Loading...
CITY OF SALEM OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION PLAN UPDATE 1996_VOL 1 CITY OF REPORTOPEN SPACE AND RECREATION PLAN UPDATE 1996 VOLUME 1: r4+ 40 NEIL J. �� J A Y , �• �r S y -�- _ , `r •�_; �� � `ate r- .W��i�- -���i� ,fir w i _. ' a 'f=. :� �^.•'..,,,,,,ma�yy..� •..,� ;fi HARRINGTON, MAYOR OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION PLAN UPDATE COMMITTEE ABBY BURNS WILLIAM CULLEN REBECCA CURRAN JOHN GALARIS WENDI GOLDSMITH GARY MOORE DOMINIQUE PAHLAVAN RANDALL WIETING CRAIG WHEELER, CITY PLANNER PRINCIPAL AUTHOR: LARISSA BROWN,ASSISTANT DIRECTOR FOR COMMUNITY PLANNING Acknowledgments William E. Luster, City Planner(to May 1996) Salem Planning Department: Juli Riemenschneider, Jane Guy, Steve Dibble Salem Assessors' Department November 1996 TABLE OF CONTENTS Volume 9: Report Section 1 - Plan Summary . . . . . 1 Section 2 - Introduction . . . . . . . . . 1 A. Statement of Purpose . . . . . . . . . . 1 B. Planning Process and Public Participation 2 Section 3 - Community Setting 2 A. Regional Context . . . . . . . 2 B. History 3 C. Population Characteristics . . . . . . . . . 5 D. Growth and Development Patterns . . . . . . . . 7 Section 4 - Environmental Inventory and Analysis . . . . 10 A. Geology, Soils and Topography 10 B. Landscape Character . . . . . . 11 C. Water Resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 D. Vegetation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 E. Fisheries and Wildlife . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 F. Scenic Resources and Unique Environments . . . . . . . . . . . 15 G. Environmental Problems . . . . 17 Section 5 - Inventory of Lands of Conservation and Recreation Interest . . . . . 19 A. Protected Parcels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 B. City-Owned and Private Unprotected Parcels . . . . . . 21 C. Public and Nonprofit Parcels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Section 6 - Recreation Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 A. City Recreational Facilities . . . . . . . . 24 B. Team Sports and Fitness Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 C. Private Recreational Facilities . . . . . . . . . 26 Section 7 - Community Goals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 A. Description of Process . . . . . . . 27 B. Statement of Open Space and Recreation Goals . . . 28 Section 8 -Analysis of Needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 A. Summary of Resource Protection Needs . . . . . . . . . . 28 B. Summary of Community's Needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 C. Management Needs - Potential Change of Use 29 Section 9 - Goals and Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Section 10 - Five-Year Action Plan . . . . . . . . 33 Section 11 - Public Comments 39 Section 12 - References . . . . . . . . . . . 45 List of Maps Map 1 - Zoning Map 2 - Surface Geological Features Map 3 - Soils Map 4 - Hydrology Map 5 - Vegetation Map 6 - Scenic Resources and Unique Environments Map 7 - Lands of Conservation and Recreation Interest Map 8 - Five-Year Action Plan Land Inventory Matrix Tables 1. Population Change 1800-1994 2. 1980 and 1990 Population by Census District and Population Density 3. 1994 Population by Ward - Percentage of Population under 17 years 4. Land Use Classification - 1985 5. Estimated Build-Out Figures Under Current Zoning 6. North Shore Public Coastal Frontage By Municipality 7. Plants Typical of Salem Habitats 8. Fish, Shellfish, Birds, and Mammals Documented in Salem 9. Prehistoric and Historic Site Preservation Priority Areas 10. Size of City-Owned Open Parcels Volume 2: Appendices A - Historic Maps B - Rare and Endangered Species C - Hazardous Waste Sites D - Parks and Playgrounds Inventory E - Community Survey F - Site Visits Checklist G - Salem Multi-Purpose Trail System H - Section 504 Self-Evaluation for Handicap Accessibility SECTION 1 - PLAN SUMMARY The City of Salem is a mature urban community with over 11 miles of coastline, relatively large expanses of wetlands and woodlands, historic sites and architectural districts, and over 30 parks and playgrounds — including parks of regional significance. The 1996 Salem Open Space and Recreation Plan gives the highest priority to the protection and enhancement of Salem's unique environmental, recreational, and cultural resources, with a special focus on waterfront issues. The Plan recommends acquisition of a few key sites to support these goals, as well as other specific actions designed to enhance the environmental and recreational quality of life in the City of Salem The first six sections of the Plan contain information and analysis on the City's cultural and natural environment; development history; protected and unprotected lands of recreational or conservation interest; and recreation programs. Based on this information and on community input, the Open Space Committee developed the community needs analysis, goals, objectives, and five-year program of specific actions delineated in the second half of the Plan. SECTION 2 - INTRODUCTION A. Statement of Purpose This Plan is a comprehensive update of the City's open space planning priorities. The plan is intended to serve as a source of information on the City's environmental, open space, and recreation resources, a guide to open space and recreation policy, and an agenda to be pursued in the next five years. This is the first plan written in conformance with the 1990 requirements of the Commonwealth's Executive Office of Environmental Affairs. Salem's first Open Space and Recreation Plan was prepared for the Conservation Commission in 1973 and focused especially on an environmental inventory. The Community Development Master Plan of 1979 included a detailed and extensive section on the environment (including recreation) and numerous recommendations. Many of the recommendations of these two previous plans have been carried out, particularly the addition of land to the Forest River Conservation Area and the park and playground improvement program. Some recommendations remain on the City's agenda, awaiting the convergence of opportunity and funding. Although the 1996 Plan recommends specific actions, its flexibility accommodates a realistic and practical approach to preserving, enhancing, and expanding the City's open space and recreational resources. 1 B. Planning Process and Public Participation The 1996 Open Space and Recreation Plan was developed by the Open Space and Recreation Committee, appointed in June 1995 by Mayor Neil J. Harrington, and prepared by Salem Planning Department staff members. The Committee included representatives of the Planning Board, Recreation Commission, and Conservation Commission, as well as Salem residents who have special expertise in open space issues including a wetlands consultant, a biologist, an urban planner/landscape architect, a landscape designer, and an open space administrator. Committee members were divided into three subcommittees: Landscape Values; Recreation; and Conservation. They reviewed a draft of the plan sections on community setting and environmental analysis and relevant materials prepared by other City groups, including the recreation and open space goals of the 1996 Master Plan Update committee, and the 1994 Maritime Development District Study. Committee members also went into the field to inventory both public and private open spaces. Planning Department staff inventoried playgrounds, parks, and cemeteries. The Committee sought public input and collaboration in the update process through a variety of means - a survey, interviews with neighborhood activists, public review of the draft, and a public hearing. SECTION 3 - COMMUNITY SETTING A. Regional Context Salem, a city of 8.1 square miles in area, is located in Essex County, approximately 16 miles northeast of Boston. It is one of the oldest urban centers on the North Shore, a subregion of the greater Boston area which stretches along the coast from the Mystic to the Merrimack Rivers. Salem is bordered on the north by the Danvers River, Beverly Harbor and the City of Beverly beyond. The eastern shore of Salem faces the Beverly and Salem Harbors and the town of Marblehead. The southern land boundary of Salem abuts the towns of Marblehead and Swampscott and the City of Lynn. To the west is the City of Peabody. Salem is a member of the North Shore Task Force, one of eight subregions of the Metropolitan Area Planning Council, collaborating with neighboring communities in open space activities and discussions of regional open space issues and opportunities. Compared to other urban communities in its region, Salem has exceptional open space resources, both in size and quality. The coastal lowlands between Boston and Beverly have been modified in many places to accommodate an almost unbroken expanse of urbanized environments. Salem is lucky to have one of the most significant natural open space interruptions along this densely-occupied coast: the combination of Thompson's Meadow, the Forest River Conservation Area, and significant portions of the Salem Highlands. 2 B. History Salem's founding and subsequent history have been strongly marked by its location and environment. Its estuaries provided rich fishing grounds for the Native Americans who made their summer camps in the area. One of the first English settlements in North America, Salem was established in 1626 by a group of colonists from Cape Ann looking for a new site for a fishing station and trading post. During the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries Salem became a center of fishing, shipbuilding, and trade with the West Indies, the Mediterranean, and East Asia. By the early nineteenth century, the port of Salem was second only to Boston in New England trade volume. Rich merchants built mansions in the Chestnut Street area and around the newly landscaped Common. Salem's golden age of international trade was permanently disrupted by the War of 1812. In addition, as merchant ships increased in size over the course of the nineteenth century, Salem's shallow inner harbor was unable to accommodate them. Salem residents then turned to industry, succeeding particularly in shoe-making, leather-processing, and textile production. As the City grew in population, residential districts expanded. Immigrant workers lived in cramped tenements along the waterfront and in industrial districts, but in the second half of the nineteenth century more spacious residences extended up North Street in North Salem, along Lafayette Street towards South Salem, and along Bridge Street. Development in the Salem Highlands and the southern part of the city remained very limited. Juniper Point, the oldest residential section of Salem Neck, originated in 1870 with a subdivision of lots for summer cottages. The Great Fire of 1914 accelerated the development of downtown. The fire started with a warehouse explosion in Blubber Hollow and raged until it reached the harbor, incinerating some four hundred businesses, including the Naumkeag Cotton Mill, and nearly three thousand homes. The mansion districts escaped destruction, but millworker housing in the Point and the Lafayette Street area up to Leach and Holly Streets were in ashes. The mills and their housing were quickly rebuilt but the formerly residential district of lower Lafayette Street took on a more commercial character with the construction of hotels, commercial blocks, and auto salesrooms. Salem's population peaked in the 1930s. It was the business, legal, and retail center of Essex County. Since the decline of rail and the opening of Route 128 in the 1950s, Salem has become one of several centers on the North Shore. The City is also known as a tourist destination while continuing to support an industrial sector. In addition to Salem State College, founded in 1854, the City is home to the Peabody Essex Museum, and the Salem Maritime National Historic Site, the first National Historic Site in the National 3 Park System. The Park Service has constructed a new visitor center and made improvements to Derby Wharf and other sites. The renovated complex will be completed with the construction of a replica sailing ship and replica warehouses. The Museum will also be making a $75 million investment in its downtown Salem facilities in the next few years. Early environmental, park and open space history. In Salem's early history, its coastal location and riverine environment were the keys to the city's development. However, over the centuries the pressure of increased population and new industrial and transportation-related activities modified the coastline and the extent and configuration of the North and South Rivers. As the City became more densely-populated and industrial, residents created a strong park system. At the time of colonization, the South River formed a tidal basin and harbor at the present site of Riley Plaza. Over the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, the tidal basin and the downstream shores of the river were filled to provide land for warehouses, wharves, railroad yards, and a train station until nothing remained of the original river except the short channelized stream which today emerges from a culvert under Lafayette Street near the intersection with Derby Street. The channel originates in the wetlands at Old Mill Pond. The last fill project on the river was completed in 1941. The North River also originally had a wide estuary stretching between present Mason and Federal Streets nearly to Pope Street. Industrial pollution made the river so noxious during the nineteenth century that the City dredged and filled the river as part of a sewage system construction project. The North River still flows from its origin in Peabody into Salem, but it is now a narrow, channelized river until it emerges from under the Route 114/North Street overpass into downtown Salem. (See Appendix A - Historic Maps.) Salem Common was the City's first urban park. The swampy pasture was drained and landscaped by public subscription and renamed Washington Square in 1802. Greenlawn Cemetery was laid out in 1807 and Harmony Grove in 1840. Salem citizens participated in the public parks movement which emerged as reaction to the intense industrialization of the nineteenth century. Salem also became a summer tourist destination, attracting visitors to the Willows by the first train on the North Shore and to resort hotels on Salem islands. Over 350 acres of public parks were created in a few decades: Salem Willows (1883), Liberty Hill Park (1883, now the Bates School), Ledge Hill/Mack Park (1886), Highland Park (1906), Forest River Park (1907), and Gallows Hill Park (1912). Most of these lands were estates that had escaped subdivision and the City saw the value of preserving them for public use. The city obtained these lands in a variety of ways: the bequest of public-spirited residents, purchase, and eminent domain. For example, Highland Park had been pasture land (Salem Great Pastures) since at least the mid- 4 eighteenth century. The City purchased the land to build the high school, and the remaining land became Highland Park. In succeeding years the City continued to add to Salem's park and playground network. Highlights include the opening of the municipal golf course in 1933 and the creation of five neighborhood parks and playgrounds in the 1940s (Pickman, McGlew, Splaine, Juniper Point, and McGrath). Kernwood Marina opened in 1961 and the special playground for handicapped children at the Willows also dates from the sixties. Creation of new parks and playgrounds continued into the 1970s. After a period of reduced attention, the initiation of the annual park and playground improvements plan in 1990 focused on renovations and maintenance. Nearly every park and playground in the City has benefited from improvement projects since 1990 C. Population Characteristics Salem's population reached 36,000 by 1900 and has fluctuated relatively little during the twentieth century. According to the City Census, the population peaked at over 43,000 in the 1930s. By the 1960s the population was approximately 40,000 and began to decline in the 1970s and early 1980s. Total Salem population at the time of the 1990 U.S. Census was 38,091. From 1980 to 1990 Salem's population remained essentially stable, decreasing by 173 or less than 0.5%. According to the 1994 City Census, the population has declined very slightly since 1990 to 37,988. Over the next 15 years total population is projected to remain at the same level of approximately 38,000. (See Table 1.) Population distribution and density. As one of the oldest urban centers in the nation, Salem is very densely populated in its historic core (census tracts 2042 and 2043): the Historic Districts, downtown, and the Point. Bridge Street Neck, which has many tightly- packed 2-to 4-family buildings, is the next most densely populated area of the city. Where the housing stock is primarily single family or large two-family houses -- North Salem, South Salem, and Witchcraft Heights -- the population density is correspondingly lower. Finally, the southwestern and south central parts of the City, which contain extensive open spaces and areas unsuitable for development, have the lowest overall population densities in Salem. Population densities declined slightly in all census tracts between 1980 and 1990, with the exception of slight increases in density in the southern parts of the City and the Witchcraft Heights area. (See Table 2.) Sex and age composition. The 1990 population had a small majority of females over males: 20,465 (53.7%) females to 17,626 (46.3%) males. The median age was 33.5, slightly older than the 32.1 median in 1980. Nineteen percent of the City's population was 17 or under, and 12.3 percent was age 65 or older. According to the 1994 City Census, 5 20 percent of the population was 17 or under while 15 percent was age 65 or older. These statistics suggest that the populations of both the young and the old have been growing slightly at the expense of the 18-64 population segment. The most densely-populated part of the City also has the highest proportion of children. Nearly 25 percent of the population in Ward One, which includes areas such as the Point and the Derby Street neighborhood, was under 17 years old in 1994. However, high population density does not always imply a high proportion of young people. Wards Three and Five contain the second most densely-populated census tracts, but the percentage of children and youth is at or below the overall city average. Ward Seven, the southeastern portion of the city, has the lowest percentage of residents under 17, probably because of the presence of Salem State College. (See Table 3.) Race and ethnic composition. The Salem population in 1990 was 93 percent white, 2.7 percent black, 1.4 percent Asian or Pacific Islander, 0.3% American Indian, Eskimo or Aleut, and 2.7 percent "Other." The largest minority population is Hispanic, making up 6.7 percent of the total population. The majority of Hispanics in Salem are of Dominican origin, with significant numbers from Puerto Rico as well. The Hispanic population tends to be younger than the overall population, with a median age of 24 years in contrast to the overall median of 33. Nearly 37 percent of the Hispanic population was under 18 years old and only 3.3 percent was 65 or older in 1990. The majority of the Hispanic population lives in the Point Neighborhood. Household composition. Sixty percent of all Salem households in 1990 were classified as "family households," and 12.6 percent of all Salem households were female- headed families with children. In contrast, 32 percent of all Salem households were made up of one person. Twenty-eight percent of Salem households contained one or more persons aged 65 or older. Salem's recreational facilities must serve single people as well as families, the elderly as well as youth. Housing. Three-quarters of Salem housing units are in multi-family buildings, ranging from two-family homes to condominiums and large apartment buildings. In 1990 only 42.4 percent of occupied housing units were occupied by their owners. Nearly 50 percent were renter-occupied and the rest were vacant. Even if every existing single family home, 2- and 3-family home, and condominium unit in Salem were occupied by an owner, only 53 percent of the housing units in the city would be owner-occupied. Income characteristics. Salem is a middle-income community. In 1990 the median household income was $32,645, slightly below the state median of $36,952. Nearly twelve percent of the population in 1989 had incomes below the poverty level. Poverty levels were particularly marked among households with female heads, 28 percent of whom had incomes below the poverty level. 6 Journey to work. In 1990, slightly over 70 percent of Salem residents drove to work alone. The average travel time to work was 23 minutes. These data imply that the majority of employed Salem residents work outside the city. Major employers. The most significant employers in Salem include North Shore Medical Center; Sears Credit; Salem State College; New England Power; EG & G Electronics; and collectively, city, county, state, and federal government. Some of these employers -- Salem State, NEPCO, the national historic site -- offer open space amenities that are formally or informally available to Salem residents. Tourism. As a major tourist center on the North Shore, Salem draws thousands of visitors every year. Although they are essential to the City's economy, their presence also contributes to residents' perception of population density, especially downtown and in the historic districts, and particularly in the summer and fall. Implications of population composition and trends. To meet the needs of its population, Salem must offer recreational amenities and open space resources for a complex urban population: single persons as well as families, youth and the elderly, households with their own backyards and those which depend on public parks. Ward One, in particular, may need more neighborhood-based recreation and open space resources because it includes dense neighborhoods with the highest proportion of children and low- income households and a large number of renters. D. Growth and Development Patterns Patterns and Trends. Salem conforms to the historic pattern of settlement on the North Shore: coastal lowlands and lowland valleys first, river basins second, and uplands last. After World War II, Salem's population had already passed its peak and residential development pressures were not strong enough to overcome the high cost of development in the ledge- and marsh-filled southern part of the city. In the center-west part of the city Witchcraft Heights subdivision was built in the 1960s and in the southeast the Pickman Park subdivision appeared in the 1970s. When the first urban renewal plan began in the 1970s with the demolition of several historic buildings, citizen outcry redirected the process towards adaptive reuse and infill projects. The Essex Street pedestrian mall and the Pickering Wharf complex were products of the downtown revitalization movement of the 1970s. Although Salem has limited land suitable for development and the population is not expanding, the increasing number of households during the last quarter century has had an encroaching effect on the non-urban acreage in Salem. According to the state's Executive Office of Environmental Affairs, between 1971 and 1985 the urbanized acreage 7 in Salem increased 8 percent, while the open acreage decreased 14 percent, forested acreage (already limited) decreased 10 percent, and wetlands decreased one percent. The regional real estate boom of the late 1970s and the 1980s fueled limited residential and commercial growth in Salem. The existing commercial development along Highland Avenue and Loring Avenue expanded, attracting shoppers who formerly patronized downtown stores. New infill condominium developments and condominium conversions of existing buildings proliferated in the already built-up parts of the City. In addition new condominium complexes in South Salem were built off Highland Avenue and Loring Avenue. Some 1100 condominiums have been approved, of which approximately half have been constructed. Twenty-one percent of Salem's land, approximately 1150 acres, is under public or quasi-public ownership. Land in this category includes Winter Island, Thompson's Meadow, the Forest River Conservation Area, Greenlawn Cemetery, and city parks and beaches. (See Table 4: Land Use Classification.) Infrastructure. a. Transportation. The major regional highways, 1-95 and Route 128, are both within 4.5 miles of the city limits. The arterial roads serving Salem are state Routes 1A, 107, and 114, and the Boston Street entrance corridor from Peabody which links with Route 128. Public transit is provided by MBTA buses and commuter rail service to Boston and other North Shore communities, and by an MBTA-subsidized private bus line within the City. A number of transportation improvements are underway in Salem which are designed to improve traffic safety, to relieve traffic congestion caused by through traffic, and to provide alternative and intermodal links with neighboring communities. The Salem/Beverly Transportation Project, combining a new bridge, a new parkway and boulevard, and a linear park, is the largest single transportation improvement in North Shore history. The first section of a bicycle path has been constructed at Webb Street. Also programmed for improvements are the City's major entrance corridor, Boston Street, and Bridge Street, which will be the main artery of a revitalized Bridge Street Neighborhood. b. Water supply. Salem's primary water source is Wenham Lake which is recharged by the Putnamville Reservoir, the Ipswich River, and Longham Reservoir. Water supplies for Salem and Beverly are administered by the Salem-Beverly Water Supply Board. The total storage capacity of the Salem-Beverly Water System is 3.5 billion gallons. The average daily water use by Salem is 5.143 million gallons per day (MGD), approximately 135 gallons per day per capita. Today, the system's maximum treatment capacity is 24 MGD with possibilities of expanding up to 32 MGD; however, due to a raw water supply problem, expansion capabilities are limited. 8 c. Sewer service. Almost all residences and businesses in Salem are served by the municipal sewer system. No new septic systems are permitted. The Salem sewer system is tied into a regional treatment plant operated by the South Essex Sewerage District (SESD) serving Salem, Peabody, Danvers, Beverly, and Marblehead. There are only a handful of remaining septic systems in the city. Scheduled and proposed subdivisions. In the fiscal year ending June 30, 1995, the Salem Planning Board endorsed nine small subdivision plans that did not require approval and issued a Site Plan Review Special Permit for 20 housing units (Phase 3A) of the Fafard Residential Development. In addition, two small subdivisions were approved: Hilton Street (3 lots); Calumet Street (5 lots). Two retail project Site Plan Review Special Permits were approved for Highland Avenue: 1) Bagel Shop, 2,808 sf., and 2) Rockett Development, 52,000 sf. The Planning Board also issued a Planned Unit Development Special Permit for the construction of a Stop & Shop Supermarket on Howley Street at the Salem-Peabody line. The permit includes many conditions related to traffic, site design, and neighborhood improvements. The subdivision plan for the Swampscott Road Industrial Park was also approved. Some of the last remaining unbuilt industrial land in Salem, this 29-acre park will contain six parcels with a potential build-out of 300,000 square feet of industrial space. Thermal Circuits, the first tenant in the industrial park, was granted all the required approvals for construction and ground-breaking took place in October 1995. No other subdivisions have been proposed as of late 1995. The focus in the future is expected to be on redevelopment of abandoned industrial sites, for example, the former Parker Brothers site, GTE-Sylvania, Flynntan, and empty buildings, such as the old Police Station and the old County Jail. Long-term development patterns. Salem's long-term development is regulated through the city's zoning ordinance and subdivision regulations by the Planning Board and the Zoning Board of Appeals in conformance with the Master Plan (an update will be issued in 1996). The zoning districts and mechanisms include the following: residential, industrial, commercial, wetlands, multifamily, cluster, planned unit development, central development district (mixed use), business park, and entrance corridor overlay district. (See Map 1: Zoning.) Site plan review by the Planning Board is required for all nonresidential projects over 10,000 square feet and all residential projects over 5 units. There is no available maximum build-out plan under current zoning. A very rough estimate based on gross acreage and zoning limitations results in a total maximum of 2,218 housing units in 941 structures. However, because many parcels do not meet minimum zoning requirements and much of the land is unbuildable, a realistic number of 9 p I Q R S A 8 C D ! I 2 2 ; � _ 3 _II � I 1 S I BSI � L L � �, S oy` r _r V 10 f f«' - i, 10 v I �( � b. ,I Pam•.,.\ �` .� SALEMIPLANNTING BOARD _ '�1 �ZOtUNG OftDINANC,�M� I I laJt.b.nOv-� ORIGINALLY ADOPTED A1JGUST 2f, 9-4 CHAIRPERSON •1 I MAP AMENDED. SEPTEMBER 2,1949 �P AUGUST I. 19T; I j Oi u-� I JANUARY 3,1975 1 SEPTEMBER 15,1976 90.__ MAY 20.19TT JUNE 17,1985 j JULY I,1965 I�j DECEMBER 17,1990 12 GG \ ATTEST: j C TY CLERK,SALEM i j p p Q R S potential new housing units is likely to be less than half these numbers. (See Table 5 for details.) If demand for new housing increases, the City's Master Plan encourages infill construction of single-family homes, adaptive reuse of existing structures, and cluster development. Likewise, City policy emphasizes retail development in existing downtown or corridor sites, and industrial development in the Swampscott Road industrial park or existing industrial sites. Salem's development issues are those of older, industrial small cities: preservation and upgrading of existing housing and businesses, and economic development. The City seeks to balance needed economic development with the preservation and enhancement of neighborhood quality of life. Extreme development pressure on open land is not a concern in Salem. ............................................................................................................................................................................................................. COMMUNITY SETTING: IMPLICATIONS FOR OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION > Salem's densely-populated ward One, which includes the neighborhoods; :with the highest proportion of children and low-income households, as well; :as large numbers of renters, lacks sufficient neighborhood-based recreation: :and open space facilities. However, the City's concentrated population; ;pattern has permitted the City to maintain substantial open space available: to all residents in the southern part of the municipality. > Unlike more rural communities on the North Shore, Salem is not: :experiencing excessive residential development pressures. Building: :constraints on remaining open land in Salem are severe given the: :combination of environmental conditions and large areas of protected land. :: :Already approved condominium developments are not yet complete. Future: :residential development in Salem is likely to focus on adaptive reuse of: :existing buildings and infill development. Commercial or industrial: :development will be directed to existing commercial corridors, underused: :industrial sites, or designated industrial parks. Upcoming transportation: :improvements are designed to ameliorate traffic congestion within the City. ........... . .._ ............ . SECTION 4 - ENVIRONMENTAL INVENTORY AND ANALYSIS A. Geology, Soils and Topography Geology. Salem's geological character results from the advance and retreat of glaciers which deposited mixtures of clay, sand, gravel, and boulders (glacial till) on the 10 r4 .jam D- ? G w x':� ` 41 .`� :;.�:fi:_..;::•:''•�r. _r •jt', )r .'. r�� jig U 9 O II o• 11 ❑'.' w ry Oil LL co Ln .a O O Cc z o x iY �'N CD Mpg J� C•r •*�'4, 0 1 � �v .fig,�r5: � _;� �,. _ i,;� �`'��� r '' � � O .rl'J /`fir•- p� �� '•..A. .::. - <:� �, SIG"� ••. - E y1�Tt,` .` •O �: I _fit. - •. M ., /� "�� i'�• icy I \ _ :. z in cr �l r- 09 12 underlying bedrock during the Pleistocene Era, some 12,000 years ago. Over time the sea level fluctuated, leaving deposits of marine clays inland, and rivers cut deep valleys. Because bedrock is at or near the surface throughout most of the city, little groundwater is collected. Collection areas include the Forest River estuary and various wetlands. Over one-half the precipitation is runoff and flows along fractures and rivers to the ocean. (See Map 2: Surface Geological Features.) Soils. Soils in Salem are rocky and shallow, and in many places have been modified for urban development. Natural coastal areas consist of sandy beaches, rock bound outcroppings, and tidal marshes, while the harbor and the South and North River basins have been modified by fill. Lowland areas are typically peat and muck or meadow, and bedrock outcroppings (ledge) are interspersed at high elevations. Hickley gravelly sandy loam deposits are found in pockets on outwash plains. Coarse fragments are found in the upper soil layers. Sand and gravel lies below the second layer. Gloucester soils developed from glacial tills are found on gently sloping areas to steep uplands. Stone fragments make up to 35-37 percent of the soil volume. Other soils include Orono silt loam, Merrimac fine sandy loam, and Essex fine sandy loam, stoney phase. (See Map 3: Soils) Topography. Salem is situated in the New England Seaboard Lowlands and shares common natural features with its neighboring towns and cities: coastal lowlands of varying width, irregular rocky or marshy coastlines, diverse stream and river basins, and scattered small hills and upland areas. Most elevations are well below 400 feet and the average elevation is below 100 feet. Land surfaces generally slope from the interior to the coast. The two major drainages are the North River, which drains into Beverly Harbor, and the Forest River, which drains into Salem Harbor. The highlands and uplands of Salem consist of several steep hills with 100-200 foot elevations located in southwest Salem. These steep slopes historically presented the most enduring constraints on urban development, and the area has been undeveloped until recently. B. Landscape Character Salem's landscape today mixes distinctive natural and cultural landscapes with the urbanized residential and industrial areas of varying vintages characteristic of Eastern Massachusetts communities. Much of the natural coastline and inland water bodies have been filled to accommodate centuries of development, and very few of the original plant and animal communities have been left untouched by the same forces. However, within its small area, Salem retains a variety of natural landscapes: wetlands, rivers and streams, ponds, tidal flats, coves and harbors, rocky shores, upland ledges, and scrub forest. 11 The city's unique cultural landscapes derive from its long history. The sites associated with Salem's colonial and federal history are the most well-known, though residents also value the pockets of Victorian residences in South and North Salem and emblematic sites such as the Salem Willows. Less often acknowledged as distinctive are the landscapes of Salem's industrial and immigrant history: Blubber Hollow, the area around the Russian Orthodox Church, the mills and worker housing in the Point. These also contribute to the experience of Salem's historic landscape. Salem has 11.22 miles of coastal frontage, of which 50.2 percent is publicly owned - by local, state, or federal government or by nonprofit land conservation organizations. In the North Shore region, from Saugus to Salisbury, only Ipswich, Newbury, Rockport, Rowley and Salisbury have higher percentages of publicly-owned coastal frontage. (See Table 6: North Shore Public Coastal Frontage by Municipality.) Although half Salem's coastal frontage is publicly owned, access is not always easy because these figures include remote areas such as harbor islands. The main streets are inland from the water and much of the downtown shoreline is taken up by residential or industrial development, offering at best only a few glimpses of the sea. The New England Power Company plant, the South Essex Sewer District sewage plant, and Shetland Office Park impinge on many views of Salem Harbor, overwhelming by their size both the historic buildings on the shore and the boats in the harbor. The Boston Gas tanks in Collins Cove and the junkyard and parking lot on the North River have a similar effect on the visual character of these shorelines. There are, however, many points of public access to the water, especially outside of downtown: • access to Salem Harbor: Forest River Park, Palmer Cove, Derby Wharf, Winter Island, • access to Beverly Harbor/Collins Cove: the Willows, Collins Cove Park and Walkway, McCabe Park/Kernwood Marina • access to the North River: Furlong Park In addition, Great Misery and Little Misery Islands, owned by the Trustees of Reservations, offer harbor views, meadows, specimen trees, stands of pines, and ruins of a turn of the century casino hotel to those with access to private boats or the summer weekend excursion boat that leaves from Beverly. Finally, there are several significant expanses of relatively natural wetland and wooded upland in Salem. The Forest River Conservation Area contains 138 acres of wetlands, dense forests, an estuary, and tidal coves, performing an essential ecological role and providing a sense of natural open space very close to the densely-built city center. Wooded swamps extend along the tributaries of the Forest River, edge Strongwater Brook 12 •bi•�i• .��.� ' pppJ .V. �^ x I yP Ili J _ / ,,,, �itl"��f,�• r -tit a COD lie 94 iLh CD Imo_ L i is os � ° c �� M � �Si/poi , �h •�, o west of Highland Avenue, and border Thompson's Meadow, a large wet meadow (owned by the Town of Marblehead) adjacent to the Conservation Area and Highland Park. Natural areas of thick, woody vegetation are rare in Salem, both because of development pressures over the centuries and because the shallow or nonexistent soils of much of the Salem Highlands will not support woody plants of significant size or density. Remaining areas of this type, which contribute to the variety of Salem's landscape include: the slope facing Spring Pond, the area west of Strongwater Brook, the hill directly between the Forest River salt marshes and Thompson's Meadow, areas in Highland Park and between Highland Park and Thompson's Meadow, and areas south of Swampscott Road surrounding the Prophet Elias Monastery near the Salem-Swampscott line. C. Water Resources Surface water. In addition to the saltwater expanses of Salem Harbor and Beverly Harbor, major water bodies in the City include the Forest River, the Danvers River, the North River, the South River Canal, Strongwater Brook, Spring Pond, and the Gravel Pit Pond. Old Mill Pond and Rosie's Pond are slowly being filled in by their surrounding marshes. There are also small ponds at Peter's Point. The three rivers -- the North, South, and Forest Rivers -- define the City's major watersheds. The Gravel Pit Pond is owned by Marblehead for an emergency water supply. Spring Pond, which straddles the Salem-Peabody line, is part of the water supply system for the City of Peabody. Flood hazard areas. The boundaries of the one hundred year floodplain are shown on Map 4: Hydrology. Floodplain and shoreline areas in Salem are necessary to conservation because of their role in flood control. Beyond the floodplains, wetland and stream areas are periodically flooded. Many areas affected by seasonal flooding (such as the North River) have characteristics of both freshwater wetlands and tidal flats. Wetlands. There are approximately 171 acres of inland wetlands (i.e. freshwater marshes and swampland) in Salem. Freshwater marshes in Salem include Spring Pond, Thompson's Meadow, a marsh in Highland Park, a marsh on Strongwater Brook, and marshes along the Forest River and South River. Fresh water marshes provide habitat for birds and marsh animals, replenish groundwater, and store surface runoff, slowing the progress of flood waters. Wooded swamplands in Salem are located along Forest River tributaries, north and south of Swampscott Road, along Strongwater Brook tributaries west of Highland Avenue, and opposite Thompson's Meadow east of the B & M railroad tracks. Wooded swamps recharge groundwater areas by absorbing water during spring rain periods and gradually 13 LIJ lie .0 Al z 14:' r ...::•r� .3 4 l a YA fV � Ll Cr,�'F.:''' :+ .�'�`-' , � / 't�`ZV•��;p - �:J _ w._1 +���.-.t�,t�rrr��' a p � zzwYV (o .� �,�. � >:tt . .•�/ r�. � j' I I I map � Ln co O j yr ( r' s rY� releasing it during summer months. Moreover, because of their water holding abilities, swamps are also excellent flood control areas. lW - Forest River Conservation Area There are approximately 37 acres of salt water marshes in Salem, including the Forest River estuary and small areas surrounding Peter's Point in the Danvers River. Salt marshes are highly productive ecosystems which form the basis of the food chain and protect marine life during spawning and growth periods. Salt marshes also protect inland areas from ocean storm damage. Because of their flushing abilities, salt marshes also clean inland waters. Aquifer recharge areas . Groundwater recharge takes place in the Forest River estuary and other wetlands. The high percentage of impermeable surfaces in Salem, both natural and man-made, results in a high rate of precipitation runoff. D. Vegetation Forest land. Wooded vegetation found today in Salem is "secondary growth" and includes oak, birch, hickory, and white pine in the forest areas. Thickly wooded uplands' which serve as halItat for both birds and mammals are rare. 14 Wetland vegetation. In freshwater marshes, the predominant vegetation is narrow- leaf cattail and phragmites, an invasive reed. Invasive exotic species such as purple loosestrife are also evident. Wooded swamps typically contain trees and shrubs such as alder, willow, dogwood, and red maple. Vegetation typical of the salt marshes includes saltwater cord grass, high water cord grass, spike grass, and sea lavender. Rare plant species. The Massachusetts Natural Heritage and Endangered Species Program, an agency of the Department of Fisheries, Wildlife, and Environmental Law Enforcement, has listed five rare plant species as historically documented in Salem. The last documented observation of any of these species was in 1901, but habitat for them continues to exist and individuals may still be extant. (See Appendix B: Rare and Endangered Species for more detailed information.) (See Map 5: Vegetation and Table 7: Plants Typical of Salem Habitats.) E. Fisheries and Wildlife The combination of aquatic, wetland, and upland environments, and their edges give Salem an unusually wide variety of habitats for such an urbanized place. Salem's parks, "urban wilds," and suburban residential areas support a fairly diverse number of species. Fish, shellfish, birds, mammals, and reptiles that have been documented in Salem are listed in Table 8. Rare animal species. The Massachusetts Natural Heritage and Endangered Species Program, an agency of the Department of Fisheries, Wildlife, and Environmental Law Enforcement, has listed thirteen rare animal species as historically documented in Salem. Only 3 species of birds on this list were documented in recent decades. The most recent documented observation of any of the other listed animals dates from 1934. However, as in the case of listed plants, the habitat for these species remains and undocumented individuals may exist. (See Appendix B: Rare and Endangered Species for more detailed information.) F. Scenic Resources and Unique Environments Scenic landscapes. Salem has a number of scenic natural and historic landscapes which are attractive in themselves and/or provide scenic views: the Willows, Derby Wharf, Winter Island, the Common, Forest River Park, Ledge Hill Park, Highland Park, Gallows Hill Park, the Forest River Conservation Area, and the Misery Islands Reservation. Major characteristics or unusual geologic features, and any other resources for potential protection and exploration. Many of the most important unique natural and 15 cultural environments in Salem are already preserved. Acquisition of the Leggs Hill property, which contains Salem's highest point, has been under discussion. In addition, improvement of downtown waterfront access and amenities is a priority of the City government, which recently received the results of a planning study for waterfront redevelopment. Cultural, archeological and historic areas. Salem has a long tradition of historic preservation and consciousness. The early establishment of the Peabody Museum and Essex Institute (now the Peabody-Essex Museum) testifies to Salem residents' concern for their cultural heritage. The Salem National Maritime Historic Site was the first urban historic site designated by Congress for preservation and administration by the National Park Service. Although the continuing maintenance of historic properties requires substantial attention and resources, both private owners and public institutions focus considerable efforts in this direction. Salem's historic resources include: • one of the few remaining colonial period wharves in the country ' - • many seventeenth and early ,l eighteenth century structures from the Puritan and early maritime periods - • four local historic districts �� r encompassing approximately 550 seventeenth, eighteenth, and early nineteenth century structures • a large early cotton textile factory, immigrant settlement houses and neighborhoods, and leather industry archeological . resources - - • historic sites associated with the late seventeenth century witchcraft _ trials - - Salem has twenty-four National Register _ - _- - Individual Properties and nine National Register Historic Districts. A multi-million dollar improvement project is underway at the National Maritime Historic Site which Turner Street at Salem Harbor will be capped by the construction of a and the House of Seven Gables replica tall ship to be moored at Derby Wharf. 16 The archeological survey of Salem prepared for the City in 1988 lists preservation priority areas for prehistoric sites and historic sites based on previous archeological findings and historic documentation. (See Table 9 for more information.) Areas of critical environmental concern. Salem has no state-listed Areas of Critical Environmental Concern. (See Map 6: Scenic Resources and Unique Environments.) G. Environmental Problems Hazardous waste sites. State-listed confirmed hazardous waste sites are shown in Appendix C. Salem has one Federal Superfund site, known as Salem Acres, at 57 Marlborough Road. PCBs, sludge, wastewater and chromium were released at this undeveloped site from a lagoon or pit resulting in a groundwater release, a surface water release and a threat to the soil. Landfills. No landfills currently operate in Salem. The last landfill was closed approximately 50 years ago and was located at the present site of the Bentley School. Solid waste is collected at the curbside by a private contractor once a week and is taken to Laidlaw Waste System, a transfer station located in Peabody. At the transfer station, wastes are compacted and then transported to either a materials recovery facility in West Roxbury or a landfill in Plainville. Salem also operates a successful curbside recycling program and is a member of the North Shore Regional Recycling Committee. Erosion. Natural erosion occurs along the Danvers River from Cabot Farm northward, in the northwestern section of Collins Cove, and the east side of Winter Island. There is seawall erosion at Juniper Point. Removal of natural vegetation along the banks of the North River, parts of Memorial Drive, and the areas near March Street and the Salem-Beverly Bridge makes these areas vulnerable to erosion. In addition, City regulations do not require soil conservation measures to mitigate erosion during construction. Chronic flooding. According to the City Engineer there is periodic flooding at the following locations: • Juniper Point - Winter, Cheval, and Hosmer Streets • Bridge and Howard Streets - the drains fill with seawater at high tide and then cannot accommodate additional water when it rains • Commercial Street and North River Canal area • Emmerton and Forrester Streets 17 i .� .�00, 0 H istoric Districts �r View_ s nmon • Salem Wood 1 Water Views lem Willows 1 Fore r ;> Cons'' -.-- Will er Island • �r ��. ID UNIQUE ENVIRONMENTS • Canal Street between Ocean and Hersey, where there is a congested drain line • Jefferson Avenue near Margin Street As part of its drainage and road improvement plans, the City will be addressing these flooding problems. Sedimentation. Sediment is carried into Salem's rivers and harbor by stormwater drains and runoff. The undredged portions of Salem Harbor and the rivers are extremely shallow. Development impact. Because of the paucity of easily developable land in Salem, the City is not under severe development pressure. However, the new development that does take place is carefully monitored by the Planning Board and Conservation Commission to avoid environmental damage. For example, approval of proposed drainage systems routinely requires gas and oil separators in catch basins which must be cleaned out regularly. Restricted use of salt as a de-icing agent on roadways and parking areas proposed for construction is also a condition of approval. Many wetlands along Highland Avenue have been lost to landfill, and the water quality of the lowlands and coastal plains is still unsatisfactory, threatening recreation land in these areas. Ground and surface water pollution: point and non-point. Water pollution in Salem includes historic pollution from industrial uses which can affect water if sediments are disturbed, a few remaining combined sewer outflows, boat waste, and stormwater runoff. The state goals for water quality in Salem Harbor, the North River and the Forest River are to make those water bodies fishable and swimmable. None of these uses is currently supported, according to a 1995 report by the Massachusetts Bays Program. All shellfish beds (836 acres) have been closed for harvesting in Salem since the 1960s. However, efforts to eliminate point pollution should improve water quality in the next five years. The South Essex Sewerage District (SESD) is building a secondary treatment plant which is expected to begin operation in late 1997. A program of extensive rehabilitation, repair, and replacement of the City's water, sewer, and drainage systems is underway, including elimination of combined sewer outflows and cross-connections, to improve water quality, pressure, and flow. Both stationary and mobile boat waste pump- out stations have been established to ameliorate pollution from boats. As a result of all these efforts, nonpoint pollution from stormwater runoff will soon be the only major remaining source of pollution to Salem waters. The City is preparing a pamphlet for distribution to all residents to let them know how they can reduce their contribution to water pollution. Salem Sound 2000, a public-private partnership 18 encompassing six municipalities, has active scientific, educational, and community programs focused on improving water quality in the region. ............................................................................................................................................................................................................... :ENVIRONMENTAL INVENTORY AND ANALYSIS: IMPLICATIONS FOR OPEN SPACE AND RECREATION > Much of the remaining undeveloped land in Salem is marked by the: presence of ledge (bedrock at or near the surface), steep slopes, or wetlands. Water quality is improving as a result of programs to control point pollution.; :Salem's cultural landscapes receive significant protection, as do many of the: City's natural landscapes, in particular the City's last remaining natural estuary, the Forest River. Preservation, if not restoration, of other wetlands; :is essential and more visual and physical access to the water is needed. The: :rarest natural landscape resource in the City is wooded upland. .............................................................. . . . fi - - SECTION 5 - INVENTORY OF LANDS OF CONSERVATION AND RECREATION INTEREST A. Protected Parcels Conservation Lands. The Salem Conservation Commission holds title to 128.91 acres of land which is protected as conservation land in perpetuity. Most of this land is composed of the numerous parcels that make up the Forest River Conservation Area, much of it swamp, wet meadow, and marsh, with some upland woods and brush. Hiking trails and a marsh boardwalk exist in part of the conservation area, but the Conservation Commission does not budget funds for maintenance. Park& Recreation Department Lands. The City of Salem has 39 parcels of park or playground land, ranging from Highland Park, the City's biggest park, to numerous neighborhood playgrounds, and tiny urban squares. Eighty-five percent of the City's 557.87 acres of parks and playgrounds are dedicated parklands under Article 97 of the state constitution and are managed by the Park & Recreation Department. Conversion of these lands to other uses would require action by the state legislature. In several cases, 19 city-owned parcels on paper streets have been added to existing protected parks. These parcels are not permanently protected. In addition, there are several city-owned areas that the Park & Recreation Department maintains but which are not permanently protected: Broad Street Playground, Patten Park, and Memorial Field. Cabot Farm Playground, a 2-acre parcel, is also managed by the Park & Recreation Department but owned by the Kernwood Country Club. This land is somewhat protected by the Country Club's Chapter 61 B status, but is not permanently protected. (See Item C below.) In 1990 the City of Salem launched a park improvement program. An annual park and playground inventory and improvement plan has been implemented ever since, with resulting improvements to virtually every park and playground in the City at a cost of$ 2.2 million by the end of fiscal year 1996. The funds come primarily from federal and state grant programs. Salem's network of parks and playgrounds effectively covers almost the entire City. There are, however, two neighborhoods that lack totlots or small playgrounds for the use of younger children who cannot cross major roads to get to the nearest playground: the Cabot Street area in South Salem, and the Beaver Street area near Boston Street. The Point, Salem's most densely-populated neighborhood. could also benefit from more open space. The parks in the neighborhood, Mary Jane Lee Park and Palmer Cove, are very heavily used. (Appendix D: Parks and Playgrounds Inventory contains maps and assessments of each park and playground in the City.) f i Greenlawn Cemetery 20 Cemeteries. Public and private cemeteries in Salem take up 225.48 acres of land and contribute to the City's inventory of open spaces, both downtown and in North Salem. In addition, several Salem cemeteries have historic importance. Public cemeteries comprise 62.71 acres, including the seventeenth-century cemetery at Charter Street (1.47 acres) and the 55.8-acre Greenlawn Cemetery, laid out in the early nineteenth century. It is reputedly the second-oldest landscaped cemetery in the country (after Mt. Auburn in Cambridge). B. City-Owned and Private Unprotected Parcels City-owned open parcels. The City owns 93 open parcels of land totaling 115.74 acres, including parking lots. Some of these parcels are extremely small; only one parcel is over 10 acres - the 38-acre tract at 0 Loring Avenue rear, much of which is wetlands. (See Table 10: Size of City-Owned Open Parcels.) Although these parcels are not formally protected, a substantial number are not developable because they are mostly wetlands or very steep, or they are small remnants of land left over many years ago after subdivision into house lots. Many of these parcels function as "urban wilds," natural buffers which provide open space and environmental services (wetlands, habitat)within the urban environment. Certain parcels are smaller than required by zoning for development, and some cover the Palmer Cove and Collins Cove flats. Five parcels have addresses on a paper street and have been incorporated into Gallows Hill Playground. Two parcels are small inner harbor islands, Jeggle Island, and the Island Southwest of Jeggle Island. Ram Island, also City-owned, lies off Marblehead. The City also owns several open parcels on Bakers Island. Given the delicate island environment and considerable summer population already using the island, it might be prudent to convert these parcels into permanently protected conservation land. Two of the parcels on this list were recently deeded to the City and will be used for a neighborhood park on Northey Street. Seven parcels are used for parking downtown; the best alternative use for these lands in the City core would not likely be recreation or open space. Privately-owned parcels. Like many of the City-owned open parcels, many private parcels are not developable because of the existence of wetlands or extremely steep ridges. New England Power Company owns approximately 75 acres for electric power rights-of-way. These lands have important buffer and conservation value and most would be difficult to develop because of site conditions. It is highly unlikely that there will be any change of use in the near future, though the power company may eventually change its operations or distribution methods in Salem. Most of the remaining developable land in the City is in relatively small parcels. 21 However, there are several larger tracts of land in South Salem that extend into Marblehead that have long been of interest to the City of Salem for recreational and open space use: • 0 Leggs Hill Road - 18.48 acres, including the highest point in Salem • 485 Lafayette Street - 1.39 acres, known as the "Lead Mills" property, which is on the water at the mouth of the Forest River estuary. Other private parcels have potential for expanding recreational use on the North River and creation of pedestrian and bicycle trails: • 16-20 Franklin Street- 1.67 acres, abutting Franklin Park and currently occupied by an automobile junkyard which could be relocated to a suitable site • Boston & Maine Railroad right-of-way - unused railroad lines can be transformed into bicycle and pedestrian trails -North River Parkway (Bridge Street Bypass) - The preliminary design for this new roadway includes a landscaped pedestrian/bicycle path along the road from Washington Street to March Street. This plan will also provide for best management practices to treat road runoff into the North River. In addition there is a parcel on Highland Avenue, the site of an old farm, which could be studied for possible nature value in conjunction with neighboring NEPCO lots. Potential post-mining uses for the Lynn Sand and Stone Company gravel pit are also worthy of consideration. Finally, there is some discussion of seeking funding for acquisition and construction of a new wharf for both cargo and cruise ships adjacent to the NEPCO plant. That project would include some public open space. C. Public and Nonprofit Parcels City-owned open parcels which have not been specifically protected are discussed in item B above. However, Salem also includes open lands owned by neighboring municipalities, the federal government, the state, and the transit authority. Nonprofit organizations include recreation, educational, and conservation institutions. Other Municipalities. The City of Peabody owns 146.22 acres, originally acquired for watershed land, in southwest Salem near Spring Pond and off Marlborough Road around the Peabody water tank. The Marlborough Road parcel may be included in a proposed Peabody municipal golf course. The Town of Marblehead owns two significant parcels, originally for reserve watershed protection, and two smaller parcels of less than half an acre each. The two 22 large parcels are known as "Gravel Pit Pond," 26.9 acres at 445 Loring Avenue, and "Thompson's Meadow," 79 acres at 161 Swampscott Road, adjacent to Highland Park. The Gravel Pit Pond land is zoned for single family housing. Thompson's Meadow is zoned Residential Conservation, meaning any residential development requires two-acre lots. Most of this parcel is wetlands, but 12 to 14 acres could be developed. Acquisition of Thompson's Meadow has long been one of the City's conservation goals, but Marblehead has been unwilling to sell. Because the parcel is no longer official watershed protection land, the town is now believed to be willing to consider a sale. The Town of Swampscott owns 1.8 acres on Swampscott Road abutting Thompson's Meadow. Although this parcel is zoned for business development, it is almost entirely wetlands. Except as noted above, there is no indication that the neighboring municipalities plan any changes in the use of these parcels. State Lands. The Commonwealth of Massachusetts owns 62 acres at Salem State College. Some of that property is open space used for athletic fields and passive recreation, with relatively easy access for all Salem residents. Federal Lands. The U.S Department of the Interior owns 8.21 acres in downtown Salem as the Maritime National Historic Site, including Derby Wharf on the water, an herb garden, and other small open spaces open to the public. The federal government also owns a lighthouse site on 8.8 acres of Bakers Island. The lighthouse is no longer in use by the Coast Guard and it is not known if any new uses are planned. Some Salem residents would like to see this parcel provide public access to Bakers Island, which is otherwise entirely private, including the only pier. Any kind of public access proposal would undoubtedly meet stiff opposition from property owners on Bakers Island. Transportation Lands. The MBTA owns 36.5 acres at 242 Bridge Street, the parcel containing the commuter rail line track. Nonprofit Lands. Nonprofit lands of recreation or conservation interest in Salem are open to the public to varying degrees. Two large private cemeteries in Salem, Harmony Grove and St. Mary's Cemetery, and one very small private church cemetery, St. Peter's, total 162.77 acres of land that contribute to the City's open spaces. Two significant parcels of Salem land are used for summer camp activities open to participants only. Camp Lion of Lynn, MA (the Lynn Lions' Club) owns 69.31 acres of unprotected land which are used by the Campfire Girls summer camp and other youth organizations. The property is also a favorite location for birdwatchers. Although the 23 _ �t � �0.. - •1.Or T JP N. Air 1+ �`"Ir♦ • rrt}" �-; ; `1A\�Rj•. r 1 � e � �• .�I• � f�..r ' S .t. 1,V '�,_a �1�,�• _ "����� .d w �•' I/ _ '.F�`1`9 / \� l Ir�+�'• R' n•.a�sY�t' 1!�� ,.�. :i;' -* V .. .I `«• .ish;`�.���`'�,t',•mil' l� rcl � , � ^.J i• !rr i +'•- ��• ��� 'y � a� 1G.'{1nC1 w�)�t�..:�'a� :I � - � f.!y�,.'•`�,I -, • n,�:'.} -.�d'• 1. ` ` aF13�%. - 'T.•`fJ. �7�A „l�Coll•Iu,r'�St; ,,�7•I�rr�� � 1 •�� �. Y1 �'+'1�'� 6,,�r lj '� (S 1.0' l 'r?�l<C• �y 4'7`• `'•�s.�1~' �.L '�ie I'':5 rye. r•:r,� ''t . e+•,j�n •� ,.'.N :`�7 -r- �•/ '.F , t• u IdB H�yE+,: 04 :{�4 1:,. �LlJ' ,� .i p 7�'.'_`�-k�+ •r' r,o\' l�,T 1 •�L "i ?r , f.•: 4 r+� - .l - �(s/��',,,,;�� , 4•' , I F ..;' ...•i .rG,L^a �:' ,.i+t1•'J•i •N' �L�,e �I. .� d ',y��•� A� •o` :• •i.T��/'�`` 4 (� 712.k! 1�j 1 I;i I I � l� .ay'1' �^�- I :\ ' `I \ "!� „S•^^I■ «`l:�a.• _r7 J1^. -7.i 1 PROTECTEDt LANDS .,• _ '� fl.,. � �. / r, ,• �,:` �/ ,�,;• '�:I� � �• �; l:`� t � � r � ® City Parks and Playgrounds Conservation Consery Land � .,s � (w�•� a 1 .� ', ES Cemeteries ' ,'��f/:rt^ ��• o �},. �:aIE_1�'" Federal Park r� j` 1` -�\• / C� i�`� �' ?.A' f• a'- /1 y\ \\� ,J 1•' i�1 Chaplet 61 ';y:a';• �` '� .� ..`� -i it - .\ J' - - f •� .�;r�i'�, vJ.s: � / _ _ ` � (.:1� Nonprofit(not shown on map) A' `�,•\ ♦ �• \, � M / •• �. .t.• ''♦ �� ;!l, (irc:d Misery IsImIJ �•t' .J, ��• ,\l ` ! r• -V� r• :, Z �� ,�. .` �1�,` Linlc Misery Island �.` .• ;,, [ -,. _ • ' ,\ 2 UNPROTECTED LANDS Parks and Playgrounds - ( Ygrounds y. II \ .� e ;N' lac- '� 1 r•11 ® City-Owned Open Parcels f1 _ �� .\.t,�� ,(';�i '3'°i+ ! '`_ .`,� �► 3� � Js �a . ", Not shown on map: Islands and island parcels i ` - _, • ;�,•. 'a `" t�`v. .' �- _ \'' ® r Municipalities Owned By Other i alities ^-�'.v-�_' � ,I •• .�• � ��/ fit'o �,• ��y' \\1 j .r.>;,o,a,,�-ti'..•�<;.. `'I 11 ; \+144a I ..{ :v.f � ( \ 0.,�1+4 •, �` I NO nprofit y.. .� c � 1 ` , • tr `tf\� .: ,a `` Not shown �.� _ :rxs„+csc ._. ? 1. Y ,'.,,,.�a�' ; Z1. �: y `, fi, '• 1 Isll map: ' + � :• Z`{ s'aOd�(. �� P`IFiid� M ('t1ilJYcn'aI(olll SlJlld '� r('^ 1 ��, t 'aa b 'r •��•- •�' ��'.a i �h�� ��� h��� r "' ('11111: IFlallll Isr �f - .•7��I�� �. �l:t;,, iMi r... �>��Y�,�` � � l t OG �.�''n Ilr 1••;• _ _r I. ♦ - y`� • '•tibv =Lri., :, 4 tl3ySi: y�' ?! \ �x 1\�•1 —.'';•.;,:`�': <a�'�'' •,it _���Q�dL'll.�i.:. a �,% ' '`�• ~`'-+` �`�'-''- •al. .b -s „ �1 4 1 . •sa:1 r>b '\• t',, ''. •�_\. :` :x;.a�' - �� j411 I' -♦O, tE\`..�, ����'�L ^-; 'Ki Iyv _ ` �: �iqC, .-�•: •"ai?:,'�+,.\r.' �\ S!�- `J n�n�r�• •aa.�r l ' —�-Jd y -•� R;' • i-• -�'"?'':ram: r/,� $"t%f,�� ._ -� '�V:,r� � •tk:'r' � rt r �' i'i �;— I MAP 7: LANDS OF CONSERVATION AND RECREATION INTEREST C071Y OF �''•1'�.`I�.�.%' °�..`:�. '`� ° LAC � 9 MQ� �o t 10,114 s 191 RL 9y property has no deed restriction, the charter of Camp Lion specifies that the land is to be used for youth recreation. The Marblehead/ Swampscott YMCA owns Children's Island (formerly known as Cat Island). It is used as a children's day camp during the summer and can also be reserved on weekends for adult and family groups. Children's Island has a swimming pool and playing fields. The Kernwood Country Club is a private club. However, it is not fenced and neighborhood residents are permitted access for walking, sledding, and cross-country skiing. The Club's recreational lands receive tax abatements under Chapter 61 B which operates as an incentive for continued open space and recreational use. If the land is offered for sale, the City will have first right of refusal, and if the land use is changed to nonrecreational uses, the owner must repay the last 10 years of abated taxes, with interest, to the City. The Trustees of Reservations (TTOR) own two beautiful islands in Salem Harbor, Great Misery Island (75 acres) and Little Misery Island (5.78 acres). On summer weekends there is a boat to Great Misery Island run by TTOR from Beverly. Otherwise, only those with private boat transportation have access to the island. There is no pier. The House of Seven Gables includes in its 1.78 acres on Derby Street a gracious waterfront park. This park is open only to visitors to the House. Finally the Trustees of the Plummer Farm School, a home for boys, own 23.60 acres on Winter Island for the use of the residents of the home. (See Map 7: Lands of Conservation and Recreation Interest and the Land Inventory Matrix.) SECTION 6 - RECREATION PROGRAMS A. City Recreational Facilities Parks. The community survey results (though unscientific) suggest that the Willows, Winter Island, Forest River Park, and the Common draw users from all over the City. Many of the other large parks, however, are rarely visited by residents from outside the immediate neighborhood, especially Mack Park, Gallow's Hill Park, and McCabe Park (Kernwood Marina). Promoting public awareness of these parks should be part of any program to expand residents' knowledge of the City's open space and recreation resources. Athletic fields and courts. Salem's athletic fields are located in parks and on school grounds. They are very heavily used and include 7 Little League baseball diamonds, 3 major league baseball diamonds, 3 regulation softball diamonds, 4 regulation soccer fields, and one football field. In addition there are 16 tennis courts (3 lighted) and 25 basketball 24 courts (2 lighted). The Municipal Golf Course in Highland Park has 9 holes and soon will have a new clubhouse. There is heavy demand for all the athletic fields which are used by school teams, city-sponsored teams, and private leagues. Because of this demand it is difficult to allocate the proper amount of time for fields to rest between games. Staffed playgrounds. In July and August, 21 playgrounds are staffed with two playground instructors each from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Some 250 children participated in the summer playground program in the summer of 1995. Waterfront facilities. Certified lifeguards staff the city's seven beaches (two at Forest River) and the Olympic-sized salt water swimming pool at Forest River. There are approximately 1500 mooring spaces in Salem Harbor. Spaces are in high demand and usually filled by the beginning of the boating season. Kernwood Marina, which has space for only some 15 boats, is particularly in demand because it offers parking and a boat ramp. Winter Island offers about 150 spaces in Cat Cove, a tender rack with 126 spaces, and floats which can accommodate five to seven boats. New boat ramps are scheduled for construction in 1996 at both Winter Island and Kernwood Marina. Five private yacht clubs and marinas offer mooring spaces and approximately 200 boat slips to members. J � The Willows Other recreational facilities. Salem's parks include 30 picnic grounds. There are pedestrian nature trails in Highland Park, parts of the Forest River Conservation Area and along Collins Cove, as well as a stone dust walking trail around the Common. The first 25 section of the multi-purpose trail system has been completed at Webb Street. The wetlands mitigation portion of the Salem/Beverly Transportation Project will create a new park with bike and pedestrian paths along the North River between Flint and Washington Streets. There is no city-owned recreation building in Salem. Indoor activities sponsored by the City use school facilities and private organizations such as the YMCA also have indoor recreational facilities. B. Team Sports and Fitness Programs The Salem Parks and Recreation Department offers a wide array of summer and winter programs to residents, including basketball leagues for adults, youth, and children, softball leagues,and a women's volleyball league. An aerobics program attracts approximately 200 participants. Free swimming lessons are available at Forest River pool. In addition, the City offers a sailing program. Eight privately operated sports leagues offer Little League Baseball and Softball, Babe Ruth Baseball, Legion Baseball, North Shore Baseball, Youth Soccer, Youth Football, Youth Hockey, and Youth Tennis. Salem State College baseball and women's softball teams also use city fields, as do teams from Salem businesses. The sports leagues serve many residents. Youth Soccer and Little League each have 1000-1200 participants, and the city-sponsored basketball league attracts about 500 children and youths. In addition there are several teams which play in inter-city leagues. Softball and volleyball leagues have the largest adult participation: 20-23 men's softball teams (about 275 men), 8 women's softball teams (about 100 women), and 18 volleyball teams (approximately 220 participants). There is also an adult over-30 soccer team and two Hispanic softball teams which play teams from other communities. According to Parks and Recreation staff, participation in the City's sports programs increases every year, but programs are limited by the facilities available. As noted earlier, the demand for athletic fields and facilities for team sports is very high. In the spring and summer almost every field is in use on weekday evenings and during the day on weekends, precluding a resting period for the fields. Indoor programs, such as basketball, must compete with school programs for the use of school facilities. C. Private Recreational Facilities Private recreational facilities in Salem offer activities for a fee. Indoor swimming pools are available at the Salem YMCA and the Salem State College O'Keefe Center. Salem State also has an indoor skating rink and the YMCA offers a variety of fitness programs. Salem State programs are available to community members on a limited basis during the school year and more widely during the summer. Children's activities are 26 available at the Boys and Girls Club and the House of Seven Gables Settlement House. Kernwood Country Club has a golf course, swimming pool, and tennis courts available to members, who pay substantial membership fees and must provide references. The Naumkeag Association has a facility on the ocean near the Willows which members can use for events. The membership fees are modest. There are also five private yacht clubs or marinas: Jubilee, Hawthorne Cove, Salem Willows, Palmer Cove, and Pickering Cove. These facilities offer approximately 200 boat slips. SECTION 7 - COMMUNITY GOALS A. Description of Process The Open Space and Recreation Plan Committee members developed community goals by analyzing existing environmental conditions and recreational resources in Salem, reviewing other planning documents which touched on these issues, such as the recreation and open space goals of the Master Plan Update committee and the Maritime Development District Study, analyzing the results of a survey of residents, and interviewing neighborhood leaders. In addition, the Committee consulted the staff members in the Parks and Recreation and Planning Departments with responsibility for environmental and recreational issues. Public review of the draft Plan during October 1996 and a public hearing on November 4, 1996, provided yet more public input. In early fall of 1995 approximately 1500 survey questionnaires on open space and recreation needs were distributed to public places in the City of Salem, including the library, banks, City Hall, and retail businesses. One hundred completed surveys were returned. A copy of the survey and the results are included in Appendix E. In order to broaden the range of community input, Committee members also interviewed local leaders representing neighborhood associations and other interest groups about open space and recreation issues: North River Historic Neighborhood Juniper Community Club Association Federal Street Neighborhood Boston Street Improvement Association Association Point Neighborhood Action Group Chestnut Street Neighborhood Salem Common Neighborhood Association Association Salem Harbor Community Development Northfields Neighborhood Association Corporation Mack Park Area Little League South Salem Neighborhood Association Friends of Salem Woods Pickman Park Neighborhood Association 27 B. Statement of Open Space and Recreation Goals Within its 8 square miles Salem is richly endowed with extremely valuable natural and cultural resources. The depth and breadth of its architectural heritage may be unmatched by any other city of its size. At the same time, the City is not entirely built up and has an extensive network of playgrounds, parks, and protected natural areas. The natural landscape ranges from high, ledge-crowned ridges to quiet ocean coves and the wetlands of the Forest River estuary. Protection of the City's unique resources for recreational, environmental, and cultural purposes and upgrading of access and maintenance is the community's overriding goal. Acquisition of new recreation and conservation lands is secondary, although there are a few select sites which are needed for conservation or recreation purposes. Salem residents identify particularly strongly with their water resources. An ideal open space system would provide better access to the waterfront, both visual and physical, improved beaches and oceanfront public lands, and a more attractive landscape along the North and South Rivers. Residents also support a system of bicycle and pedestrian trails. In addition, they recognize the importance of conservation land but would like better trails and nature study information in the City's conservation lands, particularly the Forest River Conservation Area. Finally, residents strongly support actions to enhance environmental health, especially water quality improvement. SECTION 8 -ANALYSIS OF NEEDS A. Summary of Resource Protection Needs Over the more than 350 years of Salem's history, many natural environmental processes have been significantly modified by human agency. Two of the three major river basins in the City have been filled and/or channelized, and drainage and encroachment upon other wetlands has been widespread. Upland meadows and woodlands have disappeared because of development for agriculture and housing. Harbor and stream pollution remains a concern. The preservation of remaining natural ecological processes and examples of Salem's environmental diversity, and the restoration, where possible, of compromised ecological processes, are the most critical environmental issues facing the City— both to promote ecosystem health and to provide residents with a better quality of life. Survey respondents overwhelmingly supported the preservation of conservation land and pollution prevention and control. Although they generally supported acquisition of more conservation land, they preferred using state or federal funding, rather than city funds, for any acquisition. The City's environmental goals focus on protection and enhancement of existing resources and selective acquisition of a few key properties. Coastal habitat preservation and improvement of water quality and beaches is essential, particularly in light of plans for 28 waterfront development. Although the City's last remaining natural estuary, the Forest River, is permanently protected by conservation lands, improved oversight of these lands can better ensure that they are not used for illegal dumping or other damaging activities. The Conservation Commission should continue aggressive enforcement of wetlands regulations and protection of wetland resources. B. Summary of Community's Needs Salem residents recognize and value the City's unique cultural and recreational resources. Historic sites and architecture, waterfront sites, and important parks such as the Willows, the Common, Winter Island, and Forest River Park, symbolize Salem's sense of place to the people who live here. Excellent maintenance of these "symbolic landscapes" is especially important to a sense of community well-being. Community priorities include improved maintenance of existing facilities, improvement of beaches and waterfront access (including access to harbor islands), and better access to Salem's recreational resources by pedestrian and bicycle trails. Residents express a desire for nature-based and environmentally-friendly recreation — biking, hiking, and skiing trails along the water, in the woods, and linking Salem sites with areas in neighboring jurisdictions. As is the case in many communities, there is great demand in Salem for a limited number of athletic fields and for space for indoor recreational activities. Salem has made a strong commitment to providing park access to the disabled. All parks renovated within the last five years meet Americans with Disabilities Act requirements. The City's goal is to remove all barriers from every City park. In addition, four major parks will have specially designed or adapted facilities for disabled persons: Forest River Park, Salem Common, Salem Willows, and Winter Island. C. Management Needs - Potential Change of Use Management Needs. The survey and interviews suggest that community residents tend to prefer enhanced maintenance over acquisition of more property. Parks and playgrounds are well-maintained, but conservation lands are not properly maintained due to a lack of maintenance funding. Maintenance expectations are very high for the "symbolic landscapes," such as the Common and the Willows, which are emblems of Salem's sense of place. Maintenance trends are positive. The recent merger of the Parks and Recreation Departments under one superintendent has consolidated many maintenance responsibilities. Current management is shared by several entities: • Parks and playgrounds: Park & Recreation Department • Trash removal in parks and playgrounds: Park & Recreation; Public Works; private contractor. Trash barrels are painted different colors to indicate which of the 29 departments or the contractor is responsible. There can be barrels of all three colors in a single park. • Traffic islands outside of downtown: Park & Recreation waters these spaces. Other maintenance is provided by private contractors, summer youth programs, and volunteers. • Downtown from the Washington Street rotary to Riley Plaza, including the Essex Street mall: Cemetery and Shade Tree Department. • Public cemeteries: Cemetery and Shade Tree • Street trees: Cemetery and Shade Tree • Conservation lands: no regular maintenance performed • Lighting: most park lights are rented from Mass Electric, which is responsible for maintenance and repair Some summer maintenance is performed by seasonal labor, mainly students. They can be good workers if there is sufficient training and supervision and programs to ensure such training and supervision should be developed. The City Beautification Committee is investigating the possibility of privatizing the maintenance of all traffic islands to a landscaping company. The small, left-over parcels of City-owned land which are not traffic islands, too small to be parks, and not clearly functional, are often the areas whose maintenance is neglected. New and future open space areas, such as the multi-purpose trail whose first portion has already been built along Webb Street, must also be included systematically in a maintenance plan. Any review of management arrangements should take these areas into account. Accessible parts of the Forest River Conservation Area are suffering from a lack of maintenance, improvement, and oversight. In many places trails are in rough and eroded condition, and degraded by bicycle and motor bike use. The Forest River boardwalk needs repair, but its old-fashioned design — boards dropped onto the marsh — should be abandoned. Reconstruction should use up-to-date designs which protect the marsh as much as possible. Another serious problem in the conservation area is littering and dumping. During site visits in September 1995 a Committee member observed bottles, dumping of trash, and dumping of soil and grass clippings in a parking area by a trail head. Improved maintenance of trails in conservation areas is desired by many residents and illegal dumping should be curbed. However, access and use of conservation areas must be balanced with their primary functions of ecological services and provision of habitat. Finally, continuing the annual inventory of the condition of parks, beaches, cemeteries, and other public spaces will provide information for timely replacement, rehabilitation, and restoration of deteriorated resources. Potential Change of Use. All parks and playgrounds are expected to continue to be 30 heavily used. There is great demand for athletic fields, and the Park & Recreation Department is always looking for new space for more fields, but abutters sometimes object to the noise and parking problems created by team uses and prefer retaining passive recreational uses. The City's annual park planning process, in operation since 1990, has enhanced communication among park neighbors, athletic field users, and City representatives about these issues. The most often discussed open space and recreation issue in Salem is the possibility of expanding the municipal golf course from 9 to 18 holes. (There is consensus on the need for a new clubhouse, which is expected to be under construction in 1996.) In addition, several private parcels of land are under consideration for park or conservation land, and there are plans to purchase unused railroad rights-of-way for a multi-purpose trail system. Golf_Course Expansion. The existing golf course covers 55 acres of Highland Park's 270 acres. Highland Park includes high ledges, wooded uplands (known as Salem Woods), meadows, and wetlands. There is no current expansion proposal, but a 1988 feasibility study presented a conceptual plan to expand the course and all its associated buildings to approximately 83 acres, leaving 187 acres. Proponents of golf course expansion point out that Highland Park would then provide a first class recreational facility while continuing to accommodate non-golf uses such as nature trails and cross-country skiing. An expanded golf course could be funded from the revenue it would generate, as a new golf course would not only be self-sustaining but would generate revenue for the City. Some of that revenue could be used to fund and promote nature study activities, trail maintenance, creation of accessible scenic overlooks, and so on. Opponents of golf course expansion argue that it would replace much of the last remaining wooded uplands in Salem with golf holes. They point out that preservation of specimen trees and woody growth to enhance playing characteristics is not the same as preservation of an entire ecological area. In addition, opponents argue that the modifications of environmental conditions (vegetation, soils, drainage, and so on) where the new holes would be constructed, as well as the chemical maintenance requirements of an additional 9 holes, would inevitably affect adjacent areas, including wetlands. Leggs Hill and Lead Mills Parcels. Both of these private properties straddle the Salem-Marblehead boundary and are being considered for acquisition in conjunction with the Town of Marblehead as open space. As noted earlier, the 18.5-acre Leggs Hill parcel contains the highest point in Salem, overlooking the Forest River tidal basin. It may become subject to development pressure and sale. The Salem portion of the Lead Mills property contains 1.39 acres and is located between Salem Harbor and the Forest River tidal basin. The property owner is willing to donate the property, but remediation of lead- 31 contaminated soil is necessary. Ferris Junkyard. This 1.67-acre property occupies a prominent spot on the North River shore. It abuts Furlong Park and can easily be seen from the train station and the roads which converge on downtown Salem. Relocation of the automobile junkyard business on the parcel to a suitable site and conversion of the property into parkland has been discussed. Railroad Rights-of-Wadi. The City is negotiating to buy the Boston & Maine Railroad right-of-way, which runs into Marblehead, for conversion to a bike/pedestrian trail. The planned Salem Multi-Purpose Trail System includes bike lanes on roadways, walking trails, and conversion of unused railroad rights-of-way to bike/pedestrian trails separated from motorized traffic. The trail system is designed to link with routes in Peabody, Marblehead, and Beverly, thus fitting in with regional plans such as the North Shore Trails Study prepared by the Metropolitan Area Planning Council in 1995. A prototype of the Salem rail to trail conversion is already complete at Webb Street and planning is underway for the Boston & Maine project. (See Appendix G: Proposed Salem Multi-Purpose Trail System.) SECTION 9 - GOALS AND OBJECTIVES The Committee used information from the environmental resource inventory, the community needs inventory(including the survey and interviews) and the 1996 Master Plan Update to develop goals and objectives for recreation and open space development: Goals Objectives Protect and improve coastal and inland -Acquire key wetland and buffer water resources. properties. -improve information and training available to Conservation Commission. -Eliminate/reduce point and nonpoint pollution. -Eliminate/reduce contaminated sediment in rivers. Protect locally rare and unique natural -Protect examples of Salem's ecological resources. variety. Protect and improve areas of historic and -Focus on neglected areas. scenic significance, especially along the -Provide consistent highest maintenance water. standards for "symbolic landscapes." 32 •Acquire key parcels to provide scenic viewing points and visual access to the water, and align multi-purpose trails along waterways to the extent possible. Enhance public access to waterfront and •Improve resident and visitor perception harbor. of and experience of Salem's waterfront and harbor location. Expand recreational facilities and •Provide more recreation options in the programs. following categories: team sports; indoor recreation; winter recreation; water-based recreation; nature-based recreation. Continue capital improvements to parks •Continue to update equipment and and playgrounds as needed. surfacing to comply with current safety and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) standards. Improve public awareness of recreational •Make residents aware of underutilized resources. resources. Improve overall beach and park •Organize maintenance activities for maintenance. maximum efficiency and effectiveness. SECTION 10 - FIVE-YEAR ACTION PLAN Goal 1: Protect and improve coastal and inland water resources. Objective: Identify and plan for acquisition of key wetland and buffer properties. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Plan for acquisition of Thompson's Meadow ■ ■ ■ ■ Objective. Improve expertise of Conservation Commission membership Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Provide workshops or other training for new Conservation Commission members. ■ ■ ■ ■ • Update wetlands map. ■ ■ ■ 33 Objective: Eliminate/reduce point and nonpoint pollution. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Eliminate Combined Sewer Outflows ■ ■ • Publish and distribute to public a pamphlet on resident actions to reduce nonpoint pollution ■ • Develop an ordinance to require soil erosion control at construction sites. ■ • Develop plans for stormwater runoff best management practices into all new development plans through subdivision regulations and zoning ordinances, and in golf course and athletic field maintenance. ■ ■ • Pursue funding to expand household hazardous waste collection program. ■ ■ ■ ■ Objective: Eliminate/reduce contaminated sediment in rivers and harbor. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Request Army Corps of Engineers dredging and sediment disposal of federal channel. ■ • Pursue Seaport Bond funding for dredging and sediment disposal for expanded deep water port. ■ ■ • Dredge South River and dispose of sediment ■ • Pursue funding for sediment testing in the North River basin in preparation for possible dredging and sediment disposal. ■ ■ ■ Goal 2: Protect and improve areas of historic and scenic significance, especially along the water. Objective: Focus on neglected areas. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Inventory City-owned parcels of less than one-quarter acre to determine if they should be retained, offered to abutters, or to neighborhood groups for greenspace projects ■ ■ • Study potential uses for barracks and hangar building at Winter Island ■ ■ • Restore and interpret historic resources on Winter Island ■ ■ 34 Objective: Provide consistent highest maintenance standards for"symbolic landscapes." Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Request City Beautification Committee to create a short list of the most important and emblematic public landscapes, such as the Common, the Willows, and Winter Island, for a special priority maintenance program. ■ Objective:Acquire key parcels and sites for multi-purpose trails, scenic views, and visual access to the water. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Acquire old railroad rights of way for multi-purpose trails ■ ■ • Pursue funding for public space along the North River in the Bridge Street neighborhood ■ ■ ■ • Pursue funding to relocate existing junkyard on North River to a more suitable site and redevelop the parcel as park land ■ ■ ■ • Pursue acquisition of Leggs Hill and Lead Mills properties in conjunction with Marblehead ■ ■ ■ • Pursue funding to acquire parcels for proposed South Harbor Plan. ■ ■ Goal 3: Protect locally rare and unique natural resources. Objective: Protect examples of Salem's ecological variety. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Transfer city-owned parcels on Baker's Island to Conservation Commission for permanent protection. ■ • Develop a process to review policy on the tidal gates at the Forest River estuary from an ecological, public health and economic perspective ■ ■ • Prepare environmental study of possible golf course expansion impact on Salem Woods ■ ■ 35 Goal 4: Expand recreational facilities and programs. Objective: Provide increased recreational opportunities. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Construct multi-purpose trail systems for bikes, pedestrians, and cross-country skiers as funds and land become available ■ ■ ■ ■ • Study feasibility of construction of indoor recreation center ■ ■ • Find a location to provide outdoor ice skating and review control of and opportunities for skating on local ponds ■ ■ ■ • Improve hiking trails in Forest River Conservation Area and Highland Park ■ ■ ■ • Expand programming for water related activities such as swimming, water safety, and environmental awareness ■ ■ ■ • Acquire land for neighborhood totlots or playgrounds as it becomes available in the Cabot Street and Silver Street areas ■ ■ ■ • Find a location, pursue funding, and construct additional soccer fields ■ ■ ■ • Pursue funds to acquire land and construct proposed family recreational park at South River (Peabody and Congress) ■ ■ ■ Goal 5: Continue capital improvements to parks and playgrounds as needed. Objective: Update equipment and surfacing to comply with current safety and ADA standards. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Continue annual inventory and project plan for park maintenance and improvements ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ • Continue ensuring Americans with Disabilities Act compliance in all improvement projects ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ 36 Goal 6: Improve public awareness of recreational and conservation resources. Objective. Make residents aware of underutilized resources. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Publicize recreational opportunities more effectively using mailings, the press, events, cable access TV, etc. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ • Promote use of picnic areas at McCabe Park. ■ ■ ■ ■ • Develop brochures and guides for trails in the Forest River Conservation Area. ■ ■ • Update and republish Salem Woods trail guide. ■ ■ Goal 7: Enhance public access to the waterfront and harbor. Objective: Improve resident and visitor perception of and experience of Salem's waterfront and harbor location. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Pursue funding for continued implementation of the South Harbor Plan for downtown waterfront development ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ • Continue increasing float space at Winter Island pier and construct a new boat ramp ■ • Identify and preserve all existing public waterfront access areas ■ ■ • Convert portion of old Salem-Beverly Bridge to a public recreational pier as part of the Salem/Beverly Transportation Project ■ ■ • Study appropriate access to islands ■ ■ • Connect waterfront to multi-purpose trail system ■ ■ ■ • Increase public landings in downtown ■ ■ • Create public waterfront walkway beginning at Shetland Office Park and downtown to designated port area ■ ■ • Study feasibility of waterfront walkway connecting Forest River Park to downtown ■ ■ 37 Goal 8: Improve overall beach and park maintenance. Objective: Organize maintenance activities for maximum efficiency and effectiveness. Actions 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 • Review management of maintenance activities ■ ■ • Insure adequate supervision of summer maintenance employees ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ • Develop and implement a priority maintenance plan for the symbolic landscapes designated by the City Beautification Committee ■ ■ ■ • Encourage formation of neighborhood "Friends of the Park" groups to assist the City in routine maintenance ■ ■ ■ See Map 8: Five Year Action Plan Consistency with Regional and State Plans. The Metropolitan Area Planning Council (MAPC) and the Commonwealth of Massachusetts have developed recreation and open space plans for metropolitan Boston and for the state as a whole, known as MetroGreen and the Statewide Comprehensive Outdoor Recreation Plan (SCORP) respectively. Salem's focus in this Open Space and Recreation Plan on the protection and enhancement of water resources and waterfront access, as well as the protection of unique landscape and cultural resources and the expansion of recreational opportunites, are consistent with regional and state open space goals. MetroGreen. MAPC's criteria for land protection as delineated in MetroGreen include lands of local conservation interest, rights-of-way and adjacencies with recreational potential, wetlands, scenic landscapes, and major waterbodies. Salem's Action Plan includes proposals which fit under all these criteria. SCORP. Salem is part of the Northeastern Massachusetts region for the purposes of SCORP, though its urban character gives it much in common with the neighboring Metropolitan District Commission (MDC) region. SCORP priorities for the Northeastern Region and the MDC Region include improvement in the maintenance and quality of all types of recreation facilities, development of new sports/recreation facilities, and special attention to water-based recreational activities. Salem's plan contains similar recreation priorities. 38 � . 1100,• } A, Waterfront Access, Acquisition, � � and Recreation i — — Bicycle/Pedestrian Trails: Acquisition and Construction • �k Other Potential Acquisition Projects • Trail Guides and Improvements North River Properties - • Dark development _.,..K ..NO— � , • Recreational Pier Bypass Bike" ath Thompson s Meadow Salem Woods j South i er �•••� Forest River / L. •• Conservation Area Marbiehea ranch Bike Path ^� �..��� � Port Deve ment - public access '�� � `.- �. •^,,.ter' 1 1 ,�•..y• �'t -fit i(hter Island �• Leggs Hill •• ^� L .�v' MAP 8: FIVE-YEAR ACTION PLAN Improvements •� � Lead Mills • �.� v Tawr L Brow n SECTION 11 - PUBLIC COMMENTS Letters of review follow from: • Mayor Neil J. Harrington • Salem Planning Board • Salem Park and Recreation Commission • Salem Conservation Commission • Metropolitan Area Planning Council 39 yig -� frr0 CITY OF SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS NEIL J. HARRINGTON MAYOR November 22, 1996 Craig Wheeler City Planner Salem Planning Department One Salem Greer. Salem, MA 01970 Dear Mr. Wheeler: I have reviewed the draft City of Salem Open Space and Recreation Plan Update prepared by the Planning Department and the Open Space and Recreation Plan Update Committee. The Plan's thorough discussion and analysis of Salem's environmental, recreational, and cultural resources successfully conveys the unique mix of our City's open spaces. The delineation of goals, objectives, and specific actions for implementation makes the Plan a practical and flexible blueprint for open space and recreation activities over the next five years. The Plan's special focus on waterfront issues is consistent with the many initiatives now underway to rejuvenate Salem's maritime identity. I support this Plan and look forward to implementing its recommendations during the next five years. Sincerely, Neil J. Harrington Mayor SALEM CITY HALL • 93 WASHINGTON STREET SALEM, MASSACHUSETTS 01970 • 508/745-9595 FAX 508/744-9327 ICOVDI HassadjusrIts One �$tt1em Guru October 23, 1996 Craig Wheeler City Planner Salem Planning Department One Salem Green Salem, MA 01970 Dear Mr. Wheeler: The Salem Planning Board has reviewed the draft City of Salem Open Space and Recreation Plan Update. The Board was effectively represented on the Open Space and Recreation Plan Committee which worked on the Plan and fully supports the goals, objectives, and five-year action program outlined in the Plan. The Board will refer to the Open Space and Recreation Plan in matters affecting open space and recreation resources. Sincerely, Walter B. Power,III Chairman CITY OF SALEM,MASSACHUSETTS ti On gecrea j �4j• E.Lawrence McIntire Mack Park l r Superintendent P.O.Box 465 l� Salem,Massachusetts 01970 744-0733 ' 744-or8o John A Galaris Fax:74 0-9 299 Philip E.Harrington Katherine O'Leary t, Dr.James T.Ryan ' 1996 James W. Shea v November 20, 1996 Larissa Brown Planning Department City of Salem 1 Salem Green Salem, MA 01970 Re: Open Space Use Plan Dear Ms. Brown: This letter is to notify you that the Park and Recreation Commission reviewed the City of Salem Open Space Plan draft as submitted. The report was approved unanimously by Commission members at the Park and Recreation Commission meeting held on November 5, 1996 We look forward to receiving the final report. Very truly yours, /James Shea an JS:dt �oN Cpti� z� zConservatimCommissim li\ Salem. Massachusetts 01970 ASS 9%Fy M�,yv November 14, 1996 Craig Wheeler City Planner One Salem Green Salem, MA 01970 Dear Mr. Wheeler: The Conservation Commission was pleased to review the draft City of Salem Open Space and Recreation Plan Update. Abby Burns, one of our members, was actively involved in developing the plan as the Conservation Commission's representative on the Open Space and Recreation Plan Committee. The Plan provides a thorough discussion of conservation issues and the Conservation Commission supports the goals, objectives, and actions developed in the Plan. The Commission will refer to the Plan,when appropriate, to guide its deliberations on open space and conservation activities. Sincerely Yours, Fred J. Harney Chairman Metropolitan Area Planning Council 60 Temple Place,Boston,Massachusetts 02111 617/451-2770 Fax 617/482-7185 MAPC Serving 101 cities and towns in metropolitan Boston November 6, 1996 N 0e Craig Wheeler Salem Planning Department One Salem Green Salem, MA 01970 Dear Mr. Wheeler: The Metropolitan Area Planning Council has reviewed the City of Salem Open Space Recreation Plan Update - 1996. The plan is thorough and well-written. I would like to offer the following minor comments: 1) Subregion-The plan should mention that Salem is a member of the North Shore Task Force, one of eight MAPC subregions. The North Shore Task Force is a group of communities that meet regularly to discuss issues of common interest and is an excellent forum for discussing regional open space issues and opportunities. There should also be mention made of the North Shore Trails Study which MAPC did for the North Shore Task Force in 1995. 2) Regional Open Space - On page 21 there is reference to open space in Salem owned by other municipalities. This would be a good place to discuss the open space efforts of surrounding communities with particular attention to any parcels of open land that straddle town boundaries. Thank you for the opportunity to review this plan. -'sincerely, Pavid C. Soule Executive Director cc: Joel Lerner, Division of Conservation Services salemos.doc ltrfrdcs.dot William G.Constable,President Richard A.Easler, Vice President Grace S.Shepard,Secretary Richard C.Walker,III, Treasurer David C. Soule, Executive Director PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER SECTION 12 - REFERENCES A Conservation, Open Space and Recreation Plan for the City of Salem - 1973. Prepared by Wallace, Floyd, Ellenzweig for the Salem Conservation Commission. "Section I. The Environment," in the Salem Community Development Master Plan, 1979. Brengle, Kim Withers (Northfields Preservation Associates), A Preservation Master Plan for the City of Salem, Massachusetts: Strategies for the Preservation of Salem's Historic and Archaeological Resources. 1991 Massachusetts Bays Program, "Massachusetts Bays 1995 Comprehensive Conservation and Management Plan: An Evolving Plan for Action," June 1995. Massachusetts Department of Environmental Management. Massachusetts Coastal Land Inventory: Extent and Distribution of Publicly Owned Shoreline. 1988. National Park Service, The Salem Project: Study of Alternatives, January 1990. Maritime Development District Plan, Hopkinson & Partners/Keefe Company/Raine Associates, June 1994 Master Plan 1996 Update, draft January 1996. 45 Land Inventory Matrix Land Inventory Matrix The Inventory of Lands of Conservation and Recreation Interest lists parks and playgrounds, conservation lands, cemeteries and unprotected open parcels owned by the City of Salem, as well as the larger traffic medians and islands, which were included because they are City properties which require maintenance. Some of them have protected status under Article 97 of the state constitution. Also included in the inventory are lands owned by other public entities and nonprofit organizations, some of which are also protected to varying degrees. Finally, the matrix includes a limited number of private open parcels. Many of these are undevelopable because of wetlands or steep topography. These lands, along with parcels such as the electric distribution rights-of-way function as "urban wilds," providing habitat for wildlife and relief from built-up spaces for people. Other private parcels are listed because their location or other characteristics make them potentially suitable for recreational development or open space conservation. Inclusion on this list, however, does not in itself imply plans for a specific parcel. Funding key: CDBG - Common Development Block Grant (federal) UPARR - Urban Park and Recreation Recovery Program (federal) USH - Urban Self-Help (state) LWCF - Land and Water Conservation Fund (federal through state) 47 r z 0 U W 0 O m o_ v_ O w�❑ m m 0m mmm ma+ LLmd mm mm m C9 uu 0 mUU Ud, OW mrnm urnm rnm ornm rnm mm m mr rrnu o r0rn <rn rcrnm morw r r r r o G Q,rnmrn Q wZ _ c CL ? I m C z m m m m m m m m m m m Q m m m m m m m m m m Q m m ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ O ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ d ❑ N ❑ LLi U U U U U. U. U U U U U U U 7 U U U U) U U Q _U J a a v a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a a m O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 O o o g 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 r- d rn rn m rn rn o m w of m rn oo rn w rn o, rn rn rn rn rn J Q z Z W 0 CL �^ a z 0 w K U r... W 2 U m m OU C0 0C -oC mZ a0 0o 0 0 0 mC m�aC_I m0u°C aoC0 rnC0_ iCrnm3° , aC0a0o) orncd arnC0mN0 a0rnC0Nm a0rnC0N a0rnC0d a0rnC0N aC`0o1 a0rnCm a0rnCm a0CmN a0mNrn a0oCmd, a0 O 0000 00 000 ax 0 00 0 0000 000000 00 0 rnM M. U. M. m_ m o_ 0 0 0 o o 0rnCmd 0000 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 mdtOm md 0m m m m m W mm m d 210 d mU ` o U ` b U 0 u 0 0 U u U 0 u 0 Ulu u 2 m m a N m d E 2 d m m d m 2 m m m uE 2 2 2CmN N m C C C C c � C C I C c C C C C c C C C C C C C C c c C c C C C 0 0 0 0 0 0 0, 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 'm m a is m Tv m m m m m m m m m m m m m z d d 2 d d m m d v m d d m d d d d m m m m m m m m m w u 0 u u 0 L 0 UI o u U U U U a u o 0 o u u U U 0' U W u u o Ow m m m 0 m d o m m m m o m m a 0 o m m 0 m m 0 m m N (7 .6 C5 .6 Ni 06 a 025 .d W o5 .5 .5 aS .5 oe US .6 . .6 0 .6 .6 .6 .e .0 0! wf op .6 �f N N N N a) N ANC . N . . N N . N N N i N N W Q �3 m m m m d �v m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m `m m m m m m m m a a 42 a a a U o. a a a d a a d_ a a m_ a__a a a a a a a a a a 0-1 a -z a -- z ❑ c c o F- 00 O wAG L W q Q Q rn (� G' -6 -6O —o O O O O O O O O O O N O O O O O O O -0 -0y O O O O O O 2 U U U U U U d' U U U U U U U U 2 U U U U U U U U U 2 U U U Ui U U w E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E z a) m N m m N m a) m m a) m m 0 0 tU N m m N U1 2 N m 0 W (V 0 N N a1 N m m m m m m m m m m m m 13 m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m O m m m m m m m m m m m w to m cn m m <n cn m m m m (n Of U) m m m co m m co N q o o N O 6 M a w o ri v o 0 o N ui °? o o of o 0 o w o o 0 o m ti� o ins M o o ry F O N M N t0 V a N O O �O N O Q U N' O V O O O N N N r r O M O O cM"i N W N I I Z U U a] M U N U U U Ui N U U U U U z0 ZO K m m m m m of m 1 m 2 m � m m m 2 2 2 2 Of � m 2 mi m K m m 2 ULL �I Z U7 > (n iq 2 Q O Q c 0 cn c m m m c a a w m in! ` �_ o E >. s ! Z O U U W N ml U' Sc 2 U 0 u1 ca ca 5, L d > N t o r ' ! U J Q C M L O W M c m U w O m U O caa � O ), ❑ al c m .O J to m m co m J M a vMi rn m v (7 g a LL �' N d o Q d U) o c v - LL = N ao m x n a m ` m m o W X d' m T T y LL O R _! m N N N r N C N M Z N M E ` N l00 rl' ❑ U m cm _ m` am c amU o >mQ O a) a U N 0 y c : NNSw En o 4. oo m U WOO N LLJm y E t y E L L r o. E n �` cYi O` (7 c E E E Q m o O o m o o 0 a m o 0 m �' 40 � m m m m m U u m m m m u m n 3 m n �' m U U U U 0 w W W U 2 S Y J J �_ �; �, �. a a o ' p rn M m m coo v o r Z (gyp d• n m N N 1� V M W n CO'1! N M N M M N a N N n N 0 Q Q � U � N Qa N N M M M O M M N N N 7 N M M M 01 M N M M N 7 V V r mj m ml d m an d -V a m y 0 0 0 0 0 c 0 a) d o EL � a�' 11 u o m o 0 �� m� lu 0 � d v� c c c c c c c n, a, c• a n g. n a_ n n n o. 0, n� n n_ n a. � g C7 G! � 2 U W H N �gg W � I K O z 2 O U � Z I w o a w Z r-. al W O L7L L i6 a N Y W C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C 00 O O O O D O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O L O O y w z Z Im 0 Z Z 0 0 2 Z 0 0 Z 0 Z m 0 0 0 0 0 Z Z 0 2 m 2 2 2 N N N N UI N N N U1 Gl Ol N m N U1 m N N O hl N N N N N N N O U U U O O O _ O O O U OU O • O O O O UUU VUUU OLL O -00 O U U O O U `l d N d N N d N d d N N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q Q d v v d 0 U O O O O O O O O O N C CO OC C, C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C U U U U U U O O O O O O O O 0 O O O O O O O O U U U U U U U U U U U U UI U U U U U U U U U U U U U UOf U otf a'S a'f c8 a5 w! LL' K K K 2 0' C K 0' � K � K � C' K a' LL' K K 45 N d N N Ql `1 0l m m m m m m m `o `o `o o `o a o `o o `0 0 `o o `0 `O o `o 0 0` `o o 0 `0 0 0 `0 a a a a a LL LL LL LL LL U. LL LL LL LL LL LL: U. LL LL' LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL E E E! E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E EI E E E E E E E E E E 0 0 0 0 O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 U U U U U U U U U UI U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U O O' O O O O O C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C C I C C C C C C C C C C C D o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0, o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 4OnEEm jENp {mEE4pl �Ep EWZC ONZC UO.2C U.ZC� UmrNZC, UNNN O O O O O O O O O O O O 00 0 O O 0 2C UNOZNC �NO2NC I UMOZNC UmOZNC. UmMOZNC NNOOOOUUUUUUU UUUU U UUU U U_ W m y N N cn (0 co n co (nv M O (0O O 10 N O �2 �2 ZNC N O O O O O O M c6 M .- .-• O O O O O O O O O r' W Ow d' K a' a' di K E2 w Of m LL' LL' E E a' E' E' E' E 2 F' E K K K K a' K E E' LL' K Y a � c r• � C N J m � C yyN C m m m co m 71 a > m J J J m N N N 'O V 'O 'O 'O N U 'C > m y y U N O S V V m m m m m (0 m m m m N 0 _ J J V Y O W N O O > > m m _ _ o c a 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 • O O 0 - 0 a' m j+ T T C C m i0 N m m m m m m N N m N N N m N N N 4l U V m v v a O m °� io is m E E m obi a�i m m d v m m m > > > > > > > > > > m c d o o m 2 al X Cf 0 O O O w M a d O D- n w 00 � a a r M m M W N O m R N O U U l0 M O O H O a 7 O O Y9 m M R V M M( M M N N N o • N V' O co- r n m ¢ m M t0 m l0 CO O] Ol O LO m I� M R N m f� m O O NM N N M M N N M * m m m m m m m m m m O O) m O Ol W W Z N N M M V V m N N U M M M M M N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N U i i e e e e e e e e e e a e e e e e 0 0 0 0 0 m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m, m m m o 0 0 0 0 0 0 a E a T m m m N Eo0 0o E n a L -E v c m -• L L N m m O U m m O C a C a Q O a O 2 N p O V c c cc cc c OC OC 20 O O 0 0 O O 0 O O O C C — O O m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m rn v a a 2 Z 2 mN mN 0N m2N 00N 00 N0 mZ mZN 0N m2 mZ 0 0 0 0 0 00 0 m > > m m N N N N N 2 O O 0tj 0 Oc Uc 0 0 U U Uc Uc 0 0C Uc 0 0 U C pC C V m m m d m mm m m m m 3 n• LL 3 ¢ ¢ ¢ Q Q Q Q ¢ Q Q ¢ ¢ ¢� Q Q N N N N N N N N N N N 6 fA U 3 N 0 0 0 O c 0 O C 0 c c 0 O c 0 C c 0 O O O O O O LU U U U U U U U U U U U U pm � � DE � — — NiNNrN N . N N . co — pVj LLm LLm m `l N m m m m m N N W d d OOOO 000 O LLOOOOO O O y LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL LL m LL LL LL U N E E E E E E E' E E E E E E E E E E E E H E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E 6 E 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 cl 0 UUUUUUUUUUUUUU1UUUUU00 c c c c c c c c c c c c c c' c c c c U c o o `o `o `o `o o `o 0 0 0 0 o `O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 a 0 .mmm •mm •miammm •m m m m m m 'm m m m m 0 C) 0 0 E E E E E E E E E E E E E E N N N N N N N N N N N N N C m m c c c C O OO O C CCCC OC OC OC OC OC OC OC OC OC OC O m m m m m m l U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U U (n U U)- 0 Ul (n (nl In U). CO. (n W. M (A W M N o o �0 m m O '? u7 N O O N M. N O O 1� QO M m O) m m m V m m M M t0 O _ U U U N U UI N N' N N N M U U Q Z R Q J � Z d m d d d 0 O222 N W m U) `) C W J d m 3 3 3 3 3 U m 3 3 3 U Q v� m c m iA z y co m m 3 m m m 3 3 m m m 3 m > c N p J T T a c m N C fq' O N N > m > w Q 0 °' m 0 �_ 0 y N N U' Z Z Z Z m m Z Z .0 (A L Q U N L L L > N N v m m m 2 m m m Z Z m m m 2 0 w x J ¢ ai r m m c E — >_ M LL'e Vm) r _o m0 mm Jmm =rm mEm mEm mm mEm d LL N 0 O Zi Z LL O O U U 2 'm c, 0- LL o o M N O W J w r._ N m m O N M V LL'J m m M O m O M O N N V 10 �O M Q O O O O O O O O O O O M m V M N N N N M M M M M M Cl) M m M M M M N N Q U � V V V M M M M i C C C C C C C C C C C c0 {0 c0 l0 N t0 l0 t9 c0 l0 lC N N N N Ul N N N N N N •— 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 E E E E E E E E E c OCE E d d � � m m E a°1i v v m Z` •— N 7 � N > O v l0 E in w N N a v v � d N N N C r to a L � L U O O N N N O U O O y rn rn 2 m �. n c N c3 3 3 E E > o .o m `m v a rn N N rn m a 0 ° 0 0 d � � ❑ 0 0 m a � � ci m >. 3 0 �� 3 O C j N N C � O C 0_ N U1 � ❑ 3 3 >� L o n E 1 `o `o o `o `o o `o `o `o 0 0 0 0 `o `oi o o `o `o `o `o `o `o 0 0 0 0 01 `o `o 0 of o `o `o `o o `o Z^ D D 2 2, 2 2` 2` 2• Z� 2• 2' D 2� 2� 2` 2 2` 2` 2 2 2 I 2' z- D 2 2 -- w 0 U E E EIEI E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E N 0 N N 2 N N N UI UJ N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N U1 N N N u m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m w m m m m c3 m m m m m m m m m m m -Itm r— U) En 0 w m co (0 0 cn w U) 0 w w w (n w 0 U) 0 w U) w U) U) cn U) CO U7 U) U7 U) U1 U) U) U1 U) U) O In O O M a - N N (O O co O 0 l0 N p O 'O co VO . O n m a q O O1� V; M O N O O? (D N (nO O O O O O O O ON OM O O C. O O 4 O O O O a o O O O O O Oa N M w N j N N ` C vl N Y N > U C @ N C Q 0 (D a CO J N O m O m > C � � N N � > � N N y C Q N m Cl) Q ai ai Q m o m m y m' o 0 o Q m m o w c m in m o m d o v in in Q c > > v t d m y o m c .o m m d > o u m m m m c in Q Q c _� m d c > >, c Cl) ¢ V) O C N (0 IO C N N C — U1 (n V) V) (n U) L IO f0 L 2 V1 N UI E aci a°'i d -� E c m m ❑ o Q E E � — o `o 3 2 0 2 c�i 2 Q a� (7 J ¢ a ❑ ❑ ❑ ❑ > Y C Y C O Q N Z M ❑ N > Q- N N - (O U O O a0 Q Q J M M O M I� W co N N N r, O qO M N O N O OD O W O co W M O M M M to N N N M m O N O] M r O M N O O O r O N V N N M N M V ' co M O O 7 d' LO N (D (O c0 N N N N r-- a i m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0EE I a a L U � a E ati aEi C O LL 'O f0 m U O OCL NLL C 0 E c LL LL ° > m c m a o O O Ni U N 8 a m m m m O O O >, U U O m C m = m m m C T; O L L L L L aJ aJ aJ '5 ¢' `o 0 0 0 `o o `o to `o to `o 0 0 `o `o o a>i o m a>i `o `o `o 0 0 0 016 0 0 0 0 `o i o `o 0 U U Zl U U U U U U U U U U U U U U 2 U w wo d' U 2' U U U U U U U U U U U U I U U U E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E E' E E m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m n m (0 m m n m m m rn m n w m 0 m m m m <n m m m rn m w n m. m. m m 0 o o v o m M v rn a rn ir+ �n n o M o rn �n o v N a m i- M o M �n rn o in co M O CO O m m O M O. M N a N N M N O N O N O N O M M I 7 O O N 1, O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O O 01 O O O O O —O O O O N O O O a m 'O N N N N N m �I1 LO �O �O N m m m m m m � m � 0 m m m m m m m m of of m mci: w o C r � m N N UI •—• mON' O O s(O� om mMO) NO1 m�' Nd M_ (dD_ N Oai, (Nn UMm M (M!N1. iNn U.N.1 (UNNn. (Ln uNN� U'ZOJ' [LNNn. (Nn �cN v—N Jc rNcN>o ¢CdJc>o N>u� ' N al ( m � W> O uO Q i _ n ,C o LLI >HOn 0) N� Q oo o LLm m NWm LLm mmr o LL m LL UI U M CO o LL m LL LL MN 2LO0) NI m a) 0 QcNN>m O N N M �• M m O n mi m N m O m M O M V O �T t0 (D O1 O) m 4i O V n m O N N M M Mi V R al VI �OOI (MO I� m 7 a O N N N V N m M m N N N N M N O N O N N N N N N NI NI N N� NI N N M CM m m M M M f�') N m M co M r— I L L_ 3 O T T m N a N m v N N Q 0 3. 0 E _E a n N c c n a U U C C N m 0_ CL I C CI N � O a m O O u rn L A mI c y c 0 U• UI m N m ro m m m a cn u) u) a m E m E m Y rn rn rn o� m m m a a a E E N "-' m c c cLL °- °- ° E m m o m m o mm m m m m m E N m E m z z z U N N Q ¢ C C 2 - O O O O O O O O O O m m C C E `o o `o `o o `o `o `o `o o `o a a a a -1 E h `o `o `o ` `o m c° c� CJ U m c `o 0 U U U U U U U U U o N m m J J N E E E E E E E E E E E Q a, E 9° a° O m ❑ ❑ ❑ °. o. a? woo v m m m m m m £ 2 ro m m Uj N ui �i ai E E N N m m m m m m m m m m m m m m `m m 3 m d m m m 2 2 I � u) u) u) u) u) U) U) u) u) a) In g u) a, a_ a d' p0 O (OD 1q O OOI r- m O CN'] m OO m p N O O N O M r- M N V C) m �j m r N N O O) h O O N O O O O O O O O O O O N m V O m (° O r O M �• �. � 2 � � � 2 m � 2 � � � � 2 m 2 2 � � S S m ❑ m T O N o N -No o c m a m a `m c `m m `) Z J m O a ° a o `m m v iA cq in E ai ai c m c a m m m in Q E in u) y o m a a c o f Q Q w aCj Q m Q Y O m 0N U C N a) m y .J 2 m j U O O O a- m 3 J in in a E E E o ° Q m v x x d c o o o E Ik m T % o' E Q m = 2 2 a) m m w N ti m d t t m �v m m E O Z WI w o 3 3 U H c m m o 3 `o m o N 0 c c O rn rn g Q, m y m m L m J J J u a E 2 2 7 S 2 m a U �0 N M r V1 3 t L U N O O O m m N m m O N m O M N r m o - O d' m V m M V 7 U) z z O �• °� M ti M m m m M m m 1 O Z m �` r N N M M N N N N (° O r 41 O N M M g h M v v M p n v n n to m a ti o m v a v O M M m rn M M M st a a a o 0 0 c c c d m m at d d > O 3 ❑ ❑ o 0 N la n n n m m D m a� Cc m t ML 0 0 0 L L 0 0 0 •EE c c - - v ^_ T n m m U N C m m m U a " ! T m o& E E 0 o rn o o , r c E o ° > > Y Y Y W 2� > > 'p O a1 a1 C C C C C c C C C N N ? C CI O O O O O O o a1 N m O N N m al N N N N N N a a O V O C C C C C C O O O O O n n n C N C d 9 U U U U U >+ C -0O 0 m 0 O O E 0 a O m m 0 _ ooi 'o L C a m 3 v m m m o 3 n m a o a a N N al m c 0 N N a0E E E E E E E E O 0 O m3 ° u0 (1u °c m c i c C E. ami a°�i m w aa)i m m` t t t t a m to Co a)m cn a ari a�i a�i ari a�i 10 U m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m E O W aEi 0 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > to U m u a a r o 0 0 0 0 U 0 o c o 0 0 0 U U U U U o c r f6 Z` Z" o m ❑ W 0 0 0 `o 0 o m o 0 010 0 2 n m n n > j U m c a a ai a a c 10 E 3 U b 2 2 2 d m m ��° m m m m m m ❑ H H H C C d } U U rq - 'Ei 0 Ooa o oo Lm - d m m Em mC3 mC3 o 0C3 ZC30 rEE -'NJ° . Y > ¢ ZZZZ WWWto Co U 0 U Y rn r m o o co ov, C. m o0 o CO o o io-, o ,� o in O 8 O D a N N N r M N W O O M 0 N f0 O M a O N V V' N Y-1 N a0 N if1 N r O O r O] O O N N O M N N t0 O �!1 Co M m O O M N u-i 4N M U U U U U U m '' a a c c m m J m 12 m o m d o L w Z O O 0_ o' a E m m E m m K cc: .o c U 0 '0 N° omrmym a NNC UmE 20 UU atQrnNONCo �l Ln=rN0`o xgMu QamrCirn9 a❑orm m :E oE UOdNo md[m�Momn]- mil ova oE m oo o od Z 0 Q COm0m vd 222c3 o 2mL = m =rn mw }v w z 0 �f o0 oo 0 v U 2 7 m U W o �mmmYY N UO N W0, mrn . N . NZ mN�nm d t0 Q M N N M N d O r N a N M M N N O O m M V M N N N r, a a n r„ m m m o n a 0 0 0 d m � v v v m m m m m m m a n a a a n a v v v v c c c o c, C C C C C C C C t0 IO � N 10 d d N d N U U J U C C U U U U U U U U N N N IV N N N N A IO f0 N lQ (V > > > > > > > - n a n n n 6 d 6 N Q N H V � O p 2 0 ca m LL g h N N N O 0 t U co -It ao rn ti Ul N O CO 0 ` N h N C T = N T 'O N > C N w C p Q 6 C c m a J E 10 fn O LL N N O7��2 V_ N. O._ .L7 V H O' NONco O N (D N Tables TABLE 2 1980 AND 1990 POPULATION BY CENSUS DISTRICT AND POPULATION DENSITY Census Tract 1980 Pop./Sq. Mil. 1990 Pop./Sq. Mi. 2041(S. Salem) 8,016 5,344 8,546 5,697.33 2042 (Chest- 4,854 13,118.92 4,702 12,708.11 nut/Canal) 2043 (Point/Derby) 3,382 14,704.35 3,159 13,734.78 2044 (Com- 3,759 4,176.67 3,435 3,816.67 mon/Neck) 2045 (Bridge St.) 3,062 7,468.29 3,033 7,397.56 2046 (N. Salem) 2,249 4,940.68 5,339 4,524.58 2047.01 (High- 3,865 1,375.44 4,118 1,465.48 land/SW Salem) 2047.02 (Witchcraft 5,452 5,738.95 5,809 6,114.74 Heights) Source: U.S. Census 1980 and 1990 61 TABLE 3 1994 POPULATION BY WARD -PERCENTAGE OF POPULATION UNDER 17 YEARS Ward A ie 0-16 % of Total Age 17+ Total 1 1327 24.73 % 4036 5365 2 974 17.58 % 4566 5540 3 1011 19.30 % 4226 5237 4 1073 19.62 % 4396 5469 5 946 17.63 % 4420 5366 6 1105 20.42 % 4312 5412 7 846 15.12 % 4750 5596 Source: City Census 1994 62 TABLE 4 LAND USE CLASSIFICATION- 1985 The most recent available breakdown of Salem land use was issued by the state's Executive Office of Environmental Affairs (EOEA) in 1985. Salem was not included in a land use update project in 1990 because it was among a group of communities where changes in land use between 1985 and 1990 were deemed to be minor. It is likely that the 1985 information remains valid. Acres Percent Residential 1,785 34.1 Commercial 256 4.9 Industrial 267 5.1 Transportation 180 3.4 Agriculture 16 0.3 Urban Open Land 382 7.3 Recreation 345 6.6 Water 64 1.2 Other 1,936 37.0 63 TABLE 5 ESTIMATED BUILD-OUT UNDER CURRENT ZONING Figures given below for the maximum number of units are based on gross acreage and zoning limitations. Not all parcels meet minimum zoning requirements and much of the land is not buildable for environmental or other reasons. There is less land available for multi-family construction than for single-family construction. Realistically, the actual number of new housing units which could be produced under current zoning is likely to be less than half the numbers given here. Zoned RC (Residential Conservation): • 560.8 acres available • parcels average 18.7 acres each • maximum number of units - 250 Zoned RI (Single-Family Residential): • 137.07 acres available • parcels average 3 acres each • maximum number of units - 411 • some portion of an additional 161.5 acres may become available when the Superfund site located on the parcel is cleaned up. (Clean-up is scheduled to begin in 1995. Monitoring and development restrictions will be put in place on some portion of the site under all clean-up alternatives.) Zoned R2 (Two-Family Residential): • 16.33 acres available • parcels average 2 acres each • maximum number of units - 95 (48 buildings) Zoned R3 (Multi-Family Residential): • 116.48 acres • only two parcels are larger than 8 acres (one 36-acre parcel and one 18-acre parcel) • maximum number of units - 1,462 (232 buildings) Total maximum number of housing units: 2218 in 941 structures Source: Computed from Assessor's Records 64 TABLE 6 NORTH SHORE PUBLIC COASTAL FRONTAGE BY MUNICIPALITY Municipality Total Coastal Publicly Owned % of Total Publicly Frontage Coastal Frontage Owned Salem 11.22 5.63 50.2% Beverly 10.58 0.94 8.9% Essex 3.03 1.52 50.2% Gloucester 47.19 4.74 10.0% Ipswich 22.99 18.55 80.7% Lynn 4.38 1.18 26.9% Manchester 11.85 1.82 15.4% Marblehead 16.22 2.69 16.6% Nahant 11.49 5.03 43.8% Newbury 12.69 6.89 54.3% Newburyport 7.11 0.80 11.3% Rockport 14.74 12.33 83.6% Rowley 8.20 6.72 82.0% Salisbury 6.90 4.92 71.3% Saugus 0.36 Swampscott 3.80 0.33 8.7% Total 192.75 74.08 38.4% Source: DEM, Massachusetts Coastal Land Inventory, Table 3. 65 TABLE 7 PLANTS TYPICAL OF SALEM HABITATS Upland Areas: Older remaining woody growth is mostly pitch pine, juniper, and scrub oak. Vegetation in nonwoody areas includes moss, lichens, and wild grasses. Wild herbs, pitch pines, and sumac are found in rock and humus pockets. Forest vegetation includes oak, poplar, maple, birch, white pine, hemlock, pitch pine, and rhododendron Wooded Swamps: alder, willow, dogwood, red maple, swamp white oak, red oak, American elm, tamarack, hemlock, yellow birch, and Atlantic white cedar. Freshwater Marshes: sedges, bur reed, shortweed, pickerel weed, arrowhead, duckweed, wild rice, spike rush, bulrush, reeds, cattails, watershields, water lilies, grasses, water milfoil, coon tails, wild celery, and pond weeds. Source: 1972 Conservation, Open Space, and Recreation Plan 1979 Community Development Master Plan 66 Greater yellowlegs Barn Swallow Black-and-white Warbler Solitary Sandpiper Blue Jay American Redstart Ruddy Turnstone American Crow Northern Waterthrush Semi-palmated Sandpiper Black-capped Chickadee Mourning Warbler Least Sandpiper Tufted Titmouse Common Yellowthroat Short-billed Dowitcher White-breasted Nuthatch Wilson's Warbler American Woodcock Brown Creeper Canada Warbler Laughing Gull House Wren Northern Cardinal Ring-billed Gull Winter Wren Rufous-sided Towhee Herring Gull Marsh Wren American Tree Sparrow Iceland Gull Ruby-crowned Kinglet Chipping Sparrow Great Black-backed Gull Blue-gray Gnatcatcher Field Sparrow Common Tern Veery Henslow's Sparrow Rock Dove Swainson's Thrush Fox sparrow Mourning Dove Hermit Thrush Song Sparrow Black-billed Cuckoo Wood Thrush Swamp Saprrow Yellow-billed Cuckoo American Robin White-throated Sparrow Eastern Screech-Owl Gray Catbird White-crowned Sparrow Great Horned owl Northern Mockingbird Dark-eyed Junco Barred Owl Brown Thrasher Red-winged Blackbird Northern Saw-whet Owl Cedar Waxwing Rusty Blackbird Common Nighthawk European Starling Common Grackle Chinmey Swift Warbling Vireo Brown-headed Cowbird Belted Kingfisher Red-eyed Vireo Orchard Oriole Yellow-bellied Sapsucker Blue-winged Warbler Northern Oriole Downy Woodpecker Nrothern Parula Purple Finch Hairy Woodpecker Yellow Warbler House Finch Northern Flicker Chestnut-sided Warbler American Goldfinch Eastern Wood-Peewee Magnolia Warbler House Sparrow Willow Flycatcher Yellow-rumped Warbler Wild Turkey (reintroduced) Least Flycatcher Black-throated Green Warbler Eastern Phoebe Blackburnian Warbler Great Crested Flycatcher Palm Warbler Eastern Kingbird Blackpoll Warbler Horned Lark Tree Swallow N. Rough-winged Swallow Bank Swallow C. Mammals Raccoon Cottontail Rabbit Little Brown Bat Muskrat Gray Squirrel Big Brown Rat Skunk Red Squirrel Norway Rat Fox Mole Jumping Mouse Long-tailed Weasel Opossum House Mouse Short-tailed Weasel Short-tailed Shrew White Footed Mouse Mink Chipmunk Beaver Meadow Vole 68 D. Reptiles and Amphibians Snapping Turtle Brown Snake Fowlers Toad Spotted Turtle Green Frog Two-Lined Salamander Box Turtle Wood Frog Red-Backed Salamander Wood Turtle Leopard Frog Dusky Salamander Black Racer Snake Pickeral Frog Red Spotted Newt Milk Snake Grey Tree Frog Marbled Salamander Ribbon Snake Spring Peeper Garter Snake American Toad Sources: 1972 Conservation, Open Space, and Recreation Plan 1979 Community Development Master Plan 1996 "Birds of Salem" -Species reported since 1985, Natural History Dept., Peabody-Essex Museum 69 TABLE 9 PREHISTORIC AND HISTORIC SITES PRESERVATION PRIORITY AREAS Prehistoric priority areas: • Salem Neck and the Islands • South/Forest River Drainage and Wetlands • Strongwater Brook • North/Danvers River Estuaries • Salem Harbor • North Salem Historic period priority areas: • Old Planters' Settlement (March Street area) • Winter Island • Blubber Hollow • Essex Street/Derby Street District • Historic Cemeteries • County Jail, Jailer's House, site of John Ward House, and Howard Street Cemetery • Maritime Waterfront Underwater District • Salem Willows Source: Brengle, Kim Withers (Northfields Preservation Associates), A Preservation Master Plan for the City of Salem, Massachusetts: Strategies for the Preservation of Salem's Historic and Archaeological Resources. 1991. 70 TABLE 10 CITY-OWNED OPEN PARCELS Size of parcel Number of parcels Number of acres <114 acre 39 4.44 1/4 acre to 2 acres 44 28.5 >2 acres to 8 acres 9 36.47 >8 acres 2 46.5 Total 94 115.91 Source: City Assessor's Maps 71