial interest in the outcome of a case, that Board member shall notify the Chairperson of the conflict of interest situation, shall take a place with the public at the meeting and shall not participate in deliberations by the Board for this Particular case. 9. Quorum Four members of the Board will constitute a quorum. 10. Regular Meetings Unless otherwise noted, regular meetings of the Board of Appeals shall be held on the third Wednesday of the month at 6:30 pm at 120 Washington Street. The Board of Appeals may post a yearly schedule in advance and amend this schedule as needed. I1. Special Meetings Special meetings may be called by the Chairperson, or at the request of three members. Written notice thereof shall be given to each member at least 72 hours before the time set, excluding holidays and weekends. Notices shall be posted publicly as required by law and meetings. 12. Minutes of the Meeting All minutes of the Boards meeting once they have been approved by the Board become public record. Any petitioner, abutter or other interested party may receive a written copy of the minutes once they become available. Additionally, copies of the meeting recording may be made available to petitioners, abutters, and others. Costs incurred for the reproduction of the minutes or recording shall be borne in its entirety by the requester. Such costs shall be determined by the City department acting as the supplier. This section shall not however, prohibit a City official from receiving a copy of any written minutes so long as said request is made in conjunction with official City business. CITY OF SALEM BOARD OF APPEALS RULES AND REGULATIONS- PAGE 2 i ARTICLE U. APPLICATIONS TO THE BOARD I. Applications Every application for action by the Board shall be made on the office form. These forms shall be furnished by the Clerk of the Board upon request. Any communication purporting to be an application shall be treated as mere notice of intention to seek relief until such time as it is made on the official application form. All information called for by the form shall be furnished by the applicant in the manner therein prescribed. For all Variance requests a written Statement of Hardship demonstrating the following must be attached: a) Special conditions and circumstances that especially affect the land, building, or structure involved, generally not affecting other lands, buildings, and structures in the same district; b) Literal enforcement of the provisions of the Ordinance would involved substantial hardship to the applicant; and C) Desirable relief may be granted without substantial detriment to the public good, and without nullifying or substantially derogating from the intent of the district or the Purpose of the ordinance. For all Special Permit requests a Statement of Grounds must be attached. An application for a special permit for a nonconforming use or structure shall include a statement demonstrating how the proposed change shall not be substantially more detrimental than the existing nonconforming use to the neighborhood in accordance with Art. V, § 5-3. Such a statement Should include reference to the following criteria: a) Social, economic, or community needs served by the proposal; b) Traffic flow and safety, including parking and loading; c) Adequacy of utilities and other public services; d) Impacts on the natural environment, including drainage; e) Neighborhood character; and 0 Potential fiscal impact, including impact on City tax base and employment. Ten (10) copies of the form and all application materials must be submitted. In addition, the applicant shall advise the Board of any requests for Variances or Special Permits made for the property in question, by any party, over the last five years. 2. Filing Period Every application shall be filed and every appeal taken and heard within the guidelines as provided for by State Law. 3. Plans to Accompany Petition All applications relative to construction or exterior alteration must include ten (10) copies of the exterior design plans, drawn to scale, with the scale indicated. Exterior elevations must CITY OF SALEM BOARD OF APPEALS RULES AND REGULA"CIONS- PAGE 3 indicate dimensions and include all sides affected by the proposal. Exposed foundations should also be depicted on elevations. A Certified Plot Plan is required for all new construction and any constriction to existing structures where the proposed work would affect the structure's footprint. Mortgage Plans may be submitted in the place of Certified Plot Plans for existing one and two family structures when the exterior alterations are not two feet or less from the property line. A Certified Plot Plan must be stamped and dated by a registered engineer or land surver. The following items most be on the Certified Plot Plan: yo a) If petitioner seeks dimensional variances, plans must include a chart showing how the proposal falls short of the Ordinance's requirements. b) Plans must show all existing features of the property relevant to the proposed project, including without limitation, any easements, water, sewer and gas lines, underground electrical lines, paper streets, conservation areas, wetlands or waterways, hazardous waste disposal sites or historical sites. c) If off-street parking is required by the Ordinance, plans must show the layout and number of parking spaces set aside for the proposed use. Proposed parking layouts must include access ways and buffer zones. 4. Cost for Petition All applications shall be accompanied by the checks required in the Board's Fee Schedule. ARTICLE III. HEARINGS 1. Notice Notice of hearings shall be advertised as required by the provisions of the Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 40A. 2. Hearing to be Public All hearings shall be open to the public. No person shall be excluded unless he is considered by the Chairperson to be a "Serious Hindrance" to the workings of the Board. 3. Representation and Absence An applicant may appear on his own behalf, or be represented by an agent or attorney. In the absence of any appearance without due cause on behalf of an applicant, tlae Board will decide on the matter using the information it has otherwise received. When an abutter, petitioner and/or representative, or any interested person addresses the Board at any time during a public hearing reading trona a prepared statement, said statement, shall be submitted to the Chairperson and placed in the file and become part of the permanent record. CITY OF SALD4 BOARD OF APPEALS RULES AND REGULATIONS- PA(]E 4 pI 4' 4. Order of Business a. _ Roll Call b. Review of cases to be heard c. Hearing of cases as follows: 1. Reading of the petition and legal notice by the secretary, together with presentation of exhibits; if any. 2. Applicant's presentation 3. Opponent's presentation, if any, and questions by those seeking information 4. Applicant's rebuttal, restricted to matters raised by opponent's presentation. 5. Each hearing shall be allotted such time as the Chairperson deems to be necessary to allow for a full debate. In situations where the Chairperson deems it to be appropriate, the public hearing shall be limited to 20 minutes. 6. Members of the Board who are hearing the case may direct appropriate questions to all parties during the hearing. ARTICLE IV. DISPOSITION BY THE BOARD 1. Voting Requirement The concurring vote of at least four(4) members of the Zoning Board of Appeals shall be necessary in any action taken by the Board. The record shall show the vote of each member upon each question or, if absent or failing to vote, indicate such fact. It shall, in addition, set forth clearly the reason or reasons for its decisions. The order in which the roll call is taken for voting shall be systematically alternated so as not to have the same voting order of members on each petition. 2. Withdrawal An application may be withdrawn by notice in writing to the Secretary at any time prior to I the publication of a notice of public hearing thereon. Thereafter a petition may be withdrawn only with the approval of the Board. In the event that any petitioner chooses to withdraw a petition after it has been advertised, for any reason, he shall be required to pay all expenses relating to re-publishing of notices. 3. Reconsideration Once a petition has been voted upon and the meeting adjourned; there shall be no reconsideration of a decision of the Board. 4. Continuance The Board may choose to continue a case to a date and time certain provided that the date and time of continuance is announced at each public hearing and the statutory time limits are followed. CITY OF SALEibf BOARD OF APPEALS RULES AND REGULATIONS- PAGE 5 5. Reapplication No appeal, application or petition which was denied by the Board shall be acted avorably upon within two (2) years after the date of final unfavorable action unless the Board finds by f a vote of four (4) members that there are specific and material changes in the conditions upon which the unfavorable action was based and unless all but one of the members for the Planning Board consents thereto and after notice is given to parties of interest of the time and place of the proceeding which the question of such consent will be considered. (See Mass. General Laws, Chapter 40A, Section 16). r CITY OF SALEM BOARD OF APPEALS RULES AND REGULATIONS- PAGE 6