Loading...
13 Hawthorne Blvd Materials Combined Design Review Board Recommendation 13 Hawthorne Boulevard Advisory Design Review of Municipal & Religious Building Reuse Ordinance Meeting Date: April 22, 2020 Members Present: Paul Durand, Chair, Helen Sides, Vice-Chair, David Jaquith, Glenn Kennedy, Catherine Miller, Marc Perras, J. Michael Sullivan Members Absent: None At a regular meeting of the Design Review Board (DRB), upon a motion duly made and seconded, it was unanimously voted to recommend design approval of the proposed historic restoration of the former Immaculate Conception parochial school and conversion into a residential building with a preference to house those in the creative economy as presented. Referenced Plans and Documents 1. Plan Set titled ’13 Hawthorne Boulevard Salem Historic Schools’, prepared by Icon Architecture, 101 summer Street, Boston, MA 02110, containing the following documents: a. Garden Level Plan, A-101, dated 8/31/18; b. First Floor Plan, A-102, dated 8/31/18; c. Second Floor Plan, A-103, dated 8/31/18; d. Third Floor Plan, A-104, dated 8/31/18; e. Roof Plan, A-105, dated 8/31/18; f. Building Elevations, A-201, dated 8/31/18; g. Building Elevations, A-202, dated 8/31/18; h. Window Details Replacement – Historic Approach, A-800, dated 8/31/18; i. Window Details Restoration – Historic Approach, A-800B, dated 8/31/18; j. Notes, Legend, and Abbreviations, C-100, dated 2/13/20; k. Demolition Plan, C-100, dated 2/13/20; l. Site Plan, C-300, dated 2/13/20; m. Grading and Drainage Plan, C-400, dated 2/13/20; n. Planting Plan, C-500, dated 2/13/20; o. Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan, C-500, dated 2/13/20; p. Site Details, C-600, dated 2/13/20; q. Utility and Stormwater Details, C-601, dated 2/13/20; r. Stormwater Details, C-602, dated 2/13/20; s. Landscape Details, C-603, dated 2/13/20; t. Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Details, C-604, dated 2/13/20. 2. Staff Comments dated 4/15/20. Design Review Upon discussion and deliberation, the Board voted to recommend the Planning Board approve the project’s design and presented based on the following findings: • Conformance to Design Standards: The DRB found that the proposal to restore the building and retain its historical features is in conformance with the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties (‘Secretary’s Standards’). The project met the Secretary’s Standards to preserve the existing historic fabric, restore missing or damaged fabric, and reconstruct historically significant features. • Retention and Refurbishment of Exterior Historical Features: The retention of the historic windows, the limitation of adding exterior features to only those that provide universal access and meet building and safety codes, and the refurbishment of copper flashing and gutters, the slate roof, and the cornice and other decorative stone features, together create a project that respects the building’s history and its physical place in the community. • Additional Positive Project Features: In addition to the preservation of distinctive exterior historical features, the DRB is very supportive of this project for the following reasons: o Preservation of Interior Historical Features: Preservation of the auditorium, hallways, and staircases, are all critical interior historical elements that tell the story of the building’s former use as a school. o Proposed Tenancy: The proposal to dedicate living units to those in the creative economy will help meet a housing need in this community and providing studio space, galleries, shops, and gathering space in the former auditorium will further reinforce the sense of community in this building. If you have any questions or concerns regarding this recommendation, please contact via Kate Newhall-Smith, Principal Planner, at knewhallsmith@salem.com. Signature of the DRB By the signature below, I certify that this recommendation accurately reflects the actions of the Design Review Board. __________________________________ ____________ Paul Durand Date Chair 4/24/2020 CONSULTANT TITLE: CONSULTANT TITLE: CONSULTANT TITLE: MECHANICAL, PLUMBING, ELECTRICAL & FIRE PROTECTION ENGINEER: CIVIL ENGINEER: STRUCTURAL ENGINEER: PROJECT TEAM: LOCUS MAP: OWNER/DEVELOPER: ARCHITECT: PL O T T E D O N : ISSUE DATE: ICON ARCHITECTURE 101 Summer Street, Boston, MA 02110 617.451.3333 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 3 8 P M 13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS FEBRUARY 13, 2020 NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC. SITE PLAN REVIEW NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION 96 LAFAYETTE STREET, SALEM, MA 01970 LIM CONSULTANTS, INC 6 PLEASANT ST, MALDEN, MA 02148 NITSCH ENGINEERING, INC 2 CENTER PLZ #430, BOSTON, MA 02108 WOZNY BARBAR & ASSOCIATES, INC 1076 WASHINGTON ST, HANOVER, MA 02339 VHB 99 HIGH ST #10, BOSTON, MA 02110 IRWIN ENGINEERS INC 33 W CENTRAL ST, NATICK, MA 01760 X X ? 21 2 1 20 19 19 18 17 15 16 17 1 5 16 19 1 8 1 7 16 17 17 17 18 1 8 roof drain roof drain roof drain UTILITY POLE 2" pipe-capped Water-3" Electric Gas 1-1/2" COPPER CITY NOTES wood fence X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X iron fence GG GG GENERAL NOTES 1. WITHIN CLASSROOMS: A. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALKBOARD RAILS, CHALKBOARDS, SCOTIA MOULDING, AND EXISTING DOORS AND TRIM, TO BE REMOVED,CATALOGUED, AND PROTECTED, TO BE REINSTALLED IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. B. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK CABINETS TO BE REMOVED, CATALOGUED & PROTECTED, TO BE RESTORED & REINSTALLED, WHERE POSSIBLE, IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. C. EXISTING CLASSROOM BUILT-IN CABINETRY TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE D. EXISTING CLASSROOM CHALKBOARDS & RAILS TO BE REINSTALLED IN LIVING ROOM & BEDROOM SPACES WHERE POSSIBLE. E. ITEMS NOT REINSTALLED ARE TO BE RETURNED TO OWNER. F. EXISTING CLASSROOM WALLS TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. G. EXISTING HARWOOD FLOORS TO BE RETAINED & REFINISHED WHERE POSSIBLE. 2. WITHIN CORRIDORS: A. WAINSCOT IN HALLWAY TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. B. EXISTING WOOD HANDRAILS & MILLWORK AT STAIR TO BE RESTORED. C. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT HALLWAY SIDE OF DOORS TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. D. EXISTING PLASTER AT WALLS TO REMAIN. E. HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. 3. REFER TO ENLARGE UNIT PLANS FOR TYPICAL APPROACH FOR UNIT LAYOUTS 4. EXISTING DOORS TO BE STORED ON SITE FOR DETERMINATION ON HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE. LEGEND AREA OF FLOOR INFILL AREA OF HISTORIC TRIM AREA OF HISTORIC CHALK BOARDS & RAILS A-201 2 A-201 1 ACCESSIBLE ROUTE 774 SF 1BR G05 470 SF ST G18 835 SF 2BR G11 660 SF 1BR G10 675 SF 1BR G09 648 SF 1BR G04 675 SF 1BR G03 666 SF 1BR G02 656 SF 1BR G01 473 SF STUDIO G08 495 SF STUDIO G07 7' - 11 1/8" UNASSIGNED UNASSIGNED REMOVE EXISTING CONCRETE LOADING DOCK INFILL EXISTING BOILER ROOM FLOOR TO MEET CORRIDOR ELEVATION INFILL EXISTING GYMNASIUM FLOOR TO MEET CORRIDOR ELEVATION NEW RESILIENT FLOORING AT CORRIDORS EXPOSED BLOCK TO BE RETAINED & REFINISHED, TYP INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. AREA OF RAMP & STAIR ABOVE NEW WINDOW WELL DEMO EXISTING EXT STAIR & DOOR BELOW; PROVIDE NEW WINDOW & WINDOW WELL EXISTING STAIR TO BE REMOVED DEMO EXISTING EXT STAIR & DOOR BELOW; PROVIDE NEW WINDOW & WINDOW WELL LONG TERM BIKE STORAGE ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 1 0 P M A-101 GARDEN LEVEL PLAN13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 4'0 8'16' NO R T H MARK DATE DESCRIPTION ? 21 21 2 1 20 19 19 18 15 16 17 1 5 16 19 1 8 1 7 16 17 16 17 17 18 1 8 1 9 20 wood fence X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X c h a i n l i n k f e n c e iron fence U N I O N S T R E E T GG GG DOUBLE HEIGHT STAGE 683 SF 1BR 101 665 SF 1BR 102 1001 SF 2BR 106 654 SF 1BR 104 675 SF 1BR 103 251 SF MANAGEMENT G001A REMOVE EXISTING CONCRETE LOADING DOCK REMOVE RETROFIT INFILL AT HISTORIC MASONRY OPENINGS TO ACCOMODATE NEW WINDOW & DOOR SYSTEMS NEW RAMP FROM ACCESSIBLE PARKING TO SECONDARY ENTRY INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR AND PARTITIONS; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP NEW RESILIENT FLOORING AT CORRIDORS HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. HISTORIC TRIM [INC WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALK RAILS, SCOTIA MOULDINGS] TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED AS HIGHLIGHTED, TYP REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP. EXISTING WOOD FLOORING AT AUDITORIUM AND STAGE TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED. PROTECT DURING DEMO & CONSTRUCTION. INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP PROTECT & MAINTAIN EXISTING CORRIDOR DOOR & GLAZING SYSTEM REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP. (BOTH SIDES) U U U U U U EXISTING CLASROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE HISTORIC TRIM [INC WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALK RAILS, SOCITA MOULDINGS] TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED AS HIGHLIGHTED, TYP. LINE OF EXISTING BALCONY OVERHEAD DOUBLE HEIGHT HA W T H O R N E B L V D A-201 2 A-201 1 A-202. 3 P PROTECT & MAINTAIN BULLETIN BOARD CASES IN CORRIDORS WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP RES ENTRY PUBLIC ENTRY LOBBY ACCESSIBLE ROUTE 3509 SF NON-RESIDENTIAL G001 WC WC 726 SF 1BR 105 RAMP DOWN RAMP DOWN RA M P DO W N NEW WINDOW WELL DEMO EXISTING EXT STAIR & DOOR BELOW; PROVIDE NEW WINDOW & WINDOW WELL EXISTING STAIR TO BE REMOVED DEMO EXISTING EXT STAIR & DOOR BELOW; PROVIDE NEW WINDOW & WINDOW WELL 646 SF NON-RESIDENTIAL G001F MAX OCC: 234 B IK E P A R K I N G B I K E P A R K I N G GENERAL NOTES 1. WITHIN CLASSROOMS: A. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALKBOARD RAILS, CHALKBOARDS, SCOTIA MOULDING, AND EXISTING DOORS AND TRIM, TO BE REMOVED,CATALOGUED, AND PROTECTED, TO BE REINSTALLED IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. B. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK CABINETS TO BE REMOVED, CATALOGUED & PROTECTED, TO BE RESTORED & REINSTALLED, WHERE POSSIBLE, IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. C. EXISTING CLASSROOM BUILT-IN CABINETRY TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE D. EXISTING CLASSROOM CHALKBOARDS & RAILS TO BE REINSTALLED IN LIVING ROOM & BEDROOM SPACES WHERE POSSIBLE. E. ITEMS NOT REINSTALLED ARE TO BE RETURNED TO OWNER. F. EXISTING CLASSROOM WALLS TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. G. EXISTING HARWOOD FLOORS TO BE RETAINED & REFINISHED WHERE POSSIBLE. 2. WITHIN CORRIDORS: A. WAINSCOT IN HALLWAY TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. B. EXISTING WOOD HANDRAILS & MILLWORK AT STAIR TO BE RESTORED. C. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT HALLWAY SIDE OF DOORS TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. D. EXISTING PLASTER AT WALLS TO REMAIN. E. HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. 3. REFER TO ENLARGE UNIT PLANS FOR TYPICAL APPROACH FOR UNIT LAYOUTS 4. EXISTING DOORS TO BE STORED ON SITE FOR DETERMINATION ON HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE. LEGEND AREA OF FLOOR INFILL AREA OF HISTORIC TRIM AREA OF HISTORIC CHALK BOARDS & RAILS ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 1 4 P M A-102 FIRST FLOOR PLAN13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 1/8" = 1'-0"1 FIRST FLOOR PLAN 4'0 8'16' NO R T H MARK DATE DESCRIPTION DN 1001 SF 2BR 207 463 SF STUDIO 202 685 SF 1BR 201 465 SF STUDIO 203 653 SF 1BR 205 682 SF 1BR 204 927 SF 2BR 206 A-500 2BR A-500 1BR A-500 ST CL OF BEAM OVERHEAD, VIF INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. NEW RESILIENT FLOORING AT CORRIDORS HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. HISTORIC TRIM [INC WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALK RAILS, SCOTIA MOULDINGS] TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED AS HIGHLIGHTED, TYP INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. PROTECT & MAINTAIN EXISTING CORRIDOR DOOR & GLAZING SYSTEM EXISTING CLASROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP PROTECT & MAINTAIN EXISTING CORRIDOR DOOR & GLAZING SYSTEM HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT CORRIDOR SIDE OF DOORS TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED, TYP U U U U U U U EXISTING CLASSROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING CLASROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP EXISTING CLASROOM CHALK RAILS TO BE REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE PROTECT, MAINTAIN & RESTORE EXISTING HARDWOOD FLOORS AT CLASSROOMS WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP OPEN TO BELOW UNASSIGNED 869 SF NON-RESIDENTIAL G001M OPEN TO BELOW GENERAL NOTES 1. WITHIN CLASSROOMS: A. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALKBOARD RAILS, CHALKBOARDS, SCOTIA MOULDING, AND EXISTING DOORS AND TRIM, TO BE REMOVED,CATALOGUED, AND PROTECTED, TO BE REINSTALLED IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. B. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK CABINETS TO BE REMOVED, CATALOGUED & PROTECTED, TO BE RESTORED & REINSTALLED, WHERE POSSIBLE, IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. C. EXISTING CLASSROOM BUILT-IN CABINETRY TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE D. EXISTING CLASSROOM CHALKBOARDS & RAILS TO BE REINSTALLED IN LIVING ROOM & BEDROOM SPACES WHERE POSSIBLE. E. ITEMS NOT REINSTALLED ARE TO BE RETURNED TO OWNER. F. EXISTING CLASSROOM WALLS TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. G. EXISTING HARWOOD FLOORS TO BE RETAINED & REFINISHED WHERE POSSIBLE. 2. WITHIN CORRIDORS: A. WAINSCOT IN HALLWAY TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. B. EXISTING WOOD HANDRAILS & MILLWORK AT STAIR TO BE RESTORED. C. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT HALLWAY SIDE OF DOORS TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. D. EXISTING PLASTER AT WALLS TO REMAIN. E. HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. 3. REFER TO ENLARGE UNIT PLANS FOR TYPICAL APPROACH FOR UNIT LAYOUTS 4. EXISTING DOORS TO BE STORED ON SITE FOR DETERMINATION ON HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE. LEGEND AREA OF FLOOR INFILL AREA OF HISTORIC TRIM AREA OF HISTORIC CHALK BOARDS & RAILS ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 1 8 P M A-103 SECOND FLOOR PLAN13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 1/8" = 1'-0"1 SECOND FLOOR PLAN 4'0 8'16' NO R T H MARK DATE DESCRIPTION 685 SF 1BR 301 463 SF STUDIO 302 476 SF STUDIO 303 680 SF 1BR 304 653 SF 1BR 305 INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. NEW RESILIENT FLOORING AT CORRIDORS HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. HISTORIC TRIM [INC WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALK RAILS, SCOTIA MOULDINGS] TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED AS HIGHLIGHTED, TYP INFILL EXISTING OPENING TO PROVIDE UNIT SEPARATION; REMOVE EXISTING DOOR HARDWARE, DOOR & FRAME. HISTORIC DOOR TO BE FIXED IN PLACE IN SAME LOCATION ON ONE SIDE OF DEMISING WALL W/ RATED GWB INFILL WALL BEHIND, TYP. ALL HISTORIC TRIM & HARDWARE TO BE RETAINED/REINSTALLED WHERE POSSIBLE. PROTECT & MAINTAIN EXISTING CORRIDOR DOOR & GLAZING SYSTEM EXISTING CLASROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE PROTECT & MAINTAIN EXISTING CORRIDOR DOOR & GLAZING SYSTEM HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT CORRIDOR SIDE OF DOORS TO BE RETAINED & RESTORED, TYP EXISTING CLASROOM BUILT-IN CASEWORK TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE U U U U U A-201 2 A-201 1 A-202. 3 A-202. 4 PROTECT, MAINTAIN & RESTORE EXISTING HARDWOOD FLOORS AT CLASSROOMS WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP GENERAL NOTES 1. WITHIN CLASSROOMS: A. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO, WAINSCOT, FLOOR BASE, CHALKBOARD RAILS, CHALKBOARDS, SCOTIA MOULDING, AND EXISTING DOORS AND TRIM, TO BE REMOVED,CATALOGUED, AND PROTECTED, TO BE REINSTALLED IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. B. ALL EXISTING MILLWORK CABINETS TO BE REMOVED, CATALOGUED & PROTECTED, TO BE RESTORED & REINSTALLED, WHERE POSSIBLE, IN SELECT LOCATIONS AS HIGHLIGHTED. C. EXISTING CLASSROOM BUILT-IN CABINETRY TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE D. EXISTING CLASSROOM CHALKBOARDS & RAILS TO BE REINSTALLED IN LIVING ROOM & BEDROOM SPACES WHERE POSSIBLE. E. ITEMS NOT REINSTALLED ARE TO BE RETURNED TO OWNER. F. EXISTING CLASSROOM WALLS TO BE RETAINED WHERE POSSIBLE. G. EXISTING HARWOOD FLOORS TO BE RETAINED & REFINISHED WHERE POSSIBLE. 2. WITHIN CORRIDORS: A. WAINSCOT IN HALLWAY TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. B. EXISTING WOOD HANDRAILS & MILLWORK AT STAIR TO BE RESTORED. C. EXISTING DOOR TRIM AT HALLWAY SIDE OF DOORS TO REMAIN AND BE RESTORED. D. EXISTING PLASTER AT WALLS TO REMAIN. E. HISTORIC CLASSROOM ENTRY DOORS TO BE RETAINED & FIXED IN OPEN POSITION, TYP. 3. REFER TO ENLARGE UNIT PLANS FOR TYPICAL APPROACH FOR UNIT LAYOUTS 4. EXISTING DOORS TO BE STORED ON SITE FOR DETERMINATION ON HISTORICAL SIGNIFICANCE. LEGEND AREA OF FLOOR INFILL AREA OF HISTORIC TRIM AREA OF HISTORIC CHALK BOARDS & RAILS ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 2 0 P M A-104 THIRD FLOOR PLAN13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 1/8" = 1'-0"1 THIRD FLOOR 4'0 8'16' NO R T H MARK DATE DESCRIPTION ROOF NOTES - SLOPE CANNOT EXCEED 1" RISE MAX ACROSS CONDENSING UNITS - ALL ROOF VENTS MUST BE SEPERATED BY AT LEAST 12" O.C. - REMOVE ALL COPPER GUTTERS, CAPS & FLASHING THAT ARE CORRODED OR DAMAGED BEYOND REPAIR. ROOF BELOW NEW ROOFTOP EQUIPMENT OFFSET MIN 10'-0" FROM ROOF EDGE EXISTING CAST STONE CAP W/ COPPER FLASHING, TYP. REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING CAST STONE CAP W/ COPPER FLASHING, TYP. REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE RD RD REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP EXISTING BRICK PARAPET W/ COPPER CAP & FLASHING, TYP; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING BRICK PARAPET W/ COPPER CAP & FLASHING, TYP; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING COPPER ROOF TO BE REFURBISHED, WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP EXISTING COPPER ROOFING AND FLASHING TO BE REFURBISHED WHERE POSSIBLE, TYP EXISTING COPPER CAP & FLASHING, TYP; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP A-201 2 A-201 1 A-202. 3 A-202. 4 REMOVE EXISTING FLAT ROOFING SYSTEM & PROVIDE NEW MEMBRANE ROOF SYSTEM REMOVE EXISTING FLAT ROOFING SYSTEM & PROVIDE NEW MEMBRANE ROOF SYSTEM EXISTING SLATE SHINGLE ROOF TO BE REPAIRED IN KIND ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 2 2 P M A-105 ROOF PLAN13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 4'0 8'16' NO R T H MARK DATE DESCRIPTION FIRST FLOOR 24' -10" SECOND FLOOR 37' -10" GARDEN LEVEL 12' -10" ROOF 64' -10" THIRD FLOOR 50' -10" CEILING 62' -4" NEW CEILING 44' -7 3/4" VI F 11 ' - 6 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 12 ' - 0 " REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE A-800 4 FRONT ENTRY THRESHOLD (SURVEY) 21' -4 143/256" B.O. STAIR (SURVEY) 17' -3 77/128" FIRST FLOOR 24' -10" SECOND FLOOR 37' -10" GARDEN LEVEL 12' -10" ROOF 64' -10" THIRD FLOOR 50' -10" CEILING 62' -4" EXISTING GYMNASIUM FLOOR 7' -10" NEW CEILING 44' -7 3/4" VI F 5' - 0 " VI F 12 ' - 0 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 11 ' - 6 " NEW RAMP FROM ACCESSIBLE PARKING TO SECONDARY ENTRY REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW AND CASING TRIM, CATALOGUE & STORE ONSITE, REFINISH & REINSTALL IN LOCATION OF REMOVAL-TYP. REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR REFINISHING PROCEDURES. A-800B 1 ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 2 7 P M A-201 BUILDING ELEVATIONS13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 1/8" = 1'-0"2 PROPOSED - WEST ELEVATION 1/8" = 1'-0"1 PROPOSED - NORTH ELEVATION 2 1 4'0 8'16' MARK DATE DESCRIPTION FIRST FLOOR 24' -10" FIRST FLOOR 24' -10" SECOND FLOOR 37' -10" GARDEN LEVEL 12' -10" ROOF 64' -10" THIRD FLOOR 50' -10" CEILING 62' -4" EXISTING PLATFORM LEVEL 37' -4" EXISTING GYMNASIUM FLOOR 7' -10" 3 A-500B NEW CEILING 44' -7 3/4" VI F 11 ' - 6 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 13 ' - 0 " VI F 12 ' - 0 " VI F 12 ' - 6 " VI F 17 ' - 0 " REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW AND CASING TRIM, CATALOGUE & STORE ONSITE, REFINISH & REINSTALL IN LOCATION OF REMOVAL-TYP. REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR REFINISHING PROCEDURES. REMOVE EXISTING RETROFIT DOOR & TRANSOM ASSEMBLY; PROVIDE NEW GLAZED METAL DOOR & TRANSOM SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION A-800B 2 A-800B 1 Sim EXISTING SLATE SHINGLE ROOF; REPAIR IN KIND FIRST FLOOR 24' -10" SECOND FLOOR 37' -10" GARDEN LEVEL 12' -10" ROOF 64' -10" THIRD FLOOR 50' -10" CEILING 62' -4" EXISTING GYMNASIUM FLOOR 7' -10" NEW CEILING 44' -7 3/4" REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP EXISTING COPPER FLASHING & GUTTERS TO REMAIN; REFURBISH WHERE POSSIBLE REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW SYSTEMS & FRAMES & PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG. DWGS, TYP ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 3 4 P M A-202. BUILDING ELEVATIONS13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 4'0 8'16' 1/8" = 1'-0"3 PROPOSED- SOUTH ELEVATION 1/8" = 1'-0"4 PROPOSED - EAST ELEVATION 3 4 MARK DATE DESCRIPTION ETR EXTERIOR WALL REUSE EXISTING WINDOW CASING OR MATCH EXISTING, TYP PT WD BLOCKING AS REQ'D ETR STONE SILL, TYP; REF SPECS FOR STONE RESTORATION ETR EXTERIOR WALL NEW JAMB FLASHING BYND NEW ALUM WINDOW SYSTEM, TYP MEETING RAIL BRICK BEYOND APPLIED MUNTIN SPACER BAR AT APPLIED MUNTIN APPLIED VERT MUNTIN BYND APPLIED MUNTIN SPACER BAR AT APPLIED MUNTIN FILL VOIDS WITH LOW EXPANDING FOAM INSUL (NEW) NEW WD STOOL & APRON TO MATCH EXISTING, TYP. NEW JAMB FLASHING BYND NEW SELF ADHERED MEMBRANE FLASHING NEW MTL SILL PAN FLASHING W/ UPTURNED LEG NEW ALUM PANNING 2 1 / 4 " REVEAL WINDOW UNIT VARIES, VIF INTERIOREXTERIOR INTERIOR WINDOW SCREEN INTERIOR WINDOW SCREEN REINSTALL EXISTING TRIM OR MATCH EXISTING, TYP NEW PTD GWB, TYP. NEW PT WD BLOCKING, TYP NEW PTD GWB RETURN REINSTALL EXISTING TRIM OR MATCH EXISTING, TYPBRICK BEYOND NEW PTD GWB RETURN NEW PTD GWB RETURN FILL VOIDS W/ LOW EXPANSION FOAM INSUL EXISTING STEEL LINTEL TO BE PRIMED/PAINTED, AS REQ'D VARIES 5" . 13 / 1 6 " 5" 13 / 1 6 " ETR STONE SILL & BANDING; REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP. 5' - 4" MO, VIF 1' - 8" VIF 11' - 0" MO, VIF 9' - 1 3 / 8 " M O , V I F 5" 13 / 1 6 " 2 1 / 2 " 5" 5"13/16"5"13/16" 5" 13 / 1 6 " 2 1 / 2 " 5" 7" EXISTING WOOD WINDOW REPLACEMENT SCOPE: • REMOVE ALL EXT & INT SCREENS • REMOVE ALL INFILL MATERIALS • REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW, FRAME & TRIM; CATALOGUE & STORE TRIM ONSITE • COORDINATE ALL PROCEDURES PER ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT • PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG DWGS, TYP • REFINISH & REINSTALL EXISTING WINDOW TRIM IN LOCATION OF REMOVAL; OR MATCH EXISTING TYP INTERIOREXTERIOR 5" 13 / 1 6 " 2 1 / 2 " 13 / 1 6 " 5" VARIES ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 3 6 P M A-800 WINDOW DETAILS REPLACEMENT - HISTORIC APPROACH 13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 3" = 1'-0"2 PROPOSED 3/4" = 1'-0"4 WINDOW ELEVATIONS, TYP 3" = 1'-0"1 EXISTINGEXISTING CLASSROOM WINDOW TO BE REPLACED/REPLICATED, TYP MARK DATE DESCRIPTION EXISTING WOOD WINDOW RESTORATION SCOPE: • REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW & CASING TRIM; CATALOGUE & STORE ONSITE DURING DEMOLITION • REMOVE EXISTING PAINT; COORDINATE ALL PROCEDURES PER ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT • REGLAZE • PROVIDE NEW HARDWARE INCLUDING POWER ASSIST • PAINT AND REFINISH PER SPECIFICATIONS • REINSTALL IN LOCATION OF REMOVAL • PROVIDE NEW INTERIOR ENERGY STORMS ETR STONE SILL; REFERENCE SPECIFICATIONS FOR STONE RESTORATION, TYP. 10 ' - 3 " , V I F VI F 12 ' - 1 0 " M O , V I F 6' - 10" MO, VIF 5"13/16" 6" 2" 5" . EXISTING WOOD WINDOW REPLACEMENT SCOPE: • REMOVE ALL EXT & INT SCREENS • REMOVE ALL INFILL MATERIALS • REMOVE EXISTING WINDOW, FRAME & TRIM; CATALOGUE & STORE TRIM ONSITE • COORDINATE ALL PROCEDURES PER ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANT • PROVIDE NEW WINDOW SYSTEM TO REPLICATE ORIGINAL CONFIGURATIONS PER ORIG DWGS, TYP • REFINISH & REINSTALL EXISTING WINDOW TRIM IN LOCATION OF REMOVAL; OR MATCH EXISTING TYP3' - 8 3 / 4 " M O , V I F 6' - 0" MO, VIF 3 3 / 4 " 13 / 1 6 " 1 3 / 4 " 1 3/4"13/16" INTERIOREXTERIOR 2 3 / 4 " 13 / 1 6 " 3 3 / 4 " INTERIOREXTERIOR MASONRY BEYOND NEW JAMB FLASHING BYND FILL VOIDS W/ LOW EXPANDING FOAM INSUL NEW MTL SILL PAN FLASHING W/ UPTURNED LEG NEW ALUM PANNING SAMF ETR EXT WALL APPLIED MUNTIN VERT. APPLIED MUNTIN SPACER BAR NEW PT WD BLOCKING, TYP SHIM AS REQ'D ETR STONE SILL INTERIOR WINDOW SCREEN PAINT ETR RETURN 3 3 / 4 " 13 / 1 6 " 2 3 / 4 " ETR EXT WALL PT WD BLOCKING AS REQ'D EXTR STEEL LINTEL TO BE PRIMED/PAINTED, AS REQ'D FILL VOIDS W/ LOW EXPANSION FOAM INSUL NEW ALUM WINDOW SYSTEM TYP NEW JAMB FLASHING BYND VERT. APPLIED MUNTIN ARCHITECT CONSULTANT STAMP KEY PLAN SHEET TITLE PROJECT NUMBER: DRAWN BY: CHECKED BY: 8/31/2018 MHC SUBMISSION 2/ 1 2 / 2 0 2 0 3 : 5 6 : 3 8 P M A-800B WINDOW DETAILS RESTORATION - HISTORIC APPROACH 13 HAWTHORNE BLVD SALEM HISTORIC SCHOOLS NORTH SHORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT COALITION, INC.218010.2 BD Checker 3/4" = 1'-0"1 RESTORED WINDOW ELEVATION, TYP EXISTING WOOD AUDITORIUM WINDOW TO BE RESTORED, TYP 3/4" = 1'-0"2 REPLICATED WINDOW ELEVATION, TYP 3" = 1'-0"3 BASEMENT REPLACEMENT WINDOW SECTION MARK DATE DESCRIPTION April 22, 2020 Paul Durand, Chair Design Review Board 98 Washington Street Salem, MA 01970 Dear Mr. Durand, We are writing to comment on several matters coming before the Design Review Board at its meeting on April 22nd. 30 Federal Street Historic Salem provided comments on December 19, 2019 to the Salem Redevelopment Authority primarily with respect to the effect of the project on the pedestrian walkway, which we noted is “an important urban amenity”. We note that the revised plans labeled DRB 4.22.2020 do not address this concern in any way. As a consequence, please consider the 12/19/19 comments to be outstanding. 49 Federal Street This handsome Victorian Mansard house is a contributing building in the Federal Street National Register District. We wanted to remind both the DRB and the SRA that the design guidelines to be applied for buildings 50 years and older are the Secretary of the Interior Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties and the Salem Historical Commission Guidelines (Salem Renewal Plan, Section 3.3). We are concerned that the few remaining 19th-century residential structures in the SRA district have come under increasing threat from very large additions which appear to not to be in compliance with the guidelines. We urge the DRB and the SRA to seriously consider the resulting alteration of historic fabric in projects going forward. We also ask you to consider the impact on the urban design of the district due to the increase of impervious surface areas created to accomodate parking for additional units. 13 Hawthorne Boulevard and 160 Federal Street The redevelopment of these historic schools are before the DRB for design review in accordance with the Municipal and Religious Building Reuse Ordinance. We want to express to the Board our enthusiastic endorsement of these plans and the efforts of the North Shore CDC to create needed affordable housing while repurposing these important historic buildings. Sincerely, Tim Jenkins, President Cc: Salem Redevelopment Authority